relationship between psychological contract & human resource practices
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
1/41
1
1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
The Indian banking sector has emerged as one of the strongest drivers of Indias
economic growth. The Indian banking industry has made outstanding advancement in last
few years, even during the times when the rest of the world was struggling with financial
meltdown. India's economic development and financial sector liberalization have led to a
transformation of the Indian banking sector over the past two decades. Today Indian
Banking is at the crossroads of an invisible revolution. The sector has undergone
significant developments and investments in the recent past. Indian banks, the dominant
financial intermediaries in India, have made high-quality progress over the last five years,
as is evident from several factors, including annual credit growth, profitability, and trend
in gross non-performing assets (NPAs).
While annual rate of credit growth clocked 23% during the last five years, profitability
(average Return on Net Worth) was maintained at around 15% during the same period,
while gross NPAs fell from 3.3% as on March 31, 2006 to 2.3% as on March 31, 2011.
The Indian banking industry which is regarded as one of the most flourishing and secure
in the banking world has been selected for the study. The last decade has seen many
positive developments in the Indian banking sector. A large number of banks have startedfocussing on innovation and value creation which is mirrored in its market valuation.
With the liberalization of Indian economy; the Indian banking sector was exposed to the
world market. Bank s play a dominant role in Indias financial system and are, therefore,
expected to play a key role in furthering the agenda of financial inclusion with a view to
achieving inclusive growth and development. Today, at 35%; it contributes significantly
to the total gross domestic product (GDP) of the country.
Currently, Indian banks face several challenges, such as increase in interest rates on
saving deposits, possible deregulation of interest rates on saving deposits, a tighter
monetary policy, a large government deficit, increased stress in some sectors (such as,
State utilities, airlines, and microfinance), restructured loan accounts, unamortised
pension/gratuity liabilities, increasing infrastructure loans, and implementation of Basel
III.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
2/41
2
1.2 PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT
The psychological contract refers to mutual unwritten expectations that exist between an
employee and his/her employer regarding policies and practices in the organization.
Argyris (1960) first referred to the psychological contract only in passing as the
relationship between employer and employee. Levinson (1962) is the father of the
concept and defined psychological contract as unwritten contract, the sum of the mutual
expectations between the organization and employee. Psychological contrac ts are mental
models or schemas that develop through an individuals interactions and experiences. The
definition given by Rousseau (1990) highlights employees perception of the existence of
mutual obligations deposited with the employer. It is an emotional bond between
employer and employee. It is implicit and thus unofficial and includes mutual
responsibilities and expectations. The common theme underlying these definitions is that
the psychological contract refers to an employees unexpressed beliefs, expectations,
promises and responsibilities with respect to what constitutes a fair exchange within the
boundaries of the employment relationship. Today, it is easy to recruit people but what is
challenging is to retain them and make them go an extra mile at work. Employers should
generate passion among the employees and create an environment that fosters creativity
and commitment. This can be achieved by building a positive psychological contractwhich results in good employment relationships. It is an emotional bond between
employer and employee.
The strength of the psychological contract depends on how far the individual believes the
organization is in fulfilling its perceived obligations above and beyond the formal written
contract of employment. Thi s in turn determines individuals commitment to the
organization and his/her motivation, job satisfaction and extent of feeling secure in the jobs. It leads to positive attitudes and a high level of commitment. The concept of
psychological contract addresses those relationships that are very hard to define clearly in
a formal employment contract, such as: knowledge and skills development, ones work
and motivation, relationships with ones boss and co -workers, the role one is expected to
fulfil, the ethical code by which the employee and the organization will act, the support
one can expect from the organization and vice versa, and so on. Psychological contracts
are voluntary commitments that limit ones future action. They are open -ended and need
to be flexible enough to accommodate changes without breaking. It is observed that
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
3/41
3
potential employees can enter into employment relationships with dramatically opposing
views of one anothers rights. The traditional psychological contract provides a clear
contract and reduces uncertainty for employees with reference to jobs. The contract was
forthright and existed in stable and unchanging environments that were certain of growth.
The psychological contracts of employees differ from one another according to several
properties: (1) their specific contents or terms, (2) the overall proportion of transactional
versus relational terms, and (3) the total size of the contract relative to the individuals life
space. Additionally, transactional and relational portions of the psychological contract
influence one another; they are not independent. (Guzzo and Noonan, 1994). The central
premise is that employees are the key to sustainable competitive advantage, therefore, it
follows that relationship between employers and employees are critical to ensuring
productivity and the continued release of creation and innovatively. Employers expect
employees to work hard and generally do what the management demands, and in return
employers will provide with good jobs and good pay and advancement opportunities.
1.2.1 TYPES OF PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT
Two major types of contracts are common in the workplace; transactional and relational.
The former is associated with economic exchange and the latter with social exchange.
Unlike economic exchange, social exchange involves unspecified obligations, the
fulfilment of which depends on trust because it cannot be enforced in absence of a
binding contract (Emerson, 1981). Rousseau and Benzoni (1994) further explore the
concept and identify four types of psychological contracts at workplace:
1. Transactional Contract: Rousseau defines this contract an employment
arrangement with a short-term or limited duration, primarily focused upon
economic exchanges; specific, narrow duties and limited worker involvement in
the organization (Rousseau, 2000).
Narrow/Specific: The employee is obliged to perform a fixed or limited set of
duties, to do only what he or she is paid to do so. The employer has committed to
offer the worker only limited involvement in the organization, little or no training
or other employee development
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
4/41
4
Short-Term: The employee has no obligation to remain with the firm; is
committed to work for only a limited time. The employer offers employment for
only a short period and is not obliged to future commitments.
2. Relational Contract: Relational contracts are presented as open-ended, less
specific arrangements that establish and maintain a relationship, being based on
emotional involvement as well as financial reward (Robinson and Rousseau,
1994).
Stability: The employee is obligated to remain with the firm and to do what is
required to keep his or her job. The employer is committed to providing stable
wages and long-term employment.
Loyalty: The employee is obliged to support the fir, manifest loyalty and
commitment to the organizations needs and interest s. Employer is committed to
the well-being of the employees.
3. Bal anced Contr act: Balanced contracts are open arrangements with both parties
contributing to each others learning and development, conditioned on the
economic success of the employer (Sutherland and Wocke, 2008).
External Employability: Career development on the external labor market.
Employee is obligated to develop marketable skills. Employer is committed to
enhancing workers long -term employability both within and outside the
organization.
Internal Advancement: Career development within an internal labor market.
Employee is obligated to develop skills that are valued by the current employer.
Employer is committed to career advancements within the firm.
4. Transitional Contracts: Essentially a breakdown in contracts, reflecting the
absence of commitment regarding future employment as well as little or no
explicit performance demands on contingent incentives (Rousseau and Benzoni,
1994).
Mistrust: Employee mistrusts the firm because of poor communication and the
employer withholds important information from the employees. The employer
mistrust the employees
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
5/41
5
Uncertainty: Employee is uncertain about the nature of his or her own obligations
to the firm. Employer measures and assesses the extent to which the employee is
uncertain about the commitment to the organization.
