supporting research and findings: 1. review of …€¦ · · 2014-10-09review of surrounding...
TRANSCRIPT
1
SUPPORTING RESEARCH AND FINDINGS: 1. Review of surrounding high-density residential development Staff reviewed several multi-dwelling projects around the university and in other parts of the community for the number of units, number of bedrooms, number of required parking and number of parking provided. Specific developments requested by the City Commission were included in the review. Staff focused on larger projects associated with high-density residential development. Not counted in this summary are large homes that have been converted to multi-dwelling residential structures and boarding houses. Staff did include some Greek housing located immediately adjacent to the University. Most of the high-density residential development occurred prior to the adoption of the 2006 Land Development Code. The significant difference between the two codes is the changes to allowable density and the off-street parking calculation. Prior to 2006, very high-density residential uses [Greek housing and dormitory-type residences halls] were located in the RD-(Residence-Dormitory) District. This area included all of the KU campus area east of Iowa Street, as well as areas surrounding the University. See Figure 1. Other zoning district that permitted a very high-density1 residential use included RM-2, RM-2A, RM-3, RO-1 and RO-1A. These zoning districts were located adjacent to the RD district in the Oread Neighborhood or along the major arterial street corridors such as N. Iowa, W. 6th Street, Bob Billings Parkway, Clinton Parkway, and S. Iowa Street. One exception to this location description is a large area zoned RM-2 located in the Pinckney Neighborhood north of W. 6th Street. While zoned for high-density development, much of the Pinckney Neighborhood area is developed at a density less than 20 dwelling units per acre. See Figure 2.
Prior to 2006, a large area both north and east of the KU Campus was zoned RD (Residence-Dormitory District). This district allowed the highest maximum density, 54 dwelling units per acre, of any residential district in the City. The next highest density residential district was RM-3 at 43 dwelling units per acre. These districts were associated with multiple-family dwellings and dormitory type residence halls as well as Fraternity and Sorority uses. The Land Development Code, adopted in 2006, provides a distinction between very high-density residential development and Greek housing. The code substantially reduced the area zoned for Greek housing to areas that were currently developed with or owned by Greek organizations. See Figure 3. The maximum density allowed in the highest intensity residential zoning districts was also adjusted downward from 54 to 32 dwelling units per acre.2
1 High-density residential use is density of 16 dwelling units per acre or greater. 2 Additional density can be earned in residential zoning districts in some cases by using bonus points to achieve a higher overall density.
2
Prior to 2006 off-street parking required for these districts was based on bedrooms or units, depending on the use or base zoning district.
Spaces Bedroom 1.5 Per each 1 bedroom apartment or studio 1.5 Per each 2 bedroom apartment (other than RM-3 or RD) 2.5 Per each 3 bedroom apartment or larger (other than RM-3 or RD)
1 Per bedroom for 2 bedroom apartment or larger when located in in RM-3 or RD 1.5 Per 2 lawful occupants of fraternity, sorority, dormitory type residence hall, and
rooming/boarding house
Most of the multi-dwelling and fraternity/sorority uses surrounding the university were developed under this design standard. The following table provides a summary of specific high-density multi-dwelling uses in the immediate area surrounding the proposed Here at Kansas as requested by the City Commission.
Sample of High Density Residential Development Around University
Address Units Bedrooms Parking Required
Parking Provided Neighborhood
Use/Project Name
1400 BBP 627 1036 1089 1128 Sunset Hills Meadowbrook 1043 Indiana St. 32 102 114 114 Oread Varsity House
1200 Oread Mixed-Use/10 condo 311 reduced
to 167 200 Oread The Oread 1800 Naismith Dr. 252 459 unknown 228 University Place Naismith Hall 1605 Tennessee St. 24 44 44 45 Oread Melrose Place
Additional high-density residential developments were also reviewed for bedrooms and off-street parking requirements. The attached tables and maps provide a comparison of these various developments. As expected, developments farther from the university include larger parking areas. Off-street parking is dominated by surface lots rather than garages other structured type parking. Many multi-dwelling projects do provide carports as an amenity for some portion of the off-street parking for the development.
3
2. Review of other collage towns: Staff reviewed the parking requirements for multi-family developments in the Big 12 university communities as well as four previous Big 12 communities. As expected, the results are varied. The Lawrence Development Code requires 1 space per bedroom + 1 space per 10 dwelling units to accommodate guests. The majority of communities require 1 – 2 spaces for each one-bedroom unit. The most variation is seen in the three- and four-bedroom units where requirements vary from 1 – 4 spaces per unit. The average requirement for a three-bedroom apartment was 2.5 spaces per unit.
