r[pc wkcgy[zf yix - cardozo law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
FNMFMMNKNTKXGCPEKRKG\:IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
B.FYEPF;C.B\DZFBPGRF;D.[GZ[KF[NFFIPZFFFNM\K\CP[R\ZK"J;E.IKZG\FVSKYFGPCIRKFF\BDEG\;F.KISG[N
ZK"JBNPINNK[C\;G.SKMGO.
B.FYEPF1
FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN)1885=1945;NFNQZK"J(,FKFKNKEFGRDZKFGCQ
RBPQNPGZ[\FF\GZRK\,PCK\PEZ[GFPSGTU[NFI\OSGVZG\NPKEKG2
.
NKPKOF[\YTCTKKZFVK[KJBQCSNGCYKF,[OMKFQMZCGZB[K[KCF3
TE
NPNIP\FTGNOF[RKKF.ZK"JF\VZSOCZCKOCTKYZCHMG\IKCGZG
FSRSXKGRK’BOFCRKO[PIF’,[BG\GM\CCPFNLPNIP\FTGNOF[RKF,
~67|
1PBPZHFCBNIEEPGENRGSU[NFIPZFFNM\K\,TNCSKSPBPZGFI[GC[N
FI[GC[NC’CZBGQ,’FIPZF:IPK[FJKVGSKOPQFT\FIE[F’,EKRKK[ZBN,M=MB
)\["S=\[S"B(,TP’123=.237FPBPZFKRGVZYP\GLTCGE\FEGYJGZ[NK,FRM\C\
CKPKOBNFCFRIKK\VZGV’EC[GGZWPQFPINYFNVKNGSGVKFCBGRKCZSKJ\CZ=BKNQ,
CRG[B:’IHGQFDBGNF[NFZCK[[MZ[NPFJKKMJNFK"E:\PGZG\C\VKS\G
FP[KIK\CPFNLF[GBF’.\GE\KNGTKE\F\CKTG\)The Claims Conference(TN
FSKGTFREKC[FG[KJFNPIYZK.
2BZCTFPGHMZKOMZCG\KG[NZK"J,GFO:FZC[NGOGKEZ)PICZSEZ\SVZK’KE
[NGO’(;FZCPZEMKNKCGKRYNZ)PICZSVZK’NCG[KPZEMK’(,FZCP[FDZKRGGNE
PIGSJ)PICZ[G"\’TZGD\FC[O’(GFZC[PGBNZGHRCZDPBGRSEGZU)PICZSVZK
’CBZ[PGBN’(.
3[PF[NFK[KCFFKF’PGZKF’.TNBGEG\KFZBGB’VGYS,K[KCG\FGRDZKFCDEGN\Q
GCIGZCRQ,C,KZG[NKO\[P"H,TP’50=.60
![Page 2: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
CTGEG[GFFMVNKJCN\KIGYKCCGEV[J.NBIZVZSGOFSVZ[CZK"J
NSNGCYKF,[ORNMEG[GNINBG[GGKW.
CPBPZHFNBBTSGYCSVZ’BOFCRKO[PIF’,MKBOBSYGZB\\VKS\G
F\GZRK\GFFNM\K\[NZK"J,MVK[FKBCBFNKEKCKJGKC[RKOFBZGMG\[N
FKXKZFF\GZRK\[NG[YEPGNPNIPF.CPFNL[RG\TCGE\GFZCRK\M\C
ZK"JBNVK\[GCG\FNM\KG\,GPFQKXBGCIKKGCMZLBIE[N[G"\P[RF
[MKZ,GMZL[RK[TPENVRKFEVSFTZCFPNIPF.MQMKRSZK"J,CIKCGZ
CTNBGVKFDG\K=EZ[RKC[O’JGCKDBN’,TGEMPF\[GCG\FNM\KG\.BGNO
PM\CKEG[ZEGYZGCNBNU\[GCG\FNM\KG\GIKEG[KO\GZRKKORGSVKO,
[PRKBHMGRSGCKEKCRG,FZCIKKOPRIOJKMJN,NMZMK[G"\P[RF[MKZ
[TGPEKONVRKRGMKGO4
.ZK"JFKFVGSYPGTZLCKG\Z,GF\M\CGKG\KGTO
DEGNKEGZGKGMKIGTEMPFDEGNFFKK\FKGYZ\G.MLTGNFDOPQFFSMPG\TN
SVZKG,PVKPKJCIMPKFGRDZKFGDNKNG\KF5
.
CPBPZHFBEDKOMKXERKSIZK"JCXTKZG\GCXGZFCFKZFMPFPKSGEG\
FP[RFFFNM\K\FBGZ\GEGMSK\,GMRDHZ\PMLB\FRJKKFNFIPZFFNM\K\
MBKEKBGNGDKF.MQBCY[NFZBG\MKXEF\PGZFFZTKGRK\FPVGZSP\[N
~68|
4M\CKFZK"JCFORTSGYCPBPZHF:JGCKDBN,CZEKGC1926;[G"\P[RF[MKZ,B,
CZEKGC\ZV"E;[G"\P[RF[MKZ,BGZIIKKO,C,KZG[NKO\[P"H;[G"\P[RF[MKZ
KGZFETF,KZG[NKO\[R"B;[G"\P[RF[MKZIG[QP[VJ,BCQFTHZGBGZIIKKO
PFEGZF\RKRBGF[NPG\NKGZFETF,KZG[NKO\[R"G.P[RF[MKZBGZIIKKOINYC
GP[RF[MKZIG[QP[VJMGRSGNBIZGRFCFGXBFFYZGKF:P[RF[MKZPFEGZ\
\[S"I,FPMKNFDOMPFGMPF\GSVG\[FKGC[GNKM\CKG[NZK"J,GCFQTZLZC.
CPFNLFPBPZKKT[FCFQ[KPG[.MZLB[NF[G"\KXBNBGZPIE[CKZG[NKO
\[N"E,CPFEGZ\XKNGO.CPFEGZFHGRGSUYGCW\XNGPKOGVYSKPKNKG\,[OPGCB
XKNGO[NM\CFSPKMF[FTRKYFZCZGHRCZDNZK"J,CFKG\FBIZGQCQT[ZKOG[\KKO
CNCE.SYKZFMNNK\TNM\CKGFFNM\KKO[NZK"JPXGKFNBGZLTCGE\G[NK’
VZKENREZ,’FZC[NPFK[[MZJKMJN:PP\RDENXKGRG\N\GPLCXKGRG\’,TCGE\
PGSPL,BGRKCZSKJ\CZ=BKNQ\[R"J.
5NVRKRGPXGKG\FSMPG\NSVZKGPB\:FZCPBKZBZKYPJGZRB,FZCK[TKFHKNCZ[JKKQ
PGGKXQ,FZCBCZFOPRENFNGK[JKKRCZDPCZGEK,FZCTYKCBSGVZ)CRG[NF"M\C
SGVZ"GZCF[NVZ[CGZD,NKPKOCKZG[NKO(,FZC[PGBNTRDNPZBEGPK[NB,FZC
YNPQGCZ)ZCF[NVK[JKBQ(,Z’PBKZEQVNGXYKPBGSJZGC,FBEPG"ZZ’PBKZKIKBN
FNGKPBGSJZGCXF,Z’ECCTZK[GGKERVNEPJ[TCKQ,FZCKFG[TCGYSCGKOPDBNBRJB
GZ’KGSUIKKOHGRRVNEPKZG[NKO.NPFEGZFFIE[F[NM\CKGFGSKUCRGFSMPG\
P[RKIMPKOPBGIZKONG,FZCKXIYKTYCGKKSGFZC[NPFHNPQBGKTZCL.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 3: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
ZK"J,[P[\YV\CSVZG’BOFCRKO[PIF’,FGZ@\FC[KRGK\GET\KPGYEO
N[GBF,M\GXBFPRK\GIBKZGTKFHPQGP\VKSFFNM\K\KKIGEK\6
.
P[R\F[NFBGZ\GEGMSKFFFGRDZK\RIYZFFKJCCTCZ,GCMNNHFDO
DK[\FFFNM\K\FPIPKZF,7
BGNOEGPRK[K[TZLZCCPBPZKNRGMI[\K
RYGEG\.ZB[K\,FPIYZTNFBGZ\GEGYSKFFFGRDZK\P\ZMH,ZGCGMMGNG,
CPIXK\F[RKF[NFPBFF\[T-T[ZF8
.HB\C[NFPBGZTG\FP[PTG\KKO
[F\ZI[GC\YGVFHG)BSKV\PKFBNGGKW’,9
VKNGDFYFKNG\,10
GMQEKGRKO
FNM\KKOP[PTG\KKOTNSGDKG\NKCFMEGDP\FRK[GBKQFBHZIKKO,11
PTPE
ICZKFYFKNG\FNB=BGZ\GEGYSKG\,12
[KRGKKOCPRFDKK[ZBNCRK[GBKQ,13
CCZK\PKNF,14
CFRFD\C\KFMRS\,15
GTGE(.NTGP\HB\,FPIXK\FZB[GRF
[NFPBFFT[ZKO,\YGVF[CFFGJPTGKSGEG\FBGZ\GEGYSKFCYZC
FPRFKDKOFZGIRKKOGFYFKNG\FBGZ\GEGYSKG\PIEDKSB,BLCFINF[IKYF
~69|
6TGETNMLZBGK’FZ[YGCKW,’BOFCRKO[PIF:PIKCGZYBRGRKNKXKZFEKBNYJK\’,
TNKSVZ,MC)CEVGS(.
7ZBGNFNQFTZF.37
8NSYKZFPPXFTN\YGVFHGZBG:J. Katz, ‘The Identity of Post EmancipatoryHungarian Jewry’, Y. Don and V. Karady (eds.), A Social and Economic
History of Central European Jewry, New Brunswick 1990, pp. 13-31.9ZBGR’YXCGZD,’VSY=CK\=EKQ[NPKMBNGCKW\ZM"G’,T’BJYSGK’[NPGQ)TGZMKO(,
SVZM"W,KZG[NKO\["O,TP’273=.286ZBGDOK"KMFQ,IMPKFGRDZKFGFSVZG\
F\GZRK\CF,KZG[NKO\[R"H,TP’65=.67
10ZBGMFQ)NTKNFTZF9(,TP’27=82;K’M"W,FYZT[NBR\BIF:VZK[\FBGZ\GEGYSKO
PMNNFYFKNG\CFGRDZKFGCDZPRKF,KZG[NKO\[R"F.TNBVKGRKF[NBSMGN\\NPKEK
FI\"SGDK[\FFBDZDJKCK\ZBGDOP’VZKEPQ,FICZFFIZEK\:PYGZG\,PDPG\
G\FNKMKO,KZG[NKO1991,TP’14=.17
11ZBGZP"NGKRYNZ,K[CPXZU,GGBKJXTQ\Z"S,PRDEZBGC’[KY,GNFXEKYXEKY,
SBSVBNB\ZT"C.TGEZBGZP"[DNHRZ,[G"\EGZZCKTK,C,KZG[NKO\[N"H,SKPQ
XB.GMQCFYEP\GNIKCGZGIYGZECZ,PGRYBJ[\ZS"B.
