shouts and whispers an introduction to immunoregulation in periodontal disease
TRANSCRIPT
!"#$%& '() *"+&,-.&/ '(+(%.#)$0%+#(%#+11$(#.-2$3'%+#(+( ,-.+#)#(%'3 )+&-'&-!!"#$!% "# $"%&$'! % "$() "# &*%+$!
&'()( *+ ,*--,( ./01- -'2- 32-*(4- +0+5(3-*1*,*-6 -/
5')/4*5 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( 3,26+ 2 728/) )/,( *4
.(-()7*4*49 -'( 0,-*72-( .*+(2+( /0-5/7(# $0+5(3-:
*1*,*-6 -/ 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( *4;/,;(+ -'( *4-()3,26
1(-<((4 125-()*2= -'( '/+- 24. (4;*)/47(4-2, >25-/)+
?@*9# AB# C- *+ <(,, (+-21,*+'(. -'2- 125-()*2 *4 -'(
.(4-2, 3,2D0( 1*/E,7 2)( -'( 520+( /> -'( *4F2772:
-*/4# G/<(;()= +*45( -'( AHIJ+ *- '2+ 1((4 5,(2) -'2-
4/- 2,, 3,2D0(+ )(+0,- *4 3)/9)(++*;( .*+(2+(# C4 AHHK
-'( 5/4+(4+0+ )(3/)- /> -'( L/),. L/)M+'/3 /4 N,*4:
*52, O()*/./4-*5+ ?AB 5/45,0.(. -'2- -')(( 125-()*2,
+3(5*(+= !"#$%&#"'"()* +,(+,-).,*= /01,("2)0,..3*
)01,("'&0414'0"',1)(* 24. 5)((4#4..) 6"#*&1%,)=
+'/0,. 1( 5/4+*.()(. 2+ -'( 728/) 3()*/./4-2,
32-'/9(4+# $01+(D0(4-,6= $/5)24+M6 (- 2,# ?PQB .(+:
5)*1(. 2 4071() /> 125-()*2, 5/73,(R(+ <*-' -'(
728/) S)(. 5/73,(RT= 5/4+*+-*49 /> !7 +,(+,-).,*= 5#48
$"(4') 94(1,0".) 24. 57 6"#*&1%,)= 1(*49 2++/5*2-(.
<*-' 2.;245(. >/)7+ /> 5')/4*5 3()*/./4-*-*+#
U,-'/09' -'()( *+ 9(4()2, +033/)- >/) -'*+ 5/45(3-=
*- *+ 2,+/ <(,, )(5/94*V(. -'2- -'( 3)(+(45( /> -'(
32-'/9(4*5 125-()*2 $4# *4 *+ *4+0>E5*(4- -/ 520+(
.*+(2+(# C- '2+ )(5(4-,6 1((4 +'/<4 -'2- -'()( *+ 2
'*9' .(9)(( /> ;/,2-*,*-6 *4 -()7+ /> 25D0*+*-*/4 24.
,/++ /> -'( 30-2-*;( 3()*/./4-2, 32-'/9(4+ /;() 2
W:6(2) 3()*/.# X(,2-*;(,6 >(< +018(5-+ '2. -'(+(
/)924*+7+ /4 70,-*3,( /552+*/4+ ?QB# L'(-'() /)
4/- -'( 125-()*2 <()( 25-02,,6 ,/+- /) 80+- .(5,*4(.
-/ ,(;(,+ 1(,/< -'( .(-(5-*/4 ,*7*- /> -'( 2++26
)(72*4+ -/ 1( .(-()7*4(.# Y(;()-'(,(++= -'*+ +-0.6
5,(2),6 +'/<(. -'( ,*7*-2-*/4+ *4 5)/++:+(5-*/42,
7*5)/1*/,/9*52, +-0.*(+ 24. 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(
24. '*9',*9'-+ -'( >25- -'2- 7246 *4.*;*.02,+ 726
'2)1/) -'( /)924*+7+ <*-'/0- 724*>(+-*49 3)/9)(+:
+*;( 3()*/./4-2, .(+-)05-*/4 ?QB#
G/+- >25-/)+ 2)( 5,(2),6 /> >04.27(4-2, *73/)-245(
?PAB# C4 -'*+ 5/4-(R-= -'( <26 *4 <'*5' -'( '/+-
)(+3/4.+ -/ -'( 125-()*2 *+ .(-()7*4(. 16 -'( 42-0)(
24. 5/4-)/, /> 1/-' -'( *442-( 24. 2.23-*;( *7704(
)(+3/4+(+# U+ 3/*4-(. /0- 16 Z2)+'2,, ?AWB &'(
+0,50,2) 24. 8045-*/42, (3*-'(,*2 '2;( 1((4 -'/09'-
-/ )(3)(+(4- -'( 2332)(4- :4); .,(; *4 -'( 1/.6T+
21*,*-6 -/ +(2, /0- -'( /0-+*.( (4;*)/47(4- *#(# -'(
3,2D0( 1*/E,7# C4 )(2,*-6 '/<(;()= *- 25-+ 7/)( 2+ 2
92-(M((3()= +(,(5-*;(,6 2,,/<*49 -'( 32++29( /> 24-*:
9(4+ 24. 5(,,+ 2+ <(,, 2+ 3)/.05*49 2 )249( /> .(>(4:
+*;( 7/,(50,(+# L'*,( -'( 3'6+*52, 12))*() >045-*/4 />
-'( (3*-'(,*07 5244/- 1( 04.()+-2-(.= *- *+ 4/<
)(5/94*+(. -'2- (3*-'(,*2 -')/09'/0- -'( 1/.6 3)/:
.05( 2 .*;()+( )249( /> 24-*7*5)/1*2, 3(3-*.(+# &/
.2-(= 2- ,(2+- >/0) >27*,*(+ /> .*>>()(4- 24-*7*5)/1*2,
3(3-*.(+ ?!:.(>(4+*4+= ":.(>(4+*4+= N2-'(,*5*.*4+=
$23/+*4+B '2;( 1((4 >/04. *4 '0724+# U4 /;();*(<
/> -'(+( 7/,(50,(+ 24. -'(*) 3/++*1,( )/,( *4 3()*/.:
/4-2, .*+(2+( *+ 3)(+(4-(. 16 Z2)+'2,, ?AWB *4 -'*+
*++0(# &'*+ *+ 4/- 24 (R-(4+*;( )(;*(< /> .(>(4+*4+ 10-
)2-'() 24 /;();*(< -/ '*9',*9'- -'( *73/)-24- 5/4-)*:
10-*/4 /> -'(+( 7/,(50,(+ *4 .*+(2+( 32-'/9(4(+*+ 24.