1.3 HUMAN RESOURCE PRACTICES
Human resource practices send strong messages about what organisations expect and
what employees can anticipate in return. They are major mechanisms employees use to
understand the terms of their employment. Also, human resource practices create
contractual and future intentions through hiring practices, reward practices and
developmental activities. Organisations even use them as communication tools. Human
Resource practices send strong messages to individuals regarding what the organisation
expects of them and what they can expect in return and are thus indicative of
organisation intentions. Human Resource practices communicate promises and future
intents in the name of the organisation through hiring practices, reward practices and
developmental activities. Individuals commonly view these promises as forms of
contracts, as enduring mental schemas and act according to the commitments conveyed
and behaviours cued.
One of the most potent organisational factors influencing the psychological contract of
employees is human resource practices. In the changing economy, traditional employee-
employer relationship based on trust, loyalty commitment and long-term relationship has
also drastically changed. Studies affirm the crucial role of organisational variables such as
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
6/41
6
human resource practices on influencing employee conception of psychological contract
and organisational outcomes (Rousseau, 1990).
Psychological Contract is developed through an interactive process and is influenced and
shaped by various organisational processes (Rousseau, 1990; Tsui et al., 1997). It is
believed that HR practices send strong messages to individuals regarding what the
organisation expects of them and what they can expect in return (Rousseau, 1995) and
are thus indicative of organisation intentions. HR practices communicate promises and
future intents in the name of the organisation through hiring practices, reward practices
and developmental activities. Individuals commonly view these promises as forms of
contracts, as enduring mental schemas and act according to the commitments conveyed
and behaviours cued (Rousseau, 1995).
Recruitment and Selection: This is the first instance when the employee comes
into contact with the employer of the organization. Therefore, if the recruitment
process is managed well, it may significantly affect employee attitudes and
behaviors (Aggarwal and Bhargava, 2008). As employees join an organization
with the belief that employer will live up to the promises made to them and if they
are not fulfilled then the employee considers the psychological contract violated
and may react in ways that may go against the interest of the employer (Morrison
and Robinson, 1997)
Training and Development: New work experiences, interesting assignments,
expensive skill based training in line with the firms business objectives and a
planned career, signal an organizations intention to foster a long -term
relationship (Aggarwal and Bhargava, 2008). Human resource professionals can
influence the attitudes not only by giving the required training but also by
involving them into the need assessment phase and giving them a realistic preview
about the benefits they can expect from the training (Sims, 1994).
Pay/Reward Management: Reward management is an important inducement of
the exchange process between employers and employees (Gerhart and Milkovich,
1992). Rewards have been recognised as an important element of the
psychological contract defining the relationship between employers and
employees (Lucero and Allen, 1994). Reward and remuneration packages that are
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
7/41
7
in congruence with employees expectations, encourages them to serve beyond
their job description, gain professional expertise, and cultivate core competencies
across functional groupings (Hiltrop, 1995). Appropriate reward management
system motivates employees to apply skills and abilities and encourage them to
work harder and improve work processes.
Performance Management: Rousseau and Ho (2000) matched compensation
system to employee psychological contract. Based on these two dimensions, the
authors have identified four types of relationships: short-term relationships with
specific measures of performance, short-term relationships with unspecified
measures of performance, long-term relationships with specified measures of
performance, and finally long-term relationships with unspecified measures of
performance.
Human resource practices can play an important role in orchestrating the culture of an
organisation. HR practices represent a set of salient and universal practices that can create
the foundation for particular form organisational climate to develop (Ostroff et al., 2000;
Schneider, 1990). Human resource practices like realistic job previews, developmental
appraisal which captures employee expectations and identification of training needs in
consultation with the employees, results in formation of progressive organisational
culture which talks with people, not at them. Importantly, the climate or culture
perceptions of organisation also shape individual inferences about what the organisation
is like.
1.4 NEED FOR THE STUDY
The efficient, dynamic and effective banking sector plays a decisive role in acceleratingthe rate of economic growth in any economy. The banking industry in India has helped in
the economic growth of the country. With the liberalization and privatization; banks
today contribute to the GDP of country. The banking sector in India has evolved not just
to participate in the growth of the economy but in a way to catalyze the growth of the
economy. With Grameen banks, ATMSs etc., it has made tremendous impact on the
lives of millions of people who are poor, marginalized and living in rural and far flung
topographies. Banks today are one of the major sources of employment for people in
India. Indian banking sector was also one of the few sectors to be unaffected by the global
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
8/41
8
recession. Given its significance in the economy; banking sector should be studied to
understand the various managerial and human resource implications in it. In this people
economy one of the most challenging task that organizations face is to gain commitment
from employees which eventually leads to increased loyalty, productivity and retention.
The strength of a psychological contract highlights job attitudes and performance of the
employees in the organization. A healthy psychological contract results in voluntary
commitment resulting from the employees. Further, it motivates employees to comply
with the contract.
1.5 PURPOSE OF THE STUDY
The main purpose of the study is to find out if there is any existing relationship between
the psychological contract and the human resource practices in the organizations. Also,
though there have been a large number of studies discussing the impact of human
resource practices on psychological contract; there hasnt been a systematic attempt to
understand the same. Thus, the present study is aimed at developing a deeper
understanding about psychological contract and human resource practices amongst
employees serving the banking sector in India.
1.6 STRUCTURE OF THE STUDY
The first chapter gives an introduction to the topic under study as well the need and
purpose of the same.
The second chapter contains the literature review of the theoretical framework which
gives an overview of the key concepts about psychological contract and human resource
practices.
The third chapter contains the research methodology adopted and the key hypothesis
analyzed and tested.
The fourth chapter gives the empirical findings of the study conducted which contains the
results of the correlation and regression analysis.
The last chapter gives the findings, conclusion and suggestions.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
9/41
9
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Review of literature is the first step towards conducting any study as it serves as a vital
link between the research proposed and the research already conducted. It gives an overall
picture about the study to be undertaken and at the same time helps in identifying the
research methodology to be adopted with focus on the scope for future research. Also, it
helps to identify the gaps in the previous studies and how one can add more value to the
research already done.
This review is done to explore the various human resource practices that can affect the
psychological contract in the organizations.
2.2 HOW REVIEW HAS BEEN CONDUCTED
For this study, 20 research papers related to the study were reviewed. Most of the papers
reviewed are on studies conducted outside India; though; few studied done in India have
also been included. After reading through the research papers; the findings and gas of the
study conducted were written and a proper log was prepared before writing it in a formal
format.
2.3 STUDIES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT
Nadin & Williams (2012) examined the psychological contract from the employers'
perspective, by examining violations where the employer rather than employee is the
victim. The approach used was to study small business owners using qualitative
interviews, incorporating critical incidents technique. The analysis revealed the
significant disruption and damage caused by these incidents, with employers involving
other employees in their response as they set about the essential repair work required.
