revaluating typological standards

50
- uating po- gical andards e- aluating ypo- ogical tandards valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- ogical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- ogical Standards valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards uating po- ical ndards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards valuating Typo- logical Standards Re- valuati Typo- logical Standa Re- valuatin Typo- logical Standa Re- valuat Typo- logica Stand Re- valuating Typo- ogical Standards Re- valuating Typo- logical Standards Barch Design Report 01 Benjamin Hale Year 05 Manchester School of Architecture Semester 01 Fez Medina Reconnecting a City through Post- Impact Led Conservation Magda Sibley & Griff Evans Semester 02 Manchester, New Islington Gemischtgenuzte Hochäuser Projekt Manchester Griff Evans & Isabelle Doucet. Architecture as Urban Catalyst

Upload: benjamin-hale

Post on 21-Mar-2016

236 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

A 5th Year Design Report from the University of Manchester School of Architecture

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Revaluating Typological Standards

B

enja

min

Hal

e

S

TU

DIO

1 &

2 D

ES

IGN

RE

PO

RT

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Re-valuating Typo-logical Standards

Barch Design Report 01Benjamin Hale

Year 05

Manchester School of

Architecture

Semester 01Fez Medina

Reconnecting a City through Post-

Impact Led Conservation

Magda Sibley & Griff Evans

Semester 02Manchester, New Islington

Gemischtgenuzte Hochäuser

Projekt Manchester

Griff Evans & Isabelle Doucet.

Architecture as Urban Catalyst

Page 2: Revaluating Typological Standards

!!

!"#$%&"#$$%&'(&")%*'%%+"*',"-'%$$!+./"0%1"2%-!+(3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+

Title: [Re]valuating Typological Standards

A Design Report on Work Produced by Benjamin Hale

2(+79%/*%6"479,,$",: "#679!*%7*56%

2(+79%/*%6";+!<%6/!*&2(+79%/*%6"2%*6,=,$!*(+";+!<%6!/*&

0!:*9">%(6"

#5*9,68"?%+@(A!+3B3C($%B5*,6/8"2(.-("4!)$%&D"E6!:: "F<(+/"(+-"G/()%$$%"H,57%*

'()*+,-./#.0.*%1

G+",6-%6"*,"5+-%6*(I%"*9%"',6I"7(66!%-",5*"*9!/"&%(6D"G"',5$-"$!I%"*,"%J*%+-"A&"*9(+I/"*,"A&"*5*,6/D"2(.-("4!)$%&D"E6!:: "F<(+/" (+-" G/()%$$%" H,57%*3" K!*9,5*" *9%!6" .5!-(+7%" (+-"=%6/%<%6(+7%"A&" ',6I" ',5$-" 9(<%" +,*" -%<%$,=%-" *," *9%"%J*%+*"!*"9(/3"G"',5$-"($/,"$!I%"*,"*9(+I"*9%"/*5-%+*/",: "*9%"5+!<%6/!*&" ,: " 0%1D" :,6" *9%!6" 7,+*!+5%-" 7,,=%6(*!,+" !+" *9%"

L,=&6!.9*"M"?%+@(A!+C($%"479(+1"NOPN

!!!"#$%#%&'$(#)'#*&)+,-."+,-./0-#"'-"*1!!!"%&'$(#)'#*&)%/*&+%2'%#%,3/#"+,-./0-#"'-4

Page 3: Revaluating Typological Standards

!!!

Page 4: Revaluating Typological Standards

!<

Page 5: Revaluating Typological Standards
Page 6: Revaluating Typological Standards

<!

!"#$%&'#(&)"'!*+)",!-+#!&!./*&

Page 7: Revaluating Typological Standards

<!!

2.3%&"Q6,@%7*"!A(.%/":6,A"4%A%/R*%6"S+%"T"B',",: "#(;L3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/"(6*',6I

B9%"#679!*%7*56%"(/";6)(+"L(*($&/*"/*5-!,"5+!*"7%+*6%/",+"*9%"%J=%6!A%+*(*!,+"(+-"5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: "*9%"-!::%6%+*"/9(=%/"(6R79!*%7*56%" 7(+" *(I%" !+" ,6-%6" *," :5+7*!,+" (/" (+" 56)(+" 7(*($&/*3"B9%",<%6($$"(!A",: "*9%"/*5-!,"!/"*,")%7,A%"("=$(7%":,6"*%/*!+."*9%"+,*!,+",: "7(*($&/*"!+"-!::%6%+*".%,.6(=9!7($D"A%*9,-,$,.!7($"(+-"*9%A(*!7"/%**!+./

Page 8: Revaluating Typological Standards

<!!!

Page 9: Revaluating Typological Standards

!J

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

4*%5+/6(%"+*7 7 7 7 P" " " " " "" "8$9:%.57;<86-%659-7 8+*%.=%7 "&7 !.1:+*1.7 %+7 >%6/"+7?*"%7@5+:+1"%"+*7 7>.0.1%.57A*.

C!/*,6!7($"(+-"B9%,6%*!7($"Q,/!*!,+" " UF+<!6,+A%+*D"Q$(7%"(+-"47($%" " V

>.0.1%.57B,+

C!/*,6!7($"(+-"B9%,6%*!7($"Q,/!*!,+" " PPF+<!6,+A%+*D"Q$(7%"(+-"47($%" " PP

8$9:%.57;C86-%659-78+*%.=%7""&[email protected]+*9-7!.1:+*1.

>.0.1%.57A*.L6!*!7($"W5-.%A%+*/" " " PXL,+*%A=,6(6&"L,+*%J*" " " PX

>.0.1%.57B,+

8$9:%.57;DE.1"#*7F78+006*"(9%"+*&7A6%-"*.7+3 7G.957H7>%6/"+7I+5)7 7 7 7 77>.0.1%.57A*." " " " "?6!%: " " " " " PV?6!%: "#==6(!/($" " " " PVH%/!.+"2%*9,-,$,.&"" " " NOL,+/*657*!,+"L,+*%J*"" " " NO7 7 7>.0.1%.57B,+" " " " "?6!%: " " " " " NP?6!%: "#==6(!/($" " " " NPH%/!.+"2%*9,-,$,.&"" " " NPL,+/*657*!,+"L,+*%J*"" " " NP

8$9:%.57;JE"11.5%9%"+*&7'K1%59(%" " " " " "#)/*6(7*"" " " " PV"

8$9:%.57;HLM.*%7N+*%$&7N9*($.1%.57"*7N+%"+*" " " " " "B9%"#6+-($%"G+*%6<%+*!,+" " " NX

77 7 7 7 7 78$9:%.57;ON9*9#.0.*%729,79*/7@59(%"(.&7@5+3.11"+*9-7>%6/".17

Y%7*56%/"(**%+-%-"T"45AA(6&" " NU06,+*"Q(.%" " " " NV

8$9:%.57;PB.($*+-+#Q79*/7L*M"5+*0.*%

R888@7:5.1.*%9%"+*7S75.:+5%T

8$9:%.57;U

"" " " " " ""!

#0123124+++

Page 10: Revaluating Typological Standards

P

%12506782901

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

(+($&/!/" (+-" 6%/%(679" 7,+-57*%-" =6%<!,5/$&" !+" *9%" /%RA%/*%63"B9%"L96!/*A(/")6%(I":,$$,'%-"("/5=%6R76!*![5%"'!*9!+"*9%"/79,,$"'9%6%"*9%/%"!-%(/"'%6%"=6%/%+*%-"*,",*9%6" 5+!*/" (+-" (" 7,+/*657*!<%" %<($5(*!,+"'(/" /,5.9*3"

/%A%/*%6"*',3"B9%"/%A%/*%6"*',"=9(/%",: "*9%"5+!*D"'(/"+(A%-" \C,5/!+." *9%" 2(//%/8" Y%(6+!+." :6,A" ?%6$!+]3"B9%"5+!*"6%<,$<%-"(6,5+-"("6%/%(679%-")(/%-"\-!/7,<%6&]"=6,7%//3"FJ!/*!+."A(//"9,5/!+."*&=,$,.!%/"'%6%"%J(AR!+%-"!+"?%6$!+"("7!*&"'9%6%"*9%6%"9(/")%%+"A579"%J=%6!RA%+*(*!,+"'!*9"9,5/!+."*9%"!+9()!*(+*/",: "(+"!+-5/*6!($"

G/()%$$%"H,57%*"(+-"E6!:: "F<(+/"'(/"+,*"%//%+*!($$&"("

*9%" /*5-%+*" 9(-" )%%+"',6I!+." !+" *9%" 5+!*" ',6I/9,=/"

$%7*56%")&"%!*9%6"E6!:: "F<(+/",6"G/()%$$%"H,57%*3"G+"A&"7(/%"G"-!-"(66!<%"(*"("=,!+*"'9%6%"G"*9,5.9*"!*"=,//!)$%"*,"=5/9"*9%"-%/!.+":56*9%6"(+-"*9!/"6%/5$*%-"!+"(+"%(6$&"7,+7%=*5($"/79%A%3"#"76,//R5+!*"76!*![5%"'(/"(.(!+"9%$-"

R!+./"(+-"*9%")%.!++!+./",: "("<!()$%"7,+7%=*3"

Page 11: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

N

>.0.1%.57A*.7AM.5M".,

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

2(.-("4!)$%& >.0.1%.57B,+7AM.5M".,

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

H6"G/()%$$%"H,57%*

Page 12: Revaluating Typological Standards
Page 13: Revaluating Typological Standards

^

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 14: Revaluating Typological Standards

X

Page 15: Revaluating Typological Standards

_

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 16: Revaluating Typological Standards

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester One

#7:275;:+#0123<2+%=+

"34>0143+20+)192+?50>0492901

H5%" *," *9%"+(*56%",: " *9%"5+!*" (+-" !*]/" /%=(6(*!,+" !+*,"*'," /%A%/*%6/" G" '!$$" (**%A=*" *," $!+I" *9%A" !+" /579" ("

'9!$/*"(77%=*!+."*9%":(7*"*9(*"($*9,5.9"),*9"/%A%/*%6/"7,+7%+*6(*%",+"*9%"(+($&/!/",: "%J!/*!+.")5!$-!+."*&=,$,R.!%/":,5+-"!+"*9%"56)(+"/%**!+."*9%&",:*%+"-,"/,"'!*9,5*"("76,//",<%6"!+*,"("7,AA,+"*9%,6%*!7($"$(+-/7(=%"(+-"G"'!$$"9(<%"*,"7,AA5+!7(*%"A&"6%/=,+/%")&"/%=(6(*!+."*9%/%"7(/%/3

>.0.1%.57A*.8+65%Q95/7V+61"*#

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`%++%*9"06(A=*,+]/"%//(&"\B,'(6-/"(" L6!*!7($" a%.!,+($!/A]" G" )%7(A%" !+*%6%/*%-" !+" *9%" %:R:%7*/" ,: " .$,)($!1(*!,+" ,+" *9%" 9,A,.%+!1(*!,+" ,: " 6%R.!,+($"(679!*%7*56($"(%/*9%*!7/"(+-" *%79+,$,.!%/"9(<!+."