2+ 3/++*1,( -'()23(0-*5 7/.2,*-*(+# @/) 2 7/)( 5/7:
3)('(4+*;( )(;*(<= )(2.()+ 2)( )(>())(. -/ [2,( ?IB#
\45( -'( (3*-'(,*2, 12))*() <*-' *-+ 24-*7*5)/1*2,
3(3-*.(+ *+ 1)(25'(. -'( 2.23-*;( *7704( )(+3/4+(
5/7(+ *4-/ 3,26# N6-/M*4(+ 2)( 5(4-)2, -/ -'*+
)(+3/4+(= +05' -'2- -'( 3)/.05-*/4 /> S233)/3)*2-(T
56-/M*4(+ )(+0,-+ *4 .(;(,/37(4- /> 3)/-(5-*;(
*7704*-6 24. -'( 3)/.05-*/4 /> S*4233)/3)*2-(T
56-/M*4(+ ,(2.+ -/ -*++0( .(+-)05-*/4 24. .*+(2+( 3)/:
9)(++*/4 ?AJB# "0+- '/< -'( *7704( +6+-(7 5'//+(+
24. )(90,2-(+ -'( )*9'- 56-/M*4(+ *+ 045,(2)= 2,-'/09'
9(4(-*5 >25-/)+ 2)( 7/+- ,*M(,6 *4;/,;(.# X(5(4-,6=
N0,,*424 (- 2,# ?]B *4 2 W:6(2) ,/49*-0.*42, +-0.6
+'/<(. -'2- 2 +3(5*E5 *4-(),(0M*4 ?C^B:A 9(4/-63(
<2+ 2 5/4-)*10-*49 10- 4/4(++(4-*2, >25-/) *4 -'(
3)/9)(++*/4 /> 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(# _D02,,6 -'(6
+'/<(. +7/M()+ <*-' !7 +,(+,-).,* '2. +*94*E524-,6
7/)( 3)/1*49 .(3-'+ 9)(2-() -'24 ]#W 77 5/732)(.
<
!4#,"9"(1"."+& =>>>? @".7 AB? =>>C? <DEA F"$&#,+%1 ! G.)0;:4.. H3(;*+))#9 =>>C
!#,(149 ,( I4(')#;7 /.. #,+%1* #4*4#-49 4567898:;8<8=> ?@@@
<*-' +7/M()+ <*-'/0- !7 +,(+,-).,*# U- -'( +27( -*7(=
C^:A 9(4/-63(:3/+*-*;( +7/M()+ '2. IJ` 7/)( 3/5M:
(-+ !]#W 77 -'24 C^:A 9(4/-63(:4(92-*;( +7/M()+
?]B# &'*+ +-0.6 5,(2),6 +'/<+ -'( *4-()3,26 1(-<((4
125-()*2= '/+- 24. (4;*)/47(4-2, >25-/)+#
U+ +-2-(. 21/;(= 56-/M*4(+ 2)( 5(4-)2, -/ -'( 32-'/:
9(4(+*+ /> 24 (;():*45)(2+*49 4071() /> .*+(2+(+=
*45,0.*49 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(# N6-/M*4(+ 2)( *4-()5(,:
,0,2) 7(++(49()+ 24. 2+ +05' )(3)(+(4- 2 M(6
7(5'24*+7 16 <'*5' 5(,,+ *4;/,;(. *4 *7704(
)(+3/4+(+ 5/7704*52-(# &'(6 2)( 0+02,,6 3)/.05(.
-)24+*(4-,6= />-(4 *4 3*5/7/,2) 5/45(4-)2-*/4+= 24.
