research department workshop on cef-networks development of cef networks design stanislav sima lada...
TRANSCRIPT
Research Department Workshop on CEF-Networks www.ces.net
Development of CEF networks design
Stanislav SimaLada Altmannova
Prague May 17th, 2005
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
2
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Previous presentations available on-line I.Development of the CESNET2 optical network. TERENA
Networking Conference, Limerick, June 4, 2002.(Nothing-In-Line approach + 189 km NIL operation announced)http://www.terena.nl/conferences/tnc2002/Slides/sl3c2.ppt
Long distance fiber connections in NREN, TF-NGN Budapest, October 18, 2002.
(10 Gb/s NIL possible up to about 300 km, single fibre bi-directional transmission in production network up to 125 km)
http://www.terena.nl/tech/task-forces/tf-ngn/presentations/tf-ngn9/sima.ppt
Fibres and advanced optical devices for a new networking strategy. TERENA TF-NGN Cambridge, September 16th, 2003.
(Fibre is strategic asset. CEF networks concept. Free space optics for cost-effective first mile. Connect Near over Border by fibre.)
http://www.terena.nl/tech/task-forces/tf-ngn/presentations/tf-ngn12/20030915_SS_Optical.pdf
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
3
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Previous presentations available on-line II.
Procurement and lighting of dark fibre. CEF Networks workshop, Prague May 2004.
(Double payment of fibre infrastructure? NIL results. CESNET-made optical amplifiers deployment announced.)
http://www.ces.net/doc/seminars/20040525/pr/CEF%20Networks3ext.ppt
Towards a Nation-wide Fibre Footprint in research and education networking. TERENA Networking Conference, Rhodes, June 9, 2004.
(Dark fibres brings progress to REN design and subsequently to WAN design generaly. From naive economy to strategy. National fibre footprint in European NRENs. GLIF and CzechLight.)
http://www.terena.nl/conferences/tnc2004/programme/presentations/show.php?pres_id=97
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
4
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Network design Specifications of three items are needed:
– Network services, – building elements, – implementation (deployment, setup, …)
Top-down design process starts with network services specification, botom-up design process starts with building elements specification
Neither of above two start points is „the best“ !!! Results of one way design are suboptimal (i.e. bad),
returns and corrections of decisions in design process are needed !!!
Experience and theoretical knowledge of circuits design and computer design help to deeply understand above problem
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
5
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Legacy in network design Buiding elements, implementation and operation of large
scale networks are procured Procurement is long process (especially if public funding
is used): e.g. 7-24 month Returns and corrections of decisions are very difficult or
impossible in procurement process Vendors have limited possibilities to tailor services and
equipment to user needs, so they offer „universal solution“ (=suboptimal for given case)
Exceptions:– legal system in some countries is not so restrictive to research– lower scale networks (e.g. Metropolitan) make implementation
and operation by own staff
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
6
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Development of network design Legacy design proces often gives suboptimal network services
(costs, rate, flexibility…): mainly transmission layer is poorly designed from technical and economical point of view (is the most hidden to user)
In general, improvement possibilities were proved: – procurement of dark fibres instead services– procurement of multivendor equipment plus integration
Necessity of bad reliability and interoperability was not proved Multidomain operation is needed generaly and includes
multivendor interoperability and multidomain monitoring and control
Disadvantage: design and operation are more complicated Solution: procure support of design, implementation and
operation, and save own ability to quick return and correct design (including retendering etc.)
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
7
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
New situation in network design Main source of innovation is optical technology now Fibres are the most important buiding element now Change of P2P services by P2P fibres was first step only New transmitters, receivers, amplifiers, gratings etc. are
available, some of they even with MultiSource Agreements
CEF Networking enables high availability and cost-efectivness of new services (e.g. Facilities based networking, E2E lightpath on demand, fibre switching…)
CEF approach starts in WAN or MAN in companies, corporates, military, municipalities and hospitals (etc.): new market segment is emerging, tasks of vendors are changing
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
8
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
CESNET2 fibre procurement Re-tendering since 2001 to 2005, goals:
– decreasing costs, including single fibre lines– shorter lines including first mile– NIL approach– two or more fibre pairs to network node– reliability increase by physical diversity of first
miles to node– single provider of dark fibre line (spans could
have different owners)– first mile for international lines in Prague– first mile for fibre connection of user premises– cross border fibres (single provider)
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
9
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
10
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
11
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
12
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
13
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
14
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
15
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
DF Lines 3 500 km of fibre pair operational in CESNET2
350km of single fibre within CESNET2
660 km of fibre pair in CzechLight testbed
More than 760 km of special fibres on the spools in laboratory
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
16