%J=%6!%+7%-"/,A%",: "*9%"/(A%"7,+7%=*/"A%+*!,+%-"!+"R

*%6%-"-,'+" !+*,"7,+/%6<(*!,+"(+-" !*"'(/" *9!/" 6%.!,+($":,75/",: "*9%"5+!*"(+-"!*]/"(==6,(79"*9(*"-6%'"A&"(**%+R*!,+3"B9%"7,+7%=*"*9(*")5!$-!+./"(6%"A%6%$&":6%%/*(+-!+."=!%7%/",: "=,$!*!7($D"(%/*9%*!7($",6"75$*56($" !7,+/"/9,5$-")%"76!*!7($$&"79($$%+.%-3"B9!/"'(/"79($$%+.%-"!+"*9%"5+!*")&"(--6%//!+."(")6,(-"6(+.%",: "(679!*%7*56($"[5%/*!,+/"6%$(*%-" *," 56)(+" 7,+*%J*D" *9%" *(+.!)$%" (+-" !+*(+.!)$%"9%6!*(.%D" 75$*56($" (+-" /,7!($" 7(=!*($D" 6%.%+%6(*!,+D" +%'"*&=%/",: "=,=5$(*!,+/"b%J=(*6!(*%/")5&!+."9,5/%/"!+"0%1"(+-"*9%"79(+.!+."-%A,.6(=9!7",: "*9%"6%.!,+c3"?&"[5%/R*!,+!+."'9%*9%6"*9%"6,$%",: "*9%"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%"!+"*9%"56)(+"/%**!+."(+-"!*]/"7(*($&*!7"%::%7*/D"*9%"(679!*%7*56($"=6,)$%A(*![5%/",: "*9!/"*&=,$,.&"(6%"6(!/%-")%&,+-"*9%"A%6%" =6(7*!7%" ,: " (679!*%7*56%" (+-" (!A/" *," 7,A%" *," ("76!*!7($"5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: "*9%"6,$%",: "-%/!.+"(+-"/=(*!($"!+*%6<%+*!,+/"!+"7,+*%A=,6(6&"(+-"9!/*,6!7"7,+*%J*/3"

G+",6-%6" *," *%/*" *9%"6%/!$!%+7%",: " *9%" *&=,$,.&"G"A(-%"(+"%(6$&"/5..%/*!,+"*9(*"*9%"7,+7%=*"A!.9*"+,*"%+*!6%$&"!+<,$<%"("6%7,+/*657*%-"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%/D"+%!*9%6"("6%R!+*%6=6%*(*!,+" ,: " (" -'%$$!+." )5*" !+" 5/!+." *9%" %J!/*!+.":()6!7"d6%e!+/%6*"("75$*56($"95)")(7I"!+*,"*9%"A%-!+(3"G+"

',6I/" =6,-57%-" !+" *9%"A%-!+(" *," *9%" :,6%!.+" *,56!/*3"B9!/"=6,7%//",: " !+*%.6(*!+."A!J%-"=6,.6(A/"9(/")%%+"("7,AA,+":%(*56%",: "/,A%",: "*9%"A,6%"6%7%+*"56)(+"6%.%+%6(*!,+"!+!*!(*!<%/"!+"*9%"-%<%$,=%-"',6$-")5*"(/",: "&%*"!/"5+*6!%-"(+-"5+*%/*%-"!+"*9!/"/7%+(6!,3"

Page 17: Revaluating Typological Standards

U

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

V"1%+5"(9-79*/7B$.+5.%"(9-7@+1"%"+*7

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b*9%"Z,6*9"#:6!7(+"

(+-"49(-6(79"K,,-/"b'9,"$(*%6",+"',5$-")%7,A%"$%(-R!+."B%(A"PO"A%A)%6/c"!+"*9%"%J*%+/!,+",: ",+%",: "F7,R9(6-]/" =6,@%7*/" !+"L(/()$(+7(D"L(66!%6%/"L%+*6($%3" B9%"(+($&/!/",: "(**%A=*/"(*"(//!A!$(*!+."*9%"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%"!+*,"("/%*",: "A,-%6+"-%/!.+"/*6(*%.!%/"9(/"'!-%$&")%%+"6%.(6-%-"(/"(":(!$56%"'!*9!+"(679!*%7*56($"-!/7,56/%3"B9%":,75/"(*"*9!/"/*(.%",: "*9%"5+!*"6%/*%-",+"6%R-!/7,<%6!+."*9%"*6!%-"(+-"*%/*%-"*%79+![5%/",: "!+*%6<%+*!,+"7(66!%-",5*")&"(679!*%7*/"(*"*9!/"*!A%"75$A!+(*!+."!+"("6%=,6*",: "

=,6*:,$!,":,6"&,56"<!%'!+.3"B9%"',6I"7(66!%-",5*"9%6%"(7*%-"A%6%$&"(/"(+"!+*6,-57*!,+"*,"*9%"\=6,)$%A(*![5%/]"/," *9(*"'9%+"A(I!+."-%7!/!,+/" $(*%6",+" !+"-%<%$,=!+."("7,+7%=*"*9%/%",5*7,A%/"7,5$-"!+:,6A"/,A%"I!+-",: "7,+7%=*5($"=6,=,/($3" "#*"*9!/"%(6$&"/*(.%D"-%7!/!,+/",+"=6,.6(A"9(-"+,*")%%+"A(-%"(+-"*9%6%"'(/"+%<%6"(")%R$!%: "*9(*"9,5/!+."',5$-":,6A"*9%")(/!/",: "("=6,=,/($D"!+R/*%(-"*9%6%"'(/"(+"!+*%6%/*"!+"$!+I!+."(+&".!<%+"7,+7%=*"'!*9"*9%"'!-%6"A%-!+("(+-"*9%":6(.A%+*%-"7!*&",: "0%1"b("6%/5$*",: "*9%"06%+79"Q6,*%7*,6(*%"-%<!(*!+.":6,A"!*]/"/*(+-(6-")5$$-,1%6"(==6,(79"(+-"!+/*%(-"/!A=$&")5!$-R

!+."("\+%'"7!*&]"*',"A!$%/"*,'(6-/"*9%"'%/*c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

!A=(7*"7,+/%6<(*!,+]"'(/"A%+*!,+%-D"(/":(6"(/"7,+/%6R<(*!,+"!/"7,+7%6+%-D"*9!/"'(/"'9%+"*9%"A%-!(+"(+-"*9%"7!*&",: "0%1"(/"("'9,$%"/('"!*]/".6%(*%/*"%J=(+/!,+"'!*9"

R*!,+",: "<($5()$%",)@%7*/"*9(*"A(&"$!I%$&")%7,A%"%J*!+7*3"B,-(&D"!*".,%/")%&,+-"("A%6%"7%$%)6(*!,+",: "(+"9!/*,6!R7($"!7,+3"B9%"=6%//56%",: "95A(+"+%%-/",+"56)(+"9%6!*R(.%"/!*%/"9(/"'!-%+%-"*9%"/7,=%",: "7,+/%6<(*!,+"!+"*9(*"!*"+,'"$!%/"!+"*(+-%A"'!*9"/,7!($"(+-"%7,+,A!7"-%<%$,=RA%+*3"L,+/%6<(*!,+!/*/"7(A%"*,"6%($!1%"*9(*"*9%!6"*(/I",: "/765*!+!1!+." /*,+%/" (+-" 7$%(+!+." /56:(7%/" !/" +%.(*!<%$&"(::%7*%-")&"("-%(6*9",: ":5+-!+.3"B9%"=6%//!+."+%%-",: "*9%" =%,=$%"'9,/%" 9%6!*(.%" !/" (" $!<!+." (+-"+,*" (" /*(*!7"$%.(7&"!/"7,+/%[5%+*$&"-(/9%-3

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a!79(6-" 43" Y%<!+%" -%/76!)%/" (/" *9%" \+%/*%-" 6%($A/]" ,: "/,7!($"(+-"75$*56($"A(.+%*/"*9(*"A(I%"(+"9!/*,6!7"7!*&"("

<!/!,+" )%:,6%" !A=$%A%+*(*!,+" ,: " =9&/!7($" =6,@%7*/" !/"%A)(6I%-"5=,+3"C,'%<%6D"*9!/"<!/!,+"/9,5$-"+,*")%"(/R/5A%-"*,")%"("A%6%"=(6(795*%-"!-%(",6"7,A=$%J"%[5(R*!,+")5*"!+<,$<%"("6(*9%6"A,6%"9,$!/*!7"(==6,(79D"'9!79"

Page 18: Revaluating Typological Standards

V

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester One

7(+")%"*6(+/$(*%-"!+*,"(7*!,+"!+"*9%"7,+/%6<(*!,+"/*6(*R%.&3

B9%"=$(++!+."*9%,6!%/"*9(*":,6%7(/*"'9(*"("7!*&"/9,5$-"$,,I" $!I%" !+" *9%" +%J*" *'," ,6" *96%%" -%7(-%/" +," $,+.%6"/*(+-"*,-(&3"B9%6%:,6%D"!+/*%(-",: "/=%+-!+."A579"*!A%",+"=6%=(6!+." (" $,+.R*%6A"56)(+" /7%+(6!,D" (" $%//" *!A%R7,/*$&" ($*%6+(*!<%" !/" +,'" )%!+." -!/75//%-" )&" =$(++%6/3"B9!/"($*%6+(*!<%"!/"$%(6+!+.":6,A")%/*"=6(7*!7%"(+-"(<%6*R!+."*9%"6!/I/"(+-"%66,6/",)/%6<%-3"#/"%(79"56)(+"/!*%"9(/"!*/"=%75$!(6!*!%/"*9%"(66(&",: "*9%!6"<(/*"=6,)$%A/"/9,5$-"*9%6%:,6%")%"7,+/!-%6%-3

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

*9%"a5%"E5%6+!/"C;?"(7*!+."(/"("7(*($&/*":,6"*9!/"=6,R7%//3""L*M"5+*0.*%7@-9(.79*/7>(9-.

?&"5*!$!1!+."*9%"%J!/*!+."/*657*56%"(+-"/!A=$&"6%,6.(+R!1!+."*9%".6!-"*9%"/7($%"(+-"/=(7%",: "*9%"=6,=,/%-"!+R

E56%+!/D" +,6" %::%7*" *9%" 6,,: " $%<%$" ,: " *9%" )5!$-!+." !+"6%$(*!,+"*,"*9%"/566,5+-!+.")5!$-!+./3"B9%".6!-"'(/"76%R(*%-"5/!+."*9%"%J!/*!+."7,56*&(6-/"(/"$!+%(6".5!-%/D"-!/R/%7*!+."*9%":,56"@5J*(=,/%-"7,56*&(6-"/=(7%/"(+-"76%(*R!+." !+*%6%/*!+."=,!+*/",: " !+*%6(7*!,+"'9%6%"*9%/%".6!-/"A%%*D"*9!/"!/"'9%6%"(6*!/*!7"$!7%+/%"9(/"*(I%+"=6%7%-%+*"!+"*9%"=6,=,/%-"/79%A%"&%*"-,%/"+,*"-%*6(7*":6,A"*9%",6!.!+($":%%$",: "*9%")5!$-!+./3"B9%"5/%6/",: "*9%")5!$-!+."

'!$$" )%"=6!+7!=($$&" *,56!/*/"'9!$/*" ($/," %+7,56(.!+." $,R7($"!+<,$<%A%+*"!+"*9%"/=(7%"!/"%//%+*!($"*9%"7%+*%6"'!$$")%"A(!+*(!+%-")&" /*(:: " (+-" 7$!A(*!7($$&" 7,+*6,$$%-"5/R!+."%J!/*!+."*%79+![5%/",: "7,,$!+.3"2(-%"%(/!%6")&"*9%"A(!+*(!+%-"7,56*&(6-"<,!-/" *9(*" (7*" (/"+(*56($" 7,,$%6/",: "*9%"/=(7%3"

B+:7!"#$%&"0%/D"2%-!+(D"%J=(+/!,+"=6,.6%//!,+3"4,567%"8"#5*9,6/"S'+

!"#$%&"0%1D"2%-!+("?$5%"E(*%D"PVNO4,567%"8";ZF4LS

Page 19: Revaluating Typological Standards

PO

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 20: Revaluating Typological Standards

PP

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester Two

>.0.1%.57B,+V+61"*#7%$.7N911.1

B9%"5+!*" :,75/%-",+"7,$$%7*!<%"9,5/!+." !+" *9%" /%7,+-"/%A%/*%6D"7,A=,/%-",: "!+-!<!-5($"7%$$/"/!**!+."(A,+./*"("$(6.%6"=(*79',6I",: ",*9%6"!+*%6$,7I!+."7%$$5$(6"5+!*/3"B9%"=6,7%//",: "6%=%*!*!,+"'(/"%+7,56(.%-"(*"*9!/"/*(.%D"

#f?" /!*D" A!66,6%-" !+" (" 9,6!1,+*($" =,/!*!,+" 65++!+."(76,//" *9%"/!*%D"7,5+*%6!+." *9%"A(!+"(J!($"=(*9" $%(-!+.":6,A"*9%"6,(-"*,"*9%"7(+($"%-.%3"B9%"*5*,6/"/%*",5*"*9%"=6,7%//",: "',6I!+."'!*9!+" *9%"5+!*"(+-"($$,'%-"5/" *,":,$$,'",56",'+"(!A/"(+-"*9%,6%*!7($"(==6,(79%/3"?%6$!+D"(" L!*&" =,//%//!+." A(+&" %J(A=$%/" ,: " 9,5/!+." %J=%6!RA%+*(*!,+" (7*%-" (/" (")(7I-6,=",: "A579",: " *9%"',6I"=6,-57%-"'!*9!+"*9%"5+!*"(+-"5$*!A(*%$&"9(-"("=6,:,5+-"%::%7*"5=,+"A&",'+"/79%A%3

K!*9!+"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,A"*,-(&"*9%"*%+/!,+/"(6!/!+."

