rose atoll national wildlife refuge 300 ala moana blvd., rm ......rise a mere 8 feet above sea...

6
U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge Planning Update Number 1, November 2009 Help Us Plan for the Future! Coral garden in Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge’s lagoon / Greg Sanders, USFWS Over the next month, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) will be seeking input from the public, interested agencies, and organizations regarding their interests, concerns, and viewpoints about important refuge management issues. This information will be helpful in the production of a Comprehensive Conservation Plan (CCP) for the Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge, which will be incorporated into a Rose Atoll Marine National Monument Management Plan. This is the first in a series of planning updates to keep you informed and invite your participation in the planning process for the Refuge. As we begin this planning process, we are provided the opportunity to look at our habitat management and public programs from fresh perspectives. Currently, the Refuge is closed to the public to protect nesting seabirds and rare marine life that reside at the atoll. The purpose of the Refuge will remain the same as when the area was set aside “for the conservation, management and protection of its unique and valuable fish and wildlife resources.” However, we have an opportunity to consider whether public programs such as environmental education and wildlife observation may be possible and to review our management of habitats such as coral reefs, sand islands, and Pisonia forest. Your insights and observations are needed to provide a more complete and thoughtful process. Please share your ideas with us by attending upcoming public meetings (see page 6 for details) or by submitting written comments to the refuge (see page 6 for contact information). Public Open House Meeting A Public Open House Meeting will be held November 19, 2009, in Pago Pago (see page 6 for details). Your participation is critical to the success of this effort – we want to hear from you!

Upload: others

Post on 05-Feb-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service

    Rose AtollNational Wildlife RefugePlanning Update Number 1, November 2009

    Help Us Plan for the Future!

    Coral garden in Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge’s lagoon / Greg Sanders, USFWS

    Over the next month, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS)will be seeking input from the public, interested agencies, and organizations regarding their interests, concerns, and viewpoints about important refuge management issues. This information will be helpful in the production of a Comprehensive Conservation Plan (CCP) for the Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge, which will be incorporated into a Rose Atoll Marine National Monument Management Plan.

    This is the first in a series of planning updates to keep you informed and invite your

    participation in the planning process for the Refuge. As we begin this planning process, we are provided the opportunity to look at our habitat management and public programs from fresh perspectives.

    Currently, the Refuge is closed to the public to protect nesting seabirds and rare marine life that reside at the atoll. The purpose of the Refuge will remain the same as when the area was set aside “for the conservation, management and protection of its unique and valuable fish and wildlife resources.”

    However, we have an opportunity to consider whether public programs such as environmental education and wildlife observation may be possible and to review our management of habitats such as coral reefs, sand islands, and Pisonia forest. Your insights and observations are needed to provide a more complete and thoughtful process.

    Please share your ideas with us by attending upcoming public meetings (see page 6 for details) or by submitting written comments to the refuge (see page 6 for contact information).

    Public Open House MeetingA Public Open House Meeting will be held November 19, 2009, in Pago Pago

    (see page 6 for details).

    Your participation is critical to the success of this effort – we want to hear from you!

    You are invited to the first Open House Public Scoping Meetings

    Meetings will be held in the Manu‘a islands during November. They will be advertised locally. One meeting will be held on the island of Tutuila at the Utulei Convention Center on Thursday, November 19 from 4 to 6 p.m.

    We hope to see you there!

    How Do I Contact the Service or Provide Comments?

    For more information on the National Wildlife Refuge or to provide your comments:

    Don Palawski, Project LeaderRose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge300 Ala Moana Blvd., Box 50167Honolulu, HI 96850Phone: (808) 792-9550Fax: (808) 792-9586E-mail: [email protected]: http://www.fws.gov/roseatoll/

    Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge300 Ala Moana Blvd., Rm 5-231Box 50167Honolulu, Hawaii 96850

    6

    Address Correction Requested

    Octopus cyanea on Rose Atoll / Greg Sanders, USFWS

  • 2 5

    National Wildlife What?Refuges are places where wildlife comes first. The National Wildlife Refuge System comprises the world’s largest collection of lands set aside specifically for wildlife and provides important habitat for native plants and animals. The National Wildlife Refuge System is administered by the Department of the Interior’s Fish and Wildlife Service, the principal federal agency responsible for conserving, protecting, and enhancing the nation’s fish and wildlife populations and their habitats for the benefit of the American people.

