standing and special committees, other grand …...annual reports standing and special committees,...

Annual Reports

Standing and Special

Committees,

Other Grand Lodge Units

and the

Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library

The

Grand LodGe

of

free and accepTed Masons

of The

sTaTe of new York

235th Annual CommunicationMay 2 – 3, 2016

For the period ending December 31, 2015

©Copyright, 2016Paul M. Rosen

Grand Secretary of the Grand Lodgeof Free and Accepted Masons of the State of New York

reporTs of sTandinG* and speciaL coMMiTTees

Awards * ...........................................................................................................1Camp Turk ........................................................................................................3Charters * .........................................................................................................4Civility Ambassadors .......................................................................................5Communications ..............................................................................................6 Publications * ...............................................................................................8Community Service * ......................................................................................8 Masonic Blood and Organ Donor Program Sub-Committee .......................9 Masonic Model Student Assistance Program (MMSAP) Sub-Committee ..9 New York Masonic Safety ID (MSID) Program Sub-Committee ..............10Compliance and Assessment ..........................................................................11Concordant Bodies ........................................................................................11Constitutions * ...............................................................................................12Correspondence and Relations * ....................................................................13Custodians of the Work * ...............................................................................14George Washington Masonic Historic Site at Tappan ....................................18George Washington Masonic National Memorial ..........................................19Grand Lodge Convention ...............................................................................19Grand Lodge Educational Assistance ............................................................20Law Enforcement *........................................................... .... .........................22Leadership and Educational Services * .........................................................23Long-Range Planning * .................................................................................24Masonic Benevolence * .................................................................................25Masonic Brotherhood Fund * ........................................................................27Masonic Care Community Ambassador Program ..........................................27Masonic Fellowship .......................................................................................28Masonic Hall Tours ........................................................................................30Membership Development .............................................................................31Military Outreach ...........................................................................................33Necrology * ....................................................................................................37Observant Masonry ............................................................................................Restorations * .................................................................................................40Ritual Renaissance .........................................................................................41Surviving Spouse and Loved Ones ................................................................41Technology .....................................................................................................42Youth ..............................................................................................................43

reporTs of oTher Grand LodGe UniTs

Commission of Appeals .................................................................................46Masonic War Veterans ....................................................................................47District Grand Lodge of Syria-Lebanon ........................................................49American Lodge of Research.........................................................................51Infinity Lodge of Research .............................................................................52Justice Robert H. Jackson Lodge of Research ...............................................54Veritas Lodge of Study and Research ............................................................55Western New York Lodge of Research ...........................................................55

reporT of The TrUsTees of The LivinGsTon Masonic LibrarY

The Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library of Grand Lodge ......56

1

COMMITTEE ON AWARDS

To the Grand Lodge:It is the Committee on Awards which has the responsibility of

implementing the Dedicated Service Award, the Fifty -Year (Plus) Award Programs and the Grand Lodge Community Service Awards, as well as recommending to the Grand Master the creation of new awards.

Dedicated Service AwardsThe Committee met in December 2015 to consider nominations for the

Dedicated Service Awards (DSA). The total statewide recommendations received were fifty-seven (57), of which a total of forty-four (44) were ratified. The average age of membership of the recipients was sixty-four (64) years and the average years of membership was twenty-five (25).

Fifty -Year (Plus) AwardsLapel Pins Certificates 50 -Year Medals 50 -Year Aprons

Fifty Years 336 373 23 381Fifty-five Years 269 286Sixty Years 225 249 278Sixty-five Years 153 134Seventy Years 26 29 27Seventy-five Years 5 5Eighty Years ____0 ____0 ____ ____ TOTAL AWARDS 1014 1076 23 686

Our congratulations go out to all of our Brothers for their years of service to the Craft, as well as to the DSA presentations for the recipients.

Grand Lodge Community Service AwardsThe Committee received recommendations for three (8) DeWitt Clinton

Awards (for Non-Masons or Non-Masonic Organizations Only), four (4) Jacob Morton Awards (for Masons, Masonic Lodges or Districts Only), and three (3) Grand Lodge Certificate of Appreciation for Excellence in Service to the Community (for Masonic and Non-Masonic recipients) to screen for approval or rejection and to process them.

DeWitt Clinton Award John G. Di Liberto March 14, 2015 Melissa Thompson March 25, 2015 Brooktondale Fire Dept., Inc. March 25, 2015 Susan Taylor Thomas April 09, 2015 Steven G. Griffin April 19, 2015 Wendy S. Berk May 14, 2015 Tammi D’Antoni May 28, 2015 Karen McCarrick November 08, 2015 Jacob Morton Awards Brother Benjamin Singer February 07, 2015 Anchor Astoria Lodge No. 729 April 28, 2015 Brother David Rothstein December 01, 2015 W∴William J. Peist, Sr. December 01, 2015

2

Grand Lodge Certificate of Appreciation for Excellence in Service to the Community

W∴Adam R. Schoepflin, 273NY April 28, 2015 Brother Christopher Kane, 273NY April 30, 2015 Brother William A. Carter, 1057NY April 30, 2015My Brothers, I hope you have a chance to read the two articles which I

prepared for the 24” Gauge - The Lodge Resource Handbook.The First Article is: “THE DEDICATED SERVICE AWARD”

The information contained within will help you to understand the Dedicated Service Award, it’s history, forms, letters, presentation and more. It will also help you to choose the Brother in your Lodge who meets the criteria for the award.The Second Article is: “COMMUNITY SERVICE AWARDS”

The information contained within will also help you to understand:The DeWitt Clinton Award, which is for Non-Masons or Non-Masonic

Organizations Only. The Jacob Morton Award, which is for Masons, Masonic Lodges or

Districts Only. The Grand Lodge Certificate of Appreciation for Excellence in

Service to the Community, is to acknowledge those individuals and organizations that do not meet the highest criteria necessary for a DeWitt Clinton or Jacob Morton Award.

It also contains: Award Requirements, Applications, Presentation Program Recommendations, Public Relations Materials and suggestions.

My Brothers, your Lodges are looking for ways to recognize outstanding people in your community as well as Brothers. These awards will help you to accomplish this.

The Committee would like to thank those Lodges who have reached out to recognize and recommend those individuals and organizations who have given excellence in Community Service on behalf of Masonry and the Grand Lodge of New York.

We, the members of the Committee, would like to thank our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, for his support and for the opportunity to serve our Grand Lodge. The Committee would also like to thank R∴W∴Paul Rosen, Grand Secretary, R∴W∴Richard W. Bateman, GP, Assistant Grand Secretary, and their staff as well as the Lodge Services Department for their most helpful assistance in the work of this Committee. Thanks also to the Lodges that invited Committee members to speak at and to participate in their DSA programs.

Respectfully submitted, GeorGe r. Wacob, Chairman

GreGory Noulas, Vice Chairman Metropolitan Region

DouGlas D. airth Western Region thomas l. JeNisoN Mid-State Region

Joseph t. eNtler Metropolitan Region charles e. KNapp, Jr., Hudson-Champlain Region

alfreD W. ferGersoN Mid-State Region William h. GreeNe Western Region

robert l. hoGaN, Jr. Hudson-Champlain Region

3

bruce WiDGer, PGM, ConsultantEmeriti

seymour Dember, Past Pres. and Trustee Emeritus, Trustees of Masonic Hall & Homepaul c. fritsch, Gilbert J. Walter

THE COMMITTEE ON CAMP TURKTo the Grand Lodge:

This past summer, 2015, turned out to be one of the most successful camping seasons for many years, due to the efforts of many people.

For fifty-two weeks of the year, Mr. Andrew Croniser, the caretaker at Round Lake, and his staff are at work keeping the buildings, furnishings, equipment, and the area in pristine condition and the Committee thanks them for all their hard work and dedication. For seven weeks each summer, Round Lake, though, becomes the home of the Masonic Youth Camp or as it is better known, Camp Turk.

The Committee would like to thank those who were responsible for the successful 2015 camping season, starting with our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, and his wife, Lady Susan Taylor Thomas, as well as our Deputy Grand Master, R∴W∴Jeffrey M. Williamson, who, along with the whole Grand Line, supported and promoted the camp in their travels around the state. It is through the efforts of these Elected and Appointed Officers of the Grand Lodge, under the leadership of our Grand Master, that the knowledge, importance, and the need to support Camp Turk has increased in the minds of Masons in this great state of ours. .

We thank our Camp Administrator, Ms. Mollie Denslow and our Camp Director, Mr. Ray Farrell, who, along with their staff and counselors, provide a camping experience that is second-to-none. The Chairman would also personally like to thank a group of Brothers who are dedicated to the success of Camp Turk, this being the Grand Lodge Camp Turk Committee. These Brothers dedicate 365 days, every year, to working to promote Camp Turk and to improve the camping program, and it is a special honor for me to be a part of this group.

For the fourth year in a row, we had an increase in the number of campers registered for camp. There were 190 boys, up from 171 last year, and 237 girls, up from 212 last year. There were also 14 day-campers, up from 6 in 2014.

We would be remiss if we did not thank the Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home for their financial commitment to the continued upgrading and improvements of the facilities at Camp Turk. We also thank all the District Deputy Grand Masters and the Brothers of New York State who help in promoting the camp, and we encourage your continued support in providing campers and/or financial support for our camper scholarships, or for purchases from our wish list.

Respectfully submitted,DaviD f. stoy, Chairman

richarD c. bartziK marK D. haNsoN paul D. reitzmichael cooper harry G. hoWalD berNarD schWartzlouis D. DeNato, sr. GeorGe f. KivoWitz DaviD WalterricharD l. freNz robert f. luDWiG JohN G. WriGht, Jr. eDWarD W. mosso

4

COMMITTEE ON CHARTERSMost Worshipful Grand Master, Right Worshipful Deputy Grand Master, Most Worshipful Past Grand Masters, distinguished East, honored guests, Brothers All:

I wish to take this opportunity to thank the Brothers of the Charters Committee for their diligence in laboring in this very unique corner of the Masonic quarry. The committee wishes to express our appreciation for the skill, knowledge, and invaluable assistance given to us by the Grand Secretary, R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen, the Assistant Grand Secretary, R∴W∴Richard W. Bateman and our Judge Advocate, R∴W∴Steven Adam Rubin, and for their support of this Committee.

The Committee would like to thank the District Deputy Grand Masters and the Lodge Committees for their cooperation in expediting the processing of the necessary and extensive paperwork needed to accomplish a Consolidation.

The following is the Annual Report of the activities of the Charters Committee:

* Dover Lodge No. 666 and Harlem Valley Lodge No. 827 in the Dutchess Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Oblong Lodge No. 666 in the Dutchess Masonic District, effective April 2, 2015.

* Black Lake Lodge No. 319 and Hammond Lodge No. 861 in the First St. Lawrence Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Black Lake Hammond Lodge No. 319 in the First St. Lawrence Masonic District, effective April 2, 2015.

* Kosciuszko Lodge No. 1085 in the Bronx Masonic District has Petitioned the Grand Lodge to remove its location from the Bronx Masonic District and to be located in the Sixth Manhattan Masonic District. Approval granted by the vote of Grand Lodge, effective May 4, 2015.

Belmont Lodge No. 474 in the Allegany Masonic District has Surrendered its Charter, effective May 27, 2015.

Hancock Lodge No. 552 in the Delaware Masonic District has Surrendered its Charter, effective May 27, 2015.

De Ruyter Lodge No. 692 and Cautious Lodge No. 726 in the Cortland-Madison Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as De Ruyter No. 692 in the Cortland-Madison Masonic District, effective May 27, 2015.

Marathon Lodge No. 438 in the Cortland-Madison Masonic District and Point of Light Lodge No. 795 in the Broome-Chenango Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Marathon Lodge No. 438 in the Cortland-Madison Masonic District, effective May 27, 2015.

Seneca Lodge No. 113 and Pocahontas Lodge No. 211 in the Ontario-Seneca-Yates Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Pocahontas Lodge No. 211 in the Ontario-Seneca-Yates Masonic District, effective May 27, 2015.

Unity Lodge No. 9 and Columbia Lodge No. 98 in the Columbia Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Unity Lodge No. 9 in the Columbia Masonic District, effective June 2, 2015.

* These Lodge changes were voted on at Grand Lodge 2015, but are included in the Grand Secretary's count for 2015.

5

** These Lodge changes occurred after December 31, 2015 and are not included in the Grand Secretary's count for 2015.

Richville Lodge No. 633 in the First St. Lawrence Masonic District has Surrendered its Charter, effective July 10, 2015.

Humanity Lodge No. 406 in the Wayne Masonic District has Surrendered its Charter, effective August 27, 2015.

Livingston Manor Lodge No. 791 in the Sullivan Masonic District has Surrendered its Charter, effective September 14, 2015.

Francis Lewis Lodge No. 273 and Brandeis Lodge No. 1165 in the Queens Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Francis Lewis Lodge No. 273 in the Queens Masonic District, effective September 22, 2015.

** Lodge of the United Services (LOTUS) No. 1118 in the Fourth Manhattan Masonic District is declared Forfeited by the Penalty imposed by a Masonic Trial Commission, effective January 12, 2016.

** Adirondack Lodge No. 602 and Iroquois Lodge No. 715 in the Essex Masonic District have Consolidated, to be known as Iroquois Lodge No. 602 in the Essex Masonic District, effective January 25, 2016.

** Damascus Lodge No. 867 in the Third Kings Masonic District has Surrendered it Charter effective February 18, 2016.

** Pioneer-Mount Moriah Lodge No. 20 in the First Manhattan Masonic District has been granted approval for a name change, to be known as Mount Moriah No. 20 in the First Manhattan Masonic District effective February 18, 2016.

On behalf of the Brothers of Charters Committee, I wish to express our appreciation to our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, for allowing us to continue to serve our Fraternity.

Respectfully submitted,hoWarD e. boNsaiNG, Chairman

DuNcaN m. belliNGer, PSGW, Vice ChairmancraiG e. cobb robert s. fiNley W. KiNG mix heNry l. cooNs Gary s. hartmaN elDoN N. White

albert a. li

JohN e. De meurers, sr., Consultant

CIVILITY AMBASSADORS COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

In early 2015, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master of Masons in the State of New York established a Committee on Civility. Feeling that the Masonic Fraternity, which already embraces the concept of civility, and indeed mandates it through our rules, edicts and customs of how we interact and address each other while in the Lodge, we felt this to be a natural fit.

Freemasons can make a great impact in this area just by being ourselves. We are taught to be respectful to others, deferential to Lodge Officers and to be mindful of how we treat each other while in Lodge and abroad in the world. As Chairman of the Committee, I have had the privilege of helping to spread the word throughout the Grand Jurisdiction.

6

I would like to acknowledge and thank R∴W∴Jeffrey M. Williamson, Deputy Grand Master, for allowing me time during his Town Hall Meetings to present our program on Civility. I believe the program was helpful and gave each of the Brothers something to consider ... being Civil buys a lot and costs nothing. I would also like to give a heartfelt thank you to the members of the Civility committee, R∴W∴Douglas H. Spadaro, R∴W∴Robert J. Servidio and R∴W∴Charles M. Roberts. Their friendship and contributions to the Committee made serving with them all both an honor and a joy.

Respectfully submitted,christopher J. houGh, Chairman

charles m. roberts robert J. serviDio DouGlas h. spaDaro.

COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONSTo the Grand Lodge:

The biggest challenge we have facing effective communication within our jurisdiction continues to be the inherent challenges associated with a multiple generational fraternity. Each group has their own paradigm for how it views and interprets the world. As Chair of this Committee, I can report that we found that each generation (with members ranging from 21 to 100 years old) should be sensitive to the communication requirements of the entire Fraternity. Older Brothers may require a hard copy of the local Lodge bulletin, while younger members use Facebook or Twitter. Our Fraternity also enjoins that we should always strive to improve ourselves, and we strongly recommend that younger Lodge leaders provide written newsletters and bulletins for our senior members. As for our older members - Remember - you are not too old to learn! We challenge you to upgrade your computer skills and to get online with the rest of society. We must all Adapt, Change, Survive and Grow!

The Grand Lodge Communications Committee recognizes and uses the following tools to effectively reach out to our membership base: The Grand Lodge Website, Hiram’s Highlights, Atholl1781-Email System, The Empire State Mason magazine, and Facebook. Each of these tools provides an excellent opportunity to interconnect with our multiple generations of Brethren.

Special appreciation is extended to Brother Kenneth J. P. Stuczynski, the Webmaster of NYMasons.Org who submits the following report on the website activities:

The Grand Lodge website at NYMasons.Org was redesigned in the first half of 2015 to reflect our focus on membership for the NorthStar Project. The design concept was modeled after the Grand Lodge of Michigan's website, (with their permission) and the new site is fully responsive to handheld devices. This year, processing and tracking of education assistance applications was handled through the subdomain, eapapplication.nymasons.org. An interactive map of Lodges was added, but a Lodge locator is still in the works while improving Lodge database accuracy and settling questions of public contact information.

The information for many other programs and Committees have been expanded or updated, including a page for “Civility” and detailed information on nominations for District and Grand Line Officers. A page was added to

7

give credit to Brothers who contributed to the development of the site, such as photos and content editing.

Website traffic statistics indicate similar traffic from the previous year (over 20,000 visits and nearly 16,000 unique visitors per month), but approximately 30% more page views and longer visits (sometimes greater than 30% being over 30 seconds, a very high mark). The number of visitors going directly to the site is up to 60% (directly typing in the address, shortcuts and bookmarks, or links in email), with other traffic coming from Facebook, Masonic sites, and even Lodges and Districts within our jurisdiction, most notably Sullivan District. The most common search words continue to be variations of “Free mason”, “Grand Lodge of New York”, and “How to Become a Freemason.” After the redesign, the most visited page was “Becoming a Mason”.

Three members of the Communications Committee met at St. John’s Day weekend. Assisted by Brother Stephen C. Gruber of the Sullivan District, I held the first “Webmaster's Conference” at the Masonic Medical Research Laboratory . Over 20 people attended, including Grand Line Officers, District and Lodge webmasters, and others via teleconference.

A year and a half after the Deputy Grand Master’s initiative that every District in the jurisdiction should have a working website, only a handful remain to be done, after accounting for Redistricting, and another handful are actively in the process of remediation. Five sites were set up, and resources allocated at no cost to the District, with training to be managed locally. It is expected there will be eight-to-ten more in the upcoming months.

Across the state, and in articles in The Empire State Mason, I have encouraged and trained people in "best practices" (particularly the use of “Digital Asset Records”) to preserve the continuity of Lodge and District web assets, and have also encouraged the use of coordinated digital calendars.

An unofficial body, The Digital Square Club of New York, was formed for Brothers who serve (or who wish to serve) the Craft through the use of their skills in Digital Media. The Digital Square Club provides mentorship, collaboration, communication, the dissemination of Grand Lodge guidelines, a pool of talent, crowd-sourcing of tasks, and the proposing of "best practices" and other professional recommendations for Grand Lodge. There are many examples (available on request) where Grand Lodge and the Craft have already benefited from the utilization of this new human resource.

My current goal is to further and firmly establish the position of an official District Webmaster for each District, with specific duties that include supporting and training Lodge and Body webmasters within their District, and maintaining an accurate contact list thereof. This, in turn, will enable me or future Grand Lodge Webmasters (and Grand Lodge in general) to communicate efficiently across the state, and to improve the quality and appropriateness of the Craft’s web presence ... down to the smallest quarry.

In closing, we would like to express our appreciation to R∴W∴William M. Sardone, our Hiram’s Highlights Editor, R∴W∴Richard W. Bateman, GP, Assistant Grand Secretary, and R∴W∴Robert E. Welsh, Jr., for their fine work on Atholl1781 E-mail System, and R∴W∴Stephen L. Zabriskie, for editing and laying out content in the The Empire State Mason magazine.

8

The Committee would like to sincerely express our appreciation to M∴W∴William J. Thomas for the challenge with which he has charged the Committee, and we look forward to seeking even better communication in the future!

