sc, no need to invite public tenders for strategic defence equipment

8/20/2019 SC, No Need to Invite Public Tenders for Strategic Defence Equipment

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sc-no-need-to-invite-public-tenders-for-strategic-defence-equipment 1/15

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. 3193 OF 2006

UNION OF INDIA & ANR. ..Appella!"

Ve#"$"

H%L NIFE POER S'STEMS LTD. ..Re"p()e!

J U D * M E N T

R. BANUMATHI, J.

T+," appeal a""a,l" !+e (#)e# )a!e) 2-.10.200 pa""e)

/ !+e H,+ C($#! ( Del+, all(, !+e appeal , LPA N(.2445 (

200 !+e#e/ ),#e!, !+e U,( ( I),a !( ,""$e a a)7e#!,"e8e!

, lea), e"pape#" +a7, ,)e ,#$la!,( ,7,!, !e)e#" (#

!+e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" 8e!,(, !+e )e!a,le) !e+,al

"pe,,a!,(" a) !+e appella!" !( (",)e# all !+e p#()$!" +,+

8ee! !+e !e+,al "pe,,a!,(" a) !+e#e/ p#(ee) !( "ele! !+e

/e"! p#()$! , a(#)ae ,!+ la.

2. T+e "$/e!:8a!!e# ,7(l7e) , !+e p#e"e! a"e ,"

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" #e;$,#e) (# !+e I),a Na7. I),a Na7 +a"

!+#ee !pe" ( "$/8a#,e" (# +,+ !+#ee ),e#e! !pe" (

1

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

/a!!e#,e" a#e $"e). Tpe:I /a!!e# (# E<M "$/8a#,e"= Tpe:II

/a!!e# (# SS< la"" "$/8a#,e" a) Tpe:III /a!!e# (# F(>!#(!

la"" "$/8a#,e". I,!,all= !+e"e /a!!e#,e" e#e ,8p(#!e) #(8 !+e

O#,,al E;$,p8e! Ma$a!$#e#. I 7,e ( !+e #e$##,

#e;$,#e8e! ( !+e /a!!e#,e"= "$/"e;$e!l a )e,",( a" !a?e !(

p#(#e"" !+e,# ,),e,"a!,(. D,#e!(# *ee#al @$al,! A""$#ae

D*@AB (#?, $)e# !+e M,,"!# ( Deee +a" a )e!a,le)

p#(e)$#e !( )e7el(p,),e,"e #,!,al ,!e8""pa#e". A" pe# !+e

"a,) p#(e)$#e= !+e *(7e#8e! ,)e!,,e" !+e p("",/le 7e)(#" a)

a""e""e" !+e,# apa,!!e+,al ;$al,,a!,(" a) !+e#ea!e# a

)e7el(p8e! (#)e# ," plae) ( !+e p#(p("e) "$ppl,e#. D$#, !+,"

pe#,() ( )e7el(p8e! ( !+e "pa#e"= !+e *(7e#8e! a##,e" ($!

#e$la# ,"pe!,( a) !+e p#()$! ," )e7el(pe) $)e# !+e ae," (

(,,al" ( !+e Deee M,,"!# a) (,e#" ( !+e D*@A a#e

a""(,a!e) !+#($+($! !+e )e7el(p8e! p#(e"" #,+! #(8 !+e !,8e

( "($#, ( #a 8a!e#,al" !( e"$#e !+a! !+e p#()$! (! (l

8ee!" !+e !e+,al ;$al,,a!,(" /$! ," $ll #el,a/le a) #ee #(8

a e##(#" , a!$al pe#(#8ae.

3. % (ll(, !+e a/(7e #,(#($" p#(e)$#e=

M". S!a)a#) %a!!e#,e" L!). a" )e7el(pe) a" a ,),e($"

8a$a!$#e# (# "$ppl, Tpe:III "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e".

2

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

M". S!a)a#) %a!!e#,e" L!). a" "$/"e;$e!l )e7el(pe) a" a

8a$a!$#e# ( Tpe:I "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" , !+e ea# 1955.

