seismic resilient pipelinesseismic resilient pipelines advanced sensors • collaboration among...

40
SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES Tom O’Rourke Thomas R. Briggs Professor of Engineering Cornell University SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jun-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    Tom O’RourkeThomas R. Briggs

    Professorof Engineering

    Cornell University

    SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    TOPICS•San Francisco•Los Angeles•New Zealand

    •Earthquake Effects•Next Generation Pipelines•Pipeline Intelligence

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    200 km

    N

    San Francisco

    5 km

    120 km2

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    Zones of Soil Liquefaction

    Zone of liquefaction induced deformation

    =

    N

    0 1 km

    Zones of Soil Liquefaction

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    0 1 km

    Zone of liquefaction induced deformation

    College Hill Reservoir

    University Mound Reservoir

    Lake Honda Reservoir

    0 1 km

    Zone of liquefaction induced deformation

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    22-in. (550 mm) Cast Iron Trunk Line

    16-in. (400 mm) Cast Iron Trunk Line

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    1906 Earthquake Water Loss

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    7am,4/18/1906

    7am,4/19/1906

    7am,4/20/1906

    7am,4/21/1906

    7am,4/22/1906

    Mill

    ion

    Gal

    lons

    of W

    ater

    College Hill

    University Mound

    Lake Honda

    Chart7

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Lake Honda

    University Mound

    College Hill

    Million Gallons of Water

    1906 Earthquake Water Loss

    31.1

    30

    11.4

    13.7

    12.2

    0

    8.5

    6.5

    0

    5.4

    5.6

    0

    1.5

    5.2

    0

    LakeHonda_24_3H_2

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake(24 hrs, 3 Hydrants for 19-20 and 2 Hydrants for 21-22)

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    18073760

    15712160

    13500320

    8500000

    11547520

    6824320

    2400640

    5400000

    9266400

    2756160

    0

    1500000

    6985280

    0

    0

    LakeHonda_18_3H_2

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    20240426.6666667

    17878826.6666667

    15666986.6666667

    8500000

    13714186.6666667

    8990986.66666667

    4567306.66666667

    5400000

    11433066.6666667

    4922826.66666667

    0

    1500000

    9151946.66666666

    854666.666666667

    0

    LakeHonda_16_3H_2_85

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    Simulation

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake (16 hrs, 3 Hydrants for 19-20 and 2 Hydrants for 21-22)

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    18420493.3333333

    8500000

    9532653.33333333

    5400000

    5464493.33333333

    1500000

    1396333.33333333

    LakeHonda_16_3H_2

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake (16 hrs, 3 Hydrants for 19-20 and 2 Hydrants for 21-22)

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    20782093.3333333

    18420493.3333333

    16208653.3333333

    8500000

    14255853.3333333

    9532653.33333333

    5108973.33333333

    5400000

    11974733.3333333

    5464493.33333333

    0

    1500000

    9693613.33333333

    1396333.33333333

    0

    LakeHonda_3_2Hydrants

    Description:2 pipelines connected to Lake Honda Reservoir.

    No break was modeled

    two hydrants were modeled at Van Ness St

    hydrant operating pressure is 15 psi

    Lake Honda Reservoir9046

    Volume (mg)3310686

    Elevation (ft)36512222

    c valuePipe 1 (16 in.)Pipe 2 (16 in.)Total Flow(gpm)Time to Empty (hr)

    End Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)End Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)

    7020032522002846609890.219.13195583258.78112

    8520039172003422733974.915.896807012810.56816

    10020045592003979853864.413.6644022812.29472

    Hydrant 3512280

    c valueEnd Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)122947208.78112

    70300294810.56816

    85300334712.29472

    1003003684

    16 hr18 hr24 hr

    TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100

    7am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.17am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.17am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.1

    7am, 4/19/190613.720.818.416.27am, 4/19/190613.720.217.915.77am, 4/19/190613.718.115.713.5

    7am, 4/20/19068.514.39.55.17am, 4/20/19068.513.79.04.67am, 4/20/19068.511.56.82.4

