stability improvement of a wind diesel system using an energy storage unit
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
1/121
Stability Improvement of a Wind/Diesel
System Using an Energy Storage Unit
Chung Der Chyuan (11012902)
25th October 2002
A Thesis submitted for partial fulfillment of the degree of
Bachelor of Engineering (Electrical)
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
2/121
Stability Improvement of a Wind/Diesel System
Using an Energy Storage Unit
Chung
Der Chyuan
25th October 2002
Bachelor Of Engineering
Dr. W.W.L. Keerthipala
This report presents the modeling and simulation of an isolated
Wind/Diesel system. The simulation was done using the
PSCAD/EMTDC software package. Individual system components were
simulated and discuss in details. Stability aspect of the Wind/Diesel
system under various type of disturbances were analyzed and
improvements technique was introduced to the system. Finally,
recommendations were iven for future work and conclusion made.
Wind Turbine, Induction Generator, Diesel Generator, Energy Storage
Unit, Stability, Disturbances, PSCAD/EMTDC
Electrical
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
3/121
Mr. Chung Der Chyuan
04 Werribee Crescent
Willetton
Perth, W.A. 6155
25th October 2002
Professor A. M. Zoubir
Head of school
School of Electrical and Computer Engineering
Curtin University of Technology
P.O. Box U1987
Perth, W.A. 6000
Dear Professor Zoubir,
Project Thesis for Engineering Honours Project 402
Please find the attached thesis on the project titled Stability Improvement of a
Wind/Diesel System using Energy Storage Unit, in the fulfillment of the
requirements of the Engineering Honours Project unit for the Award of Bachelor of
Engineering (Electrical)
Thank you & best regards,
Chung Der Chyuan
Student No: 11012902
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
4/121
Abstract
The main objective of this final year project is to analyze and simulate the complete
scheme of wind/diesel system. The analysis of typical wind/diesel energy systems for
remote area applications is being performed using the PSCAD/EMTDC software.
Using software modeling of a wind/diesel system provides an in-depth understanding
of the system operation before building the actual system and also the testing and
experiments of system operation under disturbances is not possible on the actual
system.
The first stage of the project is to analyze each individual wind/diesel system
components using mathematical equations and to model them in software simulation.
The simulation was done in time domain analysis and the resulting waveforms are
shown in the report.
In the second phase of the project, each individual system components were
combined to form the overall wind/diesel system. Dynamic stability analysis on the
wind/diesel system was performed and stability improvement technique was being
used to stabilize the system performances.
i
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
5/121
Acknowledgments
The author would like to thank the people who have contributed to the development
and progress of this final year project. Without their guidance and patience, the
project would not have come to this stage.
Many thanks must be extended to Dr. W.W.L. Keerthipala, who has been so
generous with his time in support, guidance, patience and advice throughout the
project. Much gratitude is due to the project co-supervisor, Mr. James Goh for his
interest and time spent in this project, as well as his assistance in providing
information and in discussing certain aspects of the wind/diesel system.
Many thanks to the School of Electrical Engineering for the computer facilities and
software during the working process of this project.
ii
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
6/121
Table of Contents
Abstract......................................................................................................................... i
Acknowledgments........................................................................................................ ii
Nomenclature.............................................................................................................. ix
CHAPTER ONE
1.0 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................. 1
1.2 Background information ........................................................................................ 1
1.3 Wind Power ........................................................................................................... 4
1.4 Wind Component................................................................................................... 6
1.4.1 Wind Turbine Components............................................................................. 7
CHAPTER TWO
2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW ...................................................................................... 9
2.1 Introduction............................................................................................................ 9
2.2 Wind Turbine Generators..................................................................................... 11
2.2.1 Induction Generator Applications................................................................. 12
2.2.3 Analysis Of Induction Generator.................................................................. 13
2.2.4 Dynamic Performance Of Wind Turbine-Induction Generator .................... 14
2.2.5 Unbalanced-Voltage Problem In Wind Turbine Generation ........................ 15
2.2.6 Wind Turbine Generator Site Selection........................................................ 17
2.3 Wind/Diesel System............................................................................................. 18
2.3.1 Wind/Diesel System Fundamental................................................................ 19
2.3.2 Wind/Diesel System Strategies..................................................................... 22
2.4 Wind Hybrid System............................................................................................ 25
iii
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
7/121
2.5 Wind Farm ........................................................................................................... 26
2.5.4 Wind Farm Power Quality............................................................................ 27
2.5.1 Wind Farm Protection................................................................................... 29
2.6 Flickers................................................................................................................. 30
2.7 Noise .................................................................................................................... 31
CHAPTER THREE
3.0 Modeling of Wind/Diesel System........................................................................ 32
3.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................... 32
3.1 Induction Machine ............................................................................................... 33
3.2 Synchronous Machine Model .............................................................................. 36
3.3 Synchronous Machine Automatic Controller ...................................................... 39
3.3.1 Automatic Voltage Regulator (AVR) ........................................................... 40
3.3.2 Excitation system .......................................................................................... 42
3.4 Compensation Capacitor Bank Model................................................................. 44
3.5 Energy Storage Unit............................................................................................. 45
3.5.1 Battery Energy Storage System .................................................................... 46
3.5.2 Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage (SMES) Unit ........................... 47
3.5.3 Flywheel Energy Storage.............................................................................. 50
CHAPTER FOUR
4.0 Computer Simulation ........................................................................................... 52
4.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................... 53
4.2 Wind Turbine Model............................................................................................ 55
4.3 Induction Generator Model.................................................................................. 59
iv
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
8/121
4.4 Diesel Generator Model....................................................................................... 62
4.5 Power-Conditioning Unit ..................................................................................... 64
4.5.1 Rectifier Model ............................................................................................. 65
4.5.2 Inverter Model .............................................................................................. 67
4.6 Overall System Operation.................................................................................... 70
4.6.1 Synchronization ............................................................................................ 70
CHAPTER FIVE
5.0 System Operation With Energy Storage Unit ...................................................... 73
5.1 Disconnection of Diesel Generator From System ............................................... 74
5.2 Fault Occurrence at Wind Generator Bus-bar...................................................... 76
5.3 Wind speed variation ........................................................................................... 80
CHAPTER SIX
6.0 Future Recommendations .................................................................................... 83
CHAPTER SEVEN
7.0 Conclusion ........................................................................................................... 85
CHAPTER EIGHT
8.0 References............................................................................................................ 86
Appendix A: Overall System Operation
Appendix B: Disconnection of Diesel Generator From System
Appendix C: Fault Occurrence in Wind Generator Bus-Bar
Appendix D: Wind Speed Variation
Appendix E: Load Profile of Albany
v
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
9/121
List of Figures
Figure 1. 1: Growth of wind and PV capacity [15]...................................................... 3
Figure 1. 2: Wind Turbine Components [47]............................................................... 7
Figure 2. 1: Single line diagram for typical wind turbine generator configuration. .. 11
Figure 2. 2: Connection of wind energy system [18]................................................. 16