M". E>,)e I)$"!#,e" L!). a" )e7el(pe) a" a ,),e($"

8a$a!$#e# ( Tpe:II "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" , 1959. I !+e ea#

1995= M". S!a)a#) %a!!e#,e" L!). "(l) ,!" /$",e"" !( M". E>,)e

I)$"!#,e" L!). S,e !+e= M". E>,)e I)$"!#,e" L!). +a" /e(8e

a ",le 7e)(# , "$ppl, /a!!e#,e" (# all !+#ee la""e" (

"$/8a#,e" !( !+e I),a Na7. O,e#" ( D*@A a#e ("!a!l

a""(,a!e) ,!+ !+e 8a$a!$#, ( !+e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" ,

E>,)e I)$"!#,e" L!). a" a) +e !+e a#e #e;$,#e) / !+e I),a

Na7. A" M". E>,)e I)$"!#,e" L!). +a" /e(8e !+e ",le 7e)(#=

, 2004= *(7e#8e! "!a#!e) e>pl(#, !+e p("",/,l,! ( )e7el(p,

a(!+e# "$ppl,e# a" "e() "($#e (# "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e". %$! a"

pe# !+e p(l,= !+e *(7e#8e! a(! #e,"!e# a(e (# "$ppl (

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" ,!+($! (ll(, !+e p#(e)$#e (# p$!!, !+e

7e)(# !+#($+ !+e p#(e"" ( !+e )e7el(p8e!. I a e7e!= !+e

#e;$,#e8e! ( !+e "$pe#7,",( ( D*@A , )e7el(p8e! ( !+e

p#()$! a) !+,#!ee ;$al,! !e"!" ,!e)e) !( !e"! "$/8a#,e

/a!!e#,e" ($l) e7e# /e ),"pe"e) ,!+.

4. T+e #e"p()e! 8a)e ,!" #ep#e"e!a!,( , O!(/e#

2004 !( !+e M,,"!# ( Deee la,8, !+a! ,! +a) )e7el(pe)

3

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a) !+a! !+e a#e $)e# ,!e#al e7al$a!,(.

O 31.03.200= !+e #e"p()e! #e;$e"!e) !+e M,,"!# ( Deee

(# a )e7el(p8e! (#)e# "( !+a! !+e #e"p()e! a /e )e7el(pe) a"

!+e "e() "($#e ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a) !+e #e"p()e!

a#ee) !( $)e#( "!#,e! !e"!" /e(#e ,! ($l) /e #e,"!e#e) (#

"$ppl, !+e p#()$!. A" !+e #e",)$al l,e ( !+e e>,"!, /a!!e#,e"

a" (8, !( a e)= , J$l 200= !+e *(7e#8e! +a" /ee

p#(e"", !+e #e;$e"! / !+e Na7 !( p$#+a"e "$/8a#,e

/a!!e#,e". S,e (l M". E>,)e I)$"!#,e" L!). a" !+e !+e (l

app#(7e) "$ppl,e# ( all !pe" ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"= ,! a"

p#(p("e) !( ,""$e Re;$e"! F(# P#(p("al RFPB !( M". E>,)e

I)$"!#,e" L!). al(e a) !+e Deee M,,"!e# a7e app#(7al !(

,""$e RFP !( M". E>,)e I)$"!#,e" L!). (# "$ppl, ele7e "e!" (

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e".

. Re"p()e! ,le) #,! pe!,!,( /e(#e !+e Del+, H,+

C($#! ( 1-.09.200 la,8, !+a! ,! "+($l) /e ,""$e) a #e;$e"! (#

p#(p("al a" ell= a" ,! a" #e,"!e#e) (# "(8e (!+e# p#()$!"

a8el !(#pe)( /a!!e#,e". %e ,! (!e) !+a! !+e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"

la,8e) !( +a7e /ee )e7el(pe) / !+e #e"p()e! e#e e,!+e#

)e7el(pe) $)e# !+e ae," ( !+e D*@A (# !+e *(7e#8e! pa,)

(# )e7el(p8e! ( !+e p#(!(!pe ell". T+e lea#e) S,le J$)e

4

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

7,)e (#)e# )a!e) 0.10.200 ),"8,""e) !+e #,! pe!,!,( (/"e#7,

!+a! , !+e e>!a! p(l, e7,"ae" "ele!,( (# "+(#!l,"!, ( a pa#!

