standards in the digital single market: setting priorities...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Case Id: 05d6b79a-7326-4f95-ab6c-0e0f3f7ab5e7Date: 24/12/2015 12:30:14
Standards in the Digital Single Market: setting prioritiesand ensuring delivery
Fields marked with * are mandatory.
General information on respondents
*Do you wish your contribution to be published?Please indicate clearly if you do not wish your contribution to be published.
YESNO
Submissions that are sent anonymously will neither be published nor taken into account.
The Commission may contact you in case a clarification regarding your submission is needed. Ifyou do not wish to be contacted, please state this clearly in your reply.
I wish to be contacted:YESNO
* I'm responding as:
An individual in my personal capacityThe representative of an organisation/company/institution
*What is your name?
Rosario
*What is your surname?
Baratta
*
*
*
*
2
003222820650
*Please enter your email address:
Please enter your telephone number:
*Please enter the name of your institution/organisation/business:
TELECOM ITALIA S.p.A
* Is your organisation registered in the Transparency Register of the European Commission andthe European Parliament?
YesNo
*Please indicate your organisation's registration number in the Transparency Register.
36682861898-97
*Please enter the address of your organisation:
via Gaetano Negri, 1- 20123 Milano - Italy
*My institution/organisation/business operates in:
Italy
*What is the primary place of establishment of the entity you represent?
Italy
*Please indicate your main field of business activity and the field of activity related to theconsultation's topic (if not identical to the overall business activity).
Telecommunication
*Please select the description that applies to your organisation.
Enterprise (not SME)
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
3
%0.13
P/M650
Is your organisation active in ICT standardisation?YesNo
*Please indicate the Standard Setting Organisations in which you are active:
ETSI, ITU, GSMA, 3GPP, oneM2M, OMA, BBF, OPNFV, MPEG, W3C, IETF and
others (more than 30 in total).
And if possible:
- The approximate number of person-months devoted to standardisation related activities.
- The percentage this means to the total of your resources.
Questions
II.1 Questions on general framework and problem statement
It is of particular interest to understand if the standards currently under development effectivelymatch interoperability and successfully creating a Digital Single Market. In addition, it isespecially interesting to identify those actions in standards development that could act as asolution for wider industry and public needs, not limited to the specific technologies that havebeen standardized.
Please indicate whether you agree to the following statements and explain your answerbriefly.
Q1.1 - Do you share the Commission's analysis in Part 2 of?this document
YESPARTLYNONO OPINION
*Please explain:
Telecom Italia is in favour of the Commission support of key priorities
for standardisation purposes but we do not deem necessary regulatory
imposition in this filed.
*
*
4
Q1.2 - ICT is assuming a greater role in sectors of the economy which were not previouslysignificant users of ICT. How do you see for the economy, in particularthe role of ICT standardsbeyond the ICT sector?
Very ImportantImportantModest importanceNot importantNo opinion
*Your comment, indicating a specific sector:
We do not think that is a good idea to address standardization by
sector/domain. To let DSM to flourish, it is needed to focus on standard
solutions which allow reusing communication and ontologies across
different sectors. This is for obvious cost reasons, but more relevantly
to exploit the opportunities given by cross-sector services, which are
presumably more significant than the sum of each sector business. It is
important to give priority to standard solutions able to support
inter-domain services and information sharing and able to easily
interwork with legacy systems.
Q1.3 - Do you agree that setting priorities for ICT standards at EU level, accompanied by cleartime-tables, could help standard-setting organisations in better organising their work andsupport the Digital Single Market?
YESPARTLYNONO OPINION
*Please explain why:
ICT is a complex environment. Priority will help especially if a
particular attention will be devoted to the activities related to
interworking and combination of services. It is important to give
priority to standards that are able to limit the fragmentation of the
solutions and are able to combine vertical markets together.
Q1.4. - What other steps should be considered to ensure that any such prioritisation wouldenjoy broad support of key stakeholders?
A Comunity Building around the concept of developing common and
interoperable solutions is the only way to favour DSM.
