scaling up high-impact fp/mnch best practices in the asia...
TRANSCRIPT
SCALING UP HIGH-IMPACT FP/MNCH BEST
PRACTICES IN THE ASIA/NEAR EAST REGION
TECHNICAL MEETING REPORT APPENDICES
October 2007 This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development. It was prepared through the Global Health Technical Assistance Project.
SCALING UP HIGH-IMPACT FP/MNCH BEST
PRACTICES IN THE ASIA/NEAR EAST
REGION
TECHNICAL MEETING REPORT APPENDICES
DISCLAIMER
The authors’ views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the
United States Agency for International Development or the United States Government.
This document (Report No. 07-001-40) is available online. Online documents can be located in
the GH Tech web site library at www.ghtechproject.com/resources.aspx. Documents are also
made available through the Development Experience Clearinghouse (http://dec.usaid.gov).
Additional information can be obtained from
The Global Health Technical Assistance Project
1250 Eye St., NW, Suite 1100
Washington, DC 20005
Tel: (202) 521-1900
Fax: (202) 521-1901
This document was submitted by The QED Group, LLC, with CAMRIS International and Social
& Scientific Systems, Inc., to the United States Agency for International Development under
USAID Contract No. GHS-I-00-05-00005-00.
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 1
APPENDIX 1: LIST OF PARTICIPANTS
First Name Last/Family Name
Organization Title
Philip Harvey A2Z/JHU Technical Director
Sabry Hamza Abt Associates, Inc. Professor of OB/GYN
Huda Murad Abt Associates, Inc. Reproductive Health Task Manager
Nagham Abu Shagra Abt Associates/PSP QA & Program Technical Specialist
Rita Leavell Abt Associates/PSP Project Director
Peter Oyloe Academy for Educational Development
Resident Advisor
Camille Saade Academy for Educational Development
Director, the AED/POUZN project
Koki Agarwal ACCESS Director
Patricia Gomez ACCESS/JHPIEGO
Joseph De Graft Johnson
ACCESS Program Community Interventions Specialist
Hannah Gibson ACCESS/HSSP Chief of Party
Sabera Turkmani ACCESS/HSSP Midwifery Program Officer
Shams Bigana ACCESS/HSSP PPH Program Officer
Robin Anthony Kouyate ACCESS-FP Senior Program Officer/BCC Specialist
Catherine McKaig ACCESS-FP Director
John Pile ACQUIRE Senior Technical Advisor
Netra Bhatta ADRA Project Director
Corazon Barba AED Resident Advisor
Eleonore Fosso Seumo AED Senior Technical Officer
Zulfiqar Bhutta Aga Khan Foundation Professor & Chairman
Seema Pahariya Aga Khan Foundation Senior Program Officer
Amat Al Karem
Al-Hori Al Sabeen Hospital Hospital Director
Vinod Paul All India Institute of Medical Science
Neonatologist
Suneeta Mittal All India Institute of Medical Sciences
Professor and Head
Yoriko Jinno American Refugee Committee
Reproductive & Child Health Coordinator
David Prettyman AmeriCares Country Director
Abdulghani Al-Ghuzi Amman Health Office Director General of the Health Office in Amman/Jordan
2 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Shiv Khare Asian Forum of Parliamentarians on Population and Development (AFPPD)
Executive Director
Indira Narayanan BASICS Senior Technical Advisor, Newborn Health
S. Katherine Farnsworth BASICS Project Program Coordinator
Diana Silimperi BASICS Project Technical Director
Manodari Thapa Bhaktapur Hospital Hospital Nursing Administrator
Kishwar Azad BIRDEM
Kaosar Afsana BRAC Programme Coordinator
Nahed Helal Cairo University Professor of Pediatrics
Jahangir Hossain CARE Health Advisor
Milly Kayongo CARE Senior Technical Advisor for Maternal Health CARE
Sisokhom Sek CARE MCH Program Coordinator
Nirmala Sharma CARE Program Coordinator
Michelle Lang-Alli Catholic Relief Services Regional Technical Advisor for Health
Bulbul Sood CEDPA Country Director
Sushma Baidawar Central Regional Health Directorate, Hetauda
Acting Director
Indu Capoor CHETNA Director
Armando Lee CHITS
Nancy Sloan Columbia University
Mia Ventura Commission on Population
Deputy Executive Director
Jocelyn B. Aca Compostela Valley Provincial Health Office
Provincial Health Officer
Nidhi Chaudhary Constella Futures Senior Program Specialist
Basma Musa Ishaqat Constella Futures Country Director / Jordan
Shivani Kumar Constella Futures Manager, Capacity Building
Anil Mishra Constella Futures State Representative
Shivani Sachdev Kapoor Constella Futures State Representative, ITAP, Jharkhand
Rachel Sanders Constella Futures Policy Analyst
Monica Tripathi Constella Futures Manager NGO Advisor
Lynette Walker CORE Group Deputy Director
Mohamed Sweed CSIA Executive Manager
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 3
Rekha Udani D Y Patil Medical College & Hospital & Research Center
Carole Bandahala Department of Health Chief Health Program Officer
Honorata Catibog Department of Health Director
Lourdes Paulino Department of Health Medical Specialist
Paulyn Jean Rosell-Ubial Department of Health Director
Cemellie Bernadette V.
Sabay Department of Health Family Health Cluster Coordinator
Josephine J. Villafuerte Department of Health City Health Officer, Davao City
Nidhi Khare Department of Health and Family Welfare
Special Secretary
Amarjit Singh Department of Health and Family Welfare
Secretary, FW & Commissioner, Health
Kirana Pritasari Directorate of Child Health, Ministry of Health
Shakeel Nayara Directorate of Family Welfare
Joint Director
Chandra Bhan Prasad Directorate of Medical Health and Family Welfare
Additional Director
Bhanu Bhakta Yengden District Public Health Office
Senior Public Health Administrator
Sanam Anwar Dr. Sushila Nayar School of Public Health Incorporating
Madhukar Bharambe Dr. Sushila Nayar School of Public Health Incorporating
Senior Lecturer in Statistics and Demography
Amol Dongre Dr. Sushila Nayar School of Public Health Incorporating
Chetna Maliye Dr. Sushila Nayar School of Public Health Incorporating
Moslehuddin Ahmed EngenderHealth Director of Programs
Abu Faisel EngenderHealth Country Representative
Jyoti Vajpayee EngenderHealth Country Director
Salwa Bitar Extending Service Delivery Project
Senior RH/FP Advisor
Milka Dinev Extending Service Delivery Project
Project Director
Pauline Muhuhu Extending Service Delivery Project
Senior Advisor for Best Practices
4 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Shannon Pryor Extending Service Delivery Project
Grants and Program Coordinator
Caroline Tran Extending Service Delivery Project
Program Officer
David Wofford Extending Service Delivery Project
Senior Commercial Sector Advisor
Intesar Al Saidi Faculty of Medicine Reproductive Health Department/Yemen
Ahmed Al-Haddad Faculty of Medicine Reproductive Health Department/Yemen
Ruth Talisic Family Care and Maternity Clinic
Midwife
Shilu Aryal Family Health Division RH Coordinator
Bal Krishna Suvedi Family Health Division Director
Nisha Gupta Family Health International
Associate Director Research Utilization
Graham Neilsen Family Health International
Technical Advisor, Sexual & Reproductive Health
Jason Smith Family Health International
Director of Research Utilization
Jennifer Wesson Family Health International
Senior Research Associate, HSR
Irina Yacobson Family Health International
Assistant Medical Director
Sadhana Desai Federation of Obstetrics and Gynecology Societies of India
Clinical Specialist
Nahla Abdel-Tawab FRONTIERS Program, Population Council
Program Associate
Nathalie Charpak Fundacion Canguro Pediatrician
Yati Soenarto Gadjah Mada University Director of the Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics and Pediatric Consultant for Gastro-hepatology
Beth Peterman Gates Foundation Program Officer, Global Health Strategies
Mary Taylor Gates Foundation Senior Program Officer
Mohammed Binafif German Technical Cooperation (GTZ)
Douglas Huber GH Tech Consultant
Annette Bongiovanni GH Tech QED Group Consultant
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 5
Shahzado Sheikh Government of Pakistan, Ministry of Population
Secretary
Haris Ahmed Greenstar Social Marketing
Senior Program Manger
Daoud Abdeen Hanan Project Capacity Building Associate Director
Begum Arab Health
Teresinha da Silva Sarmento
Health Alliance International
Program Assistant
Nadine Hoekman Health Alliance International
Country Director/Program Manager
Jennifer Hulme Health Alliance International
District Office Coordinator
Abdul Majid Health Department, Government of Sindh
Zafar Iqbal Gondal Health of Rawalpindi District, DOH
Executive District Officer
Aubhugn Labiano Health Policy Development Program
Mary Ann Lansang Health Policy Development Program
George Adriaansz Health Services Program (JSI)
Laurel Maclaren Health Services Program (JSI)
Susna De Health Systems 20/20 Project
National Health Accounts Coordinator
Consuelo D. Aranas HEALTHGOV Project Health Programs Team Leader
Rosario Marilyn
Benabaye HEALTHGOV Project Service Delivery Coordinator - Mindanao
Ellen Bautista Hellen Keller International, Inc.
Monitoring and Evaluation Manager
Nafisa Al Jaifi Higher Council of Childhood and Motherhood
Head of Higher Counsel of Childhood and Motherhood
Ahmad Al Qatitat Higher Population Council
Deputy Secretary General and RH Manager
Abdulmonem Malkawi Higher Population Council
Project Manager
An Bach Cam Hue Central Hospital
Mohammed Abdullah Al-Hashash
Ibb Health Office Health of Reproductive Health in Ibb Health Office
Shams Arifeen ICDDR,B Head of the Child Health Programme
Mahbub Chowdhury ICDDR,B
6 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Marjorie Anne Koblinsky ICDDR,B Director of Public Health Sciences Division
Charles P. Larson ICDDR,B Director Health Systems and Infectious Diseases Division
Ishtiaq Mannan ICDDR,B Management Specialist
Malay Kanti Mridha ICDDR,B
Rashed Shah ICDDR,B Projector Coordinator
Priya Nanda ICRW Regional Advisor, South Asia
Amanda Phillips IDEAS International Associate and Co-Director of Smooth Path
David Braunholtz Immpact Senior Statistician
Budi Utomo Immpact
Kalpana Apta India
Dileep Mavalankar Indian Institute of Management
Associate Professor
Mustika Sofyan Indonesian Midwives Association
Victoria Jennings Institute for Reproductive Health, GU
Director
Priya Jha Institute for Reproductive Health, GU
Country Representative
Meredith Puleio Institute for Reproductive Health, GU
Program Assistant
Milagros Rivera Institute for Reproductive Health, GU
Director
Sameena Chowdhury Institute of Child & Mother Health
Professor
Richard Fuchs International Development Research Center
Regional Director
Kristin Parco International Organization for Migration
Program Manager - Health
Maria Nenette Motus International Organization for Migration, Regional Office for Southeast Asia
Regional Migrant Health Program Advisor
Laurie Parker IntraHealth International, Inc.
