superconducting cable technology for renewable energy ...terrawatts.com/wirec-hayashi.pdf80 60 40 20...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Sup
erco
nduc
ting
Cab
le T
echn
olog
yfo
r Ren
ewab
le E
nerg
y Tr
ansm
issi
on
March
6, 20
08Ka
zuhi
ko H
ayas
hiGe
nera
l Man
ager
SUMI
TOMO
ELE
CTRI
C IN
DUST
RIES
, LTD
.
HTS
Cab
le
WIR
EC20
08 (
Mar
ch 6
, 200
8)
2
Unb
elie
vabl
e P
erfo
rman
ces
of H
TS D
I-BS
CC
O
0
500
1,00
0
1,50
0
2,00
0
050
100
150
200
250
Cur
rent
(A)
Voltage (μV)
Res
ista
nceCu
200m
m2
(-1
96℃
)
DI-B
SCC
O0.
9mm
2
Ic=2
10A
(-1
96℃
)
No
Res
ista
nce
①S
uper
Hig
h C
arry
ing
Cur
rent
!②
No
Tran
smis
sion
(C
urre
nt)
Loss
!①
Supe
r Hig
h C
arry
ing
Cur
rent
!②
No
Tran
smis
sion
(C
urre
nt)
Loss
!
3
Crit
ical
Cur
rent
(Ic)
2004
: Epo
ch M
akin
g Y
ear t
o D
I-BS
CC
OC
T-O
P (C
onTr
olle
d O
ver P
ress
ure)
DI-B
SCC
O
Den
sity
: 100
%
10µm
Smal
ler &
Les
s D
iffer
ent P
hase
s
150~
210A
(525
A/c
m-w
idth
)10
0%up
Tens
ile S
treng
th(a
t R.T
.)>1
50M
Pa
>1.5
tim
es
Uni
t Len
gth
Long
er th
an 1
mile
4 tim
esY
ield
90%
and
abo
ve-
Pre
ssur
e: 3
00 b
ar(=3
0MP
a)Te
mp.
: 900
℃C
onte
nt o
f O2
is c
ontro
lled
Yea
rIc(A, 77K)×Wire Length (m)
0
50,00
0
100,0
00
150,0
00
200,0
00
250,0
00 1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
10A
20A
40A
110A
165A20
1A
Ic(7
7K)
DI-B
SCC
OBSCCO
YBCO
210A
201A
165A
110A
40A
20A
10A
Ic (
77K)
Pre
ssur
e: 3
00 b
ar(=3
0MP
a)Te
mp.
: 900
℃
210A
4mm
0.9mm
2
0.23mm
Trad
ition
alC
oppe
rH
TSB
I-BSC
CO
≒1A
/mm
2
[w
ith L
oss]
150~
210
A/m
m2 (
77k:
LiN
2)
~42
0 A
/mm
2 (65
k:Li
N2)
~1,
200A
/mm
2 (20
k:Li
H2)
~1,
500A
/mm
2 (4k
:Li
He)
[w
ith N
o Lo
ss]
410
0m-1
14M
VA
-100
0A C
able
Col
d di
elec
tric
desi
gned
3-P
hase
in O
ne C
ryos
tat
φ13
6mm
φ39
mm
Cor
ruga
ted
SUS
pipe
cry
osta
t (th
erm
al in
sula
tion)
-Hig
h In
tegr
ity
form
er
Supe
rcon
duct
ing
cond
ucto
r
PPLP
Ele
ctric
insu
latio
n(h
igh
diel
ectr
ic s
tres
s,sm
all d
iele
ctric
loss
)D
evel
oped
by
SEI
Supe
rcon
duct
ing
shie
ld
Bi-2
223
tape
0.5m
m
5
Non
-Exp
losi
ve
Non
-Fla
mm
able
Gre
en
No
Indu
stria
lW
aste
Liquid Nitrogen Coolant
HTS
Cab
le
Superconductivity
Larg
e C
urre
nt
Car
ryin
g
EM
I-Fre
eN
o E
lect
rom
agne
ticP
ollu
tion
AC
DC
❊D
isas
ter P
reve
ntio
n ❊
Gre
en❊
Ultr
a Lo
ng L
ife
21st
Cen
tury
-Sty
le
❊La
rge
Cap
acity
Tra
nsm
issi
on❊
Ene
rgy
Sav
ing
❊E
MI-f
ree
Ultr
a Lo
w L
oss
Pow
er C
able
Advanced
Green
Ext
ingu
isha
ble
No
Ther
mal
Exp
ansi
on
or C
ontra
ctio
n(N
o D
egra
datio
n C
able)
Mer
its o
f HTS
Cab
le
6
0
20
40
60
80
05
10
15
Inst
alla
tion
Cos
t(M
$/km
)
Mod
elC
apac
ity:1
500M
VA
0
200
400
600
800
Loss
Red
uctio
n(c
onv.
