single- and two-component grb spectra in the fermi gbm-lat ... · overview 1 introduction 2...
TRANSCRIPT
Single- and Two-Component GRB Spectrain the Fermi GBM-LAT Energy Range
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros
Dept. of Astronomy & Astrophysics,Dept. of Physics and Center for Particle Astrophysics
Pennsylvania State University
arXiv:1202.2821
5/7/2012
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 1 / 16
Overview
1 Introduction2 Magnetic dynamics3 Radiation components
Prompt emissionRadiation from rdec
4 Example spectraTheoreticalObserved
5 Conclusions
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 2 / 16
Introduction
Before Fermi - EGRET and projections for LAT
Extra component and/or cutoff
Hints of extra PL componentGonzalez et al. (2003)LAT GRBs predicted Band etal. (2009) -higher thanobservedSign of tentative cutoff inprompt (Kocevski et al.1201.3948)
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 3 / 16
Introduction
Before Fermi - EGRET and projections for LAT
Extra component and/or cutoff
Hints of extra PL componentGonzalez et al. (2003)LAT GRBs predicted Band etal. (2009) -higher thanobservedSign of tentative cutoff inprompt (Kocevski et al.1201.3948)
Number Of Photons Detected1 10 210 310
Nu
mb
er O
f G
RB
/yr
1
10
>1 GeV
>10 GeV
>100 MeV
>1 GeV
>10 GeV
All selected Burst
Only bursts with Beta<-2
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 3 / 16
Introduction
Before Fermi - EGRET and projections for LAT
Extra component and/or cutoff
Hints of extra PL componentGonzalez et al. (2003)LAT GRBs predicted Band etal. (2009) -higher thanobservedSign of tentative cutoff inprompt (Kocevski et al.1201.3948)
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 3 / 16
Introduction
Fermi GBM/LAT observations
GRB 080916C-smooth Band functionGRB 090902B-extra power law comp.GRB 090926A-extra PL comp.+ break
goals: reproduce simple PL high energy behaviour, extra PL and cutoff
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 4 / 16
Introduction
Fermi GBM/LAT observations
GRB 080916C-smooth Band functionGRB 090902B-extra power law comp.GRB 090926A-extra PL comp.+ break
goals: reproduce simple PL high energy behaviour, extra PL and cutoff
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 4 / 16
Introduction
Fermi GBM/LAT observations
GRB 080916C-smooth Band functionGRB 090902B-extra power law comp.GRB 090926A-extra PL comp.+ break
goals: reproduce simple PL high energy behaviour, extra PL and cutoff
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 4 / 16
Introduction
Fermi GBM/LAT observations
GRB 080916C-smooth Band functionGRB 090902B-extra power law comp.GRB 090926A-extra PL comp.+ break
goals: reproduce simple PL high energy behaviour, extra PL and cutoff
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 4 / 16
Magnetic dynamics
Magnetically dominated jets
Magnetic dynamics: Γ ∝ r1/3 (baryonic Γ ∝ r)εB goes from ≈ 1 in the prompt to . 10−1 at rdecDissipative photosphere: reconnection, weak shocks, turbulencePhotosphere in accelerating phasePrevious studies: Band-like prompt spectrum naturally arises-Vurm et al. 2011, Thompson 1994, Giannios and Spruit 2007
Γphot.
R Rphot. saturation deceleration
magnetic model
R
η
barionic model
~R1/
3
Γ
Γ~
R
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 5 / 16
Radiation components
Radiation Sources- Two Zone Model
Prompt component from photosphere (e.g. Beloborodov 2010)FS/RS synchrotronPrompt up-scatters on FS/RS electrons (Murase et al., 2011)FS/RS SSC (Sari & Esin, 2001)BB, BB+FS, BB+RS (Ryde, 2005; Ando & Meszaros, 2008)p+ sync., FS+RS, RS+FS (Razzaque et al., 2009, He et al., 2011)Max synch./KN cutoffs (Guetta & Granot, 2003)
RphRdec
RS FS
RS−EICFS−EIC
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 6 / 16
Radiation components Prompt emission
Prompt Emission from Magnetic Dissipation
Magnetic energy dissipates at rph (e.g. semirelativistic shocks)(Giannios 2007, Lazzati & Begelman 2011, Meszaros & Rees,2011, McKinney & Uzdensky 2011)E.g. Alfvenic turbulence naturally produces the Band function withα = −1, β = −2 (Thompson, 1994)Prompt peak is synchrotron radiation from photosphere
rph = 6.5× 1012 cm L3/5t ,53 r2/5
0,7 η−3/5600 ∼ 0.5 AU
Γph = (rph/r0)1/3 = 87 L1/5
t ,53ζ1/5r r−1/5
0,7 η−1/5600
εobsph,syn = 310 keV ζ−1/2
r (1 − ζr)1/2r1/2
0,7 ε1/2B,0 Γ
3r(1+z
2
)−1
weak thermal componentT(rph) = 2.7 keV L−1/60
t ,53 ζ−4/15r η
4/15600 r−7/30
0,7 Γ−1/2r
(1+z2
)−1
Pairs at the photosphere? -consider both cases.
