summary report - seameo hom on sea-tvet, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · summary report . the 5th high...

40
1 | Page Hosted by the Ministry of Education of Brunei Darussalam, Politeknik Brunei (PB), Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) and International Affairs Unit (MoE) SUMMARY REPORT The 5 th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and Training (SEA-TVET) with the theme of “Strengthening Efforts towards TVET 4.0” was organised by the Ministry of Education of Brunei Darussalam, Politeknik Brunei (PB), Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE), and International Affairs Unit (MoE) on 9-10 September 2019 at The Centrepoint Hotel, Gadong. Brunei Darussalam. The meeting aimed to: 1) discuss the current situation of TVET collaboration during 2018-2019; 2) identify the strategies to improve the regional cooperation and harmonisation for the region; 3) determine and plan for the regional directions and strategies to advance quality of TVET in Southeast Asian countries that may enhance the responsiveness of the member states and the region towards Industry 4.0; and 4) strengthen cooperation among the TVET Ministries/Departments and TVET development agencies among Southeast Asia and with other countries beyond Southeast Asian. The meeting was officially opened on 9 September 2019 by His Excellency Dato Seri Setia Awang Haji Hamzah bin Haji Sulaiman, the Minister of Education of Brunei Darussalam. The SEAMEO Secretariat Director, Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela also gave an opening remarks, The meeting was attended by approximately 104 delegates who are Secretary Generals/Director Generals/Directors on TVET of Ministries of Education, Ministries of Labour and Training, Ministries of Science and Technology, Ministries of Higher Education and other related Ministries from the

Upload: others

Post on 01-Dec-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

1 | P a g e

Hosted by the Ministry of Education of Brunei Darussalam, Politeknik Brunei (PB), Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) and International Affairs Unit (MoE)

SUMMARY REPORT

The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and Training (SEA-TVET) with the theme of “Strengthening Efforts towards TVET 4.0” was organised by the Ministry of Education of Brunei Darussalam, Politeknik Brunei (PB), Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE), and International Affairs Unit (MoE) on 9-10 September 2019 at The Centrepoint Hotel, Gadong. Brunei Darussalam. The meeting aimed to:

1) discuss the current situation of TVET collaboration during 2018-2019; 2) identify the strategies to improve the regional cooperation and harmonisation for the

region; 3) determine and plan for the regional directions and strategies to advance quality of TVET

in Southeast Asian countries that may enhance the responsiveness of the member states and the region towards Industry 4.0; and

4) strengthen cooperation among the TVET Ministries/Departments and TVET development agencies among Southeast Asia and with other countries beyond Southeast Asian.

The meeting was officially opened on 9 September 2019 by His Excellency Dato Seri Setia Awang Haji Hamzah bin Haji Sulaiman, the Minister of Education of Brunei Darussalam. The SEAMEO Secretariat Director, Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela also gave an opening remarks,

The meeting was attended by approximately 104 delegates who are Secretary Generals/Director Generals/Directors on TVET of Ministries of Education, Ministries of Labour and Training, Ministries of Science and Technology, Ministries of Higher Education and other related Ministries from the

Page 2: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

2 | P a g e

Southeast Asian countries, namely, Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Vietnam and Timor Leste.

o Brunei Darussalam: Ministry of Education Ministry of Culture Youth and Sports Ministry of Primary Resource and Tourism Ministry of Development

o Cambodia: Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training

o Indonesia: Ministry of Education and Culture;

Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education

o Lao PDR: Ministry of Education and Sports

o Malaysia: Ministry of Education

o Myanmar: Ministry of Education

o Philippines: Department of Education (DEPED)

Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA)

o Singapore: Ministry of Education

o Thailand: Ministry of Education

o Timor Leste: Embassy of the Democratic Republic of Tomor-Leste

o Vietnam: Ministry of Education and Training (MoET);

In addition, representatives from partner countries such as Germany, United Kingdom, Japan, China, and Korea participated in the meeting. The Development Agencies included SEAMEO, ASEAN Secretariat, GIZ, UNESCO, ASEAN-China Centre, KOSEN (Japan), KRIVET (Korea). Representatives from industry such as Chambers of Commerce, Industry Associations, TVET Associations. The participants also included 37 local participants from Brunei Darussalam who are TVET Policy Makers, TVET Institution Administrators, Industry Associations and companies from Brunei Darussalam.

Page 3: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

3 | P a g e

A) PROGRAMME:

1) Opening Ceremony:

• Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela, Director of SEAMEO Secretariat stated the importance of regional collaboration in TVET (Technical and Vocational Education and Training) due to its important roles in developing human resources. TVET has also been highlighted in many Ministerial and High Officials Meetings as a priority area on education development until 2035. Various national and regional initiatives in TVET have been co-created and co-developed among Southeast Asian countries and Development Agencies since the 1st High Official Meeting on SEA-TVET on August 2015 with the objectives (1) to advance the quality of TVET in various aspects, and (2) to improve the internationalisation and harmonisation of TVET institutions in Southeast Asia. The chosen theme, “Strengthening Efforts towards TVET 4.0” is timely due to the fast-changing technology in manufacturing and service sectors, influenced by the Industrial Revolution 4.0.

• His Excellency Dato Seri Setia Haji Hamzah bin Haji Sulaiman, the Minister of Education

of Brunei Darussalam stressed the important role of technical vocational education and training in the 21st century. He also advised ASEAN and SEAMEO to continue to work together to improve the effectiveness of TVET for the 21st century. He stressed the need to strengthen our capabilities and provide an ecosystem that can support the digital revolution through investment in emerging technologies and modernizing physical facilities, building capacities, and matching skills to emerging markets demands. Training programmes will have to keep pace with industrial trends and developments in order to stay relevant in the future through upgrading curriculum, teachers’ training, and promoting life-long learning. The Minister also shared the development of TVET in Brunei Darussalam, including the development of the Brunei TVET Teacher Standards (BTSS), which is aligned with SEAMEO’s Regional TVET Teacher Standard, improving access for life-long learning.

Page 4: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

4 | P a g e

2) Official Announcement of Industry 4.0 Feature in SEA-VET.net After the Opening Ceremony, the official announcement of Industry 4.0 Feature in SEA-VET.net was done by Dr Mohd Zamri Sabli, Director of SEAMEO VOCTECH and Alexander Tsironis, Project Manager, GIZ/RECOTVET explained the Industry 4.0 Feature in SEA-

VET.net. Director of SEAMEO VOCTECH shared some of the achievements of the online platform since its official launch in 2018 and highlighted the achievement in terms of knowledge uploaded and number of viewers. The Project Manager from RECOTVET demonstrated the use of the online platform highlighting its purpose and function and how the audience can use and contribute. The participants were encouraged to join the community and to start downloading and uploading materials.

3) Session 1: Country Initiatives: Strengthening Efforts toward TVET 4.0

• The Keynote Speech addressing the topic, “Digitalisation Industry 4.0, VET 4.0: The German Way of Transformation” by Mr. Herbert Tutschner from BIBB, Germany. Mr. Tutschner explained the profiles of the Federal Institute for Vocational Training (BIBB) and shared some key points stating that digitalisation needs more qualified people. The digitalisation requires different level of qualifications such as university level, CVET (Continuing Vocational Education and Training) for high skills. He stated that digitalization is about disruption and agility. Then he shared bout the strategy of the Federal Government on transformation, policy, research, programmes and standards of the VET programmes. To enter digitalization, TVET institutions must update the curriculum and the programmes based on new occupations. He also shared the qualification of trainers for digital media as one example of important job in this era of digitalisation and the key competencies that TVET graduates should have, including the personal competence and professional competence. The speaker then concluded that digitalisation is not a new phenomenon, it is more than just a transformation; it is a disruption with positive and negative consequences.

Page 5: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

5 | P a g e

Country Presentations 1. Brunei Darussalam Her Excellency Siti Rozaimeriyanti binti DSLJ Haji Abdul Rahman, Legislative Council Member, President of Puja Brunei Darussalam, Director and Principal Architect of EcoBumi Arkitek talked about “Building a F.A.S.T. future for Brunei Darussalam. She began with a brief introduction to the current youth unemployment and issues surrounding TVET education. She then further highlighted that educational systems need to change in order to respond to SDG 4, which is “to increase the number of youth and adults who have relevant

skills, including technical and vocational skills for employment, decent jobs and entrepreneurship” to address the 4 ASEAN Strategic Goal 4: which include maximizing access; strengthening regional harmonization; establishing regional quality assurance and reducing skill gaps. She then recommended the tripartite strategic partnership between the private, public and education sector. By doing so, the businesses and industry are able to support TVET laws and regulations and work together with education institutions to

develop effective strategies to promote TVET education. Finally, she highlighted that in cooperation with ASEAN Secretariats and GIZ, “F.A.S.T: Future ASEAN Sustainable TVET”, ASEAN will develop the ASEAN skills standards to be implemented in 2021. 2. Indonesia

Dr Ismunandar, Directorate General of Learning and Student Affair, Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education shared his presentation on “Developing Vocational Higher Education for 2020-2024” with objectives to support national competitiveness through the creation of higher quality education combined with science and technology, and innovation capability. Ministry of Research, Technology, and Higher Education (MORTHE) of Indonesia proposed that TVET sectors must promote entrepreneurial education and lifelong learning in order to adapt and to counter against disruptions, besides understanding the local and global disruptions and contextualize the skills taught by properly trained teachers. Cooperation between TVET sectors and relevant stakeholders is needed. He also shared a national initiative called Multi-Entry Multi-Exit System (MEMES) to strengthen vocational education to provide opportunity for progression in accordance to the Indonesian Qualifications Framework levels. He then shared about revitalization of vocational higher education with the main strategy to increase vocational Gross Enrolment Ration (GER) in certain areas of industry, such as tourism, e-commerce and Industry 4.0, agriculture and fishery technology as well as health. Finally, he shared five national initiatives namely: Vocational Acceleration Programme, Increase in capacity of existing polytechnics, Increase courses at existing polytechnics, Increase in capacity of non-polytechnic vocational higher education institutions, and Establishment of new polytechnics.

