sales support manual · danfoss semco has approximately 80 employees, with various backgrounds and...
TRANSCRIPT
SALES SUPPORT MANUAL
SEM-SAFE® HIGH-PRESSURE WATER MIST FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEM
FOR INDUSTRIAL AND COMMERCIAL APPLICATIONS
MAY 2016 REV. 3
1
Introduction
2
Company Profile
3
Product and Technology Description
4
High-Pressure Water Mist Competitors
5
Where to Play and Why
6
7
8
9
10
FOREWORD MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 1
Foreword
This manual has been developed as a sales support tool for our partners across Europe. Our intention is to
update this manual on a regular basis to enable us and our partners to keep pace with the market changes that
have an impact on us all.
We would appreciate your feedback and your contribution to future revisions.
COPYRIGHT/CONFIDENTIALITY STATEMENT
The following statement will form part of the Danfoss Semco’s Sales Support Manual:
“The information contained within this manual is confidential and its content must not be communicated to
any third party. Failure to keep the content of this manual confidential may result in a disciplinary action.
No part of this manual may be reproduced or transmitted in any form, or by any means, electronic or
mechanical, including photocopying, scanning, recording, or other information storage and retrieval systems,
for any purpose, without the express written permission of Danfoss Semco A/S. “
© 2016 Danfoss Semco A/S. All rights reserved.
Chapter 1
Introduction
INTRODUCTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 3
1. Introduction
Danfoss Semco has for many years strived to provide both our Partners and end users with innovative and
high quality products and solutions. We have put our emphasis on the technical aspects of our business and
used our Design Manual as our primary training and documentation tool.
In line with our aspirations of being one of the top players in the water mist market, there is a strong need to
be equally skilled in the sales process and the commercial aspects of our business. This Sales Support
Manual will provide you with an overview of products, markets, competitors and sales tools. Combined with
your local understanding and knowledge, we hope it will make your sales efforts more successful. Our
objective is for the manual to be used by both experienced sales representatives as a reference tool, but also
for new sales representatives to become familiar with our products and the sales process faster and thus
becoming more successful.
When facing increased competition it is of paramount importance that we understand the customers better
than our competitors, and can create more value for the customers.
In this third revision of the Sales Support Manual we have updated all chapters based on your feedback and
our additional experience from our Annual Partner Seminars. We have also added several new sales tools to
help you understand the competitive situation better and new sales kits such as Hospital, Hotel and Data
Centers.
Chapter 2
Company Profile
COMPANY PROFILE MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 5
2 Company Profile
2.1. History
Danfoss Semco is one of the global leaders in the sales, development, production and service/commissioning
of certified fixed fire fighting systems. The company was formed in 2006 when two leading firms in the
field, Danfoss A/S and Semco Maritime A/S, joined forces to form the present company, Danfoss Semco.
Initially our company was based on Semco Maritime’s fire division. This division of Semco Maritime has
pioneered the use of high-pressure water mist systems from the very beginning, and has extensive experience
in the design and installation of fixed fire fighting systems. Over the same period, Danfoss has cemented its
position as one of the world’s leading developers and manufacturers of nozzles, high-pressure pumps and
valves, and has been Semco Maritime’s preferred components supplier for years.
Over the past years, we have spent considerable resources on building our own technology and competences
and invested significantly in new approvals including VdS (OH1, OH2, flammable liquids, paint booth) and
FM (Light Hazard and data center).
Danfoss Semco is owned by C.W. Obel (holds 40% of the shares in Danfoss Semco) and Danfoss (holds
60% of the shares). Today Danfoss Semco is an integral part of the Danfoss Group, Denmark’s largest
industrial company with a daily output of more than 250,000 finished components, sales of 5,1 bn EUR and
more than 23,000 employees worldwide
2.2. Business Areas
Danfoss Semco has two main offices: Our office in Odense comprises all back up functions and
R&D. Our office in Wuquin, China comprises manufacturing of Pump Units for the Chinese land
market
Furthermore, we have sales offices in Beijing and Shanghai, China.
FIGURE 2.1. DANFOSS SEMCO LOCATIONS
COMPANY PROFILE MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 6
There are four main business areas: Water Mist Land, Water Mist Marine, Gas and Foam (marine) and
Service
FIGURE 2.2. BUSINESS AREA BY TURNOVER
Within the industrial and commercial water mist business area (internally known as Water Mist Land),
Danfoss Semco has a successful track record across Europe and Asia with a wide range of different projects,
in both industrial, commercial and public buildings.
Within the water mist marine segment, Danfoss Semco has pushed the boundaries for development and
design and now offers a wide range of solutions for numerous application areas. We are the first company to
obtain full distance (spacing) to bulkhead and are spearheading the conversion from gas based systems to
water mist based systems, especially within the offshore segment.
Our gas and foam business area supplies fire fighting systems based on gas, foam and dry chemical powder
to the marine industry worldwide. This business area focuses on container ships, tankers, car carriers and
RO/RO ships. The division is the world’s premier low-pressure CO2 based fire fighting systems supplier for
the marine industry.
We have provided fire fighting systems for more than 2,500 vessels including the world’s largest container
ship, passenger vessel and car carrier.
Our after sales business area provides spare parts and commissioning/service worldwide to the marine
industry. Danfoss Semco is a service supplier approved by several classification societies and provides
valuable and cost-saving overviews at multiple levels. We provide unique, comprehensive documentation
accessible at any given moment anywhere in the world.
COMPANY PROFILE MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 7
2.3. Our Ambition
Danfoss Semco and all our employees have begun a journey to transform the company and our identity from
a traditional workshop based culture to a modern industrial company. We aspire to be recognized as an
innovative and customer focused company that delivers quality products on time at a competitive price. We
want to be the No. 1 choice for both our partners and the customers (end users). To sum it all up we have
condensed our ambition to the following:
We aspire to be the recognised leader
in our focus segments
achieving high growth and sustainable profit
for Danfoss Semco and our Partners.
We strive to deliver the right, easy & safe
solution making us
the No. 1 choice
2.4. Our Organisation
Danfoss Semco has approximately 80 employees, with various backgrounds and skill sets - sales engineers,
sales managers, design engineers, projects managers etc. With their skills and knowledge combined, Danfoss
Semco is pushing the boundaries of high-tech fire fighting systems.