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 7 / 16
Radiation components Radiation from rdec
Forward- and Reverse Shock
At rdec = 4.8× 1016 cm ∼ 3000 AUεB goes from ≈ 1 to . 10−1
FFSmax(εc) = 0.15 Jyεc = 3.7 eV (UV) FAST coolingFRS
max(εm) = 92 JyεRS
m = 1.1× 10−5 keV (FIR) SLOW coolingCutoff at ε(γMAX)
Does a RS develop?- take both cases
RphRdec
RS FS
RS−EICFS−EIC
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 8 / 16
Radiation components Radiation from rdec
External inverse Compton
τRS = 6.4× 10−6
τFS = 1.1× 10−8
cutoff and peak at εKN(γ)
εFpeakε,RSEIC ≈ εbrNε,pτRSε
RSEICKN = 2.3× 10−8 erg cm−2 s−1
εFpeakε,FSEIC ≈ εbrNε,pτFSε
FSEICKN = 7.2× 10−10 erg cm−2 s−1
RphRdec
RS FS
RS−EICFS−EIC
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 9 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example theoretical spectrum with pair cutoff
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EICFS
RS
BB
RS-SSC
FS-SSC
pairs
FS-EIC
Lt = 1053 erg/s, ζr = 0.6,n = 10 cm−3,η = 600, εB,pr = 1, εB,FS = εB,RS =
10−2, εe,FS = εe,RS = 10−2, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.4,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 10 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example theoretical spectrum with pair cutoff
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EICFS
RS
BB
RS-SSC
FS-SSC
pairs
FS-EIC
Lt = 1053 erg/s, ζr = 0.6,n = 10 cm−3,η = 600, εB,pr = 1, εB,FS = εB,RS =
10−2, εe,FS = εe,RS = 10−2, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.4,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 10 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example theoretical spectrum with pair cutoff
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EICFS
RS
BB
RS-SSC
FS-SSC
pairs
FS-EIC
Lt = 1053 erg/s, ζr = 0.6,n = 10 cm−3,η = 600, εB,pr = 1, εB,FS = εB,RS =
10−2, εe,FS = εe,RS = 10−2, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.4,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 10 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example spectra: model with no pair cutoff 1.
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EIC
FS
RS BB
FS-SSC
FS-EIC
Lt = 1053 erg/s, ζr = 0.5,n = 30 cm−3,η = 400, εB,pr = 1, εB,FS = εB,RS =
2× 10−2, εe,FS = εe,RS = 5× 10−3, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.5,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 11 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example spectra: model with no pair cutoff 1.
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EIC
FS
RS BB
FS-SSC
FS-EIC
Lt = 1053 erg/s, ζr = 0.5,n = 30 cm−3,η = 400, εB,pr = 1, εB,FS = εB,RS =
2× 10−2, εe,FS = εe,RS = 5× 10−3, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.5,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 11 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example spectra: model with no pair cutoff 2.
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EIC
RS
RS-SSC
BB
FS-SSC
FS-EIC
FS
Lt = 5× 1052 erg/s, ζr = 0.6,n = 102 cm−3, η = 400, εB,pr = 0.9, εB,FS =
10−2, εe,FS = 2× 10−2, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.4,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 12 / 16
Example spectra Theoretical
Example spectra: model with no pair cutoff 2.
10-6 10-5 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 105 10610-9
10-8
10-7
10-6
¶ @MeVD
¶F¶@e
rgcm-
2s-
1D
prompt
RS-EIC
RS
RS-SSC
BB
FS-SSC
FS-EIC
FS
Lt = 5× 1052 erg/s, ζr = 0.6,n = 102 cm−3, η = 400, εB,pr = 0.9, εB,FS =
10−2, εe,FS = 2× 10−2, r0 = 107 cm, z = 1,β = 2.4,p = 2.4
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 12 / 16
Example spectra Observed
Example: fitting the model to Fermi measurements 1.
Data provided by Bin-Bin Zhang (Veres, Zhang and Meszaros in prep.)
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 13 / 16
Example spectra Observed
Example: fitting the model to Fermi measurements 2.
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 14 / 16
Example spectra Observed
Example: fitting the model to Fermi measurements 3.
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 15 / 16
Conclusions
Conclusions
Magnetic model fits well Fermi GBM/LAT dataGood for inetrpreting observationsExternal IC needed for additional PL comp.If RS is present, strong extra componentCan reproduce:-smooth Band spectrum-Band spectrum + extra PL component + cutoff
for more, please see:arXiv:1202.2821
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 16 / 16
Backup slides
Why we do not invoke internal shocks?Internal shocks are radiatively inefficient and also are typicallyexpected at radii ris = ctΓ2 ∼ 3× 1013tv,−3Γ
23 cm, too small for both
showing small variability and to allow GeV photons to escape(Rγγ > 1015 cm).Dissipative photospheres can be 50% radiatively efficient; theirspectrum reproduce the Band function, with a peak which isthermal (baryonic dyn) or synchrotron (mag.dyn), and where lowand high energy slopes are due to scattering (baryonic) and orSynch/IC (magn dyn) - see Thompson 94, Rees, Meszaros05,Pe’er, Meszaros, Rees 06 and Beloborodov 11.Magnetic dynamics: useful because (a) suspect mag. fieldsdominant in high Eiso bursts (since need Blandford-Znajek), (b)dissipation very efficient due to reconnection, (c) spectrum isBand-like (Giannios 07, Thompson 94 or Vurm 11).
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 17 / 16
Time resolved spectra, e.g. 080916C work in progress
Peter Veres and Peter Meszaros (PSU) Multicomponent HE spectra GRB conf. 2012, Munchen 18 / 16