rules 41 42 and 45
TRANSCRIPT
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 1/20
ORDINARY APPEAL (RULE41)
PETITION FORREVIEW (RULE 42)
PETITION FORREVIEW ON
CERTIORARI, orAPPEAL BY
CERTIORARI
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 2/20
Application of Rule 41on Ordinary Appeal- Appeals from the
judgment or nal orderof the RTC in theexercise of its original
!ri"#i$%ion (calledOrdinary Appeal
!ote" #f a litigant losesin the $TC and % onappeal% loses in theRTC% the mode of appeal to the CA is &y'ay of a petition forreie' under Rule 4)%&ecause the decision of the RTC is one in theexercise of its appellate jurisdiction*
+hen to Appeal"- Within 15 days from
notice of the judgmentor nal order appealedfrom*
- +hen record on appealis re,uired Appellant shall le anotice of appeal and arecord on appeal within
Application of Rule4)- Applies to an
appeal from the judgment or nalorder of the RTCto the CA in casesdecided &y theformer in itsa&&'lla%'
!ri"#i$%ion
+hen to Appeal"
• Within 15 daysfrom notice of thedecision sought to&e reie'ed or of the denial of ./s$! or $R led indue time after judgment
• Court may grant
an add/l 10 daysproided theextension issought"
pon propermotion
.ayment of
the fullamount of the
Application of Rule 40- to the 2C"
o Appeal from a 35 of the
RTCo Only ,uestions of la'
are raisedinoledo 6ecided in the exercise
of its orig jurisdiction(p*789
o Appeal from 35R of theCA
o Raised only ,uestionsof la' distinctly setforth
o Certiorari under Rule 70: improper remedy; 'ill&e dismissed outright
o Appeal from 35R of2andigan&ayan
o Raised only ,uestionsof la' distinctly setforth
o Appeal from 6Rulingsof CTA <n =anc
o Appeals from 35 in apetition for a 'rit ofamparo to the 2C
o Appeals from 35 in a
petition for a 'rit ofha&eas data
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 3/20
30 days form notice of judgment or nal order
- >a&eas Corpus cases 'ithin 4? hours from
notice of judgment ornal order
>o' to Appeal"
• Appeal to the CA incases decided &y RTC inthe exercise of itsoriginal jurisdictiono Filing a notice of
appeal 'ith the
court 'hichrendered the judgmentnal orderappealed from
o Serving a copythereof upon theaderse party
• +ithin the period forta@ing appeal% theappellant shall pay tothe cler@% 'hich
rendered the judgmentor nal order appealedfrom% the full amount of the appellate court docket fee
doc@et andother la'fulfees depositfor costs
&efore theexpiration of thereglementaryperiod
!o further
shall &egranted<BC<.T forcompellingreason and in
no case toexceed 10days
>o' to Appeal"
• =y ling a eried.5R ' CA paying doc@et
and other la'fulfees depositing
.099 for costs
furnishing theRTC theaderse party 'a copy of thepetition
o 5or Amparo >a&eas6ata - ,uestion raisedneed not only &e,uestions of la' &ut
also ,uestions of fact%or &oth la' and fact
+hen to Appeal"o +ithin 10 days from
notice of the 35appealed from% OR
o +ithin 10 days fromnotice of the denial of$R or $! led in duetime
o
5or justia&le reasons%may &e extended%proided" pon proper
motion .ayment of the full
amount of thedoc@et and otherla'ful fees deposit for costs&efore theexpiration of the
reglementaryperiod
!o further shall &e
granted <BC<.T
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 4/20
o &y notice of appeal: deemed perfectedas to him upon theling of the notice
of appeal in duetime
o &y record on appeal
- deemed perfectedas to him 'ithrespect to thesu&ject matterthereof uponapproal of therecord on appealled in due time
• +ithin D9 days after the
perfection of all theappeals : the Cler@shall erify thecorrectness completeness of therecordso #f incomplete% to
ta@e such measuresto complete suchrecords
o certify to thecorrectness of therecords
o to transmit the
(.<R5<CT#O!
