report of psp compliance monitoring and evaluation … · report of psp compliance monitoring,...

LAGOS CENTRAL AM&E REPORT, 2019

1

REPORT OF PSP COMPLIANCE MONITORING AND EVALUATION VISIT TO ISOLO LOCAL GOVERNMENT

AREA ON MONDAY 26TH AUGUST, 2019

OPERATOR/OBSSERVATION RECOMMENDATION/ACTION TAKEN REMARKS

UNIVERSAL CARE LTD, APENA WARD

Operator has four trucks but three are presently active.

Mrs Olaniwun (08039101416) on 22, Akiti Ave attested to once a weekly service.

Jeed Trinity Nur/ Pry Sch Admin on Oseni Laidi street reported operator visited twice in the last (two) 2 months.

Mr Samuel (08127257006) on 20, Femi Orebote disclosed operator have not been seen in month.

Mr Mohammad Mustafa (08033030658) CEO of Moyub Hospital of Hajiya Halima Mohammad close confirmed that operator has not serviced his street in months.

CDA Chairman, Alh F.A Abisiga (08023985244) of 7, Bayo Oyewale street attested to two-three times monthly service by operator. He remarked that operator was now regular due to his position in the community.

Madam Bridget, Civilian Head of the POWA Market Okota confirm operator services are irregular even after paying till end of July 2019.

Mr Lots (08033275239) of His Pride Nur/ Pry sch on Alh Agbeke street opined that no operator comes to cart their waste in years now.

LIST OF SOME STREETS COVERED Akiti Ave, Oseni Laidi, Femi Orebote, Taiwo, Segun Omolale, Hajiya Halima Mohammad cl, Bayo Oyewale, Dele Orisabiyi, Alli Dada, Adesola, Ogunbela, Lateef Aregbe and Alh Agbeke.

The team went to different locations within the ward to interview tenements and ascertain their performance .

Operator should be served warning and compelled to service all tenements within allotted slot.

Operator service not satisfactory and improve on its service delivery.

Operator is functional but partially effective

Operator does not have the capacity to service all the streets in his ward.

Most of the residents

patronize cart pushers.

SAROBOL NIG LTD, OKOTA WARD

Operator has seven trucks, work from Monday to Saturday and covers fifty eight streets.

Mrs Juliet (08061222610) of Baba Ewe street attested weekly operation by operator.

Mr James (08055173681) on 4, Samuel street confirmed that operator services are regular.

LIST OF SOME STREETS COVERED

Baba Ewe, Samuel, Sholape, Apena, Balogun, Ajoke, Enoma, Latunde close and Chief Idowu Rafiu.

Tenements were interviewed at different locations within allotted slot to verify performance of operator.

Residents were encouraged to continue patronizing PSP and desist from using cart pushers.

Operator is on ground and effective.


2

JELOTS O.O NIG LTD, AGO PALACE WAY WARD

Operator has four trucks and covers thirty five streets.

Mrs Blessing (08141210098) on 21, Rabiatu Agbabiaka attested to regular and effective services by operator.

Residents interviewed confirmed operator work weekly and wrote a letter of inconvenience services during the raining period. Operator now working weekly and effective.

LIST OF SOME STREETS COVERED Rabiatu Agbabiaka, Saheed Aregbe, Noble Frank Ahante, Lateef Abamidele, Hakeem Dosumu, Paris Agaro Ave, Oyindamola Shogbesan, Olukayode Awofisayo, Sunday Aghedo.

Residents were encourage by AM&E to continue patronizing PSP and desist from using cart pushers.

Matine Exotic Bar & Restaurant was visited by the AM&E team to stop dumping at an unoccupied building and start patronizing operator .

They however promise to start engaging his services.

Operator is on ground and effective.

PICTORIAL EVIDENCE COMPLIANCE MONITORING AND EVALUATION VISIT TO ISOLO LOCAL

GOVERNMENT AREA ON MONDAY 26TH AUGUST, 2019

AM&E INTERVIEW GATEMAN OF JEED

TRINITY NUR/ PRY SCH AM&E INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF

OSENI LAIDI STREET AM&E INTERVIEW MARKET WOMAN

AT POWA MARKET AM&E INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF

TAIWO STREET

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF SEGUN OMOLOLA STREET, OKOTA.

