spur regional strategy...• case study: dublin urban limit line tool 2: zoning policies •...

45
SPUR Regional Strategy Managing the Urban Edge - Greenbelt Alliance + SPUR

Upload: others

Post on 30-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

SPUR Regional StrategyManaging the Urban Edge - Greenbelt Alliance + SPUR

Page 2: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Page 3: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Page 4: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Page 5: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Page 6: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENTHIGH RISK: 63,500 AcresGreenbelt lands that are likely to be developed in the next 10 years

MEDIUM RISK: 229,600 AcresGreenbelt lands that are likely to be developed in the next 10 to 30 years.

LOW RISK: 2,146,000 AcresGreenbelt lands that are not likely to be developed in the next 10 to 30 years.

PERMANENT PROTECTION: 1,192,900 AcresGreenbelt lands that are permanently protected from development, including public lands, land trust properties, and conservation easements.

URBAN: 790,300 AcresLands that are developed at a density of at least one residential unit per 1.5 acres, or the equivalent density for commercial or industrial development.

AT RISK:THE BAY AREA GREENBELT

C

M

Y

CM

MY

CY

CMY

K

Page 7: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

1

Managing the Urban Edge: Successful Policy Tools to Protect Open Space

and Plan for a Resilient Future

A SPUR Regional Strategy White Paper Prepared by the Greenbelt Alliance

In Partnership with SPUR

Page 8: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Tool 1: Voter-Enacted Land Use Protections

• Urban growth boundaries• County-level voter protections• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line

Tool 2: Zoning Policies

• Protecting existing open space• Resilience planning policies

I. Protecting Agriculture and Natural Habitat

Page 9: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

I. Protecting Agriculture and Natural Habitat

Dublin Urban Limit Line Example

Page 10: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

I. Protecting Agriculture and Natural Habitat

Resilience Planning

Page 11: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Tool 3: LAFCo Policies to Referee Sprawl

• LAFCo standards• Case Study: Santa Clara County LAFCo

Tool 4: Environmental Review Practices

• California Environmental Quality Act• Case Study: Vehicle Miles Traveled policy in San

Jose

II. Regulating Land Development

Page 12: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Tool 5: Mitigation of Open Space Impacts

• Programs to mitigate agricultural and habitat impacts

• Advance Mitigation Planning• Case Study: Seattle Transfers of development

rights

II. Regulating Land Development

Page 13: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

II. Regulating Land Development

Santa Clara County Regional Conservation Investment Strategy

Page 14: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Tool 6: Open Space Districts

• Special district government agencies• Case Study: Sonoma County Agricultural

Preservation and Open Space District

Tool 7: Reverting Developed Land

• Voluntary buyouts

III. Acquiring Parks and Natural Lands

Page 15: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

III. Acquiring Parks and Natural Lands

Voluntary Buyouts

Page 16: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Tool 8: Regional planning

• Councils of Government and Metropolitan Planning Organizations

• Case Study: Washington State Growth Management Act

IV. Regional Planning

Page 17: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Key Differences:

• reservoir of affordability, need for economic dev’t

• non-charismatic agricultural landscapes

• future impacts of rail: reinforcing centers, inducing sprawl?

The New Frontier: Sprawl in the Central Valley

Page 18: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

TRANSPORTATION

ENVIRONMENT

Discussion

Page 19: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Managing the Urban Edge:

Protecting Coyote Valley as Nature-Based Infrastructure

Andrea Mackenzie, General Manager

Santa Clara Valley Open Space Authority

January 21, 2020

Page 20: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

MissionThe Open Space Authority conserves the natural environment, supports agriculture, and connects people to nature by protecting open spaces, natural areas, and working farms and ranches for future generations.

Page 21: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture
Page 22: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture
Page 23: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

ESSENTIAL ENVIRONMENTAL, ECONOMIC, AND COMMUNITY BENEFITS

§ Improved air quality§ Wildlife protection§ Water quality protection§ Flood attenuation§ Local food production§ Ecosystem resilience to

climate change

§ Public health and enjoyment§ Protection of life and property

from Wildland Fire Management

§ Carbon Sequestration, Climate Adaptation, and Resilience

Page 24: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Value of Ecosystem Services in Santa Clara

County

$1.6 billion to $3.9 billion per year

of Natural Capital Goods & Services

Page 25: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Copyright © 2011 Earth Economics

How Do We Value Nature and Our Natural Capital?

Page 26: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Fall 2016 Loma Fire, San Jose, CA

Page 27: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Winter 2017 Coyote Creek Flood, San Jose

$100 M

14,000

Storm Damage

Residents Displaced

Page 28: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Copyright © 2011 Earth Economics

Page 29: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

GHG Mitigation

Page 30: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

A N I R R E P L A C E A B L EM U LT I - B E N E F I T L A N D S C A P E

C O YO T E VA L L E Y:

Page 31: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Coyote Valley

Diablo Mountain RangeSan Jose

San Francisco Bay

Santa Cruz Mountain Range

Page 32: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture
Page 33: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture
Page 34: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

San Jose

Coyote Valley

Diablo Mountain Range Santa Cruz Mountain Range

Morgan Hill

Page 35: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Tracking Coyote Val ley Bobcat Movement 2 0 1 7 - 2 0 1 8

Page 36: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Coyote Valley Water Resources

Page 37: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Creek Floodplains in the City of San Jose

Page 38: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Natural Floodplains, Northern Coyote Valley. Winter 2019

Page 39: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

event

Page 40: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

COYOTE VALLEY & AGRICULTURE

Page 41: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

Purchase of North Coyote Val ley Lands

Derek Neumann

Page 42: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture
Page 43: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

$46.3 Million(Measure T)

$42.16 Million(+ $2.41M Weyhe)

$5 Million(Measure Q)

Total: $96 Million

Page 44: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

The Properties

Page 45: SPUR Regional Strategy...• Case Study: Dublin Urban Limit Line Tool 2: Zoning Policies • Protecting existing open space • Resilience planning policies I. Protecting Agriculture

COYOTE VALLEY AS A COMMUNITY

ASSET