silke weinfurtner- emergent spacetimes
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
1/101
Emergent spacetimes
By Silke Weinfurtner
and collaborators:Matt Visser, Stefano Liberati, Piyush Jain, Anglea White, Crispin Gardiner and Bill Unruh
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
2/101
Emergent spacetimes
By Silke Weinfurtner
and collaborators:Matt Visser, Stefano Liberati, Piyush Jain, Anglea White, Crispin Gardiner and Bill Unruh
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
3/101
Outlook
Spacetime geometry and general relativity
A world full of effective spacetimes
Concept of emergence
....
Emergent spacetimes bearing gifts:
From emergent spacetimes to emergent gravity...?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
4/101
Spacetime geometry and general relativity
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
5/101
space ( d ) + time ( 1) spacetime ( d +1)
Geometry of spacetime:
independent components (without dynamical equations)
In general relativity free particles are freely falling particles - noexternal force but remain under the inuence of the spacetimegeometry. The kinematical equations of motion for free testparticles following geodesics:
Spacetime geometryEinstein: Gravity a consequence of spacetime geometry!
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
6/101
General relativity also identies (in a coordinate covariantmanner) density and ux of energy and momentum in the n
dimensional spacetime as the source of the gravitational eld .
Stress-energy tensor:
Einstein tensor:
Einstein eld equations
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
7/101
Spacetime and gravity
spacetime
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
8/101
Spacetime and gravity
spacetime
Broad class ofsystems withcompletely different dynamics:
electromagneticwaveguide, uids,ultra-cold gas ofBosons andFermions;
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
9/101
Spacetime and gravity
spacetimeEinsteindynamics:
Broad class ofsystems withcompletely different dynamics:
electromagneticwaveguide, uids,ultra-cold gas ofBosons andFermions;
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
10/101
Spacetime and gravity
spacetimeEinsteindynamics:
Broad class ofsystems withcompletely different dynamics:
electromagneticwaveguide, uids,ultra-cold gas ofBosons andFermions;
xRestricted dynamics: Emergent gravity..?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
11/101
A world full of effective spacetimes
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
12/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
13/101
A simple example: Sound waves in a uid ow
The kinematicequations for small -classical or quantum - perturbations
(i.e., sound waves) in barotropic,invicid and irrotational uid aregiven by
Exact analogy to amassless minimallycoupled scalar eld inan effective curved spacetim:
The rst analogue model: Schwarzschild bh
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
14/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
15/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
16/101
Task:
Problems:
Results:
Relevance:
Can we use a uid to mimic a Kerr black hole?
+ Physical acoustics only for wavelength with:
+ Only 1 degrees of freedom for acoustic spacetime+ Conformal atness of spatial slice in acoustic metric
Penrose process; Superradiant
Scattering; Hawking radiationThe equatorial slice through arotating Kerr black hole is formallyequivalent to geometry felt by phononsentrained in a rotating uid vortex.
c k || v ||
Acoustic Kerr black hole
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
17/101
Natural occurence..?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
18/101
v 1 / r
v r
Sound of superradiance?A tornado is a violently rotating column of air,and outside its core it is a perfect example of anirrotational vortex:
The highest wind speeds recorded do not exceed150 m/s (about 0.5 Mach), due to different physics in the core of the vortex:
Idea:
Problem:
Possibility of supersonic wind ows in tornados..?
Natural occurence of acoustic bh
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
19/101
Propagation of ripples in a basin lled with liquid is governed by
velocity parallel to the basin
Advantage: Extreme ease with whichone can adjust the velocity of thesurface waves
Via the depth of the basin!
