system no : 151 state of new jersey run date: 190916 ... · 5404000a 03-06-19 soto, gertrudis...

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 01 BELLEVILLE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5403489F 02-25-19 SULLIVAN GROUP, INC., 02-12-19 4003 1.02 1 149,100 115,000 129.65 YEAR TO DATE 1 149,100 115,000 129.65 5407382A 05-22-19 JULIANO, PAMELA 05-15-19 1502 1 C0006 2 127,500 175,000 72.86 5407077A 05-16-19 MINAYA, CRISTINA 05-07-19 9601 1 C0011 2 180,200 247,000 72.96 5405926A 04-22-19 DE LA ROSA, BETSY & ISRAEL 04-02-19 9703 7 2 207,400 280,000 74.07 5408506A 06-10-19 LUU, GABRIELLA & CHRIS 05-21-19 8905 38 C0022 2 190,400 255,000 74.67 5409166A 06-12-19 GUAN, ZU T & GU, DONG LINK 05-24-19 6904 35 2 239,900 315,000 76.16 5407385A 05-28-19 KUTTEN, MOSHE & NEHAMA 05-02-19 506 3 C0036 2 146,600 190,000 77.16 5409182A 06-26-19 PIONTEK, THOMAS M & JOAN 05-24-19 1002 18 C0105 2 152,300 195,000 78.10 5405797A 04-12-19 MARTINEZ, SONIA E 03-06-19 4302 11 2 289,100 370,000 78.14 5405939A 04-29-19 GUIDA, GIOVANNI 04-18-19 7304 1 C0012 2 195,800 245,000 79.92 5405328A 04-03-19 KOTHARI, KEYUR V. 03-27-19 8905 38 C0025 2 190,400 237,000 80.34 5408493A 05-21-19 LOPEZ, PEDRO & ET AL. 04-22-19 8006 2 2 344,800 425,000 81.13 5407075A 05-16-19 LINDO, ANGELICA & VELEZ, D 04-23-19 4705 4 2 233,200 285,000 81.82 5407397A 05-31-19 DRAGHI, MARGARET F 05-17-19 3702 7 2 247,400 300,000 82.47 5403378A 02-07-19 TINGLER, LUKE O. 01-30-19 2501 1 C1307 2 252,300 305,000 82.72 5404902A 03-20-19 DELUXE HOME BUILDERS, LLC 03-15-19 9602 6 C0026 2 201,000 242,000 83.06 5407400A 06-03-19 GROOME, BRENDA & O'BRIEN, 05-10-19 7905 20 X 2 330,400 394,872 83.67 5409179A 06-26-19 AVA FUNDING LLC (TRUSTEE) 06-14-19 9601 1 C0010 2 180,200 215,000 83.81 5409180A 06-26-19 IANNACONE, DAVID G 05-30-19 701 7 C0058 2 176,900 210,000 84.24 5407408A 06-06-19 DIAZ, RUBIN 05-17-19 6702 38 C0004 2 154,900 182,500 84.88 5404905A 03-20-19 CANDURA, JOSEPHINE A 03-08-19 7304 1 C0007 2 195,800 230,000 85.13 5405223A 03-28-19 BUCKLEY, GERALD P JR & DIA 03-11-19 3703 9 2 294,500 345,000 85.36 5403482A 02-21-19 KALENIKOVA, AYA & BOJOVIC, 02-04-19 7003 22 2 410,300 480,000 85.48 5407394A 05-30-19 ACOSTA, SILVIO L 05-16-19 5302 10 2 290,700 340,000 85.50 5405010A 03-21-19 NOGUEIRA, HUGO 03-15-19 1002 18 C0008 2 158,300 185,000 85.57 5409158A 05-03-19 JAQUEZ, CEDRI 03-20-19 3402 24 2 291,200 340,000 85.65 5405564A 04-15-19 GEDALA, RAO D & NAIDU R 04-04-19 506 3 C0030 2 146,600 171,000 85.73 5408494A 06-07-19 MAMMEN, STANLEY P & PRINCY 05-22-19 701 7 C0106 2 176,900 206,000 85.87 5408495A 06-07-19 PINTO, JOSEPH & GIOVANNA 05-15-19 6402 11 2 275,500 320,000 86.09 5409168A 06-18-19 EHP28-30B GREYLOCK LLC 05-23-19 9901 25 2 325,600 375,000 86.83 5405941A 04-30-19 URBAN PROPERTIES SOLUTIONS 02-22-19 9703 15 2 295,200 339,000 87.08 5404005A 03-06-19 CHAU, LING 03-01-19 1202 17 2 325,400 370,000 87.95 5405012A 03-22-19 MAS, OLGA 03-15-19 8001 23 2 303,200 343,000 88.40 5409441A 06-21-19 PATEL, BHAVIN 06-03-19 3501 21 2 398,900 445,000 89.64 5405953A 05-07-19 CASTILLO, DOMINGO & NORMA 04-24-19 6405 3 2 242,100 270,000 89.67 5405014A 03-25-19 PERRY, STEPHANIE 03-08-19 1403 7 2 306,800 341,000 89.97 5403368A 01-25-19 KRAUSE, ENITH 01-10-19 7703 12 2 230,000 255,000 90.20 5409184A 06-28-19 CHELINHO, AIRES M 06-19-19 6304 19 2 303,700 335,000 90.66 5407255A 05-20-19 WANG, YUXI 04-24-19 2501 1 C0102 2 290,900 319,900 90.93 5408518A 06-14-19 BALSEIRO, JORGE 05-29-19 2701 32 C0006 2 159,500 175,000 91.14 5407393A 05-30-19 MEJIA-ULLOA, ERICK A 05-14-19 7202 24 2 259,800 285,000 91.16 5403831A 02-27-19 MAGRO, ALFREDO 02-21-19 3704 30 2 277,900 304,000 91.41

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 01 BELLEVILLE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5403381A 02-07-19 RICCARDI, MARK & ET AL. 01-29-19 2501 1 C0918 2 284,500 310,000 91.77 5404651A 03-15-19 FIGUEIREDO, SEBASTIO & MAR 03-08-19 5302 11 2 277,200 300,000 92.40 5405954A 05-07-19 BONSENOR, PEDRO A. & ROSAR 03-29-19 804 1 2 328,200 355,000 92.45 5403830A 02-27-19 HENRIQUEZ, ENRIQUETA 02-08-19 8006 1 2 322,300 348,000 92.61 5405218A 03-26-19 CACELLA, MARYANN 02-15-19 7201 4 2 402,900 435,000 92.62 5403488A 02-25-19 FONTANEZ, GERARDO 01-29-19 6903 18 2 311,900 335,000 93.10 5409173A 06-20-19 ADABALA, SAI S 05-24-19 1907 13 2 289,400 310,000 93.35 5403825A 02-11-19 VERLINGO, THOMAS 02-04-19 3504 24 2 322,900 345,000 93.59 5407070A 05-13-19 PATEL, KUSUM 05-07-19 7004 17 2 234,700 250,000 93.88 5405943A 04-30-19 HAIGHT, MAUREEN & DAVID E 04-17-19 6801 34 2 338,500 360,000 94.03 5407073A 05-15-19 INZINNA, TAMMY & JOHN 04-17-19 9401 2 2 254,200 270,000 94.15 5403991A 03-01-19 DE FABRIZIO, JEANNE & JONE 01-25-19 4004 1 2 227,200 240,000 94.67 5405560A 04-10-19 ROMERO - REY, ROSARIO 03-22-19 6404 9 2 303,200 320,000 94.75 5409181A 06-26-19 FARINA, VINCENT & SODA, LE 05-23-19 2501 1 C0607 2 251,200 265,000 94.79 5405011A 03-21-19 214 LITTLE ASSOCIATES, LLC 02-27-19 8005 23 2 348,900 368,000 94.81 5405959A 05-10-19 WEINBEL, PATRICIA V 04-30-19 7201 12 2 247,200 260,000 95.08 5407071A 05-13-19 PREZIOSO, JOHN 04-26-19 9602 6 C0011 2 200,200 210,000 95.33 5405326A 04-02-19 MOHINDRU, AARTI & VIKRAM 03-27-19 2501 1 C0715 2 290,900 305,000 95.38 5403998A 03-05-19 MJEF GROUP, LLC. 02-15-19 8101 42 2 349,600 365,000 95.78 5403372A 01-29-19 MUNOZ, KETTY & MANUEL 01-09-19 4901 23 2 434,300 450,000 96.51 5408513A 06-12-19 FALCO, MARIO & RODRIGUEZ, 05-31-19 2501 1 C1309 2 290,900 300,000 96.97 5409176A 06-24-19 RABIN, LORI 06-04-19 5401 9 C0020 2 312,400 320,000 97.63 5403993A 03-04-19 DELACRUZ, ROLANDO 02-06-19 1501 32 2 337,600 345,000 97.86 5407258A 05-23-19 AURIEMMA, NICHOLAS JR 05-13-19 5902 27 2 270,500 275,000 98.36 5408520A 06-17-19 MUSCARNERO, JOSEPH & TABIT 06-11-19 6002 14 2 296,000 299,000 99.00 5407383A 05-22-19 HIGGINS, JOHN 04-30-19 7902 27 2 223,000 224,500 99.33 5409178A 06-26-19 FIELDS, MEL & PATRICIA 04-22-19 1602 11 2 243,900 245,000 99.55 5402913A 02-01-19 ANDERSON, ELIZABETH C 01-24-19 7504 21 2 210,700 211,600 99.57 5405224A 03-28-19 MCCARTHY, LYNN 03-15-19 2501 1 C0110 2 278,800 280,000 99.57 5407259A 05-23-19 PELLICIA, LUCINA & MARCIAL 05-14-19 5505 9 2 280,000 280,000 100.00 5405325A 04-02-19 CALZARETTA, DOMINICK A 03-28-19 5301 30 2 270,100 270,000 100.04 5404799A 03-18-19 ROSALES, JORGE B 02-26-19 8904 12 2 240,600 240,000 100.25 5405918F 04-09-19 GARCIA, MICHAEL & NICOLE 03-28-19 4106 12 X 2 270,800 270,000 100.30 5405960A 05-10-19 BHAGAT, SIMON & DIANA L 04-11-19 2501 1 C1010 2 284,500 283,500 100.35 5404000A 03-06-19 SOTO, GERTRUDIS 02-28-19 7301 27 2 259,700 258,000 100.66 5407260A 05-24-19 89 HECKEL STREET HOLDINGS 05-07-19 103 14 2 161,400 160,000 100.88 5402914A 02-04-19 HARRIS, SHIRLEY E 01-25-19 8507 14 2 285,300 281,000 101.53 5407387A 05-28-19 ABADA, EUSEBIO & VIOLETA 05-13-19 2901 26 2 295,400 290,000 101.86 5409172A 06-20-19 MAJOR CROWNE, LLC. 06-06-19 5501 14 2 285,900 280,000 102.11 5403390A 02-13-19 DU, LARRY & CHENG CHENG & 01-24-19 4407 5 2 334,900 325,000 103.05 5405934A 04-24-19 FRANK C. REALTY, LLC, 04-05-19 604 13.01 2 469,400 455,000 103.16 5407403A 06-04-19 UM, KI HYUN & YOUNG SIL 05-28-19 2501 1 C1402 2 318,600 307,000 103.78 5407262A 05-24-19 FUCHS, SCOTT & AMY 05-14-19 6303 21 2 300,300 287,500 104.45 5408504A 06-10-19 SULLIVAN, MARIE J 05-31-19 2803 20 2 283,500 269,900 105.04 5405226A 03-29-19 BONATO, FREDERICK 03-25-19 1002 18 C0001 2 159,100 150,000 106.07 5405942A 04-30-19 JOSHI, NITIN & JOSHI 04-11-19 2501 1 C0505 2 318,600 300,000 106.20

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 01 BELLEVILLE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5409170A 06-19-19 PANNULLO, LORETTA 06-03-19 403 31 C0005 2 106,400 100,000 106.40 5403999A 03-06-19 O'HARA, MATTHEW K 01-31-19 7201 5 2 351,300 330,000 106.45 5403370A 01-28-19 GARCIA-TORRES, JACOB R 01-18-19 1002 18 C0190 2 158,300 145,000 109.17 5405950A 05-07-19 LATONA, MONICA 04-11-19 8605 13 X 2 142,300 130,000 109.46 5409175A 06-24-19 GABRIELE, ELIO 05-28-19 9602 5 2 222,100 200,000 111.05 5405324A 04-01-19 MCDONNELL, MICHAEL 02-19-19 3802 30 2 319,700 286,000 111.78 5405930A 04-23-19 BELL, DIANA M. 03-19-19 8003 4 2 247,500 220,000 112.50 5407079F 05-17-19 JANOWSKI, WILLIAM JOHN 04-20-19 1002 18 C0200 2 131,100 115,500 113.51 5407395A 05-30-19 ANCONE, CATHERINE R 05-24-19 7004 31 2 217,600 185,000 117.62 5407058A 05-03-19 NARUKI, PAUL G 04-29-19 703 2 C0038 2 148,200 123,000 120.49 YEAR TO DATE 97 25,345,300 27,284,772 9,074.65 5405955F 05-08-19 PALDINO, DOMINIC 04-24-19 7101 2 4A 387,400 400,000 96.85 5401872F 01-15-19 FILIPPONE, CALVIN 01-08-19 1404 1 4A 455,100 458,500 99.26 5408514F 06-12-19 140 WASHINGTON AVENUE LLC 05-31-19 8601 11.02 4A 247,000 235,000 105.11 5404004F 03-06-19 259 WASHINGTON AVENUE, LLC 03-01-19 7705 3 4A 442,300 420,000 105.31 5405956F 05-09-19 LARICCIA, ROBERT & JOANNE 03-28-19 401 9 4A 228,000 160,000 142.50 YEAR TO DATE 5 1,759,800 1,673,500 549.03 5407264F 05-24-19 RICCIARDI, PAUL J JR & AMY 05-15-19 106 4 4B 122,700 185,000 66.32 YEAR TO DATE 1 122,700 185,000 66.32 5403477F 02-15-19 CB STEPHENS OWNER, LLC. 02-08-19 8803 6 4C 2,736,000 3,773,165 72.51 5403468F 01-22-19 FANO, THOMAS & HELEN 01-09-19 1301 17 4C 507,500 475,000 106.84 YEAR TO DATE 2 3,243,500 4,248,165 179.35 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 106 30,620,400 33,506,437 9,999.00

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394237F 07-27-18 12 OAKTREE LANE LLC, 07-02-18 1028 11 1 116,500 174,000 66.95 YEAR TO DATE 1 116,500 174,000 66.95 5406001A 04-26-19 YOUNG, ANN K & SHOUSE, SAR 04-15-19 223 4 2 285,600 561,000 50.91 5409036A 06-17-19 ZHANG, XIAODONG & YUNG, YU 06-12-19 970 1 C010B 2 74,100 140,000 52.93 5407414A 05-06-19 KOLODENKER, RUSIAN 04-22-19 970 1 C078B 2 66,100 124,000 53.31 5407266A 04-08-19 MARTINEZ, ROBERTO & NOELIA 02-22-19 24 6 2 252,200 451,000 55.92 5407273A 05-06-19 ZLT PROPERTIES LLC, 04-30-19 214 20 2 218,600 380,000 57.53 5393090A 07-09-18 BOONE, TODD R 06-27-18 370 12 2 213,800 370,316 57.73 5403500F 02-13-19 JEFFERSON, CYNTHIA 01-10-19 482 62 CB025 2 146,200 249,900 58.50 5399924A 11-15-18 JANGLEE, ELAWATY 11-02-18 721 8 2 288,100 489,000 58.92 5395387A 08-29-18 ACEBO, IVAN 08-15-18 367 17 2 207,200 349,000 59.37 5408973A 06-14-19 42 JOHN 3C ASSOCIATES, LLC 05-30-19 482 62 CC050 2 146,200 242,000 60.41 5399955A 11-27-18 MCGUIRE, TIMOTHY & KATHRYN 11-21-18 216 27 2 334,000 552,500 60.45 5408942A 05-23-19 SOLOMON, LATTELLE A & REAV 05-08-19 482 62 CC048 2 149,400 245,000 60.98 5397627A 10-16-18 FARIES, SCOTT E 09-27-18 692 2 2 335,000 546,000 61.36 5408864F 06-07-19 ORLOV, ALEKSANDR 05-28-19 698 6 2 276,100 450,000 61.36 5399918A 11-14-18 CLEMENTS, DARLENE M 10-24-18 33 8 2 197,500 320,000 61.72 5400717A 12-13-18 AYERS, MAXINE M & MARAJ, R 12-05-18 697 95 C0148 2 109,200 175,000 62.40 5408951A 05-30-19 PENAFIEL, DARWIN & GLORIA 05-15-19 377 2 2 249,700 400,000 62.43 5403761A 02-26-19 GALLAGHER, CASSANDRA 02-19-19 482 62 CE065 2 148,500 236,000 62.92 5408944A 05-28-19 RJT PROPERTIES, LLC, 05-09-19 697 95 C0145 2 107,000 170,000 62.94 5394837A 08-07-18 KAKKANATTUCHIRAYIL, PHILIP 07-16-18 815 1 2 257,400 408,000 63.09 5396877A 09-24-18 FAIRVIEW MANAGEMENT,LLC 09-14-18 723 3 2 281,100 445,000 63.17 5394827A 08-03-18 RODRIGUEZ, ROSEMARY 07-12-18 662 5 2 230,800 365,000 63.23 5408935A 05-20-19 PORTILLO, MARY ELLEN 05-14-19 249 7 CA006 2 177,900 280,000 63.54 5397587A 10-05-18 BERGAMOTTO, JAMES 09-26-18 697 72 C0036 2 109,500 171,500 63.85 5408958A 06-04-19 COLLINS, PATRICK W & MEGHA 05-28-19 217 55 2 265,600 415,000 64.00 5405334A 03-18-19 AGUDELO, CARLOS MARIO 10-26-18 102 10 2 239,100 373,400 64.03 5407283A 05-16-19 MONTERO, CHRISTOPHER A & J 04-24-19 283 26 2 204,600 317,000 64.54 5393118A 07-19-18 ECONOMOU, PETER & CORREA, 07-13-18 968 5 2 266,900 413,000 64.62 5395828A 09-06-18 LUDWIG, FABIAN 07-13-18 963 23 2 285,600 440,000 64.91 5408862A 06-03-19 JONES, ANNMARIE & EDWARD 05-16-19 101 2 2 227,600 350,000 65.03 5408965A 06-12-19 GRUTT, ARTHUR T JR & DONNA 05-29-19 697 95 C0172 2 144,700 222,500 65.03 5408975A 06-17-19 BELLO, JULIANNE 06-12-19 249 7 CA036 2 179,800 276,000 65.14 5404221A 03-05-19 GARRIS, THOMAS & ELIZABETH 03-01-19 249 7 CA026 2 183,100 280,000 65.39 5393795A 07-20-18 MALKOC, AKIN 07-12-18 32 18 2 203,500 311,000 65.43 5397622A 10-15-18 BETTENBENDER, RITA 09-28-18 249 12 C0021 2 173,900 265,000 65.62 5395508A 08-29-18 TARANKO, STEPHEN M 08-03-18 1057 13 2 395,900 603,000 65.66 5397607A 10-10-18 DEGRAW, DAVID & GENTILE, T 09-28-18 844 3 2 342,800 520,000 65.92 5405337A 03-19-19 GONCALVES, MANUEL 02-17-19 697 72 C0043 2 145,000 219,900 65.94 5394843A 08-08-18 DELEVA, JOSEPH 07-19-18 728 26 2 329,500 495,000 66.57 5409464A 06-28-19 YUKHTMAN, ILYA 06-18-19 972 37 2 323,800 486,000 66.63 5401231A 12-26-18 GONZALEZ, RAMON 10-04-18 19 18 2 143,400 215,000 66.70

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394239A 07-27-18 DAMASCENO, CHRISTINE 07-18-18 40 13 2 206,800 310,000 66.71 5396545A 09-12-18 OAG, GAVIN 09-04-18 931 72 2 303,900 455,000 66.79 5401248A 12-28-18 PEREZ, HECTOR 12-18-18 43 1 2 214,300 320,000 66.97 5397609A 10-10-18 AZAM, NADIM & MELISSA 10-05-18 991 140 2 257,900 385,000 66.99 5400625A 12-12-18 RODRIGUES, ALEXANDER S & N 12-01-18 193 40 2 298,100 445,000 66.99 5393115A 07-18-18 D 'ALEO, JOANNE 06-28-18 1382 37 2 346,800 516,000 67.21 5396904A 09-28-18 SCHLOSSER, DONALD LOUIS 09-14-18 721 13 2 319,500 475,000 67.26 5401226A 12-21-18 UNGER, MITCHELL P 09-08-18 788 44 2 451,000 670,000 67.31 5409463A 06-28-19 MODERO, JOSEPH & ELIZABETH 06-17-19 1203 16 2 372,100 552,000 67.41 5405969A 04-03-19 DAVID, TRAVIS & ET AL. 03-22-19 910 10 2 256,800 380,000 67.58 5394864A 08-15-18 ARCADIPANE, MARY L 07-26-18 991 80 2 267,100 395,000 67.62 5397601A 10-09-18 WILLIAMS, CRAIG E 08-31-18 332 23 2 221,900 328,000 67.65 5408946A 05-28-19 ALVAREZ, CARLOS & ALLISIN 04-09-19 482 62 CE074 2 146,200 215,000 68.00 5397584A 10-04-18 STICKLES, JONATHAN 09-26-18 792 52 2 317,100 466,000 68.05 5396432A 09-18-18 DURNA, JENNIFER 09-04-18 792 79 2 294,000 431,000 68.21 5399919A 11-14-18 ZELLER, DAYSI D 10-20-18 1027 24 2 253,100 371,000 68.22 5393807A 07-24-18 GRENA, LOUISE 07-13-18 332 37 2 252,600 370,000 68.27 5400621A 12-11-18 TUCCI, MICHAEL D 11-30-18 697 95 C0115 2 116,100 170,000 68.29 5397615A 10-12-18 POLAK, EDWARD 09-21-18 1026 15 2 273,100 399,000 68.45 5393790A 07-19-18 GRAHAM, WILLIAM P 07-13-18 182 4 2 284,200 415,000 68.48 5407265A 04-08-19 MOHAMED-KAO, DEBBIE & HARM 03-08-19 33 4 2 198,900 290,000 68.59 5395495A 08-22-18 D'ALESSIO, ARTHUR B & GUO, 06-15-18 1320 14 2 337,000 491,000 68.64 5393075A 07-02-18 MINICHINI, JOAN 06-26-18 423 18 2 322,700 470,000 68.66 5402765A 02-05-19 AMIN, MAHESH KUMAR & VARSH 01-18-19 15 22 2 140,800 205,000 68.68 5399948A 11-26-18 MALHOTRA, KUMUD 09-29-18 285 8 2 248,100 361,000 68.73 5405355A 03-29-19 MURPHY, FRED 03-18-19 192 24 2 299,300 435,000 68.80 5395823A 09-05-18 BRADLEY, SABRINA 08-21-18 1455 10 2 241,400 350,000 68.97 5393098A 07-11-18 MYKOWSKI, MICHAEL 05-24-18 913 39 2 228,500 331,000 69.03 5395479A 08-20-18 MONTICK, ISABEL D & ET AL. 07-03-18 697 72 C0018 2 107,000 155,000 69.03 5405356A 03-29-19 ULLOA, MIGUEL 03-25-19 45 14 2 131,200 190,000 69.05 5408960A 06-06-19 VIGNIER, NATHALIE 05-31-19 366 31 2 275,600 399,000 69.07 5401235A 12-26-18 SINANAN, BISSUNDAT 12-20-18 16 6 2 300,600 435,000 69.10 5396883A 09-25-18 LOPEZ, IRENE 09-07-18 661 1 2 224,700 325,000 69.14 5394852A 08-09-18 LI, CHEN 08-01-18 733 4 2 217,400 314,000 69.24 5402757A 01-30-19 SABATO, DENNIS A & BETSY A 01-15-19 1087 16 2 308,100 445,000 69.24 5394831A 08-06-18 LATIFI, JOVANKA & RUSH 07-30-18 931 76 2 329,200 475,000 69.31 5395496A 08-22-18 TATZ, JOSEPH R & ET AL. 08-09-18 933 84 2 357,200 515,000 69.36 5401238A 12-27-18 SATRIO, DJUNADI 12-17-18 820 33 2 270,500 390,000 69.36 5402927A 02-07-19 LEVER, LAUREN 01-28-19 431 51 2 271,200 390,000 69.54 5396914A 10-02-18 DURETTE, ANDRE 09-11-18 1177 28 2 382,500 550,000 69.55 5409187A 05-22-19 TODISCO, MICHAEL J 05-20-19 1382 20 2 306,200 439,900 69.61 5409026A 05-22-19 CONKLIN, STEPHEN 05-11-19 991 60 2 323,900 465,000 69.66 5393110A 07-16-18 KERRIGAN, LORI A 06-25-18 697 95 C0136 2 107,000 153,500 69.71 5408950A 05-30-19 MORROW, JOSHUA & BUCHANAN, 05-10-19 734 32 2 233,600 335,000 69.73 5409031A 05-31-19 PEZZINO, CAROL A 04-30-19 934 58 2 309,600 442,500 69.97 5399208A 11-13-18 DELRUSSO, JOHN J 10-25-18 900 19 2 254,100 362,000 70.19

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5397597A 10-09-18 FOGG, DEREK L & TRACEY M 09-28-18 919 26 2 341,300 485,000 70.37 5403760A 02-25-19 KELLY, RICHARD 02-13-19 697 72 C0007 2 107,000 152,000 70.39 5405989A 04-22-19 MATTHEWS, GREGORY B & MC N 03-27-19 1200 2 2 400,000 568,000 70.42 5405336A 03-19-19 RAMOS, JOHN JR. & CARMEN V 03-05-19 378 4 2 257,500 365,000 70.55 5400709A 12-06-18 ARIAS, SUITBERTO & HUNTER, 12-03-18 1324 9 2 300,700 425,000 70.75 5394861A 08-13-18 OHRI, NEVZAT 07-31-18 1445 59 2 283,300 400,000 70.83 5396912A 10-01-18 GKIONIS, GEORGE 09-05-18 1200 55 2 272,700 385,000 70.83 5396892A 09-27-18 ROSARIO, LUIS 08-24-18 822 45 2 276,500 390,001 70.90 5393087A 07-06-18 VICINIO, MOLLY 06-08-18 697 72 C0026 2 115,800 163,000 71.04 5395386A 08-28-18 HIDALGO, DARIO JEREZ 08-23-18 96 17 2 211,100 297,000 71.08 5395500A 08-24-18 YEUNG, FONG 08-03-18 786 19 2 319,900 449,000 71.25 5397624A 10-15-18 LAURENS, LEOPOLDO A 10-10-18 697 95 C0081 2 119,300 167,000 71.44 5409372A 06-19-19 33 MONROE PL LLC, 05-30-19 282 24 2 325,800 456,000 71.45 5393117A 07-19-18 LIVINGSTON, NANCY 07-13-18 249 12 C0045 2 119,400 167,000 71.50 5394848A 08-09-18 SCHUITEN, JACOB 08-02-18 182 6 2 264,600 370,000 71.51 5394832A 08-06-18 DAVIS, RANDOLPH & MICHELLE 07-18-18 823 22 2 197,000 275,000 71.64 5407422A 05-14-19 MEYER, DANIEL & ALEXIS 05-07-19 1176 5 2 333,600 465,000 71.74 5396433A 09-18-18 HALL, CAMERON J 07-20-18 825 16 2 213,200 297,000 71.78 5407271A 04-16-19 COX, NED 03-18-19 19 9 2 149,300 208,000 71.78 5396894A 09-27-18 MARTINEZ, JAMIE 09-19-18 781 1 C0006 2 118,500 165,000 71.82 5395824A 09-05-18 COLON, BIENVENIDO 08-17-18 1322 47 2 334,400 465,000 71.91 5400617A 12-10-18 LASHUK, WALTER & KAREN 11-30-18 123 21 2 186,300 259,000 71.93 5393104A 07-12-18 MURPHY, JENNIFER & BRIAN 06-15-18 1146 14 2 262,600 365,000 71.95 5401234A 12-26-18 TOBIN, BERNICE M 12-17-18 19 1 2 136,800 190,000 72.00 5404506A 03-12-19 MILLER, PAUL 03-07-19 1054 18 2 396,100 550,000 72.02 5398362A 10-16-18 LANGLAIS, DORIAN 10-05-18 213 20 2 326,800 453,660 72.04 5398677A 11-07-18 ORLOFF, ELIAS G & KAYLA CO 10-03-18 1453 28 2 299,500 415,000 72.17 5398672A 11-05-18 TRIOLA, CARMINE 10-30-18 104 25 2 220,300 305,000 72.23 5405342A 03-26-19 BEESLEY, DAVID 03-21-19 1172 61 2 298,200 412,500 72.29 5409373A 06-24-19 CHAVEZ, LEONORE 05-21-19 335 58 2 264,700 366,000 72.32 5408955A 06-03-19 SANDERS, BENJAMIN R & TRIS 05-28-19 511 36 2 229,700 317,500 72.35 5398376A 10-23-18 CORCORAN, RUTH VIRGINIA 09-28-18 795 12 2 195,400 270,000 72.37 5397585A 10-05-18 GASAK, ANDRZEJ 09-10-18 1172 35 2 333,100 460,000 72.41 5402124A 01-09-19 MILES, DANIEL & MALCOLM, M 01-02-19 1444 31 2 289,900 400,000 72.48 5404206A 02-27-19 BARKER, PATRICIA 02-20-19 182 3 2 266,400 367,500 72.49 5408947A 05-29-19 JOHNSON, RIGOBERTO 04-24-19 424 44 2 355,300 490,000 72.51 5408970A 06-14-19 RAZZAK, ABDUR 06-10-19 156 1 2 192,200 265,000 72.53 5404217A 03-05-19 ERIKSEN, KJELL B. 02-13-19 811 62 2 362,900 500,000 72.58 5398670A 11-02-18 BROWN, TERRY 10-24-18 19 13 2 149,000 205,000 72.68 5401225A 12-21-18 CONNELL, PATRICIA PARK 12-10-18 1051 89 2 332,300 456,999 72.71 5407423A 05-14-19 KOJANI, ELTON & OLJA 04-18-19 724 3 2 327,700 450,000 72.82 5400701A 11-29-18 RUBIN, JENNIFER 10-26-18 697 95 C0147 2 115,800 159,000 72.83 5395489A 08-21-18 RIVERA, DIGNA & SOSA, MARV 08-15-18 825 25 2 204,200 280,000 72.93 5395509A 08-30-18 NERGES, PHILIP & MELISSA 08-20-18 190 7 2 239,000 327,500 72.98 5393114A 07-18-18 MACIAK, DEREK J 07-06-18 574 27 2 355,700 487,000 73.04 5399194A 11-07-18 MATTINA, LOUIS 10-18-18 42 11 2 263,000 360,000 73.06

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5395513A 08-30-18 CHAU, DAVID Q & SELENA P 07-30-18 1458 13 2 283,600 388,000 73.09 5409457A 06-24-19 FENSTER-KUEHL, ELLEN 05-22-19 1177 14 2 383,700 525,000 73.09 5395483A 08-20-18 FIEDLER, OLYMPIA F 06-13-18 221 15 2 276,900 378,000 73.25 5409033A 06-12-19 MASCARI, JOHN P & JULIE L 05-19-19 1055 49 2 348,000 475,000 73.26 5409385A 06-28-19 OGLESBY, QURAN 06-14-19 10 9 2 230,800 315,000 73.27 5399195A 11-07-18 ZOUGARI, MARIE M 10-12-18 249 7 CB021 2 181,800 248,000 73.31 5404500A 03-08-19 BLAKE, MICHAEL & ANDREA 02-08-19 213 37 2 312,500 426,000 73.36 5408948A 05-29-19 ASTUDILLO, CASEY 05-17-19 781 1 C0004 2 146,800 200,000 73.40 5408938A 05-21-19 861512 LLC, 05-09-19 63 57 2 334,200 455,000 73.45 5409190A 05-29-19 AGASAN, ALICE L. 05-06-19 1263 1 2 286,500 389,900 73.48 5395504A 08-28-18 MARCHETTA, PATRICIA 07-13-18 1173 1 2 243,000 330,000 73.64 5397575A 10-03-18 FIGUEROA, ERIKA M 09-18-18 185 16 2 269,100 365,000 73.73 5396419A 09-10-18 SANDERSON, MARK 08-24-18 578 21 2 274,600 372,000 73.82 5395491A 08-22-18 SCHOENFELDER, STEVEN & KAI 08-13-18 933 88 2 332,400 450,000 73.87 5409384A 06-27-19 RUPRAM, YUDESH K & PURNIMA 02-27-19 13 8 2 334,500 452,500 73.92 5400601A 11-29-18 BEHUM, RASEDA & ALAM, RUHE 08-23-18 8 41 2 218,100 295,000 73.93 5402136A 01-18-19 ARAMBULO, SERGIO & JOSEFIN 11-26-18 287 23 C0110 2 213,100 288,250 73.93 5397595A 10-05-18 LEWIS, STEPHEN E 09-30-18 1383 25 2 347,500 470,000 73.94 5393080A 07-05-18 SEXTON, ALLANE J 06-15-18 972 20 2 294,000 397,500 73.96 5396425A 09-12-18 VELASTEGUI, JOHN 08-22-18 1456 14 2 242,600 327,000 74.19 5407419A 05-13-19 CRONKHITE, DREW & AMBER 05-08-19 933 22 2 360,400 485,000 74.31 5405345A 03-27-19 DOUGHERTY, THOMAS JR 03-19-19 1111 9 2 260,100 349,900 74.34 5404210A 02-28-19 2057 NEWARK AVE, LLC, 02-15-19 36 28 2 241,800 325,000 74.40 5399203A 11-09-18 RODRIGUEZ, ANTHONY 10-31-18 991 156 2 322,000 432,000 74.54 5409449A 06-18-19 ANDREANO, KEVIN & ELIZABET 05-01-19 1172 59 2 344,800 462,000 74.63 5395820A 09-04-18 BRUCE PROPERTIES LLC, 08-24-18 488 16 2 325,900 436,000 74.75 5407420A 05-13-19 CETL, MIROSLAV & SUNIDA 04-11-19 1454 14 2 318,900 426,000 74.86 5393081A 07-05-18 BALDWIN, NICHOLAS & ANNE 06-22-18 902 12 2 254,600 340,000 74.88 5399923A 11-15-18 KALICHARAN, PHILLIP 10-29-18 1200 49 2 288,400 385,000 74.91 5393083A 07-06-18 SHENG, WEN HAO & CHEN, YU 06-13-18 373 3 2 238,800 318,000 75.09 5409447A 06-17-19 CARBON, ROSALIN 06-07-19 919 9 2 251,900 335,000 75.19 5399215A 11-15-18 FELICIANO, RICARDO JR 10-16-18 724 33 2 225,600 300,000 75.20 5393797A 07-20-18 SHEARS, JAMES M 06-27-18 1264 3 2 383,800 510,000 75.25 5405340A 03-22-19 ZEMANECK, THOMAS JR 03-18-19 335 84 2 270,500 359,000 75.35 5397619A 10-12-18 VENEZIA, JEFFREY M 10-09-18 1456 30 2 411,700 546,000 75.40 5400611A 12-05-18 SMART INVESTMENTS GROUP, L 10-25-18 336 34 2 261,100 346,000 75.46 5409368A 06-18-19 DIPLOMAT PROPERTY MANAGER 03-27-19 731 13 2 330,100 437,400 75.47 5402111A 01-04-19 HAYES, RYAN & COURTNEY 12-14-18 287 23 C0101 2 196,900 260,000 75.73 5403499A 02-13-19 FALCONE, JEANNE 01-11-19 697 72 C0073 2 113,600 150,000 75.73 5393792A 07-20-18 LEE, KAI SUN 07-06-18 1143 14 2 235,000 310,000 75.81 5396876A 09-21-18 DELANEY, AARON 08-31-18 1188 4 2 390,400 515,000 75.81 5408966A 06-12-19 NJ LEAGUE ESSEX LLC, 05-23-19 123 48 2 251,900 332,000 75.87 5394236A 07-26-18 ROMANO, GREGORIO 07-17-18 282 29 2 417,400 550,000 75.89 5409196A 06-10-19 PARKER, MARY MAUREEN 05-30-19 1174 24 2 337,800 445,000 75.91 5398678A 11-07-18 SMALL, SHIZELLE & MARTIN, 10-09-18 7 7 2 206,100 271,000 76.05 5402101A 01-02-19 GULLEY, JEFFREY S & CANE, 12-14-18 1051 23 2 372,300 489,000 76.13

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5404209A 02-28-19 SPITERI, ALFRED 02-21-19 1189 14 2 422,900 555,000 76.20 5399196A 11-07-18 BRESALIER, STEVEN E & SAMA 10-25-18 1173 51 2 369,900 485,000 76.27 5409465A 06-28-19 LUSTRE, WILFREDO M 06-17-19 1293 149 2 339,400 445,000 76.27 5393103A 07-12-18 WAGNER, DEAN & ANDREA 06-11-18 845 3 2 359,900 471,500 76.33 5397401A 09-07-18 MASSEY, ANGELIQUE S 07-24-18 1261 12 2 267,400 350,000 76.40 5398372A 10-22-18 MANN, SARAH 09-13-18 811 34 2 222,700 291,500 76.40 5408859F 05-22-19 PATEL, SHYAMSUNDER 02-28-19 1143 7 2 275,400 360,000 76.50 5393788A 07-02-18 CHRENKA, PAULA A & ANA 06-25-18 282 60 2 581,700 760,000 76.54 5395506A 08-28-18 PETKOS, JENNIFER R 08-15-18 752 87 2 425,500 555,000 76.67 5395498A 08-23-18 KOGAN, IRINA 08-17-18 845 1 2 360,700 470,000 76.74 5399945A 11-21-18 CARRETTA, JOSEPH M & SUSAN 11-16-18 841 64 2 350,400 456,500 76.76 5398364A 10-17-18 CAMPOVERDE, VICTOR 08-22-18 287 23 C0111 2 215,100 280,000 76.82 5394824A 08-03-18 SHAH, PUNIL 07-30-18 971 6 2 313,200 407,500 76.86 5409034A 06-12-19 ORLANDO, JENNIFER & HOSHIY 05-28-19 967 19 2 292,200 380,000 76.89 5398666A 11-01-18 ALONGI, PAUL 10-15-18 1261 19 2 315,300 410,000 76.90 5397573A 09-24-18 ABATE, PAUL F (TRUSTEE) 09-19-18 1084 16 2 300,300 390,000 77.00 5402628A 01-24-19 SCOTT, ERIC W & LILLIAN R 12-17-18 186 9 2 368,900 478,000 77.18 5402922A 02-06-19 ZYGMUNT, W & L & FREITAG, 01-18-19 515 31 2 372,000 482,000 77.18 5393803A 07-23-18 LAMATTINA, SOPHIE A 06-18-18 1329 3 2 266,500 345,000 77.25 5396873A 09-19-18 STEINER, PAUL A 08-29-18 1448 86 2 309,900 400,000 77.48 5393811A 07-25-18 POPESCU, ROBERT S & CHANTA 07-13-18 217 35 2 294,500 380,000 77.50 5400710A 12-07-18 KULENDRAN, TOSCA KINCHEL 11-13-18 783 7 2 290,800 375,000 77.55 5405975A 04-11-19 JONES, WILLIAM T & LINDA 03-29-19 1293 9 2 294,700 380,000 77.55 5402924A 02-07-19 WRIGHT, RALPH JR 02-01-19 124 5 2 194,000 250,000 77.60 5398378A 10-25-18 COLASANTI, ANTHONY 10-19-18 970 43 2 298,900 385,000 77.64 5408967A 06-13-19 ROMEO,SHEILA WALSH & KIMBA 05-30-19 736 3 2 427,200 550,000 77.67 5408941A 05-23-19 MALIK, PRERNA & ARUNA 05-10-19 514 36 2 345,900 445,000 77.73 5399930A 11-16-18 CERAMI, MARYANN 10-22-18 731 12 2 226,000 290,000 77.93 5394245A 07-30-18 WATTS, IAN E. & KATHERINE 06-25-18 690 18 2 307,900 395,000 77.95 5404498A 03-07-19 GANEY, JAYME 02-25-19 513 34 CA016 2 118,000 151,000 78.15 5395829A 09-06-18 KACEDON, THOMAS 08-31-18 513 34 CB002 2 81,300 104,000 78.17 5399942A 11-21-18 FILORAMO, MICHAEL 11-13-18 462 20 C003B 2 144,900 185,000 78.32 5402118A 01-08-19 KANTOR, BRIAN 11-30-18 970 24 2 276,300 351,000 78.72 5400600T 11-29-18 SOUTHSIDE NSP 2018-1 REO, 11-15-18 696 16 2 275,900 350,000 78.83 5401247A 12-28-18 CHANG, FU-LU 12-19-18 1087 15 2 342,900 435,000 78.83 5395827A 09-06-18 HIRAPARA, VINOD 06-30-18 1086 5 2 291,900 370,000 78.89 5402620A 01-22-19 RUIZ, GILMA 01-14-19 424 22 2 313,700 397,000 79.02 5397611A 10-11-18 DEVITO, DEIDRE 09-25-18 515 25 2 347,300 439,000 79.11 5409027A 05-23-19 CORUJO, ROBERT 05-08-19 991 4 2 249,200 315,000 79.11 5393086A 07-06-18 CARSILLO, MICHELE S 06-26-18 734 23 2 241,800 305,000 79.28 5397571A 09-20-18 SCHELLER, JON 09-05-18 992 18 2 309,600 390,000 79.38 5401237A 12-27-18 PILLOT, DANIELLE M 12-14-18 423 5 2 305,700 385,000 79.40 5408954A 06-03-19 BAKER, EMMETT J III 05-03-19 34 4 2 214,500 270,000 79.44 5399940A 11-20-18 SHELDON, JAMES J 09-28-18 1293 145 2 238,500 300,000 79.50 5396891A 09-27-18 DORSO, MICHAEL 09-05-18 1266 28 2 306,200 385,000 79.53 5409375A 06-24-19 POP-ELECHES, GRIGORE 05-20-19 334 95 2 268,200 337,000 79.58