+/7(= +05' 2+ C^:Q= 726 '2;( 2 ;()6 )(+-)*5-(. )249(
/> 25-*;*-6# C4.((.= -'( 728/)*-6 /> *7704( )(+3/4+(+
/550) ,/52,,6 24. />-(4 1(-<((4 -</ 5(,,+ 5/48092-(.
-/9(-'() ?@*9# PB# C4 -'*+ 5/4-(R-= -'( 242,/96 524 1(
.)2<4 -'2- <'(4 -</ 5(,,+ 2)( -2,M*49 -/9(-'() -'(6
S<'*+3()T# G/<(;()= <'(4 5(,,+ -2,M -/ /4( 24/-'() 2-
2 .*+-245( -'(6 726 S+'/0-T 16 3)/.05*49 ,2)9(
27/04-+ /> 56-/M*4(# $05' 56-/M*4(+ +05' 2+ C^:A
24. C^:K 2)( -'()(>/)( 3)/.05(. 16 2 ,2)9( 4071()
/> 5(,,+ 24. 2)( 3)/.05(. *4 )(,2-*;(,6 ,2)9( D024-*:
-*(+# C- *+ -'()(>/)( ())/4(/0+ -/ 5/732)( -'( ;2)*/0+
56-/M*4(+ D024-*-2-*;(,6 24. +099(+- -'2- 246 .*>>():
(45(+ 2)( /> 9)(2-() /) ,(++() 1*/,/9*52, +*94*E5245(#
L*-'*4 -'( 5/4-(R- /> -'*+ 242,/96 *- 524 1( +((4 -'2-
*7704/)(90,2-*/4 /) 5/4-)/, /> -'( *7704( )(+:
3/4+( *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( *+ 2 +()*(+ /> S+'/0-+T
24. S<'*+3()+T 2+ 5(,,+ -2,M -/ /4( 24/-'() <'*,( -'(6
5/712- -'( 125-()*2, 2--25M#
N6-/M*4(+ 2,+/ '2;( 2 -)(7(4./0+ 10*,-:*4 )(.04:
.2456= 7246 56-/M*4(+ '2;*49 /;(),233*49 >045-*/4+#
C^:A 24. C^:K 2)( -</ +05' 56-/M*4(+= 2+ 2)( C^:Q 24.
C^:A]# G(45(= 5/4-*40*49 -'( S+'/0-+T 24. S<'*+3()+T
242,/96= 5(,,+ '(2) -'( +27( 7(++29( >)/7 2 ;2)*(-6
/> +/0)5(+ +/ -'2- -'( 21+(45( /> /4( 56-/M*4( 10- -'(
3)(+(45( /> 24/-'() 726 )(+0,- *4 -'( +27( 1*/,/9*52,
/0-5/7(# _D02,,6= 7246 56-/M*4(+ 2)( 24-29/4*+-*5
24. 292*4 -'( /;()2,, 1*/,/9*52, (>>(5- *+ -'( )(+0,- />
-'( 12,245( 1(-<((4 2,, 56-/M*4(+ )2-'() -'24 -'(*)
*4.*;*.02, ,(;(,+# C- +'/0,. 1( /1;*/0+ -'()(>/)( -'2-
56-/M*4(+ >045-*/4 2+ 2 4(-</)M 24. *4.*;*.02, (,(:
7(4-+ /> -'( 4(-</)M 5244/- 1( +-0.*(. *4 *+/,2-*/4
?AIB# @/) (R273,(= Z2)-0+5(,,* (- 2,# ?AKB '2;( +'/<4
-'2- )(5/71*424- '0724 C^:AA ?24 *4'*1*-/) /> C^:A
3)/.05-*/4B (>>(5-*;(,6 *4'*1*-+ 3()*/./4-2, 2--25':
7(4- ,/++ *4 2 ./9 7/.(,# &'()(>/)( -'( +-0.6 />
C^:A <*-'/0- )(>()(45( -/ C^:AA ?2+ <(,, 2+ /-'() *4'*:
1*-/)+ +05' 2+ C^:AJ 24. C^:A)2B 726 <(,, 1( 7(24:
*49,(++ /) 2- 1(+- .*>E50,- -/ *4-()3)(-# &'( <(2,-' />
4(< *4>/)72-*/4 (7()9*49 >)/7 -'( '0724 9(4/7(
3)/8(5- 24. )(,2-(. *4*-*2-*;(+ '2+ )(;(2,(. 7246
4/;(, 56-/M*4(+ <*-' 2+ 6(- 04M4/<4 >045-*/4+
?AHB# &'( +-0.6 /> 56-/M*4(+ 24. -'(*) )/,( *4 *7704/:
)(90,2-*/4 24. .*+(2+( 32-'/9(4(+*+ <*,, -'()(>/)(