(# p$#p("e" ( #a,", a )e7el(p8e! ,)e! (# a al!e#a!,7e

,),e($" "($#e ( e;$,p8e!= !+," "!ae 8$"! /e "$e""$ll

#(""e) /e(#e 7e!$#, $#!+e# ,!( !+e ,""$ae ( #e;$e"! (#

p#(p("al a) !+e#ea!e# ,""$ae ( a PAC. T+e lea#e) S,le

J$)e $#!+e# +el) !+a! p#($#e8e! 8e!+() a" a p(l, 8a!!e#

a) !+e p(l, ),) (! "$e# #(8 a ,lleal,! a) , a e7e!=

!+e p(l, +a" (! /ee +allee) / !+e #e"p()e! , !+e #,!

pe!,!,(. A#,e7e) / ),"8,""al ( !+e #,! pe!,!,(= !+e #e"p()e!

,le) LPA N(.2445200 +,+ a" all(e) 7,)e !+e ,8p$e)

$)8e! )a!e) 2-.10.200 a) !+e H,+ C($#! ,""$e) ),#e!,("

!( !+e M,,"!# ( Deee !( p#($#e e7e !+e #,!,al "pa#e pa#!"

l,?e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" (l a!e# ,""$, a)7e#!,"e8e! a)

all, (# (pe !e)e#. A""a,l, !+e ,8p$e) $)8e!= !+e

appella!:U,( ( I),a +a" p#ee##e) !+," appeal.

6. M". P,? Aa)= lea#e) A)),!,(al S(l,,!(# *ee#al

( I),a al(,!+ M#. @a)#, appea#, (# !+e appella!"

(!e)e) !+a! +,le !e)e# ," ,""$e) (# (88( $"e ,!e8"=

p$#+a"e ( "pe,al,e) a) #,!,al "pa#e pa#!" (# !+e Deee

M,,"!# a(! /e )(e / a (pe !e)e# a) , !+e ,"!a! a"e=

5

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

!+e#e e#e $"!,,a/le #ea"(" (# !+e *(7e#8e! !( la"",

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a" #,!,al a) "pe,al,e) )eee p#()$! a)

!( p#($#e !+e "a8e (l #(8 !+("e "$ppl,e#" +( +a7e )e7el(pe)

!+e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" $)e# !+e ae," ( D*@A a) a#e )$l

app#(7e)#e,"!e#e) ,!+ D*@A. I! a" "$/8,!!e) !+a! , #ela!,(

!( e""e!,al )eee "$ppl,e"#,!,al "pa#e pa#!"= !+e *(7e#8e!

8$"! e"$#e !+a! !+e "$ppl,e# +a" !+e ee""a# !e+,al

;$al,,a!,("= ,#a"!#$!$#e a) apa,! !( )e7el(p !+e p#()$!

a) , #,!,al "pa#e pa#!" l,?e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"= !+e

*(7e#8e! a(! p$! !+e l,e ( ,!" )eee pe#"(el a)

"$/8a#,e (#!+ "e7e#al #(#e" ( #$pee" !( #,"? ",8pl /ea$"e

!+e #e"p()e! la,8" !( +a7e !+e apa/,l,!. I! a" "$/8,!!e) !+a!

!+e H,+ C($#! a" (! #,+! , ),#e!, !+e *(7e#8e! (#

,""$, !e)e#" (# #,!,al "pa#e pa#!" l,?e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"

,!+($! ?(, +e!+e# !+e "a,) p#()$! a ,!+"!a) all !+e

!+,#!ee ;$al,! !e"!" a) #e)e# #el,a/le pe#(#8ae ( /(a#).

-. Pe# (!#a= lea#e) ($"el (# !+e #e"p()e!

