synopsis ashok 2012 a
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
1/29
How to write a synopsis
Indigenous Knowledge System of the Rajbanshis People of North Bengal
(With Special Reference to Agriculture)
Submitted By
ASHOK DAS GUPTA
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
2/29
Introduction
Indigenous peoples are those communities living in close to nature. They are the folk people or
ethnic communities who are regarded as aborigines or natives during the colonial period. They
have historical continuity with pre-invasion and pre-colonial societies. They have their own
territories where they now have become non-dominant sectors. They consider themselves distinct
from rest part of the society. They have appraisal for their land, their ethnicity, culture, social
institutions and even legal systems. They however might be influenced by various outside
influences. They maintain intimate understanding of nature, generation-wise intellectual
reasoning and informal experimentations on trail and error method. So, definitely Indigenous
Peoples in each case develop a set of indigenous knowledge traits or traditional knowledge traits.
When these knowledge traits work systematically in accordance to mode of production, division
of labor, social system and faith-fear-belief systems, it is the indigenous knowledge system
(IKS). IKS related to the ecosystem or microenvironment could be community specific or area
specific. It serves for those who stay far away from modern facilities and meets the ends for
basic livelihood. As modernity can cause harm to humanity and nature in various ways, the
alternatives have to be learnt from IKS. We can not separate IKS the rational part from its non-
rational part. However, IKS can be broadly divided into so many forms in the context of folk life,
such as, agriculture, animal husbandry, poultry, fishery, handicraft, agro-forestry, biodiversity
management, sustainable development, alternative ways of disease treatment, weather
forecasting, disaster mitigation, and so forth. Nikobarese and Shompens of Great Nikobar island
(Patnaik and Prasad, 2009), aboriginal Vanuatu fishermen (Johannes and Hickey, 2004), Inuit of
Arctic (Nakashima, 2003) are various examples of Indigenous Peoples. Rajbanshi people are
living in agrarian pockets of North Bengal (India) and they might have possessed IKS regarding
agriculture and other related issues. Many of the Indigenous Peoples are moving towards
globalization or opposing it; but in that due course situations have been emerged out when they
could eventually loose their IKS. But it is their cultural values and social norms standing along
with the civilization that does not let the IKS being totally lost. There is an urgent need to
document those IKS. The technical open-ended parts are easy to document. But in case of close
ended IKS embedded deeper inside the culture are hard to be documented. For that we have to
understand the folk cognition and cultural symbols, and only then in a proper methodological
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
3/29
way, we can perhaps decode the information. For that we even have to follow the post-
modernity. In this way, we can get a holistic picture of the entire scenario.
In this regard, North Bengal is the northern political geography and administrative zone of West
Bengal state of India. Out of total 19 districts of the state, the region constitutes only six northern
to river Ganges (Jalpaiguri, Koch Bihar, Darjeeling, North Dinajpur, South Dinajpur and Malda).
North Bengal could be divided into several zones: Darjeeling Himalayas, Kalimpong hills, Terai
foothills (Darjeeling district); Duars foothills (along Jalpaiguri-Bhutan international boundary);
plains of Teesta-Brahmaputra valley (Jalpaiguri-Koch Bihar); upper plain of Mahananda valley
(North Dinajpur); lower Plain of Mahananda valley (Malda); Atrai-Purnabhaba plain (South
Dinajpur), Varendrabhum highlands (Baikunthapur-Rajganj area and Mainaguri of Jalpaiguri
district, Haldibari-Mekhliganj and Sitai-Sitalkuchi of Cooch Behar, Chopra-Goalpokhar of North
Dinajpur, Kumarganj of South Dinajpur and Habibpur-Bamangola of Malda). Actually,
Varendrabhum or Dinajpur highland that has in majority gone into the hands of North Western
Bangladesh (Rajshahi Division consisting of 16 upa-zilas), is actually a watershed that separates
Teesta-Torsha and Mahananda river systems to its east and west respectively. From Tibet-
Bhutan-Sikkim-Kalimpong-Duars, the former flows down into Jalpaiguri-Cooch Behar plains
and meet into Brahmaputra-Jamuna of North East India-Bangladesh continuity. The later
imitates from Darjeeling-Nepal, flows down into Terai-North Dinajpur-Bihar (neighboring state)
and meets into Ganges with a continuity of Malda-Bangladesh. This is also the Malda-
Murshidabad region or Mid Bengal where Ganges forms the Bengal Delta of Bay of Bengal.
Delta is shared both by southern West Bengal and Bangladesh. In this Mid Bengal, the river
divides the state into North Bengal and South Bengal. Malda along with Dinajpur now
partitioned into North Bengal and Rajshahi Division is actually the Gour Vanga transnational.
So, North Bengal is actually means Mechi-Mahananda basin of Terai, Baikunthapur-Rajganj,
and Teesta-Torsha plains of Jalpaiguri-Cooch Behar with included areas like Duars (Doors),
Kalimpong Himalayas and Darjeeling Himalayas.
Rajbanshis are staying in actual North Bengal or Bengal frontier, pockets in Duars and Gour
Vanga, when only northern West Bengal is concerned. Rajbanshis are basically agrarian people
staying in both river plains and highland watersheds. Rajbanshis are so exclusive within the
social structure of North Bengal. Without the Rajbanshis neither organization of social structure
in North Bengal nor IKS embedded within folk life could ever be recognized. According to
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
4/29
Census 2001, Hindu Rajbanshis are 129,904 in Darjeeling of total individual 1,609,172; in
Jalpaiguri 811,567 out of 3,401,173; in Koch Bihar 972,803 out of 2,479,155; in Malda 144,158
out of 3,290,468; in North Dinajpur 405,140 out of 2,441,794 and in South Dinajpur, 224,988
out of 1,503,178 and there of total 14,724,940 of North Bengal, Rajbanshis have a population of
2,688,560 (18%). They might have good knowledge over traditional agriculture and agro-based
biodiversity management of North Bengal. In that context their indigenous knowledge is going to
be studied here.
Statement of Problem
Knowledge is a philosophical term and can be conceptualized as a set of various facts and
information traits. It is of two types: scientific and indigenous. Both work as systems and hence
we use the terms like Scientific Knowledge System and Indigenous Knowledge System (IKS).
These two together constitute Global Knowledge System.
Scientifically proved knowledge is the scientific knowledge, whereas knowledge of the
Indigenous Peoples can be treated as Indigenous Knowledge (IK). There is actually no
universally accepted definition of IK. This is the major obstacle in doing research with IK.
IK is the actual knowledge of a given population that reflects the experiences based on traditions
and includes more recent experiences with modern technologies (Haverkort, 1991). Indigenous
knowledge (IK) is the local knowledge- knowledge that is unique to a given culture or society.
IK contrasts with the international knowledge system generated by universities, research
institutions and private farms. It is the basis for local level decision making in agriculture, health
care, food preparation, education, natural-resource management and a host of other activities in
rural communities (Warren, 1991). Indigenous knowledge is the systematic body of knowledge
acquired by local people through the accumulation of experiences, informal experiments, and
intimate understanding of the environment in a given culture (Rajasekaran, 1993). Indigenous
Knowledge traits are oral, undocumented, simple; dependent over the values, norms and customs
of the folk life, production of informal experiments through trial and error, accumulation of
generation wise intellectual reasoning of day to day life experiences, loosed and rediscovered,
practical rather than theoretical as well as asymmetrically distributed. IK is also regarded by
several names, such as, folk knowledge, traditional knowledge, local knowledge, indigenous
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
5/29
technical knowledge (ITK), traditional environmental/ ecological knowledge (TEK), Peoples
Science or ethnology that often look very much confusing and overlapping (Das Gupta, 2011).