Project Director
Nadia Shamsuddin Ipas Asia Regional Advisor
Jean Shaikh IYCN Project Project Director
Ram Shrestha IYCN Project Country Program Specialist
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 7
Noriko Fujita Japan International Cooperation Agency
Chief Advisor
Tokiko Sato Japan International Cooperation Agency
Senior Advisor on Reproductive Health
Shivaprasad Goudar Jawaharlal Nehru Medical College
Director of the Department of Medical Education
Nabeel Akram JHPIEGO
Rajendra Bhadra JHPIEGO
Alain Damiba JHPIEGO Vice President, Global Programs
Silvia Holschneider JHPIEGO
Anne Hyre JHPIEGO
Rahila Juya JHPIEGO
Ricky Lu JHPIEGO
Ron Magarick JHPIEGO
Cesar Maglaya JHPIEGO
Leslie Mancuso JHPIEGO
Judith Moore JHPIEGO Resident Advisor
Asmuyeni Muchtar JHPIEGO Midwifery Advisor/Infection Prevention Specialist
Naweed Nayib JHPIEGO
Edgar Necochea JHPIEGO
Niaz Mohammed
Popal JHPIEGO Neonatal & Child Health Officer
Deirdre Russo JHPIEGO
Harshad Sanghvi JHPIEGO Medical Director
Geeta Sharma JHPIEGO
Jeff Smith JHPIEGO Regional Technical Dierctor
Djoko Soetikno JHPIEGO
Stephanie Suhowatsky JHPIEGO
Shabana Zaeem JHPIEGO
Cynthia Stanton JHSPH Epidemiologist
Fayyaz Ahmad JHUCCP Joint Secretary WRA Pakistan and Team Leader for the John Hopkins Center for Communication Program
Hari Fitri Wahyuni JHUCCP Country Representative
Catherine Richey JHUCCP/INFO Project Senior Technical Writer
Mahbubur Rashid JiVitA Project Senior Medical Epidemiologist
Nabeela Ali John Snow, Inc.
8 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Mary Carnell John Snow, Inc. Director, Center for Maternal, Newborn and Child Health
Penny Dawson John Snow, Inc. Child Survival Specialist
Reginald Gipson John Snow, Inc. Chief of Party
Sudhir Khanal John Snow, Inc. Project Director - Mini Program
Marcy Levy John Snow, Inc. Technical Officer
Theo Lippeveld John Snow, Inc. Vice President
Iftikhar Ahmed Mallah John Snow, Inc. Field Operations Manager
Nuzhat Rafique John Snow, Inc.
Anabella Sanchez John Snow, Inc. Technical Advisor
Jaganath Sharma John Snow, Inc. Project Director - Mini Uniject
Frances Tain John Snow, Inc. MCH Technical Advisor
Salahuddin Ahmed Johns Hopkins University
Samir Alalfy Johns Hopkins University Deputy Chief of Party for Technical Services
Abdullah Baqui Johns Hopkins University Associate Professor
Rolf Klemm Johns Hopkins University Assistant Scientist, Department of International Health, Bloomberg School of Public health
Vishwajeet Kumar Johns Hopkins University Center Director
Alain Labrique Johns Hopkins University Assistant Professor
Raed Abu Hayyaneh Jordan Health Communication Partnership
Community Mobilization Specialist
Lina Qardan Jordan Health Communication Partnership
Senior Technical Advisor
Pisake Lumbiganon Khon Kaen University Professor in OB/GYN
Rabindra Pradhan Kiritipur Volunteer Society
Vice Chairperson of Communication Committee
Soekirman Soekirman Koalisi Fortifikasi Indonesia
Chairman
Basharat Naseer Lady Wellingdon Hospital
Omar Ali Lahj Health Office Director General of the Health Office in Lahj
Malak Musawa Lahj Health Office Head of Reproductive Health in Lahj Health Office
Stacy Lea Saha LAMB Project
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 9
Oona Cambell London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine
Reader in Epidemiology and Reproductive Health
Michel Pacqué Macro International Senior Child Survival Specialist
Shea Rutstein Macro International Inc Technical Director
Mubarak Shah Mubarak Management Sciences for Health
Chief of Party, TechServe Program
Timothy Allen Management Sciences for Health
Deputy Director, Center for Leadership
Jonathan Quick Management Sciences for Health
President & Chief Executive Officer
Richard Kohl Management Systems International
Technical Director of Scaling Up
Ghazala Aman Marie Stopes Society Senior Program Manager
Nara Peang MCH-PHD Kam Pongcham
Vice Chief
La Ine Pal MCH-PHD Pursat Chief
Rehana Ahmed MDG Center Nairobi Reproductive Health Specialist
Vicki Penwell Mercy In Action Director/Midwife
Abdul Nasser Al-Kabab Ministry of Health
Silu Aryal Ministry of Health
Veasna Chhorn Ministry of Health Program Manager, CDD & ARI
Ngoc Duong Ministry of Health Program Officer
Nadeem Hassan Ministry of Health Assistant Director General Health
Sri Hermiyanti Junizarman Ministry of Health
Khawla Kawa Ministry of Health Chief of Family Planning Department/MCHD
Zareef Khan Ministry of Health Nutrition
Karima Mayar Ministry of Health
Abeer Mowaswas Ministry of Health
Linh Nguyen Ministry of Health Reproductive Health Program Coordinator
YashoVardhan Pradhan Ministry of Health
Hong Rathmony Ministry of Health
Isam Shraideh Ministry of Health Head of OB/GYN Department/MOH
Navraj Subha Ministry of Health
Mandodari Thapa Ministry of Health
Misliza Vital Ministry of Health ICMI National Officer
10 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Najiba Zia Yaftali Ministry of Health Safe Motherhood Initiative Officer
Abdul Khaleque
Chakder Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Line Director
Altaf Hossain Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Deputy Program Manager
Mohammad Khan Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Md Abdul Mannan Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Jayalakshmi Mysore Sitaramiah
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Jamil Osman Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Abdul Quader Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Program Manager
Saleh Muhammad
Rafique Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Anil Sharma Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Uttarakhand
Additional Director - National Programs
Yahia El Hadidi Ministry of Health and Population
First Undersecretary and Head of Population and Family Planning Sector
Khaled Otteifi Ministry of Health and Population
Consultant of OB/GYN
Abdel Haleem Ragab Ministry of Health and Population
General Manager of Population Planning
Nahla Shebl Ministry of Health and Population
CHL Coordinator & IEC Responsible
Nawa Raj Subba Ministry of Health and Population
Senior Public Health Administrator
Dilip Kumar Dey Ministry of Home Affairs Deputy Director
Shahzad Ahmad Ministry of Population Welfare
Director General (Monitoring & Statistics)
Muhammad Farooq
Khan Ministry of Population Welfare
Religious Scholar
Esker Mumtaz Ministry of Population Welfare
Director General Technical
Nasser Al-Absi Ministry of Public Health
Narongsak Angkhasuwaphla Ministry of Public Health Director General of Department of Health
Qudisa Burhany Ministry of Public Health OB-GYN Specialist
Masouda Faizee Ministry of Public Health OB-GYN Specialist
Siripon Kanshana Ministry of Public Health Chief Inspector General
Al Khader Laswar Ministry of Public Health
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 11
Mosleh Al-Toali Ministry of Public Health and Population
Aweed Dehyar Ministry of Public Health of Afghanistan
Training Specialist, Maternity Hospital
Hamida Ebadi Ministry of Public Health of Afghanistan
Productive Health Director
Dharma Manandhar MIRA President
Arwa Al-Rabee MOPHP Deputy Minister for Population and Reproductive Health
Steven Solter MSH/BASICS Adviser, Cambodian MOH
Gulardi Wiknjosastro National Clinical Training Network (NCTN)
Assad Hafeez National Program for Family Planning and Primary Health Care
National Coordinator
Rinawati Rohsiswatmo Neonatal Working Group, Indonesian Pediatric Association
Stephen Hodgins NFHP/Nepal Project Director
Asha Pun NFHP/Nepal
Ramchandra Silwal NFHP/Nepal
Phirun Lam NRPH Deputy Director
Abdul Bayes Bhuiyan Obstetrics and Gynecology Society of Bangladesh
Lester Coutinho Packard Foundation Country Director
Iwan Ariawan PATH University of Indonesia
Deborah Armbruster PATH Director, POPPHI
Patricia Coffey PATH Program Officer
Brian McLaughlin PATH Representative Thailand & Cambodia
Alfredo Fort Path/Macro International Senior Health Adviser
Rekha Masilamani Pathfinder International Country Representative
Phuong Nguyen Pathfinder International
Ha Nguyen Pathfinder International Program Officer
Daniel Pellegrom Pathfinder International President
Cathy Solter Pathfinder International Director of Technical Services
Effek Alamsyah PERINASIA Second Chairman
Hadi Pratomo Perinasia Chairman Program Planning Committee
12 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Shehlina Ahmed Plan Asia Regional Office Regional Health Advisor
Lisa Bowen Plan International Reproductive, Maternal & Newborn Health
Kedar Baral Plan Nepal Health Coordinator
Mechai Viravaidya Population and Community Development Association
Shahida Azfar Population Council Chief of Party - DFPAP Project
Sharif Hossain Population Council Senior Program Officer
Mohamad Ejazuddin
Khan Population Council Regional Associate Director
Peter Miller Population Council Deputy Country Director
Mary Sebastian Population Council Program Officer
Vaishali Sharma Mahendra
Population Council Senior Program Officer
Kheng Heng Population Services International
Health Services Manager
Virgilio Pernito Population Services Pilipinas Inc
Chief Executive Officer
Lemuel Marasigan PRISM Senior Technical Director
Agnes Pacho PRISM Regional Director for Luzon
Anand Sinha PSP One Chief of Party
Shaheen Akhtar
Arain Public Health School Hyderabad
Midwifery Tutor
David Nicholas QA Project/URC QA Project Director, and Sr. VP URC
Mony Eam RACHA Safe Motherhood Team Leader
Nasy Sun RACHA Deputy Executive Director
Chanlida Heng Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia
MD
Mao Keo Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia
Deputy Director Clinical Services
Chutema Ping Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia
Sreng Veth Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia
MD, MPH
Davy Vong Reproductive Health Association of Cambodia
Clinic Manager
Ahmed Al-Kabir RTM International
Masood Abbasi Save the Children Provincial Manager
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 13
Lubana Ahmed Save the Children Program Manager, ACCESS Program
Jatan Bhowmick Save the Children Deputy Program Manager
Patricia Daly Save the Children ACCESS, Deputy Director
Wahidul Islam Save the Children
Ashish KC Save the Children
Neena Khadka Save the Children Health Team Leader
Chandra Rai Save the Children Program Manager
Meena Sharma Save the Children Program Officer
Stephen Wall Save the Children Senior Newborn Health Advisor
Aftab Tariq Ihsan
Yousafzai Save the Children Deputy Director
Abhay Bang SEARCH Director
Kazi Rahman SHIMANTIK Deputy Executive Director
Savita Chauhan SIFPSA Deputy General Manager
Subbamaicker Krishnaswamy SIFPSA General Manager
Alok Tandon SIFPSA Executive Director
Rithy Chau Sihanouk Hospital Center of HOPE
Director of Capacity Building
Shobha Basnet SMNF Nepal Treasurer
Suveckshya Shah SMNF Nepal Program Officer
Hashina Begum Social Marketing Company
Head, Social Franchising & Quality Assurance
Manisha Panwar Staet Government of Uttarakhand, Department of Health
Secretary of Health
Bindu Bajracharya Support to Safe Motherhood Programme
Human Resource Advisor
Nader Nassif TAKAMOL Private Sector/Corporate Social Responsibility Specialist
Maged Youssef TAKAMOL Field Operations Team Leader
Abdul Ali Waris Tech Serve Project
Bruce Rasmussen The International Rescue Committee
Chief of Party, PRIDE Project
Lauri Winter Timor Leste Asistensia Integradu Saude
Technical Director
14 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Noor Khanom Tres Des Hommes Medical Doctor
Dat Duong UNFPA Program Officer
Zahidul Huque UNFPA Country Representative
Mobashar Malik UNFPA
Hendry Plaza UNFPA Program Officer for Reproductive Health
Jebun Nessa Rahman UNFPA
Josephine Anne
Sauvarin UNFPA
Ghulam Shabbir UNFPA
Armunanto Armunanto UNICEF
Martha Cayad-an UNICEF Health Specialist
Rudolph Knippenberg UNICEF Senior Advisor
Ian Pett UNICEF Senior Adviser
Nancy Terreri UNICEF Senior Advisor Maternal and Child Health
Ratih Dharmi Woelandaroe UNICEF APO-Health UNICEF Wamena
Mosammat Rashida
Begum University of Dhaka Medical College
Assistant Professor (OB/GYN)
Farhana Dewan University of Dhaka Medical School
Associate Professor
Emorn Wasantwisut University of Mahidol Director, Institute of Nutrition
Siddarth Raj Agarwal Urban Health Resource Center
Executive Director
Sainath Banerjee Urban Health Resource Center
Regional Program Coordinator/Technical Specialist
Thada Bornstein URC Sr. QA Advisor & Training Director, QAP
Vanny Peng URC Field Officer
John Yeh US Department of State Senior Science Advisor
Musalkazim Ali USAID MCH Management Specialist, BHS
Iman Ali Ahmed Awad USAID Senior Health Advisor
Gretchen Antelman USAID Senior MCH Advisor, BHS
Rushna Ravji Aqil USAID Service Delivery Technical Advisor
Ali Arbaji USAID Project Management Specialist
Shadia Attia USAID Research and Monitoring Advisor
Alfred Bartlett USAID Senior Advisor for Child Survival
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 15
Neal Brandes USAID Health Research Advisor/Health Specialist
Sheena Chhabra USAID Chief, Health Systems Division
Gary Cook USAID Senior Health Advisor
Carolyn Curtis USAID Public Health Specialist
Charya Sokun Hen USAID Family Health Team Leader
Mohammad Shapor
Ikram USAID Project Management Specialist Health
Muhammad Isa USAID Program Management Specialist - Health
Lily Kak USAID Maternal and Newborn Health Advisor
Nazo Kureshy USAID Team Leader Child Survival & Health Grants Program
Nahed Matta USAID Senior Maternal and Newborn Health Advisor
Mary Lynn McKeon USAID Health Officer
Monique Mosolf USAID
Maureen Norton USAID Senior Technical Advisor
Anne M Peniston USAID Director, O/HFP
Stephen Settimi USAID Senior Fellow & Technical Advisor - USAID Global Health, ICT/Knowledge Management
James Shelton USAID Science Advisor
Mary Skarie USAID Health Office Director
Rajiv Tandon USAID Senior Advisor, Child Survival
Teodulo Clemente de J.
