s. suckewer et al- recent progress in soft x-ray laser development at princeton
TRANSCRIPT
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 1/8
JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE,
Colloque C6, supplement au na 10, Tome 47, octobre 1986
R EC EN T P R O G R ES S I N S O F T X-RAY LASER DEVELOPMENT AT PRINCETON
S. SUCKEWER, C.H. SKINNER, D. KIM, E. VALEO, D. VOORHEES and
A. WOUTERS
Plasma Physics Laboratory, Princeton University, princeton,
NJ 08544, U.S.A.
Abstract - Recent advances in research on soft X-ray lasers at Princeton are
described. A one-dimensional code has been constructed which is in good agreement
with the measured radial dependence of soft X-ray gain at 182 A in a magnetically
confined recombining plasma. Multichannel detectors have been installed in the
diagnostic spectrometers and spectra of the line emission in axial and transverse
directions are presented. Initial measurements of the relative divergence and, very
recently, absolute divergence measurements of the axial 182 beam have been made by
scanning the axial spectrometer across the beam.The absolute divergence was measured
to be in the range 5-10 mrad, depending on experimental conditions and the maximum
power of soft X-ray beam was 100 kW. Finally, a new two laser approach to create
gain at wavelengths below 100 A is briefly described.
I. INTRODUCTION
Progress in the development of soft X-ray lasers has been recently reported
by several 1aboratories.l At Princeton, an approach hased on a magnetically
confined recombining plasma column, cooled by radiation losses, has generated
amplification of stimulated emission of a 100 (a one pass gain length of
kll%6.5) .2 In this experiment a commercially available 1 kJ TEA COg laser
(duration 8n nsec, maximum gain was obtained at an energy 300 J) was incident
on a carbon disc target in a strong (90 kG) magnetic field. Rapid recomhination,after the laser pulse, created a population inversion between levels 3 and
2 in hydrogen-like carbon, (cvI). Installation of a soft X-ray mirror3 in
a double pass arrangement provided an additional demonstration of the
amplification of stimulated emission. With a measured normal incidence
reflectivity of 12% at 182 1, a 120% increase in axial stimulated emission
was ob~erved.~n work with axially oriented, thick (35~) arbon fiber targets
coated with a t&in layer of aluminum, gains of up to 6 cm-l were also generated
on the CVI 182 A transition4.
In this article, we will focus on recent progress in the theoretical
interpretation of our earlier results, measuremepts of the relatively small
divergence of the soft X-ray laser beam at 182 A with power %I00 kW, and on
the development of a system (two-laser approach) for the study of conditions
for lasing action significantly below In0 8.
11. COMPARISON OF GAIN MEASUREMENTS WITA A ONE DIMENSIONAL MODEL
A key element in the achievement of relatively large amplification of
stimulated emission was the realization, from measurements of the radial profiles
of the CVI line radiation, that the most favorable conditions for maximum gain
Article published online by EDP Sciences and available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/jphyscol:1986603
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 2/8
JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE
should exist in the off-axis regions of the plasma column. Gain was measured
hy recording the amplification (enhancement), E, of the axial CVI 182 k emission;
that is the ratio of the 182 stimulated plus spontaneous emission in the
axial direction to the mostly spontaneous 182 tf emission in the transverse
direction. The enhancement is related to the one pass gain, G, by:
By varying the position of the laser focus on the carbon disc target with resDect
to the observation volume of the axial and transverse monochromators it was
possible to measure the gain as a function of radius r in the plasma column.
The results of one such scan were presented earlier.5 Although in that experiment
the C 0 2 laser energy was not optimal, there was a rapid rise of the enhancement
in the region r = 1.5 to 2.5 mm off axis. Further experiments2 with optimal.
plasma conditions led to measurements of an amplification of E %l00 near
r = 1.3 mm.
A one-dimensional hydrodynamic plus atomic physics model has been developed
to aid understanding these result^.^ In this model a single mean flow velocity
was used to describe the ion mass motion. After solution of time-dependent
equations for the ion density, momentum and electron energy, the gain was
calculated by a post processor code from the electron density and temperature
and the number density of the ground state populations of fully stripped and
hydrogen like carbon. Because the laser pulse length is longer than the
compressional Alfven transit time, radial pressure balance is quickly established
in the plasma. Strong heating on the cylindrical axis of symmetry (at the
laser focus) leads to a centrally peaked temperature profile with a corresponding
electron density minimum. On the other hand, off axis, strong radiative cooling
by CIV leads to low temperature, high density conditions conducive to a fast
recombination rate and high 182 gain. With the introduction of an ion
diffusion rate an order of magnitude greater than the classical value, totally
stripped ions were transported from the center to the cold off axis region
where fast recombinati.on generated high gain.
