research article electron microscopic studies of ilmenite from...
TRANSCRIPT
Research ArticleElectron Microscopic Studies of Ilmenite from the ChhatrapurCoast Odisha India and Their Implications in Processing
D S Rao1 and D Sengupta2
1 Mineral Processing Department CSIR-Institute of Minerals and Materials Technology Bhubaneswar Odisha 751 013 India2Department of Geology and Geophysics Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur 721 302 India
Correspondence should be addressed to D S Rao drdandasrinivasraogmailcom
Received 2 April 2014 Revised 20 June 2014 Accepted 25 June 2014 Published 15 July 2014
Academic Editor Franco Tassi
Copyright copy 2014 D S Rao and D Sengupta This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons AttributionLicense which permits unrestricted use distribution and reproduction in any medium provided the original work is properlycited
Ilmenite from the Chhatrapur coast Odisha India was studied using optical microscope X-ray diffraction particle size analysisand electron microprobe to decipher their micromorphology texture(s) and elemental composition The micromorphologicalfeatures by electron microscope indicate that weathering processes such as mechanical and chemical affected the placer heavymineral ilmenite These detrital ilmenites contain TiO
2in the range of 5025 to 5541 and FeO 4272 to 4999 in addition
to Al2O3 MgO MnO CaO Na
2O Cr
2O3 NiO ZnO ZrO
2 V2O5 and HfO
2(0 to 0034) Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio in the ilmenite
varied from 0413 to 05 which indicates the effect of weatheringoxidation confirming microscopic observations All the resultsrevealed that these ilmenite grains were derived from the gneissicgranitic basic and high grade metamorphic rocks belonging tothe Eastern Ghats Group of the Precambrian complex of coastal Orissa
1 Introduction
Ilmenite (FeTiO3) an important and the most abundant
ore mineral of titanium occurs in India along the coastalbeach sands of Odisha Andhra Pradesh Tamil Nadu andKerala states One important occurrence in Odisha is in thecoastal stretch over a strike length of 18 kms (covering atotal area of 26Km2) between Gopalpur in the south andconfluence of the Rushikulya river with Bay of Bengal atGanjam in the north [1ndash6] The Indian Rare Earths Limited(IREL) a public sector undertaking of the Departmentof Atomic Energy Government of India is mining andprocessing ilmenite along with other heavy minerals likegarnet monazite rutile sillimanite and zircon from thesesands since 1984 at its Chhatrapur (Matikhalo) plant Severalresearchers have studied the ilmenites from across the worldto assess the provenance from the geochemistry of ilmenites[7ndash11] However no in depth study has been undertakenon the variation in the chemical composition from grainto grain for the Chhatrapur beach placer ilmenites asidefrom some preliminary investigations [12 13] and the workon surface microtextures [14] In view of this the authors
present here a detailed mineral geochemistry (by EPMA)for characterizing the ilmenites from the beach sands ofChhatrapur area Ganjam district Odisha The results havebeen interpreted based on the present study for not onlythe understanding of the provenance of the ilmenites in thisregion but also their effects in processing andor utilization
2 Geology of the Area
The coastal area of Odisha (from Gopalpur to the Mahanadidelta) runs in a NEndashSW direction nearly perpendicularto the strike of the Eastern Ghats rocks The Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit (84∘5410158401015840221015840ndash85∘310158401015840481015840N Lat 19∘1510158401015840ndash19∘26101584010158403610158401015840 E Long) is located in the GanjamDistrict of OrissaState on the southeastern sea coast of India The details ofthe location map are described elsewhere [6] The Orissacoast in general and the Chhatrapur coast in particular areessentially alluvial devoid of any rocky exposures and consistof unsorted fine tomedium grained rounded to subroundedand moderate to well sorted sand [15] mixed to varyingdegrees with heavy ilmenite sillimanite zircon monazite
Hindawi Publishing CorporationJournal of GeochemistryVolume 2014 Article ID 192639 8 pageshttpdxdoiorg1011552014192639
2 Journal of Geochemistry
garnet rutile and pyroxenes as well as amphiboles and light(quartz feldspar) minerals The coast is characterised byextensive formation of dunes [4] that have around 20 of theheavy minerals [2] These dunes are separated by low-lyingareas and interdunal valleys Regionally the area forms a partof the Precambrian (belonging to the Eastern Ghats) complexand includes upper Gondwana laterites Tertiary sedimentsand Quaternary beach placersThe Eastern Ghats mobile beltis one of the oldest groups of rocks in the Indian Peninsula[16]The rocks of this belt are mainly consisting of charnock-ites khondalites granites granodiorites and unclassifiedgranulites The belt shows a fairly consistent trend (NEndashSW) for over 1000 kms from Prakasam District of AndhraPradesh to the southeastern edge of the Talcher coalfield ofOdishaTheEasternGhats aroundChhatrapur in theGanjamDistrict form detached hill ranges that are mainly composedof charnockite khondalite group granites granodioritesand unclassified granulites The charnockite rocks are silicarich with orthopyroxene (hypersthene)-bearing granuliticcomposition whereas khondalite is metasedimentary andcontains a variety of minerals such as sillimanite + garnet plusmngraphite plusmn spinel plusmn cordierite and hypersthene in additionto quartz and K-feldspar (orthoclase) [17 18] Associatedwith these and also included in the khondalite group arethe quartzitesgarnetiferous quartzites liptinites and calc-silicate rocks More or less these Eastern Ghats rock typesform a banded assemblage metamorphosed under granulitefacies conditions and are permeated by quartz-feldsparneosomes [4] Based on the mode of occurrence of differentlithounits along with their structural analysis Rao et al [4]published a stratigraphic succession of the areaThis area liesin a semiarid subtropical climate The main drainage systemof this area is the river Rushikulya (that flows southeasterly)which originates from the highlands of EasternGhat group ofrocks and debouches into the sea at Ganjam Of course manystreams and streamlets (Bahuda and Ghoda Hoda) whichoriginate from the nearby coastal hills also join the sea nearby the Chhatrapur deposit These streams are ephemeral innature and are the major suppliers of the sediments to thisregion
3 Materials and Methods
Concentrated ilmenite sample from Chhatrapur coast wasobtained from the Indian Rare Earths Limited CompanyChhatrapurThe sample was characterized by optical micros-copy X-ray diffraction (XRD) particle size analysis scanningelectron microscopy (SEM) and electron probe microanal-ysis (EPMA) The samples were mounted in epoxy resin(cold mounting) and polished using conventional methodsfor optical and electron microscopic studies The polishedsection of ilmenites was then examined and analysed by aJEOL Super Probe JXA-8600 model electron microprobeoperating along with a current setting of 2 times 10minus8 A and usingStandard Programme International (SPI) mineral standardsand online ZAF correction procedures Particle size analysisof the sample was carried out using laser diffraction analyzer(CILAS-1180 Particle Size Analyzer France make)
Inte
nsity
(cou
nts)
ilmenitepseudorutileP
I
1800
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
010 15 20 25 30 35 40
2120579 (deg)
PI
PI
PI
PI
IPIP
III I I
I
IP
P
PPP
IPIP
I
I
Figure 1 X-ray diffraction pattern of the ilmenite sample
4 Results
41 XRD and Particle Size Analysis Thebulk ilmenite samplewas ground to below 45 microns and subjected to X-raydiffraction The X-ray diffraction of the ilmenite sample(Figure 1) indicates predominantly ilmenite (JCPDS num-ber 29-0733) and minor quantities of pseudorutile (JCPDSnumber 29-1494) Similar observation was also made bySasikumar et al [19] for the ilmenite of this area Thevariation of particle size and particle size distribution isshown in Figure 2 The particle size of the sample variedbetween 004 microns to 600 microns The particle size ofthe sample varies between 100 and 500 microns and 80 ofthe ilmenite is around 200 microns The mean particle sizeis 17514 microns Ilmenite in this deposit is fine to mediumgrained and moderately well sorted to well sorted and showsunimodal distribution and fine to coarsely skewed Based onthe particle size and perfection of roundness it can be statedthat the ilmenite from this locality is texturally matured
42 Optical Microscopy Reflected light microscopic studiesof this ilmenite sample indicate that ilmenite is the majorphase withminor amounts of hematiteThe quantity (volumepercentage) of hematite in the sample is too low for whichhematite peaks were not observed in the X-ray diffrac-tion pattern The ilmenite occurs mostly as subroundedto subangular grains marked by numerous surface pitsetch marksgrooves crescentic pits and mesh-like patternsSometimes ilmenite contains exsolved laths streaks andirregular bodies of hematite Similarly hematite also containsexsolved bodies of ilmenite which may be laths fine streaksand as patches Ilmenite-hematite intergrowth also gives riseto emulsion texture and seriate texture The alteration of thegrains has occasionally resulted in an amorphous to cryp-tocrystalline to microcrystalline mass resembling leucoxene(Figure 3) and pseudorutile Leucoxene and anatase occur aspatches along the margins and fractures of ilmenite whichis due to alteration of ilmenite The alteration characteristics
Journal of Geochemistry 3
0
20
40
60
80
100
Particle size (microns)
Cum
ulat
ive v
alue
()
minus100 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 8000
Figure 2 Particle size analysis of the ilmenite concentrate sample
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
50120583
