rizal spt lecture 2 social contract theories
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
1/15
Rizal/Socio-Political
ThoughtLecture no.2
Social Contract TheoriesLocke, Hobbes and Rousseau
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
2/15
Hobbes: The Leviathan
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
3/15
Thomas Hobbes: The Leviathan
state of nature - before there were any governments - theimage of permanent warfare, everyman against every
man.
Human beings need an all powerful state to protect themfrom themselves.
In Leviathan, Hobbes ignored the concept of divine rightand instead placed the source of government legitimacysquarely in humanitys hands
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
4/15
Thomas Hobbes: The Leviathan
Hobbes proposed a kind of dictatorship on the basis of the
consent of the governed: I authorize and give up my
right of governing myself, to this man or this assembly of
men, on this condition, that thou give up thy right to him,
and authorize all his actions in like manner to the end
he may use the strength and means of them all, as he
shall think expedient, for their peace and common
defense.
Hobbess notion of a covenant is precisely what is meant by
a social contract: people freely agreeing with one another
to be governed in a certain way.
It is Leviathan, a giant of a state to which everyone should
voluntarily submit for their own good.
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
5/15
Locke: The Second Treatise of Government
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
6/15
Locke: The Second Treatise of Government
State of Nature: Society without government was full offears and continual dangers, exacerbated by thecorruption and viciousness of degenerate men.
Locke contended that humans were born free. Peopleowned their own lives and their own labor. As a result,everybody had a right to own whatever they couldappropriate or take advantage of with their own labor, as
long as they did not harm anyone else in the process.
These were natural laws, Locke declared, discerniblethrough reason.
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
7/15
Locke: The Second Treatise of Government
In Lockes terms, the individual has three possessions life,liberty and estatethe individuals property.
Government is created to preserve these natural rights and
possessions -- People voluntarily establish a governmentby mutual agreement; in other words, on the basis of asocial contract.
Any government that pursues these basic purposes is
legitimate, because it springs from natural laws.
The powers of the state must be strictly limited and alwayssubordinate to popular control.
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
8/15
Jean Jacques Rousseau: The Social Contract
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
9/15
Jean Jacques Rousseau: The Social Contract
The primitive man was thus a noble savage, peaceful anduncorrupted, free, healthy, honest and happyThe Noble
Savage is similar to a child.
With the development of wider social interactions and an
explicit division of labor came all the evils of advanced
social life: greed, vanity, social inequality and aggression.
It is society that corrupts human beings and encourages evil
tendencies
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
10/15
Jean Jacques Rousseau: The Social Contract
Social Contractwas that government must be based onpopular consent. In order for government to be trulylegitimate, the people in each generation should have theoption of accepting or rejecting it.
Legitimacy is therefore based in a tacit social contractamong free people who collectively constitute whatRousseau called the sovereign. It is the collectivesovereign that is the ultimate source of law.
People are united in an organic body politic on the basisof the general will. The general will is the common good;it represents what is best for the community as a whole
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
11/15
Integrating the Social ContractIs there consent from the governed?
Issues on the legitimacy of the leaders need to be resolved topave the way for genuine consent.
If we are to give our consent, we would be squarely placingour trust on the ability of our leaders to govern us.
In the absence of consent some of us have been indifferent
or tolerant to those who govern us.
Who do give our consent to? As a vacuum of leadership, arewe forced to another choice of a lesser evil?
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
12/15
Integrating the Social Contract
Sovereignty from the people and the General Will
When will the people invoke their sovereignty in their socialcontract with our leaders? - EDSA 1 and 2 are instanceswherein the people invoked their sovereignty.
Looking at it from another perspective, when we invokedour sovereignty, would we be better off economically,politically and socially as a nation.
At the end of the dayAs a people do we really know thevalue of our sovereignty?
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
13/15
Integrating the Social Contract
Contract between the government and the people
Is it the people or the government who failed to fulfill theirend of the contract?
As constituents do we tend to obligate our government toprovide us with almost everything to the point thatgovernment is spreading itself thinly in the provision ofbasic goods and services.
On the governments side are they too consumed inpursuing their self interest that they have forgotten tofunction as a government that works for the people
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
14/15
Integrating the Social Contract
A working social contract is characterized by a mutual trustfrom both parties, that the deliverables would beresponsively realized.
Once we enter into a contract, we are placing our trust inthem, as such we must learn to discern more carefullyand this can be seen in the way that we would be votingin the upcoming election.
-
7/22/2019 Rizal SPT Lecture 2 Social Contract Theories
15/15
Thank you