shit flow diagram (sfd) · bhimavaram, andhra pradesh 1 a sanitation (or shit) flow diagram...
TRANSCRIPT
BHIM
AVA
RAM
, AN
DH
RA P
RAD
ESH
1
A Sanitation (or Shit) Flow diagram presents a clear picture of how excreta flows are managed within the city. The diagram clearly depicts how excreta flows from user interface to the final disposal. It has the following stages:
Containment
ØIn the periphery of the city, mostly low to middle-income households are dependent on the lined pit with semipermeable walls and an open bottom, without an outlet. Prefabricated concrete rings are installed to create a pit
ØWhile in the centre of the city, the middle to high-income group households have lined tanks with impermeable walls and open bottom with an outlet connected to open drains or septic tanks connected to open drains
ØHouseholds having an individual bore well prefer lined structure as containment system to avoid the intrusion of black water into the ground water. As most of the households use groundwater for washing and non-drinking purpose
ØFor the construction of the lined tanks, the prefabricated concrete rings are installed into the dug pit. Few households informed during survey that they have sealed the containment by pouring concrete at bottom of the pit
ØIn case of septic tanks, a rectangular pit is dug and then in-situ construction of the septic tank is carried out. Baffle walls are provided in the septic tank as per the availability of area; in case of space constraint a fully lined tank with outlet connected to open drain is constructed
ØIn case of apartment buildings ranging from 4 floors, baffle walls are provided in the septic tanks
ØTypes of on-site containments observed during field visit: -• Septic tanks connected to open drains (33%
population)• Lined tanks with impermeable walls and
open bottom connected to open drains (17% population)
• Lined pit with semipermeable walls and open bottom without outlet (49% population)
SHIT FLOW DIAGRAM (SFD)2
01
7C
entr
e fo
r Sc
ienc
e an
d En
viro
nmen
t41
, Tug
hlak
abad
Inst
itutio
nal A
rea,
New
Del
hi 1
10 0
62, I
ND
IAPh
: +91
-11-
2995
6110
- 51
24 -
6394
- 639
9 F
ax: +
91-1
1-29
9558
79E-
mai
l: cs
e@cs
eind
ia.o
rg
Web
site
: ww
w.c
sein
dia.
org
SFD Description
Onsite sanitation
SN not contained: 25%
FS contained: 17%
FS not contained: 57%
FS contained – emptied: 15%
FS not contained – emptied: 29%
1%Open
defecation
28%FS not
contained
44%FS not
delivered totreatment
25%SN not
delivered totreatment
Open defecation
2% FS contained– not emptied
Safely managed Unsafely managed
Local area Neighbourhood City
Key: WW: Wastewater, FS: Faecal sludge, SN: Supernatant
Offsite sanitation
20
17
Cen
tre
for
Scie
nce
and
Envi
ronm
ent
41, T
ughl
akab
ad In
stitu
tiona
l Are
a, N
ew D
elhi
110
062
, IN
DIA
Ph: +
91-1
1-29
9561
10 -
5124
- 63
94- 6
399
Fax
: +91
-11-
2995
5879
E-m
ail:
cse@
csei
ndia
.org
W
ebsi
te: w
ww
.cse
indi
a.or
g
2
BHIM
AVA
RAM
, AN
DH
RA P
RAD
ESH
Ø1% of the population practice open defecation ØFS contained or not is dependent on the
system polluting the groundwater. Depth of groundwater table <10m from the sanitation system is considered to pose a significant risk
Emptying & Transportation
ØEmptying of the containment systems in the city takes place using private vacuum tankers
ØPrivate emptiers are solely responsible for the emptying services. There are a total of 6 private operators and 7 vehicles operating in the city
ØAll the suction machines are truck mounted. The capacity of each tank of a vacuum tanker is 5000 litres.