Page 6: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

6 | P a g e

3. Malaysia Mr Zainuren Haji Mohd Nor, Director of Technical and Vocational Education Division, Ministry of Education Malaysia presented a country paper on “TVET Efforts Toward TVET 4.0 from MOE Perspectives”. Mr Zainuren shared in his introduction - Malaysia’s (Ministry of Education) perspective regarding IR4.0, by highlighting the Prime Minister’s quote from TVET Conference in 2019, “TVET will be a game changer in our effort developing local high skills human capital that would reduce country’s dependence on foreign workers. The government

will continue to strive to enhance the capacity of Malaysian youth in TVET to ensure the needs of high technology industries can be met by local workers”. He also conveyed that there has been extensive collaboration between Malaysia’s Ministry of Education, Ministry of International Trade and Industry, and industry ‘strong’ players to strengthen IR4.0 and its two key components: 1) Internet of Things 2) Big Data Analytics. Mr Zainuren shared Malaysia’s way forward, which is to

create 1.5 million new jobs by 2020 and is seeking recommendations from collaborating nations in how to achieve that number successfully. He also shared the ‘Human Capital Qualities Framework’ sharing the formula of [C] Competence = {[K] Knowledge, [S] Skills, [E] Experience}, and powered by [A] Attitude; TVET is not only the preparation for work but also preparation of life. To do this, he briefly mentioned on the initiatives of IR4.0 components of school curriculum and collaborations with relevant partners. 4. Singapore Mr Vincent Yu, Senior Manager, Higher Education Policy Division, Ministry of Education, shared his presentation on “Singapore on Going Efforts towards TVET4.0”. He started with the introduction of The Skills Future Movement that Singapore had embarked in 2014 which promotes lifelong learning with the intention of preparing Singaporeans for the future workforce and providing them with opportunities to develop their fullest potential regardless of their starting points. The four Key Thrusts that underpin The Skills Future Movement are: (i) helping individuals make well-informed choices in education, training and careers; (ii) develop an integrated high-quality system of education and training that responds to constantly evolving needs; (iii) prompt employer recognition and career development based on skills and mastery; and lastly (iv) foster a culture that supports and celebrates lifelong learning. He shared Singapore’s strategies and initiatives that have been implemented in order to create a strong link between TVET institutions (polytechnics/ITE), such as the collaboration between ITE and industry partners, the establishment of Centre of Innovations (COIs) to encourage innovation and enterprise and representation of industry partners in ITE’s and Polytechnic’s School/Academic Advisory Committees. The presentation then concluded by looking at the approaches that Singapore is undertaking in an attempt to further strengthen the links between The SkillsFuture Movement and Singapore’s TVET institutions: Work-Study Programmes, Enhanced Internships&Industry collaborations, Skills Frameworks, and Strengthening Continuing Education & Training.

Page 7: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

7 | P a g e

5. Session 2: Regional Initiatives for TVET Development in Southeast Asia by

Development Agencies

The following regional initiatives were presented for endorsement and discussion by the following organisations: In Session 2, Part 1: Regional Initiatives for TVET Development in Southeast Asia by Development Agencies, moderated by Dr Mohd Zamri Sabli, Centre Director of SEAMEO VOCTECH, 6 papers were presented.

1) Progress Report of ASEAN TVET Development Council by Mr Elmer K Talavera, Executive Director, National Institute for TESD (NITESD), TESDA, Philippines. TVET plays an important role in preparing for IR 4.0 workforce requirements. He explained about the history of the ASEAN TVET Council (initially referred to as ASEAN TVET Development Council). ASEAN TVET Council is a multi-sectoral/cross-sectoral body that will provide policy advice, recommendation, and coordination on TVET initiatives. The vision of ASEAN TVET includes higher productivity in the digital economy, establishing globally competitive human resources, market-responsive workforce skills, greater employment opportunities, and human-centred future of work. The Priority Areas highlighted were the development of market-responsive workforce through LMIS, conducting researchers pertaining to TVET, rebranding the image of TVET, supporting the capacity building of TVET trainers/personal at schools and in companies, strengthening of TVET quality assurances in AMS, opening means to share best practices and lessons learnt on TVET implementation, and finally, TVET financing. The ASEAN TVET Council will be launched in 2020 in Vietnam whereas the Terms of References will be adopted during the 35th ASEAN Summit which will take place in Bangkok, Thailand in November 2019.

2) ASEAN Initiatives for TVET Development by Ms Pitchanuch Supavanich, Senior Officer, Human Development Directorate/ Labour and Civil Service Division, ASEAN Secretariat. Ms Pitchanuch presented a progress report on initiatives being implemented in the ASEAN nations in the development of TVET. The main goal is to identify and develop a working system that would accommodate TVET and its linkages of labour workforce, education, youth, and SMEs. She also shared brief findings of research on ASEAN Readiness on IR4.0. She then listed down ASEAN initiatives on ASEAN and TVET, TVET Labour & Education and TVET Youth & SMEs.

3) Future ASEAN Agenda for TVET by GIZ-RECOTVET by Mr Bahrin Mohammad, Council Member (Education & Examination) Institute of Surveyors, Engineers & Architects Brunei Darussalam.

Page 8: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

8 | P a g e

Mr Bahrin Mohammad shared a brief background of this agenda, the urgency for change in TVET among ASEAN Member States (AMS) and the revision of current legal and policy frameworks. By identifying the challenges and countering them with practical solutions is essential to strengthen the cooperation of businesses and industries. The ASEAN Regional Working Group highlighted the top five recommendations: (1) Set up National TVET Councils co-chaired by senior public and private sector representatives to drive coherent, future-oriented national TVET agendas, (2) form skill standard development committees that support business and industry in leading the development of skill standards, (3) form an ASEAN Future Workforce Council led by business and industry, (4) develop skills information platforms to make information about the supply and demand of skills publicly accessible online, and (5) allocate an appropriate annual budget to TVET and consider the establishment of a TVET fund.

4) Regional Cooperation on TVET 4.0 for the Year 2020-2030 By Mr Ingo Imhoff, Programme Director, GIZ-RECOTVET Programmme, Vietnam. Mr Ingo Imhoff shared the objective of RECOTVET which is to strengthen the capacity of TVET systems in the ASEAN region to adapt to the requirements of digitalization and IR4.0. Strategic partners to carry out the initiatives include (1) Regional: ASEAN, SEAMEO, and International Organizations, (2) National: Ministries of education and labour and their specialized agencies, (3) Business and industry: chamber associations, enterprises. According to findings, “Digitalization” is the dominant topic of regional and national discourse. While strategies for dealing with the skills implications of digitalization exist, they are often very general and consultation-driven. There is, however, an increasing readiness to cooperate across sectoral boundaries, but there is a lack of specific reform plans for the TVET systems. He then shared various activities under regional TVET cooperation including regional policy dialogues, business and industry cooperation, regional knowledge platform, training on digital competencies and teaching methods; LMIS, skills forecasting and future competencies; and providing support for strategy development.

5) SEAMEO VOCTECH-GIZ/RECOTVET Modules for Industry 4.0 presented by Ms Siriporn Parvikam, Programme Component Manager, GIZ/RECOTVET, Thailand. RECOTVET with VOCTECH shared the main points regarding the relevance of regional in-service training modules for industry 4.0 in TVET and its implementation. There are three modules in total; Modules are jointly developed by international and regional experts with proven experience in field of Industry 4.0 and advanced teacher training institutions from the ASEAN region. Each training module has their own target group and pre-requisite: Module 1: Innovative Teaching and Learning for Industrial Changes due to Industry 4.0, the training was held in Bangkok, 5-16 August 2019. Module 2: Professional Development Training for TVET Teachers in Industry 4.0 to be conducted in Kuala Lumpur on 19-27 September 2019. Module 3. “Curriculum design for Industry 4.0 Work process” to be held in Bangkok on 7-15 October 2019. Recommendations from the training were shared including seeking for support at the national level to share about the training and to nominate qualified multipliers to participate in regional multiplier trainings. She shared that it would be helpful to provide financial support for additional participants if the country is sending more than one participant. Another recommendation added was to provide the resources to translate the modules and supporting materials into local language and to support the replication of innovative in-service training modules developed under the auspices of SEAMEO VOCTECH and with support of RECOTVET among TVET institutions in the country. Finally, she mentioned the need to build alliances for upgrading TVET teachers with national and regional training institutions and donor organisations.

