s ummary report · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 met 4.1 th sys pro nu be ap th 4.2 in sys tru ind th...

24
S Tr Su Pr Ap Pr Nco P of or Ex Th SUMMAR rust Board ubject repared by pproved by resented by ame of onsidered/ap Purpose: Th f care, as m rganisation. xecutive Su he paper provi Unadjusted figures for d There were to around 1 Community The Trust (SHMI) for is 107, the (March 201 Weekly mo 82.6% of de be ‘definitel had a NCE clinical care Quality of ca RY REPO meeting pproved by his report pr measured . mmary ides informatio mortality, risk deaths prior to e 2,065 deaths 72 deaths eac y Hospitals) giv performs with October 2013 Trust is ‘as ex 4 to February rtality review eaths reviewe ly not prevent POD grade of e, and 10.5% are was judge RT South Tee data to end Jo Raine, Deputy Dire Mr Richard Tony Robe Nag, Assoc Trust Board rovides ass by hospital on on: k adjusted mo o admission ar s in 150,049 s ch month in S ving an unadju hin the expec 3 – September xpected’ on th 2015) is ‘high continues with d were grade table’ with 2.6 f 1 (good prac % were graded ed to be Excel es Hospitals d of Quarte Data Analys ector (Clinica Wight, Medi erts, Deputy ciate Medical d urance on t mortality, ortality (SHMI re also reporte spells in the 1 outh Tees (at usted mortality cted range fo r 2014 (103). his measure, her than expec h over a thou d as ‘Expecte 6% showing s ctice). 3.2% w d as showing lent or Good i D s NHS Foun er 4 2014/20 st Clinical E al Effectivene ical Director Director (Cli l Director the overall q delivered b and HSMR), m ed. 2 months Apr James Cook y rate of 1.38% or the Summa For the period although the cted’. usand complet ed’, and 96.8% ome evidence were graded a g room for im n 92.6% of ca Date of meet ndation Trus 015 Effectiveness ess) nical Effectiv quality by the Dec App Info Ass mortality in ele ril 2014 - Marc and Friarage % compared t ary Hospital-le d January to D HSMR for the ted since Octo % were judged e of preventab as showing ro mprovement in ases. Agend ting 30 June st Mortality s and Tony veness) and cision proval ormation surance ective admiss ch 2015 whic Hospitals and to a peer rate evel Mortality December 20 e latest availa ober 2013 (19 d on the Hoga bility. 82.6% oom for impro n organisation a Item 12 2015 Report: Roberts, Dr Sath ions. A&E h equates d including of 1.46%. y Indicator 14 HSMR ble period 90 in Q4). n scale to of deaths vement in n of care.

Upload: others

Post on 18-Jan-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

S

Tr

Su

Pr

Ap

Pr

Naco

Pofor

Ex

Th

SUMMAR

rust Board

ubject

repared by

pproved by

resented by

ame of onsidered/ap

Purpose: Thf care, as mrganisation.

xecutive Su

he paper provi

Unadjustedfigures for d

There wereto around 1CommunityThe Trust (SHMI) for is 107, the (March 201

Weekly mo82.6% of debe ‘definitelhad a NCEclinical careQuality of ca

RY REPO

meeting pproved by

his report prmeasured .

mmary

ides informatio

mortality, riskdeaths prior to

e 2,065 deaths72 deaths eac

y Hospitals) givperforms withOctober 2013Trust is ‘as ex4 to February

rtality review eaths reviewely not preventPOD grade ofe, and 10.5%are was judge

RT

South Teedata to endJo Raine, Deputy Dire

Mr Richard

Tony RobeNag, Assoc

Trust Board

rovides assby hospital

on on:

k adjusted moo admission ar

s in 150,049 sch month in Sving an unadjuhin the expec3 – Septemberxpected’ on th2015) is ‘high

continues withd were gradetable’ with 2.6f 1 (good prac

% were gradeded to be Excel

es Hospitalsd of QuarteData Analysector (Clinica

Wight, Medi

erts, Deputy ciate Medical

d

urance on t mortality,

ortality (SHMI re also reporte

spells in the 1outh Tees (at usted mortalitycted range for 2014 (103). his measure, her than expec

h over a thoud as ‘Expecte

6% showing sctice). 3.2% wd as showinglent or Good i

D

s NHS Founer 4 2014/20st Clinical Eal Effectivene

ical Director

Director (Clil Director

the overall qdelivered b

and HSMR), med.

2 months AprJames Cook

y rate of 1.38%or the Summa

For the periodalthough the cted’.

usand completed’, and 96.8%ome evidencewere graded ag room for imn 92.6% of ca

Date of meet

ndation Trus015

Effectivenessess)

nical Effectiv

quality by the

Dec

App

Info

Ass

mortality in ele

ril 2014 - Marcand Friarage % compared tary Hospital-led January to DHSMR for the

ted since Octo% were judgede of preventabas showing ro

mprovement inases.

Agend

ting 30 June

st Mortality

s and Tony

veness) and

cision

proval

ormation

surance

ective admiss

ch 2015 whicHospitals andto a peer rate evel MortalityDecember 20e latest availa

ober 2013 (19d on the Hogability. 82.6% oom for impron organisation

a Item 12

2015

Report:

Roberts,

Dr Sath

ions. A&E

h equates d including of 1.46%.

y Indicator 14 HSMR ble period

90 in Q4). n scale to of deaths vement in n of care.

Page 2: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOUTH TEES HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST Agenda Item: 12 Trust Mortality Report for Board of Directors data to end of Q4 2014/15

Report prepared by Tony Roberts and Jo Raine, Clinical Effectiveness. 03/07/2015 Page 2 of 24 M:\Clinical Governance\Clinical Effectiveness\CHKS\Mortality Reports for Board\FINAL Mortality Report Divisional Level Q4 14/15  

Next Steps

Development of the specialist palliative care service is likely to be reflected in increased numbers of patients receiving a specialist palliative care code and the Trust should monitor the impact this has on HSMR.

The Trust is collecting data for the national CQUIN schemes for patients with sepsis and acute kidney injury. The Trust should use this data to assess the impact on mortality in these high risk patient groups.

Supports Trust Strategy Map in the following areas

quality & patient safety

business sustainability

operational excellence organisational capability

deliver integrated care   improved cost

control   improved patient flow   improved

information  

forefront of clinical innovation  

increased productivity  

improved innovation processes  

continuous service improvement culture

 

specialised services development

 increased revenue & market share

 strong governance & risk management

 workforce development  

service quality and safety  

enhanced services  

  strong partnerships & engagement

 

If a key risk(s) has been identified, please describe below

The Trust continues to be an outlier on HSMR.

