sustain ble ann arbor forums - ann arbor, michigan...key climate change impacts for a2...

59
Ann Arbor Forums 2013 Sustain ble

Upload: others

Post on 18-Mar-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Ann Arbor Forums

2013

Sustain ble

Page 2: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Sustainability Framework Climate and Energy • Sustainable Energy • Energy Conservation • Sustainable Buildings

Community • Engaged Community • Diverse Housing • Human Services • Safe Community • Active Living and Learning • Economic Vitality

Land Use and Access • Transportation Options • Sustainable Systems • Integrated Land Use

Resource Management • Clean Air and Water • Healthy Ecosystems • Responsible Resource Use • Local Food

Page 3: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Sustainable Systems

• Plan for and manage constructed and natural infrastructure systems to meet the current and future needs of our community

Page 4: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Systems

Municipal Facilities

City-Owned Buildings

Parks and Recreation

Solid Waste

Transportation

Airport

Alternative Transportation

Bridges

New Streets

Other Transportation

Parking Facilities

Street Construction

Utilities

Sanitary Sewer System

Stormwater Management

Water System

Page 5: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Make Drinking Water

Distribute Drinking Water

Collect Wastewater

Treat Wastewater

Build New Streets

Repave Streets

Build Bridges

Inspect Bridges

Collect Trash

Own and manage Transfer Station Operator

Collect Recycling

Own and Manage Materials Recovery Center

Collect Compost

Own and Manage Compost Center

Manage old landfill and legacy contamination

Own and Manage Natural and Recreation Parks

Own and Manage 2 recreation and 2 hydro dams

Own and Manage stormwater collection system

Own and manage 2 canoe liveries

Page 6: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

WHAT IS CHANGING?

Page 7: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

WHAT EFFECTS CAN WE EXPECT?

Page 8: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

WHAT YOU CAN DO?

Page 10: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Municipal emissions % of total:

1.7% (2000) and 1.2% (2010)

Page 11: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

A FEW PLACES FOR MORE INFORMATION OR TO GET INVOLVED

Page 12: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Upcoming Forums FEBRUARY 13, 2013 • Economic Vitality

– Mary Jo Callan, Director, Washtenaw County Community and Economic Development

– Dan Gilmartin, Executive Director and CEO, Michigan Municipal League

– Paul Krutko, President and CEO, Ann Arbor SPARK – Ingrid Ault, Executive Director, Think Local First – Paul Saginaw, Founding Partner, Zingerman's Deli

MARCH 21, 2013 • Diverse Housing APRIL 18, 2013 • Transportation Options

Page 13: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Tonight: Sustainable Systems

• Daniel Brown, Great Lakes Integrated Sciences and Assessment (GLISA)

• Jennifer Lawson, Water Quality Manager

• Cresson Slotten, Systems Planning Unit Manager

• Rick Norman, Director of Emergency Management

• Jason Frenzel, Huron River Watershed Council

• Q & A

Page 14: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

More Information

Matthew Naud

Environmental Coordinator

[email protected]

www.a2gov.org/sustainability

www.a2energy.org/climate

Page 15: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Climate Change in Ann Arbor Daniel Brown, Research Associate, GLISA

Page 16: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

What is GLISA?

• Great Lakes Integrated Sciences and Assessments

• NOAA-funded research center, based at UM

• Network of environmental, social, and climate scientists

• Connects practitioners and scientists

• glisa.msu.edu

Page 17: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Global Trends and Regional Trends

Global Trends are more certain than regional trends.

Natural variability plays a larger role at the regional scale.

Local changes in land use can alter the severity of climate change impacts.

Page 18: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Observed Ann Arbor Temperature

Page 19: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Observed Ann Arbor Precipitation

25% Increase

Page 20: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Extreme Weather

The number of heavy precipitation storms has increased and will likely continue to increase.

But droughts could become more frequent and more severe as well.

Page 21: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Shorter Winters Across the Region

Earlier last winter frost in spring

Later first winter frost in autumn

Future growing season longer by

~1-2 months

Wubbles & Hayhoe (2004)

Page 22: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Changing Snow

Photo credits: NASA

• More precipitation falling as rain instead of snow

• Reduced overall snowfall for the region

• Reduced snow accumulation

• More lake effect precipitation events

Page 23: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Key Climate Changes for A2

• Warmer average temperatures

• Warmer low and nighttime temperatures

• Shorter winters

• More total precipitation

• More severe precipitation events

• More extreme heat and drought

Page 24: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Key Climate Change Impacts for A2

• Infrastructure

• Public Health – Risk of extreme heat

– Flooding and water contamination

– Emergency management

• Economic Impacts – Tourism, recreation

– Transportation

Page 25: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination
Page 26: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Office of Emergency Management

Climate Change and Sustainability

Rick Norman PEM

Director of Emergency Management

City of Ann Arbor

Page 27: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Climate Change and Disasters

FEMA - Crisis Response and Disaster Resilience 2030:

Forging Strategic Action in an Age of Uncertainty

FEMA - Climate Change, Long Term Trends and their

Implications for Emergency Management

NOAA - National Climate Data Center

DHS – Department of Homeland Security - Climate Change

Adaptation Report

MSP – Emergency Management and Homeland Security

Division – Draft, Threat And Hazard Identification

And Risk Assessment (THIRA)

Page 28: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

What do We Do?