6) Survey to Assess Industry and TVET Institutions Readiness for Industry 4.0”

presented by Dr Paryono, Deputy Director, SEAMEO VOCTECH, Brunei Darussalam. Dr Paryono shared that there is a need to know to improve the readiness of industry and TVET institutions for IR4.0 in Southeast Asia. Based on the recommendations from the 4th

Page 9: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

9 | P a g e

HOM SEATVET, there are three main objectives for the survey: (1) To assess the readiness for IR 4.0 of TVET institutions in SEAMEO Member States, (2)To assess the readiness for IR 4.0 of business and industry players in SEAMEO Member States, (3) To solicit feedbacks and recommendations from TVET and industry leaders for the future development in Southeast Asian countries. Besides using questionnaire to assess the industry and TVET readiness, the study will also use Focus Group Discussions as data collection tools to address the following questions: (1) What changes could be expected in industry due to the implementation of Industry 4.0, (2) How will the roles of workers and semi-engineers change, (3) What is the status of the current adoption, and (4) What initiatives should be taken by industry in response? This paper was presented with requested decision to carry out the research either by: (1) Each SEAMEO member countries conduct its own study and share the findings with SEAMEO, (2) Each SEAMEO member countries and potential funding donors will contribute some funds for the conduct of the study carried out independent body or by SEAMEO Centres, or (3) Just for reference only, up to member countries to decide whether to conduct the study or not. The decision will be made during the round table discussion among High Officials. Part 2: Regional Initiatives for TVET Development in Southeast Asia by Development Agencies or partners moderated by Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela, Director of SEAMEO Secretariat

7) Skill 4.0 for Industry by Mr Jonathan Ledger, Global TVET Specialist, Department of International Trade, UK. He shared the background information on United Kingdom’s Department of International Trade (DIT) Education Team and how the organisation has been fostering collaborative relationship with the ASEAN region, especially in the aspects of sharing the best education practices, creating mutually beneficial opportunities and partnerships, enabling reformation of education systems and enhancing skills and education in key industrial areas. The presenter then explained how the UK expertise has been supporting the development of the next generation skills in ASEAN countries, for example through multi-country skills 4.0, Pearson BTEC Qualifications in Thailand, Educational Governance & Quality Assurance, Advanced Aviation Technical Capacity and Skills 4.0 for Industry. To conclude, he underlined that the UK remains committed in working together with ASEAN countries to develop and enhance their skills capability in order to meet the demands of industry 4.0. Recommendations for consideration and approval by the TVET High Officials: (1) SEA Ministers invited by the UK Government to agree to attend the successful Education World Forum and BETT show being held in London in January 2020, (2) Ministers and their delegations from all ASEAN countries to actively participate in the UK Wilton Park Skills and Education Dialogue planned for February 2020 in Vietnam, potentially to coincide with the Bett Asia Summit Malaysia and BESS Vietnam), (3) SEA education ministry officials, alongside officials from ADB, to take part in a visit to UK during early 2020 to gain a greater

Page 10: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

10 | P a g e

understanding of the UK skills and broader education capability and how this can support development across ASEAN countries.

8) TVET Regional initiative of UNESCO on Entrepreneurship Education was presented by Ms Yoojeong Seo, Programme Specialist, UNESCO-Bangkok. She clarified what UNESCO can and cannot provide in response to the request from country members. The speaker spoke about the UNESCO’s functions for TVET which are to provide content experts, quality assurance experts, ICT experts, pedagogy experts, course planning guidelines, and institutional course planning tools. The speaker highlighted the recent activities of UNESCO: UNESCO-UNEVOC TVET leadership Programme for the Asia -Pacific area and a meeting on entrepreneurship Education for 4th Industrial Revolution EE-NET 8th UNESCO – APEID meeting. The speaker concluded that the above were the initiatives of UNESCO to achieve entrepreneurship in TVET.

9) Towards a Community of Shared Future: China-ASEAN TVET Collaboration by Ms Zhou Hui, Deputy Director, ASEAN China Centre. She introduced the background of the organization and the 4 flagship programmes that are currently practiced. The presenter then highlighted on China’s recent TVET reform initiatives where she emphasized on the common challenges faced and tackling the issues by introducing the national implementation plan. Currently, there are 1.3 million TVET teachers but regarded as a relatively low image and reputation in society. Curricular teaching materials are all up to date but have yet to improve and align with the industry 4.0 as teachers have no experience with the latest pedagogical methods (theory rather than practice). The presenter then shared the current status on the topic of ‘ASEAN-China TVET collaboration’ where she emphasized on the establishment of collaborative platforms, student mobility and TVET-Industry integration. Moreover, the section on future collaboration was also presented based on the components on innovation-driven development, quality development, win-win development and multi-dimensional development. China has recently introduced a new ‘XY certificate system’ for TVET where certificate X is for diploma students and certificate Y is for occupational certificate. Towards the end of the presentation, she hoped that the relationship between China and ASEAN could improve in three aspects: (1) Collaboration in innovation- How can we bring innovation in the system, (2) Quality- to enhance quality of TVET and collaborative programmes and the sustainability of the quality. She suggested on joint development of curriculum and standardisation, (3) Multi-dimensional regional framework. ACC requests: 1) Information about the latest TVET policy developments and the status quo of TVET

system in ASEAN countries (some are available online and some are not) and produce a brochure for the reference of Chinese TVET institutions and

2) Information about ASEAN countries’ demands in terms of TVET collaboration with China and suggestions for future collaboration.

10) SEAMOLEC Initiative on the Online Course Development by Utilizing Common ASEAN

Tourism Curriculum (CATC) By Ms Cahya Kusuma Ratih, Manager (Research and Development), SEAMEO Regional Open Learning Centre (SEAMEO SEAMOLEC). SEAMOLEC shared the objectives, target participants and expected outputs of the programme. The presentation started with the information on how tourism sector is regarded as one of the most-ready sectors to implement ASEAN-MRA (ASEAN Mutual Recognition Arrangement). The presenter highlighted that in order to answer the needs of the region in equipping tourism professionals, distance learning system using ICT medium can be the potential approach in providing education and trainings for students. As a means to pursue SEAMOLEC’s effort in developing an effective distance learning model for tourism, 6 ASEAN countries and institutions were selected to be involved in piloting the three-year programme. In order for SEAMOLEC to prepare for the online course and its contents, the organisation is working together with the Ministry of Education and Culture, Republic of Indonesia and Tourism Professional Certification Board (TPCB) in each country. In 2019, SEAMOLEC is focusing on developing, testing and reviewing the online course. In 2020, the organisation

Page 11: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

11 | P a g e

would start on implementing the online course for the 12 chosen schools (1st Pilot), reviewing and updating the initial courses, as well as developing new courses. In 2021, SEAMOLEC will be embarking on their 2nd Pilot. In closing, the presenter conveyed the expected outputs for the planned programme, which are the provision of online courses based on CATC toolboxes unit-competencies and materials to ASEAN students and the formulation of best practices, which will then be utilised as a robust foundation in developing skilled workers in ASEAN tourism sector. High Officials are requested to facilitate cooperation for SEAMOLEC with TVET institutes as well as related partners in order to develop and implement CATC toolboxes-based online courses during the 1st and 2nd pilot. During the pilot, it will only be 6 out of 242 competency units that will be available online. After the pilot, several selected TVET authority/institutes are encouraged to develop the online contents and utilizing best practices from SEAMOLEC initiatives.

11) Progress Report on TVET Training for Special Education Needs Teacher and Proposal by Ms Hjh Salmah Binti Jopri, Centre Director, SEAMEO Regional Centre for Special Education (SEAMEO SEN). She stated that children with disability have every right on TVET training. It may not need high technology but the activities must take into consideration of their disability, the safety and also must be able to develop their cognitive ability. The speaker also highlighted the progress report on TVET training in the field of special education where implementing urban agriculture is the main focus. In 2016, there was a pilot project on urban agriculture programme. In 2017 there was a customized course. In 2018 there was an urban agriculture training for Vietnam special Educational needs teachers and community learning centre educators. The speaker highlighted the proposed TVET training projects for 2019-2020: (1) Training Urban Agriculture for SPET (Special Education Teachers) at Bandung, (2) Entrepreneurship for SPET at Kedah, Malaysia. The speaker emphasized that entrepreneurship for special educational needs teachers need organizational skills, time management, leadership development and interpersonal skills. The High Officials are requested to: (1) take note on the training projects that has been conducted for Vietnam Special Educational Needs Teachers and Community Learning Centre Educators; (2) support the hosting of the proposed TVET training project initiatives for Special Educational Needs Teachers in respective countries; (3) support and recommend input for the TVET training projects; (4) suggest relevant experts institutions to co-host the TVET training projects; (5) co-funding expenses (training venue, experts invitation, mobilization and accommodation of participants) for the TVET training projects.

12) SEA-TVET Student Exchange Programme by Ms Piyapa Su-angavatin, Project Officer, SEAMEO Secretariat. She shared the background, aims and the current status of the programme. The presenter then highlighted, with illustrations, on the participations of institutions and students from 5 countries mainly Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand and Vietnam. She explained further on how the process has been implemented for the Student-Exchange programme where the SEAMEO Secretariat acts as a facilitator during the process. A total of 1143 students had been involved with the student-exchange program since January 2018 where the latest batch of students (August- November 2019) has the highest number of participants. The presenter then shared feedbacks received, with data and illustrations, from industries based on the overall satisfaction of students’ performance, quality of work, skills satisfactory, achieving of learning goals during internship, the institutional expectation and internalization of the programme. Overall, the data displayed have shown positive feedback and significant differences. The presenter then shared the upcoming 5th batch of SEA-TVET Exchange in 2020 hosted by Duy Tan University, Da Nang City, Vietnam on 17-18 October 2019 where the institutions support air-ticket and hotel.

In response to a question regarding budget for students’ exchange, she responded that expenses and funding is based on a cost sharing basis. Parents will need to cover airfare, living cost, food, pocket money, and visa. Receiving institution will provide accommodation and pay for extra activities provided to students.

Page 12: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

12 | P a g e

6. Session 3.1 and 4.1: High Officials’ Round Table Meeting

This session was one of the most important sessions of the High Officials Meeting on SEA-TVET. The session was conducted as a closed and informal session among heads of delegations and official representatives from Ministries/Departments of Education and related Ministries of Southeast Asian countries and representatives from SEAMEO Regional Centres.