FIGURE 2.3. ORGANISATION CHART
Chapter 3
Product and Technology Description
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 9
3. Product and Technology Description
3.1. High-Pressure Water Mist Principle
High-pressure water mist systems operate by dispersing water at high-pressure through specially designed
nozzles. Water is forced through micro-nozzles or drilled nozzles to create a very fine mist that has a double
extinguishing effect: It cools the fire like a traditional sprinkler, but simultaneously also starves the fire of
oxygen like a gas system.
When water mist comes into contact with flames, it evaporates and expands approximately 1,700 times. Fire
extinguishing with water mist is achieved by a combination of:
Heat extraction from the fire
Oxygen reduction by steam smothering at the flame front
Blocking of radiant heat transfer
Cooling of combustibles
For a fire to survive, it relies on the presence of the three elements of the ‘fire triangle’: oxygen, heat and
combustible material. The removal of any one of these elements will extinguish a fire. A high-pressure water
mist system goes further than other technologies as it attacks two elements of the fire triangle: oxygen and
heat.
The very small droplets, in a high-pressure water mist system, quickly absorb so much energy that the
droplets will evaporate and transform from water to steam. This is due to the high surface area, relative to the
small mass of water. Each droplet will expand when being entrained into the fire and will deplete the oxygen
and combustible gasses halting the chemical chain reaction. You can find the Danfoss Semco fire triangle on
our Danfoss Semco YouTube channel (https://www.youtube.com/user/DanfossSemco).
FIGURE 3.1. FIRE TRIANGLE
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 10
A traditional sprinkler system spreads water droplets over a given area, which absorbs heat and therefore
cools the combustible materials. Due to their large size and relatively small surface, the main part of the
droplets will not absorb enough energy to evaporate, and they quickly form a pool on the floor. The result is
a limited cooling effect.
That’s why high-pressure water mist cools more efficiently per litre of water: Up to seven times better than a
traditional sprinkler system.
FIGURE 3.3. WATER MIST VS. TRADITIONAL SPRINKLERS
FIGURE 3.2. OXYGEN % BY VOLUME
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 11
3.2. The Danfoss Semco SEM-SAFE® system
Danfoss Semco designs, develops and manufactures high-pressure water mist systems for industrial and
commercial applications. The system is called SEM-SAFE®, which is a registered trademark of Danfoss
Semco. The first part of the name ‘SEM’ comes from the company name ‘Semco’. The second part of the
name “SAFE” refers to the function of the product, in this case a safety system.
The SEM-SAFE® high pressure water mist system comprises three main components:
1. A Pump Unit that takes the water from the public main or reservoir through the tank on the unit
through the high pressure pumps to the discharge manifold. The system pressure can range from 60-
130bar.
2. A number of section valves that divides the complete system into different sections depending on the
layout and design. The section valves can be operated manually or automatic (e.g. by solenoid or by
a motor).
3. A range of different nozzles designed to use the minimum water and power
FIGURE 3.4. SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM AND MAIN COMPONENTS
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 12
3.2.1 SEM-SAFE® Key Components
As one of the acknowledged pioneers of high-pressure water mist, Danfoss Semco has gained vast
experience from its many installations across the world. Danfoss Semco has direct access to its own
development and production of all three key components needed for a top performance and cost-effective
high-pressure water mist system: Nozzles, pumps and valves. All the products are made of first-class
materials and in a comprehensive tested design.
Specially Designed Water Mist Nozzles
The SEM-SAFE® water mist nozzles are based on two different
technologies.
One is the technology used in the unique Danfoss simplex micro nozzles
that has been a speciality for decades. Thanks to the special form of the
simplex micro nozzles, the water gains strong rotary motion in a swirl
chamber and is almost instantly transformed into a water mist that is
sprayed into the fire. The wide spray angle and the specially engineered
spray pattern of the Danfoss micro nozzles enables superior spacing. The
droplets formed in the micro nozzles are shaped under a pressure of approx.
100 bar and have a size of 10 to 50 micron.
In order to maintain its technology-leading position, Danfoss Semco has also
developed a new series of high-pressure water mist drilled nozzles. These
nozzles are based on a patented nozzle designs and method for generating
water mist. To enhance the process of turning water into mist, the holes
drilled in the nozzles are partly conical and partly cylindrical. The
positioning of the holes is designed to direct the water only towards the
places where the fire is, this way minimizing water consumption. The
patented method for the hole geometry in the nozzles allows larger spacing
and superior distribution of the water droplets, resulting in improved control
when extinghusing fires. Water is distributed through the drilled nozzle holes
at a pressure of 60-100 bar.
FIGURE 3.5. SIMPLEX MICRO
NOZZLE
FIGURE 3.6. DRILLED NOZZLE
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 13
Module Build Pump Unit Design
To ensure flexibility for fitting all systems and applications the Pump
Units are built on standard modules. Pump systems can utilise one or
more pump units connected through a discharge manifold to the water
mist system to meet any system design requirements. The pump system
can feed either automatic frangible glass bulb nozzles or open nozzles in
both "wet" and "dry" applications.
The system can be provided with diesel pump(s), electrical pump(s) or
both.
When the system is activated, only one pump will be started. For
systems incorporating multiple pumps, the pumps will be started
sequentially. Should the flow demand increase due to the operating of
more nozzles (automatic wet systems only); the additional pump(s) will automatically start. Only as many
pumps as are necessary to keep the flow and operating pressure constant with the system design will operate.
The high pressure water mist system remains activated until qualified staff or the fire brigade manually shut
off the system.
Intensive research has led to the creation of the world’s lightest, most efficient and most compact high-
pressure pump. The Danfoss pumps, used in Danfoss Semco systems, are multi-axial pumps made in
corrosion resistant stainless steel. The unique design uses water as a lubricant, meaning that routine servicing
and replacing lubricants are is not needed. The pump is protected by a range of international patents and is
widely used in various segments. The pumps offer up to 95% energy efficiency and very low pulsation, thus
reducing noise.
Diesel pump systems will activate all pump/pumps will all
be started simultaneous. The diesel unit will keep the water
flow and pressure constant at the calculated design level. If
the flow is to high the surplus flow will be let back to
reservoir or to drain. The high pressure water mist system
remains activated until qualified staff or the fire brigade
manually shut off the system.
The pump unit is a single combined skid mounted package
consisting of the necessary amounts of pumps, manifolds,
control panel and eventual tank on the unit.
FIGURE 3.7. UNIQUE PUMP
Figure 3.8. SEM-SAFE® PUMP UNIT
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 14
Corrosion proof section valves
Danfoss Semco high-pressure valves are made from stainless steel
and are highly corrosion-proof and dirt resistant. Section valves are
supplied to the water mist fire fighting system in order to separate the
individual fire sections and/or providing alarms to the fire alarm
panel.