Figure 3 Mineralogical and textural features of ilmenite takenunder reflected light Note the various sizes and shapes of theilmenite grains and some of the grains are also fresh while some arealtered (a) The ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur Deposit showingthe rows of subparallel pits left by leaching out of the hematiteexsolution lamellae (b) The alteration along grain boundaries (c)along fractures of ilmenite (d) Patchy leucoxene is observed bycomplete alteration of ilmenite
of the ilmenite from this area were studied in detail in [420] Rao et al [4] concluded that the alteration leads toenrichment of TiO
2 MgO Al
2O3 Cr2O3 SiO2 K2O V2O5
BaO CaO and Na2O with loss of FeO MnO and ZnOThey
further advocated that the alteration products could be dueto the exogenic processes that operated on these ilmenitesafter their release from the parent rocks of the Eastern Ghatscomplex
43 Scanning Electron Microscopy Micromorphologicalstudies of ilmenite from the study area by SEM depict thedevelopment of a number of microfeatures on the ilmenitegrains The ilmenite grains of this area exhibit subroundedto rounded shape (Figures 4(b) 4(d) and 5(a)) along withimpact ldquoVrdquo marks and deep pits are seen resulting frommechanical collision and later from solution activity (Figures4(c) 5(b) and 5(d)) Mechanical features like V-shaped pitssuggest that grains are formed by grain to grain collision inan aquatic environment [21] Even the crescentic structures
pits as well as sets of grooves (Figures 5(c) and 6(c)) ori-ented either in same different directions or in differentdirections might have developed by the effects of solutionactivity Undulatory wavy surfaces formed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks were also observed on theseilmenite grains (Figures 4(c) and 5(d)) The present studyof micromorphological features by electron microscopeestablishes the fact that two types of weathering processessuch as mechanical and chemical affected the placer heavymineral ilmenite that operated during their transportationas well as after deposition
44 Mineral Chemistry The mineral chemistry of ilmenitewas determined by EPMA spot analysis The major andminor elemental composition analyses of the ilmenite fromthis deposit are given in Table 1 along with the structuralformulae and end member compositions The TiO
2content
of the ilmenite from this deposit varies from 5025 to55411 which is comparatively lower or higher than thetheoretical ilmenite 5275 [22] Higher TiO
2may be due
to leaching of other cations Lower TiO2could be due to
the presence of hematite exsolved with ilmenite Sukumaranand Nambiar [7] reported 50 to 56 of TiO
2from the
ilmenites of Ratnagiri coast of Maharashtra which is wellcomparable with the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coastTheminorvariations could be due to the source rock basis The FeOcontent of the ilmenite from this deposit varies from 42719to 49987 The large range of FeO in the ilmenite couldbe due to hematite exsolved with in ilmenite Ilmenite fromthe Honnavar beach is having 50 to 5633 TiO
2and 41
to 4689 FeO [8] The result presented here is broadly inagreement with those of Hegde et al [8] The MnO contentof ilmenite in this deposit varies from 0125 to 0579whiletheMgO content varies from 0069 to 1357The presence ofsignificant amounts of manganese and magnesium indicatesthat the ilmenite of Chhatrapur constitutes a solid solutionseries with pyrophanite and geikielite respectively [23] As aresult of these solid solutions the TiO
2content of the ilmenite
is higher or lower than the ideal value Significant amountsof V2O5(0247 to 0306) Al
2O3(0 to 0087) Cr
2O3(0
to 0089) NiO (0 to 0051) ZnO (0 to 0233) CaO (0 to0061) and Na
2O (0 to 019) were also detected in these
ilmenite grains K2Oand SiO
2were analysed but not detected
in any of these grains However these grains contain traceamounts of ZrO
2(0 to 0036) and HfO
2(0 to 0034) in
their crystal lattice which is reported here for the first time
5 Discussion and Conclusions
The chemical composition (particularly TiO2concentration)
of the ilmenites can be compared with that of the igneousand metamorphic ilmenites to identify the possible sourcerocks [10 11 24] The igneous ilmenites show a widevariation of TiO
2concentrations (42ndash52) whereas the
ilmenite compositions derived from metamorphic sourceshave a mean value of about 51 TiO
2 These Chhatra-
pur ilmenites have titanium dioxide concentration rang-ing from 5025 to 5541 and are well comparable to
4 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 4 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) general view of the ilmenite concentrate (b) roundedto subrounded grains of ilmenite and (c and d) rounded to subrounded edges of angular grains of ilmenite with flat surface indicating longdistance transportation of the sediments
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 5 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) rounded grains being pitted and fractured along a lineardirection which could be due to mechanical collision of grains (b) Deposition of foreign materials along the fractures as well as grooves ofthe ilmenite grains (c and d) Platy grains having been leached out leaving behind pitsgroves
Journal of Geochemistry 5
Table1EP
MAresults
(inwt
)ofvarious
ilmenite
grains
from
theC
hhatrapu
rcoast
12
34
56
78
910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
Al 2O
30061
0001
0036
008
0087
0028
0007
004
60036
0008
0038
0031
0028
0019
0005
0057
0062
0011
004
FeO
44368
45242
45877
44638
45053
4576
846
394
42719
4532
94535
547691
49987
44685
43729
45301
46781
45387
4453
945935
4710
9MgO
0959
0185
0375
066
60659
017
0512
0248
0951
0225
0071
1254
0707
1357
0554
0429
0863
0729
0069
0399
MnO
0281
028
0202
022
0205
0283
0477
0346
0244
0294
0579
041
0286
0125
0493
0161
0501
0177
0147
0206
CaO
00
00018
00013
00061
0019
0021
000
60014
0007
00002
0005
00
0003
0013
Na 2O
00071
00
00
0003
0023
001
0056
0005
0000
40012
000
9019
0223
0026
0039
TiO
253708
5374
153114
55094
53503
53231
51488
55411
52455
53027
5025
45665
53282
54656
52228
5215
352683
53933
53883
51574
Cr2O
30041
0018
0043
0016
0023
004
80033
0025
0025
008
0028
0054
0019
0015
0053
0036
0089
0017
0004
8NiO
00
00
00
00
0003
00028
00023
0034
00013
00
00051
ZnO
0164
00008
00
0049
0038
0041
000
90
0021
00016
0233
0004
40
00031
0ZrO
20
00012
00012
00016
00
0036
00
000
90011
0035
00
001
0011
0028
HfO
20
00015
00003
00034
0033
0026
00
00
00
0021
0029
00
002
V2O
50292
029
0286
0294
0293
0287
0284
0306
0287
0287
0273
0247
0289
0295
0284
0286
0276
0295
0296
0279
Total
99874
99828
99968
1010
399
838
99877
99279
99283
99404
99417
98955
97719
99354
10049
98981
99943
10008
99985
10041
99806
TiTi+
Fe0483
0478
0472
0488
0478
0473
0461
0500
0472
0474
044
80413
0479
0491
0471
0462
0472
0483
0475
0458
Basedon
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
Al
00036
000021
000
4600051
00016
0000
4100027
00022
000
0500023
00018
00016
00012
000
0300034
00036
000
0600024
Fe18
524
18978
19269
18373
18862
19245
19752
17695
19123
19142
20545
22158
18799
18053
19236
19758
19035
18575
19188
19976
Mg
00714
00139
00281
004
8900492
00127
00389
00183
00715
00169
00054
0099
0053
00999
004
200323
006
4500054
00057
00301
Mn
00119
00119
00086
000
9200087
0012
00206
00145
00104
00126
00253
00184
00122
00052
00212
000
6900213
00075
000
6200088
Ca0
00
000
090
000
070
00032
0001
00011
000
03000
08000
040
000
01000
030
0000
02000
07Na
0000
690
00
0000
0300022
0001
00055
000052
0000
0400012
000
0900185
00215
00025
00038
Ti20165
20272
200
6120392
20143
20128
19713
20825
199
20125
1946
618
203
20157
20291
19943
19808
19868
20227
2024
1966
6Cr
00016
000
0700017
000
06000
0900019
00013
0001
0001
00033
00011
00023
000
08000
0600021
00014
00035
000
070
00019
Ni
00
00
00
00
000
010
00012
0000
0900013
0000
050
00
00021
Zn000
60
000
030
000018
00014
00015
000
030
000
080
000
0600085
000017
00
00011
0Zr
00
000
030
000
030
000
040
0000
090
0000
02000
03000
090
0000
02000
03000
07Hf
00
000
020
00
000
05000
05000
040
00
00
0000
03000
040
0000
03V
00117
00117
00115
00116
00118
00116
00116
00122
00116
00116
00113
00105
00116
00117
00116
00116
00111
00118
00118
00114
Total
397
51397
01398
5839523
39765
397
9640215
390
95400
23398
08404
741746
397
71396
39399
8240128
4013
393
09397
1240264
Endmem
ber
compo
sition
Pyroph
anite
06148
06186
0438
04854
044
7506156
10124
08045
05215
064
8212
133
07886
06272
02722
1067
03424
10707
040
103211
04321
Gaekelite
36886
07226
1431
25799
25307
06515
19118
10154
35854
08695
0259
42431
27248
52293
2114
1603
32423
02898
02952
1478
Ilmenite
95697
98659
9813
196935
97022
98733
97076
9818
95893
98482
9852
894968
96648
94499
96819
98055
95687
99309
99384
9809
6 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 6 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) Step like wavy surface feature developed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks (b) Crescentic structures and pits produced by solution activities (c) Porouspitted surface developed by solutionactivities (d) Flaky porous and corroded surface developed due to chemical weathering appearing
the metamorphic ilmenites The TiO2concentration of the
present ilmenite suggests that the ilmenites were formed ina high grade metamorphic environment such as granulitefacies metamorphic rocks The granulite facies metamor-phic rocks include charnockites khondalites (quartzitesgar-netiferous quartzites quartz-granulites quartz-garnet-silli-manite-graphite-schist liptinites and calc-silicate rocks)granites pegmatites granodiorites and unclassified gran-ulites Asmentioned earlier the geology of the catchment areaof Rushikulya river and Chhatrapur is dominantly consti-tuted of the Eastern Ghat group of rock types Hence theEastern Ghat group of rocks appears to be the major sourcefor the ilmenite Outcrops of igneous intrusive rocks in theEastern Ghat group also suggest that the ilmenites wereformed in a high grade metamorphic environment [25]
The wide ranges of the V2O5(0247 to 0306) Cr
2O3