)(72*4 2 5)*-*52, (,(7(4- /> 3()*/./4-2, )(+(2)5'
>/) +/7( 6(2)+ -/ 5/7(#
$*45( *- <2+ E)+- 3)(+(4-(. 2- -'( CNOX 7((-*49 *4
\+2M2 *4 AHHP ?PPB -'( & '(,3() ?&'BAa&'P '63/-'(+*+
>/) -'( *7704/)(90,2-*/4 /> 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( '2+
2--)25-(. 2 ,/- /> 2--(4-*/4 ?>/) )(;*(< +(( $(67/0) %
!(77(,, ?P]BB# U 4071() /> +-0.*(+ '2;( +'/<4 2
.(5)(2+( *4 &'A )(+3/4+(+ *4 3()*/./4-*-*+= <'*,(
/-'()+ '2;( +'/<4 *45)(2+(. &'P )(+3/4+(+# $/7(
+-0.*(+ '2;( 5,2*7(. 2 ./7*4245( /> &'A )(+3/4+(
/;() &'P )(+3/4+(+ *4 3()*/./4-*-*+= <'()(2+ /-'()+
'2;( +'/<4 2 3)(./7*4245( /> &'J 5(,,+ *4 3()*/.:
/4-*-*+ ?)(;*(<(. *4 P]B# &'(+( +-0.*(+ 2)( .*>E50,- -/
5/732)( +*45( -'(6 0+(. 2 ;2)*(-6 /> 5(,,+ 24. -*++0(+=
2 ;2)*(-6 /> -(5'4*D0(+ 24. 2 ;2)*(-6 /> +-*70,24-+#
C4 2..*-*/4= -'( *421*,*-6 -/ .(-()7*4( .*+(2+( 25-*:
;*-6 5,*4*52,,6 72M(+ *4-()3)(-2-*/4 .*>E50,-= *> 4/-
*73/++*1,(# Y(;()-'(,(++= *- *+ 29)((. -'2- 5/4-)/,
/> -'( &'Aa&'P 12,245( *+ 5(4-)2, -/ -'( *7704/:
)(90,2-*/4 /> 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(#
Plaque
SusceptibleNon-susceptible
Specific pathogens
Environmental factors
SmokingStress
Genetic factorsCytokine gene polymorphisms
A+2B CB !$&0-,%+D+3+%E %# ,-.+#)#(%'3 )+&-'&-B
A+2B ?B ;"- 1'F#.+%E #G +11$(- .-&,#(&-& #00$. 3#0'33E.'%"-. %"'( &E&%-1+0'33E '() #G%-( D-%*--( %*# 0-33& 0#(HF$2'%-) %# #(- '(#%"-.B
J4&'"3# K 5)&."#
E>
&'()( *+ *45)(2+*49 (;*.(45( -'2- -'( &'Aa&'P 12,:
245( *+ 5/4-)/,,(. 16 2 )249( /> >25-/)+= 2,, /> <'*5'
2)( 3/++*1,( <*-'*4 -'( 3()*/./4-2, -*++0(+# U4 /;():
;*(< /> -'(+( >25-/)+ *+ 3)(+(4-(. 16 !(77(,, %
$(67/0) ?AJB *4 -'*+ *++0(# &'(+( *45,0.( -'( >/,,/<*49b
;"- ('%$.- #G %"- +(('%- +11$(-.-&,#(&-
U +-)/49 *442-( *7704( )(+3/4+( <*,, )(+0,- *4 ,2)9(
27/04-+ /> C^:AP 24. C^:Ac 3)/.05-*/4 16 7/4/:
56-(+ 24. 4(0-)/3'*,+ -'2-= *4 -0)4= <*,, 3)/7/-( 2
&'A )(+3/4+(# C4-(),(0M*4:Ac <2+ .*+5/;()(. *4 AHcH
2+ CY@:# *4.05*49 >25-/)# C^:Ac *+ +-)05-0)2,,6 '/7/:
,/9/0+ -/ C^:A" 24.= -/9(-'() <*-' -'(*) )(5(3-/)+ 2)(
7(71()+ /> -'( C^:AXa&/,,:,*M( )(5(3-/) ?&^XB +03():
>27*,6# &'*+ 520+(+ +*7*,2) +*942,,*49 24. +*942,
-)24+.05-*/4 7(5'24*+7+# C^:Ac *+ )(5/94*V(. 2+ 2
56-/M*4( -'2- *+ 21,( -/ (4'245( -'( 72-0)2-*/4 />
42*;( & 5(,,+ -/ &'A 5(,,+ 2+ 2 5/>25-/) <*-' C^:AP= 24.