to In
itial
Cos
t)&
CO
2Em
issi
on(M
$/km
)
Tran
smis
sion
Loss
(kW
/km
)
Inst
alla
tion
HTS
Cab
le
(66k
V 3-
in-O
ne)
HTS
Cab
le
(66k
V 3-
in-O
ne)
Con
vent
iona
l Cab
le
(275
kV S
ingl
e Ph
ase)
DC
AC
600
8002100
340
Conventional
Cable
Troughing
Tunnel
150
230
HTS
Cab
le
150
Duc
t
HTS
Cab
le
150
Duc
t
Tunn
el C
ost
Cab
leLo
ss R
educ
tion
CO
2Em
issi
on
Red
uctio
n of
Lo
ss
CO
2Em
issi
on(1
00$/
t-C)
Con
ditio
nIc
of W
ire:2
00A
CO
P:0
.1G
ener
atio
n:0.
1$/k
Wh
Load
Fac
tor:1
.0Tu
nnel
Cos
t:70k
$/m
Loss
Red
uctio
nC
O2
Emis
sion
1/2
1/4
1/4
1/10
〈77
8ton
-C/k
m/y
ear〉
〈21
0ton
-C/k
m/y
ear〉
〈21
ton-
C/k
m/y
ear〉
〈C
O2
Red
uctio
n〉Eco
nom
ical
Eva
luat
ion
of H
TS C
able
7A
lban
y Pr
ojec
t : P
roje
ct O
verv
iew
Pro
ject
Man
ager
; Site
Infra
stru
ctur
e,
Man
ufac
ture
of 2
nd g
ener
atio
n H
TS c
ondu
ctor
Hos
t util
ity, c
onve
ntio
nal c
able
&
syst
em p
rote
ctio
n, s
yste
m im
pact
st
udie
sD
esig
n, b
uild
, ins
tall,
and
test
the
HTS
cab
le, t
erm
inat
ions
, & jo
int
Des
ign,
con
stru
ct a
nd o
pera
te th
e C
ryog
enic
Ref
riger
atio
n S
yste
m, a
nd
prov
ide
over
all c
able
rem
ote
mon
itorin
g an
d ut
ility
inte
rface
Sup
porte
d by
Fed
eral
(DO
E) a
nd N
Y
Sta
te (N
YS
ER
DA
) Fun
ds
•350
m lo
ng -
34.5
kV -
800A
rms
-48M
VA
•Col
d di
elec
tric,
3 p
hase
s-in
-1 c
ryos
tat
•Wor
ld fi
rst i
n-gr
id o
pera
tion
in A
lban
y, N
Y
8
Wor
ld F
irst i
n-G
rid U
nder
grou
nd H
TS c
able
Cab
le
Join
tC
oolin
g S
yste
m
Nor
th T
erm
inat
ion
Sou
th te
rmin
atio
n
July
20,
2006
21:
00E
ST
Onl
ine
<-W
orld
’s 1
stde
mo.