 

Page 3: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOUTH TEES HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST Agenda Item: 12 Trust Mortality Report for Board of Directors data to end of Q4 2014/15

Report prepared by Tony Roberts and Jo Raine, Clinical Effectiveness. 03/07/2015 Page 3 of 24 M:\Clinical Governance\Clinical Effectiveness\CHKS\Mortality Reports for Board\FINAL Mortality Report Divisional Level Q4 14/15  

Contents 

1  Executive Summary .......................................................................................................... 5 

2  Recommendations for improvement of mortality ........................................................... 5 

3  Background to Report ...................................................................................................... 6 

4  Methods ........................................................................................................................... 6 

5  Report from the Mortality Group ..................................................................................... 6 

Table 1: Lessons Learned: Mortality Reviews Q4 2014/15 ......................................................... 7 

6  Mortality Measures: Summary Hospital Level Mortality  Indicator  (SHMI) and Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratio (HSMR) .............................................................................. 8 

Table  2:  SHMI,  total  discharges,  observed  and  expected  deaths,  %  aged  75+  and banding by Acute Trust for October 2013 – September 2014. ................................................... 8 

Figure 1: SHMI with banding using 99% Control Limits and over‐dispersion adjustment ......... 9 

Table  3:  HSMR,  total  discharges,  observed  and  expected  deaths,  HSMR  with  and without palliative care adjustment for January 2014 ‐ December 2014. ................................... 9 

Figure 2: HSMR by Acute Trust for January 2014 ‐ December 2014......................................... 10 

Figure 3: SHMI and Unadjusted Mortality Rate for South Tees. .............................................. 11 

Figure 4: HSMR and Palliative Care Coding for South Tees. ..................................................... 11 

Figure 5: Proportion of Deaths with Palliative Care Coding (South Tees, North Tees and County Durham & Darlington Trusts) ....................................................................................... 12 

Figure 6: Spells with palliative care coding (specialist: Z515, general: Z518) South Tees Hospitals NHS FT April 2011 to May 2015 ................................................................................ 12 

7  Mean‐Centred HSMR and SHMI ..................................................................................... 13 

Figure 7: Mean Centred displays for SHMI and HSMR: South Tees. ......................................... 14 

8  Unadjusted Mortality: Trust Overview ........................................................................... 15 

Table 4: Crude Mortality: number of deaths, mortality  rate and peer data  to Centre level April 2014 – March 2015. ................................................................................................. 15 

Figure  8:  Crude Mortality  Rate April  2005  – April  2015    including  Rolling  12 month averages. .................................................................................................................................. 15 

Figure  9:  SHMI Defined Mortality  Rates:  Trust, North  East Region  and National  July 2011 – January 2015. ............................................................................................................... 16 

Figure 10: SPC Chart of Deaths April 2006 – May 2015. .......................................................... 16 

Figure 11: Deaths per month per Division and Centre January 2011 – April 2015. .................. 17 

Table  5: Deaths  in  South  Tees  Acute  and  Community Hospitals  April  2014  – March 2015. ......................................................................................................................................... 17 

Page 4: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOUTH TEES HOSPITALS NHS FOUNDATION TRUST Agenda Item: 12 Trust Mortality Report for Board of Directors data to end of Q4 2014/15

Report prepared by Tony Roberts and Jo Raine, Clinical Effectiveness. 03/07/2015 Page 4 of 24 M:\Clinical Governance\Clinical Effectiveness\CHKS\Mortality Reports for Board\FINAL Mortality Report Divisional Level Q4 14/15  

Figure  12:  Observed  and  Predicted  all‐cause  death  registrations  England  & Wales.   Excess mortality in 65+ year olds by week of death, England .................................................. 18 

Table 6: Deaths  in South Tees Acute and Community Hospitals by CCS Group and Age Group October 2014 – March 2015. ......................................................................................... 19 

Figure 13: South Tees: Number of deaths per week to 26 May 2015. ..................................... 19 

9  Intelligent  Monitoring  Report  and  Dr  Foster  Intelligence:  Quarterly  Mortality  Data Release ........................................................................................................................... 19 

Figure 14: CQC Intelligent Monitoring Report May 2015 ......................................................... 20 

Figure 15: South Tees Dr Foster Quarterly Mortality Data Release July 2013 ‐ June 2014 ...... 20 

Figure 16: All Trusts: Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratio July 2013 – June 2014 ............... 20 

Figure 17: South Tees: Women & Children Centre: Trends on perinatal rates from 2000‐2014 .......................................................................................................................................... 21 

Figure 18: SHMI for Colorectal Cancer ..................................................................................... 22 

Table 7: SHMI for Colorectal Cancer ......................................................................................... 22 

10  Mortality in A&E Department – Dead on Arrival or Died in Department ...................... 23 

Figure 19: Dead on Arrival or Died in Department April 2005 to date. .................................... 23 

Table 8: Initial Diagnosis on arrival at A&E: Dead on Arrival / Died in Department. ............... 23 

11  Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 24 

12  Recommendations for improvement of mortality ......................................................... 24  

   

Page 5: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

1 Ex

Th1.1SuSe

Th1.2Th“hi

Th1.3ex20nacirme

Th1.4plato Ma

2 Re

De2.1in an

Th2.2seim

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

xecutive Su

his report shummary Hoeptember 20

he HSMR fohe latest avagher than e

he number perienced 15. Figurestional and culating reseasures wh

he Mortalityaces the Trcarry our c

arch 2015.

ecommend

evelopment increased d the Trust

he Trust is cpsis and acpact on mo

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

ummary

hows that thospital-level014 (103).

or January ailable HSMexpected”.

of deaths aa relatively

s for Januarregional trespiratory vien they incl

y Group coust in a strolinical morta

ations for i

of the specnumbers ofshould mon

collecting dacute kidney rtality in the

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

he Trust pel Mortality

to DecembMR for Marc

and the uny high wintery 2015 werends and isiruses. It islude this pe

ontinues to ong positioality review

improveme

cialist palliaf patients renitor the im

ata for the ninjury. The

ese high ris

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

erforms withIndicator (

ber 2014 isch 2014 to F

nadjusted mer peak in re exceptions consistens likely to aeriod.

perform wn to respons announce

ent of mort

ative care seceiving a pact this ha

national CQe Trust shouk patient gr

015 Page 5 of

rd\FINAL Mortal

hin the expe(SHMI) for

s 107 whichFebruary 20

mortality ratdeaths, co

nally high. Tt with the nadversely a

weekly mortnd to the naed by the Se

tality

service is likspecialist p

as on HSMR

UIN schemuld use this oups.