Figure 3. 1: d-q equivalent circuit of induction machine........................................... 35
Figure 3. 2: Illustration of the positions of d-q axis on a two-pole machine ............. 37
Figure 3. 3: Phasor diagram of synchronous machine in steady state ....................... 37
Figure 3. 4: IEEE Type 1 AVR model [38]. .............................................................. 42
Figure 3. 5:Synchronous excitation control system................................................... 44
Figure 3. 6: Battery Energy Storage System interface to power system ................... 47
Figure 3. 7: SMES basic operation ............................................................................ 48
Figure 3. 8: Schematic Configuration Of A Superconducting Magnetic Energy
Storage Unit. [38]..................................................................................... 50
Figure 4. 1: Wind/Diesel system block diagram........................................................ 54
Figure 4. 2: Power curve of manufacturer vs. polynomial fit curve for 225kW turbine
.................................................................................................................. 56
Figure 4. 3: PSCAD circuit diagram of 225kW wind turbine ................................... 57
Figure 4. 4: Power curve of 225kW wind turbine...................................................... 58
Figure 4. 5: Induction Generator model..................................................................... 59
Figure 4. 6: Power generated by Induction generator................................................ 60
vi
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
10/121
Figure 4. 7: Line and phase voltages generated......................................................... 61
Figure 4. 8: Diesel Generator model in PSCAD........................................................ 62
Figure 4. 9: Diesel Generator output power............................................................... 63
Figure 4. 10: AC to DC conversion rectifier model................................................... 65
Figure 4. 11: Rectifier output voltage........................................................................ 66
Figure 4. 12: Rectifier input phase voltages .............................................................. 66
Figure 4. 13: Inverter circuit model ........................................................................... 67
Figure 4. 14: Gate signals and PWM circuit.............................................................. 68
Figure 4. 15: PWM switching technique ................................................................... 69
Figure 4. 16: Load phase voltages due to synchronization........................................ 71
Figure 4. 17: Load power due to synchronization ..................................................... 72
Figure 4. 18: Overall System circuit diagram in PSCAD.......................................... 72
Figure 5. 1: Battery equivalent circuit model ............................................................ 73
Figure 5. 2: Generated power without energy storage unit........................................ 74
Figure 5. 3: Generated power with energy storage unit............................................. 75
Figure 5. 4: Generated power and voltage during fault ............................................. 76
Figure 5. 5: Over-current circuit representation......................................................... 78
Figure 5. 6: Over-current Relay control logic............................................................ 78
Figure 5. 7: Generated power during fault with battery storage unit......................... 79
Figure 5. 8: Wind speed variation.............................................................................. 80
Figure 5. 9: Generated wind power increase.............................................................. 81
Figure 5. 10: Diesel generator power during increase of wind speed........................ 81
Figure 5. 11: Diesel generator power with battery bank during increase in wind speed
.......................................................................................................................................82
vii
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
11/121
List of Tables
Table 1: Data of power vs. wind speed curve............................................................ 55
Table 2: Result of fitting manufacturer curve data to polynomial curve of several
orders........................................................................................................... 56
viii
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
12/121
Nomenclature
Induction Generator
ids, iqs Peak stator d and q axes currents
idr, iqr Peak rotor d and q axes currents
is Rms stator current
vds,vqs Peak stator d and q axes voltages
vg Peak magnitude of air-gap voltage
im Peak magnetising current
Lm Magnetising inductance
Lr, Ls Rotor and stator self inductances
Llr, Lls Rotor and stator leakage inductances
rr, rs Rotor and stator resistances
wr Shaft speed (rad/sec)
we Electrical frequency (rad/sec)
ds,qs Peak stator d and q axes flux linkages
ds, qs Peak rotor d and q axes flux linkages
B, J Net friction and inertia of the rotating parts of the system
Tm Mechanical torque
N Number of poles
X open circuit reactance
X open circuit transient reactance
To rotor open circuit transient time constant (sec)
Vt a.c machine terminal (bus-bar) voltages (p.u)
Vd, Vq Voltage coordinates: Vt = Vd + jVq (p.u)
ix
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
13/121
Ed, Eq Voltages behind transient reactance X (p.u)
IA Current magnitude (p.u)
Id, Iq Current coordinates (p.u)
Synchronous Generator
H Inertia time constant
Xd, Xq Direct and quadrature axis reactance
Xd, Xq Direct and quadrature axis transient reactance
Xd, Xq Direct and quadrature axis sub-transient reactance
Ed Voltage behind the transient reactance Xd (p.u)
Ed, Eq Voltages behind sub-transient reactance Xd and Xq (p.u)
Tqo Open circuit sub-transient time constant (sec)
Tdo, Tdo Open circuit transient and sub-transient time constants of
direct axis (sec)
Automatic Voltage Regulator
R, A, F, E Subsystems indices: regulator input filter (R), amplifier (A),
stabilizer (S), exciter (E)
K Gain constant of subsystem indices
T Time constant of subsystem indices
Vref Reference voltage (p.u)
x
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
14/121
CHAPTER ONE
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.2 Background information
The total annual energy consumption in 1997 was 1015 BTUs and almost half of the
total primary energy used is for generating electricity. To meet this demand,
electrical generating capacity installed must be increased. [41] Today, in many parts
of the world, the decisions for new capacity installation become complicated due to
the fact that finding new sites for generation and transmission facilities of any kind
are difficult. Particularly rural areas in the developing world where most of the
population is located, most people lack the essential energy services to satisfy most
of their basic needs. The cost of grid connection in these rural areas is very high due
to a low density of population; therefore various organizations have turn to explore
alternative solutions. [21]
One of the most economical and reliable alternatives is to use diesel power
generation, but diesel power generation is very inefficient when the load is a small
percentage of the rated power of the engine. The fact that every time, there is a need
for power the engine has to operate makes it very inconvenient and reduces the
efficiency and lifetime of the power generation system. As a result, wind energy
system has been suggested to provide a good solution to supply energy loads in these
rural areas. Wind energy system has been proven to be more profitable than other
1
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
15/121
electrification utilities for rural areas and also it can provide an uninterrupted supply
of electricity, ease of installation, low maintenance and high reliability. [21]
Farmers have used wind energy for centuries in many different applications, but due
to todays business conditions, it is difficult to decide which applications will be
economic to use. [6] Comparing windmills in the early years, todays wind turbines
uses innovative technology that have substantially reduced the cost of electricity
generated from wind power. In the 1920s and 1930s, farm families throughout the
world used wind to generate enough electricity to power their lights and electric
motors. The use of wind power declined with the government subsidized
construction of utility lines and fossil fuel power plants [41]. However, due to the
energy crisis in the 1970s and growing concern for the environment have gained an
interest in alternative, environmental friendly energy resources. Today, homeowners
in rural and remote locations again examine renewable generated energy to provide
electricity for domestic needs [26].
Wind is a natural resource created by heating of the earths surface. Using wind
turbines, wind can be utilized and convert into electrical energy by connecting
mechanically rotating blades to a generator.
2
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
16/121
With the technical advances in wind turbine technology, the efficiency of wind
turbines increases and the cost per kilowatt-hour (kWh) of wind generated electricity
decreases. The wind industry also achieved in areas such as noise reduction, power
quality and also the power output capacity which is the amount of electricity a wind
turbine can produce at specific wind speed increasing. As a result, world wind energy
capacity is currently doubling every three years and two months; this is shown in
figure 1.1. From figure1.1, it can be seen that as a comparison, photovoltaic is
growing at a slower rate than wind. [15]
Figure 1. 1: Growth of wind and PV capacity [15]
3
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
17/121
1.3 Wind Power
Winds are only an intermittent source of energy. From past investigations and
studies, the intermittency of wind energy is no barrier to large-scale usage. The most
basic and important application of wind is to generate electricity, with the wind
turbines operating with utility grid systems or in parallel with diesel engines in
remote locations. Utilities have the flexibility to accept a contribution of about 20%
or more from wind energy systems and more than 50% fuel savings from wind-diesel
systems. [32]
The kinetic energy in the air mass m moving with speed V is given by [41]:
Kinetic Energy =2
1. m . V2 joules 1.1
The power in moving air is the flow rate of kinetic energy per second.