Section valves manufactured of stainless steel (AISI 316) for each of
the sections to be protected are supplied for installation into the pipe
system. A complete range with multiple functionalities is available for
all types of systems.
The valve design makes them very compact, for easy installation and
operation.
FIGURE 3.9. SECTION VALVE
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 15
3.2.2 Building Types protected with SEM-SAFE® High-Pressure Water Mist System
From complex fire fighting systems for museums, heritage sites, data centres, hotels, office buildings and
universities to a variety of industrial buildings, Danfoss Semco has built a successful track record using the
SEM-SAFE®
high-pressure water mist system.
Health Care Facilities
Clinics, senior care centres, hospitals
Data Centres
Offices and Shopping Centres
Including restaurants and bars
Hotels and Housing
Educational Institutions
Schools, universities
Cultural Institutions and Archives
Libraries, museums, archives
Industrial buildings
Food processing factories , cable tunnels, power plants, industrial
production
Infrastructure
Metro stations, train stations, airports, underground card parks
Special construction
Old churches, towers, old theatre buildings, wood-rood buildings,
wind mills, city halls, parliament houses
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 16
3.3. Description of other Fire Fighting Technologies
Whilst the reader of this manual may have a good understanding and the knowledge of working with the
technologies listed below, this section is meant as an aid to those Partners that do not traditionally trade in
these different technologies. It is also useful for those Partners that have recently recruited new members of
staff with varying degrees of knowledge and who can be new to the industry.
The following types of fire systems have been selected as they are representative of the most commonly used
and accepted technologies that will be encountered in the market place.
3.3.1 Sprinkler Systems
A sprinkler system is an active fire fighting method, consisting of a water supply system, providing adequate
pressure and flow rate to a water distribution piping system, onto which fire sprinklers are connected.
Sprinkler systems are intended to either control the fire or to suppress the fire.
Control Mode Sprinklers are intended to control the heat release rate of the fire to prevent building
structure collapse, and pre-wet the surrounding combustibles to prevent fire spread. The fire is not
extinguished until the burning combustibles are exhausted or by some form of manual intervention.
Suppression Mode Sprinklers, formerly known as Early Suppression Fast Response sprinklers, are
intended to result in a sudden reduction of the heat release rate of the fire, followed by extinguishment, prior
to manual intervention.
There are a number of different types of systems for various types of applications which are available for use,
which include wet pipe systems, dry pipe systems and alternate pipe systems, to name but a few.
The flow rate varies considerably, but on average, the typical flow rate per nozzle is 60 litres per minute at a
typical spacing of 3.5m x 3.5m.
Installation is with malleable iron fittings and carbon steel pipe.
Some typical sprinkler applications are: Commercial & public buildings, hospitals, schools, hotels etc.
3.3.2 Low-Pressure Water Mist Systems
Low-pressure water mist is a low (0-12 bar) and intermediate (12-32 bar) pressure technology, using either a
frangible bulb for closed nozzles or open deluge nozzles. The nozzles produce a mixture of large and small
droplets, with the fewer larger droplets entraining the smaller droplets into the fire plume. The lighter
droplets are drawn into the combustion zone by thermal air currents.
The flow rate varies considerably, but on average, the typical flow rate per nozzle is 24 litres to 80 litres per
minute at a spacing that varies from 3m × 3m to 4m × 4m.
The water storage supply is similar to sprinklers, but unlike sprinklers a water mist system requires a
dedicated pump due to the pressures required by the nozzles.
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 17
There are a number of options on the market for this type of system, but all have a limited degree of
approvals as they have tended to be developed by smaller companies.
Installation traditionally was with, and in some cases still is, through using copper pipe with press fittings. It
has become more common to use plastic pipe, though consideration needs to be made with protecting voids
that the pipe runs through.
Some typical applications for low-pressure water mist are: Schools, hotels, data centres, achieves, turbines,
care homes, generators etc.
3.3.3 Inert Gas Systems
The combustion process requires oxygen to be present and the amount of oxygen present will determine the
ferocity of the burning process. Under normal atmospheric conditions the level of oxygen present constitutes
around 21% of the air that we breathe.
Inert gas systems operate by oxygen depletion and will continue to sustain life, though breathing does
become deeper. Typically, the oxygen level is dropped below 15% which stops the combustion process
through oxygen depletion. If the oxygen level drops below 10%, the system becomes hazardous and has to be
locked off, to prevent a discharge whilst anyone is in the room. Standard procedure is to empty the room
from occupants and then release the gas system.
These systems utilize naturally occurring gases, which can be used in a blended combination, or on their
own, to maximize effectiveness, whilst providing a greener option environmentally.
The inert gas system with the trade name “INERGEN” is the most common and extensively used and
recognized as an efficient and environmentally friendly agent because it consists of inert gases that are
occurring naturally in the atmosphere. These gases are a mix of nitrogen, argon and carbon dioxide and work
on the principle of oxygen depletion.
“INERGEN” is widely used as a gaseous fire suppression agent within the banking and finance industry as
well as for data centres. Mainly because it is known to be very effective, safe for life, and environmentally
friendly whilst providing excellent fire protection for normally occupied critical areas.
HFC-227, Heptafluoropropane, is commonly referred to as FM200, but this is a trade name and is
manufactured by Great Lakes Chemical Corp. DuPont also manufacture this agent under the trade name FE-
227, and other Fire Suppression Companies often brand this gas under different trade names. FM200, when
discharged, is a colourless and odourless liquid.
FM200 extinguishes a fire primarily through physically cooling a fire at the molecular level. The Heat
Absorption occurs when the agent changes from a liquid to a vapour during discharge. In addition, FM200
also disrupts the combustion chain reaction which aids in the extinguishment of a fire. FM200 belongs to the
same class of agents used in refrigeration and as such, is efficient at removing the thermal energy from the
fire to the extent that the combustion process cannot sustain its self.
There are typically two types of systems:
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 18
Pre-Engineered System – These are simple systems that operate within a predetermined set of criteria and
are a quick and simple way of designing and costing a small project. They do not require a set of hydraulic
flow calculations and they are a fast, easy means of designing systems minimizes the engineering effort
required to design an effective system.
As long as nozzle selection, pipe size and pipe length limitations are adhered to, hydraulic flow calculations
are not required.
Engineered System – These systems are designed in accordance with the manufacturers design manual and
require a hydraulic calculation to be completed to validate the design. Most manufacturers have developed
their own hydraulic calculation and design software, which they issue to agents or distributers on completion
of their initial training course.