(0 to 0089) and NiO (0 to 0051) content indicates that theilmenites from this area represent an admixture ofmultiple ofsource rock types Elevated abundances of these siderophileelements in the Chhatrapur ilmenite suggest that basicrocks like pyroxene granulites along with metasedimentaryrocks like khondalite and charnockite which are present inabundance in the Eastern Ghats complex of Orissa are alsothe source rocks
The present study on beach sand ilmenite of Chhatrapurcoast is restricted only on a concentrate sample drawn fromIREL and hence it could be assumed to be amixture of recent
and older sediments as well as from a near and distant sourcebased on microscopic electron microscopic and availableliterature Mineralogical studies by optical as well as electronmicroscope on the ilmenite from this deposit revealed thatthese grains heave been subjected to chemical weatheringgiving rise to altered rims Chhatrapur ilmenite has under-gone least weathering compared to the ilmenite from beachsands of Kerala and Tamil Nadu [26] Sasikumar et al [27]have reported that the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast has 90ilmenite and 10 altered ilmenite Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio has alsobeen considered as an important parameter for estimation ofalteration of ilmenites The common process involved in thealteration of ilmenite is hydration and conversion of ilmeniteinto pseudorutile that has Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio between 05 to 06[8] This is due to the leaching of iron The observed ratio ofTi(Ti + Fe) for ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast (0413 to 0500)is comparable to that of the ilmenites from the Honnavarcoast [8]
From microscopic as well as from electron microprobestudies it can be inferred that the ilmenite from the Chhatra-pur coast fall under three different typesThese are as follows
(a) Unaltered ilmenite ilmenites without any sign ofalteration They are fresh and compact (Figures 4(b)4(c) and 5(c))
(b) Moderately altered ilmenite ilmenite grains whichshow signatures of alteration along grain boundariesor fracture planes (Figures 3 5(a) 5(b) and 5(d))
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
2 Journal of Geochemistry
garnet rutile and pyroxenes as well as amphiboles and light(quartz feldspar) minerals The coast is characterised byextensive formation of dunes [4] that have around 20 of theheavy minerals [2] These dunes are separated by low-lyingareas and interdunal valleys Regionally the area forms a partof the Precambrian (belonging to the Eastern Ghats) complexand includes upper Gondwana laterites Tertiary sedimentsand Quaternary beach placersThe Eastern Ghats mobile beltis one of the oldest groups of rocks in the Indian Peninsula[16]The rocks of this belt are mainly consisting of charnock-ites khondalites granites granodiorites and unclassifiedgranulites The belt shows a fairly consistent trend (NEndashSW) for over 1000 kms from Prakasam District of AndhraPradesh to the southeastern edge of the Talcher coalfield ofOdishaTheEasternGhats aroundChhatrapur in theGanjamDistrict form detached hill ranges that are mainly composedof charnockite khondalite group granites granodioritesand unclassified granulites The charnockite rocks are silicarich with orthopyroxene (hypersthene)-bearing granuliticcomposition whereas khondalite is metasedimentary andcontains a variety of minerals such as sillimanite + garnet plusmngraphite plusmn spinel plusmn cordierite and hypersthene in additionto quartz and K-feldspar (orthoclase) [17 18] Associatedwith these and also included in the khondalite group arethe quartzitesgarnetiferous quartzites liptinites and calc-silicate rocks More or less these Eastern Ghats rock typesform a banded assemblage metamorphosed under granulitefacies conditions and are permeated by quartz-feldsparneosomes [4] Based on the mode of occurrence of differentlithounits along with their structural analysis Rao et al [4]published a stratigraphic succession of the areaThis area liesin a semiarid subtropical climate The main drainage systemof this area is the river Rushikulya (that flows southeasterly)which originates from the highlands of EasternGhat group ofrocks and debouches into the sea at Ganjam Of course manystreams and streamlets (Bahuda and Ghoda Hoda) whichoriginate from the nearby coastal hills also join the sea nearby the Chhatrapur deposit These streams are ephemeral innature and are the major suppliers of the sediments to thisregion
3 Materials and Methods
Concentrated ilmenite sample from Chhatrapur coast wasobtained from the Indian Rare Earths Limited CompanyChhatrapurThe sample was characterized by optical micros-copy X-ray diffraction (XRD) particle size analysis scanningelectron microscopy (SEM) and electron probe microanal-ysis (EPMA) The samples were mounted in epoxy resin(cold mounting) and polished using conventional methodsfor optical and electron microscopic studies The polishedsection of ilmenites was then examined and analysed by aJEOL Super Probe JXA-8600 model electron microprobeoperating along with a current setting of 2 times 10minus8 A and usingStandard Programme International (SPI) mineral standardsand online ZAF correction procedures Particle size analysisof the sample was carried out using laser diffraction analyzer(CILAS-1180 Particle Size Analyzer France make)
Inte
nsity
(cou
nts)
ilmenitepseudorutileP
I
1800
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
010 15 20 25 30 35 40
2120579 (deg)
PI
PI
PI
PI
IPIP
III I I
I
IP
P
PPP
IPIP
I
I
Figure 1 X-ray diffraction pattern of the ilmenite sample
4 Results
41 XRD and Particle Size Analysis Thebulk ilmenite samplewas ground to below 45 microns and subjected to X-raydiffraction The X-ray diffraction of the ilmenite sample(Figure 1) indicates predominantly ilmenite (JCPDS num-ber 29-0733) and minor quantities of pseudorutile (JCPDSnumber 29-1494) Similar observation was also made bySasikumar et al [19] for the ilmenite of this area Thevariation of particle size and particle size distribution isshown in Figure 2 The particle size of the sample variedbetween 004 microns to 600 microns The particle size ofthe sample varies between 100 and 500 microns and 80 ofthe ilmenite is around 200 microns The mean particle sizeis 17514 microns Ilmenite in this deposit is fine to mediumgrained and moderately well sorted to well sorted and showsunimodal distribution and fine to coarsely skewed Based onthe particle size and perfection of roundness it can be statedthat the ilmenite from this locality is texturally matured
42 Optical Microscopy Reflected light microscopic studiesof this ilmenite sample indicate that ilmenite is the majorphase withminor amounts of hematiteThe quantity (volumepercentage) of hematite in the sample is too low for whichhematite peaks were not observed in the X-ray diffrac-tion pattern The ilmenite occurs mostly as subroundedto subangular grains marked by numerous surface pitsetch marksgrooves crescentic pits and mesh-like patternsSometimes ilmenite contains exsolved laths streaks andirregular bodies of hematite Similarly hematite also containsexsolved bodies of ilmenite which may be laths fine streaksand as patches Ilmenite-hematite intergrowth also gives riseto emulsion texture and seriate texture The alteration of thegrains has occasionally resulted in an amorphous to cryp-tocrystalline to microcrystalline mass resembling leucoxene(Figure 3) and pseudorutile Leucoxene and anatase occur aspatches along the margins and fractures of ilmenite whichis due to alteration of ilmenite The alteration characteristics
Journal of Geochemistry 3
0
20
40
60
80
100
Particle size (microns)
Cum
ulat
ive v
alue
()
minus100 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 8000
Figure 2 Particle size analysis of the ilmenite concentrate sample
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
50120583
Figure 3 Mineralogical and textural features of ilmenite takenunder reflected light Note the various sizes and shapes of theilmenite grains and some of the grains are also fresh while some arealtered (a) The ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur Deposit showingthe rows of subparallel pits left by leaching out of the hematiteexsolution lamellae (b) The alteration along grain boundaries (c)along fractures of ilmenite (d) Patchy leucoxene is observed bycomplete alteration of ilmenite
of the ilmenite from this area were studied in detail in [420] Rao et al [4] concluded that the alteration leads toenrichment of TiO
2 MgO Al
2O3 Cr2O3 SiO2 K2O V2O5
BaO CaO and Na2O with loss of FeO MnO and ZnOThey
further advocated that the alteration products could be dueto the exogenic processes that operated on these ilmenitesafter their release from the parent rocks of the Eastern Ghatscomplex
43 Scanning Electron Microscopy Micromorphologicalstudies of ilmenite from the study area by SEM depict thedevelopment of a number of microfeatures on the ilmenitegrains The ilmenite grains of this area exhibit subroundedto rounded shape (Figures 4(b) 4(d) and 5(a)) along withimpact ldquoVrdquo marks and deep pits are seen resulting frommechanical collision and later from solution activity (Figures4(c) 5(b) and 5(d)) Mechanical features like V-shaped pitssuggest that grains are formed by grain to grain collision inan aquatic environment [21] Even the crescentic structures
pits as well as sets of grooves (Figures 5(c) and 6(c)) ori-ented either in same different directions or in differentdirections might have developed by the effects of solutionactivity Undulatory wavy surfaces formed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks were also observed on theseilmenite grains (Figures 4(c) and 5(d)) The present studyof micromorphological features by electron microscopeestablishes the fact that two types of weathering processessuch as mechanical and chemical affected the placer heavymineral ilmenite that operated during their transportationas well as after deposition
