spire-p mapmaking, data processing and future...

40
SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developments Matt Griffin

Upload: others

Post on 23-Aug-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future

Developments

Matt Griffin

Page 2: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Broadband Photometer Flux

Calibration

Matt Griffin

Chris North, Bernhard Schulz, Alex Amaral-Rogers, George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell,

Marc Ferlet, Jason Glenn, Tanya Lim, Chris Pearson, Michael Pohlen, Bruce Sibthorpe, Locke Spencer,

Bruce Swinyard, IVan Valtchanov

Page 3: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Point Source Calibration

Page 4: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Measured Flux Density for a Point Source

•  Detector absorbed power ∝ flux density, weighted by aperture efficiency and SRF, integrated across the band

ν

η(ν)

S(ν)

F(ν)

S(ν) = source spectrum

F(ν) = instrument SRF

η(ν) = aperture efficiency

Page 5: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Primary Calibrator for SPIRE: Neptune Brightness Temperature Spectrum

Moreno model 2012 (“ESA-3” or “ESA-4”)

Page 6: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Neptune Spectrum and SPIRE Bands

Page 7: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Source Spectrum •  Spectrum characterised by value at some frequency

and a shape function

•  Examples:

Power law with index α :

Grey body (T, β) :

Page 8: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Monochromatic Flux Density at νo •  Measured SRF-weighted flux density is converted to

monochromatic flux density at standard frequencyνo

•  A source spectrum must be assumed

•  Power law case

•  Standard: adopt αo = –1, i.e., ν S(ν) = constant

•  Pipeline produces

Page 9: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Colour Correction •  Pipeline output = monochromatic

flux density for αs = –1

•  Colour correction factor KColP must be applied

•  Depends on “actual” source spectrum E.g., for grey body assumption:

Log(ν)

Log(Sν)

Log(ν)

Log(Sν)

Page 10: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Extended Source Calibration

Page 11: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Extended Source •  Small region at off-axis angles (θ, φ)

- Brightness - Size - Flux density - Normalised beam response

•  Measured flux density for the small region:

θ

φ

Page 12: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Extended Source •  Integrate over beam for total measured flux density

•  Same as point source case except S(ν ) replaced by sky intensity integrated over the beam

Page 13: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

•  Spectral shape: e.g. power law, grey body . . .

•  Spatial shape: e.g., Gaussian, power law, uniform (g = 1) . . .

•  Beam profile is also circularly symmetric:

•  Deriving peak surface brightness from measured flux density:

•  KMonE converts flux density (Jy/beam) to surface brightness (Jy/pixel or MJy/sr)

Some Simplifying Assumptions •  Source characterised by spectral and spatial shape functions

•  Spatial distribution is circularly symmetric

Page 14: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Case of Uniform Extended Emission: g(θ, θo) = 1 •  Integral over the beam ≡ frequency-dependent beam solid

angle:

•  This depends on how the beam solid angle varies across the band - Not measured directly - Must be modeled from band-averaged profile as measured on a point source with a known spectrum

Jy/beam → surface brightness

Page 15: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Conversion from Point Source Pipeline to Extended Emission Pipeline

•  KColE converts to peak intensity of an extended source with brightness profile g(θ, θo) and spectrum f(ν, ν o)

•  Extended pipeline surface brightness, which assumes a fully extended source with spectral index –1 :

•  Conversion to actual source peak intensity:

Page 16: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Beam Profile and Aperture Efficiency

Page 17: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Conversion from a Point Source Pipeline to Extended Emission Case

•  Treatment above is very general - Beam properties (aperture efficiency and

beam profile) are allowed to vary across the band

- Source spectral and spatial distributions can also vary

•  Details depend on detector and optical system

architecture

•  Two common cases - Absorber-coupling with 0.5λ/D square pixels - Antenna-coupling with 2λ/D circular feedhorns

Page 18: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Angle (degrees)

Absorber-Coupled Detectors

•  Array of square pixels

•  Pixel size ≡ 0.5λ/D for instantaneous full

spatial sampling

•  Wide pixel field of view ( ~ π sr)