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394254A 08-01-18 WEINBERG, LAWRENCE 07-13-18 460 13 2 405,400 509,000 79.65 5399211A 11-14-18 2 PILGRIM, LLC 10-24-18 752 59 2 391,400 491,000 79.71 5393082A 07-05-18 JENTSCH, WILLIAM D & LORI 06-27-18 1111 82 2 333,400 418,000 79.76 5404212A 03-04-19 RODRIGUES, FRANCISCO A 02-21-19 693 19 2 357,800 448,555 79.77 5404511A 03-13-19 ISIGI, EBBY 01-30-19 213 31.01 2 295,300 370,000 79.81 5406003A 04-29-19 PAGLIO, CORINNE & PALMA, A 04-05-19 422 32 2 295,300 370,000 79.81 5400712A 12-07-18 GOODMAN, MATTHEW 11-29-18 933 102 2 299,900 375,000 79.97 5402619A 01-22-19 MEOLA, THOMAS 01-07-19 1060 3 2 372,000 465,000 80.00 5393802A 07-23-18 ZAMORA, HAYDEE L 07-10-18 829 15 2 280,800 350,000 80.23 5396878A 09-24-18 FODOR, HEATHER 09-07-18 1101 48 2 281,500 350,000 80.43 5397621A 10-15-18 SHVORIN-KUNIS, SABINA 09-25-18 1448 82 2 306,000 380,000 80.53 5396304A 09-11-18 ALY, HESHAM 08-16-18 188 3 2 261,900 325,000 80.58 5399201A 11-08-18 BARRIGA, GUILLERMO & ANTOI 11-01-18 871 30 C0049 2 270,200 335,000 80.66 5395480A 08-20-18 COCCHI, DARLENE J 08-09-18 426 6 2 302,500 375,000 80.67 5403495A 02-11-19 TURI, TERESA 01-31-19 486 24 2 325,000 401,700 80.91 5401229A 12-21-18 SHELDON, JILL 12-18-18 1174 40 2 364,500 450,000 81.00 5407284A 05-17-19 DELOSH, ANN K 05-10-19 544 12 2 231,500 285,000 81.23 5407415A 05-07-19 QUINONES, MARIVEL 04-29-19 1457 20 2 349,500 430,000 81.28 5394247A 07-30-18 SCHWARTZ, EDWARD JR 07-17-18 483 8 2 276,400 340,000 81.29 5397591A 10-05-18 MACARI, JOHN 09-27-18 736 6 2 239,900 295,000 81.32 5402103A 01-02-19 BAGLIONE, NICHOLAS & GAIL 12-26-18 513 7 2 258,900 318,000 81.42 5409377A 06-24-19 FAIRVIEW MANAGEMENT, LLC 06-17-19 753 59 2 374,900 460,000 81.50 5395821A 09-04-18 DEVINE, MICHAEL 08-13-18 572 8 2 383,300 470,000 81.55 5396434A 09-20-18 66 MILL STREET, LLC. 08-31-18 783 20 2 325,700 399,000 81.63 5395511A 08-30-18 GARCIA, ISIDRA 04-17-18 784 37 2 257,200 315,000 81.65 5401250A 12-29-18 NGUYEN, HIEU PHAM TRUNG & 12-13-18 736 5 2 265,600 325,000 81.72 5395484A 08-20-18 HINKIS, JASON 08-03-18 1383 12 2 336,300 411,000 81.82 5398367A 10-18-18 KERBER, FREDERICK 09-28-18 935 6 2 323,900 395,000 82.00 5394232A 07-25-18 15 YANTECAW, LLC, 07-13-18 933 29 2 422,400 515,000 82.02 5395487A 08-21-18 BRUWER, WARREN J & HELEN M 07-26-18 462 15 2 369,300 450,000 82.07 5393076A 07-03-18 JONES, RACHAEL & DARRYLL 06-25-18 820 5 2 238,100 290,000 82.10 5398675A 11-05-18 ROSILLO, NANCY 10-30-18 393 10 2 312,300 380,000 82.18 5405330A 03-13-19 RUBBET, WANDA 02-25-19 665 28 2 259,300 315,000 82.32 5400603A 11-29-18 RODRIGUES, MANUEL D 10-19-18 362 32 2 304,700 370,000 82.35 5397604A 10-10-18 BURCHFIELD, THERESA & JON 09-17-18 96 51 2 251,200 305,000 82.36 5409192A 05-29-19 HECK, WERNER J & BETTY A 05-20-19 1382 3 2 325,900 395,000 82.51 5393808A 07-24-18 KULHAN, JOHN K 07-13-18 490 12 2 218,700 265,000 82.53 5407270F 04-16-19 DIANA, CYNTHIA M (TRUST) 03-25-19 8 23 2 230,300 279,000 82.54 5400716A 12-12-18 KIMBELL, WILLIAM & PATRICI 12-05-18 1204 102 2 365,000 442,000 82.58 5400608A 12-03-18 CALDER, RUSSELL & CRYSTAL 11-16-18 573 11 2 343,700 416,000 82.62 5393806A 07-24-18 NELSON, MOIRA 07-18-18 189 8 2 252,300 305,000 82.72 5399922A 11-15-18 SCHORPP, WAYNE 10-24-18 426 27 2 231,800 280,000 82.79 5396312A 09-19-18 BENEMILE, JULINE 09-12-18 371 8 2 265,100 320,000 82.84 5396420A 09-11-18 SIVIK, RICHARD 08-30-18 818 11 2 282,000 340,000 82.94 5409380A 06-26-19 ANBAR, CAROLYN B. 06-19-19 693 16 2 304,000 365,754 83.12 5399944A 11-21-18 SHENOUDA, HANY & ERINY 11-09-18 871 121 2 386,700 465,000 83.16

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5402122A 01-09-19 OGHIA, CHRISTOPHER J & SUZ 12-28-18 546 12 2 292,500 350,000 83.57 5405341A 03-26-19 DAWSON, ORVILLE 03-13-19 829 22 2 280,800 336,000 83.57 5393794A 07-20-18 SWITENDALE, JENNIFER 06-27-18 914 13 2 221,700 265,000 83.66 5401221A 12-20-18 PATEL, ARVIND & NIRU 12-13-18 829 18 2 272,100 325,000 83.72 5393116A 07-19-18 RIVERA, QUETZY A 07-02-18 8 34 2 235,900 281,000 83.95 5408953A 05-31-19 MINERVINO, RICHARD R 05-21-19 738 18 2 258,700 308,000 83.99 5400620A 12-10-18 DUPONT, SCOTT 11-21-18 394 25 2 216,800 258,000 84.03 5407425A 05-16-19 KELLUM, GREGORY R. & SANDR 05-08-19 931 62 2 309,500 368,000 84.10 5394243A 07-27-18 ADLER, JEFFREY B 07-20-18 1299 10 2 324,100 385,000 84.18 5402622A 01-22-19 LOPEZ, RAUL 12-31-18 733 22 2 248,400 294,900 84.23 5409188A 05-24-19 GUEVAREZ, HARRY & KIRSYS 05-22-19 1200 74 2 370,900 440,000 84.30 5401249A 12-28-18 SHAH, DANIEL T 09-20-18 1268 13 2 354,100 420,000 84.31 5407416A 05-08-19 UL HAQUE, ABRAR & JAWARIA 04-29-19 1411 60 2 349,900 415,000 84.31 5396919A 10-02-18 LIGATO, ANTONIO 09-26-18 812 23 2 350,000 415,000 84.34 5394865A 08-15-18 KOMAR, GERALD P 06-29-18 871 5 2 274,700 325,000 84.52 5393810A 07-24-18 FIO2003, LLC, 07-12-18 3 9 2 237,800 280,000 84.93 5409462A 06-28-19 STAFFORD, ROYCE B. 06-19-19 907 65 2 238,100 280,000 85.04 5393100A 07-12-18 KENNEDY, MARTIN P 06-25-18 1322 45 2 276,800 325,000 85.17 5400699A 11-29-18 FANALE, VIOLA 10-30-18 1328 1 2 225,700 265,000 85.17 5402625A 01-23-19 GARCIA-PEDROSA, DANIEL & A 01-14-19 845 5 2 443,700 520,000 85.33 5393109A 07-13-18 REILLY, EFFIE COMBIAS 06-27-18 1321 41 2 247,700 290,000 85.41 5393113A 07-17-18 MACHWE, SUMIT & MAITHILY E 07-09-18 1411 55.19 2 447,100 521,000 85.82 5407267A 04-08-19 FORGARTHY, BABBET 03-22-19 63 62 2 244,600 285,000 85.82 5396435A 09-20-18 CHU, TIMOTHY & HUANG, DONG 09-13-18 1444 47 2 347,600 405,000 85.83 5398662A 10-30-18 OREFICE, FRANK J JR 10-23-18 425 34 2 273,400 317,500 86.11 5405991F 04-22-19 CAPITAL INVESTMENTS 224 LL 04-03-19 1084 5 2 297,400 345,000 86.20 5407421A 05-13-19 DAVIDSON, BRITTANY A & AMO 05-06-19 1383 12 2 336,300 390,000 86.23 5399931A 11-19-18 ROSSETTI, THOMAS F & BARBA 11-14-18 1264 33 2 323,500 375,000 86.27 5394821A 08-02-18 RAGAN, ANTHONY DYLAN 07-25-18 966 11 2 282,000 326,000 86.50 5402636A 01-28-19 282 PARK AVE LLC, 12-11-18 515 34 2 272,600 315,000 86.54 5395501A 08-27-18 MAK, GRACE C 08-03-18 783 28 2 218,400 252,000 86.67 5400706A 12-05-18 THOMATOS, PANAGIOTIS & TAL 11-30-18 1202 14 2 346,700 400,000 86.68 5401218A 11-14-18 KAUFMAN, ELIZABETH 10-30-18 42 24 2 155,300 179,000 86.76 5407279A 05-09-19 MACOTE, CARLOS A. 04-30-19 7 44 2 237,300 273,000 86.92 5403490A 02-11-19 EULAU, ANDREW 01-29-19 734 7 2 222,100 255,000 87.10 5393077A 07-03-18 HAMM, HARLISHA & ALEX 06-08-18 287 11 C0003 2 260,800 299,000 87.22 5402098A 12-29-18 MILANO, CARMELLA 12-12-18 22 16 2 297,000 340,000 87.35 5401232A 12-26-18 PESCATORE, THOMAS J 12-17-18 1266 23 2 302,400 345,000 87.65 5396882A 09-24-18 CESARIO, JAMES D 08-31-18 123 18 2 220,800 250,800 88.04 5408959A 06-05-19 TERRA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 05-24-19 574 17 2 367,700 417,000 88.18 5397603A 10-10-18 PADILLA, JUAN JR & LAVERNE 09-27-18 485 3 2 264,800 300,000 88.27 5402112A 01-07-19 ABDELAZIZ, ABDALLA H 12-27-18 1262 25 2 340,000 385,000 88.31 5398676A 11-05-18 QUIRK, MATTHEW 10-09-18 1448 83 2 346,100 390,000 88.74 5409195A 06-05-19 BIONDI, JOHN J 05-29-19 1082 41 2 377,300 424,000 88.99 5398363A 10-16-18 BENNETT, KYLE 10-10-18 1263 33 2 349,200 392,000 89.08 5402759A 01-30-19 COYNE, MICHAEL & AMELIA 01-22-19 871 30 C0067 2 320,900 360,000 89.14

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 8 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407410A 04-09-19 DUBLANYK, JESSICA 03-29-19 871 30 C0067 2 320,900 360,000 89.14 5394856A 08-10-18 BOGGS, LINDA H 08-02-18 871 30 C0042 2 267,500 300,000 89.17 5396309A 09-17-18 VAZQUEZ, SARAH 08-24-18 363 9 2 263,100 295,000 89.19 5404207A 02-27-19 LENTINI, DARREN 02-11-19 905 4 2 351,700 394,000 89.26 5394829A 08-06-18 KONSOULIS, JOANNE & GEORGE 07-23-18 933 103 2 311,700 349,000 89.31 5393801A 07-23-18 MCWATTERS, BARRY 07-07-18 1111 80 2 294,900 330,000 89.36 5394836A 08-07-18 RYALL, MARY P 07-24-18 544 11 2 231,100 258,500 89.40 5394255A 08-01-18 ESPINAL, ROSA 07-26-18 481 26 2 250,500 280,000 89.46 5397586A 10-05-18 LOPEZ-BAEZ, SANDRA I 09-14-18 1082 45 CC017 2 282,000 315,000 89.52 5396040A 09-14-18 KAMINSKA, STANISLAWA 07-13-18 752 28 2 237,300 265,000 89.55 5405977A 04-12-19 SERFESS, JOSEPH & JESSICA 03-29-19 1082 45 CB012 2 285,800 317,500 90.02 5395494A 08-22-18 CLOUGH, RUJAY A & MICHAEL 07-18-18 220 3 2 274,600 305,000 90.03 5405973A 04-05-19 DIAZ, JUAN & MIOSOTY 08-03-18 821 11 2 252,500 280,000 90.18 5402132A 01-15-19 MCGUINNESS, JAMES 01-10-19 973 27 2 314,900 349,000 90.23 5395830A 09-07-18 GREGERSEN, MARTHA 08-30-18 753 26 2 239,800 265,000 90.49 5405810A 04-05-19 ROBINSON, NETTER L. & WILL 03-26-19 482 58 CA005 2 149,600 165,000 90.67 5393796A 07-20-18 PASLAWSKI, JOSEPH 07-12-18 572 42 2 303,900 335,000 90.72 5394859A 08-13-18 PALACA, RANULFO & NENITA 07-26-18 973 23 2 372,000 410,000 90.73 5396306A 09-12-18 SCHELLER, LINDA 08-27-18 421 38 2 252,400 278,000 90.79 5397614A 10-12-18 BASHALL, ROSE LULU 09-11-18 514 13 2 336,600 370,000 90.97 5394858A 08-13-18 SERGHIOU, THEKLA & PANAYIO 07-25-18 541 3 2 326,000 358,000 91.06 5402109A 01-04-19 KEELEY, JOHN C & MARRY ANN 12-10-18 903 5 2 343,100 375,900 91.27 5395499A 08-23-18 GRANDSTAFF, TRACY JEANNE 06-05-18 1267 1 2 326,200 356,000 91.63 5396427A 09-12-18 JOHNSON, JUDITH 08-31-18 1110 12 2 360,900 393,000 91.83 5402623A 01-22-19 GOLDSCHMIDT, RITA 01-16-19 1445 7 2 351,400 382,624 91.84 5397617A 10-12-18 MARGEOTES, ANGELINA S 09-25-18 1141 28 2 277,600 301,000 92.23 5399946A 11-21-18 ESLER, EDWARD & LINDA M 10-08-18 369 9 2 194,200 210,000 92.48 5394849A 08-09-18 CAPRIGLIONE, JULIO 07-18-18 212 42 2 301,100 325,000 92.65 5395507A 08-28-18 BECA, HALCIU 08-22-18 1413 6 2 334,300 360,000 92.86 5396421A 09-12-18 SCAGLIONE, DIEGO A 08-28-18 1326 25.02 2 521,000 560,000 93.04 5405813A 04-11-19 329-331 ELIZABETH LLC 04-08-19 820 10 2 261,200 280,000 93.29 5407409A 04-09-19 DUHO, EMILE & BEATRICE 03-28-19 725 11 2 247,800 265,000 93.51 5405804A 04-03-19 DIMICHELE, EUGENE J & LAUR 03-28-19 306 37 2 233,900 250,000 93.56 5393084A 07-06-18 FIGENSHU, DANIEL J & ELIZA 07-02-18 792 34 2 348,300 372,000 93.63 5396889A 09-27-18 VILLA, ABDON 08-24-18 307 62 2 263,000 280,000 93.93 5397578A 10-03-18 36 WARREN LLC, 09-27-18 693 58 2 421,300 446,000 94.46 5396416A 09-10-18 STONG, COLBY K. 08-30-18 1444 10 2 321,700 340,000 94.62 5405344A 03-27-19 19 PARSON CT. ASSOCI, 03-15-19 933 39 2 427,100 449,000 95.12 5393105A 07-12-18 MOORE, MICHAEL & MICHELLE 06-26-18 725 5 2 279,700 294,000 95.14 5399934A 11-20-18 TORRES, ALBERT & MARANDA 10-23-18 452 24 2 221,000 232,000 95.26 5408963A 06-10-19 HONG SHERIDAN VENTURES, LL 04-01-19 481 28 C0007 2 114,900 120,000 95.75 5402096A 12-21-18 LUCRUM REALTY, LLC. 11-28-18 1174 16 2 515,500 535,000 96.36 5402761A 01-31-19 INCA, GIOVANNY 01-16-19 1031 49 2 231,700 240,000 96.54 5400705A 12-05-18 QUARTO, JUDITH 11-14-18 1264 37 2 330,100 340,000 97.09 5396418A 09-10-18 SANKEY, MONIQUE & SEREDYNI 09-04-18 935 5 2 315,800 325,000 97.17 5395485A 08-21-18 DONOHUE, MARGARET 08-07-18 334 64 2 311,600 320,000 97.38

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 9 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399938A 11-20-18 BLANCHARD, JANET 11-07-18 187 12 2 350,600 360,000 97.39 5396422A 09-12-18 CARTY, HERBERT 08-31-18 786 39 2 384,900 395,000 97.44 5402762A 01-31-19 BERGER, SHANE 01-02-19 332 135 2 331,600 340,000 97.53 5396415A 09-10-18 BERGER, RONALD F & BERGER, 07-26-18 1083 10 2 387,800 394,000 98.43 5404218A 03-05-19 PLAZA, LOUIS & TORSIELLO, 02-28-19 824 12 2 231,800 235,000 98.64 5402615A 01-18-19 JONES, LARRY L 01-07-19 969 13 2 284,500 287,500 98.96 5398665A 10-31-18 VENA, ROBERT J 10-29-18 514 26 2 282,900 285,000 99.26 5397579A 10-04-18 DENTON, ROBERT P 09-28-18 454 10 2 209,700 211,000 99.38 5393101A 07-12-18 JOHNSON, PETER F & CAROLIN 07-09-18 1411 129 2 354,600 355,000 99.89 5405995A 04-24-19 PANDYA, SANDIP R 03-25-19 1053 23 2 401,200 400,000 100.30 5393809A 07-24-18 ZICHELLI, IONE S 07-02-18 482 58 CB014 2 151,000 150,000 100.67 5395832A 09-07-18 DROBINSKI, J'SAN 08-22-18 1031 19 2 310,500 304,900 101.84 5407268A 04-09-19 DYER, KAREN 03-29-19 426 11 2 254,600 250,000 101.84 5409378A 06-25-19 VARGAS, JUAN CARLOS 06-03-19 811 5 2 326,100 319,900 101.94 5394835A 08-06-18 TREUBERG, KEVIN A & DANIEL 07-06-18 308 12 2 275,600 270,000 102.07 5406012A 05-02-19 GRADZKI, JOSEPHINE 04-14-19 1200 11 2 318,500 308,000 103.41 5408937A 05-21-19 LA CAPRA, JOSEPH 04-01-19 421 23 2 239,900 231,750 103.52 5397598A 10-09-18 MIXT, MICHAEL 08-22-18 212 21 2 264,000 255,000 103.53 5402618A 01-18-19 TYRANSKY, BRIAN 01-11-18 844 29 2 261,700 250,000 104.68 5407274A 05-06-19 RIEDER, CHAD & ELIZABETH 04-26-19 462 23 C0105 2 117,900 112,000 105.27 5395502A 08-27-18 HENRY, VALERIE 08-10-18 512 11 2 300,800 285,000 105.54 5403496A 02-13-19 DONATO, RAYMOND A. & LISA 01-31-19 1031 23 2 274,800 260,000 105.69 5394233A 07-25-18 LIN, PIN & XIULAN 07-17-18 841 20 2 317,300 300,000 105.77 5405997A 04-26-19 MOHRBUTTER, THEODORE C & P 04-16-19 462 23 C0102 2 95,400 90,000 106.00 5402633A 01-28-19 PARSON, MERRICK 01-12-19 101 12 2 352,200 330,000 106.73 5399927T 11-16-18 SABELLA-MILLS, DAVID 10-05-18 1263 46 2 342,100 320,000 106.91 5395478A 08-17-18 J AND L DEVELOPERS LLC 07-31-18 156 44 C0012 2 171,200 160,000 107.00 5399939A 11-20-18 MUGNONE, VIRGINIA 11-05-18 488 4 2 257,000 240,000 107.08 5405971A 04-05-19 MANZO, JAMES & TINA 03-26-19 1027 25 2 259,700 240,000 108.21 5396428F 09-14-18 PEREZ, DANIEL 08-20-18 871 6 2 266,700 245,000 108.86 5408952A 05-31-19 STUZYNSKI, THOMAS 05-21-19 783 19 2 283,100 260,000 108.88 5406009A 05-02-19 RIOS, ANTONIO & CHRISTINE 04-22-19 214 6 2 223,400 205,000 108.98 5397626F 10-16-18 LAPOINT, ADA G. 08-09-18 544 3 2 239,800 220,000 109.00 5399198A 11-07-18 WARSHAW, ADAM & MINCHALA, 10-29-18 1082 83 2 411,800 375,000 109.81 5399954A 11-27-18 KEYISHIAN, SARAH 11-16-18 187 8 2 241,800 217,500 111.17 5402632A 01-28-19 WU, EVELYN 01-17-19 335 34 C0001 2 101,000 90,000 112.22 5402099A 12-29-18 TUREK, ALAN 12-10-18 462 24 2 437,400 385,000 113.61 5404213A 03-04-19 MAURILLO, BARRY 01-30-19 752 1.04 C0001 2 231,000 200,000 115.50 5402129A 01-11-19 CHIWHANE, ASHISH 01-07-19 308 63 2 290,100 250,000 116.04 5405962A 04-01-19 ROCK CAP HOLDINGS LLC 02-11-19 156 20 2 197,500 170,000 116.18 5409451F 06-19-19 KING, JOHN A & STEVEN M 05-05-19 736 14 2 271,700 222,000 122.39 5393120F 07-19-18 GREEN, MARY ALICE 07-12-18 454 43 2 252,200 195,000 129.33 5395486F 08-21-18 CALLE, WILSON 08-08-18 303 57 C0003 2 144,000 100,000 144.00 5408956F 06-03-19 DEL MASTER, DONNA M & PASQ 05-20-19 214 38 2 237,500 160,000 148.44 SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 10 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND

ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 02 BLOOMFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE YEAR TO DATE 407 112,981,400 142,887,309 32,706.24 5409583F 05-08-19 TILDEN ENTERPRISES LLC 04-29-19 20 18 4A 300,000 600,000 50.00 5400708F 12-06-18 MARKET REALTY GROUP, LLC. 10-16-18 105 37 4A 1,290,800 2,225,000 58.01 5393079F 07-05-18 KALPLAN, EDWARD 06-25-18 517 30 4A 474,200 771,000 61.50 5409194F 06-03-19 J & E REALTY, LLC, 04-30-19 517 14 4A 425,000 650,000 65.38 5397581F 10-04-18 BLOOMFIELD FOOT & ANKLE CE 09-28-18 106 34 C0005 4A 265,300 350,000 75.80 5407428F 05-17-19 TIRONDOLA FAMILY HOL, 05-03-19 224 3 4A 389,700 510,000 76.41 5402760F 01-31-19 CHENG, GUO-PAO 01-10-19 63 1 4A 287,500 365,000 78.77 5396885F 09-26-18 BOYETTE, MICHAEL 08-14-18 306 36 4A 284,100 360,000 78.92 5393089F 07-09-18 LANGNER INVESTMENTS,LLC 06-28-18 127 31 4A 349,200 440,000 79.36 5400718F 12-13-18 59 DODD STREET, BLOOMFIELD 12-05-18 94 27 4A 643,800 750,000 85.84 5404214F 03-04-19 REM REALTY CO, 02-26-19 153 19 4A 275,000 320,000 85.94 5404215F 03-04-19 FOX REALTY INC, 02-21-19 692 17 4A 1,161,700 1,330,000 87.35 5398426F 10-18-18 5DLEEDY ENTERPRISES, LLC 09-25-18 214 36 4A 249,100 269,000 92.60 5400703F 12-03-18 BLUE EAGLE REALTY, LLC. 11-27-18 20 19 4A 450,000 450,000 100.00 5395481F 08-20-18 STACK, THOMAS J III 07-20-18 306 49 4A 496,200 430,000 115.40 5409454F 06-21-19 TOMIC, MIROSLAV 06-03-19 98 33 4A 691,100 535,000 129.18 YEAR TO DATE 16 8,032,700 10,355,000 1,320.46 5406002F 04-29-19 MVR PROPERTIES, LLC, 04-16-19 547 31 4C 969,300 1,930,000 50.22 YEAR TO DATE 1 969,300 1,930,000 50.22 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 425 122,099,900 155,346,309 34,143.87

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 03 CALDWELL BORO TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5395914A 09-12-18 WHYTE, SEAN 08-29-18 32 4.08 2 432,000 611,000 70.70 5401257A 12-31-18 BUTLER, TRACEY 12-21-18 74.01 25 2 542,700 740,000 73.34 5406754A 05-03-19 VERDORN, PETER 04-26-19 27 26 2 440,300 595,000 74.00 5407433A 06-07-19 WHITE, BRUCE & RUIZ, PATRI 05-16-19 10 15 2 613,200 820,000 74.78 5406018A 05-02-19 MARTIN, GEORGINA 04-12-19 2 10.10 2 399,000 520,000 76.73 5394756A 08-17-18 LINNETT, ROBERT E JR 08-13-18 51 14 2 422,300 540,000 78.20 5393825A 07-23-18 WASVARY, STEPHANIE 07-13-18 58 10.01 2 460,100 575,000 80.02 5407434F 06-12-19 WERNICK, STEVEN & JODY 05-22-19 41.01 52 2 528,100 640,000 82.52 5394306A 08-13-18 MARSHALL, JUSTIN J & NATHA 07-24-18 54 6.1402 2 326,000 390,000 83.59 5393832A 07-27-18 CASCARANO, JOHN 07-18-18 6 13.01 2 369,000 440,000 83.86 5397226A 10-10-18 ENG, ERIC HOWARD & CHEN, I 09-27-18 54 6.1204 2 326,000 388,000 84.02 5394301A 08-06-18 FUSCO, PETER J & AMY L 07-24-18 20 11 2 441,300 525,000 84.06 5394196A 08-03-18 SUAREZ, ADAM 07-26-18 54 3.47 2 156,300 185,000 84.49 5396547A 09-27-18 LUTZ, WILLIAM P III 09-21-18 54 2.48 2 156,300 185,000 84.49 5398683A 11-07-18 CARPENTER, SARAH ELIZABETH 10-19-18 54 3.32 2 156,300 185,000 84.49 5399958A 12-07-18 PIPERNO, DAVID G 12-05-18 57 2 2 478,900 565,000 84.76 5396923A 10-02-18 BRANTLEY, BENJAMIN 09-12-18 54 6.304 2 326,000 382,000 85.34 5402933A 02-11-19 HAIS HOLDING LLC, 02-08-19 28 24 2 409,400 475,000 86.19 5394304A 08-06-18 BYRNE, ELLEN M 07-29-18 54 3.29 2 156,300 180,000 86.83 5401888A 01-16-19 CAVALIERI, ERIO G 12-29-18 42 4.04 2 353,500 405,000 87.28 5397404A 10-12-18 DEFRANK, RICHARD 09-27-18 8 10 2 472,000 540,000 87.41 5393828A 07-24-18 MONTALVO, DANIEL 07-10-18 14 4.02 2 454,200 518,000 87.68 5401886A 01-14-19 KEATING, JOSEPH 12-28-18 54 2.40 2 156,300 178,000 87.81 5393129A 07-19-18 SIEKIERKA, MATTHEW J 06-22-18 16 1 2 356,200 405,000 87.95 5399455A 11-21-18 PIERREZ, DANIEL JR 11-02-18 72.01 5 2 440,100 499,900 88.04 5394303A 08-06-18 PALLANTE, ADINA 07-23-18 43 5.10 2 379,400 429,000 88.44 5394755A 08-16-18 DECKER, TAMMI L 07-23-18 36.01 1.04 2 287,700 325,000 88.52 5407432A 06-05-19 MINISH, THERESA A 05-17-19 66 1.03 2 393,100 440,000 89.34 5393128A 07-13-18 SHICK, ERIC J (TRUSTEE) 06-07-18 36.01 3.04 2 287,700 320,000 89.91 5404006A 03-05-19 FIORE, JASON & TIFFANY CAR 02-14-19 13 2 2 434,200 481,000 90.27 5394754A 08-16-18 DELANEY, MAUREEN A 08-10-18 41.01 17 2 384,500 425,000 90.47 5393127A 07-12-18 BURROWS, GEORGE H & GAIL S 06-18-18 45 7.02 2 481,900 530,026 90.92 5403505A 02-14-19 KORA, BONIFACY & ET AL. 12-18-18 68 2.04 2 524,100 575,000 91.15 5399744A 12-04-18 TATE, MONICA M 11-28-18 36 19 2 376,300 412,500 91.22 5396122A 09-18-18 BEHRE, JAMES & GINA MARIE 07-31-18 33 1.07 2 461,500 505,000 91.39 5395520A 08-30-18 GUERRIERI, ANTHONY & LUGO, 08-01-18 53 8 2 411,400 449,900 91.44 5405363A 04-01-19 WILSON, JOSEPH & DANA 03-13-19 66 1.05 2 396,100 433,000 91.48 5402932A 02-08-19 LAFORGIA, CHRISTOPHER & ME 01-30-19 55 2.16 2 279,800 305,000 91.74 5399456A 11-21-18 EDELSTEIN, STEPHEN J 10-24-18 69 5 2 649,700 700,000 92.81 5395915A 09-12-18 CAMPBELL, JAMES R 08-23-18 54 6.104 2 326,000 350,000 93.14 5397402A 10-12-18 MOGLEN, SOL 09-26-18 66 1.18 2 392,000 420,000 93.33 5402931A 02-06-19 OGENS, DAVID 01-18-19 8 7 2 523,600 560,000 93.50 5396921A 09-28-18 BUKOWSKI, MICHAEL P 09-21-18 54 6.404 2 326,000 348,000 93.68 5396920A 09-28-18 KEESHEN, PATRICK 09-20-18 25 8 2 438,500 467,500 93.80 5400728A 12-21-18 MCGRATH, THOMAS M 12-17-18 54 6.704 2 326,000 345,000 94.49 5393831A 07-27-18 KAISER, DANIEL 07-19-18 72 1.11 2 473,800 500,000 94.76

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 03 CALDWELL BORO TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5402767A 01-30-19 LARUSSO, JOSEPH JR 01-17-19 54 6.501 2 310,300 327,000 94.89 5395519A 08-24-18 RYAN, DYLAN VINCENT 07-16-18 57 1 2 357,300 370,000 96.57 5399331A 11-21-18 KRAUSE, GARD J 11-14-18 55 2 2 362,100 370,000 97.86 5395694A 09-04-18 BRAVETTE, ANDREA 08-22-18 7.01 1.02 2 384,100 388,000 98.99 5406019A 05-06-19 16 WAKEFIELD, LLC, 03-15-19 29 35 2 548,900 550,000 99.80 5395917A 09-12-18 FLAVELLE, ANDE 08-16-18 36 9 2 360,400 360,000 100.11 5394753A 08-16-18 KOCORNIK, RICHARD WILBORN 07-30-18 73 17 2 508,300 507,500 100.16 5397405A 10-15-18 KESSLER, PAULA 08-21-18 25 2.03 2 447,500 444,900 100.58 5398684A 11-08-18 CANNARA, CHRISTOPHER R & M 10-24-18 36 29 2 396,000 390,000 101.54 5393829A 07-26-18 PALLANTE, LAWRENCE JR 07-09-18 41 11.12 2 503,900 496,000 101.59 5404577A 03-14-19 NEVINS, LINDA S. 03-01-19 10 2 2 513,100 500,000 102.62 5409199A 06-27-19 CUCUZELLA, JOSEPHINE (TRUS 06-05-19 65 1.19 2 392,000 380,000 103.16 5402137F 01-18-19 THEOBALD, JOSEPH J (TRUSTE 01-09-19 37 1.19 2 321,200 310,000 103.61 5406016F 04-26-19 DEBRUYNE, DONALD J & STEPH 04-11-19 23 24 2 461,400 445,000 103.69 5400727A 12-21-18 LAND, JONATHAN 10-09-18 58.01 15.01 2 344,300 330,000 104.33 5401255A 12-29-18 MCGOWAN, ALICE & ROSE GAMB 12-20-18 41 11.14 2 587,200 550,000 106.76 5406013A 04-16-19 BARNES, LESLIE 04-04-19 63 1 2 434,400 367,000 118.37 YEAR TO DATE 63 25,157,500 27,893,226 5,729.01 5399147F 11-13-18 PRYOR, WILLIAM BRAND 10-12-18 54 11 4A 376,200 540,000 69.67 5409201F 06-28-19 1ST TEE INVESTMENT GROUP L 06-10-19 53 12 4A 1,003,500 1,337,500 75.03 5404578F 03-14-19 327 BLOOMFIELD AVENUE 03-03-19 22 18 4A 387,200 430,500 89.94 5395916F 09-12-18 CONLEY, MICHAEL J 08-30-18 26 13.03 4A 430,600 475,000 90.65 5405364F 04-02-19 PANCOAST, CRAIG 03-08-19 55 2.02 4A 491,600 506,500 97.06 5404226F 03-08-19 BONSMA, PETER J 12-17-18 36 6 4A 382,600 320,000 119.56 5407429F 06-03-19 160 ROSELAND AVENUE 05-08-19 58.01 6.02 4A 425,600 310,000 137.29 YEAR TO DATE 7 3,497,300 3,919,500 679.20 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 70 28,654,800 31,812,726 6,408.21

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 04 CEDAR GROVE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399332A 07-09-18 CORREIA, MICHAEL 06-26-18 250 27 2 378,900 528,000 71.76 5405237A 11-01-18 MEHL, ETTA 10-22-18 300 11 C0109 2 364,200 505,000 72.12 5405236A 10-23-18 TAVARES, DUVERNEY A 10-06-18 53 63.1 2 459,300 629,000 73.02 5405240A 12-04-18 ZERPA, ADOLPH 11-27-18 300 11 C0130 2 357,800 490,000 73.02 5396929A 07-06-18 ANDERSON, RAYMOND J 06-28-18 172 45 2 454,100 615,000 73.84 5409477A 06-07-19 SCHWARTZBERG, SUSAN G & HO 05-20-19 300 11 C0154 2 385,600 515,000 74.87 5405238A 11-08-18 SUSICKE, JOAN 10-30-18 12 28 2 469,100 625,000 75.06 5398050A 10-05-18 KAST, JOHN DAVID 08-28-18 314 5 2 996,100 1,326,000 75.12 5396943A 08-30-18 ROMERO, RICHARD P & ET AL. 08-27-18 300 11 C0141 2 378,700 495,000 76.51 5396940A 08-03-18 WILSON, CHRISTOPHER J 07-27-18 68 21 2 312,700 408,000 76.64 5397957A 08-03-18 TOBEY, DAVID 07-20-18 15 18 2 477,000 620,000 76.94 5405242A 12-21-18 TUFARO, GARY V & JANICE L 11-30-18 16 6 2 400,000 519,000 77.07 5405373A 02-01-19 SCAZAFABO, ALLEN & CASCIOL 01-24-19 340 178 C0031 2 267,000 345,000 77.39 5404514A 11-07-18 DEMETROPOULOS, PATRICIA R. 10-25-18 16 7 2 401,900 519,000 77.44 5396928A 07-03-18 O'ROURKE, GEORGE P. & AILE 06-22-18 15 2 2 438,000 563,000 77.80 5399333A 09-07-18 PALAZZOLO, NANCY 08-22-18 340 178 C0016 2 259,700 333,000 77.99 5404521A 12-21-18 PEREZ, CARLA A 12-17-18 40 201 C0018 2 175,200 223,500 78.39 5405234A 08-28-18 DONNELLY, THOMAS J 08-20-18 171 15 2 407,500 519,000 78.52 5405232A 08-03-18 MURRAY, JOHN A 07-31-18 16 22 2 437,900 555,000 78.90 5397632A 09-19-18 TRAETTINO, MICHAEL 09-06-18 320 102 C0016 2 321,600 402,000 80.00 5404516A 11-08-18 SANDELLA, JOHN J & CHRISTI 10-30-18 9 5 2 420,000 516,000 81.40 5405377A 02-27-19 COLALILLO, MARK A 02-19-19 64 23 2 342,500 420,000 81.55 5409479A 06-27-19 PATEL, KANJIBHAI L. & ARUN 06-12-19 8 1 2 400,500 490,000 81.73 5396938A 08-02-18 CAI, YING GRACE 07-31-18 40 201 C0017 2 184,500 225,000 82.00 5403845A 01-28-19 WLODYCHAK, STEVEN 01-14-19 201 9 2 299,600 365,000 82.08 5405369A 01-08-19 BRESIN, ROBERT A 12-17-18 40 201 C0020 2 168,300 205,000 82.10 5402771A 01-17-19 BRUZZIO, ANTHONY C. 01-08-19 20 3 2 418,900 510,000 82.14 5409204A 05-07-19 SCARPELLI, ANTHONY & ALISS 04-12-19 67 13 2 339,000 412,000 82.28 5409202A 04-22-19 ANSARI, MABOUD & ESMAT 04-12-19 90 278 2 461,900 559,500 82.56 5405366A 01-02-19 CLARK, BRIAN P 12-26-18 52 5 2 376,600 456,000 82.59 5404523A 12-28-18 MILLER, ALEXA 12-19-18 220 12 2 388,400 470,000 82.64 5409205A 05-17-19 VIERECK, VICTOR GREGOR 05-08-19 23 15 2 421,100 509,000 82.73 5409527A 05-03-19 FITZPATRICK, BRADLEY 03-05-19 223 36 2 546,200 660,000 82.76 5409528A 06-27-19 CORRADI, FRANK J. III & RA 06-10-19 223 30 2 479,300 579,000 82.78 5397985A 10-02-18 NOORDYK, JARED M. 09-10-18 131 5 2 503,600 605,000 83.24 5409472A 04-23-19 BENSON, SHARON H 04-12-19 300 11 C0123 2 512,200 615,000 83.28 5396941A 08-14-18 SHAPLLO, TED M & ERIKA 07-30-18 174 14 2 360,000 425,000 84.71 5396927A 07-02-18 ENRIGHT, PATRICIA 06-18-18 330 77 2 415,300 490,000 84.76 5405574A 03-26-19 KOBER, KYLE 03-21-19 28 4 2 411,400 485,000 84.82 5404804A 03-08-19 PANKIEWICZ, JOSEPH 02-27-19 68 1 2 298,900 349,900 85.42 5405572A 03-11-19 DAVID KIBITELSKY REV, 02-25-19 170 26 2 455,300 530,000 85.91 5409212A 06-24-19 FREEMAN, JAMEEL A 06-02-19 22 5 2 389,600 453,000 86.00 5404518A 12-11-18 HOFF, ELAINE 11-21-18 272 20 2 411,000 477,102 86.15 5396945A 09-14-18 GARGIULO, GALE 08-22-18 250 25 2 522,400 606,000 86.20 5397631A 08-21-18 BOZZA, DEAN L 08-15-18 65 7 2 367,400 425,000 86.45 5409387A 04-05-19 ANDRIOLA, JOSEPH F. & ADRI 03-29-19 140 24 2 474,400 546,000 86.89