9
Ope
ning
Cer
emon
y on
Aug
ust 2
Join
t
350m
Term
inat
ion
Coo
ling
Sys
tem
Hig
hway
OH
line
Vau
lt
Duc
tD
uct
3-in
-One
HTS
Cab
le34
.5kV
, 0.8
kA
NY
Sta
te G
over
nor
G. E
. Pat
aki
SE
I Pre
side
nt &
CE
O
M. M
atsu
mot
o
Grid
Con
nect
ion
on J
uly
20, 2
006
10O
pera
tion
in G
RID
Ope
ratio
n fro
m J
uly
20th
.
60
62
64
66
68
70
72
74 8/3
8/4
8/5
8/6
8/7
8/8
8/9
8/10
Date
Temperature [K]
0246810
12
14
16
Transmitted Electricity (MVA)
Cable O
utlet Temp.
Cable Inlet Temp.
Transm
itted
Electricity
11
GGlo
bal EE
nerg
y NN
etw
ork
EEqui
pped
with
SSol
ar c
ells
and
IIn
tern
atio
nal SS
uper
cond
ucto
r grid
s In
tern
atio
nal S
uper
cond
ucto
r Grid
s w
ill
mak
e th
e gl
obal
ele
ctric
ity, f
low
ing
from
D
ay to
Nig
ht a
nd S
unsh
ine
to R
ainy
with
ve
ry li
ttle
loss
, pos
sibl
e.O
nly
4 %
of t
he w
orld
’s d
eser
t are
a ca
n sa
tisfy
the
wor
ld’s
dem
and
of e
lect
ricity
ge
nera
ted
with
Sol
ar C
ell o
f 10%
ef
ficie
ncy.
HTS
Cab
le G
rid
Ele
ctric
ity
GE
NE
SI
S
Glob
al-siz
ePo
wer N
etwo
rkCo
untry
-size
Powe
r Net
work
Towa
rd M
ater
ializa
tion
of “G
ENES
IS”P
rojec
t
Solar
-batt
ery
Arra
y
Tran
smiss
ionSt
ation
Engla
nd &
Th
e Eur
opea
nCo
ntine
nt
The A
sian
Conti
nent
Priva
te Ho
uses
The A
meric
anCo
ntine
nt
Japa
n
Loca
l-Size
Pow
er N
etwo
rk
GEN
ESIS
Pro
ject “H
TS D
C Ca
ble”+
“Sola
r Batt
ery F
arm”
“GEN
ESIS
”Pro
ject
“Sol
ar B
atte
ry F
arm
”“H
TS D
C Ca
ble” “G
ENES
IS”P
rojec
t
12
[Fr
om D
r. K
oich
i Kita
zaw
a]
Cle
an P
ower
Net
wor
k A
ll A
roun
d Th
e W
orld
Util
izin
g “H
igh
Tem
pera
ture
Sup
er C
ondu
ctin
g C
able
s”
HTS
Cabl
ePh
otov
olta
icPo
wer
Win
d Po
wer
13
500
to 1
,000
kV
OH
L
Con
vent
iona
l Nuc
lear
Pla
nt o
f 20
th C
entu
ry
Ele
ctric
ity o
f 1 G
W is
gen
erat
ed
at a
pla
nt a
t sea
sid
e an
d tra
nsm
itted
ove
r a lo
ng d
ista
nce
thro
ugh
high
-vol
tage
, low
-cur
rent
O
HL.
Win
d Fa
rm &
Sol
ar F
arm
of
21st
Cen
tury
Ele
ctric
ity o
f 1 G
W is
gen
erat
ed
by 1
0 to
100
units
of g
ener
ator
s lo
cate
d at
offs
hore
, des
ert o
r ot
her r
emot
e ar
eas.