Respectfully submitted, Jeffrey m. WilliamsoN DGM, Chairman

richarD W. batemaN, GP, AGS Atholl1781 Masonic Group Email ListKeith heiNrich The Empire State Masonvictor l. maNN Social MediaWilliam m. sarDoNe Masonic Newsletter ~ Hiram's HighlightsKeNNeth J. stuczyNsKi Grand Lodge of New York's Websiterobert e. Welsh, Jr. Atholl1781 Masonic Group Email ListstepheN l. zabrisKie The Empire State Mason

PUBLICATIONS COMMITTEEWilliam G. coheN Publications / GM's Messagerobert f. leoNarD, Jr. Public Relationsvictor l. maNN Social Media

COMMITTEE ON COMMUNITY SERVICE

To the Grand Lodge:There are three sub-Committees that fall under Community Service. The

Chairmen of all three sub-Committees have done a great job.The Masonic Blood and Organ Donor ProgramW∴William J. Peist, Sr., along with Brother David Rothstein and Brother

Robert Medina, have done a really good job this year. They worked along with LiveLong NY Organ Donor Network and the New York Blood Center helping the Committee Chairmen in the Districts to hold drives. The drives collected more than 1,536 pints of blood and signed up over 131 new Organ Registrations. During the drives, it was realized that many of our Brothers are already registered as Organ donors. The highlight of the year was our joining hands with LiveLong NY on October 6, 2015 for a Statewide drive, when 3,000 new Organ registrations were done in one day in the State of NY. The fruits of your labor will be seen in the future.

New York Masonic Safety ID ProgramR∴W∴Donald H. Elliott, with R∴W∴William M. Plank, had a difficult

job to perform with the limited budget and less than stellar support of some Districts, along with the fact that many Districts do not have a local Chairman. The technological advance for the Committee was the introduction of a smartphone application. With this free app, the Subject’s data is uploaded on the parents' or guardian’s Smart Phone. The information can be given to the Authorities to be put on an Amber Alert in seconds after a child is missing. We have come a long way.

Masonic Model Student Assistance Program (MMSAP)R∴W∴Donald R. Kunego is definitely the right person in the right place.

However, it has been difficult to put the program into place in 2015, due to its high cost. We have made contact with numerous school districts and stand ready to offer out help when the resources become available.

Respectfully submitted,JamsheD r. GhaDiali, Chairman

9

masoNic blooD aND orGaN DoNor proGram sub-committee

To the Grand Lodge: When the Most Worshipful Grand Master William J. Thomas began his term as

Grand Master, he saw a need to combine The Blood and Organ Donor Committees into one. The Grand Master appointed Brother David Rothstein, W∴William J. Peist, Sr., and me to chair this very important, lifesaving Committee. Also included as Committee members were W∴Edward J. Draves, Brother Gary P. Garippo and Brother Robert Medina.

As a Committee, and with the help of LiveLong NY Organ Donor Network, and the New York Blood Center, we set into motion a program to educate and make Brothers aware of the Grand Lodge's commitment to save lives. Electronic messages were sent to all District Deputy Grand Masters of the State of New York making them aware of our program.

During the first 7 months of our Committee in 2014, we were able to report that 540 pints of blood were collected, along with the registration of 47 New Organ Donors. We projected to exceed that by almost double in 2015.

My Brothers, it is our pleasure to report that, as of the writing of this report, we have succeeded in our objective. For the calendar year starting January 1, 2015 and ending December 31, 2015, we have had 49 statewide blood and organ donor drives, during which we collected more than 1,536 pints of blood and signed up over 131 new organ donors.

On October 6, 2015, our Committee also took part in a Metropolitan area, one-day Organ Donor Drive, where we assisted in signing up over 3,000 New Organ Donors, a New One-Day High Total. (Worth noting is V∴W∴John G. McAloon was responsible for signing up over 50 new donors.)

During these many drives, we have discovered that so many of our Brothers were already registered as organ donors. I congratulate those Brothers for understanding and for realizing how important these programs are.

My Brothers, at this time I’d like to thank all the Blood and Organ Donor District Chairmen for their help and dedication to this LIFE SAVING Cause. Thanks also go to the Brothers and their family and friends who came out to support us. In closing, I hope this enthusiasm continues.

Respectfully submitted,William J. peist sr., Vice-Chairman,

Blood and Organ Donor Sub-CommitteeeDWarD J. Draves Gary p. Garippo DaviD rothsteiN

robert meDiNa, ConsultantmasoNic moDel stuDeNt assistaNce proGram sub-committee

To the Grand Lodge: The Masonic Model Student Assistance Program (MMSAP) was developed

for educators to address the needs of students struggling with at-risk issues. This model of prevention and intervention has proven to be a vital tool in creating safe learning environments and in reducing violence, abuse, addiction, bullying and self-harming behavior. Schools that have successfully implemented and maintained an MMSAP Core Team have:

• Increased Attendance• Improved Academics

10

• Increased Graduation Rates• Decreased Behavior ProblemsDuring the last year, contact was established with numerous school districts

through the state which expressed interest in MMSAP programs. As a result of the number of mandated New York State teacher certification courses and scheduling conflicts, attendance at these programs could not be assured by the schools. Continued contact with these school districts will hopefully overcome these challenges and secure training sessions in the future.

As the MMSAP Chairman, I am available to provide information for your District, your Lodge and your local educators to explain what the program has to offer.

Respectfully submitted,DoNalD r. KuNeGo, Vice-Chairman,

Masonic Model Student Assistance Program Sub-Committee

JohN a. GallaNt, Committee MemberNeW yorK masoNic safety iD proGram sub-committee

To the Grand Lodge:I’m proud to report that the New York Masonic Safety ID Program (MSID)

continues to be the only non-law enforcement organization recognized by The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) and The New York State Missing Persons Clearinghouse and The New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services. This recognition brings creditability to the program and to our Fraternity.

The Executive Committee continues to work closely with Masonic Chip International to ensure the standardization of the program throughout New York State and other States using this program. What that means is this: every person that is processed has the same format, making it useful to every Amber Alert in the country. This is an improvement from New York State Amber Alert only. New York State was the leader in standardization; Masonic Chip International closely followed NYS.

We continue to work closely with E-Z Child ID, Inc., Masonic Chip International, The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC) and The New York State Missing Persons Clearinghouse to improve the program by introducing a new app for cellphones. [An app is an application program which is run off of a cellphone or computer.] With this free app, the entire child or person's information is uploaded onto the cellphones of the parents and/or guardians of children and people being processed.

You may ask why this app is important. Everyone today has his or her cellphone with them everywhere they go. When you are out, and your child goes missing and you call the police, you have your child's entire information with you on your cellphone. You simply bring up the app and send the information to the telephone number the police officer gives you, and your information is available to law enforcement before you leave. That information is available to Amber Alert in seconds. We are the only non-law enforcement group that has this capability. The program has surely come a long way from the days of bulky video cameras and tapes, to laptops and CDs, to now, with an app on a smartphone.

11

As 2015 comes to a close, we look back and reflect on the program and the number of children that we protected during the year.

The Training Chairmen, Brother Lee D. Roof, W∴Gary M. Kimpel and Brother Thomas Wong supported the larger events: the Erie County Fair in Monroe County, the NYS Fair in Onondaga County and the Strong Kids Safe Kids event in Horseheads, NY. I cannot thank them enough for all their hard work.

The number of processed in 2015 was (13,663) ReportedThe number of locations in 2015 was (200) ReportedMany Districts didn’t report their numbers. Many District Deputy Grand Masters

didn’t appoint Regional MSID Chairman, and caused some confusion in the program. This excellent program, which shows Freemasonry in a favorable way to the public, needs the support and cooperation of every one of us.

Respectfully submitted,DoNalD h. elliot, Vice-Chairman,

New York Masonic Safety ID Program Sub-Committee William m. plaNK steveN roseN

Gary m. Kimpel, Consultant, New York Masonic Safety ID Program

compliaNce aND assessmeNt committeeTo the Grand Lodge:The Grand Master established the Compliance and Assessment Committee

[formerly the Audit Committee] to review Grand Lodge entities and components. The mission of the Committee is to ensure that there is a high level of confidence in the financial reporting, internal controls and operational aspects of Grand Lodge organizations.

The Compliance and Assessment Committee conducted reviews of Grand Lodge’s financial reimbursement procedures, and various operational and financial aspects of the Masonic Brotherhood Foundation and the Masonic War Veterans of New York. The reviews focused on whether the organizations had: (1) financial controls to ensure that reimbursements were accurately reimbursed, (2) accurate records to ensure that the organization could account for all members and expenditures, (3) operations that were consistent with those described in the organization’s by-laws, and (4) investment objectives and level of risk that were consistent with current operations and financial needs.

Reports were issued that included recommendations to make changes in policies, procedures and internal controls. The Grand Master accepted all of the recommendations and changes have been made that will improve operations.

Respectfully submitted,berNarD D. rashes, Chairman

larry N. barNarD, Committee Member

CONCORDANT BODIES COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

The mission of the Concordant Bodies Committee is to meet several times a year with the goal of achieving better communications between Grand Lodge and the other organizations, and to create better visibility between the York Rite, the Ancient

12

Accepted Scottish Rite, other Concordant Bodies and the Grand Lodge.Over the last two years, the Grand Lodge implemented a Master Calendar

Program which is located on the Grand Lodge website. The address is: nymasons.org. The Master Calendar contains all of the major functions of the Grand Lodge as well as those of the Concordant Bodies. It is important to review the calendar prior to scheduling an event that might directly clash and detract from a previously posted event, for example - the Grand Lodge schedules a 200th Anniversary Rededication of a Lodge, while at the same time, a Royal Arch Festival or Knight Templar Zone School is conducted in the same county or region. This hurts attendance at both events!

The Concordant Bodies Committee recognized that there is an overall lack of interest regarding the “Re-Member the Blue Lodge Program”, and feel this initiative has come to the end of its life cycle. Our thanks are extended especially to R∴W∴George D. Emmons, Program Administrator, and to everyone who has contributed to it over the years. It is simply time to retire the “Re-Member the Blue Lodge Program” and move on.

Finally, we thank our Grand Master and the Concordant Bodies leadership team for their support and enthusiasm over the past two years and look forward to increased cooperation and interaction in the future.

Respectfully submitted, Jeffrey m. WilliamsoN DGM, Chairmancyril a. fraNcis Grand High Priest, Grand Chapter, RAMraymoND roche Grand King, Grand Chapter, RAMGarry hutchursoN Deputy Grand Master, Grand Council, RSM (Cryptic)freDericK a. beitter Grand Commander, Grand Commandery, KTricharD KerimoGlu Deputy Grand Commander, Grand Commandery, KTpeter J. samiec Grand Almoner, AASR, NMJDaviD p. speNcer Deputy for New York, AASR, NMJ

ConsultantsGeorGe D. emmoNs, Re-Member the Blue Lodge Program

James r. KiNtzel

Ex-OfficioWilliam J. thomas, Grand Master

coNstitutioNs committeeTo the Grand Lodge:The Constitutions Committee is a Standing Committee of Grand Lodge.

There are presently nine members. The primary function of the Committee is to review all propositions to amend the Constitutions and Rules of Order of Grand Lodge. (See Masonic Law: Section 332 and Rules of Order: Section XI sub 8)

The Committee members discuss them, and, through its Chairman, recommend to the Grand Lodge whether the proposed Amendments should be passed, voted down or referred to another Grand Lodge Committee for review and report back to the Grand Lodge the following year.

When proposed Amendments to the Constitutions and Rules of Order are forwarded to our Committee, the Amendment is disseminated to the

13

members of the Committee. We then review and discuss the same via email prior to the Committee’s annual meeting, held approximately one week prior to the Grand Lodge Annual Communication. At this meeting, a final discussion is held and then a vote is taken on the proposals.

Currently, at the time of writing this report, there have been a few new Amendments submitted, proposing changes to the Constitutions and/or Rules of Order for this Committee’s review. They were also disseminated to the Lodges in the Grand Secretary’s Call Letter.

Additionally, for a second reading, there are four Masonic Districts Consolidating: 1st and 2nd St. Lawrence Masonic Districts, 1st and 6th Manhattan Masonic Districts, 1st and 2nd Oneida Masonic Districts and 1st and 2nd Nassau Masonic Districts.

I speak for the entire Committee on Constitutions when I say we are grateful for our appointment to this important Committee, and we are aware of the awesome responsibility placed upon our shoulders in serving Grand Lodge.

I would like to thank M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master, for allowing me to serve as Chairman of this Committee. It is an honor. I would also like to thank my Committee Members for their hard work on behalf of Grand Lodge.

Respectfully and fraternally submitted,carl J. fitJe, PGM, Chairman

aNthoNy f. aDamo rex l. NisWaNDeraDel chahiNe virGilio s. QuiJaNoGilbert c. ferrer steveN a. rubiNhoWarD s. Kass DaNiel m. semel, Hon. PGM, MWPHGLNY

committee oN correspoNDeNce aND relatioNsTo the Grand Lodge:

The Committee is pleased to note that the Most Worshipful Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Washington State and the Most Worshipful Prince Hall Grand Lodge of Illinois accepted our proposal of full recognition.

Upon the recommendation of the Commission on Recognition of the Conference of Grand Masters of North America we suspended relations with the Grand Lodge of Valle de Mexico for not meeting the standards of recognition.

There has been some confusion in Paraguay concerning which Grand Lodge is the Regular Grand Lodge. After due study through the Commission of Recognition of the Conference of Grand Masters of North America we ascertained the Symbolic Grand Lodge of Paraguay with whom we are in Amity is the only Grand Lodge in Paraguay that meets the Standards of Recognition.

The Committee is pleased the Grand Master took the initiative to visit the Grand Lodge of Cuba solidifying relations between our Grand Lodges.

On a matter of deep concern, we had a complaint from our District Grand Lodge of Syria-Lebanon that three of our Expelled members were allowed to join El Mizpah Lodge of the Scottish District Grand Lodge

14

in Lebanon. We sent a letter to the Grand Lodge of Scotland apprising them of the situation requesting them to honor our Expulsions. To date, we are awaiting their reply.

The Committee on Correspondence and Relations continues to monitor the issue of racial and religious bigotry through correspondence that comes through the Office of Grand Secretary. To date, we have not received any negative information.

We thank the Grand Master for his confidence in appointing the members of this Committee. We are pleased to contribute our efforts in the investigation of recognition requests and other matters that come before Grand Lodge. The Committee stands ready and willing to support all Grand Lodges that practice our Ancient Craft according to the standards of recognition that have been established throughout the world of Regular Freemasonry.

Respectfully submitted,Gary a. heNNiNGseN, PGM, GS Emeritus, Chairman

carl J. fitJe, PGM carl J. smith, PGM eDWarD G. Gilbert, PGM James e. sullivaN, PGM earle J. hiNo, Jr., PGM bruce WiDGer, PGM

CUSTODIANS OF THE WORKTo the Grand Lodge:

The Custodians of the Work report as follows:First, your Committee offers for the consideration of the Brethren the

following recommendations for the Standard Work and Lectures:1. Optional Prayer to be added to those which may be given at the

Chaplain’s discretion during the Masonic Ritual of Opening.This prayer reads as follows: "Almighty and merciful God, we bless Thee forever; hear us

with indulgence, have pity for our weakness, and aid us with Thy strength. Thou to whom all thoughts and actions of men are known, give to us the wisdom to judge justly and mercifully.

If it be Thy will that we should guide and direct our Brethren, preserve us from anger and vanity and error. Keep our feet from going astray. Lead us by the way of truth. Let us not yield to temptation, and seek to usurp those powers and rights which properly belong to all Thy children. Strengthen our good resolutions to prevail against the selfishness and indifference of the world around us. Help us to perform all our duties, to ourselves, to other men, and to Thee.

Let the great flood of Masonic light flow over the world. Pardon us when we offend. When we go astray, lead us back to the true path; and help our feeble efforts to remove all obstacles to the final triumph of the great law of love; and, having faithfully performed our duty here below, wilt Thou receive us into Thy Celestial Lodge above, that house not made with hands, eternal in the heavens. Amen. (response) So mote it be."

15

2. Optional Prayer which may be given at the Chaplain’s discretion during the Masonic Ritual of Closing in place of the existing Prayer.

This prayer reads as follows: "Supreme Architect of the Universe, accept our humble thanks for

the many mercies and blessings which Thy bounty has conferred on us, and especially for this friendly and social intercourse.

Pardon, we beseech Thee, whatever Thou hast seen amiss in us since we have been together, and continue to us Thy presence, protection and blessing.

Make us sensible of the renewed obligations we are under to love Thee, and as we are about to separate, and return to our respective places of abode, wilt Thou be pleased so to influence our hearts and minds, that we may each one of us practice out of the Lodge those great moral duties which are inculcated in it, and with reverence study and obey the laws which Thou hast given us in Thy Holy Word. (response) So mote it be."

These beautiful and timely optional Prayers appear in Monitors used by the Grand Lodge of New York from the mid-nineteenth century to the early twentieth century, and their restoration would bring back the full range of Prayers available during those years. The possibility of variety should contribute additional interest to the Masonic Rituals of Opening and Closing, which are the most frequently performed pieces of Masonic Ritual.

3. Line to be given by the Worshipful Master immediately prior to the Closing Prayer.

WM— Bn, gv ur atn to th Chp.Giving this line erroneously during the Masonic Ritual of Closing has

been one of the most common Masonic Ritual errors by Worshipful Masters over the years. We observe, however, that the Masonic Ritual is meant to be responsive to the favor of the Brethren. In view of these facts, and because it makes an effective transition from the optional Closing Charge, when performed, into the Chaplain’s Closing Prayer, we believe it is a good time to make this line an official part of the Masonic Ritual of Closing.

4. Masonic Ritual direction for “due form” balloting to describe giving the d g and s of the Degree in which the Lodge is currently working, whereas previously it described giving the d g and s of Master Mason.The wording of the current direction is a reflection of Lodge practice in the

late 1950s when the first edition of the Masonic Ritual book was produced, rather than a fundamental aspect of our Masonic system. Your Committee therefore views this proposed adjustment to the language of the italicized direction as a clarification rather than a modification of the Standard Work and Lectures, but nevertheless presents it here for the consideration and approval of the Brethren.

5. Restored text on St. John the Baptist and St. John the Evangelist in the Entered Apprentice Historical Lecture.

“ ... speculative Masons dedicate theirs to the memory of St. John the Baptist, and St. John the Evangelist, who were two eminent patrons of Masonry. Since their time ... ”

16

Some version of the underlined text above appears in Monitors used by the Grand Lodge of New York throughout most of the nineteenth century. Your Committee believes that its restoration to the Lecture should help clarify that St. John the Baptist and St. John the Evangelist are featured in our Masonic Ritual because historically they have been associated with the stoneworking craft and viewed as patrons of Masonry, and not because of their status as Christian saints.6. Restored description of the elements in the Entered Apprentice

Historical Lecture.“... our mother earth, for it alone of all the elements has never

proved unfriendly to man. Bodies of water deluge him with rain, oppress him with hail and drown him with inundation. The air rushes in storms and prepares the tempest, and fire lights up the volcano. But the Earth, ever kind and indulgent, is found subservient to his wishes. Though constantly harassed ...”

The underlined text above appears in Monitors used by the Grand Lodge of New York from the mid-nineteenth century to the early twentieth century. In illustrating how water, wind and fire can be dangerous, this text prepares the listener for the contrasting disquisition on earth’s benign characteristics which follows, resulting in a more comprehensible and better balanced section of the Lecture.

7. Restored reiteration of beehive symbolism in the optional section of the Master Mason Historical Lecture.

“... he that will so demean himself as not to endeavor to add to the common stock of knowledge and understanding may be deemed a drone in the hive of nature, a useless member of society, and unworthy of our protection as Masons.”

The underlined text above appears in Monitors used by the Grand Lodge of New York throughout the nineteenth century into the early twentieth century. As the disquisition on the beehive has gone somewhat far afield by its conclusion, these few words reinforce the metaphorical association with the beehive and help tie this section of the Lecture together as a unified whole.

The Custodians of the Work hereby recommend that its seven proposals as described and set forth herein be adopted into the Standard Work and Lectures of Ancient Craft Masonry of our jurisdiction, and submit the same for a vote of the Brethren.

Second, two items regarding the Senior Deacon’s work at the Altar merit some clarification from your Committee:

• Questions have been addressed to your Committee as to whether Brothers other than the Senior Deacon are permitted to adjust or handle items on the Altar, including the Three Great Lights. In responding, we would draw attention to the fact that “attending at the Altar” is not among the enumerated duties of the Senior Deacon. While the procedure outlined in our Standard Work and Lectures calls for the Master to direct the Senior Deacon to perform that service, this is not a basis to assert that the Senior Deacon has exclusive provenance over the Altar. Moreover, it is a prerogative of the Worshipful Master to direct or authorize any Brother to perform any work in the Lodge.