12ZBGMFQ)NTKNFTZF9(,TP’155=158,GCPYGZG\FZCKO[FCKB.
13ZBGNEGDPFZP"NGKRYNZ,[G"\NCG[KPZEMK,CGEBVTSJ\ZV"I,BCQFTHZ\RKRB
SKPQPH.
14ZBGNEGDPFZ"KBSBE,[G"\KFGEFKTNF,KGZFETF,NTPCTZD\ZN"D,SKPQZRI.ZBG
DOZK"KTNJRKDZ,[G"\CRKQXKGQ,BNJGRF\ZM"I,SKPQMD.
15ZBGNEGDPFZ"PDZKRGGNE,[G"\TZGD\FC[O,SGGBNKGGT\ZT"C,BGZIIKKOSKPQKE;
MI;MJ;NB;ZKC.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 4: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
P[PTG\K\CMGIO[NFKFGEKOFBGZ\GEGYSKKOC\GLMNNKFGEKFGRDZKF16
PBKELDKSB,NBRIYZFMECTK.NVKML,PBPZKPXKD\PGRFNBPGMZ\KISK\
TNPRFKDBGZ\GEGYSK[RGNEG[DENC\GLBGGKZF[NVKNGDFYFKNG\G[N
BKEKBGNGDKFPGCRK\,BLZBFCPGTKRKGB\F\VGZZG\FYGRSVXKF[FGCKNG
DEGNKFEGZG\FYGEPKO.
[RK\,XGZ\F\RSIG\GFFNM\K\FKKIGEK\[NZK"J,GMQFTGCEF[M\C
IKCGZBKEKBGNGDKPGCRF[P\BZB\\FNKMKFKGGXZG\P[R\GFFNM\K\,
PXKCFBG\GMEPG\[ZBGKFNCIKRFPTPKYF.ZK"J,CRKDGENVGSYKO
BGZ\GEGYSKOBIZKO,I[UCVRKYGZBKGB\\FNKLVSKY\FFNMF[NGPQ
FPSEGTENJVIG\,GDKNFNTKQ=MGN[SCZ\GFBKEKBGNGDK\FKK\FFDGZO
FPMZKTCVSKY\G,FZCFPTCZN[KYGNKOVGZPBNKKOXZGVKO.BGPROBKQHF
IZKD[VGSYP[\P[DOC[KYGNKOIGW=VGZPBNKKOCVSKY\G,17
BLBXN
ZK"JPEGCZCPFNLPGXFZGPGET18
.CTPGEKOFCBKOBCY[NJTGQ[DKNGK
FNCCGRYJZK"J,KIETO\TGH\GGTOFBIZKG\[RJNTNTXPGMVGSY
GMPRFKDZGIRK,FXKCGBG\GCIHK\FPTZMFFFNM\K\NBZYCT\FKG\G
PRFKDBGZ\GEGYSKPGCFY)TE\IKN\[RG\F[NG[KO[NFPBFFT[ZKO(,
MKBODOFVMGBG\GNKPKONPCYZ\YKU[NFVSKYFFBGZ\GEGYSK\
FFGRDZK\.
~70|
16F\GXZ[NVKNGDFYFKNG\FKF[IKYFP\P[M\GFGNM\CMGIFFKISK[N
FBGZ\GEGYSKFCICZFFKFGEK\CFGRDZKF.CTGECPVYE[CKXTFPP[N\FGRDZKF
C=1880NPTNFP=%56PKFGEKFGRDZKFFDEGNF[KKMGTXPONYFKNG\FBGZ\GEGYSKG\
)NTGP\%38RKBGNGDKO(,FZK[CPVYE[CGXTCKEKFKGERZJC=1944PRGFYFKNG\
FRKBGNGDKG\NPTNFP=%62P\G[CKFFKFGEKKO[NFGRDZKF,GBKNGFBGZ\GEGYSKOZY
PTJNPTNFP=%.36ZBGK. Frojimovics, ‘Zsido hitkozsegi szervezetMagyarorszagon 1944-ben: a harom vallasi iranyzat es demografiaijellemzoirol’, R. L. Braham (ed.), Tanulmanyok a holokausztrol, vol. 2,
Budapest 2002, pp. 9-52.17ZBG:A. Ravitsky, ‘Hadash min ha-Torah? Modernist vs. Traditionalist
Orientations in Contemporary Orthodoxy’, M. Sokol (ed.), EngagingModernity: Rabbinic Leaders and the Challenge of the Twentieth Century,
Northvale, NJ 1997, pp. 35-53.18F[GG:J. Katz, ‘Da’at Torah: The Unqualified Authority Claimed for
Halakhists’, Jewish History, 11, 1 (1997), pp. 41-50.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 5: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
C.B\DZFBPGRF
[GZ[KP[R\GFFNM\K\[NZK"JRTGXKOC\VKS\TGNO\GZRK\TPGYF,
[TGSY\CY[Z[CKQFZUFE\K[FBNPXKCNBEONCKQFZU[FBEOPXKC
NTXPGCCGBGNPNBB\KKTGEGFZGIRKCTGNO.\VKSFHGYGCT\INGYF
TYZGRK\CKQFINYKOC\GGL[CKQFBNNBEO,TNKFOBIZBKFBN,NCKQ
FINYKOFR\GRKOCSPMG\GFCNTEK\[NFBEO19
.
NVKML,FDO[CPCJZB[GQRDNFS\KZG\NMBGZFCFRIG\FPGXB[N
FPGENKOFBGZ\GEGYSKKO[NZK"J,BKQHB\MKBORKSKGQNF\BKOCKQ[\K
BPK\G\,[RKXKZKO[NBGZOK[NEGQB\FPXKBG\{FPK[GZFBNGFK,
FPDEKZSGNOPSGEZGRFKZNTCGE\FBNGNF\YEPG\BNKG,GMRDEGFPK[GZ
FBRG[K,[PCJBB\FPBPXKOFBRG[KKOGB\FPJNG\FBRG[KG\FREZ[G\
CMEKNBV[ZNKFGEKNTPGECYZKJZKGRKOFBNFKKOCTGNOFHF,FZGGK\BGG\
GVK\GKKOFMZ\KKO.ECZFBN,FPGXDC\GZF[CM\CG[CTNVFCXGZ\F
FM\GCF,PCJBTYZGRG\BNFKKORXIKKO[NFRIKG\NF\YEPG\ZGIRK\[N
FBEO.BGNOPYGPG[NFBEOCPTZM\HGPXGKCKMGN\GNF\BKOB\EZK[G\
F\GZFTNINYKFF[GRKONTGNPGFP[\RF.CRYGEFHGPTXKOZK"JPBGEB\
MGIGGBIZKG\G[NFVGSY.
FCIKZFCBGZ\GEGYSKFMEZLIKKOFKK\FCIKZFPGET\[NFMZTF
NJGC\YG[PZRKGRGY[FKG\ZPCIKRFFNM\K\PHF[FKFPYGCNTEBH20
.
HB\P\GLFMZF[NRGMIFB\DZKOFDEGNKOPCK\GPIGW[FKFEG\TGPE\
CVRKFOC\YGVFFPGEZRK\,K[XGZLN\\PTRFFGNO[KCXZB\IGPG\
FE\.NVKZK"J,PFNL\GET\KHFBKRRGBNBPTRFBRG[KNPXKBG\,CKJGK[N
~71|
19TNFP\ICKQ[\KFEZMKOFPZMHKG\NF\CGRRG\C\MNK\F[NF\GZF,GMQTNP\GEG\
JKVGNGDKG\FPSKKTG\CBCIRFHGZBGB’[DKB,KFEG\:CKQE\NPGSZ,\N=BCKC
\[R"I,CTKYZTP’11=.27PFNLHFPFGGFFP[LNE’SJJPQGB’[DKB,E\GPGSZ,
KZG[NKO\[R"D.
20ZBGSYKZFBXNP"YSKNCZ,’ZB[K\XPKI\F[NFBGNJZF=BGZ\GEGYSKKF:FPXB\F
[NPSGZ\’,K’[NPGQ,B’VZHKDZGB’ZCKXYK)TGZMKO(,BGZ\GEGYSKKFKFGEK\,KZG[NKO
\[S"G,TP’297=.344ZBGDOK’M"W,FFNMFCPKXZ:PM[GNKOTNEZLFBGZ\GEGYSKF
CFGGF,KZG[NKO\[R"C.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 6: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
FIKZG\[RK\RFCKEKPRFKDKFEGZG\.HB\CTGEFFNMFCXGZ\FFVGZPBNK\,
MVK[FKB[P[\YV\CPSGZ\FEGZG\,\GCT\YZKJZKGRKOFNM\KKO
GICZ\KKO[GRKO)GCFY[Z[NFBGZ\GEGYSKF{P\GRKOKG\Z(.
CKJGKPGCFYN[\KFPDPG\FNNGGNSNKN\FPGXBFE\KFPIGE[PIGSZ
FBKHGQFPXGKCKRKFQ,P\DNFCFDFFI[GCFCSVZG’JGCKDBN’,CFDGNN
ZK"JB\KSGEK\VKS\GCB[ZNPG[DKFBPGRF.FGBVG\ICXKJGJP’ZCKRG
FDEGNPBGRSEBZUHX"N’,21
NVKGFBPGRFBKRRFVTGNFBRG[K\,MKBO:
FBPGRFCF’FGBTRKQJCTK[VGTN\PTXPFCNCMNBK[K[ZBN,CNK
[GOVTGNFIKXGRK\,KTQMKR[PG\K[ZBNFGBINYBNYKPPTNIXGCF
PMSBMCGEG,GMNINYRP[LPPKNBN[GZ[G,N[GZ[FFMN[P[O
RIXCF.GTVK"H)=GTNVKHF(MNR[PFCK[ZBNKGETGPZDK[PTXPGB\
CGZBGGPMKZB\ZCGRG,PB[ZFGBZGBFGPZDK[BKLFGBRP[LBNKG
K\CZL,PCNK[GOT[K’~F|PPRGMNNGMNN,GPPKNBCBNGFBPGRF
PBNKGPJCTFCZKBFPB\FCGZBC"F~...|22
.