IK has the following characteristics: (1) local or specific to a particular geography or micro-
environment or ecosystem and folk people living there close to nature, (2) orally transmitted, (3)
outcomes of informal experiments, intimate understanding of nature, and accumulation of
generation-wise intellectual reasoning of day-to-day life experiences, generation-wise
intellectual reasoning tested on religious laboratory of survival, (4) originated through
interactions and not at individual level, (5) empirical rather than theoretical or any abstract
scientific knowledge, (6) functional or dynamic and hence constantly changing, discovered, lost
and rediscovered in a new form (open-ended IK), (7) culturally embedded (close-ended) where
separating the technical from non-technical, rational to non-rational is problematic, (8) repeating
with time (as because IK is both cultural and dynamic), (9) segmented into social clusters or
asymmetrically distributed within a population, by gender and age, (10) shared by many and
even by the global science (Ellen and Harris, 1996).
Folk people have preserved these functional IK traits within non-functional symbols of their
value loaded folk life. In order to gather IK traits, domains that have to be decoded within the
folk life are folk song, folk proverb, folk etymology and chants, folk music, folk tales, folk
literature, folk dance, folk painting, folk sculpture, folk recreation, folk play, folk art and craft,
folk cookery, folk settlement and patterns, folk architecture, the notion of time in folk society,
weather forecasting, dialectology of folk speech, superstitions, myths, legends, riddles, folk
religion folk lore, like sense of right and wrong (folk ways), norms regarding kinship relations
and rites of passage (rites-de-passage), folk customs regarding household affairs and agricultural
operations and behavior of the folk people, folk dialect to folk technology, various type of
organization (political, economic, religious, and social) and ethno-medicinal practices (Das
Gupta, 2011).
Indigenous Knowledge System (IKS) is the cognate of IK. Folk people are well aware of how to
apply IK traits in quite a systematic way and so to gain certain nature-friendly Public Services
form the so formed Indigenous Knowledge Systems (IKS). So, Public Services from IKS are
very much helpful in filling up gaps within Scientific Knowledge System and achieving
sustainability in development programs. IKS is a multidisciplinary subject and incorporates the
following dimensions: physical sciences and related technologies, social sciences and humanities
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
6/29
(Das Gupta, 2011). IKS can again be considered as summation of all traditional knowledge
systems (TKS) scattered all over the world. Such summation in a systematic way through proper
documentation can really contribute parallel to globalization. Indigenous Peoples suffering from
global market economy can then access to Indigenous Rights (International Labour
Organization). In that case, they will not take the way of localization, rather follow the way of
globalization with certain safeguard and even contribute to overcome negative impacts of
unidirectional modernization process (Das Gupta, 2010a).
IK/IKS is very much based on the relationship among (1) mode of production and reproduction,
(2) social structure and (3) magico-religious/cultural issues. Simply saying, this is a relation
among nature, human and super-nature. Communities who treat culture as result of their psycho-
biological need and not mere psychic unity of mankind are not so much akin to civilization but
are much closer to this relation among nature, human and super- nature (NMS) (Das Gupta,
2012b).
IKS is a multidisciplinary subject and could be divided into various domains like agriculture and
post-agricultural practices; animal husbandry and poultry; ethno-fishery; hunting and gathering;
artisan; disease treatment, ethno-medicine and folk remedy; traditional economic and political
system (Das Gupta, 2010c). IKS could be divided into various domains like agriculture, animal
husbandry (including poultry and fishery), handicrafts, tools and techniques, nutrition, health
care practices and bio-medicines, psycho-social care, natural and biological resource,
management of environmental and bio-diversity resources, disaster mitigation, human resource
management, saving and lending, poverty alleviation and community development as well as
education and communication. Each of these domains is provided with own respective area and
manifestation (Mondal, 2009). If we only consider agriculture related IKS, we have to focus on
definite interrelationship among production and technical practices in a specific farming system,
conservation of crop varieties, alternative agricultural production, production of various cash
crop/vegetables/spice/fruit and flower, maintenance of the nutrition level and traditional concepts
of health, food preservation, labor-oriented hand-loom industry, traditional type of division of
labor, ethno-fishery, animal husbandry and poultry, agro-forestry and use of forest products
(timber and non-timber), sacred groove, agro-ecology and food web, bio-diversity with feed-
back, water and soil management, house construction and kitchen garden, folk taxonomy,
magico-religious performances, belief in super-nature, cultural lag, emerging socio-economic
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
7/29
challenges, social transformation, sustainable rural and human resource development (Das
Gupta, 2010a).
Actually, farmers remain no longer passive consumers, but active problem solvers (Warren,
1991). So, the highest priority is going to be given upon alternative role of IKS against the high-
cost modern crop production system (Davis and Ebbe, 1993). It could then only allow a low-
level external input among the traditional agriculturists living in nature-surrounded remote areas
(Haverkort et. al., 1992).
Review of Literature
Indigenous Knowledge System (general): Gartoulla (1992) has worked on the Ethno-Medicinal
Practices and Therapeutic Treatment within the Periphery of Ayurveda, the traditional Hindu
medicinal practice, and other value loaded cultural interpretations in Nepal provided with a rich
bio-diversity and multi-ethnic composition very much similar to that in North Bengal. Choudhuri
(2003) has emphasized on the need of proper interaction between modern and traditional ways of
disease treatment for overall betterment of the health system of the folk communities. The
traditional way of disease cure was an important part of their knowledge system. That could be
considered rather as a discipline highly involved in the mental construction of the folk peoples.
Many of their rituals were again connected to this system and therefore, deterioration or
replacement of this traditional treatment process could cause harm to the stability of the
indigenous social life. Sengupta (2003) from his study on two closely related folk communities
(Santal and Kol) in the industrial enclave of the west Singbhum, Jharkhand wrote on perception
of folk environment and folk taxonomy regarding land, plant and animal domains; color
categories, hierarchical classification of food items and categories of food taste. Anandabazar
Patrika (19th August, 2006 and 4th April2007) has published an article on the Mizo community of
North East India relevant to the discussion of IK. The concepts strongly established within the
mind of any ethnic community like the Mizos could lead to the expression of certain features
harmful for their social life and economics, particularly when the issues like women right
violation or the restriction up on the red wine manufacture from the non-eatable Bangaluru Blue
variety of grape very much sour in taste - have come in front of all. These decisions are
influenced by the Church and Youth Associations on one hand and exerted strong influence upon
the IKS on the other. Another article on the same newspaper I would like to state. Nagas in
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
8/29
Nagaland domesticate a variety or hybrid of bison that they call Mithun. This can live in hilly
condition of Nagaland and be utilized for production of good quality of milk-meat-skin
(Anandabazar Patrika, 14th March, 2007). Subramanyam and Rao (2007) have discussed on
about 40 medicinal plants in Visakha tribal agency area of Andhra Pradesh maintained within
the sacred grooves of the local tribal people (major fourteen tribes including three Primitive
Tribal Groups) in the context of deforestation.