Employers actively mobilised shared understandings at the normative level of the group,
reinforcing and sometimes renegotiating the employee obligations, as they seek to
reaffirm their authority in the eyes of all of their employees. This response reflected the
collective psychological contracts the employer holds with each of their employees and
their concerns to limit the fall-out/damage when one employee commits a violation.
Patrick (2008) Psychological contract influences the job attitudes and performance of
employees. Six psychological contract variables (relational contract, transactionalcontract, employers commitment/obligation to employee, employees
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
10/41
10
commitment/obligation to employer, emplo yers relationship with employee, and
employees relationship with employer) were measured on employees from IT
companies from randomly chosen for the study. The study revealed that relational
contract was dominant in the IT companies under study. Employees
commitment /obligation to employers was higher than employers commitment/obligation
to employees. Employees relationship with employers was also stronger than employers
relationship with employees.
Wright & Kehoe (2007) lay a great deal of emphasis human resource practices in an
organization as they can affect the organizational commitment of the employees. They
identify three dimensions of commitment that an employee develops with the employer.
Commitment target refers to the foci or object to which one is committed. An individualcan be committed to a wide variety of different targets but the commitment construct is
essentially the same regardless of the target. Commitment strength reflects the degree or
intensity to which someone is committed to the target. Commitment strength is singular,
one can be committed to multiple targets but commitment strength has the same singular
meaning regardless of the target . Commitment rationales are the multiple possible self-
explanations a person can hold for their commitment to a given target; i.e. how one makes
sense of or rationalizes their commitment. An individual can have multiple rationales fora particular commitment; those rationales can change over time, and may be conscious or
unconscious.
Freese & Schalk (2004) analyzed the different ways in which psychological contracts
can be measured. On the basis of criteria for measurement and scale development
psychological contract measurements are put to a test. The criteria are related to the way
the measurement is developed and evaluated, and the specific conceptualisations of the
content and evaluation of the psychological contract. Existing questionnaires to measurethe psychological contract are evaluated. The use of psychological contract measurements
of Psycones, or Rousseau is recommended.
Meuse, Bergmann & Lester (2001) in their study found that the perceptions of relational
component of the psychological contract have changed over time and tracks the same
over a period of 50 years. The findings suggested that part-time employees view the
psychological contract differently than their full-time counterparts, in that full-time
employees perceived a greater decrease in relational component over time. A
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
11/41
11
psychological contract survey was produced and validated for the purpose of the study.
The decrease is characterized by low levels of trust, support, respect, loyalty and
commitment.
Rousseau and Benzoni (1994) further explore the concept and identify four types of
psychological contracts at workplace. Transactional Contract is an employment
arrangement with a short-term or limited duration, primarily focused upon economic
exchanges; specific, narrow duties and limited worker involvement in the organization.
Relational contracts are presented as open-ended, less specific arrangements that establish
and maintain a relationship, being based on emotional involvement as well as financial
reward. Transitional contract is essentially a breakdown in contracts, reflecting the
absence of commitment regarding future employment as well as little or no explicit performance demands on contingent incentives
Emerson (1981) Two major types of contracts are common in the workplace;
transactional and relational. The former is associated with economic exchange and the
latter with social exchange. Unlike economic exchange, social exchange involves
unspecified obligations, the fulfilment of which depends on trust because it cannot be
enforced in absence of a binding contract.
2.4 STUDIES ON HUMAN RESOURCE PRACTICES
Fey (2001) This study investigated the relationship between human resource management
(HRM) and the performance of 101 foreign-owned subsidiaries in Russia. The study's
results provide support for the assertion that investments in HRM practices can
substantially assist a firm in improving performance. Further, different HRM practices for
managerial and non-managerial employees are found to be significantly related to firm
performance. Only limited support, however, is obtained for the hypothesized relationship
between efforts at aligning HRM practices with firm strategy and subsidiary performance.
Delaney and Huselid (1996) In 590 for-profit and nonprofits firms from the National
Organizations Survey, they found positive associations between human resource
management (FIRM) practices, such as training and staffing selectivity, and perceptual
firm performance measures. Results also suggest methodological issues for consideration
in examinations of the relationship between HRM systems and firm performance.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
12/41
12
Youndt (1996) This study examined two alternative views-universal and contingency-of
the human resources (HR)-performance relationship in manufacturing settings. Results
from a survey of 97 plants primarily supported a contingency approach to human resource
management (HRM). An HR system focused on human capital enhancement was directly
related to multiple dimensions of operational performance (i.e., employee productivity,
machine efficiency, and customer alignment), but subsequent analysis revealed that this
main effect was predominately the result of linking human-capital-enhancing HR systems
with a quality manufacturing strategy.
Huselid (1995) examined the linkages between systems of High Performance
Work Practices and firm performance. Results based on a national sample of nearly one
thousand firms indicate that these practices have an economically and statistically
significant impact on both intermediate outcomes (turnover and productivity) and short-
and long-term measures of corporate financial performance.
Rosenzwei (1994) A study of human resource management practices in 249 U.S.
affiliates of foreign-based multinational corporations (MNCs) showed that in general
affiliate HRM practices closely follow local practices, with differences among specific
practices. The degree of similarity to local practices is significantly influenced by the
method of founding, dependence on local inputs, the presence of expatriates, and the
extent of communication with the parent. In addition, sharp differences are revealed
among affiliates of Canadian, Japanese and European MNCs, suggesting strong country
effects. Together, these findings support the view of MNCs as composed of differentiated
practices, which in turn are shaped by forces for local isomorphism and for internal
consistency.
2.5 STUDIES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT AND HUMAN
RESOURCE PRACTICES
Sonnenberg, Koene & Paauwe (2011) found a positive influence of a number of HRM
practices on psychological contract and its violation. They analysed the value of
organisation level HRM practices for individual level employees' assessment of the
degree of violation of their psychological contracts. Based on a sample of 49
organisations, the paper analysed the relationship between organisation level HRM practices and individual level employees' assessment of the degree of violation of their
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
13/41
13
psychological contracts, using multi-level analysis. The findings showed that more use of
HRM practices leads to lower levels of perceived psychological contract violation for
individual employees, regardless of individual characteristics. Commitment HRM
practices explain about half of the variance in psychological contract violation that is due
to the total amount of HRM practices.
Suazo, Patricia & Rudy (2011) integrated the concept of signaling theory to propose that
organizations create psychological and legal contracts through their human resource
management practices (HRM). Focusing on the strength of the signal generated by HRM
practices, they developed a framework for contract creation. The study focused
specifically on how weak signals generate psychological contracts and strong signals
develop legally binding contracts. The propositions shed light on the importance ofconsidering not only the signals that HRM practices can generate to generate contracts,
but also the practical relevance considering the strength of signals as they relate to the
creation of psychological or legal contracts.
Scheepers & Shuping (2011) examined the effect of human resource practices on the
types of psychological contracts in an iron ore mining company in South Africa
empirically. Two questionnaires were administered. The findings showed that most
participants have relational contracts with the organisation. The study suggests that there
are relationships between these psychological contracts and specific human resource
practices. The study found that training and development was the most important human
resource practice for developing relational and balanced contracts. Employees thought
that they contributed more than their employer did to the relationship. The researchers
developed a model to illustrate the influence of the various human resource practices on
psychological contracts.
