responsive documents - crew v. council on environmental quality: regarding global warming: 6/28/2011...

8/6/2019 Responsive Documents - CREW v. Council on Environmental Quality: Regarding Global Warming: 6/28/2011 CEQ docs

1/17

0982_f_vp4qh003_ceq.txtRECORD TYPE: FEDERAL (NOTES MAIL)

CREATOR:Kenneth L. Peel ( CN=Kenneth L. Peel/OU=CEQ/O=EOP [ CEQ ] )

CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-2003 17:45:02.00SUBJECT:: [Pwd: vision Document- Printer 's version [RESTRICTED]]T O : j e f f r e y . b . c l a r k ~ l f l ' 1 1 @ inet ( j e f f r e y . b . c l a r ~ @inet [UNKNOWN])READ:UNKNOWN ~ ~ - ~ ~

TEXT:

1 of 3- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Forwarded by Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/200305:43 PM - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Phil Cooney07/09/2003 08:10:57 AMRecord Type: RecordTo: Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP@EOPcc:subject: [Fwd: vision Document - Printer 's Version [RESTRICTED]]

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Forwarded by Phil cooney/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/200308:10 AM - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

James R Mahoney 07/03/2003 03:13:11 PM

Record Type: Record

TO: [email protected]:. subject: [FWd: vision Document - Printer 's version [RESTRICTED]]

To all - I am sending this a second time. I entered th e group addressincorrectly th e f i r s t time. Jim Mahoney

- - - - - - - - ori9inal Message - - - - - - - - subject: Vis1on Document - Printer 's version [RESTRICTED]Date: Thu, 03 Jul 2003 15:05:37 -0400From: "James R Mahoney" To: CCSP@USGCRP,James R Mahoney

TO al l -

I am attaching a f i le with th e full text and i l lustrat ions of the CCSPVision document as we sent i t to th e printer las t evening. Please notethat graphics ar e already embedded in th e text on pages 3 and 10. othercolor graphics ar e attached to each of the "research element boxes" thatwill be placed as noted in th e text when th e layout is completed.

Last evening was our latest deadline to ge t a full color, full layoutdocument ready for use by secretary Abraham and secretary evans at aroll out schetluled for July 15. (Note: oo not disseminate this date.

Page 1

0 0 3 4 2 9

GEQ 013387


2/17

0 . . . . . . .

I t may change.)0982_f _vp4qh00Lteq . tx t .

Also, note that we will be able to make a very limited number of edits(best i f they are substitutions of similar amounts of text) duringgalley proof review scheduled fo r July 8 and/or 9.

I.

Jim Mahoney

- Vision Printers copy 7-02-03.doc

================ = ATTACHMENT 1 ====================ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00TEXT:Unable to convert NSREOP0103:[ATTACH.D49]SREOP01300HQ4PV.001 to ASCII,The following is a HEX DUMP:

D0CFllEOA1BllAE1000000000000000000000000000000003E000300FEFF090006000000000000

================== END ATTACHMENT 1 ~ = - = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

Page 2

CEQ 013388


3/17

. , ' I

RECORD TYPE! FEDERAL0984_f_zq4qh003_ceq.txt

(NOTES MAIL)

CREATOR:Kenneth L. Peel ( CN=Kenneth L. Peel/OU=CEQ/O=EOP [ CEQ J )

CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-2003 17:45:36.00SUBJECT:: Main CCSP oocume.nt fo r concurrence/final editsT O : j e f f r e y . b . c l a r l . o ~ @ . inet ( jeffrey.b.clarinUJnlm,.-lco. inet [UNKNOWNJ )READ:UNKNOWN ~ ----TEXT:3 of 3- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Forwarded by Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/200305:44 PM - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Phil Cooney07/09/2003 08:09:38 AMRecord Type: RecordTo: Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/[email protected]:subject: Main CCSP Document for concurrence/final edits

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Forwarded by Phil cooney/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/200308:09 AM - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Phi 1 Cooney 07/01/2003 09:19:20 AMRecord Type: Record

To: ' Quesean R. Rice/CEQ/[email protected]:subject: Main CCSP Document fo r concurrence/final edits

please print out attachment -- Strategic Plan concurrence text. thanksPhil- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Forwarded by Phil cooney/CEQ/EOP on 07/01/200309:18 AM - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

James R Mahoney 06/30/2003 07:12:38 PM

Record Type: Record

To: [email protected],[email protected]: see the distribution l i s t at th e bottom of this messagesubject: Main CCSP Document fo r concurrence/final edits

