southwest airlines · southwest airlines leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged...

12
FLORIDA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola 3/25/2018 Southwest Airlines has managed to achieve the second largest market share amongst domestic United States airline industry while consistently maintain profitability. Focusing on maintaining low operating costs through aircraft maximization and efficiency, it has also focused on employee engagement which has allowed it to pursue a cost leadership strategy with enough differentiation in the form of its staff friendliness. Its success has spawned other low-fare competitors and, more recently, ultra-low-fare carriers. As it deals with increased competition and a changing competitive landscape, it will need to leverage and enhance its existing competencies as it seeks to retain and expand on its market share.

Upload: others

Post on 17-Mar-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

FLORIDA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY

Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an

engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry

Jose Sola

3/25/2018

Southwest Airlines has managed to achieve the second largest market share amongst domestic United

States airline industry while consistently maintain profitability. Focusing on maintaining low operating

costs through aircraft maximization and efficiency, it has also focused on employee engagement which

has allowed it to pursue a cost leadership strategy with enough differentiation in the form of its staff

friendliness. Its success has spawned other low-fare competitors and, more recently, ultra-low-fare

carriers. As it deals with increased competition and a changing competitive landscape, it will need to

leverage and enhance its existing competencies as it seeks to retain and expand on its market share.

Page 2: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

1

Swimming in the oceans of a highly competitive airline industry, Southwest Airlines has

profitably navigated through stormy waters better than most companies in the industry. Just as

dolphins use their intelligence to adapt and survive in an environment with threatening predators

such as sharks or whales; Southwest Airlines has successfully risen against larger competitors by

making the most of the opportunities presented by its external environment. A major reason’s for

Southwest Airlines success rests in its low-fare business model which focuses on servicing a

concentrated group of terminals, operating a single fleet, and offering every passenger the same

product level. Similar to dolphins that conserve energy by surfing the wakes of ships, Southwest

Airline model allows the company to minimize its costs and operate more efficient, timely

flights. While its competitors have focused on pursuing differentiation strategies such as larger

airplanes, more destinations, and enhanced features, Southwest’s model of low-fares and a

simplified experience with acceptable but differentiated levels of quality have propelled it as the

second largest US domestic airline in terms of market share, which stands at 21.5 percent, only

slightly lagging American Airlines which has 22.8 percent. This success has prompted similar

low-fare airlines such as JetBlue and Spirit Airlines to enter the market, while also having to

sustain established competitors who try to improve their value propositions to regain their lost

share of the market. As it increases in size and market share, competitors will try to imitate its

features to eliminate Southwest’s competitive advantage (Hitt, Ireland, & Hoskisson, 2017). To

continue its success, Southwest Airlines will need to carefully monitor its external environment

to find areas of opportunity while leveraging the competencies of its current model and

reputation to exploit those opportunities.

General Environment Analysis

The airline industry has bright prospects largely driven by demographic, economic, and

technical trends that have a positive effect on demand (Wang & Song, 2010). Population growth

rates coupled with mass migration of the world population toward cities and the emergence of

millennials show promising signs for future customer demand. The world’s population is

expected to grow steadily at 1.09 per year, while the United States will continue to see moderate

growth of .7 percent leading to more likely customers (“Current”). Much of this growth is

expected to concentrate in cities, which see about 3 million people moving to cities globally

(Boyd, 2018). Increased density of population would likely lead to more customers needing to

travel further distances to see each other; increasing the value proposition of air travel relative to

Page 3: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

2

other methods. Also, as millennials replace baby-boomers as the largest customer segment, the

sociocultural importance they place on travel will further have a positive effect on demand

(Fromm, 2017). In addition to demographics, economic activity is expected to continue to

increase as the economy exists the recession, leading to greater number of customers able or

willing to pay to travel faster and more conveniently by air to reach their destinations (Chi &

Baek, 2013). Furthermore, technological advances such as the automation of the baggaging

process will offer airline companies the opportunity to further achieve cost savings while

reducing errors (Rijsenbrij & Ottjes, 2007).

Of less impact but equal concern; political, global, sociocultural and environmental

trends will likely create challenges for the airline industry. Among the political factors include

possible changes in airline regulations concerning greater fuel efficiency and safety. Potential

global concerns involve isolationist economic trends that might lead to less travel among certain

destinations and interest rate fluctuations in international markets which has made it more

expensive to travel to the US and has hurt legacy carriers with international reach (Trefis, 2015).