FMZFHG,[MGNVTGN\FBPGRFBKRRFBNBVTGNFBNFK\,PTGZZ\,MPGCQ,
PSVZYG[KG\.ZB[K\,BOML,PFG[GZ[F[NFMVKZF?[RK\,PFFJTO
CTKSGYCTRKKRKBPGRF,BOCNBGFMK[GZ[FBPGRFFGBP\\BNGF?K\ZTN
MQ,B\[TZSVZG[NZK"JPTJZFMK\GC:’SVZHFPMKNEZ[G\~...|NIKHGY
F\GZFGFBPGRF~...|’!TN[BNG\BNFK[NFGSKU,CCGBRGNCIGQB\FT[KKF
FFNM\K\,PFGPYGPG[NFVGSYGFPRFKDFZGIRKCCKXGZIGPG\FBPGRF?
BOBMQFBPGRFFKBMGNFVTGNFBNGFK\,PPKNBBKQJTOCFKINXG\NPTR&F
BRG[KNPXKBG\,GPYGPG[NFBEOCT[KKFFE\K\CJNGPCGJN.
BGNOZK"JF[KCPKKETNJTG\HG,GCKBZ[NBF\MGGQ[FBPGRFFKB
VTGNF[PSGZFMGNFCKEKFBN,MKBO[K[NINYCKQ[GZ[FBPGRF,
[PYGZGBNFK,NCKQFF\DCZG\TNPTMCKFBPGRF,[FKBVTGNFBRG[K\23
.
~72|
21FMGGRFNZ’[PGBNZGHRCZD)NTKNFTZF2(,PICZCBZ[PGBN,YZBYB\ZV"D.TNKG
ZBGMFQ)NTKNFTZF9(,TP’169,400=.401FZCZGHRCZDPXGJJVTPKOPSVZCMN
SVZKG[NZK"J,GCFTZXFDEGNF.ZBGTGENTKNFTZF.4
22JGCKDBN)NTKNFTZF4(,TP’20=.24
23[O.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 7: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
BRMKF"B)=F’BNFKL(,GBKRKXZKLNXGG\NLT"H)=TNHF(,ZY\RBKBIE
K[CECZ:’NBKFKFNLBNFKOBIZKOT"V)=TNVRKK(’,FKKRG[NBKFK’~F|
CKRKRGECZPSLGPCEKN[KVSKYCKRKRG~...|BCN~...|BOKFK’~F|NL
TGGRG\GIJBKO[KCEKNGCKRKRG~...|BHNBKFK’~F|NLMIHF.
CXEFVTGNFFBNGFK\FP\PKEF[NY[ZTOFBEO,MVK[FKBP[\YV\FQ
CPK[GZKOIKXGRKKO)F\GZF(GFQCPK[GZKOVRKPKKO)FY[ZFBPGRKFPEGCZ,
DZTKQ[N\Y[GZ\TOFBN[BKRRGHGRIB\FBEONTGNO(,K[XKVKKF
[FBEOK\BKOTXPGNPGENHFGKPP[B\KKTGEGMK[G\FVGRFBNFBN.
FF\BPF[FBEOREZ[BNKFFKBF\DCZG\TNMGNFPTMCKO,FPGRTKOPPRG
B\FY[ZFJCTKFBK\QFHF.
D.[GZ[KF[NFFIPZFFFNM\K\CP[R\ZK"J24
FP\I[[ZJJRGNTKN,CKQFFRIKFFBNGFK\FK[ZFGFMGIFBNGFK[PDGNO
CPT[FFBPGRFNCKQFPBPWFBRG[K[NF\DCZG\TNPM[GNKFTGNOFHF
MBPXTKNFDKTBNFKTEFBNGFKFRMSU,\GBZCK\ZVKZGJTNKEKZK"J
CF[VT\’PEZD\FBEO’[NZ’KGSUKGHKNFGZCKWPRGCFZEGY25
.
CF[VT\FGZCKWIKNYZK"JCKQ[\KXGZG\[NTCGE\F’.FBI\FGNP\
B\PXCKF[DZFFZGIRKKO[BEOR\YNCFO,GF[RKKFP\BKPFNPXCK
IKZGO,NTK\G\PNIPF.M[O[C[T\PNIP\FTGNOFZB[GRFFBHZIKO
FYVKEGNF[\P[ZYCPINYFFZB[GRFCZMCG\,[MQHGFTRKYFNBEOFDRF
PVRKFRGSTKOFPVGYVYKO[RSTGCPINYG\FRPGMG\KG\Z,MLDOCTK\G\
~73|
24CKCNKGDZVKFRZIC\TNPIYZF’IGPZG\’PXGKFBXNCZBGQ)NTKNFTZF1(TP’124
FTZF.2
25\VKS\GFFNM\K\FPIPKZF[NZK"KFGZCKWRSYZFCKEKCZBGQ)NTKNFTZF1(,TP’
192=.205TGETNZK"KFGZCKWGTNP[R\GZBGE’BG[VKHBK,’P[R\GFIKRGMK\[NFZC
KGSUKGHNFGZCKW)’FSCBPRGCFZEGY’(TNVKSVZGPEZKD\FBEO’,TCGE\PGSPL,
BGRKCZSKJ\CZ=BKNQ\[P"J;E’M"W,\RGT\FPGSZ,E,KZG[NKO\[R"G,TP’
151=290;V’VKKD,’NPI[C\FIKRGLFRGCGFZGEGYBK\’,PMNGN,C)\[R"B(,TP’
47=64;B’ZGH,’CK\IGNKONIGNKR[PF’,BZWBIZ\,40)\[S"H(,66=.73TGEZBG:
D. E. Fishman, ‘Musar and Modernity: The Case of Novaredok’, ModernJudaism, 8 (1988), pp. 41-64.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 8: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
IKZGOZGIRKG\PQFZBGKNF[\P[CDK[F\GZRK\BEGYFKG\Z.HB\MPGCQ
MINYPQF\VKSF[FXDRGNTKN,[NVKFPGYEFIKKOFE\KKOBKRRGPXGK
EGGYBCPSGZ\FRXIK\,MKBOC\ZDGOFPG\BONXGZMKFHPQ[NF,\ZDGO
[KCJBB\FMPKFF[NTGCEKFBNNFP[KLCPBPXKFOGNF\DCZTN
PM[GNKOZGIRKKOMBNFGBIZKOCEZLBNKTEO:
MQRNPEPHFCT\[FGB[T\IKZGOCPXCF\GZFGFKZBFZIPRBNKXNQ,
GPGZBF[NPNMG\[PKOR\ZGVVF,PQFFMZIBHNTPGECZGIIHY
GBPKWGNB[ZGNYKKOB\MNECZK\GZ\KRGFYEG[FGB\YCN\RG[YCNRG
PBCG\KRGGMNPRFDKRG[RFDGBG\RGZCG\KRGFYEG[KO,FMNCPEZDF
FZB[GRF.GNGNBHFMNPXCF\GZFGFKZBFKFKFI"GPFGZS,GPQFRPRT
NFTPKEBG\F~...|26
.
ZK"JFTRKYNRGMBQBPKZFVZ[RK\PV\KTFCMRG\FTNFPFNLFBGZ\GEGYSK
[FRFKDG\NPKEKFI\OSGVZ27
.KXGKKQ[[KPG[MHFCP[R\RGCFZEGYFKRG
IZKDCM\CKZK"J,GEGGYBCK\FPEZ[[NFI\OSGVZFGBHF[FJCKTTNKG
B\IG\PG.NVKMLCZGZ[F[KPG[[NZK"JCBRNGDKF[NZK"KFGZCKWBKRG
PCJBHKYF\GMRK\TPGYF,BNBPFGGF\GXZ[NEZMGFBYNYJK\.
ZK"JFGEF[FEZLCFFGBGTPK\KGRFDGBKRRFFEZLFPYGZK\[N
FIKKOFE\KKO,MKBOPGENE\KFPG\BONPXCKIKZGO,GNVKMLFKBPCJB\
FYXRFE\K\)’PEZDFZB[GRF’(,IGPZ\K\Z,[RGTEFNCXZB\IGPG\FE\.
ZK"JBUBPZHB\PVGZ[G\CFP[LN[GRG:
GMPG[BRGZGBKO[FIGYKOGF\YRG\[NFPEKRG\[FKGPSVKYKOCT\
[FK’~F|FTGNOP\FNLCPFNMFFJCTK,NBFKGPSVKYKOCT\[VSYF
CFPFNMFFJCTKGPGMZIFK’NT[G\DEZKOGSKKDG\IHYG\PQFYXFBN
FYXF,MQK[NNPGED"M)=DOMQ(NT[G\CPXCFZGIRKK,MKCT\[NB
FK’FF\DCZG\FZTMNMLCPEFDEGNFGZYFK’PFNLCPFNLFJCTKFK’
PSVKYNQFDEZKOGFSKKDKO[DEZGNRGFZB[GRKO.BCNMT\CKPKRG,
CTGF"Z)=CTGGRG\KRGFZCKO(,[TNFFVGZWGVZWDEZKTGNOCTGNO
~74|
26JGCKDBN)NTKNFTZF4(,TP’.25
27TNPGENFFIPZF[NFI\"SEKCZGZCKO,GNMQRTKZZYNECZKG[NCZBGQ)NTKN
FTZF1(,TP’154=177,GCTKYZSCKCFTZG\98=103,GCPYGZG\FRGSVKO[FCKB[O.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 9: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
FKFEG\,GMGVZB\FMNGSG\ZB\FMN,BKQEKBORTPGETXPKRGGB\
E\RGCTPKEFCKRGRK\,ZYPQFFMZINFTPKEBG\FCZGIIHYGBPKW,
GN\YQB\FMN[KFK’~F|TGPECPEZDFFZB[GRFPQFYXFBNFYXF28
.
ZK"JFKFPGETNML[TKGQVGZPBNKCPSGZ\FFNMFPGCKNNPSYRG\[GRG\
PBNF[FDKTGBNKFQPRFKDKFBGZ\GEGYSKF.TOHB\,FGBFXFKZCZK[DNK
[FPGJKCXKF[NGNTZGLPGEKVKYXKFFNM\K\BKRRFRGCT\PVZ[RG\IE[F
[NFPYGZG\,BGBUPFMRS\[KYGNKOPJVKSKKOMBPXTKVZ[RG\NTZMKO
FVGZPBNKKO.N[GQBIZ,FGBNBZYPVZ[PIE[B\PYGZG\KG,BNBCGRF
YGPFIE[FTNDCOMB[ZFPRKTFPGXFZ[NGFGBFF\PGEEG\TOZGIG\
FHPQ.KJTQFJGTQ[IZUYKXGRKG\TPE\G[NZK"J,ECZKGBKRO\GVTF
IZKDFNDPZKCRGUFZCRKFBGZ\GEGYSK.NFNQRZBFMKXERKSIZK"JB\
ECZKGCBGVQIEGIE[RKTGEKG\Z.
