section vii: coating your finished wood productinfohouse.p2ric.org/ref/03/02889/wman07.pdf ·...

Section VII:

Coating Your Finished Wood Product

Wood Products Value-Added Manufacturing and Finishing Manual

Section VII - 1

New England Woodcraft Case StudyForest Dale, Vermont

In 1987, New England Woodcraft, amanufacturer of bedroom and loungefurniture, installed a continuousfinishing line that can apply clear water-based sealers and topcoats to their flatfurniture pieces. Sealing steps includespraying, flash-off, infrared heating,followed by hand sanding . Pieces thenmake their way to the top coat spraybooth, another set of flash-off andinfrared ovens. After three years oftesting water-based emulsion finisheswith C. E. Bradley Laboratories ofBrattleboro, VT, the company completelyconverted its finishing line to waterbased acrylic clear sealers and topcoats.

Results not only included a pleasing,high quality finish with excellentperformance, but also the reduction ofVOC emission rates by 80 percent andreduced costs by 25 percent. Eventhough the water-based formulationscost more than nitrocellulose, aWoodcraft representative states thatthey get "more mileage" from the water-based formulations because of thehigher solids content.

Source: “Getting the Most from Water-based Finishes,”Furniture Design & Manufacturing, January 1991.

Section VII: Coating Your Finished Wood Product

Process OverviewThe finish of finely crafted wood furniture, cabinets and millwork is designed to provide a pleasingappearance, feeling of smoothness, and protection of the wood from physical and chemical damage, andnatural degradation. The coating materials traditionally used by the wood products industry contain asubstantial quantity of solvents that volatilize to the air within the plant and/or are directly vented to theoutside, usually without treatment. The basic operations of the typical finishing process include:! glue sizing or bleaching! cleaning / stripping! coating! drying! sanding! rubbing / buffing! equipment cleaning! repair / touch-up

Potential Wastes: Solid and Hazardous! volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions

and hazardous air pollutants (HAP) emissions! liquid wastes: spent stains, wash coats, fillers,

sealers, glazes, topcoats, solvents, spray boothwastewater

! solid wastes: spray booth filters, overspraymasking, paint solids, rags, solvent stillbottoms

! energy

Waste Reduction Options/CaseStudies/Checklists

Coating Formulations:

WaterborneWater, instead of conventional solvents, is themajor carrying medium for the coating solids inwaterborne coatings. Using waterborne coatings,or "hybrid" coatings with a combination of waterand conventional solvents can significantly reduceVOC air emissions and reduce associated wastes.

Benefits! reduce air emissions and hazardous liquid and

solid wastes! finish resists moisture, chemicals, impact and

abrasion well! adaptable to a wide range of conventional

application methods


Section VII - 2

Madison Pre-Hung Doors and Pre-Finishing Case Study

Oregon, Wisconsin

The company switched from solvent-based to water-based finishes in bothmanual and automated sprayapplications of the wood products.VOC’s were reduced from 115 tons/yearto six tons/year while nearly doublingproduction.

Madison Pre-Hung Doors and Pre-Finishing experienced cost savingsthrough reduced insurance premiumcosts, savings from avoiding purchasingan after-burner and elimination of wastedisposal costs.

The major challenge lay in achieving acomparable quality to that of a solvent-based finish. The water-based finish wasrefined as they worked with their paintsupplier.

Source: “Madison Pre-Hung Doors and Pre-FinishingConverting to a Water-based Wood Finish,”Wisconsin Department of Natural Resouces, 1995.

The Shuttery of Nanik Case StudyWausau, Wisconsin

The finishing and sanding departmentsof Shuttery of Nanik converted fromsolvent to waterborne coatings. Woodcomponents are fogged with a primer,sanded twice and top-coated with thewaterborne coatings.

As a result, the air emissions for thisoperation changed from a permitted airsource to an exempt air pollutionsource. Hazardous Waste Generatorstatus moved from Large to Very SmallQuantity Generator (VSQG orconditionally-exempt).

While the custom-made shutter dryingoven initally cost $70,000, the companysaved $32,600 the first year fromreduced or eliminated safety/DNRcompliance programs and $13,000/yearafter for reduced administrative work.

Source: “The Shuttery Of Nanik: Conversion fromsolvent to waterborne coatings for wood finishing,”Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources, 1995

! clean equipment with soap and water (in some cases)! potential reduction in fire insurance when converting from solvent coatings to waterborne! reduce toxicity and odor (in some cases)

Cautions! increase drying times, larger drying air requirements or higher oven temperatures as water takes more

time than VOCs to evaporate, especially in high humidity! store at room temperature for proper solubility and freeze protection! clean equipment immediately after use (in some cases)! use corrosion resistant equipment; costs of conversion can be significant! control moisture content of substrate and finish room humidity! raising of wood grain possible! wood surface must be free of oils and dust for good adherence properties! high gloss finish sometimes difficult to obtain; increased rubbing effort needed! some atomization difficulties, increased runs and sags, tendency to foam! refinishing is sometimes difficult


Section VII - 3

Pennsylvania House Case Study, White Deer, Pennsylvania

The Pennsylvania House manufacturingfacility in White Deer, PA is applying theUNICARB™ spray finishing system fulltime for lacquer topcoats on chairs.Starting in spring 1990, PennsylvaniaHouse worked with Union Carbide(licenser of UNICARB™ system), Nordson(developer of the spray equipment) andGuardsman Product Inc. (formulator of thetop coat lacquer) in the development ofthe system, which was installed on thechair finishing line, July, 1991.

Results include a topcoat finish ofequivalent quality and integrity to thefinish previously provided by the airassisted airless spray guns, however withonly about half as many gallons of finishused. VOC emissions have been reducedby approximately 70 percent.

High-Solids Solvent-BasedThese solvent-based coatings have a high-solids concentration in the range of 35-40 percent solids whichresults in an increased application of coating with less VOC emissions and solvent waste. There are threebasic types of high solids coatings - two component ambient temperature cured, one component heatconverted, and high solids thermoplastic solvent borne coatings.