Sutherland and Wocke (2008) Balanced contracts are open arrangements with both
parties contributing to each others learning and development, conditioned on the
economic success of the employer
Rousseau and Ho (2000) matched compensation system to employee psychological
contract. Based on these two dimensions, the authors have identified four types of
relationships: short-term relationships with specific measures of performance, short-term
relationships with unspecified measures of performance, long-term relationships with
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
14/41
14
specified measures of performance, and finally long-term relationships with unspecified
measures of performance.
Stiles, Gratton & Truss (1997) examined a key ingredient in the psychological-contract
making process, i.e. the performance management system. Focusing on three large U.K.
based organizations, the paper explores how performance management processes are
being used to facilitate moving away from the traditional contract of job security and
clear career paths, while attempting to maintain commitment and morale. The key
findings of the research were that a major element in changing the psychological contract
in the sample companies has been the renewed focus on performance management to
affect new organizational objectives. Employees regard the changes in the performance
management systems as making their employment relationships more transactional. Oneof the limitations of the study was that it did not produce a longitudinal data which makes
it unable to suggest about the changes in the commitment curve.
Rousseau (1994) Human resource practices represent a major mechanism for
implementing a firms strategic plan. These practices create a di stinct type of
relationships between employee and employer which can be characterized as
psychological contracts, that is, the belief people hold regarding the terms of their
employment relationship. These contracts affect the employees behavior towards
customers and fellow employees, and also affect their commitment to the organization.
Rousseau and Wade- Benzoni (1994) analyzed how human resource practices and
psychological contract are related to the business strategy of an organisation. Resultantly,
based on HRP and psychological contract the business strategic decisions (defender,
prospector, analyser and responsive) organisations make related choices in HR practices
that subsequently result in psychological contract of employees. Simply put, business
strategy and employment strategy influence the HR practices which in turn determines
psychological contract of employees.
Gerhart and Milkovich (1992) Reward management is an important inducement of the
exchange process between employers and employees. Reward and remuneration packages
that are in congruence with employees expectations, encourages them to serve beyond
their job description, gain professional expertise, and cultivate core competencies across
functional groupings. Appropriate reward management system motivates employees toapply skills and abilities and encourage them to work harder and improve work processes.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
15/41
15
Ostroff et al., 2000; Schneider (1990) Human resource practices can play an important
role in orchestrating the culture of an organisation. HR practices represent a set of salient
and universal practices that can create the foundation for particular form organisational
climate to develop. Human resource practices like realistic job previews, developmental
appraisal which captures employee expectations and identification of training needs in
consultation with the employees, results in formation of progressive organisational
culture which talks with people, not at them. Importantly, the climate or culture
perceptions of organisation also shape individual inferences about what the organisation
is like. Furthermore, organisational culture leads to the construction of a normative
psychological contract, which is shared by the members of the organisation.
Aggarwal & Bhargava (2009) synthesised the literature on the role of human resource practices (HRP) in shaping employee psychological contract (PC). Based on this review,
a conceptual framework for examining the relationship between HRP and PC and their
impact on employee attitudes as well as behaviour was put forward for further
examination. The approach included an extensive review of the literature, examining the
role of HRP in influencing PC of employees, between the periods 1972 to 2007 was
conducted. Adopting the multi-level approach, the paper discusses the role of individual
variable (PC) and organisational variable (HRP) on employee attitudes and behaviours.The article brings to fore the role of business and employment relationship strategy on
HRP; the relationship between HRP and organisation culture as well as employees
attitudes and behaviours; the relationship between HRP on and employee's psychological
contract; and the moderating effect of those conceptions on employee attitudes and
behaviours relationship. HRP and PC influence employee attitudes and behaviours as well
as have a bearing on organizational effectiveness.
Aggarwal and Robinson (2009) analyzed how hiring practices influence the psychological contract. As employees join an organization with the belief that employer
will live up to the promises made to them and if they are not fulfilled then the employee
considers the psychological contract violated and may react in ways that may go against
the interest of the employer. This is the first instance when the employee comes into
contact with the employer of the organization. Therefore, if the recruitment process is
managed well, it may significantly affect employee attitudes and behaviors.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
16/41
16
2.3 CONCLUSION
The above review conducted by different people gives us an insight about how human
resource practices can affect the strength of psychological contracts in the organizations.
The mutual expectations between the employer and the employee should be fulfilled in
order to maintain a strong psychological contract. The breach of psychological contract
can lead to mistrust and disloyalty which eventually affects the organization in a negative
manner. Thus, understanding psychological contract with reference to human resource
practices is crucial for the managers as it can affect attrition and job satisfaction among
the employees.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
17/41
17
3.1 INTRODUCTION
Research refers to the design of the study method and processes by which data is gathered for a
research project. It includes the blueprint for the collection, measurement, and analysis of data to
achieve the objectives of a research project. Research methodology is important in a research
work because it specifies the research design. Here the researcher explicitly defines the
operational definitions of the concepts used in the research and defines the variables that have
been included in the study. Research methodology is also important in a research work because it
also specifies the sampling design. The researcher also defines the target population and the
sampling method used. The researcher also provides the rationale for choosing a specific
sampling method. Additionally, the researcher identifies the data collection method. This could be
self-administered questionnaires, postal surveys, or interviews. Finally, the researcher focuses on
the limitations of the research. The researcher identifies significant methodology or
implementation problems such as sampling errors, response and non response errors and the
constraints of cost and time. This chapter attempts to explain the survey at hand in terms of the
study area, the study unit and the population. Further, the chapter highlights the organization and
design of the questionnaire as well as the methods of data collection and data analysis. The data
collection instrument employed in the investigation, the administration of the instrument as well
as their reliability and validity are also described. Finally, the chapter examines the different
statistical tests used to analyze the gathered data, the reliability, and the validity of the results as
well as the limitations in the collection of the data.
3.2 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
Inefficient human resource practices (like hiring, training & development, remuneration
and performance appraisal) of the organizations will affect the psychological contract
between the employee and the employer.
3.3 OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS OF THE VARIABLES1. Psychological Contract: Psychological contracts refer to beliefs that individuals
hold regarding promises made, accepted, and relied upon between themselves and
another Roussue (1900).
2. Relational Contract: It refers to open-ended relationship involving considerable
investments by both employees and employers. The contract is derived from long
term membership and participation in the organization involving high degree of
mutual interdependence.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
18/41
18
3. Transactional Contract: It refers to contracts which are short-term, primarily
focused on exchange of work in lieu of money with a specific and definite
description of duties and responsibilities and limited involvement in organization.
4. Human Resource Practices: The human resource practices under this study will
include hiring, training & development, performance appraisal and
remuneration/pay practices in the organization.
3.4 VARIABLES UNDER INVETIGATION
The variables under investigation in this study are:
Dependent Variable: psychological contract.
