statistics on judgments by state 1959-2010 · subject-matter of violation judgments 4 note : other...
TRANSCRIPT
s
Stat
istic
s 19
59 -
201
0
Statistics onjudgments byState
Subject-matter of violation judgments
2Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Ill-treatments (Art. 3)
8%
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)31%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)20%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)14%
Other rights27%
Bulgaria
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)9%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)32%
Protection of property (P1-1)
36%
Other rights23%
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)10%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
30%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)37%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
6%
Prohibition of discrimination
(Art. 14)6%
Other rights11%
Belgium
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)12%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
19%
Non enforcement (Art. 6)13%
Protection of property (P1-1)
20%
Other rights36%
Azerbaijan
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
32%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)30%
Freedom of expression
(Art. 10)12%
Prohibition of discrimination
(Art. 14)8%
Other rights18%
Austria
Ill-treatments (Art. 3)15%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
34%
Freedom of assembly and
association(Art. 11)
15%
Protection of property (P1-1)
10%
Other rights26%
Armenia
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)50%
Prohibition of discrimination
(Art. 14)50%
Andorra
Other rights12%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
44%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)6%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)16%
Protection of property (P1-1)
22%
Albania
Subject-matter of violation judgments
3Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Ill-treatments(Art. 3)24%
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)21%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)16%
Protection of property (P1-1)
10%
Other rights29%
GeorgiaRight to liberty and security
(Art. 5)7%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)34%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)39%
Protection of property (P1-1)
4%
Other rights16%
France
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)26%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)40%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)13%
Freedom of expression (Art. 10)
10%
Other rights11%
FinlandRight to liberty and security
(Art. 5)32%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)16%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)16%
No punishment without law
(Art. 7)16%
Other rights20%
Estonia
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)50%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)12%
Other rights38%
Denmark
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)13%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)24%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)42%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
7%Right to an
effective remedy (Art. 13)
7%
Other rights7%
Czech Republic
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)10%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)45%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
9%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)12%
Other rights24%
Cyprus
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)26%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)40%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)13%
Protection of property (P1-1)
7%
Other rights14%
Croatia
Subject-matter of violation judgments
4Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)16%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)17%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)33%
Freedom of expression (Art. 10)
17%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)17%
LiechtensteinIll-treatments
(Art. 3)8%
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)28%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
11%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)8%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)19%
Other rights26%
Latvia
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)12%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)57%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
7%
Protection of property (P1-1)
15%
Other rights9%
ItalyRight to a fair
trial (Art. 6)21%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)25%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)21%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)16%
Other rights17%
Ireland
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)11%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)45%
Freedom of expression (Art. 10)
11%
Freedom of assembly and
association (Art. 11)
22%
Protection of property (P1-1)
11%
Iceland
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)3%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)3%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)82%
Freedom of expression(Art. 10)
2%
Other rights 9%
Hungary
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)16%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)48%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)14%
Protection of property (P1-1)
8%
Other rights14%
Greece
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)9%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)10%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)51%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)10%
Other rights20%
Germany
Subject-matter of violation judgments
5Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)43%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)9%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)14%
Freedom of expression(Art. 10)
24%
Other rights10%
Norway
Ill-treatments (Art. 3)11% Right to liberty
and security (Art. 5)25%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)24%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)9%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)16%
Other rights15%
Netherlands
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)33,3%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)33,3%
Protection of property (P1-1)
33,3%
Montenegro
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)100%
Monaco
Ill-treatments (Art. 3)16%