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Example of lambdas and fibres costs(fibres are blue, road distances of cities are from 20 to 210 km)
Interciti Line
Rate 2001 (Euro/y/m)
Rate 2002 (Euro/y/m)
Rate 2003 (Euro/y/m)
Rate 2004 (Euro/y/m)
1 2,5G 0,83 2,5G 0,83 2,5G 0,68 1GE 0,332 34M 0,78 1GE 0,43 1GE 0,433 34M 0,84 34M 0,84 0,534 2,5G 0,61 2,5G 0,22 2,5G 0,225 2,5G 0,536 2,5G 1,21 2,5G 1,21 1GE 0,417 1GE 0,70 1GE 0,178 1GE 0,63 1GE 0,639 1GE 0,40 1GE 0,40 1GE 0,4010 2,5G 0,31 2,5G 0,3111 1GE 0,2412 2,5G 0,63 2,5G 0,63 2,5G 0,63 2,5G 0,1113 2,5G 1,64 2,5G 0,89 2,5G 0,8914 2,5G 3,8315 2,5G 2,53 2,5G 0,95 2,5G 0,95 2,5G 0,9116 2,5G 1,5517 2,5G ? 1,05 1GE 1,05 1GE 0,50 1GE 0,5018 2,5G 2,67 2,5G 0,99 2,5G 0,42 2,5G 0,4219 34M 0,98 34M 0,98 1GE 0,5020 1GE 0,29 1GE 0,29
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
17
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Cross border fibre (CBF, NoB) Viena-Bratislava-Brno-Ostrava-BialskoBiala Austria-Slovakia-Czech Rep-Poland Our presentation of experience with CBF on TF-NGN
Cambridge, September 2003 (we call it NoB, Near over Border)
SERENATE study in 2003 – we request analysis Having NoB fibre connection, you could implement
some lambdas for GEANT2 (or for Abilene in US.) Cost rule for fibres is KIS (keep it short). GN2 tender allowing fibres continues (we will use
examples, not results) NoB is supported by SEEFIRE study
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
18
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
19
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
2 years after: Analysis still needed SERENATE study, p.24, published April 22., 2003
http://www.serenate.org/publications/d9-serenate.pdf „Prices of equipment are relatively important for the economics of
transmission systems, but the overall costs heavily depend on the network architecture and topology. The basic approach is to connect geographically neighbouring universities by fibres. NRENs should carefully analyse the pros and cons of any solution going beyond this, i.e. using an overlay fibre structure, because such a solution is usually more expensive. It would be feasible and cheap, albeit not simple, to independently cross national borders to build regional fibre networks.“
„This situation requires a new and careful analysis of the architecture and topology of the transmission layer (typically a transmission structure overlaying the NREN’s topology) at the European level.“
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
20
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Overlaying fibre lines: when are needed??(lines are examples only)
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
21
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Facility based networking: GLIF and CzechLight
Global Lambda Integrated Facility (GLIF)• Environment for co-operation:
networking, infrastructure, network engineering, system integration, middleware, applications
• GLIF was established by invited participants at the 3rd Global Lambda Grid Workshop, held August 27, 2003 in Reykjavik, Island, www.glif.is
• Dark fibres are often used for Gigabit or 10 Gigabit access to cities and university premises
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
22
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Facility and production networking
• Facilility and production networking should be complementary
• Prague-Amsterdam 10 Gb/s lambda since September 1, 2004 (Cisco-Lucent-Nortel)
• We are studying/testing possibilities of lambda connection to FermiLab, RAL, Karlsruhe, Taipei etc.
We will use E2E lambdas prepared by GEANT2+NREN+MAN, if (when) available for such connections
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
23
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
GLIF – World Map December 2004
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
24
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
CzechLight connections(to GLIF, to GN2 testbed and to cz premises)
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
25
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
26
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
CzechLight intercity connections Prague – Amsterdam lambda (GLIF facility), first
mile in Prague on dark fibre, OC-192c transmission, grey 1550nm
Prague – Brno, dark fibre, 298.3 km, 66,5 dB, including 257.3 km of G.655 fibre, DWDM OC-192c transmission, NIL test
Prague – Plzen, dark fibre, 159.4 km, 36.7 dB, GE transmission by CzechLight EDFA 2in1
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
27
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
CzechLight connections in Prague region
Connections of Particle physics workplaces- Institute of Physics of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech republic, dark fibre, GE transmission- Faculty of Mathematics and Physics of Charles University, dark fibre, GE transmission - Nuclear Physics Institute of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic in Řež, dark fibre, GE transmission- Faculty of Nuclear and Physical Engineering of Czech Technical University, lambda on PASNET dark fibres by CWDM, GE transmission
We prepare connections for medical research
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
28
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
City dark fibre lines to the of CzechLight node in Prague
Point kmAttenuation 1550nm (dB)
max
Attenuation 1310nm (dB)
maxInstalling
Nuclear Physics Institute 25,3 5,9 9,64 1.9.2004
Institute of Physics Academy of Sciences of CR
25,6 8,7 12,9 8.11.2004Faculty of
Mathematics and Physics 8,9 3,18 4,61 15.10.2004
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
29
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
CzechLight configuration
Core node in Prague
Cisco 15454 with 10 G DWDM SONET, 4xGE
Cisco C3550 – 12G
Cisco C6503 with 10 GE and GE Core node in Brno
Cisco 15454 with 10 G DWDM SONET, 4xGE Cisco 6506 with 10 GE and GE prepared
Prague May 17th, 2005
Development of CEF networks design
30
Research Department CEF Networks workshop www.ces.net
Acknowledgement
Jan Gruntorad for support Miroslav Karasek, Jan Radil and Josef
Vojtech for advanced lighting of CESNET2 and CzechLight fibres
Comment: presented ideas and opinions are result of our ongoing R&D activities and are opened to improvement