Hence:
Power =2
1. (mass flow rate per second). V2 1.2
Letting P = mechanical power in moving air
= air density, kg/m3
A = area swept by the rotor blades, m2
V = velocity of the air, m/s
4
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
18/121
then, the volumetric flow rate is A.V, the mass flow rate of the air in kilograms per
second is *A*V, and the power is given by [41]:
P =21 (AV). V2 =
21 AV3 watts 1.3
The kinetic energy available in the wind is not possible to be harnessed total. This is
because to utilize all the kinetic energy of the wind and convert it to some other form
of energy, this would mean that the velocity of the air particles after the collector
device would be zero. Provided that one has available an infinite vacuum space to
collect the zero velocity air particles, this would not be possible. Therefore under
most ideal conditions, only 16/27 of wind energy can be utilized and converted to
other form of energy. This factor is known as the Betz Coefficient.
Therefore, the wind power from wind turbine is given by:
P =2
1CpAV
3 watts 1.4
Where, Cp is the power coefficient.
From the above equation, the power output from a wind turbine is proportional to the
cube of the wind speed; therefore site selection is an important factor to consider.
5
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
19/121
1.4 Wind Component
The wind power system is consist of one or more units, operating electrically in
parallel, comprising of the following components:
Wind tower
Two or three blades wind turbine
Yaw mechanism
Mechanical gear
Electrical generator
Speed sensors and control
In addition to modern wind power system the following components are often
included:
Power electronics
Control electronics
Battery storage for improving the load availability in stand-alone
configuration
Transmission link for grid connection
6
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
20/121
1.4.1 Wind Turbine Components
Figure 1. 2: Wind Turbine Components [47]
Disc Brake: The disc brake is used in case of failure of the aerodynamic brake,
or when the turbine is being serviced.
Gearbox: The gearbox has the low speed shaft to the left. It makes the high-
speed shaft to the right turn approximately 50 times faster than
the low speed shaft.
Generator: The electrical generator is usually an induction generator or
asynchronous generator.
7
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
21/121
Hub: The hub of the rotor is attached to the low speed shaft of the wind
turbine.
Hydraulics System: The hydraulics system is used to reset the aerodynamic brakes of
the wind turbine.
Body Frame: The body frame is to support the generator and contains the key
components of the wind turbine, including the gearbox, and the
electrical generator.
Main Shaft: The rotor main shaft of the wind turbine connects the rotor hub to
the gearbox.
Radiator: The radiator contains an electric fan that is used to cool the
electrical generator. In addition, it contains a hydraulics system
which is used to cool the oil in the gearbox.
Yaw Motor: The yaw motor uses electrical motors to turn the nacelle with the
rotor against the wind. The yaw drive is operated by the
electronic controller that senses the wind direction using the
wind vane.
8
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
22/121
CHAPTER TWO
2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Introduction
The generation of wind power is increasingly becoming popular in the past few
years. In the United States, many applications of wind power are related to large-
scale, utility-size wind farms where thousands of wind turbines are interconnected to
generate large-scale electricity and in other parts of the world, smaller scales wind
turbines are installed to provide electricity that is sufficient to demands. [18]
In the past, wind turbines are used as a direct shaft power. The rotor axle was directly
connected to the millstone at the old windmills. Today the output power from the
wind turbines is utilized in two ways. One is by direct use of the mechanical shaft
power, the other is letting the wind turbine power an electrical generator and then
utilize the power as electrical power. The problem of using mechanical shaft power
is of course that the wind turbine has to be close to the place of the machine used. By
letting the wind turbine drive an electrical generator, one can transfer the power over
a large distance to the final utilization. [47]
The energy produced by wind is clean and safe to use and has low external and social
costs. Liabilities related to decommissioning of obsolete power plants will not occur
on wind energy conversion systems. As comparing to fossil fuelled electricity
production, wind turbines do not produce green house gases. [47] Numerous research
9
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
23/121
and studies were conducted to investigate the environmental impact of wind energy
on the environment. These studies include the noise and visual effects on the
surrounding environment in the early year. In the recent years, studies in the United
States, Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark and the United Kingdom had concluded
that wind turbines do not pose any substantial threat to birds. [47]
Wind power is an ideal technology for electrification of rapidly industrializing
countries as well as industrialized areas and countries. Wind energy application can
include all types of systems such as: grid connected wind farms, hybrid energy
systems, and stand-alone systems. Wind energy is a reliable technology for both fuel,
and small remote grids and special applications such as desalination as well as large
grids. Since wind power is modular, more power can be added quickly as the demand
increased and it is a cost effective technology in many developing areas and
countries. [47]
10
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
24/121
2.2 Wind Turbine Generators
Most of the wind turbine generators installed, except for the case of stand-alone
systems, are directly connected to the grid. This configuration of connection is
widely used in most of the countries in the world due to its cost-effectiveness and
robust solution for the wind turbine owners.
However the main draw back of this configuration is that the wind turbine generators
consume reactive power for the excitation of the rotors. In order to compensate the
reactive power consumption, the wind turbine uses capacitor bank as shown in
Figure 3.1. Other wind turbines have installed additional capacitors to compensate
for the reactive power consumption in the transformer. The capacitor banks are
typically designed only to compensate for the generator no-load consumption of
reactive power. The capacitor bank for no-load compensation is connected to the rid
in steps, immediately after the connection of the generator to the grid. Also the
capacitor bank is divided into steps to limit the transients during switching.
GearBox
Generator
CapacitorBank
TransformerGridWindTurbine
Figure 2. 1: Single line diagram for typical wind turbine generator configuration.
11
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
25/121
2.2.1 Induction Generator Applications
In most wind energy system applications, the use of self-excited induction generator
(SEIG) is well known. [5, 55] Induction generators are capable of generating power
from variable speed as well as constant speed prime movers, however fixed speed
may not generate as much energy yield as a fully variable speed system. Induction
generators configuration is simple and the maintenance cost is low. [5] The
operating concepts of self-excited induction machines nowadays is increasingly
studied and well documented. Several methods of estimation of the generator
performance during steady state and during transient have been developed. [62]
Several domestic applications of induction machines driven from wind turbine have
been studied. The concept of using a self-excited induction generator driven from a
wind turbine for water storage heating was discussed in [55]. The primary objective
of this paper is to operate the wind turbine at its optimum tip-speed ratio using an
appropriate designed controller. [55] Using induction machine for wind energy
conversion as well as for water pumping is proposed in [36]. Since induction
generator has the disadvantage that it is a sink of reactive power and cannot provide
the reactive power requirements of consumers, a static VAR compensator is used for
providing the magnetizing currents of the induction machines in the system. [36]
From the simulated and experimental results presented in [36], through the adopting
of an indirect induction generator stator flux control strategy, the system steady state
and dynamic operation is able to maintain at a nearly constant flux operation,
meaning that the system can operate better and over wider range of speed range. [36]
12
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
26/121
2.2.3 Analysis Of Induction Generator
For a wind energy conversion system that uses induction generator, a dc link
converter is essential for power conversion. The induction generator produces current
at variable frequency. This current is rectified onto the dc link using a converter with
six active switches. To convert the dc to a fixed frequency of the utility, a second
converter with six switches is needed. This results in many switches needed for wind
energy conversion system. Hence a new method that uses a six-switch current
regulated pulse width modulated inverter and a zero sequence filter is proposed to
eliminate some of the switches used and still retaining the original functionality of
the system. [17]
The study of induction generator steady state analysis and performance
characteristics is important due to the speed fluctuations of unregulated wind
turbines, the terminal voltage may increase to dangerously high levels which have
been reported to cause capacitor failure at wind farms. Over-voltages are the major
cause of excitation capacitor failure. Using a saturable transformer connected to the
terminals of the induction generator will improve voltage regulation and also
protection against over-voltages. [62]
13
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
27/121
2.2.4 Dynamic Performance Of Wind Turbine-Induction
Generator
The problem of using wind as an input source of power generation is that wind varies
from time to time due to wind gusts, and is further disturbed by the effect of
supporting tower shadow. However with the advances in power electronics, the use
of static VAR compensator to regulate voltage produced from wind generator system
became an alternative solution to overcome the problem of input variation. To
achieved stability of the system, a state and output PI controller is proposed to
control the static VAR controller and the mechanical input power to the generator.