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 04 CEDAR GROVE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405375A 02-20-19 MAGESIS, DEREK & NICOLE 02-07-19 103 5 2 417,900 480,000 87.06 5409210A 06-13-19 ALTMAN, GERTRUDE 06-07-19 53 16 2 411,800 473,000 87.06 5397630A 08-21-18 MEILIKER, ELLEY 08-16-18 330 221 2 427,100 488,000 87.52 5396931A 07-09-18 DOANE, FORREST 06-24-18 170 82 2 424,800 485,000 87.59 5409386A 04-04-19 ARMSWOOD, THERESA RAE 03-28-19 195 15 2 420,900 480,000 87.69 5409203A 04-25-19 FRANCIS, VALERIE 04-05-19 110 71 C0013 2 207,000 235,500 87.90 5404803A 03-08-19 CUCCINELLO, JANET J 02-20-19 104 3 2 440,900 495,000 89.07 5402768A 01-04-19 CRESPO, LUS & LUZ MIRANDA 12-24-18 36 1 2 722,900 805,000 89.80 5396935A 07-26-18 CALCAGNO, ALBERT P. 07-10-18 221 1 2 422,800 470,000 89.96 5404513A 10-29-18 FERRARO, JOSEPH A 10-23-18 220 9 2 369,100 410,000 90.02 5396930A 07-09-18 PUK, KATHLEEN 07-02-18 174 9 2 396,500 437,500 90.63 5396939A 08-03-18 LIN, ERIC W 07-30-18 190 63 2 416,400 459,000 90.72 5397628A 07-13-18 BRIENZA, JOSEPH V 07-10-18 172 9 2 362,900 400,000 90.73 5397407A 07-16-18 SECOY, JOHN W & MARY BETH 07-06-18 300 11 C0136 2 508,300 560,000 90.77 5397408A 07-24-18 BAEZ, JOSE 05-31-18 13 35 2 434,200 470,000 92.38 5402769A 01-16-19 BARBUTO, DOROTHY (TRUST) 01-08-19 220 14 2 410,000 442,500 92.66 5409466A 04-03-19 JARIWALLA, JAYOOL 02-25-19 320 322 2 835,000 900,000 92.78 5396946A 09-18-18 GENNINGS, DAVID M 09-04-18 275 47 2 492,700 531,000 92.79 5404524A 01-23-19 DIGORI, MARY 01-12-19 223 47 2 465,400 499,000 93.27 5402770A 01-16-19 MATTESKY, MARC 01-11-19 103 34 2 336,300 360,000 93.42 5409388A 05-06-19 LISZCZYNSKY, ROSE M 04-30-19 120 61 2 478,200 510,000 93.76 5409392A 06-12-19 SOUFFRONT, SANTOS & BARBAR 05-24-19 150 39 2 451,100 480,000 93.98 5396932A 07-13-18 POTHACAMURY, SHANTHI 06-22-18 370 11 C0048 2 486,000 515,000 94.37 5404515A 11-08-18 DATTA, PRANAB K & CHITRA T 10-15-18 330 236 2 400,700 420,000 95.40 5397959A 10-09-18 ABRAHAM, VICTOR 09-28-18 360 16 2 401,900 420,000 95.69 5397633A 09-20-18 ABEDINI, RASAM & SUSANNE 08-24-18 221 2 2 450,700 470,000 95.89 5397629A 08-17-18 PONTUS, HELEN F 08-09-18 64 24 2 311,700 325,000 95.91 5397960A 10-12-18 CORNERSTONE HOMES MGMT, LL 10-05-18 342 12 2 336,100 350,000 96.03 5404520A 12-18-18 WALLACE, ALBERT J 11-30-18 303 13 2 375,800 390,000 96.36 5396933A 07-13-18 HEITZMAN, CHRISTOPHER J 06-20-18 370 11 C0003 2 493,100 510,000 96.69 5396942A 08-24-18 GANDHI, SENTHAMARAI & ET A 08-11-18 310 61 2 724,800 748,000 96.90 5409390A 05-23-19 TRAMAZZO, MARYELLEN 05-08-19 160 91 2 486,600 500,000 97.32 5396934A 07-24-18 UNIQUE HOME SPECIALISTS LL 06-12-18 172 49 2 407,500 417,500 97.60 5397958A 10-05-18 MCGEE, ANN & ET AL. 09-23-18 194 31 2 432,200 440,000 98.23 5404525A 02-01-19 DIBERNARDO, BARRY 12-19-18 261 51 C0047 2 643,900 655,000 98.31 5404517A 11-29-18 SYMONS, JAMES H & MEAGHER, 11-09-18 53 4 2 327,400 327,000 100.12 5397987A 10-16-18 RICHARDSON, PETER C 10-01-18 51 66 2 332,000 330,000 100.61 5396814A 08-27-18 ROTOLO, MICHAEL 04-14-18 32 9 2 572,600 561,526 101.97 5404526A 02-07-19 AUGUSTINE, VICTORIA 01-09-19 171 86 2 368,900 360,000 102.47 5404528A 03-06-19 CUMMINGS, AMY 02-14-19 90 344 2 439,700 427,000 102.97 5396936A 07-26-18 JEZO, MARIE-LOUISE 07-17-18 67 22 2 294,700 285,000 103.40 5404522A 12-24-18 POPE, JOSEPH 12-13-18 180 37 2 1,179,700 1,125,000 104.86 5398051A 10-16-18 MANFRA, JOHN 10-01-18 350 49 2 470,200 445,000 105.66 5405381A 03-27-19 JTC ENTERPRISES, LLC, 03-19-19 27 101 2 410,500 385,000 106.62 5397406A 07-05-18 NEDROW, THOMAS 06-27-18 22 13 2 454,400 425,000 106.92 5400729A 12-04-18 ZATORSKI, LYDIA A 11-15-18 270 1 2 418,700 391,000 107.08

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 04 CEDAR GROVE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5409389A 05-16-19 ADAMUS, MICHAEL L. & RACHE 05-13-19 140 2 2 418,500 389,000 107.58 5404527A 02-22-19 STERENSON, ROBERT M. & LYN 02-15-19 40 1.17 2 739,200 675,000 109.51 5400730A 12-05-18 MATHUR, GUR SARUP & PREETI 11-29-18 91 18 2 482,200 429,000 112.40 5400157A 07-30-18 PIZZANO, MARGARET L 06-23-18 194 32 X 2 542,400 482,500 112.41 5409476A 06-04-19 MARTIN, PATRICIA A 05-24-19 223 16 2 394,900 350,000 112.83 5405367A 01-07-19 RAFULOWITZ, RICHARD 12-17-18 270 3 2 417,200 355,000 117.52 5409391A 05-23-19 MERSINGER, WILLIAM A 05-16-19 130 48 2 725,000 600,000 120.83 5397986F 10-15-18 ALLEN, WILLIAM E 10-03-18 26 4 2 354,300 285,000 124.32 5399015A 11-05-18 TERMANINI, ZAFER & KLARA 10-22-18 320 344 2 985,300 789,000 124.88 5405370A 01-11-19 MICHAELS, MARY A 12-12-18 27 50 2 403,400 320,000 126.06 5405570F 02-13-19 CHRISTIAN G WERNDLY TRUST 02-08-19 160 80 2 561,300 420,000 133.64 YEAR TO DATE 103 45,606,300 50,305,028 9,388.49 5399462F 11-16-18 509 POMPTON ASSOCIATES, LL 10-18-18 150 104 4A 515,700 503,800 102.36 YEAR TO DATE 1 515,700 503,800 102.36 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 104 46,122,000 50,808,828 9,490.85

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5402954F 02-07-19 K4K LLC, 10-04-18 215 1 1 51,200 77,000 66.49 5406096F 05-08-19 SULAIMAN, NAGAT 01-08-19 340 25 1 84,000 113,000 74.34 5404415F 03-12-19 444 BROADWAY REALTY, 02-20-19 63 2 1 42,900 48,000 89.38 5402953F 02-07-19 BATTE, MAMIE 01-18-19 301 22 1 82,300 60,000 137.17 5396714F 09-28-18 WEBB, GARY 09-25-18 523 28 1 43,600 15,000 290.67** YEAR TO DATE 5 304,000 313,000 658.05 5408083F 06-14-19 BAAWUAH, TERRY 04-08-19 221 41.01 C074 2 67,600 145,000 46.62 5399407F 11-20-18 20 OAK STREET ASSOCIATES, 10-30-18 425 10 2 131,700 277,500 47.46 5398718F 11-09-18 TUTT HOLDINGS, LLC 05-21-18 740 7 2 109,700 230,900 47.51 5396216F 09-21-18 HOPE INVESTMENT SOLUTION,L 08-06-18 521 7 2 119,200 250,000 47.68 5406058A 04-30-19 158 AMHERST HOLDINGS LLC 02-07-19 523 33.01 2 131,600 275,000 47.85 5398693F 11-05-18 ALI, OMAR MAHMOUD 09-18-18 822 5 2 189,300 356,500 53.10 5405398A 04-03-19 LOZADO, SAMUEL 03-22-19 735 18 2 117,800 220,000 53.55 5402966F 02-11-19 MIGLIORISI, JOHN S 01-17-19 221 41.01 C037 2 50,500 94,000 53.72 5394344A 08-10-18 CHENG, KIMMING 07-06-18 55 44 2 138,000 255,000 54.12 5408077F 06-13-19 CONTE, SALVATORE G 02-22-19 760 12.13 2 174,600 321,000 54.39 5405592A 04-12-19 TAYLOR, MILDRED 03-06-19 191 8.02 2 171,600 310,000 55.35 5393186F 07-18-18 DAVLOUROS, ANDREW 07-03-18 500 61 2 148,400 266,000 55.79 5401818F 01-14-19 WIEDER, DAVID 12-27-18 131 4 2 195,400 350,000 55.83 5398083A 10-30-18 EVIA, ROSA 10-18-18 603 18 2 176,100 315,000 55.90 5404654A 03-15-19 DWAMENA, ADELAIDE OPPONG 03-08-19 221 41.01 C105 2 42,000 75,000 56.00 5405599A 04-15-19 HURTT, DORTHULA 02-27-19 471 21 2 213,900 375,000 57.04 5407290F 05-24-19 YOUNG, RAY S SR. 04-18-19 731 11 2 206,600 355,000 58.20 5406766A 05-17-19 AHMED, FAROOQ 04-12-19 221 41.01 C023 2 39,700 68,000 58.38 5398060A 10-24-18 GLENWOOD AVE PROPERTIES LL 09-27-18 851 14 2 189,900 320,000 59.34 5402961A 02-08-19 GREENROCK PROPERTIES, LLC. 01-31-19 404 10.01 2 168,000 280,000 60.00 5407445A 06-05-19 LA REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT 05-14-19 462 42 2 165,900 275,000 60.33 5406042A 04-24-19 STEINMETZ, ZEV & RIVIAN 04-11-19 596 10 2 140,000 230,000 60.87 5399488A 11-29-18 NELSON, TOSHIBA BENNETT 11-15-18 650 17 C0002 2 128,000 210,000 60.95 5401553A 01-09-19 HALL, JOSEPH E & TYNDALL, 10-10-18 744 1 2 143,800 234,000 61.45 5406068A 05-01-19 MILESTONE REDEVELOPMENT LL 04-24-19 492 16 2 131,100 212,000 61.84 5397240A 10-05-18 BLOOMFIELD, DEVON 09-28-18 773 12 2 139,900 223,500 62.60 5398717A 11-08-18 THE BOA GROUP, LLC. 10-29-18 143 37 2 175,500 280,000 62.68 5397641A 10-18-18 BRIZAN, LISA & CUPID, JUST 10-10-18 544 1.02 2 175,300 279,500 62.72 5402642A 01-29-19 GBM REALTY, LLC. 01-23-19 761 18 2 160,100 255,000 62.78 5406045A 04-24-19 SHABIKUMI, RUTEMBESA 02-21-19 492 78 2 104,000 164,900 63.07 5407299A 05-28-19 LA REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT 05-01-19 462 43 2 187,900 295,000 63.69 5404009A 03-04-19 TURNER, ROBERT 02-18-19 119 1 2 170,800 268,000 63.73 5404318A 03-07-19 JOHNSON-WILLIAMS, DENISHA 02-22-19 562 10.05 2 261,300 410,000 63.73 5404668A 03-19-19 AZOIC, LLC. 03-08-19 612 9 2 159,400 250,000 63.76 5405408A 04-05-19 NJ EAST ORANGE HOLDINGS, L 03-28-19 592 3 2 172,400 270,000 63.85 5393173A 07-17-18 221 NORTH 15TH STREE,LLC 06-28-18 73 19 2 191,900 300,000 63.97 5399959A 12-07-18 SHINE, SHERRY D 11-26-18 458.01 27 2 156,200 244,000 64.02

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399422A 11-26-18 AYJ MANAGEMENT, LLC. 10-30-18 72 28 2 176,100 275,000 64.04 5399409A 11-21-18 170 GREENWOOD HOLDINGS, LL 11-06-18 60 31 2 185,800 290,000 64.07 5404995A 03-21-19 LOVE, KAREN LISA 03-14-19 720 24 2 158,700 247,500 64.12 5405600A 04-15-19 THOMAS, ROLAND C & CHAROLO 03-29-19 621 8 2 196,100 305,500 64.19 5395400A 08-30-18 THIRUMANGALAKUDI, VENKATRA 08-23-18 221 41.01 C018 2 50,800 79,000 64.30 5398056A 10-23-18 LAWRENCE, DENSELY O. 10-05-18 841 23 2 183,400 285,000 64.35 5404591A 03-14-19 RENTAL SHOP LLC, 03-08-19 66 4 2 183,600 285,000 64.42 5399762F 12-05-18 SANTANA-OZUNA, FRANCISCO A 10-26-18 731 32 2 93,800 145,500 64.47 5393157A 07-10-18 TRANSCONTINENTAL SOLUTIONS 06-25-18 881 19 2 187,700 290,000 64.72 5403521A 02-25-19 WALTON, KIRON G 01-17-19 111 2.02 2 171,800 265,000 64.83 5406118A 05-15-19 PUSHTI, LLC, 04-16-19 55 47 2 142,700 220,000 64.86 5393922A 07-27-18 LYSSA,LLC, 07-19-18 470 10 2 117,500 181,000 64.92 5406059A 04-30-19 BRADLEY, PAMELA & FOLKES, 04-03-19 740 17 2 153,900 237,000 64.94 5404380A 03-11-19 ESTRIPLET, MARC 03-01-19 882 17 2 250,100 385,000 64.96 5400070A 12-10-18 KONOU, ROMAIN & ZOKO, TOA 09-17-18 741 12 2 94,400 145,000 65.10 5396213A 09-21-18 BURNETT, LESTER 05-16-18 492 28 2 124,400 190,000 65.47 5395922A 09-14-18 DOMINIO IRVINGTON LLC 08-22-18 280 2 C169 2 39,400 60,000 65.67 5401567A 01-11-19 COLEMAN, LEROY JR 12-28-18 611 2 2 176,900 269,000 65.76 5405021A 03-21-19 JEANTY, GARRY 03-18-19 822 25 2 177,600 270,000 65.78 5408802F 06-19-19 RODNEY, ZEVON & LATONYA 06-10-19 56 35 2 191,200 290,000 65.93 5396953A 10-03-18 BIG APPLE INVESTMENT,LLC 09-15-18 173 27 2 151,700 230,000 65.96 5398067A 10-25-18 PCG 5 LLC, 10-02-18 61 38 2 165,000 250,000 66.00 5396951A 10-03-18 SPENCER ELIZABETH LLC 08-10-18 53 15 2 109,000 165,000 66.06 5400175A 12-13-18 BORJA, RAMIRO A & KLINGER, 12-06-18 544 1.07 2 175,300 265,000 66.15 5402967A 02-11-19 STEINMETZ, ZEV 01-17-19 121 27 2 193,000 289,000 66.78 5404229A 03-08-19 279 HALSTED LLC, 02-14-19 736 8 2 150,000 224,000 66.96 5397410A 10-12-18 BOLA, TRACEY 09-24-18 146 14 2 173,500 259,000 66.99 5408870A 06-24-19 NDIAYE, NDEYE D 06-07-19 544 1.05 2 175,600 261,900 67.05 5399483F 11-29-18 SMITH, CARL & GRACE 10-11-18 571 23 2 214,700 320,000 67.09 5405597A 04-15-19 IGNJATOVIC, DEJAN & STEFAN 04-03-19 23 20 2 201,400 300,000 67.13 5397241A 10-05-18 CASSIDY, CORNELIUS D 09-19-18 253 12 2 195,000 290,000 67.24 5406050A 04-25-19 NCRC HOUSING REHAB FUND LL 04-08-19 293 7 2 135,000 199,900 67.53 5395746A 09-06-18 BURNETT PROPERTIES,LLC 08-03-18 370 12 2 108,100 160,000 67.56 5398061A 10-25-18 HUNTINGTON GROUP INC, 10-16-18 402 14 2 206,700 305,000 67.77 5399411A 11-21-18 9352369, LLC. 11-13-18 363 9.01 2 190,000 279,900 67.88 5406759A 05-16-19 ORANGE REAL ESTATE DEVELOP 03-12-19 464 27 2 156,500 230,000 68.04 5407297A 05-28-19 TB CONSTRUCTIONS, LLC 05-14-19 470 33 2 146,700 215,000 68.23 5401560A 01-09-19 BRIXTONE INVESTMENT 275, L 01-02-19 642 4 C114 2 38,900 57,000 68.25 5396768A 10-01-18 128 LINCOLN STREET LLC 08-23-18 551 91 2 177,700 260,000 68.35 5398711A 11-08-18 GS MAPLE, LLC. 10-18-18 261 18 2 194,800 285,000 68.35 5401274A 12-28-18 IMPRESSIVE ENTERPRISES, LL 12-14-18 31.01 3.02 2 171,000 250,000 68.40 5397649A 10-19-18 CAMPBELL, WALTER 10-10-18 290 25 2 150,500 220,000 68.41 5396703A 09-27-18 662 GROVE ST LLC, 09-26-18 220 64 2 192,000 280,000 68.57 5395874A 09-12-18 KRYPTONITE BUILDERS,LLC 08-31-18 216 22 2 185,700 270,000 68.78 5402964A 02-11-19 FOX, JOY 12-21-18 191 8.03 2 204,000 295,000 69.15 5405593A 04-12-19 PURDY PROPERTIES LLC 02-08-19 53 9 2 204,100 295,000 69.19

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393180A 07-18-18 AYENI, CHARLES O & ANNE 06-29-18 191 26.01 C054C 2 173,200 250,000 69.28 5409216A 06-27-19 395 NORTH MAPLE, LLC. 05-22-19 300 4 2 221,700 319,000 69.50 5394328A 08-08-18 MCCARTHY, JOHN 06-09-18 290 37 2 153,300 220,000 69.68 5408080A 06-13-19 COMMUNITY ASSET PRESERVATI 05-29-19 905 4.01 2 136,000 195,000 69.74 5397643A 10-18-18 BRADLEY, RICHARD 10-03-18 290 34 2 192,600 275,000 70.04 5399761A 12-05-18 203 GLENWOOD AVENUE, LLC. 11-30-18 640 7 2 223,900 318,950 70.20 5406109A 05-13-19 SI MANAGEMENT LLC, 04-29-19 560 26.01 2 137,700 196,000 70.26 5405024A 03-22-19 HAGANS, HENRY L 01-14-19 444 12 2 129,400 184,000 70.33 5403517A 02-22-19 HARRIS, MARIE & HOLLY M. 02-07-19 850 4 2 193,900 275,000 70.51 5395117A 08-28-18 GBM REALTY LLC, 08-22-18 490 45 2 162,200 230,000 70.52 5394333A 08-08-18 THOMAS, IDA C 07-31-18 480 21 2 204,600 290,000 70.55 5397431A 10-17-18 BAN, NJI 08-30-18 611 13 2 187,800 265,000 70.87 5406043A 04-24-19 FLORES, YONI Y. GUEVERA 04-05-19 773 39 2 159,600 225,000 70.93 5404231A 03-08-19 ETIENNE, OSCAR H 12-10-18 291 22 2 188,000 265,000 70.94 5394020A 07-30-18 IFILL, DAVE 07-06-18 774 10 2 166,800 235,000 70.98 5395835A 09-11-18 NJ HOMES NOW LLC, 08-02-18 72 3 2 202,400 285,000 71.02 5399021A 11-13-18 55 9TH AVE LLC, 10-09-18 70 7 2 184,900 260,000 71.12 5398081A 10-29-18 EHP242EO BURNETT LLC, 10-15-18 501 32 2 199,500 280,000 71.25 5395116A 08-20-18 ZIMMERMAN, JACOB 06-01-18 430 30 2 156,100 219,000 71.28 5401896A 01-15-19 AZIZ, DIANE 11-30-18 443 20 2 131,100 183,600 71.41 5407441A 06-03-19 TT&T TUTORING SERVICES LLC 05-22-19 13 1.01 2 120,700 168,888 71.47 5404018A 03-05-19 JOHNSON, CHANTAL & UMAR, Y 02-20-19 712 5 2 168,200 235,000 71.57 5396439A 09-25-18 JONES, JAMES 08-25-18 480 12 2 190,900 265,000 72.04 5393152A 07-09-18 HABIB, EVETTE 05-16-18 781 30.02 2 254,800 350,000 72.80 5393183A 07-18-18 COX, VELEITA 06-23-18 442 18 2 144,700 198,000 73.08 5403393A 02-19-19 MCMILLAN, M & PHILLIPS, L 02-13-19 491 15 2 213,400 292,000 73.08 5396769A 10-02-18 NEW JERSEY REHAB PROJECT L 08-30-18 65 8 2 197,000 269,000 73.23 5393155A 07-09-18 SMITH, MYRA 06-11-18 145 15.10 2 187,700 256,000 73.32 5400162A 12-11-18 BARNES, THOMAS M. 11-21-18 217 36 2 176,100 240,000 73.38 5400178A 12-13-18 MERRELL, JOSEPH & DIANA J 12-04-18 642 4 C024 2 25,700 35,000 73.43 5401566A 01-11-19 PITTMAN, XAVIEA 12-21-18 54 43 2 165,500 225,000 73.56 5405028A 03-25-19 PELHAM PROPERTIES MA, 03-06-19 750 24 2 92,100 125,000 73.68 5395107A 08-16-18 TIRADO, ANGEL L & VELEZ, I 07-30-18 70 9 2 174,700 237,000 73.71 5397258A 10-10-18 AWAN GROUP, INC. 09-07-18 362 7.04 2 143,800 195,000 73.74 5405382A 04-01-19 SHAND, MICHELE 03-28-19 12 2.01 2 219,100 295,000 74.27 5404388A 03-11-19 MCDANIEL, MELVIN 01-22-19 491 16 2 178,400 240,000 74.33 5400171A 12-12-18 ALEXANDER, JUSTIN & DENEEN 07-31-18 552 5.02 2 134,100 180,150 74.44 5407288A 05-22-19 513 S. CLINTON REALTY LLC 05-13-19 461 36 2 193,600 260,000 74.46 5397415A 10-12-18 PRIL REI LLC, 08-22-18 532 20 2 227,400 305,000 74.56 5395773A 09-10-18 MAHEDEODATH, MAHARAJ & KAL 08-29-18 597 24.01 2 201,700 270,000 74.70 5401568A 01-11-19 HONEYBEE HOMES LLC, 12-20-18 457 1 2 206,600 275,000 75.13 5403522A 02-25-19 GREENWOOD PROPERTY INVESTM 02-01-19 471 16.01 2 159,600 211,500 75.46 5393921A 07-27-18 PARK AVENUE & ASSOCIATES N 02-23-18 551.03 51 2 197,500 260,000 75.96 5395393A 08-28-18 46 HAMILTON ASSOCIATES LLC 08-21-18 340 23 2 267,400 352,000 75.97 5401569A 01-11-19 DICKER, ELAINE 08-01-18 64 52.01 2 152,500 200,000 76.25 5406777A 05-21-19 BURROUGHS, FLORA P & BRIDG 05-08-19 443 18 2 160,200 210,000 76.29

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5397420A 10-15-18 MOORE, VANESSA M 09-28-18 441 2 2 152,600 200,000 76.30 5397244A 10-09-18 LEMON, JAMES JR 08-30-18 572 22.14 2 164,100 215,000 76.33 5399217A 11-16-18 RAMSAMMY, LILIYTH 10-29-18 592 5 2 187,000 245,000 76.33 5397250A 10-10-18 VELEZ, MARCELA & RAMON 09-21-18 302 1 2 198,700 260,000 76.42 5406767A 05-17-19 BOVELL, GODFREY L & WAVENE 03-07-19 63 33 2 180,200 235,000 76.68 5400072A 12-10-18 NEERO BILT INTL, LLC. 12-04-18 441 4.01 2 145,900 190,000 76.79 5394262A 08-02-18 VELEZ, INOCENCIO 05-30-18 21 6 2 137,000 178,000 76.97 5405606A 04-17-19 JOHNSON EQUITY BY DESIGN, 04-09-19 453 18 2 174,000 224,900 77.37 5400165A 12-11-18 WILLIAMS, SALLIE 12-01-18 590 34 2 177,500 228,800 77.58 5399404A 11-20-18 33-37 SCHUYLER TERRACE 11-15-18 820 54 2 206,300 265,000 77.85 5393168A 07-13-18 BORGES, LUIS O. 07-09-18 551.01 21 2 226,400 290,000 78.07 5408800F 06-19-19 399 GLENWOOD ASSOCIATES, L 05-16-19 861 16 2 132,800 170,000 78.12 5397427A 10-17-18 KELLY, TERRY A 10-05-18 482 1.03 2 243,200 310,000 78.45 5394055A 07-31-18 JULIEN, JIMMY 07-13-18 56 45 2 183,800 234,000 78.55 5394267A 08-02-18 S BURNETT LLC, 07-31-18 501 39 2 203,000 258,000 78.68 5403875A 02-28-19 PITTMAN, XAVIEA 02-25-19 54 44 2 166,000 210,000 79.05 5400071A 12-10-18 BELTON, JACQUELINE DELORES 11-12-18 458 18.03 2 186,300 235,000 79.28 5406075A 05-02-19 WELCH, JAMES & SHARON 04-26-19 742 11 2 158,100 199,000 79.45 5407303A 05-29-19 MITCHELL, RAY & GEETA 05-15-19 162 8 2 186,700 235,000 79.45 5405200F 03-27-19 FLIPPING EAST ORANGE, 01-10-19 112 2.01 2 166,900 210,000 79.48 5402299A 01-23-19 NJ EAST ORANGE PORTFOLIO 01-16-19 121 12 2 214,900 270,000 79.59 5401547A 01-08-19 OTTI, BERNARD O.N. 12-11-18 780.01 13 2 270,400 339,000 79.76 5399425A 11-26-18 PERKINS, ANDREW T & ERIN S 10-26-18 481 15 2 231,500 290,000 79.83 5401273A 12-28-18 NOAKES, BERNICE 12-18-18 111 2.07 2 151,000 189,000 79.89 5396316A 09-24-18 FONESA, ANIBAL 09-13-18 551 1 2 119,900 150,000 79.93 5402937A 02-01-19 236 HALSTEAD ASSOCIATES, L 01-28-19 492 48 2 153,100 189,999 80.58 5393814A 07-26-18 RIGGANS, DOROTHY L 06-28-18 100 4.05 2 144,400 179,000 80.67 5405030A 03-25-19 GREEN, ANNIE MAE 03-05-19 110 9.06 2 144,000 176,900 81.40 5401297A 01-03-19 114 PARK AVENUE, INC. 12-18-18 70 1 2 196,000 240,000 81.67 5402965F 02-11-19 SUNNYSIDE TERRACE REALTY L 01-31-19 458 18.05 2 261,400 320,000 81.69 5406074A 05-02-19 ROEBUCK, GEORGE N. 04-30-19 170 3.03 2 107,900 132,000 81.74 5406106A 05-10-19 CORNERSTONE GROWTH PARTNER 04-29-19 101 5 2 177,100 215,000 82.37 5404587A 03-14-19 HUBBARD, JUNE 03-04-19 254 11 2 221,500 268,000 82.65 5406775A 05-21-19 NORTH 18 STREET PROPERTIES 05-09-19 56 6 2 199,100 240,000 82.96 5403838A 02-27-19 SPARROW, RORY 01-24-19 630.01 1.09 2 307,900 370,000 83.22 5401287A 01-02-19 RVM ENTERPRISES, LLC. 12-20-18 773 31 2 201,700 242,000 83.35 5399420A 11-26-18 LEACH, LAWRENCE R. JR. & L 11-16-18 801 14 2 300,800 360,000 83.56 5396713A 09-28-18 ROSENBERG, YUDA 08-23-18 192 5 2 259,600 310,000 83.74 5404412A 03-12-19 ORIENTAL REALTY, LLC, 02-06-19 444.01 21 2 111,200 132,500 83.92 5406765A 05-17-19 NDUMELE, ERIC & PATIENCE 05-09-19 104 9.05 2 218,900 260,000 84.19 5395881A 09-13-18 BOHANNON, LAVERNE 09-05-18 61 7 2 199,000 235,000 84.68 5406076A 05-02-19 540 NORTH GROVE, LLC. 04-18-19 120 16 2 129,500 152,500 84.92 5398701A 11-05-18 KELLMAN, MAUREEN 10-26-18 742 16 X 2 238,800 280,000 85.29 5404667A 03-19-19 DRAKE, MARY M. 02-11-19 530 2 2 190,400 220,000 86.55 5408872A 06-24-19 MURPHY, GLENDA C 06-06-19 581 6 2 203,800 233,810 87.16 5406062A 04-30-19 289 AMHERST STREET LLC 04-17-19 492 1 2 120,300 138,000 87.17

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5395095A 08-14-18 JOHNSON, GEORGE 07-10-18 300 20 2 166,200 189,900 87.52 5405038A 03-26-19 STURDIVANT, JAMES 02-26-19 261 38 2 228,900 259,000 88.38 5401562A 01-09-19 DELLY GROUP, LLC. 12-22-18 173 42 2 123,900 140,000 88.50 5401557A 01-09-19 HESTER, HOLLY & ALLEN, WIL 12-31-18 543 14 2 142,100 160,000 88.81 5406105A 05-10-19 EL, MANGSTE W & MARGRIONE 04-24-19 832 19.02 2 234,900 263,500 89.15 5395748A 09-06-18 WALLACE, CHARLES W 07-31-18 872 4 2 214,300 240,000 89.29 5406040A 04-18-19 FITZGERALD, DAVID J 02-11-19 66 12 2 29,500 33,000 89.39 5394019A 07-30-18 CARNEGIE, CLAUDIA 07-09-18 492 51 2 193,100 215,000 89.81 5396217A 09-24-18 NJ EAST ORANGE HOLDINGS,LL 08-17-18 56 8 2 184,700 205,000 90.10 5399760A 12-05-18 MCKAY, LIVINGSTON & SUZANN 11-20-18 484 23 2 194,600 215,000 90.51 5401571A 01-11-19 EML APPRAISALS LLC, 12-21-18 53 6 2 154,800 170,000 91.06 5407454A 06-07-19 THOMAS, COLLEEN D & CICERO 06-03-19 500 38 2 182,600 200,000 91.30 5400166A 12-11-18 LEWIS, CLIFFORD O 11-30-18 150 8 2 238,500 260,000 91.73 5404589A 03-14-19 FENELUS, JOSETTE 03-07-19 460 2.07 2 243,300 265,000 91.81 5402297A 01-22-19 WANG, XIANG 01-11-19 781 30.01 2 138,200 150,000 92.13 5395089A 08-14-18 GOODMAN, PEARL 08-03-18 143 8 2 186,100 199,000 93.52 5405410F 04-05-19 538 NORWOOD, LLC. 03-19-19 462 11 2 145,100 155,000 93.61 5402295A 01-22-19 PROPERTY SOLUTIONS GROUP, 12-21-18 65 25 2 160,500 170,000 94.41 5405244A 03-28-19 NJ EAST ORANGE HOLDINGS, L 03-15-19 490 19.01 2 179,400 190,000 94.42 5395398A 08-29-18 SHELBY PROPERTY LLC, 08-21-18 881 11.06 2 132,500 140,000 94.64 5405827A 04-23-19 SCOTT, JANIE M 04-11-19 121 2 2 194,300 205,000 94.78 5397242A 10-09-18 NJ EAST ORANGE HOLDINGS, L 08-24-18 894 10 2 181,000 190,000 95.26 5393201A 07-23-18 DIPLOMAT PROPERTY MA,LLC 01-29-18 24 1.01 2 153,000 160,500 95.33 5397262A 10-12-18 COTTON, WILLIAM 08-31-18 492 14 2 166,000 174,000 95.40 5405401F 04-03-19 150 SHEPARD ASSOCIATES, LL 02-05-19 424 27 2 110,200 115,000 95.83 5399473F 11-28-18 117 HOLLYWOOD, LLC. 11-09-18 20 14 2 137,100 143,000 95.87 5405397F 04-03-19 27-29 WILLIAM ST LLC, 03-11-19 53 21 2 202,000 210,000 96.19 5399155A 11-14-18 HARRIS, FREDDIE 08-20-18 603 13.01 2 207,600 215,000 96.56 5399848A 12-06-18 VARGAS, SEGUNDO & LUZ 11-27-18 603 3 2 198,000 205,000 96.59 5408867A 06-24-19 IACOVIELLO, DOMINICK 06-05-19 842 8.01 2 150,100 154,000 97.47 5402970A 02-13-19 DOVE HOME BUYERS, LLC. 01-29-19 923 15 2 176,500 180,384 97.85 5405406F 04-04-19 76 N 16TH ST LLC, 03-29-19 64 46 2 103,000 105,000 98.10 5402979A 02-15-19 30 SOUTH 20TH ST, LLC. 01-29-19 821 2 2 197,300 200,000 98.65 5399424A 11-26-18 GILLIAM, JEFFERY H 11-19-18 500 8 2 93,900 95,000 98.84 5402643A 01-29-19 RBC REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS, 01-07-19 65 11 2 159,400 160,000 99.63 5401286A 01-02-19 HENRY, ASTON & ESTELLA NEL 12-17-18 894 16 2 205,400 206,000 99.71 5407289A 05-24-19 120 EAST ORANGE LLC, 05-14-19 63 30 2 140,300 140,000 100.21 5393185A 07-18-18 SAFEGUARD HOMES LLC, 06-26-18 871 13 2 215,800 215,000 100.37 5404662A 03-18-19 URBAN INVESTMENTS LLC 03-08-19 107 1.02 2 158,300 157,500 100.51 5395876A 09-12-18 RODRIGUEZ, AMAURI 08-20-18 145 2 2 192,100 190,000 101.11 5404015A 03-05-19 SURKIS, AVRAHAM 01-03-19 453 9 2 223,000 220,000 101.36 5393206A 07-23-18 BROWN, DOROTHY 06-14-18 874 1 2 254,700 250,000 101.88 5399164A 11-15-18 BAXTER, EARL H 10-29-18 611 3 2 173,700 170,000 102.18 5395750A 09-07-18 POLLARD, ANGELINA 08-31-18 146 42 2 225,300 220,000 102.41 5398708A 11-07-18 ZHANG, LILLIAN 10-25-18 621 16 2 158,800 155,000 102.45 5398079A 10-29-18 CLARK, DAVID E 10-22-18 72 41 2 200,400 195,000 102.77

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400167A 12-11-18 ZHANG, LILLIAN 12-03-18 64 31 2 139,200 135,000 103.11 5397646A 10-19-18 COMMISSO, CLAUDINE 09-28-18 581 34 2 197,200 190,000 103.79 5403400A 02-20-19 MCARTHUR, LAMONT F 11-30-18 71 39 2 176,900 170,000 104.06 5396957A 10-04-18 GREEN, ROBERT 09-21-18 460 7.04 2 156,400 150,000 104.27 5405198A 03-26-19 EAST END PROPERTIES & DEVE 03-13-19 464 31 2 146,800 140,000 104.86 5403533A 02-26-19 424 S CLINTON ST EO HOLDIN 01-02-18 472 14 2 178,900 170,000 105.24 5403520A 02-25-19 LITTLEJOHN, SONYA 02-05-19 133 3 2 190,000 180,000 105.56 5399413A 11-21-18 WILLIAMS, EARL A.D. & PATR 11-08-18 31.01 42 2 164,500 155,000 106.13 5396318A 09-24-18 MITCHELL, MARY 08-20-18 891 3 2 135,500 127,500 106.27 5393189A 07-19-18 VUONG, TIN 04-12-18 271 5 2 160,600 150,000 107.07 5399960A 12-07-18 TETAJ, SHKUMBIN 11-15-18 533 24 2 225,900 210,000 107.57 5403530F 02-26-19 BANAHENE, PETER 02-11-19 362 7 2 193,800 175,000 110.74 5407444F 06-05-19 BRITTNEY REALTY & CONSTRUC 05-28-19 31.01 35 2 185,000 165,000 112.12 5399218F 11-16-18 MIDWEST EQUITIES LLC, 11-08-18 303 6 2 186,800 165,000 113.21 5401282F 12-31-18 NJ HARRISON BROOKWOOD & WA 12-20-18 458 41.03 2 99,900 88,000 113.52 5404311F 03-07-19 CARRINGTON, JOYC & LESLIE 01-03-19 94 13.01 2 153,500 135,000 113.70 5393184F 07-18-18 329-331 ELIZBETH, LLC. 06-13-18 731 43 2 194,600 170,000 114.47 5401301F 01-04-19 YATSONSKY, CHARLES 12-13-18 306 3 2 200,500 175,000 114.57 5404025A 03-06-19 HASAN, IBRAHIM 02-11-19 720 13 2 298,100 260,000 114.65 5398066F 10-25-18 MISSION HOMES CORP, 10-12-18 351 32 2 192,200 165,000 116.48 5395295F 08-23-18 THOMPSON, LOUISE V 08-08-18 290 33 2 188,900 160,000 118.06 5401544F 01-08-19 WALTERS, CYNTHIA A 12-20-18 801 21 2 225,200 190,000 118.53 5393216T 07-25-18 329-331 ELIZABETH, LLC. 06-19-18 144 13 2 160,000 130,000 123.08 5393175T 07-17-18 MIDWEST EQUITIES LLC, 06-29-18 599 3.01 2 189,500 145,000 130.69 5394331F 08-08-18 ASNJ2 L.L.C., 07-23-18 461 11 2 151,700 107,000 141.78 5393135T 07-02-18 DAVIS, EILEEN G (CO-TRUSTE 06-04-18 401 15 2 165,000 110,000 150.00 5409222F 06-28-19 OSTILLA SQUARE, LLC, 06-18-19 456 5 2 190,700 113,000 168.76 5394332T 08-08-18 THORNBURY HOLDINGS LLC 08-02-18 143 18 2 181,100 106,000 170.85 5399159F 11-15-18 SEENANAN, DALCHAND 11-06-18 170 3.01 2 98,000 54,000 181.48 YEAR TO DATE 250 42,852,400 55,395,781 20,114.66 5406111F 05-13-19 JENNINGS, ELEANOR 04-25-19 691 27 X 4A 200,300 400,000 50.08 5406762F 05-17-19 PARAMOUNT PROPERTIES,LLC 05-07-19 130 1 4A 575,000 1,000,000 57.50 5399748F 12-05-18 RDD ENTERPRISES, INC. 10-10-18 921 13 4A 198,600 270,000 73.56 5393203F 07-23-18 PREMIERE REAL ESTATE,LLC 07-02-18 491 58 4A 210,800 280,000 75.29 5394270F 08-03-18 NEW TIDE LLC, 07-09-18 211 9 4A 3,000,000 3,900,000 76.92 5404582F 03-14-19 STROPPA, ANTHONY & HELEN 03-07-19 744 38 4A 440,000 520,000 84.62 5406095F 05-08-19 EURO CREDIT ASSETS LLC 05-02-19 20 1.01 4A 76,700 85,000 90.24 5393930F 07-30-18 CHARLES C GOLDMAN LLC 07-17-18 384 4 4A 271,500 290,000 93.62 SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19

07 - 05 EAST ORANGE CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE YEAR TO DATE 8 4,972,900 6,745,000 601.83 5405402F 04-03-19 4-10 CARNEGIE AVE LLC 03-20-19 401 31 X 4C 1,185,800 2,050,000 57.84 5397426F 10-16-18 ROSMAR REIG I LLC, 10-11-18 74 9 4C 565,500 957,500 59.06 5402312F 01-25-19 LISHEL ASSOCIATES, LLC. 12-21-18 540.01 27 4C 555,200 888,000 62.52 5393920F 07-27-18 6 NORTH 21ST STREET, LLC 07-12-18 144 1 4C 1,150,000 1,800,000 63.89 YEAR TO DATE 4 3,456,500 5,695,500 243.31 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 267 51,585,800 68,149,281 21,617.85

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 06 ESSEX FELLS TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5395305F 08-28-18 O'NEILL, J. BLAKE 08-01-18 8.01 1.01 1 406,300 450,000 90.29 YEAR TO DATE 1 406,300 450,000 90.29 5400219A 12-11-18 ECKERT, MARIBETH G 11-26-18 3.03 11 2 1,355,500 1,750,000 77.46 5395884A 09-10-18 RICHMOND, MICHAEL & FAUSTO 08-09-18 1 1.01 C0072 2 386,200 450,000 85.82 5408526A 06-10-19 HAGHIGHI, DARYOUSH 05-17-19 1 1.01 C0044 2 395,300 460,000 85.93 5394603A 08-14-18 LEWIN, ROBERT & HIDALGO, J 06-03-18 1 1.01 C0054 2 393,800 455,000 86.55 5394602A 08-14-18 YEN, GARY & LISA 08-07-18 11 5 2 613,200 705,000 86.98 5394021A 07-30-18 SCHAEFFER, PETER N 07-20-18 2 9 2 937,400 1,050,000 89.28 5396220A 09-20-18 ROWE, MARY LOU 09-06-18 13.02 6 2 549,900 600,000 91.65 5396960A 09-25-18 JOHNSON, DAVID BANKS 08-01-18 10.06 20 2 607,000 650,000 93.38 5396959A 09-21-18 KIRBY, JORDON 09-07-18 11.08 12 2 814,900 865,000 94.21 5400218A 12-03-18 FARESE, JOHN B III 11-26-18 11.06 5.01 2 804,600 850,000 94.66 5408981A 06-20-19 ST. JOHN, THOMAS A. & CARO 05-07-19 6.03 13 2 1,322,400 1,357,000 97.45 5407311A 05-15-19 MUZZATTI, LORIS & PATRICIA 04-29-19 8 4.02 2 1,514,600 1,550,000 97.72 5399165A 11-15-18 PECK, RICHARD 10-29-18 12.02 4.07 2 1,928,500 1,900,000 101.50 5400216A 11-16-18 CODELLA, KIMBERLY BRENNAN 11-14-18 12.02 4.05 2 982,500 956,000 102.77 5400217A 11-19-18 KERWIN, JAMES & SHEILA 10-31-18 8.02 8 2 1,764,100 1,685,000 104.69 5408980A 06-18-19 GREENBERG, STEVEN M 05-24-19 12.02 4 2 874,600 835,000 104.74 5401908A 12-28-18 TOOHEY, GERARD E SR 12-20-18 10.03 22 2 866,600 750,000 115.55 5408524A 05-20-19 CUSACK, DENNIS & EILEEN 05-07-19 12.02 6 2 1,188,600 995,000 119.46 YEAR TO DATE 18 17,299,700 17,863,000 1,729.80 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 19 17,706,000 18,313,000 1,820.09