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am attaching a PDF f i le with the revised text (without annexes) of themain CCSP scientific strategic plan document, fo r ~ o u rconcurrence orfinal edits. The annexes for the document are in final checking at the

.Page l

OU3431

CEQ 013393


4/17

I I

0984_f_zq4qh003_ceq.txtCCSP office at this time. I will send them to you as soon as theircheckout i s completed - expected fo r early Tuesday. These annexes willalso be on th e website https://www.usgcrp.gov/techrvw as soon asthey eted.name:

To reduce the PDF fi le size all of the graphics fo r the plan have beenremoved from the text f i le, and are also being posted on th e samewebsite as above (with the same name and password). These graphicsshould be available by approximately 8:00 PM this evening.INSTRUCTIONS: DEADLINE IS COB WEDNESDAY, JULY 2

N.B. REMEMBER THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED

Please review this revised document, and take one of the two followingactions:

1. I f you concur with publication of the document, please send ane l e c t r o i J i i i i i i i cessa e with your concurrence to ERIN WUCHTE email:ewuchte by COB WEDNESDAY, with a copy to me.. .2. I f you wish to discuss further revisions ~ e p to the minimumfeasible), please email me of call me at 2 0 2 ~ b yCOB WEDNESDAY.

we need to keep Thursday, July 3 available fo r us to review andunderstand any open edit issues with you. we expect to commit time overth e July 4 weekend to resolve any issues, so that we can reach closureby midday Monday July 7.we must be able to release the document for final copy edit, composingand printing after July 7, so that we can have printea copies availablefo r the public presentation by secretaries Abraham and Evans currentlyschedulea for July 15 .I look forward to receiving th e message of your concurrence, or yourl i s t of issues remaining to be addressed, by Wednesday, July 2.

Thank you again fo r your attention to this.Jim Mahoney

- attl.htm- strat Plan Agency Concurrrence TEXT 6-30-03.pdf

James.R.Mahoney.vcf

Message copi ea .To: Kathie L. Olsen/OSTP/EOP@EOPE. Holly F1tter/OMB/EOP@EOPErin Wuchte/OMB/EOP@EOPsbodman "Conrad.C.Lautenbacher" scott Rayder < S c o t t . R a y d ~Robert card < R o b e r t . c a r d ~

Page 2

C:EQ 013394


5/17

t. (

0984_f_zq4qh003_ceq.txt

==================== ATTACHMENT 1 ============---=====ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0.00:00:00.00TEXT:Ladies and gentlemen,

I am attaching a PDF f i le with th e revised text (without annexes) ofthe main CCSP sc1entific strategic plan document, fo r your concurrenceor final edits. The annexes fo r the document are in final checkingat the CCSP office a t this time. I will send them to you as soon as the1rcheckout is completed - expected fo r early Tuesday. These annexeswill also be posted on th e website https://www. .gov/techrvwas soon completed.

pas -

To r le size all of the graphics for the plan have beenremoved le, and ar e also being posted on th e same websiteas above th th e same name and password). These graphics shouldbe avail e by approximately 8:00 PM this evening.

INSTRUCTIONS: DEADLINE IS COB WEDNESDAY, JULY 2

N.B. REMEMBER THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED

Please review this revised document, and take one of the two followingactions:

l. I f you concur with publication of th e document, please sendan electronic message with your concurrence to ERIN WUCHTE email:[email protected] COB WEDNESDAY, with a copy tome .

.

2. I f you wish to discuss further r e v i s i o l W M s e keep to th e minimumfeasible), please emai1 me of cal 1 me a t 202 by COB WEDNESDAY.

We need to keep Thursday, July 3 available o review and understandany open edit issues with you. we expect to commit time over th eJuly 4 weekend to resolve any issues, so that we can reach closure by middayMonaay July 7.
We must be able to release th e document fo r final copy edit, composingand printing after July 7, so that we can have printed copies availablefo r th e public presentation by secretaries Abraham and Evans currentlyscheduled for July 15.

I look forward to receiving the message of your concurrence, or yourl i s t of issues remaining to be addressed, by wednesday, July 2.

Thank you again fo r your attention to th1s.

Jim Mahoney

================== END ATTACHMENT 1 ==================

==================== ATTACHMENT 2 = = = = = = = = = = = = = ~ = = - - - = ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00 .