From software simulation results, the proposed controller shows good damping
performance for the wind generation system under severe wind gust and large
electrical system disturbances. [19] Another method of damping oscillations in terms
of induction generator mechanical point of view is to use a sliding mode control. The
sliding mode control provides suitable compromise between maximizing conversion
efficiency and damping torque oscillations under disturbances. [26, 27]
14
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
28/121
2.2.5 Unbalanced-Voltage Problem In Wind Turbine Generation
In a utility system, an unbalanced voltage occurs when single-phase loads are not
uniformly applied to all three-phases. Induction machines operating in unbalanced
conditions will results in heating problems and decreasing of operating efficiency.
Unbalanced voltage usually occurs in rural electric power systems having long
distribution lines that are fed by induction generators driven by wind turbines. Other
causes of unbalanced voltage are form unsymmetrical transformer windings or
transmission impedance, unbalanced loads in transmission lines and many others.
[18]
In a wind generation system as shown in Figure 3.2, unbalanced loading at the point
of common coupling (PCC) will result in unbalanced voltage at PCC. This
unbalanced voltage will cause large negative sequence currents due to low negative
sequence impedance of induction generator. Eventually these large currents will
cause unbalanced heating (hot spot) in the machine windings that can eventually lead
to machine failure. Also the unbalanced voltage operation will create a pulsating
torque which produces speed pulsation, mechanical vibration and acoustic noise. [18]
15
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
29/121
InductionGenerator
Unbalanced Load
Point Of CommonCoupling (PCC)
InfiniteBus
Transmission Line
LR
WindTurbine
Figure 2. 2: Connection of wind energy system [18]
Using steady state and dynamic analysis and simulation on the impact of unbalanced
voltages on the three-phase induction generator, solutions to improve the unbalanced
conditions are deduced which are to increase the power capability of transmission
lines, redistribute load periodically to equalize any unbalanced load and to use power
converter with wind turbine on the utility side. [18]
16
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
30/121
2.2.6 Wind Turbine Generator Site Selection
To design and operate a wind energy system efficiently it is important to match the
wind turbine to the potential site. If the matching requirements are not fulfil, the
energy generated from the wind energy system will not be optimal. Factors to
consider are:
variation of wind speed distribution,
cut-in velocity of wind turbine,
rated velocity of wind turbine and,
cut-out velocity of wind turbine.
To achieve the matching requirements, methods like the Weibull statistical model
and the power curves normalization method are used. Through case studies
developed in [64-66], these methods being implemented can serve as useful tool to
make judicious choice of potential site and wind turbine generator system from the
available potential sites and wind turbine generator.
17
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
31/121
2.3 Wind/Diesel System
Some years ago, wind-diesel system was configured as putting a wind turbine into
a small diesel network. These early and unsophisticated systems saved little if any
diesel fuel. As technologies advances and research being carried out, the necessary
requirement of wind-diesel system is to be able to stop the diesel engines as partially
loaded diesels run very inefficiently. [44] Grid connected wind energy conversion
system influences the system to certain extent due to varying power output from the
wind energy conversion system. On a large interconnected grid system, this is seen
mainly in localized voltage variations and fluctuations on a variety of timescales,
from voltage waveform harmonics through flicker to long-term voltage variations.
As a result a wind/diesel schemes strategy will be required, such as energy storage or
load control, so that sudden drops in wind power can be buffered in one way or
another. [54]
18
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
32/121
2.3.1 Wind/Diesel System Fundamental
Wind/Diesel system can be classified according to different levels of wind
penetration. Wind penetration is defined as: [72]
Instantaneous penetration =Wind Power Output (kW)
Primary Electrical Load (kW) 2.1
Average Penetration =Wind Energy Produced (kWh)Primary Energy Demand(kWh) 2.2
In low wind penetration, the diesel generator will run at full time with the wind
power reducing the net load on the diesel generator. All the wind energy generated
will be supplying the primary load. Low wind penetration system is the easiest to
integrate with existing diesel system and modification to the diesel plant is not
necessary; therefore it has the lowest capital cost. Due to the simplicity of this
configuration, fuel savings is only up to ~20%. [72]
In medium wind penetration, the diesel generator will operate at full time. During
high wind power levels, the secondary loads will be dispatched to ensure sufficient
diesel loading and alternatively, wind turbines are curtailed during high winds and
low loads. To achieve this dispatching of loads, simple control system is required. As
compared to low wind penetration, medium wind penetration required some diesel
controls modification, automated diesel operation and integration of secondary
loads. It also has higher capital cost and greater fuel savings of ~40%. [72]
19
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
33/121
In high wind penetration, the diesel generator can be shut down during high wind
availability and auxiliary components are required so as to regulate voltage and
frequency. Conventional diesel control will be modified with new diesel control and
sophisticated supervisory control system required to monitor the system operation.
This configuration provide as high as ~70% of fuel savings and higher capital cost.
[42]
When the wind generator output is sufficient to supply the load demand, it is
impractical to keep the diesel generator on-line as spinning reserve to cover short-
term deficits in wind generator output. Hence frequent start-stop cycling of diesel
generator is impractically high. This frequent start-stop diesel engine cycling is a
fuel-inefficient mode that also may have a detrimental impact on engine and engine
starter life. Also, there are certain types of diesel engines that have warm up
requirements, which made it impossible for rapid start-stop operation. Therefore,
under these typical circumstances it is favorable for short-term energy storage system
to be integrated into the wind-diesel system operation during prolonged windless
periods or when the wind generator output is insufficient to supply the load demand.
[1]
Seal lead-acid battery is used as a form of energy storage for the wind/diesel system.
Past objections of lead-acid batteries usage due to the requirement watering and the
hydrogen gas explosion hazard have been eliminated by the improved sealed design.
However, lead-acid batteries are ill suited to short-term storage application, which is
characterized primarily by the rate, rather than by the amount of energy transfer. As
20
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
34/121
such that a battery system of suitable power rating will be considerably oversized
with respect to its energy storage rating and thus not cost effective. [1]
Another short-term energy storage is the conventional steel flywheels, which is
directly coupled to a synchronous generator driven by diesel engine during wind
deficits. In the system the synchronous generator can be decoupled from the diesel
by clutch means but it is still connected to the load bus. The advantage of using
flywheel is that it is simple to construct. But the specific energy capacity of steel
flywheel is relatively low and especially so for rotor disks which are pierced to
receive shaft. [1] Power electronic drive capable of bi-directional power flow is
required between the diesel generator and synchronous machine so that energy from
a flywheel can be store and retrieve at continuous changing speed. In addition,
accurate control of the power in and out of the flywheel requires fast and accurate
control of the torque on the shaft of the synchronous machine. With the combination
of flywheel energy buffer and fast-response power electronic integrated into the
wind/diesel system, voltage disturbances at the point of coupling and in the
distribution system due to frequent wind power fluctuations will be avoided, also
frequent start/stop cycling of diesel generator in autonomous power systems
prevented. [29]
21
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
35/121
2.3.2 Wind/Diesel System Strategies
Many investigations have been conducted to model wind/diesel system. In [9], a
computer simulation program has been developed to investigate the dynamics of an
isolated power system supplied from diesel and wind under 100% wind penetration
in wind/diesel power supplied isolated network. A wind/diesel system model was
developed using mathematical equations and is presented in the paper. A control
policy was developed to minimize frequency and voltage disturbances due to wind
turbulence and gusts and load demand fluctuations. An eigenvalue analysis followed
by the participation-matrix technique is applied to identify weak points in the
stability of the system. Through simulation results, the implementation of the control
policy into wind diesel system under 100% wind penetration has achieved acceptable
performance.