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 07 FAIRFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396504F 09-24-18 BELLO, MICHAEL 09-14-18 3301 29.13 1 327,300 525,000 62.34 YEAR TO DATE 1 327,300 525,000 62.34 5396963A 10-02-18 RIZZO, MICHAEL A JR 09-25-18 2503 1 2 404,600 620,000 65.26 5395411A 08-28-18 INGLIS, KEVIN 08-11-18 2404 5 2 450,100 686,000 65.61 5402987F 02-04-19 SISCO, BARBARA MAVIS 01-30-19 501 9 2 233,700 352,000 66.39 5394660A 08-07-18 VIVINETTO, JAMES S & ROSEM 07-30-18 2506 19.05 2 403,700 605,000 66.73 5402994A 02-11-19 MORGAN, THOMAS J 01-31-18 2405 4 2 230,500 345,000 66.81 5408530A 06-14-19 BENSON, RAYMOND 04-24-19 3301 41 2 235,100 340,000 69.15 5400221A 12-07-18 FELICI, DENNIS 11-27-18 3102 1 2 200,000 287,000 69.69 5396502A 09-21-18 LAGLIA, DARYL & TINA 09-17-18 3704 23 2 381,900 539,000 70.85 5407470A 06-04-19 IPPOLITO, SEBASTIAN & KATH 05-20-19 4607 2 2 489,500 690,000 70.94 5401578A 12-29-18 ABUROUMI, ISMAT 12-06-18 3401 23 2 390,600 550,000 71.02 5394663A 08-09-18 CALASIBETTA, PAULETTE (CO- 07-23-18 4609 13 2 345,400 478,000 72.26 5409548A 06-27-19 RASCHAL, JEFFREY S. & EVEL 06-17-19 3704 32 2 394,100 545,000 72.31 5397658A 10-16-18 DECANDIA, JAYSON 10-01-18 2501 8.02 2 416,800 574,000 72.61 5397656A 10-15-18 KAISER, MICHAEL 09-26-18 5101 49 2 366,800 505,000 72.63 5407099A 05-10-19 WEIBERTH, PATRICIA 04-25-19 3909 21 2 327,000 450,000 72.67 5402997A 02-14-19 BONI, MONICA 02-05-19 5404 25 2 367,500 500,000 73.50 5409061A 06-21-19 SHINE, BRIAN & JULISSA 06-13-19 3301 39 2 250,700 339,000 73.95 5398092T 10-25-18 SLUKE, ELAINE (TRUSTEE) 10-19-18 303 7 2 338,100 450,000 75.13 5407097A 05-09-19 DESTEFANO, JENNIFER 04-12-19 4605 1 2 454,200 600,000 75.70 5407090A 04-08-19 MATTIE, DANIEL J & JOHN 04-03-19 4507 14 2 405,100 535,000 75.72 5395408A 08-27-18 DIETZ, CAMERON G 08-06-18 5003 15 2 311,400 410,000 75.95 5401309A 12-31-18 PASIEKA, JASON & JOY 12-20-18 2002 12 2 1,192,900 1,550,000 76.96 5406122A 04-23-19 BAYKOWSKI, ROBERT & KRISTY 03-28-19 3704 8 2 397,000 515,000 77.09 5398093A 10-26-18 GESSNER, GUNTER JERRY 10-19-18 3504 17 2 354,800 460,000 77.13 5396126A 09-14-18 RENNE, KAREN 08-24-18 4901.03 36 2 478,700 620,000 77.21 5408531A 06-14-19 CRANE, STEVEN (TRUSTEE) 05-30-19 4504 10 2 348,800 450,000 77.51 5402985A 02-04-19 DURANTINO, FRANK 01-31-19 3201 13.01 2 308,200 395,000 78.03 5407473A 06-06-19 CASTELLI, NICOLA 05-30-19 2506 2 2 297,600 380,000 78.32 5395777A 09-06-18 SCHER, JASON 08-27-18 3603 9 2 477,500 608,000 78.54 5408527A 06-07-19 BARON, GREGG H & DAWN 05-23-19 3703 7 2 495,200 630,000 78.60 5396501A 09-21-18 HABERMAS, HELMUT MARTIN 09-06-18 2409 2 2 334,300 424,900 78.68 5407092A 05-02-19 MALONEY, GEORGE F JR. & MA 04-14-19 4003 4 2 463,400 588,000 78.81 5399267A 11-07-18 CHANG, JOSEPH YA0-MING & M 10-30-18 3303 26 2 446,800 560,000 79.79 5393225A 07-24-18 LYNCH, DARREL J 07-10-18 3902 19 2 574,500 719,000 79.90 5400637A 12-13-18 CIFELLI, MARIA 11-30-18 5402 15 2 379,000 474,000 79.96 5405626A 04-15-19 SALVATO, JASON & TIFFANY 04-10-19 2505 7.02 2 536,600 670,000 80.09 5401912A 01-14-19 FAILLA, VINCENT & CHARLENE 01-09-19 3902 20 2 565,000 704,000 80.26 5400736A 12-19-18 FREIRE, JACQUELINE 12-14-18 3901 24 2 563,500 700,000 80.50 5399706A 11-29-18 MATTIA, NANCY 09-18-18 3605 18 2 357,800 439,900 81.34 5393218A 07-03-18 BANDER, SEEMAH 05-08-18 2401 16.03 2 420,900 515,000 81.73 5397659A 10-17-18 BOHMOFF, WALTER J & MARGAR 10-04-18 5309 6 2 350,500 427,000 82.08

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 07 FAIRFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393221A 07-18-18 PUZO, GIOVANNI 06-21-18 3909 31 2 197,100 240,000 82.13 5402996A 02-13-19 TUOSTO, KENNETH & JILLIAN 01-08-19 3701 6.02 2 905,000 1,100,000 82.27 5396127A 09-18-18 LUZZI, JOSEPH 09-12-18 4005 7 2 439,100 530,000 82.85 5406121A 04-18-19 PEKER, LEV & TROSMAN, INNA 04-03-19 3301 17 2 817,400 980,000 83.41 5403537A 02-19-19 WOLFER, ERIK & DEBORAH 12-03-18 4505 5 2 375,400 450,000 83.42 5399430A 11-19-18 GLINBIZZI, JOANN 10-26-18 4608 27 2 501,700 600,000 83.62 5407098A 05-09-19 GAMBINO, JOHN & LUISA 04-15-19 2404 12.10 2 813,200 967,500 84.05 5399432A 11-20-18 HAYEK, MARK & LENA 11-09-18 3602 3 2 529,600 630,000 84.06 5395639A 08-29-18 AJMO, LORI G 08-14-18 902 3 2 445,600 530,000 84.08 5402988A 02-05-19 EMPIRE HOME RENOVATIONS CO 12-11-18 3102 3.01 2 168,800 200,000 84.40 5405620A 04-02-19 DIPIAZZA, ANGELA & ALTAAI, 03-26-19 3601 13 2 755,600 892,000 84.71 5408528A 06-11-19 CIRANGLE, MARK L. 05-24-19 5101 12.01 2 620,500 732,500 84.71 5405621A 04-03-19 LIPARI, JACK C & JAIME 03-02-19 3702 11 2 515,100 605,000 85.14 5397441A 10-11-18 COHEN, GERALD P 09-28-18 4702 1.01 2 398,000 465,000 85.59 5397263A 10-05-18 ZYLA, TIMOTHY A 08-31-18 1907 8 2 575,200 672,000 85.60 5402992A 02-11-19 BARRELLA, CHRISTOPHER 01-28-19 2703 14 2 223,600 260,000 86.00 5394072A 07-25-18 LYNCH, DARREL J. JR. 07-12-18 4608 34 2 430,300 500,000 86.06 5402317A 01-18-19 HAPPEL, ERIC 12-26-18 3705 16 2 374,900 435,000 86.18 5396505A 09-25-18 SMITH, CONSTANCE M 09-14-18 3506 3 2 345,200 399,900 86.32 5407471A 06-05-19 MANCUSO, JOHN & MARTINA 05-29-19 5402 13 2 367,200 422,000 87.01 5399709A 12-04-18 ZIRK, ANNA MARIE 11-20-18 901 4 2 346,800 397,500 87.25 5396965A 10-02-18 BARNETT, ROBERT (TRUSTEE) 09-18-18 5101 18.02 2 433,600 495,000 87.60 5395405A 08-22-18 HAMMER, MICHAEL & LOIS 08-02-18 4501 5 2 353,100 400,000 88.28 5404030A 03-04-19 RUSSO, CHRISTOPHER 02-06-19 5405 5 2 397,600 450,000 88.36 5407094A 05-06-19 ZAMPAGLIONE, NICOLA G & LU 04-26-19 4002 1 2 424,300 480,000 88.40 5402993A 02-11-19 LABIB, EMIL & GINA 02-01-19 2506 8 2 358,500 405,000 88.52 5407103A 05-20-19 DELLER, THOMAS E & SANDRA 05-04-19 2101 8.36 2 609,600 685,000 88.99 5407091A 05-01-19 FALLONE, GRACE 04-12-19 4606 5 2 460,500 515,000 89.42 5395779A 09-07-18 CHRISTY, GERALD J 08-30-18 4609 24 2 385,200 430,000 89.58 5408532A 06-17-19 SANTANGELO, JAMES & CATHER 05-23-19 1909 2 2 627,900 700,000 89.70 5398094A 10-29-18 PFIZENMAIER, SIEGFRIED 10-12-18 3007 1 2 171,600 190,000 90.32 5402525A 01-24-19 WU, CHONG W 01-21-19 5201 3 2 310,800 340,000 91.41 5405625A 04-15-19 FERRANO, ANNETTE 04-03-19 3503 3 2 516,100 561,500 91.91 5402995A 02-13-19 PETRY, MICHAEL J. & NANCY 12-20-18 2101 8.31 2 662,700 720,000 92.04 5408534A 06-17-19 KASSA, ADA MAE 06-04-19 4401 3 2 398,800 430,000 92.74 5400737A 12-21-18 MONZO, JESS A 12-11-18 5101 18.09 2 825,600 890,000 92.76 5401581A 01-04-19 HOLLYWOOD ASSETS, LLC. 11-15-18 3201 14 2 280,900 300,000 93.63 5406124A 04-30-19 CONFORTI, THOMAS 04-18-19 5404.01 4.09 2 800,600 850,000 94.19 5399266A 11-02-18 RECHTEN, RANDEL L & ANNE M 10-30-18 2002 1.11 2 833,000 825,000 100.97 5397437A 10-09-18 KG REALTY INVESTMENTS, LLC 09-25-18 5101 15.03 2 346,500 335,000 103.43 5397442T 10-11-18 HINO, LUCILLE A 09-21-18 2002 14 2 502,700 475,000 105.83 5398090A 10-24-18 MALANGA, ROCCO M 09-30-18 3601.01 1.08 2 838,100 783,000 107.04 5403539A 02-19-19 DALY, WILLIAM L 02-01-19 3401 9.02 2 1,028,300 950,000 108.24 5401307A 12-26-18 JOHNSON, KENNETH 11-28-18 4501 10 2 381,100 348,000 109.51 5408811A 06-17-19 SIFUENTES, VALERIA 04-17-19 3104 8 2 200,500 175,100 114.51 5402986A 02-04-19 FITZPATRICK, KELLY 01-16-19 5201 4.02 2 688,100 595,000 115.65 SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014

PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 07 FAIRFIELD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE YEAR TO DATE 87 39,720,800 47,565,800 7,259.30 5401579F 01-03-19 FERNICOLA PROPERTIES, LLC. 12-21-18 3801 1 4A 2,339,900 4,275,000 54.73 5394166F 08-01-18 VOLPE, GEORGE M & GRACE (T 01-23-18 4701 3.01 C1108 4A 135,000 162,000 83.33 5395407F 08-24-18 40 PIER LANE WEST, LLC 08-20-18 2601 19 4A 2,756,900 3,104,000 88.82 5407095F 05-07-19 BELRO ASSOCIATES 04-24-19 4701 3.01 C8212 4A 202,500 215,000 94.19 5400638F 12-17-18 ZERBO, LOUIS 11-26-18 4701 3.01 C4209 4A 92,000 97,500 94.36 5401587F 01-10-19 TOBIA, ALBERT P 12-28-18 4701 3.01 C3201 4A 129,500 136,000 95.22 5402982F 01-30-19 CITRON, RICHARD M 01-24-19 501 13 C0006 4A 184,000 189,000 97.35 5405041F 03-15-19 WIN2LEAD ASSOCIATES, LLC. 02-18-19 4701 3.01 C3104 4A 101,400 96,000 105.63 5402524F 01-24-19 COMPLETE WOMAN MIDWIFERY,L 01-11-19 4701 3.01 C3110 4A 99,900 87,000 114.83 5396503F 09-24-18 H207H206, LLC, 09-14-18 4701 3.01 C8206 4A 131,200 105,000 124.95 5394662F 08-09-18 OXYMAGIC INC, 06-21-18 2801 19 4A 362,100 265,000 136.64 YEAR TO DATE 11 6,534,400 8,731,500 1,090.05 5393220F 07-16-18 HNJ ENTERPRISES LLC, 06-27-18 1102 7 4B 960,000 1,642,500 58.45 5399431F 11-19-18 PERMISSION PARTNERS, 10-31-18 2702 4 4B 1,884,800 3,062,500 61.54 5394664F 08-13-18 SLADE MANAGEMENT LLC, 07-16-18 2302 7 C0011 4B 703,300 965,000 72.88 5409062F 06-21-19 GEANNAKAKES, GEORGE 05-29-19 1003 8 4B 519,200 662,500 78.37 5405044F 03-20-19 HOUMIS, DAVID 03-14-19 1003 7 4B 416,700 472,000 88.28 5395780F 09-07-18 GOREN ASSOCIATES LLC, 08-30-18 1402 7 4B 2,250,000 2,500,000 90.00 YEAR TO DATE 6 6,734,000 9,304,500 449.52 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 105 53,316,500 66,126,800 8,861.21

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 08 GLEN RIDGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406791A 05-20-19 NUZZOLESE, ROBERT 05-17-19 104 12.01 2 620,500 950,000 65.32 5407480A 06-10-19 WILLS, LANCE J 05-09-19 121 8 2 1,134,400 1,550,000 73.19 5406131A 05-01-19 NABIL, SHAUN S & CHERISH M 04-23-19 21 23 2 542,200 689,000 78.69 5407475A 05-30-19 GARRITY, DENNIS & MARY 04-24-19 145 17 2 589,800 749,500 78.69 5406133A 05-08-19 DELP, TIM & MOLLY 04-30-19 88 27 2 435,800 551,000 79.09 5402999A 02-04-19 GIESEY, GEORGE B JR 01-10-19 95 25.01 2 534,300 660,000 80.95 5409228A 06-27-19 KOBYLINSKI, CHRISTOPHER & 05-09-19 33 14 2 581,700 717,500 81.07 5406130A 04-29-19 ECM HILLSIDE LLC, 04-18-19 89 10 2 507,700 612,500 82.89 5406785A 05-03-19 LEVINSON, WARREN M 04-18-19 31 45 2 657,800 792,000 83.06 5406127A 04-08-19 PERSING, SAMUEL & JOANNE 04-02-19 119 41 2 860,400 1,027,000 83.78 5405627A 04-05-19 HOLDREITH, J & STANCEL, S 03-27-19 15 4 2 407,200 479,000 85.01 5406787A 05-16-19 JORDAN, JUSTIN & BARBARA 05-10-19 118 12 2 707,900 827,500 85.55 5407474A 05-29-19 MARCHESANO, JOSEPH JR & MA 05-21-19 81 14.02 2 535,500 625,000 85.68 5406126A 04-08-19 SCHNEIDER, MARC JASON 03-28-19 70 37 C0035 2 204,100 235,000 86.85 5409227A 06-27-19 PRICE, PAUL & INES ADAN 05-10-19 16 28 2 598,800 681,000 87.93 5405047A 03-25-19 DUYM, THOMAS A 03-04-19 41 21.01 2 559,900 635,000 88.17 5406128A 04-23-19 VENDETTI, JAMES & HANNAH M 04-10-19 30 15 2 1,362,300 1,545,000 88.17 5409226A 06-26-19 GRAY, MICHAEL E 06-08-19 18 39 2 470,700 528,800 89.01 5406792A 05-21-19 LEVIN TRUST 05-06-19 75 1.03 2 677,100 760,000 89.09 5403542A 02-22-19 BAGINSKI, STANLEY V. & JUD 02-07-19 21 31 2 526,100 590,000 89.17 5408703A 06-17-19 PERSAK, CARL J & ET AL 06-05-19 13 24.01 2 558,900 625,000 89.42 5407483A 06-17-19 ZUIDERVELD, LAURA 06-04-19 16 13 2 588,200 651,000 90.35 5404670A 03-18-19 CINOTTI, WILLIAM A & LISA 03-05-19 17 9 2 540,100 595,000 90.77 5407481A 06-11-19 CLUTTERBUCK, HOWARD C. & A 06-06-19 115 17 2 819,800 888,000 92.32 5402774A 01-29-19 BENDEL, GARRETT W & CHERYL 01-17-19 119 38 2 998,500 1,070,000 93.32 5403846A 02-27-19 COSMAS, GEORGE 02-21-19 88 4 2 523,100 550,000 95.11 5406790A 05-20-19 HUH, JOONGHEE & LEE, JOOHY 05-15-19 88 1 C0307 2 595,600 621,224 95.88 5402775A 01-30-19 FELLUS, JONATHAN & BORGENI 01-24-19 52 4 2 890,700 900,000 98.97 5409229A 06-27-19 GRIMES, LISA M. 05-28-19 93 8 2 434,600 435,000 99.91 5407478A 06-07-19 MATHEW, BENNY & KOCHURANI 05-20-19 22 20 2 507,200 505,000 100.44 5406129A 04-24-19 MARCELLINO, CARL P & LARIS 04-16-19 13 11 2 1,639,000 1,535,000 106.78 5408982A 06-24-19 REILLY, DIANNE M 05-20-19 84 14 2 518,700 479,000 108.29 YEAR TO DATE 32 21,128,600 24,059,024 2,822.92 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 32 21,128,600 24,059,024 2,822.92

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 09 IRVINGTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5409071F 06-24-19 SABAG, ALBERT 06-07-19 142 18.01 1 35,000 70,000 50.00 5396585F 08-31-18 OKORO, VIVIAN 07-26-18 165 27.03 1 18,800 35,000 53.71 5406809F 04-29-19 FLAGGE CONCRETE, INC, 04-11-19 149 30 1 23,900 40,000 59.75 5398733F 10-18-18 COLE, OLU S 10-06-18 312 30 1 19,000 26,560 71.54 5396357F 08-14-18 PINE HOLDINGS LLC, 07-12-18 147 15 1 15,000 12,000 125.00 YEAR TO DATE 5 111,700 183,560 360.00 5402152F 01-09-19 100 GRACE ST., LLC. 12-27-18 219 6.02 2 95,700 215,000 44.51 5404908F 03-18-19 100 GRACE ST, LLC, 03-06-19 219 6.01 2 95,700 215,000 44.51 5399523T 10-30-18 SF HOLDINGS LLC, 10-15-18 90 16 2 135,900 263,000 51.67 5400761T 12-06-18 OLIVER, NANCHEZ 11-29-18 90 11 2 175,500 275,000 63.82 5401318A 12-24-18 FARQUHAR, SAMUEL JR 11-29-18 358 14 2 120,600 186,500 64.66 5402146A 01-08-19 YATES, JERELINE 12-20-18 331 30 2 158,500 230,000 68.91 5403549T 02-19-19 CLAYTON, CORRINE & CARLOS 02-05-19 315 12 2 142,000 200,000 71.00 5402783A 01-30-19 ESPINOZA, ROSA 01-22-19 327 11 2 135,900 190,000 71.53 5397820F 10-15-18 183 LINDEN AVENUE LLC 10-01-18 77 44 2 163,900 225,000 72.84 5397807A 10-10-18 MICHAEL, MARVENIA 09-26-18 77 33 2 103,000 140,000 73.57 5397825A 10-16-18 32 LEO PL CAPITAL LLC 09-11-18 248 3 2 142,000 193,000 73.58 5403017A 02-06-19 PAGAN, MOISEN & YOLANDA AZ 01-30-19 355 40 2 154,000 207,000 74.40 5404053F 03-05-19 TAVERAS, YURY 01-24-19 159 37 2 195,800 260,000 75.31 5406146F 04-02-19 MAJEED, ZAKIR HUSSAIN 03-28-19 116 18 2 92,700 122,000 75.98 5401325A 12-26-18 BROWER, PHILIP H 11-16-18 345 22 2 168,300 220,000 76.50 5402328T 12-29-18 LEAGUE IRVINGTON HOLDINGS, 11-30-18 349 16 2 137,600 175,000 78.63 5409068A 06-24-19 ATHAR, KHAZRAN 06-14-19 79 12 2 101,800 128,500 79.22 5403025A 02-07-19 PARK ALLIANCE LLC, 12-27-18 257 18 2 231,700 290,000 79.90 5396992A 09-28-18 GOSS, ALVIN 09-18-18 75 14 2 161,600 195,000 82.87 5408215A 05-09-19 127 DELMAR PL, LLC. 04-15-19 75 19 2 185,000 220,000 84.09 5399720A 11-02-18 SHOULARS, BEULAH 07-31-18 110 6 2 94,500 112,000 84.38 5397823A 10-15-18 EAST BAY CORP, 06-26-18 84 46 2 178,300 210,000 84.90 5396973A 09-24-18 SCOTT, DANNETTE K 09-05-18 335 9 2 110,700 130,000 85.15 5399719T 11-02-18 BOTROS, NAGI 10-31-18 346 3 2 174,800 205,000 85.27 5408827A 06-07-19 EXQUISITE REALTY LLC, 05-20-19 15 22 2 145,100 170,000 85.35 5399717A 11-02-18 CHARLES, JOCELYN & ABDELHA 06-15-18 88 16 2 131,000 153,000 85.62 5396567A 08-28-18 SOHAN, LENWORTH 08-10-18 58 16 2 107,400 125,000 85.92 5408577A 06-05-19 JENKINS, DONELL W & RASHEE 03-05-19 209 12 2 141,900 165,000 86.00 5400486A 11-29-18 JACOBS, PAUL R 11-05-18 338 3 2 237,200 275,250 86.18 5399515A 10-29-18 SIMON, ROOSEVELT 09-28-18 68 17 2 151,100 175,000 86.34 5404278A 03-08-19 THOMAS, K. ANTHONY 02-05-19 129 15 2 166,500 192,000 86.72 5396599A 09-06-18 ELVIN, DAVE 08-16-18 153 23 2 213,900 245,000 87.31 5398765T 10-24-18 220 MAPLE LLC, 07-26-18 225 19 2 251,500 283,000 88.87 5399512T 10-26-18 GEI HOLDINGS, LLC. 10-01-18 54.01 2 2 254,800 286,000 89.09 5396980A 09-27-18 138 22ND ST IRV HOLDINGS L 09-18-18 142 10.01 2 200,900 225,000 89.29 5402355F 01-11-19 SPEARS, REGINA 12-07-18 148 18 2 107,200 120,000 89.33 5401328A 12-27-18 LOUISSAINT, JEANNE H 11-03-18 73 1 2 228,200 255,000 89.49

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 09 IRVINGTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396970A 09-21-18 GEI HOLDINGS LLC, 09-14-18 65 3 2 246,200 275,000 89.53 5404906T 03-15-19 STAR SUNSHINE INVESTMENTS 02-07-19 198.01 3 2 169,200 188,250 89.88 5403574A 02-25-19 HENDRICKS, SAMUEL 12-20-18 255 33 2 117,700 130,000 90.54 5397804A 10-10-18 PERRY, MATTYE V 09-24-18 200 11 2 95,400 105,000 90.86 5405847A 03-26-19 27 SHARON AVENUE LLC, 03-15-19 280 9 2 205,300 225,000 91.24 5400422A 11-15-18 ORIENTAL REALTY LLC, 10-29-18 216 17 2 170,100 185,000 91.95 5398734A 10-18-18 AZIZ, HAMZA 09-28-18 154 39 2 207,300 225,000 92.13 5400774A 12-11-18 DAVIS, SPARKLE 11-20-18 49 12 2 175,800 190,000 92.53 5398770A 10-25-18 TURNER, BEVERLY A 09-27-18 167 3 2 186,700 200,000 93.35 5406201A 04-23-19 LLOYD, DELORES 02-28-19 70 14 2 157,000 168,000 93.45 5402368F 01-16-19 BSD 229 LLC, 01-07-19 154 21 2 77,300 82,000 94.27 5408823A 06-07-19 ELLIS AVE PROPERTIES LLC 06-03-19 141 9 2 226,600 239,900 94.46 5408878A 06-11-19 LEAGUE IRVINGTON HOLDINGS, 05-23-19 86 30 2 187,700 198,000 94.80 5408537A 05-20-19 SULCA, EDGAR 04-26-19 197 9 2 160,300 169,000 94.85 5396989A 09-28-18 FRANKS-WASHINGTON, LENA DA 09-07-18 338 6 2 114,500 120,000 95.42 5396129T 08-03-18 AMERICAN DREAM, LLC, 07-19-18 252 10 2 201,900 210,700 95.82 5402346A 01-07-19 TUTT, SHIRLEY 12-21-18 261 7 2 110,400 115,000 96.00 5403564T 02-22-19 SUTOVIC, VELISA 01-16-19 64 11 2 344,700 359,000 96.02 5397816A 10-12-18 OEUDRAOGO, KARIM 10-08-18 54 9 2 134,900 140,000 96.36 5396581A 08-30-18 SINDAB, MARTIN C 08-08-18 328 10 2 144,900 150,000 96.60 5405838F 03-21-19 240 LINCOLN PLACE, LLC 02-28-19 295 7 2 146,000 151,000 96.69 5394778T 07-19-18 LOPEZ, JOHN 06-29-18 59 16 2 145,300 150,000 96.87 5396984A 09-27-18 BRIXTONE INVEST 123 BROOKW 09-20-18 60 37 2 169,600 175,000 96.91 5396727A 09-12-18 ASSERTIVE REAL ESTATE PART 07-02-18 96 1 2 247,100 254,500 97.09 5394768A 07-18-18 FERMIN, JUAN 06-06-18 64 14 2 234,000 240,000 97.50 5402557A 01-25-19 BFM HOLDINGS, LLC. 01-08-19 316 41 C06.1 2 43,900 45,000 97.56 5408223A 05-14-19 ESSEX COUNTY ASSETS LLC 01-07-19 249 17 2 156,400 160,000 97.75 5402364T 01-15-19 GRINER, JEWEL A 01-02-19 367 20 2 148,300 150,000 98.87 5394095A 07-13-18 KMJ HOLDINGS LLC, 07-10-18 240 44 2 189,000 190,000 99.47 5396349A 08-10-18 PAUL-PIERRE, NAITIL & NASS 06-15-18 296 16 2 144,500 145,000 99.66 5396352A 08-13-18 ROGERS, ALICE I 06-13-18 8 13 2 155,200 155,000 100.13 5402390A 01-23-19 FLOWERS, PATRICIA T 01-17-19 29 2 2 140,900 140,000 100.64 5406802F 04-25-19 BLACK CONGRESS ENTERPRISES 04-02-19 47 5 2 89,700 89,000 100.79 5398730A 10-18-18 ESSEX ACQUISITIONS, LLC. 08-14-18 126 2 2 144,900 142,000 102.04 5408554A 05-28-19 NWASOMA, ANTHONY MICHAEL 05-16-19 119 10 2 188,800 185,000 102.05 5397996T 10-16-18 CHARLES, YVANE 10-04-18 50 2 2 123,000 120,000 102.50 5398748A 10-19-18 HEPBURN, CLARICE 10-11-18 131 36 2 148,000 144,000 102.78 5402145A 01-08-19 COOPER, MYRA 12-27-18 79 81 C0002 2 77,600 75,000 103.47 5398755A 10-23-18 DEPASS, LYNFORD 10-04-18 130 37 2 142,500 137,000 104.01 5404052F 03-04-19 LOAN PORTFOLIO LLC, 01-22-19 95 7 2 146,100 140,000 104.36 5397814A 10-12-18 ROBERSON, JAMIL S 04-27-18 297 7 2 209,500 200,000 104.75 5402556A 01-25-19 TETAJ, SHKUMBIN 01-03-19 237 45 2 90,000 85,000 105.88 5403014A 02-05-19 11 HERPERS, LLC. 01-08-19 218 9 2 191,000 180,000 106.11 5396972A 09-24-18 ROBINSON, DON 09-05-18 69 2 2 202,500 190,000 106.58 5397667A 10-09-18 RUTH, SHIRLEY 09-06-18 76 32 2 249,400 230,000 108.43 5396358T 08-15-18 M.R.V. ASSOCIATES, LLC 08-10-18 53 1 2 282,800 250,000 113.12

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 09 IRVINGTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5408881A 06-11-19 459 HARDING AVENUE, LLC. 04-18-19 170 3 2 161,700 140,000 115.50 5393240F 07-02-18 WALLACH BETH TRANSACTIONS 06-25-18 125 13 2 104,400 90,000 116.00 5395348A 08-02-18 795 CHANCELLOR AVENUE, LLC 07-10-18 296 1 2 232,900 200,000 116.45 5403041A 02-13-19 NEW BENGAL CONSTRUCTION IN 02-07-19 31 31 2 83,300 71,000 117.32 5400481T 11-27-18 BRIXTONE INVESTMENT GROUP, 11-06-18 55 10 2 129,100 110,000 117.36 5396128A 07-17-18 PREVILON, BERNADETTE S 06-19-18 341 34 2 192,900 160,000 120.56 5401311A 12-21-18 311 VERMONT ASSOCIATES, LL 11-07-18 75 28 2 253,300 210,000 120.62 5406824F 05-02-19 SCHUTT, GLADYS 04-09-19 33 8 2 155,000 128,500 120.62 5397175F 10-03-18 WASHINGTON, TONI ROCHELLE 10-02-18 234 4 2 116,300 95,000 122.42 5400427A 11-15-18 NJ R&R RE HOLDINGS LLC 10-15-18 126 40 2 158,200 128,000 123.59 5396321F 08-06-18 MENDOZA, AREMENTHEA 08-02-18 374 42 2 123,900 100,000 123.90 5399516F 10-29-18 WATSON, LENA T 10-05-18 312 17 2 97,400 70,000 139.14 5402329F 12-29-18 PIERCE, GLORIA J 11-29-18 47 5 2 89,700 63,000 142.38 5404035F 02-28-19 REDEN ZUH LLC, 02-13-19 149 36 2 258,300 160,000 161.44 5399524F 10-30-18 WHITE, HORACE L 10-08-18 154 4 2 195,200 120,000 162.67 YEAR TO DATE 98 15,783,700 17,119,100 9,318.75 5399775F 11-08-18 NEZIUS, MARINA & CASTOR, A 10-24-18 308 27 4A 152,400 215,000 70.88 5402386F 01-22-19 BH REALTY, INC. 01-11-19 126 28 4A 367,400 500,000 73.48 5402347T 01-07-19 STAR TOBACCO COMPANY 11-16-18 300 2 4A 628,300 765,000 82.13 5395334F 07-31-18 ROUTE 22 AUTOMOTIVE ASSOC 06-20-18 10 11 4A 159,400 185,000 86.16 5402350F 01-07-19 16 ELMWOOD LLC, 12-28-18 28 22 4A 190,100 210,000 90.52 5405854F 03-27-19 CLZ PROPERTIES, LLC, 02-08-19 351 29 4A 166,000 172,500 96.23 5396330F 08-07-18 K&C MOOK INVESTMENTS LLC 07-30-18 153 1 4A 298,200 300,000 99.40 5397171F 10-03-18 336 MYRTLE AVE, CORP 09-21-18 62 24 4A 165,500 165,000 100.30 5396532F 08-21-18 MALCOLM SHABBAZ URBAN RENE 08-13-18 127 23 4A 269,400 252,000 106.90 5403766F 02-25-19 MPM CO, 02-06-19 359 2 4A 189,700 175,000 108.40 5409481F 06-25-19 DONG, XIU YUN 06-11-19 162 22 4A 243,100 217,000 112.03 5408388F 05-20-19 ASHI GTO ASSOCIATES I 05-15-19 280 1 4A 850,000 730,000 116.44 YEAR TO DATE 12 3,679,500 3,886,500 1,142.87 5394023F 07-11-18 FLAGGE CONCRETE, INC, 07-06-18 167 23 4B 195,600 280,000 69.86 YEAR TO DATE 1 195,600 280,000 69.86 5403032F 02-11-19 PATLOIS MGMT LLC, 01-24-19 79 114 4C 944,500 1,910,000 49.45 5401327F 12-27-18 STUYVESANT COMMUNITY HOMES 12-14-18 326 12 4C 1,207,900 1,650,000 73.21 5408833F 06-10-19 LVJ PLANNING, LLC, 05-21-19 151 30 4C 331,900 400,000 82.98 5402337F 01-03-19 BROWN, FINLEY DEREK 12-20-18 35 6 4C 305,000 345,000 88.41 5406160F 04-05-19 ELVIN, DAVE 02-04-19 153 22 4C 322,900 350,000 92.26 5402358F 01-14-19 WRIGHT, YVONNE D 12-30-18 233 24 4C 244,800 250,000 97.92

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 09 IRVINGTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5402788F 01-30-19 SOLOMON, DANIEL 12-14-18 140 21 4C 251,100 200,000 125.55 YEAR TO DATE 7 3,608,100 5,105,000 609.78 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 123 23,378,600 26,574,160 11,501.26

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5403882A 02-25-19 CELLER, PAUL 02-20-19 2100 52 2 722,600 1,168,500 61.84 5395565A 07-30-18 MCMAHON, MICHAEL 07-06-18 3900 86 2 701,200 1,100,000 63.75 5398104A 08-21-18 GUDE, MANOLITA 07-29-18 3802 17 2 442,500 660,000 67.05 5399990A 11-09-18 KHMELNITSKY, BORIS 09-13-18 3809 5 2 513,500 765,000 67.12 5399027A 09-12-18 COHEN, ANTHONY S 08-30-18 1004 5 2 471,100 695,000 67.78 5393863A 07-06-18 PERCIVAL, JOHN 05-19-18 1702 14 2 440,900 650,000 67.83 5402794A 01-23-19 HAMBERGER, JOHN & ARLENE 01-17-19 401 20 2 878,900 1,285,000 68.40 5397907A 08-10-18 GARCIA, CESAR & PASQUA 08-03-18 4201 33 2 533,500 770,000 69.29 5398007A 08-16-18 VG HOME HOLDINGS III, 08-06-18 3202 12 2 411,800 593,000 69.44 5398543A 08-23-18 LU, HAI YU 08-08-18 3801 2 2 422,400 605,000 69.82 5405630A 03-27-19 NA, CHARLES 03-19-19 3600 4 2 425,000 607,000 70.02 5399529A 10-03-18 WEINER, JEREMY J 09-21-18 401 76 2 758,500 1,082,000 70.10 5398004A 08-15-18 MATUSAITIS, VITA E 08-07-18 3804 11 2 420,900 600,000 70.15 5401121A 11-27-18 CARR, BRIAN & MELISSA 10-31-18 4503 2 2 420,500 599,000 70.20 5399539A 10-09-18 WEICHERT, ROBERT & MADELYN 09-11-18 1700 97 2 422,900 600,000 70.48 5395543A 07-25-18 LEVY, IRINA & JORDAN 07-20-18 3502 14 2 473,900 670,000 70.73 5401332A 11-28-18 YANG, ZHUOCHENG & WANG, YU 11-07-18 4503 7 2 558,100 787,000 70.91 5401335A 12-03-18 MATHEW, MATHEW C 11-12-18 5101 23 2 364,700 510,000 71.51 5394025A 07-11-18 OUYANG, ZAN & XU, WENDONG 06-21-18 4401 5 2 420,000 580,000 72.41 5398552A 08-29-18 SOLTER, GEORGE J JR 08-23-18 1507 7 2 409,900 565,000 72.55 5398787A 09-06-18 AYARS, BRYAN 08-28-18 1901 17 2 548,300 755,000 72.62 5397898A 08-09-18 TURNER, MICHAEL 07-11-18 3502 55 2 508,500 700,000 72.64 5408228A 06-03-19 CANTER, JAY & GLADYS 05-16-19 2006 26 2 562,000 771,000 72.89 5397910A 08-13-18 MELLACE, PETRONILLA 07-25-18 4505 60 2 441,300 600,000 73.55 5397905A 08-10-18 GIVNER, MICHAEL & ALISON 07-27-18 401 72 2 975,000 1,325,000 73.58 5407513A 05-20-19 KAPLAN, DINA 05-14-19 2002 23 2 614,500 831,000 73.95 5395581A 08-03-18 SKOWRONEK, KEVIN 07-12-18 3302 27 2 370,000 500,000 74.00 5401605A 12-26-18 PUGLISI, DANIELE 12-03-18 3203 47 2 445,000 600,000 74.17 5398546A 08-27-18 HERRERA, JOEL E 08-16-18 4701 28 2 387,700 521,200 74.39 5398008A 08-16-18 ZHENG, YUHUAI & HU, HEPING 07-25-18 4401 9 2 435,100 580,000 75.02 5409493A 06-27-19 TENNENBAUM, SCOTT & DANA 06-17-19 2900 12 2 529,400 705,000 75.09 5399279A 09-24-18 KRAMER, DAVID 09-08-18 800 10 2 903,300 1,199,900 75.28 5399565A 10-22-18 LAZZARO, VINCENZA 10-05-18 6001 32 2 320,000 425,000 75.29 5397900A 08-09-18 MANSFIELD, ROBERT JR 07-23-18 4704 27 2 378,300 501,000 75.51 5398386A 08-22-18 NANNI, ELISA & LENZI, MICH 07-26-18 3000 41 2 594,400 785,000 75.72 5404327A 03-08-19 LEWIS, ROBERT 02-25-19 4004 11 2 513,200 675,000 76.03 5409499A 06-27-19 YAMPOLSKY, YURI & ANNA 06-23-19 3900 108 2 431,300 565,000 76.34 5395542A 07-25-18 ANAND, RICHA & GUNEET SING 07-12-18 1803 15 2 830,000 1,085,000 76.50 5406841A 05-02-19 HERMAN, GARY & MARIANNA 04-30-19 1903 33 2 644,300 842,000 76.52 5399984A 11-07-18 FELDMAN, JARED & ROBIN 11-01-18 3502 49 2 559,000 730,000 76.58 5406223A 04-24-19 MAVROMATIS, ARTHUR & LINDA 04-16-19 5100 60 2 635,300 829,000 76.63 5395556A 07-27-18 TONG, CHAN-SHONG 07-17-18 1005 4 2 479,600 625,000 76.74 5400651A 11-15-18 TSOZIK, VADIM 10-31-18 4010 16 2 423,600 550,000 77.02 5394099A 07-13-18 TCA 06-27-18 2005 13 2 558,100 724,000 77.09 5400783A 11-20-18 AURILIA, RALPH M 10-31-18 107 7.01 C4202 2 443,400 575,000 77.11 5395546A 07-26-18 CRAWFORD, PHYLLIS M 07-19-18 4009 49 2 625,000 810,000 77.16

