risk management- principle and practice
TRANSCRIPT
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:1/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� � � �� ��
•
�� � ��
•
� � �� � ��
•
�� � �� � !•
�� �" # �$ %• & ' �( )
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:2/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �� ��
•
�� � ��
-
* +
VS
, +
-
-./ 0
VS
- 0/ .
-
-1/ 2
VS
- 2/ 3
•
� � �� � ��
•
�� � �� � !
•
�� 45 � 67
• & ' �( )
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:3/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Risk (BS-25999-1:2006)8
something that might happen and its effect
9
s
:
on the achievement of objectives ;< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N< => ?@ A BCD E FGH IJ KLM N
OP QR S
TU VW * +X YZ [
T \U VW , +X ]^_ `a Z b
cde f ghi jk lmn n o pqr s
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:4/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Known (Expected) Risk -t uv w
(
xyz {|}
+Check List)~� ��
(what if/ Brain Storming )��� � � a� �� ��� ^
e.g.,� � �� ��� � ��
/
��� �� ��� � � ¡ ¢ �� £ ¤/ ¥ ¦ §¨© ª«� ¬ ® � ¯°± ²
/Dow Chemical F&EI� ³ ´¨©/
µ¶ ª«/CCB� ·¸¹ º� �© » ·¸¹ º� ¼ ½¾ ¿ÀÁ ·Â� FMEA� ÃÄ � HazOp� ��Å Æ� 5S,
ÇÈcde f ghi jk lmn n o pqr s
¨© ɾ ¿� ª«� ��Ê Ë/
ÌÍ� ÃÄ ¹ ºÎÏ� ÐÑmodule� ÒÓ ÔÕ
/
ÕÖ¾ ¿× ÎÏ ØÙÚ ª«Û ÜÝÞ × ª« ßàá â ã
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:5/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Unknown (Unexpected) Risk t uäå æt
/
çè_ `å æ �éê �ë ì aí îïð
/ ñ òó ôä �U õ
”
�ö �
”
�� � � a� �� �
e.g.,� ÷øù ±� ú ûü °cde f ghi jk lmn n o pqr s
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:6/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Known vs Unknown
cde f ghi jk lmn n o pqr s
Micro Viewpoint ýþ
/
ÿÎÏ � ·� � ÿ�á � �Z �� � � � �� �
� � �
/
�� â� ��
/
�¨ ��-./ 0
/
����á ¨©
=
ÿ Ë �� ¨© á � �- 3/ 2��� �
/
! �
/
" � � �
#$ % &W ~ &ð 'ÿÎÏ
/
() � *+� , Ø- . �/÷0 1 · �
/
2 34 �
Macro Viewpoint��/
5�/
6 7/
68 9:á � �Z � � � � �� �
;< =� × �á > ?� @ A
/
B C- 0/ ./
D ��¨© EF GÅ Æ� � ·H I- 2/ 1 �J á ;<á ·K� L M
#$ % &W NOð 'ÿÎÏ
/
() � ÒP Q� Ø- . �/0 1 · � 2
/
34 � ÷
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:7/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
Micro ViewpointRisk = Severity * Likelihood� � X�
=
YZ å æ #$
(
[\ ] ^ �
)
_å æ `� ab c d(
e � fg )
YZå æ #$> f h i
/PMj � k
burn-out
Redundantlm ��
SOPn � �� op
/buddy systemq/ f± À r
/
÷s ¯t uv wx ?
/ yx z {
YZå æ ab d|} ~ ? r �� P �f ��f ¯� �� f f �� 2 ¬ ® ��
/
¯� �� � � �� �� � � �� ��
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:8/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �� ��
•
�� � ��
•
� � �� � ��
- � c �� X�
-
� �� �
VS
� �� �
•
�� � �� � !
•
�� " # �$ %
• & ' �( )
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:9/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
Micro Viewpoint� c �� ��
(
�Î � ÃÄ
/
¹ º
/
��
)� ¡
Layer of Protection
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:10/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
Macro ViewpointX� a ¢£ � ��
(
�9 "¤ Ä
/
¥¦
)� ¡ § ¨ a ©ª #« §éê ¬ §® ¯ ° Hint:
±² ³´
/
µ¶ ³´
Source: http://tx.technion.ac.il/~gordoncn/05072011/3.Nancy_presentation.ppt
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:11/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
Macro ViewpointX� a ¢£ � ��
(
�9 "� ·Û ¸ �Î � "Ñ
e.g. Dupant)¹º » ~ X�
/
¼½ ¼¾ ¿ ÀÁ Â ® Ã °
Source:http://opim.wharton.upenn.edu/risk/library/2007Elliott,PRK,etal_'EverydaySafety'.pdf
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:12/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
Macro Viewpoint vs Micro ViewpointÄ � Å� ÆÇ a È ÉÊ Ë KÌ Í ÎÏ ÐÑ = E =Ò ÓÔKÌ Í ÎÏ ÐÑ = E =Ò ÓÔKÌ Í ÎÏ ÐÑ = E =Ò ÓÔKÌ Í ÎÏ ÐÑ = E =Ò ÓÔ ÕÕÕÕ
� À
Normal Accident TheorySociologist Charles Perrow,(1984)
identifies three conditions that make a system likely to be susceptible to Normal Accidents:
1.The system is complex
2.The system is tightly coupled
3.The system has catastrophic potential
Redundancy
� ] ^ �
:
1.
Ö ¥¦ ×Ø Ù� × ¸ ] ^
2.