The difficulties of integrating wind energy and various approaches in solving these
problems have been discussed in [13]. Also the role of energy storage is examined,
both to deal with operational problems and to improved wind energy utilization. A
summary of actual installations of wind/diesel system is presented to illustrate the
various approaches to problems covered in different locations. Results from
monitoring exercises are quoted, where possible, to indicate the performance
expected from the different system designs in practice. It was emphasize that it is
misleading to suggest that there exists one preferred design for wind/diesel systems.
The optimum design will depend on the particular needs of the consumer. [13]
22
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
36/121
System sizing is an important factor to consider when implementing a stand-alone
wind/diesel system. Through correct sizing of the system, the required power
supplied to consumer is enhance and energy produced will not be wasted [51]. A
reliable/cost evaluation model described in [51] has been applied to obtain optimal
utilization of wind energy sources in small isolated power system capacity
expansion. A useful concept regarding appropriate dates, types of energy sources and
their penetration levels in the formulation of potentially beneficial capacity schemes
for composite small isolated power system. In [22], a sizing methodology was
developed based on the power curve of wind turbine, physical (charge current
limitation) and cost considerations. The optimized energy system for various levels
of satisfaction (LLP), i.e. both able to satisfy the load with a certain percentage of the
load not satisfied and to offer the lowest kWh cost was determined and studied. An
existing isolated system is being use to justify the methodology developed and
various findings has been concluded. [22]
Besides using battery or flywheel as a form of short-term energy storage, the use of
Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage unit (SMES) can be implemented into
wind/diesel system. Due to its fast acting characteristics, SMES can effectively damp
electromechanical oscillations in the system when there is a sudden change in power
requirement. It also provides energy storage capacity in addition to kinetic energy of
the generator rotor. Through simulation results, it was shown in [57] that the system
dynamic and transient stability with SMES increases as compare to the system
without SMES. Further improvements in the control of SMES on wind/diesel system
23
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
37/121
are shown in [35]. A complete model of the wind/diesel system with SMES was
developed and was used for eigenvalue analysis and in the design of controllers.
24
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
38/121
2.4 Wind Hybrid System
In a wind hybrid system, the certainty of meeting load demands at all time is greatly
enhanced using more than one power source. Besides using diesel generator with
wind turbine for electrical generation, batteries are used to meet the daily load
fluctuation in short terms and diesel generator are used to meet long term load
fluctuation. [39]
In some hybrid systems the wind turbine is combined with PV panels to generate
electricity for stand-alone applications. Such systems usually consist of wind turbine
generators, PV panels, storage batteries and backup generators. The hybrid wind/PV
power system greatly enhance the generation of electricity and being emission free,
the energy coming from the wind and sunrays is available at no cost. [12,39]
When there is more than one source of generation in a system, a smart controller is
needed so as to protect the equipments in the system and to ensure sufficient power
flow to the load. Most controllers are electronic controller, which based on
parameters such as load demand, generator status and battery sate of charge to
perform the necessary tasks required. [12] Due to the high complexity in designing
the controller, most controllers are custom designed. Besides controllers, an inverter
or a power-conditioning unit, PCU, is necessary to drive ac loads from dc source and
also a rectifier is required to charge the battery from engine generator. [20]
25
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
39/121
2.5 Wind Farm
Wind farms are clusters of wind turbines that generate electricity. Wind farms are
usually located in areas with reliably favourable wind speeds. [50] Most of the wind
farms developed by private companies are in the United States. These private
companies uses their own land from farmers and ranches or in some cases from the
government to developed wind farm and sell the electricity produced to power
marketers, electric utilities, etc. [73]
The largest wind farms, in terms of the number of turbines in a single area, are in
California. The reasons for the California wind farms being the largest are because
the California wind farms are in places where very favourable wind occur and also
they are near to electric power transmission lines and large cities. Hence, peak winds
in these areas occur approximately at the same times as the peak electricity demand
in the cities. [73]
The three largest wind farms in the world presently are at Altamont Pass, California,
just east of San Francisco, in the Tehachapi Mountains in Kern Country, and at San
Gorgonio Pass, just north of Palm Springs, where there are thousands of wind
turbines at each of these wind farms. [73]
26
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
40/121
2.5.4 Wind Farm Power Quality
In remote/rural regions where electric power supplies are not economically favored,
the use of renewable energy resources is of great importance. Wind energy being the
most commercially interesting applications are widely used in these areas. However,
the problem with wind power installations is the power quality impact that wind
turbines have on weak or rural grids. Variations in the wind speed and also variations
in output power from wind turbines create power pulsations. This has led to high
costs for connecting the wind turbines to the grid, up to 20% of the total cost of a
wind turbine installation. [68] From the technical point of view the integration of the
power produced by standard wind turbines in a weak grid should be dealt with care
and the requested design tools must be developed and used in order to maintain the
grid power quality. [7]
On weak networks in rural areas, the majority of customer loads are single-phase. If
these are not correctly shared out between the phases, voltage unbalance will result.
Although induction machines connected to such networks will act to reduce the
unbalance, in the operating process induction machines will be subject to
overheating. It is known that in some cases voltage unbalance has been above the
specified levels, and significant wind turbine downtime has occurred. [4]
One way to improve power quality is to use turbines of various kinds in order to
optimize the energy output per invested amount of money. Or, to use converters only
at lower powers where there is an energy gain and use directly connected induction
27
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
41/121
generators at higher wind speeds. Also the converter at this configuration can, at high
wind speeds, be used as reactive power sources. [68]
The real and reactive power problems due to the wind turbines in wind farm will
affect voltages on the network as it flows through the network impedances. For
weak/rural networks, the connections of wind farms can results in significant impact
on voltages, load demands and power losses. [63]
To minimize the impact of voltage variations on the network, static compensators,
STATCOMs, can be used to improve both the steady state and dynamic impact of a
wind farm on the network. To further improve the use of STATCOMs, control
strategy is being adopted to prevent over-voltages that occur under islanding
conditions. [77] Another method to minimize voltage variations is the use of reactive
power regulation ability of an advanced power electronic interface, thus voltage
fluctuation can be minimized to acceptable levels. Also the system harmonics
requirements can be met by using higher frequency pulse width modulation, PWM,
switching technique together with a relatively low cost harmonic filter. [76]
Power utilities have also specified limits on the maximum instantaneous step change
in voltage that a customer can cause. Wind turbines can cause voltage step changes
when starting, or when changing between generators. For very weak points on a
network, this issue may be the limiting factor on the number and size of wind
turbines that may be connected. [7]
28
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
42/121
2.5.1 Wind Farm Protection
In a wind farm the protection of equipments against fault is necessary because when
a fault occur, the wind farm reliability is maintained and also lower the cost of
replacing breakdown equipments. Normally the wind turbine induction generator in a
wind farm is individually connected to a transformer and in turn connected to one or
more medium voltage power collection circuits. In a wind farm the main protection
of the generator transformer is through a medium voltage fuse that is house in a ring
main unit. In case of a low/high current fault occurrence, the fuse is able to clear the
fault in the low voltage winding as well as in the medium winding. [61]
In [61], an alternative relay is use to replace the fuse currently used to reduce the
wind farm construction cost. This proposed relay have the ability of protecting the
power collection circuit and the medium and low voltage windings of each generator
against faults and thus eliminating the use of medium voltage fuse and the ring main
unit that houses them. However the elimination of low voltage fuses is not necessary
since the low voltage fuse are inexpensive. Several monitoring studies have been
carried out based on practical feasibility of proposed relay in wind farm and
simulation to confirm the operations of relay during fault occurrence.