Typically, Engineered Systems are more complicated with elaborate piping systems that operate within a less
restrictive set of criteria than what is approved by third party agencies. These systems are designed within the
basic parameters that are outlined in the design manual, and their performance is evaluated through the
hydraulic calculation software. Most of these programs can accurately determine the expected performance
of the system when it is discharged.
Although FM200 is considered to be non-toxic, the EPA (Environemntal Protection Agency) has established
the guidelines controlling the amount (concentration) of agent provided for the protection of an area. Based
on PBPK modelling, the EPA allows FM200 for use where people are normally present (normally occupied
spaces) up to concentration of 10.5% by volume with exposure limited to 5 minutes or less.
Some typical application areas for inert gas are: Data centres, archives, data rooms etc.
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 19
3.4. Selling Against Other Technologies
When you know which technology you are competing against, please refer to the sections below above for a
quick overview, if you are not familiar with the technology. Please also note that you will find many of the
arguments and pictures used in this section in our general brochures.
3.4.1 Selling Against Sprinkler Systems
Conventional sprinkler systems have been around since the early 1900’s and are a tried and tested technology
that is effective and proven on many occasions that work. We must recognise and always acknowledge that
conventional sprinkler systems are very reliable and protects against fires.
One of the most important shortfalls of the sprinkler system is the secondary damage and loss in the
aftermath of a fire. Deep soaking and widespread water damage, furnishing and fabric may be ruined by
“black water” and considerable clean-up and business downtime is typically the case. In contrast, the water
mist system uses significantly less water. In addition, the majority of the water evaporates, causing much less
water damage to buildings, furniture, electrical installations, etc.
Another benefit of the water mist technology and lower water use is the reduction in down-time. Although
this is frequently used as an argument in production, it is equally important in office space and housing as the
cost of relocation can be reduced. For industrial companies the excessive down time means a high risk of
losing market share, which often results in a dramatic long-term negative economic effect, far in excess of
the original fire damage.
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 20
Statistics show that only 4 out of 10 industries are able to start manufacturing again after a major fire. In
industrial applications, the dramatic reduction in direct damage is of great value, but it is usually even more
important that the production line or factory will be able to resume manufacturing very quickly after the fire.
The higher distance (spacing) between the SEM-SAFE® water mist nozzles, compared to conventional
sprinklers, dramatically reduces the numbers of nozzles, pipes and fittings (up to 60%) thus giving reduced
installation time as well as coordination time between other services such as lights, ventilation ducts, cable
trays, pipes for other services etc. Our 5.5 metre spacing under CEN OH1 ~0.91 lpm/m2 should be compared
to 3.5 m for conventional sprinklers. Furthermore, the reduced number of nozzles and pipes, and their small
sizes, increases architectural freedom and reduces the need for storage space during installation.
In both retrofit installations and new buildings, the small pipe dimensions and ease of handling - due to the
low weight of the pipes - have proved to be a major benefit, making installation up to 70% faster. For retrofit
projects, our small diameter pipes and fittings and light weight system can fit in between floor or ceiling
voids. Small pipe diameters also mean less structural impact with wall penetrations and load points.
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 21
The majority of bends can be made by hand, while press fittings are used on the larger pipes. This means that
there is no need to X-ray welds, nor any space problems related to flanges, etc.
When installed, the weight of the water mist pipes, including water, will typically be 85% less than a
traditional sprinkler system.
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 22
TABLE 3.1. VALUE SELLING ARGUMENTS AGAINST TRADITIONAL SPRINKLERS
Focus on these points Value to customer
Higher spacing
Lower water consumption
Less down time
Easy to handle and integrate
Smaller water reservoir
Lower weight (address structural issues in retrofit)
Easier and quicker installation
Less secondary damage (for instance water damage)
Less risk of using market shares
Easier and quicker installation
Fewer challenges in building design (space required)
Cheaper building design
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 23
3.4.2 Selling Against LPWM Systems
A low-pressure water mist (LPWM) system is a water mist system operating at maximum 12.1 bar pressure
(according to NFPA750). One of the advantages of a LPWM system is lower cost for the equipment, mainly
due to the possible use of plastic, copper and galvanized pipe work and fittings. Pumps are also cheaper.
A disadvantage compared to HPWM is that the LPWM system uses up to 60% more water and can
potentially cause higher water damage during system activation. Again our current 5.5 metre spacing under
CEN OH1 ~0.91 lpm/m2 should be compared to 3 - 4 m for LPWM systems. Furthermore the LPWM nozzle
heads are only tested to limited ceiling heights.
The higher distance (spacing) between the SEM-SAFE® water mist nozzle heads compared to LPWM
systems reduces the numbers of nozzles thus giving reduced installation time as well as coordination time
between other services such as lights, ventilation ducts, cable trays, pipes for other services etc.
For LPWM systems there is a lack of approvals in place with the various manufacturers.
Compared to HPWM systems larger dedicated water sources are required, though it will be less than what
would be required for conventional sprinkler systems.
By the use of plastic and copper pipe work, corrosion is eliminated for LPWM systems just as it would be in
the case for HPWM systems, using stainless steel pipe & fittings.
Focus on these points Value to customer
Higher spacing
Lower water consumption
Smaller water reservoir
No need for multiple booster pumps in high rise
buildings or large systems
Our VdS and FM approvals
Easier installation
Less secondary damage (e.g. water damage)
Fewer challenges in building design (space required)
Simpler system
No risk in approval of system
TABLE 3.2. VALUE SELLING ARGUMENTS AGAINST LPWM SYSTEMS
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 24
3.4.3 Selling Against Inert Gas Systems
A significant difference between the HPWM and gas technology is that the protected space requires that all
doors are closed and the ventilation stops, but it still requires pressure venting because of the pressure
increase during release. The result is a more complex control system with actuators etc. Remember to
highlight this to the customer.
Re-ignition of a fire suppressed by a gaseous system may easily occur, if the enclosure is not tight or doors to
the enclosure are opened. Or it can happen due to lack of proper cooling of the burning materials. As water
mist both cools and removes oxygen, the temperature is quickly cooled to normal, resulting in quicker fire
fighting and avoiding re-ignition. Water mist maintains a low temperature over time, whereas the
temperature decreases slower with a gas based system.
Further it must be noted as a sales argument for water mist systems, that all cylinder based gaseous system
are only a “one shot” system! This means that there is not a second chance, if the fire is not suppressed after
the first discharge.