Independent Variable: human resource practices.
Demographic Variable: Gender, Qualification, Overall experience, Marital status
3.5 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
To find out the type of contract held by banking employees
To find out the HRM practices adopted in the Banking sector
To find out if there is a relationship between the HRM practices and the type of
psychological contract held i the banking sector
3.6 HYPOTHESES
HYPOTHESIS 1: There is no significant relationship between Psychological contract
(Transactional/Relational) and HRM practices.
HYPOTHESIS 2: HRM practices will not influence relational and transactional contracts
in the banking sector.
HYPOTHESIS 3: There is a significant relationship between Psychological contract
(Transactional/Relational) and HRM practices.
HYPOTHESIS 4: HRM practices will influence relational and transactional contracts in
the banking sector.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
19/41
19
3.7 POPULATION AND SAMPLE OF STUDY
There are around 60 banks operating in India. In these 27 are public sector banks, 15 are
private sector banks and rest include foreign banks operating in India. 10 leading public
and private sector banks on the basis of market capitalization were identified for the study
and 300 bank employees were surveyed for the study.
The population of relevance had the following characteristics:
a) Had a minimum work experience of 1 year.
b) Had a qualification (Bachelors/Masters).
c) Ws involved in work that requires some level of decision-making.
d) Was well aware of the human resource practices in the organization.
3.8 SAMPLING TECHNIQUE
Judgemental sampling technique will be adopted to collect data from the respondents for
the present study. Bank employees with a minimum one year of experience will be
considered to fill the questionnaire
3.9 TOOLS ADOPTED FOR THE STUDY
The questionnaire method will be used to collect data from the respondents. Based on the
objectives of the study, the following tools will be used:
I. Psychological Contract Questionnaire (PCQ) adopted from Millward & Hopkins,
1998; and Rousseau, 1995 (furnished as Annexure) was used to study the strength
of transactional and relational contract in the organizations.
II. The Geringer, Collete and Millmna scale was used to study the human resource
practices in the organizations.
3.10 DESCRIPTION OF THE TOOLS
3.10.1 Psychological Contract Questionnaire
The Psychological Contract Questionnaire is designed to assess the generalizable content
of the psychological contract for use in organizational research and as a self-scoring
assessment to support executive and professional education. The questionnaire was
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
20/41
20
adopted for the study to measure the psychological contract variables, viz., (i) strength of
relational contract, (ii) strength of transactional contract.
Part I: Respondents biographic data
Part II: Seventeen statements for measuring the strength of relational and transactional
contract. It uses a 7 point likert scale for the employees to choose from seven options
3.10.2 The Geringer, Collete and Millmna scale
The Geringer, Collete and Millmna scale analyzes the relation between human resource
management practices and psychological contract. There are 4 questions in this section
with 10 items each and uses a 5 point scale (1- not at all, 2- to a small extent, 3 to a
moderate extent, 4 to a large extent, 5 to a very great extent.
3.11 PILOT TEST AND RELIABILITY OF THE INSTRUMENT
The Cronbachs reliability test on the 17 PCQ statements for this sample has revealed
that reliability is a cceptable, being in the range: 0.73 - 0.89.
Table 3.1 Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha
Cronbach's
Alpha Based
on
Standardized
Items
N of
Items
.763 .795 17
The Cronbachs reliability test on the 40 human resource practices statements for this
sample has revealed that reliability is acceptable, being in the range 0.73 -0.89.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
21/41
21
3.12 STATISTICAL TECHNIQUE AND ANALYSIS
a) Reliability Test: The questionnaire though standardized was modified to suit the
study. Therefore, a reliability test was conducted which indicated a cronbachs value
between the acceptable range implying the reliability of the questionnaire adopted.
b) Correlation Analysis: Correlations analysis is conducted to seek the relationships of
the variables in terms of direction and significance of the relationships. Correlation
between the dependent variables and the independent variables will be conducted. Thisanalysis will be used to answer the hypotheses and research questions.
c) Regression Analysis: It is statistical technique for estimating the relationships
among different variables. It mainly focuses on deriving relationship between a dependent
variable and one or more independent variables.
3.13 CONCLUSION
Research methodology has helped in developing the research questions, hypothesis, andobjectives in line with those of the research techniques and the population of relevance. An
analysis is done on responses collected from 300 respondents which are interpreted in the
subsequent chapters.
Table 3.2 Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's
Alpha
Cronbach's
Alpha Based on
Standardized
Items
N of Items
.766 .824 40
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
22/41
22
4.1 INTRODUCTION
The Indian banking industry is considered as one of the safest in the world and has been
flourishing in the past many years. The last decade has seen a series of advancements and
developments in the banking sector. The policy makers, which include the finance
ministry, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and financial sector regulatory bodies, have made
a large number of efforts to improve the regulation in the sector. The Indian banking
sector now compares favourably with banking sectors in the Asian region with respect to
metrics like profit ratios and capital equalization ratios. The IT revolution had a great
impact in the Indian banking system. The use of computers revolutionised the way
banking transactions and services were offered. Today, online banking is a growing
feature in the banks across the country. Much of it can be attributed to the liberalization,
globalization and privatization drive that came to India in 1991. The reforms helped India
to expose it banking sector to worlds market and led to various innovative changes.
Apart from improving the productivity and efficiency of the banking sector in India; the
reforms have greatly changed the working of the banking sector in India.
With the emergence of private banks and international banks; the competition to serve the
customers better has increased. With excellent customer service and support services,
they are an edge above the public sector banks. However, the public sector banks still are
going strong because of the low interest rates and government support. Compared to other
markets the cost of banking intermediation is quite high in India. However, on the other
hand the bank penetration is low compared to other banks in the region. The Indian
banking sector currently contributes about 35% t the Indian GDP and is one of the largest
employers in the country offering millions of jobs to the people every year. Thus, in order
to support the vibrant and fast growing economy of India; the banking sector should
strengthen itself. The bank managements are primarily responsible to drive this change
but an enabling policy and regulatory framework would also cater to strengthening the
sector. Recapitalization, non-performing assets and prudential regulation are some of the
challenges that the Indian banking sector faces today.
The efficient, enterprising and effective banking sector plays a decisive role in
accelerating the rate of economic growth in any economy. The banking sector in India has
evolved in India to catalyze the growth of the economy and is not just another sector
contributing to the economy. The banking sector has widened its horizons and has
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
23/41
23
ventured into insurance, mutual funds and asset management. With a network that spawns
from urban metros to the rural interiors; the banking sector has affected the lives of most
Indians. Interestingly, the Indian banking sector was also one of the few sectors to be
unaffected by the global recession.
4.2 GOVERNMENT INITIATIVE IN BANKING SECTOR
The Indian banking industry is largely regulated by the government with the Reserve
Bank of India (RBI) being the apex body making the policies for banks in the country.