Environmental concerns involve the increasing concern of climate change and the role played by

airplane emissions. Not only would this create pressure for companies to buy newer fuel-efficient

models, but also could have sociocultural implications by making people opt for eco-friendly

competitors. Ultimate, these trends do not have as direct of an impact because they develop over

more time, making them easier to mitigate.

Industry Analysis

With its intense rivalry, high bargaining buyer and supplier power, the airline industry

has low attractiveness providing opportunities to companies that successfully establish

themselves the benefits of low threat of substitute products and entrants. With high capital

requirements, extensive regulations, and complex logistics, the airline industry is shielded from

new entrants by its entry barriers. With almost 4 companies controlling almost 80 percent of the

market share, retaliation would be expected from established competitors who would have

advantages of economies of scale and could price more aggressively before sustaining losses

(Hitt. et. al., 2017). While demand is expect to increase, fare prices have not which further deters

entrants. While its low threat of entrants is appealing, airlines are highly influenced and

dependent on suppliers. While competition is increasing amongst airplane manufacturers, fuel

prices have a direct influence in fare costs as companies need to charge higher fares before they

Page 4: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

3

can make profits (Chi & Baek, 2013). However, development of better fuel efficient engines has

the potential to mitigate the impact of supplier power toward more moderate levels.

Customers have a high amount of power over airline companies. Not only do companies

rely on fares as their source of profits, customers often have the ability to travel by other means

if costs are too high and with the popularity of e-commerce they can easily shop online for the

best fares or use a different competitor if they have a bad experience (Moreno-Izquierdo,

Ramón-Rodríguez & Ribes, 2015). As the fastest and furthest mass method of transportation,

airline travel is unlikely to be substituted by other forms of travel. While some customer might

choose alternatives during economic downturns, demand returns because there are no other

technologies with the same mass transportation capacities.

Intensity among rivals is high due to the several variety of competitors, lack of

differentiation (for casual customers), high fixed costs, and exit barriers (Hitt et. al., 2017). With

high bargaining buyer and supplier power coupled with intense rivalry, the airline industry has

low attractiveness. On the other hand, high entry barriers and low threat of substitutes are

appealing for companies that can successfully manage to establish themselves.

Competitor Analysis

As the largest domestic United States airline by market share, accounting for 22.8 percent

of the market, American Airlines pursues a differentiation strategy concentrating on maximizing

the number of destinations and the luxuriousness of the experience. This is evidenced by their

mission statement which states the company’s intention to modernize its fleet, while retaining the

largest reach with the goal of becoming the most profitable airline (Walters & Grovers, 2015).

The company’s core competencies rest on their established brand name, fleet quality, and

destination reach. Additionally, it has taken recent steps to introduce basic economy fares in

attempts to appeal to customers attracted by low-fare carriers as it attempts to regain market

share and increase profits (“Coming soon,” 2018).

Delta Airlines is the second largest domestic competitor with 21 percent of market share.

It pursues a differentiation/cost leadership strategy by providing customers with different flight

accommodations ranging from basic economy (low-fare), main cabin (traditional economy) and

first class. Its core competencies lie in operation efficiencies as it operates a fleet of airplanes

nearing retirement. This allows the company to rely on a greater ratio of variable to fix costs,

which enables them to respond more quickly to changes in demand (Levine-Weinberg, 2015).

Page 5: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

4

While it only has 4 percent share of the domestic market, JetBlue is the largest competitor

operating a similar low-fare cost leadership model. Founded 32 years after Southwest by one of

its former executives, JetBlue has largely imitated Southwest’s model of concentrating on

maximizing usage by focusing on popular destinations and offering a simplified experience

while offering slightly better differentiated features with more customer appeal such as free Wi-

Fi and snacks (Trefis, 2015). Their core competencies lie in a more advanced fleet with high fuel

efficiency, which has somewhat insulated them from variable changes in fuel costs relative to

competitors (“JetBlue,”2017). As described in their vision to “bring humanity” to air travel by

delivering “value, service, style and comfort,” JetBlue has focused on cost leadership with

enough differentiation and it is now leveraging their success by expanding its geographic reach

to additional high-potential destinations and providing premium fare options to increase its

market reach by catering to more demanding flyers (Trefis, 2015).

Internal Analysis

As large part of Southwest’s success is derived from its ability to offer competitive fares, its

operating activities have focused on efficiency and minimizing costs. As part of this strategy it

has operated a single airplane model, often purchasing and fixing older planes in order to reduce

expenses (Ross, 2015). While most competitors place emphasis on aircraft technology,

Southwest’s approach has enabled it to avoid having large capital expenditures while affording it

greater flexibility, as all workers are familiar with the same equipment maintenance crew is

quicker to fix potential problems, and pilots are able to operate all routes interchangeably.