Ximenes USAID Project Management Specialist
Gamilah Al-Sharai USAID/BHS Project Community Mobilization Advisor
Hamouda Hanafi USAID/BHS Project Chief of Party
Gregory Adams USAID/MCC Immunization Team Leader
Alisha Graves Venture Strategies for Health and Development
Country Programs Manager
Selvaraju Venkatachalam Vistaar Knowledge to Practice Advisor
Laxmikanta Palo Vistaar Project Advisor - Knowledge to Practice
Endang Noersita West Java Provinicial Health Office
Head of Maternal and Child Health Section
Saskia de Pee WFP Consultant DSM Project
16 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Farhana Ahmad White Ribbon Alliance National Coordinator
Arty Arthia Moesetio White Ribbon Alliance
Aparajita Gogoi White Ribbon Alliance
Pati Nabin Kumar White Ribbon Alliance
Dina Sintadewi
Landini White Ribbon Alliance Member
Betsy McCallon White Ribbon Alliance Global Secretariat
Tubagus Adi Satria White Ribbon Alliance Youth Division
Murbari Siwi White Ribbon Alliance
Itje Sri Lazurachmi White Ribbon Alliance
Luh Putu Sunitri White Ribbon Alliance
Endang Suharmini
Dahlan White Ribbon Alliance
Raeda Al-Qutob WHO Professor of Women and Child Health
Nathalie Kapp WHO Medical Officer
Lisa Thomas Women's Commission Consultant
Monirul Islam World Health Organization
Director, Making Pregnancy Safer Dept.
Daisy Mafubelu World Health Organization
Assistant Director General
Jose Martines World Health Organization
Coordinator, Newborn and Child Health
Zaitoon Qazi World Health Organization
Technical Officer
Margaret Kay Usher-Patel World Health Organization
Scientist/IBP Secretariat
Joby George World Vision Health & Nutrition Program Manager
Linda Murray World Vision Health Advisor
Manju Paul World Vision Field Program Manager
Shibu Philipose World Vision Project Officer
Sri Chander World Vision International Regional Health Advisor
Esther Indriani World Vision International Health & Nutrition Advisor
Manju Jiju Mathew World Vision International Program Manager
Miriam Yiannakis World Vision International Asia Pacific Regional Nutrition Advisor
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 17
Aman Ullah Khan WRA and Children
Save the Secretary General WRA Pakistan and Deputy Director, Save the Children
Samir Radha Yemen Parliament
Fawzia Yousef Yemen Partners Health Reform
for Consultant RH Policy Advisor
Hind Dawani Pediatrician
Sabiha Khurshid Provincial Punjab
Program Coordinator MNCH
Wastidar Musbir
Zahida Parveen Health Department
Ghulam Sakina Midwifery Tutor Chakwal
Mohammad Yousaf Provincial Program Coordinator MNCH Baluchistan
Nargis Zaman Midwifery Tutor Muzaffarabad AJK
18 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
APPENDIX 2: COUNTRY TEAM FACILITATORS
ANE Technical Meeting - Country Team Facilitators
Cathy Solter, Director of Technical Services, Pathfinder International Facilitators Coordinator [email protected] Carolyn Curtis, Public Health Specialist, USAID Floating Facilitator [email protected] Country Facilitator Email Address
Afghanistan Kokila Agarwal, Director ACCESS Program
Bangladesh 1. Marge Koblinsky, Director, Public Health Sciences Division, ICDDR,B 2. Shams El Arifeen, Head of the Child Health Programme ICDDR, B
[email protected] [email protected] or [email protected]
Cambodia Patricia Daly, Deputy Director ACCESS Program
Egypt Nahed Matta, Senior Maternal and Newborn Health Advisor, USAID, Washington
India 1. Betsy McCallon, Senior Program Advisor, White Ribbon Alliance for Safe Motherhood 2. Rushna Ravji, Service Delivery Technical Advisor, USAID Washington
[email protected] [email protected]
Indonesia Annette Bongiovanni, Consultant Extending Service Delivery Project
Jordan Salwa Bitar, MNCH/RH Advisor Extending Service Delivery Project
Nepal Lily Kak, Senior Maternal and Newborn Health Advisor, USAID, Washington
Pakistan Maureen Norton, Senior Technical Advisor, USAID, Washington
Philippines Catherine McKaig, Director ACCESS-FP Program
West Bank/Gaza Pauline Muhuhu, Best Practices Advisor, Extending Service Delivery Project
Yemen Milka Dinev, Director Extending Service Delivery Project
East Timor Neal Brandes, Health [email protected]
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 19
ANE Technical Meeting - Country Team Facilitators
Cathy Solter, Director of Technical Services, Pathfinder International Facilitators Coordinator [email protected] Carolyn Curtis, Public Health Specialist, USAID Floating Facilitator [email protected] Country Facilitator Email Address
Specialist/Health Research Advisor, USAID, Washington
Vietnam Pauline Muhuhu, Best Practices Advisor, Extending Service Delivery Project
Laos Pauline Muhuhu, as above [email protected]
Thailand Nazo Kureshy, Team Leader , Child Survival & Health Grants Program, USAID Washington
Floating Facilitator
Cathy Solter, Director of Technical Services, Pathfinder International
Floating Facilitator
James Shelton, Science Advisor, USAID Washington
Floating Facilitator
Thada Bornstein, Senior Quality Improvement Advisor & Training Director for the Quality Assurance Project at University Research Corp
20 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
APPENDIX 3: SUMMARY OF COUNTRY ACTION PLANS AFGHANISTAN
Facilitator: Kokila Agarwal, Director ACCESS Program
Goals:
Scale up preventing PPH program at home births Endorsement process
Present result of pilot project to MOPH
Disseminate result at national and international level
Secure financial resources and materials (misoprostol)
Develop the implementation guidelines to include site selection criteria
Review and finalize monitoring tools
Adjust education materials (include integrating other health services components such as PPFP)
Select sites and identify implementing NGOs
Advocate with stakeholders (community, NGOs, donors and UN agencies, others)
Develop implementation plan with NGOs
Start implementation (include training/orientation to the implementers including CHWs)
Continuously monitor the program
Introduce KMC at five facilities (district hospitals) in USAID-supported provinces
Reorganize NBC Working Group
Disseminate information of ENBC (best practices) at national level
Review report: State of the Newborn Care in Afghanistan (situation analysis)
Design formative assessment on household NBC practices: conduct, analyze and use data
Design implementation plan for the demonstration project (two selected districts)
Pilot ENBC in two selected areas
Introduce zinc for management of diarrhea for children as a component of BPHS
Feedback to MOPH and technical task force on child health management on the use of appropriate technology and approaches for use of zinc for diarrhea, and dissemination of country experiences and results
Technical brainstorming with consultative group on health and nutrition (CGHN) to develop censuses among the partners
CGHN members are MOPH, USAID, World Bank, European Commission and NGOs
Review of technical proposal by the Technical Advisory Group (TAG) for health sector
Seek MOPH leadership approval for use of zinc for diarrhea and policy adaptation
Update the current strategy to integrate the component of use of zinc in diarrhea management in light of MOPH approval and TAG remarks
Include zinc in the essential drug list for the country
Develop the plan for pilot introduction and scaling-up of use of zinc in diarrhea management
Roll-out of plan on pilot basis in three provinces
Document the result and finalize zinc use in the pilot phase
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 21
BANGLADESH
Facilitators: Marge Koblinsky, Director, Public Health Sciences Division, ICDDR,B Shams El Arifeen, Head of the Child Health Programme, ICDDR, B
Goal: Meet the MDG 4 and 5 targets to reduce maternal and under-5 mortality by 2015.