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF SEGUN OMOLOLA STREET, OKOTA

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF HAJIYA HALIMA MOHAMMOD, OKOTA.

AM&E INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF BABA EWE STREEET

AM&E INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF BALOGUN STREET

AM&E INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF ALLI DADA

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF LATEEF BAMIDELE STREET, OKOTA

BLACK SPOT AT POLICE BARRACK


3

JELOT TRUCK SEEN ON LATEEF BAMIDELE STREET SAMPLE OF BILL ISSUED BY UNIVERSAL CARE LTD.

RECEIPT AND JOB CARD PRESENTED AT JEED TRINITY NUR/ PRY SCH

COMPLIANCE MONITORING AND EVALUATION VISIT TO ITIRE IKATE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA ON

TUESDAY 27TH AUGUST, 2019

OPERATOR/OBSSERVATION RECOMMENDATION/ACTION TAKEN REMARKS

TEE BLACK VENT, BARUWA WARD

Operator has three (3) trucks, work from Monday to Saturday and covers thirty nine streets.

Mr Niyi (080231532285) on 35, Oke Ona street attested to irregular and ineffective operation by operator . Operator visited the street since three weeks ago.

Alhaji Hassan (08023602533) on 48, Odunlami street reported his house don’t give waste to operator due to irregular operation.

Harvester Garden Manager (09093885804) on 10 Aderibigbe street confirmed that operator service the street weekly.

Mr Victor (08056514212) on Ayinda street attested to regular and effective service by operator.

CDA Chairman, Alhaji S.O Ogunneyo (08034694124) on Memudu Baruwa street confirmed regular and weekly service by operator

LIST OF SOME STREETS COVERED Alawode, Aderibigbe, Oladele, Oke-Ona, Odunlami, Aderibigbe, Ayinda, Anjorin, Memudu Baruwa, Ikpoh, Cole, Abayomi, Cole and Baiye street.

Oral warning was given to operator

Residents were encouraged to continue patronizing assigned operator and desist from using cart pushers.

Operator is partially effective.

Few residents employ

the services of cart pushers.


4

FOLA JIMOH ENT, RAMONI WARD

Operator has two trucks, but only one is presently functional,

Covers thirty - five Streets and services each street once a week on Mon-Saturday.

Makes one trip to the dumpsite daily

Operator said compliance level is 20%

Mr James (08055173681) on 4, Samuel Street confirmed that operator services are regular.

Majority of the residents on Idowu, Onibuore and Owoseni streets dump in the canal and other burn their wastes.

A resident reported that House 18 & 20, Owoseni street usually burn their waste a major hazard to the neighborhood.

Residents dump waste at the junction of Olusola Keku Street which has turned to a blackspot.

Operator has difficulty getting paid for services rendered.

Mr Taiwo Jimoh (08029247776) is the Manager and Mrs Folashade Shoaga is the MD of Fola Jimoh Ent.


Zamba I &II, Dayo Ojotiku, Ebenezer, Owoseni, Idowu, Olaitan, Odunlami, Onibuore, Olusol Keku, Saibu Lawal

The AM&E Team intervened on behalf of the Operator by visiting some residences to plead with them to pay for waste collection, a lot of them agreed to begin to comply.

The operator has been complaining about the intransigence of the residents in paying for waste services at Zamba street

Operator is on ground, functional and partially effective.

PICTORIAL EVIDENCE OF COMPLIANCE MONITORING AND EVALUATION VISIT TO ITIRE IKATE LOCAL

GOVERNMENT AREA ON TUESDAY 27TH AUGUST, 2019

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF OKE ONA STREET, AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF ADERIBIGBE STREET,


5

PSP TRUCK FOUND WORKING ON SITE AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF ADERIBIGBE STREET,

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW CDC CHAIRMAN OF MUNIRU BARUWA STREET. AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF OLUSHOLA KEKU STREET.