Gravity wave analogs of black holesAuthors: Ralf Schtzhold, William G. Unruh
Journal-ref: Phys.Rev. D66 (2002) 044019
Shallow water waves - theory
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
20/101
Dumb holes: analogues for black holesAuthors: William G. Unruh
Journal-ref: Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 366 (2008) 2905--2913
Figure 1. The left-to-right ow is supersonic (faster than the velocity of low-wavenumber gravitywaves) to the left of the stanchions and subsonic to the right. The jump in average level at thewhite hole horizon (where the decreasing velocity of the uid just equals the velocity of gravitywaves) can be regarded as a zero-wavenumber wave impinging on the white hole from the right.The undulating wave (which camps out due to the viscosity of the water) going off to the right haszero-phase velocity, but a non-zero group velocity, carrying energy away from the white holehorizon. Quantum mechanically, this would mean that the radiation from a white hole horizonwould not be thermal around zero wavenumber, but rather would be a non-thermal, high-frequencyradiation emitted by the white hole horizon.
ow direction
Shallow water waves - experiment
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
21/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
22/101
Manipulating electromagnetic waves in a wave-guide so thatthey experience an effective curved spacetime in the form ofa (2+1) dimensional Painleve-Gullstrand-Lemaitre geometry.
Wave-guide consistsof a ladder circuit with:Time-dependent capacitanceCoil in each loop has constant inductanceCurrent in each circuit is given byEffective potential , such thatFor wave-length the discretness of the x-axis isnegligibly small, hence :
where
R. Schuetzhold and W. Unruh. Phys. Rev. Lett. , 95:14, 2005.
Electromagnetic wave guide - lattice structure
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
23/101
Bose-Einstein condensate -a quantum model
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
24/101
Concept of emergence
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
25/101
The concept of emergence
Emergent spacetimes involveA microscopic system of fundamental objects(e.g. strings, atoms or molecules);
a dominant mean eld regime, where the microscopicdegrees of freedom give way to collective variables;
a geometrical object (e.g. a symmetric tensordominating the evolution of linearized classical and
quantum excitations around the mean eld;An emergent Lorentz symmetry for the long-distancebehavior of the geometrical object;
high temperature p
low temperature p
f i r
s t
- o
r d
e r
ph
a s e
tr
an
si
ti
on
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
26/101
Example BEC [microscopic degrees of freedom]
A microscopic system of fundamental objects:
ultra-cold ! lute gas of weakly interaMicroscopic theory well understood:
Emergent spacetimes from Bose-gas
H = d x 2
2 m2 + V ext +
U
2
= exp( i )SO(2) symmetry
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
27/101
Example BEC [macroscopic variables]
A dominant mean eld regime:
Bose-Ein " ein condensate Spontaneous symmetry breaking:
Emergent spacetimes from Bose-gas
(t, x ) = (t, x ) = n 0 (t, x ) exp( i 0 (t, x )) = 0
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
28/101
Example BEC [geometrical object]
Small perturbations - linear in density and phase - in the
macroscopic mean-eld emerging from an ultra-coldweakly interacting gas of bosons are inner observersexperiencing an effective spacetime geometry,
where
Emergent spacetimes from Bose-gas
gab =c0
U/
2d 1
c20 v2 vx vy vz vx 1 0 0 vy 0 1 0 vz 0 0 1
;
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
29/101
Emergent spacetimes from Bose-gas
An emergent Lorentz symmetry:
Bogoliubov !# ersion relation for
Macroscopicvariables
Microscopicvariables
Example BEC [Emergent Lorentz symmetry]
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
30/101
On inner and out observer and absolute
Inner observer :Small excitations in the systemexperience an effective spacetimegeometry represented by themacroscopic mean-eld variables!
Outer observer :
Live in the preferred frame - thelaboratory frame, such that thecondensate parameters are functions of lab-time (absolute time).
(t, x ), (t, x ) = i (x x )
n (t, x ), (t, x ) = i (x x )
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
31/101
Semi-classical quantum geometry
Small perturbations around some background solution
In a generic Lagrangian , depdending only a singleScalar eld and its rst derivatives yields an effectiveSpacetime geometry
For the classical/ quantum uctuations. The equation of Motion for small perturbations around the backgroundAre then given by
C. Barcelo, S. Liberati, and M. Visser. Analog gravity from eld theory normal modes?Class. Quant. Grav. , 18:35953610, 2001.
