stimulating the brain in epilepsy anli liu md ma assistant professor of neurology nyu faces 2013...
TRANSCRIPT
Stimulating the Brain in Epilepsy
Anli Liu MD MAAssistant Professor of Neurology
NYU FACES 2013 Epilepsy ConferenceMay 5, 2013
Background: An Unmet Need
• About 2/3 of patients with epilepsy will achieve seizure control with medications
• Despite the introduction of 14 new anti-epileptic medications since 1993, there is still a huge need for patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE)
• Seizure surgery is the best option for DRE patients and offers the best chance for seizure freedom.
• However, some patients are not eligible for seizure surgeryBergey, 2013
Background: Neurostimulation
Neurostimulation options for patients with poorly controlled partial-onset epilepsy
Recent completion of well-designed large clinical
Trials
Advances in brain stimulation and
hardware technology
Background: Neurostimulation
While counterintuitive, delivering an excitatory stimulation during a seizure canDisrupt the seizure and prevent its spread. Mechanism not understood.
Background: Neurostimulation
Potential benefits:• Absent or minimal side effect profile• No teratogenicity• Distinct mechanism of action• Can occur automatically and as a supplementary treatment
Background: Partial vs. Generalized Epilepsy
Partial Epilepsy• Seizure starts from one side • Most adult-onset epilepsy• 50% have seizure control with medications
Generalized Epilepsy• Seizure starts from both sides • Most childhood and adolescent onset • Primary generalized w 80% seizure control
Background: Neurostimulation
While stimulating the brain in epilepsy seems counterintuitive, these therapies could
potentially be an excellent treatment option for patients with partial onset seizures who
are not candidates for surgery.
Neurostimulation
Invasive Non-invasive
• Vagal Nerve Stimulation (FDA 1997)
• Deep Brain Stimulation (Thalamus) (Appr. Europe and Canada 2012)
• Responsive Neurostimulation (RNS) (FDA approval pending)
• Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)
• Transcranial Current Stimulation (TCS)
Larger, multicenter controlled trialsFDA approval granted or pending
Smaller, pilot studiesApplications in epilepsy, cognition,Psychiatry, and many other neuroLogic disorders.
Invasive Neurostimulation• Vagal Nerve
Stimulation (VNS)• Deep Brain
Stimulation (thalamus)
• Responsive Neurostimulation (RNS)
A vagal nerve stimulator
Vagal Nerve Stimulation• First FDA approved device for
epilepsy and treatment refractory depression (1997)
• The most prevalent neurostimulation method (60,000 patients in US)
• Programmed to have constant modulation, and a magnet rescue setting
• Trials demonstrate between 25-50% of patients had a reduction of >50% of seizure frequency; few become seizure free.*
• Very safe. Side effects of hoarseness and cough.
Vagus Nerve Stimulation
Leads are wrapped around the vagus nerve in the neck. Through an unknown Mechanism, can decrease the frequency of seizures in partial onset epilepsy.
Fridley Neurosurg Focus 2012
Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS)
Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) has been FDA approved for Parkinson’sDisease and Esssential Tremor and is now investigated for epilepsy
Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) of the Anterior Thalamus
DBS delivers continuous low-level stimulation
The anterior thalamus has widespread connectionsAnd is an attractive target.
Patients can have multiple seizure onset zones
DBS Thalamus
• A multicenter controlled trial (SANTE, Fisher 2010) of patients with poorly controlled partial epilepsy*
40% decrease in seizure frequency after 3 months44% decrease for temporal lobe epilepsy56% decrease by 2 years13% were seizure free for at least 6 months
• Safe: no significant bleeding or death.• Side effects: Sensory changes (18%), transient
memory impairment and depression• Approved in Europe and Canada, but not in US.
Responsive Neuro Stimulation(RNS, Neuropace)• Depth electrodes Are placed into or nearThe seizure focus andConnected to a Neurostimulator Implanted into thePatient’s skull.
• Continuous EEG Is recorded by implantedcomputer
• When a seizure is Detected, electricalStimulation is deliveredAnd stops the seizure fromspreading
Fridley Neurosurg Focus 2012
Responsive Nerve Stimulation (RNS)• Large controlled trial
(Morell,2011) with drug resistant partial onset epilepsy showed a 38% seizure reduction
• Progressive improvement over time: 50% reduction at 2 years.
• Improvement in quality of life, Verbal ability, and memory• Retention 90% at 3 years,
reflecting good side effect profile• Major risks: infection and
bleeding• Waiting FDA approval
A patient with temporal lobe
epilepsy and RNS device.
Bergey 2013
Summary: Invasive Neurostimulation
PROS
• Could be an excellent therapy for patients with partial onset seizures who are not candidates for surgery.
• Good efficacy (25-40% seizure Reduction) with improved benefit over time
• Good safety profile
• May spare from side effects from epilepsy medications
CONS
• Range from slightly invasive (VNS) to invasive (anterior thalamic and RNS) neurosurgical procedures
• Risks are bleeding and infection
• Optimal stimulation parameters not proven
• Number of seizure free patients is very low, partly because of patients enrolled in studies
Non-invasive stimulation
Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)
Transcranial Current Stimulation (TCS)
Why the excitement?