    The mission of the National Wildlife Refuge System is:

    “To administer a national network of lands and waters for the conservation, management, and where appropriate, restoration of the fish, wildlife, and plant resources and their habitats within the United States for the benefit of present and future generations of Americans.”

    © Phillip Colla

    Refuge OverviewNational Wildlife Refuges located south of the equator.

    Rose Atoll is nearly square, with the ocean-side slopes about 1 mile in length. It is one of the smallest atolls in the world, consisting of two low sandy islets, Rose and Sand. Each is located on a coralline algal reef rim enclosing a lagoon.

    Rose Atoll / Greg Sanders,USFWS

    A single, narrow, shallow channel with a minimum depth of 8 feet links the lagoon to the sea. The lagoon is a maximum of 1.2 miles wide and up to about 65 feet deep, and includes 1,575 acres. Rose and Sand Islands cover areas of about 14 and 7 acres respectively, and rise a mere 8 feet above sea level.

    Rose Atoll is part of the Territory of American Samoa and was established as a National Wildlife Refuge by cooperative agreement between the Government of American Samoa and FWS on August 24, 1973.

    Despite its small size, Rose Atoll supports the largest populations of giant clams, nesting sea turtles, nesting seabirds, and rare species of reef fish in American Samoa. To date, about 270 species of fish have been recorded at the atoll. The two islands are important nesting sites for the threatened green turtle in American Samoa. Satellite tags attached to the nesting green turtles at Rose have shown that these turtles migrate between American Samoa and other Pacific island nations (i.e., Fiji and French Polynesia). In

    Rose Atoll is located approximately 130 nautical miles east-southeast of Pago Pago Harbor, American Samoa, and is the easternmost Samoan island and is one of two atolls in the Samoan Archipelago. It is the southernmost unit of the National Wildlife Refuge System and shares the distinction with Jarvis Island of being the only

    In preparing the CCP, a range of possible alternative management approaches will be explored and evaluated, including current management practices. The effects of the various alternatives on the biological resources and local communities will be evaluated in an Environmental Assessment in accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act.

    The planning team has identified some potential issues to be considered during CCP development. We want to hear your comments on these issues, and any other topics of concern, at our public meetings (see page 6). If you aren’t able to attend one of our public meetings, please submit your comments in writing to the Refuge (see page 6 for contact information), by December 31, 2009. Wildlife and Habitat Resources • Terrestrialhabitatprotectionand restoration (for the Pisonia

    forest, sea turtle nesting, seabird nesting, shorebirds)• Marinehabitatprotectionandrestoration (for coral reefs, giant clams, marine mammals, sea turtles, seabirds, and fishes)

    Visitor Services Activities• Wildlifeobservationandphotography• Environmentaleducation• Publicvisitationviasailormotorized boat

    Tentative Planning ScheduleSchedule dates are tentative and subject to change as the planning process progresses.

    Planning Step Target DatePlanning Update 1 issued November 2009Public Meetings November 2009Planning Update 2 issued February 2010Planning Update 3 issued August 2010Public Review/Comment on Draft CCP/EA September 2010Final CCP January 2011

    Preliminary Issues to be ConsideredProtection of Natural, Historic, and Cultural Resources • Threatstotheislandsandreefs(unauthorized trespass, illegal fishing, marine debris, shipwrecks, and invasive species)• Publicawarenessandunderstanding

    Other topics• Scientificexplorationandresearch• Monitoringandenforcement• Permitting

    Tridacna Maxima / Jim Maragos, USFWS

    © Phillip Colla

  • 3addition to the migratory breeding population of turtles at the atoll during the nesting season (August to February), a small resident population of juveniles apparently lives on the atoll. Endangered hawksbill turtles have also been seen in the lagoon, although it is not known if they nest on the islands.