17

• Your Committee has also been made aware of an emerging trend whereby Senior Deacons attending at the Altar pause and look around the room, ostensibly to verify that all Brethren are at the Sign of Fidelity, before proceeding with their work. This is not, nor has it ever been a duty of the Senior Deacon. The Worshipful Master has the exclusive duty of ensuring that all present comply with our forms and ceremonies. The duty of the Senior Deacon in this circumstance is to attend at the Altar as he has been directed, and nothing more. The Custodians of the Work recommend that the Senior Deacon simply pause as he addresses the Altar, taking care to execute the Sign of Fidelity slowly and perfectly with his focus on the Bible, then without further pause or glance proceed with his work.

Third, your Committee frequently receives the suggestion that our Standard Work and Lectures be made available to the Brethren in electronic form. While we have no actionable recommendation at this time, your Committee believes that this method of publication should be strongly considered by the Grand Lodge for future implementation. Not only do most of the younger Masons joining the Craft in recent years prefer to consume written media in electronic rather than printed form, but electronic publication would also offer many benefits to our older members, such as the ability to adjust the letter size for better legibility.

Fourth, your Committee reports that 2015 has been a productive year for the Custodians of the Work and relates the following summary of its activities.

At the Annual Communication of Grand Lodge, your Committee recommended that the Closing Charge be restored to the authorized Work of our jurisdiction. The Brethren voted positively on this recommendation, and the text has been duly situated in the Standard Work and Lectures of Ancient Craft Masonry.

In connection with the restoration of Masonic Ritual texts at the 2014 and 2015 Annual Communications of Grand Lodge, your Committee produced a printable electronic file containing the following:

• A printable Monitor that can be used in the performance of the Closing Charge by those who wish to read it from a printed document;

• A chart setting forth the locations of the restored texts in the 2014, 2013 and 2007 printings of the Masonic Ritual book;

• A collection of cut-out replacement pages that can be pasted over pages in the 2013 and 2007 printings of the Masonic Ritual Book to make them current with the Standard Work and Lectures;

• Cut-out replacement pages that can be substituted for pages in the 2014 printing of the Masonic Ritual Book to make it current with the Standard Work and Lectures; and

• Charts setting forth minor errors in the 2014, 2013 and 2007 printings of the Masonic Ritual Book that can be corrected by hand.

The contents of this file made it possible for any Brother to modify his 2014, 2013 or 2007 printing of the Masonic Ritual Book and bring it fully up-to-date with the authorized Work of our jurisdiction. The electronic file was transmitted to all the District Deputy Grand Masters and Assistant Grand Lecturers with the direction that they distribute it to the Masters, Secretaries and Brethren in their Districts and stand ready to support any who might need assistance in installing the revised pages into their Masonic Ritual books.

18

This effort was met with mixed success. Some Lodges and Districts are in possession of the new material whereas others appear to be largely unaware of the recent restorations and even surprised to learn of their existence. This is unfortunate, because the recent restorations have elicited numerous communications of enthusiastic support from around the state, but a Brother who is unaware of this exciting work is unable to take advantage of it. Notwithstanding, we will continue to issue materials that can be used to bring older printings of the Masonic Ritual book up to date until such time as those printings have reached a level of obsolescence that makes the incorporation of additional pages impracticable. However, we must work more effectively in ensuring that every Mason in our jurisdiction has a current valid expression of our Standard Work and Lectures.

Your Committee also continues its review of the Masonic Ritual Book as a performance guide, and is engaged in the process of reconsidering its organization, formatting and italicized Masonic Ritual directions with the goal of providing the Brethren with the best possible resource. We expect to have a fully revised Masonic Ritual book ready for presentation to the Brethren in time for the 2016 Annual Communication of Grand Lodge.

Finally, the Custodians of the Work thank the Grand Master, whose dedication to the Masonic Ritual matches our own, for the opportunity to serve our great jurisdiction.

Respectfully submitted,samuel lloyD KiNsey, Chairman, 2018

curtis a. baNKs, 2017 richarD c. frieDmaN, PJGW, 2016charles v. buNtoN, 2017 GleNN K. rubiN, 2018michael s. claytoN, 2018 thomas m. saviNi, 2016

ConsultantsfreD m. s. DoWNs, William G. vassily

EmeritilaWreNce J. hammel, Jr., peter r. KermaNi, steWart c. mcclouD ii,

William N. Walter, Gr.Chaplain Emeritus

THE GEORGE WASHINGTON MASONICHISTORIC SITE AT TAPPAN COMMITTEE

To the Grand Lodge:To The Grand Lodge:I am pleased to report that the Committee at Tappan had been very busy

planning the events to be held over the year 2015-16. We decided that it was time to have something different to present to the members and the public with concerns to the importance that transpired here at the DeWint House.

We had originally scheduled, on February 8th 2015, to celebrate George Washington's 283rd Birthday, however, due to extreme weather, we were forced to cancel the event twice, for our snow day was also impacted by extreme weather.

On September 26, 2015, our Annual Colonial Day at Tappan was held by the usual Committee. Numerous events transpired on the grounds demonstrating everyday living 200 years ago by the colonial ancestors. As usual, it was very interesting, educational, and well received by all attendees.

19

We had scheduled Grand Master’s Day on October 8th, 2015, however, due to a scheduled hurricane to impact the area, the Grand Master decided to postpone the event to a later date. The new date is now Sunday, March 13th 2016. Hopefully, the weather will cooperate. A tree dedication for the Grand Master is scheduled for that day as well.

Respectfully SubmittedmelviN ecKhaus, PGTiler, Vice Chairman louis m. irizarry II, Chairman

Gary m. maNDel, SecretaryharolD b. JoNes, Superintendent

robert f. blaNKe marK D. haNsoN KeNNeth h. merriNGDaviD l. blasch louis m. irizarry III peter c. Nozellmaurice i. coheN DaNiel e. JoNas DaviD l. richarDs

Emeritipaul p. DeWe-matheWs, WerNer h. KNiesel, c. f. William maurer iii,

NormaN e. mooN, roNalD J. steiNer, melviN Werbel

THE GEORGE WASHINGTON MASONIC NATIONAL MEMORIAL COMMITTEE

To the Grand Lodge:During 2015, the George Washington Masonic National Memorial

Association undertook extensive restoration of the sparkling pyramid atop the Memorial. The successful project consumed considerable sums of money over the year. The Association's Board of Directors extended its appreciation to those Grand Lodges and those Brothers who have contributed and continue to contribute to support this important project.

The Association's Board stresses that the role of the Memorial is to portray the ideals of George Washington and to inspire humanity to recognize the important role of Freemasonry in the life and career of our nation's first President. The vision of the Memorial is: "To inspire humanity through education to emulate and promote the virtues, character and vision of George Washington, the Man, the Mason and Father of our Country." The Board welcomes contributions from Masons and Grand Lodges to support the Memorial's vision and mission.

The Board continues the Memorial's Grand Lodge of the Month Program, the annual sale of a Holiday Ornament, the Dedicatory Tree Program to beautify the grounds and to honor and recognize individuals and organizations with a living memorial, and the maintenance and improvement of the Memorial's website -- http://www.gwmemorial.org -- for programs, projects, events, and contributions.

Respectfully submitted,shelDoN b. richmaN, Chairman

roNalD a. sablosKy, Vice Chairman

GRAND LODGE CONVENTION COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

The Grand Lodge Convention Committee is responsible for coordinating and facilitating the Masons and Family Dedication Service and Breakfast, hosted by the Metropolitan District Deputy Grand Masters Association, the Annual

20

Brotherhood Night in Delaware, hosted by the Grand Lodge of Delaware, and the Grand Lodge of New York Annual Communication, including the Grand Master’s Reception and Dinner. When the Grand Master hails from Downstate, it is also responsible for the Grand Master’s Ball.

The main purpose of this Committee is to ensure that the activities of the Grand Lodge Annual Communication, the Dedication Breakfast and the Brotherhood Night are successful, and the needs and expectations of the Grand Master, the Grand Line and the guests of Grand Lodge are fulfilled. Typically, the duties associated with these various activities include: coordination of hotel reservations; ticket sales and distribution; bus arrangements; the attendant luncheons and dinners; airport pickups; table settings and several other tasks, including stuffing of envelopes with flyers, attendance sheets and badges.

Each year brings new challenges and expectations, and, each year, we hope we’ve fulfilled them. The members of this Committee have worked tirelessly to see these duties performed. I cannot fully express my gratitude to the members of this Committee for their efforts. Their hard work is the reason these activities are successful. Their dedication, fellowship and teamwork are second to none. We have several long-term members on the Committee, supplemented with new members annually. The experience of the long-term members enables the newer members to gain valuable guidance in what's necessary for successful activities. Additionally, the efforts of the Committee are supplemented by several additional dedicated Brothers around the state that wish to see our Grand Lodge activities successful; we recognize and thank them for their help and service in various capacities as well.

On behalf of the Committee and myself, I thank the Grand Master for the opportunity to be of service to him and the Fraternity.

Respectfully submitted,richarD t. schulz, Chairman

Vice-ChairmenJoseph m. Keeler, eDWarD r. stouter James m. tWeeDie

aNthoNy f. aDamo DoNalD p. mattsoN marloN thomas robert carlisto albert mccoNNach Walter J. WasNiesKi iiiGeorGe filippiDis aNGel ruiz JohN J. White, Jr.Walter fiNGerle robert J. serviDio, PGrM’l michael p. WiNKlermattheW s. fraNK michael J. sieGel Joseph a. zimmermaNrobert t. mascialiNo liNtoN l. smith, Jr. mario ziNerco

ConsultantsricharD W. batemaN, GP, AGS, louis h. Juers, PGT,

viNceNt liboNe, PGM, Kurt ott, PGT, bruce testut

harolD h. halper, Emeritus d. 11/16/2015

GRAND LODGE EDUCATIONALASSISTANCE PROGRAM COMMITTEE

To the Grand Lodge:The 20th year of the Grand Lodge Education Assistance Program was

both an exciting and rewarding experience for the Committee. $465,000

21

in educational assistance was awarded to approximately 500 outstanding students who are the children and/or grandchildren of Master Masons of the State of New York.

This year marked the first year in which the Program was provided to Students in a “web based/online interactive format” providing a much-improved application process, and was met with great enthusiasm by applicants.

As in past years, after the Committee receives the applications, an independent firm rates them so that the Committee would show no favoritism. Public presentations were made in Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Utica, Schenectady, and New York City during June and July. I want to thank the District Deputy Grand Masters in these Districts for their assistance in setting up the presentations. In 2015, over Fifty-Four percent (54%) of the recipients attended the presentations. This was a dramatic increase from Twenty percent (20%) in previous years.

What a great experience to see and talk to the Student recipients at these presentations! The letters of thanks received from the students attest to the important value of this Grand Lodge Program. Photographs of the recipients and the Grand Master, along with a press release,were sent with press releases to local newspapers throughout New York State, and for the first time, notification was sent to Lodges informing them of recipients from their Lodge.

Many people put a great deal of effort into the success of this program and deserve appreciation and thanks. Mrs. Joan Bower publicized the program in The Empire State Mason, helping us to solicit applications along with the Grand Lodge Website. The Grand Master and the Grand Line, as well as their representatives, came and represented Grand Lodge at the presentation ceremonies, along with members of the Board of Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home. The Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home have continued the funding and provided strong ongoing support. Special thanks go to R∴W∴G. Stephen Getman, President and R∴W∴Nathan D. Lipper, Trustee, for all their assistance during the year.

R∴W∴Michael A. Shipman chaired the presentation ceremonies. R∴W∴Abraham Fichtenbaum photographed all of the presentations this year. R∴W∴Clayton “Bob” R. Ruggles, R∴W∴Alan F. Geller and R∴W∴Efrain Hernandez aided in the presentations, along with R∴W∴Thomas “Tim” M. McMullin, R∴W∴Richard S. Morley and M∴W∴Vincent Libone. W∴Russell L. Magidson assisted in the many technical responsibilities

I also wish to thank M∴W∴William J. Thomas, R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen and the Office of the Grand Secretary, as well as R∴W∴Richard W. Bateman and the Grand Lodge Staff for their help in the distribution and mailing of the various materials that were needed to assure the success of the program.

Respectfully submitted,efraiN herNaNDez, Vice Chairman michael a. shipmaN, Chairmanabraham fichteNbaum russell l. maGiDsoNricharD a. Gallo claytoN "bob" r. ruGGlesalaN f. Geller arthur f. taft

GeorGe a. harrisoN, h. stepheN lieb, EMEriti

22

COMMITTEE ON LAW ENFORCEMENTTo the Grand Lodge:

The Committee on Law Enforcement is a Standing Committee of Grand Lodge, consisting of seven members appointed for three-year terms. The duties of the Committee are as follows: (1) Before a Charter is issued to a new Lodge, this Committee shall certify that it has inspected the books, accounts and records of the Lodge Under Dispensation and has found them to be in due form; (2) To take such steps as may be necessary to prevent the violation of the laws pertaining to the Fraternity and the proper use of its name and symbols; and (3) Any other duties that may be found in the Book of Constitutions and the Book of Masonic Law of the Grand Lodge of New York.

During the past year, the Committee was asked to provide legal guidance on various Masonic matters. No Charter work was performed by this Committee during this year. One matter that frequently does come before this Committee is the unauthorized use of the Masonic symbol (the square and compasses) on business cards, websites, Facebook, Twitter, other internet sites, displays on publications, in businesses and in newspaper advertisements without permission from the Grand Lodge. Using Masonic symbols without permission because one is a Mason is a violation of Sections 134 and 135 of the General Business Law of the State of New York, which is a misdemeanor under the laws of the State of New York. This year, the Committee handled a number of matters where Masons and non-Masons used the Masonic symbol for business purposes or for various Masonic clubs without the written authorization of the Grand Lodge. This Chairman first called the alleged offender and, if needed, then sent a detailed letter outlining the infraction and the sections of the laws which illegally were being violated. If the offender did not correct the situation within a reasonable period of time, then this matter was turned over to the proper legal authorities. However, we are pleased to report that most of these matters were resolved without resort to legal channels, and the Committee assisted the Grand Master in a positive way. There is one matter that is still in progress at this time.

Another frequent problem is the well-meaning but not previously approved attempt by Brothers to do charity work under the auspices of the Grand Lodge. The same methods were successfully employed as detailed in the previous paragraph. However, at this time there is one matter still in process.

This Chairman communicated with the members of the Committee indicating each person’s responsibilities and duties and what was expected of him during his term of office. Each member was advised to call my law offices at any time whenever he wanted to discuss a matter with me.

In addition, as the past president of the Bronx County Bar Association, I have a battery of subject matter experts to consult with in all specialities of the law when necessary.

This Committee and its Chairman are grateful to M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master, and R∴W∴Jeffrey M. Williamson, Deputy Grand

23

Master, for the honor, privilege, and continuing opportunity to serve the Grand Lodge, and to our Grand Secretary, the R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen, and his Office staff for their kindness, gentility and unfailing courtesy. The Grand Master, the Deputy Grand Master, the Grand Secretary, the Assistant Grand Secretary, R∴W∴Richard W. Bateman, GP, and this Committee continue to have a wonderful working relationship.

Respectfully submitted, steveN J. baKer, Chairman, 2018 MetrolaWreNce abbey, 2016 West William mccauley, 2016 SuffolkpasQuale imbimbo, Jr., 2018 North Country Demetrios G. melis, 2018 Metrosalvatore leotta, 2017 Richmond Joseph a. QuareQuio, 2017 Metro

Consultantsrobert l. hoGaN, Jr. Dutchess

stepheN J. storeN MetroWilliam r. Williams, Jr. Hudson-Champlain

martiN a. DaNoff, Emeritus

committee oN leaDership aND eDucatioNal servicesTo the Grand Lodge:M∴W∴Grand Master, R∴W∴Deputy Grand Master, M∴W∴Past Grand

Masters, Brethren;The Committee on Leadership and Educational Services is a Standing

Committee of Grand Lodge presently consisting of a Chairman, two Vice Chairmen and twenty other members, all of whom serve at the pleasure of the Grand Master. The following programs fall under the Committee’s jurisdiction: The Lodge System of Masonic Education (LSOME), Etiquette & Protocol, Masonic Development Course (MDC), Road to the East (RTTE) and the Master’s Chair. This Committee also conducts the Training of Grand Lodge Officers (District Deputy Grand Masters and Grand Lodge Staff Officers).

The Committee meets at the Masonic Care Community Campus in Utica, NY, on a regular basis for planning the Grand Lodge Officers' Training Session and for changes in the various printed materials, tools, and courses. It is our goal to make the District Deputy Grand Masters and Grand Lodge Staff Officers the best prepared, administratively and in leadership skills, as well as to keep the educational material for the Brothers as updated and informative as possible.

However, it was also noted from the questions and discussions, that there appears to be a hole in basic Masonic Education and Masonic Law. It is apparent that we MUST require greater participation in the Courses and Training provided by this Committee and by Grand Lodge. Additional training will be held at St. John's Day Weekend as well as regional training sessions prior to the Investiture Ceremonies.

THE MASTER’S CHAIR has continued to be a success as do all the other educational programs that come under our jurisdiction. I wish to thank the District Deputy Grand Masters and the Grand Lodge Staff Officers for their hard work and dedication in conducting these courses. During this

24

past year, 237 Brothers have taken the Masonic Development Course, 180 the Road To The East and 188 The Masters Chair.

In conclusion, I thank each member of the Committee for their commitment to excellence and for their enthusiastic attitude which they project to all those whom they meet and train. I also wish to thank our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, for his confidence, trust, and support, and for allowing us to serve our Grand Lodge on this most important Committee.

Respectfully submitted, mariNo cesariNi, Chairman, PGT

martiN l. KaNter, euGeNe s. olofsoN, Vice Chairmeneric J. beNsoN steveN p. Koch timothy a. smithhoWarD e. boNsaiNG ricKy l. NeilD alDo r. smithpeter b. boyer GreGory Noulas richarD W. spriNGerallaN D. clarK marK G. peersoN alaN b. steWart DeNNis G. felDmaN, PSGD robert russell briaN D. siNGerJames michael GraDy robert J. serviDio, PGrM’l richarD m. torreyWilliam c. JoNes JohN e. zabel

LONG-RANGE PLANNING COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

As stated in last year’s report, this Committee was completely revamped and now consists of Permanent Members of Grand Lodge who have served in an elected position and who, because of working in those positions, have the needed insight into the operations of Grand Lodge. Their duties, as per the Rules of Order, is to “Develop, continually update and maintain a Long-Range Plan for Grand Lodge Structure and Operations for the future."

The Committee continued to use the theme, “Thinking Out of The Box,” and has had many discussions regarding the future of New York Freemasonry. The Committee put together a report outlining recommendations which was given to the Grand Master, the Deputy Grand Master, and the Past Grand Masters for their review. The Committee is now awaiting input from the Deputy Grand Master in going forward and adoption of this plan.

As it was in last year’s report, the Committee did not go into detail regarding technological changes because everyone was in agreement that wherever Grand Lodge can embrace and use technology to improve communications Grand Lodge will do so.

The Committee’s focus continued on the structure of Grand Lodge: Grand Lodge Elected Officers, District Deputy Grand Masters, Districts, and operations and funding of Grand Lodge. It was agreed that Grand Lodge is top heavy and needs to be streamlined due to the continual decline of membership, merging of Lodges and Districts. If membership continues to decline in the way it has in past years, it will seriously affect the operations of Lodges, Districts and Grand Lodge.

Although the thinking was “Outside the Box,” as stated, the overall feeling in many of the discussions was that New York Masonry should get back to its basic teachings and promote education in Masonic Ritual and more training in the areas of Lodge Officers, District Deputy Grand Masters, and Grand Lodge Officers.

25

The Committee also felt that slowing down the time in between Degrees was needed to ensure the new member wants to be a Mason. It was the consensus that we need to teach him more about the Degrees and his commitment to our Craft instead of rushing him through the Degrees, and to give him a deeper understanding of the Masonic Ritual and educate him on what the ceremonies are actually about. A Mentor is an important part of this and should be used for every new member.

In the area of Charity, it was felt that the members must reduce the amount of funding given to outside Charities and keep more of the funds to help, aid and assist widows, members and Lodges who need assistance. Although Masonry teaches us to practice Charity, Grand Lodge and Freemasonry is not a Charity or Philanthropic organization and shouldn’t be portrayed as such. The emphasis on sayings about Masonry that "Charity begins at Home”, and how its about “Masons helping Masons” has decreased and needs to be re-emphasized.

