siai - national bureau of economic research · 1o1inod 1ic11) 9e9r11 i07in0d iimii 9(11 vji1ids 10...

56
arsia siai OMDI$IOW sLqaM $IOM 513W0$L$lOfl A SIHHTIHM DIMOMOD MA :H8 SIaUMaJ A T2HSIHTMI qO RYJAMA WAJ Y$1UU UMA MO1TD1HTH$L i,1D .J biswb n&rc1nith .A aot .oM 1E nthoW HD$LA22$1 DIMOMODH 1O UALS1Ufl JAMOITAM 3unvA flIJII3SM OO1 8€!O AM bhdmBD QI 13dm,3U .noi1ibnuo1 n3h2 1noitsM 3d1 mod lloqqu€ !i3wUIi1 b3Iwombs I1ubizi iortius riioa rliiw noii13vnoD .nB3i d151 thqu2 b3bivolq iobiV !nt bliB imqmB$I onthbA nthnaia13bnu luo bI3ni iai 1m51X 1EthiM bna ,nambFiI nirnzijt3fl ,n&JcIi1 1f13iM b3bivolq 8O bio1nai i bnli rbrnil '(ihJ3aI i,cnmu O){ cft ni inqi3ir1c .3iqoi irft 10 noiniqo nA .chwoiD ni msioiq 'SI8T4 lo nq i iqq 2icIT .atn3rnmo3 IuIqI3d .dti51 3icnono33 lo unwfl !BnoilBM ,cti lo odi ion bnB iodiu cIi lo odi w biqx lo noii noiI .b,vii jcIh hA .n cnick .A ot bnz iID .J tnzwb d QQ! © Ilul iirti bbivmq noiirrnq ii3iIqx iuorfiiw bioup d 'sm dqiq owl bx 01 ron ixi .31U0 f1i 01 flV! i ,3flOfl © nibu1oni iib13

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jan-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

arsia siai OMDI$IOW sLqaM

$IOM 513W0$L$lOfl A SIHHTIHM DIMOMOD MA :H8 SIaUMaJ A

T2HSIHTMI qO RYJAMA WAJ Y$1UU UMA MO1TD1HTH$L

i,1D .J biswb n&rc1nith .A aot

.oM 1E nthoW

HD$LA22$1 DIMOMODH 1O UALS1Ufl JAMOITAM 3unvA flIJII3SM OO1

8€!O AM bhdmBD QI 13dm,3U

.noi1ibnuo1 n3h2 1noitsM 3d1 mod lloqqu€ !i3wUIi1 b3Iwombs I1ubizi iortius riioa rliiw noii13vnoD .nB3i d151 thqu2 b3bivolq iobiV !nt bliB imqmB$I onthbA

nthnaia13bnu luo bI3ni iai 1m51X 1EthiM bna ,nambFiI nirnzijt3fl ,n&JcIi1 1f13iM b3bivolq 8O bio1nai i bnli rbrnil '(ihJ3aI i,cnmu O){ cft ni inqi3ir1c .3iqoi irft 10 noiniqo nA .chwoiD ni msioiq 'SI8T4 lo nq i iqq 2icIT .atn3rnmo3 IuIqI3d

.dti51 3icnono33 lo unwfl !BnoilBM ,cti lo odi ion bnB iodiu cIi lo odi w biqx lo noii noiI .b,vii jcIh hA .n cnick .A ot bnz iID .J tnzwb d QQ! ©

Ilul iirti bbivmq noiirrnq ii3iIqx iuorfiiw bioup d 'sm dqiq owl bx 01 ron ixi .31U0 f1i 01 flV! i ,3flOfl © nibu1oni iib13

Page 2: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

iq I4BEBcwpqq NV cico IrH'.'q flU!iGL2UX I JQ E pI U r!WL CGIU flUTACLIX O CP!°jbuucui Oj cbUuJcu O COUOUJTC2Eq"q r QJL oç v 2cpQru1uh3u

OACLCOUJWWGUj O qp uq WCJCIJ COWIJJCLCG CUCLJfl?

CLO iUJC ( cu-2cJqu J!uu cuc? bLopjcui MIWJU flJC CJJJILCJJ' J!IJJI]U

LC92OU NqJA nnLA bI2! Pm ! jo rpri nraA pii pq qciu jnucioun2cmA jiia JJJC pToL? o nraA cz ip ipa ocij umucc uJcpuui r ou

LC LC JO1 DW JL0W fl 2WG LC flJJOU2 2flbbOI4 couucctou pcwccu !ucdrnrj!A uq

i.piciou iiijj pc /1pGu !ucowc ucdnvjirX pp (uq !wbuJJucIu) uq iipcu

OL 1p q ijcnjc upci.cu u cowbjx counc jpc uioqcj bLcqTc qrnr

pocjc Lc uo OJCLMi2 urarpjc pccnc o bLopjcw2 LcJcq o 12)uJJwCpJc iujouinipou

LQAC JO2C IJG AQ JJOCJC rnq po UM1LJUJ flu1J! 0j JJCOUJ ! JJJF JG flWG JJ91

CUJbOLL? UCPA JUCOtJJQ 2JJOCJC2 -- IIJ1CLC2 L9Q LC.TCPOU LIJ2jL o cu MO pciU2f1T.UCC JIUCL LC J!UJ! b° !UJbL0A!U pccr1Q U12 OLLO MJJCIJ IpCX JJV

jjn bb cxbjiu ipr ipcc p.ciou cu pc cxbJ9rncq v uiuz o buunimc ocj

IUL LC LC2JCOIJ2 9LC UUJOIJ JJC W02f bcLAriAc OUJJ O CCOUOUJTC LC11JpOIJ2

VBLKVC1

KE2JJflCIIO42 VI1D fl2flIcA rVn2VL4VrA212 Oh EKE2.L

V fEViDEK BE: VM ECOI'IONICI4ELLIIEK V BOKKORtEI WOK

DCCGWPCL JffiO4Uu bIJbCL *1ô?4

Page 3: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

5

1D1CflOU 0L L!UUCGJM2 OCCHL Hi C°J (iô2)

GuçLGbLGuGrrL2 9L6 C0LI16L0IJ6 0 L0MIJr 1P6 26COIJ C021 O !U6L62l L16

IT2IILX JM2 JiG 9Lf16 IJ1 1JJ6 20qSJ IIOLW2 C01JtICM6 IOMSLq2 J6uqu fO6COUOUJIC L0MflJ B9flWOJ (JJ) gJ2o 2[I.626 1J!I IUJbOI3SIJI OCTj C02 0J9M1!6X poJJ !1L.I16 !11A6W61U j021 tLOW fl2fILA L621LICP0U 26WW6

CL696 6XC6bf1O1J2 OIl (I2rILA J9M2 tOL 1]J6 WI1QI1 0 I!6M bLo]6c M6P6L uq

WOLJ LpI6L2 (pow JJ6 ML!16L2 0 JJ6 jjwiiq fo ydrnus2) MJJO P16q 1011JC0W6 JJJG !L2l CO O II1lGL6 L916 COIIf1OJ2 M92 6IJ6L9JJ? L6COur6q pA

COUI1OJ 9J0 pIJJfl 1JJ6 9pIJ& O JJ6 CL6 W9LJ(62 10 2UJOOflJ 2JJ0CJ( JDC0IJLOJ UJ9A 1!W!1 fJJ6 tIIJ9IJCIJ O CSb!f.9J 711161127A6 bLo16c OL 1L9q6 IJJG

1JJ6 cL6q W9LJ(62 0pA!OrrJA CL69162 6COUOUJ!C q21oLqou2 1U16L621 L916

bo6up9JjX Oj L69l 6COIJOUJIC 2!I1iIC911C6 JjJ6 TU4U1TOI! 0 OA6LUW67J1 !IJO

V2 q6 L9I1J1J 92 fIG26 L11J62 JJ9AG G6I! siq L6wgiU 1p6A 9L6 9J20

9 !1U6L61

LG2I11CIGcJ !1U6L621 L9162 JAIO2 9WOf12 O 9JJ 9L6 fJ6 12J911.qC L62f1JCfOU2 011

O1T1JJ692f V2!911 C0rIIUL!62 (pJcjngu 1bu uq K0L69) J19A6 26A6L6JAL9fG2 OIl cL6q1 C9L2 (MpIcp q!q o1 p6COW6 9 J9M) w jj y.9uA ot IJiGJJJIGLG2I L9162 OIl CL611 c9Lq2 1JJ6 2611916 b9226q 9 pIIJ L6fIJ 1J IJJ6 II!16L621

bji6q Ofll TI! fJ6 69LJA ThO2 V W9]o41 O 2916a IJOM JJ9AG COUILOJ2 OIl fI6

MJJ!C1J COI!1L0JJ6 I:JJG Il6L62I 19162 01! qiirniq q6bO21:2' M92 OIJJX UIIIIA11J16L621 L6f1J9fJ0IJ2 916 211JJ MIfJJ f12 711 1116 J916 501:JJ C61J1t11.A J�6flJ91JOI! 0'

rnu o) jxcc iq ucbueou' C921 9 I!69fTh6 AI6M 0 pOLL0MII1 111 JH2 W02f bLowJijGuç bjA (6'

oqour JJ9J(Gab69L6' L69C1!IJ b61119b2 i:o Ji2 0141! t91JJGL42 fIlJ6 JIJ q6plOL1e

D91116 bJ9cGq 1JJ6 f12f6L2 O C9YOL !U fIG 29W6 9169 O P611 92 IJJ6 6IJj6U2 0j

bJ9O 911q VL!210116 pow A16146q W0116A j6uqu s woi.jjA dn62loxrnpJ6 ccGqTc J9M C0IJ1L0JJ6 !I!16L621 L9f62 911q C0Il6WIl6 II2IILA woi 211!I6xbJrqcJA oLprq 1Ji6 CJJ9L!I! 0j Wf6621 Jil uq (91 fiG 29W6 69LJX b6LOq)bLGA9JGuf 0LW2 0 GCOIJOIII!C L6f1J9110W IJJLG6 b922s6a 111 fIG b61!191611C11

J�G2ILICITOII2 011 fIG 19J(IU 0 711161621 916 9111011g 1JJ6 OJ621 9IJC W021

I. IurLoqnqJou

Page 4: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

01 iooq \Ii11oqrn9i 9(11 10 vJi1ids 9(11 iimiI I07in0D 9e9r11 1ic11) 1o1inoD

.f1iioirf b9wth IIsw as n99d tort arid (wonod

910m 916 21119119(5 9dT .woivdo 916 29151 12919111i nhinhi291 lo 2120D 9r1 T JsrIi ai taix9 arIoiiDrrt29l 929111 r1w lo rIoiisnsIqx9 isluqoq fom 9rfT .9luDado

rrnaiIIoT bits h9d9H bnu191 .219wo11od Iuh9woq rIisi1 b91119119d rfi 9111 9a1J6)9d 296 9lbbim 9111 b9vivlIJ2 afIoiJDili29l \1U21J 15(11 9U16 (Q8f)

II .bs1 ti eboo lo 9DI 9111 l9woI of b9fnsW 19wonod lrl9nimolq s thiur1D

92riD eicfi iti) 1ibommoD £ lo 2l9arirbIuq sill isdi in9mu1s busy s 1(lrIiBfl9D i 116111 iswol I srlwsmoa 9Dfl 9111 qssA of yIicnJmmoD 9111 irisw icfim (iib9lD

-11011 9(5 I9v9worf 1Iiw isworiod srff iol snq 169b1 9ff T .snq 9VIiii9qmoD 9(11

9111 irisw iliw sffi 'c11ssbI .brisl of bsDubni sd Ilifa iwm isbitsl 9111 9D(112 O19s .19v91 cioaqonom 9,11 oi b9iDit1291 tth9lD lo sriq

-11191 cI bsissD 916 2110r1L11112111 IEbOa 15(11 w91v 9(11 9iSb9lqqS 9W 26 (IDUr(I aA bits 9)s1 sdli 29DfI 9111 iswol of 'cd odw (rbiurfD Isv9ibsm 9111 9)111) ia>1a

9V9119d 01 21102691 iIfiffl 916 919111 16111 9V9119d 9W 19110 9f1i 29DI1 9111 92161

Oil 26W 919111 11s isilA .Issqqs bsslqe9biw iorn s bsrl awsl (luau Jsi-11

26W 9191IT .sis 110111(110) 9(11 siolsd 21E9 ooor 911jj296q (Ii rFxw± 1svibrn 91019d murnn9llim s sino1ds8 io 2.28 0001 sibizI th rbiucb Isv9ibsm Off

916 awn iuau 111s19rl9 sioM .asii9boa dod ni awn iuau 919W 919111 1 zid

9ld1sDi1qqs 11s19n9 9d of ior1i nD199a-J1I91 £ zol bns nommoD XI9arlsrnrm

15)11 iloq 910ffl b9aasaaoq 1115219VifW 219WOTIOd 16111 9U16 0:1 9V&rf bliiow 9110

910rrrI9rft1uST .129(1 15 slthauslqmi mu3b airfi 1)1111 9W .2191) 1191 nsrI:1 is woq :11191 lo 21102 Ifs iii 96119 of lsuin9uflrIl 9111 101 a9liinurloqqo 9111 119V1

bk,ow noiishJ91 10 rrriol :1)9111)111 bits 1iaoD aidi iscli cnaI1qlua 2111 1IDI992 .'(iivibs 11D1992 11191 lo iIoiaa9lqX9 iiommo S 11)1.12 9d

lsbnLr) as awn iuau 1iieut of ashf bits ffDsoiqqn 11-191911th s 29)161 isqsq aidT

(IS 1rio 16111 9V9il9d 9W .anoifiiiiiani rnvolqmz 0j916q (anoiithrIoD 1115119)

bits no1 02 101 b9121x9 svrirf bfuo aJiI9nsd lnboe innDi1inia rliiw cloiixiliiasii

1111w 109cfi lsrniol £ 1119a91q of oafs ai 1so iuO .a9)slq 11191911ib irism 02 itI

91sI 9111 itisfqx9 I1sifn9Joq ns ii isull 02 2)11612 9viinlsqrrzoD rIjons .awsl '(IU2LI to 9Df19iaiX9 bits rfinstia srfi iii 9DsIq bits smii 2201)6 noifshsv

C

Page 5: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

uiouobojA coflq GX2fGqO1JG LYf1O1JJ6 LOL U2flLX JgM JR( IJJG2G J9M2 9bbp6q !'J W1U?i GUAILOIJUJGUf MJJGLG 110flhJGL po couq!poIJ jIun(u bucG2 wX p GIqGuj M6 pGI!6A6 fps f2 wX

yu 9JGL1JØIAG woqGJ 1J101 MG qo 1101 gqqLG22 2 liNt 6uq6L2 pøq j0Cj WO1J0bO b0MGL 9uqMJIJJ IJJGIL 1JGzpp0L2

JJJGLG MIII G 110 1OL9G III OIIL IJJGOLA — G1U2 Wff C01JI1WG Ip6I1. 6IKIOMWGUI2 LG 1LSG !t

p76L II 9J20 bL6qcr2 IJJ91 fI'eITLA J9M2 MiJJ 6 100261. (1) MJJ6IJ JJ6 L0M1JJ 1.916

jp UJO6J bL6q1c12 1J191 rieri,A J9M2 MIJJ p6 2p c46L MJJ6IJ M69J1J1 Iu6dngJilA

p6 0261 pA 1JJ6 J02262 IJJ6A 9C6 111 9 J6226U6 9p1flA 10 pOI.LoM

61921JC' qJ6IJ WTICJJ 0 1J16 9JIJ2 10 1JJ6 booi LLOW J0M6LJJJ 1JJ6 IJ.J16L621 1.916 MI!!

0LL0M MJJ6II l:116A L6C6!A6 lJ69A6 111C0UJ6 2JJ0CJ2 IT. 1J16 aribbjA o J09U2 !2JI1 C9262 MJJGL6 IUCOUJ6 2JJ0CJ2 91.6 COWbJ6I6JA b6Lw9u6ul 961J12 Mi!! IJOI

2JJOCJ( fO J0IJ 111!! M69J1JJ' 9IJ () ijJ6 nbbjA 0 JO9JJ2 10 6 L6J9lA6JX 1116J9211C

cj U) iUCOIJJ6 2JJOCJ(2 110110 6 COWbJ6f6JA b6Lw9zJ6u1 Pfll 10 2JJ L6bL626111 9

rwbGLtGc1) 2fl211fl16 OL C01JJbJ616 COJJIiI161J1 W9LJ(612 E6U1911X M6 I166

O uJOq6J JA62 couqi1oIJ2 nuq6J. MJJCJJ (I2FILA J9M2 C911 9C1 92 911 (sqImu6qJA

booP61M6611 62 O 1191111.6 MJJ6II IJJ6A 91.6 LICJJ fO 219162 0 1191111.6 MJJ6IJ 1JJ6A 91.6

119L9I1166i1J 11191 71116L621 1.9162 M!JJ 6 JOM' 96U12 L6qi2lLiprll6 !11C0W69L1qICT9JJA JOM !1J16L621 1.9162 C9IJ 9J20 26LA6 10 1L9112L6L 111C0W6

!2 !11t692!pJ6 (b6L119b2 6C9fl26 0 7Uj0LW9110119J 01. IUC6IJI1A6 bLopJ6w2)'

cou1!1J61J1 nbou p6Iu 111 i6 21916 O pou.oMw 01. J6uqrIJ i q!L6q p9u6i.1116 6A6111 13191 6 !2 J6uqu V6I112 MorlJq fl1 1)1.6161. 911 IIICOU.J6 11.91.12161.

poLL0M!1J M7JJ 6 yJJ6L 1J1911 1JJ6 W9LII19J 111U!IA 0 IIICOW6 10 911 96I11 !IJ

P0LL0M!I1 1116 UJ9thI19J rIf!J!IA 0 !IJCOIIJ6 0 91.1 96I11 !1J 1P6 6A6111 1P91 116 !2

L0UJ 16 219162 01 119f.ITL6 MJJ6U IJJ6A 91.6 J61J1U 10 1316 219162 MJJ6IJ 1J16A 91.6

J6IJqrn MJJ6U 1JJ6!L !IJCOIJJ6 !2 J1JJ' 96IJ12 MorlJq JflC6 10 L6qi2I1pnr6 !IICOIIJ6

I1JC6 96lJ12 IdIOM 1Y91 (J16A MIII 6 p0L1.0M!II MJJ6II W6TL JIJCOW6 72 JOM 91J

IPGJL JI1CJU6L u6ppoLa

UC0W6 2pOCJ(2 V61J12 C9U oiijA LG2bouq 10 pq 2JJOCJ(2 pA 0LL0MU 11.0W

1JJL0r1JJ cL6q71 u.r9LJc612 (o 1VL0JJ ecTrq6uc 29AU2) 99U2f 1JJ626 U691M6!11C0W6 2JJOCJ(2 Jj1626 96I112 91.6 922f1IJJ6 10 6 fluJ9J6 10 1112111.6 13J6W26JA62

20C79J !11211L9UC6 JIl 1J16 WOq6J 9g61112 91.6 9C6 MJIJJ I6IIJbOL9LA' q02AJJcL91c

O' 1JJ06J 0 f12111A J9M2 GXbJ9!112 111626 L6flJ9IOIJ2 92 9 BL!W!1!A6 W69112 ot

Page 6: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

2

OLIGIJ 111 pIIUNIJ pJ0LX2np2GdnGuI MOLJC MiII qo GUGL )op GxbJ!u!u MpX COWUJGLCG iij p 6U cjcq 20MG Lxuq Ufl-C0UJW6LCJSJ!2W WJICJJ JJ9LqGL 10 L0UJJ!SG 1JJU S12I1LA jM2 H0lL0!JX

IT2ITLX•

Hoj9IJq 91Jq M16Lj9uq C9f126 1J16!L 2OC!G162 10 qLob 1p6!L LG2IL!cl!0112 011

IJJ9I 6C91J0W!C LOM1J1 (sIJq 1J16 J6226IJTIJ o bojcj boMGL tOL p0LL0M6L2) !11

JOO2GIJGq III 1JJ6 b021 IJJ6qJGA9J bGLloq E0II0M!U j9MUGA (J5Q)' MG 9Lf16

9C!162 M6 9J20 J00 91 1J16 b6Loq M6L6 IT2J1LA J9M2 M6L6 L691J?I1f6L6216q !U rI2rILA eb6c!!c9JJX IJJGU l:JJ6? 9L6 !U 9U9C1(HJ 1! COWWGLC!91

(1,1910 iiq y142101J6 W9UJJA) M6M2 011 fl2flLA 1116 bJJflo2obp6L2 9L6 WfTCJJ J622

266W i:o 6 11JOlA96 92 !IJCOIIJ6 2W00cJJ!1J.' 9L6 cowb9L6q M11J1 IJJG OCL9C21LG2fLICfIOIJ2 92 bum TAG 20C19J 111211L9JJC6 JjJ6 16M12P !9M2 011 n2IILX' MJJJCJJ

B!P1!C91 0L!I12 0 (i2flL) J91A2 21LOUJX 2nbboLl OfIL UJ06J 0 1h116L621 L916

LG2L1Cf101J2 266111 9f 16921 10 COIJUUJJ IJJG p921C L6J6A91JC6 0 JJ6 uJoqGJ jjJ6

GA0J1T10U 0 IJJG WpJ!C91 fO j9Jwnq1c LG2IL!cl:!0112 011 II2rILA uq ijuq 11J91 111626

MG 9J20 bL626u1 q2cn22ou2 0 rI2nLA J9M2 III p!2I0LA M6 q!2c 1J16

bL6qc16q)' P!T1 JJ2 COLL6I9I!OU 12 6XIL6WGJX MG9JC

L0M1JJ L9f6 12 bO2II1A6JX C0LL6J91G MIIJJ J0026L FI2rILX J9M2 (991u 92

C0JJ1L01JW tOL 9 CU16 W69211L6 0 bojpcj boMGL 0 JJ6 booL JjJ6 i1If1L6OIl 11116L621 L9162 (92 bL&pcl6q pA 1116 moq6j) JJJ!2 6U6C1 COIJ1I1fl62 6A611 MJ16U

IJJSI' 6A611 JJ0JqpJ w6q1911 IIICOW6 C011219111' b0A6LIA JL69262 IJJ6 L621L!cfl0U2

Pill ojq 6U0ilJJ 20 11J91 !1116L621 L9IG L62ILJCI!0U2 M6L6 21!!! p!IJq!1J MG uq

iO (9 916 CJJ02611 6C9f126 !1 !2 UJ0GLU 61J01lJJ 0L L6J19pj6 q919 coJJGCqoIiMG 1621 1J5626 COWb9L9I!A6 2191!C2 M!11J j919 011 fl !1116L621 L9f6 J9M2 L0W

J9M2 M6L6 b9LlicnJ9qA jijr111A621W6111 uq 1JJ112 16 W9L1IJ9J 20C!9J C021 0 JIJAG2IUJGIJI 1021 f16 10 n2rn.A

L0M 6A611 21L01J6L q' qriLiu pTJJ LOM1 b6uoqe' f6 W9L!IJ9J LGfIILII2 10OIl 16 L0M1JJ L9f6 6A611 III 9 braG GU0MWGI11 6COUOWA JJJ!2 6U6C1 MonJq

9L6 UJOLG boMGqrTJ 111 20C6fA f9U pOLLOMGL2 MG ruq 1116 cowb9L9l!A6 2191!C

12 pT}16L' (5) MJJ6U !11C0m6 2J10CJ(2 9L6 1110L6 bGLw9uGul 9IJ ()MJJGII J61J6L2

Page 7: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

2OCiGG2LS62' MJJICJJ W1p JJGJb 6XbJVU MJJA O 12 S bSL(ICfIJSLJX COZJJWOIJ 11J16L621 L96 SCJO22fl 21OL9G GxJ2tGq !U tIJ!2 GCOIJOUIX tJJGIJ MOnJq pG IIJG JOMGL pornq 1J151 Gx2tGq 011 !UL1(OLWSJ1SP0II I2 10 OlIL yuoMGqG 11GM tO tJJG J1t6LSP1LGlIJbuJcpou2 SSJ1J2t W16LG2t I12PJGq fG2G LG2I4CIO1J2 MHJJ W2flLSUCG-24X16 SLgJ1WGIJ(2 JJJ62JJJG lqGs 1JS Zi2flL) LG2P4C10U2 bLOAIq6 2OCSJ IU2ZILSUCG SL LIDW 11GM — 1JJG OLUSJ 11JOI.SJ