The water mist system is ready to use shortly after a fire. There is no need to isolate the room or to fill up
cylinders, meaning that production will be ready to re-start activities faster, saving substantial costs. Stress
that by using your technology, the customer has much shorter down time.
Finally the pump unit takes up little space compared with cylinders.
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 25
Focus on these points Value to customer
Simpler design and installation
No extra installation for back-up systems
Quicker cooling
Space saving
Cost savings and safety (fewer things can go wrong)
Space saving cost saving
Less damage
Easier installation and cost savings
TABLE 3.3. VALUE SELLING ARGUMENTS AGAINST GAS SYSTEMS
3.5. Quick Overview of Strengths and Weaknesses for Each Technology
When you have identified the competing companies and technologies for a specific project, there are two
ways of preparing yourself for the sales presentation and negotiations to follow. First of all you need to
understand the strength and weaknesses of the different technologies. To help you we have prepared an
overview in the table below. Although this is only a brief overview, it will provide you with a general
insight.
The second area of preparation is that you need to understand exactly how the Danfoss Semco HPWM
solution compares with other technologies and water based competitors and how you can use this
information to improve your success rate. In the table below we have listed key strengths and weaknesses for
competition fire protection technologies. Although the applicability of these strengths and weaknesses differs
from country to country, we hope they can serve as guidelines.
Strengths Weaknesses
Gas Can be environmentally friendly
Low ozone impact (inert gas only)
Low post discharge clean-up costs
Low installation cost
Well recognized (approvals)
Long track record
Requires pressure venting
Cylinder storage – larger footprint
Refill costs
Cylinder weights
Some can be environmentally unfriendly
Requires room integrity
Maintenance cost
Sprinklers World-wide recognized approvals in place
Standards in place
Recognized worldwide technology
Water damage due to high flow rates
High cost post discharge clean-up
Space required for reservoir
PRODUCT AND TECHNOLOGY DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV .3 PAGE 26
Strengths Weaknesses
Equipment costs are low High maintenance costs
Special sprinklers and additional detection
for activation
Potential corrosion of pipe work and heavy
discoloration of water (black water)
Lower nozzle spacing
System weight
LPWM No structural constrains
Low equipment cost
Reduced water reservoir footprint (still larger
than HPWM)
Power consumption can be lower than other
technologies
Water damage due to high flow rates
Restricted height operations
Potential corrosion of pipe work and water
discoloration
HPWM High level of atomization
Small equipment footprint
Reduced water reservoir footprint
No corrosion of pipe work
Effective glass cooling
No structural constrains
Double extinguishing effect
Installation costs can be lower due to smaller
piping
No additional technology is necessary when
using HPWM system, which means lower
costs for maintenance and after sales services
Harmless to electrical equipment
Equipment costs can be higher, due to
higher quality materials used (for example
stainless steel for pipes)
The technology is not so well known
Power consumption can be higher
TABLE 3.4. TECHNOLOGY COMPARISON
Chapter 4
High-Pressure Water Mist Competitors
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 28
4. High-Pressure Water Mist Competitors
Within the high-pressure water mist market, there are a number of companies that operate across the various
market segments. When looking at our focus segment “Commercial and Public Buildings”, our market share
and approvals in place, our main competitors within the European land based market are Marioff and Fogtec.
4.1. Marioff
Marioff is a provider of water mist fire protection systems for land and marine. Founded in 1985 and
headquartered in Vantaa, Finland. They were acquired by UTC (United Technologies – a large US based
conglomerate within the fire fighting business) in 2009. They currently employ 400 people worldwide and
have an approximate turnover of EUR 102Million with an EBIT of EUR 15Million. (Figures are from
Marioff 2014 Annual Report and may not reflect end user sales through subsidiaries or UTC sales offices).
Compared to Danfoss Semco figures, this figure includes pipes, hoses, installation etc.
Marioff has a global network of subsidiaries and distributors, providing installation and commissioning
assistance as well as service and maintenance backup. Marioff network of subsidiaries covers: Australia,
Austria, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Brazil, Canada, Chile, China, Colombia, Czech Republic, Egypt, Estonia,
Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Indonesia, Italy, Kuwait, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand,
Norway, Oman, Peru, Poland, Portugal, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Singapore, Slovakia, Slovenia, South
Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, The Netherlands, Turkey, Ukraine, United Arab Emirates,
United Kingdom, United States and Vietnam.
Within the land segment, Marioff covers almost all application areas including buildings (hotels, cultural
heritage sites, data centre, hospitals, prisons and detention centres, aircraft hangers, office buildings),
transportation (road tunnels, rolling stock, underground stations), and industry and energy (gas turbines, wind
turbines, diesel generators, steam turbines, manufacturing plant, cable tunnels).
Marioff is the market leader in both the land and marine segment. Their product called HI-FOG® was
launched in the early 1990s. Marioff promotes their high-pressure water mist system with the payoff:
“Protecting people, property and business continuity”.
Approvals
Marioff has carried out far more test than any other manufacturers and holds a vast amount of approvals and
certificates, both approvals by well-recognized approval bodies and project related fire tests. They have their
own accredited test facility which provides a great advantage in relation to the availability in making fire
tests and also towards customers and their perception of the company as a serious and important player.
Marioff also has many successful references in the market which shows high skills and know-how along with
well proven solutions.
Marketing
Marioff is very strong within marketing and has an abundance of technical specifications, brochures and
videos. Depending on the venue they will exhibit under their own name in a separate booth or will be part of
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 29
a larger UTC stand. As they were the pioneer within HPWM their brand “Hi-Fog” has become a synonym
for any water mist system”
Sales Channels
Marioff’s network of subsidiaries in their largest markets can give them an advantage in having only one
connecting link to the customer, resulting in easier access to market information. The use of subsidiaries can
give Marioff a cost advantage because mark up on mark up when using distributors often results in a more
expensive product. On the other hand, when using subsidiaries, Marioff is more vulnerable if they cannot
keep the manning in activity. In addition Marioff has no other products to cover their fixed costs.
Marioff requires that their partners purchase pipes and fittings from them – regardless of price. This gives the
partners less flexibility and can make Marioff less competitive due to high pipe and fitting prices.
Marioff acts very aggressively in the market. Strategically they drop prices in certain highly competitive
markets or projects for a period of time, meanwhile keeping high prices in markets with less competition.
This provides Marioff with the strength of keeping or entering attractive segments and keeping competitors
out. However, in general Marioff is known to have a superior behavior, meaning that Marioff strongly
believe that they hold the only “real” option on the market. Being the market leader – a strong no. 1 also
contributes to this attitude.