A

f 24 ity Report Divis

ected rangeOctober 2

h is “as ex015 is 112

tes show thontinuing inThis patternnational figaffect the a

tality reviewational requecretary of

kely to be rpalliative caR.

mes for patiedata to ass

Agenda Item:

sional Level

e for the 2013 to

pected”. which is

he Trust nto April n reflects ures for adjusted

ws. This uirement State in

reflected are code

ents with sess the

12

Page 6: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

3 Bac

Th3.1Thwhthe

Th3.2resthe

4 Met

Th4.1syspronubeapTh

In 4.2sysTruIndTh20

 

5 Rep

Th5.1MomoOcrevDirthe

In 5.282jud2.6hagraimporgorgsatcaselurea

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

ckground to

his is the 24he importanhich is embee failures at

he report takstructuring e Francis Pu

hods

he Trust hastem has bovide timelymber of de benchmapropriate. T

his is the las

April 2014 stem supplust (UHB)dicator (SHhe Trust wil15 allowing

port from th

he Mortality onkhouse, ortality repoctober 2013views carrierectors, Moe Mortality G

the fourth .6% of dea

dged on the6% showingve a higheade of 1 (provement ganisationaganisationatisfactory. Qses. 44

ucidated moason for the

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

o Report

4th quarterlynce of repoedded in Sot the Mid-Sta

kes accounof the NHSublic Inquiry

as used theeen the may numbers aths/numberked againThe systemst report to i

the Trust gied by the . This sysMI) and Hl use this s

g a phased t

he Mortality

Group wasConsultant

orting on a3 and has ced out to Ortality Lead

Group was 2

quarter of aths reviewe Hogan scg slight evidr degree o(good pracin clinical l care and l care. NoQuality of c(23.2%) reore than o

e overall gra

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

y report on orting mortaouth Tees, waffordshire

nt of changeS, the Keogy into Mid S

e CHKS Sigainstay for m

of deaths er of spells)nst the En

m will remainclude CHK

gained acceUniversity

stem proviospital Sta

system in ptransition to

y Group

s establishet in Anaesa trust widecontinued oOctober 20

ds and othe23 April 201

2014/15 awed were gcale to be ‘dence of pref preventab

ctice). 3.2care, 10.5% 2.1% room

o deaths wcare was judeviews citeone 'lessonading.

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

mortality toality statistiwas highligTrust (Febr

es to mortagh Report inStaffs and th

gnpost sysmortality rep

and the u). The systengland aven available KS data.

ess to the HHospitals

ides Summndardised

parallel witho the new re

ed in Januathesia and

e basis. Thon a weekly014 will be er interested15, the next

a total of 1graded as ‘definitely neventabilitybility. 82.62% were g% as showm for impr

were given tdged to be ed Lesson'. The spe

015 Page 6 of

rd\FINAL Mortal

be presentcs at Boarhted in the ruary 2010)

lity reportinnto Trusts whe governm

tem for maporting. Thisunadjusted em also alloerage or s

to the Trus

Health EvalBirmingham

mary HospMortality R the CHKS

eporting reg

ary 2012, ch Critical Ce review oy basis. Th

circulated d parties. Tt meeting w

90 reviews‘Expected’,

not preventa. Only 1 de% of deathraded as

wing room fovement inthe lowest Excellent os Learned

ecific lesson

A

f 24 ity Report Divis

ted to Trusrd level, a Francis Re

).

ng instigatedwith high m

ment’s respo

any years as system ismortality r

ows the measelected pest until Jun

luation Datam NHS Foupital-level M

Ratio (HSMRS system ungime.

haired by DCare to coof deaths bhe reports c

shortly to The last me

will be 16 Ju

s were carr, and 96.8able’ with aeath was ju

hs had a Nshowing rofor improven both clinigrade – le

or Good in 9. Some n may not

Agenda Item:

sional Level

t Board. process port into

d by the mortality, onse.

and this used to

rate (i.e. asure to eers as ne 2015.

a (HED) undation Mortality R) data. ntil June

Dr Diane ordinate

began in covering Clinical

eeting of ly 2015.

ried out. % were a further udged to CEPOD oom for

ement in ical and

ess than 92.6% of

reviews be the

12

Page 7: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

Le

PoInanuhoInatraCoDNor PocaadDeInatreAv(ICDeDecosuPoInatraNHterDeto faiIncobesMeLabecaLoPaap

To Ta

So

 

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

esson

oor quality of dappropriate ad

ursing home / ospital appropriate ansfer/repatriaommunity HosNACPR not inignored and C

oor coordinatioare / lack of sedvanced deciselay in institutiappropriately eatment vailability of apCU/outlier) comelayed or poorelayed dischaommunity/lackupportive care oor communicappropriate ansfer/repatriaHS Trust / inartiary referral elay in treatmestaff shortage

ilure complete phys

bservations / dscalated edication Erro

ack of availabled potentially care (non ICU) ong wait in A&atient fall not eppropriately

otal

able 1: Lesso

ource: South 

Iss5.3DNadof ed

Fro5.4sequdis

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

documentationdmission fromcommunity

ation from spital place or invaCPR undertakon of clinical

enior input / sion making ing palliative caggressive

ppropriate bedmpromising car clerking rge into

k of appropriatepackage

cation with fam

ation from otheppropriate

ent/surgery dues/equipment

siological deterioration n

or e appropriate compromising

&E for a bed escalated

ons Learned:

Tees Hospita

sues arounNACPR wemissions frocare/lack oucational a

om Novemlection of oality of car

sability or

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

Hogan

n 8

7

3

lid ken 8

7

care 2

3

d are 3

2

e 3

mily 2

er 2

ue 1

ot 1

1

1

1

55

Mortality Rev

als NHS Foun

nd poor qure themes om nursingf senior inpnd M&M me

mber 2014 one quartere. Other

those wh

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

n1 Hogan>1

1

1

1

3

views Q4 201

ndation Trus

uality of dthis quarte

g homes/comput. Lessonseetings.