*
*
5
Q1.5 - What would be the most effective instrument at EU level to ensure that any suchprioritisation is taken up by relevant standard-setting organisations? (please select and rank upto 3 instruments)
1 2 3
A Commission Communication
A Commission Recommendation
Standardization requests issued to EU standard-setting organisations andincluded in the Annual Union Work Programme for Europeanstandardisation
Regulation
Priorities stated in the Rolling Plan for ICT Standardisation
No opinion
None of them
Your comment:
EC should continue to stay in constant contact with the main EU standard
organizations. Regulatory impositions should be limited only to specific
cases where the market is not matching the expectations. EC should
instead foster an industry driven standard development in official SDOs.
Q1.6 - What would be the impact of a priority ICT standards plan defined at the level of the EUon Europe's effort ?to pursue leadership in global standard-setting
POSITIVENEUTRALNEGATIVENO OPINION
*Please explain:
The result will be positive insofar as EC gives concrete support for the
promotion of projects that favour the European industry ecosystem
development. The plan should aim at limiting fragmentation of the
solutions, focusing the work and avoiding the dispersion of resources.
Additionally it will help developing all those services for which the
return of investment is uncertain due to the cost of the solution
determined by the fragmentation.
*
6
Q1.7 - What would be the impact of a priority ICT standards plan defined at the level of the EUon the ability of European companies ?to capture new global market opportunities
POSITIVENEUTRALNEGATIVENO OPINION
*Please explain:
It will help clarifying the directions of the market. The uncertainty
due to the current fragmentation of the solutions is limiting the
investment of manufacturers and service providers. An appropriate EU
regulatory approach in the Vertical spaces (automotive, health, smart
cities...) that facilitates industrial relationships among Verticals and
ICT Companies promoting inter-vertical standardised technologies should
be taken.
Q1.8 - Besides establishing a priority ICT standards plan, what other measures could theCommission (or other EU institutions) take to ensure that standardisation plays its role inachieving a Digital Single Market?
It is necessary to privilege solutions that integrate current legacy and
emerging solutions in a single communication and data sharing
interworking framework. It is also necessary to build a community which
leverages on selected standards and open source initiatives. Moreover EU
funds should be made available for the promotion of large scale research
and innovation projects, such as 5G, which could favour the European
industry ecosystem development.
Q1.9 - How should standard-setting organisations best respond to the increasing speed oftechnological development and the integration of technologies in business processes across allindustrial sectors?
A - Regarding the adaptation of existing standards tonew developments:
Ensuring that the standards are leading to interoperable, or at least
interworkable solutions. It should be avoided to legitimate as standards
duplicated and competing solutions. Standards should not be used to
ratify the fragmented market status, but to define interworkable
solutions in the market.
*
7
B - Regarding the introduction of new standards for new:technologies/products
It should be avoided to legitimate as standards duplicated and competing
solutions.
Q1.10 - How do you see the involvement of European ICT Standardization experts ininternational standardisation organisations (ITU, ISO, IEC) and global standard settingorganizations (i.e. IEEE, IETF, OASIS, W3C, ECMA international)?
A - The :SCOPE (or LEVEL?) of involvementIs appropriateShould be increasedShould be decreasedNo opinion
Please explain:
The European presence is in general still very significant, especially
in 3GPP and oneM2M. The European ICT experts should be involved in
particular in the key organisations to limit the fragmentation of the
solutions.
B - The :QUALITY of involvementIs appropriateShould be improvedNo opinion
Please explain:
The strategy in standardization is only partially harmonized among
European ICT organizations. A European harmonized position may improve
the European strength in addressing the standards. The European work
should be concentrated in the fields where European players are stronger
and the results can be effective on the global market.
II.2 Questions on priority domains for standardisation in the Digital SingleMarket
In this section, the Commission invites survey participants to express opinions and ideas onsetting priorities for ICT standardisation.
8
The Commission has identified 10 domains set out below, as well as a set of sub-domainswithin each domain. Please note that domains and subdomains are interrelated and thatoverlaps are possible and desirable in particular with respect to synergies between differentsectors. Some domains are horizontal and may benefit a large number of sectorialapplications; some other domains are more sectorial and were identified as areas where ICTstandardisation would bring important benefits.
First check whether the list of domains is complete and relevant. If the list is consideredincomplete, please complement it with additional domains that you consider priority.