44 Mineral Chemistry The mineral chemistry of ilmenitewas determined by EPMA spot analysis The major andminor elemental composition analyses of the ilmenite fromthis deposit are given in Table 1 along with the structuralformulae and end member compositions The TiO
2content
of the ilmenite from this deposit varies from 5025 to55411 which is comparatively lower or higher than thetheoretical ilmenite 5275 [22] Higher TiO
2may be due
to leaching of other cations Lower TiO2could be due to
the presence of hematite exsolved with ilmenite Sukumaranand Nambiar [7] reported 50 to 56 of TiO
2from the
ilmenites of Ratnagiri coast of Maharashtra which is wellcomparable with the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coastTheminorvariations could be due to the source rock basis The FeOcontent of the ilmenite from this deposit varies from 42719to 49987 The large range of FeO in the ilmenite couldbe due to hematite exsolved with in ilmenite Ilmenite fromthe Honnavar beach is having 50 to 5633 TiO
2and 41
to 4689 FeO [8] The result presented here is broadly inagreement with those of Hegde et al [8] The MnO contentof ilmenite in this deposit varies from 0125 to 0579whiletheMgO content varies from 0069 to 1357The presence ofsignificant amounts of manganese and magnesium indicatesthat the ilmenite of Chhatrapur constitutes a solid solutionseries with pyrophanite and geikielite respectively [23] As aresult of these solid solutions the TiO
2content of the ilmenite
is higher or lower than the ideal value Significant amountsof V2O5(0247 to 0306) Al
2O3(0 to 0087) Cr
2O3(0
to 0089) NiO (0 to 0051) ZnO (0 to 0233) CaO (0 to0061) and Na
2O (0 to 019) were also detected in these
ilmenite grains K2Oand SiO
2were analysed but not detected
in any of these grains However these grains contain traceamounts of ZrO
2(0 to 0036) and HfO
2(0 to 0034) in
their crystal lattice which is reported here for the first time
5 Discussion and Conclusions
The chemical composition (particularly TiO2concentration)
of the ilmenites can be compared with that of the igneousand metamorphic ilmenites to identify the possible sourcerocks [10 11 24] The igneous ilmenites show a widevariation of TiO
2concentrations (42ndash52) whereas the
ilmenite compositions derived from metamorphic sourceshave a mean value of about 51 TiO
2 These Chhatra-
pur ilmenites have titanium dioxide concentration rang-ing from 5025 to 5541 and are well comparable to
4 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 4 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) general view of the ilmenite concentrate (b) roundedto subrounded grains of ilmenite and (c and d) rounded to subrounded edges of angular grains of ilmenite with flat surface indicating longdistance transportation of the sediments
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 5 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) rounded grains being pitted and fractured along a lineardirection which could be due to mechanical collision of grains (b) Deposition of foreign materials along the fractures as well as grooves ofthe ilmenite grains (c and d) Platy grains having been leached out leaving behind pitsgroves
Journal of Geochemistry 5
Table1EP
MAresults
(inwt
)ofvarious
ilmenite
grains
from
theC
hhatrapu
rcoast
12
34
56
78
910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
Al 2O
30061
0001
0036
008
0087
0028
0007
004
60036
0008
0038
0031
0028
0019
0005
0057
0062
0011
004
FeO
44368
45242
45877
44638
45053
4576
846
394
42719
4532
94535
547691
49987
44685
43729
45301
46781
45387
4453
945935
4710
9MgO
0959
0185
0375
066
60659
017
0512
0248
0951
0225
0071
1254
0707
1357
0554
0429
0863
0729
0069
0399
MnO
0281
028
0202
022
0205
0283
0477
0346
0244
0294
0579
041
0286
0125
0493
0161
0501
0177
0147
0206
CaO
00
00018
00013
00061
0019
0021
000
60014
0007
00002
0005
00
0003
0013
Na 2O
00071
00
00
0003
0023
001
0056
0005
0000
40012
000
9019
0223
0026
0039
TiO
253708
5374
153114
55094
53503
53231
51488
55411
52455
53027
5025
45665
53282
54656
52228
5215
352683
53933
53883
51574
Cr2O
30041
0018
0043
0016
0023
004
80033
0025
0025
008
0028
0054
0019
0015
0053
0036
0089
0017
0004
8NiO
00
00
00
00
0003
00028
00023
0034
00013
00
00051
ZnO
0164
00008
00
0049
0038
0041
000
90
0021
00016
0233
0004
40
00031
0ZrO
20
00012
00012
00016
00
0036
00
000
90011
0035
00
001
0011
0028
HfO
20
00015
00003
00034
0033
0026
00
00
00
0021
0029
00
002
V2O
50292
029
0286
0294
0293
0287
0284
0306
0287
0287
0273
0247
0289
0295
0284
0286
0276
0295
0296
0279
Total
99874
99828
99968
1010
399
838
99877
99279
99283
99404
99417
98955
97719
99354
10049
98981
99943
10008
99985
10041
99806
TiTi+
Fe0483
0478
0472
0488
0478
0473
0461
0500
0472
0474
044
80413
0479
0491
0471
0462
0472
0483
0475
0458
Basedon
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
Al
00036
000021
000
4600051
00016
0000
4100027
00022
000
0500023
00018
00016
00012
000
0300034
00036
000
0600024
Fe18
524
18978
19269
18373
18862
19245
19752
17695
19123
19142
20545
22158
18799
18053
19236
19758
19035
18575
19188
19976
Mg
00714
00139
00281
004
8900492
00127
00389
00183
00715
00169
00054
0099
0053
00999
004
200323
006
4500054
00057
00301
Mn
00119
00119
00086
000
9200087
0012
00206
00145
00104
00126
00253
00184
00122
00052
00212
000
6900213
00075
000
6200088
Ca0
00
000
090
000
070
00032
0001
00011
000
03000
08000
040
000
01000
030
0000
02000
07Na
0000
690
00
0000
0300022
0001
00055
000052
0000
0400012
000
0900185
00215
00025
00038
Ti20165
20272
200
6120392
20143
20128
19713
20825
199
20125
1946
618
203
20157
20291
19943
19808
19868
20227
2024
1966
6Cr
00016
000
0700017
000
06000
0900019
00013
0001
0001
00033
00011
00023
000
08000
0600021
00014
00035
000
070
00019
Ni
00
00
00
00
000
010
00012
0000
0900013
0000
050
00
00021
Zn000
60
000
030
000018
00014
00015
000
030
000
080
000
0600085
000017
00
00011
0Zr
00
000
030
000
030
000
040
0000
090
0000
02000
03000
090
0000
02000
03000
07Hf
00
000
020
00
000
05000
05000
040
00
00
0000
03000
040
0000
03V
00117
00117
00115
00116
00118
00116
00116
00122
00116
00116
00113
00105
00116
00117
00116
00116
00111
00118
00118
00114
Total
397
51397
01398
5839523
39765
397
9640215
390
95400
23398
08404
741746
397
71396
39399
8240128
4013
393
09397
1240264
Endmem
ber
compo
sition
Pyroph
anite
06148
06186
0438
04854
044
7506156
10124
08045
05215
064
8212
133
07886
06272
02722
1067
03424
10707
040
103211
04321
Gaekelite
36886
07226
1431
25799
25307
06515
19118
10154
35854
08695
0259
42431
27248
52293
2114
1603
32423
02898
02952
1478
Ilmenite
95697
98659
9813
196935
97022
98733
97076
9818
95893
98482
9852
894968
96648
94499
96819
98055
95687
99309
99384
9809
6 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 6 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) Step like wavy surface feature developed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks (b) Crescentic structures and pits produced by solution activities (c) Porouspitted surface developed by solutionactivities (d) Flaky porous and corroded surface developed due to chemical weathering appearing
the metamorphic ilmenites The TiO2concentration of the
present ilmenite suggests that the ilmenites were formed ina high grade metamorphic environment such as granulitefacies metamorphic rocks The granulite facies metamor-phic rocks include charnockites khondalites (quartzitesgar-netiferous quartzites quartz-granulites quartz-garnet-silli-manite-graphite-schist liptinites and calc-silicate rocks)granites pegmatites granodiorites and unclassified gran-ulites Asmentioned earlier the geology of the catchment areaof Rushikulya river and Chhatrapur is dominantly consti-tuted of the Eastern Ghat group of rock types Hence theEastern Ghat group of rocks appears to be the major sourcefor the ilmenite Outcrops of igneous intrusive rocks in theEastern Ghat group also suggest that the ilmenites wereformed in a high grade metamorphic environment [25]
The wide ranges of the V2O5(0247 to 0306) Cr
2O3
(0 to 0089) and NiO (0 to 0051) content indicates that theilmenites from this area represent an admixture ofmultiple ofsource rock types Elevated abundances of these siderophileelements in the Chhatrapur ilmenite suggest that basicrocks like pyroxene granulites along with metasedimentaryrocks like khondalite and charnockite which are present inabundance in the Eastern Ghats complex of Orissa are alsothe source rocks
The present study on beach sand ilmenite of Chhatrapurcoast is restricted only on a concentrate sample drawn fromIREL and hence it could be assumed to be amixture of recent
and older sediments as well as from a near and distant sourcebased on microscopic electron microscopic and availableliterature Mineralogical studies by optical as well as electronmicroscope on the ilmenite from this deposit revealed thatthese grains heave been subjected to chemical weatheringgiving rise to altered rims Chhatrapur ilmenite has under-gone least weathering compared to the ilmenite from beachsands of Kerala and Tamil Nadu [26] Sasikumar et al [27]have reported that the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast has 90ilmenite and 10 altered ilmenite Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio has alsobeen considered as an important parameter for estimation ofalteration of ilmenites The common process involved in thealteration of ilmenite is hydration and conversion of ilmeniteinto pseudorutile that has Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio between 05 to 06[8] This is due to the leaching of iron The observed ratio ofTi(Ti + Fe) for ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast (0413 to 0500)is comparable to that of the ilmenites from the Honnavarcoast [8]
From microscopic as well as from electron microprobestudies it can be inferred that the ilmenite from the Chhatra-pur coast fall under three different typesThese are as follows
(a) Unaltered ilmenite ilmenites without any sign ofalteration They are fresh and compact (Figures 4(b)4(c) and 5(c))
(b) Moderately altered ilmenite ilmenite grains whichshow signatures of alteration along grain boundariesor fracture planes (Figures 3 5(a) 5(b) and 5(d))
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
