state office of adn1inistrative i-iearingssupplemental application of casey's d/bia...
TRANSCRIPT
State Office of Adn1inistrative I-Iearings
Lesli G Ginn Chief Administrative Law Judge ~
g e a zOctober 18 2016
Sherry Cook Administrator Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission 5806 Mesa Drive Austin Texas 78731
e 3
~ e
VIA REGULAR MAIL
RF TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION IURISDICTIONAL PETITIONER WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ET AL vs SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DBIA CASEYS SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
Dear Ms Cook
Please find enclosed a Proposal for Decision in this case It contains my recommendation and underlying rationale
Exceptions and replies may be filed by any party in accordance with I TEX ADMIN
CoDJ sect l 55507(c ) a SOAI I rule which may be found at VbullN1soahstatetxus
Sincerely
Administrative Law Judge KGsp Enclosure
Xe Edgar Korzcniowski Staff Attorney Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission VIA REGLLAR MAIL 427 W 20h Street Suite 600 l louston Texas 77008 Fmily elm General Counsel Tcgtus Alcoholic Bncragc Commission VIA REGULAR 1AIL 5806 Mesa Drm Austin Tcas 78731 Ed Walton Attornc for Protestant- Willis Point Firgt Baptist Church VIA REGUIAR MAIi IOI tvktm I)livc hrrdl Texas 75160 S Crrnrgc Alfonso Attorney for Applicant- Caseys diba Cascymiddots VIA REGUAR vlAIL 5340 Alpha Road Dallas middot1 exas 75240
8700 N S1e1n11011s Frtcmiddotay Suic 26 l)c1lhs Tnas 757-17 214-962-32JO (Main) 2 l 1-- 32G6 (Fax)
KAREN BOSWELi P 0 BOX 21 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CARMEN LUGATE 11645 BErry LANE KAUFMAN TX 75142 PROTESTANT
ROBIN amp M FRANCIS MACK 500 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp CAROLINE CUNNINGHAM 233 VZCR3501 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MICIAEL amp COURTNEY MORGAN 428 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTAN r
JOHN amp DELIA NIMMO PO Box 872 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DARYL amp KATHI SELF 14088 HICKORY TREE LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DAVllJ STOKES 7831 FM 751 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DARLIE amp BOB KEE P 0 ROX 337 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JODY amp ELIARETII PAN ER 2910 VZCR3417 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KAREN ALDRIDGE 309 N 6TH STREET WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DUKE BURNETT 509 VZCR 3443 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MARY JANE llUNTER 11 l VZCR 329 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RONNIE CHITTY 613 VZCR 2625 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOAN ROBINSON 1101 VZCR3204 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
THE SAMMONS FALCON WALLACE FAMILIES P 0 ROX 787 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANTS
JUSTIN amp ERIN LOWERY 426 WN COMMERCE ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RAY COLE 524 PECAN WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MOORE FAMILY P 0 BOX 52 WILLS POJNT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOB amp LAJUAN MA YFlELD 301 VZCR 3807 WILLS POlNT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DONN A GUNTER 2190 FM 2475 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS KENNETH MCDOUGLE 405 MCRAJN ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS DALE A fOSTER 908 CANTON AVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BETTY amp DON BAKER 9 POST OAK WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOYCE RAGAN 4793 VZCR 3504 WILLS POlNT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JACKIE CARL 600 TENNESSEE CIR 18 WILLS POINT TX 7569 PROTESTANT
GLADYS CALLOWAY 8053 JAMES WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CAROL BURLESON 15149El-20 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BJ ARLAND 15149 E 1-20 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE FLORES 4500 STEINER RANCH BLVD 208 AUSTIN TX 78732 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS JAMES AYCOCK 11003 BAXTER WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESJANmiddot1middot
MARK MURREY P 0 BOX 612 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LAJUAN DIXON 301 S MAIN WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROlESTANT
BOBBY DIXON P 0 BOX 31 WILLS POJNT TX 75169 PROTESTANI
EARL amp MARIS CLARK I88VZCR34l5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTEST AN I
KIM SCHWENN 31729 SI 64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
HUGH IIALL 1201 W SOUTH COMMERCE ST WELLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT amp KIMBERLY RAGLAND 951 VZCR3514 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KARLA MYERS 177 MONNING LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CARRIE MIKOS 901 E ONEAL WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
Tl IE BERBERICH FAMILY 8576CR313 TERRELL TX 75761 PROTESTANT
HAROLD MOORE 229 VZCR 3442 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DANELLE amp BRANDON FUGATE 14131 CLARK LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BR JAN STOKES 1288 VZCR3708 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DUB amp BRJANNA SEWELL 120 CR 3820 WlLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ANN amp DD DANIELL P 0 BOX 207 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY FLETCIER 340 VZCR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
lAROUJ amp JUDY TAYLOR 189 MERIDIAN LANE WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DD ROBINSON l O I VZCR 3204 WILLS POINT TX 75 l69 PROTESTANT
THOMAS CHEEK 1401 VZCR3412 WILLS POJN r TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MJLDRED LUCILLE CAMPBELL 163 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ClARA HOLDEN 101 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BARRA RA RURNETT 509 VZCR 3443 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
FREDDY NICOL 31731Sll64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RA MELLE SEWELL 8051 FM 751 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SANDRA COLGROVE 1000 ROSS ST TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
RICK JOHNS P 0 BOX 100 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
PAULE PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RONALD BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
MELISSA JOI lNSON 7324 CRABTREE LANE NORTII RICIILANLJ HILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
GREGORY amp SONIA BROWN 2004 ROANOKE RD KELLER TX 76262 PROTESTANT
MICHAEL WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CRYSTAL MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MIKE BARTON 705 ATHENS CANTON TX 75103 PROTESTANT
KATHRYN JOHNSTON 604 N 4TH ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MOE amp GERE KENNEDY 760 VZCR WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
8RENDA T WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MARY BETH HURLEY 225 L YNNELLEN LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROJESJANT
VICKEY BRADLEY 2863 WATERS EDGE QUINLAN TX 75474 PROTESTANT
KELLY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLSPONf TX75169 PROTESTANT
ANTHONY MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY BURROW P 0 BOX 177 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
AMANDA STRUTTON 49 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BETTY BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
DAVE JOI INSON 7324 CRABTREE LiNE NORTH RICHLAND IIILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
RIIONDA BROWN COBERN 6013 PARTRIDGE DRIVE FORT WOR TII TX 76 l 35 PROTESTANT
DELORES PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LYNN KING 118 THOMPSON DRIVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOJIN amp KELLY FLETCHER 452 CR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KEITH MACK 500 CR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY WHITTIKER 523 EAST FORK RD SUNNYVALE TX 75182 PROTESTANT
JUDY JETER 4337 OLEANDER TRAIL MESQUITE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
WANDA KEARNEY 587 LYONS RD GARLAND TX 75043 PROTESTANT
VICKI COLEGROVE 9063 STONEI IEARTH LANE FORNEY TX 75126 PROTESJANT
RENEE MASON 1431 RIDGE VIEW ST MESQUITE TX 75149 PROTESTANT
CHERYL GIPSON 2612 MONTCLAIR LN MESQUJTE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
ESTERS MITCH 6050 SAMPLES LANE TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
GREG MOORE P 0 BOX 247 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANmiddot1middot