    Rose Atoll is the most important seabird colony in the region, since approximately 97 percent of the seabird population of American Samoa resides on Rose. The two islands provide important nesting and roosting habitat for

    12 species of federally protected migratory seabirds including terns, noddies, boobies, frigatebirds, and tropicbirds. Only 1 year after removal of rats in 1993, two species of shearwaters (wedge-tailed and Christmas Island) were sighted on Rose Island, the first such burrowing seabirds recorded on Rose.

    The Refuge has been closed to public uses since its establishment to protect the natural resources of this small atoll. In 2002, the National Marine Fisheries Service prohibited vessels longer

    than 50 feet from fishing within 50 nautical miles of Rose Atoll. In 2004, the National Marine Fisheries Service established a no fishing zone that extends outside of the atoll to a depth of 50 fathoms (300 feet). In recent years, most management attention at Rose Atoll by FWS has been focused on removing the 120-foot Taiwanese longline fishing vessel F/V Jin Shiang Fa, which ran aground on the southwest perimeter reef at Rose Atoll in October 1993. The last remaining debris was removed from the atoll in 2007, and FWS continues to monitor reef recovery.

    Juvenile red-footed boobies on Rose Island / Jim Maragos,USFWS

    Rose Atoll Marine National MonumentOn January 6, 2009, President George W. Bush established the Rose Atoll Marine National Monument (MNM) by signing Presidential Proclamation 8337 under the authority of the Antiquities Act of 1906. The lands, submerged lands, waters, and marine environment of Rose Atoll

    support a dynamic reef ecosystem that is home to a very diverse assemblage of terrestrial and marine species, many of which are threatened or endangered. One of the most striking features is the pink hue of fringing reef caused by the dominance of coralline algae.

    Presidential Proclamation 8337 assigned management responsibility for the Rose Atoll MNM to the Secretary of the Interior, in consultation with the Secretary of Commerce. Through Secretary’s Order January 16, 2009, the Secretary of the Interior delegated management responsibility for the Monument to the FWS Director.

    The Secretary of Commerce, through NOAA, has primary management responsibility for fishery-related activities regarding the management of the marine areas of the Monument seaward of mean low water. NOAA’s National Marine Fisheries Service will be developing regulations for fishery-related activities. Agencies with jurisdiction or special expertise, including the Department of Defense, Department of State, and the Government of American Samoa, are to be treated as cooperating agencies in development of any Rose Atoll MNM management plans.

  • 4

    "

    " " " "

    " " "

    ""

    "

    "

    "

    """

    ""

    "

    ""

    "

    "

    "

    "

    "

    "!

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    !

