ringvorlesung bef 2014

49
Biodiversity research in the framework of the Jena Experiment Lionel Hertzog [email protected] Lehrstuhl f¨ ur Terrestrische ¨ Okologie Technische Universit¨ at M¨ unchen 3rd, November 2014 Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 1 / 33

Upload: lionel68

Post on 09-Jul-2015

91 views

Category:

Environment


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Presentation given on the Ringvorlesung 2014

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity research in the framework of the JenaExperiment

Lionel [email protected]

Lehrstuhl fur Terrestrische OkologieTechnische Universitat Munchen

3rd, November 2014

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 1 / 33

Page 2: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Outline

What is biodiversity?

Global biodiversity loss

Ecosystems and ecosystem function

Biodiversity and Ecosystem function research

The Jena experiment

Results from the Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 2 / 33

Page 3: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 3 / 33

Page 4: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 4 / 33

Page 5: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity

CBD definition (Art. 2): the variability among living organisms from allsources, including, ’inter alia’, terrestrial, marine, and other aquaticecosystems, and the ecological complexes of which they are part: thisincludes diversity within species, between species and of ecosystems.

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 5 / 33

Page 6: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity

Most of the species out there are still undescribed

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 6 / 33

Page 7: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity loss

Biodiversity is declining

Butchard et al (2010) Science

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 7 / 33

Page 8: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity loss

Biodiversity decline is due to various factors

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 8 / 33

Page 9: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Ecosystems

CBD definition (Art. 2): Ecosystem means a dynamic complex of plant,animal and micro-organism communities and their non-living environmentinteracting as a functional unitLikens (1992): An ecosystem is defined as a spatially explicit unit of theEarth that includes all of the organisms, along with all components of theabiotic environment within its boundaries

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 9 / 33

Page 10: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Ecosystem functions

Hooper (2005): Ecosystem function is a broad term that encompasses (...)ecosystem properties, ecosystem goods and ecosystem services.

Ecosystem properties include both size of compartments (eg pools ofmaterials like organic matter) and rates of process (eg fluxes ofmaterials among compartments).

Ecosystem goods are those ecosystem properties that have directmarket values (eg food, timber ...).

Ecosystem services are those properties of ecosystems that eitherdirectly or indirectly benefit human (eg clean air, pollination ...)

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 10 / 33

Page 11: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Ecosystem functions

Hooper (2005): Ecosystem function is a broad term that encompasses (...)ecosystem properties, ecosystem goods and ecosystem services.

Ecosystem properties include both size of compartments (eg pools ofmaterials like organic matter) and rates of process (eg fluxes ofmaterials among compartments).

Ecosystem goods are those ecosystem properties that have directmarket values (eg food, timber ...).

Ecosystem services are those properties of ecosystems that eitherdirectly or indirectly benefit human (eg clean air, pollination ...)

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 10 / 33

Page 12: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Ecosystem functions

Hooper (2005): Ecosystem function is a broad term that encompasses (...)ecosystem properties, ecosystem goods and ecosystem services.

Ecosystem properties include both size of compartments (eg pools ofmaterials like organic matter) and rates of process (eg fluxes ofmaterials among compartments).

Ecosystem goods are those ecosystem properties that have directmarket values (eg food, timber ...).

Ecosystem services are those properties of ecosystems that eitherdirectly or indirectly benefit human (eg clean air, pollination ...)

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 10 / 33

Page 13: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity Ecosystem function

Species are responsible for ecosystem functioning, if theirnumber/functional groups decline what will happen to the ecosystemfunctions?

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 11 / 33

Page 14: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

1 No relation: Functioncontroled by abiotic factoror species dominance

2 Linear relation: Samplingeffect, positive interaction(complementarity orfacilitation)

3 Asymptotic relation:Diversity effect strongeronce communities aregreatly impoverished

4 Negative relation:Pathogens/ parasitisminfection rates increases withtheir diversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 12 / 33

Page 15: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

1 No relation: Functioncontroled by abiotic factoror species dominance

2 Linear relation: Samplingeffect, positive interaction(complementarity orfacilitation)

3 Asymptotic relation:Diversity effect strongeronce communities aregreatly impoverished

4 Negative relation:Pathogens/ parasitisminfection rates increases withtheir diversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 12 / 33

Page 16: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

1 No relation: Functioncontroled by abiotic factoror species dominance

2 Linear relation: Samplingeffect, positive interaction(complementarity orfacilitation)

3 Asymptotic relation:Diversity effect strongeronce communities aregreatly impoverished

4 Negative relation:Pathogens/ parasitisminfection rates increases withtheir diversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 12 / 33

Page 17: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

1 No relation: Functioncontroled by abiotic factoror species dominance

2 Linear relation: Samplingeffect, positive interaction(complementarity orfacilitation)

3 Asymptotic relation:Diversity effect strongeronce communities aregreatly impoverished

4 Negative relation:Pathogens/ parasitisminfection rates increases withtheir diversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 12 / 33

Page 18: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

How to explore these hypothesis:

Observational vs experimental approach

field vs laboratory experiment

which system: grassland, forest, marine ...