Recently Marioff has reduced or closed their subsidiaries and moved sales into the UTC organization. We
believe this will create an opportunity for Danfoss Semco and their partners as focus is drawn away from the
HPWM business.
System Components
Marioff has a stand-alone cylinder based Gas Pump Unit (GPU). One of their strong selling points is that the
stand alone system provide up to 150 lpm – but it is a one shot system. The footprint is also large when
covering protected area for 60 minutes. Marioff has also developed a smoke scrubbing system for IT rooms,
for removing corrosive gases and smoke. Although we state that smoke scrubbing is a general effect of water
mist, Marioff has developed a specific system where they put a plastic pipe in the floor that has nozzles in
and holes in the pipe. When the system operates, the nozzles in the pipe create a negative pressure, pulling
the mist from the room into the pipe.
Although the Danfoss Semco and Marioff systems are similar in design, there are a number of areas where
our system stands out. The three most important areas are: Pump Unit design, nozzle design, and spacing.
Marioff uses check valves at the nozzle head which can be an advantage during service but opposite it makes
it possible for unauthorized persons to remove nozzles without having system alarm. In addition, not having
the largest nozzle spacing in the market is a disadvantage as the installation and material will be more
expensive.
Marioff uses cut ring connections which can result in leakage problems; this is especially a problem in
connection with suspended ceilings where access to fittings is strongly limited.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 30
Marioff’s electrical pump unit design is technically heavier; it contains more components e.g. gear boxes,
pneumatic driven pilot pump, water/dirt separator and oil lubricated piston pumps. The higher complexity
means higher risk of break down during operation and as access to the individual components is more
difficult, it also results in more expensive service.
The Marioff pump unit is approximately the same physical size and weight for the 6 pump unit. But when
more pumps are needed, our modular build up will allow us to use less space for the extra pumps, whereas
Marioff will need the double footprint – even if only one extra pump is needed.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 31
Marioff’s Strengths in Short
Description of Strengths
COMPANY
Well-established company – First mover and strong relationship with authorities to influence
regulations and legislation according to their own needs to keep competitors out
Part of UTC (strong/financial resources)
Invest heavily in sales and business development
Very aggressive in the market; Strategically they drop prices in certain highly competitive markets or
projects for a period of time to keep competitors from entering. Meanwhile they keep high prices in
markets with less competition
They control a large part of the value chain (engineering design, sales, marketing, pipes and fitting
production and installation)
MARKETING
Strong focus on marketing which results in high quality technical specifications, brochures and videos
Their branding is very strong. “Hi-Fog” has almost become a synonym for any water mist system
They have one page data sheets on conducted tests
SALES CHANNELS
They use subsidiaries as sales channels in the largest markets – easier access to market information.
Recently they are also using UTC sales force
APPROVALS
Most approvals in market, both approvals by well-recognised approval bodies and project specific fire
tests
Own fire test facilities
Most successful references in market (high skills/Know-How/well-proved solutions)
SYSTEM COMPONENTS
Technical specifications for water mists systems are often done by Marioff which they proactively
makes advantage of by specifying unique systems that only Marioff can offer (keeps the competitors
out)
They use check valves at the nozzle head which can be an advantage during service
Their product range includes GPU and smoke scrubbing system
Their nozzle range include nozzles with low flow and high ceiling height
TABLE 4.1. DESCRIPTION OF STRENGHTS FOR MARIOFF
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 32
Marioff’s Weaknesses in Short
Description of Weaknesses
COMPANY
Part of UTC – an American company – that holds a top-down management, hereby giving Marioff less
flexibility. Top managements changed frequently resulting in no consistency in direction
Acts as no.1 and the only one in the market. Arrogant behaviour towards customers
SALES CHANNELS
They require partners to purchase pipes and fittings from them
SYSTEM COMPONENTS
Not the highest nozzle spacing in the market
Technically a more complex design; more components and gear boxes
Oil lubricated pumps – hence more maintenance
They use check valves which makes it possible for unauthorized persons to remove nozzles without
having system alarm
Uses cut ring connections which can result in leakage problems
TABLE 4.2. DESCRIPTION OF WEAKNESSES FOR MARIOFF
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 33
Strengths • Strong IPR - claim 1300 patents filed/ 700 granted
• Innovative product development/high perceived spend on R&D Strong
approvals
• Wide range of nozzles – sprinkler & deluge
• Pump units:
• Diesel (DPU)
• Electric (SPU/MSPU)
• Gas (GPU)
• Declining pressure cylinder system MAU
• Initial focus on marine but successfully entered land based market
Products/Markets • Pioneered commercialisation of HPWM in 1990s
• Strong positioning
• Hi-Fog brand
• Strong market share in land based applications
• Best in class reference list
• Lower prices for huge projects
• GPU
Weaknesses • Centralised design
• Difficult to integrate UTC
• UTC limit aggressive sales tactics
• Nozzle coverage less than CEN nozzle for OH1 application
• Higher cost for the pump unit
• Arrogant
• Departure of several employees and partners
Competitive
Position
• Market leader w/ dominant position/market share
Approvals Please refer to the competitor approval matrix (chapter 4.5)
TABLE 4.3. SUMMARY MARIOFF ANALYSIS
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 34
4.2. Fogtec
FOGTEC Brandschutz GmbH & Co. KG was founded in 1997 and unites the water mist businesses of
Lechler (nozzle manufacturer) and KAMAT (manufacturer of high pressure water systems). The main
shareholders of both companies also own shares in Fogtec. Fogtec is a provider of fixed and mobile high-
pressure water mist fire fighting equipment, and has headquarters in Cologne, Germany. They currently have
100 employees worldwide. Their sales are estimated to be around EUR 25Million. They have great difficulty
in making an acceptable profit after the Eurotunnel project in 2010 and 2011. EBT has been around EUR
0.1Million the past two years (2013+2014). In promoting their product, Fogtec uses the pay-off “The smarter
way of fire fighting”
Their route to market is via a network of sales office and distributors in Austria, France, South-East Asia,
Middle East and China. In Germany, Fogtec tend to deliver and also install the projects themselves (and not
via distributors) to the end clients.
For many years, Fogtec has had a strong focus on the tunnel and rail systems. Besides this, Fogtec also has
references in the industrial, public and commercial market in applications such as: Archives, libraries, cable
tunnels, clean rooms, machinery, control and wall cabinets, conveyer belts, engine test cells, flammable
liquid stores, gas turbines, IT areas, industrial fryers, metro stations, museums, public buildings, residential
homes, hotels, hospitals, transformers, and wind power plants.