Indigenous Agricultural Knowledge System Studies: Rajasekaran (1993) has indicated to the
importance of certain informal indigenous communication systems in agricultural communities
that work incredibly well in India. There are different types of rice cultivation processes in India
that contain several issues regarding rice cropping system, soil health care practice, rice nutrient
management, seed selection and processing technique, rice transplanting technique, weed- and
pest-management strategy, as well as gender-oriented division of labor and decision-making
system. Farmers have therefore become active problem solvers. Chawhan and Oberoi (1990) in
their study conducted on Gaddi tribal women of Bharman tehsil of Chama district found that the
role of tribal women worker in the farm operation contribute to more than 70 per cent of total
workforce (except ploughing of fields, marketing of grains, irrigation and application of
pesticides and fungicides). This has happened irrespective of discrimination in technology
transfer. Beohar et al. (1999) found that both family and hired women labourers in tribal
dominated Central India were engaged in sowing, transplanting, interculture, harvesting,
transporting and winnowing. In operations like transplanting, inter-culture and harvesting the use
of female labour hours was more than that of men labour. Mishra et al. (1999) in their paper on
paddy cultivation and gap in wages between men and women labour in Kymore Plateau and
Satpura hill region of Madhya Pradesh show that women labour more participated in
transplanting of paddy, inter-culture and harvesting while, operations like preparatory tillage,
sowing, manuring and fertiliser application, irrigation and threshing operations were performed
jointly with men. They proposed for diversified farming systems such as dairy, poultry etc. so as
to increase the employment opportunities of women. Pandey et al. (1999) proposed that in
operations such as cleaning of cattle, re-collection of refuse, compost, bio-gas production etc. in
which women are actively involved in Hissar (Hariyana) need to be more skill based rather than
labour oriented. Shiyani and Vekariya (1999) examined the gender differences in groundnut and
wheat production in South Saurashtra zone of Gujarat where maximum women involvement can
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
9/29
be seen in case of hand weeding and harvesting (during groundnut and wheat productions) as
well as irrigation (during wheat production). In activities like sowing, primary tillage, application
of manures and chemical fertilisers and irrigation, women took part along with men.
Subrahmanyam (1999) showed demand of labour in respect to gender is basically subjected to
cropping intensity and cropping pattern; in Andhra Pradesh, items like paddy, cotton and chilies
had higher demand for total labour as well as female labour. Sugarcane has the lowest demand
for female labour. Tripathi (1999) in his paper has examined the level and pattern of womens
contribution in hill economy of Tehri district in Uttar Pradesh. The contribution made by women
for field preparation, manuring, and sowing were higher over men (exclusively in rice crop).
That is followed by their participation in weeding and hoeing operations as well as harvesting
and digging operations. These are associated with production of fruit and milk. Bora et al. (2000)
in their study have examined the role performance of farm women in animal husbandry activities
in the selected villages of Tezu Development Block of Arunachal Pradesh. The study identified a
total of eighteen roles performed by women. They were fodder gathering, carrying fodder to the
home, grinding of feed, cutting and boiling of fodder, feeding the animals, watering to the
animals, cleaning of mangers, grazing of animals, bathing of animals, cleaning of sheds,
grooming, milking of animals, heating of milk, selling of milk, care of new born animals, care of
sick animals and vaccination of animals. Dhillon et al. (2007) from their study in three agro-
climatic zones of Punjab found that the age of farm women ranged between 24-56 years and
majority of them belonged to the age group of 35-45 years. Actually, women in varied situations
can take part in more or less all the agricultural activities: 1. ploughing of field, 2. cleaning of
field, 3. leveling of field, 4. raising nursery for seedling (lady finger, green chilly, tomato,
cauliflower), 5. sowing, 6. transplanting , 7. mannure application, 8. fertiliser application, 9.
weeding, 10. thinning, 11. gap filling, 12. irrigation, 13. plant protection measures, 14. cutting,
15. picking, 16. shifting production to threshing floor, 17. threshing, 18. winnowing, 19. drying
of grains, 20. cleaning of grains, 21. grading, 22. storage, 23. marketing, and 24. processing. In
most of cases, women are associated with pre-agricultural and post-harvesting activities. They
are also associated with drain preparation, fencing, applying insecticides,
homestead gardening (kitchen garden), rearing poultry, rearing livestock,
collecting yams and other vegetables plus medicinal plants, and even
fishing. Addition it this, there are non-agricultural activities: handicraft work,
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
10/29
bamboo and cane work, extracting jute flex, silk extraction from cocoon,
handloom industry, dye yielding, embroidery work, sewing and dress
making, making cigar, teaching children, buying daily necessities, and raring
care of aged and children. Labour selling is also there. It may be long term or
short term, long distance or short distance, low wage or relatively high wage,
daily or conditional, private or governmental, group-wise or individual,
seasonal or yearly, haphazard or pre-decided, permanent or temporary.
Again, it depends on several factors: to meet basic family needs, absence of men
earning members, to increase family income, to meet personal needs, (and) to meet additional
family requirements. Nidup et. al. (2007) have observed that how the cultivators of North Bengal
relay on potatoes from neighboring Bhutan, rather than dormant variety of Punjab and less
susceptible ones of South Bengal so as to get good quality seed; and therefore, in order to check
this bio-piracy, Bhutan in the season of October exports small sized tubers.
Rapid developmental activities performed by the market economy of Modern World in this era
of Globalization but accordingly face six serious problems as pointed out by UNDP report:
Challenges of global warming, Rapid loss of bio-diversity, Crisis-prone financial market,
Growing international inequality, Emergence of new-drug resistant disease strains & Genetic
engineering (Grunberg et.al., 1999 in Kelkar et. al., 2004). Out of so many problems that
humanity is now facing, IKS in both agrarian sectors and pre-agrarian situations can highlycontribute to the protection of bio-diversity that is now rapidly deteriorating due to pollution,
unplanned exploitation of resources and use of genetically modified breeds in the name of
meeting the profit level, demands and pressure of common people. Biodiversity in a sense cannot
specify to either of flora or fauna, medicinal plants or crop plants, domestic breeds or wild
verities. It would encompass whole of the food chain/food web in the ecosystem. Biodiversity is
a public policy as well as a scientific issue. It is stratified into a four-level hierarchy (i.e., genetic,
species, ecosystem and landscape). It maintains ecosystem stability. IKS on the other hand
provides empirical insight into crop domestication, breeding, and management. It further acts in
favor of agro-ecology, agro-forestry, crop rotation, pest and soil management and other
agricultural activities. Agro-based IKS also develops guidelines of natural forest management
and biodiversity management (Das Gupta, 2011).
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
11/29
Indigenous Agricultural Knowledge System Studies regarding food preservation: Lal et. al.
(1986) have gathered various information regarding Preservation of Fruits and Vegetables in
different parts of India. This bulk of information would actually help in arranging a full-proof
planning about the techniques the Rajbansis have been using for preservation of food since time
immemorial. Steinkraus (1996) has been discussed about the importance and application of
Indigenous Fermented Foods which is actually another pavement of studying the IKS with
special reference to agriculture, medicine as well as heath and nutrition. Fellows (1997) has
discussed on various types of Traditional Foods, most of these foods are of preserved type. The
ways of cooking and the food ways are organized in such a manner, that the nutrition level
should maintained. Pickles, dry foods, liquor, spices, sun-dried elements, soil preserved food,
concept of fresh food and various types of food taste are very important in the study of IKS
regarding folk agriculture and animal husbandry. Battcock and Azam-Ali (1998) have mentioned
that fermentation is an affordable and manageable food preservation technique, which is very
appropriate in use where other food processing technologies such as canning and freezing are
either inaccessible or unavailable. The fermentation of staples serves as a major source of
nourishment for large populations in rural communities and contributes significantly to food
security by increasing the range of raw materials, which can be used in the production of edible
products. The consolidated information base on traditional small-scale food fermentations is
however very weak and existing information on the subject is widely dispersed. Furthermore,
"indigenous knowledge" on fruit and vegetable fermentations is being lost as technologies evolve
and populations move away from traditional food preservation practices. The Argo-Industries
and Post-Harvest Management Service (AGSI) of FAO has therefore initiated the publication of
a document series of fermented foods. The present publication on fermented fruits and vegetables
is the first of the series. The whole work prevails around the benefits, basic principles and
different types of fermentation in case of post-harvest procedure and therefore is very much
important to keep in mind during the IKS study of the Rajbansi agriculturists and food growers-
their traditional knowledge about the food preservation process & their concept of nutrition.
