retail in government securities: returns, simplicity and ... in... · in such a case why should...
TRANSCRIPT
4/22/2015 Retail in government securities: Returns, Simplicity and disposal are the big bumps ET Blogs
http://blogs.economictimes.indiatimes.com/etcommentary/retailingovernmentsecuritiesreturnssimplicityanddisposalarethebigbumps/ 1/5
FOLLOW ET:Login | Register
Blogs
Home Blogs Times View Campaigns City India World Entertainment Tech Sports Lifestyle Environment Science Spirituality Q&A Roots & Wings Business Reviews
Retail in government securities: Returns, Simplicity and disposal are the bigbumpsApril 22, 2015, 1:12 AM IST Economic Times in ET Commentary | Markets | ET
By Madan Sabnavis
The involvement of the retail sector in government securities (G-secs) has been spoken of in the credit policy and steps are
being taken to enable it. While the effort is laudable and necessary, we need to go back to the basics and evaluate why G-secs
have not been of much interest to retail investors. The issue is not of accessibility; it is conceptual.
For a household to be interested in any retail financial product, the essentials are returns, simplicity and disposal. The focus has
been on providing physical access through trading platforms, but the other issues have to be addressed.
Today the returns on government paper are fairly skewed. If we look at say the 90-day, 364-day treasury bills and 5- and 10-
year paper on a random day, they read like 7.87 per cent, 7.78 per cent, 7.79 per cent and 7.75 per cent respectively. These
yields vary on a day-to-day basis. Contrast this with a bank deposit where the returns are fixed with the same security and are
also higher. A one-year deposit gives 8-8.5 per cent.
Further, the government has created an anomaly in its domain by pricing small savings better. While there are limits on Public
Provident Fund (PPF), one can use post office instruments for diversification and get better returns. With there being no TDS
one can also escape the tax network if one chooses to. In such a case why should anyone opt for a G-sec, which carries no tax
0 1 0 0
0
�
Indiatimes The Times of India The Economic Times
4/22/2015 Retail in government securities: Returns, Simplicity and disposal are the big bumps ET Blogs
http://blogs.economictimes.indiatimes.com/etcommentary/retailingovernmentsecuritiesreturnssimplicityanddisposalarethebigbumps/ 2/5
MORE FROM ECONOMIC TIMES BLOGS
PM Narendra Modi, a Janus-faced leader?
Time Income Tax department woke up to big data
Pranab Mukherjee is reshaping methods of the President’s
office
Taking you on non-vegetarian tour of Maharashtra
An untimely reminder: Ankit Keshri’s on-field death must spur
BCCI to…
FROM AROUND THE WEB
Be Patient: An Oil-Driven Spending Boom Is Coming The
Financialist by Credit Suisse
Why is China’s Economy Slowing? TheFinancialist by Credit
Suisse
4 Lesser Known Ways to Save Tax scripbox
The World's Fastest Growing Economies OZY
Lincoln’s Last Speech New York Times
benefits?
The second issue is that of simplicity. When a household is dealing with a savings instrument, it would like to know clearly what
the attributes are. Now a G-sec is confusing even for a financially literate person. There is a face value and a market price, which
varies every day. Then there is a coupon on a bond and a yield to maturity (YTM), which vary. This yield actually matters more
than the coupon and is indicative of the return for tenure. Therefore, what should one be looking for if one buys a security in the
secondary market? As the YTM changes every day, households cannot digest this easily.
Further, there is no clarity in the structure of these papers. A fixed deposit is a fixed deposit. In the G-sec market there several:
2, 3, 4…40 year securities whose tenures change every year. Also with a multitude of securities maturing in say 2020, there are
different five-year bonds with different coupons, YTM and market prices. How is one to decide which instrument to invest in?
Also, the 10-year benchmark is the 8.40 per cent coupon bond maturing in July 2024. Factually, this does not have a 10-year
residue term from today. Anyone dealing with this data will not know how to go about viewing such paper. All securities hence
have a moving maturity period for being valued in the market. Also, all paper is issued through an auction and the cut-off price is
different from the face value, which adds to the nebulous nature of these bonds.
This is unlike equity, where a share of a company is the same as any other share of the same company.
Third, disposal is a problem and if one looks at the CCIL trading screen, we do not have more than 15 securities traded on a
daily basis, and not more than five of them will have more than 100 trades each. Therefore, even if an individual chooses to
enter or exit there won’t be much choice.