The session aimed to determine the regional directions and strategies to advance the quality of TVET in line with the Industry 4.0 in Southeast Asian countries; to review and provide further recommendations for the national and regional initiatives as presented in sessions 1 and 2; and to identify other regional policy recommendations for promoting TVET collaboration and harmonization among Southeast Asian countries. The guiding questions for discussion were as follows: 1. From the presentations in session 1 “Country Initiatives: Strengthening Efforts toward

TVET 4.0”, what actions should be taken and forms of collaboration at the regional level in response to this new development in the Southeast Asian region in the next three years?

2. From the presentations in session 2 “Regional Initiatives for TVET Development in Southeast Asia, what are the feedbacks and recommendations from the TVET High Officials?

3. What other effective interventions should we include as top regional flagship project to promote TVET collaboration, harmonisation and mobility in the Southeast Asian region?

Page 13: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

13 | P a g e

The outputs from the High Officials Round Table Meeting is presented in page 21. 7. Concurrent Session 3.2: Skill Development for TVET 4.0

This session was aimed to share the practical strategies on how TVET personnel should be transformed and be ready for Industry 4.0. was moderated by Mr Ian John Wall, Head of School, School of Business, Politeknik Brunei. The presenters included GIZ/Myanmar, Asian Development Bank, and KOSEN (Japan).

• IR 4.0 Skill Development Initiatives in Politeknik Brunei by Dr Tang Shi Siong, Head of Quality Assurance/ Head of School of Engineering, Politeknik Brunei.

He shared the vision and mission of Politeknik Brunei. He then shared about developing new policies to achieve Industry 4.0 and findings from study for the selected schools School of ICT, the students are more exposed to Industry 4.0; students and graduates are familiar with technology. Students learn 3D painting and animation; students are able to bring 3D models to life. Future plan is to move into focusing into data analytics and encourage industry-driven and innovation projects related to Industry 4.0, such as artificial intelligence. School of Health Sciences: Emerging evidence supports the value of simulation as an educational technique. Clinical simulation is integrated into the curriculum to transfer from theoretical and practical skills to clinical practice; via the simulation will provide a safe environment to promote clinical competences, self-confidence, reflective practice, and teamwork. Students can continuously practice until they acquire the necessary skills without involving living patients. School of Sciences and Engineering: To implement virtual reality in petroleum engineering programmes (for example risk safety in oil and gas). With the virtual reality, there is no need to worry about the health and safety risks, or the weather. In response to a new report published by BCG, the presenter emphasized the importance of lifelong learning and soft skills and the need to embed them into the curriculum.

Page 14: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

14 | P a g e

• The Development of Holistic Human Capital for Industry 4.0 Readiness, by Mr Ngan Cheng Hwa, Specialist Technical Training Officer, German-Malaysia Institution.

He posed a pertinent question with regards to TVET and IR4.0 - how to develop lifelong learning through IR4.0? As an aid to help answer this, Mr Ngan Cheng Hwa mentions that we currently live in “19th century classroom, 20th century teacher, and 21st century student”. He delves into three types of analysis to ponder: 1) Industry 4.0 – Where are we? 2) People – what are talent development requirements? 3) Learning & Teaching – how to develop holistic/competent talent? These are all important factors due to the fact that the world of ‘work’ and world of ‘learning’ compliment of each other; people must have the capacity to learn – and through it, TVET needs to adapt to find the ‘fitment’ and synchronize these three factors. The aim is to shift to do problem-based learning instead of teacher-based learning. This works hand in hand with IR4.0, for them to become as innovators.

• Preparing Korean TVET for Dealing with TVET 4.0, by Ms Young Sun Ra, President,

KRIVET (Korea).

She explained the challenges of Industry 4.0 to TVET such as changing work environment and aging population. Then, she listed out issues faced by TVET at Secondary level, Tertiary level and adult learners. As a result, the Korean Government is pursuing ‘Growth with Innovation’ where the new directions of TVET includes (1) A reshuffling of the TVET according to the changes in industrial structure and diversifying employment patterns, (2) Competency building and new skills training for the workforce in the era of industry 4.0, (3) Enhancing the participation in lifelong learning in order to secure the competencies for adults, (4) Shift to learner-customized TVET policies. She highlighted how the role of TVET has shifted from developing the industry labour force and providing social safety net to growth with innovation and establishing human resources foundation for the future talent. The presenter then shared the strategies in TVET Reforms under the 3 respective areas: (1) Developing competencies for new skills in the era of industry 4.0, (2) Lifelong learning for all, (3) Supporting infrastructures for TVET. To conclude, the presentation shared 3 implications: collaborative policy implementation, tailor-made supports for the recipients and adequate lifelong TVET opportunities for all.

• KOSEN Projects in Thailand, by Dr Tsutomu Matsumoto, Director, Japanese-Thai

KOSEN, Japan.

The KOSEN project in Thailand was first created due to the domestic demand during the high economic growth period from 1955-1973. This project is collaborated between Thailand and Japan to fill certain job gaps between the two nations. It is an alternative route to the ‘education path’ in Japan as shown by Dr Tsutomu Matsumoto. The Kosen project is essentially a 5-year course; with a Curricula that totals to 5340 hours. The syllabus was developed by Kosen Japan – and agreed by the partner. Training programs to ‘train the trainer’ is organised to brief the Thai instructors regarding the KOSEN pedagogy. The KOSEN graduates expected from this project are expected to create a variety of human resource jobs. Dr Tsutomu Matsumoto concluded that there was quite a difference in the style of teaching between Japan and Thailand instructors; there would be the need to improve cross cultural understanding in terms of language as well as pedagogy practices in the classroom between Instructor and student to make the KOSEN project much more effective.

8. Concurrent Session 4.2: Public-Private Partnership Model towards TVET 4.0

This session was aimed to share the practical strategies on how to establish and improve public-private partnership (PPP) to enhance the adoption of IR4.0 in TVET institutions (TVET 4.0). The invited speakers from the Department of International Trade UK, Labtech International Limited and National E-Commerce Vocational Teaching Steering Committee of

Page 15: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

15 | P a g e

PR China shared their best practices in this session. The session on Public-Private Partnership Model towards TVET 4.0 was moderated by Dr Sheikh Lukman, Central Principal, Institute Brunei of Technical Education (IBTE).

• Enhancing Industry Collaboration for Successful Implementation/ Integration of IR 4.0 by Mr Jonathan Ledger, Global TVET Specialist, Department of International Trade, UK.

As the rate of change for technology drastically advances, it proves to be challenging for individuals, businesses and public policies to keep up. As a result, a skills gap, a commercial lag and a policy deficit follows in the wake of such drastic technological advancement. Thus, it was posited that the biggest barrier for the implementation technologies is the lack of knowledge and skills among staff, along with insufficient training in current and future technologies and the high cost of implementing such technologies. This calls for the implications for IR 4.0 skills by which: Technical skills need to be of quality and relevant; Foundational skills need to be strongly promoted; Core employability skills demand to be fostered; Entrepreneurial skills must be encouraged, and Digital skills enhanced. As TVET is about skills for industry, TVET sectors are required to not only understand industry needs, but also develop industry professional benchmarks. Henceforth, TVET sectors must design, deliver and implement relevant industry training programmes whilst closely measuring its following impact and outcomes. Accordingly, employers within the industries must 0collaborate with one another to refine their own businesses and articulate the skills it needs, in essence outlining clearer career paths. Industries are to create employment, training opportunities and assist in the supervision of training and coaching to staff. Therefore, it is expected that they provide technical input to qualifications and curriculum development. In conclusion, the perception of TVET amongst students, parents, employers and wider society demands for a change.

• Improving TVET through PPP with collaboration, by Dr Steve McKee, President of LabTech and President of WorldDIDAC.

He explained how technology is shaping the workplace and economic landscape and transforming the state of TVET. Nevertheless, PPP is not without its problems as research states that there has always been a mismatch between the supply and demand of TVET graduates. This creates the opportunity for collaboration on the creation of a new generation of teaching and learning materials in digital learning. He emphasized the beneficial partnerships of Worlddidac and Labtech within the TVET sectors towards the transformation of TVET through technology, making it virtual. Virtual TVET is thus the utilization of technology for education as it helps to reduce costly physical training systems, operational costs, reach and time taken to teach

Page 16: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

16 | P a g e

and learn, henceforth improving accessibility. It also encourages the betterment of trainers and teachers, thus, there is a demand to create the right balance between virtual and practical learning within the TVET sectors. Through the application of technology, improvements can be adapted and accessed by a wide range of audience. He concluded that industries and governments can complement each other to meet the constantly growing economic demands and challenges. The collaboration from government, international agencies, TVET and industrial sectors is highly appreciated.

• Industry Technical Skills Accumulation System (ITSAS), by Mr Lu Chuyang, Deputy Director, National E-Commerce Vocational Teaching Steering Committee, PR China.

In his presentation, he shared about the Public-Private Partnership and PGSD skills development model. In order to improve the practicality and quality of teaching, the following were done : 1) The committee was formed with the order from the Ministry of Education, by the Chinese industrial associations; 2) develop a talent-demand forecasting system; 3) summarized the “skill tags” during mass data analyze of the recruitment information released by the companies; 4) PGSD skills development model and 5) developed an assessment system to obtain detailed learning reports and career orientation reports. The PGSD skills development method has been applied in the curriculum development of the World Bank assistance loan projects and the development of teaching standards/ in the Ministry of Education of China. They also work with education institutes in other countries including Thailand and Cambodia to develop courses in the field of digital trade and help them gradually build their own ITSAS. He was hoping to meet more partners to jointly promote the development of vocational education and support the emerging industries represented by the digital economy through vocational education.