29
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
43/121
2.6 Flickers
Flicker is the technical expression for root mean square, RMS, voltage variation in
the frequency range above 1Hz which occurs in the electric power systems and
causes light bulbs to flicker. The cause of flicker has commonly been attributed to
wind speed variations. Variable-speed wind turbines generally produce significantly
lower flicker than fixed-speed machines. Flicker can be an important issue for weak
networks. The limits on the flicker produced by an installation vary between utilities.
Some have a fairly simple process, whereas the international standards describes a
complex methodology designed to share out equitably the flicker capacity of the
network amongst all network users. [70]
In paper [78], two models have been developed to use as an analysis tool for
prediction of flicker induced by large wind turbine. A simple model was developed
and used to identify important busbars where flicker levels are critical. The complex
model was used to predict accurately flicker severity. In this model, all types of
existing static loads are accommodated and input to the model to investigate the
effects of flickers. A dynamic load representation was also implemented which
enabled the effects of spinning loads and their dynamics on flicker to be predicted.
[78]
30
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
44/121
2.7 Noise
One of the obstacles currently standing in the way of wind farms development is the
fear that noise from the wind turbine operation will adversely affect the living
environment near to wind farm. This fear of possible noise nuisance action against
the wind farm s makes the risk of development too high, and consequently
potentially valuable energy resources remain unclaimed. Therefore the calculation of
wind farm noise levels is essential in the development phase of wind farm design.
[49]
Calculating the far field noise levels requires two major steps. First, the sound power
output of the wind turbines must be known across the entire range of operational
wind speeds. Second, the manner in which sound attenuates as it travels from the
wind turbines to the receiver locations must be known. [49]
31
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
45/121
CHAPTER THREE
3.0 Modeling of Wind/Diesel System
3.1 Introduction
In the wind energy conversion system studies, there are many elements affecting the
stability of the system. These factors are required to be addressed first before
proceeding to the design and simulation of the system.
Take for example; when the stability analysis involves simulation times longer than
about one second, any effects due to machine controllers such as automatic voltage
regulators (AVR) and speed governor must be incorporated. The AVR has a
substantial effect on the transient stability when varying the field voltage to try to
maintain the terminal voltage constant. Also that the stability factor contributed from
the wind turbine in the overall system should not be discarded as the variation of
mechanical power occurs as a function of time.
32
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
46/121
3.1 Induction Machine
The operation of induction machine will be determined from the sign of the
electromagnetic torque and the slip, that is negative torque and slip correspond to
generator operation whereas positive torque and slip correspond to motor operation.
In order to model the induction machine, the d-q equivalent circuit of induction
machine, as shown in Figure 3.1, is required for the formulating of necessary
equations.
The direct-axis is assumed to align with the stator terminal voltage phasor, therefore
all the rotor variables are referred to the stator side. Hence, the current equations that
describe the dynamic behavior of the induction machine is given by the following
electromechanical equations [30]:
( ) drrmqrrdsrmeqsspeakqs iwLKirKiwLKwirKi 1221)( ++= 3.1
( ) dsdrrqrrmdssqsrmepeakds VKirKiwLKirKiwLKwi 12112)( +++= 3.2
( )( drersqr
r
rmrdsrsqsspeakqr iwwKLi
L
rKLriwKLirKi +
++= 1
222)( ) 3.3
( )( )
dsqr
r
rmrqrersdssqsrspeakdr VKi
L
rKLriwwKLirKiwKLi 2
2122)( +
++= 3.4
( ) mqrdsdrqsmrpeakr TJ
Niiii
J
LNw
J
Bw
+
+
=28
3 2
)( 3.5
where( )21 mrs
r
LLL
LK
= and
( )22 mrsm
LLL
LK
=
33
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
47/121
The induction machine equations are derived from Park equations after some
simplifications [30]. The most important is that the stator electrical transients are
neglected as much faster compared to the rotor ones. The equations are in per-unit
(p.u.) system with respect to the synchronous reference frame [38].
The algebraic stator equations are:
qdsdd IXIrEV '' += 3.6
dqsqq IXIrEV '' ++= 3.7
The differential equations describing the dynamics of the rotor windings are:
( )[ ] qqdo
d EsIXXETdt
dE'''
'
1'++= 3.8
( )[ ] ddqo
qEsIXXE
Tdt
dE'''
'
1'= 3.9
The electromagnetic torque equation is:
qqddAe IEIET '' += 3.10
The output active and reactive power, voltage and current under steady state
operation are given as:
{ }Ate IVP *Re= 3.11
{ }Ate IVQ *Im= 3.12
22qdt VVV += 3.13
22qdA III += 3.14
34
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
48/121
For a wind farm consisting of more than one induction machines, the number of
differential equations becomes very large. Therefore, to reduce the number of
equations, it is appropriate to assume that the number of induction machines operate
under the same wind conditions. Or the wind farm can be partitioned into groups of
n-machines which operate identically and each group can than be replaced by
equivalent machine [23].
Iqm
qr(we-wr)qswe
Iqr
iqsrr
Lm
LlrLls
Vqs
Rs
d-axis
idm
dr(we-wr)dswe
idr
ids
rr
Lm
LlrLls
Vds
Rs
q-axis
Figure 3. 1: d-q equivalent circuit of induction machine
35
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
49/121
3.2 Synchronous Machine Model
A two-dimensional reference frame commonly defined the
electrical characteristic equation describing a three-
phase synchronous machine. This involves in the use of
Parks transformations [30] to convert currents and flux
linkages into two fictitious windings located 90 apart.
A typical synchronous machine consists of three stator
windings mounted on the stator and one field winding
mounted on the rotor. These axes are fixed with respect
to the rotor (d-axis) and the other lies along the
magnetic neutral axis (q-axis), which model the short-
circuited paths of the damper windings. Electrical
quantities can then be expressed in terms of d and q-axis
parameters. Figure 3.2 presents the diagram of d-q axis
in the machine and the phasor diagram of the synchronous
machine operating in steady state is as shown in Figure
3.3.
36
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
50/121
Figure 3. 2: Illustration of the positions of d-q axis on a two-pole machine
Figure 3. 3: Phasor diagram of synchronous machine in steady state
37
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
51/121
These equations do not take into account the stator transients as much faster
compared to the rotor ones.