STERLING amp LIZ WARDEN 10982 CR 348 WILLS PON I TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT ORMS 10604 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp JANICE SNYDER 231 VZCR 3829 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ALAN SNYDER 239 VZCR 3719 WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMJ OGDIE 7515 VZCR 3504 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE amp LINDA MASON 863 VZCR35J5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMY P CUNNNHAM 16895 CR 247 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
JAMES PARKER 10612 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
JEAN LIVES Y 226 E ONEAL ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION
Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ETAL
Protestants
IN RE SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DillA CASEYS
Applicant
IJALLASCOUNTYTEXAS (TABC CASE NO 636237)
sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect
BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE
OF
All1IN1STRATIVE HEARl1iGS
PROPOSAL FOR llECISIOcll
Wills Point First Baptist Chunh first Baptist Church Wills Point Iearning Center mJ
124 imlilduas (Protestants) challenged the supplemental application filed by Cascymiddots Ji()a
Caseygt (Applicant) with the Texas Alcoholic l3cnragc Commission (TA8C or Commission) on
the basis that the place or manner in which Applicant may conduct its business varrants the
refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health piacc morals and safety or the
people anJ on the public sense of decency The Commissionmiddot s staff (Staff) remained neutral on
the application having determined that Applicant met all the technical requirements to obtain the
permit After considering the arguments and evidence presented by the parties the
Administrative Law Judge (iLJ) finds that the application should he denied
I JURISDICTION NOTICE ANO PROCEDURAL HISTORY
There were no contested issues of jurisdiction notice or venue m this proceeding
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
KAREN BOSWELi P 0 BOX 21 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CARMEN LUGATE 11645 BErry LANE KAUFMAN TX 75142 PROTESTANT
ROBIN amp M FRANCIS MACK 500 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp CAROLINE CUNNINGHAM 233 VZCR3501 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MICIAEL amp COURTNEY MORGAN 428 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTAN r
JOHN amp DELIA NIMMO PO Box 872 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DARYL amp KATHI SELF 14088 HICKORY TREE LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DAVllJ STOKES 7831 FM 751 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DARLIE amp BOB KEE P 0 ROX 337 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JODY amp ELIARETII PAN ER 2910 VZCR3417 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KAREN ALDRIDGE 309 N 6TH STREET WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DUKE BURNETT 509 VZCR 3443 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MARY JANE llUNTER 11 l VZCR 329 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RONNIE CHITTY 613 VZCR 2625 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOAN ROBINSON 1101 VZCR3204 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
THE SAMMONS FALCON WALLACE FAMILIES P 0 ROX 787 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANTS
JUSTIN amp ERIN LOWERY 426 WN COMMERCE ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RAY COLE 524 PECAN WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MOORE FAMILY P 0 BOX 52 WILLS POJNT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOB amp LAJUAN MA YFlELD 301 VZCR 3807 WILLS POlNT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DONN A GUNTER 2190 FM 2475 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS KENNETH MCDOUGLE 405 MCRAJN ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS DALE A fOSTER 908 CANTON AVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BETTY amp DON BAKER 9 POST OAK WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOYCE RAGAN 4793 VZCR 3504 WILLS POlNT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JACKIE CARL 600 TENNESSEE CIR 18 WILLS POINT TX 7569 PROTESTANT
GLADYS CALLOWAY 8053 JAMES WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CAROL BURLESON 15149El-20 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BJ ARLAND 15149 E 1-20 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE FLORES 4500 STEINER RANCH BLVD 208 AUSTIN TX 78732 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS JAMES AYCOCK 11003 BAXTER WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESJANmiddot1middot
MARK MURREY P 0 BOX 612 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LAJUAN DIXON 301 S MAIN WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROlESTANT
BOBBY DIXON P 0 BOX 31 WILLS POJNT TX 75169 PROTESTANI
EARL amp MARIS CLARK I88VZCR34l5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTEST AN I
KIM SCHWENN 31729 SI 64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
HUGH IIALL 1201 W SOUTH COMMERCE ST WELLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT amp KIMBERLY RAGLAND 951 VZCR3514 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KARLA MYERS 177 MONNING LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CARRIE MIKOS 901 E ONEAL WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
Tl IE BERBERICH FAMILY 8576CR313 TERRELL TX 75761 PROTESTANT
HAROLD MOORE 229 VZCR 3442 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DANELLE amp BRANDON FUGATE 14131 CLARK LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BR JAN STOKES 1288 VZCR3708 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DUB amp BRJANNA SEWELL 120 CR 3820 WlLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ANN amp DD DANIELL P 0 BOX 207 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY FLETCIER 340 VZCR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
lAROUJ amp JUDY TAYLOR 189 MERIDIAN LANE WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DD ROBINSON l O I VZCR 3204 WILLS POINT TX 75 l69 PROTESTANT
THOMAS CHEEK 1401 VZCR3412 WILLS POJN r TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MJLDRED LUCILLE CAMPBELL 163 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ClARA HOLDEN 101 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BARRA RA RURNETT 509 VZCR 3443 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
FREDDY NICOL 31731Sll64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RA MELLE SEWELL 8051 FM 751 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SANDRA COLGROVE 1000 ROSS ST TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
RICK JOHNS P 0 BOX 100 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
PAULE PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RONALD BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
MELISSA JOI lNSON 7324 CRABTREE LANE NORTII RICIILANLJ HILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
GREGORY amp SONIA BROWN 2004 ROANOKE RD KELLER TX 76262 PROTESTANT
MICHAEL WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CRYSTAL MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MIKE BARTON 705 ATHENS CANTON TX 75103 PROTESTANT
KATHRYN JOHNSTON 604 N 4TH ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MOE amp GERE KENNEDY 760 VZCR WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
8RENDA T WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MARY BETH HURLEY 225 L YNNELLEN LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROJESJANT
VICKEY BRADLEY 2863 WATERS EDGE QUINLAN TX 75474 PROTESTANT
KELLY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLSPONf TX75169 PROTESTANT
ANTHONY MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY BURROW P 0 BOX 177 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
AMANDA STRUTTON 49 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BETTY BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
DAVE JOI INSON 7324 CRABTREE LiNE NORTH RICHLAND IIILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
RIIONDA BROWN COBERN 6013 PARTRIDGE DRIVE FORT WOR TII TX 76 l 35 PROTESTANT
DELORES PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LYNN KING 118 THOMPSON DRIVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOJIN amp KELLY FLETCHER 452 CR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KEITH MACK 500 CR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY WHITTIKER 523 EAST FORK RD SUNNYVALE TX 75182 PROTESTANT
JUDY JETER 4337 OLEANDER TRAIL MESQUITE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
WANDA KEARNEY 587 LYONS RD GARLAND TX 75043 PROTESTANT
VICKI COLEGROVE 9063 STONEI IEARTH LANE FORNEY TX 75126 PROTESJANT
RENEE MASON 1431 RIDGE VIEW ST MESQUITE TX 75149 PROTESTANT
CHERYL GIPSON 2612 MONTCLAIR LN MESQUJTE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
ESTERS MITCH 6050 SAMPLES LANE TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
GREG MOORE P 0 BOX 247 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANmiddot1middot