Mishra (2007) has mentioned the traditional food preservation techniques of Oraon community
of tribal dominated Sambalpur region of Odisha (India).
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
12/29
Rajbanshis of North Bengal: Sanyal (1965) mentioned that Rajbanshis in and around the plains
of northern West Bengal or North Bengal have their own history of thousands of years. They
have transformed from a community to a huge complex heterogeneous social fold incorporating
animism, ancient pre-Vedic versions of Hinduism, Vedic traditions, magico-religious
performances and Buddhism, Kashyap-Bratya Kshattriya combination, Sufism and Vaishnavism,
status mobilization, and folk practices symbolic to agriculture and trade relations (Sanyal, 1965).
Das Gupta (2010a) while studying on indigenousness of the Rajbanshis has coined certain terms
like Kirata, Paundra-Kshattriya, Kashyapa, Aryan, pro-Aryan, Buddhist, pro-Kushana, Barmana
kings, Pala, Kamboja-Pala, Kaivartha-Mech, King Jalpa, Khen, Garo, Bodo, Kuchhur, Mech,
Rabha, Lepcha, Burmese-Naga, Bhutia, Drukpa, Denzongpa, Sherpa, Monpa, Mog-Arakan,
Toto, Doya, Tharu, Dhimal, Jalda, Mon, Brahmin, Kshattriya, Vaishnava, Nath/Debnath, Turk-
Afghans, Sufism, semi-independent autonomous states, Kamtapuri, Koch-Rajbanshis, Mughal-
Rajput, Assam, Manipur, Surma valley, Arakan, Burma/Bagan, Gurkha, Adivasi tribal
communities of Chota Nagpur plus Central India and Andhra that will come one by one in any
diachronic discussion on North Bengal. Das Gupta (2010b) has discussed on Rajbanshis that they
were originated from the mixing up of local Mongoloid inhabitants Kirata, continuous with the
Shiwalik hills of Himalayan range and the Bratya-Kshattriya excluded Hindu Warriors who fled
into foothills and northern plains of North Bengal from the adjacent ancient state of
Paundrabardhana. The latter has been mentioned in Mahabharata, was most probably settled in
the place of Mahananda valley and the people there have still been regarded as Pundras, whereas
the same in Brahmaputra triangle known as Mech/ Deshi (aboriginal) and if combined with the
Koch, then Koch-Rajbanshis. Some of them have been treated as Puliya due to the 400 years
long Buddhist Pala regime here in Bengal (750-1165 AD). The Rajbanshis are still singing
Kushana song that probably indicates out of once Kushana occupancy (Buddhist) over the trade
routes here in North Bengal. Kushanas were followed by Tibetans, Moghs, Palas, Kambojas,
Turk elements and the British who in 19th Century A.D., established lots of Tea Estates here in
Terai, Doors/Duars and Darjeeling hills. During that phase of tea garden establishment;
numerous ethnic groups from Nepal and people from Central Indian tribal territories (both tribes
and non-tribes) have entered in this land. Some agricultural tribal communities from the same
Central Indian region entered the territory, never went to the Tea Estates and some of them
started cultivation along with local Rajbanshi and various Bengali caste groups. Rajbanshis are
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
13/29
now a caste group, mostly Hindu; asking for their superior status; but at the same time they are
simple, little bit backward, searching for socio-economic mobility often in a political line, not
prepared to shed off all the knowledge systems and cultural values in the name of Global Market
Economy; and facilitated by the Government of India with constitutionally approved reservation
opportunities for education, occupation and social justice. Still they are successful in maintaining
their knowledge bulk and cultural values more or less intact. These Rajbanshis from past one
decade started movement in the name of ancient Kamtapur and for recent few years in favor of
Greater Koch Behar. Though these socio-political movements in the name of identity crises have
not been too much successful; but still there might be so many reasons behind such identity
issues and crises. Das Gupta (2012b) again highlighted on the fact that many tribes have been
absorbed by Brahminical heritage (Varna and caste systems of Hindu social hierarchical
stratification) or they are in a Tribe-Caste Continuum. Certain groups stay on their own ways.
But many of them are said to be highly deprived. They constitute the Dalit section in caste-
dominated Indian society. Certain low ranking castes and various tribes have been therefore
scheduled into Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (SC and ST). Primitive Tribal Group
(PTG) is also there. Not so much deprived but still with certain lower ranking status groups are
categorized within Other Backward Caste/Class (OBC). Extreme Backward Caste/Class (EBC)
is also there. ST might be a Hindu or a non-Hindu. OBC or EBC can incorporate non-Hindu non-
caste groups while being considered on class basis. These scheduling processes are performed
according to constitutional provisions of India. Often these community centric groups classified
themselves into various transnational communities. They starting dominating the local society
even the Brahminical system on politico- economic grounds. They in this way become Dominant
Communities. Some exclusive communities are Khmer, Mon, Bodo and Bhati. Rajbanshis of
North Bengal in their traditional agrarian structure are not beyond that and have got facility of
SC. Das (2001) has shown how material culture and traditional technologies could be associated
with myth and belief behind the causes of disease and illness, natural calamities and supernatural
entities. Das Gupta (2010) has encoded so many symbols to Rajbanshi performances during
festivals repeating every year season-wise and tried to emphasize on traditional agricultural
practices.
Research Scope
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
14/29
i. Contribution to Agriculture: Some good scopes related to this domain are (1) indigenous
technical practices in a rice-based farming system and watershed vegetable agriculture cum
kitchen garden; (2) indigenous way of soil and water conservation; (3) indigenous soil
classification; (4) the very nexus among the various aspects of indigenous knowledge,
indigenous peoples and sustainable agricultural practice and (5) sustainable availability of good
quality seed (important for crop production and food security).