CKJGKFNM\KRGSUN\GCRG\[ENKRGTEMFPXGKC\[GCFC[NFKFSVZ
’JGCKDBN’29
.HB\CKISNMNN[NF\NPGEFKZG[NPK:’MNFVJGZPQFECZ
GTG[FGRYZBFEKGJ’,30
GCB[ZN[BNFFBOZ[BKFBEONFIPKZTNTXPG
KG\ZPDEZKF\GZF.
ZK"JFXKCCSGDKFHGP[RFSEGZF,FPGXB\CFIPZFFFNM\K\XGZL
IKGRKCT\PXGYF,GNPT[FP[ZJJB\\VKS\FBGZ\GEGYSKFMIKEG[,
M[KRGKPQFPSGZ\FFNM\K\FPYGCN\.CRKDGENVZ[RG\FPYGCN\,NVKF
’FVJGZPQFECZGTG[FGRYZBFEKGJ’FKRGCKJGKDRBK,PSCKZZK"J[FMGGRF
FKBEGGYB[CI.FVJGZGTG[FRGFDCTXPGPRFDFEKGJ,MNGPZ,[VNGCN\K
PMGCE,[BKRRGPIMF[KXGGBG\G,BNBPMRKTTXPGMTCEGPIKKCTXPG
CIKGCKO[NBF\CY[TNKFO.
FZKENDCKYC"FXZKLNFKG\[VNGFEKGJ,GNBNFIHKYTXPGNPMGCE,
GPBQPGMIECBP\FGBMQ?EPHF[TGCEF[OCMNNCGGPYKKOPXG\KG
~75|
28[O.ZBGDO[G"\P[RF[MKZ,C,SKPQMC)~NTKNFTZF4|,TP’PB(,CKISNZBKF
PPKMNC\[BGNNTRKQ[KTZCBK[FTZGGF.
29SKPQKH)NTKNFTZF4(,TP’79=.83
30KZG[NPK,CZMG\C,I)FT"E~PFEGZ\FBYEPKFTP’24|(;KZG[NPK,[C\B,b)D
T"B~PFEGZ\FBYEPKFTP’368|(.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 10: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
TGEBKRGZBK’~F|EPIHKYTXPGRDE[K"\)=[PGK\CZL(N[VNGFEKGJ,
EPIGKKCFGBNYKKOPXG\F[O.BCNM[BRGZGBKO[TG[FGTGCEBU
CIRO,CNKXGZLGCNKIKGC,FZKHFZBK’CZGZF[PIHKYTXPGNFEKGJ,
GBKRGPEYEYCPT[KG,GTG[FBUCNKXGZL.GNDCKYC"FFGBPTNKG\B
DEGNFGK\KZ\B,GFPTNFFTNKGRF[KGMNNFKG\,B[ZMNFXEKYKO
P[\ENKONF[KDF31
.
NVKPGENHF[ZK"JPXKD,YKGOFPXGG\NVKYRFFPKEFFVGZPBNKBKRRG
PNPEECZTNPIGKCG\GFRV[K\FBPK\K\[NFBEO.FVZBYSKSFE\K
FPYGCNPEGZKEGZG\BKRRGPBV[ZFCT\TPEFDNGKF,BKRRGPCJBFHEFG\
BKEKBGNGDK\.CT\[NJ[JG[TZMKO,YGCTZK"J,IGCFTNFBEONPYOB\
TXPGCYXFFSVYJZGOFFNM\K,GNVTGNEYNZJKCK\RDEBGZIIKKO[NYKGO
PXGG\SJREZJK.PMGIECZKOBNFFSKYZK"J[’[VKZPG\ZNFIPKZ,
GBEZCB~...|FGBPEZDFDEGNF,GMQZBGKGRMGQNT[G\’32
.
I[KCG\PKGIE\K[NKKISNECZKO[M\CZK"JCFP[L,CKISNTZCF.
ZK"JFCKBB\FPEZ[FKEGTTNBGEG\FBKDGE[NBZCT\FPKRKOMPSPNB\
FIKCGZ[NBZCTFVNDKOCBGPFFK[ZBNK\33
.FTZCFFKB’RDEBEO
FFEKGJK,[BKQCGJTOGZKI’.PKG\ZNXKKQ[PEZ[HFPTGZZYG[KCKIS
NPEKRKG\FVKNGD[NFBGZ\GEGYSKFFFGRDZK\,[CKY[FNF\R\YPBNF
[RKTZGB\TXPOPQF\GZFGFPXGG\,GMQCKISNP[R\G[NZK"J,[FIHKYF
C\VKSF[NYGNYJKCE\KFP[\GYYN[NPG\ZGIRK\,\GLF\TNPG\PQ
FPK[GZ[NFDKCG[FNBGPK[NMGNVNDKFXKCGZFKFGEK34
.BGNOVZ[RG\G[N
ZK"J,IZUPDP\FFEZ[RK\,DKN\F[TCGZGNBEK[BKQMGNYG[KCFKCENG\
PBG\OINYKOCBGPF,BNB[FTZCFBUFKBPKKXD\EGGYBXEKYKODPGZKO:
FTZCFPIHKYTXPFNFEKGJGIGJB,GPYKKOCTXPFYZBE’GIJB\KRDEK
\PKE’,T"M)=TNMQ(TNF[NFBEGO,NFGZG\[RDETKRKFFIJBKO
~76|
31JGCKDBN,TP’.80
32[O.
33ZBGGKYZBZCFN,KC)PFEGZ\PZDNKG\TP’\[J=\[K(,GCPYCKNG\ZCG\CSVZG\
IH"NGFEZG[.
34EKGQRZICT\KENF\VZSOCTCGE\FEGYJGZ[NK,NTKNFTZF.1
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 11: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
[T[\F,GVKFINYNZPH[PPTJCECGZ,GBKRGMIW[IGJN[GRG,G[GPZ
TXPGPEKCGZKOFBKSGZKO,GFGBINYCNKVDO,[NBVDON[GRG.GTGPE
TNPKOZCKO,NZPHTNPYGFJFZFGTRGF~...|RPXBEMNTRKQFTZCF
FGBPZPHTNFCTN\[GCF~...|35
.
CFP[LBUPXBZK"JNRMGQNYCGT[PTN\FTZCFFKBHG[NP[FGBFZQ,
[’BIHGCRV[OPE\FTZCFNFKG\RI[CNVRKFYC"FGNVRKMNFBEO
NFEKGJ,GMPG[BPZG"’GBRIRGPF’"36
.
BDCYKEG[FFIPZFGFXC\FMPTNFNDKJKPK\GZXGKFCTKRKFCGZB,
VTNZK"JVTGN\FEZFEF=VYJG[NBNF[BKROTGPEKOCSJREZJKO
FZGIRKKOFNNG,GFXKC\PGZ\OB\CTNKF\[GCF)BOMBNF[[CGPEZL
[NZKIGYP\GZFGPXGG\,GBOMBNF[BIHG\PKECEZLF\GZF,BLIKKO
C\GET\\KYGQP\PE\(.CML[GC[NNZK"JPQFPPEFYKCGXK[NFBGPF
B\PTPEGF\KBGNGDKFKKIGEK,GFG\KZB\K[ZBNF’BPK\KKO’MYGNYJKC[N
TGCEKFBNCEZLFNM\K\PIPKZFGPIGE[\)MBPGZNTKN(.K\ZTNMQ,FGB
FTPKYB\F[YV\GTNBGEG\FFTXPFFNB=VGZPBNK\[NPPEKFFNMF
MVTGNFEYNZJKCK\[NFXJZVG\NBDGE\TGCEKFBNFBPK\KKO.
EGPRK[CMEKNF\GG\B\FNGDKYF[TGPE\CCSKSP[R\GFPIPKZF[N
ZK"JI[GCNF\CGRQCPGENF\GZRK[FXKCNVRKRG.[KNGC[N[RKDGZPKO,
GFOFSPMG\GFBIZKG\[CKEPRFKDKFEGZNF\GG\EZLIE[FNINGJKQ[N
FVZBYSKSFFNM\K,GCECCEFCFKNG\C[PKZFTNIGPG\F\GZF[PRKTF
B\FVGSYC\YGVFFPGEZRK\NF[\P[CSPMGKG\KGFPGVNDG\,FKB
[PTXC\B\P[R\G[NZK"J.
MGIF[NFIGPZFFGBCML[FKBPSVY\P[BCZGIRKIE[NT[KKF
FE\K\,B\MGIFRTGZKO[NFVGSYG[NFBGPF,B\FMGI[NKXKZ\
F\[\K\FZGIRK\FP\DCZ\TNFPTMCKO.FBEOFP[KOTXPGMFEKGJ,
MTZCF,FGBTGCEFBNFBPK\K,GBKQNEGZ[GNDRBK.
~77|
35JGCKDBN,TP’.81
36[O.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 12: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
NBEK[ZK"JNBF\ICJC[BNFFBOFFIPZFFKBVTGNFFNM\K\BG
FKVZ=FNM\K\,37
FBOFVSKYFFPIPKZFFKBINYPQFPBZDFFNM\K
FPSGZ\KBGNB,BNBFGBFXFKZCZK[DNK[FFIPZFBKRRFFFNMF
FPYGZK\.FGB\CTVTGN\FIPZFEKS=VZGVGZXKGRBNK\NPYGZF\GZRK,CMEK
NBV[ZNBEONFJCKTB\IG\PGTNFTGNOFFNM\K.PK[SKZCNNM\CEZL
HG,NVKZK"J,NBEK[NBYKE[TXPG,MKBOFGXKBTXPGPQFMNN.
TKGQPTPKYKG\ZCSGDKFIG[UVQRGSUCPFG\FIKZG\[NFVGSY.