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)13%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)25%
Protection of property (P1-1)
20%
Other rights26%
MoldovaRight to liberty and security
(Art. 5)33%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)17%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)17%
Protection of property (P1-1)
17%
Other rights17%
Malta
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)26%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)42%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
8%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)8%
Other rights16%
LuxembourgRight to liberty and security
(Art. 5)23%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)17%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)25%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)16%
Other rights19%
Lithuania
Subject-matter of violation judgments
6Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)50%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
1%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)47%
Other rights2%
SloveniaRight to liberty and security
(Art. 5)10%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)7%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)63%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)8%
Other rights12%
Slovakia
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)18%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)23%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)18%
Protection of property (P1-1)
14%
Other rights27%
SerbiaRight to a fair
trial (Art. 6)64%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)18%
Freedom of thought,
conscience and religion (Art. 9)
9%
Protection of property (P1-1)
9%
San Marino
Ill-treatments (Art. 3)15%
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)14%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)21%
Protection of property (P1-1)
17%
Other rights33%
Russia
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)6%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)30%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)7%
Protection of property (P1-1)
38%
Other rights19%
Romania
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)12%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)51%
Freedom of expression (Art. 10)
8%
Protection of property (P1-1)
21%
Other rights8%
Portugal
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)28%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)9%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)44%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)
9%
Other rights10%
Poland
Subject-matter of violation judgments
7Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)16%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)24%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)17%
Prohibition of discimination
(Art. 14)12%
Other rights31%
United Kingdom
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)33%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)15%
Right to an effective remedy
(Art. 13)11%
Protection of property (P1-1)
23%
Other rights18%
UkraineRight to liberty
and security (Art. 5)15%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)21%Length of
proceedings (Art. 6)13%
Protection of property (P1-1)
17%
Other rights34%
Turkey
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)7%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)19%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)56%
Other rights18%
"The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"Right to liberty
and security (Art. 5)17%
Right to a fair trial
(Art. 6)32%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)18%
Freedom of expression (Art. 10)
15%
Other rights18%
Switzerland
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
42%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)20%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)10%
Protection of property(P1-1) 8%
Other rights20%
Sweden
Ill-treatments(Art. 3)
5%
Right to liberty and security
(Art. 5)5%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6)
47%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)19%
Right to respect for private and
family life (Art. 8)10%
Freedom of expression
(Art. 10)5%
Other rights9%
Spain
Subject-matter of violation judgments
8Note : Other judgments : just satisfaction, revision judgments, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction
Right to liberty and security (Art. 5)11%
Right to a fair trial (Art. 6) 20%
Length of proceedings
(Art. 6)26%
Protection of property (P1-1)
14%
Other rights29%
All 47 States
Only the rights enshrined in Article 6 of the Convention are outlined in detail.
Type of judgment
9
Violation92%
No violation5%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
1%
Other judgments
2%
Bulgaria
Violation100%
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Violation70%
No violation12%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
10%
Other judgments
8%
Belgium
Violation90%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
5%
Other judgments
5%
Azerbaijan
Violation75%
No violation13%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
8%
Other judgments
4%
Austria
Violation96%
No violation4%
Armenia
Violation50%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
25%
Other judgments
25%
Andorra
Violation85%
No violation4%
Other judgments
11%
Albania
Type of judgment
10
Violation82%
No violation15%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
3%
Georgia
Violation74%
No violation14%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
8%
Other judgments
4%
France
Violation79%
No violation14%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
6%
Other judgments
1%
Finland
Violation83%
No violation13%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
4%
Estonia
Violation38%
No violation27%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
32%
Other judgments
3%
Denmark
Violation90%
No violation3%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
5%
Other judgments
2%
Czech Republic
Violation83%
No violation7%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
5%
Other judgments
5%
Cyprus
Violation81%
No violation4%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
14%
Other judgments
1%
Croatia
Type of judgment
11
Violation100%
Liechtenstein
Violation82%
No violation11%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
7%
Latvia
Violation76%
No violation2%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