Journal of Geochemistry 3
0
20
40
60
80
100
Particle size (microns)
Cum
ulat
ive v
alue
()
minus100 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 8000
Figure 2 Particle size analysis of the ilmenite concentrate sample
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
50120583
Figure 3 Mineralogical and textural features of ilmenite takenunder reflected light Note the various sizes and shapes of theilmenite grains and some of the grains are also fresh while some arealtered (a) The ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur Deposit showingthe rows of subparallel pits left by leaching out of the hematiteexsolution lamellae (b) The alteration along grain boundaries (c)along fractures of ilmenite (d) Patchy leucoxene is observed bycomplete alteration of ilmenite
of the ilmenite from this area were studied in detail in [420] Rao et al [4] concluded that the alteration leads toenrichment of TiO
2 MgO Al
2O3 Cr2O3 SiO2 K2O V2O5
BaO CaO and Na2O with loss of FeO MnO and ZnOThey
further advocated that the alteration products could be dueto the exogenic processes that operated on these ilmenitesafter their release from the parent rocks of the Eastern Ghatscomplex
43 Scanning Electron Microscopy Micromorphologicalstudies of ilmenite from the study area by SEM depict thedevelopment of a number of microfeatures on the ilmenitegrains The ilmenite grains of this area exhibit subroundedto rounded shape (Figures 4(b) 4(d) and 5(a)) along withimpact ldquoVrdquo marks and deep pits are seen resulting frommechanical collision and later from solution activity (Figures4(c) 5(b) and 5(d)) Mechanical features like V-shaped pitssuggest that grains are formed by grain to grain collision inan aquatic environment [21] Even the crescentic structures
pits as well as sets of grooves (Figures 5(c) and 6(c)) ori-ented either in same different directions or in differentdirections might have developed by the effects of solutionactivity Undulatory wavy surfaces formed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks were also observed on theseilmenite grains (Figures 4(c) and 5(d)) The present studyof micromorphological features by electron microscopeestablishes the fact that two types of weathering processessuch as mechanical and chemical affected the placer heavymineral ilmenite that operated during their transportationas well as after deposition
44 Mineral Chemistry The mineral chemistry of ilmenitewas determined by EPMA spot analysis The major andminor elemental composition analyses of the ilmenite fromthis deposit are given in Table 1 along with the structuralformulae and end member compositions The TiO
2content
of the ilmenite from this deposit varies from 5025 to55411 which is comparatively lower or higher than thetheoretical ilmenite 5275 [22] Higher TiO
2may be due
to leaching of other cations Lower TiO2could be due to
the presence of hematite exsolved with ilmenite Sukumaranand Nambiar [7] reported 50 to 56 of TiO
2from the
ilmenites of Ratnagiri coast of Maharashtra which is wellcomparable with the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coastTheminorvariations could be due to the source rock basis The FeOcontent of the ilmenite from this deposit varies from 42719to 49987 The large range of FeO in the ilmenite couldbe due to hematite exsolved with in ilmenite Ilmenite fromthe Honnavar beach is having 50 to 5633 TiO
2and 41
to 4689 FeO [8] The result presented here is broadly inagreement with those of Hegde et al [8] The MnO contentof ilmenite in this deposit varies from 0125 to 0579whiletheMgO content varies from 0069 to 1357The presence ofsignificant amounts of manganese and magnesium indicatesthat the ilmenite of Chhatrapur constitutes a solid solutionseries with pyrophanite and geikielite respectively [23] As aresult of these solid solutions the TiO
2content of the ilmenite
is higher or lower than the ideal value Significant amountsof V2O5(0247 to 0306) Al
2O3(0 to 0087) Cr
2O3(0
to 0089) NiO (0 to 0051) ZnO (0 to 0233) CaO (0 to0061) and Na
2O (0 to 019) were also detected in these
ilmenite grains K2Oand SiO
2were analysed but not detected
in any of these grains However these grains contain traceamounts of ZrO
2(0 to 0036) and HfO
2(0 to 0034) in
their crystal lattice which is reported here for the first time
5 Discussion and Conclusions
The chemical composition (particularly TiO2concentration)
of the ilmenites can be compared with that of the igneousand metamorphic ilmenites to identify the possible sourcerocks [10 11 24] The igneous ilmenites show a widevariation of TiO
2concentrations (42ndash52) whereas the
ilmenite compositions derived from metamorphic sourceshave a mean value of about 51 TiO
2 These Chhatra-
pur ilmenites have titanium dioxide concentration rang-ing from 5025 to 5541 and are well comparable to
4 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 4 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) general view of the ilmenite concentrate (b) roundedto subrounded grains of ilmenite and (c and d) rounded to subrounded edges of angular grains of ilmenite with flat surface indicating longdistance transportation of the sediments
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 5 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) rounded grains being pitted and fractured along a lineardirection which could be due to mechanical collision of grains (b) Deposition of foreign materials along the fractures as well as grooves ofthe ilmenite grains (c and d) Platy grains having been leached out leaving behind pitsgroves
Journal of Geochemistry 5
Table1EP
MAresults
(inwt
)ofvarious
ilmenite
grains
from
theC
hhatrapu
rcoast
12
34
56
78
910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
Al 2O
30061
0001
0036
008
0087
0028
0007
004
60036
0008
0038
0031
0028
0019
0005
0057
0062
0011
004
FeO
44368
45242
45877
44638
45053
4576
846
394
42719
4532
94535
547691
49987
44685
43729
45301
46781
45387
4453
945935
4710
9MgO
0959
0185
0375
066
60659
017
0512
0248
0951
0225
0071
1254
0707
1357
0554
0429
0863
0729
0069
0399
MnO
0281
028
0202
022
0205
0283
0477
0346
0244
0294
0579
041
0286
0125
0493
0161
0501
0177
0147
0206
CaO
00
00018
00013
00061
0019
0021
000
60014
0007
00002
0005
00
0003
0013
Na 2O
00071
00
00
0003
0023
001
0056
0005
0000
40012
000
9019
0223
0026
0039
TiO
253708
5374
153114
55094
53503
53231
51488
55411
52455
53027
5025
45665
53282
54656
52228
5215
352683
53933
53883
51574
Cr2O
30041
0018
0043
0016
0023
004
80033
0025
0025
008
0028
0054
0019
0015
0053
0036
0089
0017
0004
8NiO
00
00
00
00
0003
00028
00023
0034
00013
00
00051
ZnO
0164
00008
00
0049
0038
0041
000
90
0021
00016
0233
0004
40
00031
0ZrO
20
00012
00012
00016
00
0036
00
000
90011
0035
00
001
0011
0028
HfO
20
00015
00003
00034
0033
0026
00
00
00
0021
0029
00
002
V2O
50292
029
0286
0294
0293
0287
0284
0306
0287
0287
0273
0247
0289
0295
0284
0286
0276
0295
0296
0279
Total
99874
99828
99968
1010
399
838
99877
99279
99283
99404
99417
98955
97719
99354
10049
98981
99943
10008
99985
10041
99806
TiTi+
Fe0483
0478
0472
0488
0478
0473
0461
0500
0472
0474
044
80413
0479
0491
0471
0462
0472
0483
0475
0458
Basedon
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
Al
00036
000021
000
4600051
00016
0000
4100027
00022
000
0500023
00018
00016
00012
000
0300034
00036
000
0600024
Fe18
524
18978
19269
18373
18862
19245
19752
17695
19123
19142
20545
22158
18799
18053
19236
19758
19035
18575
19188
19976
Mg
00714
00139
00281
004
8900492
00127
00389
00183
00715
00169
00054
0099
0053
00999
004
200323
006
4500054
00057
00301
Mn
00119
00119
00086
000
9200087
0012
00206
00145
00104
00126
00253
00184
00122
00052
00212
000
6900213
00075
000
6200088
Ca0
00
000
090
000
070
00032
0001
00011
000
03000
08000
040
000
01000
030
0000
02000
07Na
0000
690
00
0000
0300022
0001
00055
000052
0000
0400012
000
0900185
00215
00025
00038
Ti20165
20272
200
6120392
20143
20128
19713
20825
199
20125
1946
618
203
20157
20291
19943
19808
19868
20227
2024
1966
6Cr
00016
000
0700017
000
06000
0900019
00013
0001
0001
00033
00011
00023
000
08000
0600021
00014
00035
000
070
00019
Ni
00
00
00
00
000
010
00012
0000
0900013
0000
050
00
00021
Zn000
60
000
030
000018
00014
00015
000
030
000
080
000
0600085
000017
00
00011
0Zr
00
000
030
000
030
000
040
0000
090
0000
02000
03000
090
0000
02000
03000
07Hf
00
000
020
00
000
05000
05000
040
00
00
0000
03000
040
0000
03V
00117
00117
00115
00116
00118
00116
00116
00122
00116
00116
00113
00105
00116
00117
00116
00116
00111
00118
00118
00114
Total
397
51397
01398
5839523
39765
397
9640215
390
95400
23398
08404
741746
397
71396
39399
8240128
4013
393
09397
1240264
Endmem
ber
compo
sition
Pyroph
anite
06148
06186
0438
04854
044
7506156
10124
08045
05215
064
8212
133
07886
06272
02722
1067
03424
10707
040
103211
04321
Gaekelite
36886
07226
1431
25799
25307
06515
19118
10154
35854
08695
0259
42431
27248
52293
2114
1603
32423
02898
02952
1478
Ilmenite
95697
98659
9813
196935
97022
98733
97076
9818
95893
98482
9852
894968
96648
94499
96819
98055
95687
99309
99384
9809
6 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 6 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) Step like wavy surface feature developed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks (b) Crescentic structures and pits produced by solution activities (c) Porouspitted surface developed by solutionactivities (d) Flaky porous and corroded surface developed due to chemical weathering appearing
the metamorphic ilmenites The TiO2concentration of the
present ilmenite suggests that the ilmenites were formed ina high grade metamorphic environment such as granulitefacies metamorphic rocks The granulite facies metamor-phic rocks include charnockites khondalites (quartzitesgar-netiferous quartzites quartz-granulites quartz-garnet-silli-manite-graphite-schist liptinites and calc-silicate rocks)granites pegmatites granodiorites and unclassified gran-ulites Asmentioned earlier the geology of the catchment areaof Rushikulya river and Chhatrapur is dominantly consti-tuted of the Eastern Ghat group of rock types Hence theEastern Ghat group of rocks appears to be the major sourcefor the ilmenite Outcrops of igneous intrusive rocks in theEastern Ghat group also suggest that the ilmenites wereformed in a high grade metamorphic environment [25]