Objectives: (not specified)
Interventions for Introduction of and Strengthening Existing Best Practices:
a. Maternal Health i. Existing Maternal Health Best Practices Needing Strengthening
1. Improve maternal nutrition in pregnancy and postpartum antenatal iron/folate, postpartum vitamin A, food supplementation program (NNP covers ~1/3 of the country)
2. Birth preparedness and complication readiness 3. Management of PPH (AMTSL, misoprostol); plan to scale up to 20 districts
(National PPH Task Force) 4. Short EmONC training for C-section/anesthesiology 5. Deploy and retain EmONC teams in rural areas 6. Maternal death audit 7. Upgrade H&FWCs for safe delivery 8. Safe blood transfusion at EmOC facilities 9. Establishment of fistula care 10. Encouraging service providers by ‗Best performance awards‘ 11. One-stop crisis center for violence against women
ii. Maternal Health Best Practices Proposed for Inclusion 1. Use of partograph 2. Use of magnesium sulfate for eclampsia 3. Develop and register midwives 4. Deworming of pregnant women >5mo GA 5. Post-abortion care
b. Neonatal Health i. Existing Neonatal Health Best Practices Needing Strengthening
1. BCG and OPV immediately after birth 2. Community case management for possible sepsis 3. Essential Newborn Care (ENC) package 4. Special care for LBW/preterm newborns 5. Perinatal death audit 6. National newborn health strategy
ii. Neonatal Health Best Practices Proposed for Inclusion 1. National newborn health strategy 2. Newborn vitamin A
22 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
c. Child Health i. Existing Child Health Best Practices Needing Strengthening
1. Use NIDs as opportunities for vitamin A and deworming 2. Infant and young child feeding 3. <5y Iron-folate supplementation
ii. Child Health Best Practices Proposed for Inclusion 1. Expand EPI
a. including pentavalent single dose b. (Pneumo/Hib/DPT/HepB),Rotavirus)
2. Integrated package (CSBA + C-IMCI)
d. Family Planning i. Existing FP Best Practices Needing Strengthening
1. Post-partum FP (including LAM) 2. Birth registration 3. Coverage of FP services in hard-to-reach and underserved areas 4. Emergency contraception 5. Promotion of long acting and permanent methods 6. Demand generation for FP (especially LAPM) 7. Male involvement in FP program 8. Strengthening of monitoring and supervision (e.g. Include wealth- and gender-
specific data) 9. Home delivery of injectable contraceptive follow-up doses 10. National family planning week/day
ii. Family Planning Best Practices Proposed for Inclusion 1. Counseling for newly married couples 2. Healthy timing and spacing of pregnancies
a. Delay first pregnancy for adolescents b. Interpregnancy interval c. Limiting total number of births
3. Public private partnership and local level planning 4. ―Systematic screening‖ for FP services 5. Updating of FP eligibility criteria 6. Expansion of FP services through public sector in the urban areas
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 23
EGYPT
Facilitator: Nahed Matta, Senior Maternal and Newborn Health Advisor, USAID/Washington
Goal: Improve maternal and newborn health by re-activating and strengthening an integrated postpartum care (maternal, newborn, and FP) package of services in two districts (upper and lower) within USAID-supported governorates for future scale-up at national level.
Objectives: (not specified)
Interventions 1. Strengthening existing PPC package at PHC level with new best practices 2. The PPC package implemented successfully in two districts (50 % coverage first year and
70% second year). 3. Recommendations made for program modification and lessons learnt for future scale-up by
second year
Possible Technical Assistance Needs 1. HTSP messages included in PPC package (ESD/ACCESS-FP) follow-up Dr. Yahia H./Dr.
Nahla R./Dr. Nahla T. 2. LAM message in PPC (ESD/ACCESS-FP) follow-up: Dr. Nahla R. and Dr. Nahla T. 3. KMC introduction in PPC package (ACCESS/Save the Children) follow-up: Dr. Nahla R.
and Nahed F. 4. M&E to track progress, assess model and document results (FHI/ESD) follow-up: Dr.
Yahia H.,Dr. Nahla R., Dr. Nahla T. and Mr. Maged Y. 5. Collaborative approach for scaling up (URC) 6. Follow-up: Dr. Yahia, Dr. Nahla R. and Dr. Nader Nassif 7. Prevention of pre-eclampsia study in Upper Egypt (ACCESS/JHPIEGO) follow-up: Dr.
Nahla Roushdy, Dr. Nader Nassif and Dr. Mohamed Sweed
24 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
INDIA
Facilitators: Betsy McCallon, Senior Program Advisor, White Ribbon Alliance for Safe Motherhood Rushna Ravji, Service Delivery Technical Advisor, USAID/Washington
Goal: To reduce maternal and child mortality and morbidity country and achieved MGD goals in stipulated period. Specifically, the team aims to:
1. Promote healthy timing and spacing of pregnancy (HTSP) by encouraging young and low parity couples to adopt family planning
2. Delaying first birth until 20 years of age
Objectives: Using field-tested interventions, the program will try to achieve 80 percent coverage of pregnant women receiving the following interventions:
1. ANC check up 2. Counseling on using LAM as contraceptive until six months postpartum 3. Transiting from LAM to modern contraceptive method to delay the next pregnancy 4. Delay the next pregnancy by at least 24 months (inter-birth interval to at least 36 months)
Relevant Best Practices 1. Introducing HTSP as the concept and practice for achieving MDG goals and making it as
part of the National Rural Health Mission/Reproductive and Child Health activity 2. Promotion of contraceptive choice and identification of unmet need and provision of
family planning services during the same visit (measured in terms of better method mix)
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 25
INDONESIA
Facilitator: Annette Bongiovanni, Independent Consultant
Goal: Improve the quality and equity of maternal neonatal and child health services at all levels by 2015.
Objectives for Three Working Groups: Maternal Health, Neonatal Health, and Community Mobilization
Maternal Health Working Group Objectives: 1. For births attended by skilled providers, increase active management of the third stage of
labor (AMTSL) & contraceptive updates at the community level from 50% to 100% by 2015. 2. Increase AMTSL practice in hospitals from 31% to 90% by 2015. 3. Increase use of misoprostol from five provinces to 33 provinces by 2015 to reduce
postpartum hemorrhage. 4. By 2015, for births attended by skilled providers, increase use of Magnesium sulfate for pre-
eclampsia and eclampsia: a) from 30% to 100% PHC (Puskesmas) and, b) to 100% hospital level (all hospitals have Mg++ available but not consistently used )
Neonatal Health Working Group Objectives 1. Within two years (by 2009), establish kangaroo mother care (KMC) as a standard protocol
for care of low birth weight (LBW) babies from zero hospitals to five teaching hospitals. 2. Within one year, secure donor support to start operational research on feasibility of
community neonatal infection management by community midwives and nurses.
Community Mobilization Working Group Objective 1. Facilitate the formation of ―Alert Villages‖ in at least 80% of all villages by 2015.
Relevant Best Practices 1. AMTSL for PHC providers and hospitals 2. Community PPH with misoprostol 3. EONC & LAM 4. Magnesium sulfate for treatment of eclampsia 5. Kangaroo mother care 6. Antibiotic gentamycin for newborn infections 7. Community peer-based RH programs in India and Egypt (TAKAMOL) 8. Evidence that community programs are essential to implement technical interventions
26 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
JORDAN
Facilitator: Salwa Bitar, MNCH/RH Advisor Extending Service Delivery Project
Goal: Use magnesium sulfate (MgSO4) for all patients with pregnancy induced hypertension (PIH) in all public hospitals in Jordan
Objectives 1. Make MgSO4 available at all public sector hospitals in Jordan by the end of year 2007 2. Train all public sector obstetricians and midwives on the proper use of MgSO4 in the
management of women with PIH by the end of year 2008
Interventions to Address Lack of MgS04 1. Correct immediate shortage
a. Advocate to the Minister of Health b. Emergency purchase procedure
2. Economies of scale through purchasing needed quantities for five years a. Establish a committee to project the need b. Develop feasible alternatives to current purchasing process
i. Conduct an assessment of Jordanian drug stores‘ capacity to import MgSO4 ii. Local production iii. Bundled package procurement as part of the essential drug list
Interventions to Address Capacity Building 1. Develop an evidence based guidelines of clinical practice
a. Formulate a national guideline development committee b. Develop, pilot test, and disseminate the clinical guidelines
2. Provide capacity building training to service providers a. Train 25% of obstetricians and midwives on the proper management of PIH
3. Formulate safe motherhood committees (SMCs) at public hospital level 1. Develop SMCs manual of practice for SMCs members 2. Train core members for SMCs at public hospitals
Best Practice Incorporated into the Action Plan: Magnesium sulfate for the management of pregnancy-induced hypertension
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 27
NEPAL
Facilitator: Lily Kak, Senior Maternal and Newborn Health Advisor, USAID/Washington
Goal: To reduce maternal mortality by three-quarters and under-five mortality by two-thirds by the year 2015 from the 1990 rates.
Objective: Achieve the Millennium Development Goal 4 and 5 by 2015, namely: 1. Reduce under 5 mortality rate to 54/1,000 live births 2. Reduce Maternal mortality ratio to 134/100,000 live births 3. Deliveries by SBA-60% 4. TFR to replacement level with reduced disparity between various socio-economic and
geographic groups by 2015 focusing on unmet need 5. Make MgSO4 available at all public sector hospitals by the end of year 2007 6. Train all public sector obstetricians and midwives on the proper use of MgSO4 in the
management of women with PIH by the end of year 2008
Interventions to Address Maternal and Neonatal Health 1. Piloting/expanding new interventions: Calcium for pre-eclampsia/eclampsia, HH-level NN-
resuscitation, NN vitamin A, CHX for cord-care, PPH prevention (AMTSL/misoprostol), KMC, sepsis-management for newborn babies as a component of CB-IMCI
2. Develop a core package–Pilot, introduce, and expand to 10 districts over next two years 3. For home deliveries– pilot and test some intra-partum assistance for support and care for
newborn, e.g. by FCHV or other CHW–establishing stronger HH-HF linkages 4. Antenatal health-edu/BCC- BPP – birth planning (including demand-creation for SBA),
ENC, danger sign recognition/response 5. Iron/folate/de-worming/TT 6. Post-natal care 7. 24/7 Health facility services (BEOC, BEmONC, CEmONC)
Interventions to Address Child Health 1. Community-based-IMCI – Expand to all 75 districts (from 42) by 2009. 2. Zinc expansion within CB-IMCI– 25 districts in 2007/08, and remainder by 2009 3. Japanese Encephalitis vaccine in all 21 terai districts (currently in 8 districts) by 2009 4. Maintaining vitamin A and de-worming quality coverage over 90% in all supplementation
rounds. 5. Maintaining BCG, DPT3/Hepatitis B and measles coverage over 80% 6. Maintaining quality and coverage in CB-IMCI program 7. Strengthening the logistics supply to the rural areas
Interventions to Address Family Planning 1. Targeted programmatic strategies for groups with high unmet need 2. PAC/PNC includes family planning counseling and services 3. FP counseling and services (more choices) available/increased use through outreach/CHWs 4. Emergency contraception promoted through both private and public sector
Cross-Cutting Interventions 1. Advocacy (policy to grass root level) 2. BCC (individual, family, community & service provider)
28 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
3. Community participation, mobilization, and empowerment (Health governance improvement)
4. Male involvement in all healthcare settings 5. Collaboration and PPP (institutional) 6. Integration of appropriate health interventions 7. Inter-sectoral approaches (decentralization) 8. Ensure social inclusion and equity at all levels
Best Practices Incorporated into the Action Plan 1. Household and community level
a. Neonatal resuscitation b. Neonatal vitamin A c. Chlorhexidine for cord-care d. Postpartum hemorrhage prevention e. KMC f. Sepsis management g. Community-based treatment of pneumonia and diarrhea, including zinc h. Vitamin A and deworming
2. IMCI – community-based case-management 3. Iodized salt (commercial) 4. Calcium for preeclampsia and eclampsia 5. Healthy timing and spacing of pregnancy 6. Integration of MCH services 7. Early and exclusive breastfeeding needs more emphasis 8. Collaborative effort and exploring public-private partnerships – e.g. distribution of zinc
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 29
PAKISTAN
Facilitator: Maureen Norton, Senior Technical Advisor, USAID/Washington
Goal: To scale-up state-of-the-art best practices on FP/RH & MNCH to achieve Millennium Development Goals 4 & 5
Objectives 1. By the end of 2015, reduce maternal and child mortality by three quarters and two thirds,
respectively, by adopting evidence based best practices 2. Universal coverage of modern family planning methods by 2010
Interventions to Address Maternal, Neonatal, and Child Health 1. AMTSL 2. Community package on immediate newborn care 3. Effectiveness of zinc on prevention and management of diarrhea 4. Low osmolarity ORS 5. Activities:
a. Consultative meeting b. Skill building workshops at academic institutions c. Consensus building workshop d. Inclusion in National MNCH and Lady Health Worker program e. Advocacy Advisory Network for Newborns
Interventions to Address Family Planning 1. Birth spacing as an integral part of FP/RH/MNCH program (e.g., LAM, SDM, EC, PAC)
a. Demonstrating successful examples of EC and PAC from other Muslim countries and within Pakistan
b. LAM and SDM: Integrated into MNCH package c. Pilot in 19 districts of USAID & UNFPA by 2009; scale up to 132 by 2010
Cross-Cutting Interventions 1. Involvement of Key Stakeholders/Religious Leaders
a. Formation of broad stakeholder group b. Develop strategy c. Formulate and implement agenda specific advocacy strategy for FP/MNCH
Best Practices Incorporated into the Action Plan Maternal Health: AMTSL; MgSO4 Neonatal Health: Exclusive breastfeeding; resuscitation, LBW, and sepsis management Child Health: Zinc; low osmolarity ORS; management at community level of ARI Family Planning: Strengthening of long-acting methods; plus LAM; SDM; EC; PAC Cross-Cutting: Advocacy; involvement of male and female religious leaders; adolescent/youth RH Integration: Functional integration of FP/RH/MNCH
30 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
PHILIPPINES
Facilitator: Catharine McKaig, Director ACCESS-FP Program, Johns Hopkins University
Goal: Increase the proportion of deliveries managed by skilled birth attendants from 60% in 2006 to 70% by 2010 and then to 90% by 2015.