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5409099A 06-25-19 PATEL, NILU G 06-19-19 1307 10 2 452,800 585,000 77.40 5399281A 09-25-18 PIRAK, JONATHAN J 09-05-18 3809 38 2 352,300 455,000 77.43 5399274A 09-20-18 DOBROWOLSKI, RADOSLAW 08-07-18 4008 4 2 415,200 535,000 77.61 5398776A 08-31-18 DOBRICK, ADAM 08-14-18 2602 55 2 501,200 645,000 77.71 5399972A 10-29-18 MARLOW, ANN 10-12-18 107 7.01 C3406 2 470,200 605,000 77.72 5394108A 07-23-18 FEFFER, MITCHEL SCOTT 07-03-18 3702 6 2 457,800 588,000 77.86 5394785A 07-23-18 SHARRET, DAVID & YVETTE 06-28-18 801 31 2 936,700 1,200,000 78.06 5394789A 07-25-18 PETRULLO, GENNARO & GERALD 07-11-18 2906 51 2 652,400 835,000 78.13 5401597A 12-14-18 CHOU, CHIN-AN 12-10-18 5900 48 2 613,500 785,000 78.15 5408233A 06-06-19 RENFER, MICHAEL & MELISSA 05-31-19 1602 1 2 418,400 535,000 78.21 5394103A 07-18-18 KUMAR, PRADEEP & GUPTA, NI 06-29-18 3702 22 2 572,200 731,000 78.28 5399572A 10-26-18 CHROMAN, J SCOTT & BARBARA 09-27-18 2002 15 2 569,100 726,000 78.39 5395641A 08-07-18 SATIN, ADAM & BARRIE 07-16-18 4003 3 2 604,400 770,000 78.49 5399971A 10-29-18 DAS PROPERTIES LLC, 10-24-18 1403 11 2 384,300 488,000 78.75 5405861A 04-04-19 GOLDEN, JED & STACEY 03-20-19 204 22 2 1,103,700 1,400,000 78.84 5404237A 03-04-19 JABLONSKI, ZDZISLAWA 02-14-19 6503 9 2 709,000 899,000 78.87 5406202A 04-03-19 328 EAST MT PLEASANT AVE,L 03-28-19 2401 41 2 960,000 1,215,000 79.01 5395548A 07-26-18 WANG, ZHENYU 07-18-18 3504 13 2 510,000 644,000 79.19 5399166A 09-14-18 SU, JEROME C 08-22-18 1900 18 2 484,400 610,000 79.41 5399128A 09-14-18 OKYLE, STEVEN 09-02-18 6400 8 2 1,041,700 1,310,000 79.52 5398102A 08-21-18 JONES, KAREN WOODHAL 07-26-18 4800 54 2 397,900 500,000 79.58 5403354A 01-29-19 BIEBER, DAVID 01-02-19 107 7.01 C3411 2 442,100 555,000 79.66 5395547A 07-26-18 BHATIA, RAMAN P 07-19-18 3400 1 2 580,000 728,000 79.67 5400080A 11-14-18 NIMAROFF, SORAYA 11-01-18 1307 15 2 749,000 940,000 79.68 5397914A 08-14-18 MCBRIDE, JOSEPH T JR 08-07-18 4301 28 2 400,000 500,000 80.00 5407514A 05-21-19 FENG, YUN 05-08-19 4602 3 2 473,200 589,000 80.34 5395570A 07-31-18 VERIEPE, PATRICIA A (CO-TR 07-19-18 4302 22 2 402,000 500,000 80.40 5406833A 04-25-19 SCHNEIDERMAN, MALLIE B & R 04-15-19 4203 17 2 378,800 470,000 80.60 5403044A 01-02-19 GONG, YAN 11-19-18 3811 17 2 382,900 475,000 80.61 5395645A 08-07-18 WEISS, HYLA T & ERIC 07-30-18 6800 35 2 1,250,500 1,550,000 80.68 5399574A 10-29-18 DASILVA, FERNANDO 10-19-18 4100 13 2 488,300 605,000 80.71 5399566A 10-23-18 BRYCE, KASH 10-17-18 802 14 2 989,000 1,225,000 80.73 5393945A 07-10-18 KUTAKOFF, HENRY & JUDITH L 06-18-18 1307 3 2 452,300 560,000 80.77 5398777A 08-31-18 TAYLOR, JONATHAN S 08-16-18 5701 15 2 485,000 600,000 80.83 5399343A 10-01-18 RAKOVSKY, ILANA 09-18-18 1608 3 2 760,000 940,000 80.85 5406216A 04-22-19 FRANCALANCIA, ANTONIO & AL 03-21-19 1509 14 2 340,000 420,000 80.95 5403347A 01-24-19 ARONSON, JOSEPH G.& JOAN S 12-25-18 107 7.01 C5405 2 468,900 575,000 81.55 5399989A 11-09-18 LEE, WEI-NING WILL 10-03-18 1507 27 2 716,100 878,000 81.56 5406829A 04-16-19 MARFIL, CIRILA & PADAMA, R 01-25-19 4200 52 2 440,800 540,000 81.63 5395568A 07-31-18 MOUNT, WILLIAM J 07-18-18 1510 10 2 624,200 762,500 81.86 5394109A 07-23-18 HORN, DAN & REBECCA 06-15-18 3400 15 2 680,000 830,500 81.88 5394029A 07-12-18 KIM, SUNG & EUN KYUNG 06-01-18 2102 29 2 491,500 599,900 81.93 5401828A 12-29-18 BURACK, MARK G & MARILYN 12-11-18 3901 77 2 623,600 760,000 82.05 5399988A 11-09-18 WANG, RUN-MING 11-02-18 5800 11 2 332,600 405,000 82.12 5398790A 09-07-18 SUN, YALI 08-17-18 3903 112.0401 2 1,006,300 1,225,000 82.15 5405254A 03-25-19 DIFALCO, SALVATORE 02-14-19 4303 24 2 477,600 580,000 82.34

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393946A 07-10-18 KIM, SEONG HEON & LEE, SEO 06-18-18 1902 13 2 522,100 634,000 82.35 5403359A 02-06-19 PARK, HYON BAE & YOUNG HEE 12-07-18 3900 91 2 407,200 494,500 82.35 5409498A 06-27-19 NUMARK, GAIL & DAVID 06-24-19 2502 58 2 826,000 999,999 82.60 5401118A 11-26-18 TRUST, GARY 11-12-18 1600 12 2 505,800 612,000 82.65 5394035A 07-16-18 DELMAN, AMY S & MARC K 06-12-18 5101 9 2 579,300 699,999 82.76 5403341A 01-14-19 UNG, BRYAN 12-17-18 3812 22 2 396,500 478,000 82.95 5401609A 12-28-18 RUBENSTEIN, TODD B 12-14-18 2200 61 2 790,200 950,000 83.18 5394034A 07-16-18 LUDWIG, ARNOLD J & LINDA J 07-01-18 3603 17 2 820,000 985,000 83.25 5399280A 09-25-18 63 BELMONT LLC, 08-08-18 4202 18 2 400,700 480,000 83.48 5398387A 08-22-18 VARGHESE, ROY & ROY, BETTY 08-01-18 1103 29 2 405,000 485,000 83.51 5395540A 07-25-18 KIM, JOHN YEONGHO & THERES 07-12-18 3604 9 2 565,000 674,900 83.72 5409091A 06-24-19 SPILER, DAVID A. 06-14-19 2803 21 2 653,000 780,000 83.72 5401341A 12-05-18 ESSEX WHL IV, LLC. 11-28-18 2906 8 2 440,000 525,000 83.81 5404435A 03-12-19 BEVERIDGE, THOMAS JAMES 02-15-19 900 66 2 360,800 429,900 83.93 5399973A 10-30-18 HE, KEVIN WEI RON 09-25-18 1904 6 2 592,800 705,000 84.09 5399545A 10-10-18 ULLMAN, HAROLD & STACEY 09-25-18 3300 46 2 649,000 771,180 84.16 5397902A 08-09-18 ZUBER, SCOTT A & LIZABETH 07-30-18 1802 27 2 692,500 822,500 84.19 5406221A 04-23-19 GARCIA, JOSE & NORMA 04-11-19 5800 12 2 378,900 450,000 84.20 5407506A 05-16-19 LAMPF, ROBERT & HAZEL 04-29-19 1401 11 2 395,000 469,000 84.22 5397903A 08-09-18 BERKOWITZ, JANICE 07-25-18 1602 20 2 462,700 549,000 84.28 5398782A 09-05-18 RUSYN, LARISA 08-15-18 6101 47 C128 2 495,800 588,000 84.32 5399564A 10-22-18 ZALESKI, BRANDON E 10-11-18 2800 16 2 476,700 565,000 84.37 5405639A 03-29-19 HSU, TZUCHENG 03-24-19 1509 3 2 349,000 413,500 84.40 5399556A 10-16-18 VOLPER, STEVEN 09-06-18 402 4 2 833,700 985,000 84.64 5398781A 09-04-18 ALMAKKY, ALI O 08-08-18 6101 47 C078 2 575,700 680,000 84.66 5407489A 05-06-19 SHAW, NORMAN & GAIL 04-12-19 107 7.01 C4408 2 470,200 555,000 84.72 5395642A 08-07-18 1 BRANDON LLC, 07-23-18 1700 101 2 479,100 565,000 84.80 5393948A 07-11-18 HIRSCHHORN, ALLAN R 06-20-18 4901 1 2 419,800 495,000 84.81 5398098A 08-17-18 MOSKOWITZ, SCOTT 08-12-18 703 15 2 859,400 1,013,000 84.84 5407516A 05-23-19 ERDMAN, JODI & HARVEY 05-14-19 5002 7 2 408,100 481,000 84.84 5407490A 05-06-19 NUSSBAUM, ANDREW C 03-28-19 4400 72 2 417,100 490,800 84.98 5407510A 05-17-19 BLINETSKIY, ALEX 04-15-19 6101 47 C173 2 472,000 555,000 85.05 5404927A 03-18-19 SANDERS, JEFFREY & ASTA 03-07-19 1403 1 2 366,800 430,000 85.30 5409491A 06-26-19 CHANDRA, PREETA 06-18-19 1600 67 2 340,400 399,000 85.31 5401331A 11-28-18 25 BURGUNDY, LLC. 11-13-18 5800 1 2 717,000 839,900 85.37 5394031A 07-13-18 NIMENSKY, ALLEN 07-02-18 107 7.01 C1106 2 470,200 550,000 85.49 5399531A 10-04-18 GOLDT, WALTER C JR 09-28-18 3701 15 2 440,500 515,000 85.53 5409088A 06-20-19 LEVINSON, LIAD & SARAH 06-12-19 1901 4 2 544,100 636,000 85.55 5398097A 08-17-18 FAILLA, MARIE 08-13-18 6001 8.02 C095 2 719,400 840,000 85.64 5401342A 12-05-18 GORDON, ANITA J 11-30-18 6101 47 C210 2 398,300 465,000 85.66 5398542A 08-23-18 MANGALATH, PHILIP J 08-03-18 1600 6 2 496,900 580,000 85.67 5395539A 07-25-18 CHEN, TING 06-25-18 4704 14 2 427,700 499,000 85.71 5401119A 11-26-18 SHAH, BIMAL 10-10-18 5301 61 2 1,367,100 1,595,000 85.71 5399530A 10-04-18 MILLER, SAM & LYNN 09-28-18 2801 1 2 548,700 640,000 85.73 5404923A 03-18-19 SANTUCCI, ANTHONY 03-05-19 1510 1 2 363,200 423,000 85.86 5407515A 05-21-19 LABRUNDA, BRIAN S & MARIA 05-14-19 3201 12 2 476,000 553,000 86.08

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406222A 04-24-19 WHANG, OK & BONG HEE 03-12-19 1700 87 2 464,100 539,000 86.10 5409081A 06-18-19 KIM, JUSTIN HUN 05-20-19 900 29 2 413,500 480,000 86.15 5395572A 08-01-18 REALI, DONATO 07-26-18 4009 21 2 439,400 510,000 86.16 5398778A 09-04-18 PANTOPICOS, JAMES 07-27-18 4004 1 2 316,200 367,000 86.16 5403358A 02-04-19 WATSON, TIMOTHY L 01-29-19 5001 16 2 715,100 830,000 86.16 5401604A 12-24-18 SCHIAZZANO, GERALD & MARIO 12-14-18 4502 17 2 400,900 465,000 86.22 5408590A 06-11-19 ENG, KOON WING & YUKWEI SA 05-10-19 2801 26 2 491,300 569,000 86.34 5405636A 03-27-19 SUTARIA, AMIT H 03-18-19 401 39 2 673,700 780,000 86.37 5394786A 07-24-18 RYAN, JOSEPH T & ANN 07-16-18 6001 8.02 C036 2 714,400 825,000 86.59 5397913A 08-14-18 JUVELIS, GEORGE TZOUVELIS 07-23-18 6101 47 C260 2 398,300 460,000 86.59 5399568A 10-24-18 ROSENBERG, NOAH & AMY 10-02-18 3505 14 2 1,032,200 1,190,000 86.74 5395574A 08-02-18 KORNSTEIN, SHARON D 07-17-18 202 34 2 716,000 825,000 86.79 5408227A 06-03-19 SILVERMAN, MICHAEL M 05-20-19 6502 5 2 1,042,600 1,200,000 86.88 5394787A 07-24-18 LIDDY, SARAH O'GRADY 06-26-18 3203 48 2 599,700 690,000 86.91 5408230A 06-04-19 DRAIKIWICZ, STEVEN 05-28-19 3900 101 2 410,500 472,000 86.97 5398384A 08-22-18 WALLACE, BOBBY S & KARIN 07-27-18 1300 13 2 348,200 400,000 87.05 5400648A 11-14-18 MARUCCI, JOSEPH 10-23-18 1409 3 2 542,500 622,500 87.15 5395644A 08-07-18 LEVI, LINDA K 06-28-18 6400 36 2 998,500 1,145,000 87.21 5394032A 07-13-18 GERSHGORIN, BORIS & IRINA 06-27-18 2702 7 2 584,400 670,000 87.22 5406205A 04-12-19 GAO, HONG & BAO, DAN 04-04-19 6101 47 C257 2 479,800 550,000 87.24 5409500A 06-27-19 LORD, WILLIAM & RAQUEL S. 06-18-19 3502 95 2 412,900 473,000 87.29 5408234A 06-06-19 LEVINE, DAVID & ELYSE 05-30-19 503 17 2 825,600 945,000 87.37 5395573A 08-01-18 SHKOLNIKOV, IGOR 07-05-18 1101 39 2 447,000 510,000 87.65 5395571A 08-01-18 KONDONIJAKOS, STEVEN G 07-25-18 400 12 2 755,600 862,000 87.66 5399991A 11-09-18 BAIRD, IAN S. 10-25-18 4700 20 2 442,800 505,000 87.68 5409090A 06-24-19 PARKE, CAMERON F & JULIE S 06-14-19 2702 18 2 350,700 400,000 87.68 5395578A 08-02-18 GASSMAN, JEFFREY 07-27-18 5702 25 2 548,600 625,000 87.78 5403348A 01-25-19 NORVILLE, SHAWN & MAYURA 01-17-19 1903 18.01 2 777,700 885,000 87.88 5400782A 11-19-18 SABO, MARCELLA M. 10-24-18 801 17 2 880,000 999,999 88.00 5399554A 10-15-18 SALM, ALEX I 10-05-18 6501 2 2 1,013,600 1,150,000 88.14 5401598A 12-14-18 SAVAGE, EDITH 10-26-18 3805 12 2 386,300 438,000 88.20 5406831A 04-16-19 DE MEO, JASON & KIMBERLY 04-10-19 5100 10 2 560,100 635,000 88.20 5409092A 06-24-19 REY PROPERTIES LLC, 06-07-19 3809 42 2 345,000 391,000 88.24 5398780A 09-04-18 YAM, LAI CHUNG 08-15-18 401 48 2 1,116,300 1,265,000 88.25 5406835A 04-26-19 FIGUERAS, VID M & JANE D 04-12-19 1705 17 2 467,000 529,000 88.28 5403344A 01-22-19 NEMECEK, JAMES G & ET AL. 11-30-18 4506 1 2 370,900 420,000 88.31 5394104A 07-18-18 FENBERG-LANDY, DONI 07-02-18 1501.9 13 2 703,100 795,000 88.44 5403877A 02-20-19 KATZ, ALAN & CARLA 02-07-19 500 23 2 690,000 780,000 88.46 5399340A 09-28-18 LEE, NING 09-17-18 5301 1 2 623,700 705,000 88.47 5393941A 07-06-18 WEBER, BETTY L. 06-15-18 3901 83 2 469,000 530,000 88.49 5394784A 07-23-18 KATZ, RUTH 07-09-18 500 25 2 1,240,500 1,400,000 88.61 5399282A 09-28-18 DAVIS, DEBORAH M (TRUSTEE) 09-12-18 4505 58 2 359,100 405,000 88.67 5406208A 04-15-19 TANG, HUA & MENG 03-13-19 6101 47 C177 2 444,200 500,000 88.84 5407493A 05-07-19 THIRD CHOICE, LLC. 04-29-19 6101 47 C119 2 444,200 499,900 88.86 5397901A 08-09-18 SHAPIRO, ALAN 07-25-18 3400 10 2 862,200 970,000 88.89 5395555A 07-27-18 EHEN, XIAOLE 07-19-18 4300 15 2 381,000 428,000 89.02

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401593A 12-11-18 LEE, LAP K & BELINDA Y 11-12-18 4706 21 2 374,700 420,000 89.21 5393861A 07-05-18 ALAPATT, THOMAS 06-27-18 1700 85 2 481,800 540,000 89.22 5403353A 01-29-19 VINOGRADSKY, V & CHECHURIN 01-23-19 4402 3 2 433,000 485,000 89.28 5403436A 02-13-19 NOVOFASTOVSKY, ILYA & NEHA 01-15-19 1603 37 2 410,000 459,000 89.32 5406218A 04-23-19 DOUGLAS, MICHAEL J 03-29-19 1507 26 2 376,000 420,500 89.42 5399126A 09-14-18 GLATZ, ANN M & ET AL 08-09-18 3810 37 2 344,600 385,000 89.51 5408589A 06-11-19 DEARMOND, PEGGY 05-20-19 5601 40 2 448,000 500,000 89.60 5393940A 07-06-18 ROMANO, ERMINIO 07-02-18 3802 18 2 377,000 420,000 89.76 5406832A 04-16-19 KENNY, ROBYN W 03-30-19 6001 8.02 C109 2 673,500 750,000 89.80 5403418A 01-11-19 SCHICK, JEFFREY W 12-21-18 1000 20 2 440,200 490,000 89.84 5399536A 10-09-18 SBARRO, ANTHONY R & JANET 09-24-18 1605 17 2 405,000 450,000 90.00 5399269A 09-19-18 COLEMAN, JAMES E 08-30-18 4505 93 2 366,600 407,000 90.07 5398103A 08-21-18 PANAX PROPERTIES, LLC. 07-30-18 2006 2 2 437,100 485,000 90.12 5406834A 04-25-19 RAUSCH, JONATHAN A & ALYSS 04-19-19 6001 8.02 C107 2 599,700 665,000 90.18 5404326A 03-08-19 FLAUM, SETH A. 03-04-19 1900 15 2 487,300 540,000 90.24 5407491A 05-06-19 WEINER, FELICE 04-22-19 401 64 2 857,900 950,000 90.31 5395643A 08-07-18 PONICI, ADRIAN & RODIKA 07-26-18 5100 52 2 515,000 570,000 90.35 5405863A 04-11-19 LEVENS, ROBERT J. & DANA M 03-22-19 401 40 2 849,800 940,000 90.40 5395541A 07-25-18 D'ANNA, ANTHONY & SYLVIA 07-17-18 1704 24 2 598,100 661,000 90.48 5398547A 08-27-18 MUNGIELLO, VITTORIA A 08-15-18 4204 1 2 416,800 460,000 90.61 5393857A 07-02-18 MILLER, KAREN R 06-05-18 6101 47 C193 2 525,800 580,000 90.66 5407488A 05-03-19 BURKE, SUZANNE 04-22-19 1608 11 2 399,400 440,000 90.77 5393859A 07-03-18 ARENDS, ROD M & MELISSA 06-19-18 3600 29 2 631,300 695,000 90.83 5406206A 04-12-19 DABEK, EDWARD & KELLY 04-04-19 1603 26 2 417,900 460,000 90.85 5406212A 04-17-19 PATRONE, MICHELE 04-02-19 6101 47 C223 2 495,800 545,000 90.97 5403342A 01-16-19 MILLER, ROBERT 12-22-18 3401 18 2 667,100 732,500 91.07 5404234A 02-27-19 WONG, VINCENT & TSANG, JEN 02-17-19 2803 12 2 496,600 545,000 91.12 5409497A 06-27-19 EHRLICH, ROBERT & DORIS 05-29-19 6001 8.02 C154 2 601,800 660,000 91.18 5405633A 03-27-19 MINION, COREY S (ATTORNEY) 02-26-19 6600 6 2 684,200 750,000 91.23 5398549A 08-28-18 FORSTER, PETER 08-18-18 5702 3 2 593,300 650,000 91.28 5399986A 11-08-18 SUANINO, NOEL Z & ESTRELLI 10-30-18 900 84 2 406,700 445,000 91.39 5395562A 07-30-18 BABOT, YANA 07-25-18 301 41 2 873,300 955,000 91.45 5403345A 01-22-19 GABRIEL, ANDREW & LYNNE 01-08-19 2004 58 2 795,900 870,000 91.48 5393862A 07-05-18 CICCONE, LOUIS C JR 06-10-18 3600 2 2 595,100 650,000 91.55 5409496A 06-27-19 SCOTT, RICHARD C. & COLLEE 06-20-19 3700 14 2 444,000 485,000 91.55 5395558A 07-27-18 PONANTA, MARIAN 07-13-18 6101 47 C019 2 444,200 485,000 91.59 5403045A 01-03-19 SWENSON, NILS R & CYNTHIA 12-11-18 5004 23 2 657,000 717,000 91.63 5405052A 03-21-19 POWERS, JOHN B 02-27-19 2004 8 2 375,000 409,000 91.69 5400785A 11-21-18 WADE, GEORGE 11-12-18 5001 70 2 431,900 470,000 91.89 5399978A 11-01-18 RAINAL, VALERY 10-29-18 6101 47 C092 2 574,500 625,000 91.92 5394024A 07-11-18 LIN, HONG 06-24-18 6101 47 C171 2 479,800 521,400 92.02 5398779A 09-04-18 LIEBERMAN, ARLENE 08-10-18 3810 32 2 385,200 418,000 92.15 5398786A 09-06-18 JANOWSKI, DAVID 07-30-18 2702 8 2 605,400 657,000 92.15 5393942A 07-09-18 MANNING, RICHARD B 06-19-18 1403 4 2 411,400 446,000 92.24 5403881A 02-25-19 YEH, CHIN-CHANG 02-19-19 5501 6 2 602,800 653,000 92.31 5399553A 10-12-18 SVETVILAS, CHAVALIT 10-04-18 5005 7 2 683,500 737,500 92.68

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399567A 10-24-18 KRAFCHICK, JUDITH L 10-12-18 3203 40 2 491,400 530,000 92.72 5408591A 06-11-19 SACHDEVA, ANIL & RUCHI 05-28-19 6001 8.02 C101 2 639,200 689,000 92.77 5406830A 04-16-19 XU, DAHAI & WANG, CHLOE QI 04-05-19 6001 8.02 C052 2 598,700 645,000 92.82 5399540A 10-09-18 BELFER, MARK & GALA 09-24-18 6701 4 2 1,300,000 1,400,000 92.86 5398385A 08-22-18 MINDLIN, SCOTT & MAIDA 08-17-18 500 20 2 789,500 850,000 92.88 5399551A 10-12-18 RAYKIN, BORIS 09-27-18 6001 8.02 C093 2 639,200 687,000 93.04 5409084A 06-19-19 BRAUN, BARBARA Y 06-17-19 4200 38 2 371,600 399,000 93.13 5403349A 01-25-19 HAUPTMAN, MARVIN H. & JANI 01-03-19 6101 47 C185 2 398,300 427,500 93.17 5398785A 09-06-18 POHLMEYER, JEFFREY V 08-22-18 1300 15 2 373,100 400,000 93.28 5401336A 12-03-18 BELL, ROBERT BRUCE 11-27-18 7106 10 2 1,399,900 1,500,000 93.33 5394107A 07-20-18 ALMEAS, IRA & ROBERT 07-05-18 1607 10 2 744,700 797,705 93.36 5400786A 11-21-18 16 CLIFFSIDE ASSOCIATES, L 10-29-18 301 31 2 509,300 545,000 93.45 5408229A 06-03-19 ZHU, GUO DONG & LI, LIN 05-24-19 6101 47 C164 2 444,200 475,000 93.52 5405632A 03-27-19 GALASSO, SALVATORE D 03-08-19 1606 26 2 412,300 440,000 93.70 5394026A 07-12-18 DYAPA, MOHAN & SAMBIREDDY, 06-18-18 5800 33 2 595,300 635,000 93.75 5399167A 09-14-18 BUONOPANE, MICHAEL 08-16-18 5001 71 2 342,500 365,000 93.84 5397906A 08-10-18 LANG, MONICA 07-17-18 2803 20 2 497,400 530,000 93.85 5397911A 08-14-18 HONG, SOON Y 06-19-18 6001 65 2 365,200 389,000 93.88 5399558A 10-17-18 BERMAN, PHILIP & BARBARA A 08-16-18 1400 7 2 852,500 905,000 94.20 5409495A 06-27-19 BLACK, JEANETTE 05-31-19 7101 2 2 1,074,200 1,140,000 94.23 5407499A 05-10-19 GATTO, THOMAS R 05-03-19 4900 38 2 584,500 620,000 94.27 5401606A 12-26-18 SAUL, LEON 12-06-18 1700 21 2 518,600 550,000 94.29 5399573A 10-29-18 STANKO, LORRAINE E (TRUSTE 10-24-18 1506 52 2 392,300 415,000 94.53 5395569A 07-31-18 WEISMAN, JAMI & LEEN,JEROM 07-23-18 7300 17 2 908,000 960,000 94.58 5398005A 08-15-18 GREIFINGER, RICHARD A 07-30-18 6101 47 C082 2 702,300 742,000 94.65 5399342A 09-28-18 PICHAT, ALFRED R 08-27-18 4501 5 2 378,800 400,000 94.70 5399547A 10-11-18 JOSHI, KARTIK 09-18-18 401 11 2 1,273,400 1,340,000 95.03 5409082A 06-18-19 SETTEDUCATO, ROSEMARY & GR 05-21-19 4700 27 2 442,200 465,000 95.10 5401340A 12-05-18 MINTO, NICHOLAS J. 11-27-18 4403 15 2 386,400 406,000 95.17 5406204A 04-08-19 SCHWARTZ, STANLEY & ADRIEN 04-03-19 7202 9 2 942,700 990,000 95.22 5409083A 06-18-19 SILVERMAN, JOSEPH & MAUREE 05-29-19 4904 36 2 412,600 433,333 95.22 5398553A 08-29-18 STRASSBERG, DANIEL 08-15-18 3000 31 2 385,700 405,000 95.23 5405255A 03-25-19 DONNER, ROBERT D 02-26-19 5302 9 2 738,400 775,000 95.28 5400076A 11-13-18 RANDIS, JOHN 10-23-18 5600 7 2 636,300 667,500 95.33 5403046A 01-08-19 REZNIKOVA, DARIA 12-18-18 2404 43 2 1,517,300 1,590,000 95.43 5407511A 05-20-19 MONTESION, THOMAS 04-30-19 1602 53 2 358,500 375,000 95.60 5404437A 03-12-19 JIANG, LIUJUN 02-28-19 5800 34 2 565,000 590,000 95.76 5403048A 01-09-19 SILVERSCHOTZ, MARK (TRUSTE 12-07-18 1504 17 2 482,500 503,000 95.92 5395559A 07-30-18 ROMAGNOLI, CARL 07-19-18 5401 7 2 677,600 705,000 96.11 5406226A 04-24-19 ABITINO, DOMINICK 03-09-19 2502 16 2 409,300 425,000 96.31 5403435A 02-13-19 HOWARD, ROBERT & FARINA, G 01-29-19 5500 56 2 573,900 595,000 96.45 5403360A 02-06-19 CECE, WILLIAM & VICKIE 01-29-19 4006 8 2 362,000 375,000 96.53 5403346A 01-23-19 JONES, AMANDA & ROBERT A 01-10-19 203 1.04 2 1,549,000 1,600,000 96.81 5403880A 02-25-19 319 W. NORTHFIELD RD, LLC 02-08-19 5701 1 2 400,000 412,000 97.09 5398006A 08-16-18 FRIEDFERTIG, MARC & JILL 08-07-18 2401 8 2 2,050,000 2,108,000 97.25 5405635A 03-27-19 NORD, SEYMOUR D 03-19-19 4007 5 2 398,800 410,000 97.27

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405258A 03-26-19 WEISBERG, SCOTT & NANCY 06-07-18 202 6 2 1,752,500 1,800,000 97.36 5399170A 09-17-18 FISHER, ALEXANDER 08-18-18 2004 29 2 388,500 399,000 97.37 5404922A 03-15-19 CHU, WEI & CHEN, TING 03-05-19 1602 52 2 385,000 395,000 97.47 5400781A 11-16-18 SHAH, AJIT M & ET AL. 11-09-18 1402 33 2 487,000 499,000 97.60 5403578A 02-19-19 SHAPIRO, B & KALLMUENZER, 02-06-19 1903 8 2 778,000 795,000 97.86 5405631A 03-27-19 MAHLER, ALFRED L 03-13-19 5301 59 2 671,600 685,000 98.04 5406838A 05-01-19 MAO, LIQING 04-22-19 502 4 2 619,900 630,000 98.40 5408593A 06-14-19 DIFALCO, LUCIA 05-02-19 4204 8 2 374,000 379,100 98.65 5407521A 05-24-19 RICHELIEU, ELSIE B 05-17-19 3203 9 2 424,400 430,000 98.70 5398105A 08-21-18 HUGHES, LINDA F 07-27-18 1400 26 2 634,600 642,000 98.85 5409093A 06-24-19 GROSSBARD, ARTHUR & SUSAN 06-19-19 7300 18 2 1,657,800 1,675,000 98.97 5399555A 10-16-18 GOLDMAN, ELLEN 08-29-18 7300 36 2 1,089,000 1,100,000 99.00 5395564A 07-30-18 ANDREASEN, GEORGE C 06-26-18 3900 57 2 450,800 455,000 99.08 5399341A 09-28-18 BROSS, MITCHELL 09-12-18 3000 22 2 351,900 355,000 99.13 5407494A 05-08-19 D'ALISERA, LINDA A 04-24-19 5500 48 2 466,600 470,000 99.28 5404432A 03-07-19 QUIRK, DAMON P 02-18-19 900 72 2 353,200 355,000 99.49 5398545A 08-24-18 PROSICKI, DANIEL J 08-21-18 3902 23 2 372,300 374,000 99.55 5409097A 06-25-19 CHENG, WAI WEI 06-06-19 2301 29 2 1,244,600 1,250,000 99.57 5399987A 11-08-18 MALTZ, ALAN C & JANET L 10-02-18 2400 79 2 1,400,000 1,403,700 99.74 5406214A 04-18-19 RUSSO, BARBARA F 04-12-19 1405 12 2 344,300 345,000 99.80 5399168A 09-14-18 SIMON, SARA 08-14-18 3805 15 2 372,100 370,000 100.57 5399560A 10-18-18 LEE, JOHN JUNE & HYO SEON 10-04-18 5300 24 2 600,000 595,000 100.84 5399552A 10-12-18 OUWERKERK, ANTON VAN 08-30-18 4505 2 2 484,400 480,000 100.92 5394030A 07-13-18 M SHAW AND ASSOCIATES, LLC 06-06-18 7600 15 C014 2 767,800 760,000 101.03 5406828A 04-16-19 DRYLIE, DAVID S & ROBIN L 04-08-19 3202 28 2 444,900 440,000 101.11 5395648A 08-09-18 ZHENG, ANPING 07-20-18 4904 32 2 325,000 320,000 101.56 5395552A 07-26-18 SU, WANG 06-06-18 203 1.05 2 1,475,000 1,450,000 101.72 5405634A 03-27-19 KOZLOWSKY, TIMOTHY S 03-21-19 3202 1 2 432,300 425,000 101.72 5400079A 11-13-18 JANG, KING 10-26-18 4603 1 2 688,700 675,000 102.03 5394106A 07-19-18 BERK, RICHARD & LISA 07-12-18 700 1 2 656,000 642,500 102.10 5399532A 10-04-18 ZACKER, ROBERTA 09-13-18 5001 55 2 628,600 615,000 102.21 5399277A 09-21-18 STEIN, MYRA 09-14-18 2004 77 2 567,700 555,000 102.29 5403362A 02-11-19 MANDEL, ALICE 01-29-19 3502 46 2 555,700 540,000 102.91 5399124A 09-13-18 SMITS, ANNMARIE PALERMO 08-15-18 3302 15 2 669,300 650,000 102.97 5401592A 12-11-18 INDYKE, DARREN & SAIPHER, 11-21-18 107 7.01 C3205 2 388,700 377,500 102.97 5397912A 08-14-18 STEINBERG, LOIS R 07-25-18 3505 25 2 639,300 620,000 103.11 5401599A 12-20-18 CARAVAGGIO, MARSHA 11-30-18 402 14 2 753,400 730,000 103.21 5399541A 10-09-18 SILKES, FRANCES 09-20-18 3203 46 2 516,500 500,000 103.30 5401337A 12-03-18 ROBINSON, LOUIS R. 11-20-18 1303 74 2 352,000 340,000 103.53 5395649A 08-09-18 SUNDSTROM, DOROTHY 07-19-18 1504 1 2 414,400 400,000 103.60 5407492A 05-07-19 GRECO, JOHN R & BARRANTES, 03-18-19 2704 3 2 637,400 615,000 103.64 5407487A 05-02-19 BURDETTE, IAN C. & JAMIE R 04-24-19 200 4.02 2 1,533,700 1,475,000 103.98 5406837A 05-01-19 ZHENG, CHENG 04-15-19 3702 15 2 447,700 430,000 104.12 5399023A 09-07-18 TEISCH, VIRGINIA R 08-30-18 2503 20 2 433,400 415,000 104.43 5404926A 03-18-19 SEKULA, ROBERT & SEKULA 02-27-19 2602 36 2 444,500 425,000 104.59 5407523A 05-30-19 HONG, PAN YUK & KWOK CHUAN 05-22-19 1700 66 2 615,700 585,000 105.25

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 8 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 10 LIVINGSTON TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5398001A 08-14-18 SORIN, ROBERT M & PHYLLIS 08-03-18 5001 57 2 732,100 695,000 105.34 5403047A 01-08-19 ZOLLO, ANGELO S 12-05-18 3809 13 2 425,000 402,000 105.72 5398551A 08-28-18 ZIMBARDI, MARY JANE 08-14-18 1307 21 2 758,000 715,000 106.01 5401330A 11-27-18 WOOD, LAURA & PASTER, DONN 11-13-18 1604 27 2 392,800 370,000 106.16 5408235F 06-10-19 GIUDICE, INCORONATA & ET A 05-28-19 4303 12 2 383,600 360,000 106.56 5404434A 03-11-19 GERMANSKY, MITCHELL B (T 02-28-19 1103 10 2 390,000 365,000 106.85 5395579A 08-03-18 SINDER, STUART J 07-21-18 7105 2 2 912,900 850,000 107.40 5406217A 04-23-19 SIEGEL, MICHAEL ALAN & LOI 04-08-19 3505 6 2 521,400 485,000 107.51 5408240F 06-12-19 GLASSER, DANIEL 05-22-19 107 7.01 C5406 2 388,700 360,000 107.97 5399976A 10-31-18 GREENE, ALAN 10-12-18 1501.9 1 2 782,900 725,000 107.99 5399983A 11-07-18 LATA, YERUVA MOKSHA & KAMB 10-26-18 6101 19 2 815,500 750,000 108.73 5408236A 06-10-19 CELLER, PAUL & MIRTHA 05-16-19 2104 2 2 2,330,200 2,140,000 108.89 5399537A 10-09-18 KIM, YOO HWA & ROY NAM 09-26-18 3305 15 2 625,100 573,400 109.02 5403361A 02-07-19 GATHERINGHILL PROPERTIES L 12-06-18 301 42 2 600,800 550,000 109.24 5409501A 06-27-19 CHAE, YOUNG SOO & SCOTT SU 06-13-19 2100 68.10 2 1,799,000 1,625,000 110.71 5394102A 07-18-18 BLUEWATER INVESTMENT TRUST 05-24-18 3203 14 2 411,000 371,000 110.78 5403049A 01-09-19 WROBEL HOME BUILDERS, LLC. 01-02-19 1402 20 2 383,500 345,000 111.16 5401591F 12-10-18 FEINBERG, LARRY & JULIE 11-30-18 5001 26 2 734,100 660,000 111.23 5395550A 07-26-18 GRAFAS, STAVROLULA 07-16-18 4800 30 2 428,600 380,000 112.79 5407504A 05-15-19 STERN, LORI 05-10-19 1801 9 2 641,800 567,500 113.09 5401120A 11-26-18 CHUNG, MOON HYOON 11-08-18 2906 56 2 778,700 685,000 113.68 5399270A 09-19-18 SOKOL, WENDY B & CESARI, C 09-11-18 7101 11 2 897,000 775,000 115.74 5405859A 04-03-19 JOHNSTON, JAMES P 03-22-19 1103 17 2 464,800 400,000 116.20 5401589A 11-29-18 FINK, PETER & ROBIN 11-09-18 1508 11 2 380,100 325,000 116.95 5407503A 05-15-19 PRINCE, DARREN 05-07-19 1501.5 5 2 680,100 575,000 118.28 5403340A 01-02-19 GRUBE, DIANE L 12-11-18 2906 1 2 345,700 290,000 119.21 5400075A 09-19-18 DA SILVA, MANUEL M & MARIA 09-12-18 4505 52 2 341,600 285,000 119.86 5407517A 05-23-19 MULLIN, JOSEPH T. 05-09-19 6001 51 2 468,900 390,000 120.23 5404924F 03-18-19 MCKENNA, KAREN RUTH (TRUST 02-28-19 2602 42 2 394,400 325,000 121.35 5407498F 05-09-19 GUERRERO, CARMEN 05-03-19 2301 21 2 1,450,000 1,175,000 123.40 YEAR TO DATE 352 209,688,200 236,141,715 31,453.71 5395647F 08-08-18 340 EAST NORTHFIELD ROAD L 08-01-18 7600 1 C002B 4A 408,000 575,000 70.96 5407502F 05-15-19 KRAMERS REALTY LLC, 04-03-19 3700 3 4A 560,000 525,000 106.67 5401600F 12-20-18 VIOLA HOLTZ FAMILY LP 12-03-18 3700 30 4A 7,500,000 6,600,000 113.64 YEAR TO DATE 3 8,468,000 7,700,000 291.27 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 355 218,156,200 243,841,715 31,744.98

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407536A 06-03-19 FERNANDES, THOMAS G 05-29-19 7.08 371 2 495,300 901,000 54.97 5398012A 09-07-18 PEASE, MICHAEL 08-29-18 24.08 286.05 2 717,500 1,305,000 54.98 5407114A 05-09-19 TREZZA, MARTIN 05-02-19 45.05 256 2 243,800 430,000 56.70 5401934A 12-10-18 DILUZIO, RODOLFO & ET AL. 11-08-18 45.03 137 2 262,000 443,000 59.14 5407126A 05-20-19 22 YALE LLC, 05-15-19 28.06 102 2 500,800 840,000 59.62 5408250A 06-17-19 DREYER, JOHN R 05-31-19 5.01 5 C0703 2 747,900 1,250,000 59.83 5406247A 04-15-19 ALI, HAWA O. 03-28-19 31.34 74 2 295,000 485,000 60.82 5407525A 04-24-19 LEE WEI-CHIH C & CALINA M 04-18-19 46.01 198.02 2 279,200 425,000 65.69 5405063A 03-21-19 CLESCA, CINDY F 02-14-19 45.03 115 2 293,900 445,000 66.04 5406270A 04-30-19 PENG, MINZHONG & CHEN, LIN 04-23-19 31.05 21 2 341,200 510,000 66.90 5408112A 06-13-19 PAWLICKI, DANA C & AMY R 05-04-19 24.08 286.04 2 640,900 949,000 67.53 5405064A 03-21-19 TRUS HOLDINGS LLC, 03-12-19 29.03 450 2 275,300 405,000 67.98 5408111A 06-13-19 CLEARVIEW EQUITIES LLC 05-30-19 29.15 158 2 271,900 400,000 67.98 5398110A 09-26-18 WILKERSON, ALICIA 09-11-18 46.02 229 C0006 2 201,500 295,000 68.31 5401831A 12-03-18 PORTER, RONALD E 11-01-18 12.06 233 2 614,800 900,000 68.31 5407131A 05-23-19 HEBER, MARGARETE ANN 05-17-19 29.13 45 2 240,900 350,000 68.83 5397686A 08-24-18 HENIGAN, PATRICK 08-17-18 26.05 106 2 609,500 885,000 68.87 5407110A 05-09-19 TORREY, DANIEL R. & JESSE 04-24-19 10.01 194 2 849,300 1,220,000 69.61 5409237A 06-27-19 LACHOWSKI, ZBINGIEW SR. & 06-18-19 29.16 179 2 278,600 400,000 69.65 5408707A 06-18-19 MILANO, GREGORY & EDITH & 05-30-19 44.02 118 C0361 2 147,400 209,000 70.53 5397693A 08-30-18 BECK, GORDON & KING, JUSTI 08-21-18 13.03 242 2 600,500 850,000 70.65 5404245A 02-28-19 SINGH, ANAND 02-22-19 47.02 219 2 320,500 450,000 71.22 5407527A 05-28-19 BEHRLE, WOLFGANG 05-15-19 16.03 141 2 570,000 800,000 71.25 5403600A 02-06-19 ORPHANIDIS, P & HARPER, H 02-01-19 47.04 156 2 375,000 525,000 71.43 5406229A 04-03-19 MATTHEWS, KAREN & WILLIAM 03-29-19 42.02 39 C0001 2 168,000 235,000 71.49 5408245A 06-17-19 SIMMONDS, DUVAL & SUZANNE 04-12-19 29.02 497 2 321,800 450,000 71.51 5406228A 04-03-19 DE OLIVEIRA, IVONE 03-22-19 43.05 41 2 300,800 420,000 71.62 5406269A 04-29-19 JERSEY CAPITAL GROUP LLC 04-17-19 49.14 38 2 308,300 430,000 71.70 5407557A 06-12-19 SOLANO, TAMARA 05-21-19 48.47 25 C0014 2 139,500 194,500 71.72 5405425A 04-02-19 WHITE, BRIAN & REGAN 03-26-19 38.01 253.01 2 389,700 540,000 72.17 5406239A 04-10-19 CASSERLY, MICHAEL F & DENI 04-05-19 24.08 286.07 2 577,400 800,000 72.18 5397278A 07-30-18 DESIENA, ROSE CAMPESI 07-30-18 21.02 327 2 324,900 450,000 72.20 5400787A 07-26-18 MORALES, ANDRE GUERRA 06-23-18 33.02 215 2 660,700 915,000 72.21 5407554A 06-10-19 15 YANTECAW LLC, 06-03-19 47.02 269 2 278,000 385,000 72.21 5407526A 05-01-19 27 HOFFMAN ST LLC, 02-25-19 15.03 211 2 547,500 755,000 72.52 5403581A 01-18-19 NANCE, JAMES R & TISA 12-28-18 24.05 14 2 376,600 515,000 73.13 5406278A 05-06-19 SHIRES, JEREMY 04-26-19 38.01 292.01 2 367,000 501,000 73.25 5397006A 07-27-18 WEBER, ROBERT C 07-13-18 24.02 175 2 441,900 602,000 73.41 5408252A 06-17-19 MCEWAN, WENDY J 06-05-19 49.15 74 2 371,300 505,000 73.52 5408710A 06-20-19 MARVIN, MICHAEL & FORSTELL 06-13-19 49.08 351 2 286,400 389,000 73.62 5401941A 12-18-18 GRIES, SCOTT D 11-28-18 8.10 197 2 584,300 790,000 73.96 5397690A 08-28-18 HENIGE, BRETT 08-20-18 28.05 159 2 499,400 675,000 73.99 5406281A 05-07-19 MCNEIL, GREGORY & MONIQUE 04-25-19 24.08 279 2 707,100 955,000 74.04 5398020A 09-17-18 NELSON, JACK 09-06-18 26.05 105 2 667,700 900,542 74.14 5404066A 02-28-19 185 LEXINGTON LLC, 02-25-19 29.10 369 2 449,800 605,100 74.33 5407124A 05-20-19 PAL, MARTIN & PALOVA, LUCI 04-17-19 26.01 3 2 476,900 641,000 74.40