ÖÚ �á � 2Û
(
ÜÝ ¥¦ Þ:
/
âß à �á)
3.
Ö � â E� � ã ä 1 5 � �� å �� æ � ¬À
High Reliability OrganizationFive characteristics of High Reliability
Organizations that have been identified ç
Weick, K. E.; Kathleen M. Sutcliffe, 2001.
èthat keeps them working well when
facing unexpected situations.
1.Preoccupation with failure(
( k > é ] Û â� âêá ë Æ
)
2.Reluctance to simplify interpretations (
ìíî Îá ïð Û ñò ó ãô õ "
why)
3.Sensitivity to operations
çö Ú ÷ �ø ù è
4.Commitment to resilience(
úû ü ó ýþ
)
5.Deference to expertise
çÿ 4 Ð� è
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:13/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �From Known to Unknown� �
=
� �
+
� ��ë �Y À� �
”
@ A@ A@ A@ A
”
�� �
”
E FGH IE FGH IE FGH IE FGH I
”
_ x ô
� � �� � �� � �� � �
(uncertainty)� �� � � ��
• Issue
�� � � v K 0 1
e.g.,
¤ h � h� �
• Probability� � � K 0 1� �Û Ý � �0 1 · �e.g.,
�� �
• Uncertainty� ¸ � � K ¸ K 0 1� 0 1 · � Ý �� é� ( ëá � � !à
e.g.,311
� "#
/
÷øù ±
/ $ %�± ²/ISIS
& 0 ' () * +
� �� �ë �� ,-
•
. /0 ·1 ñ � ñ àá - . �/ � � à 2Å(
�� � 3 /4
=>
ê 5 6 ·7 ) � Ú � 8
)
•
Ø � ¸ 9 : Øà Û ;< �= · � � >(
? � �@Ê 7 )
+
AB C D
+
� E ¸ F $ E
)
• Unexpected Consequence(G �/ � ( ë � j � H J
)
pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:14/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �From Known to Unknown� �� �� IJ a KL� ^ M
: � NO () 0 1 · �) P « Q� (Rá � ) P é� > w� ÿS ¤ Â� T� Û Ö � �9 U V Û W Ý â E XY � Z V
[ \ M
: � �] 1 �� ^ �_ � ¨©
(
` B aá b $ c
)� ¸ dá �ö Ú Ò d ¨© Ø e ¸ dá p �� fð(
+ < g h �i j
)
k � M Ë� lm v n� oá pq v n
=>
�K rs� ¹ º ·� K � � Ö t ¥¦ uÚ 2Û �
/
÷
v �
(
j s wx y /z 1 {R
)� ¸ Û / £ß > ?| }
(
Ö t� Å Æá ~� ¸ �= �
)
pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T gúp �� � �� � �� �4 � {1 �� á � O� ��
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:15/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �From Micro to Macro ViewpointT xyU � �å æ
: U � �� � {XU � �� � #� y KXU � � � �� �
� � 1 ¸ � �
5W1H:
� � � " � �� �S ë Æ
� Fà �� � �Û � �
something had been done to prevent the occurring of the accident (
ô � 1 � � �� 1 � �� , Ø � Ø� � �
)
� �� ô ( � �� ¡¢ £ ¤
-
� ¥ ( �á 0 1 ¦§ Ø Ùá � à� ¨ ¡ ·© � �ªë Æ �
� oá pq v n� ¥¦ uÚ 2Û �� ÷ v �
T « D� ¬ Ë ò Y Àå æ� ® ¯ ¿ �å æ
� ª« °�
/¤  � Û Ö �� ± �9 ² �á ( � ë Æ
� �� , س ´á ýþ� é� á� µ H á
� ɶ · ¥ ·á � ¸ ¥ ²¹ $ º ²
� · � � ¸ �» ¸ K 0 1
pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:16/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �From Known to Unknown/ From Micro to Macro•
¼½ ¾ X� ¼� +¿ � x a � �� � °
•
À V x ô çè_ `X À [ d� Á
..
pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:17/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �From Micro to Macro� �� À XÂ
/
�� � ÀZ b ® À X� ú W
(
� Äá
)
ÅÆ �
ÇÈ � �� � W � � ®/ W ÅÆ �
…•
��á ý u Ø , Ø ºV� I " ºÉ Ê
•
��á P Ë ¥¦ Ø , Ø
redundant?•
��á 1 5¹ º Û ¸ Û Ì Í� ¸ dá 1 5 ý "Û Î Ò . ÏÉ Ê•
��á
key person
Ø , Ø �Ð �
(
y /1 ÑÒ �
)
Ê•
��á 5® Ó
/
^Ô� ÕÖ Ö × 1 Î �× Ê
•
�� Ø , Ø , ¸ dá (� Õ ] P- . ØÙ Ê•
ö Ú ¸ dá ë Æ ¬Û �� Ø , ØÚ ÛÜ � Q Ý Ê
–
Þù � ßÛ F � � £ àá Û â :ã ö Tä–
Þù � jÛ F � åæ ;< Û ¸Ê ç T Ö �• ¤ � Ø , Ø A ;á f ¯� �• 10
è �¤ � ã
1
è � ¤ � j(100
é1
êá hÎ ã
1
é
100
êá hÎ j
)
• ¸Ê ã ä æ �� æë� × ~ æ 2( ¸Ê � �¶ k �� Ê é é Ä ! Ä
)
pqr s RS TS Ue je T g Vqe Wd k q T g
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:18/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � �� ��
•
�� � ��
•
� � �� � ��
•
�� � �� � !