'(45( -'( 3)/.05-*/4 /> CY@:## &'( 21*,*-6 /> &'(
*73/)-245( /> C^:Ac 2+ 5/:*4.05() /> CY@:# *4.05-*/4
,( -,1#" 16 -'( +055(++>0, )(.05-*/4 /> CY@:# 3)/.05:
-*/4 *4 +-*70,2-(. 7/0+( +3,((4 5(,,+ 16 4(0-)2,*V*49
24-*1/.*(+ -/ 70)*4( C^:Ac# &'( 728/) )/,( /> C^:AP *4
-'*+ 7(5'24*+7 +((7+ -/ 1( (4'245*49 C^:Ac )(5(3:
-/) (R3)(++*/4# C4-()(+-*49,6= &'A 5(,,+ (R3)(++ C^:Ac
)(5(3-/) <'()(2+ &'P ./ 4/-# N,(2),6 C^:Ac 5/0,. 1(
(R3(5-(. -/ '2;( 2 >04.27(4-2, )/,( *4 -'( 5/4-)/, />
-'( &'Aa&'P )(+3/4+( *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(# G/<:
(;()= -'( )/,( /> C^:Ac *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( 24. *-+
*4-()3,26 <*-' C^:AP 24. *4.((. C^:AW '2+ 4/- 6(-
1((4 (,05*.2-(.# Y(;()-'(,(++ -'( 1*/,/9*52, 25-*;*-6
/> C^:Ac *+ )(;*(<(. *4 .(-2*, 16 [(,2,(0 24. d*5M(, ?cB#
_D02,,6= -'()( *+ +/7( (;*.(45( -/ +099(+- -'2- !7
+,(+,-).,* ^O$ *+ )(5/94*V(. 16 &/,,:,*M( )(5(3-/)
?&^XB:P 24. &^X:K= <'*5' 3)/7/-( 2 &'P )(+3/4+(#
Y/432-'/9(4*5 ,*3/3/,6+255'2)*.( ?(#9# L*0%4#,0%,)
0".,B *+ )(5/94*V(. 16 &^X:Q 24. N[AQ= <'*5' 3)/:
7/-( 2 &'A )(+3/4+(# &'*+ *+ .*+50++(. *4 .(-2*, 16
[*R/4 (- 2,# ?HB#
;"- ('%$.- #G %"- '(%+2-(I&J
U+ .*+50++(. 21/;(= *- *+ 9(4()2,,6 255(3-(. -'2-
<'*,( .*>>()(4- 3(/3,( 726 )(+3/4. .*>>()(4-,6= +3(:
5*E5 125-()*2 2)( 4(;()-'(,(++ -'( 520+( /> 3()*/.:
/4-2, .*+(2+(# C))(+3(5-*;( /> -'( '/+- )(+3/4+(= >)/7
2 5,*4*52, 3()+3(5-*;(= *> 2 32-*(4- '2+ 4/ 3,2D0(= -'(6
'2;( 4/ .*+(2+(# C4 )(5(4- 6(2)+ *- '2+ 2,+/ 1(5/7(
2332)(4- -'2- 5/73,(R(+ /> /)924*+7+ 2)( 7/+-
3)/121,6 2++/5*2-(. <*-' .*+(2+( 24. '(45( -'( )/,(
/> 5/*4>(5-*/4 '2+ 1(5/7( *45)(2+*49,6 )(5/94*V(.#
X(5(4- .2-2 '2;( +099(+-(. -'2- 5/71*42-*/4+ />
/)924*+7+ 726 )(+0,- *4 +'*>-+ *4 -'( &'Aa&'P 24.
24-*1/.6 3)/E,(+ ?P= AJB# C4 /).() -/ 04.()+-24. '/<
5/71*42-*/4+ /> /)924*+7+ 726 *4F0(45( -'(
*7704( )(+3/4+( *- *+ E)+- 4(5(++2)6 -/ '2;( 2
M4/<,(.9( /> -'( +3(5*E5 24-*9(4+ /> -'( 32-'/9(4*5
125-()*2# U 5/73)('(4+*;( )(;*(< /> -'(+( 24-*9(4+ *+
3)(+(4-(. 16 \Td)*(4:$*73+/4 (- 2,# ?PJB# &'(+(
20-'/)+ 3/*4- /0- -'2- (25' /> -'( 3()*/./4-2, 32-'/:
9(4+ 3)/.05( 24 2))26 /> 24-*9(4+ 52321,( /> *4.0:
5*49 1/-' &'A 24. &'P 56-/M*4( 3)/E,(+ 24. -'(6
+099(+- -'2- 70,-*+3(5*(+ ;255*4(+ .*)(5-(. 292*4+-
M(6 125-()*2, (3*-/3(+ 2++/5*2-(. <*-' -'( 25D0*+*-*/4
/> (++(4-*2, 40-)*(4-+ 726 )(+-)*5- 3)/,*>()2-*/4 /> -'(
32-'/9(4+ <*-'*4 -'( 1*/E,7 24. -'()(16 *4F0(45(
.*+(2+( 3)/9)(++*/4#
;"-('%$.-#G %"-'(%+2-(H,.-&-(%+(20-33
&'()( *+ 273,( (;*.(45( -'2- -'( 42-0)( /> -'( 24-*:
9(4:3)(+(4-*49 5(,, 524 .(-()7*4( -'( 42-0)( /> -'(
&'Aa&'P 3)/E,(# N0-,() (- 2,# ?KB '2;( +099(+-(. -'2-
-'( .(>20,- ,(+*/4 *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( *+ &'A= *4
<'*5' -'( 728/) 24-*9(4:3)(+(4-*49 5(,, *+ -'( .(4:
.)*-*5 5(,,# U- -'( +27( -*7(= !(77(,, (- 2,# ?APB '2;(
+'/<4 -'2- *4 3()*/./4-*-*+ ,(+*/4+ N[AH!= N[c]! d
5(,,+ 2)( 3)/121,6 -'( ./7*424- 24-*9(4:3)(+(4-*49
5(,,= +033/)-*49 -'( 5/45(3- /> +'*>-+ *4 -'( &'Aa&'P
3)/E,( 1(-<((4 9*49*;*-*+ 24. 3()*/./4-*-*+# C4 -'(*)
)(;*(< *4 -'*+ *++0(= N0-,() % "/-<24* ?WB ,//M 2- -'(
(;(4-+ ,(2.*49 03 -/ 24-*9(4 3)(+(4-2-*/4 16 .(4.)*:
-*5 5(,,+ 24. +099(+- -'2- 2+ 24-*9(4 3)(+(4-2-*/4 *+
-'( ,*7*-*49 +-(3 *4 -'( 9(4()2-*/4 /> 24 *7704(
)(+3/4+(= 1,/5M*49 +3(5*E5 2+3(5-+ /> -'*+ 5/0,.