MBPGZ,ZK"JCKY[NFEKZP\GLFYGNYJKCFKFGEKB\BNF[BKRORPRKOTO
PYKKPKFFNMFCXGZ\FFIE[F,FBGZ\GEGYSK\.CT[G\GHB\VTNZK"J
CXGZFBYJKCK\RDEF\VKSG\FNBGPKG\[FINGNF\TGZZC\GLFTGNO
FIZEKC[NFKFPBFF\[T-T[ZF.TEG\NPDPFHGPXGKFC\IKN\FSVZ
’JGCKDBN’,CBDZ\G[NZ’KG[KTCGYSCGKONZK"J,GCFDF\G[NZK"JTNKF:
GFEZ"DR"K)=GFEZ\DEGN\GRZGKBKZ(~...|FGMKIJTG\ZCKOPCRKEGZKRG
FIG[CKOGPMRKOTXPOC[OIZEKO,GP\ICZKOGP\GTEKOB\BK[KO
VGTNKBGQB[ZF[NKMGECZKZH"NBIZKDGGO~...|GKHCIGGKYJZGNVSN
’NBGPK’,NFYZBC[OKFGEKONBGPKKO.GCBP\FGMKISGVOTN\IKN\O
MKMNK[TOGIVXOGPDP\ONVZGYPTNKFOTGNECZKZH"N,GTGNF\GZF
GTGNFBPGRF,GFKJCB[ZEGCZFEZ"DR"KCSVZGFKYZMKCEGZFHF
XZKMKONF\BPWCK\Z[B\GK\ZTGHNIHYFBPGRF38
.
~78|
37FIGPZFFKHGPFPMGRFCKEKCZBGQ)NTKNFTZF1(IGPZF’FKVZ=FNM\K\’,MNGPZMHG
[BKRFRGCT\PQFPYGZG\FFNM\KKOCYZKBFVGZPBNK\,BNBFKB\GXZ[NZXGQ
FBEONF[K\TNTXPGFDCNFRGSV\,FPTGZZ\CYZCGZD[G\E\KKO[NF\YE[G\.
ZBG[OTP’130=.132BGNOCZBGQNBRDTC[BN\FPRKT[NFVGSYNEZGLCEZLHG,
FRGDE\NMBGZFB\PTPEGMPMZKTCKQXEEKSVYCGKMGIPGNPYGZG\SPMG\KKO,GFGB
PXBCFZY’PKE\ISKEG\’.BRGPPIK[KOCHB\MKXEN\VKS\ZK"J,CBPXTG\VTGNF
HGPD[KOFBEOB\BIEPKKTGEKGFE\KKOFR[DCKOCKG\Z,CPXKBG\[FKB\GXZ[N
ZXGQBNGFK,CFK[RGSIUSCKC\KIPGZGI[[NF\R\YPFEZLFFNM\K\[NFKFEG\.
TGEZBGCFY[ZHFK’BIKJGC,’TNTPKEG\G[NPG[DFFNMFMPBVKKQHFG\C[KI
FBGZ\GEGYSK’,K’[NPGQ,B’VZHKDZGB’ZCKXYK)TGZMKO(,BGZ\GEGYSKKFKFGEK\,KZG[NKO
\[S"G,TP’87=113,GCTKYZFTZF.1BIKJGCJGTQ[BIEPPBVKKRKFBGZ\GEGYSKFFGB
FTPE\FKFEG\TNFKSGEFFNM\K[CF,\GLHRKI\PBVKKRKOVGNYNGZKSJKKO
G\ZCG\KKOBIZKO,[FKGPPBVKKRKFHFG\FKFGEK\CJZOF\V[JFFBGZ\GEGYSKF.
CBGVQVZEGYSNK,PEDKOCVRKRGZK"JMKXEEGGYBFF\R\YG\PPGENFFNMF
FVGZPBNKSJKPHPQHFG\BGZ\GEGYSK\’JFGZF’KG\ZNJTPG.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 13: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
TNECZKOBNFFTKZZK"J)C[OZ’FNNPYGNGPKKB(:39
CTGF"Z)=CTGGRG\KRGFZCKO(BRGFDTRGNHPQFHF[BGKZFTGNOGPNGBF
PNBPKRG\GBVKYGZSK\~...|[YGEOCKB\FP[KIKFK’PNIP\DGDGPDGD,
FKKRGPNIP\FKZBKOGFM[ZKO[CK[ZBN,FPIHKYKOCBPGR\FBCG\
FYEG[KO,TOFPKRKOGFBVKYGZSKO[NGIKFS"BGIKKNG\KG,GPNIPFHG
KFK’FDEGNFGFMCEF[CTGNO,GC[TFFHB\KFK’XZNK[ZBNFM[ZPBE
~...|BCNPQF[PKOKTHZGB\FXEKYKONTPGECY[ZKPNIPF.
PMBQRGMNNFSKY[ZK"JZBFXGZLC[KPG[CMNKONB=VGZPBNKKON[O
TKXGCFFNMFPIE[,CMEKNBV[ZKXKZ\BKDGE[NTGCEKFBNFRBPRKO,
[KGCIRGFKJCPBNF[BKROPGMRKONF\IKKCNEZLFFNM\K\[FGBFXKT.
MNGPZ,CKEKFVGSYR\GRFIKZG\NF\GG\EZLIE[FP[NTXPG,BOGMB[Z
CBPXTG\FFGBPMGRQYGNYJKCZBGK[NTGCEKFBN.PMGISPMG\GIKZG\
BNFPBV[ZZK"JNVGSYNFYXKQB\TPEG\KGFFNM\KG\CPGET,GBUNFXFKZ
TNMLCDKNGKNC.PCIKR\GK[NFMKZCML[FVTZCKQFFGZBFFBNGFK\
FPYGZK\NPKPG[FFFNM\KDEGN,GMMN[FMZFHG\ININMQ\GED[F\ZGPF
FBRG[K\NPVTNFFNM\K.FPIGKKCG\[NFPGQFTONEZLFFNM\K\FIE[F
PCJB\B\BPGR\FIMPKO[NGGPBV[Z\NGNFKMNNCYGNYJKCFIE[.
E.IKZG\FVSKYFGPCIRKFF\BDEG\
CCGBRGNCIGQB\PFG\FIKZG\[RGJNZK"JNTXPGMVGSYGB\FPRKTKO[NG
NF[\P[CF,RK\QNB\ZPYGZG\BIEKOFPGZKOTNFYG[FXCTRGTNKG
YGEO,NBPGZ,BIZKG\O[NPRFKDKFZGI[NFBGPFFKBCZB[GCZB[GRFTN
FYGNYJKCFK[ZBNK.C[NMLPG\ZNFO,GBUIGCFTNKFO,NF[\P[
CMK[GZKFOFVZ[RKKO)GNVZYKOFEZ[RKKO(CMEKNF\GG\B\FEZLFFNM\K\
FZBGKF[NBGZFK\DC[FYGNYJKCFK[ZBNKCXGZFZBGKF.HB\BUBOFPGEN
FFNM\K[FOPXKTKOBKRRGIGVUNPYGZG\FVGZPBNKKO,CVTZPGETGCGNJ.
~79|
38TP’.4
39TP’4=.5
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 14: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
FPFNLFPRFKDG\KFHFCBTEMFNKEKCKJGKMPTJCNTEKCPDP\
FIPZF,[FKBBIEFPBVKKRKOFCGNJKO[NFICZFFBGZ\GEGYSK\.TO
HB\,CSGDKFBI\BRGPGXBKOB\ZK"JP\BPWPBPXKODEGNKONF\KZECZ
[KXBTNKGYGNNBGSZG,GBUTGPEMIGPFCXGZFRDEZCRKOFP\RDEKO
NFK\ZG.PEGCZCPYZF[N[PQ[IN[KRGKC\FNKLKKXGZG,GYPGPTZTZKO
TNKGNBGSZG.BPRO,EGGYBCSGDKFHGEGPF[NFY[Z[NF[BNF,GMQ
NBGGKZF[V[\FCXKCGZ[N[GPZKF\GZFGFPXGG\CTYCG\KF,RGETF
I[KCG\PCIKR\DGZPKFFK\Z.CH’CBC\ZX"J)23.7.1939(,[CGTG\
SVGZKONVRKVZGWPNIP\FTGNOF[RKKFGM[RFNBIZFYP\F[NFPP[NF
FVZG=RBXK\CSNGCYKF,R\CY[ZK"JNIGG\ET\GCKISNSGDKFXKCGZK\
Y[FHG40
.CBG\F\YGVFMCZFGZD[FPXGYFMNMNK\CXKCGZFZIC,GBKSGZG
[NF[PQT[GKFKFNDZGZ[\K\GXBG\CN\KZXGKG\,MVK[PTKETNKFQ
ZK"J:
FQRGET\K[BKHFZCRKOMCZPGMRKONBSGZB\F[PQ~...|B[Z
P[\P[KOCGFMNNK[ZBNPHFMPF,PVB\BKHFTZTGZ[KXBTNKF
PIE[,GDO[PT\K\NGR\CRKK[ZBN[PNKRKOTNFZCRKOTCGZHB\
[CBGNFIPKZTNKFO,GPFDOCT\XGYFHF,[MPTJMN\FMN[GPQ
M[ZMPGIPBFG[GPQBGGH\P[GYFK[ZBNK,GNBR[BZNFOZYVLYJQ
[N[PQ,GDOHB\ZXGNBSGZTNKFO.GMPG[[PT\KPVKKEKEK~...|
CTCZGC[GYFKFGEKOCVZ[CGZDVD[CGBIEPFBR[KPT[FGFISKEKO
[CVZ[CGZDGBPZNGCHF"N)=CHGFN[GQ(:41
’B\OFZCRKO,BKQNMOPF
NT[G\BNBNBSGZB\F[PQ[P[\P[KOCGMNMLFZCFHPQ,GNFMCKE
TNMNNK[ZBN’.
GDO[PT\KYGNG\[BPZG’GPKK[PTNFOGPFRBMNBODOB\HFKBSZG
TNKRG’,GFGBDHZF[ZGCFXCGZNBKGMNNTPGECGPFDOCXGYFT\MHF,
~80|
40PVND\FTOFSNGCYK\,PVNDFCTN\BGZKKRJXKFRBXK\PGCFY\,\I\FRFD\G[N
KGHUJKSG,[NJFFINPHPQFI\KPFTNFSMOPKRMQGSKVGIICNFSGEJKOCSNGCYKF
)[NFKSVJPCZ1938,\IKN\\[ZK\ZX"J(,GPPZW1939)BEZ\ZX"J(FVMF
SNGCYKFNZVGCNKYFTXPBK\)CPRG\YPX’MKF,[IENFNPT[FPNF\YKKO(,DZGZF[N
DZPRKFFRBXK\.
41FCB\KB\F\ZDGOPBKEK[NTCZK\,MPGCBCSVZ.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 15: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
GBEZCBTGEKCKBGB\FZCKONYNYGNBNFPZG\B\VKFO’,BNGECZK
\NGRG\O42
.