6(=!-$&" %J=(+-!+." 7!*!%/" !/" !+76%(/!+.3"C,5/!+." !/" ,+$&"=(6*",: "(" $(6.%6"=!7*56%",: "56)(+"/=6('$3"B9%"69%*,6!7"

56)(+"7%+*%6/"*,"($$%<!(*%"*9%"=6,)$%A/":(7%-")&"-%<%$R

/!*%/"9(<%"+,'")%%+"7$%(6%-"(+-"5+-%6"*9%" $(/*" $(),56"

7%+*%6/" !+*%+/!:&!+." (+-" *9%"A!--$%/" 7$(//%/" 6%*56+!+."*," *9%" 7!*&" 7%+*%6/3" B9%" =6,7%//" 9,'%<%6" 6%$!%-" 5=,+"

B9!/"7,56/%"6%/5$*%-"!+"7,+*%J*5($"/79%A%/")5*" $(7I%-"

!+"9!/";6)(+"B(/I"0,67%"6%=,6*"!/"*,")%7,A%"("+%7%//!*&"!+"*9%":5*56%D"%::%7*!<%"5/%",: "$(+-"!/"<!*($$&"!A=,6*(+*3"

*,"56)(+"6%R5/%"5/5($$&"*(I%/"=$(7%")&"*9%"/%=(6(*%"/5)-!R<!/!,+",: "*9%"/%=(6(*%"$(+-9,$-!+./"(+-"!/"/5)@%7*"*,"*9%"=6,)$%A/",: "/7(**%6%-"$(+-"(+-")5!$-!+."-%<%$,=A%+*D"

Y(),56"E,<e"!+"*9%"=6,<!/!,+",: "=5)$!7"5*!$!*&"(+-"6,(-"',6I/D" $(+-" /9,6*(.%/D" %J7%//!<%" $(+-" /=%75$(*!,+" (+-"

R*!,+"/,A%"A(&"/(&":(!$%-"!+"*9%"A%*9,-,$,.!%/"(-,=*%-"!+"*9%":,6A",: "9,5/!+.3"?&"!+76%(/!+.")5!$-!+."9%!.9*D"56)(+"-'%$$%6/"7,5$-")%"9,5/%-"!+".6%(*%6"+5A)%6/",+"/A($$%6"=$,*/",: "$(+-3"C,'%<%6"A(+&",: "*9%/%"=6,@%7*/D"\Q(6I" C!$$D" a,)!+" C,,-" E(6-%+/]" )%7(A%" (//,7!(*%-"'!*9"-(6ID"-(A="(+-"5+7,A:,6*()$%"7!675$(*!,+"/=(7%/"

(+-"5+6%($!1%-".6%%+"/=(7%"/566,5+-!+."*9%/%"/79%A%/3"G+"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9!/"*9%6%"9(/")%%+"$(6.%R/7($%"7,+-%AR+(*!,+",: "A(+&"9!.9R6!/%"9,5/!+."=6,@%7*/3"B9!/"$%(<%/"

!/"*9!/"'9!79"A&"=6,@%7*/"(!A/"*,"*(7I$%3

V"1%+5"(9-79*/7B$.+5.%"(9-7:+1"%"+*

B96,5.9"("=6,7%//",: "($A,/*"%J=%6!A%+*(*!,+"(+-"6%R

+,*"("\,+%",:: ]"-%/!.+"-%7!/!,+"(+-"A(+&",: "*9%"%(6$&"%JR=%6!A%+*/D"($,+."'!*9"!+:,6A%-"6%(-!+./"/579"(/"2(*9!R(/"C%&-%+]/" \F<,$<!+."Q(6*!7!=(*,6&"H%/!.+8"#"a%=,6*":6,A"?%6$!+D"a%(79!+."?%&,+-]"(+-"0$,6!(+";6)(+/"(6*!R7$%"!+"*9%"W,56+($",: "*9%"4,7!%*&",: "#679!*%7*56($"C!/*,R6!(+/"%+*!*$%-"\a%7,<%6!+."F//%+7%"*96,5.9"H%A,$!*!,+]"

R(/"7,5$-")%"*%/*%-")(/%-"5=,+"(//5A=*!,+/"(+-",)/%6R<(*!,+/"A(-%"!+"*9%"6%(-!+./"(+-"$%7*56%/".!<%+")&"),*9"G/()%$$%"H,57%*"(+-"E6!:: "F<(+/3"2&",'+"=%6/,+($"!+R*%6=6%*(*!,+/",: "\A(//"9,5/!+.]"'%6%"($/,"(--%-"*,"*9%"A!J3"#"=9!$,/,=9&"G"9(-"-%<%$,=%-"!+"=6(7*!7%3"G"9(<%",)/%6<%-D",+"7,5+*$%//",77(/!,+/"*9%"=6,)$%A/":(7%-")&"-%/!.+%6/"'9%+"(/I%-"*,"76%(*%"-!/*!+7*!<%D"A(//"9,5/R!+." *&=,$,.!%/" *," 9,5/%" *9%"A!--$%" (+-" $,'%6" 7$(//%/3"a%R76%(*!+." 7,AA5+!*!%/" 9(/" ,:*%+" )%%+" +%.$%7*%-" !+"6%7%+*"=6!<(*%"(+-"=5)$!7"=6,@%7*/"!+"*9%"=56/5!*",: "=6,:R!*D"7,/*"(+-"/=%%-",: "7,+/*657*!,+3"B9!/"!/"'9%6%"G":%%$"(679!*%7*/"9(<%"!+"*9%"=(/*"(+-"/9,5$-",+7%"(.(!+"=6,R<!-%"("<!*($"6,$%3"S::%6!+."*9%A/%$<%/"(/",6(7$%/",: "*6!%-"(+-"*%/*%-"7,+7%=*/"(+-"*(I!+.":6,A"*9%/%"!+/=!6(*!,+D"'9!$/*"=6,A,*!+."*9%"=6,7%//%/"*9(*"7(+"',6I"!+"(".!<%+"7,AA5+!*&",6"7,+*%J*3"

L*M"5+*0.*%7@-9(.79*/7>(9-.

06,A" PV_O" 5+*!$" *9%" 6!/%" ,: " =,/*" A,-%6+!/A" !+" *9%"PVUO]/D" ,6!%+*(*!,+"'(/"'!-%$&" 6%.(6-%-" (/" (" =6!+7!=($"-%*%6A!+(+*"!+"*9%":,6A"(+-"$(&,5*",: "9,5/!+."'!*9!+"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,A3"B9%"\6!.9*"*,"/5+$!.9*]")%7(A%"(+"!A=,6*(+*" :(7*,6" !+" =%,=$%]/" $!<%/3" B9!/" )%7(A%" %/=%R7!($$&" *65%" !+" *9%" $,'%6" /,7!($" 7$(//%/D" 5+()$%" *," *6(<%$"()6,(-3"B9%" 6%/5$*"'(/" 7,66%7*$&",6!%+*(*%-"=$(+/" *9(*"*,,I"(-<(+*(.%",: "/,$(6".(!+/3"

K!*9"*9%"%A=9(/!/",+"9!.9"56)(+"-%+/!*&"*9%/%"=6!+7!R=$%/D"'9!79"9(-"!+"(+&"7(/%")%7,A%"/,A%'9(*"-!/76%-R!*%-" (/" (" 6%/5$*" ,: " *9%" 5+/(*!/:(7*,6&"=6!,6!*&" .!<%+" *,",6!%+*(*!,+"6(*9%6"*9(+"/*6%%*"(+-"=$(7%"A(I!+.D"/%%A"*,"9(<%")%%+",<%6$,,I%-3"0$(*/"!+"9!.9R-%+/!*&D"/%A!R56)(+"-%<%$,=A%+*/" $!I%"Z%'" G/$!+.*,+" 9(<%" +,*" ,+$&" 9(<%"*9%!6"=6!+7!=($"$!<!+."6,,A/":(7!+."F(/*",6"%<%+"Z,6*9D"

!"#$%&74!%A%+//*(-*D"?%6$!+D"9,5/!+."-%<%$,=A%+*3"4,567%8"Q(5$3K3W,9+"

Page 21: Revaluating Typological Standards

PN

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 22: Revaluating Typological Standards

Cultural Context I: Response to Unit Proposition - Semester Two

)5*")&"=$(++!+." *9%A",+"%!*9%6" /!-%",: "("7%+*6($" 7,6R6!-,6D" *9%&",+$&"9(-"("/!+.$%"(/=%7*D"A(I!+."*9,/%"+,*".%**!+."-!6%7*"/5+$!.9*"-(6I"(+-".$,,A&D"(+-"*9,/%"'!*9",<%6"=6%/76!)%-"(77%//"*,"/5+$!.9*"(*"6!/I",: ",<%69%(*R

6%.(6-%-"(/"("+%7%//!*&D".,,-"-%/!.+"A5/*"6%-!/7,<%6"*9%"R

$&1!+."*9%"/I&"<!%'":(7*,6/",: "7,AA,+$&":,5+-"56)(+"9,5/!+."*&=,$,.!%/"("/%$%7*!,+"7(+")%"A(-%",+"*9%"*&=%"A,/*" /5!*%-" :,6" 9!.9" -%+/!*&" $!<!+." *9(*" ($/," !+7,6=,R6(*%/"*9%"5/%6/"+%%-/":,6":(A!$!(6!*&3"G+",6-%6"*,"(79!%<%"-%+/!*&"'9!$/*"/*!$$"()!-!+."*,"*9%"$('/",: "/,$(6",6!%+*(R*!,+D"G"-%/!.+%-"("9&)6!-"*&=,$,.&"*9(*"!+7,6=,6(*%/"*9%"(-<(+*(.%/",: "*9%"%J!/*!+."-%/!.+"A%*9,-,$,.!%/",: "($$"

9,5/%D"*9%"A,-%6+!/*"/$()D"*9%"=,!+*")$,7ID"*9%"=%6!AR%*%6")$,7I"(+-"*9%"/I&/76(=%6"6%/5$*!+."!+"*9%"\G/$!+.*,+"?$,7I]3"#"*&=,$,.&"A!J!+."4g0"b4I&"g!%'"0(7*,6/c"(+-"("7,A:,6*()$%"-%.6%%",: "56)(+!*&" !+" *9%" :,6A",: "-!/R/%7*!+."/*6%%*/D"6%*(!$"5+!*/"(+-"("*6%%"$!+%-"(J!($"6,5*%3

G+"*9!/"\:(I%]"56)(+"/%**!+."("/%+/%",: "=$(7%"%J!/*/"'9%+"6%/!-%+*/"9(<%"("=%6A(+%+*"('(6%+%//",: ")%$,+.!+."*,"

+%!.9),69,,-",6"%<%+"'!*9"("7,A=,+%+*",: "("+%!.9),6R9,,-"*9(*"',6I/D"(+-"A,/*"!A=,6*(+*$&D"!/"%/*%%A%-")&"6%/!-%+*/3"G: "'%"(77%=*"*9(*"("/%+/%",: "=$(7%"9(/"!A=,6R*(+7%D",)<!,5/"[5%/*!,+/"(6%8"9,'"$(6.%"-,%/"("/79%A%"9(<%"*,")%")%:,6%"!*"7(+"%+:,67%"("\/%+/%",: "=$(7%]D"(+-"!*"

,: "*9%"/79%A%3

B9%"(+/'%6"A(&"($/,"$!%"!+"("=%67%!<%-"\$,+.%<!*&]",: "("

/9%$: "$!:%",: "_O"&%(6/"(+-"6%:56)!/9%-"9,5/!+."("$!:%",: "

$,7($R(5*9,6!*&" )5!$-!+." /=6%%" ,: " *9%" %(6$&" =,/*R'(6"&%(6/D" A(+&" /,7!($R9,5/!+." =6,.6(A/" /'!*79%-" :6,A"+%'R)5!$-" *," 6%:56)!/9!+."+!+%*%%+*9R7%+*56&" *%66(7%/3"

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

#79!%<!+."("\/%+/%",: "=$(7%]"!/"76%(*%-")&"5/!+."A(*%6!($/"(+-"(679!*%7*56($"A%*9,-,$,.!%/"*9(*"6%A(!+"7,+*%J*5($"&%*"7,+*%A=,6(6&3"`%&":(7*,6/"!+"76%(*!+."("/79%A%"*9(*":%%$/"6,,*%-"(+-"!/"+,'"7,+/!-%6%-"*,"&!%$-"/577%//:5$"7,AA5+!*!%/"),*9"!+"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,A"(+-"()6,(-3"

4*7>60095Q

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

!"#$%78.*%5.&7B9%"!-%(",: "$,+.%<!*&"7(+")%"%+7(=/5$(*%-"5/!+."(679!R*%7*56($"%$%A%+*/")5*"("\9!/*,6&]"!/"($'(&/"9(6-"*,"(79!%<%"4,567%8"

(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 23: Revaluating Typological Standards

P^

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 24: Revaluating Typological Standards

PX

Cultural Context II: Personal Proposition - Semester One

#7:275;:+#0123<2+%%=+

?35401;:?50>0492901

>.0.1%.57A*.8+65%Q95/7V+61"*#

85"%"(9-7W6/#0.*%1

B9%" -%/!.+" =6,7%//" :,$$,'%-" (+" %J*%+/!<%" 6%/%(679"=9(/%/" !+*," *6(-!*!,+($" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/!+.D" /%A!R7,+R*%A=,6(6&" /*&$%/D" %3.3" *9%" ',6I" ,: " C(//(+" 0(*9&" (+-"A,<!+." !+*," *9%"A,6%"A,-%6+!/*"=6,=,/($/",: "#B#?"#:6![5%3" G+" *%6A/" ,: " (" -%/!.+" =6,7%//"'%"'%6%" .!<%+"(" $,,/%" =6,7%//" (+-" *9!/" ($$,'%-"A%" *," %/*()$!/9" A&",'+"',6I!+."A%*9,-/3"G"76%(*%-"("A!J",: "A,-%$/"(+-"=6,-57%-"("+5A)%6",: "!+!*!($"-6('!+./"*,"%+()$%"*,"A%"