We can stimulate a superficial area to activate Deeper and widespread networks
To produce temporary and long-lasting effects
• Depression (FDA cleared)• Parkinsons Disease• Stroke• Pain• Epilepsy• Schizophrenia• Autism• Tinnitus• Alzheimer’s Disease• Tourette’s syndrome• Ataxia
Many Treatment Applications in Neuropsychiatric Disorders
Research with noninvasive stimulation is rapidly growing (71)
Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)
TMS uses an alternating magnetic field to produce a secondary current in the underlying brain tissue
TMS-guidance with MRI Brain
Co-registration of the TMS wand with the patient’s MRI Brain increases precision.Useful for presurgical planning.
TMS for Epilepsy• As seizures arise from areas of hyperexcitability, we apply low-frequency
TMS to suppress this activity
• Since 2002, a few controlled trials published showing mixed results:No significant effect Significant Decrease in Sz frequencyTheodore (2002)* Fregni (2005)Joo (2007) Fregni (2006)*Cantello (2007) Santiago (2008)
Sun (2012)
• Mix of findings due to mixed patients and protocols
• Meta-analysis of low-frequency rTMS (Hsu 2011) shows modest reduction in seizure frequency
Seizure Reduction after rTMS (Bae 2007)
Suggestion of TMS benefit persisting between 2 to 8 weeks after stimulation.
TMS Batwing (H) Coil: Stimulating Deep Targets
• Batwing Coil increases Depth of Penetration, up to 6 cm
• Currently a Pilot Study of Deep TMS in Patients with Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (Rotenberg)
TMS Safety
• Rare reports of seizure (1.4%) Bae 2007• Most seizures typical in character and duration• No reported instances of status epilepticus• Safety guidelines are now published
Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS)
• Application of a weak direct current (1-2 mA) to scalp• Modulation of brain activity, can enhance or suppress
tCS advantages
• Easy to use
• Low cost
• Non-invasive
• Painless
• Long lasting effects
• Few mild side effects (itching, tingling, headache, burning sensation and discomfort limited to the scalp site)
• Safe: no reports of seizures
Safety in tDCS
Brunoni 2011
tDCS for Epilepsy
Fregni (2006): RCT of single 20 minute session of over cortical malformation showed trend toward reduction in seizure frequency
Potentially good for patients with partial onset epilepsy with a seizure focus that is near the surface
HD-tDCS for Ongoing Focal Seizures(Alex Rotenberg, MD PhD, CHB/Harvard)
•Targeted direct current stimulation may produce a more potent effect.
Summary: Non-Invasive Neurostimulation
PROS
• Could be an excellent therapy for patients with partial onset seizures where seizure focus is superficial.
• Noninvasive
• Safe
• May spare from side effects from epilepsy medications
• May eventually be a portable, inexpensive office or home treatment
CONS
• Current research is early with mixed results
• Treatments will likely need to be repeated
• Optimal stimulation parameters not proven
Research at NYU Comprehensive Epilepsy Center
• Efficacy of TDCS for Working Memory Dysfunction and Depression in Patients with Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (now recruiting)
• TCS during Sleep to Improve Cognition in Epilepsy
Research Question
In patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), what is the efficacy of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) on:•Working Memory Dysfunction?•Depression?•Seizure Frequency?•Interictal Discharges/EEG?
Study Design
A double-blinded, randomized, sham-controlled trial of tDCS on patients diagnosed with temporal lobe epilepsy
Outcomes: • Verbal and visuospatial working memory tests• Mood questionnaires• Seizure frequency• Interictal discharge frequency
Study Design
• Participation involves 8 visits (1-3 hrs)• Subjects undergo memory and mood testing, 20 minutes of EEG at baseline• Five (5) sessions of real of sham tDCS• Repeat testing and EEG• Followup at 2 and 4 weeks
Compensated $50 a visit.
Summary: Neurostimulation
Invasive Non-invasive
• Vagal Nerve Stimulation (FDA 1997)
• Anterior Thalamic Stimulation (Appr. Europe and Canada 2012)
• Responsive Neurostimulation (RNS) (FDA approval pending)
• Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)
• Transcranial Current Stimulation (TCS)
Larger, multicenter controlled trialsFDA approval granted or pending
Smaller, pilot studiesApplications in epilepsy, cognition,Psychiatry, and many other neuroLogic disorders.
Summary: Neurostimulation
While stimulating the brain in epilepsy seems counterintuitive, these therapies could
potentially be an excellent treatment option for patients with partial onset seizures who
are not candidates for surgery.
Summary: Neurostimulation
Discuss your eligibility for neurostimulation with your epilepsy doctor.
Supporting research is important:Find out how you can get involved!
ReferencesBergey G., Neurostimulation in the Treatment of Epilepsy, Experimental Neurology, epub 2013Fridley et al. Brain Stimulation for the Treatment of Epilepsy, Neurosurg Focus 32 (3) E 13, 2012.Morrell MJ. Responsive Cortical Stimulation for the Treatment of Medically Intractable Partial Epilepsy, Neurology 2011.