Random vs targeted species loss

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 13 / 33

Page 19: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

Cedar Creek (MN, USA) biodiversity experiment from 1994

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 14 / 33

Page 20: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

Jena experiment (TH, DE) from 2002

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 14 / 33

Page 21: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

BEF China, tree diversity experiment from 2009

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 14 / 33

Page 22: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

Marine mesocosm ie Emmerson et al (2001) Nature

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 14 / 33

Page 23: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Biodiversity-ecosystem function

Climate chambers, microcosms ie Naeem and Li (1997) Nature

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 14 / 33

Page 24: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 15 / 33

Page 25: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 16 / 33

Page 26: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 16 / 33

Page 27: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 16 / 33

Page 28: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 16 / 33

Page 29: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The Jena experiment

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 17 / 33

Page 30: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The weeding

Three times per year, hand-weeding of the experimental plot to maintain targetspecies richness.

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 18 / 33

Page 31: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The weeding

Before After

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 19 / 33

Page 32: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

The weeding

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 20 / 33

Page 33: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Mowing

Mowing of the fieldsite twice per year inJune and September

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 21 / 33

Page 34: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Aboveground plant biomass

Abovegroundproductivity

2 sampling peryear in May andAugust

2 samples perplot 20x50cm

Sorted by species

Dried and thenweighted

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 22 / 33

Page 35: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Aboveground plant biomass

Plant productivityincreases withspecies richness

Plant productivityincreases withfunctional grouprichness

Slopes are varyingover time

Complementarityeffect becomestronger over time

Marcquard et al (2009) Ecology

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 23 / 33

Page 36: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Aboveground plant biomass

Plant productivityincreases withspecies richness

Plant productivityincreases withfunctional grouprichness

Slopes are varyingover time

Complementarityeffect becomestronger over time

Marcquard et al (2009) Ecology

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 23 / 33

Page 37: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Belowground plant biomass

Belowgroundproductivity

One sample per year

Soil core 0-50cm

Roots washed, dried for72h

Weighting of roots

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 24 / 33

Page 38: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Belowground plant biomass

Belowgroundproductivity

One sample per year

Soil core 0-50cm

Roots washed, dried for72h

Weighting of roots

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 24 / 33

Page 39: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Aboveground-Belowground biomass

Ravenek et al (2014) Oikos

Diversity effect only 4 years after experiment onset

No support for vertical root differentiation, negative plant-soilfeedbacks at low diversity

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 25 / 33

Page 40: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Root/Shoot biomass

Bessler et al (2009) Ecology

Root/shoot biomasslower in mixture thanexpected frommonocultures

Overyielding ofaboveground biomass islinked to this deviationfrom expected R/S ratio

Species-rich communitiesinvest less inbelowground organs

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 26 / 33

Page 41: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Pathogens resistance

Latz et al (2012) Journal of Ecology

Bacteria producinganti-fungal compoundsincrease in abundancewith plant speciesrichness

Positive indirectplant-soil feedback, maycontribute to explainsome other results

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 27 / 33

Page 42: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Carbon storage

Measurement of soil carbon concentrationOne sample every two yearsDepth from 0 to 30 cm

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 28 / 33

Page 43: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Carbon storage

Measurement of soil carbon concentrationOne sample every two yearsDepth from 0 to 30 cm

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 28 / 33

Page 44: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Carbon storage

Carbon storage increaseswith plant diversity after4 years of the experiment

Higher plant diversitymitigate carbon loss indeep soil layers

System with high plantdiversity might act ascarbon sink and mitigatepart of human CO2

emission.Steinbeiss et al (2008) Global Change Biology

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 29 / 33

Page 45: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

N cycle

Increase in the positiveeffect of plant diversityon aboveground Nstorage

Diverse mixture reducenitrate in the soil in theearly years, in later yearsdiversity increaseammoniumconcentration

High diverse mixturereduce fertilization needand reduce N leaching togroundwater

Oelmann et al (2011) Global Biogeochemicalcycles

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 30 / 33

Page 46: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

What I do

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 31 / 33

Page 47: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Potential project

http://www.ecology.uni-jena.de/praktika_bachelor_master_

themen_institut_oekologie.html

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 32 / 33

Page 48: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Potential project

http://www.ecology.uni-jena.de/praktika_bachelor_master_

themen_institut_oekologie.html

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 32 / 33

Page 49: Ringvorlesung BEF 2014

Lionel Hertzog (TUM) About Biodiversity 03/11/2014 33 / 33