Hazard Mitigation Planning Completion of Hazard Mitigation Plan

Eligible for Hazard Mitigation Grants

Phases of Emergency Management

Prevention

Mitigation

Preparedness, Planning

Response

Recovery

Page 29: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Why are We Concerned about Climate Change?

Impact of Disasters on Life Safety and Property

Cost, Limited Resources

Population, Population Density, Critical Infrastructure

Health and Disease Pattern Changes

Page 30: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Sustainability

Informed

Prepared

Disaster Resilient

Able to Help Others

Ann Arbor Sustainable Framework

Engaged Community

Safe Community

Page 31: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Sustainability

Informed CodeRED, NOAA Weather Radio, Sirens,

GovDelivery, Social Media, CTN, Broadcast Radio and TV

Prepared Disaster Supply Kit, Communication Plan

Smoke Alarms, Escape Plan, Practice

Training - First Aid/CPR/AED, CERT

Disaster Resilient Recovery

Business COOP

Able to Help Others Know Your Neighbors

Page 32: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Sustainability Emergency Management Program

Drills and Exercises Testing Capabilities

Community Partner Collaboration Collaboration among all EM Programs

Regional Collaboration Homeland Security UASI Funding

Grants

Training

Page 33: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Rick Norman, PEM

[email protected]

734-794-6980

Page 34: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Climate Change…or...

“Extreme Weather Events”

Implications for Ann Arbor's Stormwater Infrastructure

Page 35: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination
Page 36: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Blue = open water Green = pipe

Page 37: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

How old is that City-owned Pipe?

Decade Constructed Feet of Main Miles of Main Percent of Total 1900s 410 0.08 0.03% 1910s 52,545 9.95 4.29% 1920s 135,768 25.71 11.09% 1930s 40,451 7.66 3.30% 1940s 37,775 7.15 3.09% 1950s 197,359 37.38 16.12% 1960s 303,638 57.51 24.80% 1970s 149,789 28.37 12.24% 1980s 69,027 13.07 5.64% 1990s 114,035 21.60 9.32% 2000s 60,835 11.52 4.97% 2010s 6,689 1.27 0.55% unknown 55,837 10.58 4.56% TOTAL 1,224,158 231.85

Page 38: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

231 Miles of Stormwater Pipe 241 Miles from Ann Arbor to Chicago

Page 39: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Where was the creek?

Page 40: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Allen Creek (Before the Pipe) ~1920

Page 41: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Impervious Issues

• im·per·vi·ous/: adjective: Not allowing something to pass through; not penetrable.

• If it doesn’t soak in - it runs into the stormwater system

Page 42: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination
Page 43: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Terminology and Science

Page 44: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Stormwater Management Systems

• Storm drains not designed to pass all storms

–1980’s to current: pipes constructed for the 10% annual chance storm

–1998 Study - $41,000,000 to get Allen Creek to current design standards • 2012 dollars: $61,000,000

– Surcharge into street & low-lying areas will occur

• City’s storm sewer inlets have a physical limitation.

Page 45: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

• Stormwater Pipes installed in 2012 on Stadium Bridges Project – sized for the design standard storm (10% chance)

Page 46: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Quantity vs. Quality

We are REGULATED on both.

Page 47: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

History of Stormwater Regulations

• Pre-1970: No Federal regulation

• 1970: Clean Water Act

• 1979: City Stormwater Ordinance

• 1990s: Clean Water Act reauthorization

• 1998: City Stormwater Ordinance

• Current: Low Impact Development (LID)

Page 48: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Overlapping Regulatory Jurisdictions

• Federal

• State

• Michigan Building Code

• County (Washtenaw County Water Resources Commissioner)

Page 49: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

What happens when we get extreme weather events?

Page 50: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

What are we doing?

• Realistic Expectations

– There are limitations

• Deal with Stormwater at the source

– LID with private developers

–Resource for the public**

• Shift in Philosophy

–Adapting to new data and technology

Page 51: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination
Page 52: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Building Community Stewardship

Page 53: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Trends in VolunteerismTrends in VolunteerismAnn Arbor/Washtenaw CountyOpportunitiesOpportunities

Page 54: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Episodic VolunteeringEpisodic VolunteeringBaby BoomersGen X Y MillennialsGen X, Y, MillennialsCorporationsOther Impactful TrendsOther Impactful Trends

Page 55: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

Parks & NatureParks & NatureSocial ServicesUMUMNeighborhood Cohesion

Page 56: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

City governmentCity governmentNeighborliness & CivilityCommunity EngagementCommunity Engagement

Page 57: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

City governmentCity governmentNeighborliness & Civility

www.Nextdoor.comwww.Nextdoor.comCommunity Engagement

Page 58: Sustain ble Ann Arbor Forums - Ann Arbor, Michigan...Key Climate Change Impacts for A2 •Infrastructure •Public Health –Risk of extreme heat –Flooding and water contamination

City governmentCity governmentNeighborliness & CivilityCommunity EngagementCommunity Engagement

Local foodKeep rainwaterpVolunteer

*see handout in back of room