I\KZ\G[NZK"JNPXGBYGNB,GBUNTPGECVZW,BKRRFPV\KTF,M\GXBFPQ
FBIZKG\[BG\FI[MNVKFXKCGZFZIC,BIZKG\[F\IEEFTOF\YEZG\O
[N[PKBKZGVF,MVK[KCGBZNFNQ.BGNO,MPEGPRK[JKVGNGDK\BKQNT[G\
FCIRFCKQVSKYFPYNFHGNCKQP[R\GFPIPKZFTYZGRK\,MVK[F[\YVF
NTKN.N[\KFQPMRFP[G\UBIE:SPMG\G[NFVGSYNTXCB\FFNMF
NBGZQ[N\GVTG\CPXKBG\,GP\GLBIZKG\TPGYFNTPKEFCZUFZGIRK
[FBNPXKCNBEOGNYGNYJKCFK[ZBNK.
N[GQBIZ,PK[PGMQFKFNTXCB\FFNMFNVKPGEN’FPINYF
FZB[GRF’T[GKKFKF,CT\FXGZL,NTXCPGENFNM\K[N’PINYFBIZGRF’.
PNM\IKNFRGTEFFVSKYFFPIPKZFNIGNNVTGNF[\CKBB\FXKCGZFZIC
BNFKKTGEFZGIRKF\GZRKFY[FNF[DFCXGYFTK\KO,BLDONIGNNCYZCG
\GET\[KKMG\GRCENG\PQFBIZ[BKRRGPRFNBGZIIKKO\GZRK.DO’FGZE\’
FBGPFNPINYFFBIZGRF,FI\KZFN[PKZ\F\GZFC[MCG\ZICG\,BODO
CPIKZPSGKKO[NSJKKFPFVGZPNKSJKYFFFNM\K\,NDKJKPK\CTKRKG,GFKB
INYPBIZKG\O[NVGSYKFEGZ.HB\C[NFFMZF[FFYNFP[Z\\B\
FXKCGZFPCY[NYKKOBGZIIKKO\GZRKPEGYEY,BLTOHB\PCJBP\KIG\
DENFGFGNM\MNVKPRFKDKGFZGIRKKO[BKROPCKJKOBNPXGY\G.ZK"JI[[
[P\KI\FICNK\ZTNFPKEFTNGNFFKK\FNDZGZVKZGE[NFICKNF
FPBGDE\FKFGEK\,GPPKNB\VTNFFIPZFFFNM\K\CRKDGENZXKGRBN
[TGPECCSKSF.
F.KISG[NZK"JNPINNK[C\
NTKNFSCZRGB\V[ZFIZKDF[NZK"JPPGENFVSKYFFPIPKZFFZDKN
[NGNBGZF\PGEEG\GTOFXGZLNFDKCNPXGYG\FHPQ,HB\P\GLF\GETF
FPBDE\[FKBP[KP\O[NFFNMFG[NVGSYKFFNMF.BGNOSGDKFHGBKRRF
~81|
42P[RF[MKZKGZFETF,SKPRKOG=I)NTKNFTZF4(,TP’ZE=ZKC.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 16: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
BNBPCGBNBI\P[BNG\FNKCFFI[GCG\CKG\ZCP[R\GFFNM\K\,MPG
DOFZTKGRK\,[NZK"J,GFKBKISGNPINNK[C\43
.MPK[IGRLGVTNNBGZO
[NTZMKFBGZ\GEGYSKFFFGRDZK\FCENRK\,CKJBZK"JNBGZL[RKOBZGMG\
KISPRGMZGPCHFMNVKTGHCKFE\,TEMEKFMZHF[FOCPEZD\CFPF,
GPTPEOFGB’PTGG\B[ZNBKGMNN\YGQ’44
.TNZYTECZKOY[KOBNFVSY
ZK"J[K[NEGQMNBIEPFOMDGKNMNECZ,GCMNNHFBUNYGNBCTRKKQ
TKZGCKIXZG\)VSKYFYKXGRK\CKG\Z,RDEYCGXFZICFPBGE[NVGSYKO
BIZKO(:
FZKEFDBGRKOFNNG45
RYJGNECZV[GJEEGYBNFIPKZT[BGFGMDGK,
GNBNYGNB,BVKNGCEKRBETKZGC.GNVT"E)=GNVKTRKG\ET\K(C\GZF
EM\KCCFBP\,GZ[G\R\GRFNEZG[GNIYGZ,NBR[B\KVRKONZCG\KRG
FDBGRKOFR"N,GKZE\KNTGPYF[NFNMF,GZBK\K[K[NEGQCHFJGCB
)FZCF,K"F(,GNGPZENMNECZKGT[BGFGMDGKDCKTKZGC,DONYGNB
~...|46
.
~82|
43CFY[ZNRG[BHFZBGTCGE\GFZICFGFPYKVF[NB’VZHKDZ,A. S. Ferziger,Exclusion and Hierarchy: Orthodoxy, Nonobservance, and the Emergence of
Modern Jewish Identity, Philadelphia 2005.TGEZBGB’[DKBGX’HGFZ,PTDNK
HFG\KFGEK\CSVZG\FFNM\K\,\N=BCKC.2000CSVZO[NBNFFED[PG[OTN
PINNF[C\,GCTKYZCFY[Z[NBKSGZKS\OKKRG.TGEZBGE’FZJPQ,’SJKKFGDCGNG\
FSGCNRG\CFNMFFBGZ\GEGYSK\CT\FIE[F:TKGQCVSKY\O[NFI\OSGVZGFZC
P[FVKKR[JKKQGKISONSVZG\IH"NGNVGSYKKPKFCKRKKO’,TCGE\EGYJGZ,
FBGRKCZSKJFFTCZK\CKZG[NKO\[S"D.
44JGCKDBN)NTKNFTZF4(,TP’21=.22
45ZK"JPMGGQB\ECZKGMRDEZ’TYKCBBKDZGZ’TGHZM"W)PICZBCQFTGHZ(,[RKKO
PDEGNKFVGSYKOC\YGV\FBIZGRKO.
46[G"\P[RF[MKZ,B,SKPRKOJG=SJ)CZEKGC~NTKNFTZF4|,TP’.120K[HKYF
TPGYFCKQVSKY\G[NZK"JCSGDKFNYCKTG\KG[NPFZ"O[KY,FPGCT\C[G"\
PFZ"O[KY,PGRYBJ[\Z"P,BGZIIKKOSKPQZVB)GCPYGPG\RGSVKO(.DOPFZ"O
[KY,CTYCG\ZCGFI\OSGVZ,FTPKEB\EKRO[NPINNKF[C\CBGVQYZGCPBGE
NHF[NFDGK,GEBDNXPXOTEPBGEB\FDK[G\FPYNG\CTRKKQ.BGNOZK"JFGNLXTE
RGSUYEKPF,GPHFFHKFGKPGINJCKQFPGPZNDGK,BUCPIKZ[NYGNB.NPYGOHFNB
FDKTFTPE\G[NPFZ"O[KY.K\MQ[C[NMLNBFS\PLTNKGZK"J,IZUFTZM\G
FDEGNFNM\CKPFZ"O[KY.TN[KJ\G[NPFZ"O[KYCSGDKFZBG[DKBGHGFZ)NTKN
FTZF43(,TP’161=.169TNP[R\GMMNNZBGP’FKNESFKKPZ,’[BNG\G\[GCG\
PFZ"O[KY:FSVZ,MKRGSGGTZKM\G’,XVGRG\,C,)\["Q(,TP’VH=XF.
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 17: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
VSKYFHGVGZSPFC[R\1924,CMZLFZB[GQ[NF[G"\[NG.KXGKKQ[ZK"J
FMKZB\\[GC\GFPVGZSP\[NFZCKTYCTJNKRDZ47
TNBGEG\PTPEO
FCTKK\K[NPINNKF[C\CHPQFHF,GTNML[K[N[GVJOM\KRGYG\
[R[CG,48
HB\C[NFTGCEF[ZCKOPFOIGRMGCEZL[P\RMZ\PKSGEF
N\GZFGNPXGG\,GNMQBKQNF\KKISBNKFOMBNPK[[RGGVKZ[G.NPZG\HB\
NBFKFZK"JPGMQNF\I[CCTPEFHGCCGBGNFMZKTFNM\K\49
.HB\,
NJTPK,C[NFPIGKCG\FTPGYF[I[N[KPGZIGPG\KF[NFBGZ\GEGYSKF
GNFIN\TYZGQ’FPINYFFZB[GRF’TNTGNOFFNMF,BUCPIKZ[NFEZ\
INYKOZICKOPTOK[ZBNPHFG\OFKFGEK\[TGERG\ZFCYZCO.
PRDE,C[R\\ZX"C)KRGBZ1932(VKZSOZK"J50
\[GCF[RG[B\BGVK
FVGLNDPZK,GCFF\KZNMGFQPINN[C\NTNG\GNCZLCCK\FMRS\,HB\
CRKDGENVSKYF[NMPFGMPFPDEGNKFVGSYKO:51
~...|TNMQCGEBKBKQNPRGTBG\OPR[KB\MVKO~...|GBOMKFZCC["T
H"NM\CETNMQPINN[C\NBK[BMVKGP[GOEFGBRMZKNMNECZ,
KTGKKQC["TBF"TSK’P"E)STK’J(,EFGBMK[ZBNDPGZNMNEKRK
YKEG[KQ,GTKKQ[OCCK\[PGBNS"YK"D,[M\CEBT"DET[BGONDGK
FKKRGNIGPZB,BCNNBNYGNB~...|GBOMQMKGQENIGPZBFGBMK[ZBN
DPGZ,CGEBKRVYBPKRFJGCBNKET[FGBMFQ,GBORFKFPGRTKOBG\G
PNK[BMVKG,JGCBK[NIG[[K[\MIPPRG[FGBMFQ,GKXB\YNF
DEGNFPHFNGGNHZTGBIZKG~...|BVKNGNM\IKNFK[NXGG\NGNTNG\
NEGMQ,GEG"Y.
~83|
47[G"\CRKQXKGQFIE[G\,)NTKNFTZF14(,SKPQMD.
48\[GC\G[NFZCTJNKRDZRM\CFC[R\\ZM"B,GCZB[FRM\CPVGZ[G\[PEGCZ
CVSYKO[RGDTKONFNMF,GNBNPT[F.TN\[GCFHGGTNF[NMG\KFFMCKZG\CECZ
FKISNTGHCKF\GZFCPBFF\[T-T[ZFZBG:B’VZHKDZ,’HFG\BGZ\GEGYSK\GPTPEO
[NKFGEKO[BKRO[GPZKFNMF:TKGQPIGE[CDK[\G[NFZCKTYCTJNKRDZ’,K’[NPGQ,
B’VZHKDZGB’ZCKXYK)TGZMKO(,BGZ\GEGYSKKFKFGEK\,KZG[NKO\[S"G,TP’179=.209
ZBG[OFTZG\1,14G=18)HB\CRGSUNTCGE\G[NVZHKDZ,NTKNFTZF43(.