    7am, 4/21/19065.412.05.50.07am, 4/21/19065.411.44.90.07am, 4/21/19065.49.32.80.0

    7am, 4/22/19061.59.71.40.07am, 4/22/19061.59.20.90.07am, 4/22/19061.57.00.00.0

    TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100

    7am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,0007am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,0007am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,000

    7am, 4/19/190613,700,00020,782,09318,420,49316,208,6537am, 4/19/190613,700,00020,240,42717,878,82715,666,9877am, 4/19/190613,700,00018,073,76015,712,16013,500,320

    7am, 4/20/19068,500,00014,255,8539,532,6535,108,9737am, 4/20/19068,500,00013,714,1878,990,9874,567,3077am, 4/20/19068,500,00011,547,5206,824,3202,400,640

    7am, 4/21/19065,400,00011,974,7335,464,49307am, 4/21/19065,400,00011,433,0674,922,82707am, 4/21/19065,400,0009,266,4002,756,1600

    7am, 4/22/19061,500,0009,693,6131,396,33307am, 4/22/19061,500,0009,151,947854,66707am, 4/22/19061,500,0006,985,28000

    Simulation

    LakeHonda_24_3H

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake (24 hrs, 3 Hydrants)

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    18073760

    15712160

    13500320

    8500000

    11547520

    6824320

    2400640

    5400000

    5021280

    0

    0

    1500000

    0

    0

    0

    LakeHonda_18_3H

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    20240426.6666667

    17878826.6666667

    15666986.6666667

    8500000

    13714186.6666667

    8990986.66666667

    4567306.66666667

    5400000

    7187946.66666667

    103146.666666667

    0

    1500000

    661706.666666669

    0

    0

    LakeHonda_16_3H

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake (16 hrs, 3 Hydrants)

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    20782093.3333333

    18420493.3333333

    16208653.3333333

    8500000

    14255853.3333333

    9532653.33333333

    5108973.33333333

    5400000

    7729613.33333333

    644813.333333332

    0

    1500000

    1203373.33333333

    0

    0

    LakeHonda_3Hydrants

    Description:2 pipelines connected to Lake Honda Reservoir.

    No break was modeled

    two hydrants were modeled at Van Ness St

    hydrant operating pressure is 15 psi

    Lake Honda Reservoir

    Volume (mg)33

    Elevation (ft)365

    c valuePipe 1 (16 in.)Pipe 2 (16 in.)Total Flow(gpm)Time to Empty (hr)

    End Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)End Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)

    7020032522002846904660.812.897044734313.02624

    85200391720034221068651.510.917711647615.38784

    100200455920039791222245.09.545628102317.59968

    Hydrant 3733320

    c valueEnd Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)1759968013.02624

    70300294815.38784

    85300334717.59968

    1003003684

    16 hr18 hr24 hr

    TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100

    7am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.17am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.17am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.1

    7am, 4/19/190613.720.818.416.27am, 4/19/190613.720.217.915.77am, 4/19/190613.718.115.713.5

    7am, 4/20/19068.514.39.55.17am, 4/20/19068.513.79.04.67am, 4/20/19068.511.56.82.4

    7am, 4/21/19065.47.70.60.07am, 4/21/19065.47.20.10.07am, 4/21/19065.45.00.00.0

    7am, 4/22/19061.51.20.00.07am, 4/22/19061.50.70.00.07am, 4/22/19061.50.00.00.0

    TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100

    7am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,0007am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,0007am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,000

    7am, 4/19/190613,700,00020,782,09318,420,49316,208,6537am, 4/19/190613,700,00020,240,42717,878,82715,666,9877am, 4/19/190613,700,00018,073,76015,712,16013,500,320

    7am, 4/20/19068,500,00014,255,8539,532,6535,108,9737am, 4/20/19068,500,00013,714,1878,990,9874,567,3077am, 4/20/19068,500,00011,547,5206,824,3202,400,640

    7am, 4/21/19065,400,0007,729,613644,81307am, 4/21/19065,400,0007,187,947103,14707am, 4/21/19065,400,0005,021,28000

    7am, 4/22/19061,500,0001,203,373007am, 4/22/19061,500,000661,707007am, 4/22/19061,500,000000

    LakeHonda_24

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake (24 hrs)