96IJ12 MflJ L6C6th6 CI J)OOL 6iJ12 !IJ 1J16 26C0U b6qoq MflJ L6C61A6 CU- I)

I0J 26C0IJ b6L7Oq M6J Ot 1JJ6 6COJJOWA MJJJ 6 C51 9Lrq 1JJ6 M6JqJ?11J6 M6JfJ1A 6Uf2 12 JjJ6 UL21 b6L0q GUqOMW6IJl 0 1J16 booL 6U12 rrq 1J56 OflJ6L JJYJ O 1JJ6 bobrq9Iou 11booL1, Jj16 Ulel b6uoq 6U0MUJ6UI 01JJ626 2JJ0CJC2 SJC6 1JJ6 0UJJ O W9JU1J 0116-11911 O IJJ6 bobn19polj 4M691l:1JA,,

ouj? 2JJOCJ(2 10 IJJ!2 6COIIOIJJA 9L6 L6A69J6 0 961J12 !11 IJJ6 UL2I b6Loq M6 J61

M6911J1 0 316 6COIJODJX 10 0116 JjJ6L6 12 ItO 9L6916 WJC6LI9JUIX 9u1 1116

M6 M1JJ 110LW9J1S6 1J16 21S6 0 1}J6 bobrqou 10 0116 uq IJJG UL2I b6iioq

uq bGL!2p 6U12 W9XWSG S I4IJJ6-26b9L9pJ6 COUCSAG (1j!IA rrucpoirb6Loq IM0 96I12 L6bSA 1JJ6L JOSIJ2' COIJ2rnJJ6 1JJ6 LGUJSIUq6L 0 IJJ6IL !1JC0W62

SJJOM 210LS6 OL siX 01J16L 0LW 0 bjJAe!cSJ 1IJi621W6I11 !U 1P!2 6C0IJ01JJX iz

L62b011q 10 fl5626 2JJOCJ(2 pA C0I2ffl1JIJ pOLL0MrIJ siiq J6IJqnJ M6 MJJJ 1101

OU6 2JJ0CJC2 10 uqAqn9J1e 6LJOMW6IJ1 !IJCOW6 9L6 L6A69J6g V6IJ12L916 !2 261 pA IJJ6 C0IUIJJflIIIIA 10 W9XJWI6 GxbGcrGq eOqSJ M6J1,9L6 111 b6LIoq

111 bSLICnJSL' MG 922flU16 S IJJLGG b6LIOq WO6J lIt IJJ6 b6uoq S6L0' 16 11116L621

pA 1116 L66 IJJSLJ(61

20q9J I12flL91JC6 sxiq MJIJJ 1JJ6 2If1Sf401J MJJ6L6 1JJ6 !1J16L621 L916 12 qGI6LUJIIJ6g

Mijj cowbSL6 111!2 bojicA W21L11W6111 MJIJJ 1jJ6 44UL21 p621,. 2!1fl90I1 ot couJbj6I6

bojicA preI:u1w6u1 !2 1JJ6 2f916-W911q916q wgxiwriw W16L621 L916 r'916L M6

CfI2jJ1OII2 201116 0 1JJ6 6Uq0MIJ16UI LI2J( VI UL21' M6 922111116 11191 1jJ6 2!ue16

B1T2 JOM L916 qi2ILpn16e !UC0W6 L0W 16 0LP1U916 10 16 1IU0L111I1916 suq

116911A6 !UCOWG 2JJOCJC2 MIJJ LGC6IA6 J09U2 S j622 1JJSU 16 tL66 WSLJ(61 L916

pA 20C!61A !2 6J0M 1116 L66 WSLJ(61 L916 20 191 L1qAq119J2 MJJO L6C61A6

11116L621 L916 60L6 6IJ0MI1J6IJ1 2JJ0CJc2 9L6 L6A69j6q JjJ6 !1J16L621 L9f6 q621L6q

bLoAiqG 9 0LW 0 20q9j 11J21119UC62 JI1 1jJ!2 woqGj uqyqqrzSj2 9L66 10 9 IX6jjJ12 26C110U bLG2Guf2 9 1U06j 0 112IILA LG2IL!C1!01J2 M6LG II2IILX L62111C1!01J2

ii yoqj

Page 8: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

1f091J JJ9L1U 9CL022 bOOL6Z. GUf2 i o conz' obpwii w woqGJWOA6 ID 1}JG ObbO2IpG q!LGCpOIJ2

210b62 LG IJOU-PJAJ1 2 JJGIL L6 2IIJq1C91 LGIOU2 °L b9LfliJG1GL A911162 LOL MJJICJJ fJJG 2J0b62LG ijq 2f1bbJ? 0 09II LIG2 MIJJ 1JJ6 Iu6LG21 L16 BOIJJ °L JJG2G 92flWbI4OU2 O( JJG

MG MJJJ G g2flw!ue fJ1IOflJJOflt 4J1G blbGL J94 IJiG GUJ9If LOL J0gU2 9JJ2 MIIJJ JG JU16LG1

() aU-V r fl(Cb1 (cbY

UL21 0L6L couqrou Wnei jiojq OL J6 booL6L GIJ12 92 M6JJ' oi.:

oCC92!OM9J!' MG MflJ COIJ2q6L W9LJ(61 Cj69LJ 6dn!j!pMrIur Ju jJ C926

booL6L 96iJl2q16 bOOL MG 922f1W6 J9f JJ626 J09112 9L6 IJJ6JJ 9JJOC96 6drl9JJX 9CL022 JJ6

jou 2nbbJA 6dn9iou 9JM9X2 !A62 (12 fJJ6 fO9J 9W0flU1 O J09U2 9A9J9J6 10COIIThhIffU1A M6 922flTJJ6 fJJ9I 1JJ6L6 12 MO CO6LCJOIJ O J6 M69JqIA 20 IJJ9I IJJ!2

rrnc1ou j'Q) MjJCJJ 616UuW62 IJJ6 9CW9J dn9u!iX O J091J2 arrbbJGq !' 16M6 922flW6 fJJ1 luG 26COIJCj OL6L coiiqoie jiojq 20 6dr191!OU (5) AG2 (12

(5) n1(i'-r')=ti�n1 OL fl(CM'

MjccjJ pe 11L21 oLqGI. couqipou:

(Ti) n(i'-r)+trn(ci+i�r)

96UI2 drrupX o J6uqu ! 6f6LUflU6 pX UJ9xrnJT.!Ir:j09112 12 616LWM6 p? 1JJ6 M!JJ!UIJ622 O 1JJ6 LICJJ 10 jGuq JjJ6 MG9JIPA

J091J qmuq 12 L6916L IJJ9IJ J091J 2(1bbJA JIJ JJI C926 W6 9Ci9J drz9uiiiA oMJ16L6 1P6 !1J16L621 L916 C6!llU 12 6JOM W6 L66 W9L6l L916 uq' 11J112' MJJGL6

M69JIJJA 911q booL 96IJl21 COU2flUJbI!OIJ) MG M!JJ pG cou2qGLIJ 271119110112

WCL692!11 9JJq 2ILICIJA COIJC9AG !IJ !12 9L1TW6IJ1' MJJ6L6 !M'b (r2 n1q6x

MJJGL6 fl() !2 9 11JL66 PW62 COUIIUITOrI2JA qq6L6ur19pJ6 LI1UCIIOIJ 11J91 !2 2ILJCIIA

0) fl(C71)--Lri(C)'

O1JJ M69J1J1A 911q booz YGIJl2 UJ9X7UJ76:

IJJCLG92G 111 G7JJ6L I b9L9W616L C915 pG L66LL6 10 92 9U IUCLG92G 111 IIJ6d119J11A

MG M!!J G 922flW!U JJLOf1JJ0111 1JJ1 i'>i\s j5j\ 9uq JJ>J5' 20 1JJ91 91J

Page 9: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

8

(Q) [fl1(CM)-fl1(Cb) ]

L6MLII4GIJ 92:

11W62 J\5 ELOW (5)' -fl,(CM1)+J�tfl(CM5) wn2 6dfl9J 6LO' 20 () C9IJ 6

+r'(i�) [fl4(CM)-fl(Cb5)l() [fl1 (Cpik) +Jfl1 (CM3)fl(Cb

q6Lt9pAG 0 (2) qJ L62b6q o j '2:iTIJC10U' A' uq 2J59L62 9 COJJJWOIJ bL6GLL6q W9XIUJITUJ L916 0 !1116L621 JjJ6

L6A69J6q' GAGLA W6W6L O fJ16 comwriuiiX 2JJ9L62 9 COWUJOJJ 0P6C1!A6

SGLO rnc& L1J62 9L6 261 91 1JJ6 6JIJIIJJJ O 1J1J6' 60L6 9U? }I616L06U6J1X !e

MJJJCJJI2 1JJ6 GxbGclGq MGJj9LG 0 6A6LA L62q6u1 O IJJG C0UJIIImJfA 92 0 1!UJ6

(2) A2[fl(I1 -

GxbGclGq f1ffl1A:

20C19J bJ9IJ116L) MJJJ 261 J�' 1JJ6 J.U9XIIJJJ1W !1U6L621 L916' 10 W9X!11J1S6 1JJ6!L

ji, boq 6L0' M6 922JJ6 1JJI 96U12 u ljJ6 cowwwA (oL 1JJ6 6U6A0J6IJ1

9uq 1JJ91 1JJ6 dnuA 0 J09112 12 9JM9A2 b02!PA6

neraA J9M2 MJJ6L 16 booL J0911 10 1JJ6 LICJI' 20 MG MflJ 922flW6 11191 (4) pojq

0JJ0M2 L0IJJ >j 911q COIIC9AIIA jJJ6L6 !2 IJO 2oq9J III2f1L9JJC6 fIUC10IJ tOL

ye J0IJ 92 C=J' OL fl fl() 12 JJ0Wo6U60I12 0 SUA q6L66 1p61J 1J112 !iJ6dt191!IA

() fl1U-I1)\fl(i1) > fl.(e-Ci)\fl(CI)

j0IJ 92:19L1!IJ L0UJ 911 9f119LA b02!1!0U' 1116 UCJJ M1JJ 9JM9A2 J6IJ 10 16 booL 92

96I112 MJJj M9UI 10 2WOOIJJ C011211Wb1!0U p) P0LL0M!1J L0W L!CJJ 96U12

26C01J bGLloqe pA J67J1J 9b02pA6 ds-wzjpA lobooLGL 96IJ12 J'1J6MJ26 booLM6YJ1JJA 96IJf2 M!jJ M9111 O 2W001J1 couerrujbpou P61M6611 16 !L21 uqM6 M1JJ 922111116 JI91 1116 b9L9w616L2 9L6 2f1C 11191 91 L66 W9LI(61 !1116L621 L9162'

Page 10: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

6 ZJGPA6 LOL (p,) 10 6dU91 SGLO' MJJJCJJ 14 W112{ MJJGU (2) !2 UJ9X!WIGqV2 UJGIJPOUG G1L}iGL' f'(g) UGG UOf G bo 1/G H0M6AGL' 9LOI1U fjJG 2O9J obiuinw 11Jfl2f

MJJGL6 1JJ6 UCJJ j6uq bo2!pA6 dri9Iuc16e ro }J6 booL (!-6 CM5=CI5+J�F>C-CICOUC9A!1A 0j fl()' 6C91126 j55j \5 vJq M6 9L6 oujX 6X9W!U!U 1J16 irisouL6W91112 JJJJ2 6LW MJJJ 6 JJ69A6 i1IJ6L 9JJ C!LCIIUJ2f9UC62 LOW IJJG

() r(K)tII�( fl(CM5)- fl4(Cb5))'

couq cowbouGzJc °L (Q) OL:qo 1101 M9IJ 10 pOu.OM WOL6 IJJ9IJ 1116X 9A6 91 1JJ6 L66 W9LJ(61 L916 0IJJX 1116

1 11 Gdn!J!purml' IJJG booL COU2fIUJ6L2 9L6 7101 cL6qrl coIJe1L9u6q 9IJq 1JJGX

VI I6 W9L(6f-CJ69LiIJ 6drzrJrpLrrIw' fJJ6 IL2I COIJJbOIJ6UI 0 (Q) 6drnJJ2 S6L0

W9LJU9J 20C19J C021 0 19I L6qrTCI0u

fILIJJ6L L611Cf0IJ 111 1JJ6 m9xuJnw !IJI:6L621 L916 12 6X9C1J? 026l: pX 1JJ6iIJçGL62f L916 OCCITL2 M6U () 6d119J2 6LO !6 MJJ6U 1JJ6 20C!91 p6u6j11 0J 9

cou2rlwbIiou (fl1(CM)>fl1(Cb5)) 1JJJ2 616CI 12 q62L9pJ6 1116 20CJ9Jj? obf!w9111J16L621 L9162 !UC6 1J16 booL C1fJ6II2 JJ9A6 9 p1JJ6L W9LIIJ9J flIJJilX o111C0U16 LGqr2fLrpITIIou LOW IJJG LICJJ fO 11J6 booL 1P91 C011162 L0W JOM6L

P611GW O JoM6L!IJ !1U6L621 1916 W9X1W9 1P!2 26COIJCj IGLW LGUGCI2 IJJG

fl16 26C0JJq cowbou6uI !' (Q)' tr'(i�)[n(cM)-fl(cb)]' L6bL6261J12 1116 20C19J

pL2I 16LW O (Q1) 2 IJJG 20C19J C021 O L61TC11J 1JJ6 W IJJIIW !11161621 L916

O 1JJ6 7L2l: b6LJOq (fl(CL1)>J�fi1(C)Y 1P2 LGqJe pr'I!°JJ' c9bIrrLGq 111 IJJG916 CLGqII COIJ21L9I716q 9uq orijq J1J i:o 2Jfl1 HJCOIIJ6 L0W 1JJ6 26C0U bGLIoq

922ffWbIo1J' c4(K)>o) IJJ!2 L6q2ILpfl1-oU 12 rwq6e!L9pJ6 6C9f126 booL 96IJ12

p6C9r126 fJJG J6A6J O J09712 2rTbbJ6q 9JJ2 92 IJJG 11J16L621 1916 9JJ2 (92' pX

Crç1s67121 26COIJq buoq COIIarnJJbIIOIr 1J112 L6qJ2ILIpRIIOIJ C0W62 9Of7f

16q!2p4p1u1o11 LOW 16 bool Ii6U2 L21 bGLroq coLr2rruJbIrou 10 16 booLI6LW csbf.nL62 1116 9C1 11J91 JOM6LIU I6 wgxrwrrui !71161621 1916 C911262 9

orqq fiJ(6 fO OLLOM IJJOLG 19U 1J16A C911 91 IPG 11116L621 L916 W9XIUIIIUJ 1J!2

L9f6 (r'1(i�)>o)' 9U 92 J01J 92 1JJ6 111161621 L916 C6TJTU2 puq 20 I91 1116 bool

[fl(Cb1)-I�fl(Cb)]) boipi 92 J0L 92 J09U2 2nbbp6q 1126 MJ111 16 111161621wgxiwriui 071 1U6L62' 92 971 6COIJOWIC !1J16LbL6191!01J JJJG UL2I I6LUJ ((F 1Q�)

Ed1191!011 (Q)' IJJG qGLIA9IJA6 0 20C19J MGfl9LG M!IJJ LG2b6CI 10 t6 J69J

Page 11: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

To

flGIU couqpou LOL qJ2 9L6 1p1 I5J \5% I5J \5 9uq C 2 CJOG fO OIJGto 2 UJGUPOIJGq GYLJIGL' MG 9L6 G22GIJfIJfX 2f1WiIJ JJ1 f6 UCJJ M!Ji G JGuqIu O 1}JG bOOL

!If6L6 L91G p9 orqq G CJJUL6 !1 1JJG OLLOM6L pøq 9JJ flJ6 boJ!fcUJ boM6L

C021 12 JJ6 mouob2ouA OLLOM6L2 C02 O p0LLOM1II UIJq L6bL6261J12 1JJ6

JOUIJ M1JJ JJr1L J6 OLLOI6L pA co ou jj bL6-6xr1!u J09112 JJJ2p6CU126 C° y IUCOLbOLUI62 JJOM JJ1JJ6L TU6L62 L962 Oil f316 UWLIUUJ

JJ6 COU2ITW6L JJ92 O bA ou 9fl bL66XT2ITIJ 109u2 CO2 MIfi UJMUX2 J16 9OA6

b6LToq COu2rrwbfrou pr11 9J20 pGCUfl26 U JJJJJ6L !1J16L621 L016 L9!262 1JJ6 UWOffhJ

6CUfT26 IJJGA L9126 IJJG !1116L621 LU6 OIl JJ6 WULIJUj JOUII UIJCJ JOM6L ecouq(g+r\r1(g))fl(c) lu fJJUI CITLA6 JJ1JJ6L !IJ6L62 LU62 L9126 1JJ6 C021 p01pCOIJ2ITW6L 2CUJ6 pA qJG !UtGL62f L9f6 uq pA J09I1 6J9211C!fA (r6

y 1A62 1JJ6 W9LIIUJ rijiiA 01 1JJ6 26COIJq b6Loq WCOW6 IOL 11J6 booL6L

1uqq6L6IU p6cM6GII OLLOM1U Uuq J6IJqIJ

rou AUI1T6 TA62 JJ6 1L66 W9LJC61 flu6L621 L916 MJJ6LG JJ6 booL6L COIJ2fIWGL !2

12 LJ21IJ UIJq 6CUf126 C 2 19JJ!IJ 92 J09112 L126' JjJ6 IJ6L26COII 01 CO C 9IJ6XfLU J09IJ (r6 t?I�fl(Cb5)) 1JJ!2 tmJC!Oil L1262 MUJJ q16 1II16L62f L916 6C9fI26 J�

JjJ6 tnUCI!0U JU6J6 CO2 C M62 11J6 IJJULWUI C021 10 1JJ6 OLLOM6L 01 911

COIJ2ITIJJGL q6cJIJ62

JJ6 L!CJJ COJJ2IIUJ6L J6IJ2 I.150L6 Uuq JL2I b6Loq WULU9J (I1HIA 10L JJ6 booL6L

JJfl2 IITIJCI!OJJ 6CJjIJ62 MUJJ 1JJ6 !IJf6LG2I LUl6 6C9I26 92 1JJ6 11116L621 1916 L1262

A62 1JJ6 WUL!II9J rIPI!1A 01 UL2I JD6I4Oq !11C01156 IOL fJ56 bOOL6L C011211W6L

UJL6SqA rncoLboLUl6q !IIO 11J626 lflilCI!0U2 JjJ6 111UC1OI1 JU6J6 ['0911 AUI116

JJUAG L9bJJ6q WITh 1flilC!01 j6 M!JJ11JIJ622 1 f}16 L!CJI COIJ2JIUJGL O J611q !2

E1r1L6 T 2JJ0M2 fJ16 U2K 26f.flb IOL 911 6xbOIJ6UUJ IUIJUA IITUCf!0U H6L6 M6

JJ9c 1JJ6 bow. J6IJ6L2 conjq L6C61A6 u 111C0w6 g9IJ26L

20C19J obwriui MOnJq p o 26 1IJ6L621 L962 9OA6 1JJ6 1L66 UJULJ(6 L9f6 20

cOuqiou2 qrq 1101 pojq gjjq% IOL GxgwbJG 1J56 LIC}J MGL6 OLLOM6L2 1J16U IJJG

2JJOCJ(2 10 U6IJ12 M!p II691!A6 M6UJIJJ 2JJOCJ(2 !2 2OCJUJJA ob1w9J fl 1JJ626

12 21L!CIJA COUCUA6 20 11191 L6qr2fuprllTOu IL0W U6IJ12 M!IJJ boer1!J6 M69J1J5

!u6q6u12 01 1JI!2 1.621111 12 IPUI 16 Lcp6L 96IJ12 91.6 IJJ6 J6IJq6L2 Uuq IJJUI fl()

1LOIJJ pL1unJ 1316 111161.621 L916 6JOM 1JJ6 11.66 UJULJ(61 L9162 JjJ6 CLIIC!UJ

Kr'Cb)Io J6CUfI26 11J6L6 72 9 9W 11.0W L6qI2pJpcwOu' 13161.6 12 UJMUA2 U 9IJ

Page 12: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

IT

(I') WL1PGLWOL6 MJJGIJ couqJlJoU2 (J) (5) 9IJ () L6 W61 uq M6U (st)JJJ16L62 L916' 1J16U flJ6 obiiuij 7U16L621 L6 C67J7U ri rurcwJ 7uGdr1g1iA

16 1U16L621 L916 C6TJJh1 12 21iCT61JfJ? CJ026 10 1116 L66 LU9LJ(61 6dflhIJpLifIW

2rq6IJ1JX CJO2G fO 011G uq fl(X)O OL QC) C !2 2nq6u1JX CJ026 10 0116 uqrq 6!IJJ6L () n44(x) ! 211U7c161111A CJ026 io S6LO 0L JJ x)' 0. (P) c ieerthbJIGq pA 1JJ6 L!CJJ 9L6 I1OI1IJ691IA6 9Uq L126 1MW 1116 11116L621 L916 C6ll!U'

jou 92 (j) 2GCOIJ 0LJGL COIJfOU2 9L6 29126q' (5) J091J2

1oc021c11191 !I1C0Lb0L91T11 1116 L!CJJ2 rijiiX !IU0 C0212 W69U2 11191 C021 COIJJ62 CJ026L

10 IJIG IJJ9LTU9J IIIIJJIA 0 COU2fIUJb11OII 0L 1JJ6 booL 11112 CJO26IJiIJ 11169112—

6tI6Cf MOLJC2 pA L927IJ 6 IJJ9L1JSI ITçIjIA 0 COIJ2IIWbpOJJ LOL W6 LICJJ CJ026L

10 IIJqflCG 1116 M69JçJIX 10 J6U 20 16 111161621 L916 ff1121 L!26 JI! IJIG L9bJJ 1lI!2

I1J9LJ6f L96 0 !I116L621) 0L6 J1U69L 1711J11A I1UC1i0IJ2 1119J(6 !1 IIJOLG qqcnjC0W62 CJO26L fO C021 C C9f127IJ 1116 111161621 L916 10 1126 (16J9pA6 10 16 L66

IJJCL6926q 1116 J!IJG9LIIA 0 16 p92!C 11flI!IA r1UC1i0U II! 11191 U1TL6' C021 B

1101 6 bLoA6IJ J)A (12 0L 9 6I16L9J (IIIJIIA 1TI1C110Ii II! E1i1L6 5 M6 JJ9A6E!rIL6 5 2JJOM2 9 COWb9L PAG 219PC M1J!CIJ pojq w muX C9262 P1 MJJIqJ tujj

JJoJq2

f1I1CP0I1 !'J () WIT2 ff6911 11191 1116 111161621 1916 9JJ2 20 11191 1116 Gd(19J!IA 2gJJJ

Co1Jq1ou2 10 pojq)' b9L9mGlGL CJ19U6 C91T2!I1 911 ribM9lq 2JJ1 !U 1116

(Q) W0A62 0M1J MIIJJ 1116 !1116L621 1916 (92 LGdrnL6q 0L 26C0I1 0L6Lb919w6161 ajiqc ff0162 16 I1UC101J nI () tib 01 0M1i 2111C6 1116 (T1JCI0U 111

q6LIA9IJAG 0 6dfI9pOIJ (Q)• pi 6IJ6L9J M6 916 1U16L6216q III MJJ6IJJ6L 916 20C!9JJA OJ)11W9J 71116L621 1916 (fi2fl1A L621L!Cp0I1) 91u6q L0W 19JqIJ IJJGM6 bLoA6 1116 0JJ0M1U bLoboeIpou MJJICJJ !A6e 16 COWJ)9L911A6 21917C2 011

