Research Techniquesfor BME PhD students

Tamás Tettamanti, PhD

Department of Control for Transport and Vehicle Systems Budapest University of Technology and Economics

The firt steps of your scientific life

• Do research with extreme enthusiasm at any time!

Never give up!

• Create clear and realistic goals for short and long terms.

• Be professional in your scientific field but also in your career building as well!

You can be a genius but it is not enough! Be a good team player, good working partner, etc.

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 2

You cannot avoid social networks…

• Social Network Sites– for Researchers (PhD students as well)

• www.academia.edu• www.researchgate.net• www.mendeley.com

– for Professionals (or Business): • www.linkedin.com

• Do not forget that networking is a key factor for yourprofessional success!

• Social network sites can also bring jobs to you!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 3

Be always visible!

• Create a website:– about you

or – about your working group/laboratory!

• Present your scientific and professional achievement!

• Keep it up to date at all times!

• Examples:– Dept. website– www.traffic.bme.hu

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 4

Researcher websites for publication databaseand citation metrics

• Researcher IDs are important to solve the author ambiguity problem within the research community:– http://orcid.org

– www.researcherid.com

– Scopus Author ID

– Google Scholar ID (!)

• MTMT (acronym for The Hungarian Scientific Bibliography)

• Interestingly: Google Scholar is somehow the best site for citation metrics!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 5

How to start your research?

• Do not waste your time for already existing solutions!

• Keeping pace with up-to-date scientific results of your field!

• Search for publications!

Look for the state-of-the-art research!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 6

Where to research? – Library of Budapest University of Tech. and Econ.

www.omikk.bme.hu/en/online-thematic-literature/databases

– www.sciencedirect.com

– ieeexplore.ieee.org/Xplore/accessinfo.jsp

– onlinelibrary.wiley.com/

– For Hungarian students free dictionaries: https://www.szotar.net

– …

• VPN access to university IP network: www.net.bme.hu

• A brief “how to do”: http://kjit.bme.hu/images/stories/targyak/ResearchTechniques/MatlabInstallGuide_EN.pdf

• Or simply „google” it:

– www.google.com

– www.scholar.google.com

• Or use free access options:

– https://openaccessbutton.org/

– https://unpaywall.org/

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 7

How to read through a scientific paper?

• Read first: – Abstract, – Introduction, – and Conclusions! It helps to understand the main goals and results of a paper.

• Introduction is extremely important:– It always contains some literature review… citations in the Introductions will open further doors for your research

• An example: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0968090X15003447

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 8

How to choose a journal for publication?

• Impact Factor (IF) is one of the most popular metrics published by Clarivate Analytics (formerly Thomson Reuters)

• IF of an academic journal is a measure to reflect the yearly average number of citations to recent articles published in that journal.

• Calculated yearly .

• If you publish in a journal with IF, you merit the IF of the year of publishing.

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 9

IF by Web of Science – Citation Reports

• Web of Science: www.webofknowledge.com/

• Go to Journal Citation Reports!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 10

How IF is calculated?

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 11

IF and Quartiles in a given category of journals Journal Citation Reports

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 12

For IF calculation, ClarivityAnalytics only consider the journals which already have IF!

https://www.scopus.com/sources.uri?zone=TopNavBar&origin=searchbasic

• CiteScore is publicly available and calculated the same way as the Impact Factor.

• At the same time, not only the journals with IF are considered!

• Note that to gain IF for a specific journal:

– the journal must apply to get listed in Web of Science and

– after several years of indexing it might get an impact factor.

• For example: https://www.scopus.com/sources?sortField=&sortDirection=&isHiddenField=&field=idTitle&idTitle=&idTitle=Periodica+Polytechnica+Transportation+Engineering%2316884

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 13

Beside IF, also consider CiteScore of Scopus!

www.scimagojr.com

• SJR is publicly available that includes the scientific indicators developed from the information contained in the Scopus® database.