ii. Contribution to post-Agricultural Performances (such as food preservation)
iii. Contribution to Biodiversity Management
iv. Contribution to Sustainable Development study
Emphasizing on agriculture based IKS of the Rajbanshis, we could discuss on the following
topics-
Box 1: Categorization of agro-oriented IKS of the Rajbanshi People of North Bengal
1 Protection of healthy variety of crops growing in nature, domestication of wild varieties,
natural variety of high yielding crops, indigenous way of producing hybrids with high nutrition
level, retention of soil fertility and soil classification, concept of upland, lowland and marshy
land;
2 application of degradable ethno-toxicants, cutting, pruning, tissue culture and cloning, seed
treatment in the nursery to provide healthy seedlings and saplings;
3 field preparation, application of organic manure, application of eco-friendly microbes and
vectors, natural way of paste and herb control: use of larvae, insects, birds, fish, ants, white
ants and earth warm;4 symbiosis and nitrification, fishing-cum-paddy cultivation, techniques involved in shifting
cultivation and step cultivation, feed-back manner, fuel collection, use of cow dung,
classification of soil types, classification of cultivation ground, cultivation on the fertile
alluvial soil on the river islands, bush fallow cultivation, seasonal cultivation, yearly
cultivation, annual and biennial cultivation, flowering in the first year of a biennial crop
variety, mixed cultivation;
5 identification of certain plant species on trees or in soil causing severe herm to the crop
production, weeds used in removal of pests and other harmful organisms, earth-warm in
maintenance of soil fertility;
6 seed and sapling selection, roles of women, crop selection, seed germination, crop sowing,protection of ripen crops from rat, insect, bird and bat;
7 crop harvesting, crop thrashing, grain storing, preservation of the crop, fish, food, fruit, fruitpulp and so on, pressed and puffer rice, alcoholism, fermentation of rice or fruit juice, palm
juice, debt juice and production of unsaturated sweet cakes, types of pickle, prickles in mustard
oil or as stored in dried condition, use of dry neem leaves as preservatives, use of sun beam in
preservation, use of dry soil as preservative, use of pond soil in facial and skin treatment, use ofthe straw stalks for fertilizing the soil, use of straws in mushroom cultivation, burning of the
left-away straws in the post-harvest period on the cultivation ground, light trap, weed
management, use of dry soil (of rat house) as preservative;
8 mushroom cultivation, mushroom varieties;
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
15/29
9 use of algae and lichen in cookery, classification of bamboo;
10 use of bamboo in every aspect of life from drinking water in a glass made of bamboo to house
construction, techniques involved in bamboo cultivation, bamboo parts as food, fodder and
pickle, bamboo and myth, flowering in bamboo;
11 use of algae, fungi, pteridophytes and fern in cookery, dye production, wax formation andmedicinal purposes;
12 floriculture, use of pots, environmental influence, low-cost greenhouse manufacture, nurseryand water shade, use of organic manure, cutting and pruning in horticulture, garden eco-
system, shade trees, fish manure and bone dust, soil types and stones, soil sterilization, fencing,
use of roots, rhizomes, shoot, bark, lattice, leaf, bud, inflorescence, flower, anther, nectar, fruit,
seeds in various purposes, pitcher plants, extraction of essence from the flower, lemon grassproduction;
13 honey collection, nectar yielding flower species protection of the trees favored by the honey
bees, role of honey bees in ecosystem and maintenance of food web, use of honey in food, as
medicine and health protection, use of wax, use of birds in searching out the honey nest;
14 animal husbandry and poultry, construction of the shade, fodder, fertility control and breeding,
grazing, milk products and curd, indigenous techniques for increasing milk production,
protection of the cattle from leaches, protection of poultry from bird eating animals, veterinary
and control of disease in the domestic plant species, animals and birds, use of animal produce,skins, wool, bones;
15 spice cultivation;
16 vegetable cultivation;
17 ethno-fishery, pond selection, protection of pond ecosystem, liming the soil for controlling the
water pH level, careful observation of fishes in the cold foggy winter, especially regulating the
water temperature in the pond, proper physical activity and regular feeding, disease treatment,
fertility control, various techniques of fishing, fishing in the streams, fishing in the rivers,
fishing under the waterfalls, fishing in the marshy land, fishing in the paddy field, fishes asgood source of manure, fishing of fishes with extra-respiratory organ, group fishing, quick
fishing in emergency, use of ethno-toxic elements in fishing, preserved fish products, fishes in
maintenance of the health condition and nutrition level, superfluity and fish feed, cultivation of
prawns, crabs, colored fishes, insect and mosquito eating fishes as well as hybrids, use of fishes
in controlling mosquito larvae; control over snake, rat and frog; concept about water pollution
and the role of pond water as the carrier of diseases in fishes, cattle and human and related
disease cycle;
18 sericulture, selection of trees for sericulture, food chains in the natural process of sericulture,
cocoons and production and storage of silk fibers;
19 folk classification and folk taxonomy;
20 cultivation of jute, tea, tobacco, shorea, teak, legume, betel, betel nut, aurum and palm;
21 house construction, use of rice seed-coat in soil for wall construction, use of bamboo, grass,
jute stick, straw and leaves in roofing, use of wood and bamboo in construction of the
framework, house types in heavy raining areas; construction of storage, manufacture of basket,
use of basket for storing;
22 production of wooden plough and other artifacts; food preparation and cooking utensils;
23 wood and leaf collection, husking machine and the role of women; handlooms and women;
women and self-help groups; women and trade; women in the village-level power sector;
24 use of fire, control on fire, earthen stoves, earthen kiln;
25 use of stagnant water in mud-ponds under bright sun beams to remove the dry jute fibers from
the hollow straw, use of jute and straw, straws in construction, fencing and fuel source,
collection and storage of jute and other fibers, their use in handlooms and weaving cloths, mats
and seats, dying the cloth with natural color produced from soil, plant extract, emulsion of rice
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
16/29
dust and charcoal;
26 pulse cultivation, production of sun-dried preserved pulse cakes;
27 medicinal weeds; consumption of nutritious food and disease curing dishes; concept of disease,
health and nutrition; health consciousness and illness, believe in super-nature [in order to
control the nature and maintenance of the mental health];
288alternative crop production;
29 concept about season and weather, related myths, disaster management system in case of flood,
drought, heavy rain, land slide, soil erosion, deforestation, crop failure, storm, fire, attack of
insects or birds or rats or elephant or other herbivores, weather forecasting from watching the
nature and activities in the wild life;
30 protection of forestry by feed back, protection of sacred groove, conserving and maintaining
forest resources, indigenous tree classification systems, terrace planting techniques (if
applicable), trees suited for different geographical locations, tree species for providing shade
for plantation crops, forest product marketing strategies, intercropping in forest gardens, timber
yielding plants, nut yielding plants, gum and resin yielding plants, plants with other economic
importance, religious system and conservation of plant species, flowering plants, medicinal and
herbal values of wild trees, supply of global public goods and global environmental services,
water management, irrigation and fishing, indigenous irrigation techniques, preservation of
ground water level; recycling of solid waste, utilization of the superfluity in various manner.
No doubt, this work has to be done in more systematic way and according to appropriate
methodology. The best ways are to do Rapid Rural Appraisal (from silent observation to
mapping to rapid report writing), document properly and analyzing the facts later in-depth, select
key informants and case study them in an unstructured way in such a manner that they willfully
cooperate with you, decode the symbols, feel the folk life, make own mindset like the target
community, think like them, become etic to emic, absolutely be inclusive, become post-structural, even post-modern, aware about research-informant biasness, chose proper
extentionists in order to cover a wider area, implement extentionists only you have the feeling
that you are now at a stage of evaluator and moderator, etc. (discussed in the methodology part).
Focus Group Discussion can also be used. That is good for cross-cultural study in emic
approach. There you can be a moderator. For example, men and women, student and farmer,
milkman and day laborer, hunter and fuel wood gatherer, highlander and valley people, rich and
poor, Hindu and Muslim, semi-urban and absolutely rural, Rajbanshi and non-Rajbanshi, etc.
Regular visit is a must here. That can be throughout the season. You have to sure that the target
group if know you in any way from earlier date will feel that you are equally oppressed and a
part of the Indigenous Peoples group. Inclusiveness is very much necessary. You have to impress
the informant on your own and without any intervention of a third person. That type of rapport is
really a tough job. And remember always one thing that you need financial assistance as the
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
17/29
work is not village specific, but micro-environment specific from where you have to document
information as much as possible in post-structural and post-modern ways. You have to go
beyond questionnaire and schedule survey. Try to be innovative and go beyond a frame. Be
completely objective, qualitative, extra-scientific and humanitarian. You have to understand
indigenous classifications about social system, economy, polity, and religion. You have to realize
the story beside the story. As you progress, they output will be quite impressive and quick. Go to
public gathering. Select informant not on educational ground or connection to the outside, but on
the basis of his/her understanding of nature, innovativeness and own perception (IKS). And do
not disclose the secrets on how you be cognitive and then post-structural. And do not disclose the
informants. That is also ethical issue. You should know that an illiterate indigenous person is
more sensitive than a literate one. But obviously the researcher has to construct some research
questions to some extent. What are those? Basically Wh-questions are to be asked. And in the
next step: How?