Fig. 1
PLASM A RADIUS (mm)
7;-_r
.zw
I
Radial profiles of CVI 182 % gain, k,,,,, and electron temperature, Te,versus radius in the plasma column as predicted by a lD code.
Figure I shows the predicted gain versus radius and it can be seen that
high gain occurs in a narrow %50-100p wide annulus at a radius of 1.4 mm.
This is in excellent agreement with the experimental results.
OO 0.5 1.0 1.50
2.0 2.5
-5
2 0 0 FaW[L
3
+[L
2- t o o 2
\ Corbon disc 8.\
\
- y~~t Time Of
\ kmox
\-- f' kmox\\
-- \
\ -
r\ Mognetic Fie ld
Radiatio n Cooling 8.
Diffusion -
Diffusion
CoefficientD = 2 . 5 ~ 1 ~ ~ c m ~ / s e c
- '\\
\\
I I -
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 3/8
111. AXIAL AND TRANSVERSE EMISSION SPECTRA
Recently, multichannel detectors, based on microchannel/reticon arrays,
were installed in the axial and transverse soft X-ray spectrometers. These
oermit the recording of emission spectra in the axial and transverse directionsin a single laser shot. One example is shown in Fig. 2. In the transverse
spectrum, the spontaneous CVI 182 A emission is weak compared to the strongest
lineoin the spectrum, OVI 173 L. However in the axial direction, the stimulated
182 A emission dominates the spectrum.
Some exciting results ohtained very recently were made by scanning the~os it ion of the axial spectrometer in the transverse direction (perpendicularto the axis of the plasma column). The axial emissions are imaged by a grazing
incidence mirror onto the entrance slit of the axial spectrometer (see Ref.
2 for experimental arrangement). The mirror is constructed by bending a glass
strip therefore the optical quality of the system is not ideal. Hence a
transverse scan of the axial spectrometer gives information of the relative
divergence of the stimulatedo 182 A emission in comparison to non-lasing lines.
As shown in Fig. 3 the 182 A emission was so intense on axis that the detectorwas saturated whereas the CVI 186 ? and OVI 173 A lines remained weak with
a flat spatial profile.The axial spectra presented in Fig. 2 were ohtained at a position of the
spectrometer corresponding to x = 2 5 0 ~ n Fig. 3. This horizontal positionof spectrometer was established for all earlier measurements2 by alignment
of the system i.e. C02 laser focusing mirror, target slot, and the spectrometerentrance slit using a He-Ne laser beam. However, from Fig. 3 we can see that
maximum gain is near x = 200u with a corresponding amplification of 182 1radiation ahout factor of 5 larger than presented earlier2. The sensitivity
of axial instrument for the data of Fig. 3 was higher than in Fig. 2 in order
to measure intensity changes of the non-lasing lines.
0
Fig. 2 Transverse and axial spectra in the region near 182 A from a carhon
disc target with four carbon blades. The laser energy was 500 J.
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 4/8
JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE
To obtain information ahout the absolute divergence of the soft X-ray
laser beam, the grazing incidence bent mirror was removed. In its place a
1 mm wide and 10 mm high collimating slit was installed to block reflections
from the walls of the vacuum chamber. Figs. 4 and 5 show the result of a
shot-hy-shot horizontal scan of both the collimating slit and the axial softX-ray spectrometer. The principle of the experiment is presented schematically
on the right-hand side of Fig. 4, and on the left-hand side is shown the
intensity distribution of the CVI 182 1, CV 186 1, and OVI 173 lines for
a magnetic field R = 20 kG. For every shot the intensities of all three lines
were recorded simultaneously on the multichannel detector of the axial soft
X-ray spectrometer. One may see that the lasing line, CVI 182 W , is strongly
peaked on axis with a F W H M % ~ . ~m at distance 304 cm from plasma (target).
This corresponds to a horizontal divergence of the beam ofo%9 mrad. At the
same time the intensities of the non-lasing lines OVI 173 A and CV 186 % are
quite constant over the scan region %3 cm.