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h(-%"(+-")&"(-9%6!+."*,";ZF4LS"7,+/%6<(*!,+"/*(+-(6-/"G"!+R*%+-%-" *,"A(!+*(!+" *9%" /7($%" (+-" :%%$" ,: " *9%" %J!/*!+."'($$/")&"/!A=$&"!+*%6%/*!+."*',"+%'"%+*6(+7%/D",+%"A,6%"=6,+,5+7%-"*9(+"*9%",*9%63"B9!/"*,,I"!+/=!6(*!,+":6,A"

/,A%",: "*9%"6%$!.!,5/"/79,,$/":,5+-"!+"*9%"A%-!+("(+-"',5$-"(7*"(/"("/!.+($"*,"=(//%6/")&",: "*9%"$,7(*!,+",: "*9%"%+*6(+7%"(/"*9!/"7,5$-"9(<%")%%+"5+9%%-%-"!+"(+"(6%(",: "*9!/"/=(*!($"7,A=$%J!*&3

8+*%.0:+595Q78+*%.=%

a%/*,6!+."*9%"<!6*5%/",: "(+"(6%("$!I%"*9%"A%-!+("!+"0%/"

!/"/%%+"(/"("/!+.5$(6"%+*!*&D"7,+/%6<(*!,+",: "(+&")5!$-R!+."A5/*"=6,<!-%" ("5*!$!*&" :,6" *9%" 7,AA5+!*&" (+-" *9%"

/=(7%3"B9%"A%-!+("A5/*"+,*")%"/%%+"(/"("+,/*($.!7"%+<!R6,+A%+*"(+-"G")%$!%<%"A&"/79%A%D"'!*9"!*]/"A!J*56%",: "

$!*%6($$&"7,+/%6<(*!,+"(+-"/,7!($"(+-"(679!*%7*56($"7,+R/%6<(*!,+3"B9%"A%-!+(D" (/" (+"%+*!*&"9(/"79(+.%-",+"("+5A)%6",: ",77(/!,+/"(+-"!*"!/"*96,5.9"%<,$5*!,+"*9(*"!*"'!$$"/56<!<%3"L,+/%6<(*!,+!/*/")%$!%<%"*9(*"*9!/"A(&"/=%$$"*9%"%+-":,6"/577%//:5$"6%/*,6(*!,+/D"5*!$!1!+.",6!.!+($"%$%RA%+*/3"?5*"!+"(+"(6%("(/"=(*79"',6I%-"(/"*9!/"+,*9!+."

R

A&"/79%A%"(79!%<%/"*9!/3"?&"5*!$!1!+."A,-%6+")5!$-!+."*%79+![5%/"(+-"%$%A%+*/"'9!$%"/*!$$"6%/*,6!+."*9%"%J!/*!+."/*657*56%"(+-"/9,'!+."!*"!+"!*/":5$$"$!.9*"*9!/"=6,7%//"'!$$"

(),5*" *9%" +(*56%" ,: " A,-%6+" 7,+/%6<(*!,+" !+" =6,*%7*";ZF4LS"C%6!*(.%"/!*%/"/579"(/"*9!/3

!"#$%78.*%5.&7B9%"%+*6(+7%"*,"*9%"a5%"E5%6+!/"L5$*56($"L6(:*/"L%+*6%"

4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 25: Revaluating Typological Standards

P_

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 26: Revaluating Typological Standards

Cultural Context II: Personal Proposition - Semester Two

>.0.1%.57B,+V+61"*#7%$.7N911.1

85"%"(9-7W6/#0.*%1

G+"*%6A/",: "I%&"A,A%+*/",6"=9(/%/"!+"*9%"-%/!.+"=6,R7%//"*9%/%"%J!/*%-"!+"*9%":6,A",: "*96%%"-!/*!+7*"(+-"!+R*%+/%"6%/%(679"%J%67!/%"=9(/%/"7,A)!+%-"'!*9"("/%*",: "6%(-!+./3" F(79" =9(/%/" $(/*!+." ,+%" '%%I" *9!/" .(<%" *9%"5+!*"(-%[5(*%"*!A%"*,"*%/*"(+-"!A=6,<%"5=,+"*9%"',6I"7(66!%-" ,5*" !+" *9%" (:*%6+,,+" ',6I/9,=/3" B9%" =9(/%/"

R*65&"2!%*/I(/%6+%D" *9%"G+*%6R'(6"4!%-$5+.%+"(+-"Q,/*R'(6"B6()(+*%+/*(%-*%3"G+"*9%/%"6%/%(679"=9(/%/"'%"'%6%"

*&=,$,.&D"*%/*!+."!*"!+"(+",6!.!+($"-%/!.+",6"(--!+."!*"*,"(+"($6%(-&".6,'!+."(66(&",: "!-%(/"(+-"7,+7%=*/"=6%/%+*R%-"(+-"',6I%-"5=,+" !+" *9%"(:*%6+,,+"',6I/9,=3"B9%"#+7,(*/"(6%(D"(+-"(/"!*"!/"+,'"I+,'+"*9%"Z%'"G/$!+.*,+"(6%("9(/"("9!/*,6&",: "*%+%A%+*")5!$-!+."/!A!$(6"*,"*9(*":,5+-"!+"*9%"?%6$!+"2!%*/I(/%6+%D"'!*9"("/9(6%-"7,56*R&(6-i=5)$!7"6%($A"/!**!+."(*"*9%"A!--$%",: "*9%"7,A=$%J3"G" :,5+-" *9!/" :(/7!+(*!+." (+-" =56/%-" *9!/" (==6,(79" !+"A(+&",: "*9%"%(6$&"A,-%$/"G"=6,-57%-3"B6&!+."*,"(79!%<%"

-%+/!*&" *,"("-%.6%%"'9%6%"/%+/%",: "=$(7%"'(/"+,*"5+R-%6A!+%-3"#/"A(+&",: " *9%/%" \2(+79%/*%6"B%+%A%+*/]"9(<%")%%+"-%A,$!/9%-"(+-"*9%"?%6$!+"*&=,$,.&"$!A!*!+."-5%"*,"!*]/"=6(7*!7($"-%/!.+"G"-%7!-%-"*,"!+7,6=,6(*%"%$%RA%+*/" ,: "A,6%"A,-%6+!/*" .6!-" (+-" 7%$$5$(6" =$(++!+.D"

R*56%/" !A=$%A%+*%-")&"B%(A"POD"/579"(/" \a,)!+"C,,-"E(6-%+/]"-%/!.+%-")&"#$!/,+"(+-"Q%*%6"4A!*9/,+3"B9%"A,-%$"A(I!+." =6,7%//" ,: "A&" -%/!.+" /*6(*%.&" :,6A%-"(+" !+*6!+/!7" %$%A%+*" !+" ($$,'!+."A%" *," ,<%67,A%" *9%",)/*(7$%" ,: " 76%(*!+." (" [5(/!" $!I%" /%$:R!A=,/%-" \56)(+R!*&]"*9(*":%$*".6,5+-%-"!+"*9%"/566,5+-!+."(6%(3"a%$&!+."5=,+"A(*%6!($!*&"!/"+,*"/!A=$&"*9%",+$&"'(&"!+"'9!79"*,"(79!%<%"/%+/%",: "=$(7%"(+-"*9%"A(/*%6=$(++!+.",: " *9%"/!*%" :,6A%-" *9%"=6!+7!=($" :,75/"=,!+*",: "A579",: "A&"',6I3"E%**!+."*9!/"6!.9*"'(/"*9%"A(!+":,75/"(+-"5=,+"

/7($%/"(+-"7,A=$%J!*&"'%6%"=6,-57%-"*,"*6&"(+-"*%/*"*9%"7,+7%=*/"=6%/%+*%-"*,"A%"!+"*9%"A,6+!+."$%7*56%/3"G"(6R6!<%-"%<%+*5($$&"(*"*9%"9&)6!-"\Z%'"G/$!+.*,+]")$,7I"<!("("/%6!%/",: "A,-%$/"(+-"-!/75//!,+/"'!*9"A&"*5*,6D"*9!/"=6,7%//"'(/"6%7,6-%-"!+"*9%":,6A",: "(+"\(7*!<%"(679!<R

,+"*9%"',6I"=6,-57%-3"B9!/"=6,7%//",: "',6I!+."!/"+,*"7,AA,+" !+" *9%" /79,,$" &%*" !*" ($$,'%-"A%" *,"(79!%<%"("9!.9" $%<%$",: "/,=9!/*!7(*!,+" !+"A&"-%/!.+",<%6"("/9,6*"=%6!,-",: "*!A%3"

8+*%.0:+595Q78+*%.=%

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

/=(7%/D" b76%(*%-")&" $,7(*!+."=(6I!+."(*")(/%A%+*" $%<%$c"%+7,56(.%/" 7,AA5+!*&" !+*%6(7*!,+" *9,5.9" %<%+*/" (+-"79!$-"=$(&3" G: " *9%6%"'(/",+%"76!*!7!/A",: "A(+&",: " *9%"A,-%6+!/*"9,5/!+."=6,@%7*/"!*"'(/"*9(*"=5)$!7"/=(7%"'(/"

=6,@%7*"=5)$!7"/=(7%"=$(&%-"("I%&"6,$%":6,A"*9%",5*/%*"(+-"'(/"A(6I%-",5*"!+"*9%"A,-%$"A(I!+."=6,7%//3"K!*9R!+"*9%"-!/7!=$!+%"!*/%$: "*9%"=6,@%7*",::%6/"($*%6+(*!<%/"*,"9!.9R6!/%" (+-" $,'R6!/%" /,7!($" 9,5/!+." /5..%/*!+." *9(*"9!.9"-%+/!*&"-,%/"+,*"($'(&/"A%(+"$(7I",: "7,AA5+!*&D"(" 76!*!7!/A",: "A(+&",: " *9%"A,-%6+!/*"9,5/!+.")$,7I/"*9(*"'%"/('"-%A,$!/9%-"!+"*9%"PVVO]/3

!"#$%&7g!%'"*96,5.9"(=(6*A%+*D"\C,5/!+."*9%"2(//%/]"/%A%/*%6"*',"

=6,@%7*3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 27: Revaluating Typological Standards

PU

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 28: Revaluating Typological Standards

PV

Design and Communication: Outline of 5th Year Studio Work - Semester One

@349A1+B+#0CC7198;2901=+

D72:913+0E+/3;5+F+*27690+G05H

>.0.1%.57A*.8+65%Q95/7V+61"*#

B9%":,$$,'!+."79(=*%6" !/",6.(+!1%-" !+"/579"("'(&"*9(*"%(79" /*5-!," )6!%: " !/" =6%/%+*%-" (+-" *9%+" (" /5AA(6&"5+-%6" *9%"9%(-!+./" 6%[5!6%-" !+" (77,6-(+7%"'!*9"#a?"$%(6+!+." L6!*%6!(3" B9%/%" /5AA(6!%/" '!$$" )%" )6!%: " )5*"9!.9$!.9*"*9%"<($!-"7,+*6!)5*!,+/"(+-"6%/=,+/%"A(-%"*,R'(6-/"*9%"/%*")6!%:/3

)@%4(2)66'-*&#3%&</66%/664('&-=',(4%#)66'&)%#-&/666%#666+-#$666+*(,<=(2.666%2<666*&+%2666/'%,)/666%2<666#$)(&6660-#)2#(%,666&-,)666%/666*&+%2666'%#%,3/#666?-&666F'-666'(#()/"65$)666'-2')0#/666-? 666*&+%2666'%#%,3/#/666%2<666F'-'(#()/666!(,,666+)666)@0,-&)<666+)?-&)666&)B()!(2.666#$)666,(#)&%#*&)666%&-*2<666'-*&#3%&<66$-*/(2.66%/66%66B)&2%'*,%&66?-&4>66%<-0#)<66%2<66%<%0#)<66(266B%&(-*/66',(4%#('>66/-'(%,66%2<66'*,#*&%,666'-2#)@#/"666V)!666?-&4/666-? 666'-*&#3%&<666$-*/(2.666%&)666)4)&.(2.666(2666#$)6669W666/*'$666%/666#$)666XNS8666%!%&<666!(22(2.6668''-&<(%66<)B),-04)2#66(266:%4+&(<.)66+366G)(,<)266:,)..66S&%<,)3668&'$(=#)'#/66%2<66Y-223+&--166A*%&#)&66+3666Z)#)&66S%&+)&"665$)/)66%2<66-#$)&66$-*/(2.660&-C)'#/66!(,,66+)66*/)<66#-66<(/'*//66,-!66&(/)66$(.$66<)2/(#366$-*/(2.666(266#$)669W66%2<66#$)66%<-0#(-266-? 662)!664-<),/"66