• 2hall &e led inthe proper form"
5ile 8 legi&lecopies%original to thecourt
2hall"
o 2tate thename of the parties%'ithoutimpleadingthe lo'er
courtsjudges either as. or R
o #ndicate thespecicmaterialdatessho'ingthat it 'asled ontime(material
data)o 2et forth a
statementof the
for compellingreason and in nocase to exceed 10days
>o' to Appeal" File a eried petition
' 2C 'ithinreglementary periodraising only ,uestionsof la'
ay to the cler@ of 2Cthe doc@et otherla'ful fees .099 forcosts
Su!mit the petition '
the proof of serice of acopy of petition on thelo'er court concernedand the aderse party(failure to comply"ground for dismissal
2C may deny on its
o'n initiatie% on theground that"
1 Appeal is 'omerit
) .rosecuted
manifestly fordelay
D Euestions raisedtherein are toounsu&stantial to
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 5/20
same to theappellate court% and
o furnish the parties
'ith copies of his
letter of transmittalof the records to theappellate court
• pon receiing theoriginal record onappeal theaccompanying docstransmitted &y thelo'er court% as 'ell asthe proof of payment of
the dic@et and otherla'ful fees% the clerk of "# shall docket thecase and notify the parties
• After 40 days fromreceipt of notice of thecler@% the appellant shall le a !rief with proof of service uponthe appellees
• +ithin 40 days from thereceipt of appellant/s&rief% the appellee shall
mattersinoled%issuesraised%
specication of errorsof fact orla' or &oth
o Accompanied &yclearlylegi&leduplicateoriginals of judgmentnal order of &oth lo'ercourts
2u&mit a
certicationunder oaththat he hasnotcommencedany otheractioninoling
same issuesin 2C% CA or inany othercourtso #f he
re,uireconsideration
o $ode of Appeal under
Rule 40 shall &eapplica&le to &oth ciiland criminal cases%<BC<.T in criminalcases 'here thepenalty imposed isdeath% reclusionperpetua or lifeimprisonment
.roisional Remedieso .etition under Rule 40
may include anapplication for a 'rit ofpreliminary injunctionor other proisionalremedies
o $ay see@ the same &yeried motion anytimeduring its pendency
!ot a $atter of Right-granted only 'hen special important reasons could
justify the petitiono <xample"o Court &elo' has
decided a ,uestion of su&stance not yet
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 6/20
le his own !rief with proof of service to theappellant
• +ithin )9 days
from receipt of the appellee/s&rief% theappellant may le a reply !rief answering points in theappellee$s!rief not covered in his
main !rief o <xtension of time fortheling of &riefs'ill !OT&eallo'ed%exceptfor good
suFcient causeand onlyif the
learnedthat asimilaraction has
&een ledor ispending :heunderta@esto promptlyinform thecourt 'ith0 daystherefrom
Failure to
comply to #%& ' ground for dismissal
CA nds thepatentlypetition 'omerit : maydismiss%prosecutedmerely fordelay or that
the ,uestionsraised are toounsu&stantialto re,uireconsideration
determined &y 2Co Court &elo' has
decided a ,uestion of su&stance in a 'ay that
is pro&a&ly not inaccord 'ith la' or jurisprudence
o Court &elo' departedfrom the accepted usual course of judicialproceedings
o <ery appeal to the 2Cis not a matter of right<BC<.T" death penaltyor reclusion perpetua
o <xamples of Euestions
of Ga'5act
5actual-#ssue =ar Ruleo 2C is not a trier of
facts% and unless thereare exceptingcircumstances% it doesnot routinely underta@ethe re-examination of the eidence presented
&y the contendingparties during the trialof the case
o 3urisdiction of the 2C incases &rought &efore it
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 7/20
motionforextension is led
&eforetheexpiration of the timesoughtto &eextended
o #n
petitions forcertiorari%prohi&ition%mandamus%,uo'arranto andha&eascorpus
cases%&riefsare notled
#n
#f CA does
not dismiss: mayre,uire R to
le acomment(not a *+('ithin 19days fromnotice
if CA ndsprima faciethat the lo'ercourtcommitted an
error of fact or law that 'ill'arrant areersal ormodication of the appealeddecision : maygie duecourts to thepetition
CA may set
the set for oral
argument orre,uire theparties tosu&mitmemorandas
from the CA is limitedto reie'ing reisingthe errors of la'
o 5indings of fact of CA%
'hen supported &ysu&stantial eidenceare conclusie and&inding on the partiesand are not reie'a&le&y the Court
o The Court has thepolicy of respecting thendings of facts of specialiHedadministratie agencies
o #t is only the errors of the CA% 'hich isreie'ed &y the 2C% notof those of the trialcourt% etc*
o The Court% instead of denying the appeal hasanother option : mayrefer the appeal to theCA for decision orappropriate action
+hen ,uestions of factmay &e passed uponin a Rule 40a The conclusion of
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 8/20
stead%
thepartiesshallletheirrespectie
memora
'ithin 10 daysfrom notice
Case deemed
su&mitted :