Benefits! reduce air emissions, and liquid and solid wastes! realize less compliance and disposal costs! less material required to coat, reduce solvent usage and costs! reduce number of spray applications to achieve the same coating thickness! high transfer efficiency! reduce inventory, less handling and shipping costs, additional available floor space! less fire risk, potential reduction in fire (in some cases)

Cautions! cannot use effectively in dip or flow coating applications! wood surface must be clean! may require high temperature curing with narrow "time/temperature/cure window"! difficult to control film thickness and sagging; may require heater! sensitive to ambient temperature and humidity! finished piece difficult to repair! overspray is tacky and difficult to clean! reduce shelf life, short pot life for two component coating! odor and slow flash-off require use of vented flash-off zones

Polyester-/Polyurethane-BasedPolyester-based and polyurethane-based coatingsare used significantly outside the U.S. Use of thesecoatings can result in a reduction of VOC airemissions over nitrocellulose solvent-basedcoatings. Polyester-based coatings include styrenederived polyester of 100 percent solids which iscured by ultraviolet (UV) radiation, and acrylicpolyesters (30-50 percent solids) which are curedby catalytic reaction or UV radiation. Thesecoatings are typically applied by conventionalspray guns or flat line applicators. Curing mayrequire an initiator such as organic peroxide orUV radiation.

Benefits! reduce solvent usage and associated costs! reduce air emissions, solvent wastes and

associated compliance and disposal costs! fast drying, less floor space needed! durable finish! resistant to heat, chemicals, impact! high gloss with polyurethane! multiple application methods


Section VII - 4

Lowenstein Case StudyPompano Beach, Florida

Loewenstein is a seating manufacturerthat finishes over 250 varieties of chairs.Late in 1987, it was ordered to reduce itsannual VOC emissions (290,000 lbs.) by 31percent with a deadline of February 1,1989. By April of 1989 Loewenstein hadreduced its annual emissions to 165,000lbs, and as of March 1993, they were downto 75,000 lbs. per year.

This reduction is a result of changing fromtheir previous sealer and with 16 percentsolids to a epoxy acrylate UV sealer and68 percent solids.

They have also switched to non-electrostatic guns for stain touch up andguns for sealer and topcoat applications.

Other benefits included improved filmproperties and appearance, less coatingsto achieve the desired film thickness, earlysealer film hardness that permitsextensive without wearing through thecoating.

Source: “Lowenstein VOC Dip Continues,” IndustrialFinishing, May 1993.

Cautions! may require a clean room! coated piece is difficult to repair! polyester is chemically incompatible with nitrocellulose materials, can not be used in the same system

or on the same piece - potentially explosive! short life potential (1-6 hours)! respiratory protection may be required (potential exposure to isocyanates)! UV radiation curing may be difficult for non-flat surfaces since energy transfer is along "line of sight"! some users report "plastic" looking finish

Carbon Dioxide SystemIn this system, super critical carbon dioxide is used to decrease viscosity and enhance atomization andreplaces all or a substantial amount of the solvents used in the conventional spray application of coatings.The system's specially designed spray guns and nozzles enable the resin concentrate to be mixed with thecarbon dioxide. The coating cures by air or baking. The use of carbon dioxide (CO2) based coatings canreduce VOC emissions by 50 percent over nitrocellulose solvent-based coatings.

Benefits! reduce solvent usage and associated costs! reduce VOC air emissions, solvent wastes and

associated compliance and disposal costs! reduce worker exposure! high quality finish! high solids content! nitrocellulose resins can be used and do not

need reformulation! fewer coating applications needed! high transfer efficiency! sometimes reduces sanding requirements! easy to repair

Cautions! limited suppliers of system equipment! technology still in the developmental stage

with limited experience! lower fluid delivery rates than air spray guns! gun and tubing is bulky! royalty costs! use of equipment requires training

Radiant CuredThe physical and chemical properties of a coatingare altered by ultraviolet (UV), electron beam(EB), or infrared (IR) radiation so that a rapidpolymerization takes place. In general, radiationcured coatings require less energy, less time tocure, and contain less VOCs than conventionalcoatings. Common radiation cured coatingsinclude acrylate based materials and epoxies.


Section VII - 5

Benefits! very high solids content! reduce solvent usage and associated costs! reduce air emissions, solvent wastes and associated disposal costs! reduce energy costs! high film thickness, fewer coats needed! durable and glossy finish! increase production rates, short curing times! small ovens! UV systems are easily installed / retrofitted! low air movement reduces dust contamination

Cautions! necessity of automation! design changes usually require significant modification! finished pieces difficult to repair! not applicable to coatings which contain pigments (e.g., stain)! higher capital investment than conventional ovens! higher cost for UV and EB coatings! potential toxicity of coating constituents, dermatitis! shrinkage / adhesion problems with acrylate! curing three dimensional pieces is difficult! may require a clean room! some "plastic" looking finishes reported by users

Coating Application Technology:

Summary of Spray Application MethodsSpray Application

MethodComparable Transfer

EfficiencyAtomization Quality Categories of Coating

Applied

Conventional Air low very fine solvent bornewaterborne

High Volume, LowPressure

medium to high fine UV-curablesolvent bornewaterbornehigh solids

Airless low coarse solvent bornewaterborne

Air Assisted Airless low to medium fine solvent bornewaterbornehigh solids

Electrostatic high fine solvent bornehigh solidspowder coatwaterborneUV-curable


Section VII - 6

Ethan Allen Inc. Case StudyOld Fort, North Carolina

Ethan Allen, who manufactures dining andbedroom furniture, replaced air assistedspray guns with HVLP equipment. Eachoperator is required to attend annualtechnical training provided by the spray gunmanufacturer.

Spraying efficiency has increased and thequantity of material to be filtered has beenreduced. The investment was $3000 (12 guns@ $250). Raw materials were reduced by$15,000 to $20,000 per year, and costsassociated with waste management anddisposal were reduced.

Source: Case Study: Ethan Allen, Inc., North CarolinaWaste Reduction Resource Center, December 1993.