the team r of the degroups of

hose care

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

n NCEPOD1 6

3

2

3

1

2

1

18

4/15

t.  Mortality 

documentater as weremmunity hos learnt are

moved toeaths for repatients su

record in

015 Page 7 of

rd\FINAL Mortal

D NCEPOD >1 2

4

3

6

4

2

2

3

2

1

1

3

1

2

1

1

1

1

40

Reviews Dat

tion and is issues aro

ospitals andbeing fed b

owards reveporting of uch as thosndicates a

A

f 24 ity Report Divis

Expected 8

7

3

8

7

2

3

3

2

3

2

3

1

1

1

1

1

56

tabase. 

ssues arouound inapp

d poor co-orback to the

viewing a preventab

se with a a complica

Agenda Item:

sional Level

Total

8

7

3

8

7

2

3

3

2

3

2

3

1

2

1

1

1

1

58

und the propriate rdination Trust in

random ility and learning

ation or

12

Page 8: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

    

1 N

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

mibro

Th5.5revcoCoHe

6 Morand

Th6.1adjStaNEfro

SH6.2of oba san

Th6.3forSosixSH

Tabban

Sou

                      

NEQOS Hospit

ProviderCounty Dur

North Tees

South Tees

Gateshead

South Tyne

City Hospita

The Newcas

Northumbria

North Cumb

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

sadventureought to the

he Secretaryviews will burse and

onfidential ealthcare Qu

rtality Meas Hospital S

he Summarjusted moratistics (HEEQOS NHSom October

HMI reports discharge

served numstatistical md comorbid

he Summarr all trusts iouth Tynesixth consecuHMI outlier,

ble 2: SHMI,nding by Acu

urce: SHMI Da

                      

tal Mortality M

rham and Darlington

and Hartlepool NH

s Hospitals NHS FT

Health NHS FT

eside NHS FT

als Sunderland NH

stle Upon Tyne Hos

a Healthcare NHS F

bria University Hosp

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

in their lase group by c

y of State foe compulsothe Trust Enquiry intuality Impro

sures: SumStandardise

ry Hospital-rtality followES) linked S North Eas

2013 to Se

all deaths from hosp

mber of deamodel accoities.

y Hospital-n the NE wde which a

utive quartewith a value

, total dischute Trust for O

ata Release H

            

Monitoring Re

n NHS FT

S FT

T

S FT

spitals NHS FT

FT

pitals NHS Trust

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

st spell of cconsultants

for Health aory in all Tris attendinto Patient

ovement Pa

mmary Hosed Mortalit

-level Mortawing hospdeath cer

st Hospital eptember 20

in hospital pital across

aths for eachunting for p

level Mortawith the excare high outer in which e of 119.

arges, obserOctober 2013

HSCIC April 20

eport 24: Octo

Discharges Obs

84298 2

45872 1

92203 2

35285 1

22656 1

58925 1

106621 2

64427 2

48481 1

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

care are als.

announced rusts. Furtheng consulta

Outcome artnership (H

spital Levety Ratio (HS

ality Indicatital admissrtificates. TMortality M

014.1

and all deas the NHSh hospital wpatients’ ag

ality Indicatoeption of Ntliers in thisNorth Tee

rved and ex3 – Septembe

015.

ober 2013 ‐ Se

served % aged 75

904 67.4

827 67.3

634 62.7

407 68.5

125 65.3

999 68.3

512 54.9

929 71.4

661 68.4

015 Page 8 of

rd\FINAL Mortal

so reviewed

in March ther details a

ation days and Death

HQIP).

el MortalitySMR)

or (SHMI) sion using The data is

Monitoring R

aths that ocS in Englanwith the numge, sex, me

or (SHMI) worth Tees a

s release ofs and Hart

xpected deathr 2014.

eptember 201

5+ Expected

2816

1536

2570

1400

951

1801

2629

2762

1718

A

f 24 ity Report Divis

d as are an

hat clinical mare expected

with the h (NCEPO

y Indicator

calculates Hospital

s drawn frReport 24 w

ccur within nd, compamber expectethod of ad

was “as exand Hartlepf data. Thtlepool has

hs, % aged

14.  May 2015 

SHMI Ca

103.1 as e

118.9 Higher th

102.5 as e

100.5 as e

118.3 Higher th

111.0 as e

95.6 as e

106.1 as e

96.7 as e

Agenda Item:

sional Level

ny cases

mortality d in due National

OD) and

r (SHMI)

the risk Episode rom the

with data

30 days ring the ted from dmission

xpected” pool and is is the been a

75+ and

ategory

expected

han expected

expected

expected

han expected

expected

expected

expected

expected

12

Page 9: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 1

Source:

Table 3:palliativ

Source:

City HospitaCounty DurhGateshead HNorth CumbNorth Tees NorthumbriSouth Tees South TynesThe Newcas

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

1: SHMI with b

SHMI Data Re

: HSMR, totae care adjust

HED May 201

als Sunderland NHS ham and Darlington Health NHS Foundatbria University Hospand Hartlepool NHSa Healthcare NHS FoHospitals NHS Founside NHS Foundatiostle Upon Tyne Hosp

Trust N

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

banding usin

elease HSCIC

al dischargestment for Jan

15.

Foundation TrustNHS Foundation Trution Trustitals NHS TrustS Foundation Trustoundation Trustdation Trustn Trustpitals NHS Foundatio

Name

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

ng 99% Contr

C April 2015.

s, observed anuary 2014 - D

No Discharge

33ust 43

243834435114

on Trust 68

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

ol Limits and

and expectedDecember 20

esObserved Deaths

ExDe

3652 13663234 17954871 9228995 11704083 12303119 20981920 17034738 8128224 1600

January 2

015 Page 9 of

rd\FINAL Mortal

d over-dispers

d deaths, HS14.

pected eaths HSMR

1332.3 1021716.4 104905.5 101159.6 1001004.4 1221964.3 1061589.5 107604.1 1341699.1 94

014 ‐ December 201

A

f 24 ity Report Divis

sion adjustm

SMR with and

HSMR (withoutadjusting for palliative care)

2.53 108.754.58 100.271.83 94.240.89 98.742.46 119.446.81 111.677.14 102.784.42 128.624.17 92.32

14

Agenda Item:

sional Level

ment

d without

) Category5 As Expected7 As Expected4 As Expected4 As Expected4 Higher than Expec7 Higher than Expec8 As Expected2 Higher than Expec2 As Expected

12

ctedcted

cted

Page 10: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 2

Source:

HS6.4givavfig

Th6.5to co

 

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

2: HSMR by A

HED (May 20

SMR for theving the Truailable figurures is 112

he estimate 5 points (seding (see fi

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

Acute Trust fo

15).

e trust in thust a ratingres for the p.4 which wo

for the impee table 3).gure 5).