Q2.1 - Please identify and rank the domains (up to 5) and subsequently subdomains (up to 3per domain) within each domain that you consider a priority. If specific domains or subdomainsare missing please add them.at most 5 answered row(s)
1 2 3 4 5
Domain 1: 5G communications
Domain 2: Cloud computing
Domain 3: Cybersecurity
Domain 4: Data driven services and applications
Domain 5: Digitisation of European Industry
Domain 6: eHealth and aging
Domain 7: Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS)
Domain 8: Internet of Things
Domain 9: Smart Cities
Domain 10: Smart and Efficient Energy Use
Others
9
Subdomains of Domain 1: 5G communicationsat most 3 answered row(s)
1 2 3
Architecture definition
Channel model characterisation for innovative usages (e.g. V2V)
Converged control plane (fixed mobile)
Evolved Packet Core (EPC)
Multi domain SDN interoperability
Multi tenancy and multi technology C-RAN
Network slicing
New radio access technologies and waveforms, including backhaul/fronthaul integration
Resource identification
SDN Northbound interface
Others
Domain 2: Cloud computingat most 3 answered row(s)
1 2 3
Application portability
As a service solutions (IaaS, PaaS, SaaS)
Cloud networking infrastructures
Cloud platforms
Moving non-personal data between service providers
Service Level Agreements (SLAs)
Process Computation Integrity
Others
10
Domain 3: Cybersecurity
at most 3 answered row(s)
1 2 3
Cyber security design requirements
Process standard for incident reporting
Process standard for cyber risk management
Process standard for vulnerability disclosure
Technical standards for encryption
Technical standards for public key infrastructure
Technical standard for security and privacy by design
Others
Domain 8: Internet of Things
at most 3 answered row(s)
1 2 3
Advanced Manufacturing / M2M
Building and Home automation
Energy / Environment monitoring
Medical and health care systems
Reference architectures and related standardised interfaces
Smart cities and communities
Smart living environment for ageing well
Smart farming and food security
Transportation (including ITS, C2C, C2I, automated driving)
Wearables
Others
11
Domain 9: Smart Cities
at most 3 answered row(s)
1 2 3
Application Programming Interfaces for urban platforms
Urban Indicators
Urban Management System (city planning)
Urban Ontologies (for specific domains (including city objects, geometricelements and themes) or cross-domain)
Urban Platforms
Urban transactions (payments, identification, etc.)
Others
Please answer to Q2.2 to Q2.6 . In your answer pleasefor each of the domains selectedspecify if applicable the subdomains that you have selected.
*Q2.2 - For the and the subdomains which you have selected,Domain 1: 5G communicationsplease explain briefly how the criteria indicated in Box I apply to them. We copy the criteria foryour convenience.
Link to DSM objectives and other EU policies
Competitiveness of the European industry
Clear and achievable targets
Evidence of market relevance and stakeholders needs
Domains where standard setting has direct benefits for consumers
The 5G communications as defined by 3GPP, ITU-T, ITU-R, are in line with
the DSM objectives and the EU policies. Being a global initiative, the
benefits are for the overall community and remains in the hand of
European players to take the maximum benefits from the 5G specification.
The targets are in line with the market evidences and the stakeholders’
needs that reflect the European competitive market.
*
12
Q2.3 - The Priority ICT standards plan should lead to the production of technical specifications,standards or architectures where there is a need/gap, but could also propose any other type ofstandardisation action such as landscape analysis, gap finding, roadmaps or, ecosystembuilding that could contribute to ensure that standardisation plays its role in achieving a DigitalSingle Market. Please explain if a standardisation need/gap exists in the Domain 1: 5G
and sub-domains which you have selected. Please also indicate within whichcommunications time-frame such need could be addressed. Please limit to a maximum of five needs/gaps perdomain or sub-domain:
All the major gaps are expected to be addressed by the current on-going
standardization activities, in particular those inside the 3GPP.
Q2.4 - Among those below, which action could be a priority in the Domain 1: 5G and sub-domains which you have selected.? Please rank the list below andcommunications
explain your choice.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
• Mandating EuropeanStandardisation Organisations(ESOs) for fast delivery ofstandards/technicalspecifications.
• Foster cooperation amongstandards developmentorganisations for ICT priorities
• Support Research & Innovationprojects to contribute tostandardisation
• Community Building
• Support creation ofpublic-private partnerships - PPP
• Increase strategic coordinationof ICT standardisation at EUlevel.
• Ensure consistent application ofexisting standards
• Accelerate the identification ofICT technical specifications mostcommonly used for theirreference in public procurement
• Other
• No opinion
13
*Please explain:
5G is under definition in 3GPP, ITU-T, ITU-R. We think that further
standardization actions should be carefully evaluated to avoid delaying
the delivering of 5G.