Tiz's Door Sales (TDS) Case StudyEverett, Washington

TDS manufactures interior and exterior doorsand frames, window and base moldings, andstained railings. HVLP spray guns werepurchased to replace 20 percent efficientconventional spray guns on manual spraylines. Along with the conversion to HVLP,TDS also installed automated flat line sprayequipment which increased applicationefficiency, recycled overspray, switched fromtoluene-based coatings to less hazardouscoatings, uses heat instead of solvents tothin coatings, uses dedicated pumps andlines for each type of coating, blocks gunnozzles and blows air back through guns anddelivery systems to reduce waste duringcleaning.

TDS has reduced coating use by one-half(1991 - 18,000 gallons saved ~ $180,000) andexperienced significant savings in labor andwaste disposal costs.

High Volume, Low Pressure (HVLP)SprayHVLP spray guns atomize materials withwarm, dry air between 0.1 and 10 psi, whileconventional spray guns usually atomizematerials at 60 to 100 psi. The low pressure airof HVLP systems transfers the coating to thesubstrate with low velocity and prevents therapid expansion of spray caused by higherpressure guns, resulting in less overspray, lessbounce back, and better transfer efficiency (40-70 percent).

Benefits! increase transfer efficiency, reduced

overspray! reduce worker exposure from bounce back! reduce VOC air emissions! lower booth clean-up costs! reduce filter replacement costs! decrease booth wastewater treatment costs! sprays well into cavities and recesses! can be used for a variety of coatings (e.g.,

waterborne, high solids)! finish as good as conventional spray guns

with low to medium viscosity coatings

Cautions! less complete atomization, atomization

may not be sufficient for fine finishes! slower application rate may affect high

production rates! worker training is a must for success

Airless SprayAirless spray systems atomize the coating byincreasing the coating's fluid pressure (rangesfrom 500 to 6500 psi) without introducing apressurized air flow.

Benefits! high transfer efficiency (35-65 percent)! reduce coating usage! reduce air emissions and wastes! high rates of paint flow, can move gun

faster! greater productivity, less operator fatigue! ability to apply highly viscous fluids! no air hose providing increased gun

handling versatility


Section VII - 7

Henredon Furniture Case StudyMorgantown, North Carolina

Henredon converted from Spray guns toHVLP equipment (7-10 psi) for applyinglacquers, sealers, and stains to chairs andbenches. Spray operators received on-sitetraining.

The company realized a $120,000 annualsavings from a 15 percent reduction incoating usage. Product quality improvedwithout impact to line speed and VOCemissions were reduced by over 126,000lbs. Spray gun purchase and installationranged from $350-$500 per gun. Paybackperiod was 3.5 months.

Source: D.B. Williams, “Incentives and Techniques forPollution Prevention in Furniture Coating Operations,”presented at The Furniture Industry and theEnvironment, Hickory, N.C., November 19, 1992.

Thomson Crown Wood Products Case Study

Mocksville, North Carolina

Wood and wood finished televisioncabinets are manufactured by ThomsonCrown. Parts of these cabinets werecoated with air-assisted airless spray guns(high air pressure up to 55 psi) with a poortransfer efficiency and a high generationrate of VOC emissions and coating waste.HVLP spray guns were purchased toreplace the existing guns.

Material reductions of 65 percent forequalizer, 65 percent for toner, 35 percentfor glaze, 35 percent for no-wipe, and 53percent for water-based black finishes thattotal 13,300 gallons per year have beenrealized with an estimated savings of$137,000. The cost of the project was$21,000.

Source: Pollution Prevention for the Wood FinishingIndustry, U.S. EPA/SEDESOL Pollution PreventionWorkgroup, May 1994.

Cautions! reduce spray pattern! relatively poor atomization! expensive nozzles! coatings limitation! tip plugging! danger of skin injection! increase training and maintenance

Air-Assisted Airless SprayAir-assisted airless spraying combines compressedair atomization with airless atomization. About 85percent of the atomization of the coating isprovided by fluid pressure (150-800 psi) as inairless, and the remaining 15 percent is providedby air pressure (5-30 psi) supplied at the nozzle.

Benefits! high transfer efficiency relative to

conventional (40-70 percent)! finish comparable to conventional spray! reduce material usage! less overspray and bounce back

Cautions! not compatible with some coatings! risk of skin injection! increase maintenance! increase operator training! capital cost

Electrostatic TechnologyDuring electrostatic coating, coating particles aregiven a negative electric charge and the piece to befinished is either grounded or is given a positivecharge. This electrostatic action causes the coatingparticle to be drawn to the piece creating a hightransfer efficiency of 35-70 percent for sprayguns, and 60-90 percent for rotary disk(centrifugal force) applicators. This allows eachpiece to be coated with fewer passes and lesscoating material and associated waste. The particlevelocity and electrostatic charge must be balancedto achieve optimum coating.

Benefits! high transfer efficiency! reduce material usage and associated VOC

emissions and waste! uniform film thickness


Section VII - 8

Larson Juhl, Inc. Case StudyAshland, Wisconsin

Larson Juhl used Air Assisted Airlesssprayers to apply the finish onto milledmouldlings. They switched to HighVolume Low Pressure spray guns inseven of its nine finishing processes,resulting in a 45 percent decrease inacrylic- and nitrocellulose-based paints.

Payback was immediate as the decreasein maintenance, parts inventory, andwaste disposal outweighed the cost forpurchasing the HVLP systems--enoughto realize an $18,000 payback the firstyear with just one system.

Source: “Larson Juhl, Inc.: Replacing AAAL (AirAssisted Air Less) spray guns with HVLP (HighVolume Low Pressure) spray guns,” WisconsinDepartment of Natural Resources, 1995.

Thomasville Furniture Case StudyThomasville, North Carolina

Thomasville Furniture was realizing an 80percent loss of finishing materials (20percent transfer efficiency) from theirconventional air spray guns on their chairfinishing line. In 1979, the companyinstalled five hand-held airlesselectrostatic sprayers in an effort toreduce the amount of coating materialwasted.