-
ìí î M
-
xy ïë ð ð
ñ Ñ
/
� Ñ
/
ý ~ �
@Ê 7 )
/
?V 7 )§ Ð
5Why/¤ Ä
Detection & Protection
-
� � ò d ó xy ïë
/
ä �U ôô õ-
� � ò d ó xy ö÷
/
ú øù ô ú
•
�� �" # �$ %• & ' �( )
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:19/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Case Discussion00
û
00
ü
00
ýÛ 00
� 0 1 ¯°± ²Þ × � þÿ ¢
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:20/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ��° � 0 1 k� �� �� �� �
”
”
�������� �� � � � �� � � � �� � � � �� � � �Û ¤ � � Ò � Ò � �� � � ¤ Ä ��25
��� � � �� �x ù !" # § $% § ÓÛ � .< § Ó � Ò P l& Û H '� � � ��� Ñ $% § Ó�
” ( ( ( (
” )ù !" #* p ¥ � � $% § )ù !" #Û +Ú x ?, � 'ê5- ù ! " # )À . /0 1Û 2 qq � )� � 3 � � ÷ �4 �Û �� qù !" #5 6÷ ÍÛ 7 2� � 8 � $% � q �
3
9á � � 3 ��Û Þ × � � � � : ; J |<
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:21/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ��
q �
3
9 )
500
�= � � 3 � � > �? @Û .< > �¹ A f : �Û 3 � � B ° Ø $% §ÓC D 9 "EÛ � � ] Û F § Ó �G H ; ó � �
RC
9 E� I© J ;�
1
9K L � <
q �
3
9 )� � � � : ; > J |�
1
9 K L �Û � Ò M §N
3
�, O PÐ J | )� �Û Q� � � � � � J | >ë åR 0 7 2K L �Å Æ ST ± ² ·U �Û K L · � � f± »Û)ê 5V F 5 1 )Àù ¯W & t ] t »� � Xù Û 7 2ù ±
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:22/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�Y Z[
- \] ^ _\] ^ _\] ^ _\] ^ _
~° � 0 1 � ¥
( ) `a bc`a bc`a bc`a bc � ù ± de 2 þ ¢ <
( (((() f a bcf a bcf a bcf a bc �¸� � gh �
(1) 25
� �� � � �� .< ) $% § Ó| l& $% ö i <(2)
| Û h 8ê 5ù !" # )À . /Ú � � 3 �� ÷ �4 � Ø � <
( jjjj ) kl bckl bckl bckl bc � | m /� � n 1 § Ð <
op q r s top q r s top q r s top q r s tuuuuç � èv Mö wx ¤¤ �= y ¤¤Ú פ � kÛ Ú q y Ñz AÚ ÿ- ¤ � @Ê )� � n 1 {|} ~< �� � �� �� � �� �� � �
16
� �
1
�� � � �� �� � �
23
� �
1
� �çq èv Mö Ú ¬ ¹ º � y� §Û ¥ f 6� us * Û Þ × �© Û ÚÚ ¤¤ � 9 )4 A l& y u� � u� S �� � uö i § y� @Ê ( Ë < (� �� �� � �
196
�� � � �� �� � �
5
�
)ç� èv Mö Ú ¬ ¹ º � y� ¤¹ ºÛ ¥ f 6 �± ²� ¯°� |} N Þ × ¤¤ ) ��Û | �� h 8� � /� �� � � A� � !¡ ¢ A � y �� � AÚ I { gR � ) Ø � ÷ Í < (
�� �� �� � �� � �
197
� �
4
£� � � �� �� � �
5
� �
2
�
)ç ÿ è p � � (� ¤¤ �8 = � ¤ � P K ) (� Î 4Û Ú &¥ � � ÃÄ � �� Ä ¦� � u§¹ º kÛ Ú ª« y y� ° � )¨© Û > �� A ; ) > f §¨ < k Ë ×Û v MÚ q ¤¤ ? � �© > Ñz ÒP { |} ~< (
� �� ª «¬ ® ¯° ± ²³ � �
12-3
�� � � �� �� � �
14
� �
1
�
)
´ µ s t s ¶· ¸¹ º »¼ ½¾ ¿´ µ s t s ¶· ¸¹ º »¼ ½¾ ¿´ µ s t s ¶· ¸¹ º »¼ ½¾ ¿´ µ s t s ¶· ¸¹ º »¼ ½¾ ¿ÀÀÀÀ
Á µ s t à ÄÁ µ s t à ÄÁ µ s t à ÄÁ µ s t à ÄÀÀÀÀ Á µÅ  à lÁ µÅ  à lÁ µÅ  à lÁ µÅ  à l ÀÀÀÀ
“ÿ Ëö Û F � � ßT F Æ ñ Ñ
/
� ÑÇ ý ~ � Ê
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:23/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
ÈÉ ÊË Ì Í É ÊË Î ÏÐ ÊË ÑÒ Ó� Ô � a ÕÖ °
~° � 0 1 � ¥
( ) `a bc`a bc`a bc`a bc � ù ± de 2 þ ¢ <
( (((() f a bcf a bcf a bcf a bc �¸� � gh �
(1) 25
� �� � � �� .< ) $% § Ó| l& $% ö i <(2)
| Û h 8ê 5ù !" # )À . /Ú � � 3 �� ÷ �4 � Ø � <
( jjjj ) kl bckl bckl bckl bc � | m /� � n 1 § Ð <
×Ø ÙÚÛ ÜÝÞ ßà áâ ãä åæç èé êë ìí îï ðñ �� ò !F ÷/ Ð ó �� Ç ôõ ö¹ Ê
÷ Z �� Ç ôõ ø où Ê
÷K 1 �� ô � æ Púá ôõ ù Ê
û 6á ñ Ñ
/
� Ñ
/
ý ~ �
ü 6 + ý
/
þ×
/
ÿ ~ �� � Ø � � I Ê� � S � �
/
�� ã �� Ð �� A Ê
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:24/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Micro Viewpoint
� �� Ë � � { éê�� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ��
� �� ��� �� �� ���� ���� ���� ���������� ! "#$%
&' ()* + ,
-. /0 &'12 34 56
78 "# 9&' :;
� �� �< => : ?� �
1F
@A B&' :; CD EFG *H I
J ( /2 KLMN . 56
� �8 OP QR4 ST �
UV WX&' YZ
UV WX [\>2 YZ
( � @ { Ø F] ^_ i�� ô � Ø F `a bcÊ d ¥ Ð j � à P Q� e bf ¦
g . h U&' 34�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:25/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �5 Why
ij kl mn on on on o pqr s
,
tuv,
twxy z {| }~
� ��(
��)
�� ��
(
��
)
n
��
(
��
)
�� ��
(
��
)
����
����
��
why
why
why
why
why
����������
�� ���� ��
�� �� � ¡ ¢£ ¤
?