Effective curved-spacetime quantum field theory description of the linearization process:
Kinematics versus dynamics!
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
32/101
....
Emergent spacetimes bearing gifts:
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
33/101
Signature of spacetime
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
34/101
Signature of spacetime - why (-,+,+,+)?
Spacetime foliation into non-intersecting spacelikehypersurfacese (Lapse and Shift)
Signature of spacetime is a certain pattern ofEigenvalues of the metric tensor at each point of themanifold [Loretzian (-,+++) or Riemannian (+,+++)]
There is no driving mechanism within GR that driveschanges in the signature of the geometry...
Kinematics of signature change (Lapse is a non-dynamical variable)
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
35/101
Signature of spacetime - what is it really?Spacetime foliation into non-intersecting spacelike
hypersurfacese (Lapse and Shift)ds 2 = gab dx a dx b = ( n a n a ) N
2 dt 2 + h ij (dy i + N i dt ) (dy j + N j dt )
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
36/101
BEC: Interactions spacetime signature
c 20 c (t )2
U U (t ) gab = c(t)U (t)/
2d 1
c(t)2 0 0 0
0 1 0 00 0 1 00 0 0 1
v
0
c20 =n 0 (t, x ) U (t )
m
U > 0 repulsive ;U < 0 attractive .
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
37/101
BEC: Interactions spacetime signature
c 20 c (t )2
U U (t ) gab =c(t)U (t)/
2d 1
c(t)2 0 0 0
0 1 0 00 0 1 00 0 0 1
v
0
c20 =n 0 (t, x ) U (t )
m
U > 0 repulsive ;U < 0 attractive .
gab + c(t )
2
0 0 00 +1 0 00 0 +1 00 0 0 +1
g ab
c(t )2
0 0 00 +1 0 00 0 +1 00 0 0 +1
Lorentzian signature Riemannian signature
U > 0 repulsive ;U < 0 attractive .
l h
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
38/101
Daily signature change events...
The bosenova experiment:
l h
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
39/101
Daily signature change events...
The bosenova experiment:
Lorentzian signatureRiemannian signature
ld h f ld
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
40/101
Quantum eld theory on Riemannian manifolds
Q ld h Ri i if ld
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
41/101
Quantum eld theory on Riemannian manifolds
D il i h
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
42/101
Daily signature change events...
Can we understand the bosenova experiment via the emergentspacetime programme?
Need to understand particleproduction process via
sudden variations in atomic-interactions...
Q ld h Ri i if ld
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
43/101
Quantum eld theory on Riemannian manifoldsPhysical grasp on quantum field on Riemannian manifolds super-Hubble horizon modes in cosmology:
Mechanism responsible for enormous particle production worksanalogous to cosmological particle production during ination:
vk (t ) + e ff v k (t ) = 0 ,
2at = k
A+ m 2
Q ld h Ri i if ld
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
44/101
Quantum eld theory on Riemannian manifoldsPhysical grasp on quantum field on Riemannian manifolds super-Hubble horizon modes in cosmology:
Mechanism responsible for enormous particle production worksanalogous to cosmological particle production during ination:
vk (t ) + e ff v k (t ) = 0 ,
2at = k
A+ m 2
k (t ) + k2
e 2 Ht+ m 2 d
2
H 2
4 k (t ) = 0
m < dH
2
k < k HubbleHorizon
Q t ld th Ri i if ld
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
45/101
Quantum eld theory on Riemannian manifoldsPhysical grasp on quantum field on Riemannian manifolds super-Hubble horizon modes in cosmology:
Mechanism responsible for enormous particle production worksanalogous to cosmological particle production during ination:
vk (t ) + e ff v k (t ) = 0 ,
2at = k
A+ m 2
k (t ) + k2
e 2 Ht+ m 2 d
2
H 2
4 k (t ) = 0
m < dH
2
k < k HubbleHorizon
frozen modes all modes are *frozen*
Signicant particle production on ALL scales!???