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

or January 20

he period Jg of ‘Higherperiod Marcould give a

act of specThis is bec

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

014 - Decemb

anuary 201r than Expech 2014 – Frating of ‘H

cialist palliatcause the T

015 Page 10 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

ber 2014

4 – Decemected’. Howebruary 20igher than E

tive care coTrust is belo

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

mber 2014 wever, in th15 (provisioExpected’.

oding on HSow national

Agenda Item:

sional Level

is 107.1 he latest onal) the

SMR is 4 average

12

 

Page 11: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

 

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 3

Source:

 

Figure 4

Source:

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

3: SHMI and U

NEQOS Hosp

4: HSMR and

NEQOS Hosp

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

Unadjusted M

pital Mortality M

Palliative Ca

pital Mortality M

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

Mortality Rate

Monitoring Re

re Coding for

Monitoring Re

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

for South Te

eport 24. Data

r South Tees

eport 24. Data

015 Page 11 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

ees.

a extracted fro

.

a extracted fro

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

om HED April 2

om HED April 2

Agenda Item:

sional Level

2015.

2015.

12

 

 

Page 12: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 5County

Source:

Figure 6Hospita

Source:

Sin6.6Sppenorel

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Deaths with

 Palliative

 Care Co

ding

 (%)

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

5: ProportionDurham & Da

HED. (May 20

6: Spells witls NHS FT Ap

CBiS

nce the witpecialist Parsonalised tes. Wheratively eas

March12 June1

P

Source: NEQOS HospData from HSCIC con

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

n of Deaths warlington Trus

015)

th palliative pril 2011 to M

hdrawal of alliative Ca

care plansre electronily in all pa

2 Sep12

roportion of 

pital Mortality   Monitorntextual indicators, May

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

with Palliativsts)

care coding May 2015

the Liverpore Team h

s, either in ic systems

atients iden

Dec12 March1

R

deaths with 

ing: Report 24y 2015

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

ve Care Cod

(specialist:

ool Care Pahave taken

new docus are availatified as dy

13 June13

olling year ‐ end poin

palliative ca

015 Page 12 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

ing (South T

Z515, genera

athway (ann on the rumentation able it is pying. Use o

Sep13 Dec13

nt

re coding (ro

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

Tees, North T

al: Z518) So

nd equivalenrole of oveor written

possible to of electroni

March14

olling year)

Agenda Item:

sional Level

Tees and

outh Tees

nts), the erseeing in case do this

ic ‘flags;

June14 Sep14

ENGLAND

South Tees

North Tees

CDD

12

 

Page 13: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

    2 MIllu

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

evup

Th6.7by go

So6.8teama

7 Mea

NE7.1anthemo

                      Mohammed MA,ustrative Case‐Stu

‐40

‐30

‐20

‐10

0

10

20

30

40

7 8 9 10111

2011/1

‐1000

‐800

‐600

‐400

‐200

0

200

400

600

7 8 9 10111

2011/

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

en in trusts of patients

he Trust hasSPCTs recod.

ome Trusts am. The Takes it clear

an-Centred

EQOS haved HSMR ba

e Regional ortality indic

                      ,  Stephens  AJ.  Audy paper. PLoS O

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

12 2012/13

South Tees ‐M

Me

12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

12 2012/13

South Tees ‐Mea

Mean

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

s without EP who are dy

s replicatedceive the Z5

are classifyTrust does r SPCT team

HSMR and

e developedased on a pMortality G

cator, observ

            A  Simple  InsightONE 2013;8(3): e5

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112 1

2013/14

Mean centered SH

ean centered SHMI

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

2013/14

an centered Discha

n centered Discharges

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

PRs meansying by SPC

d all known 515 code w

ying additionot believem members

d SHMI

d an appropaper publiGroup. Mearved, expect

tful  Approach  to57845. 

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

2014/15

MI

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

2014/15

arges

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

s more proaCTs.

methods fowith modest

nal specialie that this is must have

oach for trushed in 20

an-centred ted and dis

o  Investigating  a

‐80

‐60

‐40

‐20

0

20

40

60

80

7 8 9 101112

2011/12

‐80

‐60

‐40

‐20

0

20

40

60

80

7 8 9 10111

2011/1

015 Page 13 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

active ident

or ensuringresults as c

st nurses as appropriae SPC quali

sts to unde132, this is displays shcharges.

  Hospital  Standa

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112 1

2 2012/13

South Tees ‐Mea

Mean

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

12 2012/13

South Tees ‐Mea

Mean

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

tification an

g that patiencoding was

as part of thate. The gifications.

erstand thedistributed how trends

ardised Mortalit

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112 1

2013/14

an centered Expec

n centered Expected

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112 1

2013/14

an centered Obser

n centered Observed

Agenda Item:

sional Level

nd follow

nts seen already

e SPCT guidance

eir SHMI through

s for the

ty  Ratio:  An 

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

2014/15

cted

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 101112

2014/15

rved

12

Page 14: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

7.

7.

 

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 7

Source:

The S2observenumbestable.

The HS3monthsThe nu

‐40

‐30

‐20

‐10

0

10

20

30

40

1 2 3 4 5

‐600

‐400

‐200

0

200

400

600

1 2 3 4

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

7: Mean Centr

HED May 201

HMI for Soed and expr of discha

SMR for Sos. The nummber of dis

6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4

2012/13

South Tees ‐M

Me

5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3

2012/13

South Tees ‐Mea

Mea

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

red displays f

15.

outh Tees pected dearges used

uth Tees hamber of obsescharges us

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2

2013/14

Mean centered HSM

ean centered HSMR

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2

2013/14

an centered Disch

an centered Discharges

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

for SHMI and

has remaaths used toin the calc

as remaineerved and

sed to calcu

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

2014/15

MR

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

2014/15

harges

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

d HSMR: Sout

ained stableo calculateulation of S

ed stable aftexpected d

ulate HSMR

‐80

‐60

‐40

‐20

0

20

40

60

80

1 2 3 4 5

‐80

‐60

‐40

‐20

0

20

40

60

80

1 2 3 4 5

015 Page 14 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

th Tees.

e. HoweverSHMI hav

SHMI is var

ter the rise deaths has

has risen.

6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4

2012/13

South Tees ‐Mea

Mea

6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4

2012/13

South Tees ‐Mea

Mean

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

r, the numve both fallriable but r

following thfallen in la

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2

2013/14

an centered Expec

n centered Expected

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3

2013/14

an centered Obser

n centered Observed

Agenda Item:

sional Level

mbers of en. The

relatively

he first 8 ast year.