�� �� ¥¦ §¨ ©ª
?
�� �« ¬ ®¯ °± ²
?
�� �³ ´µ ¶· ¸
?
Micro Viewpoint
¹º � »¼
: ½Ê ¾_ `�U ¿À Áñ Ñ �
� Ñ �ã ø �
(Root Cause)
ñ Ñ
/
� Ñ
/
ý ~ �
=
� ô  � �á
Why) ä� { {Ä l ¸ Ä ~ ÊÅ
�� �Æ §³ ´· ¸
?
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:26/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Micro Viewpoint Ç È ÉÊ »¼ � ËÌ
:
¨ ¡ �
(
Ö æ ! � â* � � 2)
� � s * 0 ïÛ ¥� �¹ º Ír � !Î ê , ØÏ ÐÑ Ò Ê
Single Point Failure !
Ó � � ^High � Low
�4 ê 5Û , Ø pq � ê5� ¡ Ô A
(Leak Sensor) Û F P �Ò � � �F : � I {� ] Û �
(
ñT .< � �Õ ¢ IÖ
) .< , Ø f ��
(dike) Û g × |}Û 9þ �á I� G � D IØÛ Ö� � ;� y� 9þ
)
f ¯� �� � � f¹ ¨
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:27/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
xy � Ù ÚÛ Ü Ñ Ý ËÛ Ü Ñ
~° � 0 1 � ¥
( ) `a bc`a bc`a bc`a bc � ù ± de 2 þ ¢ <
( (((() f a bcf a bcf a bcf a bc �¸� � gh �
(1) 25
� �� � � �� .< ) $% § Ó| l& $% ö i <(2)
| Û h 8ê 5ù !" # )À . /Ú � � 3 �� ÷ �4 � Ø � <
( jjjj ) kl bckl bckl bckl bc � | m /� � n 1 § Ð <
(
0 1 ¯° ( �á
)
Þ ßÞ ßÞ ßÞ ß àáàáàáàá uuuuØ ¯° � v Ø P B7 )¯° � Ê >
•
t u
•
âù
•
& ¯Û ��S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
(
Þ × ° ëã �á)
äåäåäåäå àáàáàáàá uuuuØ P B gh ¸ 9 :K Ø ° ë
•t u� � |}
•
f ¯� � ¸ æ 9
•
� � �� ç â
/
s * à �
•
|} ~x A â�
•
� f ¥¦ â�
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:28/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Macro Viewpointèé êë ìíD îï ðñ òóèé êë ìíD îï ðñ òóèé êë ìíD îï ðñ òóèé êë ìíD îï ðñ òó
(
¸ ��� ¤ � ÃÄ á � I
)
1
� ô¹ Q� f ¯� �õ ] ÃÄ � 1 5� ö "× ~
2.
ÒP ¹ Q� ÷ � ã ä× ~ æ 2Û øù� � »
(e.g., PP
§ �
/
ß þ d # ú û)
3.
� f f ° ¥¦ ü e � � ý Ìã ? É
disable� þÿ h� � , Ø 9�/
) P 9�4.
f ¯� �
integrity
�T ý Ìã ?á 1 5 � �� ÃÄ × ? ß5.
ã �á
detection(
|} ~ ?
)
�
protection(
�� �
)
Þ × ý ! × 34á �á ýþ � � h � �
(
Ø
¸ �» Û /� ¸ �» j/� ¸ �» Û ´/ : j }
)
6.
¸ Þù ,�� Þù �¤ 1 5
=>
�1 �� Ø P K ô �(
ñT ãá j ( � �T d � j (
)
7.
§ Ð þ 4 E w " � ��
(
�
)Û â E �� 9: ¨©8.
Î 4 ! � �¤ ¸ � �� ÿ� B Õ � � � ^� �á �(
�� Û 9 �
VS
¸ ] 9 ��á ¨©
)
9.
F Ø ¨ �4 E � � - �Û â E /8 a Õ(Peter F. Drucker:
� � - � ã �� a Õ ×
Sexy..)