Another core competency rests in its logistics, as it operates gate-to-gate routes; it is able to more

efficiently and quickly manage the baggage process and reduce errors arising from diverting

luggage to connecting flights (Zane & Reyes, 2010). Due to its value in providing flexibility and

its rareness, these capabilities provide Southwest Airlines with a temporary competitive

advantage which could last until the cost of new airplanes, in combination with their fuel savings

rivals that of the savings afforded by older planes. In such scenario, its model would become a

weakness and a competitive disadvantage because it wouldn’t be able to compete by using its

focal low cost strategy.

Another core competency includes its customer service activities which have allowed the

company to consistently be ranked amongst the top in various customer service surveys. This is

largely driven by its simplified flight experience and its investment in its human capital as it has

Page 6: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

5

shared profits with employees for the last 43 years and has avoided having to lay off (Dhal,

2017). These conditions have contributed to Southwest Airlines reputation for having a friendly

and engaged workforce and are indicative of strong Human Resources and Management support

activities. Should customer taste become more demanding, the company would be at a

competitive disadvantage because it would require large capital investments and would have to

reconsider its competitive strategy.

SWOT Analysis

When considering the trends of population shifts toward cities and millennial trends

placing less emphasis on features, Southwest airline’s current model is well positioned because it

focuses on gate-to-gate popular destinations. While its operating activities provide strength due

to flexibility and cost efficiencies, it should be concerned with sociocultural trends placing larger

priority on eco-friendliness which might lead customer to opt for airlines with the latest most

fuel-efficient fleet. Additionally, it has reason to be concerned with additional low-fare airlines

such as JetBlue and newer “ultra-low-fare” entrants such as Spirit or Frontier entering the

•Competitive Rivalry

•Supplier and fuel costs

•Environmental demands

•Population shifts toward cities

•Millenial customers and product preferences

•High traffic, proximal international destinations

•Older Airplane Fleet

•Single supplier reliance

•Limited differentiation capacity

•Cost efficient gate-to-gate model

•Flexible fleet and operational capacity

•Customer Service

•Engaged Workforce

Strenghts Weaknesses

Threats Opportunites

Page 7: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

6

market. With millennial generations replacing baby-boomers as the largest flying segment,

Southwest Airlines should focus on leveraging its customer service reputation to add low-cost,

high perceived value features, allowing it to maintain differentiation from imitating rivals while

continuing to improve its value proposition to potential customers. Lastly, the company should

leverage its operating competencies to gradually replace older models with a new generation of

higher fuel-efficient models that would help it further lower operating costs in the long-term

while strengthening its operating model against potential threats.

Strategy Formulation

Strategic Alternatives

Considering the importance the cost leadership business level strategy has played in its

success, Southwest’s Airlines could continue its focus around further cost competitiveness. As it

attempts to appeal to a greater customer base, it must adopt some differentiation while being

unable to solely pursue differentiation strategies that represent a dramatic change from its

existing model (Hitt. et. al., 2017). Not only would it not be able to take advantage of its

competencies, it also would be at a disadvantage with larger competitors with modern fleets,

larger distribution channels and destinations. On the other hand, implementing an integrated cost

leadership/differentiation strategy would help Southwest Airlines pursue operational efficiencies

to be price competitive while it simultaneously engages in activities to differentiate its product

and appeal to a broader market segment.

As its share of the domestic market has reached a saturation point, corporate level

strategies of diversification could help add new value and growth. Among its options, it could

maintain low diversification levels by focusing on the domestic US market. Additionally, it

could maintain its dominant business design and pursue value-adding diversification by

expanding to international markets or offering complementary services to customers (Hitt. et. at.,

2017). Among the strategies, it can pursue mergers of acquisitions of firms where it seeks to

enter new markets; it can form strategic alliances such as codeshare agreements with other

airlines, or it could also open its own terminal. It can manage its international strategy through a

global strategy, which maintains central control of operations; or pursue a transnational strategy

which maintains central strategic control and adds local market input through regionalization of

the company’s management structure.

Alternative Evaluation

Page 8: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

7

From an internal strengths perspective, the cost leadership strategy would allow

Southwest Airlines to leverage a historical core competency of operational efficiency and

simplified processes and it would require the least changes to its organizational culture. On the

other hand, it has the potential to leave the company exposed by failing to meet the needs of

more demanding customers. Adhering to a cost leadership strategy, could also limit its appeal to

value seeking customers and fail to take advantage of higher paying or more frequent-flying

business travel segments. With an integrated cost leadership/differentiation strategy, Southwest

Airlines would maintain focus on operational efficiencies and cost competitiveness in the low-

fare model, while also pursuing opportunities that add customer value without having an adverse

effect on its cost leadership capabilities. Using its customer service competencies and its

simplified flight experience, it could leverage these capacities to add low-cost features that make

the customer’s experience more comfortable and pleasant, without focusing on luxury.