Actually, you will face the question from the people of the informant group first. If they do not
ask your name, your place, your aim, your religion, your ethnicity; you ought to believe that the
place is not right to conduct the fieldwork. Either they have misinformation regarding you from
earlier or they should have bad impressions about the earlier visitors/strangers/researchers. And
if they ask you the questions, then you should answer them in proper way (if you can
communicate through language). It would depend on situation that if you name a person of
neighboring sacred place or market. You may meet a shepherd, a peasant, a day laborer, a
fisherman, a gatherer, a housewife working in her kitchen garden, a wood cutter, an aged person
taking rest under the tree, children playing in a temple site, gathering in weekly market. Do not
miss the opportunity to talk with women doing domestic work especially fuel collection or a
person walking in the path on foot in a hurry. You may face embarrassing questions: Are you to
here to buy our agricultural land? Are you a thief? etc. If you can convince them, they can invite
you to their homestead. And even offer food and drink. Some simple questions you can also ask-
Where is the religious place? Could you bring me a glass of water? How long are you in this
occupation? Is your job still profitable? Can I call from your mobile phone? What types of crops
you usually cultivate? Why you do not cultivate this type of crop? What are you doing? Can I
take rest here for a while? What are you eating? Can I join you? Can I help you? Share your
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
18/29
experiences. What type of plant is this? What types of species do you have here? Why you pray
to this deity? Yes! Political situation is like thatwhat do you think? How you manage all this?
Is there any valuable object? Why are you afraid so much of this? And in this way you have to
enter into discussion. As good would be the discussion, people will gather there and
automatically a kind of group discussion will emerge out. You can also ask for castles, poultry
and fishing. You have to be good in folk communication. You can ask about natural resources,
their utilizations, micro-environments and distance related questions. But question only when
you have to ask or you have a very short time span in your hand. Be aware that your collected
information traits will not be mishandled or wrongly interpreted. Some typically agriculture
related questions are as follows- What are the crops grown in various agro-ecological
environments of the study villages? Is it a monocropped or intercropped area? What are the
sources of irrigation? What manure is applied? How you control the pest? What is the size of the
farm holding? What are the primary soil types of the farm holding? How are the farmers
classified? What kind of division of labor exists? What are the roles of men and women laborers?
What are the tools and implements used by them? What do you feed your livestock? How you
perform treatment of the livestock? How do you know their quality? How do you form complex
production system? How do you make more profit? What do you think of your present and of
past? What do expect of your future? Why do not you involve in alternative agriculture? Why are
you using modern facility? Why are you not satisfied with the production system? How do not
you send your children go to school? Why you prefer male child? Why are you not living in
traditional joint-extended family structures? And in this manner, many more questions could be
asked. But ranking and scoring (timely approach) are highly maintained. And also some other
relevant information traits are to be incorporated where Case Study or long interviews are must-
(1) beliefs, values, and customs of the producer, (2) the process of decision-making and
communication and (3) relation among sociofacts, artifacts and mentifacts composing together
agrofacts, (4) production system, social system, economy, polity and religious issues as well as
(5) nexus among nature, people and super-nature. The research can also contribute to food
production and resource conservation. Important steps are to be keeping in mind (1) cropping
systems, (2) seeds and sowing, (3) seed processing, (4) soil health care management, (5) planting
techniques, (6) crop nutrient management systems, (7) weed management techniques, (8) plant
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
19/29
protection strategies, and (9) post-harvesting procedures including food preservation. However,
may not all the steps be covered! Or we can get some extra information.
Aims and Objectives
Aim of this study is to examine and explore IKS (here, agro-oriented) of a specific community
(here, Rajbanshis) within a particular bio-geographic region (here, the northern part of West
Bengal). The research work will highlight on traditional agricultural practices, food processing
and biodiversity management (including seed management) and will also discuss on sustainable
agriculture for future generations. Considering the agriculture oriented production system,
Rajbanshi IKS can be good source of information traits on the following domains.
For the Rajbanshi people, agriculture oriented IKS study may not confine within agriculture, but
rather go beyond this. Of which the major are as follows-
1. agriculture, post and pre agricultural activities in terms of sustainable and organic
cultivation;
2. fishery, poultry and livestock;
3. protection of sacred grooves and regular supply of ethno-medicines, medicinal
importance of the plants neighborhood;
4. processing and preservation of food substances;
5. food and food-ways, concept of nutrition;
6. agricultural and associated biodiversity;
7. complex production systems;
8. agro-forestry and minor forest produce;
9. division of labor;
10. folk life and religious/cultural symbols;
11. decision making- social structure in terms of economy, polity, social institutions
and organizations.
The research can be framed according to the following steps- (1) Politico-economic background
of North Bengal and social formation of the Rajbanshis; (2) indigenousness of the Rajbanshis;
(3) Agriculture oriented Indigenous Knowledge System of Rajbanshis of North Bengal; (4)
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
20/29
Rajbanshi Indigenous Knowledge System in service to biodiversity management; (5) Division of
labor, gender and social organizations within the traditional Rajbanshis; (6) Conceptuality on
polity and economy; (7) conceptuality on super-nature; (8) Rajbanshi IKS and sustainable
development.
Rationale of Approach
i. Choosing appropriate methodology;
ii. Investigating on open ended IK;
iii. Investigating on close ended IK;
iv. Investigating on IKS;
v. Emphasis on mode of production and division of labor;
vi. Emphasis of social system;
vii. Emphasis of super-nature;
viii. Emphasis on communication among nature, social system and super-nature;
ix. Emphasis on agrofacts, psychofacts, sociofacts and artifacts;
x. Emphasis on religious institution (as if religious laboratory of survival);
xi. Emphasis on performances, their symbols and inner meanings- a journey from symbol to
World View and again from complex mind structure to ethno-science and folk life;
xii. Synchronic and diachronic studies;
xiii. Overlapping of etic and emic perspectives;
xiv. Research conducted on extra-scientific post-modern humanitarian ground, in an in-depth
qualitative way, objectivity overruling subjectivity and least amount of biasness during
researcher-informant interaction (Das Gupta, 2010c, 2011, 2012a).
Hypothesis
Rajbanshi is a greater social fold and rural, folk and agrarian in nature. Its indigenous production
system can contribute into biodiversity management and sustainable agriculture. Agricultural
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
21/29
patterns in watershed and river plains are different. Agriculture here is not singularly confined to
the Rajbanshis, but open to wider multiculturalism of North Bengal (to certain extent).
Agriculture is both modern and traditional-sustainable. Traditional-sustainable is fallen under
IKS that shows gradual evolution.
Methodology
Muchena and Williams in 1991 cited the argument of Bennett (1980) and mentioned that human
components are actually analytical equivalents to environmental components and related
information/knowledge in a given socionatural system. Muchena and Williams also cited
Brokensha et. al., 1980, and Posey, 1983, as they had indicated to the difficulties in front of
encoding in religious beliefs, rituals, ceremonies and myths highly related with the IKS. Rational
and non-rational parts are inseparable here. But even then in order to gather the IKS of a given
community, the researcher has no better option to decode these symbols.
Das Gupta (2010c) emphasized three types of communication (formal and informal) - firstly,
with people (via exchange of goods/message/women/power of word); secondly, with nature (via
Traditional Knowledge System/TKS); and thirdly, with Super Nature (via performances that
could be cultural/ social/ magical/ religious/ agricultural-seasonal). The network so formed
maintains connectivity among agrofacts, artifacts, sociofacts and mentifacts/ psychofacts. IKS
(adaptive) is generally tested in the religious laboratory of survival (religious institution out of
various non-adaptive institutions of social system). Festivals, related symbols and their inner
meanings are helpful in proper diagnosis of the folk mind set of the Rajbanshi agrarian rural
structure with both synchronic and diachronic perspectives. Overlapping of etic and emic
perspectives (from symbols to the World View and again from complex mind structure to ethno-
science and folk taxonomy) have to be studied on post-modern humanitarian ground, in a
qualitative way, deep micro-level study, objectivity overruling subjectivity and least amount of
biasness during researcher-informant interaction.
