substantive restrictions on marriage why do we care?
Post on 20-Dec-2015
215 views
TRANSCRIPT
Non-relation restrictions (Incest) What is this substantive restriction
on marriage and what are the variations one might find among the states?
Non-relation restrictions (Incest) How does the state justify this
restriction on marriage? Note the Snyder article on page 8 –
variations on arguing government interest and the role of morality arguments.
Non-relation restrictions (Incest) How could one argue that those
interests are not legitimate state interests or that the substantive restriction is not tailored to meet those interests?
Constitutional Analysis? Equal Protection : Race (rejected argument of equal
treatment as a class and focused on individual choices)
Due Process: Liberty Interest Marriage? Characterized as “a
"basic" civil right of man”
Describe the Wisconsin Statute:
Court approval required if:Non-custodial parent & EITHER Non-payment of support obligationOR Child would be a “public charge”
Due Process Analysis: 1. Characterize the Right
Is there a fundamental right? Right to marry is of "fundamental
importance“ What are the origins of this right? Right to privacy
Due Process Analysis: 1. What level of
scrutiny? Depends on: Whether the regulation is a
“significant intrusion” on the right to marry
If not, reasonableness If so, "Critical examination"
What is “Critical Examination”? Comparable to strict
scrutiny “Sufficiently
important” state interest
“Closely tailored” to effectuate those interests.
How does the statute fail? Under inclusive: - law doesn't prohibit additional
financial burden Over inclusive: - maybe second spouse will help
pay
Other opinions Stewart (concur): marriage is a privilege Powell (concur): substantially interfere
test is too fuzzy; need to defer to state Stevens (concur): economic status is
key Rehnquest (dissent) - deference to state
Why does Mr. Zablocki care? Legal sex?: "marriage is only
relationship in which the state of Wisconsin allows sexual relations to legally take place“
Practical benefits of marriage? Symbolic benefits of marriage?
News Flash!
Wisconsin v. Oakley Father who has refused to pay
child support can be required to avoid having another child, unless he shows that he can support that child and his current children.
Test your understanding: All persons marrying for the first
time must attend state‑licensed counseling sessions, addressing management of finances and interpersonal relations. Sessions cost $50.00. To obtain license, must have a certificate of completion.
Same-Sex Marriage What is this substantive restriction
on marriage and what are the variations one might find among the states?
Same-Sex Marriage How could one argue that those
interests are not legitimate state interests or that the substantive restriction is not tailored to meet those interests?
Age restrictions What is this substantive restriction
on marriage and what are the variations one might find among the states?
Monogamy requirements What is this substantive restriction
on marriage and what are the variations one might find among the states?
Monogamy How could one argue that those
interests are not legitimate state interests or that the substantive restriction is not tailored to meet those interests?