)(3)(+(4- 2 ;2,*. +-)2-(96 >/) -'( 5/4-)/, /> 3()*/.:
/4-*-*+#
;H0-33 .-0-,%#. I;K6J 'GG+(+%E
&'()( *+ (7()9*49 (;*.(45( -'2- '*9' &:5(,, )(5(3-/)
2>E4*-6 <*-' +'/)- +*942,*49 -*7( >2;/)+ 2 &'A
)(+3/4+( <'*,( ,/< &:5(,, )(5(3-/) 2>E4*-6 <*-' 2
3)/,/49(. +*942,*49 -*7( >2;/)+ 2 &'P )(+3/4+(# U+
6(-= '/<(;()= -'( &:5(,, )(5(3-/) 2>E4*-6 /> 5(,,+
*4;/,;(. *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( '2+ 4/- 1((4 .(-():
7*4(.# C4 -'(*) )(;*(< *4 -'*+ *++0(= e272V2M* %
Y2M28*72 ?PKB )2*+( -'( 3/++*1*,*-6 /> 20-/*7704*-6
5/4-)*10-*49 -/ -'( 3()*/./4-2, ,(+*/4# &'( (R3)(+:
EE
M''3("#4+3.)1,"( ,( $4#,"9"(1). 9,*4)*4
+*/4 /> '(2- +'/5M 3)/-(*4+ *4 -'( 3()*/./4-2, -*++0(+
*+ 3)(+(4-(.= -/9(-'() <*-' -'( 3/++*1*,*-6 -'2- -'(
*7704( )(+3/4+( -/ -'(*) 125-()*2, '/7/,/9 ?!)/_^
24-*9(4+B 5)/++:)(25-+ 24. '(45( 5/4-)*10-(+ -/ -'(
*4F2772-/)6 ,(+*/4# &'(6 >0)-'() 3)(+(4- (;*.(45(
-'2- )(90,2-/)6 & 5(,,+= <'*5' 5/4-)/, 20-/*7704*-6=
2)( *4 >25- ,25M*49 *4 -'( 3()*/./4-2, -*++0(+#
=-(-%+0&
f+*49 2 7/0+( 7/.(,= !(77(,, (- 2,# ?A]B '2;(
+'/<4 -'2- +0+5(3-*1*,*-6 -/ !7 +,(+,-).,* *4>(5-*/4
*+ *4 32)- .(-()7*4(. 16 -'( GP '23,/-63( 24. -'2-
-'*+ 2,+/ )(F(5-+ -'( &'Aa&'P 3)/E,(# U,+/= -'()( *+
*45)(2+*49 (;*.(45( -'2- -'( 56-/M*4(+ <'*5' *4F0:
(45( &'Aa&'P >045-*/4 2)( *4F0(45(. 16 9(4(-*5
3/,67/)3'*+7g -'*+ 726 5/4-)*10-( -/ .*>>()(45(+
*4 *4.*;*.02, ;2)*2-*/4 *4 &'Aa&'P )(+3/4+(+ 24.
