8/20/2019 Rep. Edcel Lagman,Et Al vs Exec. Sec. Ochoa, Et Al GR No. 19306, Dec. 7, 2010

1/2

G.R. No. 193036REP. EDCEL C. LAGMAN, REP. RODOLFO B. ALBANO, JR., REP. SIMEON A.DATUMANONG, and REP. ORLANDO B. FUA, SR.v.E!ECUTI"E SECRETAR# PA$UITO N. OC%OA, JR. and DEPARTMENT OF BUDGETAND MANAGEMENT SECRETAR# FLORENCIO B. ABAD

FACTS&

 To '(an)o(* + -a*a/n o/an, 2n/ 4aan/ -o((', 4aan/*a+(a, '+5 P(5d5n', B5n/no S*5on Ano III, a' '+5 da4n o) +ad*n'(a'on, /n5d on J7 30, 8010 an E5-'v5 O(d5( No. 1 5'a:+n/'+5 P+n5 T('+ Co**on o) 8010 ;T('+ Co**on

8/20/2019 Rep. Edcel Lagman,Et Al vs Exec. Sec. Ochoa, Et Al GR No. 19306, Dec. 7, 2010

2/2

d5*anda:5 and 5n)o(-5a:5, and 'o d5'5(*n5 4+5'+5( o( no' '+5(5 +a :55n a/(av5 o) a:5 o) d-(5'on a*on'n/ 'o a-? o) 5-5 o) (d-'on on '+5a(' o) an7 :(an-+ o( n'(*5n'a'7 o) '+5 /ov5(n*5n'.

%o45v5(, ?5 a*o' a o45( -on)5((5d :7 '+5 Con'''on, '+5 o45(o) Jd-a R5v54 :5-' 'o *'a'on, 'o 4'& ;1< '+5(5 *' :5 an a-'a-a5 o( -on'(ov5(7 -an/ )o( '+5 55(-5 o) d-a o45( ;8< '+5 5(on-+a5n/n/ '+5 a-' *' +av5 a 5(ona and :'an'a n'5(5' n '+5 -a5-+ '+a' +5 +a 'an5d, o( 4 'an, d(5-' n(7 a a (5' o) '5n)o(-5*5n' ;3< '+5 5'on o) -on'''ona'7 *' :5 (a5d a' '+5 5a(5'o:5 oo('n'7 and ;=< '+5 5 o) -on'''ona'7 *' :5 '+5 v5(7 *o'a o) '+5 -a5.

A*on/ a '+55 *'a'on, on7 '+5 5/a 'andn/ o) '+5 5''on5( +a:55n ' a' 5. T+5 -o(' -on(*5d '+a' '+5 5''on5(5/a'o( +ad '+5(5'5 'andn/ 'o -+a5n/5 E5-'v5 O(d5( No. 1 a '+57 a(5 ao45d 'o5'on '+5 vad'7 o) an7 o-a a-'on 4+-+, 'o '+5( *nd, n)(n/5 on '+5((5(o/a'v5 a 5/a'o(. Evd5n'7, '+5 5''on (*a(7 nvo?5 (a'ono) '+5 o45( o) '+5 Con/(5 a a :od7 'o 4+-+ '+57 :5on/ a *5*:5(. T+

-5('an7 '5 '+5( (5ov5 'o 'a?5 '+5 -d/5 )o( Con/(5 a an n'''onand (55n' '+5 -o*an' on '+5 (a'on o) '+5( o45( and (/+' a*5*:5( o) '+5 5/a'(5 :5)o(5 '+5 Co('.