    Hawai'i

    Maui

    Moloka'iOahuKaua'i

    Ni'ihau

    Pearl & Hermes

    Reef

    LisianskiIsland

    LaysanIsland

    GardinerPinnacles

    MaroReef

    French FrigateShoals

    Necker Island

    NihoaIsland

    Portland

    180°

    170°W170°E

    160°W

    150°W

    140°W

    130°W

    160°E

    150°E

    140°E

    10°N

    20°N

    30°N

    40°N

    50°N

    10°S

    E q u a t o r

    E qu a

    t or

    KIRIBATI

    FIJI

    FRENCH POLYNESIA

    MARSHALL ISLANDS

    PAPUA NEW GUINEA

    PALAU

    TUVALU

    VANUATU

    SOLOMON ISLANDS

    NAURU

    TONGA NIUE

    TOKELAU

    FEDERATED STATES OF MICRONESIA

    AMERICAN SAMOA

    WESTERN SAMOA

    WALLIS & FUTUNA

    GUAM

    N. MARIANA ISLANDS

    LaeAur

    Nui Ahe

    Hao

    Rota

    Tobi

    Fais

    Ulul

    Etal

    Ujae

    Arno

    MiliKiliEbon

    Beru

    Niue

    Eiao

    Reao

    Atiu

    Pagan

    Koror

    Merir

    Helen

    Ngulu Sorol

    PulapElato

    Losap

    Nauru

    Bikar

    WothoAiluk Mejit

    Wotje

    Makin

    Kuria

    Anuta

    Alofi

    Orono

    Atafu

    Upolu

    Flint

    Maria

    Mitiaro

    Swains

    Guguan

    Saipan

    Angaur

    Ulithi

    Woleai

    IfalikNomwin

    Murilo

    Kosrae

    Banaba

    Taongi

    Utirik

    Likiep

    Majuro

    TarawaMaiana

    OnotoaTamana Arorae

    Fataka

    Ngende Utupua

    Niutao

    Futuna

    Rotuma

    Malden

    Vostok

    Rurutu

    Kure

    WESTERN CAROLINE ISLANDS

    EASTERN CAROLINE ISLANDS

    GILBE

    RT

    Tahiti`Ana`a

    KauehiArutua

    Tepoto

    Ahunui

    Morane

    Pinaki

    Manuae

    Maug IsAgrihan

    Sarigan

    Peleliu

    Colonia

    Puluwat

    Satawal

    PulusukNamoluk

    Satawan

    Nukuoro

    Ujelang

    Namorik

    Marakei

    Abemama

    Aranuka

    Nikunau

    Tikopia

    Nanumea

    VaitupuFakaofo

    Tutuila

    Savai`i

    Teraina

    Taveuni

    `Ua Pou Hiva`Oa

    Tubua`i

    Maupiti

    Mataiva

    Moruroa

    Penrhyn

    Mangaia

    Asuncion

    Alamagan

    Anatahan

    Faraulep

    Eauripik

    Hall Is.

    Pingelap

    Enewetak

    Maloelap

    Reef Is.

    Vanikolo

    Funafuti Nukunonu

    Starbuck

    Caroline

    `Ua Huka

    Rimatara

    Manihiki

    Iwo Jima

    Nanumanga

    Babeldaop

    Pulo Anna Chuuk Is.

    Kwajalein

    Nukufetau

    Niulakita

    Tabuaeran

    Lau Group

    Nuka Hiva

    Fatu Hiva

    Puka Puka

    Tatakoto

    Manra

    GROUP

    NORTHERN LINE ISLANDS

    SOUTH

    ERN

    LINE

    ISLA

    NDS

    MARQUESAS ISLANDS

    Rakahanga

    Rarotonga

    Torres Is.

    Nukulaelae

    Kiritimati

    Fangataufa

    Palmerston

    Supply Reef

    Sikaiana Is.

    Filippo Reef

    Vava`u Group

    Uvea

    Ha`apai Group

    Kapingamarangi

    Nukumanu Islands

    Admiralty Islands

    Minami Tori Shima

    Farallon de Pajaros

    Farallon de Medinilla

    Aguijan

    Aitutaki

    Kanton Enderbury

    Birnie

    SOCI ETY ISLANDS

    PHOENIX GROUP

    Tinian

    PohnpeiSapwuahfik

    Mwoakilloa

    CHUUKYAP

    POHNPEI KOSRAE

    Bikini Rongelap

    Jaluit

    LibNamu

    Ailinglaplap

    Jabwot

    Butaritari

    Abaiang

    Nonouti

    Tabiteuea

    Duff Is.

    Ra`ivavaeMaria Islands

    Mo`orea

    Bora Bora

    Manus New Hanover

    New Ireland

    New Britain Bougainville

    BISMARCK ARCH.

    Trobriand Islands

    D`entrecasteaux Is.

    Misima Huahine

    Rangiroa

    Manihi FakahinaSanta IsabelNew

    Georgia

    Choiseul

    GuadalcanalMalaita

    MakiraRennell

    N O RT H

    P A CI F I C

    O C E AN

    Japan

    China

    Russia Russia

    South Korea

    North Korea

    Australia

    Indonesia

    Mexico

    Aleutian

    Island

    s

    Kuril`sk

    iyeIsl

    ands

    Mongolia

    ^

    PapuaNew Guinea

    Midway Atoll NWR

    Hawaiian Islands NWR

    Kilauea Point NWRHuleia NWR

    Hanalei NWRKakahaia NWR

    Kealia Pond NWR

    Hakalau Forest NWR

    James Campbell NWROahu Forest NWRPearl Harbor NWR

    Kingman Reef NWR

    Palmyra Atoll NWRHowland Island NWR

    Jarvis Island NWR

    Baker Island NWR

    Guam NWR

    Rose Atoll NWR

    Johnston Atoll NWR

    ^

    M A R I A N A S T R E N C H M . N . M .