O#*<)2#/666!(,,666!-&1666(26660%(&/666#-666<)B),-0666%2666*2<)&/#%2<=(2.666-? 666#$)666%&'$(#)'#*&%,666%2<666)2B(&-24)2#%,666A*%,(#()/6-? 6+-#$6B)&2%'*,%&6%2<66'-2#)40-&%&366'-*&#3%&<66$-*/(2.66#$&-*.$66

/#*<3666(2666#$)6664)<(2%666-? 666I%&&%1)'$666!(,,666+)666-&.%2(/)<666/-666#$%#666/#*<)2#/666%'A*(&)666%2666)@0)&()2#(%,666*2<)&/#%2<=(2.666-? 666#$)666I-&-''%2666B)&2%'*,%&666'-*&#3%&<666$-*/)666%2<666-? 666*&+%2666/0%')/666(2666#$)666$(/#-&('666,-!666&(/)666$(.$666<)2/(#3666

'(#36665$)6660&-@(4(#3666-? 666#$)666G&)2'$666:-,-2(%,666'(#3666!(,,666%,,-!666/#*<)2#/666#-666*2<)&/#%2<666#!-666B)&3666<(??)&)2#666*&+%26664-&0$-,-.()/666%2<666#$)(&666%//-'(%#)<666+*(,<(2.666#30-,-.()/666%2<666

%2<666#-666#$)666&%0(<,3666'$%2.(2.666/-'(%,>666'*,#*&%,666%2<666)'-2-4('666'-2<(#(-2/666+-#$666(2666I-&-''-666%2<666(2666#$)6669W"6665$)666/#*=

I%2'$)/#)&666%2<666(2666#$)666$(/#-&('666?%+&('666-? 666I%&&%1)'$666(2666-&<)&666#-666<)B),-066#$)66<)/(.266-? 66%66'-2#)40-&%&366',*/#)&66-? 66'-*&#3%&<66$-*/)/66%/66*&+%266'%#%,3/#/"66

2(.(-("4!)$%&"R"#(;L"4%A%/*%6"S+%"?6!%:

Y%//,+/"$%(6+*"!+"*9%"%(6$&"/*(.%/",: "*9%"6%/%(679"=6,R7%//"=6,<!-%-"A%"'!*9"*9%"*9%,6%*!7($".6,5+-!+.":6,A"'9!79"*,"7,+7%!<%"(+-"7,+/*657*"A%"-%/!.+3"S56"<!/!*"*,"0%/"=6,<!-%-"A%"'!*9"(+"!+/!.9*"!+*,"9,'"A(+&",: "*9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%/" +,'" /%6<%" (" -!::%6%+*" =56=,/%"(+-"*9%!6"(-(=*()!$!*&"!/"/,A%'9(*":(/7!+(*!+.3"B9%"/!AR=$!7!*&" ,: " *9%!6" $(&,5*" ($$,'/" :,6" (" <%6&" 9!.9" $%<%$" ,: "

!+"*9%"2%-!+("!+"0%/3"2&"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9%")6!%: "79(+.%-"/,A%'9(*" (/" *9%" /%A%/*%6" =6,.6%//%-" *96,5.9" .5!-R(+7%":6,A"A&"*5*,6/3"B9!/"'(/"-5%"*,"*!A%"7,+/*6(!+*/"

=6,7%//" ,: " -%/!.+!+." (" \7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%]" =%6" /%" '(/"()(+-,+%-" (+-" G"-%7!-%-" *,"=56/5%" (" 6%/*,6(*!,+" (+-"7,+/%6<(*!,+" 6,5*%" '9!$/*" 5*!$!1!+." A&" 5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: " *9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%" (/" (+" (-(=*()$%" %+*!*&]3" " B9%"I+,'$%-.%".(!+%-"*96,5.9"6%/%(679"'(/"+,*"'(/*%-"(+-"A&"=%6/,+($"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9%")6!%: "($*9,5.9"+,*"-!6%7*D"-!-"!+7,6=,6(*%"/,A%",: "*9%"I%&"=,!+*/"6(!/%-"!+"*%6A/"

06(7*($".6,'*9"=(*R*%6+"%J=%6!A%+*/3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/"

,'+3

Page 29: Revaluating Typological Standards

NO

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

5*!$!1!+."*9%"7,56*&(6-"/=(7%"(/"\A!76,7$!A(*!7"76%(*,6/]"(+-"A&"6%/=,+/%"*,"*9%"-%)(*%",: "*9%!6"6%$%<(+7%"*,"F7,"L!*!%/"!+"("=6,*%7*%-"56)(+"%+<!6,+A%+*3

E.1"#*7N.%$+/+-+#Q

2,-%$"A(I!+."=$(&%-"("$(6.%"6,$%"!+"5+-%6/*(+-!+."*9%"/566,5+-!+.":()6!7"(+-"/7($%-"A,-%$",: "*9%"=6,J!A!*&"A%-!+("'(/"=6,-57%-3"B9!/"%+()$%-"5/"*,"A%(/56%"*9%"!A=(7*"!+"(".6,5="*9(*",56"+%'"(--!*!,+/"',5$-"9(<%3"G"($/,"7,+-57*%-"("+5A)%6",: "7,A=5*%6"/76!=*!+."%J=%6!RA%+*/"!+",6-%6"*,".(5.%"*9%"%::%7*/"A&"(--!*!,+"',5$-"9(<%",+"*9%":5*56%".6,'*9",6"7,+*6(7*!,+",: "*9%"A%-!+(D"*9!/"'(/"7(66!%-",5*"5/!+."Q,/*"Q6,7%//!+."/,:*'(6%"(+-"-!/=$(&%-"*9%"7,+*6(7*!,+"(+-"%J=(+/!,+",: "*9%"A%-!+(",<%6"("/%*"=%6!,-3"#"'(J"A,-%$"'(/"($/,")5!$-"!+",6-%6"*,"($!.+"*9%"7,56*&(6-"/=(7%/",+"*9%"/!*%"*,"*9%"/=(7%/"79,/%+"(/" *9%"A(!+"(6%(/",: " :,75/D"%::%7*!<%$&"9%$=!+."A%"*,"(//%//",+7%"(.(!+"*9%"%::%7*",+"/=(7%D"9%!.9*"(+-"($!.+A%+*"A&" =6,=,/%-" 6%/*,6(*!,+"',5$-" 9(<%" 5=,+"*9%"/566,5+-!+."-'%$$!+./"(+-"',6I/9,=/3"

B9%"!+!*!($"7,+7%=*/"'%6%"*%/*%-D"(+-"6%*%/*%-"5/!+."=$(+",<%6$(&/"(+-"/A($$R/7($%"A,-%$/"!+",6-%6"*,"(/7%6*(!+"*9%"

,+"("=6,@%7*",: "*9!/"/7($%"(+-"<(6&!+."(.%/",: "*9%"(-@(R7%+*"-'%$$!+./"'9%6%"7,+/*657*!,+"*%79+![5%/"-!::%6"(/"'%$$"(/"$%<%$"79(+.%/3"B9%"=9&/!7($"A,-%$"=$(&%-"("=(6*"!+"9%$=!+."5/"*,"5+-%6/*(+-"*9%/%"79(+.%/"(+-"'(/"5/%-"%J*%+/!<%$&"*96,5.9,5*"*9%"-%/!.+"=6,7%//3"G+",6-%6"*,"=6%/%+*" *9%"A,/*" 7%+*6($" (/=%7*/" ,: "A&" -%/!.+" G" %AR)(6I%-"5=,+"=6,-57!+."("/%*",: "<!/5($/"*9(*"',5$-":5$R

!A=,6*(+*"6,$%"!+"=6%/%+*!+."A&"-%/!.+"A%*9,-,$,.&3"

8+*1%56(%"+*78+*%.=%

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

Page 30: Revaluating Typological Standards

NP

Design and Communication: Outline of 5th Year Studio Work - Semester Two

>.0.1%.57B,+V+61"*#7%$.7N911.1

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

/'%,)>6 #30)6 %2<6 /'-0)6 -? 6 #$)6 (2#)&B)2#(-2"6 )"."6 0*+,('6 $%,,!%3/>6

<).&))6-? 60*+,('2)//6-? 6/$%&)<6/0%')/6D'-&&(<-&/>6$%,,!%3/>62*4+)&6-? 6&--4/>6<--&/E>6(2#).&%#(-260*+,('6%2<60&(B%#)6/0%')/"6O#*<)2#/6%&)6)@0)'#)<6#-60&)/)2#6#$)(&6<)/(.26&)/)%&'$6#$&-*.$6#$&))6)@)&='(/)/>6-? 6!$('$60-//(+,36+*#62-#62)')//%&(,36-2)6!(,,6+)6!-&1)<6-*#6(2#-6.&)%#)&6<)#%(,"65$)6<)/(.2)&,36&)/)%&'$6NO6#$)60&-C)'#>6/-6!)6<-2;#6%(46#-6'-2/(<)&6#$)/)6#$&))6)@)&'(/)/6%/6%2%,3/(/6#-6!$('$6#$)26%6<)/(.26!(,,6?-,,-!"6N2/#)%<6#$)36!(,,6'&)%#)6%267%'#(B)6%&'$(B);6-&6&)%,=#(4)6 &)'-&<(2.6 -? 6 #$)(&6 ,)%&2(2."6Y)0)2<(2.6 -26 '$-/)26 &)=/)%&'$6<)/(.26?-'*/)/>6/#*<)2#/6%&)6)@0)'#)<6#-60&)/)2#6#$)(&6!-&16#$&-*.$6'-2')0#*%,6<&%!(2./>6<(%.&%4/>6#)@#/>6#$&-*.$6#30-,-.('%,6

=#(-26-? 6%2<64%/#)&(2.6-? 6&)0&)/)2#%#(-2%,6#--,/6%&)6'-2/(<)&)<6%/60%&#6-? 6#$)6<)/(.26&)/)%&'$6)@)&'(/)"

H63" G/()%$$%"H,57%*"T"E6!:: "F<(+/" R"#(;L"4%A%/*%6"B',"?6!%:

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

7,+7%=*3"G+",6-%6"*,"*%/*"*9%"7,+7%=*"(.(!+/*"*9%")6!%: "/%*",5*")&"*9%"*5*,6/"G"=6,-57%-"("+5A)%6",: "A,-%$/"*,"*%/*"*9%"!-%(",: "=5)$!7"/=(7%D"*9%/%"'%6%"=9,*,.6(=9%-"(+-"6%7,6-%-"(+-"=6,<!-%-"A%"'!*9"(".6,5+-%-D"*%/*%-"(+-" *9%,6%*!7($$&" )(/%-" =,/!*!,+" :6,A" '9!79" *," =6,R.6%//"A&"-%/!.+3"2&"=9!$,/,=9!7($"(==6,(79"'(/")(/%-"

(6,5+-" *9%" 7,+7%=*" (+-"'%$$" 6%/%(679%-"=,/!*!,+" *9(*"/,7!($"9,5/!+.",: "*9%" $(/*" *'%+*&"&%(6/"9(/"/*($$%-"-5%"*,"*9%":(!$56%/D"(+-"(-,=*!,+",: "*%79+![5%/"=6%/%+*%-"!+"*9%"PV_O]/3"B9%"<%6&")%/*"%J(A=$%/",: "=5)$!7"9,5/!+."(*"*9!/"*!A%"',6I%-"'%$$"(+-",:*%+"(79!%<%-"("A%(/56()$%"-%.6%%",: "!A=6,<%-"$!<!+.3"B9%/%"*%79+![5%/"'%6%"6%=R$!7(*%-"(+-"/,A%'9(*"-!$5*%-"!+":56*9%6"/79%A%/"(76,//"*9%";+!*%-"̀ !+.-,A3"B9%",5*7,A%",: "*9!/"'(/"/79%A%/"*9(*"$(7I%-"(+&"*9%,6%*!7($",6"(7(-%A!7".6,5+-!+.3"L,+R*%J*"'(/"!.+,6%-"(+-"'9(*":,$$,'%-"'(/"*9%"()(+-,+RA%+*",: "*9%/%"9!.9R-%+/!*&"9,5/!+."=6,@%7*/3"B9%"=,/!R*!,+" G" *,,I" :6,A"(+"%(6$&"=,!+*"'(/" *9%" 6%-%$!<%6&",: "*9%/%"/79%A%/")5*"'!*9"($*%6(*!,+/"A(-%"*,"%+:,67%"*9%"7,+*%A=,6(6&" !-%($",: " $!<!+."(+-"/5/*(!+()!$!*&3"C,5/R!+."!/"(*"("/9,6*(.%"!+"*9!/"7,5+*6&D"(+-"*,"(".6%(*%6"-%R.6%%" /,7!($" (+-"(::,6-()$%3" G: " *9!/" !/" *,")%" /,$<%-"(+-"*9%"*%79+![5%",: ")5!$-!+."(::,6-()$%"9,A%/")%7,A%"("