ling of thelast pleadingormemorandumre,uired
Residual 3urisdiction
- also applies to Rule4)
- RTC loses jurisdiction oerthe case uponperfection of theappeals led in duetime theexpiration of thetime to appeal of the other parties
- RTC% ho'eer%despite theperfection of theappeals% may still "
o to issue ordersfor theprotection andpreseration of the rights of
the CA is groundedentirely onspeculations%surmises and
conjectures& #nference made is
manifestlymista@en% a&surd orimpossi&le
c There is graea&use of discretion
d 3udgment is &asedonmisapprehension of facts
e 5indings of facts areconIicting
f CA% in ma@ing itsndings% 'ent&eyond the issuesof the case and thesame is contrary tothe admissions of &oth appellant appellee
g 5indings of fact of the CA are contrary
to those of the trialcourt
h 5indings of fact areconclusions 'ithoutcitation of specic
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 9/20
nda'
ithinanon-extendi&leperiodof D9da
ysfrom
the parties%'hich do notinole anymatter litigated
&y the appeal%o approe
compromise%o permit appeals
of indigentlitigants
o order execution
pending appealin accordance'ith 2ec* ) of Rule DJ
o
allo''ithdra'al of the appeal%proided thatthese are done&efore the CAgies duecourse to thepetition
2tay of 3udgment- The appeal
shall stay the judgmentnalorder % unlessthe CA% the la'or the rules
eidence on 'hichthey are &ased
i 5acts set forth inthe petition% as 'ell
as in the ./s mainand reply &riefs% arenot disputed &y theR
j 5indings of fact of CA are premised onthe supposedeidence andcontradicted &y theeidence on record
K Court nd adiergence &et* Thendings of the !GRCand of the CA : Courtset aside the doctrinethat the ndings of specialiHedadministratieagencies should &erespected% andin,uired into the facts'hen the case 'asappealed to it
Rule 40 * Rule 70R!l' 4
A&&'al * C'r%iorari=ased only on ,uestions of la'
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 10/20
receipt
of thenoticeissued&ythecler@thatall
theeid
shall proideother'ise
<B.!" ciil
cases decided
under theRules on2ummary.rocedure
$ode of appeal
#noles reie' of 35 of CA% 2=% CTA% RTCor other courts on the merits
5iled 'ithin 10 days from notice of 35appealed from
2tays the 3O appealed from
The appellant and the appellee are theoriginal parties to the action% and the lo'er
court or ,uasi-judicial agency is notimpleaded
$otion for reconsideration is not re,uired
The court is in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction and po'er of reie'
5iled 'ith the 2C*
+hen Rule 70 is treated asRule 40"
1 .etition has &een led'ithin the 10-day
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 11/20
ence
sarealreadyattachedtotherecord
Euestions that may
&e raised on appeal"• +hile Rule 44
proides thatthe appellantmay include in
period reglementaryperiod
) .u&lic 'elfare theadancement of pu&lic
policy dictate suchtreatment
D +rits issued 'ere nulland oid
4 =roader interests of justice re,uire suchtreatment
0 Euestion decisionorderamounts to anoppressie exercise of judicial authority
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 12/20
his assignmentof error any,uestion of la' or fact
that has &eenraised in thecourt &elo'and is 'ithinthe issuesframed &y theparties
o #n
appealfromthe ,*"to "#under ,ule -1should%.* raised pure/uestions of law!ecauseof Sec
of ,ule 50
• nder 2ec* )of Rule 09% anappeal under
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 13/20
Rule 41 ta@enform the RTCto CA raisingonly ,uestions
of la' shall &edismissed
o 2ssues
purely of lawnot !eingreviewa!le !y saidcourt
Residual 3urisdiction
• Term refers to
the authorityof a trial court"
o to issueordersfor theprotection andpreseration of
therights of theparties%'hich
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 14/20
do notinoleanymatter
litigated&y theappeal%
o approecompromise%
o permit
appealsof indigentlitigants
o orderexecutionpendingappealinaccordance 'ith2ec* )of RuleDJ
o allo'
'ithdra'al of theappeal%proide
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 15/20
d thosearedoneprior to
thetransmittal of"
th
eoriginalrecordortherecordona
ppeal%
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 16/20
or e
e
nif theappealshaealready&een
perfecte
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 17/20
dorde
spitetheapproalof
therecordonapp
eal%or
i
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 18/20
ncas
eof apetitionforrei
e'underRule)4
&ef oreth
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 19/20
eCAgi
esduecourseto
thispetition
o thisconceptisaaila&l
e at astage in'hichthecourt is
7/23/2019 Rules 41 42 and 45
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rules-41-42-and-45 20/20
normallydeemedto hae
lost jurisdiction oerthecasesu&jectmatterinoledin theappeal
o noresidual
jurisdiction tospea@ of 'herenoappealpetitionhaseenled