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

2014/15

cted

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

2014/15

rved

12

Page 15: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

8 Una

Table April 2

Source

Th8.1motheforPrestrrat

Ho8.2expaa peva

Figure 8

Source:

 

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

adjusted Mo

4: Crude Mo2014 – March

e: CHKS Signp

here were 2ortality rate e unadjuster the Trust, evious inveructure of sther than tra

owever, Janperienced iralleled in rhigh level ople, in theccine (see f

8: Crude Mort

CHKS Signpo

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

ortality: Tr

ortality: numb2015.

post.

,065 deathsof 1.38% a

ed mortalityTertiary se

estigation sservices inansferring p

nuary 2015in a single regional andof respirat

e communitfigure 12).

tality Rate Ap

ost.

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

rust Overvi

ber of deaths

s recorded and an ave

y rate remaervices havsuggests th the Trust

patients to o

5 saw the hmonth in a

d national ftory illnessty and the

pril 2005 – Ap

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

ew

s, mortality r

in the acuteerage of 17ins below t

ve higher unhis is beca, which pr

other provid

highest numalmost a defigures for ts, particular

relative ine

pril 2015 inclu

015 Page 15 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

rate and peer

e setting in 72 deaths pthe peer avnadjusted mause of theovides rehers.

mber of deecade – 24he winter prly influenzeffectivenes

uding Rolling

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

r data to Cen

the period per month. verage. As mortality thae differenceabilitation s

eaths the tr44 deaths. period and isza affectingss of this ye

g 12 month av

Agenda Item:

sional Level

 

ntre level

giving a Overall, is usual

an peer. e in the services

rust has This is s due to elderly ear’s flu

verages.

12

Page 16: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 9January

Source:

Th8.3mounda

Th8.4it awin

Figure 1

Source:

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

9: SHMI Definy 2015.

HED.

his report isortality rateadjusted rays of discha

he Trust willallows promnter pressu

10: SPC Chart

CHKS Signpo

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

ned Mortality

s the last te. In futureate as this iarge. It align

l count in-hmpt (weeklyres.

t of Deaths A

ost./CAMIS

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

y Rates: Trus

time we we the Trustincludes allns with the

ospital deay or daily

April 2006 – M

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

st, North East

ill have a t will use dl in-hospitalSHMI indic

aths using inif needed)

May 2015.

015 Page 16 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

t Region and

CHKS versdeaths incll deaths anator and is

nternal datareporting,

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

d National Ju

sion of unaluded in S

nd deaths wnationally d

a (CaMIS) bparticularly

Agenda Item:

sional Level

ly 2011 –

adjusted HMI for

within 30 defined.

because y during

12

 

Page 17: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

 

Figure 1

Source:

 

Fro8.5res& CtheHo

HospJAMEFRIARREDCFRIARECH ‐RUTSCARTLAMGUISGran

Table

Source

Ov8.6Ho15

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

11: Deaths pe

CHKS Signpo

om April 2sponsibility Cleveland ae Carter Beospitals.

pital ES COOK UNRAGE HOSPICAR PRIMARRY HOSPITAL‐ EAST CLEVESON TER BEQUESTBERT MEMOSBOROUGH Gnd Total 

5: Deaths in

e: South Tees

ver the pastospital’s sta9 (70.0%) h

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

er month per

ost.

011 South for the Com

and North Yequest East

IVERSITY HOTAL Y CARE HOSL ELAND HOSP

T PRIMARY CORIAL COMMGENERAL HO

South Tees A

Hospitals NH

t year, recoatistics. Of have appea

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

Division and

Tees Hosmmunity SeYorkshire (Ht Cleveland

OSPITAL 

PITAL 

PITAL 

CARE HOSPITMUNITY HOSPOSPITAL 

Acute and Co

HS Foundation

ords have gthe 227 de

ared in Acu

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

Centre Janu

spitals NHServices DivisHambleton &, Guisborou

DeIn 

TAL PITAL 

ommunity Hos

n Trust.

gradually beeaths recorte Hospital

015 Page 17 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

ary 2011 – Ap

S Foundatiosion of Midd& Richmondugh and Re

eaths Trust beds 

162827148193510291115

2066

spitals April 2

een includedrded in Comstatistics.

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

pril 2015.

on Trust adlesbrough,dshire), par

edcar Prima

Deaths inCommunbeds 

8 1 8 9 5 0 9 1 5 6 

2014 – March

d in with thmmunity HoOf those th

Agenda Item:

sional Level

assumed Redcar rticularly ary Care

n nity 

Total Deaths

162

1252

223

150

68 21

h 2015.

he Acute ospitals, hat were

12

62827149443732322615

134

Page 18: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

 

    3ht4hn2

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

noinp

 

Th8.7puinc

FigureExces

Source:

Na8.8we(Apthagrowe30

                      

ttps://www.gov.uttps://www.g2015wk09.pdf

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

t included aput into thei

he Public Hblished on

crease in wi

e 12: Observs mortality in

: Public Health E

ationally, exeek 50 201pril) 2015. at 86.4% ofoup (rising tere in the 8.2% in Febr

                      

uk/government/sgov.uk/governf 

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

as these wr care.

Health Engla4th June 2nter deaths

ved and Pren 65+ year old

England. Week

xcess death4 (mid DecTrust mort

f deaths in to 90.2% in85 and overuary 2015.

            

statistics/mortalinment/upload

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

were deaths

and Weekly015 confirm

s particularly

edicted all-cds by week o

kly All Cause Mo

hs particulacember) onality followsDecember

n January 20er age grou.

ity‐weekly‐all‐cauds/system/upl

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

in GP bed

y All-causemed that Eny in 65+ yea

cause death f death, Engl

ortality Surveilla

arly in the only falling tos a similar p2014 were015). 28.3%p, rising to

use‐mortality‐surloads/attachm

015 Page 18 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

ds and the T

e Mortality Sngland expear olds.3

registrationsand

ance Week 23 R

over 65s hao predicted pattern. Int in the age

% of deaths o 30.7% in

veillance  ment_data/file

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

Trust had n

Surveillancerienced a

s England &

Report. 4 

ave occurrelevels in w

ternal figureed 65 and o in DecembJanuary 20

e/409624/EDS

Agenda Item:

sional Level

no other

e report notable

& Wales.

ed since week 12 es show over age ber 2014 015 and

SSSBulleti

12

Page 19: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

 