Objectives: (not specified)
Interventions (Priority Activities) 1. Policy framework of national plan of action for MNCH with new best practices finalized
and approved 2. Operational guidelines for integration 3. Advocacy tools for target stakeholders 4. Family health book demonstration site 5. Pre-service and in-service training curriculum 6. Updating training materials & CMMNC manuals 7. Upgrading health facilities as BEmONC/CEmONC 8. Integrated supervisory M&E tools 9. Advocacy for amendment of midwifery law 10. Advocacy for inclusion of AMTSL into MCP in PhilHealth
Best Practices for Scale-Up Incorporated into the Action Plan 1. Capacity and empowerment of frontline health workers to provide injections (MgSO4,
gentamycin, immunizations), use partograph, provide SDM, long-acting and permanent methods
2. Amend the Midwifery Law 3. Inclusion of AMTSL in current curricula for pre-service and in-service training manuals for
midwives 4. Resource mobilization for local government and private sector as well as SHI
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 31
TIMOR LESTE
Facilitator: Neal Brandes, Health Specialist/Health Research Advisor, USAID, Washington
Goal: Reduce neonatal mortality – from 33/1,000 lb to 23/1000 lb—to improve the lives of mothers and children.
Objectives 1. Facilities and Equipment: Every community health center (CHC) identifies a place for
delivery with essential equipment a. 30%- 40% of CHC have delivery space now in pilot districts b. In one year, 100% of CHC will have delivery space in pilot districts c. In five years, 100% of CHC nationwide
2. Community Engagement/Behavior Change Communication a. Ensure 100% PSF volunteers operationalize use of community register in 4 pilot
districts in first year b. Development of BCC strategy for newborn care within continuum of care for
mothers and children c. Develop community mobilization component of the BSP to include newborn care
3. Quality Improvement a. Train all midwives and 100% of health post staff in Essential Newborn Care
(ENBC) (end of 2008 in 4 pilot districts, scale up within five years) b. Minimum package of ENBC delivered on first and second postpartum visits (1 year) c. Strengthen linkages between facility and community and initiate community
oversight of strategy (5 years)
Interventions for Equipping of Facilities for Delivery and Neonatal care 1. Build consensus and mobilizing resources with stakeholders and set timeline for national
scale-up 2. District level assessment and planning by DHS--Identify resources needed and begin
procurement 3. Community mobilization planning 4. Reorganize existing facility space 5. District annual plans recalibrated in for additional resources required 6. Monitoring 100% CHCs in pilot districts ready for deliveries and scale-up
Interventions for Engaging Community for Newborn Health 1. Build stakeholder consensus 2. Establish pregnancy register in pilot Community Health Volunteers (CHV) SD and village
mapping 3. Village/Suco council strategic planning 4. Develop neonatal of the child health BCC strategy 5. Pilot timed and targeted messages register in 2-4 sub districts 6. Adapt tools and develop materials for radio serial 7. Pilot different educational approaches for Suco councils and CHV 8. Scale up and roll out alongside national strategic plan for CHVs and BCC
32 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Interventions for Improve quality of care for newborns 1. Establish policy on delivery of postpartum care 2. Refine package of ENBC/include KMC 3. Define national-level job descriptions and build capacity to support quality improvement
processes 4. Study tours for KMC/home-based care/systems support of the newborn 5. Ongoing national and local feedback systems including defining accountability of Suco
council 6. Scale up and roll out alongside national strategic plan
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 33
VIETNAM
Facilitator: Pauline Muhuhu, Best Practices Advisor, Extending Service Delivery Project
Goal: To contribute to reduction MMR due to PPH in Northern Vietnam through scaling up the comprehensive intervention of AMTSL at all service delivery points.
Objective: By the year 2010, reduce MMR from 411/100,000 lb (2002) to 200/100,000 lb in Northern Mountainous Region
Interventions 1. Disseminate the MOH‘s Policy on AMTSL nationwide 2. Advocacy for friendly application of the policy at all levels 3. Update training materials on AMTSL
a. pre-service at secondary medical school, ethnic midwife training b. refresher/in-service training c. Update M&E checklists & medical supplies d. TOT training and replicate training at all level
4. Coaching/Training Follow-up for skill building 5. Supportive supervision and technical backstopping 6. M&E: track progress and measure impact
a. Baseline b. Intermediate indicators (compliance to national guidelines of AMTSL, utilization of
services) c. Final outcomes (MMR)
7. Collaboratives amongst stakeholders: MOH, WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, Pathfinder International, GTZ, World Bank, Netherlands, Local and International NGOs, civil society organizations; with the MOH as leading the support
8. Community mobilization/BCC on maternal and neonatal health 9. Constant availability of drugs (oxytocin Uniject, oxytocin vial), medical supplies (blood loss
bag) and others
Best Practices: Comprehensive interventions on AMTSL (Niger experiences in scaling up AMTSL) ―Ethnic minority midwives‖ (who have low education level and skills-based training for 18 months) will apply AMSTL
34 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
YEMEN
Facilitator: Milka Dinev, Director Extending Service Delivery Project
Goal: To contribute to the reduction of maternal and neonatal mortality rates as a result of complications of pregnancy, childbirth and post partum by starting to work in Al Sabeen Hospital (the main referral MNCH/FP hospitals) and then scaling up to the other biggest hospitals (where more deliveries occur).
Objective: Four best practices will be introduced and applied efficiently and effectively as per agreed upon standards and guidelines in the main referral hospitals in Yemen by the end of 2009.
Interventions 1. Approval and support of the MPH&P for the introduction of the best practices by the team
leaders 2. Incorporate standards and guidelines in the newly developed RH/MNCH standards of the
Ministry of Public Health. 3. Meet the General Directors of health offices as well as the directors of the targeted hospitals
and related service providers to discuss the best practices to be introduced in their hospitals. 4. Incorporate standards and guidelines in the newly developed RH/ MNCH standards of the
Ministry of Public Health. 5. Introduce these best practices to the donors and other interested stakeholders.
Best Practices Incorporated into the Action Plan
1. Kangaroo mother care 2. Postpartum family planning 3. Immediate and exclusive breastfeeding 4. Neonatal infection prevention 5. Distribution of vitamin A
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 35
APPENDIX 4: DAILY EVALUATION FORMS
DAILY EVALUATION FOR TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 4, 2007
PLENARY: Catalyzing and Sustaining Change: Strategies for Improving Maternal Health and Achieving MDG Goal 5 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The plenary session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about the state of the art on newborn health.
3. I gained understanding of how some donor agencies are addressing the global mandate of scaling up newborn, infant, and child health.
4. I gained understanding of how at least one country is scaling up newborn and child health interventions.
Comments:
PLENARY: Using Effective Change Processes for Scaling-up FP/MNCH Best Practices Please indicate the degree to which you agree
or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The plenary session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
the state of the art on newborn health.
3. I gained understanding of how some donor agencies are addressing the global mandate of scaling
up newborn, infant, and child health.
4. I gained understanding of how at least one country
is scaling up newborn and child health interventions.
Comments:
36 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
DAILY EVALUATION FOR TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 4, 2007
TECHNICAL SESSION C (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-1 MAT-4 FP-3 FP-4 INT-2 CC-5 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an evidence-based best practice.
3. At least one of the best practices presented were relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one
of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
Comments:
TECHNICAL SESSION D (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-8 MAT-1 CC-3 CC-10 FP-9 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about a best practice.
3. At least one of the evidence-based best practices presented were relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one
of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
Comments:
Place completed evaluation in labeled boxes located throughout the conference area.
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 37
DAILY EVALUATION FOR WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 5, 2007
PLENARY: Catalyzing and Sustaining Change: Strategies for Improving Maternal Health and Achieving MDG Goal 5 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The plenary session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about the state of the art on newborn health.
3. I gained understanding of how some donor agencies are addressing the global mandate of scaling up maternal health.
4. I gained understanding of how at least one country is scaling up maternal interventions.
Comments:
PLENARY: Using Effective Change Processes for Scaling-up FP/MNCH Best Practices Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The plenary session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
the state of the art on family planning.
3. I gained understanding of how some donor agencies are addressing the global mandate of scaling
up family planning.
4. I gained understanding of how at least one country is scaling up family planning interventions.
Comments:
Place completed evaluation in labeled boxes located throughout the conference area.
38 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
DAILY EVALUATION FOR WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 5, 2007
TECHNICAL SESSION C (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-1 MAT-4 FP-3 FP-4 INT-2 CC-5 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an evidence-based best practice.
3. At least one of the best practices presented were relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one
of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
Comments:
TECHNICAL SESSION D (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-8 MAT-1 CC-3 CC-10 FP-9 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
a best practice.
3. At least one of the evidence-based best practices presented were relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
Comments:
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 39
DAILY EVALUATION FOR WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 5, 2007
PLENARY: Past Progress and Promising Directions for Family Planning in Asia Please indicate the degree to which you agree
or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The plenary session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
the state of the art family planning practices.
