robert hurt trying to make sense of high resolution infrared...

35
Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared spectra of cool stars Hugh Jones University of Hertfordshire collaborators including Yakiv Pavlenko, Serena Viti, France Allard, Eduardo Martin Robert Hurt

Upload: others

Post on 19-Mar-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Try

ing t

o m

ake s

ense o

f hig

h

resolu

tion infr

are

d s

pectr

a o

f cool sta

rsH

ug

h J

ones

Un

ive

rsity o

f H

ert

ford

sh

ire

co

llab

ora

tors

in

clu

din

g

Yakiv

Pavle

nko,

Sere

na V

iti, F

rance A

llard

, E

duard

o M

art

in

Ro

bert

Hu

rt

Page 2: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

M t

o T

dw

arf

sM

to

T d

warf

s Op

pen

heim

er

et

al.

(1998)

Page 3: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Lin

e lis

ts a

re c

rucia

l (f

or

sa

mplin

g)

Jones,

Pavle

nko,

Viti et

al. 2

002

Page 4: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Wa

ter

va

po

ur

lis

ts d

o a

gre

at

job

be

yo

nd

2

Wa

ter

va

po

ur

lis

ts d

o a

gre

at

job

be

yo

nd

2

mm

Jones,

Pavle

nko,

Viti et

al. 2

002

Page 5: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

HC

N/H

NC

H

CN

/HN

C --

sta

rt t

o m

od

el

sta

rt t

o m

od

el

CC-- r

ich

sta

rs

rich

sta

rs

Harr

is,

Pa

vle

nko

, Jo

nes e

t al.

(2003)

Page 6: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

6

Impro

vin

g fit to h

ot band

s w

ith

experim

enta

l energ

y levels

Page 7: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

7

Pote

ntial to

measure

12

12C

/13

13C

Page 8: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

CO

lis

t excelle

nt

CO

lis

t excelle

nt

Pa

vle

nko

& J

on

es (

2002)

Page 9: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

CO

lis

t e

xc

elle

nt

CO

lis

t e

xc

elle

nt

--b

ut

need

to

be c

are

ful

bu

t n

eed

to

be c

are

ful

Pa

vle

nko

& J

on

es (

2002)

Page 10: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

CC12

12O

/CO

/C13

13O

dete

rmin

ati

on

O d

ete

rmin

ati

on

Pa

vle

nko

& J

on

es (

2002)

Page 11: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Deri

ve lo

g g

, V

sin

i, [M

/H]

Deri

ve lo

g g

, V

sin

i, [M

/H]

Jo

nes,

Pa

vle

nko

, V

iti et

al.

2005

(2002)

Page 12: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Deri

ve r

eliab

le p

ara

mete

rs f

rom

D

eri

ve r

eliab

le p

ara

mete

rs f

rom

sim

ilar

pie

ces o

f h

igh

reso

luti

on

sim

ilar

pie

ces o

f h

igh

reso

luti

on

sp

ectr

asp

ectr

a Jo

nes,

Pa

vle

nko

, V

iti et

al.

2005

(2002)

Page 13: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Poor

fits

to a

tom

ic lin

es in I

R

Vit

i, J

on

es e

t al.

2002

Page 14: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Po

SS

O

Po

SS

O

(Ph

ysic

s o

f S

ub

(Ph

ysic

s o

f S

ub

-- Ste

llar

Ob

jects

)S

tellar

Ob

jects

)

inte

nd

to

qu

alify

fo

r in

ten

d t

o q

ualify

fo

r ‘‘ E

UE

U’’n

etw

ork

netw

ork

Un

ive

rsit

y C

olle

ge

Lo

nd

on

, U

niv

ers

ity o

f H

ert

ford

sh

ire

, Im

pe

rial C

olle

ge

, U

niv

ers

ity o

f B

urg

un

dy, C

en

tre d

e

Re

ch

erc

he

As

tro

no

miq

ue d

e L

yo

n, In

sti

tuto

de

Astr

ofi

sic

a

de

Ca

na

rie

s, L

un

d U

niv

ers

ity, N

ati

on

al In

sti

tute

of

Sta

nd

ard

s a

nd

Te

ch

no

log

y, N

ati

on

al S

ola

r O

bs

erv

ato

ry,

Ha

mb

urg

er

Ste

rnw

art

e, N

iels

Bo

hr

Ins

titu

te, U

niv

ers

ite

t va

n

Am

ste

rda

m, P

ozn

an

Un

ive

rsit

y o

f T

ech

no

log

y, In

sti

tut

D’A

str

op

hys

iqu

e d

e P

ari

s, M

ain

Astr

on

om

ica

l O

bs

erv

ato

ry

of

Ukra

ine, U

niv

ers

ity o

f C

alifo

rnia

Lo

s A

ng

ele

s, C

en

tre

fo

r A

str

op

hys

ics

Page 15: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

1)

Ide

ntify

1.0

-2.5

m

fe

atu

res

Spectr

al atlases fro

m H

inkle

, W

alla

ce &

Liv

ingsto

n

Dark

um

bra

l sunspot (3

300K

)