Finally, it was felt that the recommendations made by this Committee should be adopted and put into a basic Long Range Plan that each succeeding Grand Master can work with.

I want to thank all the members of this Committee for their insight and ideas and I look forward to continually working with them next year in putting together a workable Long Range Plan for Grand Lodge.

Respectfully submitted,carl J. fitJe, PGM, 2017, Chairman

mariNo cesariNi, PGt, 2017 carl J. smith, PGM, 2018Gary a. heNNiNGseN, PGM, 2016 robert D. stacK, Hon. PGM, 2018stepheN s. KiNG, PJGW, 2017 charles p. uhle, PJGW, SGW, 2017Kurt ott, PGt, 2018

Ex-OfficioJeffrey m. WilliamsoN, DGM, 2016

COMMITTEE ON MASONIC BENEVOLENCETo the Grand Lodge:The Committee on Masonic Benevolence was established with the principal

responsibility to provide help, aid and assistance to all distressed and worthy Master Masons within the jurisdiction of the Grand Lodge of the State of New York, as well as to their widows and dependent family members during times of particular difficulty and hardship.

To that end, the Committee is here to assist the Lodges and their respective Districts throughout the state in providing financial relief to those in need, as well as to provide direction to information for broader and more long-term assistance through outside agencies, such as State and Federal Social Services and Veterans assistance programs, should that be necessary. The Committee is further charged with encouraging the use of the Masonic Care Community in Utica if circumstances deem this to be an appropriate, alternative solution.

This Committee’s budget is funded by donations made to the Masonic Brotherhood Fund, that are allotted for Masonic Benevolence. It is therefore important to bear in mind that these funds are limited and need to be made

26

available to many worthy applicants throughout our jurisdiction over the course of the budgetary year. Masonic Benevolence is intended to be a stopgap used to meet immediate, short-term monetary needs ... to cover such essentials as food, medicine, heat and rent while a more permanent solution is sought, such as a return to productive employment, local public assistance programs or social services. It should not be expected that these funds are available to be used to support an applicant’s particular lifestyle or assist to pay outstanding financial debt, nor are they intended to supplement the costs associated with ongoing, long-term care.

In order that the Committee may properly address the short-term financial needs of those in distress and to expedite the process, particularly in an emergency situation, it is imperative that we receive accurate and complete information regarding the applicant’s circumstances. Requests for assistance are transmitted to the Committee by means of one of two different forms, which must be completed by the applicant and submitted to this Committee by the Secretary of the applicant’s Lodge. The first is our short form, No. 5A, which is specifically designed for requests for emergency aid up to $500.00. The second, the longer form No. 5, is intended for requests in excess of $500.00 and requires more detailed information be provided by the applicant. Both forms are supplied annually to the Secretary of each Lodge.

Where financial assistance is requested, we continue to emphasize the importance of a three-tier monetary solution through the individual Lodge, the respective District and this Committee, within the capacity of each. Because the need for assistance throughout this jurisdiction continues, it’s incumbent upon the Districts to be proactive in providing that second-tier of Masonic Benevolence. While the Lodges, for the most part, have met their responsibilities in this area, even when funds are very limited, more than 30% of applications received indicate no District level aid has been granted. In order to assure each District remains a valuable resource in support of their respective Lodges, we continue to stress that each reevaluate their Masonic Benevolence procedure and, where necessary, establish and maintain its own, robust Benevolent Fund.

It is the policy of this Grand Lodge Committee to act on each valid request received and determine what assistance, if any, will be provided. Although the past year has seen a 27% decline in requests from the previous year, the average amount of those requests has increased by 20%, indicating that the economic strain in many areas throughout the state continues to have an adverse effect on many of our brothers and their families. It’s therefore of paramount importance that each Lodge be diligent in providing solid guidance and support to those applying for aid and assistance, in order that their needs can be validated in a timely fashion and met where appropriate.

Respectfully submitted,huGh c. DuNGey, Chairman

richarD W. batemaN, GP, AGS GeralD f. irWiN laWreNce h. ricecharles v. buNtoN steveN J. Joyce reGiNalD J. schWeitzerJohN s. curtis Jacob f. Karb iii bruce testutGary e. heNry ramoN morales iii DaviD f. velKas scott D. mosher

27

EmeritiDeNNis f. corlette, michael J. mimozo, Wesley C. Powell

MASONIC BROTHERHOOD FUND COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

The Campaign kicked off with the Grand Master's Appeal Letter and Donation Inserts were ready to go with the aid of P. J. Green, Inc., a printing and direct mail house in Utica, New York. The Area Chairman had their supplies and were told to start setting up Seminars around the State, which they did. I am sorry to say the attendance at some Seminars in the middle of the State were not great, but we did well in other areas.

I had R∴W∴ralph Pfeiffer, our Vice Chairman, contact the Area Chairman to present the program to the Lodges. One of the bright points was the People to People booklet, and every order of supplies sent to Grand Lodge requested this item.

We have helped a number of Brothers and their widows and we are proud of that, and this was with the aid of the Grand Master and the Masonic Benevolence Fund Committee and their Chairman, W∴Hugh Dungey. It is to be noted that funds for this Charity are created by the Masonic Benevolence Endowment Fund (which you have supported).

We are looking forward to seeing the totals and hope in these economic times to see an increase of support.

I appreciate the efforts of all the workers for the Masonic Brotherhood Fund, including the Grand Secretary's Office Staff and your support my Brothers

Respectfully submitted,bruce testut, Chairman

ralph pfeiffer, Vice Chairman Area 1: DaviD f. velKas Area 10: roGer s. fraNKArea 2: GeorGe r. Wacob Area 11: Garry e. campbell Area 3: eDWarD m. WeiGert Area 12: WaDe a. calerArea 4: michael D. GreNaDier Area 13: terry oaKleyArea 5: freDericK W. Grieve Area 14: JeD K. braNDoWArea 6: albert l. bayless Area 15: melviN r. husseyArea 7: fraNcis p. bureK Area 16: heNry W. robiNsoNArea 8: toDD J. coNDoN Area 17: DaviD m. moNKArea 9: roNalD e. siNclair Area 18: raNDall l. hartWicK

MASONIC CARE COMMUNITY AMBASSADOR PROGRAM COMMITTEE

To the Grand Lodge:The Masonic Care Community Ambassador Program officially became a

Grand Lodge Committee in May of 2014, through the foresight and commitment of the Most Worshipful William J. Thomas, Grand Master.

The Masonic Care Community Ambassador Program, or MCC Ambassador Program, was formed for the purpose of disseminating information about the responsibilities and role of the Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home, and the financial challenges currently facing the

28

various entities under the Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home's charge, as well as enhancing communications with the Board of Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home, The Grand Lodge of the State of New York, its members and, specifically, the Masonic Care Community.

The MCC Ambassador Program is divided into Nine (9) Regions, with Regional Administrators appointed throughout the Grand Jurisdiction as follows:

1) Western Region - R∴W∴John W. Krupp2) Western Lakes - R∴W∴Derek E. Van Houten3) Mid-State North - R∴W∴Norman M. McKnight4) Mid-State Central - (To Be Determined)5) Mid-State South - W∴Lynwood J. Bennerson6) Hudson-Champlain North - (To Be Determined)7) Hudson-Champlain Central - R∴W∴Neil R. Bonesteel8) Hudson-Champlain South - W∴Thomas J. Nervegna9) Metropolitan Region - W∴Glenn Donlon

With monthly talking points given at Lodge meetings and District events, and the resurgence of the use of the “Box of Remembrance”, and “Wish List” items to support the Masonic Care Community, the Program has been met with enthusiastic acceptance. Town Hall Meetings and Fundraising events have increased the awareness of the challenges facing the Masonic Care Community, Grand Lodge and the Board of Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home. Brothers are encouraged to contact their Regional Administrator to act as “Lodge Ambassador” for their Lodge.

Special thanks go to M∴W∴William J. Thomas for recognizing the importance of this program, along with the President of the Board of Trustees of the Masonic Hall & Home, R∴W∴G. Stephen Getman; Trustee R∴W∴Kurt Ott, PGT, Liaison, Trustee R∴W∴Michael J. Siegel, Liaison; the remaining members of the Board of Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home; R∴W∴Robert J. Raffle, Executive Director, Masonic Care Community, Ms. Victoria Cataldo, Director of Development; Ms. Kathy Contino-Turner, Director of Communications and Marketing, Masonic Care Community, and all of the dedicated Brothers across the Grand Jurisdiction for their hard work and dedication in making this Program a success.

Respectfully submitted,michael a. shipmaN, Chairman

lyNWooD J. beNNersoN GleNN DoNloN NormaN m. mcKNiGhtNeil r. boNesteel JohN W. Krupp DereK e. vaN houteN

thomas J. NerveGNa

MASONIC FELLOWSHIP COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

I wish to thank the Masonic Fellowship Committee’s Area Vice Chairmen, Committee Chairmen, District Deputy Grand Masters, and District Fellowship Committee Chairmen for their assistance and valued participation, which enabled our Committee to have another very successful and productive year.

29

On June 10, 2015, our Committee sponsored the Grand Secretary’s Golf Classic at Marine Park Golf Course in Brooklyn, NY. Once again, R∴W∴Walter J. Wasnieski III, Down-State Event Chairman, with the help of Co-Chairmen R∴W∴Angel Ruiz, R∴W∴Mark K. Suckle, R∴W∴Richard L. Giordano and W∴Marshal D. Shichtman, did an outstanding job making this event possible.

The huge success of this event not only enabled the Fellowship Committee to make generous contributions to our Masonic Care Community, The Ruby Kaplan Scholarship Fund and Caddy For A Cure, which assists disabled Veterans, but also provided the opportunity for over 100 Brothers and guests to have a spectacular day of golf and to enjoy a wonderful dinner. Again, I personally wish to thank Brothers Wasnieski, Ruiz, Suckle, Giordano and Shichtman for their dedication and hard work for our Committee.

Under the leadership of Up-State Golf Chairman, Brother Richard J. Arthur, participation in golf outings in the upstate area has increased this year, and we expect continued growth in popularity.

Committee Member and Downstate Golf Chairman R∴W∴Walter J. Wasnieski III organized and chaired a Masonic Fellowship Event held on March 28, 2015, at the Nassau Coliseum. Approximately 80 Brothers, families and friends attended the New York Islanders Hockey Game, and the event raised $750.00 for Camp Turk.

The Grand Master’s Day at West Point on October 17, 2015, was once again a huge success. Grand Master William J. Thomas, with most of the Grand Line, along with approximately 100 Brothers, their families and friends, were in attendance. Many thanks to the members of Pelham Lodge of the Bronx District and Harry S Truman Lodge of the Eighth Manhattan District who prepared the delicious food that was served to the Grand Master and the Grand Line. Everyone enjoyed great fellowship and good food at the numerous tailgate parties. Thanks also go to the Districts, their respective District Deputy Grand Masters, and Grand Lodge Staff Officers, as well as to the Brothers and their families who attended. A very special thanks to Event Chairman, R∴W∴Charles Catapano, Grand Treasurer, for coordinating this very successful event.

Committee Member and Downstate Golf Chairman R∴W∴Walter J. Wasnieski III organized and chaired a Masonic Care Community Day Event, a New York Islanders Hockey Game, held on March 28, 2015 at the Nassau Coliseum. There were 100 Brothers, families and friends in attendance. The event was a success and $2,000.00 were raised for Camp Turk.

In closing, as I have done in the past, if re-appointed Committee State Chairman, I will send letters to the District Deputy Grand Masters, introducing myself and informing them of their respective Area Chairmen along with suggested activities which may be of interest to the Lodges within their districts. I will also request the District Deputy Grand Masters provide me and their respective Area Chairman with the names and contact information of their Appointed District Chairman. It is my hope that this proactive approach will continue to increase Masonic fellowship activities throughout the state of New York.

I wish to thank all District Deputy Grand Masters and District

30

Fellowship Committee Chairmen for their hard work in promoting Masonic Fellowship within their Lodges and Districts.

I also wish to extend my sincere thanks to Committee members R∴W∴Charles Catapano, Vice-Chairman, R∴W∴Louis H. Juers, Vice Chairman, R∴W∴Gerald R. Dievendorf, Bowling Chairman, Brother Joseph Ottati, Fresh Water Fishing Chairman, Brother Richard J. Arthur, Upstate Golf Chairman, R∴W∴Walter J. Wasnieski III, Downstate Golf Chairman, R∴W∴Mark K. Suckle, Downstate Golf Co-Chairman, R∴W∴Angel Ruiz, Downstate Golf Co-Chairman, R∴W∴Richard L. Giordano, Downstate Golf Co-Chairman, and W∴Marshal D. Shichtman, Downstate Golf Co-Chairman.

Respectfully submitted by,Joseph N. maNDel, State Chairman

charles catapaNo, GT, Vice Chairmanlouis h. Juers, PGT, Vice Chairman

GeralD r. DieveNDorf, Bowling ChairmanJoseph h. ottati, Fresh Water Fishing ChairmanricharD J. arthur, Golf Tournament (Upstate)

richarD l. GiorDaNo, Golf Tournament (Downstate)aNGel ruiz, Golf Tournament (Downstate)

marshal D. shichtmaN, Golf Tournament (Downstate)marK K. sucKle, Golf Tournament (Downstate)

Walter J. WasNiesKi iii, Golf Tournament (Downstate)charles catapaNo, GT, Grand Master’s Day at West Point Chairman

JohN N. loWe, Salt Water Fishing Chairman

COMMITTEE ON MASONIC HALL TOURSTo the Grand Lodge:

The Masonic Hall Tours Committee is responsible for providing tours to guests of our headquarters in New York City. Home to approximately 72 Lodges from throughout the metropolitan area, Masonic Hall attracts visitors from all over the world ... Masons and non-Masons, men and women, young and old ... to view its 11 beautiful Lodge rooms, including the Grand Lodge room.

In 2015, the Committee, consisting of its 9 volunteer guides, provided tours to approximately 4,000 visitors. The approximate breakdown on the number of visitors, according to place of residence is as follows:

Visitor origins top 5 Visiting Countries:New York City: 698 France 188Other New York State: 189 Brazil 186USA (outside NYS): 680 England 178International: 870 Italy 74 Total: 2,437 Scotland 68

In October 2015, Open House New York [OHNY] once again had Masonic Hall as one of the locations to visit in New York City. Many of

31

the “open” locations publicized by OHNY are open to the public in any case. Others are open only during OHNY weekend. Although Masonic Hall provides tours 6 days a week in its normal course, the publicity afforded by OHNY results in a much higher volume than normal over a single weekend. Tours of the individual rooms were provided by Committee members while OHNY provided volunteers who handled crowd control support.

2015 opeN house NeW yorK (october 17th & 18th) Visitors: 1,550

Grand Total: 3,987Respectfully submitted,

Gilbert c. ferrer, ChairmanarmaND cosQuer JoNathaN forDham michael livschitzDeNNis a. DauGherty viNceNt s. Giambalvo martiN WatteNberG KeNNeth J. GiNN

William h. sohNi, Emeritus

MEMBERSHIP DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEETo the Grand Lodge:

Continuing with its important and critical mission, the Membership Development Committee has focused its efforts on two distinct levels. The first deals with the entire process and philosophy how our Lodges acquire new members, and the second is how our Lodges keep the new Master Masons fully satisfied and engaged as life-long participating members of the Lodge.

With the permission of the Grand Master, the committee was enabled to launch its new initiative called the NorthStar Project. This is a comprehensive, structured system that takes a prospective member (accompanied by his Success Coach) through a series of meetings and social events designed in a way that a prospect can truly see if the Masonic Fraternity is a good fit for him. It also lets the Lodge membership see if the new prospect will fit into their existing culture as well! Our guiding maxim is: “Make him a friend first, a Mason second!” The new District Deputy Grand Masters have been charged to appoint a District Umbrella Chair in their respective Districts and two Success Coaches for each Lodge to ensure its success. To date, we have trained approximately 425 new Success Coaches, as of this report, with many more waiting for upcoming state-wide, regional seminars. Training dates will be posted in Hiram’s Highlights and the Atholl1781 Newsletter when arrangements are organized.

Our New York Grand Lodge website referral system was successfully launched this year. When a prospect fills out the form on the website, it electronically is sent to R∴W∴Joseph A. Passaretti II who sends it to the appropriate District Deputy Grand Master with the proviso that the referral is transmitted to a vibrant Lodge located within his District. To date, we have referred 645 prospective leads to the DDGMs and another

_____

32

277 prospective members to sister jurisdictions. It is our intent that future prospective members will automatically be processed through the new NorthStar software, and electronically sent to the Lodge Success Coaches.

Our special thanks is extended to the Committee members who worked very diligently on the creation of the NorthStar training syllabus, software, power points and training seminars. You truly are good and faithful workmen laboring in the quarries of Masonry!

We also discovered an alarming fact that a large percentage of Lodges do not use the Lodge System of Masonic Education, LSOME, or have not even heard of its existence. The 2016-2018 Grand Lodge Staff Officers have been charged with the responsibility to ensure that every Lodge in this jurisdiction is properly using the LSOME system including the DVDs, and the five-part booklets. The District Deputy Grand Master in each District has been charged with the overall responsibility to ensure its implementation in each Lodge.

The records of May 2015 disclose the fact that we raised 1044 Master Masons and unaffiliated another 1187 members for non-payment of dues. The unofficial summary for the current year reveals that we raised approximately 969 Master Masons and again unaffiliated another 1057 members for non-payment of dues. Our actual membership as of this report currently stands at 36,822 Members. (Subtract 1,575 dual members totaling 35,247) Based on current projections we will be at 30,000 members by 2020. We simply cannot ignore the membership retention issue! It’s a responsibility of every member to make sure the new members feel they belong to a great Lodge that truly practices the tenants of our Craft.

Fraternally Submitted,Jeffrey m. WilliamsoN, Chairman

Joseph a. passaretti ii, Co-Chairman

DaNiel J. DiNatale Nicholas D. lettiere michael J. sieGelalfreD W. ferGersoN aNDreW o. roberts michael e. storcKricharD c. frieDmaN raymoND roche Walter J. WasNiesKi iiiReferrals from the Grand Lodge website as of 9/24/2015

654 Total Referrals sent to the District Deputy Grand Masters 277 Replied to or referred to other Jurisdictions 931 Total Requests Answered

District Name Total Referrals District Name Total Referrals

ALBANY 11 FOURTH MANHATTAN 29 ALLEGANY 0 FIFTH MANHATTAN 29BRONX 57 SIXTH MANHATTAN 0BROOME-CHENANGO 4 SEVENTH MANHATTAN 27CATTARAUGUS 3 EIGHTH MANHATTAN 27CAYUGA-TOMPKINS 14 NINTH MANHATTAN 13CHAUTAUQUA 3 TENTH MANHATTAN 7

33

CHEMUNG-SCHUYLER-TIOGA 2 MONROE 11CLINTON 1 SECOND NASSAU 27COLUMBIA 1 NIAGARA-ORLEANS 6CORTLAND-MADISON 2 FIRST ONEIDA 2DELAWARE 1 SECOND ONEIDA 1DUTCHESS 5 ONONDAGA 3FIRST ERIE 8 ONTARIO-SENECA-YATES 3SECOND ERIE 8 ORANGE-ROCKLAND 9ESSEX 0 OSWEGO 2FRANKLIN-HAMILTON 1 OTSEGO-SCHOHARIE 2FULTON-MONTGOMERY 0 QUEENS 73 GENESEE-WYOMING 0 RENSSELAER-SCHENECTADY 8GREENE-ULSTER 2 RICHMOND 18HERKIMER 1 FIRST ST. LAWRENCE 0JEFFERSON 2 SECOND ST. LAWRENCE 0JEFFERSON-LEWIS 1 SARATOGA-WARREN 2FIRST KINGS 28 STEUBEN 1SECOND KINGS 67 SUFFOLK 33THIRD KINGS 27 SULLIVAN 1LIVINGSTON 2 WAYNE 1FIRST MANHATTAN 30 FIRST WESTCHESTER-PUTNAM 11SECOND MANHATTAN 17 SECOND WESTCHESTER-PUTNAM 10 Total State Wide 654

committee oN military outreachTo the Grand Lodge:

Mission Statement and Scope of ProjectIn an ever-expanding endeavor to present a working relationship

with those who proudly serve, and have served, our great nation - The United States of America, The Military Outreach Committee of the Grand Lodge of the State of New York and its programs strive to both maintain and make new inroads into the lives and needs of these selfless military individuals and their families for the service and sacrifice that the principles of their duties enjoin.