9. Bilateral/Networking Session:

This session provided opportunity for institutions/organisations to explore possible areas of collaboration and to strengthen/renew partnership. During the session, there were 17 institutions participated with 14 potential collaborations agreed among the following partners. The outputs from this session were presented in Session 6 on 10 September by the SEAMEO VOCTECH.

Organisation Partners Agreements SEAMEO Secretariat

China Association of Trade in Service

• Digital Skills Seminar in China, with speakers from SEA in January 2020

Politeknik Brunei (Dr. Siong) • Student exchange programme – requires additional information prior to joining 5th batch student exchange in 2020

ASEAN Secretariat

ASEAN CHINA CENTRE (Ms. Zhou Hui)

• Strengthening the relationship with ASEAN Secretariat, through conduct of future meetings on aspects of TVET and project implementation

National E- Commerce Vocational Education Teaching Steering Committee (Mr. Lu Chunyang)

• Promoting TVET education in the ASEAN area. Expanding its presence into the economic corridor, on how to grasp and share the digital economy in ASEAN for sustainable development, e.g. recommendations in the aid on

Page 17: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

17 | P a g e

how to recognize and endorse skills and certification

Labtech International Limited

SEAMEO TED (Cambodia) • Interested to have collaboration on Virtual TVET and software application, in relation to the conduct of training/workshops for technical skill at high school level

Ministry of Education, Malaysia Ministry of Education, Singapore Ministry of Education, Thailand

Ministry of Education and Sports, Lao PDR

• Training of TVET teachers in Lao PDR on IR4.0 (Lao PDR to first discuss with colleagues on the specific area required and will communicate further)

BIBB (German Federal Institute for Vocational Training)

National E-Commerce Vocational Teaching Steering Committee PR China (Mr. Lu Chuyang)

• Areas of collaboration have yet to be finalised through BIBB’s International Sector

Department of International Trade, UK

Department of TVET, MOE of Myanmar

• Training of TVET Teachers in the UK

• Teacher training – to learn and implement the UK TVET System

• Request of support in terms of infrastructure and equipment

UNESCO, Bangkok

Korean Research Institute for Vocational Education and Training (KRIVET)

• Conduct of regional workshop in Unison

• Facilitation in looking for human resource personnel who speak and teach English fluently

• To invite guest speakers

Page 18: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

18 | P a g e

10. Session 6: Synthesis and Ways Forward

The results from the Bilateral/Networking Session were presented in this session by Ms Noorhayati Cynthia Binti Abdullah, Training and Professional Development Manager cum TVET Specialist, SEAMEO VOCTECH.

The synthesis report which concluded a brief summary and highlights from the High Officials Meeting of day 1 was presented by Dr Paryono, Deputy Director of SEAMEO VOCTECH.

11. Closing Session:

The Declaration of Agreements from the High Officials’ Round Table Meeting was presented by Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela, Director of SEAMEO Secretariat. The details of ‘Declaration of Agreements’ is in page 21.

The Closing Remarks was presented by Dr. Haji Azman bin Ahmad, Permanent Secretary (Higher Education), Ministry of Education, Brunei Darussalam. He stated that the meeting coming to its conclusion and that the 5th HOM Meeting has met its objectives: 1) To discuss the current situation of TVET collaboration for the past year and to identify the strategies to improve regional cooperation and harmonization; 2) to determine and plan for the regional directions and strategies to advance quality of TVET in Southeast Asian towards Industry 4.0 and 3) to strengthen cooperation among the TVET ministries/departments and TVET development agencies among Southeast Asia and other countries beyond the region.

Page 19: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

19 | P a g e

He concluded his remarks by reminding that TVET need to play a bigger role in this region. The theme of the 5th HOM SEA-TVET “Strengthening Efforts Towards TVET 4.0” is timely to prepare to embrace the digital revolutions that will influence both ways of living and ways of preparing the future workforce. Finally, to improve the quality of TVET and its graduates by strengthening efforts in TVET by giving time, investment, cooperation, and support from many parties through the close social partnership between Government, Industry, TVET institutions, and regional cooperation, collaboration and harmonization.

12. Welcome Dinner:

The Welcome Dinner was hosted by Ministry of Education, Brunei Darussalam on 9 September 2019 at Tarindak d’Polo Restaurant, Jerudong. All delegates were invited.

13. Study Visit:

Besides the formal meeting, the study visit programme was organised to visit Agrome IQ International Sdn Bhd on 10 September 2019.

Page 20: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

20 | P a g e

14. Exhibition: The exhibition with the theme” Industry Revolution 4.0” was organised concurrently with the meeting on 9-10 September 2019. The exhibitors included the following industries and development agencies:

• SCS Information Technology Sdn Bhd • Agrome IQ International Sdn Bhd • Labtech International Ltd • Institute of Brunei Technical Education • Politeknik Brunei • Jerudong Park Country Club Sdn Bhd

B) Agreements from the TVET High Officials’ Round Table Meeting: The TVET High Officials’ Round Table Meeting was one of the most important sessions held on 9 September 2019. This was convened to suggest actions/forms of collaboration at the regional level in response to the new development of TVET 4.0 in Southeast Asia; to provide recommendations on regional initiatives as presented in session 2; to identify the interventions for promoting TVET collaboration, harmonisation, and mobility; and to recommend improvement and the host of the 6th HOM on SEA-TVET.

Page 21: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

21 | P a g e

The Round Table Meeting was attended by approximately 24 participants who are Director Generals, Directors and official representatives from Ministries of Education, Higher Education, Labour, and other related Ministries from 11 Southeast Asian countries, Representatives from related SEAMEO Regional Centres and also Representative from ASEAN Secretariat.

Agreements/recommendations from the High Officials’ Round Table Meeting include as follows: 1) Recommended collaborative actions for Industry 4.0 at regional level in response to the

new development in the Southeast Asian region in the next three years.

1.1 Regional TVET Teacher Standards could be implemented as a reference towards IR 4.0 across the region:

a) SEAMEO VOCTECH has been tasked to improve the existing Regional TVET Teacher Standards by including the competencies for Industry 4.0.

b) Guidelines on how to apply the Standards for the country should be developed. c) The Regional TVET Teacher Standards should be disseminated and announced to all

related Ministries of Southeast Asia. d) Maximise the platform of “SEA-VET.net” for sharing information

1.2 The other related suggestions are as follows:

a) Strengthening collaboration among the countries through Competency Training for Teachers, Train the Trainers, In-Company Trainers for IR 4.0.

b) Improving curriculum and competency framework c) Integrating Community Development should be considered as a part of the programme. d) Improving ‘NEXUS’ between institutions and industry

Page 22: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

22 | P a g e

e) Upgrading students’ skills through on-the job-training of student exchange programme; and

f) Rebranding TVET as the 1st Choice for students through scholarships; dual system apprenticeship; career and further study pathways; advocacy and involvement of local community and government; more TVET based research; education and career guidance; changing mind-set of parents and organising activities such as Open Day/ Skills Competition

1.3 Recommendations for related regional initiatives as presented in Session 2

a) SEAMEO VOCTECH-GIZ/RECOTVET Modules for Industry 4.0

• Selection of the right candidates/trainees • Online Training should be considered • Multiply Effect Training should be applied • Optimising the knowledge transfer of the trainees

b) Survey to Assess Industry and TVET Institutions Readiness for Industry 4.0 by SEAMEO

VOCTECH • Collaborative Survey can be conducted by working with donors such as ADB and involve

the collaboration of Chambers of Commerce • Further discussion at the country level is needed. • SEAMEO VOCTECH can revise the proposal and share the draft for inputs. • A platform for dialogue among the countries should be conducted by SEAMEO

VOCTECH.

2) Reviewing the Progress Reports and Regional Initiatives as presented in Session 2 All High Officials/Representatives agreed on all regional proposals as presented in Session 2 for further discussion and implementation:

a) Progress Report of ASEAN TVET Development Council by TESDA b) ASEAN Initiatives for TVET Development c) Future ASEAN Agenda for TVET by GIZ-RECOTVET d) Regional Cooperation on TVET 4.0 for the Year 2020-2030 by GIZ/RECOTVET e) SEAMEO VOCTECH-GIZ/RECOTVET Modules for Industry 4.0 f) Survey to Assess Industry and TVET Institutions Readiness for Industry 4.0, by SEAMEO

VOCTECH g) Skill 4.0 for Industry by UK International Trade h) Regional Initiative of UNESCO on Entrepreneurship Education i) Towards a Community of Shared Future: China-ASEAN TVET Collaboration, by ASEAN

China Centre j) SEAMOLEC Initiative on the Online Course Development by Utilizing Common ASEAN

Tourism Curriculum (CATC) by SEAMEO SEAMOLEC k) ProgressReport on TVET Training for Special Educational Needs Teachers and Proposal by

SEAMEO SEN l) SEA-TVET Student Exchange Programme by SEAMEO Secretariat

3) Interventions to promote TVET collaboration, harmonisation and mobility in Southeast

Asian Region

a) Collaborate with other partners and countries beyond Southeast Asia b) Improve industry collaboration c) Exchange TVET experts and teachers d) Develop cross-country programmes for developing underprivileged communities

Page 23: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

23 | P a g e

4) The Next 6th HOM on SEA-TVET

The High Officials proposed the Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training; and Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport of Cambodia to host the next 6th HOM on SEA-TVET.