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5408247A 06-17-19 AMC INVESTMENTS LLC, 05-29-19 47.01 215 2 253,000 340,000 74.41 5398121A 10-02-18 JOHNSON, DREW M 09-05-18 35.01 174 2 399,300 535,000 74.64 5408246A 06-17-19 RANN, TYLER & ELIZABETH 06-03-19 14.02 228 2 548,800 731,500 75.02 5398113A 09-27-18 COMMUNITY ASSET PRESERVATI 09-04-18 46.04 302 2 247,700 330,000 75.06 5407529A 05-28-19 GARLAND,WILLIAM J & CLAIRE 05-10-19 8.08 209 2 976,200 1,300,000 75.09 5406238A 04-10-19 MATTSON, TYLER & COCUZZA,M 04-02-19 46.03 12 2 305,300 405,000 75.38 5407316A 05-22-19 WALTERS, KAREN Z & BRIAN L 05-14-19 28.08 59 2 567,500 752,500 75.42 5408244A 06-11-19 ENGSTROM,JESSICA L & OTIEN 05-17-19 43.42 17 2 431,500 570,000 75.70 5398557A 10-17-18 WIESE, ELLEN 10-15-18 26.03 64 2 424,100 560,000 75.73 5397702A 09-06-18 BAKER, JAMES 08-30-18 33.02 211 2 542,200 715,000 75.83 5405420A 03-28-19 PETERSON, EDWARD J. 03-21-19 38.01 259 2 481,900 635,000 75.89 5402157A 12-20-18 REIS, MARK L 12-15-18 10.02 144 2 928,000 1,220,000 76.07 5408901A 06-19-19 MCNEELY, JAMES H & MARIE 06-13-19 33.04 11 2 464,900 611,000 76.09 5404240A 11-09-18 SHIRES, JEREMY 10-05-18 49.05 630.01 2 316,500 415,000 76.27 5401614A 11-16-18 CROWDER,THOMAS M+MYERS,JAM 11-13-18 8.08 220 2 928,400 1,215,000 76.41 5408241A 06-11-19 CORR, GAVAN & AVEEN 06-04-19 14.15 313 2 619,900 810,000 76.53 5406280A 05-06-19 WALTERS, EPSEY MERIWETHER 04-30-19 21.02 286 2 469,200 611,000 76.79 5402800A 01-10-19 BARFOED, THOMAS 12-05-18 25.01 29 2 599,100 780,000 76.81 5404282A 03-06-19 CHINA, DARREN & JULIA 01-18-19 49.11 158 2 339,000 441,000 76.87 5396788A 07-20-18 MESSNER, GEORGE U III 06-21-18 18.01 244 2 654,300 850,000 76.98 5409235A 06-27-19 GOMEZ, VICTOR A. & NOREEN 06-24-19 14.15 293 2 800,900 1,039,500 77.05 5405065A 03-21-19 PALMER, FRANCIS 03-15-19 33.01 304.01 2 450,200 584,000 77.09 5397002A 07-27-18 PIETRYCHA, THOMAS 07-19-18 35.01 198 2 380,200 493,000 77.12 5407537A 06-03-19 KLAESSON, TORE 05-22-19 14.03 84 2 655,600 850,000 77.13 5406241A 04-11-19 REVIS, JUDITH Y 04-08-19 46.03 5 2 305,300 395,000 77.29 5398563T 10-23-18 WADE, KATHLEEN O & GARRY S 10-12-18 32.04 149.01 2 521,900 675,000 77.32 5404441A 03-11-19 LEFEVERE, JIMMY 03-01-19 26.04 113 2 523,300 676,101 77.40 5405062A 03-21-19 DAVIS, DIANE 03-14-19 27.01 98 2 524,600 677,077 77.48 5405261A 03-22-19 CHIESA, PIERINA 03-12-19 16.01 25 C0303 2 137,800 177,500 77.63 5397464A 08-20-18 TORRE, MARK 08-08-18 14.03 20 2 595,300 766,500 77.66 5393257A 07-09-18 PEEK, DANIEL 06-28-18 10.02 150 2 992,800 1,275,000 77.87 5403586A 01-23-19 GORMAN, MICHAEL E & ANNE T 01-09-19 10.04 69 2 872,800 1,120,000 77.93 5406264A 04-25-19 TEMPLIN, NEAL A & CLARISSA 04-18-19 11.05 101 2 569,100 730,000 77.96 5405059A 03-19-19 DALL, ROBERT J. & CHRISTIN 03-11-19 22.02 63 2 523,300 671,150 77.97 5407117A 05-13-19 CALANDRA, ROBERT 05-06-19 21.04 99 2 390,200 500,000 78.04 5397680A 08-22-18 JILLARD, ERIC & BLACK, MEA 07-27-18 13.06 85 2 722,200 925,000 78.08 5397293A 08-08-18 WEDMID, ANATOLE 07-27-18 15.02 41 2 602,500 770,000 78.25 5402795A 01-03-19 SPENCER, BEVERLY 12-28-18 46.01 206 2 322,500 410,000 78.66 5407134A 05-23-19 BUTZ, NORBERT LEO & MICHEL 05-20-19 24.08 288.01 2 551,600 700,000 78.80 5396830A 07-24-18 SHAY, MINTZE 07-12-18 23.05 323 2 711,200 900,000 79.02 5405418A 03-27-19 SCHUPPE, JONATHAN T 03-22-19 22.01 35 2 523,600 662,000 79.09 5406277A 05-02-19 JACQUES, E & PHILLIPPE, C 04-12-19 46.01 274 2 253,100 320,000 79.09 5397295A 08-09-18 WARZOCHA, FRANK J 07-30-18 49.08 357 2 317,200 399,999 79.30 5397283A 08-01-18 CRIMMINS, TIMOTHY 07-12-18 26.01 5 2 524,600 660,000 79.48 5406284A 05-10-19 QUINN, JOHN & COURTNEY RAE 04-30-19 32.03 109 2 716,100 898,100 79.73 5406268A 04-29-19 48 HUGHES MAPLES NJ LLC 04-16-19 47.02 232 2 312,100 391,000 79.82

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401615A 11-19-18 GIBBONS, MOLLIE 10-30-18 16.01 25 C0604 2 151,800 190,000 79.89 5404438A 03-08-19 KRISHNAPPA, RITESHA 03-01-19 33.01 136 2 556,000 696,000 79.89 5398441A 10-12-18 ZAHOR, LYNDA 09-28-18 10.01 201 2 678,300 847,500 80.04 5400792A 10-29-18 SIMPSON, GERALDINE 10-25-18 45.03 141 2 296,200 370,000 80.05 5397455A 08-15-18 SCHWARTZ, YANIV SCHAHAR 08-01-18 31.34 188 2 513,500 641,000 80.11 5396456A 07-13-18 PICCOLA, LAWRENCE L JR 07-02-18 35.05 64 2 497,700 620,000 80.27 5406235A 04-08-19 KRAUS, GEORGE & COLLEEN 03-27-19 10.06 55 2 931,700 1,160,000 80.32 5406253A 04-17-19 JOHNSON, HOWARD & GALE 03-14-19 13.06 99 2 662,600 825,000 80.32 5407552A 06-10-19 CORLISS, MARC 05-29-19 49.03 551 2 399,400 495,000 80.69 5407127A 05-20-19 GURTMAN, JEFFREY & JESSICA 05-15-19 14.03 2 2 609,600 755,000 80.74 5396780A 07-17-18 BUTZ, NORBERT & FEDERER,M 06-28-18 22.01 5.01 2 426,400 528,000 80.76 5408709A 06-20-19 BAKER, COREY 05-30-19 44.03 180 C2871 2 129,300 160,000 80.81 5407533A 05-31-19 HAWKINS, LILLIAN & ROSE, J 05-23-19 24.08 291 2 546,100 675,000 80.90 5398109A 09-24-18 HORCASITAS, CARLOS MANUEL 09-06-18 38.02 227 2 489,500 605,000 80.91 5397284A 08-03-18 ARMENTROUT, BRIAN 07-26-18 22.03 265 2 616,600 762,000 80.92 5407543A 06-05-19 HARTKERN, DAVID T & MEADE, 05-14-19 25.02 46 2 635,200 785,000 80.92 5400796A 10-31-18 SHERMAN, DONOVAN 10-17-18 24.11 37.01 2 429,600 530,000 81.06 5406271A 04-30-19 HERBERT, CYNTHIA 04-17-19 42.01 52 2 259,500 320,000 81.09 5408243A 06-11-19 MARTIN, PAUL P & VALERIE 05-30-19 33.02 213 2 524,900 647,000 81.13 5403599A 02-06-19 CRAIG, DAVID 02-01-19 44.02 118 C1562 2 130,000 160,000 81.25 5400803A 11-07-18 BRIEDIS, AUSMA M 10-01-18 47.01 172.02 2 138,600 170,000 81.53 5403601A 02-06-19 JANTELLE, CHARLES A 01-18-19 32.03 108 2 455,800 559,000 81.54 5400797A 10-31-18 64A PLUS LLC, 10-25-18 44.02 118 C0070 2 195,900 240,000 81.63 5407113A 05-09-19 BARKIN, JOEL & CHERYL 05-03-19 22.02 252 2 528,200 645,999 81.76 5406272A 04-30-19 EVANS, REESE 03-12-19 16.03 145 2 774,200 946,400 81.80 5406236A 04-09-19 MEERE, BRIAN F & WERNER 12-31-18 26.01 25 2 509,300 622,000 81.88 5403064A 01-11-19 HOLT, JOSEPH J 12-12-18 15.03 214 2 590,700 720,000 82.04 5404439A 03-11-19 ODLE, JUSTIN OMAR 02-25-19 44.03 180 C2891 2 125,200 152,575 82.06 5408900A 06-19-19 SANICHAR, PREMIE 05-29-19 38.01 211 2 314,800 380,000 82.84 5401619A 11-21-18 SMITH, JERRY L 10-11-18 26.04 114 2 463,400 559,000 82.90 5398437A 10-09-18 SEIDMAN, SUSAN & TORRES-FE 10-01-18 44.03 180 C0392 2 153,500 185,000 82.97 5405061A 03-20-19 GOLDSTEIN, MARK S 02-22-19 26.07 145 2 510,800 612,000 83.46 5409234A 06-27-19 HAFNER, LARRY 06-06-19 46.01 194 2 313,300 375,000 83.55 5405419A 03-28-19 JACOBS, JUSTIN & DANNA 03-18-19 19.20 82 2 588,000 703,450 83.59 5403610A 02-15-19 ROTH, JARRET & BARKLEY, DA 01-22-19 14.15 148 2 775,800 925,000 83.87 5403062A 01-10-19 KINGSLEY, JEFFREY 01-07-19 15.02 25 2 756,700 902,000 83.89 5407553A 06-10-19 DEDDENS, MARGARET K 06-02-19 7.08 212 2 882,500 1,050,000 84.05 5397019A 08-14-18 BROSIUS, BRINTON & ANTHONY 07-18-18 13.08 16 2 1,514,300 1,800,000 84.13 5397288A 08-03-18 NAG, SAGARNIL 06-18-18 10.08 21 2 1,111,200 1,320,000 84.18 5405424A 04-01-19 DURR, BETSY L & ROBERT J 03-19-19 13.05 103 2 610,700 725,000 84.23 5408902A 06-21-19 DAMENS, JEFFREY 06-13-19 14.15 325 2 725,700 859,000 84.48 5393259A 07-10-18 HEISCHUBER, MYRNA & PAUL 06-29-18 8.10 166 2 598,600 705,000 84.91 5397462A 08-20-18 RADONCIC, NEJAD 08-03-18 32.03 106 2 528,400 622,000 84.95 5398562A 10-22-18 CHILSTROM, BUENA H 10-07-18 8.09 177 2 876,600 1,031,000 85.02 5397465A 08-21-18 MCDANIEL, NICHOLE 08-01-18 21.06 161 2 374,400 440,000 85.09 5409231A 06-24-19 HERZFELD, CHARLES 05-30-19 22.01 7.01 2 525,200 617,000 85.12

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401347A 11-09-18 GUEVARA, ASHFORD 10-03-18 42.06 228 2 340,800 400,000 85.20 5403775F 02-26-19 BOYLE, JODI B (ADMIN) 01-28-19 44.03 180 C0671 2 157,800 185,000 85.30 5398561A 10-22-18 CRAWFORD, MARK & ERIKA 09-17-18 30.03 89 2 452,600 530,000 85.40 5409394A 06-27-19 PORES, BETH M. 06-06-19 23.05 11 2 759,500 889,000 85.43 5397699A 09-04-18 BARTON, BRUCE 08-20-18 22.01 33 2 513,300 600,000 85.55 5407112A 05-09-19 KELLER, MICHAEL B. & JENNI 04-13-19 32.04 115 2 565,500 660,000 85.68 5407528A 05-28-19 FAUSEL, DAVID C & REBECCA 05-19-19 5.02 9.01 2 775,400 905,000 85.68 5400800A 11-02-18 FLOYD, CAMERON & LINDA 10-18-18 14.15 135 2 685,200 799,000 85.76 5400788A 10-26-18 ARNOLD, MICHAEL & DAVENPOR 10-14-18 31.02 204 2 579,200 675,000 85.81 5398018A 09-12-18 SHELBY, KATHLEEN M (TR) 08-27-18 25.01 16 2 590,700 688,000 85.86 5393249A 07-05-18 HOLLISTER, PAUL 06-29-18 33.01 124.01 2 542,100 630,000 86.05 5397692A 08-29-18 STAMM, NATHAN 08-20-18 15.07 327 2 475,100 552,000 86.07 5398559A 10-18-18 PITKOFF, RONI 10-09-18 6.02 10 2 771,000 895,000 86.15 5397681A 08-22-18 KROLL, DAVID N & KATHLEEN 04-20-18 32.03 50.01 2 694,900 805,000 86.32 5409395A 06-28-19 SPARKS, JOSHUA 06-13-19 36.02 272 2 479,100 555,000 86.32 5397684A 08-23-18 FOX, SELENA JILL 08-17-18 35.01 175 2 449,900 520,000 86.52 5404597A 03-13-19 LUEBKE, TAYLOR E 01-13-19 22.03 263 2 787,900 910,000 86.58 5401943A 12-18-18 PAGANINI, CHRISTOPHER G 12-07-18 8.07 6 2 651,100 750,000 86.81 5404063A 02-28-19 PRIME INVESTORS INC, 02-21-19 15.06 220 2 695,000 799,000 86.98 5403608A 02-14-19 LYNCH, ELIZABETH W & ET AL 01-30-19 19.02 62 2 532,200 611,000 87.10 5393263A 07-13-18 MC CALL, ERIN M 06-15-18 8.10 408 2 645,200 740,000 87.19 5398560A 10-18-18 MC EVOY, BRIAN 10-05-18 7.08 382 2 636,500 730,000 87.19 5396455A 07-13-18 FARLEY, KATHERINE M 06-23-18 14.03 8 2 592,500 679,000 87.26 5406266A 04-26-19 BRIER, STEVEN & ELLEN 04-15-19 30.01 35 2 497,300 569,000 87.40 5397287A 08-03-18 SONNEMAN, CHRISTOPHER 06-29-18 33.04 18 2 518,500 593,000 87.44 5407535A 06-03-19 OLIVERO, MARK & STEPHANIE 04-25-19 14.03 30 2 831,000 950,000 87.47 5397697A 09-04-18 CRANDALL, ELIZABETH J 07-31-18 26.01 30 2 525,600 600,000 87.60 5397701A 09-05-18 SMITH, MARK 08-30-18 38.03 135 2 313,400 357,500 87.66 5406242A 04-11-19 HAVIV, SHLOMO & BEEN, JANE 04-03-19 9.03 13 2 676,100 770,000 87.81 5396782A 07-18-18 TILLEY, JANNIE 07-13-18 47.03 57 2 309,900 352,605 87.89 5398440A 10-12-18 MUENCH, KEVIN F 09-11-18 23.05 22 2 766,900 872,500 87.90 5398010A 09-06-18 STONE, TUCKER 06-27-18 24.04 134 2 479,900 545,000 88.06 5398024A 09-21-18 COSGROVE, CONSTANCE E 08-31-18 38.06 91 2 369,900 420,000 88.07 5393254A 07-06-18 PISANI, DAVID 06-25-18 10.06 61 2 1,131,800 1,285,000 88.08 5407129A 05-23-19 RODGERS, IDA L 04-02-19 49.02 489 2 299,700 340,000 88.15 5407555A 06-10-19 SOHR, KIRK W & CLAUDIA W 05-22-19 15.05 161 2 630,900 715,000 88.24 5401945A 12-19-18 TRANSIT-ORIENTED PROPERTIE 10-23-18 16.01 25 C0406 2 237,400 269,000 88.25 5396779A 07-16-18 DEAN, CHRISTOPHER & JADE 07-09-18 6.03 30 2 794,400 900,000 88.27 5407551A 06-10-19 TANHOFF, HOPE 05-28-19 7.04 82 2 618,100 700,000 88.30 5398014A 09-11-18 GEFFEN, ZVEE 09-06-18 27.02 86 2 577,000 652,330 88.45 5405056A 03-18-19 HACKLER, KYLE E & BERNADET 03-14-19 21.03 56 2 451,400 510,000 88.51 5404248A 03-05-19 PETGRAVE, KIRK 02-22-19 31.03 248 2 504,800 570,000 88.56 5406251A 04-16-19 PETERS, JONATHAN B & MARGA 04-08-19 23.02 148 2 929,500 1,049,000 88.61 5401862A 12-03-18 SCHNEIDER, STEVEN 11-26-18 6.03 173 2 673,700 760,000 88.64 5401617A 11-19-18 COUILLARD, RACHEL 11-05-18 7.08 386 2 604,000 681,100 88.68 5408706A 06-17-19 GAMBINO, FRANK & DANA 06-03-19 26.04 74 2 501,500 565,000 88.76

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5398117A 09-28-18 MATTERS, CRAIG 09-25-18 27.04 44 2 599,500 675,000 88.81 5404246A 03-01-19 ROSENBAUM, SHLOMOH 02-22-19 28.07 141 2 439,700 495,000 88.83 5403773A 02-25-19 GONZALEZ, JOSE & RACHEL 02-18-19 43.02 140 2 347,800 390,000 89.18 5397001A 07-27-18 HALL, NICHOLAS D 05-24-18 13.07 43 C0001 2 428,200 480,000 89.21 5403587A 01-24-19 EDSHI MANAGEMENT LLC, 01-18-19 47.01 196 2 356,500 399,000 89.35 5409233A 06-24-19 DO, DZU 06-17-19 10.04 78.01 2 699,300 782,500 89.37 5397008A 07-27-18 CASERTA, MARIO 07-19-18 11.01 60 2 760,900 850,000 89.52 5407128A 05-21-19 CHRISTIE, BRYAN D 05-13-19 28.03 173 2 540,200 603,000 89.59 5397461A 08-20-18 COLLEY, JEREMY H 08-15-18 24.06 242 2 895,800 999,000 89.67 5400802A 11-05-18 BLUMBERG, JESSICA 10-16-18 27.02 90.01 2 521,900 581,000 89.83 5404533A 03-12-19 MARABUTO, FAUSTINO 03-07-19 45.01 441 2 368,500 410,000 89.88 5407548A 06-06-19 MINERLEY, GLENN & JOANNA 05-21-19 25.06 130 2 656,100 730,000 89.88 5406233A 04-05-19 PIERSON, PAUL & LANZARA, A 03-23-19 38.04 139 2 463,200 515,000 89.94 5404595A 03-13-19 OWUSU, FOSTER & WUSU, MIST 01-11-19 46.01 198 2 346,400 385,000 89.97 5401349A 11-13-18 EDDY, MATTHEW PAUL 10-30-18 32.03 51 2 585,400 650,000 90.06 5398017A 09-12-18 GERSON, JOSHUA & JENNY 08-23-18 28.03 201 2 523,300 580,000 90.22 5396828A 07-23-18 HAAVIE, ROBERT & KEHOE, AM 07-09-18 36.04 81 2 505,400 560,000 90.25 5397291A 08-07-18 KARL, BRENDA M 07-26-18 21.06 154 2 475,400 524,900 90.57 5407550A 06-10-19 PARKS, ANDREW & JANET S 05-22-19 8.10 178 2 670,200 740,000 90.57 5407532A 05-29-19 ROY,MATTHEW M & CULBERSTON 05-10-19 6.03 31 2 625,000 690,000 90.58 5397698A 09-04-18 SARNO, GENEVIEVE 08-24-18 42.11 336 2 267,800 295,000 90.78 5396790A 08-01-18 PLEVINSKY, TODD P 07-15-18 6.01 19 2 763,000 839,000 90.94 5401940A 12-18-18 NAVLEN, LEE 12-07-18 7.07 16 2 578,600 635,000 91.12 5407115A 05-09-19 ENSIGN, CHESTER & HUBER, M 05-07-19 27.02 66 2 656,100 720,000 91.13 5401928A 12-04-18 WOLF, ALAN 11-19-18 27.07 58 2 511,100 560,000 91.27 5401348A 11-13-18 SORIANO, CHRISTOPHER 11-01-18 23.05 29 2 1,225,300 1,340,000 91.44 5407120A 05-14-19 RHODES, FREDERICK P 04-29-19 38.07 99 2 521,600 570,000 91.51 5397007A 07-27-18 STERN, MARC 07-05-18 24.08 290 2 494,500 539,900 91.59 5397292A 08-08-18 WEINSHEIMER, ANDREA 07-27-18 49.15 58 X 2 293,200 320,000 91.63 5404243A 02-14-19 CASAL, MARCELINO 01-23-19 10.01 211 2 595,600 650,000 91.63 5407538A 06-04-19 CORT, JEFFREY C & ELIZABET 05-08-19 19.20 72 2 523,500 570,000 91.84 5393251A 07-06-18 QUAGLIA, ROCCO 06-20-18 15.03 114 2 645,400 701,000 92.07 5398389A 10-04-18 COHN, DAVID 09-12-18 6.01 15 2 772,200 837,500 92.20 5397676A 08-21-18 BESADAR LLC, 08-14-18 49.09 392 2 307,100 333,000 92.22 5397285A 08-03-18 TAZEWELL, JOSEPH L 07-23-18 8.10 405 2 600,700 650,000 92.42 5402160A 12-24-18 MOREY, ROBIN W 12-14-18 28.04 27 2 529,100 572,500 92.42 5407122A 05-16-19 BRAGG, GAIL 04-29-19 35.06 21 2 496,800 535,000 92.86 5403770A 02-22-19 TERTUS, RODRIGUE & MARIE 01-10-19 38.06 62 2 455,300 490,000 92.92 5401624A 11-30-18 EDWARDS, ALETHIA C 11-14-18 47.01 217 2 267,200 287,300 93.00 5401616A 11-19-18 NIGARA, PATRICIA K. 11-09-18 44.02 118 C0150 2 139,500 149,750 93.16 5393243A 07-02-18 LYON, DAVID & LYZA 06-06-18 43.42 252.01 2 363,400 390,000 93.18 5393248A 07-05-18 SMITH, LEE N 06-27-18 8.06 23 2 694,600 745,000 93.23 5402158A 12-21-18 MARABLE, VALERIE 12-13-18 49.14 7 C0008 2 251,900 270,000 93.30 5403611A 02-15-19 SHIBER, DAN & LIMA, ANNADA 02-07-19 14.15 139 2 610,300 653,000 93.46 5401937A 12-11-18 MOORE, KENNETH C & SANDRA 11-30-18 49.12 225 2 298,800 319,500 93.52 5396998A 07-25-18 DAVIO, PETER JOSEPH & KELY 06-30-18 38.07 99 2 521,600 557,000 93.64

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400805A 11-07-18 SUN, JORGE A 11-02-18 27.01 97 2 561,300 599,000 93.71 5396359A 09-17-18 WINTER, DANIEL I 06-26-18 6.01 180 2 963,000 1,025,000 93.95 5397683A 08-23-18 WULACH, JAMES S 08-20-18 23.04 291 2 683,700 727,500 93.98 5401931A 12-06-18 GARDNER, WILLIAM B JR & MA 11-03-18 28.04 20 2 564,300 599,000 94.21 5403585A 01-23-19 ENGLISH, JACK L 01-11-19 14.03 65 2 647,600 687,000 94.26 5407121A 05-16-19 ATANASIO, JOSEPH F. & MIRI 05-03-19 6.01 168 2 594,900 630,000 94.43 5407130A 05-23-19 32 LEO PL CAPITAL, LLC 05-17-19 42.11 364 2 326,000 345,000 94.49 5393255A 07-06-18 EVANS, ROGER L 06-19-18 22.05 89 2 497,800 526,500 94.55 5407119A 05-13-19 OLIN, DIRK D & GILLIGAN, J 05-04-19 23.04 295 2 657,500 695,000 94.60 5396454A 07-12-18 LOUNSBURY, JEFFREY & ET AL 06-27-18 7.08 383 2 639,200 675,000 94.70 5396999A 07-25-18 KOHN, STUART & AMY B SALOM 07-11-18 30.01 38 2 545,800 576,000 94.76 5406234A 04-08-19 GIST, ROBERT F & BARBARA B 04-01-19 7.06 35 2 603,200 635,000 94.99 5403590A 01-25-19 KING, RONALD & MORCILLO, G 12-28-18 35.06 15 2 532,800 560,000 95.14 5396452A 07-12-18 KAPLOWITZ, ZACHARY & MOLNA 06-15-18 44.03 180 C0672 2 163,000 170,000 95.88 5401936A 12-11-18 CIRRI, MATTHEW P & SMITH, 11-28-18 21.02 47 2 561,000 584,000 96.06 5400798A 10-31-18 RAKOWSKY, IHOR 10-17-18 31.04 262 2 650,000 676,000 96.15 5403592A 02-01-19 MARKOWITZ, LYNN 06-29-18 13.07 43 C0002 2 437,900 455,000 96.24 5397296A 08-09-18 PERKINS, CURTIS 07-31-18 25.02 74 2 563,500 585,000 96.32 5407314A 05-22-19 KANE, MATTHEW J & SARA M 05-14-19 8.06 2 2 800,000 830,000 96.39 5397286A 08-03-18 FERRIS, JAMES 06-22-18 42.43 204 2 321,100 333,000 96.43 5397290A 08-07-18 MOORE, SONIA J 08-02-18 31.03 244 2 685,600 710,000 96.56 5400789A 10-26-18 MELE, VINCENT & JOHN & MIC 04-18-18 35.04 143 2 422,300 435,000 97.08 5396781A 07-18-18 VINCI, ANTHONY JOHN 06-11-18 13.07 41 2 873,200 899,000 97.13 5396776A 07-13-18 EUBANKS, MARLENE R 06-28-18 8.01 54 2 607,300 625,000 97.17 5401929A 12-05-18 BRESSON, RACHEL & RICHARD 11-29-18 43.04 223 2 370,000 380,000 97.37 5407125A 05-20-19 ELLIS, TIMOTHY TODD 05-15-19 6.02 195 2 973,700 999,000 97.47 5397704A 09-06-18 PRESTON, HILARY 08-29-18 8.04 321 2 1,197,400 1,225,000 97.75 5396778A 07-16-18 EDOUARD, MARGARETTE 07-06-18 37.02 60 2 367,000 375,000 97.87 5402797A 01-04-19 PATTERSON, JOHN K 12-31-18 46.07 54.02 2 270,200 276,000 97.90 5397294A 08-08-18 SMITH, KENNETH 08-03-18 36.01 298 2 440,700 449,000 98.15 5405264A 03-27-19 NORMANDY INVESTMENTS, LLC 03-15-19 12.08 243 2 1,350,300 1,375,000 98.20 5397696A 08-30-18 BEST, TERREL & IVY 08-21-18 30.02 58 2 559,900 570,000 98.23 5403593A 02-01-19 LP PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT, L 01-15-19 21.01 244 2 388,600 395,000 98.38 5401938F 12-11-18 CHIRICHELLA, JUNE (ADMINIS 11-28-18 35.06 48 2 375,400 380,000 98.79 5401939A 12-14-18 DEUBEL, CHARLES C. III 11-27-18 11.03 40 2 637,400 645,000 98.82 5406237A 04-10-19 GATHERINGHILL PROPERTIES,L 04-01-19 46.02 240 2 375,100 379,000 98.97 5403606A 02-13-19 MACLAUGHLIN, BARBARA A. 02-08-19 32.02 75 2 477,700 480,000 99.52 5408904A 06-21-19 KOONTZ, ROBERT SR. 06-12-19 44.03 180 C0551 2 125,200 125,000 100.16 5407534A 05-31-19 LEE, CHRISTOPHER B 05-28-19 28.08 131 2 618,500 614,000 100.73 5404279A 03-06-19 MADELUNG, RICHARD S 02-21-19 42.05 294 2 381,300 377,000 101.14 5404596A 03-13-19 WILKERSON PROPERTY G, 02-28-19 24.04 125 2 482,900 475,000 101.66 5405417A 03-27-19 ALLEN, DITTA LONIE 02-27-19 49.16 97 2 320,800 315,000 101.84 5403597F 02-05-19 PATTERSON, DAVID B & LOUIS 01-31-19 22.01 32 2 479,100 470,000 101.94 5393258A 07-10-18 14 OREGON ASSOCIATES, LLC. 04-09-18 29.02 495 2 277,400 270,000 102.74 5398565A 10-25-18 ALGHANDOOR, AMR 10-18-18 12.09 266 2 969,400 940,000 103.13 5402156A 12-20-18 PRUZAN, TODD 10-16-18 8.02 141 2 867,700 840,000 103.30

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396829A 07-23-18 OXNER, KIM MECHIELA 07-17-18 48.47 15 2 374,200 360,000 103.94 5398444A 10-15-18 BERMUDEZ, MELISSA I 09-24-18 25.06 109.01 2 690,100 660,000 104.56 5403591A 01-31-19 EGLOVITCH, MARILYN 12-10-18 21.03 214 2 470,700 450,000 104.60 5404532A 03-12-19 DEFREITAS, JAMAL 02-08-19 49.05 650 2 361,900 345,000 104.90 5407531A 05-29-19 NEW ASSETS, LLC, 05-20-19 21.05 107 2 420,700 399,000 105.44 5398439A 10-10-18 KALSCHED, JONATHAN K. 09-19-18 15.07 416 2 460,500 435,000 105.86 5404281A 03-06-19 WALKER, ROBERT L & CONSTAN 01-18-19 30.01 29 2 583,200 549,000 106.23 5406246A 04-12-19 GIBB, STEVEN 04-03-19 49.10 135 2 253,000 238,000 106.30 5406255A 04-18-19 JOHNSON, ARNITA 04-08-19 36.05 34 2 354,300 332,000 106.72 5405260A 03-22-19 MAGNY, FRITZ 03-19-19 43.03 200.01 2 310,300 290,000 107.00 5406263A 04-25-19 BUCHOLTZ, HARVEY K & JOAN 01-23-19 7.05 133 2 802,500 749,000 107.14 5404442A 03-11-19 MANDELBAUM, JEROME 03-07-19 9.01 125 2 778,000 720,000 108.06 5396831A 07-25-18 ONYEJEKWE, IVY 07-12-18 35.05 35 2 491,900 455,000 108.11 5398433F 10-04-18 RAIO, LOUIS JR (TRUSTEE) 09-25-18 21.11 367 2 466,500 423,000 110.28 5400806A 11-09-18 BROWN, JAMES W 11-01-18 45.05 256 2 243,800 220,000 110.82 5404280A 03-06-19 ASF DEVELOPMENT, LLC, 01-23-19 35.05 30 2 597,400 537,000 111.25 5407133A 05-23-19 WALKER, ANDERSON C III 05-07-19 35.01 170 2 447,600 400,000 111.90 5393256A 07-06-18 SCULLY, ALICE 05-29-18 14.02 162 2 493,100 440,000 112.07 5406265A 04-25-19 FISHER, ARNOLD & MARILYN F 04-15-19 5.01 5 C0901 2 519,100 462,000 112.36 5403588A 01-24-19 O'CONNELL, GERALD L 11-09-18 38.01 292.01 2 367,000 325,000 112.92 5402397A 12-31-18 CLOUD, ODETTE SAINT 12-27-18 49.15 49 2 294,000 260,000 113.08 5403772A 02-25-19 BV ACA II, LLC, 02-12-19 29.01 510 2 339,500 299,900 113.20 5397674A 08-21-18 SERVICE, GEORGE & NORA 08-02-18 24.04 132 2 510,500 450,000 113.44 5406232A 04-05-19 WESTREICH, PHILIP D. & ET 03-11-19 5.01 5 C0706 2 363,700 320,000 113.66 5406279A 05-06-19 GRABER, BENJAMIN 04-17-19 38.05 44 2 366,300 320,000 114.47 5393250A 07-05-18 ANDERSON, ALLISON 05-01-18 49.05 630.01 2 316,500 275,000 115.09 5397466A 08-21-18 PEREZ, ARACELI 07-20-18 13.07 52 2 1,156,300 999,000 115.75 5404440A 03-11-19 MARGULIES, MARY 02-26-19 36.02 239 2 316,100 272,500 116.00 5403589A 01-25-19 TIMMER, GARY & FONTAINE 12-22-18 36.03 261 2 471,200 402,000 117.21 5407545A 06-05-19 ZEITLIN, ANDREW 05-29-19 13.06 83 2 1,170,800 995,000 117.67 5407132A 05-23-19 REHOV YIGAL ALON LLC, 05-01-19 31.34 131 2 370,800 315,000 117.71 5406258A 04-18-19 SKAGGS, COREY R & JULIE A 04-15-19 21.01 36 2 493,800 418,000 118.13 5396997A 07-25-18 SANTOS, JOSE M & VIANEL T 07-12-18 42.11 551 2 361,800 305,000 118.62 5406267A 04-26-19 LEITNER, JENNIFER A 04-26-19 21.05 107 2 420,700 350,000 120.20 5407546A 06-06-19 VENCKUS, RACHEL & ROY JONA 05-15-19 38.07 5 2 241,000 200,000 120.50 5408242F 06-11-19 QUINONES, EDWIN & NIEVES,A 05-17-19 46.03 6 2 313,200 250,000 125.28 5405054F 03-15-19 SCOTT, KERI-ANN & CRAWFORD 03-08-19 49.09 401 2 427,900 335,000 127.73 5401621F 11-21-18 HOLMES, MARCELLA 10-31-18 38.01 259 2 481,900 362,000 133.12 5403595F 02-04-19 PERRY, THOMAS J. 01-24-19 32.03 103 2 566,600 425,000 133.32 5406230F 04-04-19 HOWELL, TERRY M. 03-12-19 29.04 539 2 252,900 165,000 153.27 YEAR TO DATE 316 163,877,300 190,001,278 27,772.87 5404242F 02-06-19 WAREL, INC. 02-01-19 12.03 163 4A 1,381,800 1,830,000 75.51 5405423F 03-29-19 1992 SPRINGFIELD AVE,LLC 03-18-19 21.07 413 4A 450,000 580,000 77.59

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 8 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 11 MAPLEWOOD TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5403579F 01-14-19 STEVENS, DARRYL C 01-07-19 12.06 239 4A 519,400 520,000 99.88 5404241F 02-01-19 J&C INTERNATIONAL REALTY, 01-19-19 28.03 179 4A 1,049,700 1,050,000 99.97 5401933F 12-10-18 BUCKEYE PROPERTIES, INC. 11-19-18 19.20 125 4A 920,100 890,000 103.38 5406260F 04-24-19 DECROCE, JOSEPH 02-19-19 47.04 162 4A 573,300 550,000 104.24 5407317F 05-24-19 1546 SPRINGFIELD LLC, 04-25-19 31.34 81 4A 212,600 199,000 106.83 5401930F 12-06-18 JONES, LONNIE 11-30-18 49.10 118 4A 445,300 400,000 111.33 5396996F 07-17-18 DISTEFANO, KENNETH L 06-28-18 21.07 377 4A 4,173,500 3,075,000 135.72 5397689F 08-28-18 KUKREJA, RAKESH 06-14-18 47.03 51 4A 284,200 190,000 149.58 YEAR TO DATE 10 10,009,900 9,284,000 1,064.03 5407116F 05-10-19 HIGHLAND PLACE ASSOCIATES 04-29-19 12.03 162 4C 686,700 1,750,000 39.24 YEAR TO DATE 1 686,700 1,750,000 39.24 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 327 174,573,900 201,035,278 28,876.14

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 12 MILLBURN TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396135F 09-07-18 GENGOS, SUSAN NUSSBAU 08-21-18 3201 8.01 1 832,600 999,000 83.34 5409100F 06-11-19 ARTIS, SHANE G 05-21-19 2001 2.02 1 847,500 635,000 133.46 YEAR TO DATE 2 1,680,100 1,634,000 216.80 5393294A 07-17-18 SHAHZAD, SHADAB & VENNEKOT 06-22-18 107 15 2 765,400 1,158,000 66.10 5393865A 07-19-18 GONNELLO, ROBERT 07-16-18 802 20 2 580,500 825,000 70.36 5396798A 09-21-18 CHALNICK, ANDREW T 08-02-18 1703 12 2 1,319,400 1,865,000 70.75 5400828A 12-21-18 SULLIVAN, NEIL S & ELIZABE 12-05-18 1103 13 2 486,300 675,000 72.04 5402172A 12-31-18 WONG, MARTIZA LEE & ET AL. 11-30-18 603 8 2 917,500 1,250,888 73.35 5393272A 07-06-18 GAIOTTI, ANTHONY J 04-23-18 212 20 2 781,300 1,045,000 74.77 5402188A 01-15-19 CLIPPER, ANDREW 12-27-18 208 17 2 869,600 1,137,250 76.47 5408396A 06-05-19 FINGERMAN, ANDREW & ROBYN 05-20-19 504 22 2 740,900 965,000 76.78 5393289A 07-13-18 MARIN, KENNETH & WYATT, CY 06-22-18 4502 3 2 1,315,200 1,655,000 79.47 5395947A 08-06-18 PETRILLI, MICHELE 08-01-18 906 21 2 460,800 575,000 80.14 5395968A 08-17-18 GORCKE, TOBIAS H 07-27-18 301 5 2 1,066,100 1,329,690 80.18 5396103A 09-04-18 WOLK, TONY L. 08-24-18 4305 13 2 1,610,500 1,979,000 81.38 5407567A 06-04-19 PAN, LUTING & HUA, DANIELL 05-24-19 1801 57 2 926,500 1,138,000 81.41 5396097A 08-28-18 LYNN, GARY 08-15-18 607 27 2 884,700 1,085,000 81.54 5407200A 05-09-19 ZENN, DAVID & KIMBERLY 05-02-19 504 21 2 807,200 990,000 81.54 5395963A 08-15-18 REDDEN, ROBERT S 07-05-18 405 5 2 676,100 828,000 81.65 5404536A 01-31-19 RUIBAL, EVELINO A 11-08-18 605 9 2 871,300 1,065,000 81.81 5396800A 09-25-18 BASILE, VINCENT V 09-17-18 4902 5 2 2,430,900 2,950,000 82.40 5395974A 08-21-18 DIPIETRO, DARIO & GAETANA 07-26-18 1001 10 2 690,500 833,000 82.89 5407322A 05-20-19 ARKIN, JONATHAN S 05-13-19 211 13 2 690,400 829,000 83.28 5399577A 11-15-18 CHAPMAN, CHERYL CATHER 11-01-18 1102 15 2 450,300 540,000 83.39 5393868A 07-23-18 GERNE, CHRISTOPHER & ALEXA 07-12-18 212 10 2 716,800 859,000 83.45 5395975A 08-22-18 DING, GAO & LI, WEN & ET A 07-29-18 1806 15 2 926,900 1,105,000 83.88 5396133A 09-06-18 MACCA, JOSEPH 08-21-18 610 13 2 857,200 1,020,000 84.04 5395950A 08-08-18 UMINSKI, PAUL JASON 08-02-18 2002 12 2 951,600 1,120,000 84.96 5395953A 08-09-18 MARCOVICI, BRYAN N & LEILA 07-29-18 1905 8 2 987,700 1,160,000 85.15 5395962A 08-15-18 BIER, MELLISSA 08-09-18 4903 6 2 1,385,000 1,625,000 85.23 5400819A 12-12-18 SUTTON, MARK & BRENDA 11-27-18 102 2 2 1,010,300 1,180,000 85.62 5393281A 07-09-18 CALDER, CEDRIC L. 06-29-18 905 20 2 800,600 928,000 86.27 5407189A 05-06-19 HARRIS, MARILYN A & MICHAE 04-16-19 1904 56 2 961,900 1,115,000 86.27 5393869A 07-23-18 PERLISTEIN, STUART G 06-29-18 1811 14 2 1,122,300 1,300,000 86.33 5395972A 08-20-18 CURTIS, EVA 05-28-18 1904 85 2 1,407,100 1,628,000 86.43 5393275A 07-09-18 WANG, JING 06-27-18 906 27 C536B 2 242,100 280,000 86.46 5393266A 07-02-18 WOODS, CHARLIE 05-18-18 104 3 2 830,100 960,000 86.47 5400535A 11-19-18 153 HIGHLAND LLC, 11-07-18 3104 2 2 1,579,000 1,825,000 86.52 5395970A 08-17-18 PHILLIPS, TATIANA & NICHOL 07-19-18 1904 95 2 1,290,900 1,485,000 86.93 5407160A 04-02-19 WAI, LAWRENCE & TSANG, MAN 01-25-19 1808 21 2 1,000,000 1,150,000 86.96 5407188A 05-06-19 SCHLOSSER, JARED & AMANDA 04-24-19 4202 14 2 1,062,000 1,220,000 87.05 5407192A 05-08-19 DEVINE, DYMPNA 04-29-19 903 7 2 511,700 585,000 87.47 5407560A 05-29-19 DANE, BENJAMIN PATRICK & K 05-03-19 4204 4 2 871,100 995,000 87.55