Q2.5 - Please indicate any other standardisation initiatives which would help achieving theDigital Single Market in the and sub-domains which you haveDomain 1: 5G communicationsselected., and who in the standardisation landscape would be best placed to lead on theseinitiatives:
Particular attention should be given to ensure that the 5G system is
globally interoperable, like it is for LTE, UMTS e GSM. While on the
radio technologies this is still ensured, on the network part there is a
certain tendency to relax the level of standardization in favour of
dedicated solutions. This area should be a priority to ensure service
roaming across Europe and to avoid the increase of the interworking
costs. 3GPP is the appropriate organization where these issues can be
addressed.
Q2.6 - Would your organisation be prepared to invest resources in standard-setting to achievethe priority standards within the proposed time-frames?
Please answer this question only if you are responding as the representative of an
organisation/company/institution.
YESYES, provided some conditions are metNONo opinion
*Please explain your choice and specify conditions:
Telecom Italia is already involved in 5G standardization inside 3GPP,
GSMA, ETSI ISG NFV, NGMN and inside OMA and oneM2M for the service
aspects. We believe that actions in these groups are sufficient to
achieve the priority goals in standards. Nevertheless this level of
involvement is likely going to be reduced due to the costs. The
standardization activities require a big effort with a big component of
innovation and research investment; most of them are shared with the ICT
community. A financial support from the EU institutions could help
maintaining the European excellence in standards definition.
*
*
14
*Q2.2 - For the and the subdomains which you have selected,Domain 2: Cloud computingplease explain briefly how the criteria indicated in Box I apply to them.
:We copy the criteria for your convenience
Link to DSM objectives and other EU policies
Competitiveness of the European industry
Clear and achievable targets
Evidence of market relevance and stakeholders needs
Domains where standard setting has direct benefits for consumers
The current Cloud computing standardization activities are in line with
the DSM objectives and the EU policies. Being part a global initiative,
the benefits are for the overall community and remains in the hand of
European players to take the maximum benefits from the cloud
specifications and open source implementations.
Q2.3 - The Priority ICT standards plan should lead to the production of technical specifications,standards or architectures where there is a need/gap, but could also propose any other type ofstandardisation action such as landscape analysis, gap finding, roadmaps or, ecosystembuilding that could contribute to ensure that standardisation plays its role in achieving a DigitalSingle Market. Please explain if a standardisation need/gap exists in the Domain 2: Cloud
and sub-domains which you have selected.. Please also indicate within whichcomputing time-frame such need could be addressed. Please limit to a maximum of five needs/gaps perdomain or sub-domain:
As an extension of current cloud, it is important to support the
initiatives in the area of Network Function Virtualization (NFV).
*
15
Q2.4 - Among those below, which action could be a priority in the Domain 2: Cloud computingand the subdomains which you have selected? Please rank the list below and explain yourchoice.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
• Mandating EuropeanStandardisation Organisations(ESOs) for fast delivery ofstandards/technicalspecifications.
• Foster cooperation amongstandards developmentorganisations for ICT priorities
• Support Research & Innovationprojects to contribute tostandardisation
• Community Building
• Support creation ofpublic-private partnerships - PPP
• Increase strategic coordinationof ICT standardisation at EUlevel.
• Ensure consistent application ofexisting standards
• Accelerate the identification ofICT technical specifications mostcommonly used for theirreference in public procurement
• Other
• No opinion
*Please explain:
The relevant specifications have been already identified in the ETSI
Cloud initiative and in the ETSI NFV Industry Specification Group. A
common European strategy could help speeding up the standards
deployment.
*
16
Q2.5 - Please indicate any other standardisation initiatives which would help achieving theDigital Single Market in the and the subdomains which you haveDomain 2: Cloud computingselected, and who in the standardisation landscape would be best placed to lead on theseinitiatives:
A common European support to the open-source initiatives in the
cloud/NFV areas could help speeding up the implementation of the
solution and could help reaching the goals of DSM. 3GPP and ETSI ISG NFV
are the best places where the activities can be carried out.
Q2.6 - Would your organisation be prepared to invest resources in standard-setting to achievethe priority standards within the proposed time-frames?