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
From Micro Viewpoint� � ) ( �� 1 * � �q á
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:29/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Macro Viewpointb È � çå æ� ö÷ øù ô �
(
¸ ��� ¤ � ÃÄ á � I
)�� E ��� E ��� E ��� E �
1
� ô¹ Q� f ¯� �õ ] ÃÄ � 1 5� ö "× ~
(
� þ
/
, Ø � ×)
2.
ÒP ¹ Q� ÷ � ã ä× ~ æ 2Û øù� � »
(e.g., PP
§ �
/
ß þ d # ú û)
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:30/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Macro Viewpointb È � çå æ� ö÷ øù ô �
(
¸ ��� ¤ � ÃÄ á � I
)� � � � � � � � � � � �
3.
� f f ° ¥¦ ü e � � ý Ìã ? É
disable� þÿ h� � , Ø 9�/
) P 9�4.
f ¯� �
integrity
�T ý Ìã ?á 1 5 � �� ÃÄ × ? ß5.
ã �á
detection(
|} ~ ?
)
�
protection(
�� �
)
Þ × ý ! × 34á �á ýþ � � h � �
(“
Ø
” ¸ �»
”
Û /
”� ”
j/
”� ”
/ : j }
”)
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:31/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Macro Viewpointb È � çå æ� ö÷ øù ô �
(
¸ ��� ¤ � ÃÄ á � I
)!" Í #$ %& D ' ( Í) *!" Í #$ %& D ' ( Í) *!" Í #$ %& D ' ( Í) *!" Í #$ %& D ' ( Í) *
- +, -.+, -.
//
/ 0 -1 23 45 67 89 :;/ 0 -1 23 45 67 89 :;6.
¸ Þù ,�� Þù �¤ 1 5
=>
�1 ,ª Ø P K ô �
(
ñT j ()
7.
§ Ð þ 4 E w ��
(
" � �
/
<õ
)Û â E �� 9: ¨©8.
Î 4 ! � �¤ ¸ � �� ÿ� B Õ � � � ^� �á �(
�� Û 9 �VS
¸ ] 9 ��á ¨©
9.
F Ø ¨ �4 E B CÛ â E /8 a Õ
(Peter F. Drucker:
� � - � ã �� a Õ ×
Sexy..)
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
=> ?@ A BC DE F G ?H
(incidents)?@ IJ KL BM ?N GOPQ RST U VW XY Z[ \] ^_` ab cd GO PQ Re f G
root cause
g Bh fijk ST Gl m ` no pqr s tu v wx y vz {| D}~ x � G �� � �� � �� �
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:32/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �Macro Viewpoint
� �� �
/
Ë �� �
� �� �� �� �� �� �� �� ��� ���� ���� ���� ��
× ~7�
�� 7���
/
� k
� �� �/�� �
¥¦ p ¡¢ £ 5 �
÷ � K ¤ �(¥ ¦§Ø¨ ᩪ ä ©« . : � ª
(
h ¬
/
y°)
& �zd® p ãa4 ¯°m / ÷ �
a / 1 5±² ³ ¬� 2m @Ê× ~
�á © îâ E 5 �� � ; â
d® Ú ´÷ � ;Ú» © � �
¢ µ ¸¢¶� � ¶·� � ¶·� � ¶·� � ¶·
� � � �� � � �� � � �� � � �¸ � ��¸ � ��¸ � ��¸ � ��
� 7 �� Ø e Ò dá �á� ¢ £ 5 �
¥� �0 ¹ ߺ »¼ ¸ d ʽ ¾¿ À½ ¾¿ À½ ¾¿ À½ ¾¿ ÀÀÀÀÀ� Ë » Á
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:33/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
 à ÄÅ à ÄÅ à ÄÅ à ÄÅ%& ÆÇ%& ÆÇ%& ÆÇ%& ÆÇ
�� × ~ê§
/
�á ýþd® ÈÉ Ê
/ËÌ
Detection/Protection
Í � ü ý× ~ ¬ /
( �0 1Î
/
,� (� �� �ùÏ Ð j
Bypass Interlockâ E ¢ v
÷+ 5 �m /Ñ ÒÍ �Ó Ô ��
/d® �Õ
÷ � ;Ú» © � �
� � Ú ´âß H Ö
� � ¶·� � ¶·� � ¶·� � ¶·
×Ø ÙÚ×Ø ÙÚ×Ø ÙÚ×Ø ÙÚ%& ÆÇ%& ÆÇ%& ÆÇ%& ÆÇ
¨© § Ð = Û � < Ü � 6 Æá �Ý Þß à �1 Ö tá á »� � 7á â ãØ �ä @ � N T j (Û z Û å� 0 R ß� � , Ø ² ö lm Û � Ø Òö � m
� 7æ çÏ :è j
ûä â é â ¦ Û
÷ � m /êë� ¥� �� �ùÏ Ð j
� 7æ çÏ :è j
Éì íá îï Û { {1 ¨© § Ð � � ��
...
�S g ge h T k l �S gS r gh k d �e
Macro Viewpoint
� �� �
/
Ë �� �
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:34/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �ðñ òó ô õö ÷ø
•
ùú û üý
•
þ ÿ �� û ùú
•
ùú û �� �� �
•
ùú û� � �
-
� �� [ +X � & a �
-
� � X� � ��� �
-
�� ° �� ° �� °
• � � �� �
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:35/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� � � ¹� � �� ¹ � ! " ó# � �� $ %& ' ($ %& ' ($ %& ' ($ %& ' (
� � a ) *v � +, -.