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    21945920

    20124320

    18377600

    8500000

    19291840

    15648640

    12155200

    5400000

    16637760

    11172960

    5932800

    1500000

    13983680

    6697280

    0

    LakeHonda_18

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    24112586.6666667

    22290986.6666667

    20544266.6666667

    8500000

    21458506.6666667

    17815306.6666667

    14321866.6666667

    5400000

    18804426.6666667

    13339626.6666667

    8099466.66666667

    1500000

    16150346.6666667

    8863946.66666667

    1877066.66666667

    LakeHonda_16

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Observation

    C=70

    C=85

    C=100

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in Lake Honda in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake (16 hrs)

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    31100000

    13700000

    24654253.3333333

    22832653.3333333

    21085933.3333333

    8500000

    22000173.3333333

    18356973.3333333

    14863533.3333333

    5400000

    19346093.3333333

    13881293.3333333

    8641133.33333333

    1500000

    16692013.3333333

    9405613.33333333

    2418733.33333333

    LakeHonda_2Hydrants

    Description:2 pipelines connected to Lake Honda Reservoir.

    No break was modeled

    two hydrants were modeled at Van Ness St

    hydrant operating pressure is 15 psi

    Lake Honda Reservoir

    Volume (mg)33

    Elevation (ft)365

    c valuePipe 1 (16 in.)Pipe 2 (16 in.)Total Flow(gpm)Time to Empty (hr)

    End Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)End Point Elevation (ft)Flow (gpm)

    7020035112002846635786.518.35247234029.15408

    8520042002003422762272.215.306568704610.97568

    10020048562003979883562.313.205055649912.7224

    530100

    127224009.15408

    10.97568

    12.7224

    16 hr18 hr24 hr

    TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100TimeLake HondaC=70C=85C=100

    7am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.17am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.17am, 4/18/190631.131.131.131.1

    7am, 4/19/190613.724.722.821.17am, 4/19/190613.724.122.320.57am, 4/19/190613.721.920.118.4

    7am, 4/20/19068.522.018.414.97am, 4/20/19068.521.517.814.37am, 4/20/19068.519.315.612.2

    7am, 4/21/19065.419.313.98.67am, 4/21/19065.418.813.38.17am, 4/21/19065.416.611.25.9

    7am, 4/22/19061.516.79.42.47am, 4/22/19061.516.28.91.97am, 4/22/19061.514.06.70.0

    TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100TimeObservationC=70C=85C=100

    7am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,0007am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,0007am, 4/18/190631,100,00031,100,00031,100,00031,100,000

    7am, 4/19/190613,700,00024,654,25322,832,65321,085,9337am, 4/19/190613,700,00024,112,58722,290,98720,544,2677am, 4/19/190613,700,00021,945,92020,124,32018,377,600

    7am, 4/20/19068,500,00022,000,17318,356,97314,863,5337am, 4/20/19068,500,00021,458,50717,815,30714,321,8677am, 4/20/19068,500,00019,291,84015,648,64012,155,200

    7am, 4/21/19065,400,00019,346,09313,881,2938,641,1337am, 4/21/19065,400,00018,804,42713,339,6278,099,4677am, 4/21/19065,400,00016,637,76011,172,9605,932,800

    7am, 4/22/19061,500,00016,692,0139,405,6132,418,7337am, 4/22/19061,500,00016,150,3478,863,9471,877,0677am, 4/22/19061,500,00013,983,6806,697,2800

    Chart1

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Lake Honda

    University Mound

    College Hill

    Date and Time

    Gallons of Water

    Gallons of Water Stored in the 3 Largest City Reservoirs in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 San Francisco Earthquake

    31.1

    30

    11.4

    13.7

    12.2

    0

    8.5

    6.5

    0

    5.4

    5.6

    0

    1.5

    5.2

    0

    Sheet1

    Amount of Water (Milligon gallons) Stored in Various Reservoirs in the Days Following the April 18, 1906 SF Earthquake

    Lake HondaUniversity MoundCollege HillTotal Water Stored

    7am, 4/18/190631.130.011.472.5

    7am, 4/19/190613.712.20.025.9

    7am, 4/20/19068.56.50.015.0

    7am, 4/21/19065.45.60.011.0

    7am, 4/22/19061.55.20.06.7

    Lake HondaUniversity MoundCollege HillTotal Water Stored (gal)