-'()(>/)( +0+5(3-*1*,*-6 24. 3)/9)(++*/4 *4 3()*/./4:
-2, .*+(2+(# &'*+ 3/++*1*,*-6 *+ )(;*(<(. 16 &26,/)
(- 2,# ?PWB# &'(+( 20-'/)+ 3/*4- /0- -'2- <'*,( -'()(
*+ 4/ ./01- -'2- 2 9(4(-*5 (,(7(4- *+ 24 (++(4-*2,
5/73/4(4- /> -'( 3()*/./4-2, ,(+*/4= 2 5(4-)2, )/,(
>/) 56-/M*4( 9(4( 3/,67/)3'*+7+ *4 *7704/)(90,2:
-*/4 )(72*4+ +099(+-*;(#
U,, /> -'(+( 7(5'24*+7+ 2)( 4/- 70-02,,6 (R5,0+*;(
24. *- *+ ,*M(,6 -'2- *7704/)(90,2-*/4 /> *4F2772:
-/)6 .*+(2+(+ ?+05' 2+ 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(B *4;/,;(
.*>>()(4- 7(5'24*+7+ 2- .*>>()(4- -*7(+ *4 .*>>()(4-
32-*(4-+ 24. 3)/121,6 4/ /4( 7(5'24*+7 *+ 7/)(
*73/)-24- -'24 24/-'() ?AcB# &'( 233,*52-*/4 />
4(< M4/<,(.9( 24. -(5'4/,/9*(+ *4 -'( E(,.+ />
9(4/7*5+= 3)/-(/7*5+ 24. +-)05-0)2, 1*/,/96 '/,.+
)(2, 3)/7*+( *4 -()7+ /> (+-21,*+'*49 2 -)0,6 '/,*+-*5
3*5-0)( /> 5/73,(R .*+(2+(+ 2+ <(,, 2+ 3)/;*.*49
)2-*/42, -2)9(-+ >/) .*294/+-*5 24. -'()23(0-*5 +-)2:
-(9*(+# L*-' -'*+ *4 7*4.= -'( 20-'/)+ /> -'( +()*(+ />
2)-*5,(+ >/) -'*+ *++0( /> !4#,"9"(1"."+& =>>> '2;(
1((4 5'2)9(. -/ .(+5)*1( 3)/9)(++ *4 -'( 5/73,(R
E(,. /> *7704/)(90,2-*/4 24. 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(
24. -/ *45,0.( 2 .*+50++*/4 /> '/< -'(+( 4/;(,
233)/25'(+ 7*9'- (4,*9'-(4 /0) )(+(2)5' (>>/)-+ *4
-'*+ 2)(2# &'*+ *++0( 1)*49+ -/9(-'() (R3()-+ >)/7 >/0)
5/4-*4(4-+g *- ./(+ 4/- 2--(73- -/ )(25' 2 5/4+(4+0+
10- )2-'() -/ (+-21,*+' /0) 50))(4- M4/<,(.9( 24. -/
+(- -'( >)27(</)M >/) >0-0)( )(+(2)5'#
6-G-.-(0-&
A# U4/467/0+# N/4+(4+0+ )(3/)- >/) 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(+b
32-'/9(4(+*+ 24. 7*5)/1*2, >25-/)+# /(( !4#,"9"(1". AHHKb
Cb HPKhH]P#
P# N'//* "^= d/))(,,/ ZU= $7*-' _$= i20.()() Z# O/,2)*V2-*/4
/> !"#$%&#"'"()* +,(+,-).,*:+3(5*>*5 '(,3() &:5(,, +01+(-+
16 3)*/) *7704*V2-*/4 <*-' N3*"2)014#,3' (30.4)13'# O#).
H,0#"2,". M''3(". PJJJb CLb AcAhAcI#
]# N0,,*424 ZO= L(+-()724 d= G27,(- $Z= O2,7() "_= @2..6
Z"= ^249 YO= $(67/0) !"# U ,/49*-0.*42, +-0.6 /> *4-(),(0:
M*4:A 9(4( 3/,67/)3'*+7+ 24. 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( *4 2
9(4()2, 2.0,- 3/30,2-*/4# P F.,( !4#,"9"(1". PJJAb ?Mb
AA]IhAAQQ#
Q# N0,,*424 ZO= G27,(- $Z= L(+-()724 d= O2,7() "_= @2..6
Z"= $(67/0) !"# U5D0*+*-*/4 24. ,/++ /> !"#$%&#"'"()*
+,(+,-).,*= /01,("2)0,..3* )01,("'&0414'0"',1)(* 24. !#48
-"14..) ,(14#'49,) /;() 2 W:6(2) 3()*/.b -'( (>>(5- /> 2 -)*:
5,/+24a5/3/,67() .(4-*>)*5(# P F.,( !4#,"9"(1". PJJ]b N@b
W]PhWQA#
W# N0-,() NL= "/-<24* X# U4-*9(4:3)(+(4-2-*/4 24. -'( )/,( />
.(4.)*-*5 5(,,+ *4 3()*/./4-*-*+# !4#,"9"(1". =>>> PJJQb NLb
A]WhAWI#
K# N0-,() NL= "/-<24* X= O2,05M2 jU= [2;/0+- "= d(,, [= d24:
5'()(20 "# _;*.(45( 24. 2 4/;(, '63/-'(+*+ >/) -'( )/,( />
.(4.)*-*5 5(,,+ 24. !"#$%&#"'"()* +,(+,-).,* *4 2.0,- 3():
*/./4-*-*+# P !4#,"9"(1). Q4* AHHHb NOb AhI#
I# [2,( dU# O()*/./4-2, (3*-'(,*07b 2 4(<,6 )(5/94*+(. )/,( *4
'(2,-' 24. .*+(2+(# !4#,"9"(1". =>>> PJJPb N@b IJhIc#
c# [(,2,(0 Y= d*5M(, Z# C4-(),(0M*4:A" 24. *4-(),(0M*4:Ach)(9:
0,2-*/4 24. 25-*;*-6 *4 ,/52, *4>,2772-*/4# !4#,"9"(1". =>>>
PJJQb NLb QPhWP#
H# [*R/4 [X= d2*41)*.9( dL= [2);(20 XO# Z/.0,2-*/4 /> -'(
*442-( *7704( )(+3/4+( <*-'*4 -'( 3()*/./4-*07# !4#,"98
"(1". =>>> PJJQb NLb W]hIQ#
AJ# !(77(,, _= $(67/0) !"# C7704/)(90,2-/)6 5/4-)/, /> &'Aa
&'P 56-/M*4( 3)/>*,(+ *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(# !4#,"9"(1".