Please answer this question only if you are responding as the representative of an
organisation/company/institution.
YESYES, provided some conditions are metNONo opinion
*Please explain your choice and specify conditions:
We are already involved in the Cloud/NFV standardization activities
inside ETSI ISG NFV, 3GPP and GSMA. Nevertheless this level of
involvement is likely going to be reduced due to the costs. The
standardization activities require a big effort with a big component of
innovation and research investment; most of them are shared with the ICT
community. A financial support from the EU institutions could help
maintaining the European excellence in standards definition.
*
17
*Q2.2 - For the and the subdomains which you have selected,Domain 3: Cybersecurityplease explain briefly how the criteria indicated in Box I apply to them.
:We copy the criteria for your convenience
Link to DSM objectives and other EU policies
Competitiveness of the European industry
Clear and achievable targets
Evidence of market relevance and stakeholders needs
Domains where standard setting has direct benefits for consumers
The current standardization Cybersecurity activities are in line with
the DSM objectives and the EU policies. The current technology provides
sufficient mechanism to support Cybersecurity, nevertheless there is a
gap in the definition of common processes, starting from the selected
subdomains. New mechanisms to ensure privacy and security will be
required in relation to the technology developments, e.g. 5G and IoT.
Q2.3 - The Priority ICT standards plan should lead to the production of technical specifications,standards or architectures where there is a need/gap, but could also propose any other type ofstandardisation action such as landscape analysis, gap finding, roadmaps or, ecosystembuilding that could contribute to ensure that standardisation plays its role in achieving a DigitalSingle Market. Please explain if a standardisation need/gap exists in the Domain 3:
and the subdomains which you have selected. Please also indicate within which Cybersecuritytime-frame such need could be addressed. Please limit to a maximum of five needs/gaps perdomain or sub-domain:
The major gap is related to the definition of common process as said
above and re-listed here:
• Process standard for incident reporting
• Process standard for cyber risk management
• Process standard for vulnerability disclosure
This gap should be addressed as early as possible, because it is a
limiting factor that reduces the efficacy of all the available
technologies.
*
18
Q2.4 - Among those below, which action could be a priority in the anDomain 3: Cybersecurityd the subdomains which you have selected? Please rank the list below and explain your choice.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
• Mandating EuropeanStandardisation Organisations(ESOs) for fast delivery ofstandards/technicalspecifications.
• Foster cooperation amongstandards developmentorganisations for ICT priorities
• Support Research & Innovationprojects to contribute tostandardisation
• Community Building
• Support creation ofpublic-private partnerships - PPP
• Increase strategic coordinationof ICT standardisation at EUlevel.
• Ensure consistent application ofexisting standards
• Accelerate the identification ofICT technical specifications mostcommonly used for theirreference in public procurement
• Other
• No opinion
*Please explain:
NC
Q2.5 - Please indicate any other standardisation initiatives which would help achieving theDigital Single Market in the and the subdomains which you haveDomain 3: Cybersecurityselected, and who in the standardisation landscape would be best placed to lead on theseinitiatives:
3GPP and ETSI TC CYBER are the organizations that are currently more
impacting the ICT environment.
*
19
Q2.6 - Would your organisation be prepared to invest resources in standard-setting to achievethe priority standards within the proposed time-frames?
Please answer this question only if you are responding as the representative of an
organisation/company/institution.
YESYES, provided some conditions are metNONo opinion
*Please explain your choice and specify conditions:
Telecom Italia is already involved in the Cybersecurity standardization
activities in almost all the standardization bodies. We are particularly
involved in 3GPP for the communication aspects and in ETSI TC CYBER.
Nevertheless this level of involvement is going to be reduced due to the
costs. The standardization activities require a big effort with a big
component of innovation and research investment; most of them are shared
with the ICT community. A financial support from the EU institutions
could help maintaining the European excellence in standards definition.
*Q2.2 - For the and the subdomains which you have selected,Domain 8: Internet of Thingsplease explain briefly how the criteria indicated in Box I apply to them.