    Weds., Apr. 18, 7AM31,100,00031,100,03031,100,041

    Thurs., Apr. 19, 7AM13,700,00013,700,01213,700,012

    Fri., Apr. 20, 7AM8,500,0008,500,0078,500,007

    Sat., Apr. 21, 7AM5,400,0005,400,0065,400,006

    Sun., Apr. 22, 7AM1,500,0001,500,0051,500,005

    Sheet2

    Sheet2

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Lake Honda

    University Mound

    College Hill

    Date and Time

    Million Gallons of Water

    1906 Earthquake Water Loss

    31.1

    30

    11.4

    13.7

    12.2

    0

    8.5

    6.5

    0

    5.4

    5.6

    0

    1.5

    5.2

    0

    Sheet3

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Lake Honda

    University Mound

    College Hill

    Million Gallons of Water

    1906 Earthquake Water Loss

    31.1

    30

    11.4

    13.7

    12.2

    0

    8.5

    6.5

    0

    5.4

    5.6

    0

    1.5

    5.2

    0

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Lake Honda

    University Mound

    College Hill

    Million Gallons of Water

    1906 Earthquake Water Loss

    31.1

    30

    11.4

    13.7

    12.2

    0

    8.5

    6.5

    0

    5.4

    5.6

    0

    1.5

    5.2

    0

    7am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/19067am, 4/18/1906

    7am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/19067am, 4/19/1906

    7am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/19067am, 4/20/1906

    7am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/19067am, 4/21/1906

    7am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/19067am, 4/22/1906

    Lake Honda

    University Mound

    College Hill

    Million Gallons of Water

    1906 Earthquake Water Loss

    31.1

    30

    11.4

    13.7

    12.2

    0

    8.5

    6.5

    0

    5.4

    5.6

    0

    1.5

    5.2

    0

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    AUXILIARY WATER SUPPLY SYSTEM

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    JONES ST. TANK

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    1989 LOMA PRIETA EARTHQUAKE

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    EARTHQUAKE SAFETY AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE BOND

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    MULTI-MODAL SIMULATION

    Combined Simulation for Permanent Ground

    Deformation & Seismic Wave Effects

    Probabilistic Simulation for System-wide Seismic

    Wave Effects

    Simulation for Ground Failure, Accidents,

    Human Threats

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    LADWP NORTHRIDGE EQ SYSTEM RESPONSE

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    LOS ANGELES RESILIENCE• Strengthen Buildings

    • Soft story/non-ductile concrete

    • Fortify Water System• Fire protection, resilient

    water pipelines

    • Enhance Telecommunications

    Resilience by Design

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE SEQUENCE• ~ 185 Deaths• CBD Destroyed

    – ~ 1800 CBD Bldgs. Demolished

    – ~ 55,000 Residences Damaged

    • > $30(US) B Direct Losses ≈ 20 % GDP

    • Massive Liquefaction& Infrastructure Damage

    Christchurch

    Christchurch

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE SEQUENCE

    MW = 7.14 Sept 10

    MW = 6.013 June 11MW = 6.2

    22 Feb 11

    MW = 5.923 Dec 11

    MW = 5.714 Feb 16

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    CHRISTCHURCH LIQUEFACTION

    52 km296 km2

    91 km2

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    San Francisco borderline

    LiquefiedArea

    CHRISTCHURCH LIQUEFACTION IN SAN FRANCISCO

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM1700 km of Distribution Pipelines1700 Repairs

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    LIGHT DETECTION & RANGING (LiDAR)• High Resolution LiDAR Measurements

    • Settlement on 5-m• Lateral Movementon 4 & 56-m

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES22

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    GAS DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM

    Water Distribution System

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    PE PIPELINES AFTER 4 SEPTEMBER 2010 EQ

    2.6 km of replacementHDPE & MDPE pipelines

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    Earthquake Induced Ground Deformation• Seismic Waves• Fault Rupture• Liquefaction

