summary of energetic particle...

32
SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONS Boris Breizman, Nikolai Gorelenkov and Energetic Particle Group 21st US Transport Task Force Workshop Boulder, Colorado March 25 - 28, 2008 Statistics: 22 talks = 10(experiment)+12(theory/modeling) 7 talks by students

Upload: others

Post on 23-Mar-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONS

Boris Breizman, Nikolai Gorelenkov and Energetic Particle Group

21st US Transport Task Force WorkshopBoulder, Colorado

March 25 - 28, 2008

Statistics:22 talks = 10(experiment)+12(theory/modeling)7 talks by students

Page 2: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 3: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Highlights of Presentations

Page 4: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM &acoustic modes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 5: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

E. E. Edlund (presented by M. Porkolab) “Experimental study of reversed shear Alfvén eigenmodesduring ICRF minority heating and relationship to sawtooth crash phenomena in Alcator C-Mod”

Page 6: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

N.N. Gorelenkov “Properties of reversed shear Alfvén eigenmodes in ideal MHD”

Kinetic treatment developed forreversed shear Alfvén eigenmodes (Alfvén cascades with downwardfrequency sweeping)

Slowly varying part of the modeagrees with MHD theory

Page 7: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

R. Nazikian “N=0 axisymmetric mode in DIII-D”

TAEs QC modeTAEs

GAM

Page 8: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

G.Y. Fu ”Energetic particle-induced geodesic acoustic mode ”

Page 9: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

C. Nguyen“Theoretical and experimental study of the threshold for kinetic-MHD beta Alfvén eigenmodedestabilization in Tore-Supra”

Page 10: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 11: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

E.D. Fredrickson “Toroidal Alfvén eigenmode avalanches”

Page 12: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Scintillator imagesrecorded by fastvideocamera

Particles with a broadrange of pitch-angles arelost when multiple modesare present

D. S. Darrow “Neutral beam ion loss during EPMs and RSAEs in NSTX plasmas”

Page 13: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

D. Liu “Correlations of signals of neutral particle analyzer diagnostics with instability bursts”

Page 14: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD(Y.Zang, Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 15: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Y. Zhang “Observation of Doppler-shifted cyclotron resonance of fast ions with shear Alfvén waves”

Page 16: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

T. A. Carter “Studies of nonlinear processes associated with Alfvén and drift-Alfvén waves”

Page 17: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

J. Pratt“Drft-wave eigenmopdes and spectral gaps in tandem mirrors”

Page 18: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 19: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

C. Deng (presented by D. Brower) “Fast-electron-driven instabilities in the HSX stellarator ”

Page 20: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

A. Macor “Fast particle triggered modes: experimental investigation of electron fishbones”

Page 21: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

J. Snipes“Fast electron driven Alfvén eigenmodes in the current rise”

Page 22: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 23: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

D. A. Spong “Energetic particle stability and confinement issues in 3D configurations”

Page 24: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 25: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

R.V. Budny ”Predictions of fast ion parameters in ITER plasmas”

Minor

Page 26: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acousticmodes) (Edlund, Gorelenkov, Fu, Nazikian, Nguyen)

Experimental evidence for avalanche particle losses in NSTX(Fredrickson, Darrow, Liu)

Fundamental examination of wave-particle physics in LAPD (Y.Zang,Carter, Pratt)

Fast electron driven modes (Brower, Macor, Snipes)

Progress in modeling 3-D configurations (Spong)

Integrated ITER-oriented modeling (Budny)

Gyrokinetic simulations take-off (Chu, Lin, Nishimura, Lang, W.Zhang,Dannert)

Trends and Developments in Energetic Particle Area

Page 27: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Z. Lin “Gyrokinetic simulation of energetic particle turbulence and transport”

Page 28: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

Y. Nishimura “Gyrokinetic particle simulation of toroidicity induced Alfvén eigenmode”

(GTC)

Page 29: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

M. Chu “Gyrokinetic simulation of energetic particle driven TAE modes”

GYRO

Page 30: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

J. Lang “Gyrokinetic delta-f simulation of energetic particle driven modes”

GEM

Page 31: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

W. Zhang “Turbulent transport of energetic particles by microturbulence”

(GTC)

Page 32: SUMMARY of ENERGETIC PARTICLE SESSIONSfusion.gat.com/conferences/ttf08/files/fri/Breizman_TTF_2008_EP_Summary.pdf · Continuing interest to low-frequency perturbations (GAM & acoustic

T. Dannet “Turbulent transport of beam ions”

(GENE)