Several of the codes included special standards for either mixed use districts or districts near downtown or campus locations. As noted, the Lawrence Development Code increased requirements in 2006 to require additional parking for larger-bedroom developments. With current work to analyze and revise various standards in ARTICLE 9 – PARKING, LOADING AND
ACCESS, it may be appropriate for Staff to do additional research to determine the specific needs for apartment developments in Lawrence. See Spreadsheet.
4
3. KU Parking Review Jayhawker Towers and Stauffer Place are the only apartments on Campus. Currently much of the parking for Stauffer Place is used by the Daisy Field (Daisy Hill) freshman due to the loss of Daisy Field (Daisy Hill) parking lots to construction. Stauffer Place also has a large international graduate student population. International students most often do not own cars and thus do not purchase permits. An observation provided by KU parking staff is that GSP/Corbin and the Scholarship Hall residents are located close enough to available City streets with on-street parking and are likely to choose to park off-campus rather than purchase a student parking pass. See Figure 4.
Hall (Capacity) Actual Residents
Class of Permit Holder
# Permits
Sold
% with Permits
Jayhawker Towers (747) 672 Class 432 64% Freshman 168 Freshman 88 52% Sophomore 228 Sophomore 147 64% Junior 133 Junior 102 77% Senior 126 Senior 91 72% Graduate 17 Graduate 4 24%
Hall (Capacity) Actual
Residents Class of Permit
Holder #
Permits Sold
% with Permits
Stouffer Place (269) 200 Class 141 71% Freshman 2 Freshman 31 1550% Sophomore 2 Sophomore 0 0% Junior 7 Junior 5 71% Senior 15 Senior 15 100% Graduate 174 Graduate 90 52%
See Spreadsheet for complete KU parking data summary. Assumptions for applying parking to the Here project:
1. The proposed Here project will function similar to the apartments on campus and be dominated by a higher percentage of upper-class students (non-freshman).
2. An average of the sophomore, junior and senior residents that currently having parking permits in the Jayhawker Tower apartments is to 71%.
3. Applying the 71% of permitted vehicles to the Here project calculates to a requirement of requires 477 off-street parking spaces for the residential use.
[71% of 672 occupants = 477 students with a car]
£¤59
£¤40-59
£¤40
£¤59
UV10
Iowa S
t
Kaso
ld Dr
W 6th St
W 23rd StClinton Pkwy
Bob Billings Pkwy
Irving HillR
dEngelRd
M em oria lDrJa yha w k Blv
d
Petefish Dr
Sunnysid e AveWestb roo ke St
M esa W a y
Bec kerDr
SunflowerRd
W estPerim eterRd
Lila cLn
Anna Dr Oliver Dr
Sc hwegler Dr
W 14th StAlum niPl
Ha nover Pl
Ja na Dr
W 21st St
Burdick Dr
Gla c ierDr
High Dr
Simons Dr
Creek Dr
Chipp erfie
ld Rd
W 5th St
Vermont St
Indiana St
Ridge Ct
W 10th St
W 22nd St
Illinois St
W 26th St
Missouri St
Ya le Rd
Rhode Island StAlabama St
W 22nd Ter
New Hampshire St
JanaDr
EmeryRd
W 25th St
W 19th TerKasold Dr
Stra tford Rd
Sunset Dr
W 21st Ter
Arkans as St
Hilltop Dr
Ja suDr
W 29th Ter
Orc ha rd Ln
Tennessee St
Schwarz Rd
W 12th St
Florida St
Ha rva rd Rd
Marvonne Rd
Frontier Rd
W 17th St
Un iversityDr
Melholland Rd
Holiday Dr
Kentucky St
Highland Dr
Ohi oSt
Ava lon Rd
StAn d rews Dr
E 8th St
Top eka Ln
Engel Rd
Bluffs Dr
Da kota St
W 27th St
Rim roc k Dr
W 7th St
Wisconsin St
GillAve
La zyBroo k Ln
Kansa
s St