"$/8,!!e) !+a! !+e #e"p()e! (# !+e ,#"! !,8e 7,)e ,!" le!!e# )a!e)

06.10.1999 +a) "+( ,!" ,!e!,( !( )e7el(p !+e "$/8a#,e

/a!!e#,e" a) #e;$e"!e) !+e appella! !( p#(7,)e !+e "pe,,a!,("

( !+e "a8e a) , #e"p("e !( !+e "a8e= appella!" 7,)e le!!e#

6

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

)a!e) 22.11.1999 )$l p#(7,)e) !+e !e+,al "pe,,a!,(" a) (

!+e /a"," ( !+e "a8e= #e"p()e! +a) )e7el(pe) p#(!(!pe ell" (

!+e "a,) /a!!e#,e" (# !e"!, +,+ e#e (e#e) !( !+e appella!"

(# e7al$a!,( a /a? , Ma#+ 2004 a) )e"p,!e "$+ (e#,=

!+e appella!" ),) (! a## ($! a !e"!. C(!e!,( ( !+e

#e"p()e! ," !+a! !+e (!,$e) !( ,7e"! +$e "$8" (#

)e7el(p, p#(!(!pe ell" ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" $)e# le,!,8a!e

e>pe!a!,( !+a! !+e #e"p()e! ($l) /e (",)e#e) a" a

al!e#a!,7e "($#e (# "$ppl, "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e". F$#!+e#

(!e!,( ( !+e #e"p()e! ," !+a! !+e (()" p$#+a"e) ,!+($!

a !e)e# ( p#(p#,e!a# /a"," (l #(8 (e "($#e ," a la#a!

7,(la!,( ( !+e ("!,!$!,(al 8a)a!e ( A#!,le 14 a) /

),#e!, !( ,""$e a a)7e#!,"e8e!= !+e H,+ C($#! #,+!l +el)

aa,"! !+e 8((p(l ( ",le "($#e (# "$ppl ( "$/8a#,e

/a!!e#,e".

5. e +a7e a#e$ll (",)e#e) !+e #,7al (!e!,("

a)7ae) / !+e pa#!,e" a) pe#$"e) !+e )e!a,l" ( !+e p#(e)$#e

(# )e7el(p8e! ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a) 7a#,($" !e"!" #e;$,#e)

!( /e ()$!e) ( !+e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a) (!+e# 8a!e#,al (

#e(#).

7

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

9. T+e )eee p#($#e8e! a /e la"",,e) ,!( !(

/#(a) +ea)"G:

,B F,#"! a!e(# a#e (88( $"e ,!e8" ( ee#, (#(88e#,al "pe,,a!,(" a) !+e"e a#e a7a,la/le , (pe8a#?e!. F(# e>a8ple a# /a!!e#,e"= "pa#e ( 7a#,($" 7e+,le" e!. T+e"e ,!e8" a#e p#($#e) / !+e M,,"!# ( Deee / Ope Te)e# E;$,# OTEB ,.e. / a)7e#!,"e8e!" , !+e p#e"" a)e/",!e.

,,B Se() a!e(# a#e !+("e 8a!e#,al" +,+ )( (! all,!+, !+e a/(7e (88( $"e a!e(#. T+e"e "pa#e" a#e8,"",( #,!,al "!#a!e, )eee p#()$!"= +,+ a#e p#($#e)(l #(8 !+("e ,#8" +,+ a#e #e,"!e#e) ,!+ D,#e!(# *ee#al

( @$al,! A""$#ae D*@AB +,+ $!,(" $)e# !+eM,,"!# ( Deee. T+e "$ppl,e# +a" !( /e #e,"!e#e) ,!+D*@A (# !+e "$ppl ( !+a! "pe,, p#()$!.