1916 Ot !1J16L621 11191 C9TJ 6 qGLiA6q pA 211.11b16 qfl6L6IJq9OU II! 1JJ6 9bb6IcqIx

[If j9C1 11J6L6 916 9120 9 19L161A 0 C0Wb9194iA6 21911C2 OIl JJ6 20C19JJA oblIw9J

W9LJ(61 C021 0 C9bT19J

9JM9X2 JIG 61MGGU 16 U.JOUOb2OUX OLL0M6L2 C021 0 C9b719J 911q IJJG L66

0LL0M6L 0 9 P1JJ6L IUIGLG2I L916 916 IIJCOLbOL9IGq Hi IJIG c021 co B M7JJ

72 16 IIJOIIOb2OIJA C021 0 C9bJI9J P111 !1 !2 LGf1C6 GC9fl2G 1J16 pGU6I12 10 1JJG

C021 B 12 1116 C021 11I1C110IJ rTeGq MJ1611 62PU11IJ 1G 20C19J obiuiriur C021 B

Page 13: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

'5

(c,) M616 u6Ir!pJ6 JJJG ecouq b9Ll o () ivrjj jj tinp 2Gcouq bGLIoq692161 o wj rjJ g22nwbfou 20 J6 CJJ9U62 !U UL2I 161W Oj

bGLioq W9L1U9J 111!I!IA O !UC0W6 JJJ91 66C1 OCCI1L2 OIJJA L9L6J)' 91Jq M6

J6uqIu 66C1 qowu9162 4JJ6 21L9!JJ1 !IJCOUJ6 IIIGdllgJIlA G6C1 OIl 26COIJ

9IJ 26COU bGuoq W9LIJ9J JIPJIO 0t !MC0W6 OL 1JJ6 bool C9U IJYLLOM ! 1IJ!2W0116A JJ16 b P6U66U JL21 b6Loq W9LIJ9J fII!IIIA O !1JC0W6 0L 1}16 bOOL

!1J6dfl9l! 111 IJJG 1UflL6 W69U2 f1J91 JJ6 M69JIJJA JJ9A6 J622 q62116 10 J6uq

M6 9J20 IJq 1J191 9J�\9I5O rluq6L 9!LJX 21LTIJ6IU coIJqou2 H!IJ61

L!26 92 IJJ!2 M1JJWIJ622 10 b9A L1262

L!262 JjJ6 tL66 W9LJ(61 !1U6L6 1916 uq 1J16 2oq9JJX obpw9j 111161621 L916 O1JJ

2GCOIJq bGLIoq 9JJ2 uq 92 1 9JJ2' 1J16 /MJJ1IJU622 10 bA 0L J09112 Ioq9X 9J20

J0M6L V L0M1JJ L962 1126' 1JJ6 IJJ9LJ1J9J fl11J11) O coIJ2nwbpoIl !U 1JJ6E1nLG 'f 2JJ0M2 1JJ9 9 JJTJJ6L LOM1P 1916 W9J(62 9JJ 0 1JJ6 C0212 0 p0LLOMJJJ

b6Loq 0L6 J6Uq!u 9J20 W691J2 1JJ91 r(I�) L!262LJCJJ II' IJJ6 26COIJq b6qoq iiq 1JJ6 W9LIJ9J fU!J!IA O 1JJ6 bool !" 1JJ6 26COIJq

!1J6d179J!1A A0L6 J6uqu M1q6152 1JJ6 P61M66U 1JJ6 W9LIU9J TI1J1A 0 J6

IJJG 1U1119J iU6df19J11I 66C Jj16 26COIfq 161W lU () t9JJ2 CJ69LJA

C0UJ110IJ2 II! 1JJ6 bLobo2!lou r19L9IJ166 IJJ9I 1JJ6 J6uqu 6R6C1 !2 J9L6L 1y9u

C9f1262 fl(Cb') JI rq n4(Cb) 10 L!26 20 !1 II9LLOM2 11J6 9b IJJGpr'1 1JJ6 19112 6C91T26 J6uqzJ 17262 MUJJ 1q9J IJ6dfl9I!1A — 111!2 611qJ1J1116d119J!1A f'622 IIJJPYJ GIJqOMUJ6IJI IOL 16 bool L9!262 (fl1(Cb')-D1�fl(Cb))'

6COUOUJA jJ16 11121 COWbOIJGIJI 0 (Q) O62 1101 IJJOA6 WIICJJ M1p !M1!9111169IJ2 1JJ91 1J16 111161621 1.916 C6!J11J 12 LJ271J Ill 1156 L0M1JJ 1916 01 1116

BIG COWb9L9pA6 2191:!C 9J�\9C5O (O1TIJCj oujA rlIJq6L 21L!IJ6U1 C0IJq10U2)

W9W1S90U bLopJGw2 J0M612 1jJ6 C0212 0 151JJ 111161621 19162 2!,CSU1JA

fIlljTlX 011156 booL) W69112 11191 UCOLbOL9lIJ 1156 M69j1jJA42 COIJC6LII2 11110 1jJ6

11512 JJ1gJJ6L W9L7IJ9J fl11p11 101 1156 M69j1jJ) (II! COWb9L!2OJJ 10 1jJ6 W9L1II9J

Cj026 10 1JJ6 W9L!IJ9J fll!J!IA 0 1156 bool V2 II! 1156 C926 01 jOM LI2J( ØA6L2IOIJ'

6L662 01 11111191 1U6d119j!1A WGSIJ 1JJ91 IJJG W9L!JJ9I IU!WA 011156 MG9JIJJA 12

E1r1L6 2JJ0M2 1P6 COWb9L9I!A6 2191IC OIl 1Uh1!9j TI16df19j11) L9bj1iC9jJ? ['OM

17262 MJIJJ 26CO1J bGLJoq !1J6d119j!1X

Ii�>i' 115611 1156 objwgj 711161621 1916 CG!j!I1 11262 M!IJJ 1156 LOM1JJ 1916 911(1

Page 14: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

IJJGIL JUCOIJJG 2JJ0CJ(2 20 rPI MG JNAG OUG bJGCG °L U OA6LJ9bbJU GIJGIiJli0U2 26pIb

MJJO IJOM pGX LG pou.0MGL2 OL JGUqGL2' uq XOIiU q1JGU2' M0 AG A61 0 GXbGUGUCGjjy!rGwPA6!A MG conjq IJnuJc o IJJG bobnjou puiG GL0 JuCOthou1J ojq C!1SGU2'

7IJ6L62 LfG

2JJ0CJ(2 4OM MG JJOM IJJç IJJGLG MIJJ 6 C0IIJTC MJIJJTU 20C16A Otk6L JJG

M6 922f111J6 1J191 IIJ6211LG 4 0 1J1G bobnjiiou JJA6 O26LA6 1JJ6!L !11C0W6

1156!L !JJCOUJ6 2J10CJC2' uq 1JJ026 MJJO JJ9A6 IJOI 026LA6 IJJ6!L IUCOW6 2J10cJc2

IIJ6 6L0 1JJ91 11J6L6 9L6 1M0 L011b2 0 C711S61J2 — JJO26 MJJ0 JJ9A6 0p26LJ6qH6L6 M6 IJCJ116 9 116M bobrijçou 9 f11uJ6 6L0 H6L6 M6 922i1W6 1JJ91 92 0

XX20 O .1 qtt7IJGdn9J7O

MTIJJ pIJJ 6L662 0 M69J1JJ !1J6d119I! PIU M!JJ !!f-1J6 bGLw9u6iU !IJCOWGqJebb69L IJJG W02 2I1JUGII TIJIGLG2I LG2J1!Cf!0U2 MIJJ OCCITL !" 6COIJOIJJ!62

ra ojjA b6Lw9u6u fJJGU JGuqu 9uq IJJ6 1126 O !11C0W6 L621L!C1!0112' M!JJ

IJJG LTCJJ 9GUI2I GUqOMWGUI2 2JJOCJC2 b6L2r1 bGqGcfJA fl IJJG flJCOUJ6 flJ6dI19J!D

JJ9AG 971 TIJC6IIfIA6 fO !IJAG2I flJ6JL 6IJ0MWGIJ1 1JJ91 IIJC6IJfA6 MIJJ q29bbG9L !

21L!1J6IJf fl 61JqoMw611l 2JJOCJ(2 qo IJOf L6b691 OA6L fpJJ6 j6 M69JJJA wcei

9J20 Li262' prU !71C0mG !IJ6dt19!! oiijX 9Cf2 O W9J(6 IT2IILA L621L!C1OU2 JJJOL6

11J6 6COIJOUJX L!262 11J6 9!IJ2 L0W L6q21LpncxJ 1pLor1JJ IUCOIJJ6 L62P4C1!0U2

jJ56 U6dr19J1A C0UUGC10U2 6JJ 112 1JJ9 92 IJJG 9W011U1 O 0A6L9J 7U6dr191!1A rn

6C01J011J162

!ITh62PJJ6Lr1 20 JJ6 20C!9J C02f2 O L62L!Cl!OIJ2 MonJq p6 JJ7JJ6L ! L0M!IJ1J5611 L0M!7J 6COIJOUJJ62 MonJq JJ9A6 1JJ6 JJJJ62f p6U61!12 ILOW bJJA2!c91

MJ56L6 LOMJJ 72 6uq06uon2' MJ56L6 UJOIJ6A M92 IJJ62r6q 111 bpXeicj c9b!19J'

IIJCOUJ6 tOL IJJG MG9JIJJA 171 1JJ6 26COIJq b6Loq JU LTJOL6 COUJbJ6X woqGJe'

J0M JU 1JJ72 woq6J 1JJ911 66Cl OCCIIL2 6C91126 0 9 JOMGL W9LJU9J r1I!1A o

W16L621 L916 L62fLICfJOIJ2 O p6 011JJ6L ! 29II9IJ1 GCOUOIJJ!62 MJJ6L6 L0Mrp !2

JJJ6LG 9L6 U91TL9J 7IIfGLbLGI9JOU2 O 1J1626 couJb9LgiA6 297C2 MG GXb6C

bGLIoq

JJG W9L!IJ9J IIfTJIIJG2 0 IIJCOU16 0L IJJG booL 911cJ IJJG MG9JIJJX JU flJG 2GCOJJq

q0wIJ9l62 1JJ6 bo2!cIG GGCI o ecouq bGLJoq 1UGdri9J!X ou JJG GM66UnJ6dn9pA 92 jou 92 16 U69l!/6 GU6CI o 26COU b6Loq IzJGdrl9JlIX ou J09712

Page 15: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

J'f

11J0L6 0t6IJ 9 brc O 20C19J 1U2nL9uC6

2OCT91 IIJ2rIL9UC6 111 f1W62 O JJTJJ mJC6L911JIA' 71I16L62 L96 L62P1C1T0112 Miff 6

L62L!CI!O7J2 fO GCOUJ6 11101.6 O 911 OITICOW6 O L6Ul266JI1 uq J622 9 LOUIS O

bL6qcpJ6' !6 92 IJJ6 LH1UJ6L O 1JJ6 zJoLw6q L!262 M6 6Xb6Cf 111161.621 L916

jj1J2 bloboe1pou 16Jj2 (12 1JJ91 92 2JJOCJ(2 iiq IIJCOUJ6 211.691112 6C01JJ6 IJJOL6

IIJf6LG2f 1916 C61JTU MTJJ UJOAG 9CJ( fOM9L2 112 obpiiigj 20(39J 1h12flL9UC6 L916

1T1J1JJ0LIIJ6 (01. UJOL6 pLo9qJA' 1JJ026 6Xb6CfI1 111C0W6 eJJocJce) L!262' 1J1611 1JJ6

LIOW !12 b6LL6CI 20C!91 111211191kG Lgg:6 \f2 1J16 Ifl1W6L 01. boj!14c91 bOM6L °L IJJG

1J1616 91.6 20W6 flJ0UU6 96I1l2' 1JJ6 111161621 L9f6 C6ff1U MJJ qA6L6 2J!JJ1JX

M911f T1Jf6L62f 19f6 C6!J!IJ2 (I) L6LFf266JCTU 9IJ (5) 20q9J !U29UC6 2 jOU 92TIff 6L62f11f JjJ6 II! friTfIOII 12 2rU1b1A 1J191 1JJ6L6 91.6 fMO 1.6920112 MpX 961112

011 IJJG U1UUGL (01. bojipcj B0M6L) °L IjJG 11JoL9IJf 91.6 2jpfA woi.1110A62 MJIJJ 1JJ6 bOflf!C91 bOMGL 0j OLL0MGL2 uq j611q612 JjJ6 261 °L L62ffJ12

JjJ6 tTL2f 26f 0j L62t1J12 916 L9ILJA iIJfII!14A6 9IJq f6JJ (12 (J.W1 1JJ6 IIJf6L62f 1016

2f9fC2 011 I:JJG IJ(1W6L 911q bojircj bOMGL °L 1JJ6 ?onii 91.6 LGAGL2Gq

1u0L9ul:) J0M6L2 IJJG 111f6162f L9f6 C6TJ1I1 J yM <yb' W61J 1JJ6 COUIb9L91IAG

!1J161621 19f6 C61JpJ IL yM>yb' 1J16I1 911 111CL6926 ! fJJG bOM6L °L 1J16 Xonu (01.

fJJ6If 911 111CL6926 111 fJJ6 boMGL 01 I11TW6L 0 fJJ6 Aonz (j-4) J0M6L2 fJJ6

M69JIJJA (1M ) 9IJ L9112 M!IIJ IJJG boicj bOM6L O 1316 1)001 (yb ) IL yM >yb'bk002l.t01 5 JJJG ObI!W9J 111161621 11262 M!IIJ 1316 bojipcj boMGL OL 1JJ6

jjqu cowb9L9pAG 2f9fC2 OR °L 13112 6dfl91!OIJ MG bLOAG ! 1J16 9bb6IJqx fJJSf:

(flflJ -

('L)

131626 J)91610 M6TJJf2 1JJ6 116M 20q9J bJ9I1IJ6L12 blopj6us 6COUJ62 fO WSx1UJ16:

yM' icq yb fO 1JJ6 rnJ7uoLw6q' M69J1]JA 9uq booi q136u2 L62b6C1!I6JX MIII'L6J911A6 M61JJf2 TA6I1 fO 1J1626 131166 LO(1b2 MG 9221U 1,91.610 M61JJf2 °L yrl'

LICJJ SIICJ 1JJ6 JIqOLuJ6q bool lI'6 J,9L610 bLopJ6w I10M q6bGLrq2 OIl 1JJ6IJJLGG L0fIb2 111 fI'6 bobrijpou: 1J16 (1111UOLW6q (01. 1J16 AO11U)' IJJG IULOLW6CJ

1JJ6 b162611c6 O 911 1IJoLuJ6q 26C1!OI1 °L 1J16 bobnj9c6 W691J2 IJJ9I 13161.6 91.6

Page 16: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

12

L126 92 M61J 1P626 COIJJb9L9pAG 29flC2 MOLJ OL JJ6 L66 UJ9LJ(61 !JJIGLG2I

16 obpwj !U1GL61 L916 o L!26 yOL6 LOM1 c12 obpw 11116L621 L916912G2 IJJG ObIJUJ9J JUIGLG2I 1916 fO 9JJ yOLG 2GCOU bGLIoq iu6drlgJilA C91262

JJJOAGWGIJI2 916 Ill IJJG LU9UUGL bLGq!ClGq 9p016 NOLG !'1!1!J !116d1191!IX

WOAG2 2TI1TT)C9IJ1JA M!IJJ CJJ9I162 !U b919w6161 A9Jf162 9ZJ 11)91 1JJ626

9r1f9LJ(X uq L66 W9L1(612 j9JG J9 9J20 2J10M2 1JJ1 1116 obiwj !1U6L621 1916

ID 1UCL6926 20C19J M6Jt9L6 UJOL6 11)911 2O 0 11)6 C1)219UC6 61MG6I1 COUJbJ6I6

J9pJ6 1 2JJOM2 11)6 1G6 W9LJ(61 J6uq11J 9uq Obf!W9J 11J16L621 19162 POIJJ 26LA6

bGqGcc 20C19J W2flL9UC6

LGG W9LJ61 p0LL0M!IJ uq j6uqiu' () 111161621 1916 L621L!Cfl0IJ2 9uq (f)(J) 9r119LJ (110 p0LL0M11J — MJJTCJJ 12 9JM9?2 r11J11A UOUU9JT6 10 S6L0) (5)

J111J6 9TIJ2 L0W JIW1111J 111161621 L9f62 M6 COU.Jb9L6 0f1L bo221pJ6 2C6119L102:

£9PJ6 J9' M6 C9U 266 JJ9 111616 916 GXcL6UJ6J) J9L6 91IJ2 1.0W LI2J( 2JJ9L1U Pf11

ffI1C0I1 12 1116 J09L!fJJUJ1C rrucpow fl2!U b9L9UJ616L A9Jt162 qocriwirq !'MG JrnA6 COU216L6 fMO flilfilA trnJclIoLr2 OL 1p12 Gx6LC!26: 11)6 1I21 flI!j!IA

1116 !L21 G2V

916 LG6 tLOUJ 11)626 IJJOL9J JJ9S9L 01 9A6L2G 2616C1!OU blopJ6uie) COUJ6 CJO2G 10

brabo26e MG 916 0IiJ) JI1cGL62fGq 111 MJ161J56L 111161621 1916 L621L!C10U2 (MJJIcJ1

9IJq UJOL9J JJ99Lq bLOpJ6UJ2 m9A U19J(6 11191 L!21( 2J19L!11 11J6921pJ6' PITI 0L 0(11

(J \5 9iJ (3\5) II! 6111)61 C926 MG p6JJ6A6 11)911116 219I19L SA6L26 26J6Cj0U1J16111261A62 99!I121 p6C0W1I1 M69JIJJA 01 booL 911q L6C6!A6 11)6 291116 !UC01716

bGqGcl L!21C 2JJ9LflJ W06j III 11)91 IJJoq6J' !" l!W6 6L0 96I1I2 bGq6cIJA 1112(116

M6 916 1I116L6216 111 coWb9L1JJ 111161621 1916 L621L!CPOJJ2 MIII! 9 1L21 P621

111161621 L9f6 L621L1Cf0U2 916 6H6C1!A6 111 6J1IIflU91!I1 JIJqIAiqn9J LI2JC

L62111C1701J2 916 911 III6UGCflAG UJ69U2 0 20C19J IIJ2IIL9UCG 92 M6JJ 92 9 C926 MJJGU

21911C2 MTIJJ 201116 ITI1CI0IJ9I 0LW2 uq 9J20 21)0M2 9 C926 MJ1G1I 11116L621 1916

6J1uJ!I19pI1 L12J( 10 1UMIfl9J2 jpr dnG2l!ou poj 2JJOM2 11)6 cowb9L9A6JA6IJ uA 1uqc91ou 9POfll 1)OM 1T26Lt1I 1U16L621 £916 LG2IL!C110112 916 !U

£9162 12 obpmj M1)GIJ OIJJGL 0LW2 0 42J( 2J19L1U qo 1101 GX!21 M6 JJ9A6 1101

L62ILICIJOIJ2 111016 1JJ0L0f1JJJX MPIJG M6 JJ9AG bLoAGu 11)91 1!W!11I1 !1116L621

111 11)12 2GCIJOLF MG LGITILU 10 11)6 p92!C iiioq&j 91J GX9WIIIG 11)6 A91fl6 °L 111161621

C0t20 £t%I cq 0CflS b01Ci\

Page 17: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

2612 0 LG2OII9j6 b919w6161 A9Jf162 1U161621 L916 162p.!CpoIJe 6JTWTUf6 111016

7219JJC6 P6IMGGJJ 1J16 1166 W911C61 6drnJJpL!rJw iiq 1JJ6 jJL21 p621 1IJJqGL 26I6L9J

W9LJ(61 7I1GL62f' JIJIGLG2f 1916 LG2IL!CPOJJ2 61!w71J916 IJJOLG IJJ9IJ 0 1156

1156 Obqm9J 111161621 1916 2!U111C9UI:JA iwbLoAG2 fJJ6 27!T91!OIJ 0E6L luG 1166

cowb9LA6 29fC2 9L66 MIW l026 JI! 1156 W06j HOM6A6L M6 266 JJ6L6 11591

J9pJ6 5p 2JJ0M2 1JJ6 L621TJ12 101 IJJ!2 bI6c6M!26 J11169L IITIICIIOW y9i1J l:J16

6J0M 5?) 9U () lJ.r9 1j56 bool P6IJ6UI 9 101110115 J0M61 115161621 19162

(I) 11591 1JJG LIcp wiiei: 1J6G o 29A6 (JJ6L6 fO 9Aoq coIJarrnJb11ou qLobb1s101 1156 LJCJJ IMO 169111162 916 116C6229LA 101 fI2TILTA J9M2 10 6 pIJJJ? 66q:1A6:

9 J9L6 q6L6UC6 pi 1J16 W9LI19J fIf!J!IA 01 !11C0U16 101 1156 bool uq !IJcow6C6119111 L91162 01 J6IJq11J (1156 6f921!c1A 12 6L0 pi m9u? bJ9c6y IJq (5) 115616 2

Low J6uqT1s bojicA r JJ9 (j) juqw dn9uijG2 916 19!LJX !1161921!C OA6L0 j6IJqiU 1156 16920112 MJJA 1JJ 11I!I!IA IfIUCI!011 X6Jq2 191g6 9!1JaM!J1 6 bo221p16 fO 261 1JJ6 111161621 1916 91 p\913 911q 21JJ JJ9A6 boe1p6 dn9ulj162coijerrwbçrois 01 1156 L!CJJ !2 115016 IJJ9IJ 5? P1 porp b6uoq2 HOM6A6L !t I< 11

jou 92 1156 coLr2rlWblToIJ o qm boor !2 j622 IJJSIJ 5? pi POll5 bGLIoq2 sisq 1J16

(1115q61. C6L9flJ b9L9w616L A9J1T62) 1116 1166 W9LJC6I 1916 01 711161621 Mflj 6 J\ 9

MJJICJJ rI2flLA 162111C1101J2 916 61PC16151 2ocij bopck MIllS 11J12 IWJJIX 1f115C1101J

COIJC9A!IA 11110 f]56 IT1!j!IA trIUCIjOU' p111 9JJ0M2 (12 fO 2JJOM colJqp!oIJ2 IIIJCj6L

M7115 9 9U p L69f6L 115911 S6L0 11512 b!6c6!26 J!1169L lfIIICl!OU !IICjITC62 201116

(�) fl(X)=+PYPU[X-S' 0]'

triucpoxj biGcGMJ2G 1515691:

ooq 20C!9J bojicA' MG cOIJ2iq6L 9 26COIJq ITI!JTIA 1C1!0U 1156 26C0I1 ii11j11A

10 2J10M 11591 115616 916 C0U7P0IJ2 flhJ6L MpICp 111161621 1916 L62114C1!01J2 916

011 j6U15J 20 11591 115161621 1916 162111C110112 9CCOWb152JJ j622 101 20C!91 M6R9L6

12 UJ115112 0116) V116115b12 fO 9LfJlIa9IJX J0M61 1156 111161621 1916 drzicjqX CJJOJ(6

flllI!IA' J6uqi1J 12 15JJJJA 26112!f!A6 10 CJJ9IJ62 Ill 1156 111161621 1916 (1156 6J9211C!IA