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 12 MILLBURN TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407327A 05-22-19 YANKOWITZ, ROBERT & RHONDA 05-07-19 207 14 2 721,400 823,500 87.60 5395932A 07-27-18 THOMAS, ANDREW P 07-19-18 106 14 2 909,400 1,035,000 87.86 5407173A 04-26-19 VISCEGLIA,FRANK D & NICOLE 04-15-19 5202 1 2 1,193,300 1,355,000 88.07 5407202A 05-13-19 PARAGANO, NAZARIO M & MARI 04-29-19 1102 22 2 537,500 610,000 88.11 5393274A 07-06-18 ARCELLA, THOMAS E 05-08-18 3505 6 2 1,814,600 2,050,000 88.52 5395954A 08-09-18 MARTIN, WICKUS 06-23-18 212 14 2 756,000 850,000 88.94 5393273A 07-06-18 MAO, LIQING 06-08-18 906 27 C536A 2 243,000 273,000 89.01 5393295A 07-18-18 PEPIN, JAMES 07-05-18 206 18 2 733,000 820,000 89.39 5396100A 08-30-18 DIETERLE, RICK & JENESSA 08-21-18 4201 15 2 891,600 995,000 89.61 5404537A 03-04-19 SHARMA, RAJESH 02-12-19 406 16 2 627,800 700,500 89.62 5409116A 06-19-19 TAPAL, SHAKIL 06-05-19 603 6 2 780,600 870,000 89.72 5400825A 12-19-18 BALZANO, DOMINIC HENRY 11-06-18 807 21 2 747,400 832,000 89.83 5393873A 07-24-18 LUFTIG, ALLAN & JANICE 06-18-18 810 27 2 786,600 875,000 89.90 5407164A 04-11-19 QI, GUOFENG & PAN, YAMING 04-02-19 403 5 2 615,800 685,000 89.90 5395943A 08-02-18 RUTKAY, LOUISE 07-11-18 502 23 2 844,900 939,000 89.98 5396794A 09-18-18 KIRK, KIM J 09-10-18 5102 1 2 1,277,400 1,418,000 90.08 5407172A 04-24-19 CASSANO, ANTHONY D & ELIZA 04-12-19 1804 6 2 892,700 990,000 90.17 5407561A 05-29-19 GOTTHARD, MARTHA 05-24-19 5109 15 2 898,300 995,000 90.28 5395941A 08-02-18 SANTANA, CHRISTOPHER 07-30-18 2402 5 2 2,579,500 2,850,000 90.51 5399580A 11-15-18 BRONSTEIN, JAN 10-31-18 3608 7 2 1,184,300 1,300,000 91.10 5407183A 05-02-19 SPIEGEL, MENAHEM & SARA 04-29-19 507 50 2 763,700 837,500 91.19 5393279A 07-09-18 WEINER, JONATHAN M 06-29-18 3802 8 2 1,824,200 2,000,000 91.21 5395960A 08-14-18 SLAFF, JEFFREY & ELKIN, AN 07-18-18 4501 15 2 1,512,200 1,656,500 91.29 5395979A 08-24-18 ZEITEL, NAOMI 08-17-18 3605 14 2 1,216,500 1,330,000 91.47 5399230A 10-29-18 KENNEDY, JAMES M JR 10-22-18 906 27 C422A 2 243,300 266,000 91.47 5399225A 10-22-18 HAAS, ROBERT J & KING, VIC 08-22-18 201 13 2 1,101,400 1,201,000 91.71 5407182A 05-02-19 FOSS, KATHERINE MARY 04-23-19 504 18 2 916,000 995,000 92.06 5397188A 10-02-18 MALLON, SANFORD B 09-01-18 3802 23 2 1,475,200 1,600,000 92.20 5395946A 08-06-18 KHADEMI, ALLEN & HILARY 07-27-18 3502 3 2 1,263,600 1,370,000 92.23 5395951A 08-08-18 KING, MICHAEL 07-12-18 1302 4 2 1,988,700 2,156,000 92.24 5400537A 11-26-18 CALICCHIO, MICHAEL A 11-15-18 1209 22 2 792,800 855,000 92.73 5407204A 05-13-19 STANLEY, BARBARA 04-29-19 1703 14 2 1,067,600 1,150,000 92.83 5404086A 02-05-19 CARTIER, JAN R. 01-09-19 804 1 2 668,800 720,000 92.89 5409111A 06-18-19 PATEL, ANIL & BINALI 04-26-19 4503 6 2 2,646,200 2,845,000 93.01 5409112A 06-18-19 O'NEIL, JOHN D 04-24-19 304 12 2 835,100 895,000 93.31 5397305A 10-04-18 FAVIA, THOMAS J 09-20-18 1709 22 2 926,200 990,000 93.56 5393288A 07-12-18 WHALEN, EVAN & ERICA 06-13-18 207 3 2 712,200 759,888 93.72 5402185A 01-14-19 HSIUNG, SHIH-LEE 01-08-19 605 20 C1036 2 310,500 330,888 93.84 5397707A 10-09-18 STREAR, ANDREW & JOAN A 09-21-18 3501 3 2 1,258,700 1,340,000 93.93 5409104A 06-12-19 TOMKO, RICHARD J & KARA E 05-28-19 501 11 2 799,900 849,000 94.22 5395976A 08-23-18 BORETS, MAKSYM 08-17-18 611 3 2 752,500 797,000 94.42 5400539A 11-26-18 STATNIKOV, ALEXANDER 11-03-18 203 8 2 1,027,800 1,087,500 94.51 5396136A 09-07-18 GERIBON, HECTOR 08-21-18 1905 14 2 903,000 955,000 94.55 5408395A 06-05-19 MAILLARD,STEPHANE &DELPHIN 05-28-19 604 25 2 823,700 870,000 94.68 5397299A 10-02-18 SALESKI, JOSEPH T 08-30-18 404 8 2 583,000 615,000 94.80 5407320A 05-16-19 WETMORE, D & DELESKY, C 04-01-19 2109 5 2 2,518,900 2,650,000 95.05

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 12 MILLBURN TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400538A 11-26-18 TOTO, DOMENIC D 10-12-18 3603 14 2 1,126,600 1,175,000 95.88 5407194A 05-08-19 LU, JIJUN & YANG, FANGYUN 04-30-19 3201 23 2 1,490,900 1,555,000 95.88 5407178A 04-30-19 ANTHONY, IRUTHAYARAJ P 02-25-19 401 16 2 647,500 675,000 95.93 5399234A 11-02-18 HOROWITZ, CRAIG & RHONDA 10-25-18 3502 14 2 1,154,600 1,202,500 96.02 5407323A 05-20-19 COOK, HENRY 05-02-19 311 10 2 552,400 573,500 96.32 5395931A 07-27-18 JONES, MARIE MUELLER 07-20-18 803 24 2 588,300 610,000 96.44 5395935A 07-30-18 MCDERMOTT, VIRGINIA G 07-11-18 1804 32 2 834,400 861,000 96.91 5399235A 11-07-18 OKUN, ROBERT & RONI 10-22-18 3001 2 2 2,501,700 2,575,000 97.15 5409590A 06-28-19 JHAWAR, KUSH K & PRIYA 06-13-19 1904 59 2 1,171,800 1,200,000 97.65 5402189A 01-16-19 PANICO, VICTOR A 01-10-19 1804 5 2 971,100 993,000 97.79 5407187A 05-06-19 LONGO, PAUL F & FRANCES MA 04-29-19 1803 1 2 931,400 952,000 97.84 5395949A 08-07-18 VALLABHANENI,KRISHNA K &DA 08-01-18 1301 19 2 1,635,500 1,670,000 97.93 5407144A 03-21-19 PERILMAN, ADAM 02-25-19 4501 40 2 1,195,200 1,220,000 97.97 5399581A 11-16-18 POMERANTZ, KENNETH (CO-TRU 11-07-18 504 13 2 750,300 765,000 98.08 5395936A 07-30-18 RAMASAMY, DHANASEKARAN 07-16-18 3502 21 2 1,329,100 1,355,000 98.09 5395934A 07-30-18 GORDON, THOMAS S & JOANNE 07-10-18 4407 10 2 987,700 999,999 98.77 5409106A 06-12-19 MASTERS, PHILIP M & KAREN 05-31-19 309 15 2 690,600 699,000 98.80 5393292A 07-13-18 SHAN, HUIYUAN 06-15-18 612 4 2 920,100 930,000 98.94 5404079A 01-29-19 PERLMUTTER, DAVID & ALLISO 01-19-19 206 27 2 794,900 802,500 99.05 5393871A 07-24-18 DUARTE, JACQUELINE 07-12-18 605 20 C1023 2 299,400 300,000 99.80 5400821A 12-17-18 KAPLAN, LISA 12-10-18 810 7 2 733,600 735,000 99.81 5402191A 01-16-19 BOOKBINDER, NANCY (TRUSTEE 11-02-18 602 10 2 653,900 655,000 99.83 5407159A 04-01-19 SHI, YUN QING 03-26-19 810 34 2 721,300 722,000 99.90 5395952A 08-08-18 HAN, SUNG KEE 07-12-18 1801 69 2 929,300 930,000 99.92 5396792A 09-18-18 STAMBERGER, CAROL L 09-04-18 806 32 2 736,000 736,000 100.00 5395938A 07-31-18 RED BANK, LLC, 07-23-18 1401 24 2 3,983,500 3,975,000 100.21 5396101A 08-31-18 RUDIN, DAN 07-14-18 1812 1 2 888,400 885,000 100.38 5399239A 11-09-18 BYRAKUR, SREEVISHNU S 10-31-18 309 10 2 618,400 616,000 100.39 5404091A 02-21-19 COLASACCO, DALIA & MARCO 12-26-18 4802 1 2 1,455,600 1,450,000 100.39 5404096A 02-28-19 GUPTA, SANJEEV & PADMINI 01-28-19 4903 57 2 1,490,800 1,485,000 100.39 5402173A 01-02-19 MEMMOLO, JOSEPH & DEBORAH 12-10-18 1808 11 2 856,000 852,000 100.47 5399238A 11-09-18 NARAYAN, ANANTH 10-28-18 312 21 2 603,600 600,000 100.60 5396137A 09-10-18 SHULDMAN, KENNETH & EMILY 08-29-18 203 13 2 750,300 745,000 100.71 5407185A 05-03-19 SKATOFF, ANDREW & JULIE 04-26-19 1501 5 2 1,509,800 1,495,000 100.99 5400822A 12-18-18 78 CLINTON LP, 12-12-18 104 13 2 891,400 880,000 101.30 5407140A 03-15-19 GARETANO, GARY & KRINSKY, 02-22-19 806 22 2 836,000 825,000 101.33 5397187A 10-02-18 MANSOUR, CLAUDETTE A 08-29-18 2501 9 2 1,319,500 1,298,000 101.66 5402169A 12-29-18 SRIDHARAN, KANNAN & SHOBHA 12-19-18 1904 21 2 914,300 899,000 101.70 5402176A 01-07-19 SMOLENSKY, VLADIMIR 11-30-18 605 20 C1006 2 290,000 285,000 101.75 5393290A 07-13-18 COBB, NIGEL 06-24-18 3302 4 2 1,936,100 1,900,000 101.90 5395939A 07-31-18 KORNEYEVA, TATYANA 07-26-18 906 27 C670A 2 239,900 235,000 102.09 5407171A 04-24-19 MILLER, PATRICIA 04-09-19 310 9 2 538,200 525,200 102.48 5399233A 11-01-18 SEADER, DAVID L & SARA 10-24-18 303 3 2 897,400 875,000 102.56 5393874A 07-24-18 HOCHMAN, RONALD & LAUREN 06-30-18 4905 11 2 1,516,900 1,475,000 102.84 5409110A 06-18-19 GROSMAN, ALAN M & BETTE B 06-03-19 1904 25 2 906,200 880,000 102.98 5407146A 03-25-19 LEE-YU, YEEMOON 03-20-19 5108 8 2 1,202,700 1,164,000 103.32

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 12 MILLBURN TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396104A 09-04-18 ZHANG, XIAOHUA 08-10-18 3603 4 2 1,173,200 1,135,000 103.37 5407565A 05-31-19 GOLDMAN, ROBERT T 04-05-19 3002 10 2 1,710,900 1,650,000 103.69 5400813A 12-10-18 2002 GREGORY AND CHARLEEN 07-27-18 5201 4 2 1,244,000 1,199,000 103.75 5395984A 08-28-18 BECKER, ROBERT K 08-16-18 1208 7 2 737,700 710,000 103.90 5407318A 05-16-19 KEYLES, MICHAEL & CARMELLA 04-20-19 5106 14 2 1,197,100 1,150,000 104.10 5395969A 08-17-18 FEINBERG, MARGERY GERING 08-08-18 3801 3 2 1,562,900 1,500,000 104.19 5393872A 07-24-18 MIRSKY, PETER 07-13-18 3605 11 2 1,567,500 1,498,000 104.64 5407326A 05-22-19 COHEN, JEFFREY & CHRISTINE 05-07-19 3903 12 2 2,804,600 2,675,000 104.84 5407184A 05-03-19 LA GRECA, THOMAS J. JR 04-16-19 203 11 2 857,600 815,000 105.23 5399227A 10-24-18 BARR, NEIL & KIVA 10-10-18 1403 14.01 2 3,210,800 3,050,000 105.27 5395982A 08-27-18 NG, VICTOR 08-13-18 1506 37 2 1,842,700 1,750,000 105.30 5409108A 06-13-19 CIAVARELLA, DAVID & KERNAN 05-06-19 2604 10 2 1,653,600 1,570,000 105.32 5399224A 10-22-18 PLATZMAN, STEVEN B (TRUSTE 10-11-18 3501 19 2 1,161,900 1,100,000 105.63 5407181A 05-02-19 ROUNICK, ERIC S. & IRENE S 04-27-19 4407 13 2 1,098,700 1,040,000 105.64 5397712A 10-17-18 KEENAN, PAUL 09-19-18 209 10 2 803,100 760,000 105.67 5407165A 04-11-19 PANZER, JASON E & NAOMI 04-05-19 2303 5 2 1,353,700 1,280,000 105.76 5396139A 09-18-18 KESSLER, JONATHAN 05-14-18 2109 4 2 2,067,800 1,955,000 105.77 5395945A 08-06-18 GOULD, ANTHONY & LORI 07-30-18 3803 2 2 1,484,800 1,400,000 106.06 5407180A 05-01-19 SHAPIRO, SHERRI COHEN 04-05-19 4001 4 2 1,888,000 1,780,000 106.07 5404095A 02-26-19 MAZELLAN, THEODORE 02-12-19 3803 29 2 1,253,600 1,175,000 106.69 5407153A 03-28-19 HOUSTON, JANE P. 03-13-19 2209 2 2 2,080,800 1,950,000 106.71 5399579A 11-15-18 MAYO, DANIEL 11-08-18 5107 14 2 2,305,800 2,160,000 106.75 5407193A 05-08-19 FEINBERG, PETER E 04-10-19 3305 4 2 1,594,800 1,490,000 107.03 5393276A 07-09-18 COLLINS, DENNIS M & CAROLI 06-28-18 3410 3 2 2,398,100 2,240,000 107.06 5397706A 10-09-18 LANGBERG, GLENN & SUSAN 09-26-18 1403 3 2 3,401,700 3,175,000 107.14 5393278A 07-09-18 RUDD, HOWARD 05-30-18 2803 2 2 1,713,200 1,595,000 107.41 5395930A 07-26-18 KELLOGG, GAIL C 07-12-18 1402 9 2 1,612,700 1,501,000 107.44 5402187A 01-14-19 MANDEL, ROBERT 12-14-18 3604 18 2 1,337,700 1,245,000 107.45 5408394A 06-05-19 KING, SYLVIA D. 03-18-19 504 5 2 725,500 675,000 107.48 5399231A 10-30-18 DI PIETRO, DARIO D 10-11-18 1002 10 2 694,800 646,000 107.55 5395959A 08-13-18 ROTH, MICHAEL & TERRI 08-03-18 3204 9 2 1,433,600 1,330,000 107.79 5396796A 09-20-18 LIN, YUHLIN 07-10-18 4504 5 2 1,175,800 1,090,000 107.87 5408398A 06-07-19 BAYAR, HAROLD STEVEN 05-31-19 505 1 2 815,200 755,000 107.97 5409107F 06-13-19 BLAU, HODA & MICHAEL & KEN 05-09-19 4903 50 2 1,732,000 1,600,000 108.25 5409587A 06-27-19 MULLIN, ANDREW CASEY & NAD 06-03-19 3404 2 2 1,434,300 1,325,000 108.25 5400536A 11-20-18 SPECKHART, ELISABETH J 10-11-18 5102 7 2 1,237,700 1,140,000 108.57 5407168A 04-18-19 SCOLA, JEANNE 04-04-19 1604 28 2 921,800 849,000 108.57 5407135A 11-26-18 VINCRIS PROPERTIES LLC 11-12-18 805 10 2 838,200 770,000 108.86 5404073A 01-18-19 KOKSOY, ULKER & HAKAN 01-14-19 309 17 2 679,700 623,900 108.94 5400815A 12-10-18 MILLER, LESLEY G 10-31-18 3101 15 2 2,131,100 1,950,000 109.29 5400816A 12-11-18 MERLE, KARL III & LEVITT, 10-13-18 1210 12 2 658,800 600,000 109.80 5395948A 08-07-18 QCKENNA, CHARLES B 07-02-18 1712 22 2 826,600 751,000 110.07 5402170A 12-31-18 ADILLON, CONRAD & CAROLINE 11-01-18 1202 8 2 1,231,400 1,118,000 110.14 5407179A 04-30-19 ALPERT, IRWYN O & ROBIN S 04-25-19 810 33 2 716,800 650,000 110.28 5393291A 07-13-18 RAAD, MICHELE L 06-20-18 3606 29 2 1,884,000 1,700,000 110.82 5395973A 08-20-18 FELDMAN, DAVID & GRACE 07-27-18 402 50 2 936,400 845,000 110.82

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 12 MILLBURN TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407156A 03-28-19 FALLA, RODERICK & DIANE 03-25-19 209 2 2 785,100 705,000 111.36 5397181A 09-27-18 JIANG, CHIH-WEI 08-28-18 1301 14 2 970,000 870,000 111.49 5400824A 12-19-18 COLE, RICHARD J 12-14-18 707 9 2 742,100 665,000 111.59 5395927A 07-26-18 SHANKAR, RAVI 07-06-18 2111 29 2 2,111,800 1,889,000 111.79 5409585A 06-27-19 CALLEN, GEORGE W. & CHERYL 03-12-19 3405 1 2 1,230,100 1,100,000 111.83 5409101A 06-12-19 ROONEY, ELEANOR C & CATHY 05-31-19 1904 5 2 549,500 490,000 112.14 5409114A 06-19-19 DANIELS, STUART & ISMENE 06-11-19 4705 20 2 1,015,900 905,000 112.25 5408400A 06-10-19 WINER, JONATHAN & HELENE 05-24-19 2804 9 2 1,632,500 1,450,000 112.59 5393286A 07-11-18 KAID, KHALIL & CHATHA 06-25-18 4204 10 2 1,804,300 1,600,000 112.77 5395937A 07-30-18 KHAN, MOHAMMAD S & NEK P 06-17-18 4903 18 2 2,099,000 1,845,000 113.77 5408391A 06-04-19 MURRAY, JOSEPH J & BARBARA 05-11-19 2901 10 2 2,816,100 2,465,000 114.24 5395964A 08-15-18 NAYAR, DHIRAJ 07-30-18 5002 14 2 1,956,000 1,701,000 114.99 5395944A 08-03-18 NAVIN, JOAN G 07-17-18 2105 9 2 1,209,600 1,050,000 115.20 5407174A 04-26-19 MARSDEN, PETER & DAWN 04-15-19 1606 9 2 916,100 795,000 115.23 5400544A 11-28-18 HARRISON, DAVID S & BETH M 11-19-18 4501 42 2 1,411,500 1,222,500 115.46 5407203A 05-13-19 FAY, BENJAMIN & KRISTEN 04-29-19 2406 4 2 3,320,900 2,875,000 115.51 5407141A 03-19-19 MARINO, DANIEL A. & STEPHA 02-28-19 2901 19 2 1,398,000 1,205,000 116.02 5400818A 12-11-18 MERYN, RUTH B 10-02-18 3606 20 2 1,196,600 1,030,000 116.17 5407175A 04-29-19 BRUCKER, MARC D & ALISA 04-08-19 4501 8 2 1,707,500 1,460,000 116.95 5397180A 09-26-18 JOHNSON, BENJAMIN 09-14-18 3605 19 2 2,339,500 2,000,000 116.98 5397186A 10-01-18 KLEIN, SONJA 08-29-18 2203 2 2 2,816,800 2,400,000 117.37 5407136F 12-06-18 ZALTSBERG, GRIGORY & NATAL 11-26-18 4704 12 2 2,393,500 2,035,000 117.62 5402186F 01-14-19 SCHNEIDER, CORY F & JILL 12-20-18 4903 40 2 2,980,000 2,525,000 118.02 5409586A 06-27-19 ZAMORE, NEAL & BARJOVIC, J 06-17-19 2502 2 2 1,192,700 1,009,100 118.19 5407148A 03-25-19 MILLER, MICHAEL 03-01-19 1901 14 2 1,345,600 1,137,000 118.35 5407142A 03-19-19 SAWYER, WILLIAM K & REBECC 02-22-19 607 18 2 773,500 650,000 119.00 5400817A 12-11-18 PETRUZZINI, JOSEPH & JULIA 11-16-18 1205 4 2 1,131,500 950,000 119.11 5393870A 07-24-18 LARDIZABAL, JOSE L 06-25-18 3002 8 2 1,436,200 1,203,000 119.38 5397306A 10-04-18 PETRUZZINI, JULIANA & FRAN 09-21-18 1904 101 2 1,182,200 990,000 119.41 5397300F 10-02-18 PANDEY, RAMESH 04-07-18 206 8 2 623,200 520,000 119.85 5396797A 09-21-18 PERLOWITZ, JEFFREY ALAN 09-05-18 1502 33 2 6,000,000 5,000,000 120.00 5393293T 07-17-18 ARDEN, MELISSA JOY 07-10-18 4206 6 2 3,310,700 2,750,000 120.39 5400550A 12-06-18 ST JOHN, JOAN F 11-13-18 2204 7 2 1,470,000 1,217,500 120.74 5402166A 12-26-18 WHITE, DIANNE 12-17-18 1206 12 2 1,029,800 850,000 121.15 5407319A 05-16-19 LEHROFF, STEVEN & RANDI-EL 04-25-19 3608 20 2 1,309,900 1,080,000 121.29 5404089A 02-13-19 GOTFRIED, FERN & DUGAN, MI 01-03-19 1603 1 2 1,031,200 850,000 121.32 5397184A 09-28-18 BOYLE, MICHAEL SEAN 09-11-18 2208 5 2 1,966,200 1,620,000 121.37 5408399A 06-10-19 HORN, JEROME H 05-15-19 610 7 2 666,000 545,000 122.20 5400551A 12-06-18 BERWICK, SARAH & DOHRN, CL 11-19-18 1401 25 2 1,813,800 1,475,000 122.97 5393269A 07-02-18 MARTIN, LISA G 06-27-18 1204 10 2 1,234,800 999,999 123.48 5407199F 05-09-19 DEMEO, DANIEL R. JR. & ANA 03-17-19 2901 7 2 3,100,000 2,510,000 123.51 5408392A 06-04-19 PERCARIO, LUKE A 02-27-19 4405 16 2 978,700 785,000 124.68 5407563F 05-30-19 MCQUILKIN, MAUREEN 04-11-19 208 2 2 749,900 600,000 124.98 5400814F 12-10-18 MASON, ANDREW S & MARIANNE 11-15-18 3104 14 2 1,675,000 1,337,200 125.26 5404088A 02-11-19 WOLFE, ANITA J 02-06-19 3503 20 2 1,604,900 1,275,000 125.87 5407162A 04-04-19 RICHARDSON, MICHAEL J. & A 03-26-19 3406 5 2 1,572,000 1,242,000 126.57

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 12 MILLBURN TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400543A 11-28-18 BALBO, ANTONE & ET AL. 11-07-18 5005 35 2 2,629,900 2,075,000 126.74 5400548A 12-03-18 EILEEN ROSEN 2016 REVOCABL 10-17-18 4703 1 2 1,179,000 930,000 126.77 5395929A 07-26-18 SCHRON, ELISE SILVERMAN 07-16-18 5004 1 2 1,270,800 999,999 127.08 5396096T 08-28-18 GORDON, DAVID A 07-05-18 1503 1 2 1,842,300 1,445,000 127.49 5409105F 06-12-19 BEACHAM,JEFFREY B & MARIA 06-05-19 3503 6 2 1,228,400 950,000 129.31 5407152F 03-27-19 LI, BILAN 01-09-19 4903 56 2 1,597,700 1,230,000 129.89 5400533A 11-15-18 DORNEY, JAMES M 11-03-18 1207 57 2 1,436,700 1,100,000 130.61 5396799F 09-24-18 HEAD, LESLIE 08-28-18 1101 42 C09 2 1,267,700 970,000 130.69 5393285A 07-11-18 NEJAT, ALIEH B & IRAJ 06-27-18 4502 12 2 1,733,400 1,325,000 130.82 5397307A 10-05-18 PARKER, SPENCER 09-11-18 2803 5 2 1,866,800 1,422,500 131.23 5404539A 03-04-19 XIE, HONGQIANG 02-08-19 3406 12 2 598,000 455,000 131.43 5404087A 02-07-19 MACCORMACK, MARTIN J 01-09-19 3503 13 2 1,122,700 847,000 132.55 5402182A 01-08-19 SHAPIRO, STEVEN 12-17-18 1606 6 2 949,200 715,000 132.76 5407158A 04-01-19 SIMAEE, DAVID & LORIE 03-22-19 4506 22 2 1,310,000 985,000 132.99 5395957A 08-13-18 METCALFE, JAMES M & KATHRY 07-19-18 2805 3 2 2,386,900 1,780,000 134.10 5407139A 03-14-19 AUSTIN, FREDERICK W & BARB 02-06-19 3503 18 2 1,136,000 845,000 134.44 5402177F 01-07-19 STARACE, NICHOLAS F II 12-10-18 5102 27 2 1,189,500 870,000 136.72 5395977F 08-24-18 BARKER, DEBORAH JENSEN 08-15-18 2301 10 2 3,351,400 2,450,000 136.79 5409591F 06-28-19 FARBER, MORTON 05-06-19 3306 4 2 2,273,600 1,650,000 137.79 5395955F 08-09-18 HEAD, LESLIE 07-19-18 1503 9 2 1,930,000 1,400,000 137.86 5407325F 05-21-19 GIANNI, CHARLES (TRUSTEE) 04-30-19 3102 15 2 1,540,000 1,100,000 140.00 5407191F 05-07-19 WALDOR, PETER & JODY 04-29-19 2503 32 2 1,586,500 1,095,000 144.89 5396102T 08-31-18 BETTERIDGE, EDWARD J JR 08-09-18 1903 13 2 1,101,400 750,000 146.85 5400820F 12-13-18 ZALK, LAURENCE 11-28-18 3605 1 2 2,208,800 1,480,000 149.24 5395971F 08-17-18 MATKIWSKY, WALTER 08-06-18 2108 10 2 1,593,800 1,037,500 153.62 5399226F 10-23-18 THOMAS, CHARLES & ET AL. 10-15-18 5003 1 2 1,443,400 925,000 156.04 5409589F 06-27-19 FRIEDMAN, PETER C. & JENNI 06-20-19 2104 6 2 2,375,200 1,500,000 158.35 YEAR TO DATE 251 321,757,100 307,057,001 26,099.86 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 253 323,437,200 308,691,001 26,316.66

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5408713F 06-19-19 MENK, CARL 06-10-19 3209 31 2 412,700 802,500 51.43 5400237F 12-10-18 SPENCER, VANESSA A 11-15-18 3209 26 2 360,100 700,000 51.44 5409240F 06-21-19 SURIANO, ELIO & LISA 05-23-19 2408 44 2 311,600 575,000 54.19 5403075F 02-13-19 VIZZONE, JOHN & SANDRA 01-31-19 204 15.08 2 937,000 1,725,000 54.32 5400245F 12-11-18 DE PROSPO, LORRAINE M 12-06-18 2203 3 C0003 2 240,500 427,500 56.26 5393301F 07-03-18 14 FOREST STREET 202, LLC. 06-21-18 3201 33 C4202 2 182,000 300,000 60.67 5393318F 07-10-18 DAY-BOODHOO, SARAH E & GAV 06-29-18 3212 10 2 396,800 650,000 61.05 5405642F 04-04-19 WILL, EILEEN 03-25-19 1501 5 C2702 2 192,500 312,500 61.60 5396006F 09-12-18 SOBERS-LEVITT, MARY 08-31-18 3202 27 2 411,600 650,000 63.32 5396002F 09-10-18 ZECCHINO, NICHOLAS III 08-31-18 4308 13 2 366,200 575,000 63.69 5402400F 01-18-19 LAZZAROTTI, SHERYL KING 01-11-19 4204 23 2 375,100 575,000 65.23 5408114F 06-11-19 TWO22 LLC, 05-15-19 1907 17 2 196,000 300,000 65.33 5393316F 07-09-18 PINKUS, GREGORY & IRANI, S 06-22-18 708 5 2 630,400 952,000 66.22 5407571F 05-30-19 CERAME, LEONARD M. & DONNA 05-12-19 603 8 2 662,200 999,000 66.29 5396000F 09-10-18 WEITZNER, LARRY 06-29-18 2213 9 2 435,600 648,000 67.22 5406303F 04-26-19 ALDRIDGE-DUNCAN, GRANT P & 04-18-19 2805 38 2 644,700 953,000 67.65 5399288F 11-15-18 UDDIN, MOHAMMED ZAHI 11-09-18 4203 4 2 356,400 525,000 67.89 5408688F 06-17-19 MCCANN, RICHARD P 05-16-19 1509 29 2 487,900 716,000 68.14 5405864F 04-11-19 LEHMAN, JAY S & SALLY M 03-26-19 2101 13 2 716,900 1,050,000 68.28 5409399F 06-26-19 WEINER, FRED & LAURA 05-29-19 502 4 2 1,400,900 2,050,000 68.34 5400235F 12-10-18 BLACKBURN, DOUGLAS D. T 11-21-18 3204 13 2 348,600 510,000 68.35 5405650F 04-10-19 RUBIN, DAVID & WARGO, KARE 04-01-19 1805 29 2 821,200 1,200,000 68.43 5401355A 12-28-18 MOLLOY, CINDY E 12-04-18 1810 16 2 870,800 1,259,000 69.17 5405641F 04-03-19 GARMANY, FAY L 03-08-19 3203 2 2 438,800 633,500 69.27 5393321F 07-12-18 LONEGAN, BRYAN K & MARY H 06-22-18 3107 11 C3031 2 255,200 367,500 69.44 5401625F 01-03-19 FUNG, JUSTIN & KRISTINA E 12-20-18 3302 7 2 357,800 515,000 69.48 5402403F 01-22-19 MAURER, DOUGLAS & CAROL 01-16-19 3802 71 2 664,100 950,000 69.91 5408689A 06-17-19 HERRERA, LUIS 06-05-19 1911 22 2 316,400 452,000 70.00 5404444A 03-07-19 MARTIN BREEN, PATRICK J 02-22-19 3107 11 C3002 2 255,200 364,000 70.11 5397829A 10-22-18 GREEN, GERARDO & HARRIS, T 09-07-18 3202 9 2 443,800 625,000 71.01 5393303A 07-05-18 BLANCKMEISTER, CAROLYN 06-29-18 2605 26 C0005 2 515,300 725,000 71.08 5398130A 10-25-18 WEGEL, ERIC & ADRIENNE 10-15-18 4210 13 C0005 2 227,800 320,000 71.19 5393877A 07-27-18 MINNIG, CLIFF W 07-18-18 3303 49 2 299,100 420,000 71.21 5409012A 06-24-19 DIMANT, EYAL A & ELYSSA A 06-08-19 1809 11 2 553,500 776,500 71.28 5393299A 07-02-18 DIXSON, JAMES L 06-04-18 3507 40 2 966,600 1,350,000 71.60 5406871A 05-16-19 KLEIN, MICHAEL C. & MELISS 05-03-19 3201 32 C6301 2 240,300 335,000 71.73 5395656A 08-28-18 HANTMAN, STEPHANIE L 08-18-18 3108 18 C0010 2 161,900 225,000 71.96 5394792A 08-14-18 AMSINGER, GREGORY & ERICA 08-03-18 1203 4 2 1,351,800 1,875,000 72.10 5408116A 06-13-19 ALICANDRI, JAY & JENNIFER 05-15-19 3802 21 2 940,500 1,300,000 72.35 5394119A 07-31-18 44 UNION STREET, LLC, 07-12-18 3108 18 C0002 2 166,800 230,000 72.52 5396612A 09-27-18 SMITH, BRIAN A 09-14-18 3201 32 C6306 2 207,000 285,000 72.63 5406865A 05-15-19 DANIELS, MICHAEL 04-26-19 2212 15 C03.2 2 201,300 275,000 73.20 5409243A 06-25-19 DECARVALHO, IVAN 06-21-19 2503 29 2 378,000 515,000 73.40 5393349A 07-24-18 DARTOIS, VERONIQUE A 07-17-18 3108 18 C0012 2 165,400 225,000 73.51 5407331A 05-29-19 CARROLL, DEVIN & MICHELLE 05-17-19 1711 18 C6.10 2 219,300 298,000 73.59 5400555A 12-18-18 CRANN, ELIZABETH C 11-14-18 3904 89 2 283,400 385,000 73.61

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405427A 04-01-19 CHANGSUT, ARSENIO JR & DIA 03-27-19 3801 16 2 567,200 770,000 73.66 5398454A 10-31-18 RIZZUTO, ROBERT P 10-23-18 1503 20 2 1,308,100 1,775,000 73.70 5393312A 07-09-18 LOCKWOOD, DANIEL 06-07-18 1709 21 2 641,100 869,000 73.77 5397320A 10-11-18 SILAS, RALPH 10-03-18 4107 3 2 329,800 447,000 73.78 5398796A 11-07-18 TAYLOR, FLORA D 10-29-18 4202 2 C2010 2 306,200 415,000 73.78 5396610A 09-24-18 SKULE, JEREMY O 08-17-18 3607 2 2 779,800 1,055,000 73.91 5394904A 08-22-18 WHITE, DIANE SATTERFIELD & 08-10-18 2305 16 2 546,700 739,000 73.98 5407575A 06-03-19 BROOKS, KATHLEEN M. 05-14-19 1711 18 C7.16 2 244,300 330,000 74.03 5394112A 07-30-18 ARBELO, PABLO G & CHRISTEN 07-20-18 4601 78 2 510,900 690,000 74.04 5394387A 08-09-18 SANTARCANGELO, JASON 07-26-18 4202 2 C5008 2 301,400 407,000 74.05 5404101A 03-06-19 NEXGEN HOLDINGS LLC, 02-07-19 1509 24 2 474,200 640,000 74.09 5405868A 04-17-19 GREGORY, C & TAYLOR, G 04-10-19 4402 9 2 695,500 937,500 74.19 5405645A 04-05-19 KNORS, CHRISTOPHER & TRICI 03-22-19 4202 2 C4007 2 297,700 400,000 74.43 5394703A 08-16-18 HAMILTON, CHARLES 07-27-18 4601 119 2 694,800 930,000 74.71 5393336A 07-17-18 WAX-ORLOFF, AMY 07-03-18 2110 3 2 748,000 999,999 74.80 5395658A 08-29-18 CELANI, EMANUELE 06-07-18 407 4 2 879,100 1,175,000 74.82 5400250A 12-13-18 HUNTER, SIDNEY C & TAHI 10-29-18 4001 28 2 517,300 690,000 74.97 5394383A 08-09-18 SYLVESTER, MARTA 07-20-18 4507 15 2 533,600 710,000 75.15 5400246A 12-12-18 NADIR, NADIR A & GIEL, KAT 11-20-18 1501 5 C6303 2 312,800 415,000 75.37 5399599A 12-03-18 BARTLEY, GEORGE A & CAROL 11-14-18 1902 15 2 305,300 405,000 75.38 5399792A 12-04-18 11UM LLC, 11-30-18 1401 19 2 731,200 969,950 75.39 5393350A 07-24-18 KILIAN, MARK D 06-22-18 705 5 2 648,900 855,000 75.89 5395784A 09-10-18 OKUMURA, TERILYN 07-16-18 4202 2 C2011 2 307,700 405,000 75.98 5402806A 02-04-19 ELLISON, C. MICHAEL 11-18-18 4403 9 2 1,073,100 1,410,000 76.11 5409401A 06-28-19 CAMPBELL, SABRINA C 06-13-19 3106 12 C4.18 2 282,400 371,000 76.12 5402568A 01-28-19 YONG, SIN TECK ALAN 12-11-18 407 13 C0015 2 1,019,900 1,338,000 76.23 5399787A 11-30-18 WITTIG, JAMES C 11-28-18 4702 87 2 1,249,000 1,638,000 76.25 5399284A 11-14-18 ROSINI, NEIL J 10-15-18 1603 12 2 1,126,900 1,475,000 76.40 5402399A 01-18-19 KELSEY, RICHARD & SUZANNE 12-16-18 803 27 2 601,100 786,000 76.48 5408117A 06-14-19 SEVICK, MARY ANN 05-30-19 3106 12 X C3.16 2 290,700 380,000 76.50 5394176A 08-02-18 BAUER, CHRISTOPHER 07-23-18 2308 3 C3205 2 352,200 460,000 76.57 5394212A 08-03-18 ROBERTS, JAMES MICHAEL 07-31-18 2505 9 2 644,300 839,000 76.79 5397309A 10-04-18 SCHIANO, KRISTY 09-20-18 1501 5 C6107 2 323,400 421,000 76.82 5395840A 08-28-18 REUTER, MICHAEL 08-15-18 801 16 2 735,300 955,000 76.99 5405267A 03-27-19 SOKOL, FREDERIC J. 03-21-19 1501 5 C6301 2 192,500 250,000 77.00 5396281A 09-21-18 BOGAN, DARRYLE 09-07-18 2204 14 2 432,900 562,000 77.03 5395844A 09-04-18 FERONE, LOUIS 08-27-18 406 26 2 1,701,800 2,206,000 77.14 5399783A 11-30-18 GLOSTER, ANTHONY & CELESTE 10-31-18 1511 21 2 366,600 475,000 77.18 5400833A 12-26-18 BEGLEY, JENETTE M 12-14-18 3411 11 2 741,600 960,000 77.25 5400239A 12-10-18 STRAUSS, IRENA 11-15-18 3001 26 2 521,600 675,000 77.27 5398799A 11-08-18 TANAKA, YASUO & MIYAZAKI, 10-17-18 4803 13 2 565,600 730,000 77.48 5394883A 08-16-18 DALLAS, STEPHEN J 08-07-18 2502 14 2 689,800 889,000 77.59 5407584A 06-05-19 ANDREWS, JAMES M III & LOU 05-28-19 4402 12 2 591,200 760,000 77.79 5395847A 09-10-18 BOOSE, JUSTIN 08-31-18 2606 24 2 1,167,000 1,500,000 77.80 5406285A 04-08-19 DEAN, BRANTLEY & CAROLINE 04-01-19 2302 14 2 572,400 735,250 77.85 5397834A 10-23-18 CULLER, ALAN CAY & JEAN SM 10-18-18 1210 11 2 615,400 790,000 77.90