Deee M,,"!#D*@A +a" a 7e# "!#,e! p#(e)$#e /e(#e a

7e)(# ," #e,"!e#e) ,!+ D*@A (# "$ppl, !+e p#()$!. I !+e

"e() a!e(#= !+($+ !+e p#()$! ," 8a$a!$#e) / a p#,7a!e

"$ppl,e#= ,! ," (! a" , !+e *(7e#8e! ," !(!all ),"a""(,a!e) #(8

!+e p#()$!,( p#(e"" ( !+e p#()$!. A" ," "ee #(8 !+e

S!a), O#)e#" ( !+e D*@A Ae>$#e P:1B= p#,(# !( #a! (

#e,"!#a!,(= !+e *(7e#8e! pa" !+e 7e)(# !( )e7el(p !+e

p#()$! $)e# ,!" "$pe#7,",( (# (7e# a pe#,() ( !,8e. O,,al" (

!+e D*@A a#e p("!e) a! !+e a!(# ( !+e "$ppl,e# !( e"$#e !+a!

!+e (()" "( p#()$e) a#e a/"(l$!el , (#)e#. T+e ,"pe!(#" (

D*@A ,"pe! e7e# "!ae ( p#()$!,( #,+! #(8 !+e "($#, (

!+e #a 8a!e#,al" / !+e 7e)(# a" ,! ," ;$,!e p("",/le !+a! !+e

8

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

7e)(# 8a p$#+a"e ,e#,(# ;$al,! 8a!e#,al +,+ 8a /e

),,$l! !( )e!e! , !+e ,al p#()$!. De7el(p8e! ( !+e "e()

"($#e ($l) #e;$,#e $p!( a 8a>,8$8 ( !+#ee ea#"= a" !+e

)e7el(p8e! p#(e"" ,7(l7e" )#a, $p ( )e!a,le) !e+,al

"pe,,a!,(" a) pe#(#8ae #,!e#,a /a"e) ( +,+ !+e ,#8

+a" !( p#epa#e a )e!a,le) )e", (# ea+ a) e7e# (8p(e! !(

8ee! !+e "!#,e! 8,l,!a# "!a)a#)".

10. T+e "$/e!:8a!!e# ( !+e p#e"e! a"e ," "$/8a#,e

/a!!e#,e". T+e ,8p(#!ae ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" !( a "$/8a#,e

a(! /e $)e#e"!,8a!e) a" ,! ," "!#a!e,all a 7,!al e;$,p8e! (#

"$/8a#,e". S$/8a#,e" (# ),e"el ele!#,al 7e""el" #$ ( /a!!e#

p(e#. P(e# !( !+e "$/8a#,e ," p#(7,)e) / a/($! 240 !( 25

/a!!e#,e"= e,+, a/($! 500 ?" ea+= )epe), ( !+e a!$#e (

"$/8a#,e. T+e (l "($#e ( p(e# !( a "$/8a#,e +e ,! ),7e"

/e() ,e 8e!#e" ,!( "ea(ea ," "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e".

I8p#(7e8e! , /a!!e# !e+(l( a) apa,! ," ala" a

,8p(#!a! (al , "$/8a#,e )e",. %a!!e#,e" a#e $,;$e "($#e (

ele!#, ee# , $)e#a!e# a7,a!,(. +e a "$/8a#,e ,"

$)e# "$#ae= all ,!" e;$,p8e!" a#e p(e#e) #(8 !+e /a!!e#,e"=

ele!#, 8a+,e"= l,+!"= ,!e#al (88$,a!,( e!. +,+ 8ea"

!+a! #,+! #(8 !+e ,#"! "!ae= !+e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a#e 7,!al (#

9

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

(pe#a!, "$/8a#,e. S$#7,7al ( "$/8a#,e )epe)" ( ,!" #a),(

(,"e le7el" +,+ a#e ),#e!l #ela!e) !( !+e e,,e! $!,(, (

(/(a#) e;$,p8e! a) 8a+,e# e"pe,all +e !+e /a!!e#,e"

+,+ ," !+e (l "($#e ( p(e# a) ee#. I !+e /a!!e#,e" a,l=

"$/8a#,e ,ll /e ,!+($! p(e# a) ,! a +a7e a!a"!#(p+,

("e;$ee" ( 8e a" al"( "$/8a#,e ($l) /e l("!. D*@A

!+e#e(#e e"$#e" !+a! ,! ," a""(,a!e) )$#, !+e p#()$!,( ( !+e

/a!!e#,e" / !+e app#(7e) 7e)(# a) (l !+("e /a!!e#,e" +,+

pa"" !+e !+,#!ee !e"!" a#e p$#+a"e) / !+e Na7. I a"e (

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"= /e(#e a pa#!,$la# 7e)(# ," app#(7e) (#