…– ¸ / Û Ñz · � � ÷ù á �0Û cÊ � " Â º � à P 1á ïð–
ö �� Ý 0� é�á Ý ¥ } �Ú F 2 � (á � Ð �Û � ¡ 3Ç ( / �P–
K ' ü ·á ßà D 4� K j � 5 ¢ n
(=
67 8 9
)
–
: § � ê; û �Û �� <= >? @ A £á æ ÷� 4 lB Û P ÷ "C A æ ÷� 4 D¥ Òm º
(
s « ( ë ] Ûá 34 �
)
–
E · wF !Û Õ GH �I J �� ©
(
s « ] Û 0 1 · �)
–
K þ1 H J þLá 18
§
(
� V �Ï : þÚ H Jã �M N »Û 2« K þ · �
)
–
i j � O
(
Ø � o »
/
a {á P ú ù)
� Q(
RS ¸ F S)
–
�] 1 , ØT � ø o _ � ¨© � Ê ¸ ÷ « UÛ Ê ¸ 2« U
-
, Ø< � "V <
– Risk Availability
Þ × � �� ø o _ � ¨©–
ö Ú ¨© á p �Û � WÚ F � v ÖDefining risk is thus the exercise in power
–
F Æ ] Ñz� ¸ ] XY Z[ \ ] tZ[ \ ] tZ[ \ ] tZ[ \ ] t^^^^ l _ Â ` Ã abl _ Â ` Ã abl _ Â ` Ã abl _ Â ` Ã ab
�k U T q gqk T S T c m h f �e gd de r
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:36/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
� ef gh �� Q ij k � e � ' (& l m' (& l m' (& l m' (& l m
( � no p
)
�k U T q gqk T S T c m h f �e gd de rqrqrqrqr uuuu( �0 1 � v Ø � ¥ ç â� � � £ â
Fà 1 ¹ º ·� � Û s ãt ÒP � �h i ¸ á
/
â yu v wu v wu v wu v wuuuuÀ Óx ¯� ¹ º � 1 · � � >Û �
� y zÊ Ø > f h i · 5� ͹ § { w ~|¥¦ � � f �� ¥¦}~ �}~ �}~ �}~ �uuuuÍ � yx � § ê 5 �Ê ä¤ Ä �¥ Ò× ~� ª ���� �° Ø ¦ � �� F Ø� � �� � ú
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:37/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
� ef gh �� Q ij k � e � � � Ì � � Î� �
�k U T q gqk T S T c m h f �e gd de r
B � � K� < � � �� K � � 6 ß K � � | K� < � �� K� B � �� K� � �� � �� � �� � �� �� �� �� � \ �� º »\ �� º »\ �� º »\ �� º »
"
K
"
�á 1 ÷S � � |}Þ × ¯°± ² ( �
F� �©á � � }� Û Ú - Ê Ø f ��
Detection/Protection
· 5Û � F l& � ͹ f : úÑ�� } � ~ ?¡ ¢ ¥¦ N f � §¨
º � ( �º � ( �º � ( �º � ( �� �� �� �� � \ �� º »\ �� º »\ �� º »\ �� º »
"
�
"
�á ] 1 ; ( �Û �� ¤ Ä �� ! M §á Û á
/
�0¼ H ¤ � ÷ � = lm v ná � B� �K rs� ¹ º ·� K � ¡ ¡ �á a4 � à �è 1 ¢P ËÛ � Q { |} ~1 > f ( �0 1á æ �� @Ê × ~� £¤� ê / ü ý � �Û Þ: f � §¨ z K £¤� 0 R ¦ �� j �� j �� j �� j �� ¥� ¥� ¥� ¥ \ �� º »\ �� º »\ �� º »\ �� º »
“
6
”
�á 1 9 " ��á 5 �� C � �� � �ù ä� Ó ¬6 Já ¦t � & � 0 1 £4 � H J ( �á ��Û Õ { � ¥ 4 E� ��§ 4 � H J ( �á 0 1 ] P E ¥1 � " � á ¨ ·Û H m ° ) � e â© e ÷S ª è =á �äÛ Ý ã � Û (¥ ¦§ « j wá ¬ ¨� ®¯° â± ² �m ú
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:38/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
³´ µ ¶·¸p R k h ¹k h gi Te o ge n n q T U º
»¼ ½¾¿ ÀÁÂ
/
ÃÄÅ ÆÇÈ ÉÊË ÌÍÎ ÏÐ
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:39/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
³´ µ ¶� Ñ ' Ò� ÓÔT "#� ¯° ghÛ ABC
ÿ �á Õ ÷� 0 ¹ ¥ � Ê
p R k h ¹k h gi Te o ge n n q T U º
Plan View
Office Building
Factory
Building
Utility Building
Warehouse
Side View
Basement Parking
1F Utility/Facility
2F Fab/Warehouse
3F Office
RF Cooling Tower
Basement Parking Utility
1F Clean Room
Office
Cooling Tower/Scrubber
Warehouse
3F Clean Room Utility
Office
Office/Restaurant
A BC
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:40/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
³´ µ ¶Ö b �^ � Ó
ABC� �= × ~� ¨ ¤ × Ø »� A/ ö i� q/ Ù ÕK ÿ � Ø � eÚ � ÊÔT "#� ¯° ghÛ ABC
ÿ �á Õ ÷� 0 ¹ ¥ � Ê
p R k h ¹k h gi Te o ge n n q T U º
A PP/PVC
ÛÜ
B FRP
ÛÜ C SUS
ÛÜ
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:41/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
Ý´ µ ¶� � Ô Þ
…Integrity
� { �¸ T _ ¸ eÛ � Ô gh W ¢ ¤ �÷ A � � ¢) Û ? ß ¢ X �
p R k h ¹k h gi Te o ge n n q T U º
Source:http://www.chemtron.net/system.htm
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:42/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
Ý´ µ ¶
Detection/Protection/Interlock Integrity
� { �¸ T _ ¸ eÛ � Ô gh W ¢ ¤ �Ú �á � £¤� / ¥ � �Û ÔT ghá �ä z Û 0 R ¦ �
(
Ü ûä â ¢ { 9..)