The Military Outreach program is designed to be interactive with the growth and commitment necessary to executing its mission statement. There currently exist many non-Masonic operations which strive to supply broad financial support. While this will always be necessary, the Military Outreach Committee believes that personal interaction is necessary to promulgate true involvement with the military community. The history of our Grand Lodge through the years has been punctuated with a number of worthy military support related programs, from the foundation of veteran relief groups, Charity Balls held for returning veterans, the Masonic War Chest donations from the Second World War, hospital visitations, sending relief packages overseas through all conflicts, etc. These were all met with great success, and exemplified the patriotism we as Masons take great pride in.

34

In the present day, various conflicts continue to escalate across the globe and our deploying servicemen and women, and their families, need our support more than ever. Our Grand Lodge has always set aside funding for programs of this nature, but it is time to take on our commitments as citizens and Masons on a Lodge and District basis. To give a brief outline of the intentions- there are no prerequisites. No membership in an underlying group is necessary, nor is this gender specific. It is encouraged that you involve your wives, children, friends, or others who would desire involvement.

There are three groups that we are currently focusing on:*our Active Duty Soldiers*our VA Hospital residents*our Veterans

ACTIVE DUTYAs the deployments and homecomings of our military personnel continue,

there are many events that we can assist in. There are currently a number of military units assigned from New York. These are spread out over a great distance. Through the support of the Committeemen, we are asking each District to “adopt” a military unit which is either being deployed, or is currently deployed. Each of these units already has an internal support group known as an FRG (Family Readiness Group) in place which oversees deployment and return ceremonies, holiday parties, and picnics, etc., providing morale and support to its members and families. These FRG’s are currently required to provide their own funding for the families at these events and are under strict guidelines as to how the funding is raised as well as provide for the necessary labor required to hold these events. In conjunction with director of each FRG, each District would participate in one or more of the following:

(A) Assist in the fund raising aspects of these events as a District, so that all family members and friends of these units may attend. The financial outlay is minimized when spread out across the Lodges involved in the District, and is, in many cases, difficult for the FRG to obtain on its own.

(B) Assist in the labor involved of setting up and breaking down of these events as well as the serving or cooking of food. This gives the military personnel attending the ability to spend more time at these venues with those they love instead of either waiting for them to finish working the event, or participating in the labor themselves. This requires nothing more than the volunteering of your time at events for those who give and serve us on a daily basis.

(C) Set up and execute programs for donation “care packages” from each District to be sent to the units at various times throughout the year. The needs of those deployed are specific to their locations and what has already been sent. This allows for the requests from the units themselves to be met versus a “blanket” policy of sending generic articles.

(D) District Military Outreach Chairmen would keep contact with various personnel of the “adopted” unit throughout the year via

35

email to follow up on news and needs of the individuals. This allows for personal interaction and the exchange of ideas from the unit to the District. Getting to know personalities and associating a name with a face is vastly more rewarding and beneficial than nameless statements and donations from unknown sources.

VA HOSPITAL & NYS VETERANS HOMESThere are numerous New York State Veterans’ Homes and VA

(Veteran Affairs) Hospitals operating across the state of New York. The veterans who are residing in these facilities are in need of interaction with the outside world, which they seldom receive with any regularity. Some are there for physical service related disabilities, but none have returned from their service without some sort of scarring, physical or otherwise. These veterans show a deep commitment to each other as well as a continuing commitment and patriotism to the principles of our great nation which they proudly served.

(A) The incorporation of VA Hospital visitations is not new and they have always been popular events. Keep in mind that when your event is over, you will go home to your life and the outside world. The residents will not, but outside of their interaction with you, they will go back to the day-to day-regimen within those walls. Your participation changes their outlook for the day and brings them a hope of continuation.

(B) District related events: Districts can employ a program of Veteran Appreciation Day at their local VA Hospital. How better to share the appreciation with Masonic-related veterans than to include their fellow servicemen and women with whom they have common experiences? These can be incorporated with gift donations in the way of clothing and personal articles, as in the case of care packages where appropriate.

(C) Districts can host various holiday parties, breakfasts, and brunches, etc. This brings not only an opportunity to enjoy fellowship with our veterans but also the continuation of established relations as the events continue.

(D) Recreation room donations: Many VA Hospitals have Recreation rooms for the residents. These “Rec Rooms” are frequently in need of donation of books, puzzles, and board games, etc. for the residents to enjoy.

(E) “Commissary Cards” are of frequent use to the residents. These are inexpensive books of tickets or cards which can be redeemed for purchases at the store on premises for personal articles. Districts can contact the Veteran Affairs Supervisor for purchase and distribution of these cards.

VETERANS in our CommunitiesFrom WWII, The Korean War and The Vietnam War, to our current Iraq

and Afghanistan Veterans, we must always be prepared to help and support them all, in any way we can.

Whether it’s helping a Veteran navigate through the maze of VA regulations they might be dealing with to working with your local officials to help a Homeless Veteran find an Apartment, there are many who could use the help.

36

We encourage our Brethren to reach out to the Veterans, invite them to events or even to help out at an upcoming VA event .

These programs are not limited in their design, but may be adjusted to the needs of the circumstances and situations to better promote personal involvement and interaction with those we wish to assist. Thinking “outside of the box” works and has currently been employed by several Districts around this Grand Jurisdiction. Many people this year and beyond will send financial donations and be content that they have provided a valuable service and done their duty. If you really want to help these patriots, get to know them, form friendships, ties, and understandings that last beyond the balance of a checking account. Show the world the commitment that Masons have to their Craft and country.

We were on the move in 2015. Here’s a brief overview:

- We started off by providing Volunteers and a Continental Breakfast for the Military Inter-Faith breakfast service held at Camp Smith in Cortlandt Manor.

- Our “Hearing Aides for the VA” program has been a huge success and to date, has provided over 150 Hearing aides to the Castle Point and Montrose VA Facilities.

- During the year, we have also supported Breakfasts held at the VA for their full-time residents.

- Our annual VA Barbecue was again held at George’s Island (next to the Montrose VA).

- A Combat Engineer unit from Kingston held their Family Barbecue with the full support of the District.

- Over 40 Veterans were bused in from the VA to a local Baseball game.- A full display of Military artifacts, including the evolution of

the Infantry Rifle, was provided to the West Point Combat Infantry Association’s Annual Ball.

- We’d also like to congratulate the Second Westchester-Putnam District for holding their first Annual Military Outreach Golf Outing.

- In December, Masons from eight different Districts provided Holiday Meals for the Soldiers' families and children. The parties were held in Whitestone, Peekskill and New Windsor.

- We finished the year by packing and shipped 32 boxes of donations to Soldiers serving in Afghanistan.

My Brothers, it is important to know that all of these events and many more held in our State were made possible through the donations and dedication that you, our Lodges and Districts, have made. We would like to thank the Most Worshipful William J. Thomas for his unwavering support for our Veterans and the Masonic Military Outreach Program. We look forward to expanding our Military Outreach program even further in 2016, and thank all of the Volunteers who made these events possible.

Fraternally submitted,michael J. peters, Chairman

marK D. haNsoN, Vice ChairmanraymoND G. barber DoNalD c. mariNo alfoNso serraNo

37

roy a. bilby James masKiell GeorGe sialmashoWarD e. boNsaiNG William l. mayers DouGlas h. storeyDeNNis a. breheNy peter c. pizzorNo DeNNis m. turtoN, sr.DaviD p. craWforD JohN p. roWaN charles p. uhle, PJGWrobert m. Getschel myroN e. roWe eDWarD D. Walther ivlaWreNce e. hooD thomas r. saWyer JacK D. WeismaNalleN c. laNG e. William WhittaKer

committee ON NECROLOGYTo the Grand Lodge:

Grace to you and peace to you.Brethren, I greet you from the Grand and Supreme Architect of the Universe.We have been favored to stand today to solemnly give tribute to the memory

of our Right Worshipful Brothers who have laid aside their working tools of this life, and entered into the realm of spirit, where death no longer reigns. So, let us look beyond the sadness of this moment to the light and hope of tomorrow. Fill us then with the power and comfort of Thy presence, that we may say with assurance, as Job of old in his grief, "The Lord give, and the Lord has taken away, blessed be the name of the Lord.” Amen.

The Short service includes the lighting a solitary candle to symbolize the light of each departed brother.

These are our Right Worshipful Brothers from 2015 whom we remember this day:

Harry F. Anderson □ 839NY Edmund Kolb, Jr. □ 2NYPerry Anderson, Jr. □ 684NY Virgil T. Kranking □ 551NYThomas A. Barbour □ 435NY Irwin J. Kukafka □ 1037NYBurton A. Barrenger, Jr. □ 32NY; □ 875NY Gasper La Fata □ 1130NYGeorge H. Beers □ 1185NY David McDonald Lantz □ 1138NYLe Roy T. Bennett □ 975NY Melvin H. Levy □ 948NY; □ 1175NYRaymond Smith Blanchard □ 3NY Alan C. Lewis □ 85NY; □ 400NYArthur Blanden □ 529NY Eric Lindholm □ 250NYAllan Boudreau □ 287NY Ralph D. Locke □ 965NYDavid Aladar Brown □ 1016NY Ruel R. Lovett □ 837NYClinton C. Capron □ 165NY William Lovinger □ 922NYRichard A. Carlsen □ 956NY Robert E. MacPherson □ 1179NYRoger M. Clary □ 383NY Milton E. Marsh □ 226NYJohn Wilson Currie □ 799NY Charles V. McMains □ 178NYPaul A. Dionisio □ 542NY; □ 634NY James H. Merritt □ 580NYGeorge Dondero, Jr. □ 1066NY Richard Meshejian □ 588NY; □ 727NYThomas P. Donnelly □ 471NY; □ 1130NY Edward L. Meyers □ 1185NYPaul A. Draghi □ 651NY Richard V. Miller □ 863NYEugene P. Dreyer □284NY; □403NY; □483NY; □511NY George F. Mulkins □ 167NY

38

Carl H. Faust □ 1134NY Gerald P. Oliver □ 1198NYBenjamin Fein □ 598NY Michael L. Palazzo □ 266NYWilliam "Bill" C. Feingold □ 1066NY Leroy W. Pomeroy, Jr. □ 129NYPeter A. Fershtman □1009NY; □1057NY Francis Edward Powley □336NY; □392NYJerry Festa □ 813NY Irving Reiter □ 284NYLouis R. Fish □ 177NY David Ernest Rodler □ 240NYAlton H. Fisher □ 393NY Charles A. Root, Jr. □ 118NYDavid Flores □ 250NY Leland F. Sanford □ 399NYEugene W. Fuller □ 521NY Bernard L. Schachter □ 1174NYGaddiel C. Gallardo □ 516NY; □ 1172NY Wayne Elmer Schlifke □ 879NYVito Jack Getti, Jr. □ 224NY Alexander Eli Selikoff □ 46NY; □ 712NYHans Jon Gideon □ 968NY Jules E. Shayo □ 266NY; □ 782NYEdward Giesler □ 776NY Floyd A. Sheldon □ 1180NYG. Thomas Grape □ 109NY; □ 479NY Stuart W. Shulenburg □ 796NYPaul H. Gross, Jr. □ 458NY D. Robert Slocum □ 145NY; □ 219NYHarold J. Gundelach □ 389NY; □ 439NY Harry R. Snyder, Jr. □ 175NY; □ 21RIHarold H. Halper □ 934NY Edmund Richard Stuven □ 557NYWalter F. Hastings □ 378NY Eric S. Tinney □ 1180NYLeonard Helmprecht □ 740NY Harold E. Turner □ 975NYFrederick W. Hennings □ 368NY Frank C. Van Gelder □ 112NYGeorge Herron □ 701NY Charles W. Vandermosten □ 956NYIrwin Hirshon □ 890NY Philip R. Vidal-Chevalier □ 387NYCharles W. Hobbs □ 782NY Thomas E. Warren □ 521NYRichard Hudec □ 31NY John O. Webster □ 121NYJames J. Hunsinger □ 126NY William J. Weismantel □ 255NYRussell L. Hurlburt □ 543NY Richard F. Westcot □ 501NYCharles D. Hurley □ 1166NY Norman E. Whitaker □ 193NY; □ 1174NYOmar Karom □ 1126NY Clark G. White, Jr. □ 1179Robert W. Kidd □ 627NY George Norris Wineberg □ 796NYRobert J. Koehler □ 838NY

The great Creator, having been pleased, out of His infinite mercy, to remove our Brothers from the cares and troubles of this transitory existence to a state of endless duration, thus severing another link from the fraternal chain that binds us together, may we who survive them be more strongly cemented in the ties of union and friendship; that, during the short space allotted us here, we may wisely and usefully employ our time and, in the reciprocal intercourse of kind and friendly acts, mutually promote the welfare and happiness of each other.

The solitary candle will be extinguished to symbolize the transition from life to life.

Respectfully submitted,steNricK b. aDams, Chairman

marK D. isaacs roNalD J. reiD José l. valeNcia, Jr.WaiNriGht G. f. mcKeNzie, sr. KeNNeth e. WaGNer, PGStB

39

observaNt masoNry committeeTo the Grand Lodge:

At the beginning of his term, in establishing the Observant Masonry Committee, the Grand Master expressed his desire to see as many Lodges as possible becoming ‘Observant’ according to the New York definition. He reflected that, given the requirements, every Lodge in the State should either be Observant or striving to become Observant. New York has taken a different tack from the manner in which the term is used abroad in other States. In New York, it is less a reflection of a desire to be elitist, and more a reflection of pride in what one does and what one belongs to.

The Ritual Renaissance Program and the NorthStar Project initiatives provide most of the building blocks to becoming a vibrant Lodge, one which Brethren would want to attend regularly and one which prospective members would be proud to join. Surely these are the very foundations upon which an Observant Lodge is built!

This year has seen a large number of inquiries for information. And yet, we will not be handing out any Certifications. Why is this? Preparing to become Observant is not an overnight activity. Whether the Brethren of an ailing Lodge are seeking to reground it in a stronger foundation to guarantee its survival, or the aim is to create a new Lodge from the ground up, both approaches take time. This is a long-term project, just like the others developed to enhance Masonic Ritual, education, mentorship and other key aspects of Lodge life. We should celebrate our successes: to gain two new Observant Lodges – Harmonie Lodge No. 699 and Seneca River Lodge No. 160 – within two years is a victory for the Masonic experience, and stands up well against the experience of other States.

As I traveled around New York and visited a number of Lodges where the members are striving to make their Lodge experience something which provokes excitement, and whose meetings provide food for conversation long after the closing gavel has sounded, I have realized that, while the several initiatives which we are pursuing to enhance the Lodge experience all contribute to that goal, Observant Masonry is the thread which ties them all together to create a whole

I commend those Lodges and, in particular, those Masters who are striving to raise the level of Masonic Ritual and instruction in their Lodges, and who encourage their members – and visitors – to aim for a higher standard.

Respectfully submitted,richarD J. poWell piers a. vauGhaN, Chairman

reDistrictiNG committeeTo the Grand Lodge:

During the Deputy Grand Master Town Hall Meetings we thoroughly discussed the reshaping and consolidating process. We reminded everyone that Districts are merely administrative boundaries set up for that purpose- they do not impact Lodge life or the Masonic experience!

At the beginning of Grand Master Thomas’ term, we started with 60 Masonic Districts with a membership base of 37,750 members. Responding to our request, several Districts has already begun the Redistricting/

40

Reshaping process. Note: Our actual membership as of this report currently stands at 36,822 Members.

The following 14 Districts are in the process of consolidating: First and Sixth Manhattan, First and Second Nassau, First and Second Oneida, Clinton and Essex, Saratoga-Warren and Washington, 1st St. Lawrence and 2nd St. Lawrence, Albany and Rensselaer- Schenectady. This initial effort is a great start and represents an approximate 10 percent reduction in the quantity our Districts.

Several other Districts are actively negotiating with adjoining Districts to find the best fit for the Lodges in their Districts. Our goal is to continue this process over the next few years. By consolidating our Masonic leadership resources, we will ultimately strengthen our Lodges. Remember: A flowering shrub will come back with even more vigor when actively pruned!

We have also appointed each of the new District Deputy Grand Masters to be a member of the new Redistricting Committee as well. Sentimentality towards the “way things were in the past” and personal piques and grudges against individual Brothers must be shaken off for the greater good of our fraternity. We appreciate all of our Brethren’s efforts in making this a true reality.

Fraternally,Jeffrey m. WilliamsoN, Deputy Grand Master

COMMITTEE ON RESTORATIONSTo the Grand Lodge:

Two individuals have petitioned to be restored to the Rights and Privileges of Masonry during the year 2015.

R∴W∴Edward M. Gundersen, who had been a member of St. Patrick’s Lodge No. 4, was Expelled from the Fraternity on March 11, 2003 following a Masonic Trial to consider his convictions for several Class A felonies. On or about December 8, 2014, he had petitioned St. Patrick’s Lodge No. 4 for Restoration; however the Lodge balloted unanimously to deny his Petition, that vote having taken place on January 15, 2015. Due report of same was made to this Committee.

W∴A. William Bodine, who had been a member of Humanitas Lodge, No. 1123, was originally Suspended for two years, such Suspension to be lifted by a favorable ballot of the Lodge, he having been found guilty of the charges brought against him. Humanitas Lodge had not and did not ballot on lifting the Suspension, and consequently, on December 5, 2008, he was Expelled from the Rights and Privileges of Masonry with effect from October 18, 2006. On or about May 1, 2009, Mr. Bodine petitioned the Grand Lodge for Restoration. Humanitas Lodge reported then that it had not and would not ballot on his petition for Restoration. On or about November 3, 2015, Mr. Bodine again petitioned the Grand Lodge for Restoration. The Worshipful Master of Humanitas Lodge No. 1123 reported on December 15, 2015 that the Lodge had not and would not take any action on the petition for Restoration of Mr. Bodine.

Upon reviewing the facts in each case, the materials supplied by the Grand Lodge, the actions of St. Patrick’s Lodge No. 4, the non-actions of Humanitas Lodge No. 1123, and considering the impact of these matters upon the

41

integrity and reputation of the Masonic Fraternity, it is the recommendation of the Committee on Restorations that both Mr. Gundersen and Mr. Bodine not be restored to the Rights and Privileges of Masonry.

The Committee is grateful for the opportunity to serve our Brethren and the Grand Lodge.

Respectfully submitted,GeorGe D. emmoNs, Chairman

DouGlas W. aDams Joseph roDriGuez richarD W. spriNGerJoseph a. passaretti ii alaN m. schlesiNGer robert e. Welsh, Jr.virGilio s. QuiJaNo Joseph a. zimmermaN

ritual reNaissaNce committeeDear Brothers,

It has been my pleasure to once again be named as Chairman of the Ritual Renaissance Committee. This Committee was created to assist the Ritual Director in each Lodge, a Brother appointed by the Worshipful Master, to assist in the performance of the Masonic Ritual. In Year 4, we strived to give insight into the First Degree Historical Lecture by breaking it down into six speaking parts, as well as providing performance tips and meanings. We have taken a look at both First Degree Charges and have done the same. We will be producing a new Year 4 CD with new instructions on how to use it best. What our Committee would ask from everyone is their feedback on our Orientations and what they would like to see from us.

The overall success of this program comes from everyone participating in doing what they need to do to improve the Masonic Ritual in our State. We could not exist if it were not for the generosity and support from our Lodges and other Masonic Bodies who have donated the use of their buildings for our Orientations! This is indeed Brotherly Love at its Finest!

Our Committee would like to thank our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, and our Deputy Grand Master, R∴W∴Jeffrey M. Williamson, for their unwavering support. We also thank the Office of the Grand Secretary for their invaluable help. But the real thanks goes out to the many Brothers who have donated their time and talents to our project.

Fraternally,steWart c. mcclouD ii, Chairman

richarD m. torrey, Vice-Chairman

praveeN K. aNumolu, New York City William b. fiNK, Jr., Albany James a. cobb, Plattsburgh steveN J. Joyce, OleanDaNiel J. DiNatale, Buffalo charles e. KNapp, Jr., Binghamton William J. eDWarDs, Rochester michael J. miller, Syracuse

surviviNG spouse aND loveD oNes committeeDear Brothers of Grand Lodge,

There have been fewer requests this past year for the Pins and Cards to be presented to our Surviving Spouses and Loved Ones. Are these Ladies being overlooked?

The Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home are providing these beautiful Pins and Cards, free of charge, to any Lodge which requests them.