"$ppl ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"= a" pe# !+e p(l,= ,#"! !+e

(7e#8e! ,""$e" )e7el(p8e! ,)e! !( !+e l(e"! /,))e# a) !+e

*(7e#8e! pa" !+e p#(p("e) 7e)(# !( )e7el(p !+e p#()$! a)

!+e p#()$! ," )e7el(pe) / !+e 7e)(# $)e# !+e "$pe#7,",( ( !+e

D*@A (,,al". P#()$! "( )e7el(pe) $)e# !+e "$pe#7,",( (

D*@A +a" !( $)e#( !+,#!ee !e"!" a" "!,p$la!e) , Ae>$#e P:2.

M,,"!# ( DeeeNa7 a$!+(#,!,e" a(! aep! !+e ,al

p#()$! ,!+($! /e, $ll a""(,a!e) ,!+ !+e )e7el(p8e! ( !+e

p#()$! #,+! #(8 !+e "!ae ( p#($#e8e! ( #a 8a!e#,al !( !+e

"!ae ( ,al p#()$!. A" pe# !+e p(l,= RFP ($l) /e ,""$e) (l

!( a ,#8 +,+ ," )$l #e,"!e#e) ,!+ D*@A (# "$ppl ( !+e

10

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

p#()$! a!e# )e7el(p8e! ( !+e p#()$! $)e# !+e ae," ( D*@A.

Ha7, #ea#) !( !+e #e;$,#e8e!" ( a +,+l #,!,al "pa#e pa#!

l,?e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"= !+e *(7e#8e! +a" #a8e) !+e p(l, (#

,""$ae ( !+e )e7el(p8e! ,)e!= )e7el(p, !+e "($#e a)

#e,"!#a!,( ,!+ D*@A. I! ," pe#!,e! !( (!e !+a! , !+e #,!

pe!,!,(= p(l, ,!"el a" (! $)e# +allee. I a!= , !+e #,!

pe!,!,(= #e"p()e!:(8pa ,!"el p#ae) (l (# ,""$ae (

#e;$e"! (# p#(p("al $)e# !+e p(l,. T+e H,+ C($#! ),) (! ?eep

, 7,e !+e p(l, ( !+e *(7e#8e! a) !+e 8a)a!(#

#e;$,#e8e! ( D*@A /e, a""(,a!e) ,!+ !+e )e7el(p8e! (

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" +,+ ," a #,!,al )eee "pa#e pa#!.

11. I !+e ($!# ,"+e" !( pla a "$/"!a!,al #(le , !+e

I),a Oea a) A#a/,a Sea= I),a 8$"! e"$#e +,+ "!a)a#)"

( )eee p(e# (8pa#, ,!+ !+e e,+/($#, ($!#,e" a) ,!

"+($l) +a7e 8()e#,e) "$/8a#,e". M()e#,e) "$/8a#,e"

#e;$,#e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" ,!+ +,+ "(p+,"!,a!e) "!a)a#)

$)e# !+e ae," ( D*@A. T+e *(7e#8e! a(! p$! !+e l,e (

,!" )eee pe#"(el a) "$/8a#,e (#!+ #(#e" ( #$pee" !( #,"?

",8pl /ea$"e !+e #e"p()e! la,8" !( +a7e !+e apa/,l,! a)

a "$ppl "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e". F(# "$+ )eee #,!,al "pa#e

pa#!" l,?e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"= !+e#e a(! /e a (pe

11

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

a)7e#!,"e8e! ,7,!, !e)e#". A)7e#!,"e8e!" a#e ,""$e) all,

(# !e)e#" (l (# (88( $"e ,!e8" +,+ a#e (#8all a7a,la/le

, !+e (pe 8a#?e! ,!+ a ,)e #ae ( "($#e". S$/8a#,e

/a!!e#,e" )( (! all $)e# !+," a!e(# ( (88( $"e ,!e8". T+e

#e"p()e! a(! la,8 a 7e"!e) #,+! !( /e ,""$e) a

)e7el(p8e! ,)e! (# RFP (# a "$ppl (#)e# ",8pl /ea$"e ,! +a"

8a)e ,7e"!8e!" !( 8a$a!$#e "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e".