STERLING amp LIZ WARDEN 10982 CR 348 WILLS PON I TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT ORMS 10604 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp JANICE SNYDER 231 VZCR 3829 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ALAN SNYDER 239 VZCR 3719 WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMJ OGDIE 7515 VZCR 3504 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE amp LINDA MASON 863 VZCR35J5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMY P CUNNNHAM 16895 CR 247 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
JAMES PARKER 10612 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
JEAN LIVES Y 226 E ONEAL ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION
Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ETAL
Protestants
IN RE SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DillA CASEYS
Applicant
IJALLASCOUNTYTEXAS (TABC CASE NO 636237)
sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect
BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE
OF
All1IN1STRATIVE HEARl1iGS
PROPOSAL FOR llECISIOcll
Wills Point First Baptist Chunh first Baptist Church Wills Point Iearning Center mJ
124 imlilduas (Protestants) challenged the supplemental application filed by Cascymiddots Ji()a
Caseygt (Applicant) with the Texas Alcoholic l3cnragc Commission (TA8C or Commission) on
the basis that the place or manner in which Applicant may conduct its business varrants the
refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health piacc morals and safety or the
people anJ on the public sense of decency The Commissionmiddot s staff (Staff) remained neutral on
the application having determined that Applicant met all the technical requirements to obtain the
permit After considering the arguments and evidence presented by the parties the
Administrative Law Judge (iLJ) finds that the application should he denied
I JURISDICTION NOTICE ANO PROCEDURAL HISTORY
There were no contested issues of jurisdiction notice or venue m this proceeding
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
JACKIE CARL 600 TENNESSEE CIR 18 WILLS POINT TX 7569 PROTESTANT
GLADYS CALLOWAY 8053 JAMES WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CAROL BURLESON 15149El-20 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BJ ARLAND 15149 E 1-20 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE FLORES 4500 STEINER RANCH BLVD 208 AUSTIN TX 78732 PROTESTANT
MR amp MRS JAMES AYCOCK 11003 BAXTER WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESJANmiddot1middot
MARK MURREY P 0 BOX 612 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LAJUAN DIXON 301 S MAIN WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROlESTANT
BOBBY DIXON P 0 BOX 31 WILLS POJNT TX 75169 PROTESTANI
EARL amp MARIS CLARK I88VZCR34l5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTEST AN I
KIM SCHWENN 31729 SI 64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
HUGH IIALL 1201 W SOUTH COMMERCE ST WELLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT amp KIMBERLY RAGLAND 951 VZCR3514 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KARLA MYERS 177 MONNING LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CARRIE MIKOS 901 E ONEAL WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
Tl IE BERBERICH FAMILY 8576CR313 TERRELL TX 75761 PROTESTANT
HAROLD MOORE 229 VZCR 3442 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DANELLE amp BRANDON FUGATE 14131 CLARK LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BR JAN STOKES 1288 VZCR3708 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DUB amp BRJANNA SEWELL 120 CR 3820 WlLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ANN amp DD DANIELL P 0 BOX 207 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY FLETCIER 340 VZCR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
lAROUJ amp JUDY TAYLOR 189 MERIDIAN LANE WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
DD ROBINSON l O I VZCR 3204 WILLS POINT TX 75 l69 PROTESTANT
THOMAS CHEEK 1401 VZCR3412 WILLS POJN r TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MJLDRED LUCILLE CAMPBELL 163 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ClARA HOLDEN 101 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BARRA RA RURNETT 509 VZCR 3443 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
FREDDY NICOL 31731Sll64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RA MELLE SEWELL 8051 FM 751 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SANDRA COLGROVE 1000 ROSS ST TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
RICK JOHNS P 0 BOX 100 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
PAULE PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RONALD BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
MELISSA JOI lNSON 7324 CRABTREE LANE NORTII RICIILANLJ HILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
GREGORY amp SONIA BROWN 2004 ROANOKE RD KELLER TX 76262 PROTESTANT
MICHAEL WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CRYSTAL MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MIKE BARTON 705 ATHENS CANTON TX 75103 PROTESTANT
KATHRYN JOHNSTON 604 N 4TH ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MOE amp GERE KENNEDY 760 VZCR WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
8RENDA T WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MARY BETH HURLEY 225 L YNNELLEN LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROJESJANT
VICKEY BRADLEY 2863 WATERS EDGE QUINLAN TX 75474 PROTESTANT
KELLY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLSPONf TX75169 PROTESTANT
ANTHONY MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY BURROW P 0 BOX 177 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
AMANDA STRUTTON 49 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BETTY BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
DAVE JOI INSON 7324 CRABTREE LiNE NORTH RICHLAND IIILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
RIIONDA BROWN COBERN 6013 PARTRIDGE DRIVE FORT WOR TII TX 76 l 35 PROTESTANT
DELORES PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LYNN KING 118 THOMPSON DRIVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOJIN amp KELLY FLETCHER 452 CR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KEITH MACK 500 CR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY WHITTIKER 523 EAST FORK RD SUNNYVALE TX 75182 PROTESTANT
JUDY JETER 4337 OLEANDER TRAIL MESQUITE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
WANDA KEARNEY 587 LYONS RD GARLAND TX 75043 PROTESTANT
VICKI COLEGROVE 9063 STONEI IEARTH LANE FORNEY TX 75126 PROTESJANT
RENEE MASON 1431 RIDGE VIEW ST MESQUITE TX 75149 PROTESTANT
CHERYL GIPSON 2612 MONTCLAIR LN MESQUJTE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
ESTERS MITCH 6050 SAMPLES LANE TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
GREG MOORE P 0 BOX 247 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANmiddot1middot
STERLING amp LIZ WARDEN 10982 CR 348 WILLS PON I TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT ORMS 10604 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp JANICE SNYDER 231 VZCR 3829 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ALAN SNYDER 239 VZCR 3719 WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMJ OGDIE 7515 VZCR 3504 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE amp LINDA MASON 863 VZCR35J5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMY P CUNNNHAM 16895 CR 247 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
JAMES PARKER 10612 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
JEAN LIVES Y 226 E ONEAL ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION
Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ETAL
Protestants
IN RE SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DillA CASEYS
Applicant
IJALLASCOUNTYTEXAS (TABC CASE NO 636237)
sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect
BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE
OF
All1IN1STRATIVE HEARl1iGS
PROPOSAL FOR llECISIOcll
Wills Point First Baptist Chunh first Baptist Church Wills Point Iearning Center mJ
124 imlilduas (Protestants) challenged the supplemental application filed by Cascymiddots Ji()a
Caseygt (Applicant) with the Texas Alcoholic l3cnragc Commission (TA8C or Commission) on
the basis that the place or manner in which Applicant may conduct its business varrants the
refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health piacc morals and safety or the
people anJ on the public sense of decency The Commissionmiddot s staff (Staff) remained neutral on
the application having determined that Applicant met all the technical requirements to obtain the
permit After considering the arguments and evidence presented by the parties the
Administrative Law Judge (iLJ) finds that the application should he denied
I JURISDICTION NOTICE ANO PROCEDURAL HISTORY