p R k h ¹k h gi Te o ge n n q T U º
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:43/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
Ý´ µ ¶
Management Ö tÓ ¬
/
ß ¢ s
/
� ¥ �¸ T _ ¸ eÛ à á W ¢ � â
p R k h ¹k h gi Te o ge n n q T U º
ãããã ääää
¨© § Ðá ¨ ¡ ô �å� , Ø � é � ¡� ¸ � �æ - � ¡� , Ø �Û � ¡� � 7 Ø ¡¢ç � 7 , ¡¢
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:44/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �ðñ òó ô õö ÷ø
•
ùú û üý
•
þ ÿ �� û ùú
•
ùú û �� �� �
•
ùú û� � �
• � � �� �
-
è é� W � � X�
-
� � X� W è é
-
êU a êë {.
-
ìíî W ïð v � � a ñò � kð
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:45/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
� � X� óóóó ôôôô
(
õ� ö÷ø B ¤ Å
)ùúû ú ü ýþ
(IOSH84-S362
ÿ� � �� �� �� �� � � � �
)z ° � � �¤ � �8 ÷Ú | z ° � �Û �� Ò ¥ s ÎÚ | z ° � � <
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:46/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
� � X� ó ôó ôó ôó ô
(
�� �
+
�� �
+
© B l� Å
)� �� � �� � ª !á � �� , Ø© ö ô �� � Þ� * < w"á # l ;× ÛÜ
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:47/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º ôôôô
� �� õ . � ÅÆ �
•
© ö ¸ d ë Æá $% Ä �
( & BCP/BCM)
•
F � [\ ÿS ë Æá ¨© dz �
•
÷¨© ��� ¬ ®á § ê
• f ¯� �� � ×á æ 9 »
• Detection
�
Protection
á '/ »
• ¸ d y4� Î 4� 5®� � �� (� �á () "V� ¨ ¡ ·©•
ü e �� £ß 1 jè 1 � Ê
*+ Ç a � #, �
•
F ��� -. 9:á �� } �(H m �� / �
)
•
F f ¯� �
(H m !
)
á �� �•
� 0 #á 1 ÿÎ 4 � �1 ô �� H m �M•
é� ¸ Tá z K 1 ô �•
2 ¨3 Û�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:48/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º ôôôô
PDSA
a
lessons learned•
( �1 �¥ á ·KÛ H m 45
•
Ú â1 æ ã /á 6 ^
•
7¤ 8á § Ð 2Å 1
PDSAÛ ¸ 1 PDCA�
–
�9 =Ú 1
StudyH m
Check
–
Ð ï ¸ d Ø � P 1 �á ¥R � + <
–
1 F Q �� ßà ;<á m �Û � �: ;�
Study
� Z
idea
� �� ¸ work(
ÐÞ× ô �á ë ÆÛ < � ¥¦ I
variance)
– ¸ 1 ß
check
�
highlight
9 � �� ,=
j Ê
( ¸ 1 Ð rsá �H 1 Ð Ö � rsá ë Æ
)
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º� � 7 �� ( �á KÛ ] � � � � �á K ß� �
(
>? � �
)
á � �Ç �@ =Ú
•
úp �� , Ø� � �
/
�� > ?| }
•
Ö êë �9 ¸ ] 9á ¨© Û W v¨© úÕÄ �
•
ÿ 4 ; ( � ABÛ CD Ö E Fº
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:49/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º ôôôô
� ÓG Þ× ~
A>B>C but
÷ �H »� ¨©
A<B<C
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º$ B , ØI �á J ö¨© § Ð cÊ á
Redundant/ Resilience
K d
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:50/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º ôôôô
Management of Change and Integrity¢ ��� Ü �� Û 9 � 2
(
= Â ¸ � � § ¸ §/ Û j s j (z K � �L ¸ L á)
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:51/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º ôôôô_ MN
-
½ ¾O P
/Trade-OffQ �� Qq ¨© �Ç ¸ ¥R
Q �� Qq s * !àá 34 �
(
¸ö ¸
)
min Risk= f ( Type
S
Error , Type T
Error)Type
S
Error
U <ö á ;× sáç V ,ß = - =á (W , Ø XY T ·K
Type
T
Error
U <sá ;× ö áç V ß =  ¸- =á ( ëW r B s *¸ Zß [, � úÕ â5 Û z 1 æ �á ¨© Å
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
\ ]^\ ]^\ ]^\ ]^
(
* ¡ ¢
/
! �
)• VESDA/
¯¡ * ¡ ¢Û Þ × 5 Ó � � ç×
(
êë
/
� R_ �
)•
`ù � a
UVIR
* ! � � �ù : � Ú ÛÞ × 5 Ó � Ó
(
êë
/
� R_ �
)•
.< d® F T IÖ Û Õ ¥ ( �0 1b Òç×
(
êë
/
� R_ �
)•
c h© �� ÷ � � ¨ §d � Û ßà *! �Û Þ × .< e�
(
êë/
� R_ �)
\ ( ]^\ ( ]^\ ( ]^\ ( ]^
(¸ ! �
)•
0 1 ¯ °/
¥ ¦ , Ø ! � 0 ¢Û 7 2 �� ¢ L (êë
/
¥¦ ¤ Ä � É� T
)•
`ù � a| ØUVIR
� ! � �ù : � Ú� d � Û Þ × � f � � ¢ L (
� T �f
)•
ã / gh 0 1Û .< d ® ¸ Zb Ò ç×N " ÷ þ Õg
(
êë
/
� R_ �
)• ¸ � ¨ § d � Û ÔT ( �h d e âi4
(
êë
/
� Rx j >?