49ZBGP[RF[MKZ,B)CZEKGC~NTKNFTZF4|,TP’124(.
50P[RF[MKZ,C,SKPQNE)BGZIIKKO~NTKNFTZF4|TP’SF=SH(.
51[O,TP’SH.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 18: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
FVTZCKQF\[GCG\FNNGFTNF\PKFG\DOCYZCPYGZCKG[NZK"J.NEGDPF
FZCPZEMKZGJRCZD,DKSG[NZK"J,VRFBNKGCBDZ\,52
FCKTVNKBFIPGZF,
GFTNFYG[KG\VGZPBNKG\ZCG\MRDE[KYGNKFVSKYFF\PGFKO[NZK"J.
TKYZJTR\GFKK\FTNFIKZG\[RJNNTXPGZK"J,BDCEIKK\MGN[KYGN
VGZPBNKSCKZ,P\GLSCZFCTN\ZYTBKEKBGNGDKCGNJ:
B\FFZBK\NET\[N[\FTPGEKOB[ZTNKFOTGNOFFNMFTGPE,
FVZ"I)=FVZKIE[(~...|GVP"D)=GVZKPDEKO(~...|GC["TF\RKB
)GC[NIQTZGLF\RKB(53
~...|MGNOP\RCBKOCSDRGQBIE,EFPINN[C\
CVZFSKBBKRGRG[BMVKG.
GPTM\"F)=GPTN\MCGE\GZ\GFZPF(EIFB\ECZKFOPFNMF,CBPZL
[BORPRTBG\GPNK[BB\MVKGK[NIG[JGCB[K[\MIPPRG
GPBIZKO[FGBMFQ,GKXB\YNFDEGNFPHFNGGNHZTGBIZKG~...|.
\PFBRKBKLTNFTNET\PTM\"F)=PTN\MCGE\GZ\GFYEG[F(
NEIG\CZBK’~F|YNG[FMHGB\ECZKFPBGZG\FDEGNKOB[ZNBGZORST
GRNL,GFDTTXPLNVKECZKL~...|54
.
RSKGRG\KG[NFZCZGJRCZDNF[KCTNPFNMKGFFNM\KKO[NZK"JCBGVQ
VGZPBNKREGRGNMK[NGQ,[MQZK"JTXPG,MVKFCIR\GFRMGRF[NFZC
ZGJRCZD,CIZNFCKJFXKEFGNBNF\I[CCPYGZG\GC[KYGNKOBNF,NRGMI
SCZ\GFFDKGRK\,FPJF=FNM\K\GFBKEKBGNGDK\.BKRRKPCY[NZPGH[ZK"J
F\TNOPPYGZG\FFNMF,NBMQ!ZK"JZBFNRDETKRKG[KYGNKOZICKO
CCGBGNVSGYFNMF,GRYJCTPEFPYNFGCTPEFPIPKZFNBCFMZIPMGI
[KYGNKOVGZPBNKKO,MKBOP[KYGNKOBKEKBGNGDKKOGP\GLFMZFC\VYKEG
MVGSY[BIZBKTNCKXGZFYGNYJKCBG\GFGBP[Z\55
.FEZLFRMGRFNCIGQ
~84|
52’MFQFPINN[C\BOK[BB\MVKG’,PGZKF,SI,J=K)\[P"C(,TP’NF=PC.
53SVZGFFNM\KFRGET[NZ’[RKBGZHNPQPNKBEK,PKKSEISKEG\NKGCBCKJ[,GPICZ
SVZF\RKB.
54TP’NF=NG.
55CFY[ZHFZBGKNXKKQN[\KTPEG\PRGDEG\NDPZK,BLYZGCG\PBGEHGNHGPCIKR\
F\RDEG\QN\VKSF[PCJBZK"J,CECZKO[FCBRGP[PGTEMF.Z"BCY[K=EGZGQ,
’SKKT\BE[PKB:TN[KYGNFET\CFMZT\FFNMF’,I’TPK\,B’FMFQGI’CBZ
)TGZMKO(,PRIFNPRIO,\NBCKC\[S"I,TP’153=158,SGCZ[MGNFMZTF[NVGSY
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 19: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
B\[\KVSKYG\KG[NZK"JBKRRFNFXKDQMSG\ZG\HGB\HG)FDO[CZK
[PSYR\FECZKO[GRFPQFYXFBNFYXF(,MKBONJTGQ[FRTNO[F[\RF
CKQYCKT\FRGSIFF[GNN\B\KFEG\G[NPINNF[C\NHG[PYZC\BG\G
N\GLXKCGZFP\VNNKOFGBHFG\G[NFYGNYJKCBG\GP[Z\ZK"J.
N[OFCR\FVTZFYKXGRKCKQFNMKFZGI[NVSKYG\BNGK[NFS\KKT
CBDZ\I[GCF[XGZVFNKGPRG[NZK"J56
.FBDZ\,FP\GBZM\NRKSQ\ZX"D
)BVZKN1933(,P\BZ\B\CY[\G[NZK"JPB\KEKEG,ZCCTKKZFFGRDZK\,
NBZDQNZK"JBV[ZG\NEZG[TNBGEG\IKHGYPXGG\F\VKNKQCVRKYFKNF
RKBGNGDK\.ZK"JFTKECPM\C[CKGRK1931EKCZCBG\GBHGZCXGZFPBGENB
PMCE\MNVKTGHCKF\GZF,G[MT\FGBPCY[N\YQB\EZMKG:
GBNKI[GCMKBECZY[FMPGCVTOZB[GQ[ECZ\KECZKIKZGVKO,
R[CTBRKNG[MNEKCGZKKFKGPBFCF~...|GBEZCBBCY[BNUPIKNG\
TNB[ZVDT\KBHCMCGEO,GMT\BTKETNKB\F[K"\)=F[OK\CZL(,
[ZYPBFCF{[CBP\BRKBGFCMNK[ZBN,BVKNGBOCNKKEKT\GTCZ
TNMNF\GZFMGNF,FGBBIBFGCNK,MKDOFGBPHZTBCZFO,KXIY
GKTYC57
.
~85|
MNNBKRRFP[NG,MKBOFKB\GXZ[NFSKT\BE[PKB,FRGMIG\FBNGFK\FIGVV\
TNKG.FFCENKOCKQVSKYG\[NVGSYKO[GRKORGCTKOPFCENKFBK[KG\[NFO,GNVKML
PF[ZBFBNGFK\[GRF,GFZK’BNGGBNGECZKBNFKOIKKO’,BGNOPMGNPYGOFFMZTF
FFNM\K\BKRRFBNBVTGNFBNGFK\C[GZ[F.PRDE,B’DZKRGGNE,’BNGBEOCP[VJ
FTCZK:FFKCJFVKNGSGVKGF[NMG\KGFPT[KG\:PS\V\KIFNEKGQ’,PETKFKFEG\,43
)\[S"F=\[S"G(,TP’201=225,JGTQ[\MNK\G[NMGNPT[FFVSKYFFFNM\KFGB
NFIEKZB\F[NKJFFBNGFK\C\GLPMPRKFPXKBG\.MNGPZ,FFGZBG\FFNM\KG\TN
VKEZMF[N\GZF)ECZKGRBPZGCTKYZCFY[ZP[VJK(PMRKSG\B\FBNMDGZO
PXGGF,BGMUGPCXT[NFFGZBG\FBNGFKG\.PYGPO[NCRKFBEOCPFNLFHFFGB
\KGGMKCBGVKG,GCRKFBEOPBV[ZKOB\FEKRPKG\[NECZFBN.[\KFFCRG\FNNG
PPTJG\B\PYGPGFPFG\K[NFVGSYCPT[FFVSKYFFFNM\KGPG\KZG\BG\G
M[IYQP[RF.ZK"J,PRDE,PG\KZB\FPT[FFBNGFKTNMRG,MPGZFZB[GRK,MPEZKL
GPXGGF[NFEKQCTKYZGGC[GZ[G,BLPGXBCPT[FFBRG[K[NFFEZMFFFNM\K\
FNMFNPT[FMNKCKJGKTPGYNVGSY,GNPT[FNBGPFMGNF,GBPXTKNT[KKFE\K\
RTNF,[FKB,CPKEFZCF,\MNK\F[NFTCGEFFE\K\.
56BPGRFXZGVFCMGZF[GBF,INYC,)KG"NT"KCRGI’P’JKKMJBN(KZG[NKO\["S,TP’
YKH=YN.
57TP’YMI=YMJ.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 20: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
FDKNGKFPZD[[CECZKOPTKENNBSVYTN\PGZFZTKGRK\TPGYFBG\F
IGGF,NRGMIFIZEFPVRKDGZNG[NFTONEGZG\KG.MLM\CCFP[LECZKG
[O:58
BCNMT\[F[TFEIGYFPMNXENMNNK[ZBNCMNPYGPG\PG[CG\KFO,
CTGGRG\RGFZCKO,TGEDCZFTNKHZOFPI[CG\NFGXKBPI[C\KBN
FVGTN,CECZFRGDTNJGC\CK\K[ZBN,MKFHPQDZPBNFKG\NKNFGTKN
~...|.GCTKRKFECZCZGZMKPF[RT[FIP\FPXKYCB[MRHTNK[ZBN,59
FGBZYNTGZZB\K[ZBNP\ZEP\O,NZBG\[BL[YZRINGNFO
FZTVBPTZGFPBETZRTHKZGRD~...|GMT\[NCG\CRKBEOFK[ZBNKRMRTG
GR\ZMMGPMIXZG\FEGZ,GPMI[PGTG\FPCFKNG\B[ZR[PTGPPEKR\
B[MRH,PF[TG[KO[OTOBIKRGCRK=K[ZBN,F’KZIO,GPKKGETPFKGNE
KGO,MKFPEKRG\P[GC[G\CDKKSG\FBNFCMNB\ZGB\Z.
BGPRODOMBQZBFZK"JXGZLTPGYNPIG\MRDE\GVT\FZVGZPF
GFRKBGNGDKF,GMRDE\GVTG\BIZG\[RDZPG,NJTR\G,CKEKFPGEZRKHXKF.
PPIBG\BNFFS\KKDYPTFCFP[LEZMG.BGNOPIB\GP[YV\NNBSVYB\
TPEG\KGFPSGZ\KG\,CECCETOZXGRGFTPGYNFKPRTPPKPG[PGINJ[N
\VKSG\TGNPG,MFMZTFTZMK\CTEBIEG\K[ZBN.ZK"JSCZ[TKYZFRJN
GFEBDFNPXCFBGPFPGJNTNM\VKPRFKDKFEGZFFNM\KKOGFFDG\KKO,
~86|
58TP’YKH=YMC.