There were no contested issues of jurisdiction notice or venue m this proceeding
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
ClARA HOLDEN 101 VZCR 3404 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BARRA RA RURNETT 509 VZCR 3443 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
FREDDY NICOL 31731Sll64 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RA MELLE SEWELL 8051 FM 751 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SANDRA COLGROVE 1000 ROSS ST TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
RICK JOHNS P 0 BOX 100 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
PAULE PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
RONALD BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
MELISSA JOI lNSON 7324 CRABTREE LANE NORTII RICIILANLJ HILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
GREGORY amp SONIA BROWN 2004 ROANOKE RD KELLER TX 76262 PROTESTANT
MICHAEL WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
CRYSTAL MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MIKE BARTON 705 ATHENS CANTON TX 75103 PROTESTANT
KATHRYN JOHNSTON 604 N 4TH ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MOE amp GERE KENNEDY 760 VZCR WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
8RENDA T WILLIAMS 251 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
MARY BETH HURLEY 225 L YNNELLEN LANE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROJESJANT
VICKEY BRADLEY 2863 WATERS EDGE QUINLAN TX 75474 PROTESTANT
KELLY REMMERS 4310 VZCR 3502 WILLSPONf TX75169 PROTESTANT
ANTHONY MORGAN 3325 VZCR 3502 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BOBBY BURROW P 0 BOX 177 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
AMANDA STRUTTON 49 VZCR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BETTY BROWN P 0 BOX 1477 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
DAVE JOI INSON 7324 CRABTREE LiNE NORTH RICHLAND IIILLS TX 76182 PROTESTANT
RIIONDA BROWN COBERN 6013 PARTRIDGE DRIVE FORT WOR TII TX 76 l 35 PROTESTANT
DELORES PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LYNN KING 118 THOMPSON DRIVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOJIN amp KELLY FLETCHER 452 CR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KEITH MACK 500 CR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY WHITTIKER 523 EAST FORK RD SUNNYVALE TX 75182 PROTESTANT
JUDY JETER 4337 OLEANDER TRAIL MESQUITE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
WANDA KEARNEY 587 LYONS RD GARLAND TX 75043 PROTESTANT
VICKI COLEGROVE 9063 STONEI IEARTH LANE FORNEY TX 75126 PROTESJANT
RENEE MASON 1431 RIDGE VIEW ST MESQUITE TX 75149 PROTESTANT
CHERYL GIPSON 2612 MONTCLAIR LN MESQUJTE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
ESTERS MITCH 6050 SAMPLES LANE TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
GREG MOORE P 0 BOX 247 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANmiddot1middot
STERLING amp LIZ WARDEN 10982 CR 348 WILLS PON I TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT ORMS 10604 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp JANICE SNYDER 231 VZCR 3829 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ALAN SNYDER 239 VZCR 3719 WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMJ OGDIE 7515 VZCR 3504 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE amp LINDA MASON 863 VZCR35J5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMY P CUNNNHAM 16895 CR 247 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
JAMES PARKER 10612 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
JEAN LIVES Y 226 E ONEAL ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION
Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ETAL
Protestants
IN RE SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DillA CASEYS
Applicant
IJALLASCOUNTYTEXAS (TABC CASE NO 636237)
sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect
BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE
OF
All1IN1STRATIVE HEARl1iGS
PROPOSAL FOR llECISIOcll
Wills Point First Baptist Chunh first Baptist Church Wills Point Iearning Center mJ
124 imlilduas (Protestants) challenged the supplemental application filed by Cascymiddots Ji()a
Caseygt (Applicant) with the Texas Alcoholic l3cnragc Commission (TA8C or Commission) on
the basis that the place or manner in which Applicant may conduct its business varrants the
refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health piacc morals and safety or the
people anJ on the public sense of decency The Commissionmiddot s staff (Staff) remained neutral on
the application having determined that Applicant met all the technical requirements to obtain the
permit After considering the arguments and evidence presented by the parties the
Administrative Law Judge (iLJ) finds that the application should he denied
I JURISDICTION NOTICE ANO PROCEDURAL HISTORY
There were no contested issues of jurisdiction notice or venue m this proceeding
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
DELORES PHILLIPS 20 WINGO WAY WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
LYNN KING 118 THOMPSON DRIVE WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOJIN amp KELLY FLETCHER 452 CR 3528 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
KEITH MACK 500 CR 2627 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JOHNNY WHITTIKER 523 EAST FORK RD SUNNYVALE TX 75182 PROTESTANT
JUDY JETER 4337 OLEANDER TRAIL MESQUITE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
WANDA KEARNEY 587 LYONS RD GARLAND TX 75043 PROTESTANT
VICKI COLEGROVE 9063 STONEI IEARTH LANE FORNEY TX 75126 PROTESJANT
RENEE MASON 1431 RIDGE VIEW ST MESQUITE TX 75149 PROTESTANT
CHERYL GIPSON 2612 MONTCLAIR LN MESQUJTE TX 75150 PROTESTANT
ESTERS MITCH 6050 SAMPLES LANE TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
GREG MOORE P 0 BOX 247 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANmiddot1middot
STERLING amp LIZ WARDEN 10982 CR 348 WILLS PON I TX 75169 PROTESTANT
BRENT ORMS 10604 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
RICHARD amp JANICE SNYDER 231 VZCR 3829 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
ALAN SNYDER 239 VZCR 3719 WJLLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMJ OGDIE 7515 VZCR 3504 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
EDDIE amp LINDA MASON 863 VZCR35J5 WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
JEREMY P CUNNNHAM 16895 CR 247 TERRELL TX 75160 PROTESTANT
JAMES PARKER 10612 CR 360 TERRELL TX 75161 PROTESTANT
JEAN LIVES Y 226 E ONEAL ST WILLS POINT TX 75169 PROTESTANT
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION
Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ETAL
Protestants
IN RE SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DillA CASEYS
Applicant
IJALLASCOUNTYTEXAS (TABC CASE NO 636237)
sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect
BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE
OF
All1IN1STRATIVE HEARl1iGS
PROPOSAL FOR llECISIOcll
Wills Point First Baptist Chunh first Baptist Church Wills Point Iearning Center mJ
124 imlilduas (Protestants) challenged the supplemental application filed by Cascymiddots Ji()a
Caseygt (Applicant) with the Texas Alcoholic l3cnragc Commission (TA8C or Commission) on
the basis that the place or manner in which Applicant may conduct its business varrants the
refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health piacc morals and safety or the
people anJ on the public sense of decency The Commissionmiddot s staff (Staff) remained neutral on
the application having determined that Applicant met all the technical requirements to obtain the
permit After considering the arguments and evidence presented by the parties the
Administrative Law Judge (iLJ) finds that the application should he denied
I JURISDICTION NOTICE ANO PROCEDURAL HISTORY
There were no contested issues of jurisdiction notice or venue m this proceeding
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE COMMISSION
Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT LEARNING CENTER ETAL
Protestants
IN RE SUPPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF CASEYS DillA CASEYS
Applicant
IJALLASCOUNTYTEXAS (TABC CASE NO 636237)
sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect sect
BEFORE THE STATE OFFICE
OF
All1IN1STRATIVE HEARl1iGS
PROPOSAL FOR llECISIOcll
Wills Point First Baptist Chunh first Baptist Church Wills Point Iearning Center mJ
124 imlilduas (Protestants) challenged the supplemental application filed by Cascymiddots Ji()a
Caseygt (Applicant) with the Texas Alcoholic l3cnragc Commission (TA8C or Commission) on
the basis that the place or manner in which Applicant may conduct its business varrants the
refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health piacc morals and safety or the