:We copy the criteria for your convenience
Link to DSM objectives and other EU policies
Competitiveness of the European industry
Clear and achievable targets
Evidence of market relevance and stakeholders needs
Domains where standard setting has direct benefits for consumers
The Internet of things as defined by oneM2M is in line with the DSM
objectives and the EU policies. Being a global initiative, the benefits
are for the overall community and remains in the hand of European
players to take the maximum benefits from the oneM2M specifications. The
work in oneM2M, supported by ETSI TC SmartM2M, has a significant link
with EU driven initiatives, such as the standardization of Smart
Appliances, the AIOTI initiative, the Smart metering (M/441) and Smart
grid (M490) mandates. The targets are in line with the market evidences
and the stakeholders needs, which reflect the European competitive
market and therefore are addressing the customer expected needs.
*
*
20
Q2.3 - The Priority ICT standards plan should lead to the production of technical specifications,standards or architectures where there is a need/gap, but could also propose any other type ofstandardisation action such as landscape analysis, gap finding, roadmaps or, ecosystembuilding that could contribute to ensure that standardisation plays its role in achieving a DigitalSingle Market. Please explain if a standardisation need/gap exists in the Domain 8: Internet of
and the subdomains which you have selected. Please also indicate within whichThingstime-frame such need could be addressed. Please limit to a maximum of five needs/gaps perdomain or sub-domain:
The current major problems, which IoT is facing, are the fragmentation
of service enablement platform and the definition of common
semantics/ontologies, besides the need to interwork with legacy and
vertical solutions. Currently the only major standardization
organization in this area is oneM2M and its precursor ETSI TC smartM2M.
OneM2M has already addressed the fragmentation and partially the
ontologies/semantic problems, and it is expected to complete the work
regarding the ontologies/semantic part by middle 2016.
The alternative to the standard is represented by a wide set of
industrial initiatives, that are very fragmented between the vertical
business domains and also inside the vertical business domains, with a
dramatic lack of cross domain interworking.
The landscape, the major gaps and the requirements are well known and do
not need further analysis.
On the contrary EU driven initiatives to support the oneM2M standard and
the ecosystem building could helping speed up the DSM construction.
21
Q2.4 - Among those below, which action could be a priority in the Domain 8: Internet ofand the subdomains which you have selected? Please rank the list below and explain Things
your choice.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
• Mandating EuropeanStandardisation Organisations(ESOs) for fast delivery ofstandards/technicalspecifications.
• Foster cooperation amongstandards developmentorganisations for ICT priorities
• Support Research & Innovationprojects to contribute tostandardisation
• Community Building
• Support creation ofpublic-private partnerships - PPP
• Increase strategic coordinationof ICT standardisation at EUlevel.
• Ensure consistent application ofexisting standards
• Accelerate the identification ofICT technical specifications mostcommonly used for theirreference in public procurement
• Other
• No opinion
*Please explain:
NC
*
22
Q2.5 - Please indicate any other standardisation initiatives which would help achieving theDigital Single Market in the and the subdomains which you haveDomain 8: Internet of Thingsselected, and who in the standardisation landscape would be best placed to lead on theseinitiatives:
Achieving the DSM depends on cross domain data sharing and interworking
and oneM2M is currently the only place where this is standardized by
means of the oneM2M interworking framework. This is also reflected in
ETSI TC SmartM2M in specific areas such as Smart Appliances. OneM2M is
under endorsement also by ITU-T SG 20.
Initiatives to enlarge community building to support common ontologies
and semantic interworking will help achieving the DSM.
ETSI TC SmartM2M is in charge of coordinating ETSI activities related to
oneM2M and should be the focus of EU effort to support standards in this
domain.
Q2.6 - Would your organisation be prepared to invest resources in standard-setting to achievethe priority standards within the proposed time-frames?
Please answer this question only if you are responding as the representative of an
organisation/company/institution.
YESYES, provided some conditions are metNONo opinion
*Please explain your choice and specify conditions:
Telecom Italia is already involved in oneM2M, ETSI TC smartM2M. We
believe that actions in these groups will be sufficient to achieve the
expected goals for DSM. We are also already involved in the related
IoT/M2M activities in 3GPP, OMA, HGI, BBF ,ITU-T and ETSI TC ITS.
*
23
*Q2.2 - For the and the subdomains which you have selected, pleaseDomain 9: Smart Citiesexplain briefly how the criteria indicated in Box I apply to them.
:We copy the criteria for your convenience
Link to DSM objectives and other EU policies
Competitiveness of the European industry
Clear and achievable targets
Evidence of market relevance and stakeholders needs
Domains where standard setting has direct benefits for consumers
Smart cities are the combination of multiple services and systems and
are excellent examples of IoT. See also answers on IoT.