Compiled and synthesized by IBTE, reformatted by SEAMEO Secretariat

8 October 2019.

Page 24: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

1

PARTICIPANT DIRECTORY

As of 4 October 2019

Page 25: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

2

List of Participants

A. COUNTRY/MINISTRY HIGH OFFIICIALS AND REPRESENTATIVES Brunei Darussalam

1) Dr Haji Azman bin Ahmad Permanent Secretary (Higher Education) Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

2) Yang Mulia Dr Shamsiah Zuraini Kanchanawati binti Haji Tajuddin

Permanent Secretary (Core Education) Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

3) Mr Walter Chong Head of International Affairs Unit Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

4) Mr Ali Hamdani bin Haji Muhammad Diah

Acting Deputy Director Higher Education Division Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

Cambodia

5) Mr Rath Sara Director Vocational Orientation Department Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport No 185, Norodom Blvd, Khan Boengkengkang, Phnom Penh, Cambodia Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

6) Mr Viseth Phoung

Deputy Director General Directorate General of TVET Ministry of Labour and Vocational Training Phnom Penh, Cambodia Email: [email protected]

Indonesia

7) Dr Ir M Bakrun, MM Director of DTVE Directorate of Technical and Vocational Education Ministry of Education and Culture Jakarta, Indonesia Email: [email protected]

8) Ms Arfah Laidiah Razik Head of Section Evaluation, DTVE Directorate of Technical and Vocational Education Ministry of Education and Culture, Jakarta, Indonesia Email: [email protected]

Page 26: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

3

9) Dr Ismunandar Director General Directorate General of Learning and Student Affair Ministry of Research, Technology and Higher Education Jalan Pintu Satu Senayan, Jakarta, Indonesia Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

Lao PDR

10) Mr Vannalek Leuang Deputy Director General Technical and Vocational Department (TVED) Ministry of Education and Sports Lan Xang Avenue, PO Box 67 Vientiane, Lao PDR E-mail: [email protected]

Malaysia

11) Mr Zainuren bin Haji Mohd Nor Director Technical and Vocational Education Division Ministry of Education Level 5-6, Block E14, Complex E Federal Government Administrative Centre 62604 Putrajaya, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

Myanmar

12) Dr Aye Myint Director General Department of Technical and Vocational Education Minister of Education Office No 21, Oattara Thiri Township Nay Pyi Taw, Myanmar Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

Philippines

13) Ms Maria Cecilia Nayve Supervising Education Program Specialist Bureau of Curriculum Development Special Curricular Programs Division Department of Education 3F Bonifacio Bldg., DepEd Complex Meralco Ave, Pasig City, Philippines Email: [email protected]

14) Mr Elmer K Talavera

Executive Director National Institute for TESD (NITESD) Technical Education and Skills Development Authority (TESDA) TESDA Complex, Gate 1 East Service Road South Superhighway, Taguig City, Philippines Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

Singapore

15) Ms Siew Lee Lim Assistant Director, Higher Education Policy Division International Cooperation & Strategy Team/ Higher Education Policy Division Ministry of Education 1 North Buona Vista Drive, Singapore 138675, Singapore Email: [email protected]

Page 27: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

4

16) Mr Vincent Yu Senior Manager, Higher Education Policy Division International Cooperation & Strategy Team/ Higher Education Policy Division Ministry of Education 1 North Buona Vista Drive, Singapore 138675, Singapore Email: [email protected]

17) Mr Aw York Bin Deputy CEO (Industry) Institute of Technical Education 2 Ang Mo Kio Drive Singapore 567720 Singapore Email: [email protected]

Thailand

18) Mr Athippatai Potang Senior Human Resource Officer Bureau of Personnel Competency Development Office of Vocational Education Commission Ministry of Education Ratchadamnoen Nok Road, Dusit, Bangkok, Thailand 10300 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

Timor-Leste 19) HE Mr Marcal Avelino Ximens

Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Embassy of the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste to Brunei Darussalam No 18, Simpang 612, Jalan Muara Kampong Salambigar BC1515, Bandar Seri Begawan

20) Ms Cristiana Gloria Third Secretary EMBTL-Bandar Seri Begawan Embassy of the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste to Brunei Darussalam No 18, Simpang 612, Jalan Muara Kampong Salambigar BC1515, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

Vietnam 21) Mr Thanh Bui Trung

Rector Hung Yen University of Technology and Education Ministry of Education and Training Vietnam Email: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

B. DEVELOPMENT AGENCIES/ GLOBAL PARTNERS ASEAN China Centre

22) Ms Hui Zhou Deputy Director Education, Culture and Tourism Division ASEAN-China Centre No. 43 Liangmaqiao Road, Chaoyang District Beijing 100600 China Email: [email protected]

23) Mr Zhang Fengyu

Education Officer ASEAN-China Centre

Page 28: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

5

No. 43 Liangmaqiao Road, Chaoyang District Beijing 100600 China E-mail: [email protected]

24) Mr Lu Chunyang Deputy Director National E-Commerce Vocational Education Teaching Steering Committee Room No 212, Building 1,Yi Quan Hui Building No 35 Shang Di Dong Rd.,Hai Dian District Beijing City Email: [email protected]

25) Ms Tan Xiao

Translator National E-commerce Vocational Education Teaching Steering Committee Room No.212, Building 1, Yi Quan Hui Building No.35 Shang Di Dong Rd., Hai Dian District Beijing City Email: [email protected]

ASEAN Secretariat

26) Ms Pitchanuch Supavanich Senior Officer Human Development Directorate/ Labour and Civil Service Division The ASEAN Secretariat 70A Jalan Sisingamangaraja, Kebayoran Baru, Jakarta 12110, Indonesia Email: [email protected]

Bahrin Mohammad Associates

27) Mr Ir Bahrin Mohammad Council Member Bahrin Mohammad & Associates Institute of Surveyors, Engineers & Architects (Puja), Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

BIBB (German Federal Institute for Vocational Training)

28) Mr Herbert Tutschner Head of Unit ‘Structure and Organisation of VET’ BIBB (German Federal Institute for Vocational Training) Drachenfelsstr 29, 5317 Bonn, Germany Email: [email protected]

British High Commission, Brunei Darussalam

29) Mrs Siti Mahmud Commercial and Prosperity Manager Foreign Commonwealth Organization British High Commission Block D, Yayasan Complex, Jalan Pretty Bandar Seri Begawan, Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

British High Commission, Kuala Lumpur

30) Ms Husna Hamini Hashim Senior Manager, ASEAN Education Manager British High Commission Kuala Lumpur Level 27, Menara Binjai Off Jalan Binjai, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH (GIZ)

31) Mr Ingo Imhoff Programme Director

Page 29: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

6

RECOTVET Programme Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH (GIZ/Vietnam) 6th Floor, Hanoi Towers 49, Hai Ba Trung Street, Hanoi, Vietnam Email: [email protected]

32) Mr Alexander Tsironis Advisor RECOTVET Programme Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit GmbH (GIZ/Vietnam) 6th Floor, Hanoi Towers 49 Hai Ba Trung Street, Hanoi, Vietnam Email: [email protected]

33) Ms Siriporn Parvikam

Programme Component Manager Regional Cooperation for TVET in ASEAN German International Cooperation (GIZ/Thailand) Bureau of Personnel Competency Development, Thailand Email: [email protected]

34) Mr Ansgar Schaefer

Junior Consultant GIZ Gesellschaft fuer international Zusammenarbeit Gmbh (GIZ/Germany) In der Aue 8, 36282 Hauneck, Germany Email: [email protected]

German-Malaysian Institute

35) Mr Ngan Cheng Hwa Specialist Technical Training Officer Electrical Engineering Department German-Malaysian Institute Jalan Ilmiah, Taman Universiti, 68000 Kajang Selangor, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

Japanese-Thai KOSEN 36) Dr Tsutomu Matsumoto

Director Japanese-Thai KOSEN Office of Vocational Education Commission Ministry of Education Ratchadamnoen Nok Rd Dusit, Bangkok 10300 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

Korea Research Institute for Vocational Education and Training (KRIVET)

37) Dr. Young Sun Ra President Korea Research Institute for Vocational Education and Training (KRIVET) #1201 Social Policy Building, Sejong National Research Complex Sejong-si, Republic of Korea E-mail: [email protected]

38) Mr Choi Hyunsik

Researcher Centre for International Cooperation, KRIVET #1201 Social Policy Building, Sejong National Research Complex Sejong-si, Republic of Korea E-mail: [email protected]

Labtech International Limited 39) Dr Steven McKee

President of World DIDAC and President of Labtech

Page 30: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

7

Labtech International Limited Kav 34, Kawasan Industri Sekupang Batam, Indonesia Email: [email protected]

40) Mr Bradley Ker

Business Development Executive Labtech International Limited Kav 34, Kawasan Industri Sekupang Batam, Indonesia Email: [email protected]

41) Mr Shafiek Sultan

Regional Marketing Manager (Asia) Marketing Department Labtech International Limited No. 16, 2nd Floor, Jalan Tengku Ampuan Zabedah D9/D Shah Alam, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

Department of International Trade, UK

42) Mr Jonathan Ledger Global TVET Specialist Department of International Trade 3 Whitehall Place, London SW1A 2AW, United Kingdom Email: [email protected]

UNESCO Bangkok

43) Ms Yoojeong Seo (Nadine) Programme Specialist Division of Educational Innovation and Skills (EISD) UNESCO-Bangkok 920 Sukhumvit Road Klongtoey, Bangkok 10110, Thailand Email: [email protected]

C. SEAMEO REGIONAL CENTRES SEAMEO SEAMOLEC (SEAMEO Regional Open Learning Centre)

44) Mrs Cahya Kusuma Ratih Manager (Research and Development) SEAMEO SEAMOLEC Kompleks Universitas Terbuka Jalan Cabe Raya, Pondok Cabe, Pamulang Jakarta 15418, Indonesia Email: [email protected]