TEXT:Unable to convert NSREOP0103:[ATTACH.D89]SREOP01300HQ4QZ.002 to ASCII,The following is a HEX DUMP:

================== END ATTACHMENT 2 ====================================== ATTACHMENT 3 ====================ATT. CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00

TEXT:begin:vcardn:Mahoney;Jnmes

Page 3

CEQ 013395


6/17

0 9 8 4 _ f ~ q 4 q h 0 0 3 _ c e q . t x t

x-mozilla-html:FALSEorg:Nationa1 oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOM)version:2.1 email;internet:[email protected]:Assistant secretary of commerce for oceans and Atmosphereadr;quoted-printable:;;u.s. Department of commerce,=OD=OARoom5804,

=0D=0Al4th street & constitution Avenue, NW;Washington;oc;20230;fn:James R. Mahoney, Ph.D.end:vcard

================== END ATTACHMENT 3 =====----=======-===

Page 4

CEQ 013396


7/17

~ : . : ; : l. : ki"'"t.:. r

00~000GJ

Draft CCSP D eliverables 220ct03.docSynthesis and Assessment Products

Draft Table of Agency Leads

USDMJSGS (S)


8/17

; ~ ~ : - : : : r ; .~ \ 1-

~ ' ......

:. ~ ~ ; ~ ~

yaws

Draft CCSP Deliverables 220ct03.doc

NASAIUSGSJDOE (S)

NASA/DOE (S) (USGS)Titus (EPA)Szabados (NOAA)UndstromiFriedl(NASA)

JPL

I I I l I almisano (DOE) I I. ._ 2-4 State-of-lmowledge of hresholds of change that could NSF (L) ECO NSF contact TBO

, . :. ' " ~......

. ;;\....r

GSFC/ARC

GSFC


9/17

~ - ~ ~ : ~ t c

..; ; : ~

..

.,,

nmeFQime

,2-4I

i years

2 4

years

Draft CCSP Deliverables 220ct03.doc-- - - -- -- - -Topic Agencies

economic implications of dlffenmt atmospheric NASAIUSGSIEPAINOAAIDOEconcentrations of greenhouse gases. (S)

State-of-the-science of sqcloeconomic and EPA(L)environmental Impacts of climate varlabiDty. NOAAINASAIDOEIUSAID(S)

Within the transportation sector, a summary of clmate DOT(L)change and vadabUitysensitivities, potential Impacts, USGS(S)and response options. DOE(S)

~

.Working Contact Point Resources

Group IdentifiedGrambsch (EPA)Goodrich (NOAA)Houghton (DOE)

HCR Scheraga (EPA)ECO Simpson (NOAA)

Friedl (NASA)Houghton (obE)

OS Savonts (DOT) 345K(DOT)Burkett (USGS)Petty (DOE)

CCSP GoalS E1cp/olo the w ~ t ~ e t ~ l l l l dIdentify the limits of evohllng knowledge to manage risks an d opportunities related to climate varlabl/lly and

wlthln2 Uaes an d limitationsof obServations, data, forecaats, NASA(L) HCR BlrklMcPherson sseyears an d other projections in decision support for selected EPiVNOAAIUSGSIDOE (S) OS (NASA)

sectors and regions. Blerwagen (EPA)Livezey (NOAA)Berenknopf (USGS)Am1hor(DOE)

wilhln2 Best practice apprnaches for characterizing, NSF/NASA (L) OS O'Connor/Eavey (NSF) sseyears communicating,and Incorporating scientific EPiVNOAAIUSGSIDOE(S) Comm. BlrkiMcPherson

uncertainty Indeclslonmaldng. (NASA)Gamble (EPA)Simpson (NOAA)Berenknopf (USGS)Fe11811fOOEl.

wlthln2 Decision support experiments and evaluations using NOAA(L) OS Nierenberglllvezeyyears seasonal to Interannual foracasts and observational NASAIEPAIUSGSIUSAID (S) (NOAA)

data. BirkiHablb(NASA) GSFCIGISSGamble (EPA)BeNnknopf (USGS)DOE contact TBD

AC Atmospheric Composition eve Climate Variability and Changewe Water Cycle LC Land Use/Land Covercc CadMm Cyc;leHCR Human Contributions ModelingDS Decision Support OBS ObservationsDM D a t a ~ e n t COMM Communications

I


10/17

# ~ ; " " ~ .41 ~~ . . .

Email addresses for DOE eontacts:Jeff Amthor:Rick.Petty:Anna Palmisano: Anna Nnjiiji ' iJ()b.n Houghton: - - -- .Wanda Ferren:

Emailaddresses for DOT CODtads:Michael.Savonis michael.savouis

Diaft CCSPDeliverables 220ct03.doc

Roger Dahlman: Roger.DahlmamPeterLunn:

(b) (6)


11/17

I

From: Hannegan, Bryan J.Sent: Thursday, December 30, 2004 3:02PMTo: Ahsha TribbleCc: C ~ o n e . y ,Phil; Olsen, Kathie L.; Wuchte, Erin; Schwab,MargoSubJect: RE: [Fwd: CCSP Guidelines Announcement]

Page 1 of1

Ahsha - please find attached a redline with my comments, using language from the letter Jim posted on the website to accompany the release of the S&A G uidelines. Please call if questions, t_hanks, Bryan

------ Original Message - - - - - - ~Subject:CCSP Guidelines Announcement

D a t e : F r i ~17 Dec 200412:20:19-0500From:Ahsha Tribble

OrganJzation:NOAA

CCSP EOP Pr inc ipa l s ,

The NOAA Office of Legis la t ive Affai rs would l i k e to have acommunications document to give to the Hil l an d other cons t i tuen t sregarding the r e l ease of the Guidelines fo r Producing CCSP Synthesis an d.Assessment Reports . The d r a f t i s at tached fo r your review. We invi tey o u ~comments, i f any, ~ next week p r i o r to sending t h i s document out .

Thank you,Ahsha

********************************************Ahsha N. Tribble, Ph.D.Technical Chief of Sta ffOffice of Assis tant Secretary o f Commerce

Fo r Oceans an d AtmosphereHCHB/Room 580414th & Const i tu t ion Ave, NW

DC 20230(DOC)( F a x )*******************************

file://G:\FOIA - Climate\2004\Deliberative\12.04\RE Fwd CCSP Guidelines Announceme... 4/12/2007CEQ 01622


12/17

FW MahoneyRevkin interviewFrom: Holbrook, William F.sent: Monday, March 07, 2005 4:09PMTo: Cooney, Phil; Hannegan, Bryan J.; Hopkins, Robertsubject: FW: M a h o n ~ y / R e v k i ninterview

FYI

-----original Message----- From: Kent Laborde [mailto:[email protected]]sent: Monday, March 07, 2005 3:42 PMTo: Holbrook, william. F. .subject: Mahoney/Revkin interview

Bill.Andy Revkin has requested an interview with or . Mahoney to discuss CCSP deliverablesand "apparent issues on the chain thru which they'll be approved." He said thediscussion is not solely about Rick Piltz resignation from ccsP, but is related tothe topic. He is avai 1 able tomorrow afternoon fo r a phone interview .

I think th.is interview is chiefl for background, but may lead to a separate articlesolely on this subject. I'm clar1fying this now with Andy and trying to get morespecifics. Is there any specific language we should use? .

~ i j ~ - -

Page 1

t : \ 1 1 " ~..-;: '!'"'> -\ . 'l.i 1\. '

CEQ 016282


13/17

.v u.s. Government Review of J:PCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of climate change - - ADDENDFrom: Connaughton, James sent: F r i d a ~ ~ 1 2006 3:27 PMTo: WatsonH

subject: FW: nment Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment .Report -Mit1gation of climate change - - APDENDUM

Please give me a ring to discuss.

-----originalFrom: curtis,To: Garman,conrad.c.wehrum.Beth.JLynCC:Frybergemclean.bwatsonhlwhohj ku1 ~ n t A J r c : l t iJeff.Judy.carmensent: Fri May 12 14:38:13 2006Subject: u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation ofclimate change -- ADDENDUM

Dear climate change Technology Program Principals:I apologize for the multiple email messages on this subject. However, several pointshave been raised from my previous email that deserve clarification, which arepresented below.1. In order to ensure a comprehensive review of the Report and the commentsreceived 1 i t i s hoped that there are about 4-6 members will be on eachsub-comm1ttee, resulting in a total of 28-42 participants on the entire reviewcommittee.2. For planning purposes, the participants should assume a total of about 1 *weeksfor review and meetings. During this time, the participants will review theirrespective chapters, comments and participant in reviewing meetings lasting about 3days in washington D.c. I t i s anticipated that the reviews and meetings will occurin the late August through early September.

3. The committee m ~ m b e r swill be responsible for: (1 ) reviewing and c o ~ ~ n t i n gonth e chapters to wh1ch t h e ~are assigned as well as the S u m m a r ~for Pol1tymakers andthe Technical summary; (2 reviewing all public comments r e c ~ 1 v e don the chaptersthey are assigned; and (3 participate in a 3 day meeting in washington oc todiscuss and reach consensus on al l comments.