T Pl ki b t i t
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
46/101
Trans-Planckian beats signatureHydrodynamic approximation: Variations in the kinetic energyof the condensate are considered to be negligible, comparedto the internal potential energy of the Bosons.
2
2 m
2 n 0 + nn 0 + n U
U = U 2
4mn 0( n 0 )2 ( 2 n 0 )n 0
n 20
n 0
n 20+ 2
Keeping quantum pressure term leads to effective interaction seen by inner observer:
condensate in box[uniform number density]
harmonic trap[position dependent sound speed]
H = dx 2 m 2 + V ext + U 2
T Pl ki b t ig t
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
47/101
condensate in box[uniform number density]
Trans-Planckian beats signature U = U
2
4mn 0( n 0 )2 ( 2 n 0 )n 0
n 20
n 0
n 20+ 2 U = U
2
4 mn 0
2 .
healing length:
k 2 m k
2 k c (t ) k
k
2k = c (t ) k 2 + 2m
2
k 4
Lorentz
symmetry
2 (t) = qpc(t)
2
= / 2mc(t)
2
c 2 (U ) = n 0 U m
c 2k ( U ) = c2 (U ) +
2m
2
k 2
T Pl ki b t ig t
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
48/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
hydrodynamic
approximationmodied hydrodynamics[including quantum pressure effects]
Number of quasiparticlesinnite!?
T Pl ki b t ig t
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
49/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
hydrodynamic
approximationmodied hydrodynamics[including quantum pressure effects]
Trans Planckian beats signature
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
50/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
hydrodynamic
approximationmodied hydrodynamics[including quantum pressure effects]
U| ik U k = U +2
4 mn 0k 2
Trans Planckian beats signature
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
51/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
Trans Planckian beats signature
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
52/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
Trans Planckian beats signature
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
53/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
Trans Planckian beats signature but why?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
54/101
Let s do quantum gravity phenomenology, in the sense of anultra-high energy breakdown of Lorentz symmetry
d +1 F ( d ) = m where
Trans-Planckian beats signature - but why?
Trans Planckian beats signature but why?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
55/101
Let s do quantum gravity phenomenology, in the sense of anultra-high energy breakdown of Lorentz symmetry
d +1 F ( d ) = m where
d +1 is the spacetime DAlembertian d +1 =
1
g d +1 a g d +1 g
ab b
Trans-Planckian beats signature - but why?
Trans Planckian beats signature but why?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
56/101
Let s do quantum gravity phenomenology, in the sense of anultra-high energy breakdown of Lorentz symmetry
d +1 F ( d ) = m where
d is a purely spatial DAlembertian d =
1
g d i g d g ij j
d +1 is the spacetime DAlembertian d +1 =
1
g d +1 a g d +1 g
ab b
Trans-Planckian beats signature - but why?
Trans Planckian beats signature but why?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
57/101
Let s do quantum gravity phenomenology, in the sense of anultra-high energy breakdown of Lorentz symmetry
d +1 F ( d ) = m where
d is a purely spatial DAlembertian d =
1
g d i g d g ij j
d +1 is the spacetime DAlembertian d +1 =
1
g d +1 a g d +1 g
ab b
2e ff ective = A
d
m2
+ F (k2
/A ) + k2
/A
i sinh E m 2 + k2 /A + F (k2 /A ) Ad/ 2 dt
Trans-Planckian beats signature - but why?