3. I gained understanding of how some donor agencies are addressing the global mandate of scaling
up family planning interventions.
4. I gained understanding of how at least one country is scaling up family planning interventions.
Comments:
TECHNICAL SESSION E (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-2 NIC-5 MAT-2 FP-2 SCL-3 CC-8 Please indicate the degree to which you agree
or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session objectives were met
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an evidence-based best practice.
3. At least one of the best practices presented were
relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
Comments:
40 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
DAILY EVALUATION FOR THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 6, 2007
TECHNICAL SESSION F (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-4 MAT-2 MAT-5 FP-9 SCL-2 SCL-4 SCL-5 CC-11 Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
a best practice.
3. At least one of the evidence-based best practices presented were relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
Comments:
Place completed evaluation in labeled boxes located throughout the conference area.
Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region 41
DAILY EVALUATION FOR FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 7, 2007
PLENARY: Where is the “I” in FP/MNCH? Please indicate the degree to which you agree
or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The plenary session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
the integration of FP/MNCH programs.
3. I gained understanding of how some donor agencies are integrating FP/MNCH programs
4. I gained understanding of how at least one country is integrating FP/MNCH programs.
Comments:
TECHNICAL SESSION G (Refer to the program guide and circle the session you attended):
NIC-7 MAT-6 FP-7 INT-1 SCL-4 CC-9 Please indicate the degree to which you agree
or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an evidence-based best practice.
3. At least one of the best practices presented were
relevant to my country situation.
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one of the best practices I learned during this session.
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
Comments:
42 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
DAILY EVALUATION FOR FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 7, 2007
GLOBAL e-LEARNING Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. It was easy to use to e-Learning course.
2. I gained knowledge relevant to my own setting.
3. I will apply knowledge learned through e-Learning when I return home.
4. I will recommend that my colleagues take the e-
Learning courses.
What did you like best about the e-Learning courses?
What would you change about the e-Learning courses?
SKILLS LAB (Offered on Tuesday and Thursday) Please indicate the degree to which you agree or disagree with the following statements:
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. I learned at least one new skill.
2. The skills offered were relevant to my own setting.
3. I will apply knowledge learned through at a Skill Lab when I return home.
4. I would have liked more time to work in the Skills Lab.
What did you like best about the Skills Lab?
What would you change about the Skills Lab?
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 43
APPENDIX 5: EVALUATION RESULTS
Day 1, Tuesday, September 4, 2007
NIC Plenary: Scaling-up Newborn, Infant, and Child Health Programs: The
Global Mandate (N = 10)
Results
Total Completed Forms = 10
Total Neonatal, Infant & Child Plenary
= 10
Total Category A = 10
Sessions Not Identified = 4
Sessions Identified = 6
Total Category B = 10
Sessions Not Identified = 3
Sessions Identified = 7
Table 1: NIC Plenary
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met (NR= 1)
40% (4)
30% (3)
10% (1)
10% (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about the
state of the art on newborn health.
30% (3)
30% (3)
30% (3)
10% (1)
3. I gained
understanding of how some donor agencies are addressing the
global mandate of scaling up NIC health
50%
(5)
40%
(4)
10%
(1)
4. I gained
understanding of how at least one country is scaling up NIC
interventions.
40%
(4)
50%
(5)
10%
(1)
No Comments
44 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session A (N = 10)
Session Attended Not Identified (N = 4)
Table 2: A
Session Not Identified
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session
objectives were met.
50%
(2)
50%
(2)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an
evidence-based best practice.
50% (2)
25% (1)
25% (1)
3. At least one of the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
50% (2)
50% (2)
4. When I return
home, I will explore adapting one of the best practices I learned during this
session.
50%
(2)
25%
(1)
25%
(1)
5. The presentation
was interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
75%
(3)
25%
(1)
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 45
Technical Session A
Sessions Identified (N = 6)
Sessions with n < 4 (N = 6)
CC-1: Advocacy for Policy Development and Implementation (n = 2)
FP-1: Family Planning through the First Year Postpartum (n = 1)
MAT-3: Prevention & Treatment of Pre-Eclampsia/Eclampsia (n = 3)
Table 3: A
Session Identified
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session
objectives were met.
MAT-3 (3)
FP-1 (1)
CC-1 (1) CC-1 (1)
2. I gained
sufficient knowledge to understand about
an evidence-based best practice.
MAT-3 (1)
FP-1 (1)
CC-1 (1)
MAT-3 (2)
CC-1
(1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
MAT-3 (1)
FP-1 (1)
CC-1 (1)
MAT-3 (2)
CC-1
(1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session.
CC-1 (1) MAT-3 (3)
FP-1 (1)
CC-1 (1)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
CC-1 (1)
MAT-3 (2) FP-1 (1)
CC-1 (1) MAT-3 (1)
Comments:
“People went over time in NIC-3”
46 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session B (N = 10)
Session Attended Not Identified (N = 3)
Table 4: B Session Not
Identified
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met.
(2) (1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
(2) (1)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented was relevant to my country situation.
(2) (1)
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting
one of the best practices I learned during this
session.
(2) (1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
(2) (1)
No Comments
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 47
Technical Session B
Session Attended Identified (N = 7)
SCL-1: Scaling-up Community-based Skilled Birth Attendants (N = 4) Table 5: B SCL-1
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Some-what
Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met.
25% (1)
25% (1)
25% (1)
25% (1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an evidence-based best practice.
(NR = 1)
25%
(1)
25%
(1)
25%
(1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my country situation.
50%
(2)
25%
(1)
25%
(1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned during this session.
50% (2)
50% (2)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and discussion.
25% (1)
50% (2)
25% (1)
Comments:
Request for presentations.
“Excellent session but much more interest than expected; however the group
accommodated.”
48 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session B
Session Identified (N = 7)
Sessions with n < 4
FP-6: Learning from Our Success and Our Failures: Evidence-based Programming for
Adolescents (n = 2)
CC-2: Using Data for Decision Making to Achieve the MDGs (n = 1)
Table 6: B
FP-6 & CC-2
Strongly
Agree
Agree Some-
what Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session
objectives were met.
FP-6 (1) FP-6 (1) CC-2 (1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an evidence-based
best practice. (NR = 1)
FP-6 (2) CC-2 (1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
FP-6 (1) FP-6 (1) CC-2 (1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session.
FP-6 (1) CC-2 (1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
FP-6 (2) CC-2 (1)
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 49
APPENDIX 7: EVALUATION RESULTS
Day 2, Wednesday, September 5, 2007
MAT-P—Maternal Health Plenary: Strategies for Improving Maternal
Health (N = 62)
Results
Total Completed Forms = 66
Total Maternal Health Plenary = 62 (NR = 4)
Total Scaling-up Plenary = 58 (NR = 1)
Total Category C = 58 (NR = 8)
No Session Identified = 21
Session Identified = 37
Total Category D = 60 (NR = 6)
No Session Identified = 25
Session Identified = 35
Table 1: Maternal Health
Plenary
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met. (NR = 1)
24% (15)
55% (34)
13% (8)
5% (3)
3% (2)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about the state of the art on [maternal]
health.
21% (13)
60% (37)
10% (6)
3% (2)
3% (2)
3% (2)
3. I gained understanding of
how some donor agencies are addressing the
global mandate of scaling up maternal health.
19% (12)
18% (11)
21% (13)
8% (5)
5% (3)
2% (1)
4. I gained understanding of how at least one
country is scaling up maternal interventions.
26% (16)
42% (26)
21% (13)
3% (2)
5% (3)
2% (1)
50 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Comments:
“Session was much too long. Too much figure heads with same data we all know.”
“Too many information in too many slides that became boring. I don’t see any relation
b/t UNFPA presentation and strategies for improving maternal health and achieving
MDG-5….please stick to time.”
“Time is short compared to information.”
“All presentations were good.”
“Q&A is taking too much time because of stories and discussion. I hope you can control
this.”
“Good presentations by Koblinsky and India case. Rest is too general.”
“Objectives not clear.”
“Please encourage presenters to keep time; so that participants could ask questions.
Propose that moderator takes 3-5 questions at a time to encourage great
representation of conference participants.”
“None of the country or presenters highlighted the difficulties or failure of programs. I
strongly believe that every program has its own difficulties which [were] not shared in
the presentations.”
“Congratulations to the presenters. The moderator was good in keeping well with
time.”
“Plenaries consistently dull (except 1-2 presenters). Suggest asking presenters to
present any new and engaging, innovative information. Donors presentations particularly
dull.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 51
SCL-P Scaling-up Plenary: Using Effective Change Processes for Scaling up
FP/MNCH Best Practices (N = 58)
Table 2: Scaling up Plenary
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
NR=1
21% (12)
67% (39)
5% (3)
3% (2)
2% (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about the state of the art on [scaling-up].
NR=1
6% (10)
60% (35)
7% (4)
10% (6)
2% (1)
3. I gained understanding of
how some donor agencies are addressing the
global mandate of scaling up neonatal health.
19% (11)
55% (32)
9% (5)
9% (5)
7% (4)
4. I gained understanding of how at least one
country is scaling up neonatal interventions].
NR=2
21% (12)
50% (29)
16% (9)
3% (2)
5% (3)
2% (1)
Comments:
“Too long. Somewhat repetitive of abstract.”
“The presentations are too long.”
“Valuable presentations, need more time to discuss each and to exchange experience
that could also be “models” to be replicated totally or tailored accordingly.”
“Time is so short compared to the subject.”
Presentations were very good.”
“It is often the case, at home funding is not available for scaling-up. Richard Khol’s
presentation was excellent-however, I would like to know how UNICEF, UNFPA, Bank
and other big donors are considering to fund scale-up activities. I know USAID is
committed but what about other donors—especially those in European countries?”
“The presentation by MSI should have been presented ..ing day—as guide for ..ax.”
“This was a great presentation. Relevant material was shared. It was wonderful to have
different perspectives from MSI which competed the traditional development thinking.
Important, though, to respect the time limits.” “Congratulations to the organizers and the presenters.”
52 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category C (N = 58)
Session Not Identified (N = 21)
Table 3: C Session Not
Identified
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Some-what
Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met.
19% (4)
81% (17)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an evidence-based
best practice. NR = 1
33% (7)
62% (13)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
43%
(9)
43%
(9)
14%
(3)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session.
33% (7)
48% (10)
19% (4)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
24%
(5)
48%
(10)
24%
(5)
5%
(1)
Comments:
“Overloaded program.”
“Start prompt time.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 53
Technical Category C (N = 58)
Session Identified (N = 37)
NIC-1: Essential Newborn Care for all Newborns (n = 12)
Table 4: C NIC-1
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
50% (6)
50% (6)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an
evidence-based best practice.
42% (5)
50% (6)
8% (1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation. NR=1
50%
(6)
25%
(3)
17%
(2)
4. When I return
home, I will explore adapting one of the best practices I
learned during this session.
50%
(6)
25%
(3)
25%
(3)
5. The presentation
was interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
42%
(5)
50%
(6)
8%
(1)
No Comments
54 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category C
Session Identified (N = 37)
FP-4: Monitoring and Evaluation for Maternal Health (n = 10)
Table 5: C FP-4
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
30% (3)
50% (5)
10% (1)
10% (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based best practice.