Thank you again for your kind support in helping us develop a comprehensive reviewdocument.

Mike

Page 1

004:176

CEQ 017683


14/17

~ u . s ~Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation 9f climate change -- ADDEND

Dear climate Change Technology Program Principals:

As you may be aware, the Intergovernmental Panel on climate change (IPCC) iscompleting i t s Fourth Assessment Report (AR4)i and soon there will be a Governmentand Expert Review. The climate change Techno ogy Program (CCTP), at the request ofthe Department of state, is coordinating the review of th e working Group III secondorder Draft, Mitigation of climate change. The Government and Expert review willtake -place from 24 July 2006 to 15 september 2006.

A committee will be formed to evaluate the merit of submitted public comments andprepare the official u.s. Government submission to the IPCC. As chair, I amrequesting your nomination of a9ency representatives to serve on this reviewcommittee. Please s e n d ~ i o n sdirectly to me at< m a i l t o : m i c h a e l . c u r t i s ~ m i c h a e l . c u r t i s @ h q . d o e . g o v by Monday, May 22,2006.

The AR4 --Mitigation of climate change is.organized as shown below. I anticipatet h a t . s ~ v e r a l c h ~ p t e r swill be grouped together and sub-committees formed.aroundspec1f1c expert1se, such as: 1, 2 and 3 (introduction, framing issues,, issues related to mitigation in thelong-term context)4 (energy supply)

5 (transportat1on and infrastructure)6 (residential/commercial)7 and 10 (industry and waste management)8-9 (agrjculture, forestry)

Page 2

CEQ 017684


15/17

v u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report.- Mitigation of climate change --ADDEND!11-13 (mitigation from cross-sectoral, sustainable development, policies)

Much of our work will be performed in the sub-committees where the members will bereviewing the collected public comments. In addition, ali committee members will beasked to review and participate in evaluation of the summary for Policymakers andthe Technical summary.

A preliminary schedule for th e review is as follows:24 July - 23 August: comments received on Draft AR4 Mitigation of climate change

24 August: Comments collated forwarded to ~ C T P

25 August: CCTP sends c o ~ m e n t sto review committee members6 september - 8 september: committee meeting (venue TBD but likely to be held at DOEHQ in washington DC) . 11 September: Final collation and summary transmitted to state and ccsP.

12-14 september: state finalization of official USG position15 september: state transmittal to IPCC secretariat

This schedule is tight with l i t t le slack; however we need to conform to the IPCCRules and Procedures that stipulate an eight week Government and expert review timeperiod.

Thank you for your support of this very important review process. I f you have anyquestions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact me.Mike

Michael R. curtis Ph.D.u.s. Department of Energyoffice of Policy and International Affairsscience and Technology Policy, PI-451000 Independence Ave, swwashin 20585 (b) (6): 202F: 202 (b) (6)

outline of AR4 Mitigation of climate change

summary for PolicymakersTechnical summary

Page 3

CEQ017685


16/17

~ u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of climate change - - ADDENQINTRODUCTIONAND FRAMING ISSUES

1. Introduction

2. Framing Issues,_.

ISSUES RELATED TO MITIGATION IN THE LONG-TERM CONTEXT

3.. Issues Related to Mitigation in th e Long-term context (summary)

Emission.scenarios, mitigation and stabilization scenarios, costs,-socio-economic impl icat ions .

Development pathways

Role of technologies

Interaction of mitigation and adaptation

Linkages between short and medium term mitigation and long-termstabi 1 zati on

SPECIFIC MITIGATION OPTIONS IN, THE SHORT AND MEDIUM TERM

4 . energy supply

5. Transport and i t s infrastructure

6. Residential/commercial

7. Industry

8. Agriculture

9. Forestry

10. Waste management

CROSS SECTORAL, NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONALDIMENSIONS

11. Mitigation from a cross-sectoral perspective

Introduction

cross-sectoral mitigation options

Technology research, development, deployment, diffusion and transfer

synergies and trade-offs with other policiesoverall mitigation potential and costs

Macroeconomic effects

Spill-over effects

Page 4

CEQ 017686


17/17

v u.s . Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of climate change -- A D ~ E Assessment of bottom-up and top-down analysis

Mitigation and adaptation

12. sustainable development and m i t i g a t i o ~

13 . Policies., instruments,. and co-operative arrangements

Page 5

CEQ 017687