people anJ on the public sense of decency The Commissionmiddot s staff (Staff) remained neutral on
the application having determined that Applicant met all the technical requirements to obtain the
permit After considering the arguments and evidence presented by the parties the
Administrative Law Judge (iLJ) finds that the application should he denied
I JURISDICTION NOTICE ANO PROCEDURAL HISTORY
There were no contested issues of jurisdiction notice or venue m this proceeding
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION PAGf 2
Therefore those matters are set out in the findings of fact and conclusions of law without further
discussion here
On August 9 2016 a hearing convened at the State Office of Administrative Hearings
(SOAH) in Dallas Texas before AU Kyle J Ciroves Applicant was rcpnsentcd by attorney S
George Alfonso and Staff was represented b~ nttorney Edgar Korzeniowski Protestants Wills
Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Vere
represented by attorney Ed Walton John Nimmo and Patricia Simpson appeared pro se and
represented the individual Protestants The record remained open until September 1 2016 so
the parties could file written dosing arguments
II LEGAL STANDARDS AND APPLICABLE LAW
The commission or administrator may refuse to issue an original or renewal permit ith
Pr without a hearing if it has reasonable grounds to heliemiddote and finds that any of the follomng
c1numstance exiits the place or manner in middothich the applicant may conduct his business
arrants the refusal ofa permit hascd on the grncntl cl fare hcalth peace morals and salcty of
the people and on the public -ien-ie oJdecency 1
1 Te Alco Bev Code~ 1 l 46(a)(8)
111 DISCUSSION
Applicant is a restaurant operating across the street from Wills Point First Baptist Church
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center Applicant previously operated a
restaurant and bar approximately two blocks from the Church It is seeking to hamiddote its Private
Club Registration Permit and a Bemiddoterage Cartage Pennit transferred to its new location
Donald Myers testified on behalf of Protestants Wills Point First Baptist Church (Church)
and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center (Learning Center) Mr Myers has been
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAH lgtOCKFT NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 3
the pastor of the Church for 14 years He testified that Applicants place of business is located
across the street from the Church One of the Churchs parking lots is between Applicants place
of business and the Church An aerial photograph2 shows the Churchs parking lot has more
than 30 parking spaces
Church rxh I
Mr Myers said that the parking lot is used by parents Monday through Friday who are
dropping off and picking up their children from the Learning Ccnttr The Learning Center is
next to the Church He said approximately 78 students ranging from 8 weeks of age to preshy
kindergarten attend the Learning Center throughout the day In addition students up to sixth
grade attend the Leaming Center after school
Mr Myers said a youth group of betveen 40 to 50 children meets from 530 pm to 900
pm on Wednesdays These children sometimes play hasketball in the parking lot Ire said that
the parking lot is used by the Church throughout the year for other functions including Bible
Study concerts and car washis Once a year the city has the Blue Bird 1-estial with booths
alo11g the stnxt and a bounce house m the parking lot
rfr Myers said there are approximately 16 parking spaces 011 the sidlt of till street here
Applicant is located I le is concerned that if those spaces are occupied Applicants patrons will
park rn the Church parking lot when children arlt prcsltnt Mr t--1yltrs said the Church did have a
sign that read middotmiddotChurch Parking Only but the sign Vas knocked down a couple of years ago and
Vas never replaced Mr Myers said that people did not pay attention to the sign anyway
He also said the parking lot is bordered on three sides by an alley owned by the City
anyone can use the alley and therefore the Church cannot erect a fence around the parking lot
to keep others out Mr Myers testified that the City docs not have an ordinance restricting the
distance from schools to establishments serving akohol
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 4
Mr Myers said he bclicws the presence of Applicants place of business would have an
adverse cftCct on the public sense of decency Ile said Applicants place of business middotwould not
be a good thing for the children to see when they go to school Furthermore Mr Myers said
Applicants place of business would adversely affect public morals because it Vould not be a
good example forthe children Mr Myersmiddot biggest concern is the adverse effect on public safety
created by Applicants patrons parking in the Church parking lot He fears that intoxicated
drivers could harm the children attending the Church_ Learning Center and their associated
functions
John Nimmo testified on behalf of the individual Protestants Mr Nimmo resides in
Wills Point and is 3 member of the Church He based his testimony on his JO-yearsmiddot experience
as a fire fighter in Dallas lie said there are more incidents of assaults accidents and injured
persons in areas around establishments that srrve alcohol He is concerned that intoxirated
patrons would interact ith Church youth creiting the possibility of an adverse effect on public
satl-ty and public peace llr Nimmo said that prelousl) there ere tO restJurants at the
location here Applicant intends to serve alcohol I le testified that both of those restaurants had
a middotbring your own alcohol polky and their patrons Ould park in the Chunh parking lot
Pat1middoticia Simpson 1lso testified on behalf of the indiidual Protestants Ms Simpson is
the director of the Learning Center She reiterated the testimony of 1r Myers concerning the
times parents and students utilize the Church parking lot Jnd their possible interaction with
Applicants patrons Ms Simpson also said that she has observed that patrons of other
businesses on the same block as Applicant use the Church parking lot
Jason Leath is the owner and operator of Appficant lie testified that Applicant was
previously at another location and he was the owner and operator there for approximately 3
months Mr Leath said that alcohol was sold at the previous location but there ere no alcoholshy
related incidents He said he has an obligation not to serve alcohol to intoxicated people but he
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAll DOCKET NO -158-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION P-Gt 5
Mr Leath showed photographs 3 of parking sraces in front of Applicantdegs establishment
along a perpendicular street approximately a half-block away from the establishment and a
parking lot that Mr Leath said his patrons could use In all Mr Leath showed dozens of parking
spaces within approximately one block from his establishment He said his establishment has a
tin code capacity of80 people
App Exh 3
IV AN AL YSIS
Staff did not take a formal position in this hearing Protestants arc very concerned that
the issuance or the permit vould be detrimental for the pwplc vho attend the Church and the
children who attend the Learning Center While the City of Wills Point does not have an
ordinance restricting the proximity of schools to establishments serving alcohol the possible
adverst ifticts of intoxicated patrons optrating motor Thicks in a parking lot where school
children are present should not be ignored Ir Leath sh(1ed that thtrc arc a numbcr ofpmking
spacLS near his establishment hut it is reasonnhle to conclude that his patrons viii park in the
Church parking lot tr the parking spaces in front of his establish men arc nccupicd the Church
parking lot would be tht cloSLSt pbcL to patmiddotk It is not rLmiddotasonabk to assume the cstah]i-hrncnlmiddots
patrons will rark hair a blocJ ltlmiddotay hen the~ can park Jinctly across the stnct
The sale of alcoholic beverages ln an area so closc to a school could be detrimental to the
health and safety of the children who utilize the parking lot D1middotspitc Mr Lcaths assurance that
he does not serve alcohol to intoxicated individuals there still is a possibility that individuals
consuming alcoholic beverages at Appicantdegs place of business could he intoxicated Mr Leath
admitted it is impossible to determine if someone is slightly over the legal limit The children
attending the Iearning Center or partaking in other Church activities should not be exposed to
individuals who may be driving in the parking lot while intoxicated
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAH DOCKET NO t58-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DFCISION P-GE 6
Based on the evidence the ALJ finds Protestants have proven that the place or manner in