•  Cold stop limits field of view

•  Near top-hat illumination of the telescope

•  Pixel couples to Airy disk

Cold enclosure

D

Illumination pattern

Page 19: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

2λ/D

Feedhorn-Coupled Detectors

• Single-mode feedhorns

• Tapered (~ Gaussian) illumination of the telescope

• Maximum aperture efficiency

when horn diameter ≡ 2λ/D • Throughput is λ2

Illumination pattern

Page 20: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Aperture Efficiency vs. Detector Size

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 30

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Horn diameter or pixel side ( F*Lambda)

Aper

ture

effic

iency

G

Ape

rtur

e Ef

ficie

ncy

Size (units of λ/D)

Absorber-coupled pixel Feedhorn

Page 21: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE SRFs and Aperture Efficiencies

Page 22: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Primary Illumination Edge Taper Variation across the Band

2λ/D Feedhorn

Page 23: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Beam Profile for 2λ/D Feedhorn with λ /Δλ = 3

λ/Δλ = 3

2λ/D Feedhorn

Page 24: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Corresponding Beam Solid Angle

λ/Δλ = 3

Ω ∝ ν-1.75

2λ/D Feedhorn

Page 25: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Earlier SPIRE Method of Dealing With This Effect: λ2 Weighting of the SRF

P = Point source (no weighting) E = Extended source (λ2 weighting)

P

P P

E E E

Frequency (GHz)

Tran

smis

sion

( ) ( )2

oo ⎟

⎞⎜⎝

⎛=νν

νν RR

Page 26: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Beam Solid Angle and Aperture Efficiency for 0.5λ/D Pixel

η(νo) = 0.158

Page 27: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

η(νo) = 0.158

0.5λ/D Absorber-Coupled Pixel: Beam Solid Angle and Aperture Efficiency

Page 28: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Ω(ν) η(ν) = constant

η(νo) = 0.158

0.5λ/D Absorber-Coupled Pixel: Beam Solid Angle and Aperture Efficiency

Page 29: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Examples

Page 30: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Feedhorn Coupling, Square Passband with νo at Centre

λ/Δλ =

10

5

3

Point source colour correction factor vs. source

spectral index

Page 31: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Different Choice of Nominal Frequency

λ/Δλ = 3 Centre

- 3%

+ 3%

Page 32: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Colour Correction (Power-Law SED)

Page 33: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Colour Correction (Grey Body SED)

Page 34: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Beams

Circularised profiles

• Broadband beams measured on Neptune (α = 1.3 – 1.5)

• Averaged over all detectors

ΩMeas = (450, 795, 1665) sq. arcsec. with 4% uncertainty

Page 35: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Beams • Modelled 250-µm beam at νeff and band edges

Assumption is that measured broadband beam = monochromatic beam at some frequency νeff

Page 36: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Beams • Effective Beam Solid Angle vs. Source Spectral Index

Page 37: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Beams • Effective Beam Solid Angle vs. Grey Body Temperature

Page 38: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Calibration of Partly Extended Emission

Conversion factor from extended source pipeline to total flux density for a Gaussian source brightness profile

Page 39: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

SPIRE Calibration of Partly Extended Emission

Conversion factor from extended source pipeline to peak surface brightness for a Gaussian source brightness profile

Page 40: SPIRE-P Mapmaking, Data Processing and Future Developmentsherschel.esac.esa.int/CalibrationWorkshop5/... · George Bendo, Jamie Bock, Alex Conley, Darren Dowell, Marc Ferlet, Jason

Conclusions •  General scheme for calibration of broadband photometric

measurements of point-like, semi- or fully-extended emission

•  Can be applied to absorber-coupled or antenna-coupled systems

•  Calibration implementation for SPIRE: see - Talks by George Bendo and Bernhard Schulz - Poster by Chris North - Updated SPIRE Observers’ Manual

•  New method produces brightness values ~ (7, 7, 12)% lower than previous method for a ν3 uniformly extended source

•  Future work: - Develop practical scheme for dealing with semi-extended emission - Reduce beam solid angle ΩMeas uncertainties using Neptune shadow map to remove zodiacal light and background point sources