Low diversification would allow Southwest Airlines to use its current capabilities with

the gate-to-gate model and single distribution channel to focus on its current low-fare model to

achieve economies of scale. Because of the importance of achieving economies of scale in the

airline industry, the single-business diversification strategy would help Southwest leverage the

operational benefits from the single-model fleet and its focus on high transit cities to achieve

greater economies of scale than possible by competitors pursuing more diversified strategies. On

the other hand, a dominant business strategy would involve Southwest’s continued presence in

the domestic US, while expanding into international markets or increasing cargo flights. As the

degree at which it is able to expand share of the domestic US market decreases, increasing

diversification will the firm make the greatest use of the opportunities presented by its

competitive environment. Additionally, maintaining a dominant business design would help

mitigate risks from new markets, while pursuing value creating diversification with operational

and corporate relatedness would help transfer its capabilities in service and operations to gain

growth and new knowledge of international markets.

As it seeks to enter new markets, choosing a global strategy would allow Southwest

Airlines to maintain central control and management of its operations. Employing a gate-to-gate

model with select destinations and a single fleet, it can take advantage of the standardization of

its operations because they are less complex and easier to manage in a global strategy than those

of competitors with more complex destinations and fleets. Because of the fairly similar demands

Page 9: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

8

and expectations of travelers toward airlines, a global strategy also takes advantage of its

external environment because it doesn’t need to be as concerned about local responsiveness,

allowing greater economies of scale. A transnational strategy would involve central management

and control of activities, but it would also involve the regionalization of operations to allow for

greater responsiveness. Diversifying its managerial inputs would also allow Southwest Airlines

to benefit from increased transfer of knowledge (Hitt. et. al., 2017). On the other hand, it would

incur greater staffing costs which could have a detrimental impact on its current low cost

operational core competencies.

In pursuing diversification, it has the option to pursue cooperative strategies, merger and

acquisition strategies, and organic growth strategies. While cooperative strategies provide

Southwest an opportunity to achieve strategic agreements with other carriers with codeshare

agreements that might help it provide a differentiated product, it would not incur the same

rewards it would through acquisitions or new ventures (Hitt. et. al., 2017). While acquisitions

provide a quick entry and a bypass to entry barriers, they are often risky and difficult to

implement. On the other hand, organic expansion to new destination take longer than

acquisitions but offer greater control and are easier to manage.

Alternative Choice

As it must transform from a low-fare carrier to meet the changing needs of its customer

base, Southwest Airlines should adopt a business level integrated cost leadership/differentiation

strategy because it allows it to leverage its existing operational capacitates to pursue price

competitive strategies. Additionally, it is able to leverage its service and organizational culture

competencies in pursuing differentiation strategies that further improve its customer’s flight

experience as a direct response to environmental demands posed by high customer power and

high competitive rivalry. In turn, this helps the firm differentiate from competitive imitators who

match its cost appeal. Because it has limited domestic growth opportunities, it must

simultaneously pursue a corporate level dominant-business international diversification strategy;

involving destinations that help the company maintain corporate relatedness and sharing of

activities because they in turn are essential to its business level strategies of cost leadership.

Strategic Alternative Implementation

Action items

Page 10: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

9

As it shifts from a cost leadership strategy to an integrated one, it will need to carefully

manage and balance new features so that they do not compromise the firm’s cost leadership

appeal and drive away loyal customers at the expense of pursuing new ones. Another challenge

rests in transferring its core competencies of organizational culture across international

destinations. Furthermore, the acquisition of new terminals, new staff and equipment also

requires increased capital investments. Because it also relies on a single distribution channel

(except for business sales), it also must consider increased advertising costs as it is not able to

use the publicity provided by third-party distribution channels.

In implementing its strategy, it would be best facilitated by a functional structure.

Because it will continue pursuing a cost leadership strategy, the functional structure would help

the firm maintain a lower cost structure through centralized coordination (Hitt. et. al., 2017).

While it also will pursue differentiation, it will do so by leveraging its workforce and service

competencies in developing features that are process related and experience related, following

similar examples as maintaining no check bag fee policy, no re-scheduling fees and frequent

flyer rewards program. Because its international diversification strategy will be reliant on its

dominant business and incremental expansion to international destinations, the functional model

can help the company emphasize its operational cost efficiencies capabilities without disrupting

the synergy of operations by adopting a multidivisional structure.