Q2.3 - The Priority ICT standards plan should lead to the production of technical specifications,standards or architectures where there is a need/gap, but could also propose any other type ofstandardisation action such as landscape analysis, gap finding, roadmaps or, ecosystembuilding that could contribute to ensure that standardisation plays its role in achieving a DigitalSingle Market. Please explain if a standardisation need/gap exists in the Domain 9: Smart
and the subdomains which you have selected. Please also indicate within whichCitiestime-frame such need could be addressed. Please limit to a maximum of five needs/gaps perdomain or sub-domain:
The current major problems, which Smart cities are facing, are the
fragmentation of service enablement platform and the definition of
common semantics/ontologies besides the need to interwork with legacy
and vertical solutions. See also answers on IoT.
*
24
Q2.4 - Among those below, which action could be a priority in the andDomain 9: Smart Citiesthe subdomains which you have selected? Please rank the list below and explain your choice.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
• Mandating EuropeanStandardisation Organisations(ESOs) for fast delivery ofstandards/technicalspecifications.
• Foster cooperation amongstandards developmentorganisations for ICT priorities
• Support Research & Innovationprojects to contribute tostandardisation
• Community Building
• Support creation ofpublic-private partnerships - PPP
• Increase strategic coordinationof ICT standardisation at EUlevel.
• Ensure consistent application ofexisting standards
• Accelerate the identification ofICT technical specifications mostcommonly used for theirreference in public procurement
• Other
• No opinion
*Please explain:
NC
*
25
Q2.5 - Please indicate any other standardisation initiatives which would help achieving theDigital Single Market in the and the subdomains which you haveDomain 9: Smart Citiesselected, and who in the standardisation landscape would be best placed to lead on theseinitiatives:
Smart Cities are part of IoT and are sharing the same problems with
dramatic evidence due to the Smart Cities multiservice multi-domain
nature.
The major problem is the fragmentation, data sharing and the definition
of common ontologies/semantics and their interoperability and
interworking. Support and community building around oneM2M, as an
interworking framework able to glue together the legacy and the specific
vertical solutions will help achieving the DSM.
Q2.6 - Would your organisation be prepared to invest resources in standard-setting to achievethe priority standards within the proposed time-frames?
Please answer this question only if you are responding as the representative of an
organisation/company/institution.
YESYES, provided some conditions are metNONo opinion
*Please explain your choice and specify conditions:
Telecom Italia is already involved in significant initiatives of
standardization that will support smart cities such as oneM2M, HGI, ETSI
TC SmartM2M, ETSI TC ITS, as well in relevant industrial consortium such
as Energy@home. Nevertheless this level of involvement is going to be
reduced due to the costs. The standardization activities require a big
effort with a big component of innovation and research investment, most
of them shared with the ICT community. A financial support from the EU
institutions could help maintaining the European excellence in standards
definition.
II.3 Other Comments
*
26
Other comments:
We are interested in all the domains identified in this questionnaire
and we believe that there are as well a lot of other relevant domains.
At the same time we see the questionnaire is going in multiple
directions
The first 4 domains are a sort of system wide enablers of the
communication and storage.
Domain 1: 5G communications
Domain 2: Cloud computing
Domain 3: Cybersecurity
Domain 4: Data driven services and applications
The remaining domains are component of Domain 8: Internet of Things
Domain 5: Digitisation of European Industry
Domain 6: eHealth and aging
Domain 7: Intelligent Transport Systems (ITS)
Domain 9: Smart Cities
Domain 10: Smart and Efficient Energy Use
And the list can be further extended to other relevant domains.
In general, we agree on some relevant peculiarities of each of these
domains, but we think that these domains overlap and are
inter-correlated.
For this season is preferable not to address them separately, because
the great enemy of the DSM is fragmentation and the major priority is
the selection of solutions capable to address the integration of
services and technologies among these domains. These domains will
continue to have specific protocols and solutions, but it is important
to enable the information sharing at the application layer between
domains and to ensure interworking whenever direct interoperability is
not achievable.
For this reason we have focused our attention on IoT, and on the Smart
Cities domain as champion of all the DSM related domains.
Background Documentsanalysis.pdf (/eusurvey/files/f2d6718c-7e07-4955-9505-c94113bbbe0f)
Contact [email protected]