Trans-Planckian beats signature
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
58/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
i sinh E m 2 + k2 /A + F (k2 /A ) Ad/2 dt
Particle production in *real* world with naive LIV terms:
Trans-Planckian beats signature
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
59/101
Trans-Planckian beats signature
i sinh E m 2 + k2 /A + F (k2 /A ) Ad/2 dt
Particle production in *real* world with naive LIV terms:
i sin E B m 2 + 2qp k4 + B k 2 /A A d/ 2 dt
Particle production in analogue *world* - a BEC - withquantum pressure correction to the mean-eld:
Conclusions for signature change events
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
60/101
Conclusions for signature change events
* quantum modes on a Riemannian manifold have like super-Hubble horizon modes during ination=> Explains particle production
* Signature change events in the *real* universe show seriousproblems: driving the production of an innite number ofparticle, with innite energy, which are not removed bydimension, rest mass, or even reasonable sub-class of LIV
Conclusions for signature change events
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
61/101
Conclusions for signature change events
* quantum modes on a Riemannian manifold have like super-Hubble horizon modes during ination=> Explains particle production
* Signature change events in the *real* universe show seriousproblems: driving the production of an innite number ofparticle, with innite energy, which are not removed bydimension, rest mass, or even reasonable sub-class of LIV
If there is a way to drive sig. change events within therealm QG, there should be a mechanism to regularize the
innities..! (Analogue to the situation in the BEC)
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
62/101
Quantum gravity phenomenology
Quantum gravity phenomenology [LIV]
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
63/101
Quantum gravity phenomenology [LIV]QGP: Summarizes all possible phenomenological
consequences from quantum gravity . While differentquantum gravity candidates may have completely distinct
physical motivation, they can yield similar observableconsequences, e.g.
.
1) Presense of a preferred frame;2) All frames equal, but transformation
laws between frames are modied.
D. Mattingly. Modern tests of Lorentz invariance. Living Reviews in Relativity , 8(5), 2005.
Analogue Lorentz symmetry breaking
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
64/101
Analogue Lorentz symmetry breaking
Bose-Einstein condensate:
Electromagnetic waveguide:
Symmetry breaking mechanism in different analogue modelslead to model-specic modications:
Despite all fundamental differences similar modications:
Any emergent spacetimes based on analogue models per denhave a preferred frame: The external observer.
Generating a mass and Goldstones theorm
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
65/101
[*] Back to the equation of motion -Can we extend the class of elds...
[*] Mass generating mechnism - Explicit symmetry breaking...
Generating a mass and Goldstone s theorm
[*] Goldstone
s theorem - Spontaneous symmetry breaking...
Goldstones theorem
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
66/101
Goldstone s theorem...
... whenever a continuos symmetry is spontaneouslybroken, massless elds, known as Nambu-Goldstonebosons, emerge. [Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell, A. Zee]
Per denition Bose-Einstein condensation always (spontaneously) breaks SO(2) symmetry of many-body
Hamiltonian!!!
= d x 2
2 m2 + V ext +
U
2
= exp( i )SO(2) symmetry
Mass generating mechnism - all about symmetries
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
67/101
Mass generating mechnism all about symmetries
Explicit symmetry breaking through
transitions in a 2-component system
M. Visser and S. W. Phys. Rev. , D72:044020, 2005.
U AB
U AA
U BB
Mass generating mechnism - all about symmetries
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
68/101
Mass generating mechnism all about symmetries
Explicit symmetry breaking through
transitions in a 2-component system
M. Visser and S. W. Phys. Rev. , D72:044020, 2005.
U AB
U AA
U BB
Mass generating mechnism - all about symmetries
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
69/101
Mass generating mechnism all about symmetries
Explicit symmetry breaking through
transitions in a 2-component system
M. Visser and S. W. Phys. Rev. , D72:044020, 2005.
U AB
U AA
U BB
Mono-metricity
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
70/101
Mono metricityMore complicated hyperbolic wave equation:
Emergent massive elds
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
71/101
Emergent massive elds
the acoustic metrics are given by
In-phase perturbtion (= mass zero particle):
Anti-phase perturbtion (= mass non-zero particle):
Collective excitations + microscopic ngerprints
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
72/101
Collective excitations microscopic ngerprintsBeyond the hydrodynamic approximation...