The first breakthrough came when government decided to nationalize the banks in
1970 s. This brought a large number of banks under the control of government and
changed the way banking operated in the country. In the early 1990s, the liberalization
brought with it emergence of a large number of private sector banks which were licensed
by the government. These came to be known as New Generation tech-savvy bank. The
next milestone in the Indian banking sector came with the governments decision to relax
the norms with respect to Foreign Direct Investment, thereby; allowing all foreign
investors in banks to have voting rights. At present the cap is at 74% with some
restrictions. The new policy jolted the banking sector completely and changed the
traditional operating ways of banks. A modern and technologically enabled outlook was
adopted by the banks to survive this new wave of change. This led to the birth of retail
boom in the country with the people receiving a lot from their banks.
Currently, banking in India is reasonably mature with regards to the products & services
offered and its ability to reach a large number of consumers. However; the private sector
and foreign banks have still a long way to go in terms of penetration in the rural sector
and it seems a daunting task. Indian banks have strong and transparent balance sheets in
terms of assets quality and adequacy of capital when compared to other banks in theAsian region.
4.3 SWOT ANALYSIS OF INDIAN BANKING SECTOR
The Indian banking sector is considered as one of the most secure sectors to work with
across the world. The strengths of Indian banking sector lie in its ability to remain stable
because of the regulatory practices that exist in the country. Policy makers in the country
have introduced reforms to improve the functioning of the sector. Extensive reach, strong
balance sheets and government policies are some of the strengths of the sector. However,
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
24/41
24
on the other hand a fragmented industry structure, restrictions employed on the
availability of capital, lack of institutional support structure and an under developed
system of corporate governance are the weaknesses of the Indian banking sector.
Due to the growth of Indian economy the demand for banking services has also grown
with specific focus on retail banking and investment services. Liberalization of norms, IT
growth and the growing knowledge of hybrid capital are some of the opportunities that lie
ahead of the banking sector in the country. Threats for the banking industry include
instability of the system, and increase in the inflation rate of the country which could
impact the interest rates and increase in the number of foreign players would pose a threat
to the public sector banks as well as the private players.
4.4 FUTURE OF THE BANKING SECTOR
The Indian banking sector can expect to grow at a substantial rate as the economy and the
GDP the country is on the rise. With the rise in the number of foreign banks operating in
India, the banking sector will see a lot of competition with focus on improving the
customer satisfaction through effective and efficient banking services. Given the
significance of human resources; the future strategy should focus on competencies of
employees, their ability to learn and the ability of managers to manage soft skills inorganizations. It is imperative of the banking sector to focus on crucial areas like human
resources with respect to building an organization culture and developing leadership
which can serve as a source for competitive advantage in the long run. This implies that
banks need to focus on both the quantitative and qualitative aspects of business. Apart
from this; derivatives, retail banking, hybrid banking will be the future of banking sector.
.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
25/41
25
5.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter deals with the analysis of the relationship between psychological contract
and human resource practices existing in the banking sector in India. This chapter
contains the analysis of primary data collected through the standardized questionnaire
administered to the bank employees. The techniques mentioned in Chapter 3 were used to
analyze the data using SPSS.
5.2 RESPONDENT PROFILE
A total of 300 bank employees across 10 major banks participated in the survey for the present study. The participants were from diverse backgrounds with respect to their age,
education and level in the organization.
The current gender ratio tells us that out of the 300 people who participated in the survey;
majority of them were males (59%) as is indicated in the graph. However, females
constituted 41% of the total population of respondents.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
26/41
26
Most of the respondents who participated in the survey belong to the lower (41.67%) and
the middle (45%) level in the organization depending upon the level of responsibility they possess on the job. Only a few respondents (13.33%) belonged to the higher level in their
organizations.
Out of the 300 employees who were administered the questionnaire; most of them had a
higher level degree in education. As seen in the graph, 76.67% of the respondents had a
post graduate degree while 23.33% of employees had a graduate degree.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
27/41
27
Graph 5.4
Out of the 300 employees who were administered the questionnaire; 63.6% of them had2-4 years of total experience on their jobs. This was followed by employees who had 5-7
years of experience (26.6%). Very few employees who participated in the survey had
more than 7 years of experience. This indicates that most of the people who participated
in the survey were new on their jobs with not many years of experience. Their career had
just started in the organization.
Graph 5.5
Out of the 300 employees who were administered the questionnaire; majority (35%) of
them belonged to the age group 26-29 years. This was followed by people in the age
group 22-25 years (28.3%). Thus more than half of the respondents were young. This is
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
28/41
28
good for the study as they represent the new age work force and it is important to
understand their expectations.
5.3 STRENGTH OF PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT IN BANKING
SECTOR
The strength of psychological contract in the banking sector was analyzed by calculating
the mean and standard deviations of the responses received from the bank employees and
the results are analyzed as under:
Table 5.1
Contract Mean Standard Deviation
Transactional 5.88 0.52847
Relational 5.3104 .70068
The mean value of transactional contract is 5.88 while that of relational contract is
5.3104. From the results tabulated; one can imply that in banking sector transactional
contract seems to be stronger than the relational contract. This suggests that in the Indian
banking sector the employees usually are committed to employment arrangement for a
short-term primarily focused on exchange of work in lieu of money with a specific and
definite description of duties and responsibilities and limited involvement in organization.
However; there is not much variation in the means and standard deviations of relational
contract.
5.4 STRENGTH OF PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT IN PUBLIC
SECTOR BANKS
The strength of psychological contract was analyzed separately for the public \sector bank
employees to understand which type of psychological contract is prevalent in the
organization. The analysis was done with the help of mean and standard deviations
calculate from the data collected from the bank employed in both the organizations.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
29/41
29
Table 5.2
Psychological Contract Mean Standard Deviation
Transactional 5.716 0.58821
Relational 5.471 0.90538
From the above analysis, one can imply that though there isnt much variation in the
mean values of transactional and relational contract; but in public sector banks it is the
transactional contract that seems to be stronger than the relational contract. This means
employees have limited involvement with the work they do and work mainly for the
monetary benefits associated with the job. The non-monetary and psychological benefitsare not much important for the public sector employees. Much of this can be attributed to
the culture that exists in the public sector banks in India.
5.5 STRENGTH OF PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTRACT IN PRIVATE
SECTOR BANKS
The strength of psychological contract was analyzed separately for the private sector bank
employees to understand which type of psychological contract is prevalent in the
organization. The analysis was done with the help of mean and standard deviations
calculate from the data collected from the bank employed in both the organizations.
Table 5.3
Psychological Contract Mean Standard Deviation
Transactional 5.15 0.33716Relational 6.05 0.4016
From the above analysis, one can imply that relational contracts are much stronger in
private sector banks than the transactional contracts as can be analyzed from the means
tabulated. There is also much difference in the standard deviation values. This means that
employees in a private sector banks result from long-term employment arrangements
based upon mutual trust and loyalty. Growth in career and remuneration comes mainly
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
30/41
30
from seniority and other benefits and rewards are only loosely related to work
performance. The contract is derived from long term membership and participation in the
organization. Much of this can be attributed to the culture that exists in the private sector
banks in India.