With increasing magnetic field (B = 35 kG and 50 kG) we observed further
narrowing of soft X-ray laser beam down to a 5 mrad (Fig. 5). This indicatesthat with a higher magnetic field maximum gain is created in a more narrow
plasma region (less than 50p transversely). Refraction of the 182 emissioni.n the plasma is negligible as the electron density (ne (L l ~ l ~ c m - ~ )s toolow and thus an estimate of the divergence of the stimulated emission in single
pass amplification can be obtained from ray tracing. With an annular width
of 50p as predicted by the one-dimensional code and a plasma length of 1 cm,
the angular range of rays that pass through the gain region is 10 mrad. With
a peak in the gain profile at a particular radius the divergence will be even
less and thus the 1D calculation provide a good understanding of the remarkably
low value of the measured divergence.
We also observe a slight shift of the peak intensity of the 182 1 radiation
at higher magnetic fields, which may be caused by a small tilt of the magnet
at high currents. Another interesting feature is the rise of the 182 8 line
intensity near the geometrical limits of scan indicated by open circles and
triangles in Fig. 5. The limits are determined by diameter of vacuum tubehetween the target and the soft X-ray spectrometer. In order to decrease the
effect of shot-to-shot line intensity fluctuations, the 182 % radiation was
normalized in Fig. 5 to OVI 173 8 line intensity (173 if line intensity was
quite uniform across the scanning distance, as can be seen in Fig. 4). Ourinitial interpretation was that this rising intensity of 182 k radiation near
the edges of the scan was due to diffraction effects on the edges of targetslot. However a more likely explanation may just be the reflection of the
182 1 radiation (grazing-incidence reflection) inside the vacuum tube. In
the future, we plan to reinstall the grazing-incidence mirror and relocatethe axial soft X-ray spectrometer with the entrance slit in the focal plane
of the bent mirror in order to measure the divergence of 182 if radiation inthe far-field.
Knowledge of divergence allowed us to estimate the total power of softX-ray beam 100 kW from measurements of the intensity of the 182 1 radiation
(a1-3 mJ) and pulse duratipn ($10-30 nsec).
IV. TWO LASER APPROACH TO X-RAY LASER DEVELOPMENT BELOW 100 HWe consider the lasing actiogs presently achieved by Livermore and Princeton
in the spectral region 100-200 A, to be the beginning of the rogd toward the
development of lasers in the more important spectral region -10 A. Therefore,
as a next step we are proceeding with a program for the development of soft
X-ray lasers at wavelengths below 100 i. We have begun constructing an
experiment in which a 1.5 kJ CO2 laser generates a highly ionized magnetically
confined plasma column in which a powerful (Id 1016 w/cm2) picosecond laserbeam will produce a population inversion and gain. The role of the C02 laseris to provide access to the high energy, short wavelength transitions of high
Z ions which are then excited by the picosecond laser via multi~hoton rocesses.
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 5/8
Scanning Axia lSpectrometer
EntranceS l i t
S l i t
3 0 4 c m
Plasma
Fig. 3 Transverse scan of CVI
182 1, CV 186 1, and
OVI 173 8 emission
showing a strong central
peak for the CVI 182 2stimulated emission.
In this figure, "Satur.indicates the level
above which the detector
is saturated. Intensi-
ties ahove this level
were obtained hy com-
paring the non-saturatedregion of the 182
spectral profiles.
Fig. 4 Absolute divergence
measurement: (31,9 mrad)
of the 182 A lasing
radiation for a magnetic
field B = 20 kG. For
comparison are shown
intensities of non-
lasing lineg OVI 173 1and CV 186 A, recorded
simultaneously with
182 8 line.
10 1 2 3 4 5
HORIZONTAL DISTANCE X (cm)
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 6/8
JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE
Fig. 5
Element
Fig. 6 Wavelength of the 4s24p45s2 - 4 ~ 2 4 ~ 5 5 sransition in the KrI iso-
electronic sequence (from Ref. 8) .