The algebraic stator equations in p.u. are [38]:
qqdsdd IXIrEV '''' += 3.15
ddqsqq IXIrEV '''' = 3.16
The differential equations corresponding to the rotor winding dynamics in p.u. are:
( )[ ]qqqdqo
d IXXETdt
dE '''''''1'' = 3.17
([ ]dddqqdo
qIXXEE
Tdt
dE''''''
''
1''+= ) 3.18
+
= q
dd
ddq
dd
ddfd
do
qE
XX
XXE
XX
XXE
Tdt
dE''
'''
''
'''
''
'
1'3.19
The electromagnetic torque equation is:
qdqdqqddDe IIXXIEIET ''''''' += 3.20
The equations for synchronous machine current, output power and output voltage are
the same as for the induction machine.
38
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
52/121
3.3 Synchronous Machine Automatic Controller
In dynamic power system simulations of more than one second, it is recommended to
include the effects of the machine controllers, at least for the machine most affected
by the disturbance. Also the use of controller representation is becoming a must for
first swing stability with systems being operated at their limits with near critical fault
clearing times [30].
Two main controllers used for a turbine generator set are the automatic voltage
regulator (AVR) and the speed governor. In the AVR model, there consists of a
voltage sensing equipment, comparators and amplifiers controlling a synchronous
machine that can be generating or motoring. In the speed governor there consists of
similar equipment used in the AVR but in addition it requires taking the turbine into
account [30].
39
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
53/121
3.3.1 Automatic Voltage Regulator (AVR)
Many different AVR models have been developed for different types of power
systems. The importance of AVR is to provide the synchronous machine the proper
field voltage, hence maintaining the desired voltage and reactive power that the
synchronous machine generates. The main advantage of using AVR is that it can
respond immediately to voltage deviations during both normal and emergency
operation [38].
The IEEE had defined several AVR types and the main and most commonly used
two are the Type1 and Type2 model [30]. The differential equations of the IEEE
Type 1 AVR model (Fig 3.3.1) can be written in a matrix form for convenience:
40
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
54/121
+
=
0
0
01
0
10
01
000
1
.
.
.
.
ref
A
A
t
R
R
r
F
A
R
E
E
E
EF
EF
FEF
F
A
A
AA
A
R
R
r
F
A
R
VT
K
VT
K
V
V
V
V
T
K
T
TT
KK
TTT
K
T
K
TT
K
T
K
V
VV
V
3.21
A
ST
K
+1 E STK +1
SE
F
ST
SK
+1
R
ST
K
+1
-
+
Vmin
Vmax
VA
|Vt|
VF
Input Filter
Derivative Feedback
Exciter
Regulating amplifier
--
+Vref
VR
41
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
55/121
Figure 3. 4: IEEE Type 1 AVR model [38].
3.3.2 Excitation system
The issue of power system stability is becoming more
crucial. The excitation and governing controls of the
generator play an important role in improving the dynamic
and transient stability of the power system. Typically
the excitation control and governing control are designed
independently. Changes in the values of these controls
affect the transient response of the machine. Different
types of governors and AVRs would then have different
output characteristics that must be considered in this
thesis in order to simulate the response with a set of
accurate time constants of the synchronous machine.
42
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
56/121
Typically the excitation system is a fast response system where the time constant is
small. Its basic function is to provide a direct current to the field winding.
Furthermore, the excitation system performs control and
protective functions essential to secure operation of the
system by controlling the field voltage. Hence the field
current is within acceptable levels under a range of
different operating conditions. The protective functions
of the excitation system ensure that the limits of the
synchronous machine, excitation system and other
controlling equipments are not exceeded. Its control
functions include the monitoring of voltage and reactive
power flow. These contribute as an important factor in
power system stability. Figure 3.5 illustrates typical
excitation systems within a control system. This diagram,
which is originated from IEEE Trans., vol. PAS-88, Aug
1969, illustrates a typical excitation control system for
a synchronous generator. It clearly defines the elements
of the various subsystems.
The regular governing control is a traditional PID
control, which is similar to IEEE type 1 model. The
excitation control in this thesis will assume a linear
optimal control.
43
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
57/121
Figure 3. 5:Synchronous excitation control system
3.4 Compensation Capacitor Bank Model
Induction generator absorbs reactive power for its excitation and therefore causing an
increased in the reactive load in the power system. The capacitor banks are
connected to the wind/diesel system to maintain the reactive power to acceptable
level and also it contributes a positive effect in voltage regulation.
44
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
58/121
The capacitor banks are connected in steps to the wind/diesel system. In the
simulations they are interpret as injected currents in the network.
The injected current is given as [38]:
cap
tcap
X
VjI
~~
= 3.22
The required reactive power for the induction generator is:
)(
3lineavelineline
IVQ
= 3.23
3.5 Energy Storage Unit
When the wind/diesel system experienced disturbances, the generating units are not
always able to respond rapidly enough to keep the system. However, if high-speed
real or reactive power control is available, load shedding or generator dropping may
45
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
59/121
be avoided during disturbances. One of the high-speed reactive power controls
available is through the use of flexible ac transmission systems (FACTS) devices.
However, a better alternative would be to have the ability to rapidly vary real power
without impacting the system through power circulation. Hence, energy storage units
are important in the role of maintaining system reliability and power quality. Ideally
for energy storage units is to be able to damp oscillations, respond to sudden changes
in load, supply load during transmission or distribution interruptions, correct load
voltage profiles with rapid reactive power control, and still allowing the generators to
balance with the system load at normal speed.
The following sections will present a few of the energy storage units available and
some operation details of each of the storage units.
3.5.1 Battery Energy Storage System
Batteries are one of the most cost-effective energy storage technologies available,
with energy stored electrochemically. A battery system is made up of a set of low-
voltage/power battery modules connected in parallel and series to achieve a desired
46
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
60/121
electrical characteristic. Batteries are charged up when they undergo an internal
chemical reaction under a potential applied to the terminals. They delivered the
absorbed energy when they reverse the chemical reaction. Some of the advantages of
using battery energy storage system are: high energy density, high energy capability,
round trip efficiency and cycling capability [41].
Battery stored dc charge, so power conversion is required to interface a battery with
an ac system. The used of power electronics converters which can provide bi-
directional current flow and bi-directional voltage polarity with rapid response
improves the battery technology. A simple block diagram, Figure 3.6, summaries the
battery energy storage system interface to the system.
BatterySystem
ControlSystem
Powersystem
Discharging
Charging
AC/DCPowerConditioningsystem
Figure 3. 6: Battery Energy Storage System interface to power system
3.5.2 Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage (SMES) Unit
In superconducting magnetic energy storage (SMES), electric energy is stored by
circulating a current in a superconducting coil, or inductor. Because no conversion of
energy to other forms is involved (e.g., mechanical or chemical), round-trip
47
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
61/121
efficiency can be very high. SMES can respond very rapidly to dump or absorb
power from the grid, limited only by the switching time of the solid-state
components doing the DC/AC conversion and connecting the coil to the grid [45].
As an energy storage device, SMES is a relatively simple concept. It stores electric
energy in the magnetic field generated by DC current flowing through a coiled wire
(Fig 3.7). If the coil were wound using a conventional wire such as copper, the
magnetic energy would be dissipated as heat due to the wire's resistance to the flow
of current. However, if the wire is superconducting (no resistance), then energy can
be stored in a "persistent" mode, virtually indefinitely, until required [35].
Current I
Figure 3. 7: SMES basic operation
The SMES unit being considered here consists of a superconducting coil, a forced-
commutated converter and a controller. The forced-commutated converter uses gate
turn-off, GTO, thyristors so that the SMES system is able to generate and absorb
active and reactive powers in four-quadrants. An SMES system with the above
48
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
62/121
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
63/121
Figure 3. 8: Schematic Configuration Of A Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage Unit.