(6%(/" (+-" $!.9*!+."A5/*"+,*")%7,A%" *9%"+,6A3"B9%/%"=6,7%//%/"($,+."'!*9"*9%"(-,=*!,+",: "=5)$!7"/=(7%/"(/"("<!*($"-%/!.+"7,+/*6(!+*"($$,'%-"A%"*,"-%/!.+"("/79%A%"*9(*"(-9%6%/"*,"*9%/%"!+9%6%+*"=6!+7!=$%/3"

E.1"#*7N.%$+/+-+#Q

B9%"*%/*!+.",: "!-%(/"'(/"7(66!%-",5*"5/!+."("/%*",: "7,ARA5+!7(*!,+"A%-!5A/3"Q6%/%+*(*!,+",: "7,+7%=*/"*,"*9%"5+!*"(+-"A&"=%%6/"(7*%-"(/"(".,,-"'(&",: "*%/*!+."("+%'"!-%(" (/" '%$$" (/" ,::%6!+." 5=" +%'" ($*%6+(*!<%/3" Q9&/!7($"(6%(/" ,: " *9%"A,-%$/" =6,-57%-"'%6%" ($/,"A%(/56%-" !+"

/,:*'(6%RA%(/56!+." *%79+![5%/3"B9%" (-,=*!,+",: " (5.RA%+*%-"6%($!*&"!+"*9%"-%/!.+"=6,7%//"($/,"($$,'%-"A%"*,"*%/*"A&"7,+7%=*/"!+"6%($"*!A%D"(+-"($$,'%-":,6"(":(6"A,6%"

?&"-!(.6(AA!+."(+-"A(==!+."*9%"',6I!+."=6,7%//"G"(-R9%6%-"*,"*9%"=6!+7!=$%/"/%*",5*"!+"*9%"=6,@%7*")6!%:3"B9%"76%(*!,+",: "\!A(.%/]",6"\A,+*(.%/]"!+"=6%/%+*!+."(+"!-%("'(/"=(6(A,5+*"(+-" *9!/" :,6A%-" *9%")(/!/",: "A&" 6%=R6%/%+*(*!,+"=6,7%//3"B9%"\(7*!<%"(679!<!+.]"=6,7%//"'(/"6%7,6-%-"!+"*9%":,6A",: "("\',6I!+."*!A%"$!+%]"*9(*"'(/"

=6,7%//"($,+."*9%"*!A%$!+%",: "*9%"/%<%+"'%%I"',6I!+."=%6!,-3"

N9"*[email protected].*%9%"+*7N./"601

Q9,*,"A,+*(.!+.#5.A%+*%-"a%($!*&2,-%$"2(I!+.4I%*79!+.iQ$(+",<%6$(&"-!(.6(AA!+.

!"#$%7B+:&7;*!$!/!+."(5.A%+*%-"6%($!*&"<!/5($!/(*!,+"*%79+![5%/"*,"*%/*"-%/!.+3"

4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

H%/!.+!+."'!*9"A,-%$/3"\C,5/!+."*9%"2(//%/]"/%A%/*%6"

*',3"4,567%8"(5*9,6/",'+3

Page 31: Revaluating Typological Standards

NN

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 32: Revaluating Typological Standards

Dissertation

@944352;2901=+

!I425;82

B"%-.

L$,+%RL!*&"R"C(/"*9%"Z,*!,+",: "\Q$(7%]"?%%+";+-%6A!+%-")&"L566%+*"2,-%$/"!+"a%*(!$"Q$(++!+."(+-"H%/!.+j

'K1%59(%7

B9%"56)(+"$(+-/7(=%",: "4,5*9"K($%/]"*',"$(6.%/*"7!*!%/D"Z%'=,6*"(+-"L(6-!:: "9(/")%%+" !+"(" /*(*%",: "7,+/*(+*"*6(+/:,6A(*!,+"/!+7%"*9%"!+*%6R'(6"=%6!,-/D"(77%$%6(*%-"!+"*9%"PV_O]/"'!*9"*9%"7$%(6!+.",: "*9%"!+-5/*6!($"7%+*6%/",: "*9%/%"*',"7!*!%/"(+-"*9%"=6,.6%//!,+"*,"("/%6<!7%")(/%-"%7,+,A&3"B9%"5+/5!*()$%"-%<%$,=A%+*($"+(*56%",: "*9%"7%+*6($"(6%(/",: " *9%/%" \*,'+/]D"'9%6%" *9%"6%A+(+*/",: "

$(6.%"-%<%$,=%6/3"B9!/"=(<%-"*9%"'(&":,6"*9%"#A%6!7(+!R1(*!,+",: "*9%";`]/"6%*(!$"$(+-/7(=%"'9%6%"$(6.%",5*",: "*,'+"/9,==!+."\Z,+R=$(7%/]"(7*%-"(/"(")(7I-6,=":,6"*9%"

'(/"/,,+"(".,<%6+A%+*($"/9!:*"!+",=!+!,+"(+-"=,$!7&"(/"*,"*9%"/5!*()$%"+(*56%",: "/579"-%<%$,=A%+*/D"*9%"$(6.%"/7($%"()(+-,+A%+*",: "*,'+"7%+*6%/D"!+-%=%+-%+*"6%*(!$R%6/" 7($$!+.",5*" :,6" 9%$=" (+-" *9%"=,$!*!7($" %$!*%" %79,!+."*9%!6"76!%/3"#"=,$!7&"/9!:*"*,'(6-/"("/%6!%/",: "\a%*(!$R$%-]"56)(+" 6%.%+%6(*!,+" =6,@%7*/" /,,+" )%7(A%" *9%" +,6AD"A(/I!+." *9%A/%$<%/" (/" *9%" 756%" *," -%.%+%6(*!,+" (+-"!+<%/*A%+*3" #/" F56,=%(+" 7!*!%/" )%7(A%" A,6%" \A($$R

(+-"A%-!5A"/!1%-"6%*(!$/" /9!:*!+."5='(6-/" !+"/!1%D" *9%"7!*&"9(/"/9!:*%-",+7%"(.(!+"*,"("/9,==!+.RA($$"=(/*!79%3"B9!/"9(/".!<%+"6!/%"*,"*%6A/"/579"(/"\L$,+%"B,'+]/]"(+-"\L,=&7(*"H%<%$,=A%+*/]"'9%6%"*9%"<%6&"+(*56%",: "7,+R*%A=,6(6&"-%<%$,=A%+*/"9(/"($$,'%-":,6"("/7%+(6!,",: "

=6,<!/!,+" ,: " -!<%6/!*&D" (" :(7*,6" (7I+,'$%-.%-" (/" <!*($"*,"*9%"/577%//",: ",56"!++%6"7!*&"%+<!6,+A%+*/"6%A(!+/"

5+,)*(!+()$%bW(+%" W(7,)/"PV_Pc3"B9%"7,A=%*!*!,+" *9(*"'(/",+7%"'(.%-")%*'%%+"7!*&"(+-"/5)56)D"9(/"A!.6(*%-"

R=,6*"(+-"L(6-!:: ":(7%"(".6%(*%6"-(+.%6":6,A"(+"($$!(+7%",: "6%*(!$%6/"'!*9!+"*9%"7!*&D"*9(+":6,A"/9,==!+."7%+*6%"/5)56)/D")5*"*9%/%"*',"7!*!%/"9(<%")%%+"7,A=%*!+."'!*9"%(79" ,*9%6" (+-" *9%" 6%.!,+" (/" (" '9,$%3" Z%'=,6*" /5:R:%6!+."5+-%6"*9%"'%!.9*",: "!*]/")!..%6")6,*9%6D"L(6-!::3"#/"),*9"7!*!%/" %A)(6I"5=,+"=6,A,*!+." *9%A/%$<%/" (/".$,)($" =$(&%6/" (+-" 7,A=%*!+." (.(!+/*" *9%!6" F56,=%(+"7,5+*%6=(6*/"9(<%"*9%&")%7,A%"@5/*"(+,*9%6"A%*6,=,$!R*(+"<,!7%",: " \Q,/*RG+-5/*6!($"a%<!<($]"'9%6%"*9%" !+9%6R%+*"+(*56%",: "*9%!6"(-,=*%-".$,)($!/(*!,+"9(/"=,*%+*!($$&"

=,$!7&",: "\),,/*%6!/A]"(+-"Z%'=,6*"!/":,$$,'!+.")$!+-$&"

*9!/"7,+*%J*"*9%"+,*!,+",: "\=$(7%]"(+-"\!-%+!*&]"9(/"(6.5R()$&")%%+"$,/*"*,"\)6(+-95)/]"(+-"7,+/5A%6"$(+-/7(=%/3"

-,'+*56+",6"-,%/"*9%"=6,)$%A"$!%"!+"*9%"<%6&"+(*56%",: "*9%"A(79!(<%$$!(+":,6A",: "7(=!*($!/A"(+-"*9!/"/*(.%",: "\L$,+%"B,'+]".$,)($!/(*!,+"*9(*"4,5*9"K($%/"9(/"(-,=*R%-D"'9%6%"*9%"(".6(-5($"9,A,.%+!1(*!,+",: "(679!*%7*56%"!/" 6%.(6-%-" (/" (77%=*()$%j"K9," 76%(*%/" \=$(7%]" !+" ,56"7!*!%/"(+-"'9,"(6%"*9%"=(6*!%/"!+<,<$%-"!+"*9!/"=6,77%//j"?(7I.6,5+-"G+:,6A(*!,+L(6-!:: ]/"+,*()$%"/577%//",: "$(*%"A5/*")%"(**6!)5*%-"*,"("'!-%"6(+.%",: ":(7*,6/"9,'%<%6"!*"-,%/"9(<%"("7,6%"/%*",: "=,$!7!%/D" ,5*$!+%-")&" !*]/" -%<%$,=A%+*" (.%+7&D" (-,=*%-":6,A",*9%6";`"7!*!%/3"B9%/%"(6%" $(6.%$&"6%R6%=6%/%+*(R*!,+/" ,: " *6!%-" (+-" *%/*%-"A%*9,-/" (+-"9(<%" =6,<!-%-"L(6-!:: "'!*9"/,A%"/577%//3"C,'%<%6"*9%"%::%7*/",: "$(6.%"6%*(!$",+"!*]/"9!.9R/*6%%*"9(/"($6%(-&"76%(*%-"("/,A%'9(*"-!/@,!+*%-"7!*&"'9%6%"*9%",$-"/9,==!+."(6%(/"9(/")%.(+"*,"/9,'"/!.+/",: "-%.%+%6(*!,+3"B9!/"!/"($/,"%<!-%+*",+"("A(76,"/7($%"'!*9"*9%"7(/%",: "Z%'=,6*D"$,/!+.",5*",+"

#"<!/5($"76%(*%-"*,"=6%/%+*"*9%,6!%/"(+-"7,+7%=*/"=6%/%+*%-"!+"A&"-!//%6*(*!,+3"

4,567%8"#5*9,6/",'+

Page 33: Revaluating Typological Standards

N^

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

A579"!+<%/*A%+*",<%6"*9%"$(/*"*%+"&%(6/"*,"L(6-!::3"B9%"/!.+/" ,: " 6%*(!$" -%.%+%6(*!,+" (6%" 7$%(6$&" %<!-%+*" !+" *9%"

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

!.3.-.(%"+*7F7!.-.M9*(.7%+7>%6/"+7>%6/Q

B9%"-!//%6*(*!,+" ($$,'%-"A%" *,"=56/%" (" $,+.R/*(+-!+.":(/7!+(*!,+" '!*9" *9%" 6%*(!$" (+-" %J=%6!%+7%" %7,+,A&"$(+-/7(=%" ,: " ,56" +(*!,+3" a%.(6-%-" (/" (+" !A=,6*" !+*,"*9%";+!*%-"`!+.-,AD"*9%"6%/%(679",::%6%-"(+"!+*%6%/*R!+."!+/!.9*"!+*,"*9%"%::%7*"(":,6%!.+"\*&=,$,.&]"7(+"9(<%",+"*9%"%+<!6,+A%+*"(+-"56)(+"A!J",: "("*&=!7($"?6!*!/9"

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

Page 34: Revaluating Typological Standards

NX

msa - Event Month

'J312+K012L=+

K;18L34235+91+K02901N9*($.1%.574*7N+%"+*&7'*7.M.*%756*7917:95%7+3 7%$.70197.M.*%170+*%$7:5+#590

2(+79%/*%6"!+"A,*!,+"'(/"("5+!*"76%(*%-")%*'%%+":,56"A%A)%6/":6,A"*9%"5+!*"#679!*%7*56%"(/";6)(+"L(*($&/*3"

R-%+*/"@,!+%-"A&/%$: "(+-"*9%"*96%%",*9%6"A%A)%6/"!+"("',6I/"=6,.6(A"65+"(/"("A%(+/",: "=6,<!-!+."/,A%":,6A",: "/&+%6.&")%*'%%+"/*5-%+*/"!+"*9%"/79,,$3