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 7/8
The feasibility of exciting either one subvalence electron or two valence
electrons of an ion through multiphoton processes7 was studied for the argonand krypton isoelectronic sequences excited by a powerful picosecond KrF*
(2480 i) 1aserb8 The excitation of two valence electrons (e.g. 4s24p45s2 state)
is especially attractive because of the faster progression to shorter wavelengthswith increasin2 change of the target ion. One potential lasing transition
would be 4 ~ ~ 4 ~s2 + 4 ~ ~ 4 ~ ~ 5 snd Hartee-Fock values of the wavelength scaling
of this transition in the Kr isoelectronic sequence are s h o q in Fig. 6 from
Ref. 8. The potential lasing wavelength for e.g. cd12+ is 89 A. An additionaladvantage with the higher ionization stages is that competing processes such
as photoionization or autoionization are reduced or eliminated. Multiphoton
excitation is also expected to significantly increase the population inversion
and gain at 182 W in the current experiment.
As shown in Fig. 7 , the new experimental system incorporates two lasers;
a 1.5 kJ COq laser to produce the ionized medium and a powerful picosecondlaser to generate the population inversion. The target is placed in a solenoidal
magnet which will radially confine the plasma and produce the long, thin geometry
suitable for laser action. Primary diagnostics will consist of multichannelsoft X-ray spectrometers and an X-ray streak camera.
The powerful picosecond laser is expected to generate a 1 J, Ips, 2480 ilaser pulse. The main oscillator is a YAG-laser pumped dye laser at 6470 1which amplified in a three stage dye amplifier producing an energy output of
a few mJ. This is then drequency doubled and mixed with the 1.06~ YAG-laser
to produce a 1 ps, 2480 A pulse with an energy of a few hundred IJJ. In the
final stage, two KrF* amplifiers increase the pulse energy to the joule level
with an (unfocussed) power in the terawatt range. Focussing by a suitablelens will produce intensities in excess of 1016 w/cm2 and in addition to short
wavelengths laser applications, will produce new insights into the interaction
of radiation with ions in a regime where the laser field is comparable to the
Coulomb field between the electrons and the nucleus.
TWO LASER APPROACH TO X-RAY LAS ER DE VEL OP MEN T# 8 5 X ' 5 q 3
SYSTEM DIAGRAM
Syst em D.A.S. D.A.S.
Acquisition
Fig. 7 Diagram of new experimental setup "Two-Laser Approach" to X-ray laser
development below 100 2.
8/3/2019 S. Suckewer et al- Recent Progress in Soft X-Ray Laser Development at Princeton
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/s-suckewer-et-al-recent-progress-in-soft-x-ray-laser-development-at-princeton 8/8
JOURNAL DE PHYSIQUE
We would like to acknowledge support and encouragement from H. Furth and
J.R. Thompson; assistance with the analysis of the multiphoton excitation scheme
by C.W. Clark, M.G. Littman, T.J. McIlrath, and R. Miles; significantcontributions by C. Keane, L. Meixler, C.H. Nam, J.L. Schwob, T. Srinivasan,
and W. Tighe; and technical assistance from L. Guttadora and J. Robinson.
This work was made possible by financial support by the U.S. Department
of Energy Basic Energy Sciences, Contract No. KC-05-01, and the U.S. Air Force
Office of Scientific Research, Contract No. AFOSR-86-0025.
See e.g. other papers in this Proceeding.
S. Suckewer, C.H. Skinner, H. Milchberg, C. Keane, and D. Voorhees,
Phys. Rev. Lett. 55, 1753 (1985).
T.W. Barbee, Jr., S. Mrowka, and M.C. Hettrick, Appl. Opt. 6,83 (1985).H. Milchberg C.H. Skinner, S. Suckewer, and D. Voorhees, Appl. Phys.
Lett. 47, 1151 (1985).
S. ~uck&er, C.H. Skinner, H. Milchberg, C. Keane, and D, Voorhees, PPPL
Report 2207 (March 1985); also Proc. Int. Conf. "Laser 85", Las Vegas,
NA (~ec. 985).
E.J. Valeo, C. Keane, and R.M. Kulsrud, Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 30, 1600
(1985); also S. Suckewer et.al.; Proc. Int. Conf. "Laser 85", Las Vegas,
NA (Dec. 1985).
T.S. Luk, H. Pummer, K. Boyer, M. Shahadi, H. Egger, and C.K. Rhodes,
Phys. Rev. Lett., 2, 10 (1983).
C.W. Clark, M.G. Littman, R. Miles, T.J. McIlrath, C.H. Skinner, S.
Suckewer, and E. Valeo, J. Opt. Soc. Am. March 1986.