Fogtec have numerous third party type approvals and also have a number of certificates for various
applications. In 2006 they completed the SOLIT 2 (Safety of Life in Tunnels) fire testing, which gives them
a strong position in this segment of the water mist market. Fogtec has VdS OH1 and OH3, flammable liquid
and FM machinery space approvals. Fogtec tend to make project specific fire tests – often out of their own
accredited test facilities IFAB.
Approvals
Fogtec is strong on patents; they hold 111 international patents or patent applications. For the time being they
choose to send in more applications compared to the competitors.
Fogtec has their own test facilities - Institute For Applied Fire Safety Research “IFAB” which is responsible
for the test facilities.
Fogtec has a wide range of references within most segments. One of their important references is the
EUROTUNNEL project.
Sales Channels
Fogtec has a strong network of sales offices.
System Components
Fogtec has smart nozzle socket. As sealing is on the nozzle, it is very easy to weld. It is also not a problem to
twist the nozzle into the socket, even in a case where a suspended ceiling allows no access from the side. (in
DS we have to add point welding against twisting and remove o-ring before welding). This gives Fogtec a
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 35
cost advantage in connection with installation. The disadvantage of the nozzle is that it does not provide the
largest spacing. In addition Fogtec has soft starter and phase failure as standard equipment on the pump unit.
Technical features such as manual operating switches on the control cabinet are standard for pumps and
jockey pumps. This enables the user to manually operate the pumps equipment in addition to enabling easier
filling of the system the by jockey pump.
Fogtec’s section valves are compressed air motorized valves which gives a big safety advantage, they are,
however, more expensive.
The Fogtec pump unit is normally constructed with separate water break tanks in plastic, so the pump unit
and the break tank will, all together, take up more space in the pump room. Fogtec also make use of oil
lubricated piston pumps which calls for more maintenance in comparison with water lubricated pumps like
the Danfoss Semco pump.
Fogtec’s strengths in short
Description of Strengths
COMPANY
Strong in their home market Germany
Specialists in the transportation and tunnel segment – their target segment
Handles all areas of tunnel projects themselves
Wide range of references within most segments
Important reference in EUROTUNNEL
SALES CHANNELS
Strong network of distributors – represented in many countries
APPROVALS
Strong on patents (they hold 111 international patents or patent applications. For the time being they
choose to send in more applications than the competitors)
Various project specific fire tests and third party approvals
Own test facilities
SYSTEM COMPONENTS
Smart nozzle socket – easy welding
Jockey pump has a manual operating switch on pump control panel which makes filling of system by
jockey pump simple
Section valves are compressed air motorized valves which gives a big safety advantage
TABLE 4.4. DESCRIPTION OF STRENGHTS FOR FOGTEC
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 36
Fogtec’s Weaknesses in Short
Description of Weaknesses
COMPANY
Relatively small company – may find difficulties to finance the extremely expensive full scale fire test
in order to obtain further certification and approvals – poor financial performance
APPROVALS
Not so many type approvals
TECHNICAL PERFORMANCE
Not the highest nozzle spacing in the market
Uses oil lubricated pumps – more maintenance
Large Pump unit footprint
Expensive section valves and pump unit
TABLE 4.5. DESCRIPTION OF WEAKNESSES FOR FOGTEC
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 37
Strengths • Wide range of nozzles – sprinkler & deluge
• Pump units:
• Diesel
• Electric
• Close working relationship with Lechler
• Declining pressure cylinder system
• New nozzles OH1/OH3 VDS approved
Products/Markets • Distributes via independent fire protection companies
• Strong references in the tunnel market.
• New VDS approvals
• Expertise in land based applications – witnessed fire tests
• Establish brand name & focus on brand development
• Proven technology
• Strong reference list
Weaknesses • Limited recognised land based approvals
• Limited nozzle coverage for OH applications
• Prices
• Pump unit (old design)
Approvals Please refer to the competitor approval matrix (chapter 4.5)
TABLE 4.6. SUMMARY FOGTEC ANALYSIS
4.3. Other Water Mist Competitors- Short Description
The product range of other water mist competitors also includes low pressure. Some of them offer both high
pressure and low pressure.
Minimax GmbH with its head office in Bad Oldesloe and a branch office in Bad Urach was founded in
1991. Minimax has a turnover of close to €1 billion and employs more than 6,000 people. 30 companies
worldwide are members of the Minimax group - in Europe, Eastern Europe, Asia, USA, South America and
the Middle East.
Since 1993, Minimax has developed and installed high-pressure and low-pressure water mist extinguishing
systems under the “Minifog” brand name with the payoff “Always a step ahead” for a wide range of
applications within marine and land.
The range of land applications for which the “Minifog EconAqua” (building protection) water mist sprinkler
system can be used is as defined in the VdS guidelines for sprinkler systems (VdS CEA 4001). These include
fire hazard classes LH, OH1 (which do not involve risks to production) and OH2 (only multi-storey car parks
and underground garages). Typical applications: Public buildings, care facilities, offices, railway stations and
underground garages.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 38
The system approvals of VdS and FM include engine rooms and turbine enclosures and their auxiliaries as
defined in FM 5560, up to a volume of 2,430 m³ and a height of 13.5 m. (high-pressure water mist)
Strengths • Wide range of nozzles – sprinkler & deluge
• FM approvals
• VDS approvals
Products/Markets • FM approvals
• VDS approvals
Weaknesses • No knowledge about water mist
• No communication internally
• Section valve size
• Econ aqua = sprinkler light
Approvals Please refer to the competitor approval matrix (chapter 4.5)
TABLE 4.7.SUMMARY MINIMAX ANALYSIS
Ultra Fog AB is located in Gothenburg, Sweden. As of December 13, 2010, Ultra Fog operates as a
subsidiary of the Italian fire protection company CATEF srl. The main activities are moved to Poland. There
are very few activities left in Sweden now.
Today Ultra Fog AB has less than 20 employees who are all working at the office in the north of Gothenburg
in Sweden. The turnover of Ultra Fog in 2014 rose dramatically to EUR 10Million due to large cruise ship
orders in Italy.
Ultra Fog AB cooperates with a number of distributors for industrial and commercial market in Germany,
Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, Taiwan, UK, USA, Philippines, Czech Republic, Korea, and Finland. In UK,
Italy and US Ultrafog has sales offices.