42

The Lodge Chairman, or Secretary, when requesting pins and wallet cards for distribution by your Lodge, can do so by contacting:

William C. Jones2049 State Route 350

Macedon, NY 14502-9147(H) (315) 986-9150(C) (585) 489-6027

[email protected] 13 of the Surviving Spouse and Loved Ones Packet (the order form)

must accompany the request. If you have more than 1 request, a list of the same information may be included on the back. I will do my best to send your pins and cards within one day.

I would ask all Lodges to include our Brothers who have lost their wives to be invited to any function you hold for the Surviving Spouses. He is a Surviving Spouse, and that was the original intent of the program, as his wife supported and encouraged him in his Masonic endeavors. A Brother who loses his wife hurts just as much as the Lady who loses her husband, but we as men, are too proud to admit it. Naturally, he won’t receive a pin and card, but keep him in your Lodge's thoughts as well.

Should any Lodge Secretary or Master need a copy of this program, please contact me and I will gladly send you the complete packet. If you have e-mail, I will send it electronically, either in Word or PDF.

Respectfully submitted,William c. JoNes, Chairman

Regional Advisorsalbert W. hoffmaN, Western Region Advisor

Gary h. Kall, Central Region Advisor charles Krotz, Hudson-Champlain Region Advisor

lleWellyN a. Williams, Metropolitan Region Co-Advisor

COMMITTEE ON TECHNOLOGYTo the Grand Lodge:

Under direction and encouragement of our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, together with the overwhelming support of the Grand Secretary, R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen and his Office, I am proud to say that we have continued the advancement of our technology towards the 21st century and beyond, with the continuing standardizations of technology and the constant comparing of vendors services, the Technology Committee has been able to keep expenses for projects down to a minimum. This allows the Technology Committee to not only stay within budget but, for 8 consecutive years now, to save Grand Lodge thousands of dollars in yearly services.

Over the last couple of years, I have been honored to report to this Grand Lodge the implantation of several new advancements: the Wi-Fi system in each of the Lodge rooms; the TV systems in the Grand Lodge room, the upgrading and maintaining of New Computers in the Grand Secretary’s office and Finance Department; and, last but not least, everyone's favorite, the Electronic Voting System (which will be used extensively this 2016 election year.)

43

This year, I am proud to say that the Technology Committee has been working closely with the Membership Development Committee to help implement the R∴W∴Jeffrey M. Williamson’s project for his term as Grand Master, the NorthStar Project. This software is a bold new step in helping to keep track of potential and new candidates to help make our Fraternity grow.

This past year has also been a maintenance year with some growth. We are in the middle of upgrading our servers and our Internet speed to be better enabled to handle the traffic for the Grand Secretary’s Office as well as internet traffic.

Following along the same lines, and working with the Board of Trustees of the Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library, of which I am also a Trustee, we have finished digitizing the Lodge Historical Folders and have stored them on a new searchable server, allowing the Library to store more files and reduce our physical footprint as well as allow for more access for more of our Brothers. The Library's report will go into more detail of this.

I have been working with the Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home in upgrading the speed of our Internet service and have added more bandwidth as well as a sound system and projection in the newly renovated rooms. This will allow Grand Lodge and the Trustees to provide more and current services to our members and potential rentals.

Projects planned for the upcoming year.1. We are still in the process of converting all VHS and audio

cassettes tapes of past events and Grand Lodge Sessions into digital format for preservation and mass viewing.

2. We will continue to Digitize more content, so we will be upgrading the Grand Lodge Servers to allow space and traffic for the new digital files.

3. We will be working on internet services as well as updating the Wi-Fi in the Lodge rooms

Technology is a living, breathing entity, ever-growing, changing and evolving, and we need to stay abreast of that, as well as grow and evolve, if we wish to continue to move forward into the future and not get left behind.

I wish to thank the Grand Master and the Members of the Grand Lodge for all their support and faith and for allowing me to serve this Grand Jurisdiction. I would also like to thank all the Brothers who have volunteered their time and effort on this Committee.

Respectfully Submitted,eDWarD a. chiaNi, Chairman

clifforD t. Jacobs marloN thomas

COMMITTEE ON YOUTHTo The Grand Lodge,

This report is submitted to the Grand Lodge from the entire Committee on Youth, the individual names appearing at the end of this report.

Realizing the importance of Youth as the future of the Fraternity, it is our goal to assist Lodges and their members in the development and growth of

44

programs that provide and promote Youth activities in all communities in New York State. Our mission is to lead the Masonic Fraternity in providing services on behalf of young people, and training for adults who work for the betterment of youth.

The Grand Lodge of the State of New York is working to enhance the programs of the Masonic Youth groups, and supports initiatives to keep children safe from violence, abuse, and exploitation, and to provide specialized education for adults who offer leadership to youth in New York State. Each Lodge and District is encouraged to support youth activities in its community, whether Masonic or not. We must support our own Masonic Youth Organizations, advising our eligible youths on all Grand Lodge Programs available to them, such as Camp Turk and Scholarship Assistance, while also providing worthwhile and wholesome activities for all to engage in. Through the many recognition programs in place in the Grand Lodge of New York, we are able to recognize publicly, by way of award, good works done for the sake of doing good.

Frank M. Totton Essay ContestThe Fifth Manhattan District Association Endowment Fund, Inc.

once again supported the Frank M. Totton Essay Contest. A first prize of $1,500.00, along with ten other cash prize winners, was awarded. We join with all concerned in thanking the Fifth Manhattan District Association Endowment Fund, Inc., for their generosity and support.

This year’s topic was, “Civility, What Is It, and Why Is It Important in Our Lives?”

Winners of the Frank M. Totton Essay Contest are as follows:Placement and Name Sponsoring Lodge District

1st Zachary Eric Williams Rising Sun No. 103 Saratoga Warren2nd Miranda Cintron Garibaldi No. 542 Tenth Manhattan 3rd Jan Nicolas Teng Columbian No. 484 Fourth Manhattan4th Samantha Miller Auburn No. 124 Cayuga-Tompkins5th Grace Caradori Drumlin Square No. 1180 Wayne6th Cara Roberts Jerusalem Temple No. 721 Orange-Rockland7th Kole Brink Carroll No. 1147 Chautaugua8th Nicholas Rice Wantagh Morton No. 63 First Nassau9th Shannon Frear Unity No. 479 Monroe10th Jordyn Harris Service City-Geba No. 1009 QueensTie Emily Veeck Old Town No. 908 Suffolk

Honorable-mention winners will be announced at Grand Lodge Session. All those who served on the Committee are to be commended for their attention to detail, and for the fine performance of reading and grading the essays.

The Daniel Carter Beard Masonic Scouter Award - A National recognition approved by the Boy Scouts of America to recognize outstanding service to the youth of our communities through service connected with the Scouting movement. A beautiful bronze medallion with a unique, purple and gold “square-knot” patch accompanies the certificate with a personal letter of congratulations from our Grand

45

Master. For qualified Masons only. Seven recognitions have been received by worthy Brothers throughout New York State during the present year. One Hundred Eighty-Nine Brothers have been so-recognized in our Jurisdiction since inception.

General Douglas MacArthur Award for Exemplary Service to Youth - This year, there have been Five recognitions distributed throughout New York State. The award has been enhanced by incorporating a 2” bronze medallion in the likeness of General MacArthur, with pipe, which now accompanies the certificate, along with a personal letter of congratulations from the Grand Master. This recognition, for private, non-Masonic individuals or organizations, is for their good works having to do with the youth of our communities.

Eagle Scout Commendation - The Grand Lodge has offered, to those qualified as Eagle Scouts, a special commendation. Included is a personal letter of congratulations from our Grand Master, accompanied by a Boy Scout, nationally-approved bronze medallion. The medallion, with the Masonic Square and Compasses, along with the words “New York Masons” and “Citizenship” emblazoned on it, is most impressive. More than Fifteen Hundred Eagle Scouts have received the recognition in its new form. One Hundred Twenty-Five Eagles received their proper recognition this year.

Girl Scout Recognition “Gold Award” - The Masonic Girl Scout Gold Award was created eight years ago. It is a National Masonic Award program in conjunction with the Girl Scouts of the U.S.A., and is administered by the Grand Lodge of the State of New York as a service to all regular Grand Lodges of the United States. There are 236,000 troops and groups in more than 90 countries, and over 300 local Girl Scout Councils across the United States. The Girl Scout Gold Award is the highest award that a Girl Scout may earn in her career as a Girl Scout. A special pin of recognition created for this purpose, with the Girl Scout logo and the Masonic Square and Compasses, accompanies the certificate, along with a letter of congratulations from the appropriate Grand Master. This year, Seventy-Three young ladies were so recognized. To date, over Seven Hundred Ninety-Six young ladies have received this recognition.

In addition, this year, a closer relationship has been established between this Committee and the Blood and Organ Donor Sub-committee of the Community Service Committee of Grand Lodge. Through the good works of this Sub-committee's Chairman, W∴William J. Peist, Sr., many lives in New York will be potentially saved, Masonic and otherwise.

One Hundred Thirty-One organ donors have stepped forward, and over Fifteen Hundred pints of blood were donated. Each organ donor may save 8 lives. That means that more than One Thousand lives can be prolonged. Quite an accomplishment!

Our Committee thanks our Grand Master, Deputy Grand Master and Grand Secretary for their advice and assistance. I also thank the District Deputy Grand Masters and Grand Lodge Staff Officers as well as the members of this Committee for their feedback and suggestions. We also thank the Lodge Secretaries who have been in contact with our Committee in regards to various functions of the Committee. In the past three years, over Two Hundred Fifty Lodges have participated in the Frank M. Totton Essay

46

Contest and Eagle recognition program. I also must take this opportunity to thank the Lodge Services Department as well as Mr. David Cabral, Mrs. Jessica Cornejo and Ms. Bridget Primo, for their assistance in the performance of this Committee’s function.

There is still much to be done to achieve the goals of this Committee, and work is underway to achieve these goals. We are attempting to produce a Masonic Scholarship Resource Guide which will list scholarship, grant and loan opportunities primarily for Masons, their siblings, children, grandchildren, and members of the Masonic-related Youth Groups. We will continue to develop plans that will introduce more and more children, as well as their parents, to Masonry and its ideals of Friendship, Morality, Brotherly Love, and Charity.

Grand Master Nathan Turk often used this quote while serving as Chairman of this Committee: “Who mentors a boy by the Master’s plan shapes the course of the future man.” How true it is today, even more than ever before. We will take the Masonic principles and teachings into the hearts and minds of our young people.

The Committee wishes to thank M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master, for giving us the opportunity to serve our youth and our beloved Fraternity.

Respectfully submitted, cary s. cohN, Chairman

craiG heNDersoN d. 10/23/2015, Vice ChairmanerNest G. meNDler, Vice Chairman

DaviD r. barKsteDt lloyD N. DeaN lee D. roofeDWarD t. bartels James e. JoNes eric p. roseNmelviN J. birNbaum Javier a. ramirez briaN D. siNGer James c. ricKarD, iii

reports of other GraND loDGe uNits

commissioN of appealsTo the Grand Lodge:

The following Matters were heard:1) In the Matter of W∴Walter S. Cook III, the Trial Commission's Decision

was amended to Expulsion.2) In the Matter of Brother Michael H. Horowitz, the Trial Commission's

Decision of Suspension was affirmed.3) In the Matter of W∴Charles D. VanDeMark, the Trial Commission's

Decision was affirmed.4) In the Matter of Brother Fellowcraft Rahul Dev Manchanda, the Trial

Commission's Decision was affirmed.5) In the Matter of R∴W∴Carl F. Rymski III, the Trial Commission's

Decision of an additional seven (7) years Suspension is vacated.Fraternally yours,

Jeffrey W. halbreich, 2016, Chief Commissioner

47

hoWarD e. boNsaiNG, 2018 Joseph a. QuareQuio, 2018Joseph s. crociata, Jr., 2016 michael r. sieGel, 2017 Jay s. DaNKberG, 2017 albert r. trezza, 2017

MASONIC WAR VETERANSTo the Grand Lodge:

“Active Brotherhood andService to all Mankind”

This is the motto of the Masonic War Veterans. I am very happy to report that the Masonic War Veterans have been very active in fulfilling this pledge to our Masonic Fraternity, our fellow veterans and the community.

The Grand Post Masonic War Veterans has always been ready, willing and able to serve the Grand Master in the presentation of Colors at all Grand Lodge functions including the Grand Lodge Annual Convention, the Masonic Interfaith Breakfast and St. John's Day Weekend. In addition, we have provided a Color Guard for virtually every Concordant Body Convention or event where our Grand Master was in attendance. Our subordinate Posts have also provided this outstanding service to their District Deputy Grand Masters whenever called upon.

While these are all very important duties and commitments, the Masonic War Veterans are much more than wearing uniforms and carrying flags. Many of our Posts are known for the service work they perform in their communities as well as the considerable assistance given to our active duty military and veterans.

For many years, one of our Posts has sponsored a Patriotic Essay Contest for students in grades 6-12. This very worthwhile program has been very successful in promoting patriotism and love of Country among our youth.

A military lounge has been established at the airport in Rochester. Our local Masonic War Veterans Post was an active participant in this accomplishment. Due to the efforts of this Post and other Veterans Service Organizations, active duty military members now have a quiet and private place of their own to greet or depart from loved ones. A similar project is now underway at the Buffalo Niagara International Airport and is spearheaded by the Commander of the local Masonic War Veterans Post.

Several of our Posts have participated in and continue to assist in highway cleaning events in their city, town or county.

Many Posts have conducted Veterans Day Ceremonies in their Lodges and elsewhere in their community, and have contributed time and finances to the Marine Corps “Toys for Tots” program.

Posts throughout our state give great aid and support to veterans in our VA Hospitals and nursing homes. In addition to visitation and distribution of clothing and comfort items, dinners and entertainment events are offered. One of the most desired and appreciated things we can do is just spend time visiting and talking and letting these veterans know just how much we appreciate them and all they have done for us. This may be the most important thing we do. This is the true meaning of Brotherhood.

Time and space does not allow me to list all the success stories that have been

48

reported. The Officers and Directors of the Grand Post are very appreciative of all the good work that has been performed by our Posts on behalf of our Masonic Family. Many people have worked tirelessly to make these programs and events successful. Their efforts and hard work reflect well on our great Fraternity.

The Grand Post continues in its goal to have a Masonic War Veterans Post within every Masonic District in the state. Past Commander General and R∴W∴Dennis A. Breheny has traveled extensively in this regard, and has been very successful. Several new Posts have been chartered, and some of our Posts that had gone dark are being re-chartered. District Deputy Grand Masters who would like assistance in establishing a new or re-chartered Post in their District should contact the Grand Post.

This year, the Annual Convention of the Grand Post will be held on the weekend of May 13-14 at Salvatore’s Grand Hotel in Williamsville, NY. One of the highlights of this meeting is the awarding of the Masonic War Veterans Masonic Veteran of the Year. I am very pleased to announce that this year’s recipient is Brother Paul E. Rudnicki, Esq. Brother Rudnicki is well-known in the Western New York Community for his many years of service to our neediest Veterans. He is the founder and leading force in the raising of hundreds of thousands of dollars and countless tons of food for a local Veterans' food pantry. Recently, the facility was named the Captain Paul E. Rudnicki Food Pantry in his honor. He is an outstanding choice and is most deserving of this high honor. For further information about our Convention and all our activities, please visit our website at grandpostmwv.org.

In closing, I would like to say that this has been a very challenging as well as rewarding year for the Masonic War Veterans. Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, our Commander in Chief, has charged us with advancing the Grand Post into a new era where we will be able to function in a more business-like manner so that we may continue to provide valuable service to our veterans and our Grand Lodge. With his considerable leadership, encouragement and support, along with the efforts of my fellow Grand Post Officers, we are well on our way to achieving this objective.

Respectfully submitted,briaN e. Will, Commander General

William J. thomas, Grand Master, Commander-in-ChiefWilliam J. Welsh, First Lt. Commander General

DoNalD r. KuNeGo, Second Lt. Commander General JohN p. roWaN, Treasurer General

robert t. maNtia, Adjutant Generalcarl hoyt, sr., State Director

richarD J. trescott, State DirectorDeNNis a. breheNy, Assistant Treasurer General

DeNNis m. turtoN, sr., PCG, Assistant Adjutant General curtis W. cole, Grand Post Chaplain

paul e. ruDNicKi, Grand Post Judge Advocate alaN KerNer, Grand Post Quartermaster

49

DISTRICT GRAND LODGE OF SYRIA-LEBANONTo the Grand Lodge F. & A.M., of the State of New York:

On May 5th, 2015, the staff officers of the District Grand Lodge of Syria-Lebanon was reappointed and installed, with R∴W∴Michel A. Timonian as the District Grand Master, M∴W∴Leon G. Zeitounalian, Honorary Past Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of Armenia, as the District Grand Secretary, and R∴W∴Raffy H. Timonian as the District Grand Secretary Emeritus and Liaison Officer for the Masonic year 2015-2016.

In 2015, the 10 Lodges in the District worked as follows: - 31 Brethren were initiated. - 18 Brethren were passed. - 30 Brethren were raised. - 01 Brother was affiliated. - 61 Brethren were unaffiliated (NPD). - 03 Brethren dimitted. - 03 Brethren were restored. - 01 Brethren passed away.

In 2015, the District membership decreased from 556 to 525 Brethren, a decrease of 5.5%. This is due to the un-affiliation of 61 Brethren for not paying their dues for over 3 years.

The continuation of the civil war in neighboring Syria and several terrorist attacks is having a dire effect on Lebanon, both economically and politically, not to mention the 1.5 Million Syrian refugees which constitutes about 30% of Lebanon’s population. Nevertheless, the Brethren kept meeting and the Lodges were extremely active, each within its territory, with lectures and Brotherhood-enhancing activities.

Here is a list of some of the activities in which the Lodges were involved:Syrio-American Lodge No. 1:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Syrio-American Lodge

managed to make a financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon.

• Distributed 50 food boxes of food rations to the needy.• Provided complete blood tests for 30 needy individuals (adults & children).

New York Lodge No. 2:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, New York Lodge made

a financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon.• Distributed 50 boxes full of rations containing 55 lbs. of food to needy

families.• In collaboration with Lebanon Lodge No. 10, they took 35 orphans to

the movies and for dinner at McDonalds.Fakhr Ud Deen Lodge No. 3:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Fakhr Ud Deen Lodge

made a financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon.Suleiman Lodge No. 5:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Suleiman Lodge made a

financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center Of Lebanon.

50

• During Christmas, Brethren with their families visited and distributed food ration boxes and Christmas presents to the SOS Children Village in Behersaf, Mount Lebanon.

• Donation to Lebanese Red Cross.El-Berdownie Lodge No. 7:• Charity donation to the Elderly (Dar Al Saada For the Elderly).

El Merj Lodge No. 8:• Donation to “Jours d’Esperance Association” in Zahle City, Bekaa

Valley, East of Lebanon. This is an association for the rehabilitation of handicapped children.

Turbol Lodge No. 9:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Turbol Lodge made a

financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon. • They also distributed food and toys to 85 Children during Christmas in

the Kobbe region in the northern city of Tripoli.• During Christmas, distributed food to 60 needy families.

Lebanon Lodge No. 10:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Lebanon Lodge made a

financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon.• In collaboration with New York Lodge No. 2, they took 35 orphans to

the movies and for dinner at McDonalds.Ani Lodge No. 11:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Ani Lodge made a

financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon.• Donation to the Lebanese Armenian Red Cross organization.• Donation to the Lebanese Armenian Orphanage.

Three Pillars Lodge No. 12:• In collaboration with the District Grand Lodge, Three Pillars Lodge

made a financial donation to The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon. • Distributed 100 boxes of food rations as well as blankets to needy

families in the Zahle’ region.During September 2015, the District Grand Lecturer, R∴W∴Armen

Asfahani, gave 3 coaching sessions using the guidelines of the Ritual Renaissance Program.

During December 2015, the District Grand Secretary, M∴W∴Leon G. Zeitounalian, had a coaching session with all the secretaries and some of the Worshipful Masters of the Lodges using the guidelines of the Grand Lodge of New York’s Secretaries Handbook. It was followed by a debate concerning “Leadership” and suggestions for membership “Recruitment” with an emphasis on “Retention of current members.” A second coaching will follow in April 2016.

In between December 10 – 30, 2015, the District Grand Lodge of Syria-Lebanon distributed 100 food ration boxes and some blankets to needy families.

