servicenow vs h-p

24
1 1 Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page1 of 24

Upload: otterom

Post on 19-Nov-2015

20 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Court order invalidates four Hewlett-Packard patents in ServiceNow trial.

TRANSCRIPT

  • 1

    1

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page1 of 24

  • 2

    2

    3

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page2 of 24

  • 4

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page3 of 24

  • 5

    6

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page4 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page5 of 24

  • 46, ECF 79-10. Dr. Menasc generally describes the

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page6 of 24

  • benefit of the 683 patent in terms of its ability to handle large volumes of service requests, each

    with its own contractual deadline. Menasc Decl. at 125-27.7

    8

    7

    8

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page7 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page8 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page9 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page10 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page11 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page12 of 24

  • 9

    9

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page13 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page14 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page15 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page16 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page17 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page18 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page19 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page20 of 24

  • 10

    10

    Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page21 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page22 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page23 of 24

  • Case5:14-cv-00570-BLF Document101 Filed03/10/15 Page24 of 24