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Table Group

Source

Of 8.994CC(66

Figure

Source:

9 IntellMortality

Th9.1‘4’co14En

CCS G122 ‐sexu109 ‐127 ‐bron2 ‐ Se100 ‐159 ‐157 ‐

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

6: Deaths inp October 201

e: CHKS.

f the 1,123 8 occurred

CS Group 16 in the ove

e 13: South Te

: CBiS 

igent Mony Data Rele

he latest CQ. Two factomposite of ) and a ‘Ris

ndocrinologi

Group‐ Pneumonia (except thally transmitted diseas‐ Acute cerebrovascular‐ Chronic obstructive puchiectasisepticemia (except in la‐ Acute myocardial infa‐ Urinary tract infection‐ Acute and unspecified

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

n South Tees14 – March 20

deaths in tin patients22 Pneumo

er 85 age gr

ees: Number

nitoring Rease

QC IMR waors relevantHospital St

sk’ for the cical conditio

hat caused by tuberculose)r diseaseulmonary disease and 

bor)rctionsd renal failure

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

s Acute and 015.

the trust in s aged 65 aonia, 174 (8roup).

r of deaths pe

Report and

s released t to this reptandardised

composite inons.

All Deathsosis or 

1

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

Community H

the period and over –88.3%) occu

er week to 26

d Dr Fos

in May 201port were: a d Mortality ndicator of

s % of all deaths A

197 17.5%77 6.9%

51 4.5%48 4.3%35 3.1%34 3.0%34 3.0%

015 Page 19 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

Hospitals by

October 2084.4%. Of

urred in the

May 2015.

ster Intellig

15. The Trjudged ‘Ele

Ratio Indicain-hospital m

Aged 65+ % of Death

17463

4340263231

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

y CCS Group

014 – Marcf the 197 d over 65 ag

gence: Q

rust was ratevated Riskators (Jul 1mortality re

s 65+ Aged 85+ % 

18.4% 666.6% 20

4.5% 164.2% 162.7% 63.4% 153.3% 14

Agenda Item:

sional Level

and Age

ch 2015, eaths in

ge group

uarterly

ted as a k’ for the 3 – Jun

elating to

of all Deaths 85+

21.2%6.4%

5.1%5.1%1.9%4.8%4.5%

12

Page 20: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

H

.

    

5 h

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Figure 14

Source: Car

Dr 9.2

• • • •

Th9.3

Dr HSM110.

Higher than E

Figure

Source:

Figure

Sou

                      

https://my.drf

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

: CQC Intellig

re Quality Comm

Foster rele

Hospital SEmergenEmergenDeaths in

he last iterat

Foster QuR 1 Expected

e 15: South Te

: Dr Foster 

e 16: All Trust

urce: Dr Foste

                      

foster.co.uk/U

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

gent Monitori

mission ease data on

Standardisecy Hospital cy Hospital

n low risk dia

tion release

arterly MorHSMR We

104.1Within Exp

Rang

ees Dr Foster

ts: Hospital S

er

            

Updates/mort

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

ng Report Ma

n the four m

ed Mortality Standardis Standardisagnosis gro

ed covers th

rtality Dataeekday 18 pected ge

r Quarterly M

Standardised

tality‐data‐for

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

ay 2015

mortality me

Ratio (HSMsed Mortalitysed Mortalityoups.

he period Ju

a Release JHSMR We

116.7Within Ex

Rang

Mortality Data

Mortality Ra

r‐english‐nhs‐

015 Page 20 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

etrics on a q

MR) y Ratio (Wey Ratio (We

uly 2013 – J

July 2013 - eekend 76 pected ge

Release July

tio July 2013

acute‐trusts‐j

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

quarterly bas

eekday) eekend)

June 2014

June 2014Low Risk

0.5Within Ex

Rang

y 2013 - June

3 – June 2014

july‐2013‐to‐j

Agenda Item:

sional Level

sis:5.

4 Groups 5

xpected ge

e 2014

4

une‐2014  

12

Page 21: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

So9.4TruTy

Inv9.5theprounwaSc

Of 9.6waevde

Th9.7deP9expoCethabirde

Fig201

Sou

 

An9.8NEthe16Se

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

outh Tees (usts. Thre

yneside, Nor

vestigation e 50 deathsocess (78.0derlying or

as 76.3 yeacore (comor

f the 39 patias judged tidence thatmonstrating

he Trust haaths. This i

95X diagnoscludes still int of HSM

entre which at there is nrth shows thpartment an

gure 17: Sout14

urce: South Te

nother area EQOS Hospe SHMI for 3.4. It sho

eptember 20

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

2000

200

Dea

ths

per 1

000

deliv

erie

s

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

(shown in ree other Nrth Tees an

of the IMRs in the peri0%). Seve

secondaryrs and only

rbidities) wa

ients whoseo be expect the deathg good prac

as been inis “Other Pesis code, wbirths whilsR. The Trucollects mu

not a problehere is a land the Cent

h Tees: Wom

ees NHS Hosp

that has flapital MortaliColorectal

ould be note014 i.e. 6 m

00120

0220

03

AnPe

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

red) has thNorth East nd Sunderla

R data for Eiod, 39 case

enteen of thy condition y 6.0% wereas 14.5.

e cases wected and 9

h could havctice.

nvestigating erinatal Conwhich is usst HSMR inst sought auch more roem with quarge discreptre to try to

men & Childre

spitals Founda

agged is coity Monitorincancers fo

ed that the months.

2004

2005

200

ntepartum stilerinatal morta

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

he 16th highTrusts hav

and (all show

Endocrinoloes had beehe patients (34.0%). e aged und

re reviewed4.9% of ca

ve been pre

the highenditions”, Tsed in still cludes it. It

assurance fobust data oality of carepancy. Work

understand

en Centre: Tr

ation Trust

olorectal cang Report 2r South Tee2014/15 fig

00620

0720

082

ll birthality rate

015 Page 21 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

hest HSMRve a highewn in yellow

ogy condition through twho died The averaer 65. The

d, in 87.2% ases were jevented wit

st CCS grhis group isbirth. It is t accounts from the Woon still birth. Cross-matk is continud why this o

ends on peri

ncers. This24 and shoes in 2014/gure only co

2009

2010

201

Early n

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

R across ther HSMR –w).

ons showedthe mortalityhad cance

age age of e average C

of cases thjudged to hth 84.6% o

roup with “s dominatednotable thafor approximomen and C

hs and this ctching caseing with the

occurs.