ØThe emptiers advertise and market their services using beguiling wall paintings, hoardings and distribution of business cards. These emptiers operate within the city as well in neighbouring towns charging 2500/trip within the city, while 3000/trip outside the city
ØAssembling of the vacuum tankers takes place at 75 km away from the city, Rajahmundry in Andhra Pradesh. A preowned truck with an average age of vehicle being 2-5 years is preferred for assembling into a vacuum tanker
ØOn a peak day, these private emptiers get about 7-8 trips per day, with an average of 1 hour dedicated to one trip
ØThe emptying is usually carried out by 3 people (1 driver + 2 labourers)
ØEmptying frequency ranges from 3 months to 2 years for the lined pit with semi-permeable walls and open bottom without outlet. Emptying frequency for septic tanks is 7 to 10 years
ØDue to no clear differentiation between the volume of the effluent and solid FS generated from the containment, it is assumed to be 50% each to reduce maximum error
Figure 1: Cast Rings
Figure 2: Lined pit with semi permeable walls and open bottom without outlet or overflow
Figure 3: Private Vacuum Tanker
Figure 4: Advertisement of vacuum tankers to call for emptying service
BHIM
AVA
RAM
, AN
DH
RA P
RAD
ESH
20
17
Cen
tre
for
Scie
nce
and
Envi
ronm
ent
41, T
ughl
akab
ad In
stitu
tiona
l Are
a, N
ew D
elhi
110
062
, IN
DIA
Ph: +
91-1
1-29
9561
10 -
5124
- 63
94- 6
399
Fax
: +91
-11-
2995
5879
E-m
ail:
cse@
csei
ndia
.org
W
ebsi
te: w
ww
.cse
indi
a.or
g
3
Figure 5: Containment outlet connected to open drain
Figure 6: Yenamuduru Drain, where sewage and septage is disposed
ØSN is attributed to be from 25 % of the population (16% from septic tanks and 9% from lined tanks)
ØFS contained is attributed to be from 17% of the population ( 17% from septic tanks ), FS contained emptied is attributed to be from 15% (assuming 90% of the system gets emptied), FS contained not emptied is attributed to be from 2% of the population which is FS remains in the tank and never be emptied
ØFS not contained is attributed to be from 57% of the population (49% from lined pit and 8% from lined tank). FS not contained emptied is attributed to be from 29 % of the population (22% from lined pit and 7% from lined tanks). FS from 28% population is not contained and not emptied which includes 24% infiltration and 4% FS which remains in the tank)
Treatment and Disposal
ØThe collected septage from households by private emptiers and the sewage generated in the city is disposed at Yenamadarru Drain
ØThe sewage flows in 30-35 km long drain and meets Kolleru Drain at Upputeru Village
ØThe Yenamadaru drain was basically a fresh water canal, which is currently polluted by the paper mills and others micro and small medium enterprises at 10-30 km upstream of the canal
ØThere is no treatment of sewage and septage generated in the city
ØIn total, FS of 98% population is unsafely managed and 2% population is safely managed
20
17
Cen
tre
for
Scie
nce
and
Envi
ronm
ent
41, T
ughl
akab
ad In
stitu
tiona
l Are
a, N
ew D
elhi
110
062
, IN
DIA
Ph: +
91-1
1-29
9561
10 -
5124
- 63
94- 6
399
Fax
: +91
-11-
2995
5879
E-m
ail:
cse@
csei
ndia
.org
W
ebsi
te: w
ww
.cse
indi
a.or
g
4
BHIM
AVA
RAM
, AN
DH
RA P
RAD
ESH
Suggestions
Short term goals• Recognize the private emptiers and issue them
license to operate• Buy more vacuum trucks, if there is a shortfall• Identify 2-3 suitable disposal sites (so that the
distance travelled by the trucks is optimized). The land could be taken on lease, private parties can be encouraged to develop business around treated faecal sludge.
• Develop DPRs for FSTPs (faecal sludge treatment plants) at these identified disposal sites
Medium term goals• Demarcate land for STPs/FSTPs in the master plan • Enforce scheduled desludging• Improve bylaws, to enforce proper design of septic
tanks• Implement decentralized waste water treatment
systems at several locations to treat supernatant and grey water and encourage reuse of treated waste water
Onsite sanitation
SN contained: 17% SN contained and delivered to treatment: 17%
FS contained: 54%
FS not contained: 29%
FS contained – not emptied: 22%
FS contained – emptied: 32%
FS not contained – emptied: 13%
FS delivered to treatment: 45%
16%FS not
contained
Open defecation
17% SN Treated
22% FS contained–not empted
45% FS treated
Safely managed Unsafely managed
Local area Neighbourhood City
Key: WW: Wastewater, FS: Faecal sludge, SN: Supernatant
Offsite sanitation