SEAMEO SEARCA (SEAMEO Regional Centre for Graduate Study and Research in Agriculture)

45) Dr Glenn B Gregorio Centre Director SEAMEO SEARCA College, Los Baños, Laguna, 4031 Philippines Email: [email protected]

SEAMEO SEN (SEAMEO Regional Centre for Special Education)

46) Ms Hjh Salmah Binti Jopri Centre Director SEAMEO SEN Level 2, Anjung Hikmah Complex IPGK Perempuan Melayu, Jalan Durian Daun, 75400 Melaka, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

47) Mr Mohd Anis Abdul Razak

Research Officer SEAMEO SEN

Page 31: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

8

Level 2, Anjung Hikmah Complex IPGK Perempuan Melayu, Jalan Durian Daun, 75400 Melaka, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

SEAMEO TED (SEAMEO Regional Centre for Technical Education Development)

48) Dr Doung Vuth Director SEAMEO TED #201 Preah Norodom Bvld, Phnom Penh, Cambodia Tel: +855 98 214 147 E-mail: [email protected]

SEAMEO VOCTECH (SEAMEO Regional Centre for Vocational and Technical Education) 49) Dr Haji Mohd Zamri bin Haji Sabli

Centre Director SEAMEO VOCTECH Acting Director/CEO Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1318, Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

50) Dr Paryono

Deputy Director Professional Affairs/Research Specialist SEAMEO VOCTECH Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong, BE1318 Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

51) Mrs Noorhayati Cynthia binti Abdullah

Teacher Education Specialist/Professional Development Manager SEAMEO VOCTECH Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong, BE1318 Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

SEAMEO Secretariat

52) Dr Ethel Agnes Pascua Valenzuela Director SEAMEO Secretariat 920 Sukhumvit Road Klongtoey, Bangkok 10110, Thailand Email: [email protected]

53) Ms Piyapa Su-angavatin

Project Officer/ SEA-TVET Coordinator SEAMEO Secretariat 920 Sukhumvit Road Klongtoey, Bangkok 10110, Thailand Email: [email protected]

54) Ms Kansiripak Muangnoycharoen

Secretary (Administration & Communication) SEAMEO Secretariat 920 Sukhumvit Road Klongtoey, Bangkok 10110, Thailand Email: [email protected]

D. EDUCATORS FROM MINISTRIES AND INSTITUTIONS IN BRUNEI DARUSSALAM

55) Honourable Siti Rozaimeriyanty Binti Dato Seri Laila Jasa Haji Abdul Rahman Director & Principal Architect / Legco Member EcoBumi Arkitek No.3, First Floor, Block C, Kg. Kiarong, Bandar Seri Begawan BE1318 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected]

Page 32: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

9

56) Dr Sheikh Lukman Central Principal Institute Brunei of Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan

57) Dr Tang Shi Siong Head of Quality Assurance Department/ Acting Head School of Science and Engineering Ministry of Education/ Politeknik Brunei Email: [email protected]

58) Mr Ian John Wall Head of School of Business Politeknik Brunei Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

59) Dr Suhaimi bin Haji Abdul Wahub Acting Principal Satellite Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan

60) Mr Hirman bin Haji Abu Senior Agricultural Officer Department of Agriculture and Agrifood Ministry of Primary Resource and Tourism Jalan Menteri Besar Bandar Seri Begawan BB3910, Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

61) Ms Nelia binti Mohammad Eusoff Education Officer Higher Education Division Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

62) Ms Hajah Rosnah binti Haji Tarip Education Officer Higher Education Division Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

63) Ms Asmawati binti Haji Ali Senior Technical Instructor Higher Education Division Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

64) Dr Syazana binti Hj Ebil Acting Deputy Director/Senior Education Officer Ministry of Education Old Airport Road, Berakas Bandar Seri Begawan BB3510, Brunei Darussalam

Page 33: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

10

65) Mr Abdul Muiz bin Madani Senior Technical Instructor (IBTE NRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

66) Ms Nurul Fakhriah binti Abu Hasrah

Senior Technical Instructor (IBTE SSRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

67) Mr Haji Rahat Aziz

Senior Technical Instructor (IBTE JBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

68) Ms Hajah Nurhafizah binti Haji Mohammad Zaki

Education Officer (IBTE SBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

69) Ms Nurul Azyan binti Jamal

Education Officer (IBTE SBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

70) Mr Muhammad Haikal Hakim bin Haji Latip

Education Officer (IBTE ATC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

71) Ms Nur Nazurah binti Haji Muhammad Alizul

Education Officer (IBTE ATC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

72) Mr Hj Md Aizuddin bin Hj Zawawi

Education Officer (IBTE SSRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

73) Mr Hemi Arwandi bin Adol

Education Officer (IBTE JBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

Page 34: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

11

74) Ms Hajah Roziaty Binti Haji Mohammad Zaki Education Officer (IBTE SBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

75) Mr Muhammad Azraie Bin Haji Amit Education Officer (IBTE SBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

76) Mr Joey Wong Senior Technical Instructor (IBTE SBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

77) Ms Dk Siti Norizah binti Pg Hj Hallid Education Officer (IBTE SSRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

78) Ms Hjh Norafiah binti Hj Jainal Education Officer (IBTE JBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

79) Mr Hj Ruzaini bin Hj Mazin Education Officer (IBTE JBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

80) Ms Dk Siti Hairani bin Pg Burut Education Officer (IBTE SBC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

81) Mr Hj Mohammad Hasrin bin Hj Mohammad Azani Senior Technical Instructor (IBTE NRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

82) Mr Ahmad Ikhwanuddin bin Haji Ali Senior Technical Instructor (IBTE NRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

83) Ms Noor Hamdiana binti Hj Abdul Hamid Head of School of Building Technology Service (IBTE NRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

Page 35: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

12

84) Mr Mohammad Fuazi bin Haji Ali Hassan Technical Instructor (IBTE NRC) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Email: [email protected]

85) Mr Denis Ho Mun Tai Director Politeknik Brunei Block 2E, Ong Sum Ping Condominium, Jalan Ong Sum Ping, Bandar Seri Begawan, BA1311 Email: [email protected]

86) Ms Hajah Hanifah binti Haji Apong Ragistrar Politeknik Brunei Block 2E, Ong Sum Ping Condominium, Jalan Ong Sum Ping, Bandar Seri Begawan, BA1311 Email: [email protected]

87) Ms Hajah Azizan binti Dato Paduka Haji Othman Head of International and Public Relations Politeknik Brunei Block 2E, Ong Sum Ping Condominium, Jalan Ong Sum Ping, Bandar Seri Begawan, BA1311 Email: [email protected]

88) Mr Hj Ehwan bin Juned

Head of Centre of Innovative Teaching and Learning Politeknik Brunei Block 2E, Ong Sum Ping Condominium, Jalan Ong Sum Ping, Bandar Seri Begawan, BA1311 Email: [email protected]

89) Mr Hamdani bin Mustapa

Head of School of Information and Communication Technology Politeknik Brunei Block 2E, Ong Sum Ping Condominium, Jalan Ong Sum Ping, Bandar Seri Begawan, BA1311 Email: [email protected]

90) Ms Armah binti Tengah

Head of School of Health Science Politeknik Brunei Block 2E, Ong Sum Ping Condominium, Jalan Ong Sum Ping, Bandar Seri Begawan, BA1311 Email: [email protected]

91) Dr Adeline Goh Yuen Sze

Lecturer Universiti Brunei Darussalam (UBD) Jalan Tungku Link, BE1410, Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

92) Dr Dayang Hajah Roslyunna binti Hj Rosli Assistant Registrar / Deputy Director Tri-CED Universiti Teknologi Brunei Tungku Link Highway BE 1410

EXHIBITORS

Page 36: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

13

93) Ms Aini Morni & Dk Siti Raafiah Mansurrah Pg Saharuddin AGROME IQ International Sdn Bhd No.14, Level 2, iCentre Building, Simpang 32-37, Kg Anggerek Desa Jalan Berakas, Bandar Seri Begawan, BB3713, Brunei Darussalam Email: [email protected]

94) Mr Haji Ahmad Faiz bin Haji Abdul Rahim

Agrotech IBTE Agrotechnology Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE) Simpang 347, Jalan Pasar Baharu, Gadong BE1310, Bandar Seri Begawan Brunei Darussalam

95) Mr Md Yussof

JPCC Sales, Marketing & Events Jerudong Park Country Club Sdn Bhd Jerudong, BG3122, Negara Brunei Darussalam

96) Mr Shahrir Shafiek Marketing Manager (Asia) Marketing Department Labtech International Limited No. 16, 2nd Floor, Jalan Tengku Ampuan Zabedah D9/D Shah Alam, Malaysia Email: [email protected]

97) Mr H Zahir Hussain

Facility Manager–School of ICT SCS Information Technology Unit 1, Block A, Little SOHO, Spg 73-5-5, Batu Bersurat Pengkalan Gadong Brunei Muara , BE3719 Email: [email protected]

Page 37: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

As of 9 September 2019

1

PROGRAMME

Monday. 9 September 2019

07.30-08.30 Registration

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 08.30-09.15 Opening Ceremony

• Brunei National Anthem • SEAMEO Colors • Al-Fatihah & Do’a • SEAMEO Song • Message by Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela, Director, SEAMEO Secretariat • Opening Remarks and Keynote Message by YB Dato Seri Setia Haji Hamzah bin

Haji Sulaiman, the Minister of Education of Brunei Darussalam • Token of Appreciation from the Minister to Head of Delegates • Token of Appreciation from the SEAMEO Secretariat to the Minister of Education

of Brunei Darussalam • Group Photo

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 09.15-09.30 Official Announcement of Industry 4.0 Feature in SEA-VET.net