(NR=1)
10% (1)
60% (6)
20% (2)
10% (1)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented was relevant to my country situation.
(NR=1)
20% (2)
30% (3)
30% (3)
10% (1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session. (NR=1)
20% (2)
30% (3)
10% (1)
10% (1)
10% (1)
10% (1)
5. The presentation was interactive and
allowed for participation and discussion.
40% (4)
10% (1)
10% (1)
10% (1)
20% (2)
10% (1)
Comments:
“The schedule is overloaded—no time to understand and re-read.”
“Limited time to discuss—should have [powerpoint] presentation for participants.”
“Second speaker too technical.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 55
Technical Category C
Session Identified (N = 37)
FP-3 Session: Health Timing and Spacing of Pregnancy Advocacy and Education (N = 6)
Table 6: C FP-3
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
33% (2)
50% (3)
17% (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice. (NR = 1)
17% (1)
50% (3)
17% (1)
17% (1)
3. At least one
of the best practices presented was
relevant to my country situation.
17%
(1)
33%
(2)
33%
(2)
17%
(1)
4. When I return home, I will explore
adapting one of the best practices I
learned during this session.
33% (2)
33% (2)
33% (2)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
17%
(1)
33%
(3)
17%
(1)
No Comments
56 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category C
Session Identified (N = 37)
MAT-4: Maternal Nutrition (N = 4)
Table 7: C MAT-4
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Some-what
Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met.
75% (3)
25% (1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an
evidence-based best practice. (NR = 1)
25% (1)
75% (3)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented was relevant to my country
situation.
50% (2)
50% (2)
4. When I return home, I
will explore adapting one of the best
practices I learned during this session.
75% (3)
25% (1)
5. The presentation was interactive and
allowed for participation and discussion.
50% (2)
50% (2)
No Comments
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 57
Technical Category C
Session Identified (N = 37)
FP-4: Tips and Tools to Overcome Medical Barriers and Improve Best Clinical Practices in
Family Planning (N = 4)
Table 8: C FP-4
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
50% (2)
50% (2)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice. (NR = 1)
25% (1)
25% (1)
50% (2)
3. At least one
of the best practices presented was
relevant to my country situation.
50%
(2)
25%
(1)
25%
(1)
4. When I return home, I will explore
adapting one of the best practices I
learned during this session.
25% (1)
50% (2)
25% (1)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
25%
(1)
75%
(3)
Comments:
“I learned nothing new!”
58 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category C
Session Identified (N = 37)
Sessions with n < 4 (N = 1)
INT-2: Impact! The Why, Hows, and Wherefores of Using Information and Communication
Technology in Scaling-up Health Service Delivery (N = 1)
Table 9: C INT-2 = 1
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
(1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based best practice.
(NR=1)
(1)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented was relevant to my country situation.
(1)
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting
one of the best practices I learned during this
session.
(1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
(1)
No Comments.
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 59
Technical Category D
No Sessions Identified (N = 25)
Table 10: D No session
identified
Strongly Agree Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral
Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met. (NR = 1)
24% (6)
56% (14)
8% (2)
4% (1)
4% (1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an
evidence-based best practice. (NR = 3)
16% (4)
56% (14)
12% (3)
4% (1)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented was relevant to my country
situation. (NR=2)
28% (7)
44% (11)
8% (2)
8% (2)
4% (1)
4. When I return home, I
will explore adapting one of the best
practices I learned during this session. (NR
= 2)
36% (9)
40% (10)
8% (2)
4% (1)
4% (1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
12% (3)
60% (15)
12% (3)
12% (3)
4% (1)
Comments:
“There are too many sessions [offered] simultaneously, which is why I could not attend
all. I will use websites for more materials.”
60 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category D
Sessions Identified (N = 35)
MAT-1: Lost Opportunities or New Innovations: The Real World of AMSTSL (N = 9)
Table 11: D MAT-1
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
22% (2)
55% (5)
22% (2)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
22% (2)
44% (4)
33% (3)
3. At least one of the best
practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
22% (2)
33% (3)
44% (4)
4. When I
return home, I will explore adapting one
of the best practices I learned during
this session. NR = 1
22%
(2)
44%
(4)
22%
(2)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed
for participation and discussion.
22%
(2)
22%
(2)
33%
(3)
11%
(1)
11%
(1)
Comments:
“Try to make all session in one floor—so long to move from one to another.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 61
Technical Category D
Sessions Identified (N = 35)
NIC-8: Newborn Resuscitation in Low Resource Settings (N = 7)
Table 12: D NIC-8
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
71% (5)
29% (2)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
71% (5)
14% (1)
14% (1)
3. At least one of the best
practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
71% (5)
29% (2)
4. When I
return home, I will explore adapting one of
the best practices I learned during
this session.
71%
(5)
14%
(1)
14%
(1)
5. The presentation
was interactive and allowed for participation
and discussion.
71% (5)
14% (1)
14% (1)
Comments:
“Excellent presentation/new information.”
62 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category D
Sessions Identified (N = 35)
CC-7: New and Renewed Use of M&E Tools for Decision Making (N = 7)
Table 13: D CC-7
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
14% (1)
43% (3)
43% (3)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based best practice.
29% (2)
43% (3)
29% (2)
3. At least one of the best practices presented was
relevant to my country situation.
57% (4)
43% (3)
4. When I return
home, I will explore adapting one of the best
practices I learned during this session.
29%
(2)
29%
(2)
43%
(3)
5. The presentation was interactive and
allowed for participation and discussion.
29% (2)
43% (3)
29% (2)
Comments:
“We need more information.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 63
Technical Category D
Sessions Identified (N = 35)
CC-3: Non-traditional Linkages with High Impact Results: Involving Religious Leaders and Men
in FP/MNCH (N = 5)
Table 14: D CC-3
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
20% (1)
80% (4)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
20% (1)
60% (3)
20% (1)
3. At least one of the best
practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
20% (1)
60% (3)
20% (1)
4. When I
return home, I will explore adapting one of
the best practices I learned during
this session.
40%
(2)
40%
(2)
20%
(1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
20% (1)
60% (3)
20% (1)
No Comments.
64 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category D
Sessions Identified (N = 35)
FP-9: Overcoming Access and Policy Barriers for IUD Use in India and Jordan (N = 4)
Table 15: D FP-9
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met. NR = 1
50% (2)
25% (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
an evidence-based best practice.
50% (2)
25% (1)
25% (1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
50%
(2)
25%
(1)
25%
(1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session.
50% (2)
25% (1)
25% (1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
50% (2)
25% (1)
25% (1)
Comments:
“[Session objectives] not mentioned.”
“Nothing was presented; the presentation was a PLAN, not a best practice because NO
results or outcomes that’s worth replicating.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 65
Technical Category D
Sessions Identified (N = 35)
Sessions with n < 4 (N = 3)
CC-10: Experiences from Country Programs II (N = 2)
INT-3: Systematic Screening: A Strategy for Increasing Utilization of Integrated Services (N = 1)
Table 16: D CC-10 & INT-3
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
CC-10 (2) INT-3
(1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an
evidence-based best practice.
CC-10 (2)
INT-3 (1)
3. At least one
of the best practices presented was
relevant to my country situation.
CC-10
(1)
CC-10 (1)
INT-3 (1)
4. When I return home, I will explore
adapting one of the best practices I
learned during this session.
CC-10 (2)
INT-3 (1)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
CC-10
(2) INT-3 (1)
No Comments.
66 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
APPENDIX 8: EVALUATION RESULTS
Day 3, Thursday, September 6th
FP Plenary: Past Progress and Promising Directions for Family Planning in
Asia (N = 33)
Results Total Completed Forms = 37 Total Plenary = 33 (NR = 4) Total Category E = 32 (NR = 5)
Sessions Not Identified = 10 Sessions Identified = 22
Total Category F = 31 (NR = 6) Sessions Not Identified = 10
Sessions Identified = 21
Table 1: FP-P Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met (NR=1 )
24% (8)
55% (18)
18% (6)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
the state family planning practices. (NR=1 )
21% (7)
49% (16)
18% (6)
6% (2)
3% (1)
3. I gained understanding of how some donor
agencies are addressing the global mandate of scaling up family planning
interventions.
18% (6)
46% (15)
30% (10)
6% (2)
4. I gained
understanding of how at least one country is scaling up family planning
interventions. (NR=1 )
12%
(4)
52%
(17)
30%
(10)
3%
(1)
Comments:
“Very useful for me.”
“I believe commodity security and availability of essential RH drugs should have been
part of one of the plenaries. Especially since quality of care is not possible without
appropriate availability of essential drugs, including contraceptives. Key for scaling-up.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 67
“Workshop organizers should copy slide presentation (put in CD) of all presentations
or at least plenary sessions and distribute to all participants….”
“Hand-out of each presentation needs to be distributed to participants in order to easily
follow the presentation as well as saving time for taking notes…Need more time for
plenary session for giving opportunity to all participants to discuss and interactive in
each session.”
“Presentations: clear, interesting; Presenters: confident; Topic: very important.”
“Speaker should make visible presentation, not just give a speech.”
“Please copy slide presentation to CD and distribute to all participants.”
“I would like to ask all presentation by hardcopy (handout).”
“We are not informed about the objectives.”
“It’s good that you had few speakers at this plenary session.”
“It is very informative and integrating session and [I] gained knowledge about family
planning.”
“Very good, keep it up.”
“President [of] Pathfinder excellent.”
“Very good meeting sharing the programme each other country situations of family
planning, etc.”
“Plenary speaker—Mr. Daniel Pellegrom—was very good; best.”
68 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session E (N = 32)
Sessions Not Identified (N = 10)
Table 2: E (no Session ID)
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
60% (6)
40% (4)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about an evidence-based best
practice.
40%
(4)
60%
(6)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented was relevant to my country situation.
NR=1
40% (4)
50% (5)
4. When I return home, I will explore
adapting one of the best practices I learned during this
session. NR=1
50% (5)
3% (3)
1% (1)
5. The presentation
was interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
50%
(5)
50%
(5)
Comments:
“Very effective (illegible word).”
“Sometimes the room was very full.”
“It is very, very informative and useful session.” (Referring to either NIC-2 or MAT-2) “I
gained knowledge about oral misoprostol.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 69
Technical Session E (N = 32)
Sessions Identified (N= 21)
MAT-2: Enabling Women to Protect Themselves from Postpartum Hemorrhage during Home
Births (N = 7)
Table 3: E MAT-2
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
(1) (5) (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
(3) (4)
3. At least one of the best
practices presented was relevant to my
country situation. NR=3
(3) (1) (1)
4. When I return
home, I will explore adapting one of the best
practices I learned during this session.
NR=1
(3) (3) (1)
5. The presentation was
interactive and allowed for participation and
discussion.
(2) (5)
Comments:
“The panel was excellent. We heard efficacy rates, 2 presentations on country
programs, and then the Venture strategies presentation on registration of the drug.
Thanks to Harshad for an excellent, clear, and interactive panel.”
70 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session E (N = 32)
Sessions Identified (N = 21)
FP-2 Session: Standard Days Method and CycleBeads: Bringing New Users to Family Planning
(N = 5)
Table 4: E
FP-2
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met.
(1) (1) (3)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based best practice.