The wide ranges of the V2O5(0247 to 0306) Cr
2O3
(0 to 0089) and NiO (0 to 0051) content indicates that theilmenites from this area represent an admixture ofmultiple ofsource rock types Elevated abundances of these siderophileelements in the Chhatrapur ilmenite suggest that basicrocks like pyroxene granulites along with metasedimentaryrocks like khondalite and charnockite which are present inabundance in the Eastern Ghats complex of Orissa are alsothe source rocks
The present study on beach sand ilmenite of Chhatrapurcoast is restricted only on a concentrate sample drawn fromIREL and hence it could be assumed to be amixture of recent
and older sediments as well as from a near and distant sourcebased on microscopic electron microscopic and availableliterature Mineralogical studies by optical as well as electronmicroscope on the ilmenite from this deposit revealed thatthese grains heave been subjected to chemical weatheringgiving rise to altered rims Chhatrapur ilmenite has under-gone least weathering compared to the ilmenite from beachsands of Kerala and Tamil Nadu [26] Sasikumar et al [27]have reported that the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast has 90ilmenite and 10 altered ilmenite Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio has alsobeen considered as an important parameter for estimation ofalteration of ilmenites The common process involved in thealteration of ilmenite is hydration and conversion of ilmeniteinto pseudorutile that has Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio between 05 to 06[8] This is due to the leaching of iron The observed ratio ofTi(Ti + Fe) for ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast (0413 to 0500)is comparable to that of the ilmenites from the Honnavarcoast [8]
From microscopic as well as from electron microprobestudies it can be inferred that the ilmenite from the Chhatra-pur coast fall under three different typesThese are as follows
(a) Unaltered ilmenite ilmenites without any sign ofalteration They are fresh and compact (Figures 4(b)4(c) and 5(c))
(b) Moderately altered ilmenite ilmenite grains whichshow signatures of alteration along grain boundariesor fracture planes (Figures 3 5(a) 5(b) and 5(d))
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
4 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 4 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) general view of the ilmenite concentrate (b) roundedto subrounded grains of ilmenite and (c and d) rounded to subrounded edges of angular grains of ilmenite with flat surface indicating longdistance transportation of the sediments
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 5 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) rounded grains being pitted and fractured along a lineardirection which could be due to mechanical collision of grains (b) Deposition of foreign materials along the fractures as well as grooves ofthe ilmenite grains (c and d) Platy grains having been leached out leaving behind pitsgroves
Journal of Geochemistry 5
Table1EP
MAresults
(inwt
)ofvarious
ilmenite
grains
from
theC
hhatrapu
rcoast
12
34
56
78
910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
Al 2O
30061
0001
0036
008
0087
0028
0007
004
60036
0008
0038
0031
0028
0019
0005
0057
0062
0011
004
FeO
44368
45242
45877
44638
45053
4576
846
394
42719
4532
94535
547691
49987
44685
43729
45301
46781
45387
4453
945935
4710
9MgO
0959
0185
0375
066
60659
017
0512
0248
0951
0225
0071
1254
0707
1357
0554
0429
0863
0729
0069
0399
MnO
0281
028
0202
022
0205
0283
0477
0346
0244
0294
0579
041
0286
0125
0493
0161
0501
0177
0147
0206
CaO
00
00018
00013
00061
0019
0021
000
60014
0007
00002
0005
00
0003
0013
Na 2O
00071
00
00
0003
0023
001
0056
0005
0000
40012
000
9019
0223
0026
0039
TiO
253708
5374
153114
55094
53503
53231
51488
55411
52455
53027
5025
45665
53282
54656
52228
5215
352683
53933
53883
51574
Cr2O
30041
0018
0043
0016
0023
004
80033
0025
0025
008
0028
0054
0019
0015
0053
0036
0089
0017
0004
8NiO
00
00
00
00
0003
00028
00023
0034
00013
00
00051
ZnO
0164
00008
00
0049
0038
0041
000
90
0021
00016
0233
0004
40
00031
0ZrO
20
00012
00012
00016
00
0036
00
000
90011
0035
00
001
0011
0028
HfO
20
00015
00003
00034
0033
0026
00
00
00
0021
0029
00
002
V2O
50292
029
0286
0294
0293
0287
0284
0306
0287
0287
0273
0247
0289
0295
0284
0286
0276
0295
0296
0279
Total
99874
99828
99968
1010
399
838
99877
99279
99283
99404
99417
98955
97719
99354
10049
98981
99943
10008
99985
10041
99806
TiTi+
Fe0483
0478
0472
0488
0478
0473
0461
0500
0472
0474
044
80413
0479
0491
0471
0462
0472
0483
0475
0458
Basedon
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
Al
00036
000021
000
4600051
00016
0000
4100027
00022
000
0500023
00018
00016
00012
000
0300034
00036
000
0600024
Fe18
524
18978
19269
18373
18862
19245
19752
17695
19123
19142
20545
22158
18799
18053
19236
19758
19035
18575
19188
19976
Mg
00714
00139
00281
004
8900492
00127
00389
00183
00715
00169
00054
0099
0053
00999
004
200323
006
4500054
00057
00301
Mn
00119
00119
00086
000
9200087
0012
00206
00145
00104
00126
00253
00184
00122
00052
00212
000
6900213
00075
000
6200088
Ca0
00
000
090
000
070
00032
0001
00011
000
03000
08000
040
000
01000
030
0000
02000
07Na
0000
690
00
0000
0300022
0001
00055
000052
0000
0400012
000
0900185
00215
00025
00038
Ti20165
20272
200
6120392
20143
20128
19713
20825
199
20125
1946
618
203
20157
20291
19943
19808
19868
20227
2024
1966
6Cr
00016
000
0700017
000
06000
0900019
00013
0001
0001
00033
00011
00023
000
08000
0600021
00014
00035
000
070
00019
Ni
00
00
00
00
000
010
00012
0000
0900013
0000
050
00
00021
Zn000
60
000
030
000018
00014
00015
000
030
000
080
000
0600085
000017
00
00011
0Zr
00
000
030
000
030
000
040
0000
090
0000
02000
03000
090
0000
02000
03000
07Hf
00
000
020
00
000
05000
05000
040
00
00
0000
03000
040
0000
03V
00117
00117
00115
00116
00118
00116
00116
00122
00116
00116
00113
00105
00116
00117
00116
00116
00111
00118
00118
00114
Total
397
51397
01398
5839523
39765
397
9640215
390
95400
23398
08404
741746
397
71396
39399
8240128
4013
393
09397
1240264
Endmem
ber
compo
sition
Pyroph
anite
06148
06186
0438
04854
044
7506156
10124
08045
05215
064
8212
133
07886
06272
02722
1067
03424
10707
040
103211
04321
Gaekelite
36886
07226
1431
25799
25307
06515
19118
10154
35854
08695
0259
42431
27248
52293
2114
1603
32423
02898
02952
1478
Ilmenite
95697
98659
9813
196935
97022
98733
97076
9818
95893
98482
9852
894968
96648
94499
96819
98055
95687
99309
99384
9809
6 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 6 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) Step like wavy surface feature developed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks (b) Crescentic structures and pits produced by solution activities (c) Porouspitted surface developed by solutionactivities (d) Flaky porous and corroded surface developed due to chemical weathering appearing
the metamorphic ilmenites The TiO2concentration of the
present ilmenite suggests that the ilmenites were formed ina high grade metamorphic environment such as granulitefacies metamorphic rocks The granulite facies metamor-phic rocks include charnockites khondalites (quartzitesgar-netiferous quartzites quartz-granulites quartz-garnet-silli-manite-graphite-schist liptinites and calc-silicate rocks)granites pegmatites granodiorites and unclassified gran-ulites Asmentioned earlier the geology of the catchment areaof Rushikulya river and Chhatrapur is dominantly consti-tuted of the Eastern Ghat group of rock types Hence theEastern Ghat group of rocks appears to be the major sourcefor the ilmenite Outcrops of igneous intrusive rocks in theEastern Ghat group also suggest that the ilmenites wereformed in a high grade metamorphic environment [25]
The wide ranges of the V2O5(0247 to 0306) Cr
2O3
(0 to 0089) and NiO (0 to 0051) content indicates that theilmenites from this area represent an admixture ofmultiple ofsource rock types Elevated abundances of these siderophileelements in the Chhatrapur ilmenite suggest that basicrocks like pyroxene granulites along with metasedimentaryrocks like khondalite and charnockite which are present inabundance in the Eastern Ghats complex of Orissa are alsothe source rocks
The present study on beach sand ilmenite of Chhatrapurcoast is restricted only on a concentrate sample drawn fromIREL and hence it could be assumed to be amixture of recent
and older sediments as well as from a near and distant sourcebased on microscopic electron microscopic and availableliterature Mineralogical studies by optical as well as electronmicroscope on the ilmenite from this deposit revealed thatthese grains heave been subjected to chemical weatheringgiving rise to altered rims Chhatrapur ilmenite has under-gone least weathering compared to the ilmenite from beachsands of Kerala and Tamil Nadu [26] Sasikumar et al [27]have reported that the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast has 90ilmenite and 10 altered ilmenite Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio has alsobeen considered as an important parameter for estimation ofalteration of ilmenites The common process involved in thealteration of ilmenite is hydration and conversion of ilmeniteinto pseudorutile that has Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio between 05 to 06[8] This is due to the leaching of iron The observed ratio ofTi(Ti + Fe) for ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast (0413 to 0500)is comparable to that of the ilmenites from the Honnavarcoast [8]
From microscopic as well as from electron microprobestudies it can be inferred that the ilmenite from the Chhatra-pur coast fall under three different typesThese are as follows
(a) Unaltered ilmenite ilmenites without any sign ofalteration They are fresh and compact (Figures 4(b)4(c) and 5(c))