17%
Other judgments
5%
Italy
Violation60%
No violation20%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
4%
Other judgments
16%
Ireland
Violation75%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
25%
Iceland
Violation95%
No violation2%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
3%Other
judgments0,1%
Hungary
Violation88%
No violation3%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
3%
Other judgments
6%
Greece
Violation66%
No violation24%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
5%
Other judgments
5%
Germany
Type of judgment
12
Violation71%
No violation29%
Norway
Violation57%
No violation22%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
12%
Other judgments
9%
Netherlands
Violation100%
Montenegro
Violation100%
Monaco
Violation91%
No violation1%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
1% Other judgments
7%
Moldova
Violation81%
No violation6%
Other judgments
13%
Malta
Violation81%
No violation11%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
8%
Luxembourg
Violation80%
No violation11%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
9%
Lithuania
Type of judgment
13
Violation95%
No violation4%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
1%
Slovenia
Violation88%
No violation2%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
8%
Other judgments
2%
Slovakia
Violation94%
No violation4%
Other judgments
2%
Serbia
Violation73%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
18%
Other judgments
9%
San Marino
Violation94%
No violation4%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
1%
Other judgments
1%
Russia
Violation91%
No violation3%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
3%
Other judgments
3%
Romania
Violation67%
No violation3%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
27%
Other judgments
3%
Portugal
Violation87%
No violation7%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
5%
Other judgments
1%
Poland
Type of judgment
14
Violation61%
No violation19%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
15%
Other judgments
5%
United Kingdom
Violation99%
No violation0,5%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
0,25%
Other judgments
0,25%
Ukraine
Violation87%
No violation2%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
8%
Other judgments
3%
Turkey
Violation92%
No violation4%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
4%
"The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"
Violation70%No violation
23%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
5%
Other judgments
2%
Switzerland
Violation50%No violation
23%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
24%
Other judgments
3%
Sweden
Violation62%
No violation34%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
2%Other
judgments2%
Spain
Type of judgment
15
Violation83%
No violation6%
Friendly settlements / Striking out judgments
8%
Other judgments3%
All 47 States
Judgments and decisions
16
Applications inadmissible /
struck out93%
Judgments7%
Bulgaria
Applications inadmissible /
struck out99%
Judgments1%
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Applications inadmissible /
struck out95%
Judgments5%
Belgium
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Azerbaijan
Applications inadmissible /
struck out96%
Judgments4%
Austria
Applications inadmissible /
struck out95%
Judgments5%
Armenia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out88%
Judgments12%
Andorra
Applications inadmissible /
struck out86%
Judgments14%
Albania
Judgments and decisions
17
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Georgia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out96%
Judgments4%
France
Applications inadmissible /
struck out95%
Judgments5%
Finland
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Estonia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Denmark
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Czech Republic
Applications inadmissible /
struck out89%
Judgments11%
Cyprus
Applications inadmissible /
struck out96%
Judgments4%
Croatia
Judgments and decisions
18
Applications inadmissible /
struck out92%
Judgments8%
Liechtenstein
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Latvia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out82%
Judgments18%
Italy
Applications inadmissible /
struck out96%
Judgments4%
Ireland
Applications inadmissible /
struck out91%
Judgments9%
Iceland
Applications inadmissible /
struck out94%
Judgments6%
Hungary
Applications inadmissible /
struck out83%
Judgments17%
Greece
Applications inadmissible /
struck out99%
Judgments1%
Germany
Judgments and decisions
19
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Norway
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Netherlands
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Montenegro
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Monaco
Applications inadmissible /
struck out92%
Judgments8%
Moldova
Applications inadmissible /
struck out78%
Judgments22%
Malta
Applications inadmissible /
struck out91%
Judgments9%
Luxembourg
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Lithuania
Judgments and decisions
20
Applications inadmissible /
struck out93%
Judgments7%
Slovenia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out94%
Judgments6%
Slovakia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out99%
Judgments1%
Serbia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out78%
Judgments22%
San Marino
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Russia
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Romania
Applications inadmissible /
struck out89%
Judgments11%
Portugal
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Poland
Judgments and decisions
21
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
United Kingdom
Applications inadmissible /
struck out96%
Judgments4%
Ukraine
Applications inadmissible /
struck out88%
Judgments12%
Turkey
Applications inadmissible /
struck out95%
Judgments5%
"The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"
Applications inadmissible /
struck out97%
Judgments3%
Switzerland
Applications inadmissible /
struck out98%
Judgments2%
Sweden
Applications inadmissible /
struck out99%
Judgments1%
Spain
Judgments and decisions
22
Applications inadmissible /
struck out96%
Judgments4%
All 47 States
s
www.echr.coe.intProvisional Edition (September 2011)
This document has been prepared by the Public RelationsUnit of the Court and does not bind the Court
For more information, see the Table of violationby Article and by State