[1] S. Liberati, M. Visser, and S. W.. Class. Quant. Grav. , 23:31293154, 2006.[2] S. Liberati, M. Visser, and S. W.. Phys. Rev. Lett. , 96:151301, 2006.
Bogoliubov dispersion realtion for 2-comp. sys.
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
73/101
ogo ubov d spe s o ea t o o co p. sys.
Naturalness problem in emergent spacetime
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
74/101
p g p
Dispersion relation obtained from our CMS has the form:
* CPT invariant (LIV in the boost subgroup)
* has the form as suggested in many (non-renormalizable) effective eld theory approaches* natural suppression of low-order modications in our model!
* analogue LIV scale is given by the microscopic variables:* not a tree-level result. results directly computed from fundamental Hamiltonian* -coefcients are different for
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
75/101
Cosmolgoy
On robustness...
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
76/101
Robustness (against microscopic modications) of quantum eld
theory in emergent spacetimes?
Emergent FRW universe emerging from Bose gas:Microscopic substructure induces Lorentz symmetry breaking
as suggested by many Effective eld theories, i.e. , preferredframe induces non-linear dispersion in the boost-subgroup.
Particle production in general is not robust and signicantmodication may appear.
S. Liberati, M. Visser, and S. W.. Naturalness in emergent spacetime. Phys. Rev. Lett. , 96:151301, 2006.
P. Jain, S. W., M. Visser, and C. Gardiner. Analogue model of an expanding FRWuniverse in BoseEinstein condensates: Application of the classical eld method.arXiv:0705.2077, 2006. Accepted for publication in Phys. Rev. A.
Application for real cosmology?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
77/101
Are there any general lessons to be learnt from emergent FRW
spacetimes - incorporating model-specic modications - for cosmology?
Planck-modications
Rainbow geometry k-dependent commutator relation for matter fields
Group and phasevelocity
Dispersionrelation
Cosmologicalhorizons
Modications in:
pp gy
Rainbow geometries
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
78/101
Emergent spacetime exhibits explicit momentum-dependence:
Macroscopic variables determine metric components:
Speed of sound for perturbations in the condensate:
Background velocity as gradient of the phase of the condensate:
Where represents the UV correction!
g
Rainbow FRW geometries
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
79/101
In (2+1) dimensions - for time-dependent atomic interactions - we get:
Where the time- and momentum dependence enter as follows:
The closest to a de Sitter like expansion (exact de Sitter inon infrared scales) is given by:
g
Rainbow FRW geometries
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
80/101
ak (t) = exp(2 H t) + (k / K) 2
In (2+1) dimensions - for time-dependent atomic interactions - we get:
Where the time- and momentum dependence enter as follows:
The closest to a de Sitter like expansion (exact de Sitter inon infrared scales) is given by:
g
Emergent scale factor during ination
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
81/101
t|k |
a k
01
23
10 40 50100
150200
10 2
10 0
10 2
(a) Scale factor without quantum pressure effects ;t s = 1 10 5 .
t
a k
0 1 2 3 10 4
10 2
10 2
10 0
10 0
10 2
10 2
(b) Scale factor without quantum pressure effects;t s = 1 10 5 .
t|k |
a k
01
23
10 40 50100
150200
10 2
10 1
(c) Scale factor quantum pressure effects ; t s =1 10 5 .
t
a k
0 1 2 3 10 4
10 2
10 1
(d) Scale factor quantum pressure effects; t s =1 10 5 .
g g
Emergent scale factor during ination
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
82/101
t|k |
a k
01
23
10 40 50100
150200
10 2
10 0
10 2
(a) Scale factor without quantum pressure effects ;t s = 1 10 5 .
t
a k
0 1 2 3 10 4
10 2
10 2
10 0
10 0
10 2
10 2
(b) Scale factor without quantum pressure effects;t s = 1 10 5 .