(b) Moderately altered ilmenite ilmenite grains whichshow signatures of alteration along grain boundariesor fracture planes (Figures 3 5(a) 5(b) and 5(d))
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
Journal of Geochemistry 5
Table1EP
MAresults
(inwt
)ofvarious
ilmenite
grains
from
theC
hhatrapu
rcoast
12
34
56
78
910
1112
1314
1516
1718
1920
Al 2O
30061
0001
0036
008
0087
0028
0007
004
60036
0008
0038
0031
0028
0019
0005
0057
0062
0011
004
FeO
44368
45242
45877
44638
45053
4576
846
394
42719
4532
94535
547691
49987
44685
43729
45301
46781
45387
4453
945935
4710
9MgO
0959
0185
0375
066
60659
017
0512
0248
0951
0225
0071
1254
0707
1357
0554
0429
0863
0729
0069
0399
MnO
0281
028
0202
022
0205
0283
0477
0346
0244
0294
0579
041
0286
0125
0493
0161
0501
0177
0147
0206
CaO
00
00018
00013
00061
0019
0021
000
60014
0007
00002
0005
00
0003
0013
Na 2O
00071
00
00
0003
0023
001
0056
0005
0000
40012
000
9019
0223
0026
0039
TiO
253708
5374
153114
55094
53503
53231
51488
55411
52455
53027
5025
45665
53282
54656
52228
5215
352683
53933
53883
51574
Cr2O
30041
0018
0043
0016
0023
004
80033
0025
0025
008
0028
0054
0019
0015
0053
0036
0089
0017
0004
8NiO
00
00
00
00
0003
00028
00023
0034
00013
00
00051
ZnO
0164
00008
00
0049
0038
0041
000
90
0021
00016
0233
0004
40
00031
0ZrO
20
00012
00012
00016
00
0036
00
000
90011
0035
00
001
0011
0028
HfO
20
00015
00003
00034
0033
0026
00
00
00
0021
0029
00
002
V2O
50292
029
0286
0294
0293
0287
0284
0306
0287
0287
0273
0247
0289
0295
0284
0286
0276
0295
0296
0279
Total
99874
99828
99968
1010
399
838
99877
99279
99283
99404
99417
98955
97719
99354
10049
98981
99943
10008
99985
10041
99806
TiTi+
Fe0483
0478
0472
0488
0478
0473
0461
0500
0472
0474
044
80413
0479
0491
0471
0462
0472
0483
0475
0458
Basedon
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
6(O)
Al
00036
000021
000
4600051
00016
0000
4100027
00022
000
0500023
00018
00016
00012
000
0300034
00036
000
0600024
Fe18
524
18978
19269
18373
18862
19245
19752
17695
19123
19142
20545
22158
18799
18053
19236
19758
19035
18575
19188
19976
Mg
00714
00139
00281
004
8900492
00127
00389
00183
00715
00169
00054
0099
0053
00999
004
200323
006
4500054
00057
00301
Mn
00119
00119
00086
000
9200087
0012
00206
00145
00104
00126
00253
00184
00122
00052
00212
000
6900213
00075
000
6200088
Ca0
00
000
090
000
070
00032
0001
00011
000
03000
08000
040
000
01000
030
0000
02000
07Na
0000
690
00
0000
0300022
0001
00055
000052
0000
0400012
000
0900185
00215
00025
00038
Ti20165
20272
200
6120392
20143
20128
19713
20825
199
20125
1946
618
203
20157
20291
19943
19808
19868
20227
2024
1966
6Cr
00016
000
0700017
000
06000
0900019
00013
0001
0001
00033
00011
00023
000
08000
0600021
00014
00035
000
070
00019
Ni
00
00
00
00
000
010
00012
0000
0900013
0000
050
00
00021
Zn000
60
000
030
000018
00014
00015
000
030
000
080
000
0600085
000017
00
00011
0Zr
00
000
030
000
030
000
040
0000
090
0000
02000
03000
090
0000
02000
03000
07Hf
00
000
020
00
000
05000
05000
040
00
00
0000
03000
040
0000
03V
00117
00117
00115
00116
00118
00116
00116
00122
00116
00116
00113
00105
00116
00117
00116
00116
00111
00118
00118
00114
Total
397
51397
01398
5839523
39765
397
9640215
390
95400
23398
08404
741746
397
71396
39399
8240128
4013
393
09397
1240264
Endmem
ber
compo
sition
Pyroph
anite
06148
06186
0438
04854
044
7506156
10124
08045
05215
064
8212
133
07886
06272
02722
1067
03424
10707
040
103211
04321
Gaekelite
36886
07226
1431
25799
25307
06515
19118
10154
35854
08695
0259
42431
27248
52293
2114
1603
32423
02898
02952
1478
Ilmenite
95697
98659
9813
196935
97022
98733
97076
9818
95893
98482
9852
894968
96648
94499
96819
98055
95687
99309
99384
9809
6 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 6 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) Step like wavy surface feature developed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks (b) Crescentic structures and pits produced by solution activities (c) Porouspitted surface developed by solutionactivities (d) Flaky porous and corroded surface developed due to chemical weathering appearing
the metamorphic ilmenites The TiO2concentration of the
present ilmenite suggests that the ilmenites were formed ina high grade metamorphic environment such as granulitefacies metamorphic rocks The granulite facies metamor-phic rocks include charnockites khondalites (quartzitesgar-netiferous quartzites quartz-granulites quartz-garnet-silli-manite-graphite-schist liptinites and calc-silicate rocks)granites pegmatites granodiorites and unclassified gran-ulites Asmentioned earlier the geology of the catchment areaof Rushikulya river and Chhatrapur is dominantly consti-tuted of the Eastern Ghat group of rock types Hence theEastern Ghat group of rocks appears to be the major sourcefor the ilmenite Outcrops of igneous intrusive rocks in theEastern Ghat group also suggest that the ilmenites wereformed in a high grade metamorphic environment [25]
The wide ranges of the V2O5(0247 to 0306) Cr
2O3
(0 to 0089) and NiO (0 to 0051) content indicates that theilmenites from this area represent an admixture ofmultiple ofsource rock types Elevated abundances of these siderophileelements in the Chhatrapur ilmenite suggest that basicrocks like pyroxene granulites along with metasedimentaryrocks like khondalite and charnockite which are present inabundance in the Eastern Ghats complex of Orissa are alsothe source rocks
The present study on beach sand ilmenite of Chhatrapurcoast is restricted only on a concentrate sample drawn fromIREL and hence it could be assumed to be amixture of recent
and older sediments as well as from a near and distant sourcebased on microscopic electron microscopic and availableliterature Mineralogical studies by optical as well as electronmicroscope on the ilmenite from this deposit revealed thatthese grains heave been subjected to chemical weatheringgiving rise to altered rims Chhatrapur ilmenite has under-gone least weathering compared to the ilmenite from beachsands of Kerala and Tamil Nadu [26] Sasikumar et al [27]have reported that the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast has 90ilmenite and 10 altered ilmenite Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio has alsobeen considered as an important parameter for estimation ofalteration of ilmenites The common process involved in thealteration of ilmenite is hydration and conversion of ilmeniteinto pseudorutile that has Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio between 05 to 06[8] This is due to the leaching of iron The observed ratio ofTi(Ti + Fe) for ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast (0413 to 0500)is comparable to that of the ilmenites from the Honnavarcoast [8]
From microscopic as well as from electron microprobestudies it can be inferred that the ilmenite from the Chhatra-pur coast fall under three different typesThese are as follows
(a) Unaltered ilmenite ilmenites without any sign ofalteration They are fresh and compact (Figures 4(b)4(c) and 5(c))
(b) Moderately altered ilmenite ilmenite grains whichshow signatures of alteration along grain boundariesor fracture planes (Figures 3 5(a) 5(b) and 5(d))
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
6 Journal of Geochemistry
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 6 Micromorphological studies of ilmenite grains from Chhatrapur area (a) Step like wavy surface feature developed due to solutioneffect and removal of blocks (b) Crescentic structures and pits produced by solution activities (c) Porouspitted surface developed by solutionactivities (d) Flaky porous and corroded surface developed due to chemical weathering appearing
the metamorphic ilmenites The TiO2concentration of the
present ilmenite suggests that the ilmenites were formed ina high grade metamorphic environment such as granulitefacies metamorphic rocks The granulite facies metamor-phic rocks include charnockites khondalites (quartzitesgar-netiferous quartzites quartz-granulites quartz-garnet-silli-manite-graphite-schist liptinites and calc-silicate rocks)granites pegmatites granodiorites and unclassified gran-ulites Asmentioned earlier the geology of the catchment areaof Rushikulya river and Chhatrapur is dominantly consti-tuted of the Eastern Ghat group of rock types Hence theEastern Ghat group of rocks appears to be the major sourcefor the ilmenite Outcrops of igneous intrusive rocks in theEastern Ghat group also suggest that the ilmenites wereformed in a high grade metamorphic environment [25]
The wide ranges of the V2O5(0247 to 0306) Cr
2O3
(0 to 0089) and NiO (0 to 0051) content indicates that theilmenites from this area represent an admixture ofmultiple ofsource rock types Elevated abundances of these siderophileelements in the Chhatrapur ilmenite suggest that basicrocks like pyroxene granulites along with metasedimentaryrocks like khondalite and charnockite which are present inabundance in the Eastern Ghats complex of Orissa are alsothe source rocks
The present study on beach sand ilmenite of Chhatrapurcoast is restricted only on a concentrate sample drawn fromIREL and hence it could be assumed to be amixture of recent
and older sediments as well as from a near and distant sourcebased on microscopic electron microscopic and availableliterature Mineralogical studies by optical as well as electronmicroscope on the ilmenite from this deposit revealed thatthese grains heave been subjected to chemical weatheringgiving rise to altered rims Chhatrapur ilmenite has under-gone least weathering compared to the ilmenite from beachsands of Kerala and Tamil Nadu [26] Sasikumar et al [27]have reported that the ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast has 90ilmenite and 10 altered ilmenite Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio has alsobeen considered as an important parameter for estimation ofalteration of ilmenites The common process involved in thealteration of ilmenite is hydration and conversion of ilmeniteinto pseudorutile that has Ti(Ti + Fe) ratio between 05 to 06[8] This is due to the leaching of iron The observed ratio ofTi(Ti + Fe) for ilmenite of Chhatrapur coast (0413 to 0500)is comparable to that of the ilmenites from the Honnavarcoast [8]