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF ZAMBA UPPER STREET.

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENTS OF ZAMBA LOWER STREET.

AM&E TEAM SNAPPED THE PICTURE OF A CANAL WITH SO MUCH DIRTS IN IT AND A HOUSE WITH WASTE IN FRONT OF IT.

REPORT OF PSP COMPLIANCE MONITORING, ADVOCACY/SENSTITIZATION TO COKER-AGUDA LCDA

ON WEDNESDAY 28TH AUGUST, 2019

OPERATOR/OBSERVATION RECOMMENDATION/ACTION TAKEN

REMARKS

ROTKAS NIG. LTD, ONIWO WARD Operator has three (3) Trucks and (1) one serves as backup. Operator covers about 60 streets, carries out operation on Monday- Saturday. Operator goes on Sunday if there is backlog and once a week service to each street. Operator makes one or two trips a day to the dump site.

The CEO informed us there was about 85% patronage and 40% payment compliance.

Operator was seen working on Olamosuba Street and have previously worked at Agboyin, Adekunle, Kuye, Koya, Enitan and Rosanwo Streets

The CEO/MD is Engr. Ola Kassim - 08033310265 and Supervisor on duty was Mrs Sarah Animashaun – 08083260878

Streets visited were seen to be in clean state


The AM&E Team went round operator’s ward and interviewed some tenements

There is need for sustained and consistent advocacy/sensitization to improve operator’s revenue generation.

Operator is on ground, functional and effective


6

Ogunlana, Ogunleye, Olamojuba, Eloseh, Koya, Akinyele, Adeshina, Kuye, Enitan, Rosanwo

TAROLA GLOBAL RESOURCES, OSHO WARD

Operator has two Trucks and one of which had engine problem and is under repair since a month ago

Operator carries out operation on Monday – Thursday and clears blackspots / backlog on Friday/Saturday

Operator makes 4-5 trips per week to dumpsite

Operator covers thirty-three streets

Some residents refused to bring their waste to where the truck was parked on Wosila Aina / Disu Esan street. The narrow road and low dropping cables is a major challenge for the operator.

Iya Elero at 25 Wosila Street reported operator has not been seen in five years.

Alhaji Saliu on 8, Wosila informed us about a disagreement with the operator and tenements because prefer operator enters their street . Operator response was not feasible due to the low dropping cable. They have now agreed at a spot where waste can be evacuated.

Mrs Ajagun (08126012653) at 13, Araromi Okeodo spoke glowingly of the operator and are satisfied with its performance. Mr Fatai (09099338881) reiterated Mrs Ajagun opinion.

LIST OF SOME STREETS COVERED Osho, Wosila Aina, Araromi Oke-Odo, Memudu, Disu Esan

Operator has a lot of challenges because a lot of residents are unwilling to pay

There should is a need for consistent and sustained advocacy

Operator is on ground, functional and fairly effective.

Operator can perform

better if residents pay promptly


7

ZULEKHA BINT NOAH, COKER ROAD

Operator covers forty-five Streets and carries out operation on Mon-Friday

Operator has six Trucks, three broke down with PTO and clutch issues within the last week and are under repair . The trucks are expected to be running by tomorrow

Operator makes two trips per day to the dumpsite.

The Manager complained about more time spent at dumpsite which has reduced their turnaround time.

He said there is 20% payment compliance

Madam Oge (08148552385) a shop owner at 31, Sekoni street disclosed that operator comes regularly on Thursdays.

Madam Chosen (08148852496) on 7, Odichie Street and her husband affirmed they were satisfied with operator services.

Mrs Salaudeen Kafayat (08037812195) who lives at 33, Sekinah Street confirmed that operator’s services was satisfactory.

At 1, Catholic Mission Street Mrs Okonkwo (08179499851) confirmed operator comes regularly on Saturday

The manager, Mr Abimbola Sulaiman (08023589261) was on ground with the AM&E Team.