(1) (2) (3)
3. At least one of the best practices presented was
relevant to my country situation. NR=3
(3) (2)
4. When I return home, I will explore adapting one of the
best practices I learned during this session. NR=1
(1) (4)
5. The presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
(1) (2) (2)
No Comments
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 71
Technical Session E (N = 32)
Session Identified with < 3 responses per session (N = 11)
SCL-3: Fostering Change (N = 3)
NIC-2: Let the Low Birth Weight and Preterm Babies Live! (N = 2)
NIC-5: Newborn Micronutrients (N = 2)
CC-8: Using Indicators and Monitoring and Evaluation to Guide Programs (N = 3)
CC-4: Promoting Women’s Health through Partnerships with Private Sector (N = 1)
Table 5:
E (w/Session ID)
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session
objectives were met. NR=1 (CC-4)
SCL-3
SCL-3 NIC-5 CC-8
CC-8 CC-8
NIC-2
NIC-2 NIC-5
SCL-3
2. I gained
sufficient knowledge to understand about
an evidence-based best practice.
SCL-3
SCL-3 NIC-5 NIC-5
CC-8 CC-8
NIC-2
CC-8
SCL-3
NIC-2
CC-4
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
SCL-3
SCL-3 NIC-5 CC-8
CC-8
NIC-2
NIC-5 CC-8 CC-4
SCL-3
NIC-2
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session.
SCL-3 SCL-3
NIC-5 CC-8 CC-8
NIC-5 CC-4
NIC-2 CC-8
SCL-3 NIC-2
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
SCL-3
SCL-3 CC-8
NIC-5
CC-8 CC-8 CC-4
SCL-3
NIC-2 NIC-2 NIC-5
Comments:
SCL-3: “An excellent session with a lot of interaction.”
CC-8: “Good. All 3 presenters were well-prepared and provided clear information.”
CC-4: “What are the [session] objectives?”
72 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session F (N = 31)
Session Not Identified (N = 10)
Table 6: F No session ID
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
30% (3)
60% (6)
10% (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about an
evidence-based best practice.
20% (2)
60% (6)
10% (1)
10% (1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
30%
(3)
50%
(5)
10%
(1)
10%
(1)
4. When I return home, I will explore
adapting one of the best practices I learned during this
session. NR=1
20% (2)
60% (6)
10% (1)
5. The presentation was interactive and
allowed for participation and discussion.
20% (2)
70% (7)
10% (1)
Comments:
“I strongly recommend that organizers should provide a copy of CD which combines all
presentations as you did in Bangladesh before last year.”
“It is informative and integrated session. I gained knowledge and when I return, I will be
adapting one of the best practice I learned during this session.” (Session referenced was
either MAT-5, SCl-4, or CC-11.)
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 73
Technical Session F (N = 31)
Sessions Identified (N = 21)
NIC-4: Infant Feeding Practices (N = 5)
Table 7: F NIC-4
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
(1) (3) (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
(2) (3)
3. At least one of the best
practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
(2) (2) (1)
4. When I
return home, I will explore adapting one of
the best practices I learned during
this session. NR=1
(3) (2)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
(1) (2) (2)
No Comments
74 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Session F (N = 31)
Sessions Identified
n = 21
MAT-2*: Enabling Women to Protect Themselves from Postpartum Hemorrhage
during Home Births n = 4
*This was the second offering of MAT-2. See Table 3 for results of evaluations for the first
offering of MAT-2 with Category E.
Table 8: F MAT-2
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
(1) (2) (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to understand about
an evidence-based best practice.
(3) (1)
3. At least one of
the best practices presented was relevant to my
country situation.
(1) (2) (1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I learned
during this session. NR=1
(3) (1)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
(2) (1) (1)
Comments:
“The presentations need to be more concise and interactive rather than passive
teaching.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 75
Technical Session F (N = 31)
Session Identified with < 3 responses per session (N = 12)
MAT-5: Empowering Communities for Improved MNH Outcomes (N=2)
FP-9: Overcoming Access and Policy Barriers for IUD Use (N=2)
INT-3: Integration of PMTCT with Treatment and Other R/MNCH Programs (N=1)
SCL-2: Expanding the Pool of Contraceptive Methods: EC, LAM, SDM (N=1)
SCL-4: Improvement Collaboratives (N=1)
SCL-5: How to Scale-up: Lessons from India, Indonesia, and Nigeria (N=1)
CC-7: New and Renewed Use of M&E Tools for Decision Making (N=1)
CC-11: Commodity Security: Essential Drugs and Supplies, Policies and Logistics (N=3)
Table 9: F
w/Session ID
Strongly
Agree
Agree Somewhat
Agree
Neutral Somewhat
Disagree
Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met. NR=INT-3
MAT-5 CC-11
MAT-5 SCL-5
CC-7 CC-11 CC-11
SCL-4
SCL-2
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based
best practice.
MAT-5 SCL-5 CC-11
CC-11
SCL-4 CC-7 CC-11
MAT-5 FP-9 FP-9
INT-3
SCL-2
3. At least one of the best
practices presented were relevant to my
country situation.
MAT-5 CC-7
CC-11 CC-11
SCL-5
MAT-5 FP-9
FP-9 SCL-4 CC-11
SCL-2 INT-3
4. When I
return home, I will explore adapting one of
the best practices I learned during
this session. NR=1
SCL-5
CC-7 CC-11 CC-11
MAT-5
SCL-4
MAT-5
FP-9 FP-9
SCL-2
CC-11
INT-3
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
CC-7
CC-11 CC-11
MAT-5
SCL-4 SCL-5
FP-9
FP-9 INT-3 CC-11
SCL-2 MAT-5
Comments:
SCL-5: “Kohl was very good. Needed more time to get further into details.”
CC-1: “Very few people attended this session.”
76 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
APPENDIX 9: EVALUATION RESULTS
Day 4, Friday, September 7, 2007
Integration Plenary: Where is the “I” in FP/MNCH? (N = 14)
Table 1: Integration
Plenary
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives
were met
14% (2)
57% (8)
21% (3)
7% (1)
2. I gained sufficient
knowledge to understand about the
integration of FP/MNCH programs.
21% (3)
43% (6)
14% (2)
14% (2)
7% (1)
3. I gained understanding of how some
donor agencies are integrating FP/MNCH
programs.
14% (2)
43% (6)
14% (2)
14% (2)
7% (1)
7% (1)
4. I gained understanding
of how at least one country is integrating
FP/MNCH programs.
14% (2)
57% (8)
21% (3)
7% (1)
No Comments
Results Total Completed Forms = 15 Total Plenary = 14 (NR = 1) Total Category G = 11 (NR = 4)
Sessions Not Identified = 2 Sessions Identified = 9
Total Global e-Learning = 8 (NR = 7) Total Skills Lab = 10 (NR = 5)
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 77
Technical Category G (N = 11)
Sessions Not Identified (N = 2)
Table 2: G (no Session ID)
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were met.
(1) (1)
2. I gained sufficient knowledge to
understand about an evidence-based best practice.
(2)
3. At least one of the best practices presented was
relevant to my country situation.
(1) (1)
4. When I return
home, I will explore adapting one of the best
practices I learned during this session.
(1) (1)
5. The presentation was interactive and
allowed for participation and discussion.
(1) (1)
No Comments
78 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Technical Category G
Sessions Identified (N = 9)
Sessions with n < 4 (N = 9)
MAT-6 Taking Emergency Maternal and Newborn Care to Rural Asia (N=3)
FP-7 Postabortion Care and Family Planning: The Weakest Link in Postabortion Care Service
Delivery (N=2)
SCL-4 Improvement Collaboratives: An Approach to Spreading Best Practices (N=2)
CC-9 Experiences from Country Programs I (N=2)
Table 3: G Session
Identified
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. The session objectives were
met.
MAT-6 (1) SCL-4 (1)
CC-9 (1)
MAT-6 (2) FP-7 (2)
SCL-4 (1) CC-9 (1)
2. I gained
sufficient knowledge to understand
about an evidence-based best practice.
MAT-6 (3)
FP-7 (2) SCL-4 (2) CC-9 (2)
3. At least one of the best practices
presented were relevant to my country
situation. NR =
CC-9 (1) MAT-6 (3) FP-7 (1) SCL-4 (1)
FP-7 (1) SCL-4 (1) CC-9 (1)
4. When I return home, I will
explore adapting one of the best practices I
learned during this session.
MAT-6 (3) FP-7 (2)
SCL-4 (1) CC-9 (1)
SCL-4 (1) CC-9 (1)
5. The
presentation was interactive and allowed for
participation and discussion.
FP-7 (1)
SCL-4 (1) CC-9 (1)
MAT-6 (2)
FP-7 (1) SCL-4 (1) CC-9 (1)
MAT-6 (1)
Comments:
CC-9: “Good presentations by countries.”
ANE FP/MNCH Best Practices Technical Meeting Report Appendices 79
Global e-Learning (N = 8)
Table 4: Global e-Learning
Strongly Agree
Agree Somewhat Agree
Neutral Somewhat Disagree
Disagree Strongly Disagree
1. It was easy to use the e-Learning course.
63% (5)
13% (1)
25% (2)
2. I gained knowledge relevant to my own setting.
63% (5)
25% (2)
13% (1)
3. I will apply knowledge learned through e-Learning
when I return home.
50% (4)
38% (3)
13% (1)
4. I will recommend
that my colleagues take the e-Learning courses.
63%
(5)
25%
(2)
13%
(1)
What did you like best about the e-Learrning courses?
“FP, ANC, Fostering Change Health System”
“The way of doing the courses.”
“Fostering Change and Monitoring and Evaluation” “Presentation.”
“Ease, relevance, session on Fostering Change”
What would you change about the e-Learning courses?
“Still under evaluation.”
“Refreshment of knowledge.”
“I would add leadership training.”
“It’s OK.”
“Add one or two sessions on leadership and team skills.”
80 Appendices: Scaling Up High-Impact FP/MNCH Best Practices in the ANE Region
Skills Lab (N = 10)
Table 5: Skills Lab Strongly
Agree Agree Somewhat
Agree Neutral Somewhat
Disagree Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. I learned at least one new skill.
60% (6)
30% (3)
10% (1)
2. The skills offered
were relevant to my own setting.
50%
(5)
30%
(3)
20%
(2)
3. I will apply
knowledge learned through the Skills Lab when I return home.
40%
(4)
30%
(3)
20%
(2)
10%
(1)
4. I would have liked more time to work in the Skills Lab. NR = 1
40% (4)
10% (1)
20% (2)
20% (2)
What did you like best about the Skills Lab?
“Opened real understanding to acronyms.”
“The checklist and guided instructions and availability of models.”
“Who should be the change agent. How [to] deal with conflict of different
stakeholders.”
“Best practices in other countries.”
“Innovative ideas generated within.”
“Good active management for third stage. Good arrangement.”
What would you change about the Skills Lab?
“I wonder if the place and audience was right for this level of detail. This is no substitute
for the real training needed for providers.”
“Scientific data to prove the new standard is effective and cost-efficient for AMSTL.” “I will use post-delivery family planning counseling.”
“Would be better performance.”
“Every skills lab was arranged accordingly so no need to change.”
For more information, please visit http://www.ghtechproject.com/resources.aspx
Global Health Technical Assistance Project
1250 Eye St., NW, Suite 1100 Washington, DC 20005
Tel: (202) 521-1900 Fax: (202) 521-1901
www.ghtechproject.com