Prima facie, this may not be an exciting market for the household. A way out is for the government to issue different papers at
face value similar to tax-free bonds, of say, NHAI. To ensure that there is liquidity in the secondary market, banks can buy
securities like PDs from individuals at any time at the going price. But then an 8.4 per cent bond for 10 years will be for a face
value of 100 and not the auctiondetermined price. The government has to pay a higher rate of interest. With PPF paying 8.7 per
cent and post offices around 8.5 per cent for five years, it cannot get away with the present yield of around 7.79 per cent.
Taking into account all these factors, it looks like the G-sec market for retail will be a slow starter, as one side has to give in. Also
if the government moves away to announcing fixed-rate bonds at a higher cost, then the rest of the market with accumulated
debt of the government will go awry as all outstanding securities will be re-priced, adding considerable volatility.
It may be best for the household to enter this market through the mutual fund route till we can iron out these issues.
(Madan Sabnavis is Chief Economist at CARE Ratings)
DISCLAIMER : Views expressed above are the author's own.
Recommended by
Be the first one to review.
Add your comment here
4/22/2015 Retail in government securities: Returns, Simplicity and disposal are the big bumps ET Blogs
http://blogs.economictimes.indiatimes.com/etcommentary/retailingovernmentsecuritiesreturnssimplicityanddisposalarethebigbumps/ 3/5
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Author
Economic Times
We must stop appeasing Muslims… for their own good of course
Let’s bake in India first: Open up the agriculture sector to help our farmers and our economy
Everybody needs Rahul Gandhi
All eyes on Rahul Gandhi
Do the homework: Modi’s projection of India abroad needs to be backed by domestic reforms
Quick takes, analyses and macro-level views on all contemporary economic, financial and political events.
Most Discussed Most Read
4/22/2015 Retail in government securities: Returns, Simplicity and disposal are the big bumps ET Blogs
http://blogs.economictimes.indiatimes.com/etcommentary/retailingovernmentsecuritiesreturnssimplicityanddisposalarethebigbumps/ 4/5
more »
All ET My Profile
Today Last 7 Days Last 30 Days Last 365 Days
Points: 500
Akshay Patil 1Points: 500
Suresh Babu 2Points: 500
Nithyanand 3Points: 500
Rajeshkumar Shah 4Points: 500
Sushil Kumar S 5Know more about Times Points
Popular Tags
bollywood aap cricket arvind-kejriwal congress government china manmohan-singh bjp inflation rbi mumbai food us upa anna-hazare india
narendra-modi supreme-court ipl rahul-gandhi modi delhi corruption pakistan
Recently Joined Authors
Like Us
Find us on Facebook
ET Opinion
13,549 people like ET Opinion.
Facebook social plugin
Like
Other Times Group news sitesThe Economic Timesइकनॉ㐰〼मक टाइ㈵〰स | ઈકોનોિમક ટાઈㄊ橔સMumbai Mirror | Times NowIndiatimes | नवभारत टाइ㈵〰समहारा〼੭㐠ㄭ टाइ㈵〰स | Go GreenLifehacker | GizmodoLiving and entertainmentTimescity | iDiva | Bollywood | ZoomHealthmeup | Luxpresso | TechnoholikGuylife | Online Songs | MensXP.com
Networkingitimes | Dating & Chat | EmailHot on the Web
4/22/2015 Retail in government securities: Returns, Simplicity and disposal are the big bumps ET Blogs
http://blogs.economictimes.indiatimes.com/etcommentary/retailingovernmentsecuritiesreturnssimplicityanddisposalarethebigbumps/ 5/5
Copyright © 2014 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service
Car PriceUsed CarsOnline SongsHindi SongsBollywood Songs Restaurants in GoaBike Price IndiaNew CarsEvents in Goa
ServicesBook print ads | Online shopping | Free SMS | Website design | CRM | TendersMatrimonial | Ringtones | Astrology | Jobs | Tech Community | Property | BuycarBikes in India | Deals | Free Classifieds | Send money to India | Used CarsRestaurants in Delhi | Movie Show Timings in Mumbai | Remit to India | BuyMobilesListen Songs | News | TimesMobile | Real Estate Developers
Trending TopicsYahoo | Photogallery | You Tube | Gold Price | Twitter | Irctc | Renault Duster |Yoga | Aadhar Card | Facebook | Poonam Pandey Photos