which Applicant may conduct his business warrants tht refusal of the supplemental application
bagted on the general welfare health and safety of the people For this reason the ALJ
recommends the Applicanrs application be denied
V FINDINGS OF FACT
I Caseymiddots (Applicant) holds a Private Club Rcgistrntion Permit and a Beverage Cartage Permit for the premises at 124 West North Commerce Street in Wills Point Texas
2 Applicant has moved to a location directly across the street from the Wills Point First Baptist Church and the First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center
3 Applicant filed a supplemental application with the Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission (TABC or Commission) to transfer its existing permits to its new location
4 Wills Point rirst naptist Church First Baptist Church ills Point Learning Center and 124 individuals (Prntestants) ehnllenged the supplemental application tiled by Applicant with the Commission on the basis that the place or manner In middothich the Apptiant may conduct its bwiness warrants the refusal of the supplernentnl applicntion based on the general welfare health peace morals and -alcty of the people and on the public s1middotnsc of decencmiddot
5 On March [ I 2016 TBCs stnT sen a notice of hearing concerning the protest to Appl leant and Protestants tmiddothe notice included the tirnc date place and nall11 of the hearing the legal authority and jurisdiction under Vhich the hearing was to be held the particular sections of the statutes and rules im olved and a short plain statement of the factual matters asserted
6 The hearing convened August 9 2016 at the State Office of Administrative Hearings (SOAH) in Dallas Texas before Administrative Law Judge (AU) Kyle J Groves Applicant was represented by attorney S George Alfonso Wills Point First Baptist Church and First Baptist Church Wills Point Learning Center were represented by attorney Ed Walton The individual Protestants appeared pro se TABC Staff attorney Edgar M Korzeniovski represented Staff but Staff took no position on the protest The record remained open until September 1 2016 so the parties could file written closing arguments
7 The Church parking lot is used not only hy people attending church but also by parents dropping off and picking up their children at the Learning Center
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060 PROPOSAL FOR DECISION PAGE 7
8 The Church conducts activities in the evenings vherc children and young adults utilize the parking lot
9 Applicants establishment has a fire code capacity of80 people
10 There are approximately 16 parking spaces on the block where Applicants establishment is located Other than these spaces the closest parking spaces to Applicants establishment are in the Church parking lot
11 The Church cannot build a fence to keep people from parking in their parking lot
12 People from businesses on the same block as Applicant park in the Church parking lot
13 Patrons of restaurants that occupied the space now occupied by Applicant parked in the Church parking lot
VI CONCLliSONS OF LAW
The Commission has jurisdiction Omiddotcr this cae -1 ex Alco Bev Code ~~ 531 5J3 535 and 1161
SOH has jurisdiction over matterlt nlatcd to the hearing in this proceeding including the authorit- to issue a proposal fr)r dec1ltion with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law Tc co Bemiddot Codesect 5-D and Tn (Jovmiddot1 Codt ~( 10cn011l1
3 Proper and timely tmtiic of the hcari ng was proYided as required in accordance with Tex Govmiddott Codesect~ 2001051 and 2001052
Based on the Findings of ract and Conclusions of Law the place or manner in hich Applicant may conduct his business arrnnts the refusal of the permits based on the general welfare health and safety of the people pursuant to Tex Alco Bev Code sect I l46(a)(8)
5 The supplemental application should be denied
SIGNED October 18 2016
roves Admmis ativc Law Judge State Office of Ad1ninis1rativc Hearings
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER
Page 1 of 17
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 3rd day of April 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
After proper notice was given this case was heard by the State Office of Administrative
Hearings (SOAH) with Administrative Law Judge Kyle Groves presiding The hearing
convened on August 9 2016 and the SOAH record closed on September 1 2016 The
Administrative Law Judge made and filed a Proposal for Decision containing Findings of Fact
and Conclusions of Law on October 18 2016 The Proposal for Decision was properly served
on all parties who were given an opportunity to file exceptions and replies as part of the record
herein No exceptions were filed
After review and due consideration of the Proposal for Decision I adopt the Findings of
Fact and Conclusions of Law of the Administrative Law Judge that are contained in the Proposal
for Decision and incorporate those Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law into this Or der as if
such were fully set out and separately stated herein
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically adopted herein
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Respondentrsquos supplemental application for the
above permits is DENIED
This Order will become final and enforceable on the 29th day of April 2017 unless a
Motion for Rehearing is filed by the 28th day of April 2017
SIGNED this the 3rd day of April 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 3rd day of April 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764798
S George Alfonso
ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
5340 Alpha Road
Dallas TX 75240
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764781
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764897
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764880
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764873
Page 3 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764866
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764859
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764842
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764835
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764828
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764811
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764804
Page 4 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765191
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765184
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765177
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765160
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765153
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765146
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765139
Page 5 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765122
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765115
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765108
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765092
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765085
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765078
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765061
Page 6 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765054
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765047
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765030
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765023
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765016
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765009
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764996
Page 7 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764989
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764972
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764965
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764958
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764941
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764934
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764927
Page 8 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764910
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764903
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156991
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156984
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156977
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156960
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156953
Page 9 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156946
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156939
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156922
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156915
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 9171082133393775156908