C926 OCCITL2 6C9ff26 011156 I09L1fJJW!C IT1!171A 11C1I011 M'fl' J09L7cJJWjC

j156 19711116 01111161621 L9f6 L621L1C110112 10 CL6916 U1ITC15 20C19J iU2f1L9I1C6 111 IJJ!2

IJJOAG 20C19J M6119L6 9IJXMJJGL6 11691 1156 U121 p621

1916 92 M6JJ H0M6A61' U616L 062 1156 711161621 1916 L62ILICIIOU W9U96 10

Page 18: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

JJ9 110 0116 MJJJ JO9U 9f JJ6 JOM6I. L916 fO COU2IIIIIGL2 (GxcGbI fJJ6LG 2 6911JfflJf6LG2f L916 L62fLJCf!0112 MJJ6L6 bLolGcf J091J2 OCCIIL 9f 9 p!p6L L9f6 M!JJ 1116911

brq 011 11GM bLOlGCf2 cp6w26JA62 J-jOMGA6L' 9LrA YUGWb fO J191k6 fMO fI6LGCj

M!JJ 6 JJffl6 20C19J M6Jj9L6 9TI12 LOW J!WiP1J fJJG !IJI6L621 L9162 IJJ9f C9IJ G

LG2fLL!Cf10112 MJJ6U J09112 YLG L6J9f6 fO 116M blol6cf JI19JJC!11 OP1!0t12IA fJJGL6

JJJ6L6 9L6 JJOM6A6L 201116 2JIJJbJ6 !UJbflC9f!01J2 O f}16 woqGJ OL !JJf6L62f L9f6

V LTCJJ6L fL69fW6Uf 0 L0MfJJ bLo16c 12 p6XoIJq ry 2cob6 0!, fJJI2 IlJOqGJ

cowwouj?MorIjq Gxb6cf fO 266 (92 MG 0) IIJfGL62f 19f6 L62fLICPOU2 0!, SGLO fO OCCITL

MJJGU 2f0L96 (!6 K1) !2 fJJG 0I1J) fGCJJIJ0J0A 0!, IJJ!2 jquq 9A9!J9pJ6' fJ1611 M6

MOf1J bLoIq6 9 U9ffIL9J !,jOOL fO f6 !11161621 L9f6 L621L1C11011 JI1 2C6119L102

woqGj I1C6 110 0116 orqq J6IJ !T fj16 !11f6162f L9f6 !,6JJ 6J0M K' fJJ!2 9UJOIIIJf

U12f b6Loq o p6 1110q6J fO K (1I1!f2 0!, OlifbrIf U fJJ6 26COIJq b6Loq o p69jj 961J12 9CC622 fO 9 f6CJJI10J0A fJ591 fL9I12!,0LI11G 0116 r1U1 0!, OtIfbrIf !U fJ16

VUOI!16L 2TIIIbJG 6xf61121011 fO I 6 woqGJ' 9JjflqGq fO 9p0A6' orijq 6 fO A6

-- ow c°w

!,L6dFI6UIJA G !,9L !,LOW 1JJ6 2OCT91 obçiwnur

9bb69J!JJ HI bGL1oq2 0!, JJ1JJJX A0I9fJ6 !11u91!ou' 211JC6 flJ626 C6ffl1J2 MIJJ

1150A6 14Ip !11U91!011 1x6q UOIIJTII9J HJf6L62f L9f6 C6!I!JJ2 M1JJ 6C0I1J6 J622

LOL 1J16 !,!L21 62f fO 6 w9ruf9IJ6q' 1JJ6 I10U.1!119J IUfGL62f 1916 C6!J!1J W112f

L9f 6 12 WOMJJ !,LOW 1f2 !,IL2f 62f L9f6' 111 fJJ6 2OCISJJX COU2fL9IJ6q obl.!wnur

W6L62f L916 C67J!11 I!, fJJ6A go CJJ9IJ6 fJJ!2 C6fl!JJ !' bL9cc6' fJJ6II 1JJ6 !IJf6LG21

91Jq fO 110f6 1J191 CJJ9U62 !U 16 1UU91!0U 19f6 eJJOzTjq JJOf 9!,!,6C1 1JJ6 L69J

I10W1U9J IIIfGLG2f L916 C61J1U !2 fO 1IJ0LG 11 O16L WOII6f9LA bJJ6uow6uou

2111Jb162f M9X fO IIICOLbOL9I6 11JU911011 lIlfO IJJG uJoqGJ uq fO 1J!'J 9Oflf 1JJ6

J1!210L!C9J !111619C1!011 6fM66L1 11111911011 9Lrq !11f61621 L9f6 C6!J!1J2 JjJ6q12Cr1226q JJ6LGIII JJ9A6 6GU 169J N0M6I6L' 11 12 OpAJOII2 f9f 1J161.6 12 9 W90L

JjJ6L6 92 66U 110 qeCri22Jou 0!, IJU91OU 111 fJJ!2 UJ06J P6C9fl26 1! A9j1162

X12%O '4 --

LI2J( 2JJ9LIIJ 20C19J MGJ!,9L6

1J1911 2O 0!, 1JJ6 qJ2I9IJCG 61M66IJ IJJG 91119LJ(A 2oq9J MGJ!,9L6 911q fJ16 UL2I 62f

Page 19: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

iiiviX uA J09U216M6L nubrq uuc OL qJ6 cou,ujnuiX rpu pGfl6L ou qGu2' IPGU f6 2if6 urnX M9U1 o puJjJZ2 AbG OL GXfLGWG 12 UO1 IJGCG22z)' II pjjA iuqGprGq' 01. bOOL 9GZJ2' 2!WbJA bGI.LouLJ

cowbJ6G 69flJv UJOLG COUJblGfG woqGJ MorlJq IJ0M L°1. J6 bLfJ q6flJ1 4P1 !2 L9L UJOLG COWWOU IJ

2GcoIJq tIUCP0IJ 0 IJ16L621 L916 L621L!C1-OU2

2 IJJ6X 9L6 wq6 JJ112 GJIW!II91OII 0 JJ7JJ L!21( J09112 W9A 6obb!u JJTJJ L12JC J0U2 j626 U2J(A J09112 go II0$ !IJCOLbOL9I6 1JJ6 20C19J C02f2

uqAqrIJ2 6COW6 ML2 o 1JIG 216J3 IJJGU IJJG 2I96 J192 U !J16161 II!0CCf1LUIJ fl q61,9nJ1 92 20c19J C0212 61JJ6L !U COI1LI C0212 OL 6C9fl26 p9xJIcLnbl

IgIG L62JCnOU2 wX bj g 26COU rmclou o 21obb!IJ pp LI2J J091J2 LOWI-10M6A6L' MJJGII W6L6 72 q6I7J1 JJ2 y616L06U674A CL022 nrq7A7qr1J2' IIJl6L62

L16 L62P4C1!0U2 WOL6 J!J(GJA 10 2lob JGUU

J(661) 11J6 291116 drzujiA O JO91J25 J-1TJJJA LI2J(A 6IJATLOIJIJJ6IJI2 IJJ9J(6 11116L621

0 1JJ6 LICJJ 10 J6U MIII 9JJ 9JJq 1JJ6 !1J16L621 L916 L62fL!ClO1J2 M!JJ J19A6 10 L!26 10

2OW61W62 OLLOM6L2 a!uJJDJA go zjo LGb9A 911A o W6IL J091J2' 1J16 M7fJwLr6a2

9JM9X2 L6COJJGCI IJJ6IL IO' JI! fl16 bL6uc6 O q69nJ1 L!21( 0 1JJ6 OLW IJJØI

M6 JJ9A6 20 9L UOL6 IJJ6 !22116 O q6SflJ1 L!2J( SIJq 922i1IJJ6 1JJ91 JGU6L2 C9IJ

12OU C --

216UJIJJ7II 11116L621 L9162

9 L6946L 20C19J C02f (cowIu ILOW IJ6J6Cf6 JJ6M bLo6cf6q) o 9L1!c!9JJAIJ6M bLOI6CI 1J9uaIJ' 16 !U16L621 L9f6 L621L!C1!0U MJJJ 6 P!P6L 2IIJCG IJJGL6 !2

L62J1!C0II M7JJ JJ9A6 fO 6X121 JjJ6 oi,jX C9U6 MJJJ p6 1JJ91 II! 1JJ6 bL626uc6 OL12J( 266 p6JoM) V2 9 L62i1f1 !1J W9IJA 2!1I191I0U2 9 2IIJJ6 11116L621 1916

Page 20: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

J2JJ'12 qGflJ1 L9fG 9JU 922flWG2 C0J1IJ16413C1IIflX 1P9 I.G JyJ o IPG J09U2

!1G qG(flJ1 U2J 12 UG6G 10 W9J(G Q puqiu JIJIGLG2I LiG

q6r1Jc L!21( 12 oAGL J2 jjne q61,9ffJf L96 () 12 9bbLox1wGJX JJ6bGLcGuf !IJ6LG2f L9G C9b M!JJ 61!JIJ!IJ9f6 u? juqiii O OLLOM6L2 MJJ0262fIJJ 2W9JJ) J MG f9J6 92 JJ6 L12y L66 CO2 O C9b!9J' JJ!2 UJ69112 9 21X

comb9u2ou j9J6 5 2J10M2 JJO2G L962 IU JJ iiq 2JJ0M2 1JJ91 oq9A ip b ib6Loq j6 COUJWGLCT9J b9b6L L96 M92 T2 qflL!1J 11J91 A69L (yeJô2O 11J6 ILG92ULX p11j L916 M92 J5J MJJICJJ M92 9 b66q L916 qr1LU P91I ! MOLcJJMJJTJG C0U21q6L1U JJOM 2ILIUgGJJI 1JJ626 L916 LGCILICPOIJ2 MGLG 11

flJ6 fl2r1L) L6211!CPOU

J6 cowb9L9rA6 2I91C2 LOW WG bL6A!Oi12 26C1!O1J bL6q1c 11J6 W0A6W6IJ2 !U

69J O A9U91!0IJ 11.1 JJ626 !1U6L621 L9162 9CL022 UI fJJ2 26C1!OU MG 266 fl

2661112 fJJ9I fJJ626 L9f62 MGLG pruqIJJ UI W911A C92621 1I1CG IJJGLG 12 9

bGL W01J1JJ L96 2f16216 JU fJJ6 29G JornJq9loU L6COww6uq91OU 91J !f61J6L9J1X L0W 10 J5 jJJ62G 19162 MGL6 2!I1!!C9IJ1JA 6JOM 1JJ6 J \sIJJSI 1JJ6 IJJ9XIWIIUI 11116L621 1916 9JJ0M6 (W6L 1JJ6 J9M2 q6L6q 9CL022 219162

A6LCJOIJ2 0 JJ2 J9M EOL 0111 bf1Lb0262 J6 !U16LG211IJ bI3 0j IJJG 9q0b10U !2

f0911 f9M 0 JJ 11112 J9M L6g1iA 1161JC6q 9J11JO21 11 219162 MJJ!CJJSqoblGq

HOM6A6L' W02f C0112(TUJ6L tIIJ9IIC6 L6f1J9P0I1 12 926 011 IJJG flIJ0LW 2W9J1

COUC11W6L UIJ9IJC6 (91rq' I1 j9C1' woci: rIC11LA J9M2) 916 ML16I1 p? 1JJ6 2i:9162

J6IJI1 L6J1J91!01J2 0p20J6i:6

p6j016 i:1J6 1JJ9UC!9J 1jIu0Aglou2 o y6 je qJ9 wq6 wiiA COIJ2fIW6L

916 12 1916 6U01TJJ 10 JJ9A6 ooq q9i: 9A9fl9p111i:X 9Uq 69LJ? 6U0S1JJ 20 1 12

1JJ91 W9J(62 1111:6121916 cowb9ueoue 692A M6 p916 JOOJ(6 91 iO 6C9fl26 11191:

0LGUi:6q J6uqw 91JCJ (5) COIJ2ITUJ6L 1U9UC6 J9M2 JJSAG 9 nU0LW1A 10 1116W

(J) 0111 1JJ6OLX COUC6LIJ2 couemjjbioii 926 011 J6uq1u oujA uoç bloqncqoU

16 1ô202 JjJ6L6 916 IMO buw9LA 16920112 tOL 11112 q6C210U (2Jc61:cp6q spoA6):

1UA62119p0I1 10 J00JU1J 9CL022 219162 91: J9M2 9U6Ci:11J COIJCI1IJJGL 1IJ9UC1U !U

uq MIqG L9UG 0j L111911C791 1L91129C1:10U2 M6 JJ9A6 L62i:LlcfGq 0111eigiiiicgii1jA OA6L 1:!WG IJq 2b9C6 JJJ6 fl 92 1621L7c1:Gq (9zJq q062 L621L!C1)

fl2IILX J9M2 JJ9AG 9 J0U JJJC1OLX III IJJG nuIl6q 19162 uq JJ9AG A9LI6q

Ill EA1IC6 LOW fl O11IJI }1JSI1CG JM2 11 J1J

Page 21: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

50

JIJCOUJG !ZJ JO Df 9/PP!!!1X L6dfl!LGq 1PJ COUJptU4OWQIIL mcowG gp qIGLGucG qiG jo o wqiu IJCow6 !u jØ 9uq bi. cibr

pni p6 bOWI G2UJ962 MGL6 619PA61?t COu291fl'

jD0th!1 O26 O6LA0U IJNG JJ6 dn9JppG I6LGLJCG 10 Offi. LGJ1II2 LG2OU tGJJ

W'- q6wocL92yJ6IJ6L2 (J�GbnpJIcSu2 JJSA6 JJ!20L!C91JA 66I! UJOL6 IJ16L62J6q II! JGIJq6L,e ipr.a

111692111.6 12 W69U1 0 CSbpTL6 bojiiicsj LOLC62 IJJSI W1JJ1 tSAOL 0LLOM6L2 OA6L

qqq IJJGS2fIL6 12 W691JJ JD CSbrfft6 q!6 L0lMJJ 1916 O !11C0m6 JjJ6 rJJLqW69211L62 9L6 WGSI!I fO CSbfIILG boA6LA OL IIJCOUJ6 ru6dngJIIA !U 1ô20 JjJ6

L0MrJJ T30-J20'j, suq () D6WOCLSI!C 0A6LII0L2JJb !' Th20 fl16 !L2 1M0

!U 2ITp2JSiJqSLq JJ0112TU II! J' (5) W6q191J X69L2 0 2CJJ0OJ!JJ (3)T30 WCOUJ6 ASLTSpJ62 O1Th bLrurni.A A9119pJ62 91.6 (i) o bobrqspoz JMflJi9L19pJ62 LOW OL 19161.) 01. L0W W6 219121!C9J 1p2P.9C1 0j IJJ6 fl 0LO OIJJ6L qss 0L IJJ!2 6X6LC126 COUJ6 LOW 1J16 COrIIJIA suq alA qsi pooj (oL

11116L621 1.916 111 IJIG 21916

0 111161.621 L9%6 L62111C110U2 ii: 9J20 L6bL6261J12 IJJG J9M12 6211111916 0 SI! 9A6L96

MIIJJOI1I SI! 6XbJICIf 111161.621 L916' Jjfl2 L916 L6bL626I112 SI, 9J16L11911A6 11J69211L6

L916 M92 IJJG qsrqi 1.916 Ot 11116L621 OIl 1J1026 COJJILSCI2 IJJ9I M6L6 MLII46IJ

ELOW 1JJ!2 L6b014 M6 9120 IJCJT16 fJJ6 J6SJ 1916 O !1U6L62V11 Jj1!2 I116L621

1JJ6 01J16L 219162k 92 1JJ6 11J16L621 L9f6 L6fljS1J0Ir1

MG rrecj 1116 T5 bGL A6SL L916 MJJTCJJ M92 1JJ6 IJJ9XJWtIIJJ L9f6 9JJ0M6 nj sjj oL6C0UJIJJ6I1Cj6 TI! J9GL S6 EOflI!9fOI! L6coww61Jq9lo1J2) EOL 11J026 219162b6L 9111111W (6116C11A61X 1101 9 L62111C1101!' 9J1JJ0J1JJ W!2 M92 1116 L62111cp011

!1116L621 L916 L621L!CI!oIr gJJoqG J2J9IJ jsq 911 111161.621 1.916 L621L!C1!OIJ O 30

WSXIWtIW 11116L621 1916 9JJOM9J6 01! M1711611 COI!119C12 EJA6 219162 jrnq 110

0 1116 2f9162 C0I!2111116L 1IJ9UC6 19M2 OITL L)LIWSLA qGb6uq6IIl A9LISpJ6 !2 1116

OIU !IJIGLG2I 1.916 L62IL!C1!0U q919 C011J62 L0W 991.1611 (T25) po couJbJ6q 91j

L6614 1L6521ILA P!!1 1916 111 JJ

69f1J1 1.916 1P91 TIr1211U62 fJJ6 sb PGIM66U 1316 b111116 1.916 (Q)) suq IJJG 4L!2J(-

Page 22: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

51

jOAGL 1116 IMGIJIA XG9L b6uoq MpIqJ iucJnqGq pG qGbLG22Iow

GwbJoAusGuc owp OAGL 1156 bo-ML bGuoq2f-1G21 JgcGL L0MJr 219162 NUfJJ LIJOLG JGIJ!G111 !U16L621 L61TJ91!OiJ2 jq L6916L

WØXWJtIIIJ J69J L9f6 0 11116L621 !2 21L0I1JX b02!PA6IX COLL6J9I6q M1111 1JJ6

M69J( prri 9J20 2rTbboLle flJ6 uJOqGJ- MG 9J20 ornJq 11 pJ16LG21U IJJ9I 1}16

JJ9A1I1 PJJ16L 1T2rILA L621L1C110112 1JJ6 IUCOWG L0MIJJ 6U6C1 12 b9WCFII9L!?

jJJG D6WOCL9I qrimw? MOLJ(2 92 GxbGclGq M!1JJ UJOLG DGWOCLUI!C 219PC2

J9M 6A615 JOMGL rn prep b0AGLIA 2f9f62

b0AGLIX W69U2 WOL6 q69nJc2) w9J62 IJJG 1161 01 6911J1 W9X1UJflJJ U16LG21

eponq 6 IIJOLG bL6A9J6I11 1 19f62 M!IJJ JOM fl1C0II16 IJJ!2 qGJj9flJl 6U6C1 (p1p11JJ16L rI2rILX L62li4C0I12 ..LP!2 !2 b9LIC11J9LJX 2f1LbL!2!11 2JIJC6 q69nJc2

o bOA6LIA 91Jq qJG 2CJJ00JJ1J W692f116 0 bOh6LlA 9L6 pOIJJ 2I10JJJX L6J916 10

L621L!C(0IJ2 L9IJJ6L We" 011 W6 bnL6 q6w9uq 0L CL6W 1JJ6 p0r12111 1JJ692111.6

fO 112 fJJ9f 1G2G 66Cf2 9L6 M0LJCJI1 UIOL6 1JJL011JJ Cj611J91JCj IOL II2rILX

I1J692f1L62 9L6 COLLGJ9I6CJ MIIJJ 1JJ6 q6j9nJi: J69J L9f6 01 !1116L621' MJJ!CJJ 2f162f!1116L621: 9L6 COLL6J9f6CJ MIfp 1JJ6 W9XIWIIJJJ J69J L9f6 0j 1U16L62f 110116 0 OI1L

1116 COLLGJ9fIOIJ2 9L6 TA6IJ lIt JJ6 5' jU6J B Vu 0[ OJIL W692fIL62 01

CoMwo

ILOW J2O fO Th80 L91J6q ILOW J 10 T8O M!11J 91J 9A6L96 O 2Th

o g) Oj 011L 219162 jiq D6W0cL9IC 0A6LIJ0L2 ELIJ9JJA 6WbJoAW6lIf L0M1JJ

o IUCOW6 L0M1JJ 9A6L96 TOT12 uq L9U6 ILOW -'fJ fO (onf

L9IJ6 ILOIJJ A69L2 fO 15 A69L2 MJfJI 911 9A6L96 0 A69La

MJf 911 9A6L96 01 5) JjJ6 W6q19u X69L2 0 2CJJ00J1I1 !" 1JJ6 21916

2JJ9L6 0 IJJG 2f9l62 bobrqiou J!'4' I" qTJ9bIq9IGq JJ0fl2!IJ L9I16q ILOIJJ J926CJ 011 bJJA2IC9J (1U!12 suq 9L6 1L66 0 1JJ6 Joc9J buc6 IIIq6X bLopj6ur 11160 fJ1626 W692f1L62 10 IIJCOW6 926 UJ69211L62 pGC9I126 1626 U16921TL62 9L6

uo boAGLIA W692i1L62 9L6 qrJ9blq9fGq 0fZ2flJ 911q 2C1100J1I1 M6 bL616L P0111

V JjJ6 W69U 0 fJJ6 IJJ9XJWITW J69J L9f6 01 !1116L621 M92 8Q� 01111116 11169112 91K4 2f911q9Lq qGAI9flOue 01111626 i9L!9pJG2 9L6 !A6I1 !U .LPI6 '

Page 23: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

1t '(111211 29229191 I flO!2a9195I iBrrrIoI nOi229191 (Ii 2i!L1291 1110 29V1 C 9IdST

.210229191 1911i0 Oil ifiiw '(iI9voq niorI (Ii 1I1Vi! irI9Dl9q (10 2W61

29111m61 lo 97.51f2 9th iol ni1Ioijno aJ11J291 929f1i 2i69q91 f1Oi229195J

riiauor1 M9b119b ill nivi1 UI9D19q JSth 02 169'( 19q OOO (Ifihhi 910(1! fI1fI169 if1fiD1I1ff12 9(IT .9iEia 9111 lo '(il9voq 9111 usd11 910ffl '(J116up9111 2911J2S9 t.1oiir1OD auc11 29v1v1112 auIOiiDhie9l '(111811 bris '(il9vOq rI99wi9d dIoiisI9l1oD

bisbnsia 9110 A .in&ilirtia '(IISDiiaiisia 26 119W 86 '(IlsDimodIoD9 21 i11J291 2iflT

riiauoc1 blsbnsiadu2 ili nivi1 noiisliiqoq 9(11 ui (c1.M) 98691Dff1 flOiJBiV9b

.nOrJsxv9b bisbnsia £ lo . to .I '(ci 9161 129191(11 fflLIfflD(6f11 9111 219W01

9moDrn bs1 9r11 bus slclsiisv tslDOffl9U S a9buIDdIi 1IOi229191 biuIJ iuO lsDrJxIoq 9111 91uJqsD 01 11169m 21 Io1inoD DtJfiDOm9b 9rlT .91512 srit lo rfiwo

01 t(169m 81 91118 £9111 r1iwoi 9ffl0)(Ii 911T .('(liooq ii9dIs) Iooq 9th lo 19WO 1011 IfilDomsU S 1911119V1 .I9bOm 9111 uI 9moDrII lo 9161 u1Jwoi 9th 91IJ1q13D

11911W 9161 189191111 fflLIftIiXBffl 9111 ITO b9119 t11SD111iIi2 s 2611 r1iwoi 9ffIODIfl

iuo mii1cio bit ob ailuesi 9a9rlT .fl9voq rueuod iol b9IlolirIoD vsrI 9W 916 e111J291 '(:1iIszJp9clI 9111 16(11 i29U2 ob '(9(1) bud &)iiBi2 9v1i616qrn0

.iooq 9111 lo tcI9m9alifDrIsIIn9 lsDiIiloq 9111 usd11 iom nuluIqaD

9v1161r1911s flS 26 iii1ooiba lo 8169'( 1151b9m 9th C9BLIIDIII iuoI cioieis51 chiT .OnsenoD (11169w b1911 9VsIf 9W 9)c11e uriss) iii1supsni lo 9luari9m 19V0 21 )tt21J6i2-i 911T .norIe '(I1SIIJDIJISq 81 199119 W11I001'ID2 lo 8Th9'( uIsIb9m

9(11 2925913111 (21s9'( O.f) ni1oorba ni cswrii bmbrisic 9110 6 bus wo1 :1111891 eidT .(noilsivsb bmbnsia .) 1 d 12919:111! lo 9:181 Is91 mzimixsm

ci ta919:1rn 1o 9161 rnurriixsrri 9111 15111 flOIlSDib(11 191111111 6 s b9191q19111i 9d 1169

Isrft 21 efIOrJs)91q191111 9V116(119116 nA .Ji1shJp9r1i 161902 i11iw 1691) 01 rn'(1I cioJ .cnosjioñ tiorfa 9Vsrl 29)612 911102 bits auiosiiod no1 9VSul 29)512 9ffl02 no1 0) 9viDubno3 219)hsm 9911 9vsrl bus niooibc ui :1a9vrn 29:16:12 noxnori

910(1! oeIs bus I119m:1c9vm 911111 9V81f 891612 itoiiod 110112 .d11woi ffl191

.2fl01i81U91 1SiD1I6ff1I SVIilJdillCib9l

19db aidi bas 'fl9voq niwod nwJ9d (wfq 1.8) noi tmo nim19dw19vo 9(11 19v9WOH1 .JIrien di lo edeudoi rti tduob u e9Afim 91LJ69(fl 9mODfli

Page 24: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

rliiw b9isf9noD 916 2i'101i6IIJ91 I6iDff 6(111 isth aia9u2 () ff0i229191 ',11riii '1L12LJ 11191(191 91011! ciJiw 291612 920(11 idi briil 9W .f1iwo1 91612 frfl9i sf10!