[38]
Using equation 3.24 and 3.25, the firing angles of the converters are calculated at
each sampling instant [38].
3.5.3 Flywheel Energy Storage
Flywheels can be used to stored energy for power systems when the flywheel is
coupled to an electric machine. In most of the cases, a power converter is used to
50
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
64/121
drive the electric machine to provide a wider operating range. Stored energy depends
on the moment of inertia of the rotor and the square of the rotational velocity of the
flywheel, as shown in 3.26. The moment of inertia, I, depends on the radius, mass,
and height or length of the rotor, as shown in 3.27. Energy is transferred to the
flywheel when the machine operates as a motor, charging the energy storage device.
The flywheel is discharged when the electric machine regenerates through the drive.
2
2
1IE= 3.26
2
2mhrI= 3.27
The energy storage capability of the flywheel can be improved either by increasing
the moment of inertia of the flywheel or by turning it at higher rotational velocities,
or both. Flywheel energy storage can be implemented in several power system
applications. If a flywheel energy storage system is included with a FACTS with a dc
bus, an inverter is added to couple the flywheel motor/generator to the dc bus.
Flywheel energy storage has been considered for several power system applications,
including power quality applications as well as peak shaving and stability
enhancement [41].
CHAPTER FOUR
51
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
65/121
4.0 Computer Simulation
In order to model and simulate the wind/diesel system, a computer simulation
software package is a much useful tool. The computer simulation software package
used in this project is PSCAD/EMTDC. Engineers, researchers and students from
utilities, manufacturers, research and academic institutes are using this software in
planning, design, developing new concepts, testing ideas, understanding what
happened when equipment failed, commissioning, preparation of specification and
tender documents, teaching and research.
EMTDC is the software that performs the electromagnetic transient analysis on the
user-designed system. Ideas, concepts and models of portions of planned and existing
wind/diesel systems can be evaluated quantitatively using the EMTDC program. The
development of PSCAD, which is a graphical user interface for EMTDC, has greatly
simplified the tasks required to setup, run, and analyze the results of a simulation.
EMTDC does all the necessary calculations and the results can be plotted out in the
graphs and printed out.
PSCAD was designed to support multiple simulator architectures. One of these is the
EMTDC. PSCAD consists of a group of software modules. There are six modules
that make up PSCAD: the File Manager, Draft, T-Line/Cable, RunTime, MultiPlot
and UniPlot.
52
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
66/121
4.1 Introduction
The wind/diesel system of interest to be modelled is as shown in Figure 4.1 in block
diagram. This wind/diesel system is used in the computer simulation studies and the
system configuration is similar to Western Australia Ten Mile Lagoon wind farm.
From the Albany load profile, Appendix, provided by Western Power Corp, the
system parameters were determined based on this load profile with some
assumptions made.
The wind/diesel system consist of:
Eight wind turbines
Eight induction generators
Two diesel engines
Two synchronous generators including excitation and governor controls
Capacitors banks
Transmission lines
Resistive load
A battery unit is to be included into the system to improve the stability performance
of the system.
53
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
67/121
Figure 4. 1: Wind/Diesel system block diagram
Due to confidential reasons, the load demand obtained is only given for a particular
summer day on 3rd December 2001. The wind speed data of Ten Mile Lagoon could
not be obtained and hence theoretical wind speed is used for the simulation.
Certain data for the synchronous generators were not given in the specification sheet
from any manufacturer available, hence data for the synchronous generators were
taken from [57] to obtain a realistic modeling.
The PSCAD/EMTDC software is used for the simulation of the wind/diesel system.
Before the overall system is simulated, the individual system components are to be
constructed first.
54
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
68/121
4.2 Wind Turbine Model
To represent the wind turbine, the power curve for a current model, 225kW rated
wind turbine manufactured by Vestas Danish Wind Technology A/S was used. The
manufacturers turbine specification sheet included the wind speed vs. power output
curve. From the power curve, a 23-point tabulation was formulated as shown in table
4.1. This data was truncated at the 18m/sec inflection point in the curve and a
polynomial fit was developed. Polynomial of second, third, fourth and fifth order fits
were than calculated with the results shown in table 4.2. The fifth order was chosen
since the residual variance will give a more accurate polynomial fit for the power
curve. The power curve when fit with the fifth order polynomial along with the
original power curve provided by the manufacturer is as shown in Figure 4.2.
Wind Speed (m/sec) Wind Speed (mile/hrs) Power output (kW)Polynomial power
output (kW)
3 6.7 0 3.3
4 8.9 6.8 2.3
5 11.2 19.5 14.3
6 13.4 31.2 35.1
7 15.7 57.1 61.2
8 17.9 87.6 89.7
9 20.1 118.7 118.3
10 22.4 149.6 145.3
11 24.6 171.4 169.3
12 26.8 189.3 189.6
13 29.1 206 205.7
14 31.3 216 217.4
15 33.6 224 224.8
16 35.8 227 228.5
17 38 229 228.9
18 40.3 230 226.8
19 42.5 225 223.0
20 44.7 215 218.5
21 47 212 214.0
22 49.2 210 210.4
23 51.5 210 208.5
24 53.7 210 208.8
25 55.9 210 211.7
Table 1: Data of power vs. wind speed curve
55
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
69/121
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
70/121
Using PSCAD/EMTDC software, equation 4.1 is being modeled as a wind turbine as
shown in Figure 4.3.from the constructed circuit, the output power with respect to
wind speed is as shown in Figure 4.4 with a cut-in wind speed of 3m/sec and cut-out
wind speed of 25m/sec and power output of 225kW at 25m/sec.
Figure 4. 3: PSCAD circuit diagram of 225kW wind turbine
57
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
71/121
Cut-in (3m/sec) Cut-out (25m/sec)
Figure 4. 4: Power curve of 225kW wind turbine.
58
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
72/121
4.3 Induction Generator Model
In Figure 4.5, the SQ100 machine model was used to model as an induction
generator that is connected to an infinite bus. The generator is started at constant
speed of 1.01 that is higher than the rated speed. Hence with this configuration the
induction machine is generating power instead of absorbing power. However, this
configuration is used for initialization purposes only. At 0.5 second, the operation is
being switched to constant torque and run in steady state. The capacitor banks are
used to supply most of the reactive power needed by the induction generator.
Figure 4. 5: Induction Generator model
59
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
73/121
From Figure 4.6, the generator active power from the induction generator is 0.35 p.u,
per unit, and absorbs 5.5 p.u of reactive power. The capacitor bank supplies most of
the reactive power and a small portion is being supplied by the source. The generated
phase-to-ground voltage is 7.9 kVRMS and the line-to-line voltage is 13.8 kVRMS as
shown in Figure 4.7.
Figure 4. 6: Power generated by Induction generator
60
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
74/121
Figure 4. 7: Line and phase voltages generated
61
-
8/8/2019 Stability Improvement of a Wind Diesel System Using an Energy Storage Unit
75/121
4.4 Diesel Generator Model
The modeling of diesel generator in the PSCAD environment (Fig 4.8) is totally
based on the connection of an exciter to the synchronous machine.
The synchronous machine has option to model two damper windings in the Q axis
and hence it can be used as a round rotor machine or a salient pole machine. The
speed of the machine may be controlled directly by inputting a positive value into the
w input of the machines, or a mechanical torque may be applied to the Tm input of
the machine.
For general use, unknown parameters are left with the default values without
changing the expected performance of the machine. The general method of
initialization and start-up which is suggested be normally used is based on firstly
entering the terminal voltage magnitude and phase.
Figure 4. 8: Diesel Generator model in PSCAD
62
-
8/