=>>> PJJQb NLb PAhQA#
AA# !(77(,, _= Z2)+'2,, XC= $(67/0) !"# N6-/M*4(+ 24.
3)/+-29,24.*4+ *4 *7704( '/7(/+-2+*+ 24. -*++0( .(+-)05:
-*/4 *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(# !4#,"9"(1". =>>> AHHIb COb
AAPhAQ]#
AP# !(77(,, _= d*). O$= N2)-() N^= [)6+.2,( j_= $(67/0) !"#
_>>(5- /> N3*"2)014#,3' (30.4)13' /4 -'( & 24. d 5(,,
)(+3/4+(+ -/ !"#$%&#"'"()* +,(+,-).,* *4 2 7/0+( 7/.(,#
F.,( LR$ M''3(". PJJPb C?Mb P]chPQQ#
A]# !(77(,, _= N2)-() N^= d*). O$= $(67/0) !"# !(4(-*5 .(3(4:
.(45( /> -'( +3(5*>*5 &:5(,, 56-/M*4( )(+3/4+( -/ !"#$%&8
#"'"()* +,(+,-).,* *4 7*5(# P !4#,"9"(1". PJJPb PNb
WHAhWHK#
AQ# !(77(,, _= N2)-() N^= G2)- [Y"= [)6+.2,( j_= $(67/0) !"#
U4-*9(4 3)(+(4-*49 5(,,+ *4 '0724 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( -*+:
+0(+# O#). H,0#"2,". M''3(". PJJPb CPb ]cch]H]#
AW# Z2)+'2,, XC# !*49*;2, .(>(4+*4+# ^*4M*49 -'( *442-( 24.
2.23-*;( *7704( )(+3/4+(+ -/ 3,2D0(# !4#,"9"(1". =>>>
PJJQb NLb AQhPJ#
AK# Z2)-0+5(,,* != @*/)(,,*4* "O= N)/'*4 NN= G/<(,, &G# &'(
(>>(5- /> *4-(),(0M*4:AA /4 -'( 3)/9)(++*/4 /> ,*92-0)(:
*4.05(. 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+( *4 -'( 1(29,( ./9# P !4#,"9"(1".
PJJJb PCb WI]hWIc#
AI# Z/+7244 &X# N6-/M*4(+b *+ -'()( 1*/,/9*52, 7(24*49k F3##
O$,( M''3(". AHHAb Nb ]AAh]AQ#
Ac# Y2-'24 N# O/*4-+ /> 5/4-)/, /> *4>,2772-*/4# S)13#4 PJJPb
O?@b cQKhcWP#
AH# Y*5M,*4 Z"= d2)-/4 "^= Y906(4 Z= @*-V!()2,. Z!= [0>> !L=
j/)4724 j# U +(D0(45(:12+(. 723 /> -'( 4*4( 9(4(+ />
-'( '0724 *4-(),(0M*4:A 5,0+-()# T4("',0* PJJPb PQb
IAchIPW#
E=
J4&'"3# K 5)&."#
PJ# \Td)*(4:$*73+/4 YZ= l(*-' O[= [2+'3() $!= X(64/,.+ _N#
U4-*9(4+ /> 125-()*2 2++/5*2-(. <*-' 3()*/./4-*-*+# !4#,"98
"(1". =>>> PJJQb NLb AJAhA]Q#
PA# $(67/0) !"# C73/)-245( /> -'( '/+- )(+3/4+( *4 -'( 3()*/.:
/4-*07# P F.,( !4#,"9"(1". AHHAb CMb QPAhQPK#
PP# $(67/0) !"= !(77(,, _# N6-/M*4(+ *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(b
<'()( -/ >)/7 '()(k /01) O9"(1". J0)(9 PJJAb LQb
AKIhAI]#
P]# $(67/0) !"= !(77(,, _= X(*4'2).- XU= _2+-5/-- "= &201724
ZU# C7704/32-'/9(4(+*+ /> 5')/4*5 *4>,2772-/)6 3()*/.:
/4-2, .*+(2+(b 5(,,0,2) 24. 7/,(50,2) 7(5'24*+7+# P !4#,"98
"(1). Q4* AHH]b ?Mb QIchQcK#
PQ# $/5)24+M6 $$= G2>>28(( U[= N09*4* ZU= $7*-' N= j(4- X^ ")#
Z*5)/1*2, 5/73,(R(+ *4 +019*49*;2, 3,2D0(# P F.,( !4#,"98
"(1". AHHcb ?Lb A]QhAQQ#
PW# &26,/) ""= O)(+'2< OZ= [/42,.+/4 O&# N6-/M*4( 9(4( 3/,6:
7/)3'*+7 24. *7704/)(90,2-*/4 *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(#
!4#,"9"(1". =>>> PJJQb NLb AWchAcP#
PK# e272V2M* e= Y2M28*72 &# U4-*9(4 +3(5*>*5*-6 24. & 5(,, 5,/4:
2,*-6 *4 3()*/./4-2, .*+(2+(#!4#,"9"(1". =>>>PJJQb NLb IWhAJJ#
EA
M''3("#4+3.)1,"( ,( $4#,"9"(1). 9,*4)*4