9ViV1U2 ion e9ob 11ua91 2irIT .boil9q mw-i2oq 9th ni 191261 W91 2w61

lotsm 6 26 11992 9d Ion bluoila 2w61 'iifw oe 2lolinoD iom nibJJ1Dni 111911191 16111 ia9LJa 2901) iiibrii1 9111 19v9woH .rI1woi 9)612 10 1r16111m1919b

iiiwo1 lo i1I9lTIIIOliVn9 "(Ioifih1J91 9111 b imq 9110 919W 2fIoi161L191 129191111

916 '(iI9voq bns '(11161Jp9n1 9moDcIi is11i 1a9IJ2 2i1Lr291 16D1IIqm9 911) 11619v0

rliod iol ablori Jk,291 ir1i 1611) bnuol 9W .1a191ni lo 29161 rnumixsm ol b9IriiI rft io1 rii11o1inoD bns 91612 9111 111 110116u1i2 I6Dililoq 9(11 iol 1Ii1101ifi0D

b9i61911o 9d 01 2ffl992 129191111 lo 9161 fflIJlTIIX6ffl 911T .9)6)2 9111 lii '(111169W

.916t2 911) (Il r11woi 1119m'c(olqm9 19161 r:E:tiw

erioJ)ilja,$1 12919111! ,ibuml6T 1)116 1i1difl .VI

91udr1121b91 01 tn69m "i1oq 161o2 lo s)9iq 6 916 2w61 (1u2U 16th £9b1 9111

9D119bw9 lo 9D91q 9110 .wSfi 1b16rf 21 iooq brIfi rbii r199w19d 9ffl0D 21 2nolbrrte9l 'I(IL!2L1 lo 111i6 10(60! 6 26W 9101 '(DiIoq 161)02 aiifi 16111 r1ii29LJ2

:)LbumI6i bnfi IfiDildid 16niho 9111 m brwol t9119 iscIl 01 9s1d19v 10 229DX9 9111

lo 9ffl02 2116)91 iqsq luo b rIoib9a 2icIT .2n011Di11291 9161 129191111 b 29)11J02 0.aw61 yIII2L 110 W11111W I6DiIthd-Ieoq briB IfiDildid 10 29D91q 1O[Em 9111

1th

Dlbuml6T .a9eoM lo aAood 9vñ 9th 111 29ffiu1 991111 2IIJDDO 129191111 iTO ff6d 9111

9Dnsnoqmi 9111 no 9D1I6Di1UIi2 ISIJJDII16q 9)61q 01 b9bn9i "(l6Jn9rnmoD 1&ildid nI .0690! bns 11im no n6d 9r11 lo 926) 9111 111 26) 211011)11)291 b9169q91 9)11111 lo 111 (1011)111291 21111 lo 9101 lflsIloqmi 9111 i29JJ2 290b noziIi9q9l 9111 926D '(116

2111 919(1w auboxa ni ai 116d 9th lo 9116169qq6 lalil 91IT ."(19b02 9ft1961a1

1ooq ei orlw uoi ihliw 9lqo9q (m lo "(116 01 '1(91100! 1)1191 ZJO"( Ii" 16tH 1191111W

moil 129191111 1D13x9 ton 116112 uo b116 1o1ib9r 6 26 mid 01 9d ion 116112 iJO'(

lo s(nfim edh9b ('Qt) imsweri5J .w6I '1ueIJ Dib9V io naibnl 9,11 19VOD ion 11kw 9W0 916 eni1in 9e9cfT Iiiu6)1 se IciJiIoq niiibnl di d n9vk enoiiinorrzb6 di bns 2w61 929d1 9ctJ of nfioI no 1e9191n1 bkdei 1kDiIb9qe 9dl i1J iii enoitE16u91 cn9le9w 9d1 of m1imi

.iooq

Page 25: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

GJ92PCJIX 0j J09U2 M9 prep OL JOM qnL!I1 pJ2 b6Loq H!PJX 6J921!C jouCIAGII (JIG L6211J12 OIl (JiG 6I!CJ6JJCA O TI2FJLA' M6 W112J 92JC MJJ6(JJ6L (J56

eoq9j L6qp4pnlou o f1J6 booL MJlpw (JiG L6J6A9111 onb 0 (JiG COIJJIJJflW(A9L(1W6I1( TI! (JiG 90A6 UJ06f JI116L621 L9f6 L62(LJCf0I!2 9L6 C0I1I16C(6 MIIJJIGIJJbOL9LX GJTWIU9P0II 0 bOA6LfA jJi6 P!P1!C9J b9962 266W (0 UJILLOL (JJ6

J09112 6(M66U H6PL6M' pri( bL!W9LIJX 1J1026 J09U2 1JJ9( M6L6 L6jS(6 o1116 (I211LA L62P4CPOIJ iii ppjcj rponpi: 2661112 10 JJ9A6 9bbJJ6q 10 9JJ 0LIJJ2 0

W9q6 CJG9L (J19( (0 11j0L6J1JGL241 J1J16L621 Je CGLI9TUJA 9cc6b19pJ6

10 41pL01JJ6L2 LG9LCJJ622 0 1JJ6TL GCOIJOWJC 2(9(112 H6L6' JJOMGAGL' 1( J2 9J20

(bo2eIpJA J9(GL ML1IIGII) pippC9J 26dr1611C6' 110 1U16L62( M92 9JJ0M6 10 6 CJ19L6q

0LW 0 jozr 1116 b96 9J20 6J1W1119(62 (JJ6 boAGL(A L6dllTL6W6IJç I1 (JJJ21116 9I1 10 IIX 111116 C0JJ(IIJ6IJ( COIJ(L9C1 J40 IU(6L62( IIJA 6 (9J(6U 011 IJA

T11(6L62( jO 9 0L6IU6L Aoii wA j6uq nbou !I1(6L62( JpJa 6X(6U2!1U6L62( OIl WOU6A' II1(6L62( 011 AICIJ19J2' !1J16L621 OIl 9UA(JJiI1 11191 !2 J69111 0L

D61116L0110WX :To: 11A0r1 2JJ9JJ 1101 J61.rq rthou J1116L62( (0 A0IL pLoIpGL'

1116 TI191 9bb69L911c6 0j 1J16 FIenLA p911' MJJ!CP ! !( W02( ql6q LOLW' 12 IIJ

tIL2J P1116 (JI12 COIJIJ6CpOIJ OCCflI2 JIJ 1116 B1P16

C01JIJ6C16 M!IIJ 9 6IJ6L9J CJi2(921G JOL COIJJLU6LC6 (92 !I1 VL!2101J6) .LJJ! J2 16

uq oLr6q MJ(JJ 9 6U6L9J p911 OIl bioa VIJ(J-tT2rILA J9M2 M6L6 0f6I1JJ9A6 (JI6 p911 011 (T2J1LA L62(LC16q (0 PL01JI6L2 (bGLp9b2 W691J1 UJ6I9bJJOLJC9JJA)

CJ69LJ? C0IJ1J6Cf6 (0 COIJ2rIWbfJOII J09112 L6J9(6 (0 boA6L(A pi 13112 C926' MG

!1116L621' IIOL th6 111W XOITL ooq 0L bL0UV1, 011C6 99!I1 (6 p911 011 FI2JTLA

(U( Aora pLOIJJ6L UJ9A J!A6 62I6 Aon A011 2Ji9JJ 1101 J61!q JW A01IL WOU6X 9(

IJJ9!UWIU JJJW 191(6 I10( Wf6L62( LLOW J11W OL JIJCL6926' fl1 L69L AO11L oq

PLO(JI6L GC0W62 bOOL' isq C9111101 W9111(9111 J1JIJJ26J MJIJJ Aori' on 2JJ9JJ

jJJG e6couq 9bb69L9uc6 0 (JI6 9IJ 011 (12111.A !2 II! f6JJ(JCfT2 5:: 11i1q I AOITL

9LW6I1(2 92 C0JJ916L9J

p911 01! rI2ITLA 12 9 tOLW 0 2oq9J bopcA fl16 A6L26 bLGc6q62 9 9U OIl fI296 0

9qWOUJIJOII IJO( 10 ML0I1 M!OM2 OL OLbJJ9II2 MJJJCJJ IIILIJJ6L 2fl6212 1J19( (JIG

!11W9!JA UIIGLbLG(6q 92 (JIG HGPL6M2 jJJG A6L26 IWW6qI9(6JX 0JJ0M2 SI!

SbbJi62 (0 (JIG booL suq (5) 1( OIJJA L66L2 (0 J09112 (0 41wA bGobJG'4, MJIICJJ M92

J1!m11 jjJ6L6 SLG (MO IWbOL(9IJ( t69f4TL62 0 (p12 91J 92 MLJI(611 JJGL6 U)11 oujX

Page 26: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

1inibIosi1x9 'pi1oq airli a)1sm (as 1i1iiu o1 9(11 ru as) a9ilqqua .ifI9iDiH9fui

19db riwsa lo acis9m ifl9DiIl9 lo 9)f1991 9th -- 1(iiDiiasI9 ob lobIJdilbnoD 9n0 1&ildicJ 9r11 111 Jn9ads 19vib6191 9d 01 am99a -- ansol noiiqmuano nsrli

9liqm9 9liinsDI9m )1991D 9(11 01 lorIq 1sr11 aJa9Lra (!i) 91f1iI .mono9 ioM .e9aoqluq rIoiiqmuenoD iol \!9v1aIJbX9 iaornls asw 1zibn91 9flOffl

no dDum wod bns r11169w bevsa no '(19I smoDcui bib dDum woif 'c(1iris11oqmi

111 1n91b91311i IsiDlflD S 6W 111169w b9VSa J&iJ 910(11 911T imoDni inru1D d a9161 Jas191n1 l9woI ob bnoqa9l 01 dDh 9111 919W 91(18 ea9I 9111 rxoiqmuanoD

mono nl9bom-9Iq 9111 rnoil 9Dn9biv9 911T .boil9q Jaiil 9111 ru ruimuanoD 119db moil anlUi9l 9(11 110 J1191X9 iz1 s ob b91191 (11i189w 9111 JsrfJ aba91Ja aij'fT .a9anql9ldu9 niono 119111 moil 1fli1 bns IEiiqsD 1&iadq 10 anivsa

.cioiiqo 1113 lo rburn isdi Ion asw noibqrrnJanoD 1911169 9(11 16111 aba9ua

9(11 b9iq9DDs 11s19n9 9vsrf anoib9a 9a9111 no asilsin9rnmo3 J819fl9 iii (I) a9buxomisM .1imcb lo miol £ 26 anoibilia9l 1uau 10 w91V 9lqrrna l9wOTIOd bris 19b1191 n99w19C1 110116191 9(11 nifl19DnoD awsl 9111" lsrli a9JrIw

9(1 01 abnsrnmoD bud nii1bon 9(1 01 b9thmsx9 ll1Jl918D cui9d no bnuo1 9d 111w

9111 lscfl 29iasd1qm9 (8f) 9rIiV9J ".yb9911 9111 01 brthl bns krIb19m 1n9in91 9bsbnsm aith aiD9nnoD d bns 9DliaIJt lsboa iol 9bsbrIsm s a9bwolq rfsrIAslsH

nisimixsm biloiq 9l9lqmoD brus 129191111 12niss ar1oi1s1u91 DibxJmIsT rliiw .lOiVsfI9d

id s bumlsT 9(11 Iii 2992 1n9)18ba1m bs1fw9moa W9IV 1110 01 (Of) 19na1191'l

13 01 lsluDilIsq ni ainioq 9H 't.biloiq 10 1(111211 lo 9Dfl1311398 9(11" 119V9 1aniss aid r11m99b91 ri9rIb bns nu119a Isubivibrui 118 91911W cfsrulaiM 9111 111 9saasq

aidi 29 1110 oT .1(111211 iol b9iDibrzz 21 bohq ,firiom r s nirliiw 9211011

9111 lo 9bslJ s IsdI 1(iilidiaaoq 9111 916111mu19 01 b9Jqm9bbs 1(Iqmia ascf 9saasq (in9m1(sq ia9l9bni lo rrruol s 1(IJID!Iqmi ai thicfw) nsol £ iol 1(119q01q lo 9211

.asid bioiq-ibcus bs9lqa9biw £ 211 01 a129U2 2118901011 1(d saasq aiñT .aiuxo

oD a'intutm1-% ik1ics noioD lo miol s 213 b9brusini 26W iijau 1aniss sbsbnsm IsDiIdiH 9u11 isrlb 9V9i19d 9W

.1(iinummoD 9(11 lo al9dmsrri iuo brrs nwob 1(Iilsloqm9f iol 9D(1611J2111 Isboa

Page 27: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

oIJ6-q9X L62ILTCfJOU 011 9LW6IJ1 bJ6q62 e L6b6916q !U D6III6LOUOWA 92 M6JJ

9LW6IJ1 111 bJ6q6 Xoii 2JJ9JJ LGIJ1LII !1 10 J'!" P6LOL6 11J6 21111 062 qoM1r14 JJJ!2

rl2rfLA L621L!C011 711 E02' 71 0JJOM2 IJJ9I AOJ1 6A6L 19J(6 AOJIL IJ6JJp0L2

A9L!0112 OLW2 O COJJ9I6L9J MpJCp M6L6 1101 b6Lwiq JmW6q916JA 9U6L 1JJ6

!IJI6LIGWbOL9J j6IJIJ COUIL9CI2 W 6IJ1L6 26462 0 L62IL!C1!0112 COIJC6LIJ2

J�62cL1Cc11s 1U16L621 M92 oujA 0116 0 1jJ6 fl1p1642 UJ9]OL L62ILICI!ou2 011

�M''1 b0iO11J6 P!6L 9Lrq j622 jJ0W06h16012 29pAj0u19Ii 20C161A

L6214Cf0I12 C9WG porzi: 6C9f126 CO62 0 1JJ2 IJ9WLG M6L6 JJ9L6L 10 6140LC6 IIJ

eneb6cç 1JJ6 qi6L61JC62 P61M66U N029!C Jq H9WW11L9p!C JU6L621 L916

MJJA JJ6 20Q9J 1I12f1L9I1C6 L0j6 0 rI2rILA j0M2 M92 j622 U666 !11 9pAjou!9 M6

!1121fl9I1C6 !221162 !" H9IIIIJJ(119PL2 c0q6 Jj16L6 !2 1!1116 L69201J 10 11IJ6L219U

61111111191:6 11116L621: L9f62 bLop9pJA 6C9J126 IJJ6LG 12 J114j6 COIJC6LIJ 0L 20C19j

qr16 JjJ6 bL!IJJ9LA WOL9J C011p0j 0 99pAJ011!9U 20C!61:A Cj69LjX 062 1101 9C1 lo

2b6qc9jj) q2pur12JJ6q L0W b6U911:A L9162 MjJ!Cj1 gbbjA 1:0 6P12 11J91: 9L6 1)921:

LOW IIJ1:6L621-tL66 J09112 1:0 J09112 91: 4OO !1116L621 bGL A69L 11U6L621: L9162 9L6

j09112 JIG piiqa 0C11W61J16 JJ9A6 9 21:LO1J A9L!61) 0 !I11:6L621: L9162 L9UI1

911 6X1:6I12JI6 q12c1122101J 0 J09112 11.1 V22AL!91J 911CJ B9PAJOIJ!915 20C!61:A JjJ6

110 2b6C11C rI211LA L61TJ91:0I1 !' 1:JJ!2 69LJ!GL qocmlJ6uc 1oJJe (moe) bLoiqq62q62b1:6 1:116 6X1:61121A6 H9WW9P1C 1169P1J6111 0 U1:GL621 CJJ9L62 1:JJGLG 12

H0M6A6L 1JJ6L6 12 110 6xbJq1: L62P CI OIl OIl IIl1:6L621: L9162

6WbJ19262 11191 q6p12 2JJOnJq p6 W96 !' 1116 bL626uc6 0 M!11162262COII11JJ!1 I:JJGIL 9226f2 92 C01191:6L9J (92 qo HJ91j'P) H9WW1TL9PL2 coq6 9J20

E11L1J16LW0L6 H9WWUL9PL2 coq6 jw2 rp6 6X161J lo MJJICJJ cvzJ

MJJO jJ9A6 2f16L6 qo 10 911 9C1 0 1J9111L6 fO q6J9A L6b9AUJ6IIç 0: q6p1:2

!U H9WW9P!.2 coq6 ji' 1P91 qoCrmJ6xJI' 1J16L6 12 9 26JJJ6I11 9!10M!U 6P10L2

1116 B!PJ!C9J IJJ9IIq9IG 2polTJq 6 cowbvLGq Mull 1JJ6 q!2CTT22f0U 0 !1J16L621 L9162

911q J11:IJ6 12 29I 99!U21 IJJ6LC9UI4J6 0C110112 6I16L9JJX

quq) j,A9uA o 1:JI6 L69i L9fL19LC1J2 M6LG 2JJL6M 1:L9GL2 (19COP zij b9LIrcnJ9L)

2fl621 9 fljJ 2C9J6 91111-COWW6LCI9J p192 (92 1116 CL66Y 9U1!—COWW6LC!91 J9M2

LGqJ2fuprrrIou Mull!'! 1116 COU,IUJIIU!1:X EA6U J622 20 062 1JJ6 !P1!C91 w911q916

jJI6 P!PJ!C91 b9229G 062 IIOf 26611! fO L6bL626U1 9 62L6 0L j11JJ 2C9J6

Page 28: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

IuqI/4q119j2 MGLG 10 c9u.X 0111 IPG!L COUJUJ!IWGIJI2 fO 2OC!Gf?

COUJWIIU9J 2GLAICG2' GXCG22UG qGpr2 01. GU2J9AGUJGIJI ci.91Gq LCf1W219UCG2 MGLG 20W6OIJ fO flJIJJ IJJGJL 0JJ9O1J2 Ill 2OqG1A 1JC6 G9LJA 111qw2w LGJ!Gq 011 9 91L 9UJof1U OL

wouObOJi2 LOi. 1JJ6 bOOL' 91J (5) 6C91126 011C6 IJJGA 6C9UJ6 2J9A62' luG booz. cofljq 'sot p conuGq1G26 9C1!01J2 MGLG oLpIqq6u (J) 10 J66b 1jJ6 bI4CG °L 19P0L jJ1JJGL 20 1J191 99IIJ 1JJ6 21916 9C12 921136 bOOL MOnq pG p64l6L OR !L 1p6? }r9q p6 obiou o 26JJ 1J36W261A62 11110 2J9AGLA bGLJJ9b2MJJO JNAG 6CO1JJ6 q621111116 (yiCG 9911J' 1116 W021 p92JC GCOIJOWIC LG920U!U MonJq IGJJ 112 11391

y 21W1J9L 9LI1U16U1 C911 p6 W9G 0L MJJX 2J9AGLX 12 9120 p1pJ1C9JJX oLpqq6u 0L 12L961!162

92 f1L6JJ OIl 20c!61A 6C9JT2G 0 69fIJr 011 6XC622!AG qpc JjJ6 69L1!6L9 261126 1JJ91 1JJ6 B1p16 !2 P.AIII IX) I"'!I 1116 6X16111 l MJJICJJ ruqLqn9J2 GU(J (11)

L621L!Cl0IJ2 W!p1 6 0 JII lP 9w0n1U 01 qjr H6LG ru b9LfcrrJ9L MG 61MG qi2cn2eGq G9LJIGL TI! IPG IIJ6OLX 2GCfIOII 1JJ91 0116 brabo26 0 !U6e1 L916

J9M

C9IJ 1P611 p6 6xbJ9IJ6q pA 1JJ6 426 0 20q9J L62boIJ2!p1!A L6drzp6q pA

011161 L621uC110112' q6eI16q o ob 96IJf2 110W 0A6LCOUJW1!IJ 1J16W26JA62

0pJi9ç0I12 T fJJ6TL boA6LA 6C9W6 100 6X116W6'51 flJ6 1126 01 rI2ITLX J9M2' 9IJ9GIJ12 corijq 110 JOU6L 11JpJJ W91!A 0 1J16 P92TC 20C!SJ uq L6J0fl2MorrJq pG cowbJ6IG lTL6I12 011 1116 COUhIIIfW!1A II! 1J16 Jj6pL6M COWW11IIIIA'

21116 11191 96iJ2 q!q 1101 L6CJIIC6 1JJ6111261A62 10 9 J6A6J 01 b0A6LIA MJJ6L6 1116X

TwboA6Li2pwGuc b61119b2 OUG 09j 01 1116 P!P17C91 L621L!C10U2 M92 1o 1119J(G

911 6161116111 °1 1JJ6 ri2flL) J9M2 MJJJCJJ' IU 9 26U26 bIGAGUf 9 6L66 01 lfllflL6

JjJ12 09J 01 W6 1rrp1166 A69L -- 1J16 J1WJ OIl 9J16U9p011 0 jIlfTILG LTJJ12 -- 12 9J20

11J94(G1) 911CJ (5) J1UJI6q IJJG 6X16U1 01 COWWIIUJGU12 f6 bool corijq w9J(6

jq flJG bool conjq 16c6!A6 (pA L6qnc!I1 9L6916 2rIbbJA 01 JJJq 011 1116

uoi: ci.tijjA 2611 11J6!L juq 1p12 L62p3C1011 WA JJ9AG (J) L926q 1J16 b11c6 01

91!6u916 IJJ6TL 1111fl16 69LIJ1112 101 CfILL6III C0iJ2flu1b10Ir 1IJC6 qJG booi. corijq

l 9120 iuqiC6q b6Ljrnbe' 9', 6wb fO JOM6L 16 9Pfl!IA 011116 bool 10A691 L621L!C1!0IJ u19q6' II! 6U6C1 JI j9U 29162 J6926JJ0JCj2 PtIl IJJOL6 TWbOLI9IIIJA

bgLçrcrzJ9L 20Jq lq6L qrnGe2) M92 L61(1UJG 10 !12 oLi!II91 OMIJ6L JJJ!2 111P1166

JIJ 1JJ6 11P!166 A69L (MpicJJ JJ9bbGuGq 6A6LA 1!11A A69L2)' bLobGLlA eojq (9Lrq n.r

jJJG b9fç6lu 011 1011112 01 C0J1916191 9J20 9bb6912 111 16 111P!166 A69L L62111cp0u2

bgXmGul

01 6C91T26 7A1U 1116 pOLI.0M61. 16 1126 01 1G bJ6q6 M92 9 101W 01 111161621

711161621 1916 6T1p6L 6C91126 1JJ6 OLL0M6L C911 LGU66 OIl IPG JO9U 111016 1L66JA

jJJG L6214C17011 011 C011916L9J 266W2 9J20 10 6 9 101111 01 L6qr1uIJ 1JJ6 6116C11A6

Page 29: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

jJJ2 L?fXWGU( 9J20 GXb1W2 luG nq9Ic q2JG (OL wpp1J

L11J1IJ2 iuç &wbie pX J6U6L2 (iuq p0LLOM6L2) 10 A0q 1156 gj -IT2ITLAJoobpojG2 10 IJJG II2I1LX L62p.ICIT0IF JjJ12 COIIC6LIJ 2(TL6JA L6bL626IJ12 J�pp!2

JjJ6 A152JJII915 2661152 b9LlcrrJ9LJX COIJC6L1J6 MJIJJ 6JWU9lIJ A9L!0fl2 1Ab62 0

(0A6L ii w2b6ci6q f!uJ6 b6Loqy10 n2rn.A }TIJ9JJA' 1JJ6 J16L621 L9f62 qGecIjp6q 92 f12r1462 9L6 50 isq L6916L