S!#a,+!a RFP a(! /e ,""$e) !( !+e #e"p()e! / ,(#,

!+e p#(e)$#e (# ,""$, a )e7el(p8e! ,)e! a) !e"!, !+e

/a!!e#,e".

12. A" !+e 8a!!e# a" pe), (# (7e# a )ea)e= e +a7e

a"?e) !+e appella!:U,( ( I),a a/($! !+e "$/"e;$e!

)e7el(p8e! ( !+e "e() "($#e (# "$ppl ( "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e"

a) (# !+e "!a!$" ( !+e #e"p()e!. I #e"p("e= ( ,"!#$!,(

M#. S..A. @a)#,= (/e+al ( !+e appella! +a" ,le) ela/(#a!e

#,!!e "$/8,"",(. I! ," "!a!e) !+a! a!e# #a! ( "!a (#)e# )a!e)

16.12.200 / !+," C($#! aa,"! !+e ,8p$e) (#)e#= !+e

appella! ,,!,a!e) a a"e (# )e7el(p8e! ( a al!e#a!e 7e)(# (#

"$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" "ee?, )e7el(p8e! ,)e!" #(8 IH@

NBDEE a" pe# ),#e!,7e" ( M,,"!# ( Deee 7,)e ID

N(.33604DN:IB )a!e) 05.02.200. A(#),l= (pe !e)e#

12

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

a" ,""$e) , e"pape#" ( 29.0.2006 +e#e, "e7e#al ,#8"

,l$), !+e #e"p()e! #e"p()e). F(# )e7el(p8e! ( a "e()

"($#e ( Tpe:I /a!!e#,e"= )e7el(p8e! (#)e# a" plae) ( !+e

#e"p()e! H%L L!). ( 22.03.200-= a" pe# +,+ !+e ,#8 a" !(

)e7el(p ($# Tpe:I ell" a! a ("! ( R".11.16 la?+" ,!+ a )el,7e#

"+e)$le ( e,+!ee 8(!+". T+e p#(!(!pe /a!!e#,e" 8a$a!$#e)

/ #e"p()e!:H%L a,le) !( 8ee! D*@A" "!,p$la!e) "!a)a#) (#

#ele7a! ),"+a#e C2B !e"!. T+e#ea!e#= ( 12.0-.2011= a 8ee!,

a" +el) ,!+ !+e pa#!,,pa!" ( DEE a) M". H%L

#ep#e"e!a!,7e". P("! )e!a,le) )el,/e#a!,(= !+e #e"p()e! a"

a"?e) !( 8a$a!$#e ($# ell" a#e"+ a) p#e"e! !+e8 (# !pe

!e"!,. Te"! ( /a!!e#,e" a" (8ple!e) a! !+e a!(# p#e8,"e" ,

J$e 2012 a) /a!!e#,e" e#e !#a"e##e) !( %CF= Se#, , Ja$a#

2013. H(e7e#= ( #ee,p! a! %CF= Se#,= 7,",/le /$l, a"

(/"e#7e) , all /a!!e#,e" a) lea) !ape ),"(!,$,! , (e /a!!e#

)$#, ,#"! 8a,!eae +a#e. D$#, aal"," , Fe/#$a#

2013= /$l, a" ($) !( e>ee) pe#8,"",/le l,8,! ( 12 88 (

all /a!!e#,e" p("! ,#"! $ll +a#e. H(e7e#= #e"p()e! (p,e) !+a!