Das Gupta (2012b) again stated that the polity could be stratified into 4 types: international
polity, national polity, regional or state polity and traditional political systems. In this global era,
what should be the mode of development? Options are there: a) Getting directly into the global
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
22/29
system through proper way or by hooks and crooks; b) (if failed), returning back to traditional or
other earlier economic systems (on choice) and initiation from the beginning; c) development in
a sustainable way: people would be negotiated rather than remaining isolated or integrated. In
Indian perspective, most people live in rural society segregated into various agrarian rural
structures. Here, the economy could be broadly classified into production oriented and trade
related types; and simultaneously categorized into Traditional, Nationalized, Mixed, Macro and
Global besides Micro economy and Micro-financing. In Indian Subcontinent, peoples could be
grouped into certain categories on certain grounds and these are as follows- 1) Agricultural
communities, caste groups and hegemony of priestly category; 2) Mega Structure builders; 3)
Mega Structure destroyers; 4) Localized femininity (in general); and 5) Expanding maleness.
These options are to be kept in mind before entering into any discussion regarding IKS and
sustainability.
Das Gupta (2012a) has cited Jorgensen (1989) who classified key informants as follows: (a) local
extension agent, (b) local school headmaster, (c) credit co-operative society officials, (d) village
milk co-operative society members, (e) farmers, and (f) men and women laborers. Criteria for
selection of key informants are (1) good knowledge on historical background of food production
and resource conservation of the study villages; (2) a minimum of ten-year experience on the
production system; and (3) not being involved in other stages of the study. Das Gupta
emphasized on communication among social researchers, agronomists, extentionists as following
the World Bank (1990) step towards extentionist to agronomist to laboratories. The author has
cited Banarjee et.al. who emphasized on exchange on IK through identification, validation,
recording and documentation, storage of retrievable repositories, transfer and dissemination. It is
actually a huge task and needs government and NGO collaboration (GO-VO). Rajasekaran and
warren (1991) emphasized on proper Training Manual and definite Guideline for Extension
Workers. Anthropologists can be extensionist or apply extentionists only through rapport
establishment and impression management. But, being an anthropologist, the researcher could
contribute holistically that is not possible for the extentionists, laboratories and agronomists.
Funding is highly required in such agriculture related studies. Rapid Rural Appraisal is the best
option here only after proper planning through training and visit method (T&V). Anthropologist-
cum-extensionist should choose the village market days, temple days, village-level women
societies, and cooperatives. He/she has to be aware of position between farming units and
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
23/29
agronomists facilitated with laboratory. Anthropologists can begin as trainee or self-trainee and
with time grow up as monitoring and evaluation rank where he/she can apply many more
extentionists. IK is needs high degree of accuracy. So, we can add more approaches besides
traditional magico-religious aspects. Approaches may therefore be magico-religious aspects,
role of cash and kind, barter and reciprocity, division of labor within the same lineage or among
the neighborhood, gender, exchange of services, large scale patronage, concept of property and
its decadence, role of myth/custom/value/norms in non-subsistent economies, traditional power
structures, traditional education system, and health. IK holders have to be aboriginal or very
much close to nature or biodiversity. Indigenous Rights postulated by International labour
Organization (ILO) can be another approach. It can be further extended to issues like bio-piracy,
illegal knowledge transfer and intellectual property rights. But this approach is not going to
utilize there.
IKS can be seen from sudden happenings, microenvironment (ecology and geography),
hitoricity, folk life, polity, health, education, economy, and obviously religious. Researcher has
to observe, doccument and analyze (Patnaik and Prasad, 2004; Das Gupta, 2012a).
Area and People: North Bengal is the northern political geography and administrative zone of
West Bengal state of India. Out of total 19 districts of the state, the region constitutes only six
northern to river Ganges (Jalpaiguri, Cooch Behar, Darjeeling, North Dinajpur, South Dinajpur
and Malda).
Maldah, North Dinajpur and South Dinajpur (collectively known as Gour Vanga) are not initially
included.
Mechi-Mahananda basin in sub-Himalayan Darjeeling district of North Bengal would be of
prime emphasis. Baikunthopur-Dinajpur watershed (or Barindland) is there that separates Teesta-
Torsha river system from the former.
Two different study areas selected are:
1) Villages under Phansidewa block of Siliguri sub-division of Darjeeling district, North Bengal
(Terai region allied with Mahananda River Valley);
2) Nishiganj area under Mathabhanga I block and Mathabhanga sub-division of Cooch Behar
district on the plains of Teesta-Torsha Valley. These areas are rich in agro-based biodiversity so
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
24/29
far maintained by the Rajbanshi agrarian rural structure. This research proposal is prepared in the
context of pilot study in these two clusters.
Tools and Techniques: Different tools are required in order to collect the data in terms of
anthropology, statistics and biology. Data are going to be taken from both primary and secondary
sources.
Primary Data Collection: In order to gather primary and area-specific information relevant to this
study; different tools could be used ion combination: a) key informants interview, d) case study,
c) silent observation, d) non-participant observation, e) participant observation, f) rapid rural
appraisal, g) participatory rural appraisal, k) focused group discussion, l) story narration, and m)
informants. Informant has to be a personality with minimum 10-year experience.
In RRA, unstructured interviews in group, key informants interview, direct observation, mapping
and diagramming, case studies, biographies, local histories, time lines, ranking and scoring, short
simple questionnaires, and rapid report writing are needed. It can includes some more radical
activism through empowerment, respect, localization, enjoyment and inclusiveness (Das Gupta,
2012a).
Secondary Data Collection: The secondary data from website, encyclopedia, books, journals,
District Gazetteers, census reports of Government of India and lastly information from print
media as well as electronic media are also required.
Certain other techniques regarding studies on biodiversity may also be required here- biological
identification, taxonomic interpretation and nomenclature of plants and animals.
Data Processing and Data Analysis: The study is completely qualitative and knowledge
documentation oriented. Information on IK/IKS taken with appropriate anthropological
methodology (documented through T&V, RRA and M&E) could be input in computer based
Decision Support System, Remote Sensing/GIS, and World-Digital-Graphic-Mental framework;
however this is not the objective of present study.
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
25/29
Time Budgeting: Library work- 1 year and pilot study -1/2 year (done), fieldwork- 11/2
year(done), report writing and data analysis (first draft)-1(done), final draft and submission- 1
year
Tentative Chapterization:
Chapter I: Introduction
Chapter II: Methodology to Study Indigenous Knowledge System
Chapter III: Politico-Economic Background of North Bengal and Social Formation of
Rajbanshis
Chapter IV: Place and People
Chapter V: Are Rajbanshis Indigenous?
Chapter VI: Agriculture oriented Indigenous Knowledge System of Rajbanshis of North Bengal
Chapter VII: A note on Biodiversity
Chapter VIII: Division of Labour
Chapter IX: Conceptualization regarding Polity and Economy- few Case Studies
Chapter X: Conceptualization regarding Super Nature- few Case Studies
Chapter XI: Rajbanshi Indigenous Knowledge System and Sustainable Development
Chapter XII: major Findings
REFERENCES
Agrawal, G.P., P.K. Mishra, and R.M. Sahu. 1999. Extent and Proportion of Womens
Participation in Paddy Cultivation A Study of Kymore Plateau and Satpura Hill of Madhya
Pradesh.Indian Journal of Agricultural Economy, 54(3): 321-322.
Azam-Ali, S. and M.Battcock. 1998. Fermented Fruits and Vegetables: A Global Perspective.
FAO Agricultural Services Bulletin No. 134. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations.