COIJJIJJ6LCI9J 6IJI6LbL!262 (2b6csTJ91A6 1L9gILr II! MJJ691) 91.6 WOL9JJA 6dfl!A9J61J1

(qGu9Le) uq 109152 O OOq2 (M15691y II 9120 6212 1J191 C6L19!U 1Ab62 0RP N6219 2:1 p6iIJ2 pA 219f!IJ 11591 lT2flLA C9IJ OCCIIL ! !°' 0 W0156A

M1JJ 1JJ6 bLOpJGUJ 0 11516L62V

qGboeIlGq M!11J 1156w) 9L6 9J20 g6916q j156 BP Aj629 2:1-2:11 69J2 qL6C1JAfl9pTJJlA 0L 0LL0M6 ooqe 01. MJJ6U WOIJ6A CJJ9II6L2 C9IJ 1.61126 couqec26q 111 1156 N!2PIJ1J H0M6A6L' UJ9IJA 011561. 9L692 0 JGuq1J (6JJrluqL6q A6SL2 p6oL6p9uq r6uq!u sq 151161.621 L9162 9L6 6X16U2!A6JAP61M6615 100-520 CE 926 015 j9ppIUTC Lf1J!1J2 OA6L 11591 b64oq 9IJ 1156 IMO

j156 CGJJI19J qOCI1W6IJI 0 1156 ..L9Uffl 12 1156 yp2JJIJ9JJ MP!CIJ M92 M41461J

1UIC EX2OU2 t1%8 ID*2C112210U

L0W 6JWIJ91pJ p9UJ(Lf1b1C62 MOJ1 JJ9A6 6GII J0M6LdrTJ-AoJrwf9LA 2oq9J 0pj910U 9IJCj 1622 Ot 9 2OC!91 M6fl9L6 2A216W' 1156 9!U2

015 1J56 M6J9L6 2X216W 0 f]J6 COIJJIJJmI15A III 69Lfl6L 2oq6f62 MJJ!CJJ JJq 6M6LJJ9A6 (1) 66iJ mJJy6JA 10 "1WJ 111611. 20q9J opj1ggpou2 isq (5) 66U 9 f1L6UJwbo26q OIl 1156 M0 20C161162 I1 Y1029!C 2OC!61A' psuJanb1 C!1!6U2 MonJq

69LJI6L L6rIJ91l0IJ2 OIl p0LL0M7I1 6WbJJ92I62 1156 q16L61J1 C0212 P9IJJCLfIbICA

11112 q6sr1J1-p926q 6XbJ9II91!OIJ 0 1156 6L6UC6 6M66U 1156 ,A4029IC CO62 uq

bGLpgbe JDA JTW11T1J 1156 111161.621 L916

0A6Lt126 91Jq 20CI6A M!JJ ILA 10 J622011 1156 OCCI1LL6IJC62 0 JJ15 142J'C q6p1

9 IJ69ifG 6X16L1591!IA 011 20C161A 115615 6X1L6W6 L12J(-f9JCIIJ MIJJ 6 1U61C16IJ1JA

conjq oA6LcowwIl 115611. 922612 JIJ 911A 20C161A MJJ6L6 6X1L611J6 b0AGLIA CL69162

H9W1111IL9P!C coq6 J19q 21111119L1A fL6q fO 1!J15 1156 6X161J1 fO MIJ!CJJ 6f0L2

Page 30: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

ii 9Drna) aloith9D 01 nino1 i1 3nibivolq thidiol siaM scisfi .r1o!JDrIi91

ol n9vi ein9e9lq bitho1 1I: Bi9M zd68 .(insmvq 1e9191111 lo rcriol B

II .noiismiolni l9bkfIi lo miol 91111 ni 1e91Ini 'Init91!JJni iom io al9bn9l 'd iib9lD iol bisq 919W a19bfl91 919(1W aas b9Ibnshl bsd aidd&51 9(11 IscIi 2f1I99

.atrz9mqol9v9b sbsii 9lIJiul JuodB noil6mlolni

01 awsl 9a9111 lo Ii1idsDi1qqs 9(11 110 1ls91D 9iiUp a9ILn oals riznrlaiM 9riT bits rüwonod diocI awolls \FIa9b sia9M sds8 .a91ilr19D riJiw eczoiiDsanBlI

9111 aqsch9q ai rIOiiDrrta9l 9, li 10 riortsftrrnl airfT .ia9l9irIi is a9li1r19 01 r1thn91 '(IIBDianrlirn as fI99 ton asW 1a9191fl1 Is nibrI91 15(11 flOiiSDibfIi ta9n01Ja

9IcJsiq9xisnu 1no asW ta9191ff1 is (IIb1I9I 19(1iB5I .aicfds5l 9r11 cf Isiommi r1i lo is1jnoD !sboa di 9biani alsubivibni ablfiwol b9iJDs1q BW ti f19(IW

Ion 915 orlw a9111r190 9aocfi ol b9Iiup9l ton ai ia9l9irIi on Is nibn9J .ifsioT

.i(19ffI9fIBh15 9111 lo Jmq

-noibubolq fI99Wi9d iioibnitath 9(11 ai rIsiirIaiM 9111 ff1 trI9mqoI9vsb I9IliOfIA

9(11 awolls 8: sia9M sds .ansol b9irI9i1o-noiiqmuar1o bits arisol b9In9ilo sdsH .noiiqmliarloD iol ion tud (rioibuboiq .9.0 b9a iol 16911W 10 rnbn91

lo 9Isuia s iol 91IEdDX9 fli al9nWO 9loia iol (9f1om b99a awolls (19V9 sia9M 119W as 9fiW a9vi9D91 a19s(1sm 9101a 91111 as no1 as aii1oiq '219flW0 91012 9111

anOiiDilia9l 15(11 si1si 01 b9m9a rlsnrlaiM 91111 bs91lA .916(12 iiloiq aid as .1iaoD 19m91JX9 9d bliJoD I1ib(191 b9aBd noibuboiq rio

(anoitDsansll nsm iii as) ansol iii rlsculaiM 9111 lo aiasclqm9 1smu1q Isriil A m9ja1a 9111 9boD DidslummsH 9111 ni aA .292291111W lo 9Drzsrloqmi 9rfi al

9111 bns a9aa9rriiW .aa9nb9id9brii rii1sriie 11smio1 101 b99r1 B b911up91

b9vlowli alao3 noiiDsansTt 9(11 r192a91 01 b9v192 m9Iea iluoD Dinidds5I rioiia 21 rbirfw ,W9IV a'19n2u91,I iarn66 iff9ffhIJTh WIolia s) Wübn9l DieBd 111

.(aiaiIsiyI9mmoD-iins nsiI9IoiailA 919W eidds$I 9111 isñi wo19d b9aauaib

(rlsnrlaiM 9th 1o noiawDaib 9viarl9ix9 its ai rbislw) smm9D nsino1dsa 9ffT

910(11 9(11 10 9ffi02 rhiiw alnsb £16m93 911T .anhILn 929(11 abrlsqx9 1is91 ti ai a91DrI9T1Ln 191110 10 aboo ff1 916 ansol II .ia9l9Irli 1o anoiia9zsp ilirnillib

b9aulno oals aidds5l 9r1T In9rn1sq91 10 irlioq 9(1116 9ns11D a9Di1q Ii J29191ni

isthi 1no la9ua enoiaaueib smoe .29111(193 (111w rI11s9b no noilidirloiq 91111

Page 31: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

ocij MGJ9L6 ! JJGJbGq fL0flJJ J6UqI1 911q p0LLOM!1J

72 L6IJf-266JqI1 UOf bLoqrzclou uq 2!UJBJA 92G OIJ 9 COI1IT2!0U 9p0r11 JJOM

UJ9XIU11711 20C19J M6fl9L6 OL (5) 926 011 201116 IJOOII MJJ6L6 1JJOIJ6A J6IJqU

A!6M2 M6L6 6!11J6L (I) p6q 011 W619bJJA2C9J 9L11W6I1f2 IJq rIuCouu6Cl6q O

uoi qL6crJA bLoqrIcG ooq i 2661112 bo22!pJ6 1J191 VL!21011612 SU1-!IJ16L621

1JJ026 IJJc bLOqZTC6 711C011J6 tLOW p.9q6 OL wo1J6A6IJq1J -- W61JJ02 IJJc qobLoqrlqlou 9L6 11J026 1JJ91 bLoqnc6 ooqe LOW M9gIL6' (IIJIJ9IITL9J tOLIJJ2 9L6

119111L91 uq IIIJIJcrILJ tOLW2 O bLoqacu ooq2 J49P1L9J 0LW2 O..LJ'!2 VL!2O6JI9I1 M6M 0j !1U6L621 !2 pge6q OIl 9 MOLJqA6M MJJ6LG 1JJ6L6 9L6

M92 l:JJ6 UJ02L 1IJIJ91flL9j tOLIJJ 0 bLoqrIclOIJ 9A9TJ9pJ6

0L MJJ!C}J 1JJ6 CfILL6UC) M92 bLoAq6q1, VL!2101:J6 9LfT6 IJJ9f wou6A-J6IIqu

jrIJJX )r121Gq' j0L JJ6 9!I1 94262 OfU O CJILL6UCA !f26R uoi 92 9 bLoqnq o JJ9

11A6LA UJIICJJ qI2JIyGq 9J20 JJ6 bL9clc6 O C9LU !IJ16L62 iq 1J16 q2JG !2obbo2IIou 10 J6IJq1J IJJOU6A 9f 11J16L62V VL!210fJ6 ML!62 !11 JJ!2 bopI!c2

ff2!!W 9U2 071 rI2IILA 6Xi2l6q 1 f}16 297716 1!W6 CL66J bp!1020b111c9J

99JIJ2J I12rILA' MJJ!CJJ orqq GA6IJcITYJJA OLW JJ6 p92!2 O CPL!21!971 91J(J

2661112 bLTW9LIJX b9LI O 20CL9621 WI:6116C1:I19J J69CA Jj16 J.0L9J112 bLoJJp!iou

JjJ6 CL661(2' JJOMGA6L' pq IJJ6IL OMII 911Ii-(72ITL? 21L9I1 O IJJO(1JU MJJ!CJJ

CL661C2 OL 9JJ C11142119112Y

2COJ9L2 6X16IJ6 fjJG 112111A L6e11!cfou o jj o JJ6 J9L6L oribe (2rIcJJ p6J4OMGA6L' J916L 16M12J1 JJ!IIJC6L2 9I1cJ Oj COfIL2& H6JI6UJC iq CJJL!21!9u

ff6 I100II 1JJ91 (T2ITLX J9M2 bLoAIq6q 9 M9A 0 ff6 Lonb !U2(1L!U !126Ww6wp6L2 JI! 6I16L9J' IJJ2 p911 0 II2KILX 011 1JJ6 1JJU-JCU!I cowwmmA 2nbboL

bJJL9262 !1 9JW021 2661112 92 fl ff6 L621i!C1011 M92 J16Jq oiijX 10 CJ026 9W!J?

EYLJX 1nq92m 6U6L9JJ? coujyuq fiG 0pJ!91!0II 011 (I2FILX 10 16M2 JU 201116

flJG fl2flLA Lopp13ou Iii H6II6 suq CJ1I41iS1J LG-gGOuUS13OU 20C16(A

011 J091J2

16M2 JJ9A6 bL!oulX 0L !1116L621 L66 J09U2 110113191 C6U17162 W9X CJJ9LG !UIGLG2I

Page 32: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

tB 9flOffl nibn91 nsd !no Jon i1i1 iVt .iluau b9!ilaib 1161imi oiBN or1J iqsDx9 afIoiiDsfIui1i JibsiD Its oJ b9oqqo i Mm iii Jud ie919Jrn

d19qu a9bivolq (If) ivsiT 2flOS91 qicfbnsiiI 1srnq ioI r19)Isil9brrn Jr1iorIi airD lo ioM .Jriijor1J DIfflOITOD9 (1i2 bflB) D1JI0JBN lo fliJflhJOD91

w917 IBb19mrrIoD-iJrxs has i919ini-iJnB 1q99b s ill b9rlDnslJcI9 1mi11 299 .bhow scii lo

9r11 1111w bumlsT 9th (11 W9iV D1m011039 9th 1D9(IffOD 01 2iqm9JJs l9ffaIJ9M

9d11 bail 9W .&)ifflOnoD9 ol rbsoiqqs (nsu!9ioieiiA 11skriJmq bus) )1991Z)

iol 9)h1xb A9iD 9tH bns ws1 1(luaLr-iins DibumIBT c199w19d 9Dr1919flib 01 rzoiiiaoqqo DibumisT 911T .a9iihslimia cxs ascii cibliuia siom 1e9191n1

rl.izw b9ciidmoD i ii ftj(1 9Ddw( IsiDoa ioI 911e9b s 01 b9iD9rmoD ITh9b al vuraij 01 floiiieoqqo )!991D 9fIT .9Dl9fflmOD lo amiol '(ThSffl 9151i11D5I 01 9lia9b s

srit rHs9rI9d io 11v9 ai ll9aii 9:n9mmoD tscfi w9iv s ol b9iD9rrnoD ai 9YI9ffifflOD .rIi9d cismurl b9q019v9b B lo ta9I9Jfli

c1i ascii 9i1BhIOr)s1 01 191)15(1 rbum asid ISiDl9fflmOD-IJIIB )199ID 9th briil 9W 1ED1EID isth b9ia9ua asH (Q1) 'adoDsJ .asid iuau-itris DibIJmIsT l9bIirrI

s istH boorlil9lil 9th ff091 01 911a9b s 'd b9lsviiom 91B 91)611 110 2)IDB±JB

aA991) 9111 1619r19 uI .b99i d hsqs rnOJ 9(1111w (J9iDoe riiii&w io) bnsd 01 9VIDJJbIIOD torI BW ti (1) 9aIJBD9d 9YI9f1I0D 01 b9aoqqo (199d 9V611 01 ffi99

9r11 Ii aq6f119 .duIssw 1o (ii1sup9rn b9iomolq ii () bns 10iVB(l9d "Isiom"

(Ii fIDI99air191 tHis \li1shJp9rIi 9fflODfli ol b916191 29iii15ffl91X9 9V1JB9fI 9d 11BD W9iV )1991D 9m9liX9 9(11 (19111 rliil 11fl9iDiThJa 915 9DI9fflJTIOD

.boOiai9bnLc

b9irisW a)19910 9(11 lsrfi ai W9IV D1IB1D0 9111 iol (IOiiBDihteLI[ 9lthaeoq 19r110 nA 10 '(JiliiiJ 1sniim 6 lo r1ir1 001 b9q019V9b 9110 Off istli 9lU 9)!Bm 01

919111 II .(Jjr1uoc1i 10 916Ja 9111 01 9Div19a ol b9aoqqo as) thoo iol nioiiqmuanoD

lr!im noiislumuDDs 111169w timil 01 nulqm9iJs nr1i 9D1i9Jaia19q lids,! ei i1!sniq .aboo iol noiiqmuacioD lo ii1iiu 1sniism 9111 9as91Dnl toll 9as91D9b

an9siJiD 10 quoi s iol r1D1s9qa '1qmia 919W aDLts1DC) 9(11 JsrlJ 9ldiaaoq ai Ii

j9boa lii aIa9i9irn Ishl9mmoD 9(11 01 1IsDiti1oq b9aoqqo 919w odw

wBf nimo$I .e9Eb rriIui cfJ noms IisiisiJmq iiini bii1eib o!s cxEmo5I 9c1T nifisv9!q ft \f aw i'bidw oJ mdD bEuo) eiojtn iti itii iini r1i bitz

.j919ini lo 9J11

IC

Page 33: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

35

ju uA bo22pJG 2lLJCOU2 PGIMGGU GM 9uqCGU1GL9IPGL O Jj O f6 WGWGL2 O II1OIJ OIJG GxbJaInJpou °L LflWGUf p G2LG roLJJ!JO 9thzGq I1J31 416 f1J OU (121ILX JJOnjq 6X16U LJOOUfX 10 l6M OL CJO2G UJ!JX w6U1p612 pair

1,9b9J EUCACJ!C91 %/C 10t 0I 0 f6O 1JJ6 CL691 JJJ!2 6b!21J6 91flJ6 IJX1120 CE b6LJoq 1156 UL2I OU1J9J C9'°" J9M LflJ!U 99J21 f12S1L) f92 1156J,40011911 (J) q62CLp62 1156 1426 o 0LW9J bLop!p!qou2 oil FI2IILX u i:p 20-

o\ ouii ptc

ITUJ6 MJJ6IJ CpL1!9zs!1 i p6cow1Lr luG qouspsui 0LC6 115 IJJ6 M6261JJ1C9J 9qw01J1Iou 10 6xb9IJq 1156 f12(IL? J9M 10 9JJ 0 20C161X C9W6 11121 911156

16L0W6 12 1156 CV14r!91J 11IflA6L29J16L 0 1156 L6ITJ9lJ0I fl1J211LbL1211JJA' 1JJ2

9Lt1W6Ul J19q p6611 W96 69LJ16L pA bP!J° ! H61J611!C 6x9uqL19'54 Pl9Lri6q 1151 11512 J9M2 2porzjq 6 nIJ!A6L29J6q 10 9JJ O 20C!61A V 2UJJ9L1 16L0m6 bLG2Gul6q 9 W910L GXfGIJ2!OJJ 0 1156 CJ9221C I12IILA J9M2 16L0W6

C111421!911 2OcJGIA 6A6U 1JJ011JJ IJJ6LG M92 9 21L0IJ bLGqiJGcpou 99!I121 112fILA

L62f1J1' ojq 119J91(JJIC L6r119l!0IJ2 OIl II221LA M6L6 IJO JOIJGL pIJq1I 01516212 isq pi bGobJG 2rTbGL2Gqsq 1116 ojq COA6II9IJI 0 1156 9M2 0 0262 V2 91116 11r6116L 10 1116 I�01JJ9IJ2', 1,911!' CJ9W6q IJJ9I 1156 11M6M C0A61J911111 P61M6615

C0WW6LC19J121J5' 1,1 6J1W111916q 1156 BOM6L 0j JSM 99!Ii21 (I2rILA ixs

1IJJr1J191J60I12 10 69LJA C1L1e1!9U 0bb02!10u 10 IT2ITLA zrq 6II6L9J U11-

COJIJUJTIIJIIA M1fJJ J!11J6 0LW9J J6uqIJ 9uq C6L19!IJJA 110 !JJ16L61 L9162

CJJL12P15 2OCIGIA qoCxTwGIJl6q II! 1156 VCI2 O 1156 Vb021J62 2r1R6212 9

P0115 9U1!-rT211LA 9uq 91111-M69J1J1 9CCITWIIJSI!oI1 IJJOL6 pLo9qJX .L156 69LJA

jquqom 0 }J69IGU11 pOIJJ 2f1621 11591 69LJA CIJL!21!915!IX M92' 11J0L6 PLOSqJA'

C9WGJ 10 1)922 lJJL0r1JJ 4316 6A6 0j 9 IJ66J6 115911 tOl 9 IJCJJ W9IJ 10 6IJ6L 4356

1156 6LW0U OIl 4356 NOfUJI uq IJ 1156 t9WOff2 21916W6111 1191 ,J1 2 692!6L jOL 9

IiJ0I,6X CJJ9IJJU TU 4356 16WbJ6 qq1!01J9JJA' 4316 91143-M69J1JJ 21916W61J12 !'

P!m26J 2JJ0M6 9 2159LbJA 91543-W0116A J6uqzJ 91131ff6 IJ J52 9119CJ(2 015 1J56

COIIJUJGLC!9J12W M92 9 b9LIJcJ9LJA 2çLoIJg 21L9!I1 111 E22611G 111q9!2Ur 162112

yIJlJ-II2ITLA 9L(1W6I112 9L6 9J2O L!6 III 69LJA CJJL!21!9U!IA' bGLp9b2 6C9fl26 91J-

f12Iuj C12i\

Page 34: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

orijq 6 bLroLriA oj lpG CP11LCP 0!. 1G 21916 (2ncp 2!1 12 JJ9L 10 p6J16M6 1P91 20C!9J JG!2j9l!0U 0 1p12 Xb6 corljq 6 GI4OLC6q 0!.

L61916q j6 b6uoq Oo-�oO CE lu M616W Eraob6 M92 9pJA cporc uqpq JJM9X2 M9U16 ro qo uq (5) L26 ii, 0LW9J j6IJqIJ 191 corijq p69C1JU 1JJL0r1JJ 1J16 426 0 16 21916 20 1JJ91 1J16 CJJflLCY conjq 6IItOLC6 MJJ9I IJJGA

9Lf1W61J1 1P91 111!2 b6Loq 29M (i) 426 II! 1316 0LW9J bOM6L 0 1116 cjiacp1J16 CJJITLCJJ' J11 11112 IJJ6OLA 92 ouj1 M69J( 2ffbboLV 0LG bJ9rr2ipJG 12 13169 1126 HI IJ6df19J11A (92 tOLW9J MG9JIJJ 1026) IIIqrlc6q 9 p6116A0J6111 L62b01126 pX

TImoJAsq II! pmqit riiitX 61M66U 2O uq JJ JI !2 16Wb1!U 10 CJY!JJJ 11191II !2 qrcrrJ1 fO rniqeisiiq MpX CJJI1LCP irq 21916 6C9W6 IJJITCJJ IJ.10L6 ULWIA

jjiuq 916L91J COITIJCJJ 0 jJ MJ1!C11 6XCOLUIJJ11IJJC9 162 112f1L6L2

16 K9pp12 j6 1I19J MoLq CU wGqrGA9J rI211LX LGr1J91ou !2 A6II pX 11160CL91!C2 91J 162112 92 1116A qo 111 IPG 20C19J 1rT2pC6 II0f0II2 0 1G jOL9JJ 911q

CJJL21GUq0W JJ9A6 92 WJ1CJJ L001 111 1116 9U11-C0UJWGLCI9J p19262 0 1116

!2 92J(6 111911 !2 1G11) MG C9IJ 266 11191 1116 9JJIJ-II2IILX A16M2 0 M6216L11

L09CJ (16 i: 2 6flJG pX 16 4Xh1M66L C9b!IfIJ9LA o 8O CE 92 41MJ16L6 111016

M!uJJ11 M6216111 E1TL0b6 10 1J16 J9!1) Jj16 q6ruou 0 IT2fILX 12 b9L1C11J9LJX

C1J9L16I1I91J6 626LA62 1116 cLGqJI 0L 6X16IJPJ 1116 0LW9J J9M2 99!U21 tI2IILA

IJJ6A M6L6 016U or1bGqy

211CJ1 9 J1JJ1' rI2ITLA J9M2 6C0UJ6 W021 2IUJJJ9L 10 16 eiujouX J9M2 (Mflp MJJ!CJJ

IJX BLIUCIb9J M9U12 fO 6J111JT11916 11J12 1Th6 0 9CIJ0U L0W 911 96U r6M6q !'

