summary of evidence“in pediatric and adolescents with a chronic illness, do electronic resources...

1
“In pediatric and adolescents with a chronic illness, do electronic resources and electronic communication based interventions improve positive treatment outcomes and treatment adherence?” Search Strategy Databases searched: CINAHL, Academic Search Premier, MEDLINE and AUM’s Cochrane. The keywords used in our search included: pediatrics, adolescents, electronics, compliance, adherence, text-messaging, internet, cell phone, e-health, and e-mail. To be included in our analysis, studies needed to have a population consisting primarily of pediatric and adolescent patients, published in a peer-reviewed journal, and involve an intervention that used an electronic resource or communication method to improve treatment outcomes. After searching in the databases and narrowing our article choices, all of our articles came from the CINAHL database. Recommendations When measuring adherence to a medical treatment program, we recommend more than one measure needs to be used. Ideally adherence should be measured using an electronic monitor and a daily diary that operates through the patient’s mobile device. Grade A (Militello et al., 2012; Quittner et al., 2008) Text message and email reminders are extremely effective in improving patient outcomes and need to be timed to coincide with the action they are related to. For example, if a child’s blood glucose needs to be checked before breakfast, the message should be programmed to be delivered shortly before the child eats. Grade A (Militello et al., 2012; Hanauer et al., 2009) Reminders should be sent to patients to bring materials pertinent to their health maintenance (e.g. blood glucose meters and medication lists) to their clinical visits. Grade B (Hanauer et al., 2009) Summary of Evidence Young people are a difficult age group for health care providers to reach and promote treatment adherence and healthy behaviors. Adherence to medication regimens is usually below 50% and poor treatment compliance is the number one cause of treatment failure (Quittner et al., 2008). Personalization of messages, timing of messages, and the use of text message over E-mail showed improved treatment adherence and compliance (Cushing & Steele, 2010; Hanauer et al., 2009; Militello et al., 2012) Studies showed great correlation between electronic interventions and health improvements in the pediatric patients The liver transplant study showed decreased rejection rates in pediatric transplant patients receiving text message reminders (Miloh et al., 2009). “Sweet Talk” study showed 81% improved self-management of pediatric diabetes patients receiving reminder text messages (Franklin et al., 2006). Automated message systems are found to be cost effective, time efficient, and close the generation gap (Militello et al., 2012; Franklin et al., 2006) Research in this subject are still new and more studies need to be conducted

Upload: others

Post on 03-Aug-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Summary of Evidence“In pediatric and adolescents with a chronic illness, do electronic resources and electronic communication based interventions improve positive treatment outcomes

“In pediatric and adolescents with a chronic illness, do electronic resources and electronic communication based interventions

improve positive treatment outcomes and treatment adherence?”

Search Strategy • Databases searched: CINAHL, Academic Search Premier, MEDLINE and AUM’s Cochrane. • The keywords used in our search included: pediatrics, adolescents, electronics, compliance, adherence, text-messaging, internet, cell phone, e-health, and e-mail. • To be included in our analysis, studies needed to have a population consisting primarily of pediatric and adolescent patients, published in a peer-reviewed journal, and involve an intervention that used an electronic resource or communication method to improve treatment outcomes. • After searching in the databases and narrowing our article choices, all of our articles came from the CINAHL database.

Recommendations

• When measuring adherence to a medical treatment program, we recommend more than one measure needs to be used. Ideally adherence should be measured using an electronic monitor and a daily diary that operates through the patient’s mobile device. • Grade A • (Militello et al., 2012; Quittner et al., 2008) • Text message and email reminders are extremely effective in improving patient outcomes and need to be timed to coincide with the action they are related to. For example, if a child’s blood glucose needs to be checked before breakfast, the message should be programmed to be delivered shortly before the child eats. • Grade A • (Militello et al., 2012; Hanauer et al., 2009) • Reminders should be sent to patients to bring materials pertinent to their health maintenance (e.g. blood glucose meters and medication lists) to their clinical visits. • Grade B • (Hanauer et al., 2009)

Summary of Evidence

• Young people are a difficult age group for health care providers to reach and promote treatment adherence and healthy behaviors.

• Adherence to medication regimens is usually below 50% and poor treatment compliance is the number one cause of treatment failure (Quittner et al., 2008).

• Personalization of messages, timing of messages, and the use of text message over E-mail showed improved treatment adherence and compliance (Cushing & Steele, 2010; Hanauer et al., 2009; Militello et al., 2012)

• Studies showed great correlation between electronic interventions and health improvements in the pediatric patients

• The liver transplant study showed decreased rejection rates in pediatric transplant patients receiving text message reminders (Miloh et al., 2009).

• “Sweet Talk” study showed 81% improved self-management of pediatric diabetes patients receiving reminder text messages (Franklin et al., 2006).

• Automated message systems are found to be cost effective, time efficient, and close the generation gap (Militello et al., 2012; Franklin et al., 2006)

• Research in this subject are still new and more studies need to be conducted