!+e /$l, a" )$e !( ,8p#(pe# pa?a, +,l"! !#a"p(#!,

/a!!e#,e" #(8 !+e p#e8,"e" H)e#a/a)B !( M$8/a,. T+e#ea!e#=

#e"p()e! ,#8H%L a#ee) ( e#!a, (),!,(" (#

13

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

8a$a!$#, ( ($# e p#(!(!pe ell" ,!+ a lea) !,8e ( !+#ee:

",> 8(!+" a) a#ee) !( (8ple!e 8a$a!$#, ( !e"! ell" /

Fe/#$a# 2014. H(e7e#= !+e#e a" )ela ( !+e pa#! ( !+e

#e"p()e! a) ,all !+e !#,al ( !e"! ell" a" (8ple!e) (

14.11.2014 a) !+e !#,al" e#e 7al,)a!e) / C@AE= Se$)e#a/a).

Te"! ell" e#e #ee,7e) a! %CF= Se#, , Ja$a# 201.

C+a#,),"+a#, !#,al" (88ee) +e#e, +a#,

pa#a8e!e#" e#e e>a8,e) a) ($) !( /e "a!,"a!(#. I !+,"

#ea#)= , !+e #,!!e "$/8,"",( ,le) / UOI= ,! ," "!a!e) a"

$)e#G:

8. T+e pe#(#8ae #ep(#! (#a#)e) / ASD M/,B%CF+e#e, all pa#a8e!e#" ( !+e ell" e#e e>a8,e)=,),a!e" "a!,"a!(# !e"! #e"$l!". I 7,e ( !+e"a!,"a!(# (8ple!,( ( ,),e,a!,( e(#!" /

#e"p()e! +e#e, M". H%L= H)e#a/a)B !+e ,#8 a"(8,a!e) a" IH@ MOD NB app#(7e) 7e)(# (# "$ppl ( Tpe:I "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" (# E<M "$/8a#,e" (25.0.201

9. ..!+e e>! p#($#e8e! a"e "+all +a7e a a)),!,(al;$al,,e) 7e)(# (# Tpe:I "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" !( ,#ea"e!+e 8a#?e! (8pe!ee (# /(!+ !e+,al a) ,a,ala"pe!".K

T+($+ !+e "$/"e;$e! )e7el(p8e!" 8a (! /e #ele7a! !(

)e!e#8,e !+e ,""$e= e +a7e #ee##e) !( !+e #,!!e "$/8,"",( in

extenso (# !+e "a?e ( (8ple!,(.

13. T+e a(#e"a,) ),"$"",( a) al"( !+e #,!!e

"$/8,"",( a" !( +( !+e #e"p()e! )e7el(pe) !+e /a!!e#,e" (7e# a

14

LatestLaws.com



LatestLaws.com

pe#,() ( !,8e #e,!e#a!e !+a! !+e )e7el(p8e! ( "e() "($#e

($l) (l /e a" pe# !+e $,)el,e" ( D*@A a) $)e# !+e

"$pe#7,",( a) ,"pe!,( ( !+e (,,al" ( !+e D*@A a) (!

,)epe)e!l. T+e H,+ C($#! ),) (! ?eep , 7,e !+e p(l, (

!+e *(7e#8e! , p$#+a", !+e #,!,al "pa#e pa#!" (# !+e

)eee a) , pa#!,$la#= , )e7el(p, "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" $)e#

!+e ae," ( !+e Deee M,,"!# a) !+e H,+ C($#! e##e) ,

),#e!, !+e appella!" !( ,""$e a a)7e#!,"e8e! ,7, )e!a,l"

a/($! !+e !e+,al "pe,,a!,(" (# "$/8a#,e /a!!e#,e" a) ,

"ele!, !+e p#()$! "$/8,!!e) , #e"p("e !( !+e a)7e#!,"e8e!

a) !+e ,8p$e) (#)e# ," (! "$"!a,a/le.

14. T+e ,8p$e) (#)e# ( !+e H,+ C($#! ," "e! a",)e a)

!+," appeal ," all(e). I !+e a!" a) ,#$8"!ae" ( !+e a"e=

e 8a?e ( (#)e# a" !( ("!".

...CJI. T.S. THA<URB

...J. R. %ANUMATHIB

Ne Del+, Ja$a# 20= 2016

15

LatestLaws.com

sc, no need to invite public tenders for strategic defence equipment

Documents