roposed nergy acility - town of romulusromulustown.com/pdfs/discussions/20171218063338... · avoid...
TRANSCRIPT
ECONOMIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL BENEFITS
Clean Facility
o Avoid Greenhouse Gas emissions from landfills
o Meet most stringent Air Standards
o No odors
All waste containers opened inside with negative pressure
Economic Benefits
o 85 Permanent jobs
o Hundreds of construction jobs
o $365 Million investment
o Electric Upgrade for Depot
Green Business Center
o Steam for industries like greenhouses
o Electric transmission upgrade
o Facilitate proposed 50 MW Solar facility
CIRCULAR ECONOMY
A circular economy is an alternative to a traditional lineareconomy (make, use, dispose) in which we keep resources in usefor as long as possible, extract the maximum value from themwhilst in use, then recover and regenerate products and materialsat the end of each service life.
SENECA ARMY DEPOT
Electric shortage- “Electrical Desert”
Zoned industrial
One of the largest vacant industrial sites in the Northeast
Federal Superfund Site
In close proximity to two former munitions incineration at the Seneca Army Depot Site
Existing infrastructure
o Water
o Gas
o Rail
o Roads
BENEFITS OF WASTE TO ENERGY
Avoid methane emission from landfills
o 25 times worse than CO2
Avoid CO2 emissions from fossil fuel combustion
Avoid CO2 emissions from metals production
Utilize fuel we are landfilling
Avoid fracking for gas, mining for coal, or drilling for oil
In the interest of public health, safety and welfare and in order to conserve energy and natural resources, the state of New York, in enacting this section, establishes as its policy that:
The following are the solid waste management priorities in this state:
(a) first, to reduce the amount of solid waste generated;
(b) second, to reuse material for the purpose for which it was originally intended or to recycle material that cannot be reused;
(c) third, to recover, in an environmentally acceptable
manner, energy from solid waste that can not be economically and technically reused or recycled; and
(d) fourth, to
dispose of
solid waste…
by land burial ….
ECL §27-0106. STATE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
POLICY
WASTE TO ENERGY IN NEW YORK TODAY
http://energyrecoverycouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/ERC-2016-directory.pdf
WASTE TO ENERGY IS THE FUTURE OF SOLID
WASTE MANAGEMENT
http://www.mepc-mn.org/Meetings/2015/Feb15/150205%20Michaels%20MEPC%20presentation.pdf
FLORIDA’S WASTE TO ENERGY FACILITY
Florida is now leading in the waste-to-energy market, with 11 facilities. This facility just came online in July 2015
West Palm Beach, Florida
AIR POLLUTION CONTROL SYSTEM
The Facility will have state-of-the-art air pollution technology to meet most advanced EPA standards
RECYCLING
Metals
o Ferrous Metals
o Non-ferrous Metals
Ash
o Beneficial use as concrete mix, aggregates, and fillers
o No landfilling on site
AIR EMISSION COMPARISON
Integrated Waste Services Association http://www.mcilvainecompany.com/industryforecast/incinerators/overview/IWSA_2007_Directory2.pdf-
PROJECT HAS A POSITIVE IMPACT ON GREENHOUSE
GAS EMISSIONS-BETTER THAN CARBON NEUTRAL
Waste Disposal Method Net GHG Emissions1
(TPY CO2e)2
Project Waste-to-Energy (WTE) -31,759 (a net GHG emission reduction)
Landfilling 136,726
Net Reduction in GHG Emissions of
WTE Project Compared to Landfill-168,485
1. Calculation based in USEPA Waste Reduction Model (WARM) Version 14 (2016). Analysisprovides credit to WTE for avoided fossil fuel (coal, gas) use due to energy production andmetals recycling.
2. TPY CO2e= Tons per year of greenhouse gas emissions weighted to the equivalent GHGimpact of CO2 based on IPCC guidelines (e.g. methane has a GHG impact 25 times that ofCO2). Even with energy recovery, Landfilling emits substantial methane and does notrecover metals.
CONSISTENCY WITH COMMUNITY PLANS Town of Romulus Comprehensive Plan
o Project will bring private industry to the decaying depot
o Increase tax base
o Host Community Plan
Seneca County Industrial Development Agency
o Currently seeking “alternative energy” on the Depot
Seneca County Draft Environmental Conservation Plan
o Wants a “zero waste” management model, making landfilling the last resort
o While Seneca County does not have a County Solid Waste Management Plan, the Conservation Planstates that “[t]he best practices are intended to contribute to higher waste diversion/recycling levels incommunities and thus reduce the amount of household and municipal waste going to landfills.”
Seneca County Draft Economic Plan
o “The lack of sufficient electric capacity and distribution at the Depot inhibits its growth as a job andbusiness center, and Seneca County is committed to supporting necessary upgrades. Renewable energymay offer at least a partial solution to the Depot’s energy problems. Seneca County is committed tosupporting the development and use of green energy sources. The Seneca County IDA helps promotegreen energy Projects at the Depot.”
o “Goal 3. Seek and support local and nonlocal businesses that strengthen and diversify the economicbase, expand and enhance the tax base, improve wage and salary levels, and utilize the residentworkforce, without diminishing the quality of natural, historical, or cultural resources in the County.”
o Strategy 3H is to “Enable alternative and renewable energy production, including, but not limited to,solar, hydro, biogas, and wind resources.”
ZONING
“A waste-to-energy facility would be classified under Article IV, Section 1 as ‘Renewable EnergyProduction (Solar, Wind, Biomass, Geothermal, etc., -- Utility Scale.’”
A waste-to-energy facility “would be allowed at the former Seneca Army Depot in either theWITE District or the IW District” by Special Permit.
INFRASTRUCTURE
Utilize existing water intake from Seneca Lake
o Seneca Lake is ~4.2 trillion gallons
Waste water will be only domestic sewage
o Re-engineered to recirculate leachate into furnace
Natural gas only used for start-up and to ensure proper temperatures are maintained
Electric Transmission lines will be upgraded
Rail lines and roads already exist
BUILDING HEIGHT
Approx. 180 feet
+/- 912’ AMSL
Approx. 260 feet
+/- 992’ AMSL
Nearby cell towerApprox. 195 feet
+/- 945’ AMSL
Farm silos average 30-275 feet
Nearby landfill is 280 feet
AMSL (Above Mean Sea Level)
PLANTS AND ANIMALS
Acoustic Bat Survey, Bat Conservation and Management, Inc., July 2017
Rare, Threatened, and Endangered Species Evaluation, Environmental Resources, LLC, September 2017
Results:
o No Northern Long-eared Bats (federally threatened)
o No Indiana bats (federally endangered)
o No Short-eared Owl
White Deer relocated off-site
No Eagle or Osprey Nests on-site
HISTORIC AND ARCHEOLOGICAL RESOURCES
The Project Site will have no adverse impact on any historic resources on the Project Site.
SHPO indicated that no archeological sites were identified within the Project Site, and that it has no concerns regarding potential impacts to archaeological resources.
ENERGY PRODUCTION
There will be either one or two steam turbine generatorswith a total capacity of about 25 MW each (50 MW total).
o Equivalent to powering approximately 40,000 homes
Alternative is steam transmission to local industries