Clean up of the spray booth is nowconducted once a week instead of onceper day. Material waste was reduced by30-40 percent and associated wastes andVOC emissions were reduced. The wallsof the spray booth are grounded so thatoverspray is attracted to the wallskeeping the remainder of the area clean.The greatest savings occurred in thelines wiping stain where stain usage wasreduced from 12 ounces per chair(dipping process) to three ounces perchair. In spite of some difficulties withhumidity problems and higher coatingprices, a payback period of one year wasrealized.

Sun Tui Case StudySt. Paul, Minnesota

In 1992, Sun Tui, which manufacturesfuton frames, installed an automatedelectrostatic spray line that applieswaterborne coatings to futon frames. Thesystem replaced conventional air spraythat applied water based coatings. Thesystem includes a conveyor line, aphotosensitive light curtain thatcommunicates piece size information tothe spray guns, water spray guns to addhumidity to the piece for betterconductivity, electrostatic bells whichapply the coating, and an infrared oven.

Results have included increasing transferefficiency 30-35 percent over theconventional system, less overspray andwasted material, and less VOC emissions.

Source: “Futon Maker Plugs into ElectorstaticFinishing System,” Wood & Wood Products, January1993.

! good wrap around coating and edge cover! can apply a variety of coatings (e.g. solvent-

/water-based, high solids, radiation curable)

Cautions! pieces sometimes need to be coated by humidity

sensitizing agent as pieces must be conductive! safety/fire risk! extra cleanliness essential! touch up coating buildup at high points and

skips (uncoated areas) in corners caused byFaraday effect

! bulky and delicate spray guns! relatively high cost! wrap-around may overcoat rear edges

Vacuum Coating Pieces are passed through a coating chamber under


Section VII - 9

Broyhill Furniture Industries Case Study Conover Plant

In December 1983, Broyhill installed anelectrostatic system in their Conover chairplant in order to obtain a better qualityfinish and reduce material and labor costs.The new system, which uses fiveelectrostatic high speed reciprocatingturbo-disks, replaced a conventional spraysystem. The system also includes a flowcoater that applies a sensitizer to makethe surface of the chairs stain-conductive,and two non-grain raising stain spraybooths.

After the system had been operating fortwo years, it was determined that materialcosts were reduced by 25 percent and thenew system eliminated the need for sixemployees, who were relocated intodifferent jobs at the plant. Associatedwastes were also reduced and thepayback period for the system was lessthan two years.

Steelcase Inc. Case StudyFletcher, North Carolina

Steelcase installed a flatline roller coatingsystem in 1985 in order to increaseproductivity, maintain consistent highquality, and reduce VOC emissions.

Paint was saved through an increasedtransfer efficiency and by converting to ahigh solids paint. A 30- 50 percentdecrease in rejects and associated touch-up work was achieved, and overall VOCemissions were reduced by 25 percent.

a vacuum. Coating material fills the chamber, coating the piece as it proceeds through the chamber. An airjet removes excess finish. Film thickness is controlled by varying the coating viscosity, vacuum magnitude,and air jet velocity. The technology is limited to pieces with the same silhouette along its entire length. Intheory, there is no wasted material as the chamber recycles excess material. Water-based coatings can buildup solid coating on reservoir walls and other parts that require cleaning.

Benefits! excellent transfer efficiency (~ 100 percent)! waste coating and VOC emissions essentially

eliminated! high production rates! low labor costs

Cautions! piece must have uniform silhouette! primary use for waterborne coatings! thinners and water can be removed from the

coating by the vacuum causing viscosityadjustments

! some tendency to foam

Dip CoatingParts are dipped into a tank of coating material.This provides better coverage and causes lesswaste than conventional air spray systems.Dipping can be manual or pieces can be loadedonto a conveyor that dips the piece into the tank.Excess coating drips off the piece and drains backinto the tank. Optimize viscosity for desiredcoating thickness. If solvent-based coatings arebeing applied, the system should be enclosed toprevent VOC emissions from escaping the tank.

Benefits! excellent transfer efficiency! reduce wastes! low labor requirements! high production rates

Cautions! finish is viscosity sensitive! not suitable for pieces with hollows or cavities! color change is difficult and slow! appearance is poor to fair compared to spray

finishes

Flow Coating In flow coating, many individual streams (10-80)of coating are directed at the surfaces of the pieceas it passes through the flow coating chamber.


Section VII - 10

Benefits! high transfer efficiency! reduce wastes! high production rates! low labor requirements! low installation costs

Cautions! poor to fair finish appearance! coating controls film thickness

Curtain Coating Curtain coating coats flat pieces by moving the pieces through a continuous flowing "waterfall" of coatingmaterial. The coating material flows at a controlled rate from a reservoir onto the pieces which areconveyed through the stream at high rates of speed. The excess coating material is trapped in a reservoirand recirculated with minimal waste.

Benefits! excellent transfer efficiency! reduce wastes! very high production rates! uniform coating thickness! lends itself to UV / EB curing

Cautions! suitable for flat work only! may require clean room! foaming and curtain breaks are sometimes associated with waterborne coatings

Roll Coating In roll coating, coatings are applied by rollers to a flat surface of the piece. The roll coaters that apply thecoating are often times engraved so as to produce a wood grain effect onto the piece if fiberboard orplywood.

Benefits! high transfer efficiency! reduce material waste! high production rates! allows the use of high solids coatings! lends itself to UV / EB curing

Cautions! limited to flat work! for solvent-based coatings, potentially large amounts of VOC emissions as the rollers have to stay wet! will not coat cavities or hard to reach areas! "ribs" resulting from poor flow of the coating are sometimes created on the substrate


Section VII - 11

Gerry Wood Products Case StudySuring, Wisconsin

This company which produces woodenjuvenile furniture and expansion gatesconverted to a dry application of aformulated wax coating for selected partsin lieu of a laquer coating. The processremained the same: using a tumblingprocess, mixing the wax and parts in abarrel before rotating.

Payback was immediate with an annualsavings of over $200,000 based ondrastically reduced VOC emissions andhazardous wastes from daily clean-up.