)Ê Økù ; � l 8 ãm� ¢¶ ¸ ¢ µá nop � ¢ Ô ß � Òá q � ¢ ñ � Éq ; õ rs �
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:52/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
Ë t u vu vu vu vw x yz Ú ¹º Î �º f� �� Y À{ ¾ ®ë |} ~è . O Pa �«� � ê 5
(
y z ��
/
â*
) vs
� Ú J ¬
(
��
)� 5® ¹ Q ÃÞ lm ¬
vs
^ à ¬H »� (
�Þ Ø�á
)
� �
vs (
�� Ø�á
)
� �� XY ·K
vs
� y L M� 0 R R G
vs
y z µ � ] Û » �U Ü ýþ ØU�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
�� � �� �� �� �� �� � �� �� � �� �� ���� �� � ¡¢ £¤ ¥¦ � �� �� �§ ¨ �©
�� ª« ¬ � ®¯ ° � � �± ²� ³´ µ ¥ �¶ ·¸
¯ ° � � �¹ º» ¼½ ¾¿ ÀÁ  µ ¬½ � ¥ � ÃÄ
(fit)� ÅÆ ° ªÇ È
=>
É ÉÊ ËÌ ÍÎ Á ¨¢ ÏÐ ÑÒ U Ó ÔÕÖ ×Ø
(
� ×Ø �Ù Ú
) µ Ó Ô � ¥¢ ×Ø � ¥Û Ü ×Ø
..ÝÞ ßà á âã äå æ çè é � ê ëì íî ï ðñòó ê ë íî ã ô õ ì ö÷ øù ú ûì üý ßà á â
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:53/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º � þÿþÿþÿþÿ
� �� �� �¸ T� ù z ¸ T � é� ¸ Tá ¨© Û - F �4 E� § Ð > f Ê� Ø� T ] Û 0 1á ¨© � a= . Ø ýþ U 5 B § ê Â
(=
¸ K 0 1/
0 1 Ý Øm º)
å � � ] �� Y À � � � �� - a � � � � � �� K j ( ¡ ¡ � 1 ¸ 4 E� ýþ ¸ ³á ßà(
j ( ) !�Ê 4 EÛ , Ø H Ö
)� ýþ ��
favor
Û 9 � ÷� Ï Ö w á Ë #(
¨ � � !Û Ï T }á � _ gR
)
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
Be careful of your thoughts, for your thoughts become your words.Be careful of your words, for your words become your actions.Be careful of your actions, for your actions become your habits.Be careful of your habits, for your habits become your character.Be careful of your character, for your character becomes your destiny.
� ¥� �
(
�� �� ¥� � �� � �� �
) � ¥� �
(
�� �¿ �� � ¥� �� �� � ! �" #� $%
) � ¨& Ç ' ×Ø ( « )* +,
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:54/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
�� ¹º � þÿþÿþÿþÿ+, - ./ � 0 ù ÈU 1ð � � �� �� � 2� � ô� ÃÄ 5® ¸ ] Û � 3 � � � � �0� ¥R � Ö tÓ ¬Ý ¸ ] Û � 3 �
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
45 67 ÕÖ 89 :Á;< � = � µ � � > �
(
? ×Ø � °@
)ÛA � � BC DE µ F � ¾G H ¥ � I ¾G¾ ³ �J K � L Í � Ú ? � L Í � £M °N ¾ ³ � B Ú
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:55/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � �
O PQ RO PQ RO PQ RO PQ R� �½ õS # Y T� Y U
VW X ù È�ð
/
� #ù b ò� �� / � k � W � �Y Z
[ x Ó� [ +
\� � ]^ ° \� � ] È
(
P _ � ·K
) ?
The race is not to the swift or the battle to the strong, nor does food come to wise or wealth to the brilliant or favor to the learned: but time and chance happen to them all. ë `á | @ Û aÛ á Þá | @ :bÛ �� á | @ :c dÛ ¤ eá | @ : ýf Û �gá | @ : µh ß F iT G �á Û 1 j �� k� j ·K k < ----
l amin Risk= f ( Type
S
Error , Type T
Error)Type
S
Error
U <ö á ;× sáç V ,ß = - =á (W , Ø XY T ·K
Type
T
Error
U <sá ;× ö áç V ß =  ¸- =á ( ëW r B s *¸ Zß [, � úÕ â5 Û z 1 æ �á ¨© Å
�k W pqr s� r RS TS Ue c º
2016/05 Risk Management Principle and Practice P:56/56
� � � �� � � � � �� � � � �� �� � � � � � � � � � � ����
� �������
m no
”
pq
”
r
”
s tu v
"
wx yz {|
:}~ ��� � ~ � }� �� � }� �
�� �� �� �� ��
:
pq r s tu v� �� �