Tran
smis
sion
ove
r a lo
ng
dist
ance
can
be
achi
eved
th
roug
h lo
w-v
olta
ge h
igh-
curr
ent H
TS D
C c
able
.
(1G
W N
ucle
ar P
lant
)
変電
所
Und
ergr
ound
Tr
ansm
issi
on
Cab
le
S/S
Out
put V
olta
geSe
vera
l 100
V
to S
ever
al k
VSu
bmar
ine
cabl
e(1
kV x
1 M
illio
n A)
Win
d Fa
rm
Sub
stat
ion
(Vol
tage
Incr
ease
)
500
to 1
,000
kV
1,00
0 to
2,0
00 A
Sol
ar F
arm
Ove
rhea
d Li
ne (O
HL)
Con
vent
iona
l Cu
or A
lcab
les
have
larg
e tra
nsm
issi
on lo
ss a
nd e
xtre
mel
y la
rge
num
ber
of c
able
s ne
ed to
be
inst
alle
d
HTS
Cab
le (
smal
l los
s an
d co
mpa
ct)
DC
Cab
le(1k
V×1
Mill
ion
A)
1-G
W L
ow-v
olta
ge, H
igh-
curr
ent T
rans
mis
sion
Sys
tem
U
sing
HTS
DC
Cab
le a
t & fr
om W
ind
& S
olar
Far
ms
太陽電池
ファーム[1]
太陽電池
ファーム[n]
風力発電
ファーム[n]
: :: :
Sola
r far
m
[1]
Sola
r far
m
[n]
Win
d fa
rm [n
]
Seco
nda
ry
batte
ry
Seco
nda
ry
batte
ry
既存の
ACネットワーク
Sol
ar
batte
ry
(1)
変換
所
*D
C/A
C In
verte
r*
Volta
ge-u
pTr
ansf
orm
er*
Faul
t Cur
rent
Lim
iter
*C
urre
nt c
ontro
l
Oth
er g
roup
s of
sol
ar o
r w
ind
farm
s
① ②
(DC
)(A
C)
(DC
)
(AC
)
(AC
)
*S
ever
al to
sev
eral
ten
kV*
Sev
eral
ten
thou
sand
to
seve
ral h
undr
ed th
ousa
nd
ampe
res
Ove
r sev
eral
hun
dred
th
ousa
nd k
w
Coo
ling
stat
ion
(1)
(Lon
g-di
stan
ce, l
ow-v
olta
ge &
larg
e-ca
paci
ty)
HTS
DC
cab
les
(D
C)
Inve
rter
/con
ver
ter s
tatio
n
DC
/AC
inve
rter
AC
(or
DC
) ne
twor
k fo
r co
nsum
ers
Key
poi
nts
Plur
ality
of H
TS D
C c
able
sM
ultil
ater
al p
ower
net
wor
k
Exi
stin
g A
C n
etw
ork
Sol
ar
batte
ry
(2)
Coo
ling
stat
ion
(2)
Faul
t cur
rent
lim
iter
Con
cept
of G
enew
able
Ene
rgy
Tran
smis
sion
by
HTS
DC
cab
les
14
Sola
r Far
mTo
tal s
pace
:A
bout
2,7
50 m
x 5
00 m
DC
/DC
co
nver
ter
HTS
DC
Cab
le S
yste
m(m
onop
olar
, 1,5
00 V
to12
kA
)×6
cabl
es
Ther
mal
insu
latio
nO
uter
cry
osta
t pip
eA
nti-c
orro
sion
jack
etLi
N2
circ
ulat
ion
Inne
r cry
osta
t pip
eC
able
cor
e
90φ
Insu
latio
n
Form
erH
TS c
ondu
ctor
HTS
shi
eld 100-
MW
-cla
ss S
yste
m
Sol
ar fa
rm
Sol
ar b
atte
ry u
nit
of s
ever
al
hund
red
kW c
lass
DC
/DC
co
nver
ter
Sol
ar fa
rm
Sol
ar b