B9%",6!.!+($")6!%: ":,6"\2(+79%/*%6"!+"2,*!,+]"'(/"76%R(*%-"*,"%+7,56(.%"*9%"/*5-%+*/"*,"%J=$,6%"*9%"7!*&"!+"("A%-!5A"*9%&"A(&"+,*"9(<%"*9,5.9*",: ",56"%J=%6!%+7%-")%:,6%3"B9%" /,$%" (!A",: " *9%"=6,.6(A"'(/" *," 76%(*%" ("

*9(*"',5$-"/5AA(6!1%"*9%!6"*9%,6%*!7($"/*(+-=,!+*"(+-"R

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

*9%",6!.!+($")6!%: "*,"/,A%9,'"!+7,6=,6(*%"*9!/"+%'",=R=,6*5+!*&3"

B$.7'5*/9-.74*%.5M.*%"+*

B9%"#6+-($%",6!.!+($$&"7(A%"*,"5/"'!*9"(")6!%: ":,6"5/"*,"-%/!.+"/,A%"I!+-",: "!+*%6<%+*!,+",6"'($$"(6*":,6"(" ]N^"9,56]"7,66!-,6"$,7(*%-"+%(6"*9%"A(6I%*"!+"*9%"2(+79%/R*%6"#6+-($%"/9,==!+."7%+*%63"G+",6-%6"*,"6%*(!+"("$!+I"*,"*9%",6!.!+($")6!%: "(+-"*9!/"+%'"=6,/=%7*!<%"=6,@%7*"'%"-%7!-%-"*,"%+7,56(.%"*9%"/*5-%+*/"*,"/*!$$"-%<%$,="(+-"

(+($&1%" *9%" 6%*(!$" (6%(/",: " *9%" 7!*&" (+-"=6%/%+*" *," *9%"

'(/"*9%+"76!*![5%-")&"*9%"/*5-%+*"*5*,6/"(+-"',5$-"$(*%6":,6A"*9%")(/!/",: "*9%!6"]N^"\9,56"7,66!-,6]"=6,=,/($3"K%")%$!%<%-" *9(*" *9%" #6+-($%" 9(-" ,::%6%-" *9%" /*5-%+*/" (":(+*(/*!7",==,6*5+!*&"*,"-%<%$,="("7,+7%=*"(+-"=6%/%+*"!*" *," ("),(6-D" *9!/" %J=%6!%+7%" !/" ($A,/*"5+9%(6-",: " (*"

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

4*7>60095Q

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

!"#$%&7Q6%/%+*(*!,+/"(+-"\(7*!<%"(679!<!+.]"=6,7%//",: "

A/("%<%+*"A,+*9"=6,.6(AA%3"4,567%8"#5*9,6/",'+

Page 35: Revaluating Typological Standards

N_

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 36: Revaluating Typological Standards

msa - Event Month

MSA_EVENTS 2011-12 event #**

Project title Manchester In Motion_An architectural exploration of digital mediaB.Arch unit/s ARCHITECTURE AS URBAN CATALYST5th year students

Samuel D. W. WestbrookBryn T. LeeBenjamin T. HaleRobert J. Rostron

Brief Description of Event

We have entered the Age where digital media techniques are a vital attribute in an Architect’s repertoire. !is event will be based on utilising this skill by displaying an intervention or ‘spectacle’ in an urban setting in Manchester. Literature in"uenced for this event and very much recommended include Kevin Lynch’s Image of City and Francois Penz’s Architect’s of Illusion.

Day 1:Introduction to project & showcase of previous examples; Visit to each site (sites tbc); Record initial discover-ies on each site (mixed media: sketching, photographs sound & video recordings, you choose!)

Day 2:Discussion of initial #ndings; what is useful? Why? Perception of the area, what do you want to represent in a digital media format?A collection of #ndings presented with order and structure.

Day 3:Present thoughts on choice of spectacle; how can it be introduced into the site? Introduction to video editing using digital media collected

Day 4:Initial testing and experimentation of spectacle on site; How can this be re#ned?

Day 5:Consider alternative methods of representation; what is the most e$ective way to present your intervention?

Day 6:Group presentations of active archive & #nal digital media production. A prize will be given to the group with the most re#ned and creative outcome.

Aims and Outputs

To promote an abstract and creative response of urban space through digital media by imaginatively interacting with the space and the public, thus creating a spectacle or an ‘experience.’ To analyse and reinterpret the narrative embodied in urban space.To think innovatively how to create an urban intervention and how that can be present in a digital media format.To develop media skills and presentational techniques.Event will culminate in digital media presentations showing interventions in the Manchester Arndale Shopping Centre!

Page 37: Revaluating Typological Standards

NU

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

K;1;A3C312+?5;82983+;16+.;M=+

?50E+*2769342SH;YF"P"8R""2#Z#EF2FZB"S0"QaSWFLB4E'BL7<P7W'XG+*6,-57*!,+"(+-"2,*!<(*!,+"/=%%7943Q,'%$$E'BL7CJ7W'XY%.($"2(/*%67$(//L,+*6(7*/D"Y('D"Y(+-D"#HaZ3K(66!+.E'BL7D<7W'XCf4D"?3LSZBaSY43K(&+%

Q$(++!+."(+-"L,+/%6<(*!,+"2(/*%67$(//QY#Z]E"Y#K" "QSYGL>iYH0" HFg3LSZB"QQ4XiY?Q3W,9+

" " " "GZBaS" " LSZBa#LBSa" FZH" E2^

" " " "Fk;#YGB>" #LLF44G?GYGB>"" FZH"HG4#?YFH"YGg3"LFZB

HSL;2FZB#BGSZ"2#4BFaLY#44"" "LS22;ZGL" ?aGF0GZE" 4QFL" "LQGiGQH" ?G2E'BL7O7N'!" " " " "aSYF4" " QaSWFLB"2#Z3"FZHE'BL7<D7N'!"0FF4"" #QQSGZB2FZB"E'BL7C;7N'!"g#Y;FiLS4BiQaGLF" HFgFYSQ2FZB" 2#4RBFaLY#44" " "HF4GEZ"HFgFYSQ2FZB" "g#Y;F"QY#ZZGZE" "LS4B"QY#Z" Q a G L RGZE"E'BL7C;7'@!7" "LS;a4FKSa`"4;?2G44GSZ

4*7>60095Q

C(<!+." ($6%(-&" 7,A=$%*%-" (" .,,-" (A,5+*",: " *!A%" !+"=6(7*!7%"bPXA,+*9/"6%.!/*%6%-"QFHac"($,+."'!*9"("*,R*($",: "*',"&%(6/"%J=%6!%+7%"',6I!+."!+"(+"(679!*%7*56($"=6(7*!7%" G" :,5+-" *9%" 2(+(.%A%+*" Q6(7*!7%" (+-" Y('"A,-5$%"<%6&"%+@,&()$%3"a%7%+*$&" *9%6%"9(/")%%+"A579"-%)(*%"'!*9!+",56"=6,:%//!,+"'9%*9%6"(679!*%7*/"(7*5($$&"

R7(*!,+($"<!7%",6"*,"(7*5($$&")%7,A%"/577%//:5$")5/!+%//RA%+",6"',A%+3"G")%$!%<%"*9%"$(**%6"*,")%"A,6%"!A=,6*(+*"(+-"*9(*"*,-(&D"*9%6%"%J!/*/"5+'!$$!+.+%//",6"/,A%'9(*",: " (+" %A)(66(//A%+*" '9%+" (679!*%7*/" (6%" [5%/*!,+%-"

,: ")%!+."("-%/!.+%63"G*":,6"*9!/"6%(/,+"*9(*"G")%$!%<%"*9!/"A,-5$%"!/"<!*($"*,"*9%"/577%//",: ",56"=6,:%//!,+3"

2&"=6,:%//!,+($/"/*5-!%/"=6,@%7*"!+7$5-%-"*%+"[5%/*!,+/D"'!*9!+"*9%/%"[5%/*!,+/"G"'(/"(/I%-"*,"=6%/%+*"%<!-%+7%",: "("<!()$%"7,/*"7,+*6,$"A%79(+!/A"!+"*9%":,6A",: "("7$!R%+*i(679!*%7*"7,+*6(7*"(+-"6%/,567%"7,+*6,$"*()$%3"Q6,R.6(AA!+."*9%"%+*!6%"7,+/*657*!,+"(+-"-%/!.+"/79%-5$%3

Page 38: Revaluating Typological Standards

NV

Management Practice and Law

Gwyn Hall

Professional Practice Submission Y05 Manchester School of Architecture Benjamin Hale 07208138

Page 39: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

2.3%&7\E'&+"C($$]"Q6,:%//!,+($"4*5-!%/"=6,@%7*":6,+*"7,<%63"

4,567%8"#5*9,6/",'+

Page 40: Revaluating Typological Standards

Technology & Enviroment

>;524+!N+,=

###?+?534312;2901+B+"3>0524,7!%*&"(==%(6/"7(5.9*"!+"("*6(="'!*9"+,"'(&",5*3"\?5/!R+%//" (/" 5/5($]" !/" +," $,+.%6" (+" ,=*!,+3"C,'%<%6D" 9($*R!+."(+-"6%<%6/!+.",56"7,+/5A=*!,+",: "A,6%"(+-"A,6%"\/*5:: ]" (==%(6/" $!I%$&" *," *6!..%6" (" A(//!<%" -%=6%//!,+"'!*9" /%6!,5/" 5+%A=$,&A%+*" (+-" =,<%6*&3" B9!/" !/" 7%6R*(!+$&"*65%"!: "($$"'%"-,"!/"\(==$&"*9%")6(I%/]"'!*9,5*":5+R-(A%+*($$&"6%-%/!.+!+."*9%"'9,$%"/&/*%A3"K%"(6%":(7!+."("/%6!%/",: "!+*%6$!+I%-"/&/*%A!7"=6,)$%A/"l"7,+/5A!+."

%J=5$/!,+",: "*9%"<%6+(75$(6"(+-"(")6%(I-,'+"!+"*9%"6%R$(*!,+/9!=")%*'%%+"\A,6%]"(+-"\)%**%6]3"B9%",+$&"'(&"*,",<%67,A%"*9%/%"/&/*%A!7"=6,)$%A/"!/"*96,5.9"("/%*",: "/,$5*!,+/"'9!79"*9%A/%$<%/"(--6%//"*9%"!-%(",: ",5*",: "-(*%"56)(+"=$(7%"A(I!+."(+-"/,7!($"/*657*56%/3

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

(6%"9%(-!+."*,"("/!A!$(6"/9!:*"!+"75$*56%"(+-"=6,.6%//!,+3""

B9%"B6(+/:,6A(*!,+"2(+!:%/*,",: "#679!*%7*56%"(+-"4,R7!%*&D"(/"("9,A(.%"*,"B9%"E6%(*"B6(+/:,6A(*!,+D"'6!*R

*%+")&"`(6$"Q,$(+&!" !+" *9%"PV^O/3"K9!$%" !+"(" 6%$(*!<%$&"/9,6*"6%=,6*"/579"(/"*9!/"'%"7,5$-"+,*"9,=%"*,"(79!%<%"(+&*9!+."6%A,*%$&"7,A=(6()$%"*,"Q,$(+&!]/".6%(*"',6ID"*9%" /7($%",: " *9%"79(+.%"'%"+%%-" *," /%%" !/" (*" $%(/*" *9%"%[5($",: "*9%"79(+.%/"9%"-%/76!)%-3

Q,$(+&!"(+($&/%-"9,'"A(6I%*"=6,7%//%/"!+"*9%"!+-5/*6!($"6%<,$5*!,+" (+-" 7(=!*($!/A"9(-" 76%(*%-" /%<%6%" 65=*56%/"!+"*9%":()6!7",: "/,7!($"$!:%D"(+-"(6.5%-"/*6,+.$&"*9(*"'%"

*9%"!+-!<!-5($"(+-"*9%"7,AA5+!*&3

[86<(??)&)2#6?*#*&)6(/62-#6C*/#62)')//%&3>6(#6(/6%,/-60-//(+,)"\

!.-9%"+*1$":7%+7>%6/"+7?*"%

G+",56"/*5-!,"5+!*D"#679!*%7*56%"(/"(+";6)(+"L(*($&/*D"'%" 9(<%" :,75//%-" ,+" *9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%" !+" *9%" 0%1"2%-!+(3"K%"9(<%" %J(A!+%-"9,'" *9%" 7,56*&(6-" 9,5/%"(7*/"(/"("A!76,7$!A(*!7"76%(*,6D"(*"),*9")5!$-!+."(+-"56R)(+"/7($%D"(+-"*9%!6"=,*%+*!($"6,$%"(/"56)(+"7(*($&/*/":,6"F7,"7!*!%/3"K%"'%+*",+"(" /*5-&" *6!=" *,"0%1"(+-" $%(6+*"9,'"*9%"7,56*&(6-"9,5/%" !+" *9%"2%-!+("-%A,+/*6(*%/"5+![5%" /5/*(!+()$%" =6!+7!=$%/D" '9!79" %/*()$!/9%-" ,56"