CEO is Alhaja Balogun R.Z (08023382312) LIST OF SOME STREETS COVERED SURULERE AVENUE, IWORO STREET, NIHINILOLUWAWA, YISA OROKI, CATHOLIC MISSION STREET, COKER ROAD, ODICHIE, SEKONI STREETS

Operator should make request for advocacy/sensitization to increase revenue

Operator should ensure that

faulty trucks be fixed as soon as possible to be added to the operational fleets

Operator is on ground, functional and effective

BLACKSPOT Local Authority Primary School, Ile-Iwe Bus-Stop


8

PICTORIAL EVIDENCE OF PSP COMPLIANCE MONITORING, ADVOCACY/SENSTITIZATION TO

COKER-AGUDA LCDA ON WEDNESDAY 28TH AUGUST, 2019

ILLEGAL DUMPING PLACE EVACUATED BY

PSP OPERATOR ROTKAS SEEN WORKING ON

OLAMOJUBA STREET FRONT VIEW OF PSP OPERATOR

ON SITE. KUYE STREET IS FREE OF DIRTS

OLAMOJUBA STREET IS FREE OF DIRTS AKINYELE STREET IS FREE OF

DIRTS CLEAN STATE OF ADESHINA STREET,

OGUNLANA STREET IS FREE OF WASTE. WASTE DUMPED ILLEGALLY ON ORILE IGANMU ROAD.

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENT

OF MEMUDU STREET. AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW

RESIDENT OF WOSILAT STREET. AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF

ARAROMI STREET.

TRUCK OF A PSP OPERATOR CARTING PEOPLE’S WASTE AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW

RESIDENT OF ARAROMI OKE-ODO STREET.

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF SKEKOMI STREET.


9

AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF

CATHOLIC MISSION STREET. AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENT

OF SKEKOMI STREET. AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW

RESIDENT OF SKEKOMI STREET. AM&E TEAM INTERVIEW RESIDENT OF

CATHOLIC MISSION STREET.

REPORT OF PSP COMPLIANCE MONITORING VISIT TO KOSOFE LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA ON

THURSDAY 28TH AUGUST, 2019

OPERATOR/OBSERVATION OBSERVATION/ACTION TAKEN REMARKS

SEMASE NIGERIA LTD, OJOTA WARD Operator has three Trucks and carries out operation on Mon-Saturday. Operator makes two or three trips to the dumpsite daily and covers twenty-eight Streets

Mrs Gbadebo (07087970864) who lives at 11, Olabisi Street told us the last month service has been irregular and that operator truck sometimes do not enter their street.

She said the drainage construction on the street was taking longer than neccessary and why residents park on the street.

Mrs Kazeem Aina (07069500218) on 4, Olabisi Street complained operator do not issue them bill but usually advice them. come to their office for collection. They take their waste to Gbadebo street where the truck is parked . Operator does not enter their street.

Mr Emeka(08069328187) on the same street said he pays promptly and was satisfied with operator’s services.

Mr Lere Atanda (08136884638) & Mr Odujola of 1, Roju Avenue admitted operator service was regular except for when there was a break down.

Mr Emmanuel (07033120589) a Pharmacy Store owner said operator’s services was regular and is satisfied with their performance.

Operator should ring a bell to announce their presence and liaise with Community leaders who we were told are willing to help clear vehicles that are obstructing their operation

Operator should ensure that bills

are issued to residents

Operator should ensure improved and effective services now that their Trucks are up and running

The Supervisor informed us that they have difficulty accessing inside Olabisi street due to double parking.

The Manager confirmed their operation was slow for some weeks due to a breakdown of two of their trucks.

Both engines knocked and one had an accident recently.


10

Mr Thank God (08160715244) at 25, Aina Street informed us of having paid for the entire year. Operator was regular and its service satisfactory to them.

Mrs Adesanya Shola (09058564203) on 22, Olatunji Street confirmed operator’s service was regular.

Mr Luqman (07039553484) on 26, Olatunji complained that operator increased their charges and operation had dwindled in the last three weeks.