natal rates fr

s was raiseows ‘notable/15 – from overs the p

1120

1220

132

neonatal dea

Agenda Item:

sional Level

e Acute – South

d that of y review

er as an patients

Charlson

he death have no of cases

“excess” d by the at SHMI mately 1 Children confirms es of still e coding

rom 2000-

ed in the e rise’ in 114.5 to

period to

2014

ths

12

Page 22: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

Fig

Sou201

Tab

Sou

La9.9elenu(inalsun

Fisc201201201201201

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

gure 18: SHM

urce: NEQOS15.

ble 7: SHMI fo

urce: HED (Ju

test data fevated but mber of in-cluding the

so lower andertaken w

cal Year SHM1/122/133/144/15 (Sep 14)4/15 (Feb 15)

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

I for Colorect

S Hospital Mo

or Colorectal

une 2015)

from HED has dropp

-hospital dewithin 30 d

nd the crudwhen the full

MI

Expnumdea

110.1116.5114.5163.4144.4

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

tal Cancer

ortality Monito

l Cancer

(to Februaped by 20 eaths is higdays) is sligde mortality year figure

pected mber of aths

No.dea

16.425.827.910.420.1

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

oring Report 2

ary 2015) spoints from

her than laghtly lower).y rate is lowes are availa

. in‐hospital aths

No.hoswit

1222201222

015 Page 22 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

24. Data ext

shows thatm the mid-st year but The numbwer. Furthable.

. deaths in‐spital and hin 30 days No.

1830321729

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

tracted from H

t the SHM-year figuret the overalber of dischher analysis

. DischargesCrurate

178303280149258

Agenda Item:

sional Level

HED April

I is still e. The l deaths

harges is s will be

de mortality e

10.11%9.90%11.43%11.41%11.24%

12

Page 23: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

 

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

10 Mor

Figure 1

Source:

An10.1anproap

In 10.2arrres

Table

Source

 

4110.3webe

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

rtality in A&

19: Dead on A

South Tees H

n average od are eitheogressing fpear on CH

the last yerest prior tospiratory arr

TOCACOREBRDIFCV(blaAAUNCH

8: Initial Diag

e: South Tees

.7% were iere broughttween 9am

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

&E Departm

Arrival or Died

Hospitals NHS

of 13 peopler declaredfurther throHKS mortalit

ar, there wo death, 9.2rest prior to

OP 10 Initial ARDIAC ARROLLAPSED ESPIRATORYREATHING FFICULTIESVA ank)

AA NWELL HEST INFEC

gnosis on arr

Hospitals NH

n the 66–85t into the d – 5pm, and

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

ment – Dea

d in Departm

Foundation T

e per montd dead on ough the hoty statistics

were 120 su2% had ‘coo death.

DiagnosisREST

Y ARREST

S

CTION

rival at A&E: D

HS Foundation

5 age groudepartment d 45.0% arr

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

ad on Arriva

ent April 200

Trust

th arrive atarrival or

ospital syst.

uch cases, 6llapsed’ and

No. Cases

721110

543322

Dead on Arriv

n Trust

p, 29.2% aby emerge

rived ‘out of

015 Page 23 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

al or Died i

5 to date.

t the Trust’sdie soon

tem. They

60.0% had d a further

% All Cases

60.0%9.2%8.3%

4.2%3.3%2.5%2.5%1.7%1.7%

val / Died in D

ged over 85ency servicef hours’.

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

in Departm

s A&E Depafterwards

y do not g

suffered a8.3% had

Department.

5. 95.0% oes. 55.0%

Agenda Item:

sional Level

ment

partment without

generally

cardiac suffered

of cases % arrived

12

 

Page 24: S UMMARY REPORT · 2015. 7. 3. · res the 4 Met 4.1 Th sys pro nu be ap Th 4.2 In sys Tru Ind Th 20 5 Rep 5.1 Th Mo mo Oc rev Dir the 5.2 In 82 jud 2.6 ha gra imp org org sat cas

SOTru

Re

M:Q4

OUTH TEESust Mortality Re

eport prepared b

\Clinical Govern4 14/15  

All10.4disthi

11 Co

Th11.1SuSe

Th11.2Th“hi

Th11.3ex20nacirme

Th11.4plato Ma

12 Re

De12.1in an

Th12.2seim

S HOSPITALeport for Board o

by Tony Roberts

nance\Clinical E

deaths in scussed at s process h

onclusion

his report shummary Hoeptember 20

he HSMR fohe latest avagher than e

he number perienced 15. Figurestional and culating reseasures wh

he Mortalityaces the Trcarry our c

arch 2015.

ecommend

evelopment increased d the Trust

he Trust is cpsis and acpact on mo

S NHS FOUof Directors data

s and Jo Raine,

Effectiveness\CH

the ED area multi-disc

has not iden

hows that thospital-level014 (103).

or Januaryailable HSMexpected”.

of deaths aa relatively

s for Januarregional trespiratory vien they incl

y Group coust in a strolinical morta

ations for i

of the specnumbers ofshould mon

collecting dacute kidney rtality in the

UNDATION Ta to end of Q4 2

Clinical Effectiv

HKS\Mortality R

e screened ciplinary teantified any a

he Trust pel Mortality

to DecembMR for Marc

and the uny high wintery 2015 werends and isiruses. It islude this pe

ontinues to ong positioality review

improveme

cialist palliaf patients renitor the im

ata for the ninjury. The

ese high ris

TRUST2014/15

eness. 03/07/2

Reports for Boar

by a Consam meetingavoidable m

erforms withIndicator (

ber 2014 isch 2014 to F

nadjusted mer peak in re exceptions consistens likely to aeriod.

perform wn to respons announce

ent of mort

ative care seceiving a pact this ha

national CQe Trust shouk patient gr

015 Page 24 o

rd\FINAL Mortal

sultant and g. To date, i

mortality cas

hin the expe(SHMI) for

s 107 whichFebruary 20

mortality ratdeaths, co

nally high. Tt with the nadversely a

weekly mortnd to the naed by the Se

tality

service is likspecialist p

as on HSMR

UIN schemuld use this oups.

A

of 24 ity Report Divis

notable cain the currees.

ected rangeOctober 2

h is “as ex015 is 112

tes show thontinuing inThis patternnational figaffect the a

tality reviewational requecretary of

kely to be rpalliative caR.

mes for patiedata to ass

Agenda Item:

sional Level

ases are ent year,

e for the 2013 to

pected”. which is

he Trust nto April n reflects ures for adjusted

ws. This uirement State in

reflected are code

ents with sess the

12