• Remarks by Dr Mohd Zamri Sabli, Centre Director, SEAMEO VOCTECH • Remarks by Mr Alexander Tsironis, Project Manager, GIZ/RECOTVET

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 09.30-10.00 Press Conference (Red Jade, Level 7)

Coffee Break (Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7) 10.00-11.10 Session 1: Country Initiatives: Strengthening Efforts toward TVET 4.0

• Keynote Speaker: “Digitalisation Industry 4.0: VET Challenges,

Approaches, Activities” by Mr. Herbert Tutschner, Head of Unit ‘Structure and Organisation of VET’, German Federal Institute for Vocational and Training (BIBB), Germany

• Country Presentations: Strengthening Efforts toward TVET 4.0 (10 minutes per country) o Brunei Darussalam: by YB Siti Rozaimeriyanty binti DSLJ Haji Abdul

Rahman, Legislative Council Member, President of Puja Brunei Darussalam, Director and Principal Architect of EcoBumi Arkitek

Page 38: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

As of 9 September 2019

2

o Indonesia: by Dr. Ir Bakrun, MM, Director of Technical and Vocational Education and Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education, Ministry of Education and Culture

o Malaysia: “TVET Efforts Toward TVET 4.0 from MOE Perspectives” by Mr Zainuren Haji Mohd Nor, Director of Technical and Vocational Education Division, Ministry of Education

o Singapore: “Singapore on Going Efforts towards TVET4.0” by Mr Vincent Yu, Senior Manager, Higher Education Policy Division, Ministry of Education

Moderator and Reflection: Dr Sheikh Lukman, Central Principal, Institute Brunei of Technical Education (IBTE)

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 11.10-12.30

Session 2: Regional Initiatives for TVET Development in Southeast Asia by Development Agencies (For information and endorsement) 6 minutes/presentation Moderated by Dr Mohd Zamri Sabli, Centre Director, SEAMEO VOCTECH 1. Progress Report of ASEAN TVET Development Council

By Dr Elmer K Talavera, Executive Director, National Institute for TESD (NITESD), TESDA, Philippines

2. ASEAN Initiatives for TVET Development By Ms Pitchanuch Supavanich, Senior Officer, Human Development Directorate/ labour and Civil Service Division, ASEAN Secretariat

3. Future ASEAN Agenda for TVET (GIZ-RECOTVET) By Mr Bahrin Mohammad, Council Member (Education & Examination) Institute of Surveyors, Engineers & Architects Brunei.

4. Regional Cooperation on TVET 4.0 for the Year 2020-2030 By Mr Ingo Imhoff, Programme Director, RECOTVET Programmme, GIZ, Vietnam

5. SEAMEO VOCTECH-GIZ/RECOTVET Modules for Industry 4.0 By Ms Siriporn Parvikam, Programme Component Manager, GIZ/RECOTVET, Thailand

6. Survey to Assess Industry and TVET Institutions Readiness for Industry 4.0 By Dr Paryono, Deputy Director, SEAMEO VOCTECH, Brunei Darussalam

Moderated by Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela, Director, SEAMEO Secretariat 7. Skill 4.0 for Industry

By Mr Jonathan Ledger, Global TVET Specialist, Department of International Trade, UK

8. TVET Regional Initiative of UNESCO on Entrepreneurship Education By Ms Yoojeong Seo, Programme Specialist, UNESCO-Bangkok

9. Towards a Community of Shared Future: China-ASEAN TVET Collaboration By Ms Zhou Hui, Deputy Director, ASEAN China Centre

10. SEAMOLEC Initiative on the Online Course Development by Utilizing Common ASEAN Tourism Curriculum (CATC) By Ms Chaya Kusuma Ratih, Manager (Research and Development), SEAMEO Regional Open Learning Centre (SEAMEO SEAMOLEC)

11. Progress Report on TVET Training for Special Educational Needs Teachers and Proposal By Ms Hjh Salmah Binti Jopri, Centre Director, SEAMEO Regional Centre for Special Education (SEAMEO SEN)

12. SEA-TVET Student Exchange Programme By Ms Piyapa Su-angavatin, Project Officer, SEAMEO Secretariat

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 12.30-14.00 Lunch (Season Restaurant, 2nd Floor)

Page 39: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

As of 9 September 2019

3

14.00-15.30 Session 3.1: High Officials Round Table Meeting Moderator: Dr Ethel Agnes P Valenzuela, Director, SEAMEO Secretariat Co-Moderator: Dr Mohd Zamri Sabli, Centre Director, SEAMEO VOCTECH Guiding Questions: 1. From the presentations in session 1

“Country Initiatives: Strengthening Efforts toward TVET 4.0”, what actions should be taken and forms of collaboration at the regional level in response to this new development in the Southeast Asian region in the next three years?

2. From the presentations in session 2

“Regional Initiatives for TVET Development in Southeast Asia, what are the feedbacks and recommendations from the TVET High Officials?

3. What other effective interventions

should we include as top regional flagship project to promote TVET collaboration, harmonisation and mobility in the Southeast Asian region?

Note: Only TVET High Officials and Ministry Coordinators are invited.

Meeting Room, Level 7

Session 3.2: Skill Development for TVET 4.0 Speakers: • IR4.0 Skill Development Initiatives

at Politeknik Brunei, by Dr Tang Shi Siong, Head of Quality Assurance Departmet/Acting Head School of Engineering, Politeknik Brunei

• The Development of Holistic Human Capital for Industry 4.0 Readiness, by Mr Ngan Cheng Hwa, Specialist Technical Training Officer, German-Malaysia Institution

• Preparing Korean TVET for Dealing with TVET 4.0, by Ms Young Sun Ra, President, KRIVET (Korea)

• KOSEN Projects in Thailand by Dr Tsutomu Matsumoto, Director, Japanese-Thai KOSEN, Japan

Moderator: Mr Ian John Wall, Head of School, School of Business, Politeknik Brunei Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7

15.30-15.45 Coffee Break (Front Area, Level 7) 15.45-17.00

Session 4.1: High Officials Round Table Meeting (Continued)

Session 4.2: Public-Private Partnership Model towards TVET 4.0 Speakers: • Enhancing Industry Collaboration

for Successful Implementation/ Integration of IR 4.0 by Mr Jonathan Ledger, Global TVET Specialist, Department of International Trade, UK

• Improving TVET through PPP with collaboration, Dr Steve McKee, President of LabTech and President of WorldDIDAC

• Industry Technical Skills Accumulation System by Mr Lu Chuyang, Deputy Director, National E-Commerce Vocational Teaching Steering Committee, PR China

Moderator: Dr Suhaimi bin Haji Abdul Wahub, Acting Principal Satellite, Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE)

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7

Page 40: SUMMARY REPORT - SEAMEO HOM on SEA-TVET, 9-10... · 2019. 10. 9. · SUMMARY REPORT . The 5th High Officials Meeting (HOM) on Southeast Asia - Technical and Vocational Education and

As of 9 September 2019

4

17.15-18.00 Session 5: Bilateral/Networking Meeting between Countries and Institutions Organised by Ms Noorhayati Cynthia binti Abdullah, Training and Professional Development Manager cum TVET Specialist, SEAMEO VOCTECH

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 19.00-20.30 Welcome Dinner at the Tarindak d’Polo Restaurant (Remarks by MOE/VOCTECH)

Level 2 Tuesday. 10 September 2019

09.00-10.00

Session 6: Synthesis and Ways Forward • Report from Bilateral/Networking Session

By Ms Noorhayati Cynthia binti Abdullah, Training and Professional Development Manager cum TVET Specialist, SEAMEO VOCTECH

• Synthesis and Ways Forward By Dr Paryono, Deputy Director Professional Affairs/Research Specialist, SEAMEO VOCTECH Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7

10.00-10.30 Coffee Break (Front Area, Level 7)

10.30-11.30

Closing Ceremony • Declaration of Agreements from the High Official Round Table Meeting by Dr Ethel

Agnes P Valenzuela, Director, SEAMEO Secretariat and Dr Mohd Zamri Sabli, Centre Director, SEAMEO VOCTECH

• Closing Remarks by Mr Haji Azman bin Ahmad, Permanent Secretary (Higher Education), Ministry of Education, Brunei Darussalam

• Presentation of Token of Appreciation from the SEAMEO Secretariat to the Hosts: 1) Mr Haji Azman bin Ahmad, Permanent Secretary (Higher Education) Brunei Darussalam, 2) Institute of Brunei Technical Education (IBTE), 3) Politeknik Brunei, and 4) SEAMEO VOCTECH

Goldstones Ballroom, Level 7 11.30-13.30 Lunch (Season Restaurant, Level 2) 14.00-17.00 Study Visit

14:00-17:00: Visiting to AGROMEiQ (An agriculture technology platform that provides farming solutions and increases overall farm productivity- www.agromeiq.com)

Contact Persons:

• SEAMEO Secretariat, Bangkok:

Ms Piyapa Su-angavatin Project Officer/SEA-TVET Coordinator Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]

• SEAMEO VOCTECH, Brunei Darussalam Ms Nursyuhaidah Haji Ahmad (For matters on 30th SEAMEO VOCTECH Governing Board Meeting) Email: [email protected]. Dr Paryono Deputy Director Professional Affairs/Research Specialist Email: [email protected]

• Ministry of Education, Brunei Darussalam Mr Walter Chong Meng Siong, Head of International Affairs Unit Email: [email protected] Ms Mariana Nordin Education Officer, IBTE Email: [email protected];