Larson Juhl, Inc. Case StudyAshland, Wisconsin

Larson Juhl, in its finishing operations forwood picture frame mouldings, was using8-10 gallons of xylene/day to clean out thepaint piping/gun system. In addition, paintcolor changes occurred 30-45 times a day,sometimes with lighter colors following thedark.

To reduce disposal costs which hadincreased 400 percent, the companyremoved paint distribution manifolds andexcess piping. Additional valving wasinstalled for a closed loop system. Colorsnow run from lighter to darker as the dayprogresses, as well.

The payback was immediate, resulting in$50,000 savings /year.

Dry CoatingDry coating can be achieved with a formulatedgranular wax that is tumbled with the partsneeding to be coated. This allows for reduction inamount of VOC’s generated while giving adequatecoverage on the parts. The pieces actually rub thesurfaces of one another to create adequate coating.Great for coating small pieces such as woodbuttons, napkin rings, and balls.

Benefits! reduce material waste! no VOC’s

Cautions! parts must be uniform in size with no sharp

edges or irregularities in shape.

Cleaning/Stripping:

Alternatives to Methylene Chloride Methylene chloride, the active ingredient in manycoating strippers, has come under increasingscrutiny for its potential damage to health and theenvironment. Alternative stripping materials havebeen developed that have less potential fordamage. These materials utilize the activeingredients:! N - methyl pyrrolidone (NMP), a water

soluble, biodegradable solvent that hasrelatively low toxicity, is nonflammable andnoncarcinogenic (but may need to be reportedto EPA).

! Gamma - Butyrolactone, a water soluble,biodegradable solvent that is FDA approvedand has tested noncarcinogenic in rats andmice

Benefits! biodegradable! nonflammable! no offensive vapors! soap and water cleanup! less VOC emissions

Cautions! hazardous waste may still be generated when

using non-hazardous strippers because of the characteristics of the materials being stripped


Section VII - 12

Ethan Allen Furniture Case StudyOld Fort, North Carolina

Ethan Allen has a training program forspray operators that utilizes video tapingas a operator training tool. The trainingconsists of three stages:

1-Operators are video taped whileperforming their job (it is important tocommunicate the purpose of the taping tothe operators before video taping starts sothat there are no misunderstandings).

2-The operators in groups of three alongwith their supervisors and technicalpersonnel, review the tapes in one hoursessions in order to identify ways toimprove. Instruction on spray techniquesis provided during the session and follow-up is provided during production on themanufacturing floor.

3-The operators are taped again and givena chance to compare the tapes andobserve the improvements.

The training is conducted twice a year andequipment and coating suppliers providetechnical assistance. The companyprojects saving $50,000 to $70,000annually as a result of 8 - 10 percentsavings in material usage. Wastes andVOC emissions are also reduced.

Source: Case Study: Ethan Allen, Inc., North CarolinaWaste Reduction Resource Center, December 1993.

Operation And Maintenance:

Train Equipment OperatorsFormal operator training is essential to successful waste reduction and should include: ! communication of safety and health, quality, productivity, waste reduction and energy conservation

goals and expectations, and how this will help the company and the operators! use of equipment in accordance with the manufacturer's specifications such as utilizing proper spray

gun air or fluid pressures, coating concentrations and flow rates, care and maintenance! proper spray technique fundamentals such as: - 50 percent overlap of the spray pattern - spray gun held six to eight inches away from the workpiece - holding the spray gun perpendicular to

the workpiece surface - triggering the gun at the beginning and

ending of each pass - maintaining a consistent gun speed

(general rule approximately 250 fpm)! safety and health hazards associated with the

equipment and materials and how to protectthemselves, prevent accidents andenvironmental incidents

Some companies periodically videotape theiroperators so that the operators can critiquethemselves and point out where improvements arenecessary (see the Case Study below).

BenefitsWhen finishing operators are properly trained,they can:! reduce material costs! achieve a higher quality finish! reduce wastes and VOC emissions! improve productivity! improve work place safety! reduce incidence of injury (e.g., carpal tunnel

syndrome) through ergonomic improvements

Cautions! informal training by other operators can

continue bad habits! infrequent or inappropriate training for the

equipment or the coating type will not help

Prepare Coatings ProperlyProper coating material preparation can impactthe amounts of material used and wasted. Forexample, too much thinning or reduction cancause running and sagging, while too littlereduction can cause defects such as orange


Section VII - 13


1-Cardboard filters that were used forall coating operations were replacedwith metal filters. The cardboard filterswere disposed of as waste, while themetal filters are cleaned in a solventtank. The waste solvent / coating mix isdistilled and the overspray is drummedfor disposal, while the solvent isreused. The metal filters used forcapturing lacquer and sealer oversprayare wiped by hand and the dust is sentoff-site for recycling.

Cost: $57,000, Waste Reduction:10,000 lbs. per year, Savings: $48,125.

2-A fabricated, sloped polyethylenetrough replaced absorbent and woodshavings to catch coating. Theoverspray is squeegeed from thetrough into a pan for disposaleliminating the absorbent as a wastematerial.

Cost: $400, Waste Reduction: 6100 lbs.per year, Savings: $38,430.

3-Polyethylene covers replacedcardboard covers for the pallets thattransferred products through coatingoperations. The overspray is peeled offthe pallet cover and drummed fordisposal and the covers reused.

Cost: $2050, Waste Reduction: 3700lbs. per year, Savings: $7450

4-Racks used to transport product arenow cleaned of overspray periodicallyby the watchman during his free time.The racks can be reused instead ofdisposed of as hazardous waste.

Cost: $200, Waste Reduction: 1900 lbs.per year, Savings: $8250.

peeling. These defects can result in rejects and waste.Proper coatings preparation includes:! always adding reducer to the material versus

material to the reducer! add reducer to the material slowly and test often

to determine when you have reached the desiredmixture

! test for complete mixing by sampling the top andthe bottom layers of the mixture and placing eachon separate pieces of glass to observe andcompare color and rate of flow

! mix materials thoroughly before use and duringuse to maintain the desired uniformity

! keep tanks covered to prevent evaporative lossesand contamination of the contents

! for continuous coating systems, monitor theviscosity of the coating in the reservoir so that theamount of solvent added is not excessive

Direct Delivery of Coating to Spray GunDirect delivery of the coating material to the spraygun or application device instead of indirect transfer(e.g., filling an interim container from a drum or tank,transporting the container to the work area,transferring the coating material from the interimcontainer to the spray gun or application devicereservoir) can provide benefits and savings.