5.6 CORRELATION ANALYSIS BETWEEN PSYCHOLOGICAL
CONTRACT AND HUMAN RESOURCE PRACTICES
The following table explains the correlation analysis conducted between the
psychological contract and the different human resource practices in the organization.
Table 5.4
Contract Human Resource Practices
Hiring T&D PA Pay
Pearson Sig Pearson Sig Pearson Sig Pearson Sig
Transactional .265 .003 .394 .042 .490 .081 .549 .002
Relational .227 .010 .328 .003 137 .004 0.122 .035
Transactional Contract and Hiring Practices
Correlation test was conducted to analyze if there exists any relationship between the
transactional contract and the hiring practices in the organization. In the given situation;
the correlation is positive and the significant value (0.003) is less than 0.05 which
indicates that there is a relationship between the two variables under study.
Transactional Contract and Training & Development Practices
Correlation test was done to analyze if the training and development practices in an
organization can influence the transactional contract. In the given situation, there is a
positive correlation between the two variables and the significant value (0.042) is less
than 0.05 which indicates that there is significant relationship between the two variables
under study.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
31/41
31
Transactional Contract and Performance Appraisal Practices
Correlation test was conducted to analyze if there is any relationship between the
performance appraisal practices and the transactional contract. The above table clearly
indicates that there is a positive correlation between the two variables and the significant
value (0.081) being more than 0.005 shows there is no relationship between the two
components.
Transactional Contract and Pay/Remuneration Practices
The above correlation test shows that there is a positive correlation between the
remuneration practices and the transactional contract. With a significant value of 0.002
the two variables under study are significantly correlated.
Relational Contract and Hiring Practices
The correlation test was done to analyze if there exists any relationship between the
relational contract and hiring practices. The results show that there is a positive
correlation between the two variables and the significant value (0.010) implies that there
is a relationship between the two components under study.
Relational Contract and Training & Development Practices
The above correlation test shows that there exists a positive relationship between the two
variables under study. Also, the significant value (0.03) is less than 0.005 which indicates
that training & development practices influence the relational contract to an extent.
Relational Contract and Performance Appraisal
The above table shows that there is a positive correlation between the performance
appraisal practices and the relational contract between the employee and employer. At a
significant value of 0.004; the two are significantly related to each other.
Relational Contract and Remuneration/Pay
The above correlation analysis shows that there is a positive correlation between the two
variables under study. However, the significant value (0.035) is more than 0.005
indicating that there is no significant relationship between the remunerations practices
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
32/41
32
and the relational contract existing in the organization. Thus, the alternate hypothesis is
rejected and null hypotheses can be accepted.
5.7 REGRESSION ANALYSIS BETWEEN THE PSYCHOLOGICAL
CONTRACT AND HUMAN RESOURCE PRACTICES
The following table explains the regression analysis conducted between the psychological
contract and the different human resource practices in the organization.
Table 5.5
Contract Human Resource Practices
Hiring T&D PA Pay
R Value R Value R Value R Value
Transactional .265 .455 .240 .481
Relational 0.52 .408 .19 .15
Transactional Contract and Hiring Practices
The coefficient of determination is 0.265 which implies that 26.5% of variation in the
dependent variable (transactional contract) is explained in the independent variable
(hiring practices). The percentage is not very high; thus, one can conclude that hiring
practices affect the psychological contract but not to a great extent. As the significance
value is 0.008 it implies that the regression model adopted is significant too as p
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
33/41
33
Transactional Contract and Performance Appraisal Practices
The coefficient of variation is 0.240 indicating that 24% variation in the dependent
variable (transactional contract) is explained in the independent variable (performance
appraisal). The percentage is quite low which means the transactional contract is not
much affected by performance appraisal practices in the organizations. As the
significance value is 0.06 it implies that the regression model adopted is not significant as
p
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
34/41
34
that the regression model adopted is significant as p
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
35/41
35
6.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses in detail the research findings after the analysis and interpretation
of the results achieved from the questionnaire administered. It also discusses the findings
which are not shown in the test followed by suggestions with respect to the topic under
study.
6.2 FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION ON FINDINGS
The major aim of the research was to find out the relationship between psychological
contract and human resource practices in the banking sector organizations. The results
showed that there is a definite relationship between the two variables and the human
resource practices greatly influence the psychological contract. At the same time, there
are few practices which dont really influence the psychological contract between
employee and employer.
1. There exists a relationship between the human resource practices in an organization
and the psychological contract that develops between the employer and the employee.
The extent of dependence however varies from one practice to another.
2. The strength of relational contract is more compared to the transactional contract in
private sector banks. This indicates that a large number of employees prefer long-term
relationship with the organization and not a short-term relationship which is defined
only by monetary gains only.
3. The strength of transactional contract is more compared to relational contract in
public sector banks. This implies that employees in a public sector bank work
primarily for money and believe in fulfilling the short-term goals that come across in
their line of sight. The employees have a narrow set of duties and limited worker
involvement is there in the organization.
4. Amongst the various human resource practices taken for the study; pay/remuneration
has the most significant relationship with the transactional contract. Since
transactional contract is identified mainly with monetary gains and less employee
involvement; the results achieved affirm the hypotheses about the same.
5. Training & Development and Hiring practices also influence the transactional
contract in the organizations though not as great as the pay/remuneration. Also,
performance appraisal has no significant relationship with the transactional contract
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
36/41
36
as the analysis showed. This affirms the fact about transactional contract that
employees are more interested in the pay as its a short term contract and the appraisal
practices might not interest them.
6. In case of relational contract, Training & Development and hiring practices indicate a
strong influence on the contract. Relational contracts are identified with strong
commitment from employees and employees expect employer to provide
opportunities for growth. This is clearly substantiated in the results.
7. However, relational contracts are not much influenced by the remuneration practices.
Interestingly, this is exactly the opposite of transactional contracts where employees
work with their main focus on money. In relational contracts; the employees are not
focused on the monetary rewards alone rather they look for non monetary benefits
also.
8. In public sector banks the strength of transactional contracts is determined by the pay
and hiring practices. The employees in a public sector bank expect the organization to
pay for the amount of work they do and there is not much effort from the employee to
walk an extra mile and do work which has a long-term orientation attached to it.
9. In private sector banks, the strength of relational contracts is determined by the
training and development practices. The employees expect the organization to invest
in the employees overall growth and development and they are ready to walk an
extra mile for the organization of their expectation of growth is fulfilled by the
employer.
10. The human resource practices like remuneration and training & development are
critical for any organization because these form the basis of the unwritten
expectations which an employee has from its employer. An effective and efficient
framework of human resource practices can greatly help in strengthening the
psychological contract between the employer and employees.
6.3 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
a) The study was conducted only in 10 banks operating in Bangalore city.
b) The study focused on random selection of employees from different levels. The
study could have been more specific with focus on only one set of employees.
c) The answers given by the employees might be influenced by their state of mind.
d) It is subject to human errors of judgement.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
37/41
37
6.4 SUGGESTIONS
I. Psychological Contract is still not incorporated extensively in to the terminology
of human resource function in banks. Human resource managers should pay heed
to the unwritten expectations that employee has from the employer and try to fulfil
them within the limits of organization.