MJ10j6 J491fll9JJX 1G CJJIILCJJ MorlJq M91J1 10 611UJ71J916 2IICP p6JJ9AoL 1121 92

bLo1J66L7u pA 96IJ12 M1JW I316 CJJIILCJJ 1 1G 6Xb61J26 0 1316 CJJIILCJJ 92 9

JJ9Lq2JJ7b 16U 9IJA C1J9L!1J 0 1116L621 pA CJGL!C2 M011j L6bL626U1 bLIA9IG

6I16L916 6111p112192W p) 1116 W92262 0L L6Ji10I1 9I1 10 61!IJJ!1J916 6XC622!A6

p6J16A6 11J91 11J16L621 LL66 J09112 M6L6 6U6L9JJA rrq pA 16 CJJITLCJJ P0Y 0L620f1LC62 (MpJcJJ WA 1101 6 20 IIJ9CCIIL9I6 111 fJJG 61JJ1JJ C6IIIrILX)' Uq MG

J9M2 fl MG A!GM 1116 CJJ11LCP 92 9 W9)OL C19111J9111 10 20CT6fA12 bLoqnc1AG

1116 2bGqpc9JJA 91111-CJ6L!C L611J910IJ 2f16212 91101116!. bo221pJ6 1126 0L II2tILA

BLTWLA COJJ6CIJOU 0 C9U0I12 111 16 69LJX UJ6q16A9 b6Loq

bobrlJ9lIoIr Jj112 p911 011 (121ILX 0L CJ6L!C2 M92 6A6U1119JJA I1coLboL9rGq !U 16

CJGL!C9J b9Lf4cIb9frou !11 n2r1LX !1 qiq 1101 91J 111161621 CJJ9L.JU 0L 1116 6U6L9J

Page 35: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

Ja9w 9111 111 ws1 '(1LJIJ lo 9aii 9111 ioI fl9Vi noiiacIBIqx9 1l9fI9 19(110 911T

ffDL99-ifI91 lo rrriol s i9w 'di isdJ i ((8Q1) irnailloT bn6 J19d9H bni.r19)I1)

19(1119 SW (biLliE) 9111 IMII 9LI1fi cIo1icIB1qx9 ai,IT .ufDurrb 9(11 iol

iuau biovfi bluoD osfw 19bn91 io (eisi 1aiini wol bsin6w orlw) l9wonod (IoncinElqx9 airlT .O9AlBm 9111 lo luo 2191)1191 191110 b9irIsw orlw) arioi1shisi

1zuw bio1n iaiil rbnlrfD 9111 9aLr&)9d 1q9x 01 llinillib IfirIw9rnoe 21

I192ii no awBi '(1uaL1 9DloIn9 bluow 19bn91 9Idlen9a o14 .IJ9aii 110 2f1Oilfih1J91

noi1ibb& ciT .awsl iuau luoritiw rioijruj1 01 '(i9boa 10 1291 9111 n1wo11s 911(1w

992 awsl \1L12L! 1aoqath a'rlDlLJcID 16v91b9m 9(11 lB alool lo Isrl9am 9111 fl9V1 10 a9DcI911Jbni (Ii119a 01 9Vii8191) 21(191 ff1bB1iX9 jo &IB9ffl Jn9biII9ni fIB 9)111

.(nirIli1

wsJ 91s$1 12919111110 noii6xsI9Sl kwsib9M-1oq 9rlT .V

1UW 10 n0116X6191 9111 21 awsl 1uau r1J Iii 29WIB±) us 10 auomsl Jaom 9IfT

9111 91911W bon9q aicli 19V0 2111 .bOil9q nolismloI9l-iaoq 9111 (11 awsl aiñi 19V0 21 ii bns 1115v919i laom 9(1 01 b9mIsb 21 awsl \1U2Li lo 9)fIBllOqffIl

di 9ns1fD clliw c1iwoi imono9 ni1D9nnoD Anul 162USD 9(11 91911w borI9q .Jn9lsv9lq iaom ai awsl iiiau

arloIiDrlia9l ioriq lo notb9[91 bs9IqeSbIw 5 2ffB9 on d asw noiisrnlol95l 911T

nbbs11s 'cd rloiiirrnmms b9rnS 219r1n0191 '(1169 9dIT .nb1sl 129191th no alrlioq (18no1Ja (f) nzwsT .191D 9(11 d 91101) isdI 11s1uDzJ1sq r11bd191

a'igcIlijJ niilb 19r11UJJ bns nivlsD rIlod lo 2W91V dIthdI91 '9nom-11r1s 9111 tiio 1oc1 9(11 lo rliuom 9111 ni 11(1 s liq 01" 1B229D9fl esw Ii isrll 1119m91512 azJomsI

s iol b91J1s a9Dslq \1I6m (Ii 110116ffl101951 9f1T ".a19ui 9111 lo iisqmo beDslq 219r1r1o191 insM ."(0109bi lsiDl9mffloD-1Jc1B nsilanclD I1s9 lo cfflid9l

bus nlier 9111 lo IIOIILVIOV9I IBiDl9mfflOD 9111 01 noiizaoqqo *IBIa III e9V19am9d1l

.e911xJld19D dIM

119110 9101ff ai awsl iuau lo n0115x5191 a'no1Ism1oI91 9111 19v9woH

.1u2UJ ianiss lj1i1 9th lo noiJB1o1vn191 lsxiihiqa all (16(11 b919dm9m91

mob99lI rxiID9nnoD 21r19m91s12 auomth Ieom 9111 lanoms ai (OCt) e'19d9W (8Q) ff021914 .noilsmloI9l lainivlsD 9,11 1o 229DDU2 9(11 1111W ewsl iiuau moil

rIoiJfimloI9l 9(11 lo noxiDsrInoD 9(11 lo cloiJqiIDa9b aith iii m9b hfi1uDiimq 21

29Dff 612 1ff919111b !619V92 )lOOi 2111992 ii 191IJIJJ .ws1 '(1Ll2U lo noiJfirlimil9 1)116

Page 36: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

fJJ62G n2nLA JM2 M6L6 qbciu 10 6coLroLurc couqwou uq 26LAG 2WGJ9M2 OJJ0M!U 11J6 L61OLW91!OLF bLo/qqru 0W6 p9cJqu 0L IJGM 1JJ1

2rlbboLl I12IILX J9M2 UJOL6 2LozJgJA• JjJ6L6 2661152 fO J)6 6A9bOL911011 0 II2ATLA

irnpou 2916 !2 WOLG 0j OLLOM6L 16 w6qI6A9J cpracp uq porijq9LL9JJ6q 20 1JJ9 1JJ6 6P1OL2 JJ9A6 bojipcj boMGL I 9'J1JJ!U 11J6 WOq6LIJJ9M2 H0M6t6L' !1 12 jrnq j0 9L16 IJJ9I IJJ6 WO6LL IJ90IJ 21916 12 UOfwq b6Lp9b2 IJJG q6q1u6 0 OflJGL bopl!c9J Lonb2 IJJSI p61J6J16q LOW fI2ITLA

V" 9J16LIJ9lA6 6XbJ9I191!0I1 UJ1pf 21L622 1JJ6 qGCJJu6 0 1JJ6 CJJI1LCJJ2 9rIIIJOLIIA

JJJI6L621 L916 tfILIJJGL tLOJJJ IPG 20C19J Obl!WflIW

bLJcG J6A6J2 'V2 W61110U6q 69L1!6L L!2!11 buc6 J6A6J2 M!JJ UJ9J(6 9 X6q S6LO

wboL16q pA 1JJ6 b9is!2p 9uq b0Lffl1T626 10 E11L0b6' C9fl26 9 L9bq 426 !9120 M0LJJ 21L6221IJ 1151 1JJ!2 bGLIoq !2 0156 0 JJ!JJ 11U,J91!011 VIJJ6L!c911 ojq'

9JJ6U 20W6MJJ91 MJJJC15 W96 1156 9A9U962 0 (I2ITLX J9M2 J622 OPA!0112 II 12

L9162 9120 9(126 IJJG OblIrIlJgJ W1&L621 £916 lo 1126 vio !IJ6drJ9J!IA wA jJis

0L !UA62111J6U1 1119q6 (T2fILX J9M2 IIJOLG C021JX U OfIL uJ0q6 jJJJ6L gL0MJJ

IJJ!2 2p! 0 61p!C9J 21911q91q2 MUll 6COUOUJIC L0M1JJ CLG9IGL ObbOLlflIJ!1!62962 IJJGA MGL6 20 G96L 10 brIl 115626 J9M2 115 bJ9c6, j9MIJ6A 1L21 C01JIJ6C16

M6L6 0A6LJJ6IJ1 20 696L 10 6J111J!1J916 (I2IILA J9M2 MJJGU !IJ 1156 UJJ6

6XCJ126 10 Lq fJJ6W26JA62 0j 1J16 1LO(1J620W6 J612J91J0Ii

1lJL0f1P0ff1 bL0162f9I11 E0b6 E96LJX 0A6LI1W6U12 L92b6q 011 10 IJJ!2p111q2 JJJ!2 219161116111 p6C9Ju6 1156 GXCIT26 0L 1J16 qI2b9lcp O rI2J1LX J9M2

HGPL6M2 110 J0I16L 6X!212 9uq 1JJ6L60L6 1156 (12IILX L621L1C11015 110 J0U6L

GdflIlA 0L CJJ9LIIAU C9J1U12 P6J!6 M92 1J191 1156 L916L119J ILIP9J 0L6L 0 4J16r12rIL162 M6L6 0L16U 10 (12 2IWbJA' 6xc6bf !I1 20 9L 92 1116A 9L6 obbo26q 10

Ito J0U6L 116C6229LA Jll J46J20IJ2 1L9112J911015 0 CJ'W j go 1101 66J 1JJ91COWUJIIII!IA 61M66U N0291C 1111162 9uq T11J C6IJgn.X C6116A9 U19J(6 (I2flLX J9M2

9p9'q0UW6151 0 rI2flLA J9M2 C91A1J 9L1162 11591 1156 C15U6L611C62 115

C9IA!15 M611f 6A615 1TL1P6L 9uq PGC9U,16 1156 2b!L!1fl9J 0LC6 p6pluq 1156

q621162 0 1JJ6 L6J0J16L2 LOL 9 ,j46M 6Lr1e9J6uJ4, MJIJJ N0291C J9M2

booL r1bL126L2 915q 2rlbboLfGq 1156 CL6qIIOL2 IJq 1156 b1115c62 H6 L616C16g 1156

H0M6A6L 111 J5 CJIILIIIg 1JJ6 b6929u112 L6A0J1 JIG qi21911C6q pJW2GJ L0W 1156015 f1211LA H12 69LJA 26L11J0JJ2 (o J2J-J5o) M6L6 21LOUJA gup-n2rILX

Page 37: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

.LoJHou (j) 9Ln6y VJ16L1191/6J 1116 wGq!6A9J CJJITLCJJ WX J19A6

JC66b 1JJ6 Li1 10 JGuq 91 !1U6L61 10 IJJGW2GJAG2 ( 6JffUcj HGP6LI rqJJ9AG P6611 9 OLW O L61J1-G6JC11J 92 CJJ11LCJJ6 POIP OLLOM6 uq 6L6 10

prnj rib 192162 0L coiJ2riwbl!OIr I' IJJ6 W6q76A9J CJJITLCJ? (I2ITLX J9M2 iirnA

11591 1116 bflL2ffll O WOJJ6A M9216 1TJ6' q21L9cr6q 11.0W 26LA1C6 10 1116 21916 uq

OtI6U 19L6 M69JIJJ 6U6L9flA) jp6A 6fl6A6 11191 111161621 M92 11I1I191L9J iiq

111 CL66C6 1116 ocI.pce obbo2Gq 111161.621 6C9fi26 1116A obboe6q IL9Cj6 (uq

111111261110 J091J2

COUJWrIu11X 26IJ2pJA M91J12 10 1.6211.1Cc 1116 flJ1AI(T9J2, pij1A 10 OA6LCOUJIJJ1I

1116 bL1C6 0 pujarrbcA (b6LJJ9b2 II! JJ9A1U 10 C9L6 101. 1116 p9IJJaIlbl) 1JJ611 JJ6MJJ!CP 911 corijq 1Jq6pf JJ!UJ26W ii 1JJ6 cowiiiiiiiiA b9q 201116 0!1U61621 1916 L621L!CP0IJ2 266U16 10 JJØAG 66U uJfGiIq6q jo jiWi 1JJ6 6L66 10

I11UCI!0112 111 011161. 1TW62 EA6U 111 J2L96J (911q 6A61J 691.1161. 111 B9pAJoLr!9)

H0M6A6L W6 JJ!2101A 0 I12rILX J9M2 21T622 1JJ91 1J1626 J9M2 J19A6 26LI6 OIJJGL

JJJCOW6 IhI6dfi9JIlA 12 L6J916 10 LG2ILICIIOIJ2 011 11116L621 L9162

11.0111 111626 2J10CJC2 Jj16 CJ919 COIJIJLW2 IJJ6 WSIOL bL6qrccou o 11512 LuoqGJ:

11u61621 1.9162 91.6 9 M9A 0 L6C152PP111!U 111C0U56 10 1JJ026 MJJO J19A6 2fl6L6

LGCG1A6 U69TA6 !11C01J16 2JJOCJ(2 gbbL6CT9fG JOM flJ16L621 19162 K621L!Cp0112 OIl

fl2ITIX j9M2 bLoAlq6 9 bLIWmA6 W69112 0 20C9j !112r11911C6 Juq!A!qrl9je MJJO

AU ouqnou

J9M2 191. on1MGJp6q 1p611. p6u62

111U911011 uq JJ!JJ 6COIJOUJIC L0M1JJ 011156 J115 C6I11f1LX 1156 C0212 0 112111A

0J)A10fl2 p91 (I2rILX J9M2 1.62boIJqGq 10 6COIIOIJJIC C0uqc0I1e' 9uq M!1JJ IPG

COJJJW6I.C19J 2lL6IJlJJ IJJ!2 C0JJI16C$0I1 12 bo221p16' Pill Fl 2661112 GI6I1 11.1016

0W9L1 (J5) COrJu6CI6q C6L19111 L6601JJ2 1LOIJJ J6uq!u MInI 16M!211L621L911J12 bJ9XGq 9 W90L L0J6 III t0W6IJ1!I1 bL0162191J1 Gc0IJOW!C L0M1p

GCOUOW!C L0M1JJ M6P61 (To) 9Lf76 11591 L66011J 11.0W COWW6LC!91

1112 21111 1101 OpArOn2 JJOM FUJbOLI9IJI 1116 L6J9X91!oIJ 0[ 1JJ6 fI2rILA J9M2 M92 10

266J(JIJ M6M 01 II2IILA J9M2

11111C11011 1116 CJJ9U6 111 1156 J9M2 bLOAIC462 111116 6Aq6uC6 IOL 9 bilIG 1.6111-

Page 38: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

SJJOC16 1JJG L620111C62 0j 20C!GIA fO 1JJ6W26JA62

OflJJf 11217LX 6Ct12G TI2TILX M92 g u&cyoq IJJSI M9XM9Lq CJGL!C2 (12G 10

Page 39: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

eiiBJ 9viin6qmoD :xibn9qqA

211601 () b9i12iis Sm 2rIoiiibcxoD lSblo bnoD92 (fl as noI aA .t rioaoo1d1 IIi1i9) 9:161 129191(11 9th thiw 9211 bris 9vii69flflOfl 916 rbii 911:1 d bsilqqua

ai 3 (dC) io (X Ifs iol) oxsx ol 9aob Iin9bi1Iua ai (X)"U (sC) l9rIiiS bns 1)116 9110 0:1 9aob 1insbi1ua ei 3 () io O�(X)"U bns 9110 01 9201D 1,lin9billLJ2

muFidiliups 19*16111 ssil 9(11 01 920b '(1i1I9iDi111Je ai flhII9D 9161 12919111i 9(1:1

i1IBup911i Ithiith diiw 21161 1I1h9D 9JSI 129191111 IBIffhiqO 9111 119111 91B1 129191(1

(f) nsclw bns :19m 9 (BC) 1)118 () (t) arloiiibnoD nsclw 91omI9rfJ1&i .(I) bns 9:161 c1iwoi 9(1:1 rfiiw 292fl cIili9D 9161 :12919:1111 Ismiiqo 9th 119111 J<5I

.ii16up9ni borisq bnoea (111W 29211

'alSffcIBIq Ifiboa 9(11 lo noi1ibno l9blo Iaiil 911:1 .(') nOi:16up9 (111w rn9d 9W :rrz9ldolq

.[ (D)IU_(WD)tU] (5I)J + (5{)'J=5{6\(3 I I 51)V6 (t)

9th 01 b9q291 rliiw riorbnijl 91J16V IBbOa 9(11 10 9VIIBV119b 9(11 21 I6\V6 rioibiiiil B 26 ylthilqmi 9(11191) 9W .f1i!19D 9161 129191rn muffIiqO

,291J16V 1919m616q lo 192 ff9Vi a iol nh1i9) sisi 12919:1111 Ismliqo 9(11 cIidriDa9b 1Bth WOID! 9W ((19109th rioibrnil ibiIqmi 9111 niau bus

.(516\V6)\(X65I6\V6)-=X6\I6 (IA)

ifs iol X6V$16 10 1I12 9(1:1 O>5I6\V6 bms bIorf arIokiiboD 191)10 brIODSa 9Dffi2

29V1191) xlblI9qqB 21(11 lo 1291 911T .X65I6\V6 lo nk 9111 d b9rlirrn9i9b ai X (ta) 10 a9V1i6V119b 9(11 10 X65I6\V6 10 2IIi2 9111

b9nhISb ai ti bits (3 I I $)J aa b9nhI9b h9qo1q 910(11 21 (5I)J IIOIIDIILJI 9rIT

:1qqua (1601 a'in96 cbix 9111 1 anoiiibno 191)10 12111 9th moil

audi (J51+ID)'U$I=(J-1I)'U ()

\ ((WD)"UJ +(WD)'U) = J (iSA)

.YGX6\J6ryJ bns X6\J6J J&rfl xibn9qqs 9r1J Juoduoidl anoiJrr9vno b1fibne 9r11 9U 9W

8C

Page 40: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

O>((D)"U 51 +(1'ND)"U) \ ((WJ)uJJJ5J = J (iiA)

brie O<(('D)'U $U+(1'D)"U) \(( 1W)"j= 11J (iiiA)

O>((WJ)"Uff1÷(1WJ)t'JJ) \((WJ)"UD5J..= sJ (viSA)

bn (iiA) .9vithoq i (iSA) iscli au vi I noi1ioqo1 hi () noiiibrioj .9viJioq ei (iiiA) bns svi19n 1euouidmriu 9Th (viSA)

:smm9I 9VO1 01 liñ9w ai ii 1ciioq thu IA

uI9r1W .9vzIz2oq i rJ 119111 O 01 90b \11rI9iD11I.ua i (X)"TJ 11911W :t mmi .9vzJ1oq xs 51J bnB J 119111 I�M rioiiibb lii

,(iiA) r1iIfiuin919llib 119,11 o1 a16up9 (X)mU 11911W :1 ntiwJ 'o \ooi1 :thI9v (viSA) bcui (iiiA)

= J (iSA)

blIB ÷I)\(I5I+ I-)= J (IiCA)

.-÷I)\(51+ D-)= J (iiiCA)

91$ jJ bns J 1jJ 9D1Ii .I<51 11911W 9Vii9fl (iiiCA) brIB (iiCA)

iii 2rIoiJd1urI9q ionim '(11rI9bi1hJe O19S eILrp9 (X)"U 119(1W 9viIB9II IJDflI .9vrJiaoq 1)IS9W a111191 XM 9111 9vs91 111w (.)U 10 9ViiSVil9b biirli 9111

:1 noi1iaoqoi lo Iooiq sill ru a9iii1Lrp9rui 910ffl Owl 91J Iliw 9W 910fffl9th1IJ1

brie (i1A)

(W)uTJ<(J)tU (illA)

oJlil bluow i9miJruoD 19100q 11rli IDSI 9(11 moil smo Ii1up9fui iiil 9(11

Page 41: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

moil) O�J 1)116 9usD9d bus (.)U 10 'iQivsnoD 9(11 moil awollol .((t) rioiiibuoD

:ai X 1919mrnsq \JTh 01 b9qa9l cIiiw ('a) lo 9V115V119b 911T

+ (f rm9T} (CA)

÷ { rrriT} ''D(1 D) "U) J + ffll9TJ . 11119T} 'wD(WD)t'U)Jt

.019S aIsIJp9 111191 JiI1 9(11 muhdiliup9 19)FIsm 9911 9(11 01 9aoID 915 9W 11911W

Je9l9Mi 9111 uI1b1I91 f199Wi9d qulanortslei 9111 d b9fUml9i9b ai Ii 9aIw19f1iO 911T .(ICA) moil 9DcIia (IoLla9IJp (Ii 1919m516q 9(11 brts is1 9111 e9fls11D a9IJISV 1919msIBq 111 911s1b s wolf ab9fl91 m11 bnoD9a

9111 II .bonq b(lOD9a bus laiuI 9(11 ru aiis 191OO 9111 lo rioiiqmLJarIoD iaiil 9111 01 boil9q b110D92 9(11 moil 9fllODuIl e9flJdilTIaib9l 9fIsfb 1919m5mq

b99r1 9(11 9Dub91 111w 9cIsrF) 1919ms15q 9(11 119(11 aruasiib iiooq 9th iol boh9q 191F)il 9111 9)fI1VIIOD 01 1)9911 9111 29DLJb91 ii 9DcIia) 9151 1919i1Ii r1ir1 ioI

1919m516q 9111 clDirIw ol 11191x9 9111 aiD9fl9l mi91 bull 911T .(b1191 01 an9Lt1D

moil rns 9111 a9as9lDruz i'birlw ruibrI91 lo trnJomB 9(11 a9aE9lDuul 9II6f1D

9(11 e9lLJiqsD rn191 Isrnl silT .an9rjiD 1910O 9111 01 a9161 Jasl9iuui 1Ii19WOL

9111 (199W19d 9ffiODfli a9lsDo11691 a9u16v 1919m615q (11 9fI6(lD £ flDiflW 01 lf19lX9

.bonsq bfIoDsa 9111 ill flsSiJb iooq srlJ bus rIDii

xmI ini1 -- I ol scas1 tis siiG uT

d ii1sLvp9ni lsilini 1111w asvom 9161 Je9l9lffi fsmiiqo 9th won bull sW :(A) nOrIsLJp9 ui ii 1111w X 1Ibs1q91

+ {I ITI19T) J((J)t51(J)tU) (iA) + { misT}

+ (C rnI9T} ((qJ)t(wJ)),J .(1 ITfl9T} ((1J)'J(D)"U_( 1J)'WD(WJ)1'jJ)J

.O19 01 9aOb ai (X)"U nsnlw ,f smmsJ brus (i1A) moil sviiieoq ai .1 misT sisi 1a919111i J9*Ism 9911 9(11 01 seob ai I rurfw s1diilsn 10 019 ei f ml9T

O1

Page 42: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

oT .sIi iieirzi muridiliup9 j9*lBm 9911 9111 (D)'UfI=(1J)'U 9aufiD9d

noiu1oe 1s19cI9 9(11 b99r1 9w O�(X)"U 119(1W 9Viifi9fl ei t (rIl9T i&rli wo(1 101

- [(WJ)"U5J+(WJ)"U)\(51)'1WD(1WD) UI6516\J6 (A) (1WD)"U

:Ii 9V1iS9fl i (BA) isdi eu 119i 1I1ii1W91 ioniM

(WD)IIU()trWD(iWD)II'U51 (TA)

eA .9vrIE9n ai ('SA) iii ml9i iij1 9(1j Ø>J=(5f)t1WJ brrn O>(WD)tttU 9Drne

(TA) ni rnl9i bnoD9a 9111 bnB O>(D)"U O<(1"D)u'U51-

i&li rniuen O>(WJ)"JJ moil 9vii&9rI o16 i ml9i biicli 911T .9V1i69(1 ei .ablo(1 (TA)

:a& 119iJr1w91 9d nfl) (((fJJ5J)(q)uU -(fIJ1+1-)(f'D)"U)MJ) (iA) ru ml9T

((WD)"TJ M+( WD)t?TJ) \(( 1WJ) u(D) U÷(WD) (J)TJ) 5fJ (8A)

� ( WJ)'tU(J)"U afi rio! W J)" U M+(1WD)rtU)\51 J 9D111e

aidi O=(X)"U 119(1W .9Viifl9fl 1)lfl9W 9d Iliw (8A) (WJ)t'J(1J)"jJ 1q=qj I=) (1911w muiidi1iupe i9)hflm 9911 9(11 A .ablori ti1ELJpsrui

(19(1W oa Oi9X ai (8A) 9mui 2201)6 IflhJp9 2i notlq(rWailoD 119(1W . WJ=WD (1J1I9iDi11LI2 ei D bnfl mJJrIdlliups 19)hflm 9911 sc11 oi 9201) 1in9Di11ua 916 9W