There are three types of direct transfer systems:1. Dead-end delivery supplies materials that do not

have settling problems to the application, withouta return line.

2. Simple flow delivery provides continuouscirculation back to the storage tank through areturn line which prevents settling in the storagetank.

3. Recirculating delivery circulates the materialthroughout the system, including in the hose of thespray gun, to prevent settling of materials withhigh settling rate. This is especially useful whenusing preheaters with high solid coatings in orderto maintain viscosity level.

Benefits! volume cost discounts for bulk coating purchases! less waste from: spills during transfer, container

residues, and evaporative losses! less employee exposure to hazardous chemicals! better finish quality through uniform material

consistency


Section VII - 14

Ashley Furniture Industries, Inc. Case Study

Whitehall, Wisconsin

Solvents were used to clean and flushspray application equipment betweencolor changes and for thin coatings. Onlynew solvent was used and the spentsolvent managed as hazardous waste.

After reviewing cost, capacity and ease ofoperation of distillation equipment, thecompany installed a batch solvent distiller,cooler for condenser water, pump andplumbing and electrical hookups.

While the project initally cost $23,000,Ashley Furniture realized a payback periodin just 6-1/2 months.

! increase productivity and lower labor costsbecause of reduced transfer tasks

! lower solvent cost and reduced solvent wastesbecause interim containers do not need to becleaned

Use Heat to Obtain Desired CoatingViscosityTraditionally, viscosity adjustments to coatingshave been made by adding organic solvents as areducer to the coating material. Also, as theambient temperature of the work place changes,the viscosity of the coating being applied changes,which causes operator problems and gunadjustments. Heat, instead of solvent, can be usedin some cases to adjust and maintain the incomingcoating to the desired viscosity.

Benefits! less solvent usage! less waste solvent and VOC emissions! more consistent viscosities! faster curing! allows the use of higher solids coatings! improves coating flow and finish appearance

Spray Equipment MaintenanceRegular care and maintenance must be performed on all equipment, especially spray equipment, to keep itin optimum working condition, prevent breakdowns or malfunctions, and waste. Some fundamentalmeasures include:! keep feed tanks clean of contamination such as dirt, dried coating particles, and dust, by keeping them

covered whenever possible! keep tanks agitated to prevent skim from forming and solids from settling! locate the compressor where it can intake clean air and maintain it properly by checking filters and

draining condensate! select the appropriate spray gun attachments - needle, nozzle, air cap - for each coating utilized! maintain proper fluid and air pressures! correlate air pressure at the spray gun with the air pressure of the coating tank to maintain proper air

pressure! perform solvent pump maintenance to prevent leakage! prevent spray gun leakage by placing only the front end of the gun in solvent when cleaning, lubricate

bearings and packings of the spray gun daily! do not spray and varnish in the same booth as it may cause spontaneous combustion! whenever possible, do not spray different types of coatings in the same booth as it may make the

resulting wastes mixed and more difficult and costly to dispose of or recycle! use closed paint gun cleaning units to control VOC emissions and exposure! equipment should be cleaned as soon as possible after use before coating cures and is more difficult to

remove


Section VII - 15

Boling Company Case StudyMt. Olive, North Carolina

Until January 1993, Boling was burningspent solvents from the finishing processfor fuel. Boling installed a "Little Still" torecycle spent thinners from the plant'swash off operations. Even though thequality of the solvent product from thedistillation process was not the qualitynecessary for reuse as wash off, by mixingone part acetone with three partsreclaimed solvent, the mixture could beused as a thinner in the spray coatoperation. The stills operated four times aweek and generates 40 - 60 gallons perweek.

The cost of the still was $4825, andoperating costs are about $0.12 per gallonof solvent reclaimed. The net savings isabout $ 100 per week, not includingreduced waste disposal costs. The stillpaid for itself in one year.

Equipment Cleaning and Line FlushingFinishing equipment cleaning is usually needed when a process is completed, for changes in coatingmaterials or colors, and when maintenance is required. The more cleaning that takes place, the more wastethat is usually generated. Also, solvents are often used to clean equipment and lines, generating wastesolvents and VOC emissions.

Here are some ideas that can help you reduce waste from equipment cleaning:! clean only as necessary rather than by schedule only! minimize the number of cleanings of the equipment by finishing with a light coating first, then

progressively use darker coatings whenever possible! flush equipment first with dirty solvent, then with clean solvent! reuse cleaning solvent until solvency is lost! use clean solvent as final equipment cleaning, then use as coating reducer! use air to blow lines free of coating back to pots! use bubble injection and pigs to aid line flushing! centralize solvent cleaning operations to reduce losses and standardize cleaning methods and type of

solvent used! use mechanical cleaning such as scraping and wiping before solvent cleaning! utilize Teflon® lined tanks to improve drainage and minimize waste coating build-up on tank walls! use rubber wipers to remove coatings off tank walls instead of rags

Inventory and Scheduling ManagementToo much inventory or lack of inventory control for materials can result in waste in the form of materialnever used (inventoried more than needed) ormaterial that deteriorates before use (exceedingshelf life). Work closely with material suppliers toprovide just-in-time (JIT) material delivery andorder accurate amounts needed for the job.

Managing production schedules to reduce colorchanges by grouping parts requiring the samefinish can eliminate substantial amounts of wastefrom gun cleaning and line flushing. Efficientproduction scheduling can maximize the usage ofcoatings with short pot life.