Mummy Favour (08136371621) on 33, Kujore Street spoke about the need to acquire more trucks by operator.

Supervisor on duty was Samuel Paulinus (09011180980) and the Manager is Zaiyan Seidu (07064464315)

PICTORIAL EVIDENCE OF PSP COMPLIANCE MONITORING VISIT TO KOSOFE LOCAL GOVERNMENT

AREA ON THURSDAY 28TH AUGUST, 2019

DRAINAGE CONSTRUCTION AND DOUBLE PARKING AT OLABISI STREET, OJOTA


11

REPORT ON A VISIT TO MAKOKO COMMUNITY ON THURSDAY 28TH AUGUST 2019 UNDER THE

YABA LCDA

1.0 ATTENDANCE

Mr .Adedeji Victor LAWMA CENTRAL DISTRICT ASSISTANT DIRECTOR

Mr Ademola Wasiu PROJECT STAFF

Miss Basirat PROJECT STAFF

Mr Fatoki Tayo PROJECT STAFF

Mr Oyeyemi Seun PROJECT STAFF

PSP OPERATOR JERRIMUG

Mr Eniola Rasheed GENERAL MANAGER

Mr Lawal Ramoni Principal Supervisor, Makoko)

Mr Dipo Ogedengbe Principal Supervisor, Iwaya)

MR ADE ADELOJA COMMUNITY REPRESENTATIVE

RESEARCHER

Akshay Gwalani MONDO 4 AFRICA

2.0 BRIEF

An NGO Mondo visited a riverine area Apollo in Makoko with the Assistant Director, and the PSP

Operator ( Jerrimug) assigned to Iwaya and Makoko located at Yaba LCDA.

The researcher feels the environment is not sustainable for human habitation. And driven with passion

to help the community tackle waste in the environment.

The AME DEPT CENTRAL District was contacted for a pre visit inspection before the real clean up

exercise. The cleaning up exercise is on 21st of September, 2019, which coincide with the World

Clean Up Day.

3.0 OBSERVATION


12

The environment has no major Government Developmental Projects

There is over three health centres in the community.

The major occupation of the people is fishing (90%) are into fishing.

They have been inhabiting the community for over 100 years.

The population is over 100,000 people including children.

Business transaction is done on water using boats for transportation.

Major health challenges confronting the community is malaria and typhoid especially during

raining season.

The people are low income earners and mostly are into trade and fishing.

Over 70% population are illiterates and live below poverty level.

The Mondo4 Africa representative request LAWMA provide personnel and trucks for waste

evacuation.

4.0 ACTION TAKEN

The representative of the community was interviewed concerning the cultural values and

beliefs

The team conducted an assessment tour of using boat to move around on the water.

Pictures were taken while on board.

PSP assigned to the area was interviewed if residents pay for waste services.

Mini dump sites were seen on the lagoon in the community.

The researcher has already consulted the community heads in mobilizing support from the

people.

5.0 RECOMMENDATION

Government should resuscitate the marine waste department to mitigate the challenges of

wastes in the riverine communities.

A Lawma intervention was needed to clear the waste of the riverine dwellers

Sustainability of programme should continue by licensing more PSP operators.

Lawma should partner with NGO on sustainable waste management of the riverine area.

There is a need for education and awareness campaign


13

PICTORIAL EVIDENCE OF LAWMA VISIT TO MAKOKO AREA

AM&E Team with PSP operator and NGO Mondo.

AM&E Team with interviewing representative of Apollo community.

AM&E Team member taking picture with a woman of Apollo community.

AM&E Team, PSP operator & NGO Mondo proceeding to the boat side.

Blackspot located on the water body.

AM&E Team on the boat embarking on the

tour. Wooden house on water with waste

litters beneath it. Picture of brackish water.

Trading activities on water. Source of clean water for the community people.


14

A place of worship in the community. Dilapidated school abandoned on water.

House built with blocks on water.

report of psp compliance monitoring and evaluation … · report of psp compliance monitoring,...

Documents