    PA C I F I C R E M O T EI S L A N D S M . N . M .

    PA C I F I C R E M O T EI S L A N D S M . N . M .

    PA C I F I C R E M O T EI S L A N D S M . N . M .

    PA C I F I C R E M O T EI S L A N D S M . N . M .

    PA C I F I C R E M O T EI S L A N D S M . N . M .

    R O S E AT O L L M . N . M .

    P A P A H A N A U M O K U A K E A M . N . M .

    Wake Atoll NWR

    Mariana Trench NWR

    Mariana Arc of Fire NWR

    Produced for the Division of Realty & Refuge InformationPortland, OregonCurrent to: 11-14-06Basemap (Date): 09-30-09Meridian:n/aFile: 05-219-4.mxd

    Land StatusU.S. Fish & Wildlife ServiceRose Atoll National Wildlife RefugeTerritory of American Samoa

    RoseIsland

    SandIsland

    M.L.L.W

    .

    M.L.L.W

    .

    0 1 2 30.5

    Nautical Miles

    168°12'00"W 168°8'00"W

    14°36'00"S

    RoseAtoll

    168°9'00"W 168°8'00"W

    14°32'00"S

    0 0.5 10.25

    Nautical Miles

    Quickbird MS Bands 3,2,1Natural Color Composite ImageCaptured on 8-26-2004

    Inset Map Boundary Map

    P a c i f i c

    TheNational WildlifeRefuge System

    in theCentral Pacific

    Scale: 1:30,000,000

    UTM ZONE 2SWGS 84

    ORTHOGRAPHIC PROJECTIONWGS 1984 SPHEROID/DATUM

    14°32'00"S

    168°10'00"W

    14°33'00"S

    O c e a n

    0 500 1,000 1,500250Miles (approximate)

    0 500 1,000 1,500250Kilometers (approximate)

    Primary Jurisdiction

    Refuge Boundary

    P a c i f i c

    O c e a n

  • 2 5

    National Wildlife What?Refuges are places where wildlife comes first. The National Wildlife Refuge System comprises the world’s largest collection of lands set aside specifically for wildlife and provides important habitat for native plants and animals. The National Wildlife Refuge System is administered by the Department of the Interior’s Fish and Wildlife Service, the principal federal agency responsible for conserving, protecting, and enhancing the nation’s fish and wildlife populations and their habitats for the benefit of the American people.

    The mission of the National Wildlife Refuge System is:

    “To administer a national network of lands and waters for the conservation, management, and where appropriate, restoration of the fish, wildlife, and plant resources and their habitats within the United States for the benefit of present and future generations of Americans.”

    © Phillip Colla

    Refuge OverviewNational Wildlife Refuges located south of the equator.

    Rose Atoll is nearly square, with the ocean-side slopes about 1 mile in length. It is one of the smallest atolls in the world, consisting of two low sandy islets, Rose and Sand. Each is located on a coralline algal reef rim enclosing a lagoon.

    Rose Atoll / Greg Sanders,USFWS

    A single, narrow, shallow channel with a minimum depth of 8 feet links the lagoon to the sea. The lagoon is a maximum of 1.2 miles wide and up to about 65 feet deep, and includes 1,575 acres. Rose and Sand Islands cover areas of about 14 and 7 acres respectively, and rise a mere 8 feet above sea level.

    Rose Atoll is part of the Territory of American Samoa and was established as a National Wildlife Refuge by cooperative agreement between the Government of American Samoa and FWS on August 24, 1973.

    Despite its small size, Rose Atoll supports the largest populations of giant clams, nesting sea turtles, nesting seabirds, and rare species of reef fish in American Samoa. To date, about 270 species of fish have been recorded at the atoll. The two islands are important nesting sites for the threatened green turtle in American Samoa. Satellite tags attached to the nesting green turtles at Rose have shown that these turtles migrate between American Samoa and other Pacific island nations (i.e., Fiji and French Polynesia). In

    Rose Atoll is located approximately 130 nautical miles east-southeast of Pago Pago Harbor, American Samoa, and is the easternmost Samoan island and is one of two atolls in the Samoan Archipelago. It is the southernmost unit of the National Wildlife Refuge System and shares the distinction with Jarvis Island of being the only

    In preparing the CCP, a range of possible alternative management approaches will be explored and evaluated, including current management practices. The effects of the various alternatives on the biological resources and local communities will be evaluated in an Environmental Assessment in accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act.