Benefits! prevent costs for unneeded materials! prevent waste disposal costs! increase floor space! store less hazardous materials! reduce waste from color changes

If you end up with an excess of coating material:! return unused materials to the vendor (make

arrangements with the vendor up-front beforepurchase)

! trade or give to other finishers to use! contact a waste exchange to see if someone

might be able to use the material


Section VII - 16

Medallion Kitchens Case Study Waconia, Minnesota

Medallion Kitchens manufactures kitchencabinets and bathroom vanities. Thecompany's desire was to reduce rawmaterial costs, reduce VOC emissions,minimize hazardous waste disposal costsand associated liabilities, and decreaselabor costs. Overspray from sealer andtopcoat applications was a problem. About75 gallons of sealer was used per day and50 gallons of hazardous waste sludge wasgenerated per day.

The company invested in a reclamationsystem for sealer . The system consists oftwo holding reservoirs and some minorplumbing. The system is designed to catchmost of the overspray before it falls intothe wash water tank. A cooling watersystem is applied to the collection trays tominimize solvent evaporation, collectedmaterial is agitated to prevent "skinning",the reclamation trays are removed andreplaced easily, and a non-stick coating isapplied to the collection trays. After about5 gallons of overspray is collected, theoverspray is removed and solvent andcatalyst is added to the material to obtainthe desired coating properties. It is thenadded back to the spray system to bereused.

The system cost about $2500 per installedbooth. Savings include $23,000 annuallyfrom reduced material usage. Wastesludge has been reduced from 50 to 25gallons per day, saving the company$30,000.


A solvent unit was installed to recoversolvents and reduce hazardous wastegeneration. A seven gallon batch still,which is run twice daily, recovers 5gallons of reusable solvent for every 7gallons of cleanup waste.

Cost: $4500, Waste Reduction: 1900 lbs.per year, Savings: $3200 per year

Thomson Crown Wood Products Case Study

Mocksville, North Carolina

Thomson Crown previously disposed ofits wet spray booth wastewater ashazardous waste. The company starteda system to separate paint solid fromthe wash water and recycle the waterback to the spray booth. The changereduced hazardous waste disposalcosts by $92,500.

Reuse and Recycling of Finishing MaterialsThere are many opportunities for the recycling of finishing materials. Recycling reduces the amount ofwaste to be treated and disposed of, and the associated disposal and compliance costs. It also reduces theamount of new materials needed.

Some ideas for recycling include:! extend solvent life by settling, filtration of solids, and using for jobs not requiring virgin solvent (e.g.,

rough cleaning)! distill solvents, either on-site or off-site! collect and reuse staining operations overspray! capture overspray in the spray booth wash

water and returning both the coating materialand the wash water back to the process(coating material that is immiscible in watercan be separated from the booth water wall bysettling and ultrafiltration)

! reuse clean-up solvents or solvent sludge forcoating secondary surfaces, where appearanceis not a factor

! exchange wastes with other companies


Section VII - 17

Checklist: Using Tanks in Your Refinishing Shop

Using open tanks in your shop can have potential harmful affects on your employees. Be aware of what towatch for.

Equipment__ Tanks of paint remover emit potentially harmful vapors. Proper ventilation is important. Make sure

you know whether the vapor from your stripping material is lighter than air or heavier than air.(Some remover vapors are lighter than air. Methylene chloride vapor is heavier than air.) Exhaustfan intakes should be located accordingly--higher than the work surface or near the floor formethylene chloride.

__ Remover tanks should be tightly covered al all times when not in use. This will save loss throughevaporation, and minimize your exposure to vapors.

__ Periodically remove stripped finish from your paint remover tank to promote the efficiency of thestripping process.

__ Make sure the paint remover in your tank is working as effectively as possible. Observe thetemperature recommendations provided by the manufacturer. Most paint removers work mosteffectively at more than 70 degrees Fahrenheit--and only half as efficiently at 50 degrees.

Employees__ Be especially careful to avoid breathing vapor from a caustic tank. Most old furniture finishes

contain lead. Lead is dissolved by caustics, and will be contained in caustic vapors.__ Protect eyes and skin from contact with remover from tanks. Wear goggles, rubber gloves, long

sleeves and an apron while working around a tank__ There must be a source of clean, fresh water near the paint remover tank so that remover can be

quickly and thoroughly rinsed from skin and eyes in case of accidental contact.


Section VII - 18

Checklist: Cut Costs Through Record Keeping

Here’s a checklist of items to keep your record keeping in order for regulatory purposes, and cost savings.

Paper shuffle__ Track the chemicals contained in the paint removers, solvents and finishes you are using by

keeping accurate files of the Material Safety Data Sheets.__ Record the items you strip or finish by revenue, time required for the job, date, and the customer.

Do this electronically and you will have a good record for direct mail advertising. __ Keep records of the removers, solvents, and finishes you purchase, by date and supplier. Compare

those with the records of items you strip or finish in order to learn whether you are using chemicalsefficiently.

Calculations__ Total the prices you charged for the items you stripped and finished.__ Total the costs for the quantity of paint remover you used during that same period. __ Total the costs of finished used during the period. __ Total your labor costs for the period. __ Total your payments on equipment for the period. __ Compute the percentage of your income you are spending on each of these expense items.__ Is your price structure adequate to cover costs and provide a profit? __ Improve your profit margin by using paint removers and solvents more efficiently and by reducing

your waste disposal costs.

Keep an accurate record of any paint removers or finishes that are wasted. __ Calculate the cost of this waste as a percentage of your operating expense. __ Does this cost warrant action to reduce waste? __ If you are wasting material due to deterioration, are containers available that can be sealed more

tightly?__ Buy in quantities adequate to your operation. Are they currently too large or too small?__ Consider changing practices or purchasing new equipment in order to reduce remover and finish

purchases.


Section VII - 19

Checklist: Protect Your Health in the Refinishing Shop

When using chemicals such as volatile organic compounds or hazardous air pollutants, keep on top ofhealth issues affecting your employees.

Precautions__ Keep Material Safety Data Sheets on hand to know what is contained in the paint removers and

finishes in case of an accident.__ Be prepared to rinse chemicals from eyes or skin in case of accidental contact.__ If you smoke, recognize that you are particularly susceptible to injury form exposure to paint

remover, solvent or finish vapors. Smoking materials are a fire hazard. Don’t smoke when workingin the refinishing shop.