5/%",: "56)(+"/=(7%D"%::%7*!<%"7$!A(*!7"6%/=,+/%",: "*9%"(679!*%7*56%"(+-"*9%"!A=,6*(+7%",: "$,7($!*&3"K%")%$!%<%"!*"!/"*9%/%"=6!+7!=$%/"*9(*"A(I%"*9%"A%-!+("!+"0%1"(+"%JR*6%A%$&"/5/*(!+()$%"=$(7%"*,"$!<%"!+3"B9%":(7*"*9(*"*,-(&]/"'(&",: "$!:%"!+"*9%"A%-!+("9(/"+,*"79(+.%-":,6"7%+*56!%/"

0%/D"A%-!+(3"4,567%8"E,,.$%"F(6*9"NOOV

Page 41: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

-!/=$(&/":56*9%6"*%/*(A%+*"*,"!*/"/577%//"(/"("/5/*(!+()$%"/,7!%*&3"

B9%6%"(6%",)<!,5/$&"$!A!*(*!,+/"*,",56"*9%,6%*!7($"=,/!R*!,+"(+-"'%"(6%"+,*"/5..%/*!+."*9%"0%1":,6A5$(" !/"*9%"=%6:%7*"A,-%$3"C,'%<%6D"(/"'%"'!$$"%J=$,6%D"A(+&",: "*9%"/5/*(!+()$%"=6!+7!=$%/"(+-"'(&/",: "$!:%"!+"*9%"0%1"A%-!+("9(<%"($6%(-&")%%+"%/*()$!/9%-",6"(6%")%!+."!+*6,-57%-"!+",*9%6"7,5+*6!%/3"#/"A(+&"56)(+!/*/"(+-"(679!*%7*/"$,,I"*,"*9%":5*56%":,6"9!.9R*%79"/,$5*!,+/"*,"7$!A(*%"79(+.%D"'%"(6%"/5..%/*!+."*9%"(+/'%6"A(&"($6%(-&")%"9%6%3

[X),('/6-? 6%6+3.-2)6)&%"6:(#()/6(26#$)60%/#6!)&)6?)<6+36#$-*/%2</6-? 6(2<(B(<*%,/\

4*7>60095Q

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

2,/*" =%,=$%]/" 7,+7%6+" (),5*" 7(6),+" %A!//!,+/" ,6" ("7(6),+" :,,*=6!+*" 7%+*%6/" (6,5+-" .(/R.511$!+." 7(6/" ,6"

*,"9,A%D",6"!+-%%-"!+"*9%"9,A%3"Y!.9*!+."(+-"9%(*!+.")5!$-!+./" .%+%6(*%/" XOm" ,: " ?6!*(!+]/" 7(6),+" -!,J!-%"%A!//!,+/" '9!$%" *9%" =6,-57*!,+" ,: " )5!$-!+."A(*%6!($/"(77,5+*/":,6"(":56*9%6"POm3

#+-"!*"!/"+,*"@5/*"7(6),+"%A!//!,+/"*9(*"(6%"*9%"=6,)$%A3"B9%"7,+/*657*!,+"!+-5/*6&".%+%6(*%/",+%"*9!6-",: "($$"*9%"'(/*%"!+"?6!*(!+"'9!$%"NOm",: "+%'")5!$-!+."A(*%6!($/",+"*9%"(<%6(.%")5!$-!+."/!*%"(6%"/!A=$&"*96,'+"('(&"(*"*9%"%+-",: "*9%"@,)3

%(79"&%(6"R"*9%"%[5!<($%+*",: "UU"E!1("=&6(A!-/"!+"F.&=*3"

&%(6/D"*!A%"(+-"/=(7%"!/"65++!+.",5*3

B9%"#679!*%7*"(/"*9%"\=$(7%"A(I%6]"9(/"/,$%"6%/=,+/!)!$R!*&",: ")%7,A!+." *9%" \/5/*(!+()$%"76%(*,6]3"B9%" 6,$%",: "*9%" #679!*%7*" 9(/" 79(+.%-" 7,+/!-%6()$&" ,<%6" *9%" $(/*"*96%%"-%7(-%/"(+-"'(/"6%7%+*$&"(**(7I%-")&"*9%"?6!*!/9"

E,<%6+A%+*":,6"!*/"=%6<%6*%-":(/7!+(*!,+"'!*9"75$*56($")5!$-!+./"*9(*"'%6%":(/9!,+%-"'!*9,5*"(+&"7,AA5+!*&"7,+/5$*(*!,+"(*"($$3"C,'"7(+"*9%/%")5!$-!+./")%"+(A%-"\75$*56($"7%+*%6/]"'9%+"75$*56%"!/"!.+,6%-"!+"*9%!6"76%(R*!,+j"#679!*%7*/"(+-"56)(+"=$(++%6/"9(<%")%7,A%"A,6%"7,+7%6+%-"'!*9"7$!%+*"/(*!/:(7*!,+"*9(+"(7*5($"5/%6":5$R

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

G+"*9!/"6%=,6*"'%"=6%/%+*%-"("7(/%"/*5-&",: "*9%"0%1"A%-!R+(D"'%",5*$!+%-"*9(*"=(//!<%"%+<!6,+A%+*($"*%79+,$,.!%/"($6%(-&"%J!/*"9%6%3"G+"*9!/"%+<!6,+A%+*D" $,7($"A(*%6!($/"(6%"5*!$!/%-"(+-"%+%6.&"7,/*/"A!+!A!/%-"*96,5.9" !+*%$R$!.%+*"-%/!.+3"K%"(6%"-!6%7*$&"=6,A,*!+."*9!/"(+-"(6%",: "*9%"(//5A=*!,+"*9(*"*9!/" !/"-!6%7*$&"*6(+/:%6()$%"*,",56"A,-%6+"56)(+"%+<!6,+A%+*/3"B9%/%"=(//!<%" *%79+,$,R

-%<%$,=%-"*9%A",<%6"A!$$%++!("*,"-%($"'!*9"*9%"7$!A(*!7"7,+/*6(!+*/" ,: " *9%" %+<!6,+A%+*" !+" '9!79" *9%&" :,5+-"*9%A/%$<%/3"G*"!/",+$&"!+"*9!/"6%7%+*".$,)($!/%-"',6$-"*9(*"'%"9(<%")%7,A%"5+('(6%"(+-"9(<%"-%7!-%-"*,"%A)6(7%"*9%"\-%:(5$*]":,6A",: "#679!*%7*56($"*6%+-/"(+-"=$(++!+."=,$!7&D"'9!79"9(/"$%-"*,"*9%"7,66,/!,+",: "*9%"<%6+(75$(63"

'%$$"(/"$,7($"7,AA5+!*&"(*"!*/"7,6%3

Page 42: Revaluating Typological Standards

Technology & Enviroment

Page 43: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 44: Revaluating Typological Standards

Conclusion - Critical Self-Re!ection year 5

#018:74901=+

S<%6"*9%"7,56/%",: "*9%"&%(6"G"9(<%"=6,-57%-"("+5A)%6",: "-,75A%+*/"(+-"6%=,6*/"*9(*"G":%%$"*9,6,5.9$&"9!.9R$!.9*"A&"9%!.9*%+%-" ('(6%+%//",: " (679!*%7*56($" !//5%/D"*9%,6&"(+-"-%/!.+3"B9%"&%(6"9(/"*(5.9*"A%"A(+&"$%//,+/"(+-"G]<%"%J=%6!%+7%-"("6%($"-%=*9",: "*%79+![5%/"'9!$/*"7,$$(),6(*!+."'!*9"A&"=%%6/3"B9%"=6,7%//"9(/"-!::%6%-":6,A" =(6*" ,+%" !+" /579" ("'(&" *9(*"A579" ,: "A&"',6I"

(+-"*9%,6!%/"-%<%$,=%-"'9!$/*"!+"=6(7*!7%3"B9%"&%(6"9(/"

=6%/%+*(*!,+D" A,-%$" A(I!+.D" -!(.6(AA!+." (+-" A(=R=!+."(+-"/,:*'(6%"7,$$(),6(*!,+3"G*"9(/"%+()$%-"A%"*,"!+76%(/%"A&"/I!$$")(/%/"*9(*"'!$$",+$&"%+9(+7%"A&"7,ARA5+!7(*!,+"/I!$$/"(/"(+"(679!*%7*3"

E"11.5%9%"+*

B9%"/5)@%7*",: "A&"-!//%6*(*!,+"9(/"($'(&/")%%+"/,A%R

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i/9%" !/"'!$$!+." *," =56/%" *9%/%"

N9*9#.0.*%7!.:+5%

B9%" A(+(.%A%+*" 6%=,6*" '(/" (" /%6!,5/$&" !A=,6*(+*"

=6,7%//"(/"'%$$"(/")5!$-!+."7,+*6,$3"06,A"*9!/"A,-5$%"G".(!+%-"(".,,-"-%.6%%",: "6%/=%7*":,6",*9%6"7,+/5$*(+*/"

*9(*"*9%"-%$!<%6&"=6,7%//"!+<,$<%/"!+=5*":6,A"("+5A)%6",: "-!::%6%+*"=(6*!%/3"B9%"(679!*%7*"6%A(!+/"+,"$,+.%6"*9%"A(/*%6")5!$-%6D")5*"!+/*%(-"9(/")%7,A%"*9%"\@(7I",: "($$"*6(-%/]3"B9(*" !/"("7,A=$!A%+*" !+"*9%"/%+/%"*9(*"*9%"(6R

)5*"($/,"5+-%6/*(+-!+.",: " *9%" 6%[5!6%-" !+=5*" :6,A"($$"

=6,756%A%+*"A%*9,-3

B.($*+-+#Q7F7L*M"5+*0.*%

R*!,+" *(5.9*"A%"A579" !+" *9%"'(&",: "=6%/%+*!+." ("+%'"\!-%(]"*,"A%A)%6/",: "A&"=6,:%//!,+"(+-"*6&!+."*,".(5.%"

R*!,+"G" *9!+I" *9%" \6%=,6*]",::%6%-" *9%"A,/*" !+" *%6A/",: ".!<%"A&/%$: "(+-"A&"*',"',6I!+."=(6*+%6/" *!A%"*,"-%R<%$,=" ,56" (6.5A%+*" (+-" =6%/%+*" (" 7,9%/!<%" =$(+" *9(*"6%/=,+-%-"*,",56"5+!*"%*9,/"'9!$/*"($/,"%+.(.!+."'!*9"*9%"*%(79!+./",",56"A,-5$%"*5*,6/D"L6(!."2(6*!+3

Page 45: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 46: Revaluating Typological Standards

Bibliography

2"%.59%65.

G++,<(*!<%"0,,-"Q(7I(.!+."B%79+,$,.!%/D"G+/*!*5*!,+",: "0,,-"B%79+,$,.!%/"bNOOVc

4*%%$D"L(6,$&+3D"NOOV3"45==$&!+."*9%"L!*&3"G+8"C5+.6&"L!*&8"C,'"0,,-"49(=%/"S56"Y!<%/3"Y,+-,+8"g!+*(.%"?,,I/3"L93"N3

27H,+,5.9D"K"(+-"?6(5+.(6*D"23"bNOOVc3"L9(=*%6"̂ 8"K(/*%"F[5($/"0,,-3"G+8"L6(-$%"*,"L6(-$%8"a%R2(I!+."*9%"K(&"

a(&-(+D"H3D"a(**!D"L3"T"4*%%A%6/D"`3D"bNOO_c3"L9(=*%6"PN8"L,56*&(6-/8"(")!,7$!A(*!7":,6Aj"G+8"F-'(6-/D"?3D"L,56*R

!+"0%1D"2,6,77,3"Y5+-";+!<%6/!*&3"4'%-%+3

434=6(**D"#34!AA/D"F3Z%!*1%6*"(+-"W3aRL,$$!+/"bNOO_c3"B9%"E6%(*"B6(+/!*!,+8"#"*($%",: "9,'"!*"*56+%-",5*"6!.9*3"B9%"Z%'"F7,+,A!7/"0,5+-(*!,+"bZF0cD"Y,+-,+D";+!*%-"`!+.-,A3

I.K1"%.1

9**=8ii'''3(:6!7(+%7,+,A!7,5*$,,I3,6.i%+i-(*(/*(*!/*!7/

C,5/%/

Page 47: Revaluating Typological Standards

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 48: Revaluating Typological Standards

Conclusion - Critical Self-Re!ection year 5

Page 49: Revaluating Typological Standards

^O

!"#$%&'(&)*+,-./01'1,*2&'-3)&+4&546-7-8529*)#2)(5#-&6-:5;&+-<&)&'/6)

Page 50: Revaluating Typological Standards