59CCIKZG\[RTZMGCDZPRKFCSVJPCZ1930HMGFRBXKOCMIPK[K\PYGNG\FCGIZKO.
TGCEFHGFKB[DZPF,MMGNFRZBF,NSEYKOZB[GRKOC\VKS\G[NZK"J,BOMK
FFMZFFHGININFBXNGCP[LHPQPF.BGNOCZGZ[MINGUFHPQ,GTOFTNKKFCMGIO
[NCRKFTGGNF,FINZK"JNIG[CCFKNG\[FPXCPIKKC.F\CJBG\GFRZD[\CBVZKN
1933,MIGE[NBIZFCIKZG\FNB=EPGYZJKG\CDZPRKF,CFQHMGFRBXKOCRXIGQ
PGIW,GM[NG[FIGE[KONBIZTNKK\G[NFKJNZN[NJGQ,PCJB\KG\ZPMGNB\
PXGY\GFNBGPK\[NZK"J.CKJGKMGBCNRYGEFHGPDKTPECZKO[M\CZK"JC[GNK
\[GCG\FNM\KG\[FKGBPGZG\NF\VZSOC\ZX"J,C[G"\P[RF[MKZ,C,G[RPXBG
CM\CKEG)FPGCBFP\GL[G"\P[RF[MKZPFEGZ\\[S"I~NTKNFTZF4|,NNBXKGQ
TPGE(.CFTZFTN\[GCF[M\C)SKPQYXF(CKISNPINGY\CKQFI\"SNRXK"C
PGGNGH’KQTNBGEG\TGXP\FFFNM\K\[N\YR\KGOJGCTNFXNFPRKSKO)NET\
FI\"SPEKQ\GZF,GNRXK"CNBMQ(,MG\CZK"J:"FTNK\KNFNMFGNPT[F[CMNT\
[K[ZBNR\GRKOCXZFZ"N)=ZIPRBNKXNQ(,MPGT\F,F’KZIOCPFZF,CT\[RXB
PFXZFCTHF"K)=CTHZF’K\CZL(RFK’~F|PIGKKCKONGPZNVRKGK\"[)=K\CZL[PG(
[KZ\FKOPQF\GZF".
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
![Page 21: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
GFJKNTNXGGBZOB\FBIZKG\NMK[NGRG\C\IGOHF.CPSVZZC[NPYGPG\
FGMKIZK"JB\FPRFKDKOFNNGTNML[BGHN\KEOFGCKNFNFKEZEZG\
FZGIRK\CBGPF,G[ZYCMGIONPNJB\FBGPFPQFPKXZF\GET\K[CGFKB
R\GRF60
.HB\CFP[LN\VKS\GFRGDT\NBIZKG\OFFNM\K\,[XZKMF
NF[\YUCVSKY\O,GNCJBB\FPPEFNBGPK[CF)MT\RK\QNECZTNPPE
NBGPK,CTGENTKNFPKNFNBGOFKK\FPGYXK\PIP\PKBGSCTKRKZK"J,
GFDGZOFPBDEFCNTEKFKFF’PINYFFZB[GRF’FFNM\K\(61
.FP\CGRQCSVZ
’BOFCRKO[PIF’,62
GCTKYZCINYKGFBIZGRKO)VZYKO[NK[K=ZCKTK(KPXB
[PDP\GFNBGPK\[NZK"JFNMFGF\TXPFTOFHPQ,GNRGMIFPBGZTG\
FY[KO[VYEGB\FTOFKFGEK.BGNO,MVK[FZBK\K,B\\IKN\F[N
FPI[CFFNBGPK\,GB\\IKN\F[VT\FTNFNLFZGIFFNM\K[NZK"J,
RK\QNB\ZMCZC\IKN\[RG\F[NG[KO,TOTNKK\FRBXKHON[NJGQ
CDZPRKF.\GVTFHB\FXJZVFN[IKYFFP\PE\GFGNM\CMGIF[N
FBGZ\GEGYSKFCFGRDZKF.
[RKFDGZPKOFNNGICZGNTPE\GFTYZGRK\[NZK"J,[NVKFNPTQ
[KPGZFYGNYJKCFKFGEKFBG\RJKK[MGIZCCKEKVGSYKFFNMFGPRFKDK
FEGZ.MGIHFPBV[ZNFONYI\CI[CGQ[KYGNKOIGW=VGZPBNKKOCPT[F
VSKY\FFNMF,CRKDGENPSGZ\FVSKYFFPYGCN\PEGZG\.[NBMVGSYKO
BIZKO[F[\P[GCP\GEFEGPF,ZK"JNBCKY[NFJPKQB\PTGZCG\G
FBKEKBGNGDK\CPT[FFVSKYF,GFTNFBG\FTNRS.FGBZBFCFFKTRG\
NXGBNGFKNKJGNKGHPFGPRFKDG\TNT\KEF[NFBGPFGTNFY[ZFTPGY
[CKRFNCKQFCGZB,HB\MINYPQFPTZLFMGNN[NFMGIG\FBRG[KKO
~87|
60ZBGJGCKDBN,)NTKNFTZF4(,TP’8=10,16=18,CBDZ\TNF\VKNKQ)NTKNFTZF57(
TP’YMG;C’\ZTBHTKZB’)PCGBG[NZK"JNP[RF[MKZ,BGZIIKKO,C~NTKNFTZF
4|,TP’35FTZ\FPFEKZCMGMCK\[O(,GTGE.
61NZB[KVZYKOTNFDEZ\FNBGPKG\CP[RFFXKGRK\E\K\ZBGE’[GGZW,FXKGRG\
FE\K\:\GNEG\GVZYKBKEKBGNGDKF,\N=BCKC\[S"D,TP’11=20;P’FNKRDZ,’KIKE
GICZF,NBGOGBRG[G\’,B’[DKBGE’[GGZW)TGZMKO(,PBF[RG\XKGRG\E\K\,B,ZP\
DQ\[S"D,TP’97=142,GCTKYZTP’116=124;E’HGFZ,’FNBGPKG\GFXKGRG\CP[R\G
[NFZCIKKOFKZ[RHGQ’,[OTP’143=178,GCTKYZTP’143=.167TGEZBGE’[GGZW,
’P\BGNGDKFNBKEKBGNGDKF:SKDGNZTKGQFNBGPKG\CFDG\FXKGRK\E\K\’,BNVKKO,12
)\[R"G(,TP’240=267,GCPYGZG\FZCKO[FCKB.
62BOFCRKO[PIF,CGEBVTSJ\["D.
IKZG\FVSKYFGBIZKG\FVGSYCP[R\FZCK[[MZ[NPFJKMJN
![Page 22: R[PC WKCGY[ZF YIX - Cardozo Law · j"kz c[ zvsf ogszv zibn .j[vegcc kygi k\nc jknvm ffg[ gegtc.wkgg[gbn ing[g emnr o[ ,fkycgnsn g\skv\ \b zgysb ob km ,’fip[ okrcf ob’ zvsc ygstb](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022022105/5bdbe4f209d3f2e0298ce682/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
[BPGZKONFKG\PG[YTKOCY[ZBEO=BNGFKO.\VYKEO[NCRKFBEOFGB
NFSKZB\FPM[GNKOFPTMCKOCTEF\YEPG\OFZGIRK\,GFSZ\PM[GNKO
HGPIKKC\,NVZYKO,PTGZCG\VTKNFTEPBGE[NPRFKDG\FEGZCVZBYSKS
FE\K.
G.SKMGO
CTPGEKOFYGEPKOFCBRGMPFGMPFFTZG\CECZP[R\GFTKGRK\[NZK"J
PQF\YGVF[YEPFNPNIP\FTGNOF[RKKF.RK\QNYCGT[RYGE\FPVRF
C\VKS\GFQCKISNVGZ[KOPEZLF\GZFGFQCKISNMNNK[ZBNMYGNYJKC
[NTGCEKFBNRTGXFCTNKK\FRBXKHON[NJGQCDZPRKF,FINPQFCIKZG\
C[R\1932,GCK\Z[B\PT\FSMOPKRMQ,FVNK[FNICNFSGEJKOGFYP\F
[NZVGCNKYFCTN\BGZKKRJXKFRBXK\CSNGCYKFC=.1938BGPRO[KJ\G
FTYZGRK\[NZK"J,NVKFK[P[YNDEGNPBGEN\ZGP\GFBK[K\[NFVGSY
N\GZF,NVSKY\FFNMFGNEZMKFFRFDFFZXGKG\[NF,NBF[\R\F.FGB
PKP[BG\FTNKTEKOZGIRKKOGICZ\KKOBIZKO,GCMLCKJBTYCKG\
PZ[KPFCPGENKOFJKVGNGDKKOFFNM\KKO[BKPWNTXPG,BL\GL[KRGKKO
PZIKYKNM\CPKPG[F\GMRK[NPGENKOBNFTNSGDKG\[GRG\.HB\CF\BO
NRSKCG\FSGCCG\BG\GGCF\BONBGGKZFFZGIRK\[[Z\FTNKGCBG\GHPQ.
PJZ\FTN[NFVGSY,NVKZK"J,FKBNVTGNNMKRGQGNCKXGZFF\BDEG\
FKFGEK\MYGNYJKC[NTGCEKFBN.\IKNFDZS[FEZLFBGZ\GEGYSK\
FPEKZF\BV[ZHB\,GNKPKOCIZCPGENFNBGPKGNBFZNKDKGHKMBPXTK
FDRFTNFBGPF63
.TYZGRG\P[R\GPNPEKOVZYI[GCC\GNEG\VSKY\
FFNMFFBGZ\GEGYSK\GCCKYGZ\FVRKPK\[F\TGZZFC\GLTGNOHF64
.
~88|
KXIYFZ[YGCKW
63ZBGK’FZ[YGCKW,’VZ[RG\\KBGZDK\NECZKFZPC"O:ZMK[\\TGEG\FPZFCP[R\FZC
K[[MZ[NPFJKMJN’,FZPC"OCRCMKFSGE,ET\,64=66)\[S"J(,TP’323=.342
64NTKGQP[NKOTNBGEG\FP\I[CKQFIGYFM\GCNBKEKBGNGDKFFFNM\K\MVK[HG
RYNJ\TNKEKFVGSY,ZBG:H. Ben-Menahem, ‘Postscript: The JudicialProcess and the Nature of Jewish Law,’ N. S. Hecht, B.S. Jackson, S. M.Passamaneck, D. Piattelli and A.M Rabello (eds.), An Introduction to the
History and Sources of Jewish Law, New York 1996, pp. 421-438.