__ Ask your suppliers, periodically, about the availability of less toxic non-flammable paint removers,solvents, and finishes.

__ Seek the advice of your physician about preventative measures, and ask about periodic blood testto assure no ill effects from exposure to chemicals.

Personal Gear__ Always wear protective clothing and equipment__ Do not wear contact lenses when using paint removers.__ Some breathing masks and respirators may increase exposure by trapping harmful chemicals near

the nose and mouth.

Workspace__ Keep your area well-ventilated. An exhaust fan should vent vapors from paint removers outdoors.

Give your shop a fresh air intake vent with a capacity of two cubic feet per minute per square footof shop space.

__ When possible, close covers on tanks containing remover and return used remover to a closedcontainer to reduce exposure to potentially harmful vapors

__ If you process a high enough volume of product to use sprayers when applying finishes, considerhigh volume, low pressure (HVLP) sprayers to get more of the finish onto the product and reduceemployee exposure to the atomized finishes.

__ If you use sprayers, consider installing a booth with an exhaust fan.


Section VII - 20

Checklist: Refinishing SafetyWhen using chemicals such as volatile organic compounds or hazardous air pollutants, keep on top ofsafety issues affecting your employees.

Precautions__ Carefully read all Material Safety Data Sheets that come with the stripping, rinsing and finishing

materials you use in your refinishing shop.__ Make sure you know the “flash point” of the materials you are using. The lower the flash point, the

more easily a material is ignited.__ Some materials used in stripping and rinsing -- thinners and petroleum distillates -- are a fire

hazard.__ Methylene chloride, a common stripping material, is not easily ignited, but many of the paints and

other finishes that become mixed with methylene chloride as it is used are ignitable. Afterconsiderable use, methylene chloride contaminated with other materials will burn and my producevery toxic gases in the process.

Workspace__ Enforce a strict “No Smoking” rule in the work area of your shop.__ Make sure that a fresh air duct in the work area is adequate to replace all the air drawn out of the

room by exhaust fans located near the stripping area, the rinse area, or in a paint booth. Withoutadequate fresh air intake, exhaust fans may draw air from the furnace flue or the hot water heaterflue. Worker exposure to combustion gases including carbon monoxide will result. Adequateventilation with fresh air will also prevent the build-up and possible ignition of combustible gases.


1 Wood Furniture Manufacturing Operations NESHAP Implementation Document, United States EnvironmentalProtection Agency, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, EPA-456/R-97-005, September 1997,http://www.epa.gov.ttn/uatw

Section VII - 21

Checklist: Application Equipment Requirement1

__ The facility does not use conventional air spray guns.

__ The facility operates conventional air spray guns, but are only used:1. If they are using the guns to apply coatings that have a VOC content no greater than 1.0 lb VOC/lb

solids, as applied;2. If they are using the gun for touchup and repair that occurs either after the completion of the

finishing operation or after the application of stain and before the application of other types offinishing materials. In addition, any materials used for touch up and repair after the stainapplication must be applied from a container with a volume of no more than 2.0 gallons.

3. If the guns are automatic;4. If the guns are used in a spray booth or other application station where emission are directed to a

control device;5. If the guns are only used for applying small quantities of finishing materials. The total amount of

finishing material applied with the conventional air spray gun must be no more than 5.0 percent ofthe total amount of finishing material used in that semiannual period; or

6. If the gun is used to apply stain and the facility has demonstrated that it is technically oreconomically infeasible to use another spray application technology.

Operator Training Program__ The facility has developed an operator training program that contains:

! A list of job descriptions and current personnel that must be trained;! An outline of the subjects to be covered for each job description;! An initial and refresher training program; and! A description how the facility will document personnel’s successful completion of the program.

Inspection and Maintenance Plan__ The facility has developed an inspection and maintenance plan that:

! Addresses equipment leaks;! Includes a monthly visual inspection to ensure there are no equipment leaks of all equipment

used to transfer or apply finishing materials or organic solvents;! Specifies how a facility will document date, result, and repairs of an inspection; and! Assures first attempt at leak repair within 5 days and final repair within 15 days, unless repair

requires replacement of the equipment in which case the facility is allowed 3 months tocomplete repairs.

Cleaning and Washoff Solvent Accounting Program__ The facility has developed a program that tracks:

! the amount of organic solvent used for cleaning and washoff each month;! the quantity of spent solvent generated from each cleaning or washoff operation each month;! the amount of spent solvent that is reused or disposed; and! the number of pieces washed off and the reason for the washoff.


Section VII - 22

Cleaning and Washoff Solvent Composition__ The facility has discontinued the use of solvents that contains known or probable human

carcinogens. (See Appendix F for list of solvents)


2 Ibid.

Section VII - 23

Checklist: Work Practice Standards2

Spray Booth Cleaning__ The facility does not use cleaning compounds that contain more than 8.0 percent VOC by weight,

unless operators are cleaning conveyors, continuous coaters and there enclosures, or metal filters.__ The facility’s solvent use is limited to 1.0 gallon per booth for preparation of booth surface for

coating/protection.

Storage Containers__ Containers that are used for storing finishing, cleaning, adhesive, or washoff materials are closed

when not in use.

Gun and Line Cleaning__ Gun and line cleaning solvent is collected into a closed container.__ Containers associated with cleaning are covered when not in use.

Washoff Operations__ Washoff tank is covered when not in use.__ The facility minimizes dripping by tilting and/or rotating the part to drain as much solvent as

possible. __ The facility is allowing sufficient dry time for the part.

Work Practice and Implementation Plan__ The facility has developed a plan to implement these work practice standards and maintain onsite.

Formulation Assessment Plan for Finishing Operations__ The facility has:

! Establish a baseline level for each VHAP of potential concern! Track annual usage VHAP of potential of concern; and! Reported all exceedences of baseline level, if any.

section vii: coating your finished wood productinfohouse.p2ric.org/ref/03/02889/wman07.pdf ·...

Documents