atte
ry u
nit
of s
ever
al
hund
red
kW c
lass
HTS
DC
cab
le (
1,50
0 V
DC)
15
Ste
p-by
-ste
p de
velo
pmen
t of
“ Gen
esis
Pro
ject
”
Ste
p Ⅰ
Ste
p Ⅱ
Ste
p Ⅲ
Ste
p Ⅳ
*Ind
ividu
al ho
uses
*Sm
all-sc
ale co
mmun
ities
*Ba
ttery
& co
nver
ter*
Auton
omou
s con
sump
tion
*Sm
all so
lar/w
ind fa
rms
*Co
nnec
tion t
o exis
ting g
rid*
Small
to m
edium
-size
d batt
ery
& co
nver
sion s
ystem
*Cu
cable
& S
i-bas
ed co
nver
ter*
Sale
of ge
nera
ted po
wer
*Sm
all to
larg
e sola
r/wind
farm
s*
Conn
ectio
n to
exist
ing
AC n
etwo
rk &
ne
twor
k bet
ween
farm
s*
Midd
le to
large
-scale
batte
ry(*1) &
conv
erter
*Cu
cable
+HT
S DC
cabl
eAp
plica
tion
of A
s Man
y SiC
Dev
ices
As P
ossib
le*
Sale
of po
wer is
domi
nant
*Sm
all to
larg
e sola
r/wind
farm
s*
HTS
DC ca
ble n
etwo
rk
(Ul
tra-lo
ng, L
arge
Pow
er T
rans
miss
ion
with
Low
Los
s)→
Esta
blish
men
t of “
glob
al po
wer g
rid”
*Si
C lo
w-lo
ss co
nver
ter
*In
tern
atio
nal in
terc
onne
ctio
n of
ele
ctric
powe
r*
PPLP
Sol
id D
C su
bmar
ine c
able
(Ul
tra-lo
ng in
tern
atio
nal in
terc
onne
ctio
n)[*
No b
atte
ry is
nee
ded
in p
rincip
le]
(Loc
al)(L
ocal:
Dom
estic
)W
ithin
indivi
dual
powe
r com
pany
’s se
rvice
ter
ritory:
Dom
estic
Multi
natio
nal:
Inte
rnat
iona
l inte
rcon
nect
ion
In p
ract
ice(
2020
-205
0-)
(Sol
ar b
atte
ries)
Batte
ry
Sola
r fa
rm
Batte
ry
Inve
rter
Sola
r fa
rm Batte
ry
Inve
rter
(Si)
Exis
ting
AC
net
wor
k
Con
sum
ptio
nar
ea
Sola
r far
m
(1)
Sola
r far
m
(2)
Con
sum
ptio
nar
eaE
xist
ing
AC
ne
twor
k
Sola
r far
m
(3)
Sola
r far
m
(4)
HTS
DC
cab
le in
terc
onne
ctio
n
(C
u ca
ble)
Sola
r fa
rm
PPLP
Soli
dDC
cabl
e
HTS
DC
cab
le in
terc
onne
ctio
n
Subm
arine
cab
le
inter
conn
ectio
n
Step
ISt
ep II
ISt
ep I
ISt
ep IV
Con
vers
ion
sy
stem
(Fro
m 2
010
to 2
050
)(F
rom
202
0 to
205
0 )
Part
ially
in p
ract
ice
Sola
r fa
rm
As
man
y Si
C c
onve
rter
s as
po
ssib
le c
an b
e ap
plie
(*1)
Bat
tery
can
be
omitt
ed w
hen
netw
ork
has
suffi
cent
pow
er s
tora
ge
capa
bilit
y.
HTS
DC
cab
le n
etw
ork
(Ultr
a-lo
ng-d
ista
nce,
larg
e-po
wer
tr
ansm
issi
on w
ith lo
w lo
ss)16