.91dii19n 1116(1191 111w (8A) no 01 9201)

moil 119(11 9J61 19*Iflffl 9911 911Lt W019d 916 a9iuil i29191ff1 (1911W 19Viifl(I19i1A aA .926) t9*Iflm 9911 9(11 rn ns11i 19W01 916 211601 tsi11 WOn)! 9W Ct) rIOlithIIOD

926) J9)116(TI 9911 9(11 iij aboil9q aaons l6up9 26W '(di169w 9(11 lo noiiqmLr 2fl0 2291 9Vi9D91 brifl 2291 11601 rli1$9W 9111 bn I 216up9 liii a 3 26 I) 919(1W

.mumiiqo oi9mI 911) ai muhdiliup9 vi)qmo c1f b1&v91 nd 9vEd e19v91 9moDni 9D11O

9ms jrfi 9)S91D 111w bciE nibnid-crocr 916 9)61 i9AlSm 991 911) 9vod6 nEI19D 9)61 ie919ifl1

.ifi1 i*urn xnI 911) nx i ni1i 961 )nni di irft e& 911) ni oeodi e ifue91

Page 43: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

1ii1Bup9ni airiT .WD<1WD idi 92ED 9rft 9d won aum ii anBoI li9rIJ no 2rx1uii a9!!1rnJp9ni irIJ e9rD .O>(X)"U diiw briE (1=3 a rio1 as) 1qj<qj e9iIqrrIi

9911 9th wol9d nuhi 9i61 i919ifIi iol 9VxjE9cI ai (8A) Jsrfi jj .9J131 t9)hlBffi

d bus (iiiA cJ) O<11J 9Dnie 9viis9ri ai (iA) ui C rzrigT

.(iiIA)

i (JU 9rii 9ViiB91I i (iA) rii ml9T

O19 10 9v1iB9fl 1911J19 915 J1119i ILIOI his 9Dn9H .(iiiA 'id) O<11J bris 9VEDfIO)

.9vtJ59n ai (ieA) bus

mon1 ko -- 3 ot ic thrmc1 iT

:abi9i (A) ui 3 rhiiw X nbs1q9I

+ It fffI9TJ (iiA) + { ml9T} 'D( J)tttJ)J

+ (C rirI9T}

{I IIII9T} ((3)tqJ(J)IIjJ(3)IwJ(w)ttJJ)J

(ih'A) moil 9e1JED9d 9idiii9t1 10 9viJiaoq i 3gJ(( J)'U5J_(J)'U) I ml9T bus O19 o 9aob ei (X)t11U noilqmuiaas d 9Dnia bns

.9IdiiI9c1 Ia vitiaoq ai J bris i9m 91E I smrrl9l lo arioiiibrloD srhi oe f<5I

i ml9i aidT ( J( J)ttU) J as n9ithw9l 9d (16) ml9T .O>(J$I-I-f)- bus O>J O<J 9aUsD9cf 9viiieoq

•(J)'>(WJ)ttJ (iiA) mo'iI bus O>DJ 9aiIs)9d 9viiiaoq ai C rrrzgT

(19(1W •((DJ51-I-1)(D)"U-( D1 + I)('D)"U)J S II9fliIW9I 9d ns h ml9T a9mOD9d 1 ml9T oa (5UJ-s-1)\$ff-= DJ bus (D)"U=(1J)"U O=(X)"U

+<IC+1 1< 1 911j . +r)\( (WJ)'tUJ .9vIJiaoq el h rnl9T bus

on1 o -- 1 o tics siQ T

Page 44: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

:abI9i (CA) ni I rfiiw X rzbsIq95J

+ (I Ifll9T} J((J)'U5I(J)tU) (iiiA) + { miT} ((I)'D('D)"uqsI-(I)' 1D( J)"U)J

(C miT} ((SI) 'D( J)"U_(I) 'WD(WD)"JJ)J + ((J)U_(wJ)'U)1J

.9vrnaoq !As9w ai I ml9T (ilA) bus t £rnm9J riiaU

niaU .J as n9iihw9l 9d rISD misT rbiriw ((5I+ I)\D$U( 5I-- J asmosd misT O=(X)" 'U

.Ilsma ei misi airli O=(XY"U 01 saob oe .Oi9 2I511p9

+ (( J)U-(D)'U)1J as risithwsi sd ns C misT rz9ufW isuii iDBI Sift 9211 9W .sviiiaoq ai C (fli9T isrli svoiq oT •((1J5I-O-)('D)"U

ui io (XY'U(Y-X)+(XYU=(Y)'U (Diisibsup 21 cIOiJDfIIJI 9(11 1I9ifW .s.i) O=(X)"U

:ses aidi

(A) ($J f)\

isrli buil 9W 1J iol rzi1zji1adua bits (D)"U=(wD)"U rziaU

(5j f) J)"U(1J5J+ D)(WJ)"U)J (0 IA)

:aIsLrps C mi9T isdi 211 21191 (0fA) bus (?A) niuzidmoD

(I I A)

.sviiiaoq sd iaijm (hA) J<JI bits D<I sDrne

sill lo iswoq IsDiiiloq sill ilhiw 29211 laSishrli lsmiiqo srIT : oaocoi1 wS II .( 9A) iooq sill lo iswoq lsDiiiloq sill ilhiw alisi bus ( w) fIi1s9W

9(11 aiswol (14-1) mo' sill 10 isclmun to iswoq siLl 111 92591D111 its usd1 io) WiUO' 9111 lo iswoq sill 111 92fi91Dfl1 (IS fl9f11 II .fI1Ii9D sisi 129191111

Page 45: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

9vii1sqmoD 9di (I9fli qJ> w II .rnhi9D 9i1 ie9l9jnx rIi iswo1 (Jniiorzi

91fi rn.io' 91b Io iwoq I&iiiloq bci l9dmufI 9r1i rio iJfii -fl)\(.U4+S(1'1-r))=S tSIIj noiluiiiedu2 JfI9ifI9VfIOD 9(1J 9iJ 9W

:(') noiisup9 9iilW9l bru3 (q+tj(14

.0 =( ("1')

:ai m9IdOq a19nc1Iq !thoa 9th ioI noiiibrloD 19b10 iiiI W911 911T

516\V6 = 0 =( (hA)

:ischi awork oi b9qe9l I{jiW (') Io 9ViifiVil9b 9th niT 0<(WD)'U(5I)J=65I6\ V6 (tA)

S ihiiw 9an fIili9D 9i1 Ja9l9idH I6miJqo 9Th JJ1J eu a119i (1 A niau) rbicfw

C9Ci1 fIili9D 9Jfi1 ie919it11 Ifimtlqo 9th eur1T .q.i titiw eIIsI bus w titiw eaii 9i61 te9l9jnz Ismiiqo 9th bus 1rhi1s9w cft oi f19vi 9nsrioqmi IMDOC 9TH xiiiw

.Iooq 9(11 oi risvi 9Drlsiloqmi ISIDOC 9Th thiiw dEl ffuIi9D

:ei 14 oJ b9qe91 rhiiw 10 9Vth3Vfl9b 9ffT

(qw)=M6\6 (CIA)

.q<w Ii !no bus Ii 9vlJieoq 9C11J0D lo Ci TiDuffW

:Ci u at iD9qa9l iftiw 10 9ViJEVil9b 9(11 9Ciw9)liJ

\ (14- t)14(qw)uA6\6 (!hA)

•A<wA Ii Icio bus Ii 9v tieoq ci ruiss ibirIw

I(f1qE1ou!tha

.DiCCEID niurisI :riobrioj (I8I) .ho'1 \T ,9hJOiCilA

4$

Page 46: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

A0L?: HLb6L C0II!I'M6PGL' VJx (TO) 1I o\ J4GM

CPTCO LL622jL6A6L' VJP6L (Jj) cououc O%\I CJJICO: flhJ!I6L2A o

HLCOflL1 BL9C61gMIJ6A K H' (T5) 'flK o' L4GM AOLJ(:

EL6G J)L622

OmpLI M6LJJL (Th21) 1 voi C' J46M AOLJC IPGXJboL6: ['SM 10Ui J)L62'

gUg2Mwr }(' (j) tq o\ pqitu cooc oivJ,6LOIJ' bIll! (J) O °\ 11" 9mpLTq6 D6TJU01J' J6JJ'flIJIA6L2JcX bL6

V1OO1l91J 1°i" .1' (J2) 111 O'11t ti\ o cwpLiqG:AI6 flIJJAGL2JA LL6

L4G11IJ6L COp' JL9U2 (J) 31t ynii \J t!tJOW L46M H6U:cpOJ9L12 J)1622

M6f111GL 1cOp' LII2 (TO) L1" O OBt1 \J% '3UC1UflhIiA6LTçX JLG22

J4GfleIl6L' icop (J) jc ECO.O%C2 4 C!J!CO cjncoOW4°° CJJ!CO' fllIM6LiØ O CJJCO J)L622

4GJ2OU 9GIJ1W!IJ (J) j o\ nu jui oooc obflPPC90U2'yrwourq6 t{O262 (Th2) 1I CU Ot. hxct 46M )OLJC D0A61

HOPOJ(6U: K9A uq )G2JJ!A flhJJA6lX bLG2afGAJ6 yLOU (J) iUt SZ%kC

146M J,OLy: CJJLI62 cupu6L12 Ou2[oJJIJ CHM (Th04) B 0fl1I I"' C°' '1Ut%19c0P2' 19u6 (J5) o\ M6M AOLJ uqow H0n26ObJ' Y' H' (T2) yu.Mu itqt uicc ouqu: c6OL6 yjjir

JLG22EIUJGX' JtUI• (J) Ilic; \JUt1 cowu1\ 6LJ6J6X: flU!AGL2!X 0j cqOLIJ!9

KGUUTICff bL62'EqMq2' CJJ!Jb6LTC ji.u2 (T�j) i C° bOLl M2p!UloU

D62LflC!/611 1ornu o't ,couui\ :B91'WOJ M!1P9W 1' (iO) 11EIULGbL6U6UL2JJ!b: LOqnc14AG' flhJbLOqriCIA6 uq

Page 47: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

JJJG !Uf6L2GCI!OU O ['0U A91fl6 uq c° C JA62 J6 L6G w9LJ61 !U6L6 L96W6 booLGL COU2fIUJ6L 1U1G2 0116 bjrr WG T116LG2 L916

• ..co ,, 1p qIecorru6q wgLuJ n1!j!1A o 2GC0U b6uoq cou2nwb1ou LOL

fIG TIJI6L2GCPOU 0 fO9U JflG iiq C02 D A62 1JJ6 0bfUi9J !U1GL621 L9f6'b6Loq counwbiou OL 11J6 LIcJJ6L COU2IIUJGL• .CO R !2 ,,C0f \f, UI!1Jfl fJ16 2C9J6 q2cos1u6q W9LUJ9I 111fl!1A 0 26c0uqUJXrnn.62 1JJ6 potLoMGL,e MGJ1p6U — W6 W0110b201J!2,2 LY16

JJJG Ul6L2GC10U 0 f0911 ASJflG uq 02J 'T IAG2 11J6 LJ1GLG2I L6 IJJ0L JJ6 bOOL6L COIJ2I'IIJJ6L cj6q p1 1156 TIJT6L62 Lf6 uq J091J 6j92C!fA• ISCO 'sf,, 2 1p6 cfl2co(flJ6q W9LI19J (1IJ!IA 0 6couq bGUOq !UCOUJ6 OLCOU2IIIJJGL

•fou J(76,, M62 W9LTU npJIIA 0 IL2I b6L0q 1UC0UJ6 0L JJJ6 booLGL

ILJcGLG2c }�gg6

JItILG j: JJJG Obpurij I11GL6 LF$JG

0'12 O2 O'3

I212

1 '22

pogu gjneC

CO2 V

I

Page 48: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

JJJG !IJIGL2GC!OU o A9JI1G uq CO2 JA62 1JJ6 L66 W9LJ(61 1IJ6L62I L916

JJ6 booL6L COU2fIUJGL W62 0U6 bJri2 f6 1UfGL62 L6• ..co ,, ip q2conu16q urnLurnj njA o 26COU b6LIoq cou2rTwb1ou OL1116 !IJ6L26C1OU O fO9U AsifiG suq CO !A62 W6 obuij !U16L621 LgGb6Loq cou2rrwbou OL JJG LIcpGL COU2rnJJGL

• 1,cO , 12 ,,C021 y1 UJ!Uf12 1116 2Cf6 2COIUJf6 W9IIUJ IIf!JTfA o coisqUJ9X1WT62 q16 pOUOMGL12 M6JJp6!IJ -- JJ6 U10110b20W2J42 LGjJJ6 !IJ16L26CIOU O fO9U AG uq CO '1f 11J6 !1U6L621 L6

OL J16 bOOL6L COU2IIIJJ6L 2cJG PA 416 !1U6L6 L6 9IJ J091J 6J2PC!fA•4cO2 2 }16 q12conu6q WSL41J9J (TI1!IX O acouq b6LIOcJ !UCOWG OLCOU2IIW6L

• ,['O A91116 gIA62 jJ6 W9T.Wj ffIJ1A O TL2 b6uoq TIJCOWG OL 1JJ6 booL6L

ILJGL62 gc0 5 0 e 0S8 03

1•0

pogu AT11Gc02c c

coc

E!flLG : fOM K!I VA6L!0U

Page 49: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

-, 4

JJJG TLUGLCGCPOU o fO9U A9Jfl6 uq C02 C !A62 JJ6 LG6 W9LJ(61 U1GLGeI LfGJJ6 booLGL COUC(IUJGL PWG2 OUG bjne IJJG UJ!6LGC! L916

• .,C02 ( 12 1JJ6 qlecorru!Gq W9L1U9j 1T!!J!1A 0 CGcouq bGLIoq couenwbiou IOL1JJ6 IUI6LCGCITOU 0 ['09U A9!1T6 uq C0C B gIA62 JG obwj 1U1GL621 L96bGI4oq coueriwb OU 0L JJ6 4CJ16L COU21TW6L• ,,C02 B., !2 ,ICO2 V.. UJTUtT2 11J6 2C9J6 12C0flU64 W9L!U9! njiA o eccoUqW9XTW162 !1J6 POLLOMGL,2 M6JJ6flJ — 1JJ6 ujoijobouie,e L91G

fIG TU6L26C0U 0 fO9U /91T6 9uq CO V iA62 !1J6 !Uf6L62 L9J6tOL W6 bOOLGL COU2I1UJGL 2C9J6 pA 11J6 TU!6LG21 L916 9Uq J0911 6!S2C1JA

•,,CO2 V.. 12 fJJ6 qrecornJ!Gq UI9L1U9J 1Tfi1JA o ecouq bGLToq TUCOUJ6 LOLCOLJ2IIUIGL

• J'091J A9!fl6,, 1AG2 JJG W9L!U9J nppfA 0 TL2I b6Lroq wcouJG oL 11J6 booLGi.

IUfGLG2c }gç6012 03

12

CO2 C

I'OgLT AginG

CO2

EII1LG : j'o IU6dflJ

Page 50: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

\

JJJ6 TIU6L2GCPOU Oj rou AI'16 uq C°t C A62 qJG L66 WLj(6l !U6L62I L9161316 bOOLGL COU2I1UJGL 4JUl62 0U6 bJrI2 }J6 iI46L62 L916

• ..C' ,, 12 J6 qieconu6q uJ9Liu9j npj!1A o 26COU b€uoq cou2rIwbfIou oi.Jps UI6L26COU o JflG uq co II !AG2 p6 obtwj ru6L621bGuoq COU2r1wb4OU OL 1316 LICJIGL COU2I1UJ6L

• ..C021 B.. !2 ,.C021 V.. WTUII2 1316 2C9J6 qJecOsnJc6q 111!J!1A O 26COU

W9X11JJT62 1316 pOLLOM6L42 M6!IP6!U — fJJ6 WPUOb2OUT2I,2 L6

JJJG IIJI6L2GCIIOU O O9U MI116 uq C°4 V Y62 1316 TiJ16L62 Lf6 13JOL W6 booL6L COU2IIUJGL 2C9j6 pX 1316 !U6I62 LYG uq jOU 6J24C!A•,C0 ,, 12 1316 T2CO11U16 UJLIUSI filjJX O 26COU bGLIoq !UCOUJ6 OLCOU2IIIJJ6L

••F0'-' MJI164, 1A62 11J6 1JJLJ119 ITfJITrA O 41L21 .b6uoq IUCOUJG 40L 1316 booLGL

IIJ6L62 jgc6

I

O32 O3 O32

C

I.

I

AgTflG

EIflLG : H!I CLOMW

Page 51: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

261 pA IJJG L66 urn4(6çM6Jt9L6 L6 1316 !U16L261 L916 uq 20C!9J M6119L6 J6A6J MJJGU 1316 !Uf6L61 L916 !2

obiwJ IIl6L62l L916 JJI6 L66 W9LI61 !U16L621 L96 uq L66 WLI(61 2OCJCJJO26IJ pA 1116 bJgIJlJ6L uq 1JJ6 Ob11JJ9! 20C!9! M6fl9L6 2 4316 20C!9! M6flL6 MIWrrlTJifA M!W bGq6cl L!2J(-2JJ94U Jj16 Ob43JJJgJ 1U16L621 L916 12 1316 !U16L621 L62OCT91 M6flSLG RI 69CJJ C926 12 261 10 6L0 jJI6 TL21 P621 M6fl9L6 L6GL2 10 1316rrppA rnic;ou j<+çu(cl)÷[çu(cS) J6 COU9U1 16LW T2 261 20 1JJ 4316JjJ626 2!WrIJ9POU2 MGL6 b6LoLw6q M!lp 96U12 JJ9ATU 911 U16L16Wb0L9J

p18' T.JI'=I2ti=c?=JI8 I2 •�5' o\0

L=•2 JI=2' I2 T800 To\0 TO2 52o\0

L8' =TI:8' 221 SOo\0 o\0 558

l=•8TI'8'I2 1ô0 52o\0

(i) () (a) ('i) (2)M6J9L6 I{916 M6JIL6 J�916 M6JL6

A91ff62 OC19J 11116L621 0C!9J PJ16L621 2OCT91

JJ9L9WGI6L JjTL2l-B621 0b11U19J ObITW9J ELGG NYLI(61 LLG6 V[9LI(61

2xwnJspou2: fII!J!IA

Page 52: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

!2 26J pA fJJ6 L66 UJLJ(GV2OCJ M6J9L6 Y16 1JJ6 IJJ6L261 L916 uq 2OCIJ M619L6 JGAGI MJJGU 1116 U1GL62f L916M6JL6 MJJ obiwj !Ul6LG2 L96 1P6 L6G WYLJ(61 !TJIGLG2f LYIG uq L66 WLJCG13J6 TI46L62f L96 CJJO6U pA 11J6 b79u116L uq W6 obunij 20qJ M6JLG !2 fP6 2O9JM6JL6 L66L2 j0 JJG IIIIIIIA MIW 6LGC U2y-JJLfl1 fIGoburnj 1U16L621 LG 1220 1JJ91 IJJG 91119L1CA 20C19J M69L6 TU 69CJJ C926 12 26 O 6LO fIG 1L2f 62fi-rucpou K+(c'- yix[o' ci - J)+ p(c3- c5 - Q])jp6 COU2f.U GLUJ !2 26JjJ626 21UIffjS0U2 M6L6 b6LoLw6q 6U2 9MU 9U Tu6146wboL9j njiiA

Ii=e' =i•iI8' I2 OO 0J2 2o\0 015

tQII' I8 OO O2 01

L2 =TI2' I2 102 152o\0 52o\0

g=1

I 52o\0 0 52o\0 0

L?=8' =TI8 I2 .T2o\O

(i) () () () ()M6R9LG JG M6RL6 J6 MGJLG

M1fl62 2OC9J J.iJ6L621 oqj pJGLG2l OCTJJLW6GL LTL2-B62 O!UJ9J buij JLG6 A4q(Gf ELG6 y9LJ(6l

LiGc6Mi2c f1u691. fihijilA

JpJG jp

Page 53: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

2onLcc: %W2UC3 'nq2P0L1-LW Bfl!UGfl rou (vAcLc)

B4WC Jc (VAcsc oL Ac)COWWCLC!1I J9bcL (- woujp)

.LLc1znLA Bifi ( wotup)

BjFLa2 VCCUU (oO A)

8.4Qax

.JoT acJnc

COWbL!0*1 O PUG1 ic i?O suq jjIVBFE 3

I.4riae

fc2cubpou I2O iIflC

Page 54: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

ro O Iâ?0 EWb!OWCU 48 Q0 1O� 't5Q4 8QIô?O- 1ô80EWbIoAwCU QLOR4 42 OR3 03?2 001 180Ô

1ô?Opicowc QLO1 1ô10- 48 VO1 051Q O84 14Ô

picowc OACL oooBGCZJ O E"Th! !A!W 48 LV8?4 18t 18 3 IDflWWDCWOCL OOACUJOL 18 O4 0O2 0 1

2CPOOJ!UNcqlsu JG9I2 Oj 48 ô?0O iOô 130

HOIUbGCCU DbT1J(C1 18 45Q.2 1QQö ITO X48

N!UJnW BLC 18 822,X 3 Iti Q 13

DC4qOUØ2CLASOU uqLq U!WflW yIyL!wflw

2flWWT.A 2fl211C2LLVBTE

Page 55: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

= 2!U11C1U W I bcLccu JGAGJ= uiicsni bcuj IQAG!

= LP 10 bcLcIg

EWbIOAWQUr

°°t10 -0.11 03.* 0304** 01Q2 -O13

iooEWb10UGU QLO!AqJ -03Q* 0't1*** 0'tQ -00t't

làI0-1O0IUCOWG QLON4)J -0301 O80t*** -083*** 01l** -0***Z2000MIW IUC0UJG OACL

CGUgOIjSWIjrn 0.10 083I**s 08s** -031***DnWW?DWOCLS QOAGUJOL 0* 0428** -03I*2CpooJIUIIU A'2 O 0Q8*

HOn2!UbCLCQUL rJbqcq

.fliWflW

Z2000H0fl2!U 2CIJOOI!U DflUIUJA I1101JJ OACL 1010-l020 I0JO80

I Dj1bqLGq AGSL2 o QOACUJOL S1JJJJIC2 MIW QLOMj QLOMqJ EWbl0W9IUSX1UJnW bCLCCUI NI!" DGWOCL bGLCQIU O IUCOUJG EUJbIO}tWQUI i'OE o, oo

2!wbIG C0LLQ1!OU

£VBFE P

Page 56: siai - National Bureau of Economic Research · 1o1inoD 1ic11) 9e9r11 I07in0D iimiI 9(11 vJi1ids 10 9(11 \Ii11oqrn9i iooq 01 (wonod arid tort n99d as IIsw b9wth .f1iioirf T 9r1 2120D

= 2!U!UC8U( ST IPC I IGAC!

** = I1JJcSUt ST flJC bGLcGU jCACJ* = 1IJflJcSUT g qic 10 bcwcij jciqiSuqS1.q EU012 IJ bSIcIUIJCZC2

yqnzcq I� 00.0 0083 0O0 03ô0 018OP2LA3fIOU2MfrWpcLO 48 48 48 48 48

EWbJOAWCUI (oos)-tTIOg**

(oo)NX!WPW 1�ST 004**

2CP0OJ!U (o33o)cqTmJ ACSL2 Oj Fax3

1ô30-1ô20 ('t) (nio)JUCOUJG QLO1i1 1 -(1013DnWWA (oQ) (o)DCWOCIST OOACUJOL -'fl34 -ijfl000MIflJ IUOWC OACL (oo) (ooo.x) (ooa)bcLc lIT OJW1JTC2 -(1112 (1143 -0118**

HOI1ZUJ (oois) (0033) (ooto)I,CLclu D1Sb!U1 -003à** 1104** 11O*

IULcthT 103t 13ô20 1310 -338 (1834

(1) (3) (3) (4)

Dcbcuqcut AL!spJc: xiwnw

()OLOMfP 1ô0-180EWbJO)WJGIU

AP1:DcbclIqcuI

IVBFE t