From microscopic as well as from electron microprobestudies it can be inferred that the ilmenite from the Chhatra-pur coast fall under three different typesThese are as follows
(a) Unaltered ilmenite ilmenites without any sign ofalteration They are fresh and compact (Figures 4(b)4(c) and 5(c))
(b) Moderately altered ilmenite ilmenite grains whichshow signatures of alteration along grain boundariesor fracture planes (Figures 3 5(a) 5(b) and 5(d))
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
Journal of Geochemistry 7
(c) Highly altered ilmenite ilmenite grain is completelyaffected by alteration leading to leucoxene (Figure 3)and forming porous structure (Figures 6(c) and 6(d))often associated with foreign materials along thefractures and grooves (Figures 5(b) 6(b) and 6(c))Sasikumar et al [27] have reported that the ilmeniteof Chhatrapur coast has 90 ilmenite and 10 alteredilmenite
From the above studies it can be concluded that theEastern Ghats group of rocks consists of khondalite suite ofrocks (consisting of garnetiferous quartz-sillimanite schistsgneisses garnetiferous quartzites quartz granulites calc-silicate rocks and quartz- sillimanite-graphite schists) char-nockite suite of rocks (tonalitic and granodioritic varietiesin composition as well as pyroxene granulites) and leptynitebesides intrusive granites pegmatites quartz veins and othermetasediments which appears to be the major source of theChhatrapur beach placer for the heavymineral assemblage ingeneral and ilmenite in particular
6 Implications in Metallurgical Processing
The Ilmenites are the major heavy mineral of the totalheavy mineral assemblage at Chhatrapur coast The physicaland chemical properties of the ilmenites vary drasticallywith respect to their alteration Considering the magneticconducting and density properties used during separationof heavy minerals one from the other it is obvious thatthe altered as well as unaltered ilmenites behave differentlyUnaltered ilmenite has a higher specific gravity and a betterelectrostatic and magnetic response than the iron poorer andtitanium richer altered ilmenite Coexistence of unaltered-altered ilmenite and presence of leucoxene in the sample needto be identified and quantified undermicroscope as they havedirect bearing on separation Since the degree of weatheringor alteration can be an indicator of its economic value com-positional characterisation by such integrated instrumentaltechniques would not only help to adopt better methodsfor industrial processing but also facilitate the production ofdifferent grades of synthetic rutile
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interestsregarding the publication of this paper
Acknowledgments
The authors are indebted to Indian Rare Earths LimitedChhatrapur Institute Instrumentation Centre of IIT Roor-kee for providing the sample and EPMA respectivelyThanks are also due for the permission of the Director ofCSIR-IMMT Bhubaneswar to publish this paper
References
[1] Indian Minerals Yearbook (Part-II) ILMENITE amp RUTILEIndian Bureau of Mines Nagpur India 50th edition 2011
[2] T K Mukherjee ldquoMining and processing of titanium mineralsin Indiardquo Metals Materials and Processes vol 10 pp 85ndash981998
[3] R G Rao P Sahoo and N K Panda ldquoHeavy mineral sanddeposits of Orissardquo in Special Issue on ldquoBeach and Inland heavymineral sand deposits of Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals R Dhana Raju M A Ali and S KrishnanEds vol 13 pp 23ndash52 2001
[4] D S Rao G V S Murthy K V Rao D Das and S N Chinta-lapudi ldquoAlteration characteristics of beach placer ilmenite fromChatrapur coast Orissa Indiardquo Journal Applied Geochemistryvol 4 pp 47ndash59 2002
[5] D S Rao B Banerjee and S C Maulik ldquoChemistry of beachplacer heavyminerals of Chatrapur Orissardquo Research Journal ofChemistry and Environment vol 2 no 4 pp 11ndash15 1998
[6] C Satpathy S Routray and D S Rao ldquoHeavy mineral recoveryfrom beach and dune sands of Ganjam Coast Orissa IndiardquoWorld of MetallurgymdashERZMETALL vol 63 no 1 pp 5ndash132010
[7] P V Sukumaran and A R Nambiar ldquoGeochemistry of ilmenitefrom Ratnagiri coast Maharashtrardquo Current Science vol 67 no2 pp 105ndash106 1994
[8] V S Hegde G Shalini and D Gosavi Kanchanagouri ldquoProve-nance of heavyminerals with special reference to ilmenite of theHonnavar beach central west coast of Indiardquo Current Sciencevol 91 no 5 pp 644ndash648 2006
[9] J D Grigsby ldquoChemical fingerprinting in detrital ilmenite aviable alternative in provenance researchrdquo Journal of Sedimen-tary Petrology vol 62 no 2 pp 331ndash337 1992
[10] D A Darby and Y W Tsang ldquoVariation in ilmenite elementcomposition within and among drainage basins implicationsfor provenancerdquo Journal of Sedimentary Petrology vol 57 no 5pp 831ndash838 1987
[11] A K Mohanty S K Das V Vijayan D Sengupta and S KSaha ldquoGeochemical studies of monazite sands of Chhatrapurbeach placer deposit of Orissa India by PIXE and EDXRFmethodrdquo Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics ResearchSection B Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms vol 211no 1 pp 145ndash154 2003
[12] K B Rao ldquoOrigin and evolution of the sand dune deposits ofthe Ganjam coat Orissa Indiardquo Exploration and Research forAtomic Minerals vol 2 pp 133ndash146 1989
[13] R Sengupta S Bhattacharya R S Rana S K Mitra and V KJain ldquoPreliminary studies of off-shore heavy mineral placers ofGopalpur-Chatrapur coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Geologyvol 62 pp 27ndash37 1990
[14] S Bhattacharyya and R Sengupta ldquoSurface microtextures ofheavy minerals from the Bay of Bengal off Gopalpur OrissardquoJournal of Geological Society of India vol 44 no 2 pp 175ndash1841994
[15] K C Sahu U C Panda and D K Sahu ldquoTexture and mineral-ogical composition of sediments alongGanjam coast East coastof Indiardquo Indian Journal of Marine Sciences vol 26 no 2 pp230ndash233 1997
[16] S Bhattacharya ldquoEastern Ghats granulite terrain of India anoverviewrdquo Journal of Southeast Asian Earth Sciences vol 14 no3-4 pp 165ndash174 1996
[17] A F Park and B Dash ldquoCharnockite and related neosomedevelopment in the Eastern Ghats Orissa India petrographicevidencerdquo Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh EarthSciences vol 75 no 3 pp 341ndash352 1984
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
8 Journal of Geochemistry
[18] R C Newton ldquoAn overview of charnockiterdquo PrecambrianResearch vol 55 no 1ndash4 pp 399ndash405 1992
[19] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B Ravikumar N K Muk-hopadhyay and S P Mehrotra ldquoEffect of mechanical activationon the kinetics of sulfuric acid leaching of beach sand ilmenitefrom Orissa indiardquo Hydrometallurgy vol 75 no 1ndash4 pp 189ndash204 2004
[20] B C Acharya S K Das and J Muralidhar ldquoMineralogymineral chemistry and magnetic behaviour of ilmenite fromChhatrapur Coast Orissardquo Indian Journal of Earth Sciences vol26 no 1ndash4 pp 45ndash51 1999
[21] T K Mallik ldquoMicromorphology of some placer minerals fromKerala beach Indiardquo Marine Geology vol 71 no 3-4 pp 371ndash381 1986
[22] W A Deer R A Howie and J ZussmanAn Introduction to theRock-Forming Minerals ELBS 1985
[23] B Nayak S Mohanty and P Bhattacharyya ldquoHeavy mineralsand the characters of ilmenite in the beach placer sands ofChavakkad-Ponnani Kerala Coast Indiardquo Journal of the Geo-logical Society of India vol 79 no 3 pp 259ndash266 2012
[24] S Bhattacharyya R Sengupta andM Chakraborty ldquoElementalchemistry of ilmenitemdashan indicator of provenancerdquo Journal ofthe Geological Society of India vol 50 no 6 pp 787ndash789 1997
[25] S Bhattacharya and R Kar ldquoAlkaline intrusion in a granuliteensemble in the Eastern Ghats belt India shear zone pathwayand a pull-apart structurerdquo Proceedings of the Indian Academy ofSciences Earth and Planetary Sciences vol 113 no 1 pp 37ndash482004
[26] D S S Babu D Das M Sudarshan V R Reddy S N Chintal-apudi andC KMajumdar ldquo 57FeMossbauer studies on naturalilmenitesrdquo Indian Journal of Pure and Applied Physics vol 34no 7 pp 474ndash479 1996
[27] C Sasikumar D S Rao S Srikanth B R V NarashimhanB R Kumar and N K Mukhopadhyaya ldquoEffect of naturalweathering and mechanical activation on the acid dissolutionkinetics of Indian beach sand ilmeniterdquo Metals Materials andProcessess vol 18 pp 211ndash224 2006
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in
Submit your manuscripts athttpwwwhindawicom
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ClimatologyJournal of
EcologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
EarthquakesJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom
Applied ampEnvironmentalSoil Science
Volume 2014
Mining
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
International Journal of
Geophysics
OceanographyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of Computational Environmental SciencesHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal ofPetroleum Engineering
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
GeochemistryHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Journal of
Atmospheric SciencesInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
OceanographyHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Advances in
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MineralogyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
MeteorologyAdvances in
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation httpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Paleontology JournalHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
ScientificaHindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geological ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttpwwwhindawicom Volume 2014
Geology Advances in