On January 18, 2016, District Grand Secretary M∴W∴Leon G. Zeitounalian, accompanied by District Grand Lecturer, R∴W∴Armen

51

Asfahani, visited The Children’s Cancer Center of Lebanon and presented a $5,000.00 check, in the name of M∴W∴William J. Thomas and on behalf of the ten Lodges in the District. As acknowledgement to District’s donation, Children’s Cancer Center presented, for a second year, two recognition plates under the name of, “Hands of Hope, Blessed are the Hands That Give.”

In the name of all the Brethren in the District Grand Lodge of Syria-Lebanon, we would like to thank our Grand Master, M∴W∴William J. Thomas, for his wise guidance and continuous support. We would also like to thank our Deputy Grand Master, R∴W∴Jeffrey M. Williamson, for his constant concern about the welfare of the Brethren in our District.

Finally, our very special gratitude to the Office of the Grand Secretary, represented by R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen, Grand Secretary, and his resourceful assistant, R∴W∴Richard W. Bateman, GP, Assistant Grand Secretary.

Fraternally submitted,michel a. timoNiaN, District Grand Master

leoN G. zeitouNaliaN, Hon.PGM, GL of Armenia, District Grand Secretary

Addendum from the Grand Secretary:Ibrahim-el-Khalil Lodge No. 4 the Charter has remained Dormant

since 1969.Chouf Lodge No. 6 is Dormant, the Charter held by the District

Grand Secretary.

AMERICAN LODGE OF RESEARCHTo the Grand Lodge:

This is a report of the undersigned, in his capacity as Secretary of the Lodge, respecting the function of his office during 2015.

Communications: Stated communications of the Lodge were held on March 31st, 2015, June 23rd, 2015, and October 29th 2015, the June meeting being the Annual Communication of the Lodge. All Stated communications were held at Masonic Hall in the City of New York.

W∴Michael A. Chaplin, MD, was elected and installed for a second year as Master of The American Lodge of Research at the Annual Communication on June 23rd, 2015.

The topics presented throughout the year included: “Jesuitic Contributions at Clermont and the Revenge Motif,” by W∴David Sheihan Hunter Lindez.“Patron Saints of the Operatives,” by R∴W∴Michael Alexander Chaplin, M.D.

Transactions: The publication of Volume XXXIX of the Transactions of the American Lodge of Research remains delayed; when ready, copies will be sent to all of our members in good standing. Brothers who wish to assist in the production of the Transactions are invited to contact the Editor, W∴Henry G. Abel III, directly via e-mail. Dues notices will be sent with the Transactions; the issuance of dues cards has been discontinued since 2009 by vote of the Lodge.

Eighty-four years ago, M∴W∴Charles H. Johnson, Past Grand Master

52

1930-1932, chartered a Lodge in New York dedicated to encouraging and publishing Masonic research, specifically to debunking Masonic myths and other such “humbuggery.” It was not the first such Masonic Lodge to be formed for such a purpose, but it has gone on to be the oldest such Lodge in the United States and, to my knowledge, in the North American continent.

This year, The American Lodge of Research reached a milestone of sorts: 365 Communications -- a year’s worth! A year’s worth of constant Masonic Light, even across 84 years, is no small feat, and I hope The American Lodge of Research will enjoy your support in its endeavors throughout the years to come.

“If the light flickers, may it only burn all the brighter.”

Respectfully submitted,michael a. chapliN, Master heNry G. abel iii, Secretary

[email protected] D. samuel, Senior Warden heNry coloN, Junior Warden

richarD W. batemaN, GP, AGS, TreasurermarK e. KoltKo-rivera, Senior Deacon coNor moraN, Junior DeaconGilbert c. ferrer, Chaplain michael livschitz, Marshal

JorGe-luis romeu, Senior Master of Ceremonyyves etieNNe, Junior Master of Ceremony

pierre f. De ravel D’esclapoN, Trustee 2017Gilbert c. ferrer, Trustee 2016

eDmuND D. harrisoN, Trustee 2015harvey a. eysmaN, Secretary Emeritus

Living Fellowspierre f. De ravel D’esclapoN roNalD m. GolDWyNharvey a. eysmaN Wallace mcleoD

Publications Sub-Committee of the American Lodge of Researchpierre f. De ravel D’esclapoN, Sub-Chairman, Publications

heNry G. abel iii , EditorGilbert c. ferrer michael livschitz

michael a. chapliN, ex-officio

INFINITY LODGE OF RESEARCH NO. ∞To the Grand Lodge:

Annual Activity Report for 2015January 8, 2015 - Attendance 8:• R∴W∴Kenneth A. Freemire, Master, Infinity Lodge No. ∞, presented

a program on the civilian salute and the masonic sign of fidelity. Also the local ritual variations according to local customs.

• R∴W∴Raymond Platto presented a Bible to that he would like to bequeath to Infinity Lodge No. ∞.

February 5, 2015 - Attendance 15:• North Woods Lodge #849 was in attendance for the evening. They

53

presided for the evening with W∴Carl J. Klossner opening and closing the Lodge. The program for the evening was the floor work for the Second Degree (Fellow Craft). After closing, North Woods and Infinity Brothers enjoyed refreshments and fellowship. It should be noted that due to sickness, several Infinity Brothers were unable to attend the meeting. Several of the halls were closed.

March 12, 2015 - Attendance 17: • R∴W∴Kenneth A. Freemire presented several items during the

business meeting ranging from the Trestle Board to the upcoming Ritual Renaissance Program in Syracuse. Time was spent reviewing Lodge responsibility, especially on care of our older Brothers. Brother Freemire also discussed the meaning behind the title "Lodge of Instruction," which is the title given to Infinity Lodge. Several Brothers commented that they really enjoyed the presentation.

April 9, 2015 - Attendance 20:• R∴W∴Kenneth A. Freemire discussed the local Oneida Masonic

Districts' (First and Second) Widows luncheon, which was held at a local restaurant. Also the upcoming District Deputy Grand Masters Visitation schedule was reviewed for the Brothers present. The program for the evening was the presentation of a 60-Year Apron, pin, certificate and letters of congratulations for Brother Harold W. Rieben. There was a letter from M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master of Masons for the State of New York, which was read. The presentation was made by W∴Michael S. Kem, Master, Amicable Lodge No. 664 in Utica, NY.

May 14, 2015 - Attendance 11:• The program for the evening was a review of the highlights of the Grand

Lodge meeting on May 4th and 5th. After the discussion which was led by R∴W∴Kenneth A. Freemire, a review of one of the topics which related to the Oneida Districts was held. This topic was the combining of the First and Second Oneida Masonic Districts into one District. At the end of the presentation, R∴W∴Raymond M. Platto informed the Brothers present that he was receiving his 45-year membership recognition from his home Lodge and would bring his certificate to a future meeting. The final business for the evening was the election of Officers for the ensuing year.

June 11, 2015 - Attendance 12:• This is the last meeting before the Lodge goes dark over the summer.

The Lodge will open again in September. The program for the evening was the instillation of Officers for the next year. The R∴W∴Raymond C. Morse, District Deputy Grand Master of the First Oneida District, was present to install the new slate of Officers.

July 2015:• No meeting held.

August 2015:• No meeting held.

September 10, 2015 - Attendance 13:• The new Master for the upcoming year, W∴Carl J. Klossner, opened

54

in due form and welcomed all Brothers to the meeting for the evening. R∴W∴Jon A. Server, Grand Steward for the Second Oneida District, was present for the evening's meetings. R∴W∴Server provided the program for the evening, a discussion of the Masonic connection to the Titanic. In his research, he found out several interesting facts related to the Masons who were present on it and who passed away due to the loss of the Titanic, which took place in April of 1912. The Brothers enjoyed the program.

October 5, 2015 - Attendance 24:• This was not the regular meeting for Infinity Lodge No. ∞, but

Amicable Lodge No. 664, Utica, NY, invited the Brothers from Infinity Lodge to attend a meeting at the Utica Temple for the evening. The Brothers were bussed to the Temple for the meeting, which replaced their meeting regularly scheduled for October 8, 2015.

November 12, 2015 - Attendance 6:• The program for the meeting this evening was on “Old Iron Sides.”

It was a short, historical presentation. The other discussions that were the hot topics for the evening were related to Protocol of the Masonic Care Community and the reporting of a Brother Mason to the Lodge. This would be discussed further at the next meeting, after some research could be done by the Master. Also, it was asked if the incoming Grand Master could present Brother Stewart F. Lee with his 70-Year Apron on St. John's Day Weekend. This will be researched and returned for discussion later in the year.

December 10, 2015 - Attendance 18:• The program for this evening was the annual District Deputy Grand

Master's Visitation. This was presented by the R∴W∴Raymond C. Morse, District Deputy Grand Master of the First Oneida District. The message shared the continuation of T.E.A.M (Together Everybody Achieves More) and the progress that was made throughout the year. After the message was given, R∴W∴Morse closed in due form. Refreshments were enjoyed by all present.

Respectfully submitted by,carl J. KlossNer, Master 2015

clyDe f. marzaGalli, Senior WardeneDWarD c. Gille, Jr., Junior Warden

siDNey D. stocKholm, Treasurermichael t. DuNN, SecretarybraDley t. liNes, ChaplainKeNNeth a. freemire, Tiler

JUSTICE ROBERT H. JACKSON LODGE OF RESEARCHTo the Grand Lodge:

The Justice Robert H. Jackson, Lodge of Research, No. 9010 continues to perpetuate the Masonic Legacy of Justice and Brother Robert H. Jackson. Justice Jackson was a member of Mount Moriah Lodge No. 145 F&AM in Jamestown, NY. He was a New Deal Lawyer, a Supreme Court Justice

55

and the Chief U.S. Prosecutor at the Nazi war crimes trials at Nuremberg, having been the choice to perform such a worthy endeavor by United States President and Grand Master of Missouri, Harry S Truman.

Since Justice and Brother Jackson and President and Brother George Washington were born in the month of February, it has become a tradition of the Justice Robert H. Jackson Lodge of Research to meet annually in February to celebrate the special accomplishments of both men at a public dinner, with appropriate discussion about the accomplishments of each.

The Lodge continues to meet for educational communications and for the presentation of research papers. The Lodge presented a public program, "Stand Up For Morality" by W∴Brother Tim Bryce, a management consultant from Palm Harbor, FL.

Respectfully Submitted,JohN h. siGGiNs ii, Master

lelaND W. sperry, Secretary

veritas loDGe of researchTo the Grand Lodge:

Kindly note that Veritas Lodge of Research in the District Grand Lodge of Syria-Lebanon has been dormant since 2000. Once it restarts operations, we will send you the reports.

Respectfully submitted by leoN zeitouNaliaN, Hon. PGM, Grand Lodge of Armenia,

District Grand Secretary, District Grand Lodge Of Syria-Lebanon

WESTERN NEW YORK LODGE OF RESEARCHTo the Grand Lodge:

The Western New York Lodge of Research has been vital and productive these last several years. In 2010, we were struggling to meet regularly, even though we had as many as 50 or more members on our roll. The year-end 2014 roster numbered 67, with 25-30 regularly attending our monthly discussion groups, making the conference room (once adequate for 10-15 chairs) more than cozy.

V∴W∴Daniel J. DiNatale started the year by presenting The Ancient Catechisms and the Third Degree Tracing Boards.

We published another Book of Transactions, and established an official Lodge of Research Tie, which you should ask him about.

W∴Myron Deputat began his year in September with his presentation on the Schumann Resonances and the Ancient Cubit.

Book reviews of The Temple and The Lodge; a biography of the Compte de St. Germaine; a recent work on Alchemy and Masonry, and one on the irregularities of the scholarly oversight of the translation of the Dead Sea Scrolls brought an end to the year’s work.

Our prospects are good going forward. We have been bringing in new and energetic Brothers who expect to contribute to both the scholarly and administrative work of the Lodge.

56

We have sadly seen several members dimit this year due to changes in their lives, so we ended the year as we began, with 67 active members.

Find out more about us at www.wnylodgeofresearch.us or on FaceBook as WNYLOR.

Respectfully SubmittedmarK J. robsoN, Secretary myroN Deputat, Master

DaviD a. biNDiG, Senior WardenKeNNeth Jerome paul stuczyNsKi, Junior Warden

freDericK c. hoWarD, TreasurerWalter eDWarD cooK iv, Senior Deacon

laWreNce abbey, Junior DeaconDaviD JohN peters, Tiler

the trustees of theCHANCELLOR ROBERT R LIVINGSTON MASONIC LIBRARY

To the Grand Lodge:Mission Statement

The mission of the Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library of Grand Lodge (the Livingston Masonic Library; the Livingston Library; the Library) is to collect, preserve, interpret, and make available for education and research, to both members of the Fraternity and others, such materials as relate to the history, philosophy, culture, and organization of Freemasonry, in its social and historical contexts, with a special emphasis on Freemasonry in New York State.

The Trustees of the Livingston Masonic Library are an Elected Committee of the Grand Lodge F&AM, State of New York, serving under the leadership of M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master. We take great pride in M∴W∴Thomas’s history as a past Library Trustee and we offer him our support in his ongoing programs and responsibilities.

Strategic PlanSeptember 2014 was the culmination of many months of review and

revision on the Library’s existing Strategic Plan. In that month, the Strategic Planning Committee presented to the full Board a revised Plan, which re-focuses the goals and objectives of the 2007 Strategic Plan toward short-term (2-year) and intermediate (5-year) outcomes, together with measurable quantifiers and committee assignments. The Board voted to approve the Strategic Plan revision, and future Board activities, meetings, and staff direction will revolve around the directions laid out in the Plan.

The revised Plan is dynamic in its construct, emphasizing movement from past or existing practices and assumptions toward future services and directions that best implement and serve the mission of the Library. One objective of the Strategic Plan is to create a plan that is constantly reviewed and revised to reflect accomplished goals and that adds new objectives as landmarks are achieved. This fluidity is accomplished largely through empowering and engaging a Board of Trustees that is directly |involved in the mission of the Library, and empowered to deliver that

57

mission through its policies, its activities, and its direction to operational staff. Our Board will continue its robust interactions and cooperation with our stakeholders, which include our patron base, but also our primary funding source, the Trustees of the Hall and Home, and our current governing body, the Grand Lodge of New York.

There are actually nine initiatives articulated in the Strategic Plan, but they largely focus on two broad categories: the leveraging of technology and the improvement, and in many cases, the simplification of Library processes.

For many years, the Library’s mission has been dictated by the day-to-day occurrences within New York State Freemasonry, and at times obscured or sidetracked by programs, agendas, and at times politics. This institution cannot survive under these conditions. The Library’s future development must be determined by its mission, and be guided by decisions that best define, implement and fulfill that mission. We urge the Grand Lodge to support that mission and the direction charted by our Strategic Plan.Technology

In the area of technology, we are highly focused on digitalization. Digitalization is the process of converting paper documents to electronic documents. In the case of the Library, for assets such as books, magazines, and pictures, to name a few, digitalization provides an answer to three issues facing every library.

The first is preservation. Many documents in the Library’s collection have historical value as objects apart from the value of the information they contain. This presents an interesting problem for the librarian who must try to preserve these documents while at the same time make their information content available to researchers. Digitalization provides an elegant solution by capturing the information once under controlled circumstances, so that the original needs minimal future-handling.

For other documents a different problem arises – natural deterioration. Some Masonic publications were printed on cheaper paper with a high acid content that naturally decomposes.

"Before the mid-19th century, western paper was made from cotton and linen clothing rags and by a process that largely preserved the long fibers of the raw material. While fibers may shorten with age, rag papers tend to remain strong and durable, especially if they have been stored properly in conditions not overly warm or humid.

"Starting in the mid-19th century, wood replaced rags as the raw material for paper manufacture. Wood is processed into paper by mechanical or chemical pulping, which produces paper with shorter (compared with rag paper) fibers...

Generally speaking, good quality paper stored in good conditions (cooler temperatures; 30-40% relative humidity) are able to last a long time -- even hundreds of years." (Library of Congress)

Certainly a controlled environment retards decomposition, but it doesn’t eliminate it. Anyone who has handled certain Masonic Proceedings from the 19th Century or before will notice this as paper dust on the hands and paper chips on the floor no matter how much care is taken! Digitalization

58

for this kind of material is a race to capture the information before the document becomes completely useless.

A second concern for our Library is the cost of storage. Physical books must be stored near their point of use, often at great cost. Once digitized, original documents can be viewed from remote locations with a cheaper footprint. In addition, there is less staff time utilized in retrieving and re-shelving.

This brings us to the final concern – accessibility. Until quite recently, patrons had to live close to a library location to benefit from its services. Digitalization promises to allow the content of our collection to be available to every Masonic researcher in New York State, and, indeed around the world. While we have made significant progress in the actual conversion process, we are still researching the tools available for distribution. Issues concerning copyright and security considerations, to name two, are also being explored.

Since our collection of books alone encompasses some 60,000 volumes, it will take some time to fully digitized the collection. In addition, the technology, while capable, is far from mature.

The Board’s approach has been to do small beta projects to advance the goal of a completely digitalized Library. In this way, we have greatly advanced our knowledge of the technology, and have gained some invaluable lessons learned.

One question is whether we are a better served by performing the conversion work with internal staff or outsourcing it to external vendors. Both approaches have advantages and disadvantages. The major concern with outside vendors is cost. This year’s Lodge Historical Files conversion, for example, exceeded initial estimates by twice, and will force the Board to delay some other efforts until 2017. On the plus side, however, approximately 250,000 documents were converted. These documents were of every variety, and the relative cost, despite the significant overrun, was still low – about 4 cents a page. To put this in perspective, our total internal conversion numbers were less than 100,000 pages over a several-year period.

Internal conversion is accomplished with three scanners purchased by the Board in preceding years. Two of these scanners are similar to the office machines familiar to most people, albeit, of high quality. These are used for high-speed, automatic feed scanning of non-fragile documents, and manual processing of more fragile documents. To date these machines have been used to scan Proceedings and commonly used books. Because books scanned in this fashion need to be sacrificed (by cutting bindings) this process is used when multiple physical copies exist.

The third scanner is an Atiz, a specialized device used by libraries and museums to scan fragile or one of a kind items. One use of this scanner was the ongoing conversion of St. John’s, No. 1 Minute Books.

There are several advantages to internal scanning. An obvious advantage is that it allows the Library to control the process and the handling of the material. This is virtually a requirement for fragile material. In addition, it allows us to get a much more detailed understanding of the technology’s scope and limitations. It also allows us to pace the work and flexibly prioritize what items are scanned in what order.

59

On the negative side, is the perennial problem of limited staff hours and issues of quality due to the lack of experience.

This year, our internal work focused on converting Proceedings from the Grand Lodge, Ancient Accepted Scottish Rite, and the American Lodge of Research, as well as some Minute Books. Although this work is proceeding less rapidly than hoped for, we are making slow and steady progress, and are working our way up the learning curve.

The major external project, as was reference above, was the Lodge Historical Files project. Although the conversion was completed in the Spring of 2015, we have delayed on-line access until early 2016, as we explore the best method for distribution.

Concern has been raised over the retention or disposal of the original paper records. The Board determined that we would first offer to return Lodge Historical Files to their respective Lodges, but there has been very little interest in recovering their history by the majority of Lodges. Although then-Director R∴W∴Thomas M. Savini recommended disposal of the remaining Lodge Historical Files, the Board has thus far retained them, albeit outside of the active Library stacks. There were several reasons for selecting the Lodge Historical Files for early conversion, mainly improving accessibly, freeing up 35 filing cabinets of space in the Library, and preserving their deteriorating content. The latter will be an ongoing concern the longer we retain the documents.

Other items digitalized internally by Archivist Brother Matthew J. Lentz over the last year include:

• NYC Branch: • All the A’s and a majority of the B’s of the Subject Files.• The American Lodge of Research Vols 1-37 • The Grand Lodge of New York Proceedings 1781-1839,

1915, 1937-1959, 1970-2014• Utica Branch:

• New York Council of Deliberation Proceedings 1867-1923 Stakeholder Relations

A second area of the strategic plan is concerned with the Library’s current organizational structure. It will undoubtedly come as a surprise to many New York State Freemasons that the Board of Trustees of the Chancellor Robert R Livingston Masonic Library of the Grand Lodge of New York, is not, in fact, the governing body of the Library. Rather this Board is charged with the oversight of a collection of funds amounting to just over a million dollars that are designated for the support of the Library. Each year, the Board uses the income generated by these funds to advance the Library’s mission in a variety of ways, usually from underwriting the cost of special projects and on rare occasion, the acquisition of new artifacts for the collection.