Arc

utu

rus (

4000K

)

Synth

etic s

pectr

a fro

m A

llard

, H

auschild

t &

P

avle

nko

2000 a

nd 4

000 K

Page 16: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Pri

ori

tise

d lin

es b

ased

on

str

en

gth

in

su

nsp

ot u

mb

ral a

nd

syn

the

tic s

pe

ctr

a

fro

m 1

-2.5

mm

ww

w.a

str

o.liv

jm.a

c.u

k/~

hra

j/spectr

atlas

Lyubch

ik,

Jone

s,

Pavle

nko,

Viti et

al. 2

004

Page 17: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

17

Page 18: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

18

Page 19: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Me

tal-

fre

eO

xyg

en

-ric

hC

arb

on

-ric

h

HeH

+,

H3+,

LiH

, H

2,

H2 C

IA,

Mo

lecu

lar

lin

e

bro

ad

en

ing

H2,H

3+,H

2O

, T

iO, C

O, C

H,

OH

, V

O, M

gH

, F

eH

, C

aH

, C

aO

H, A

lH, C

rH, S

iH, T

iH,

AlO

, M

gO

, N

H3, C

H4,d

us

t (Z

rO2

, M

g2S

iO4, M

gS

iO3,

Al 2

O3, C

aT

iO3, T

i 2O

6,

Ti 4

O7, F

e,

Ni, C

u ...),

Na

I,

Fe

I, M

nI, S

cI, F

eI, N

iI, T

iI,

Mg

I, A

lI,

CrI

, K

I, S

iI, H

eI,

L

ine

bro

ad

en

ing

-a

lka

li &

mo

lecu

lar

H2, C

O, H

CN

, C

N, C

H, C

S,

CH

4, C

3,

C2H

2, Y

O,

ZrO

,A

lH,

du

st,

M

ole

cu

lar

lin

e

bro

ad

en

ing

Th

e s

ho

pp

ing

lis

t

Page 20: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

‘.. pre

sum

ably

mole

cula

r fe

atu

res .. not nois

e .. consis

tent

changes b

etw

een o

bje

cts

of diffe

rent spectr

al ty

pes’

Page 21: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

21

Jones,

Pavle

nko,

Viti et

al. 2

005

Page 22: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

22

AM

ES

/UC

L w

ate

r lis

ts

Page 23: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

23

Rela

tively

min

or

diffe

rences

Page 24: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

24

PoS

SO

Pro

gre

ss

Ato

mic

•Measure

d -

Mn &

Ti

•Pro

mis

ing -

Al &

Cr

•Too h

ard

-N

a a

nd K

•Near

futu

re -

Sc, F

e, Y

, Lu

Mole

cula

r

•Com

pute

d -

H2O

, H

CN

/HN

C, H

3+

, T

iO, V

O,C

aH

•Near

futu

re -

NH

3

Page 25: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

25

At le

ast M

n ‘fits

Page 26: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

26

Wo

rse to

wa

rds lo

we

r

Te

mpe

ratu

res

Page 27: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

27

Rota

tion e

mphasiz

es p

roble

ms

Page 28: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

28

Page 29: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

29

Page 30: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

30

Page 31: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

31

Identify

wate

r lin

es in s

unspots

Page 32: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

32

Page 33: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

33

Se

nsitiv

ity: W

ate

r L

ine

s v

s T

em

pe

ratu

re

Tem

pera

ture

/K

Rel Intensity (x 1E-

8)

Gra

die

nt

Rela

tive

Inte

nsity

Gra

die

nt

Page 34: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Sum

mary

An

aly

ses r

ely

ing

on

a c

ert

ain

mo

lecu

les a

nd

ato

ms a

re

pro

mis

ing

, e

.g.,

CO

, H

CN

/HN

C,

H2O

, M

n

Mu

lti-in

stitu

te e

ffo

rt u

nd

erw

ay

Inve

stm

ent in

ob

se

rva

tio

na

l to

ols

ha

s b

een

ma

de

bu

t im

po

rta

nt th

at w

e h

ave

ne

ce

ssa

ry to

ols

to

in

terp

ret

Page 35: Robert Hurt Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared …iac.es/congreso/workshop/ulmsf05/pres/jones.pdf · 2006-06-14 · Trying to make sense of high resolution infrared

Outs

tandin

g issues

Ato

mic

da

ta a

re g

en

era

lly v

ery

po

or

-n

ecessa

ry to

m

easu

re (

or

em

piric

ally

de

rive a

str

op

hysic

al

oscill

ato

r str

en

gth

s)

Ma

ny m

ole

cu

lar

line lis

ts a

re in

com

ple

te

Unce

rta

in d

ust sp

ecie

s, g

rain

siz

es a

nd

co

mp

ositio

n

Te

mp

era

ture

sca

les d

erive

d fro

m d

iffe

ren

t m

eth

od

olo

gie

s d

o n

ot

ma

tch

Hig

h-q

ua

lity h

igh

-reso

lutio

n s

pe

ctr

a o

f b

en

ch

ma

rk

ob

jects

can

co

nstr

ain

ma

ny issu

es