Action plan

Using a combination of strategic and financial controls, Southwest Airlines could monitor

its strategic direction using a balanced scorecard based on strategic and financial objectives in

order to evaluate its performance and consider any necessary changes (Hitt. et., 2017). In

measuring its strategic success, it would include the goals of becoming the leading domestic US

airline by market share, Maintain or surpass current customer service levels, and double its

international reach over the next five years. In measuring its financial success, it would include

sustaining above-industry profit margins, operating margin, fuel efficiency rating, and cost per

seat.

Page 11: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

10

References

Boyd, B. (2018, January 14). Urbanization and the Mass Movement of People to Cities.

Retrieved March 24, 2018, from https://graylinegroup.com/urbanization-catalyst-

overview/

Chi, J., & Baek, J. (2013). Dynamic relationship between air transport demand and economic

growth in the United States: A new look. Transport Policy,29, 257-260.

doi:10.1016/j.tranpol.2013.03.005

Coming soon: Basic Economy on select flights to Europe. (2018, March 01). Retrieved March

24, 2018, from http://news.aa.com/press-releases/press-release-details/2018/Coming-

soon-Basic-Economy-on-select-flights-to-Europe/default.aspx

Current World Population. (n.d.). Retrieved March 24, 2018, from

http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/#pastfuture

Dahl, D. (2017, July 28). Why Do Southwest Airlines Employees Always Seem So Happy?

Retrieved March 25, 2018, from

https://www.forbes.com/sites/darrendahl/2017/07/28/why-do-southwest-airlines-

employees-always-seem-so-happy/#1d0bf4d759b0

Fromm, J. (2017, November 08). Why Millennials Are The Most Important Consumer Generation For

The Travel Industry. Retrieved March 24, 2018, from

https://www.forbes.com/sites/jefffromm/2017/11/08/why-millennials-are-the-most-

important-consumer-generation-for-the-travel-industry/

Hitt, M. A., Ireland, R. D., & Hoskisson, R. E. (2017). Cooperative Strategy. In Strategic

Management: Competitiveness & Globalization: Concepts and Cases (12th ed.). Boston,

MA: Cengage Learning.

Trefis, T. (2015, October 15). A Closer Look At JetBlue's Strategy. Retrieved March 25, 2018,

from https://www.forbes.com/sites/greatspeculations/2015/10/15/a-closer-look-at-

jetblues-strategy/#272e62773795

JetBlue Airways Corp SWOT Analysis. (2017). JetBlue Airways Corporation SWOT Analysis,

1-8.

Moreno-Izquierdo, L., Ramón-Rodríguez, A., & Ribes, J. P. (2015). The impact of the internet

on the pricing strategies of the European low cost airlines. European Journal of

Operational Research,246(2), 651-660. doi:10.1016/j.ejor.2015.05.013

Page 12: Southwest Airlines · Southwest Airlines Leveraging operational resourcefulness and an engaged workforce to adapt to future competitive dynamics in the airline industry Jose Sola

11

Rijsenbrij, J., & Ottjes, J. (2007). New Developments in Airport Baggage Handling

Systems. Transportation Planning and Technology,30(4), 417-430.

doi:10.1080/03081060701461899

Ross, S. (2015, November 23). Southwest Vs. Virgin Vs. JetBlue: Comparing Business Models

(LUV, VA). Retrieved March 25, 2018, from

https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/112315/southwest-vs-virgin-vs-jetblue-

comparing-business-models.asp

Levine-Weinberg, A. (2015, October 19). 5 Things Delta Air Lines, Inc. Management Wants

You to Know. Retrieved March 24, 2018, from

https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2015/10/19/5-things-delta-air-lines-inc-

management-wants-you.aspx

Wang, M., & Song, H. (2010). Air Travel Demand Studies: A Review. Journal of China Tourism

Research,6(1), 29-49. doi:10.1080/19388160903586562

Walters, J., J., & Grover, G. (2015, April 16). Customer or Company Mission? Retrieved March

24, 2018, from http://360connext.com/customer-or-company-mission/

Zane, C. K., & Reyes, P. M. (2010). Airlines' plight: Where has all the luggage

gone?Management Research Review, 33(7), 767-782.

http://dx.doi.org.portal.lib.fit.edu/10.1108/01409171011055834 Retrieved from

https://search-proquest-com.portal.lib.fit.edu/docview/578108192?accountid=27313