The HPWM system from Ultra Fog is a product that is sold worldwide. Ultrafog’s largest market is in marine
applications, especially in Southern Europe, USA and Asia, but land applications become more common for
them.
They use their company name as brand name and the payoff “Saves lives and reduce material damage”.
Ultra Fog HPWM system is mainly used in smaller applications such offices and homes, industries, computer
rooms, transformers, deep fat fryers and turbines. It also addresses facades and roofs on old wooden
buildings like churches in Sweden. Ultra Fog HPWM system is mainly approved according to IMO marine
standards and their main focus the last few years has been large cruise ships.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 39
Strengths • Wide range of nozzles – sprinkler & deluge
• Pump units:
• Diesel
• Electric
• Declining pressure cylinder system
• NEW FM approval for machinery spaces
Products/Markets • Marine approvals
• Expertise in land based applications – witnessed fire tests
• Expertise in marine applications
• Proven technology (pump unit)
• Sprinkler can be tested easily
• Well known in Scandinavia/UK
• OH4 test report
Weaknesses • Limited recognised land based approvals
• Limited nozzle coverage for OH applications
• Pump unit
Approvals Please refer to the competitor approval matrix (chapter 4.5)
TABLE 4.8. SUMMARY ANALYSIS ULTRAFOG
Aquasys was founded in 1993 and it is based in Linz in Upper Austria. It is part of the of the HAINZL
group, which handles fluid, automation and building technology. Aquasys is represented in the following
locations: Belgium, Croatia, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Luxemburg, Poland, Russia,
Spain, Switzerland, The Netherlands, United Kingdom, United Arab Emirates, Asia, USA and Latin
America.
In promoting their company and products, Aquasys uses the payoff “Your safety deserves responsibility” or
“fire fighting is responsibility”.
Aquasys uses a high-pressure water mist system. They target segments such as commercial buildings,
tunnels, industry, tunnels and rails. In 2002 they received accreditation for water mist tunnel systems.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 40
Strengths • Wide range of nozzles – sprinkler & deluge
• Pump units:
• Diesel
• Electric
• VDS approval OH1/OH3, cables tunnel
Products/Markets • Distributes via independent fire protection companies
• Cegelec, Uxello
• Strong references in French/Belgium market for Data Center (BNP)
• Expertise in land based applications – witnessed fire tests
• Proven technology
• Well known in Germany/Austria/Holland/Belgium
Weaknesses • Limited recognised land based approvals
• Limited nozzle coverage for OH applications
• Prices
• Pump unit
• No FM approval
Approvals Please refer to the competitor approval matrix (chapter 4.5)
TABLE 4.9. SUMMARY AQUASYS ANALYSIS
4.4. Positioning map
Across the water mist market there are many manufacturers that claim to have a leading position. When
looking at our competition, we have to consider the current approvals they have in place and market share. If
we take Marioff as having the largest share and the manufacturer with the most approvals in place, we are
able to position other manufacturers in relation to where Marioff is.
Together with Fogtec we see ourselves a strong No. 2 on the European market. Below is our view of how the
most commonly known competitors are positioned within the current market place in relation to approvals
and market share.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 41
FIGURE 4.1. ESTIMATED POSTION MAP EUROPE 2016
The axis represents the extremes of the competitive landscape, using market share and approvals as the
criteria.
By market share we have taken into account estimated sales volume.
By certification and approvals we have taken into account the level of current approvals each manufacturer
has.
When looking at the above positioning map, there are a cluster of competing companies, which have been
relatively successful over the years, also with limited approvals in place.
Marioff has recognized approvals and third party project related tests across all of the market segments. They
have by far the most certification and third party approvals in place and have an extensive reference list for
their Hi-Fog product.
Danfoss Semco has a second position in the European market when looking at approvals and market share.
Danfoss Semco has made significant investment in VdS and FM approvals. The aim is to obtain a better
position in the competitive landscape, from an approval point of view, but also to generate a steady increase
in the market share within the public and commercial segment.
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 42
Very close to Danfoss Semco, when it comes to market share is Fogtec. They have numerous third party
project related tests for various applications and operate across similar market segments like Marioff and
Danfoss Semco. Fogtec’s main segment is transportation and public space.
Looking at this figure, and understanding the various positions and approvals of the other players, our
ambition is to solidify our second place in the European market using the VdS and FM approvals and
challenge Marioff as the market leader. The positioning map has to be seen as a dynamic landscape. We
show how much Danfoss Semco has progressed within the past year and our goal for the future. But also our
competitors have an aggressive strategy, both product and market wise, meaning that their position is
changing. However, with limited market information, it is difficult to see the competitors’ exact status in the
competitive landscape. Therefore the positioning map has to be seen as a guideline for a better visualisation
of how we place ourselves in comparison with competitors.
4.5. Competitor approval matrix
Approvals
DA
NF
OS
S
SE
MC
O
MA
RIO
FF
FO
GT
EC
AQ
UA
SY
S
MIN
IMA
X
UL
TR
AF
OG
VDS OH1 office
VDS OH1 rooms
VDS Suspended ceilings and false floors
VDS hotel VDS OH2 Garage VDS OH3
VDS Machinery space < 260 m³
VDS Machinery space > 260 m³
VDS Cable tunnels
VDS Protection of stocks and production sites
with flammable liquids
VDS Paint booths
VDS for local application
VDS for protection of presses and machines
UL OH1
FM HC1
FM Protection of Data Processing Equipment
Rooms/Halls – Above-Floor Protection
HP WATER MIST COMPETITORS DESCRIPTION MAY 2016 REV. 3 PAGE 43
Approvals
DA
NF
OS
S
SE
MC
O
MA
RIO
FF
FO
GT
EC
AQ
UA
SY
S
MIN
IMA
X
UL
TR
AF
OG
FM Protection of Data Processing Equipment
Rooms/Halls – Below-Floor Protection Local
Application Design
FM Protection of Data Processing Equipment
Rooms/Halls – Below-Floor Protection
FM Machinery space < 260 m³
FM Machinery space > 260 m³
FM Steam turbine < 260 m³³
FM Steam turbine> 260 m³³
FM for local application
FM for protection of Industrial Oil Cookers
FM for protection of Wet Benches
FM for protection of continuous wood board
presses
CEN OH1 office
TABLE 4.10. COMPETITOR APPROVAL MATRIX
Chapter 5
Where to Play and Why
2
3
Incre
asin
g lik
elih
ood o
f success
Decreasing competition
A
B
E
D
C