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072765207
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984455
Page 10 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984462
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984479
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984486
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984493
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984509
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984516
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984523
Page 11 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984530
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984356
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984363
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984370
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984387
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984394
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984400
Page 12 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984417
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984424
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984431
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984448
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984257
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984264
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984271
Page 13 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984288
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984295
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984301
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984318
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 7016034000080984325
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984332
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984349
Page 14 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984158
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984165
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70160340000080984172
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984189
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984196
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRR 70160340000080984202
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984219
Page 15 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984226
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984233
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984240
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984141
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984134
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984127
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984110
Page 16 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984103
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984097
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984080
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360
Terrell TX 75161
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984073
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70160340000080984066
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
DOCKET NO 636237
TEXAS ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE
COMMISSION Jurisdictional Petitioner
WILLS POINT FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH
FIRST BAPTIST CHURCH WILLS POINT
LEARNING CENTER ET AL Protestants
VS
IN RE SUPLEMENTAL APPLICATION OF
CASEYrsquoS
DBA CASEYrsquoS Applicant
PERMIT N872991 PE
VAN ZANDT COUNTY TEXAS
(SOAH DOCKET NO 458-16-3060)
BEFORE THE TEXAS
ALCOHOLIC
BEVERAGE COMMISSION
ORDER OVERRULING MOTION FOR REHEARING
CAME ON FOR CONSIDERATION this 18th day of May 2017 the above-styled and
numbered cause
On April 3 2017 an Order was issued denying Respondents supplemental application for
permits On April 25 2017 Respondent filed a timely Motion for Rehearing
Attached to the Motion for Rehearing is the closing argument submitted by Respondents
former counsel after the hearing That document was known to and considered by the
Administrative Law Judge in making his Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law and was part
of the record known to and considered by me when I adopted those Findings and Conclusions
and made them a part of the April 3 2017 Order The arguments contained in that document
were not persuasive then and are not persuasive now
Also attached to the Motion for Rehearing are documents that were not allowed during
the SOAH hearing Since they were not allowed into evidence by the Administrative Law
Judge they are not part of the evidentiary record Government Code sect2001060 Therefore I
cannot base my decision on them and have not considered them Government Code sect2001141
Although an assertion is made in the Motion for Rehearing that their exclusion from the record
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
sect
Page 1 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
__________________________________________
__________________________________________
was error no argument is made supporting that assertion The Motion for Rehearing does not
properly preserve or present any argument that may have been made about whether the
Administrative Law Judge applied the law correctly in excluding the proffered evidence
Having fully considered the arguments set forth in the Motion for Rehearing
Respondents Motion for Rehearing is OVERRULED
All motions requests for entry of Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
and any other requests for general or specific relief submitted by any party are denied unless
specifically granted or adopted herein
Pursuant to Government Code sect2001144(a)(2)(A) this Order is effective on the
date it is signed
SIGNED this the 18th day of May 2017 at Austin Texas
Sherry K-Cook Executive Director
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I certify that the persons listed below were served with a copy of this Order in the manner
indicated below on this the 18th day of May 2017
Martin Wilson Assistant General Counsel
Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission
Page 2 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Kyle Groves
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE
State Office of Administrative Hearings
8700 N Stemmons Suite 126
Dallas TX 75247
VIA FACSIMILE (512) 322-2061
Caseyrsquos dba Caseyrsquos APPLICANT
235 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496752
Ed Walton
ATTORNEY FOR PROTESTANT
101 Metro Drive
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR70050390000575496745
Edgar Korzeniowski
ATTORNEY FOR PETITIONER
TABC Legal Division
VIA E-MAIL edgarkorzeniowskitabctexasgov
Karen Boswell
PROTESTANT
PO Box 21
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496738
Carmen Lugate
PROTESTANT
11645 Betty Lane
Kaufman TX 75142
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496721
Robin and M Francis Mack
PROTESTANT
500 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496714
Page 3 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Richard and Caroline Cunningham
PROTESTANT
2331 VZCR 3501
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496707
Michael and Courtney Morgan
PROTESTANTS
428 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496691
John and Delia Nimmo
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 872
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496684
Daryl and Kathi Self
PROTESTANTS
14088 Hickory Tree Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496677
David Stokes
PROTESTANT
7831 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496660
Darlie and Bob Kee
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 337
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496653
Jody and Elizabeth Paner
PROTESTANTS
2910 VZCR 3417
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764071
Page 4 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Karen Aldridge
PROTESTANT
309 N 6th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764064
Duke Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764057
Mary Jane Hunter
PROTESTANT
111 VZCR 3219
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764040
Ronnie Chitty
PROTESTANT
613 VZCR 2625
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764033
Joan Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496479
Sammons Falcon and Wallace Families
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 787
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496486
Justin and Erin Lowery
PROTESTANTS
426 WN Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496493
Page 5 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Ray Cole
PROTESTANT
524 Pecan
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763814
Moore Family
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 52