II. Human resource managers should lay emphasis on developing an effective and
efficient framework of human resource practices in the banks as they influence the
strength of psychological contracts between the employer and the employee.
III. Hiring practices should be made more transparent and selection of employees
should be fair and based on their competencies. All the promises made to them
while recruitment should be fulfilled. This will ensure that the expectations an
employee forms while joining are met with and psychological contract is
strengthened. The recruitment should be objective and personal biases and errors
should be avoided.
IV. Training and Development is one of the most vital human resource practices that
aids in the development of psychological contract. Today, employees want to be
employable rather than being in a secure hob. They expect the organization to
invest in them so that they can grow and in turn help the organization grow.Therefore, excellent training opportunities should be provided to the employees
for their development and learning.
V. Organizations should conduct a training needs analysis at frequent intervals to
identify the employees who need training. Also, human resource managers should
aim towards creating a learning organization where employees are pushed to learn
new things and improve their key skills and behaviors. This would ensure that
employees stay with the organization for a longer period of time.VI. Remuneration and performance appraisal should be exhaustive and employees
should be awarded according to their competencies and performance and not
because of seniority. A fair system of performance appraisal and pay shall ensure
that employees are paid for the work they perform and this would keep them
content.
VII. As analyzed, public sector banks have transactional contracts stronger than the
relational contracts. This is not the most accepted position as transactional
contracts are identified with lower employee commitment and involvement.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
38/41
38
Public sector banks should lay more emphasis on the human resource practices
aspects and try to develop relational contract with the employees. This would
ensure that the employees are more involved in their work place and contribute
more to the achievement of the strategic goals of the organization.
VIII. Private sector banks according to the study have a stronger relational contract
which is a good thing. However, there is not much variance in the scores. So,
private banks should invest more in their human resource practices and understand
what the employees want from them. This would eventually help in creating a
stronger contract at the work place.
IX. Organizations in general, should try to develop a robust set of human resource
practices at the work place because it will help in creation of stronger relational
contracts which would ensure employees are satisfied at their jobs, fully involved
in the work they do and are committed towards the organization. This aid in
building loyalty and the intentions to quit are also reduced. Thus, there is less
attrition in the organizations leading to more profits and a stable work force.
6.5 SUGGESTIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH
There has been a lot of research on psychological contract; however its relationship with
human resource practices has not been explored much. There have been a few studies
outside India but still there is a colossal scope for research. In India, though the concept
has been explained theoretically in many research papers; no quantitative study analyzing
the relationship between psychological contract and human resource practices. Therefore,
a lot of scope exists with respect to the topic and a lot of other human resource practices
like Communication, Human resource planning can be included in the range of human
resource practices and its relationship with psychological contract.
6.6 CONCLUSION
From the above analysis and interpretation of the results we can conclude that human
resource practices greatly influence the psychological contracts in organizations. In
context with the banking sector; transactional contracts are more prevalent in public
sector banks; whereas; in private sector banks relational contracts are more prevalent.
Much of this can be attributed to the differences in the organizational culture in the two.
Among the various human resource practices considered under the study; training and
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
39/41
39
development, hiring practices and remuneration have a significant relationship with the
psychological contract. To be precise; in case of transactional contracts it is the
remuneration that has the most effect while in case of relational contracts it is the training
and development and the hiring practices which influence the contract.
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
40/41
40
Aggarwal, U., and Bhargava, S. (2008), Reviewing the relationship between
human resource practices and psychological contract and their impact on
employee attitude and behaviors, Journal of European Industrial Training, Vol.
33 No. 1, 2009 pp. 4-31
Guzzo, R. and Noonan, K. (1994), Human resource practices as communications
and the psychological contract, Human Resource Management , 33(3), pp. 44-72.
Rousseau, D. M. (1995), Psychological Contract in Organisation - Written and
Unwritten Agreements , 1st ed. , Sage publication.
Rousseau, D. M and Wade- Benzoni, K. A.(1994), Linking Strategy and Human
Resource Practices: How Employee and Customer Contracts are Created, Human
Resource Management , Fall, Vol. 33, No. 3, pp. 463-489.
Scheepers, C., & Shuping, J. (2011). The effect of human resource practices on
psychological contracts at an iron ore mining company in South Africa. SA
Journal of Human Resource Management/SA Tydskrif vir
Menslikehulpbronbestuur , 9(1), Art. #302, 19 pages. doi:10.4102/sajhrm.v9i1.302
Willems, I., Henderickx, E., Janvier, R. & De Prins, P. (2003b) Psychological
contracts in the Belgian federal civil service . Paper presented at the EGPA
annual conference, Oeiras (Portugal), September 2003.
Wangithi, W. & Muceke, N. (2012). Effect of Human Resource Management
Practices on Psychological Contract in Organizations International Journal of
Business and Social Science, Vol. 3 No. 19
Sheepers, C.,& Shuping, J. (2011). The effect of Human resource practices on
psychological contracts at an iron ore mining company in South Africa. SA
Journal of Human Resource Management 9 (1). 1-19.
Rousseau,D. & Wade-Benzoni,K. (1994). Linking Strategy and HR practices: how
employee and customer contracts are created. Human Resource Management . 33
(3). 463-89.
Guzzo,R. & Noonan,K. (1994). Human resource practices as communications and
the Psychological Contract. Human Resource Management . 33 (3). 447
Suazo,M. Martinez,P. & Sandoval,R. (2011) Creating psychological and legal
contracts through HRM practices. Employ Respons Rights . 23:187 204
-
8/12/2019 Relationship between Psychological Contract & Human Resource Practices
41/41
Turnley, W. and Feldman, D.C. (2000), Re -Examining the Effects of
Psychological Contract Violations: Unmet Expectations and Job Dissatisfaction as
Mediators, Journal of Organizational Behaviour , Vol. 21, No. xx, pp. 25-42.
Millward, L.J. and Hopkins, L. J. (1998), Psychological Contracts,Organizational and Job Commitment, Journal of Applied Psychology , Vol. 28,
Issue 16, pp. 1530-1556.
Rousseau, D.M., & Greller, M. (1994). Human resource practices: Administrative
contract makers. Human Resource Management , 33(3), 372 382. doi:10.1002/
hrm.3930330308
Rousseau, D.M., & Ho, V. (2000). Psychological contract issues in compensation.
In S. Rynes & B. Gerhart (Eds.), Compensation issues in organizations: Current
research and practice . San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Whitener, E.M. (2001). Do high commitment human resource practices affect
employee commitment? A cross-level analysis using hierarchical linear
modelling. Journal of Management , 27 , 515 564.
doi:10.1177/014920630102700502, doi:10.1016/S0149-2063(01)00106-4
Wcke, A., & Sutherland, M. (2008). The impact of employment equity
regulations on psychological contracts in South Africa. International Journal of
Human Resource Management , 19(4), 528 542.