• SJR is a measure of scientific influence of journals that accounts for both:

1) the number of citations received by a journal and

2) the prestige of the journals where such citations come from!

• For example: www.scimagojr.com/journalsearch.php?q=16884&tip=sid&clean=0

• The journals are divided according to their SJR into four quartiles (groups):

– Q1 (green) comprises the quarter of the journals with the highest values,

– Q2 (yellow) the second highest values,

– Q3 (orange) the third highest values ,

– and Q4 (red) the lowest values.

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 14

You can also consider SJR (SCImago Journal Rank)!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 15

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 16

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 17

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 18

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 19

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 20

• One of the most important goal of your paper should be the expectable citations to it in the future!...

• Therefore, it is worth publishing in Open Access journals (even if it is not IF journal)!

• Take care with unknown journals which promise high IF fake and fraudulent journals exist also…An example: http://www.ijmra.us/

• Always check the editorial board and archive articles of the targeted journal… An example: http://www.ierjournal.org/pupload/vol2iss8/INDOOR%20WIRELESS%20TRACKING%20USING%20WIFI.pdf

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 21

Some tips for journal choice

After submitting the paper…

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 22

The peer review process for submitted papers

• Peer review helps to control the quality of individual articles before publishing in the journal.

• The Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society was the first journal who formalized the peer review process.

• Peer review is still the only widely accepted method for research validation.

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 23

The peer review process is hard and long…

• Authors need patience and endurance during the review process.

• Generally, authors are asked for corrections and resubmission for several times before acceptance!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 24

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 25

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 26

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 27

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 28

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 29

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 30

Let’s see a peer review process exampleTettamanti T, Luspay T, Kulcsár B, Péni T and Varga I (2014), "Robust Control for Urban Road Traffic

Networks", IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems. Vol. 15(1), pp. 385-398.

• Sept. 2012: Our manuscript was submitted to IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems (high impact factor journal)

• Dec. 2012: 1st review arrived: Major revision correction and resubmission peer review

• April 2013: 2nd review arrived: Major revision correction and resubmission peer review

• July 2013: 3rd review arrived: Minor revision correction and resubmission peer review paper is accepted!

• Sept. 2013: Final proof of the paper

• Febr. 2014: The paper was finally published!...

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 31

Let’s see the review rounds

• I show now the review rounds of my paper targeting the Transportation Research Journal…

• Cover Letter…

• Author’s Reply…

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 32

Main conclusion on impact factor journal publication process

• Very long: min. 1-1,5 years considering the publishing date

• The reviewers might be harsh but generally:– they really help you with their criticism and – they will finally improve the quality of your paper

• The main problem was always the lack of clear and concise wording of the novelty of the paper.

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 33

How NOT to write a scientific paper?

https://pdos.csail.mit.edu/archive/scigen/

…

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 34

How to write a scientific paper?

• Useful website of The European Association of Science Editors (EASE):

www.ease.org.uk/

• EASE Guidelines for Authors and Translators of Scientific Articles http://www.ease.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/EASE-Guidelines-2017-English.pdf

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 35

2nd Homework• Do not forget that the final goal is to write a scientific paper in your own research field in LaTeX.

• Prepare the structure of your own paper!

• To do this it is also suggested that you consult with your supervisor! So she/he can help you restructure the draft more efficiently, in accordance with your research.

• An example for it:

– Authors: XY, … (Reasonably, your supervisor should be your co-author!)

– Title: The two-level control of autonomous intersections

– Abstract (5-10 sentences): The paper’s aim is to propose a control design methodology for autonomous vehicles in urban traffic

network by considering the network-wide performance. The proposed two-level control strategy solves a …etc.

– Section titles:

1. Introduction

2. Model (2.1 Junction model, 2.2. network model)

3. The proposed control (3.1 Low level control, 3.2. Macroscopic level control)

4. Simulation study and evaluation

5. Conclusion

• Deadline: until next lesson

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 36

Thank you for your attention!

14 March 2019 Research Techniques 37