t|k |
a k
01
23
10 40 50100
150200
10 2
10 1
(c) Scale factor quantum pressure effects ; t s =1 10 5 .
t
a k
0 1 2 3 10 4
10 2
10 1
(d) Scale factor quantum pressure effects; t s =1 10 5 .
g g
Cosmological horizons
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
83/101
Phase velocity:
Group velocity:
Beyond the hydrodynamic limit: phase velocity group velocity
spaceMaximum distance a signal sent at t 0 can travel:
within the hydrodynamic limit
No cosmological horizon..
How far can a signal travel in areal BEC..?
No cosmological horizon..
g
Hubble parameter?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
84/101
Modied Hubble parameter:
Early times
Late times
Hubble frequency?
time
Frequency ratio
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
85/101
Characteristic value of particle production in thehydrodynamic limit:
Equation of quantum modes in the hydrodynamic limit:
Sign determines nature of quantum modes!
Modied frequency ratio
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
86/101
Modied frequency ratio:
Turning point:
Freezing and melting of quantum modes
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
87/101
Hubble horizon
Crossing andre-entering ofHubble horizonduring inationaryepoch! Inationcomes naturally toan end.
Can one alwaysunderstand the
particle productionin terms of thefrequency ratios?
Simulations versus quantitative predictions
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
88/101
t|k|
N k
01
23
10 40
50 100150 200
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
(a) N k (t ).
t|k|
R k
01
23
10 40
50100
150
100
105
1010
(b) R k (t ).
t
N k
0 1 2 3
10 4
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
(c) N k (t ) projected onto the t - N k plane. (d) R k (t ) projected onto the t - R k plane.
Planck-length during ination
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
89/101
In some sense we are dealing with a relative scale-shiftbetween the two frames, a time-dependent Planck-scale,
that enters the scale factorof the universe and the effective Hubble parameter
in an unexpected way. (Thenon-perturbative corrections have to be included at thelevel of the hydrodynamic uid equations.
Lorentz symmetry breaking due to a preferred frame (in ourspecic spacetime) has non-negligible effects on the particle
production process as the preferred frame is static!
a FRW (t ) = a FRW ,0bn(" )
ba (" )
12(d 1)
Planck (t ) =# qp
c(t )=
# qp
c0 bn(t )ba (t )
= Planck ,0
bn(t )ba (t )
However it is possible to mimic an expanding universe and keep theeffective Planck length constant:
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
90/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
91/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
92/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
93/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
94/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
95/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
96/101
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
97/101
From emergent spacetimes to emergent gravity...?
Emergent gravity
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
98/101
spacetime
Einstein
dynamics: x
Broad class ofsystems withcompletely different dynamics:
electromagneticwaveguide, uids,ultra-cold gas ofBosons andFermions;
(1+4) dimensionalquantum Halleffect, quantumrotor model;
spin-2particle?
Restricted dynamics: Emergent gravity..?
Emergent gravity
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
99/101
spacetime
Einstein
dynamics: x
Broad class ofsystems withcompletely different dynamics:
electromagneticwaveguide, uids,ultra-cold gas ofBosons andFermions;
(1+4) dimensionalquantum Halleffect, quantumrotor model;
spin-2particle?
Restricted dynamics: Emergent gravity..?
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
100/101
Id like to thank Matt and everyone at VIC for the warm welcome!
books on the Emergent Spacetime / Analogue Models for Gravity:Articial black holes (Novello, Visser, Volovik)The universe in a helium droplet (Volovik)Quantum Analogues: From phase transitions to black holes and cosmology (Unruh, Schuetzhold)
-
8/3/2019 Silke Weinfurtner- Emergent spacetimes
101/101
books on the Emergent Spacetime / Analogue Models for Gravity:Articial black holes (Novello, Visser, Volovik)The universe in a helium droplet (Volovik)