During his tenure as Director, R∴W∴Thomas M. Savini worked to strengthen the Board and increasingly used it to develop an operational policy. Over the same period of time, the members of the Board of Trustees were selected to strengthen not only its business acumen, but also its subject

60

matter expertise in museum and library governance, as well as, some tactical areas such as technology.

The operation of the Library, however, is largely funded through the generosity of the Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home. All of us who are involved with the Library owe them a great debt of gratitude.

The ownership of the Library remains in the hands of Grand Lodge, and when Grand Lodge is not in Session, the Grand Master oversees it, either directly, or most often the case, through delegates. Until recently, the supervision of the Library’s staff and day-to-day operation fell to the Grand Secretary, but upon the resignation of the Director, M∴W∴William J. Thomas asked the Library Board to oversee the operational aspects of the Library, and the recruitment of a replacement for the Director. The Grand Secretary retains administrative responsibility for the staff and financial oversight.

As part of its strategic plan, the Library Board has given high priority to establishing an excellent working relationship with the other stakeholders. The Board is unique to the stakeholder group in two particulars. First, the Library is our only focus, whereas the other stakeholders have multiple responsibilities and concerns. Secondly, the Library Board and the Library’s staff possess virtually all of the Library and Museum expertise in the Grand Lodge organization structure.

We view our responsibility then as providing the other stakeholders with information and recommendations regarding both short and long-term Library issues and opportunities. Discussions this year have been productive and have allowed stakeholders to consider many issues that are affecting the continued well-being of the Library. Among the issues under consideration are the best governance structure for the Library, optimum and affordable Library staffing, funding alternatives, and efficient facility utilization. Museum

Curator Catherine M. Walter and Trustee R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III completed a Broad-Count Inventory of the entire Museum artifact collection amounting to just under 50,000 items. They also worked on the Cataloguing Inventory, and completed cataloguing over 2,000 new pieces before stopping to make the Broad-Count Inventory.

A separate project was the data entry by Curator Walter of over 15,000 artifacts into the Database Inventory begun in May 2014, reflective of her 13 years of Cataloguing Inventory work with the collection.

We view the management of the inventory as an iterative process, and our hopes are that, depending on their significance, artifacts will be revisited to add more detail to their inventory entry.

Museum displays are an important part of sharing the collection with the Brothers. This year, there were seven (7) new exhibits by Curator Walter that are displayed at Grand Lodge headquarters.

Four were on the theme of Continuity oVer the years:1. Table Lodges: From the 1700s & the Table Lodge held by W∴Michael

Livschitz, Master 2014, Heritage Lodge No. 371, in conjunction with The American Lodge of Research and its Master for 2014, W∴Henry G. Abel III.

61

2. George Washington Inauguration with a full ticket-set of the 1889, 100th Anniversary & the Annual Modern Reenactment

3. Honorary Membership Plaques from the mid-late 1800s & Honorary Membership plaque for R∴W∴Gilbert Savitzky, Past Grand Secretary and Grand Secretary Emeritus.

4. First "Grand Master's Meeting" with George Washington voted as Grand Master of US (which was never finalized), and a modern Grand Masters Conference, with help from R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III.

Additional new exhibits were:5. An exhibit on Lajos Kossuth, the freedom fighter known as "Hungary's

Washington," with help from Brother Edward Brody, Madison Lodge No. 5, Madison, WI, who, while studying law here in NYC, translated for the Library a magnificent set of original letters and documents of Brother Kossuth's from Hungarian into English.

6. An exhibit on the Ancient Arabic Order of Nobles of the Mystic Shrine (Shriners)

7. A miniature apron "mini-exhibit" within the Apron Exhibit, with help from R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III.

Additionally, 25 of the 27 additional semi-permanent exhibits were updated and cleaned.

Longer term, we have the goal of bringing a greater focus of the Museum's artifact collection with regards to New York State Freemasonry, and, in particular, eliminating duplication and non-relevant items, while identifying collection gaps for wish list acquisitions.

Over the past several years, Grand Masters and Grand Secretaries have frequently reassigned our Curator to the Grand Lodge of New York's Proceedings production for considerable periods of time. The Board views this as detrimental to the operation of the Museum and has recommended the Curator be assigned full-time the operation of the Museum.

The Board was pleased to add two Trustees in 2014 who have brought considerable Museum expertise to the Board. They are R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III. and R∴W∴Erik M. Strohl.Resignation of Director R∴W∴Thomas M. Savini

If the Board needed any reinforcement of the necessity of flexibility in strategic planning, the resignation of long time Director R∴W∴Thomas M. Savini certainly provided it! Tom has been central to the operation of the Livingston Library for the last 16 years, and his departure will be sorely felt, and has already modified considerably both Board and Staff activity for 2015.

When Tom submitted his resignation on August 10, 2015, the Grand Master and the Grand Secretary asked our Board to assume responsibility for securing a replacement. The Board immediately appointed a search Committee chaired by R∴W∴Erik M. Strohl. Erik has significant experience in the hiring of library/museum personnel. Other members of the Committee are R∴W∴Pierre de Ravel d’Esclapon, R∴W∴S. Marlon Gayadeen, R∴W∴Frank C. Rice II, and R∴W∴Richard J. Powell.

An interviewing Committee was also appointed, composed of R∴W∴Pierre de Ravel d’Esclapon, R∴W∴Edward A. Chiani, R∴W∴Demetrios G. Melis, and R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III.

62

The Board recommended not replacing the position at the Director level, but rather to split the Library and Museum into separate units. The new staff member will serve as the Chief Librarian, complementing Ms. Catherine M. Walter as Curator of the Museum operation. While the functions are expected to act cooperatively, they will function independently under the overall supervision of the Board and the Grand Secretary’s Office.

At the close of 2015, the Committee is still evaluating candidates, having received to date about 40 resumes.

Reading CoursesThe Reading Courses remain one of our most popular services. Although

we are working toward a digital version, we are still working through copyright issues, and the technical issue of how best to disseminate the material. For the time being then, the Reading Courses will be serviced by mailing the books to enrollees.

The Livingston Masonic Library offers 17 Reading Courses to all Master Masons of Lodges under the jurisdiction of the Grand Lodge of New York. The Courses are designed to offer education and enlightenment in areas of Masonic study and interest. Brothers may participate in the Courses by visiting the Library’s Manhattan branch, or by borrowing books through the mail. The only cost associated with the Courses is return postage at book rate.

The topics and titles in each Course were selected during a revision of the existing program during the year 2007, implemented by M∴W∴William J. Thomas, Grand Master, while he was a Library Trustee, and then-Director R∴W∴Thomas M. Savini [resigned 8/2015]. Since that revision, more than 2,900 Brothers across the state have participated in a Reading Course.The Reading Courses are:1. Who Comes Here? First course, featuring what we believe are the “read first”, most expository books available on vital Masonic topics.2. Through a Porch, the course comprising classic works of Masonic writers.3. Between Two Pillars, a more in-depth look at Masonic origins and history.4. Up Three Steps, a course crafted around Freemasonry in the State of New York.5. Up Five Steps, a course featuring an in-depth study of Masonic symbolism.6. Up Seven Steps, Freemasonry in American History.7. Through an Outer Door, Biographies of Prominent Freemasons.8. Through an Inner Door, the Esoteric Course.9. Into the Middle Chamber, the Comparative Religions Course.

10. From Labor to Refreshment, the Warden’s Course.11. From the East, the Master’s Course.12. The Tabernacle Near the Ruins, the Royal Arch Course.13. The Secret Vault Under the Tabernacle, the Cryptic Mason Course. 14. The Commandery, the Knights Templar Course.15. The Valley, the Scottish Rite Course. 16. Follow Your Conductor, the Grand Lodge Staff Officer’s Course.

63

17. Worthy and Well-Qualified, the District Deputy Grand Master’s Course.Brothers in good standing may also enroll by visiting our website at

www.nymasoniclibrary.org, and following the instructions posted there.The Reading Courses serve as initial steps in Masonic education. Brothers

are encouraged to use the books in the Courses to help them to focus their areas of interest, and to review the Library’s selection of books outside the Courses to expand their knowledge and take their interests in further directions. The staff of the Library is always willing to assist Brothers in taking the next steps on the path of Masonic education.

We have 2,940 Brothers currently registered in the reading course programs. 256 were added in 2015.

Institutional CooperationFor the past three years, the Library has contracted with the Council

of Deliberation, Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite, NMJ, of New York State, to complete the digital conversion and indexing of their complete Transactions. Two years ago, we formed a similar partnership with the Grand Chapter, Royal Arch Masons, State of New York, to digitize their Proceedings as well. Late in 2014, the Library received permission from the Grand Master to begin the process of scanning the Proceedings of the Grand Lodge of New York, and that project was begun at the start of 2015. As other Grand Bodies of related Orders independently convert their Proceedings and Transactions, we can look forward to vastly-expanded access to the recorded history of Freemasonry and Masonic activities in New York State.

The Library continued its partnership with the George Washington Masonic National Memorial, involving the Memorial’s Masonic Digital Archives project. The Memorial’s Digital Archives includes the Livingston Library’s Virtual Museum, which displays photographs and detailed descriptions made and uploaded by Curator Catherine M. Walter of hundreds of artifacts in our care. In 2014, the Memorial migrated the Archives to a new software management system, which began running in 2015. Work in this area has been temporarily placed on the back-burner due, in part, by prioritization of other projects, namely the completion of the Grand Lodge Proceedings by Grand Lodge.

The Library continues its association as a member of the American Association of State and Local History and the American Association of Museums. These organizations provide opportunities for the Library staff to continue to develop ideas and strategies that keep pace with similar institutions, and to serve as a resource for other Masonic libraries across the world. We also maintain membership in more than ten domestic and foreign research lodges.

PersonnelUntil August 26, 2015, the Library operated under the direction of

R∴W∴Thomas M. Savini, who completed his sixteenth year of service with us. Brother Savini oversaw the day-to-day operations of the Library and its staff, developed and oversaw the implementation of the digital conversion and other ongoing projects, coordinated the purchase of new titles and acquisitions, processed incoming additions to the Library’s

64

archival and historical files, answered reference and genealogy questions from Masonic and non-Masonic patrons, and assisted electronic patrons and visiting researchers and tourists at the Library’s Manhattan site. A new position, Chief Librarian, will replace his librarian duties in 2016. The Board and the Grand Secretary’s Office will perform Director functions related to human resources administration of the staff, as well as certain financial and organizational management activities.

Ms. Georgia Hershfeld, Library Cataloguer, continues to perform exceptional work in the creation and refinement of the MARC records that comprise the library catalogue. Much of Ms. Hershfeld’s work involves searching for details relating to the content of the books on our shelves, and assigning subject headings, or in contemporary parlance, ‘keywords’ to each book’s bibliographic record. Her painstaking work allows us to assist patrons in finding books that address their educational needs. It’s usually because of Ms. Hershfeld’s hours of work that we are able to bring a patron the correct book within seconds of his or her request.

Ms. Catherine M. Walter, Curator, has dedicated many hours to the research, planning and installation of exhibits in the Library’s Manhattan branch, and at points throughout Masonic Hall, and in the digital exhibits displayed in our Virtual Museum. Her talent as a photographer and her skill as a curator show in the beautiful images and detailed information available to our online visitors. Her work also includes the rehousing, stabilization, inventory and research of the 50,000-piece artifact collection. Additionally, Ms. Walter works with the Grand Secretary’s Office in the ongoing project of preparing the Grand Lodge of New York’s Annual Proceedings, inclusive of the preparation and edition of the Annual Report Booklets of the various Committees, Units and Officers of Grand Lodge.

Brother Matthew J. Lentz began his second year with us as full-time Archivist. Brother Lentz is the primary operator of the Atiz digital scanner, and spends hours building digital content by scanning copies of Masonic texts, periodicals, and manuscript material. He also concentrates on the inventory, cataloging and re-housing of documents from the Grand Lodge Archives dating from the late 18th through mid-19th centuries.

Mrs. Roseann M. Huschle continues her position as Library Receptionist. She coordinates the circulation of loaned books, processes newly acquired and catalogued material for shelving, and welcomes and assists visitors to the Library’s Manhattan site. Her welcoming smile and knowledgeable assistance make visitors to our Manhattan branch feel at home.

The Board of Trustees of the Library would like to acknowledge and thank the staff for assuming additional responsibilities as a result the departure of the Director.Board of Trustees

At the 2015 Annual Communication, upon nomination by M∴W∴ William J. Thomas, the following Trustees were Elected or reappointed for 3-year terms: R∴W∴W. Bruce Renner, President, R∴W∴Pierre de Ravel D’Esclapon, 1st Vice President, R∴W∴Edward A. Chiani, R∴W∴S. Marlon Gayadeen, and R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III.

65

R∴W∴Richard H. Eberle, Past President, and R∴W∴Ronald W. White, Honorary Past President, were elected Trustee Emeritus.

On November 9, 2015, R∴W∴Jon-Paul Kidwell tendered his resignation from the Board, citing personal and business time constraints. Subsequently, M∴W∴William J. Thomas appointed R∴W∴Demetrios (Jim) G. Melis to his unexpired term.

Public Programs/OutreachThe Library’s Manhattan site saw 1,966 visitors sign its guestbook

in the year 2015. This is slightly lower than last year’s numbers, but we feel this is due to 4 months of no evening hours necessitated by the departure of the Director. Many of our guests are Masons and their families who visit New York City from places around the world, and who are drawn to the Library through a visit to Masonic Hall. Other visitors are researchers or scholars, Masonic and non-Masonic, who reside in New York City or who travel to study with us. Still others represent people who have a curiosity or interest in the Craft, and who visit the Library to find answers to their questions.

The Obscura Society, a group with worldwide membership, dedicated to rediscovering or revitalizing unique places and sites of interest, chose the Livingston Library as within their scope in 2014.

The Library Trustees and staff visited, or were visited by, a number of Lodges and Masonic groups from across the state for formal tours and lectures regarding our services, resources and collections.

Manhattan VolunteersR∴W∴William P. Stris of Valley Stream, NY, donated hours of time and

resources toward the organization and scanning of newspaper clippings from the Lodge Historical Files collection. These clippings were among the items scanned in the conversion of the Lodge Historical Files - without R∴W∴Stris’ work, the clippings would have been too fragile to scan. R∴W∴Stris' scanning work helped preserved the clippings from 753 Lodges across New York State. We are deeply grateful for his commitment.

Utica BranchThe Utica branch of the Library is under the supervision of our Second

Vice President, R∴W∴Andrew B. Hengst. R∴W∴Hengst works with R∴W∴Ronald W. White and our Utica volunteers have worked to complete a thorough re-organization of the storage and processing facilities at the site.

R∴W∴Hengst and his volunteers have already completed a massive re-housing of the artifacts housed in Utica, and set us on the road for further development of the exhibitions and storage conditions at the site. The installation of a new high-speed scanner has allowed the volunteers to begin digitization of some of the Library’s collection housed in Utica. A special thanks is due to volunteers R∴W∴Norman M. McKnight and W∴Rolland A. Miner who have been leading the digitalization effort.

Our mid-state Brothers report a steady stream of visitors to the Library's Utica Branch, particularly Brothers and their families who are visiting the Masonic Care Community. Our midstate Trustees and the Utica volunteers maintain regular cleaning and rotation schedules for the artifacts at Utica.

66

R∴W∴Edward C. Gille, Jr., continues in his role of helping with the Museum's artifacts held in Utica, and we are grateful for the time and effort he devotes to maintaining the exhibits and coordinating visitors and tours of the facility.

Our thanks go forth to our volunteers at Utica: Ms. D. Ardelle Tuckerman, Branch SecretaryMs. Beverly White, HostessR∴W∴Ronald W. WhiteR∴W∴Edward C. Gille, Jr.V∴W∴Michael A. BerardinoR∴W∴Norman M. McKnightW∴Rolland A. Miner

Acquisitions

The Library received donation of artifacts from the below (in date order). Each donation usually represents multiple items, which will be detailed in the 2016 Annual Proceedings of the Grand Lodge of New York.

1) M∴W∴Carl J. Fitje; 2) V∴W∴Daniel J. DiNatale; 3) W∴Richard H. Fassberg, in honor of R∴W∴Martin Lindenberg via R∴W∴Ronald J. Steiner and R∴W∴C. F. William Maurer III; 4) Grand Lodge of New York via Mr. J. Eric Cook in honor of R∴W∴Thomas F. Wilder; 5) Catherine M. Walter; 6) W∴John Carlson via R∴W∴Edward S. Newsham and M∴W∴William J. Thomas; 7) G. Lane Johnson, Jr. in honor of Byron S. Johnson; 8) Carolyn Quadarella; 9) Brother Michael Sivy; 10) M∴W∴William J. Thomas; 11) Georgia Hershfeld in memory of Mr. Carl Hershfeld; 12) Georgia Hershfeld in memory of Mr. Cyril Mackler; 13) W∴Russel M. Fuchs in honor of W∴Leo M. Evans; 14) Delaware Lodge No. 561; 15 + 16) M∴W∴William J. Thomas; 17) James B. Schlicke via R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen; 18) M∴W∴ William J. Thomas; 19) Samuel Bishop; 20) R∴W∴Paul M. Rosen; 21) W∴ John J. Kelly III in honor of R∴W∴Melvyn Schwartz; 22) Ilene Van Zetten in honor of W∴Edmund F. Tietz via the Grand Lodge of Colorado, the Colorado Grand Chapter Order of the Eastern Star and D'Ann Downing; 23) Janet Kirker in honor of R∴W∴Theodore Fred Kuper; 24) Faith Farm Ministries; 25) Mrs. Clarice J. Gates in honor of R∴W∴Gerald H. Gates; 26) Edie Weintraub Danovitz in honor of Ethel Greenglick Weintraub; 27) Nancy Robinson in honor of Brother Victor Emerson Lambert; 28) Jennifer Kirk in honor of Brother William Archibald Kirk; and, 29) R∴W∴Ronald J. Steiner.

Acknowledgements The Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home provide regular,

ongoing and generous support to the Library, and allow us to continue to develop our mission and expand our services to Brothers across the state, and to researchers across the world. We are deeply grateful to the Trustees of the Masonic Hall and Home for their dedication to Masonic education and to the Library. We applaud their longstanding mission toward the care of Brothers and their families and to the health and well-being of so many others at the Masonic Care Community.

67

The Fifth Manhattan Masonic District Association Endowment Fund, Inc. continues to promote educational endeavors by providing generous support to ongoing Library projects, particularly making possible the hosting of our online catalogue and virtual museum. We salute the Endowment Fund and its governing Board, and express our deepest gratitude for their commitment to Masonic education and the Library’s mission.

The Trustees of the Library and the Library staff extend deepest gratitude to all the Brethren who supported the Library through contributions to the Masonic Brotherhood Fund. These contributions go directly to the Library’s operating budget, and help us to continue our efforts to make Masonry’s history and physical heritage accessible to Masons across the State of New York.

Finally, we express our deepest appreciation to all those who have made direct donations to our collection and direct financial donations in support of our operation and projects.

We are grateful for the continuing support shown to us by the Grand Lodge of the State of New York and the Office of the Grand Secretary.

Respectfully submitted,W. bruce reNNer, 2018, PSGW, President

pierre De ravel D’esclapoN, 2018, 1st Vice PresidentaNDreW b. heNGst, 2016, 2nd Vice President

stepheN s. KiNG, 2016, PJGW, TreasurerricharD c. mills, 2017, Secretary

eDWarD a. chiaNi, 2018 Demetrios G. melis, 2017JohN p. DeveNey, 2016 scott D. peat, 2016s. marloN GayaDeeN, 2018 richarD J. poWell, 2016eDWarD G. Gilbert, PGM, 2017 fraNK c. rice ii, 2017c. f. William maurer iii, 2015 eric m. strohl, 2017

Ex-OfficioWilliam J. thomas, Grand Master

Jeffrey m. WilliamsoN, Deputy Grand Mastercharles catapaNo, Grand Treasurer paul m. roseN, Grand Secretary

thomas m. saviNi, DirEctor [Resigned 8/2015]

EmeritiheNry altmaN, William l. Dupree, richarD h. eberle, Past President, eDWarD p. faGaN, Jr., alDo a. GhirarDuzzi, Jr., freD G. hicKeiN, barry

mallah, Past President, michael l. rossoN, GeralD b. shoWalter, richarD W. WarD, roNalD W. White

standing and special committees, other grand …...annual reports standing and special committees,...

Documents