Wellin gton Rd
CrescentRd
Peb ble Ln
AtchisonAve
Red bud Ln
W 8th St
E 13th St
Murrow Ct
Ced a rwood Ave
Louisiana St
E 14th St
W 27th Ter
Stew a rtAve Clifton Ct
Yellowstone Dr
Flint Dr
Crestline Dr
W 24th Ter
W 24th St
W 20th St
M ea dowDr
E 21st St
W interb rook Dr W 29th St
Greever Ter
Madeline Ln
E 17th St
Steven Dr
E 16th St
Cynthia St
Apple Ln
W 20th Ter
E22nd St
Montana St
Pa rkHillTer
W 28th St
W 14th St
Belle Ha ven Dr
W estd a leRd
Ca m elb a c k Dr
Ca nyon Dr
Californi a St
Neb ra s
ka St
Free S
ta teLn
Pa rk Ave
Arizona St
W 18th St
Oxford Rd
W 15th St
Tra il Rd
IowaSt
Oread Ave
Jenny Wren Rd
Jona tha n Dr
Broad vie
w Dr
M urp hyDr
Mitchell Rd
South Pa rk St
W 28th Ter
Rockledge Rd
W 19th St
Michiga n St
Colora d o StW 13th St
Augusta Dr
Naismith Dr
Crestline Ct
Minnesota St
Maine St
Mississippi St
Terra c e Rd
Ca rd ina l Dr
E 7th St
Court St
W 9th St
W 16th St
W 21st Pl
W 7th St
Arkansas St
W 18th St
W 27th Ter
Redbud Ln
W 25th St
W 17th St
Mississippi St
Missouri St
W 28th Ter
Atc hisonAve
W 18th St
W 28th St
Oxford Rd
Alabam a St
W 24th St
Vermont St
W 20th St
W 26th StW 27th Ter
Crestline Dr
Ohio St
University Dr
Tennessee St
W 28th Ter
W 22nd St
Ohio St
W 28th St
Oxford Rd
W 25th St
Ava lon Rd
W 22nd Ter
W 8th St
W 27th St
W 21st St
Kentucky St
Tennessee StW 9th St
Lawrenc eAve
Maine St
Na ism ithDr
Tra ilRd
Vermont St
W 15th St
Massachusetts St
Ha rva rd Rd
W 24th St
E9th St
West Campus Rd
Lawrence Ave
Ha rva rd Rd
W 9th St
W 19th St
Louis
iana S
t
Mass
achu
setts
St
Universityof Kansas
HaskellIndian
NationsUniversity
£¤59
£¤40/59
£¤40
DISCLAIM ER NOTICEThe m a p is p rovid ed “a s is” without wa rra nty or a ny rep resenta tion of a c c ura c y, tim eliness or c om p leteness. The b urd en ford eterm ining a c c ura c y, c om p leteness, tim eliness, m erc ha nta b ility a nd fitness for or the a p p rop ria teness for use rests solely onthe requester. The City of La wrenc e m a kes no wa rra nties, exp ress or im p lied , a s to the use of the m a p . There a re no im p liedwa rra nties of m erc ha nta b ility or fitness for a p a rticula r p urp ose. The requester a c knowled ges a nd a c c ep ts the lim ita tions ofthe m a p , inc lud ing the fa c t tha t the m a p is d yna m ic a nd is in a c onsta nt sta te of m a intena nc e, c orrection a nd up d a te. Da te: 9/30/20141 inc h = 1,789 feet
900 0 900 1,800 2,700 3,600450Feet
Resid enc e-Dorm itory Distric t Zoning Pre 2006
LegendUniversitiesNAME
University of Ka nsa sRD Zoning (54 d u/AC)RM -3 (43 DU/AC)
§̈¦70
§̈¦70
£¤59
£¤40-59
£¤40 £¤59
UV10
UV10
I-70 Hwy
W 6th St
K-10 Hwy
Iowa S
t
Kaso
ld Dr
59 H
wy
N 1200 Rd
Clinton Pkwy
E 150
0 Rd
Waka
rusa
Dr
Bob Billings Pkwy
W 31st St
W 23rd St
Peterson Rd
E 23rd St
E 100
0 Rd
Hask
ell Av
e
N 3rd St
E 31st St
N Iow
a StE 1130 Rd
I-70 Hwy
E 900 Rd
E 140
0 Rd
E 120
0 Rd
W 9th St
W 19th St
Haskell Ave
Louis
iana S
t
N 1100 Rd
Mass
achu
setts
St
E 11th St
N 1 150 R d
N 1250 Rd
E 115
0 Rd
N 1300 Rd
N 1100 Rd
§̈¦70
OP10OP10
£¤40
£¤59