    The planning team has identified some potential issues to be considered during CCP development. We want to hear your comments on these issues, and any other topics of concern, at our public meetings (see page 6). If you aren’t able to attend one of our public meetings, please submit your comments in writing to the Refuge (see page 6 for contact information), by December 31, 2009. Wildlife and Habitat Resources • Terrestrialhabitatprotectionand restoration (for the Pisonia

    forest, sea turtle nesting, seabird nesting, shorebirds)• Marinehabitatprotectionandrestoration (for coral reefs, giant clams, marine mammals, sea turtles, seabirds, and fishes)

    Visitor Services Activities• Wildlifeobservationandphotography• Environmentaleducation• Publicvisitationviasailormotorized boat

    Tentative Planning ScheduleSchedule dates are tentative and subject to change as the planning process progresses.

    Planning Step Target DatePlanning Update 1 issued November 2009Public Meetings November 2009Planning Update 2 issued February 2010Planning Update 3 issued August 2010Public Review/Comment on Draft CCP/EA September 2010Final CCP January 2011

    Preliminary Issues to be ConsideredProtection of Natural, Historic, and Cultural Resources • Threatstotheislandsandreefs(unauthorized trespass, illegal fishing, marine debris, shipwrecks, and invasive species)• Publicawarenessandunderstanding

    Other topics• Scientificexplorationandresearch• Monitoringandenforcement• Permitting

    Tridacna Maxima / Jim Maragos, USFWS

    © Phillip Colla

  • U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service

    Rose AtollNational Wildlife RefugePlanning Update Number 1, November 2009

    Help Us Plan for the Future!

    Coral garden in Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge’s lagoon / Greg Sanders, USFWS

    Over the next month, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS)will be seeking input from the public, interested agencies, and organizations regarding their interests, concerns, and viewpoints about important refuge management issues. This information will be helpful in the production of a Comprehensive Conservation Plan (CCP) for the Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge, which will be incorporated into a Rose Atoll Marine National Monument Management Plan.

    This is the first in a series of planning updates to keep you informed and invite your

    participation in the planning process for the Refuge. As we begin this planning process, we are provided the opportunity to look at our habitat management and public programs from fresh perspectives.

    Currently, the Refuge is closed to the public to protect nesting seabirds and rare marine life that reside at the atoll. The purpose of the Refuge will remain the same as when the area was set aside “for the conservation, management and protection of its unique and valuable fish and wildlife resources.”

    However, we have an opportunity to consider whether public programs such as environmental education and wildlife observation may be possible and to review our management of habitats such as coral reefs, sand islands, and Pisonia forest. Your insights and observations are needed to provide a more complete and thoughtful process.

    Please share your ideas with us by attending upcoming public meetings (see page 6 for details) or by submitting written comments to the refuge (see page 6 for contact information).

    Public Open House MeetingA Public Open House Meeting will be held November 19, 2009, in Pago Pago

    (see page 6 for details).

    Your participation is critical to the success of this effort – we want to hear from you!

    You are invited to the first Open House Public Scoping Meetings

    Meetings will be held in the Manu‘a islands during November. They will be advertised locally. One meeting will be held on the island of Tutuila at the Utulei Convention Center on Thursday, November 19 from 4 to 6 p.m.

    We hope to see you there!

    How Do I Contact the Service or Provide Comments?

    For more information on the National Wildlife Refuge or to provide your comments:

    Don Palawski, Project LeaderRose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge300 Ala Moana Blvd., Box 50167Honolulu, HI 96850Phone: (808) 792-9550Fax: (808) 792-9586E-mail: [email protected]: http://www.fws.gov/roseatoll/

    Rose Atoll National Wildlife Refuge300 Ala Moana Blvd., Rm 5-231Box 50167Honolulu, Hawaii 96850

    6

    Address Correction Requested

    Octopus cyanea on Rose Atoll / Greg Sanders, USFWS