slides - voting results · voting results. policy objectives •minimise harm to the economy...

VOTING RESULTS

POLICY OBJECTIVES

• minimise harm to the economy• protect the NHS and public services• maintain living standards• take account of impacts on all parts of the UK• protect workers’ rights• avoid a hard border with Ireland

Note: Assembly members selected from a long list of possible objectives, which they developed at the first weekend. Each member could vote for up to six of these. This are the objectives that received most votes.

UK TRADE POLICY SHOULD…

• be linked to investment in training for UK nationals• keep better data on migrants; enable us to

sustain public services• benefit our economy• be responsive to regional needs• include better planning of public services

Note: Assembly members selected from a long list of possible objectives, which they developed at the first weekend. Each member could vote for up to six of these. This are the objectives that received most votes.

UK MIGRATION POLICY SHOULD…

TRADE WITH THE EUROPEAN UNION

OPTIONS

OPTION AStay in the Single

Market for goods and services

OPTION BAgree a

‘comprehensive’ trade deal covering tariffs

and non-tariff barriers

OPTION CAgree a limited trade deal covering tariffs

only

OPTION DAgree no trade deal

with the EU

TRADE WITH THE EU

14 14

19

302468101214161820

OptionA:SingleMarketforgoodsandservices

OptionB:Comprehensive

tradedeal

OptionC:Limitedtradedeal

OptionD:Notradedealwith

theEU

FirstPreferences

TRADE WITH THE EU

66

103 98

330

20

40

60

80

100

120



tradedeal



theEU

PointsforPreferences

TRADE WITH THE EU

19

27

40

5

10

15

20

25

30



tradedeal



theEU

Whatifwecan’tgetacomprehensivedeal?

TRADE WITH THE EU

31

19

05101520253035



tradedeal



theEU

Whatifwecan’tgetanytradedeal?

TRADE WITH COUNTRIES

OUTSIDE THE EU

OPTIONS

OPTION AStay in the

EU’s Customs Union

OPTION BAgree a special

customs deal with the EU

OPTION CAgree no

customs deal with the EU

TRADE WITH COUNTRIES OUTSIDE THE EU

12

35

30510152025303540

OptionA:StayintheCustomsUnion

OptionB:DoacustomsdealwiththeEU

OptionC:NocustomsdealwiththeEU

FirstPreferences


49

85

160102030405060708090






37

13

0510152025303540




Whatifwecan’tgetaspecialcustomsdeal?

MIGRATION BETWEEN THE UK

AND THE EU

OPTIONSOPTION A

Maintain free movement of labour as now

OPTION BMaintain free movement of

labour, but use controls

OPTION CEnd free

movement, but still favour

EU citizens

OPTION DSame rules for EU and non-EU citizens; total

immig. as now

OPTION ESame rules for EU and non-EU citizens; total immig. lower

MIGRATION BETWEEN THE UK AND THE EU

8

26

5 47

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

OptionA:Freemovementas

now

OptionB:Freemovement,usingcontrols

OptionC:EUfavoured,

shortoffreemovement

OptionD:EUnotfavoured;totalimmig-rationasnow

OptionE:EUnotfavoured;totalimmig-rationdown

FirstPreferences

MIGRATION BETWEEN THE UK AND THE EU

82

144

87 9255

020406080100120140160

OptionA:Freemovementas

now

OptionB:Freemovement,usingcontrols

OptionC:EUfavoured,

shortoffreemovement

OptionD:EUnotfavoured;totalimmig-rationasnow

OptionE:EUnotfavoured;totalimmig-rationdown


FITTING IT ALL TOGETHER

FITTING IT ALL TOGETHERStay in the Single Market, with free movement

of labour as now

Stay in the Single Market, with free movement of labour, using available controls

Do a comprehensive trade deal with the EU, + favourable access short of free movement

Do no trade deal with the EU, and allow free movement or favourable access

Do no trade deal with the EU, and allow no favourable access for EU citizens

OPTION A

OPTION B

OPTION C

OPTION E

OPTION F

Do a more limited trade deal with the EU, with no favourable access for EU citizens

OPTION D

Stay in the Single Market, with free movement of labour as now

Stay in the Single Market, with free movement of labour, using available controls

Do a comprehensive trade deal with the EU, + favourable access short of free movement

Do no trade deal with the EU, and allow free movement or favourable access

Do a more limited trade deal with the EU, with no favourable access for EU citizens


8

1416

10

1 1024681012141618

A B C D E F

FirstPreferences

No EU trade deal

Single Market

Single Market

Comp. EU trade deal

No EU trade deal

Limited EU trade deal

Free movement as now

Free movement using controls

EU citizens favoured

EU citizens not favoured

Free movement or EU favoured




No EU trade deal

Single Market

Single Market

Comp. EU trade deal

No EU trade deal








120

184 188153

4560

020406080100120140160180200

A B C D E F


Ifnocomprehensivetradedeal

No EU trade deal

Single Market

Single Market

Comp. EU trade deal

No EU trade deal








8

25

15

1 10

5

10

15

20

25

30

A B C D E F


Ifwecan’tgetanytradedeal

No EU trade deal

Single Market

Single Market

Comp. EU trade deal

No EU trade deal








8

30

1

11

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

A B C D E F

slides - voting results · voting results. policy objectives •minimise harm to the economy...

Documents