DISCLAIMER NOTICETh e m ap is prov id ed “as is” with out warranty or any representation of ac c uracy, tim eliness or c om pleteness. Th e burd en fordeterm ining ac c uracy, com pleteness, tim eliness, m erc h antability and fitness for or the appropriateness for use rests solely onth e requester. Th e City of Lawrence m ak es no warranties, express or im plied , as to th e use of the m ap. Th ere are no im pliedwarranties of m erc h antability or fitness for a partic ular purpose. The requester ac k nowled g es and ac cepts th e lim itations ofth e m ap, inc lud ing th e fact that th e m ap is d ynam ic and is in a c onstant state of m aintenance, c orrection and upd ate. Date: 10/1/20141 inc h = 4,369 feet
2,100 0 2,100 4,200 6,300 8,4001,050Feet
Hig h -Density Resid ential Zoning P re 2006
LegendUniversitiesNAME
Univ ersity of KansasRD Zoning (54 d u/AC)Hig h Density Resid ential (20+ DU/AC
GSP/Corbin
£¤59
Iowa S
t
EllisDr
IrvingHill
Rd
EngelRd
M em oria lDr
Ja yha wk Blvd
Sunnysid e Ave
Mississip p i St
SunflowerRd
Pop la rLn
Lila c Ln
AnnaDr
Ba gley
Dr
Oliver Dr
Sc hwegler Dr
W 14th St
Alum niPl
Ha noverPl
Louisiana St
Gower Pl
Allen Field house Dr
Pea rsonPl
Fambrough Wa y
Illinois St
Burdick Dr W esc oe Ha llDr
High Dr
Hoc h Aud itoriaDr
Ohio St
W 10th St
Vermont St
Emery Rd
Indiana St
W 19th Ter
Stra tford Rd
Sunset Dr
University DrW 13th St
Hilltop Dr
Illinois StW 12th St
W 17th St
Missouri St
Highland Dr
Ava lon Rd
Kentucky St
W 14th StAlabama St
Engel Rd
Tennessee St
Cresc e
ntRd
Louisiana St
Stew a rtAve
Clifton Ct
Arka nsa s St
W 20th St
Greever Ter
W 20th Ter
Hillview Rd
Em era ld Dr
Ha rva rd Rd
Michigan St
W 18th St
Oxford Rd
W 15th St
W 16th StOread Ave
High Dr
Strong Ave
Spe nc erDr Naismith Dr
Broa d
view DrDud ley Ct
Maine St
Mississippi St
Ed ge hillRd
Ca m b rid ge Rd
HillcrestRd
Ya le Rd
Sunnysid e Ave
Caro lin aSt
V a lley Ln
M itc hell Rd
W 9th St
W 8th Ter
W estH
illsTer
Mississippi St
W 20th St
Missouri St
Vermont St
Vermont St
W 17th St
Oxford Rd
Maine StArkansas St
W 18th St
Ohio St
Louisiana St
W 20th St
W 18th St
Sunset Dr
W 16th St
Illinois St
Alabama St
W 20th Ter
Alabam a St
Louisiana St Ohio St
Indiana St
M iss is sip pi St
W 21st St
Kentucky St
Tennessee St
Naismith Dr
W 15th St
Maine St
Vermont St
Massachusetts St
Mississippi St
West Campus Rd
Fa m b rough Dr
W 9th St
W 11th St
Naismith Dr
W 11th St
W 9th St
W 19th St
Louis
iana S
t
W 11th St
Universityof Kansas
U-KU
RS7
RS7
RM32
RS5
RS5
GPI
CD
CS
RS5
RMG
RS5
RM12DRM32
OS
RMG
RMO
RM32
GPIU-KU
CS
RM12RM32
GPIOS
RMG
RM24RM32
RM12
MURM12
OS
RMG
RMO
RMORM12D
GPI
RM32
RS7
CS
GPI
MU-PD
RSO
U-KU
CN2
RM12
RS7
RMG
RMG
CS
PCD
GPI
RSO
RMGRMG
MU
RM12
RSO
RS7PD
CN2
RM32
RSO
RM12
RM32-PDGPI
OS
RSO
U-KU
RM32
RM24
RM24
GPIRM24
RSO
RM24
RMO
RM32
GPI
OS
£¤59
DISCLAIM ER NOTICEThe m a p is p rovid ed “a s is” without wa rra nty or a ny rep resenta tion of a c c ura c y, tim eliness or c om p leteness. The b urd en ford eterm ining a c c ura c y, c om p leteness, tim eliness, m erc ha nta b ility a nd fitness for or the a p p rop ria teness for use rests solely onthe requester. The City of La wrenc e m a kes no wa rra nties, exp ress or im p lied , a s to the use of the m a p . There a re no im p liedwa rra nties of m erc ha nta b ility or fitness for a p a rticula r p urp ose. The requester a c knowled ges a nd a c c ep ts the lim ita tions ofthe m a p , inc lud ing the fa c t tha t the m a p is d yna m ic a nd is in a c onsta nt sta te of m a intena nc e, c orrection a nd up d a te. Da te: 10/6/20141 inc h = 902 feet
450 0 450 900 1,350 1,800225Feet
High-Density Resid entia l Zoning Pre 2006
LegendNAME
University of Ka nsa sRM G (M ulti-Dwelling/Greek Housing)RD Zoning (54 d u/AC)