    • Lateral Spreading• Flow Failure• Settlement• Consolidation• Buoyancy Effects

    • Landslides• Unsaturated Soil

    Settlement

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    EXTREME SOIL-PIPELINE INTERACTIONSoil Material & Geometric

    NonlinearitiesPipeline Material &

    Geometric Nonlinearities

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    TOPIC• Next Generation Hazard

    Resilient Pipelines

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    NEXT GENERATION HAZARD-RESILIENT PIPELINES

    Santa Clara Valley Water DistrictPenitencia Water Treatment Plant

    Landslide Hazard Zone72-in.-Diameter ERDIP

    (ASCE, 2018)

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    NEXT GENERATION HAZARD-RESILIENT PIPELINESWall Street

    Journal Photo

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    NEXT GENERATION HAZARD-RESILIENT PIPELINES

    8.6º

    FR SE SE x FRE FR x FE

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    NEXT GENERATION HAZARD-RESILIENT PIPELINES

    8.6º

    FR SE SE x FRE FR x FE

    (a) Push-On Joint (b) Restrained Joint

    (c) Restrained Axial Slip Joint

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES 32

    ORIENTED POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVCO) JOINTS

    Spigot Compressed into Bell

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    ORIENTED POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVCO) JOINTS

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    CONTROLLED BUCKLING

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    LARGE-SCALE TESTING: NEXT GENERATION INFASTRUCTURE

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    CUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION OF TENSILE LATERAL GROUND STRAINS

    ExceedanceLevels

    Ground StrainAccommodation

    8.6º

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    CORNELL LAB WEB SITE https://lifelines.cee.cornell.edu/

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    LESSONS: NEXT GENERATION (HAZARD-RESILIENT) PIPELINES

    •Paradigm Shift in Pipeline Technology•Market-Driven Research Funded by Industry

    •Can’t Have Resilience Unless You Have a Market

    •Next Generation Hazard-Resilient Pipeline Simulation Models

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    ADVANCED SENSORS• Collaboration Among University of Cambridge, Cornell, and UC Berkeley

    • Demonstrate Proof of Concept• Distributed Fiber Optics

    • Joint Movement• Pipeline Bending Strains & Displacement

    • Time Domain Reflectometry• Leakage

    • Underground Wireless • Data Transmission Without Wires

  • SEISMIC RESILIENT PIPELINES

    LESSONS: NEXT GENERATION (HAZARD-RESILIENT) PIPELINES

    •Paradigm Shift in Pipeline Technology•Market-Driven Research Funded by Industry

    •Can’t Have Resilience Unless You Have a Intelligence

    •Next Generation Hazard-Resilient Pipeline Simulation Models

    Slide Number 1TOPICSSlide Number 3Slide Number 4Slide Number 5Slide Number 6Slide Number 7Slide Number 8Slide Number 9Slide Number 10 EARTHQUAKE SAFETY AND EMERGENCY RESPONSE BONDSlide Number 12Slide Number 13LADWP NORTHRIDGE EQ SYSTEM RESPONSELOS ANGELES RESILIENCECANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE SEQUENCECANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE SEQUENCECHRISTCHURCH LIQUEFACTIONSlide Number 19WATER DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMLIGHT DETECTION & RANGING (LiDAR)Slide Number 22GAS DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM PE PIPELINES AFTER 4 SEPTEMBER 2010 EQEarthquake Induced Ground DeformationEXTREME SOIL-PIPELINE INTERACTIONTOPICNEXT GENERATION HAZARD-RESILIENT PIPELINESNEXT GENERATION HAZARD-RESILIENT PIPELINESSlide Number 30Slide Number 31ORIENTED POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVCO) JOINTSORIENTED POLYVINYL CHLORIDE (PVCO) JOINTSCONTROLLED BUCKLINGLARGE-SCALE TESTING: NEXT GENERATION INFASTRUCTURECUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION OF TENSILE LATERAL GROUND STRAINSCORNELL LAB WEB SITELESSONS: NEXT GENERATION (HAZARD-RESILIENT) PIPELINESADVANCED SENSORSLESSONS: NEXT GENERATION (HAZARD-RESILIENT) PIPELINES