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763807
Bob and Lajuan Mayfield
PROTESTANTS
301 VZCR 3807
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763791
Donna Gunter
PROTESTANT
2190 FM 2475
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072763784
Mr and Mrs Kenneth McDougle
PROTESTANTS
405 Mcrain St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072748736
Mr and Mrs Dale A Foster
PROTESTANTS
908 Canton Ave
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496363
Betty and Don Baker
PROTESTANTS
9 Post Oak
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496370
Page 6 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Joyce Ragan
PROTESTANT
4793 VZCR 3504
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496387
Jackie Carl
PROTESTANT
600 Tennessee Circle 18
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496394
Gladys Calloway
PROTESTANT
8053 James
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496400
Carol Burleson
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496417
BJ Arland
PROTESTANT
15149 E I-20
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496424
Eddie Flores
PROTESTANT
4500 Steiner Ranch Blvd 208
Austin TX 78732
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496646
Mr and Mrs James Aycock
PROTESTANTS
11003 Baxter
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496639
Page 7 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Mark Murrey
PROTESTANT
PO Box 612
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496622
Lajuan Dixon
PROTESTANT
301 S Main
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496615
Bobby Dixon
PROTESTANT
PO Box 31
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496608
Earl and Maris Clark
PROTESTANTS
188 VZCR 3415
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496592
Kim Schwenn
PROTESTANT
31729 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496585
Hugh Hall
PROTESTANT
1201 W South Commerce St
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496578
Brent and Kimberly Ragland
PROTESTANTS
951 VZCR 3514
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496554
Page 8 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Karla Myers
PROTESTANT
177 Monning Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496561
Carrie Mikos
PROTESTANT
901 E Oneal
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496844
The Berberich Family
PROTESTANTS
8576 CR 313
Terrell TX 75761
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496837
Harold Moore
PROTESTANT
229 VZCR 3442
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70050390000575496516
Danielle and Brandon Fugate
PROTESTANTS
14131 Clark Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764101
Brian Stokes
PROTESTANT
1288 VZCR 3708
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764118
Dub and Brianna Sewell
PROTESTANTS
1210 CR 3820
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764125
Page 9 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Ann and DD Daniell
PROTESTANTS
PO Box 207
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764132
Johnny Fletcher
PROTESTANT
340 VZCR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764149
Harold and Judy Taylor
PROTESTANTS
189 Meridian Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764156
DD Robinson
PROTESTANT
1101 VZCR 3204
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764163
Thomas Cheek
PROTESTANT
1401 VZCR 3412
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764262
Mildred Lucille Campbell
PROTESTANT
163 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764255
Clara Holden
PROTESTANT
101 VZCR 3404
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764248
Page 10 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Barbara Burnett
PROTESTANT
509 VZCR 3443
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764231
Freddy Nicol
PROTESTANT
31731 SH 64
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764224
Ramelle Sewell
PROTESTANT
8051 FM 751
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764217
Sandra Colgrove
PROTESTANT
1000 Ross St
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764200
Rick Johns
PROTESTANT
PO Box 100
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764194
Paul E Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764187
Ronald Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764170
Page 11 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Melissa Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764279
Gregory and Sonia Brown
PROTESTANTS
2004 Roanoke Road
Keller TX 76262
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764286
Michael Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764293
Bobby Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764309
Crystal Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764316
Mike Barton
PROTESTANT
705 Athens
Canton TX 75103
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764323
Kathryn Johnston
PROTESTANT
604 N 4th
Street
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764330
Page 12 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Moe and Gere Kennedy
PROTESTANTS
760 VZCR
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764347
Brenda T Williams
PROTESTANT
251 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764354
Mary Beth Hurley
PROTESTANT
225 Lynnellen Lane
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764361
Vickey Bradley
PROTESTANT
2863 Waters Edge
Quinlan TX 75474
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764385
Kelly Remmers
PROTESTANT
4310 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764392
Anthony Morgan
PROTESTANT
3325 VZCR 3502
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764408
Bobby Burrow
PROTESTANT
PO Box 177
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764415
Page 13 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Amanda Strutton
PROTESTANT
149 VZCR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764422
Betty Brown
PROTESTANT
PO Box 1477
Terrell TX 75160
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764439
Dave Johnson
PROTESTANT
7324 Crabtree Lane
North Richland Hills TX 76182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764446
Rhonda Brown Cobern
PROTESTANT
6013 Partridge Dr
Fort Worth TX 76135
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764453
Delores Phillips
PROTESTANT
120 Wingo Way
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764460
Lynn King
PROTESTANT
118 Thompson Drive
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764477
John and Kelly Fletcher
PROTESTANTS
452 CR 3528
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLAS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764484
Page 14 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Keith Mack
PROTESTANT
500 CR 2627
Wills Point TX 75169
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764491
Johnny Whittiker
PROTESTANT
523 East Ford Rd
Sunnyvale TX 75182
VIA FIRST CLASS MAILC CMRRR 70012510000072764507
Judy Jeter
PROTESTANT
4337 Oleander Trail
Mesquite TX 75150
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764514
Wanda Kearney
PROTESTANT
5817 Lyons Rd
Garland TX 75043
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764521
Vicki Colegrove
PROTESTANT
9063 Stonehearth Lane
Forney TX 75126
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764538
Renee Mason
PROTESTANT
1431 Ridgeview St
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764545
Cheryl Gipson
PROTESTANT
2612 Montclair Ln
Mesquite TX 75149
VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764552
Page 15 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Esters Mitch
PROTESTANT
6050 Samples Lane Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764569
Greg Moore
PROTESTANT
PO Box 247 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764576
Sterling and Liz Warden
PROTESTANTS
10982 CR 348 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764675
Brent Orms
PROTESTANT
10604 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764668
Richard and Janice Snyder
PROTESTANTS
231 VZCR 3829 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764651
Alan Snyder
PROTESTANT
239 VZCR 3719 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764644
Jeremi Ogdie
PROTESTANT
7515 VZCR 3504 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764637
Page 16 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17
Eddie and Linda Mason
PROTESTANTS
863 VZCR 3515 Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764620
Jeremy P Cunninham
PROTESTANT
16895 CR 247 Terrell TX 75160 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764613
James Parker
PROTESTANT
10612 CR 360 Terrell TX 75161 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764606
Jean Livesay
PROTESTANT
226 E ONeal St Wills Point TX 75169 VIA FIRST CLASS MAIL CMRRR 70012510000072764590
Page 17 of 17