Babu, S.C., B. Rajsekaran, and D.M. Warren. 1991. Indigenous Natural Resource Management
system for Sustainable Agricultural Development. Journal of International Development 3(4):
387-402.
Banarjee, S., D. Basu, D. Biswas, and R. Goswami. 2006. Indigenous Knowledge Dissemination
through Farmers Network: Exploring Farmer-to-Farmer Communication. In: B. Choudhuri and
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
26/29
S. Choudhuri. (eds.) 2007. Indigenous People: Traditional Wisdom and Sustainable
Development. IUAES INTERCONGRESS (Vol-4). New Delhi: Inter-India Publications.
Beohar, B.B., A.K. Sarawgi and A.K. Chaudhari. 1999. Womens Contribution in Paddy
Cultivation: A Case Study of A Village of Chhatisgarh Region of Madhya Pradesh. Indian
Journal of Agricultural Economy, 54(3): 323-324.
Bora, L., P. Hazarika, A. Borgohain and M. Hazarika. 2000. Role Performance of Farm Women
in Animal Husbandry Practices in Arunachal Pradesh.Indian Journal of Social Research, 41(1):
71-76.
Chawhan, S.K. and R.C. Oberoi. 1990. Role of Tribal Women in Farm Operations. Indian
Journal of Home Science, 20(2): 33-36.
Choudhuri, B. 2003. Health, Forest and Development: the Tribal Situation. New Delhi: Inter-
India Publications.
Das, M. 2001. Mashan Chitrakala (in Bengali). Lokashuriti 19: Pages 93-98. Folk and Tribal
Culture Center, Ministry of Information and Culture, West Bengal.
Davis, S.H. and K. Ebbe (eds.), 1993. Traditional Knowledge and Sustainable Development.
Environmentally Sustainable Development Proceedings Series No. 4. The World Bank,
Washington D.C.
Dhillon, M.K., H. Singh, M. Sidhu and J. Gill. 2007. Involvement of Farm Women in
Agricultural and Allied Activities Factors Associated and Constraints Faced. Indian Journal of
Social Research, 48(3): 221-227.
Ellen, R. and H. Harris. 1996. Concepts of Indigenous Technical Knowledge in scientific and
Developmental Studies Literature: A Critical Assessment. Internet source:
www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/basic.htm_68k
Fellows, P. 1997. Traditional Foods. UK: Intermediate Technology Publications.
Gartoulla, R. P. 1992. Ethnomedicine and Other Alternative Medication Practices- A Study in
Medical Anthropology in Nepal. North Bengal University, Central Library, Reference Section:
Ph.D. Thesis, Call No: 362.915496/ G244e.
Haverkort, B., C. Reijntjes, and A. Waters-Bayer. 1992. Farming for the Future: An
introduction to low-external input and sustainable agriculture. London: Macmillan.
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
27/29
Inge Kaul, Isabelle Grunberg and Marc Stern. 1999. In: Kelkar, G., D. Nathan, and P. Walter.
(ed.) 2004. Globalization and Indigenous Peoples in Asia- Changing the Local-Global
Interference. New Delhi\Thousand Oaks\London: Sage Publication.
Johannes, R. E. and F. R. Hickey. 2004. Coastal region and Small Island papers 15, Evolution of
village-based marine resource management in Vanuatu between l993 and 2001. UNESCO,
Paris, 48 pp.
Lal, G., G.S. Siddappa, and G.L. Tandon. 1986. Preservation of Fruits and Vegetables. India:
Indian Council of Agricultural Research.
Mishra, S. 2007. Traditional food preservation practices among Oraon tribe of Sundargarh
district, Orissa. South Asian Anthropologist, Vol. 7(2): 151-156.
Mondal, S.R. 2009. Biodiversity Management and Sustainable Development- The Issues of
Indigenous Knowledge System and the Rights of Indigenous People with Particular Reference to
North Eastern Himalayas of India. In: D. Das Gupta (ed.) 2009.Indigenous Knowledge Systems
and Common Peoples Rights. Jodhpur: Agrobios (India)
Muchena, O.N. and D.L. Williams. 1991. Utilizing Indigenous Knowledge Systems in
Agricultural Education to Promote Sustainable Agriculture. Journal of Agricultural Education.
1991/ Winter: Page 54.
Nakashima, D.J. 1993. Astute observers on the sea ice edge: Inuit knowledge as a basis for
Arctic co-management. In: J.T. Inglis (ed.), Traditional ecological knowledge: Concepts and
cases. Ottawa, International Program on Traditional Ecological Knowledge and International
Development Research Centre, pp. 99110.
Nakashima, D. and M. Rou. 2002. Indigenous Knowledge, Peoples and Sustainable Practice. In:
Timmerman, P. Social and Economic Dimensions of Global Environmental Change (Volume 5)
in T. Munn (ed.).Encyclopedia of Global Environmental Change. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Nidup, K., W. Roder, and S.Wangdi. 2007. Marketing Bhutanese potato Experiences,
Challenges, Opportunities. BPDP/CFC/CIP Working Paper No 4.
Norgaard, R.B. 1948. Traditional Agricultural Knowledge: Past Performance, Future prospects
and institutional Implications.American Journal of Agricultural Economics 66: 874-878.
Patnaik, R. and B.V.R. Prasad. 2009. Ethnic identity of Indigenous Tribes in Great Nikobar
Island. Studies of Tribes and Tribals, 7(2): 119-123
-
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
28/29
Pandey, U.K., K.S. Suhag, D. Singh and K.K. Kundu. 1999. Extent of Rural Women
Participation in Haryana Agriculture.Indian Journal of Agricultural Economy, 54(3): 311-312.
Rajasekaran (1993)An Indigenous Duck-Fish Production System in South India. Consortium for
International Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN). Thematic Guides.
Rajasekaran and Whiteford (1993) Rice-crab Production System. Consortium for International
Earth Science Information Network (CIESIN). Thematic Guides
Rajasekaran, B. 1993.Indigenous Technical Practices in A Rice-Based Farming System. Ames,
IA: Center for Indigenous Knowledge for Agriculture and Rural Development. Draft.
Sanyal, C. C. 2002 (1965). The Rajbanshis of North Bengal. Kolkata: Asiatic Society.
Sengupta, S. 2003.Perception of Folk Environment. Kolkata: Classique Books.
Steinkraus, K. H. 1996. Handbook of Indigenous Fermented Foods. New York, USA: Marcel
Decker Inc
Shiyani, R.L. and S.B. Vekariya. 1999. Role of Women in Groundnut and Wheat Production in
South Saurashtra Zone of Gujarat.Indian Journal of Agricultural Economy, 54(3): 318.
Subrahmanyam, S. 1999. Female Labour Absorption in Andhra Pradesh Agriculture. Indian
Journal of Agricultural Economy, 54(3): 272-281.
Subramanyam, V. and P.D. Rao. 2007. Effect of deforestation on the medicinal plants by the
tribes of Visakha Agency Area, Andhra Pradesh. South Asian Anthropologist, Vol. 7(2): 167-
172.
Tripathi, R.S. 1999. Role of Women in Hill Economy of Uttar Pradesh and Their Participation in
Decision-Making Process.Indian Journal of Agricultural Economy, 54(3): 303-304.
Warren, D.M. 1991.Using indigenous Knowledge in Agricultural Development. World Bank
Discussion Paper No. 127. Washington D.C.: World Bank. Internet source:
www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/basic.htm_68k
World Bank. 1990. Agricultural Extension: The Next Step. Policy and Research Paper No.13.
Washington, D.C.
http://www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/basic.htm_68khttp://www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/basic.htm_68khttp://www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/basic.htm_68k -
7/29/2019 Synopsis Ashok 2012 A
29/29
Signature of the Supervisor Signature of the Candidate