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405870A 04-22-19 JACKSON, TERRY & LEE, JANE 03-27-19 4601 55 2 649,100 833,000 77.92 5394124A 08-01-18 SIMEONI, STEPHEN M 07-16-18 3802 59 2 568,500 729,000 77.98 5394791A 08-14-18 CALLAGHAN, KIERAN 08-07-18 2408 24 C0006 2 265,200 340,000 78.00 5394905A 08-22-18 SPIVAK, MARK & PEGGY 07-25-18 4402 27 2 675,800 866,000 78.04 5398136A 10-30-18 WORSHAM, BRITTAIN 10-23-18 1002 2 2 592,300 759,000 78.04 5405646A 04-05-19 ASTARITA, ANTHONY & KAREN 04-03-19 4704 18 2 885,000 1,132,000 78.18 5407576A 06-04-19 GAUTIERI, VINCENT 05-21-19 3303 43 2 325,700 415,000 78.48 5406842A 04-16-19 BRAND, PETER & MARGARET K 03-28-19 3507 5 2 1,097,500 1,397,000 78.56 5399858A 12-05-18 BIGLEY, KEVIN & ERICA 11-28-18 4403 42 2 603,400 767,000 78.67 5396107A 09-17-18 LAGATREE, KIRSTEN (TRUSTEE 09-07-18 4601 52 2 571,200 726,000 78.68 5400488A 12-17-18 STROME, DAVID J 11-29-18 1301 10 2 826,600 1,050,000 78.72 5394208A 08-03-18 SANDHAM, JENIFER 07-27-18 1506 4 2 409,400 520,000 78.73 5394895A 08-21-18 MORAN, THOMAS A & MARY JO 08-10-18 4601 146 2 639,700 812,000 78.78 5399347A 11-16-18 SANDS, STEPHEN & JILL 10-25-18 2708 2 2 906,100 1,150,000 78.79 5397314A 10-05-18 SCHIAVO, ADRIANO 09-29-18 3201 32 C6302 2 182,000 230,000 79.13 5401362A 01-03-19 SHEPEN, RENNIE & BERNARD D 12-18-18 4805 113 2 787,800 995,000 79.18 5400554A 12-18-18 PRUNELL, JUSTIN E 11-30-18 405 16 2 953,100 1,201,000 79.36 5393308A 07-06-18 MCGREGOR, LANCE 06-18-18 204 1 2 1,114,300 1,401,000 79.54 5395843A 08-30-18 FARBER, LUKE & NINA 08-07-18 4601 25 2 744,000 935,000 79.57 5393331A 07-13-18 KORIAN, PETER 06-14-18 2704 16 2 963,000 1,210,000 79.59 5400236A 12-10-18 SEDEK, MARTIN & EILEEN 11-12-18 2206 19 C0202 2 327,200 411,000 79.61 5405206A 03-26-19 DRAGHICI, LAURA 02-15-19 4202 2 C2015 2 309,900 389,000 79.67 5393345A 07-18-18 MCANDREW, JASON J 07-12-18 1602 22 2 1,262,400 1,578,000 80.00 5393344A 07-18-18 MARCUS,DANIEL M+JOHNSON,KI 07-03-18 3501 39 2 781,900 977,000 80.03 5393347A 07-19-18 GALLAGHER, MARY JEAN 06-18-18 1810 13 C0003 2 256,100 320,000 80.03 5398137A 10-30-18 APONTE, RAQUEL 10-15-18 407 26 C0057 2 254,200 317,000 80.19 5394125A 08-02-18 SY, ERIC 07-18-18 3004 10 2 433,100 540,000 80.20 5402569A 01-28-19 COMBINOT LLC, 01-04-19 2214 35 2 337,400 420,000 80.33 5406861A 05-13-19 LEE, ANDREW S & RACHEL A 04-19-19 4511 19 2 486,000 605,000 80.33 5406883A 05-20-19 LIEBMAN, ALEXANDER 05-15-19 2506 35 2 947,400 1,179,000 80.36 5394385A 08-09-18 RODRIGUEZ, PAUL F 08-05-18 3504 51 2 768,400 956,000 80.38 5397964A 10-23-18 D'ANDREA, BEVERLY H 09-24-18 2901 2 2 421,300 524,000 80.40 5406287A 04-23-19 JOSEPHSON, ALEX & REBECCA 04-17-19 3502 13 2 659,300 820,000 80.40 5394898A 08-21-18 GATTO, MARK & MICHELA 08-16-18 2606 25 2 1,490,000 1,850,000 80.54 5395665A 09-04-18 BORNS, AARON 08-24-18 4401 34 2 654,000 812,000 80.54 5394210A 08-03-18 BELCASTRO, RACHAEL 07-11-18 2308 3 C3404 2 287,600 357,000 80.56 5394937A 08-24-18 BROWN, KENNETH A 08-03-18 3412 8 2 726,800 902,000 80.58 5405871A 04-22-19 HIRSCHHORN, PHILIP L 04-15-19 3507 16 2 739,100 917,000 80.60 5397963A 10-23-18 NAHABEDIAN, SARAH & DOUGLA 10-15-18 4202 2 C5017 2 286,300 355,000 80.65 5399286A 11-14-18 FALCIONI, FIORENZA 11-07-18 2104 26 C0005 2 226,300 280,000 80.82 5408691A 06-18-19 HARTINGER, JOHN S & COSTEL 06-12-19 4305 7 2 658,700 815,000 80.82 5407583A 06-05-19 SUTHERLAND, STUART & LISA 05-30-19 4503 10 2 577,600 714,000 80.90 5407572A 05-31-19 O'BRIEN, TIMOTHY PATRICK 05-21-19 406 22 2 1,278,800 1,580,000 80.94 5406863A 05-14-19 GOMEZ, FELICIA 05-08-19 2904 63 2 348,800 430,000 81.12 5400247A 12-12-18 GRAHAM, PETER & MONICA 12-05-18 4705 5 2 1,444,100 1,775,000 81.36 5395704A 08-27-18 FURIA, NINA W 07-25-18 4402 30 2 1,087,800 1,335,000 81.48

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400254A 12-14-18 KHERSONSKY, SERGE 12-11-18 4401 2 2 799,500 980,000 81.58 5393878A 07-27-18 EFTAXES, IAN 07-02-18 4401 44 2 881,400 1,080,000 81.61 5395850A 09-12-18 BRYANT, HAROLD 09-04-18 3502 38 2 657,000 805,000 81.61 5406874A 05-16-19 GRANT, ALECIA C. (TRUSTEE) 04-29-19 1903 27 2 379,600 465,000 81.63 5407588A 06-06-19 TESTA, JOSEPH A. & PATRICI 05-28-19 4506 26 2 633,300 775,000 81.72 5396747A 09-28-18 PAREDES, BLANCA 09-05-18 3308 8 2 654,400 800,000 81.80 5394175A 08-02-18 STONE, BRENDA Y 07-25-18 1910 1 2 500,200 611,280 81.83 5394935A 08-23-18 BASSIN, DONNA 08-16-18 601 21 2 695,800 850,000 81.86 5406866A 05-15-19 LESTER, ROBERT M JR & LESL 04-29-19 4202 2 C3015 2 221,500 270,000 82.04 5394907A 08-22-18 KLINE, DAVID & CHRISTINA B 06-29-18 2404 16 2 780,400 950,000 82.15 5406318A 05-06-19 PASLEY, LYDIA JOHANNS 04-19-19 4507 7 2 671,000 815,000 82.33 5394888A 08-17-18 NOLAN, EVE 07-30-18 3504 53 2 693,000 840,000 82.50 5401354A 12-28-18 STAEHLE, WILLIAM J JR 10-05-18 1806 11 2 985,900 1,195,000 82.50 5409244A 06-25-19 BAXTER, WILLIAM A. & EMILY 05-22-19 4209 20 C0002 2 312,700 379,000 82.51 5400557A 12-18-18 SPENCE, JAMES N 11-20-18 4003 25 2 416,800 505,000 82.53 5394379A 08-08-18 POLSON, JASON & CRYSTAL 08-03-18 3005 19 2 647,900 785,000 82.54 5395846A 09-10-18 DUNWORTH, GERALD J & COLET 08-22-18 4805 76 2 578,100 700,000 82.59 5396004A 09-12-18 CROWE, WADE CLARK 08-24-18 4514 17 2 825,200 999,000 82.60 5394207A 08-03-18 BAXTER, CHRISTOPHER M 07-27-18 4504 10 2 762,300 922,800 82.61 5395842A 08-29-18 MANN, HARPREET K 08-16-18 601 24 2 611,300 740,000 82.61 5397023A 10-02-18 RUSSO, ROBERT J 09-18-18 1711 18 C4.19 2 342,900 415,000 82.63 5405269A 03-27-19 BUONOMO, JAMES N 03-22-19 407 26 C0031 2 172,100 208,000 82.74 5395585A 08-28-18 COPELAND, JAMES 08-13-18 1710 1 2 559,100 675,000 82.83 5396141A 09-18-18 KAYNE, MICHAEL D 09-12-18 4511 7 2 539,900 651,000 82.93 5400654A 12-20-18 LOPEZ, GIOVANNA 12-14-18 703 17 2 705,500 850,000 83.00 5395849A 09-11-18 FELTENS, STEFAN 08-07-18 4402 8 2 1,047,800 1,262,000 83.03 5406887A 05-23-19 REICHARD, MARK & DEBRA 05-17-19 2502 4 2 590,500 710,500 83.11 5394890A 08-20-18 ALONSO, ALBERTO 08-10-18 3308 13 2 727,100 874,000 83.19 5394363A 08-06-18 WHITSETT, MARGARET JACK 07-31-18 4005 1 2 540,200 646,000 83.62 5404546A 03-13-19 KELLEY, ROBERT 03-08-19 2904 49 2 330,300 395,000 83.62 5395662A 08-31-18 KATZ, ADAM M 07-10-18 1602 25 2 1,170,900 1,400,000 83.64 5397319A 10-10-18 KRALOVICH, JOSEPH JR & KIM 10-04-18 2308 3 C3207 2 288,600 345,000 83.65 5399596A 11-27-18 HART, ANDREW D & SARAH 11-13-18 4513 16 2 544,000 650,000 83.69 5404673A 03-15-19 WAGNER, JACONDA 03-07-19 4103 8 2 359,300 429,000 83.75 5393323A 07-12-18 LUCCI, JOHN D 06-29-18 1511 5.01 C0003 2 330,900 395,000 83.77 5396143A 09-18-18 ANDERSON, JUAN & CARLENE 08-28-18 4409 2 2 599,400 715,000 83.83 5402668A 01-31-19 CARACCIOLO, ELAINE R 12-31-18 3405 6 2 622,500 742,000 83.89 5406327A 05-08-19 MANUEL, DENISE 04-30-19 4105 31 2 362,600 432,000 83.94 5396142A 09-18-18 BRANSFORD, TONI LYNNE 09-06-18 2702 10 2 734,800 875,000 83.98 5398131A 10-26-18 EISENSTEIN, V & DUFFIN, D 10-17-18 407 26 C0068 2 172,200 205,000 84.00 5401365A 01-04-19 VIOLETA, GAY & NICK 12-06-18 4210 13 C03.2 2 172,200 205,000 84.00 5400553A 12-18-18 MARADEI, GUILHERME 12-14-18 4402 34 2 920,100 1,095,000 84.03 5395654A 08-28-18 WARFIELD, RICHARD CLARK 07-26-18 1005 22 2 556,800 660,000 84.36 5399893A 12-06-18 DRANGULA, CHRISTY 11-13-18 3602 13 2 920,100 1,087,000 84.65 5395664A 09-04-18 HALL, DOUGLAS W 08-22-18 4506 27 2 655,300 771,000 84.99 5405205A 03-26-19 DEBNAM, SAMUEL L. 03-19-19 4003 7 2 425,200 500,000 85.04

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396746A 09-28-18 GONZALEZ, MICHELLE 08-28-18 2104 20 C0024 2 246,700 290,000 85.07 5395848A 09-11-18 HERSKOVIZ, DANIEL 08-07-18 1509 37 2 421,500 495,000 85.15 5395783A 09-07-18 DINAPOLI, ANTHONY 08-24-18 1711 18 C6.18 2 191,600 225,000 85.16 5399287A 11-15-18 LIEDTKA, HENRY J III 11-09-18 4601 33 2 724,000 850,000 85.18 5405428A 04-01-19 AUER, CHRISTOPHER & LAURA 03-27-19 1801 16 2 474,500 556,000 85.34 5399030A 11-13-18 KILINCOGLU, TAMER NAHIT 11-02-18 3505 36 2 653,400 765,000 85.41 5394390A 08-10-18 MARKOWITZ, WILLIAM G 07-25-18 4102 23 2 309,300 362,000 85.44 5393332A 07-13-18 MCLANNAHAN, BENJAMIN 06-29-18 3502 30 2 524,800 614,000 85.47 5395782A 09-07-18 LUFTGLASS, MURRAY A 08-26-18 3802 75 2 520,600 609,000 85.48 5401949A 01-14-19 UNGER, LAWRENCE P 12-10-18 4702 71 2 1,025,200 1,199,000 85.50 5395999A 09-10-18 STEWART, JANICE E & GAYMON 08-22-18 4601 64 2 539,100 630,000 85.57 5399595A 11-27-18 O'LEARY, KIRSTEN A & TERRE 11-12-18 4008 14 2 385,400 449,900 85.66 5406872A 05-16-19 KELLEY, BARBARA B. 04-25-19 2507 4 2 736,800 860,000 85.67 5405655A 04-15-19 GARCIA-RAMOS, MAURICIO & M 03-07-19 3001 17.02 2 803,100 937,000 85.71 5397470A 10-12-18 SCHWARTZ, BELLE 10-03-18 1711 18 C2.16 2 244,300 285,000 85.72 5393304A 07-05-18 MAYO, SCOTT 05-09-18 4007 6.03 2 743,100 866,000 85.81 5399588A 11-21-18 GAMBARDELLA, NINA 07-10-18 4507 3 2 670,000 780,000 85.90 5406879A 05-17-19 MIRSKY, JAY 05-10-19 1706 11 2 726,300 845,000 85.95 5403088A 02-15-19 LONG, SEAN & AJAA 02-14-19 3506 50 2 753,900 877,000 85.96 5406321A 05-06-19 149 WALNUT MONTCLAIR LLC 04-09-19 2311 6 2 739,300 860,000 85.97 5397832A 10-22-18 OBEROI, DHRUV & MEENA 09-27-18 407 26 C0011 2 172,100 200,000 86.05 5394391A 08-10-18 SHREEVE, JAMES & JESSICA 07-31-18 4204 6 C0001 2 258,000 299,000 86.29 5406309A 04-30-19 ROCKEFELLER,NELSON A JR &T 04-26-19 4705 4 2 2,514,100 2,911,763 86.34 5394889A 08-20-18 GRIFFIN, JAMES I 08-10-18 3606 16 2 651,100 752,000 86.58 5400829A 12-24-18 WENTE, MICHAEL & MYRNA M 12-13-18 3606 18 2 736,500 849,000 86.75 5396284A 09-21-18 DEM TWO HANDS INC, 09-12-18 1908 10 2 356,400 410,000 86.93 5394376A 08-08-18 DICKENS, JULIA 07-25-18 2108 5 C0015 2 452,100 520,000 86.94 5400242A 12-11-18 KELLER, ELAINE H 11-06-18 1711 18 C4.13 2 335,000 385,000 87.01 5407593A 06-10-19 SIHVONEN, SASU 06-06-19 3706 5 2 646,700 743,000 87.04 5406860A 05-13-19 NAMBURI, ARUNA (TRUSTE 05-06-19 2104 20 C0016 2 202,500 232,000 87.28 5402805A 02-01-19 MUKHERJEE, ANINDA & SEN, S 01-07-19 4805 80 2 455,900 522,000 87.34 5395659A 08-30-18 MAHAJAN, VIKAS 07-06-18 4514 9 2 958,300 1,095,000 87.52 5402667A 01-31-19 TORRES, MORGAN 01-24-19 2104 20 C0075 2 202,400 231,000 87.62 5408905A 06-21-19 THOMAS, RICHARD W. 05-31-19 4601 57 2 722,500 821,700 87.93 5406307A 04-29-19 MEDINA, JOSEPH 04-09-19 1801 36 2 514,700 585,000 87.98 5400249F 12-13-18 ANDERMAN, JASON MARK & GON 12-04-18 3106 12 X C2.13 2 290,500 330,000 88.03 5407589A 06-07-19 MOROKOFF, WILLIAM J 05-29-19 1603 19 2 660,000 749,500 88.06 5407587A 06-06-19 MELANSON, JESS & JENNIFER 06-03-19 3707 2 2 687,100 780,000 88.09 5400248A 12-12-18 ZAMONSKI, FAITH 11-30-18 1905 7 2 550,900 625,000 88.14 5408115A 06-11-19 UPSHAW, THEODORE JR. 05-31-19 4302 23 2 512,100 581,000 88.14 5406869A 05-16-19 FROMSON, JOSH & SACHS, HEA 04-26-19 3502 36 2 758,100 860,000 88.15 5403615A 02-22-19 SIROTA, ANDREA J. & DAVID 01-29-19 2709 9 2 1,033,600 1,170,000 88.34 5394697A 08-15-18 RULE, SIMON RICHARD 07-26-18 905 12 2 534,600 605,000 88.36 5393317A 07-10-18 FELLER, AMY (TRUSTEE) 06-29-18 903 28 2 650,200 735,000 88.46 5397468A 10-12-18 DIOGENES, ROCHELLE 09-14-18 4511 23 2 486,700 550,000 88.49 5393305A 07-05-18 NAPOLITANO, STEVEN F 06-27-18 3501 4 2 740,800 837,000 88.51

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393335A 07-17-18 BRONSTEIN, DAVID 07-02-18 3502 48 2 695,900 785,000 88.65 5396049A 09-14-18 CROSSLEY, RICHARD 06-22-18 203 7 2 1,220,300 1,375,000 88.75 5395987A 08-27-18 234 PARK ST LLC, 08-16-18 2507 5 2 679,100 765,000 88.77 5400489A 12-18-18 KAPLAN, DAVID 12-11-18 603 23 2 767,900 865,000 88.77 5396361A 09-24-18 HARTMAN, DOUGLAS H 09-11-18 1803 15 2 755,600 851,000 88.79 5400832A 12-26-18 GIDDENS, BRIAN & JENNIFER 12-12-18 1606 10 2 694,900 782,000 88.86 5396282A 09-21-18 SLATER, JONATHAN 08-28-18 3504 34 2 537,900 605,000 88.91 5395651A 08-28-18 EARLE, JAMES N 08-17-18 3001 17.03 2 805,100 905,000 88.96 5394120A 07-31-18 HADLEY, PETER J & SARAH L 06-11-18 603 27 2 1,610,800 1,810,000 88.99 5406289A 04-23-19 BRADY, KENNETH & ELIZABETH 04-15-19 2001 1 C0018 2 787,600 885,000 88.99 5393337A 07-17-18 BRANDENBURG, NEAL A 07-10-18 2505 11 2 816,000 915,000 89.18 5394204A 08-03-18 71 WILDWOOD LLC, 07-17-18 4601 83 2 571,500 640,000 89.30 5406880A 05-17-19 MCCULLOUGH, JOHN 05-13-19 704 6 2 714,600 800,000 89.33 5397313A 10-05-18 CESAREO, DANIEL 09-28-18 4703 3 2 626,300 700,000 89.47 5400556A 12-18-18 VIRGINIA, GABRIEL D 12-07-18 1711 18 C2.11 2 228,000 254,500 89.59 5404810A 03-20-19 LESSNER, JEANNE & FRANK, D 03-15-19 2802 15 2 785,700 875,000 89.79 5406854A 05-09-19 OLEN, ISABELLA 04-15-19 407 26 C0054 2 236,300 263,000 89.85 5396106A 09-17-18 MACAM, LUCIA 09-12-18 1711 18 C1.02 2 225,600 251,000 89.88 5394205A 08-03-18 127 VALLEY ROAD LLC, 07-27-18 1509 40.02 C0312 2 116,100 129,000 90.00 5400573A 12-19-18 INWOOD AVE LLC, 12-07-18 3602 1 2 900,400 999,990 90.04 5394372A 08-07-18 EPSTEIN, RICHARD & LAZEV, 07-08-18 304 16 C0001 2 720,600 800,000 90.08 5394699A 08-16-18 SULLIVAN, MARI JANE 07-09-18 4404 16 2 518,200 575,000 90.12 5395790A 09-11-18 SIMON, DEBRA 08-31-18 1603 4 2 878,700 975,000 90.12 5397965A 10-24-18 PIERRE-PAUL, JASON (TRUSTE 09-19-18 4408 5 2 942,500 1,045,000 90.19 5399593A 11-26-18 JACKSON, CYNTHIA 11-12-18 4202 2 C7004 2 297,700 330,000 90.21 5395785A 09-10-18 JORDAN, JOHN & NEWMAN, KYL 08-16-18 4802 14 2 578,900 640,000 90.45 5405644A 04-04-19 LEMIRE, FRANK & ALICE 03-27-19 4406 11 2 607,800 671,000 90.58 5399594A 11-26-18 CLEARVIEW EQUITIES LLC 11-15-18 3502 29 2 484,700 534,000 90.77 5396615A 09-28-18 12 CLAIRIDGE COURT LLC 09-21-18 4507 25 2 508,800 560,000 90.86 5395789A 09-11-18 CHAMBERS, AMY 08-30-18 3706 12 2 501,100 551,000 90.94 5407591A 06-07-19 ANDRIEU-DELILLE, SEVERIN & 05-03-19 3605 13 2 775,400 852,000 91.01 5394901A 08-22-18 KRIGSMAN, SPENCER & ELAINE 08-15-18 2505 18 2 718,500 789,000 91.06 5394117A 07-30-18 PALERMO, VINCENT J & ELIZA 07-20-18 4514 14 2 868,200 953,000 91.10 5398566A 11-01-18 LEFTWICH, BRIAN C & PAYNE, 10-26-18 4403 15 2 820,900 901,000 91.11 5404599A 03-14-19 SIRIN, SELCUK & LAUREN 03-11-19 2802 24 2 592,300 650,000 91.12 5394933A 08-23-18 SOTO, NICHOLAS ANTHONY 08-10-18 2602 17 C0003 2 454,800 499,000 91.14 5409245A 06-26-19 20 GLENWOOD LLC, 06-14-19 2706 3 2 649,500 712,000 91.22 5394122A 08-01-18 MISURACA, SALVATORE B. 07-13-18 4202 2 C4005 2 286,300 313,000 91.47 5394884A 08-16-18 LUCKINO, SAMUEL & ANDREA J 07-27-18 802 32 2 633,400 692,000 91.53 5395707A 09-06-18 DUMONT, SUSAN 08-24-18 405 22 2 1,470,500 1,606,290 91.55 5401631A 01-08-19 TRUMAN, MARK F 01-04-19 1604 15 2 554,000 605,000 91.57 5399356A 11-20-18 BRYAN, CRAIGH 11-13-18 4506 12 2 650,300 710,000 91.59 5406859A 05-13-19 RAFFERTY, THOMAS P & CHERY 05-07-19 1905 6 2 876,400 955,999 91.67 5393319A 07-10-18 KERR, MARYANN & ET AL. 06-01-18 4403 25 2 506,300 552,000 91.72 5394936A 08-24-18 CONNELL, RAYMOND R 08-06-18 4514 33 2 742,000 809,000 91.72 5403080A 02-13-19 NYLEN, PER W & CHERYL 01-31-19 2108 5 C0012 2 549,800 599,000 91.79

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394899A 08-22-18 FREEMAN, MICHAEL & WHITESI 08-15-18 903 26.01 2 698,600 760,569 91.85 5405432A 04-04-19 CAMPISANO, STEFANI 03-22-19 3206 6 C0006 2 303,200 330,000 91.88 5395660A 08-30-18 ZAFAR, KASHIF & KARAR, NAV 07-22-18 1301 31 2 1,279,900 1,389,000 92.15 5397714A 10-17-18 ULUSOY, MEHMET ALI 03-02-18 1711 18 C1.26 2 183,700 199,220 92.21 5393339A 07-17-18 GARNER, PATRICK J 06-12-18 3410 6 2 717,700 777,777 92.28 5395845A 09-07-18 DOCTOR, BARBARA M 08-31-18 2904 28.05 2 406,900 440,000 92.48 5394698A 08-15-18 D'AGOSTINO, RUDOLPH 07-13-18 4504 1 2 652,100 705,000 92.50 5401364A 01-03-19 VOMACKA, ALAN & GARCY, ANN 12-17-18 2501 14 2 665,200 719,000 92.52 5404449A 03-12-19 SIMON, ANDREW 03-05-19 602 21 2 1,434,600 1,549,000 92.61 5395650A 08-28-18 FOGLIZZO, OLIVIER 08-15-18 1709 5 2 684,500 739,000 92.63 5394695A 08-13-18 VANDERKLEIN, DIRK W & SHAF 08-06-18 1710 10 2 574,500 620,000 92.66 5395787A 09-10-18 LEARD, JOHN & ARIN 08-30-18 3409 4 2 695,000 750,000 92.67 5401358A 12-29-18 VAN BEUNINGEN, ADRIAN & RH 12-11-18 1704 10 2 626,400 675,000 92.80 5399793A 12-04-18 MACHERNIS, MICHAEL R 11-27-18 2507 7 2 708,100 762,500 92.87 5401353A 12-28-18 SADLER, LINDA A. 12-17-18 1805 1 2 623,400 670,000 93.04 5404100A 03-06-19 KENNEDY, TIMOTHY W 02-13-19 4403 10 2 875,000 940,000 93.09 5406862A 05-14-19 SF HOLDINGS, LLC, 04-23-19 3706 10 2 758,700 815,000 93.09 5397312A 10-05-18 HODGE, JAMES 06-01-18 4801 6 2 407,300 437,500 93.10 5394211A 08-03-18 TOBIN, CARMELYN D 07-27-18 3502 44 2 629,500 675,000 93.26 5401636A 01-09-19 STETKEVYCH, ALEXANDER & LE 01-02-19 4702 9 2 836,400 895,000 93.45 5394892A 08-20-18 CHESTNUT, THEODORE 08-03-18 4509 21 2 587,900 629,000 93.47 5399352A 11-19-18 HUTCHNS, KRISTEN 10-30-18 1705 14 2 432,400 462,000 93.59 5396360A 09-24-18 CALDWELL, DAVID C 08-23-18 3703 3 2 609,300 650,000 93.74 5405651A 04-10-19 CAHILL, JOHN R 03-29-19 603 11 2 987,500 1,052,500 93.82 5408906A 06-24-19 BRAVO, NELIDA 06-14-19 3802 43 2 413,200 440,000 93.91 5397478A 10-15-18 POWELL, MATTHEW H 10-04-18 3501 30 2 724,700 771,000 93.99 5407594A 06-10-19 WEIDEMANN, JOHN M 06-05-19 3603 11 2 845,400 899,000 94.04 5394700A 08-16-18 EPHROS, HILLEL 07-24-18 4514 15 2 842,600 895,000 94.15 5406867A 05-15-19 HALPERN, SETH 05-03-19 3106 12 C4.16 2 291,600 309,000 94.37 5395657A 08-29-18 GILL, BRENDAN 08-17-18 3505 38 2 666,100 705,000 94.48 5396005A 09-12-18 THAMES, MIGUEL 07-30-18 2408 23 2 1,228,400 1,300,000 94.49 5401626A 01-07-19 SWITALA, KURT T & MARY F 12-28-18 3504 50 2 663,800 702,000 94.56 5406319A 05-06-19 ZAJAC, NANCY H 05-01-19 4805 5 2 461,600 488,000 94.59 5400241A 12-10-18 SIEMONS, GARY O & FAVATA, 11-12-18 4211 11 C0009 2 255,600 270,000 94.67 5394891A 08-20-18 BOYER, DIANE W 07-25-18 1703 52 2 791,900 834,000 94.95 5406305A 04-29-19 YEAPLE, CHRISTOPHER 04-23-19 3403 12 2 579,900 610,000 95.07 5394693A 08-13-18 WALTER, WILLIAM TODD & ELE 08-09-18 1102.01 34 2 1,188,500 1,250,000 95.08 5406290A 04-23-19 RICHMAN, LABE M & ROTMAN, 04-12-19 1808 10 2 741,600 777,000 95.44 5401627A 01-07-19 24 ELM STREET CONDOMINIUMS 10-16-18 3103 4 C0023 2 428,700 449,000 95.48 5405072A 03-25-19 KRAVETZ, CRAIG 02-26-19 3309 11 2 687,700 720,000 95.51 5407595A 06-10-19 CANNELL, JOHN & ELIZABETH 05-30-19 2001 23 2 1,337,600 1,400,000 95.54 5397310A 10-04-18 SILKENSEN, BRIAN R 09-26-18 3001 60 C0005 2 226,500 237,000 95.57 5406878A 05-17-19 MEJIA, JULIE ANNE 04-10-19 803 61 2 526,700 551,000 95.59 5394702A 08-16-18 HENNING, RAYMOND & LISA N 08-01-18 2506 4 2 694,400 726,000 95.65 5398797A 11-07-18 BERTSCHE, COPELAND G & AND 10-29-18 1202 18 2 1,544,800 1,615,000 95.65 5399354A 11-19-18 CARLTON, JOHN & LAUREN 11-09-18 2703 1 2 766,100 800,000 95.76

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 8 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394116A 07-30-18 MALIK, RAASHID 07-12-18 1201 16 2 1,150,000 1,200,000 95.83 5402402A 01-22-19 HAMMOND, ASHLEY 01-16-19 3304 14 2 335,500 350,000 95.86 5393348A 07-20-18 BAEZ, MARIA SOLIS 07-16-18 3501 3 2 728,900 760,000 95.91 5403839A 02-28-19 SHAH, RAJUL 02-11-19 1711 18 C1.25 2 225,600 235,000 96.00 5406296A 04-24-19 CARROLL, THOMAS J & LAURA 04-11-19 3706 53 2 621,100 645,000 96.29 5407333A 05-31-19 SCHOGOL, ROBIN BETH 05-13-19 3607 18 2 755,900 785,000 96.29 5406313A 05-02-19 NS INVESTORS, LLC. 04-17-19 3004 1 2 385,200 400,000 96.30 5396283A 09-21-18 PENDAS, ANTHONY M 09-14-18 203 11 2 856,600 889,000 96.36 5400831A 12-24-18 LONG, GAIL M 12-14-18 1902 2 2 309,300 321,000 96.36 5405073A 03-25-19 BROWN, SHAMEEN 03-11-19 1902 14 2 342,300 355,000 96.42 5408907A 06-24-19 MOORE, SCOTT M 04-04-19 3504 25 2 751,300 779,000 96.44 5399291A 11-16-18 DIAL, THOMAS 11-06-18 2505 8 2 694,600 720,000 96.47 5403074A 02-11-19 TOBIN, JOSEPH L III 02-08-19 2701 10 2 699,800 725,000 96.52 5398798A 11-07-18 LIEW, W. RANDOLPH VAN 10-26-18 1711 18 C6.08 2 193,100 199,900 96.60 5398139A 10-30-18 FEDERGREEN, LAUREN 10-16-18 4212 1 C0008 2 222,300 230,000 96.65 5406320A 05-06-19 EGAN, SHARON 04-24-19 2607 15 2 1,266,600 1,310,000 96.69 5399285A 11-14-18 LURIE, ROBERT F 11-06-18 4502 13 2 967,800 999,999 96.78 5394886A 08-17-18 WARD, PAUL & NANCY 08-13-18 2602 29 2 910,200 940,000 96.83 5396285A 09-21-18 BLOCK, DAVID H & VIRGINIA 09-12-18 601 29 2 968,900 999,999 96.89 5407597A 06-17-19 ABRAMS, CREIGHTON III & LI 06-03-19 3703 17 2 703,300 725,000 97.01 5393310A 07-06-18 KELLY, BRIAN EDWARD 05-29-18 4509 19 2 558,200 575,000 97.08 5399355A 11-19-18 ANDRUEI-DELILLE, APOLLINE 11-13-18 3707 11 2 573,900 590,000 97.27 5406299A 04-25-19 CAMPBELL, BEVERLEY J 04-09-19 4105 38 2 275,600 283,000 97.39 5401357A 12-29-18 BRODERICK, ANDREW 12-06-18 3106 12 C1.12 2 203,800 209,000 97.51 5400487A 12-17-18 PAINE, JOHN KNOWLTON 12-05-18 3506 26 2 675,400 692,500 97.53 5407330A 05-29-19 SEGAL, SARAH K & ROGER 05-21-19 4702 17 2 1,073,900 1,100,000 97.63 5399349A 11-16-18 SERLEN, BRUCE P & NAOMI N 11-14-18 3503 13 2 661,300 675,000 97.97 5402194A 01-18-19 CHAMBERS, LEO R 01-09-19 4305 5 2 646,800 660,000 98.00 5393297A 07-02-18 ZARRILLO, C DANIEL 06-26-18 4313 3 2 666,600 680,000 98.03 5402404A 01-23-19 SCOTLAND, GLENN F & DIANE 01-04-19 2401 32 2 904,300 920,000 98.29 5406877A 05-17-19 WATSON, FREIDA C. 05-03-19 2001 5 2 828,400 840,000 98.62 5400659A 12-21-18 DABROWSKI, JEAN & ROMANGER 12-18-18 2805 22 2 559,900 567,000 98.75 5393353A 07-26-18 CARLOCK, BRIAN C 07-16-18 3505 46 2 706,300 715,000 98.78 5395705A 08-27-18 MENK, CARL WILLIAM 08-20-18 1102 52 2 1,048,500 1,060,000 98.92 5408909A 06-24-19 DWYER, JAMES HOLT & JENNIF 06-04-19 2403 2 2 1,261,300 1,275,000 98.93 5393338A 07-17-18 VAN INWEGEN, GREGORY B 06-29-18 3606 2 2 969,200 979,000 99.00 5394121A 07-31-18 CHLETOS, THOMAS R 07-17-18 501 23 2 777,300 785,000 99.02 5406315A 05-06-19 BRICKNELL, SARAH M & ERIC 04-04-19 4513 43.04 2 1,072,000 1,080,000 99.26 5397471A 10-12-18 CARR, PETER 09-24-18 502 1 2 1,045,300 1,050,000 99.55 5399586A 11-20-18 RAPAPORT, GREGG H 11-15-18 3604 31 2 1,167,400 1,169,000 99.86 5394381A 08-08-18 GURNIAK, DAVID T 07-23-18 3701 16 2 859,300 860,000 99.92 5408113A 06-11-19 DAVID, FAYE & CLAIRMONTE 05-23-19 3111 75 2 215,200 215,000 100.09 5408690A 06-17-19 CREDIT SHELTER TRU 05-23-19 4805 98 2 800,900 799,900 100.13 5393343A 07-18-18 PUGATCH, EUGENE M J 06-25-18 304 26 2 771,900 770,000 100.25 5399353A 11-19-18 HARRINGTON, THOMAS P & ET 10-30-18 1607 2 2 602,700 600,256 100.41 5393341A 07-18-18 CHURCHMAN, JAMES E III 06-28-18 4308 55 2 598,200 595,000 100.54

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 9 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400657A 12-20-18 85 CHRISTOPHER STREET, LLC 11-20-18 4303 7 2 573,800 570,000 100.67 5403888A 03-01-19 PEREZ, CATHERINE J. 02-06-19 402 4 2 780,300 775,000 100.68 5395663A 09-04-18 OSER, ROY B 08-20-18 3705 24 2 712,300 707,000 100.75 5395788A 09-10-18 PORCHER, HAROLD E & STEVEN 08-28-18 4507 22 2 571,600 567,000 100.81 5394388A 08-10-18 NORVELL, SCOTT M & EMLING, 06-23-18 1807 10 2 810,600 799,000 101.45 5404102A 03-06-19 LEDERMAN, ARLINE J 02-15-19 3204 18 2 675,600 665,000 101.59 5408683A 06-06-19 POST, WILLIAM J. & BLOCH, 05-23-19 2001 1 C0112 2 763,300 750,000 101.77 5395841A 08-28-18 CASEY, DENNIS J 08-22-18 1804 10 2 1,008,700 989,000 101.99 5399600A 12-03-18 GOTTUNG, BETH L 11-16-18 2104 20 C0021 2 234,600 230,000 102.00 5405647A 04-05-19 ROULEAU, WILLIAM J. & MARY 01-18-19 4211 15 C01.1 2 207,100 203,000 102.02 5393352A 07-24-18 FRITCHMAN, DALE 07-13-18 3106 12 C6.06 2 198,100 194,000 102.11 5393324A 07-12-18 TILTON, STEPHEN R & JUDITH 05-12-18 602 21 2 1,521,900 1,490,000 102.14 5406858A 05-13-19 HOWLETT, MARGARET A 05-02-19 3605 12 2 640,400 625,000 102.46 5394367A 08-06-18 GARABEDIAN, DOMINIC & VICT 07-16-18 504 24 2 1,029,500 999,999 102.95 5406306A 04-29-19 HIRAI, ELIZABETH A. 04-08-19 3608 22 2 783,500 760,000 103.09 5395990A 08-29-18 SWENSON, RICHARD I 08-20-18 3802 30 2 423,800 410,000 103.37 5403777A 02-22-19 WHITE, PATSEY 02-06-19 3404 7 2 630,700 610,000 103.39 5397715A 10-17-18 GAYDOS, DARLENE & ALBERT L 07-16-18 103 27 2 1,033,800 999,000 103.48 5406300A 04-25-19 MCQUEEN, STEVEN W 03-29-19 2904 58 2 341,600 330,000 103.52 5400240A 12-10-18 SPRAGUE, JOHN FREDERICK 11-16-18 1605 10 2 623,800 600,000 103.97 5394209A 08-03-18 REED-HERRERA, SHERLY 07-17-18 4202 2 C5002 2 286,300 275,300 104.00 5407332A 05-30-19 HARNER, DEBRA 05-22-19 2708 23 2 1,037,000 997,000 104.01 5396007A 09-12-18 MARSHALL, WILLIAM G 08-30-18 2204 16 2 922,700 885,000 104.26 5393325A 07-12-18 KENNY, GEROGE J & SANDRA B 06-22-18 1503 15 2 844,100 809,000 104.34 5399592A 11-26-18 ZOBLER, ANDREW E 11-19-18 901 3 2 709,900 680,000 104.40 5403781A 02-26-19 ISRAEL, AARON & JENNIFER 02-13-19 603 43 2 1,016,900 974,000 104.40 5396108A 09-18-18 SIMONS, JOHN W 07-19-18 4805 10 2 532,100 509,500 104.44 5408711A 06-18-19 LACEY, ANDREW & WENDY 06-13-19 3604 1 2 1,254,300 1,200,000 104.53 5394881A 08-16-18 BAJAJ, RAJEEV & CAROLYN E 08-04-18 2401 6 2 934,500 891,000 104.88 5408714A 06-19-19 WHITE, CLAUDE ESLEY 01-31-19 3602 11 2 676,500 645,000 104.88 5401952A 01-15-19 STOKES, PHILIP D. 11-28-18 2103 20 2 725,600 690,000 105.16 5409397A 06-24-19 CAREY, JEFFREY C 06-07-19 2706 15 2 1,371,800 1,301,000 105.44 5396280A 09-19-18 JOHNSON, NATHANIEL JR & GA 07-31-18 2101 10 2 659,800 625,000 105.57 5407569A 05-24-19 STEPPINGSTONE PROPERTIES L 05-22-19 101 2 2 1,588,200 1,500,000 105.88 5397716A 10-18-18 FISCHKELTA, GINA 10-05-18 3411 1 2 591,500 557,000 106.19 5398567A 11-02-18 XU, JAN YOKO 10-12-18 3603 20 2 975,400 915,000 106.60 5395991A 08-30-18 GLASOFER, MATTHEW & LIPTON 08-21-18 4701 15 2 994,300 930,000 106.91 5408679A 05-17-19 CURRY, JAMES P. 03-31-19 1711 18 C1.08 2 193,100 180,000 107.28 5394900A 08-22-18 OREN, GIL 07-23-18 204 12 2 805,500 750,000 107.40 5397475A 10-15-18 NOLAN, GLORIA F 10-05-18 4805 2 2 462,400 430,000 107.53 5396611A 09-26-18 UNGER, NICHOLAS 09-07-18 1801 22 2 532,700 494,000 107.83 5394794A 08-15-18 CONNOR, EDWARD WILLIAM 04-10-18 203 4 2 1,266,800 1,172,500 108.04 5404447A 03-11-19 BERMAN, DOUGLAS 02-28-19 2502 7 2 522,300 482,500 108.25 5398451A 10-30-18 MORALES, ABRAM 09-19-18 1605 20 2 508,600 469,050 108.43 5407568A 05-22-19 LENTZ, MICHAEL 05-16-19 3706 69 2 401,700 370,000 108.57 5402664A 01-30-19 LUDLUM, MELISSA L 01-02-19 1809 25 2 954,700 879,000 108.61

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 10 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400835A 12-27-18 GRELE, MICHAEL A & FEDELE, 12-10-18 2503 63 2 581,400 535,000 108.67 5408908A 06-24-19 STEINLAUF, SELMA 06-03-19 4703 13 2 851,400 780,000 109.15 5401950A 01-14-19 MCKENZIE, DONNA R 12-11-18 1202 13 2 768,600 700,000 109.80 5406875A 05-16-19 GOLDIN, ALAN & LYNNE 05-13-19 4510 1 2 487,500 444,000 109.80 5406848A 05-07-19 FREEMAN, LAURETTA B. 04-17-19 4511 29 2 469,200 425,000 110.40 5394796A 08-16-18 OSHMAN, THEODORE & ANNE 08-02-18 1101 14 2 1,302,200 1,175,000 110.83 5400238A 12-10-18 BARBER, FRANK W (TRUSTEE) 11-27-18 4510 31 2 450,700 405,000 111.28 5406873A 05-16-19 LANE, CARL & CAROLINE A. 05-07-19 3606 32 2 761,700 680,000 112.01 5404098A 03-04-19 MCCLEARN, SYLVESTER D 02-06-19 1205 5 2 1,260,600 1,125,000 112.05 5399590A 11-26-18 DUNKEL, JASON & FAITH 11-19-18 2001 17 2 979,300 873,000 112.18 5394174A 08-02-18 GUERRERO, ALIRIO H 06-18-18 4511 1 2 533,500 475,000 112.32 5396048A 09-13-18 EMERSON, ROBERT K 09-05-18 3507 3 2 776,700 690,000 112.57 5398793A 11-05-18 DUBROW, MARSHA A & ROSENBE 10-31-18 1805 31 2 678,300 602,000 112.67 5400244A 12-11-18 RICHARDSON, MICHAEL 11-29-18 2805 36 2 857,400 761,000 112.67 5409241A 06-24-19 GROTH, HILDA 06-11-19 1705 30 2 488,000 430,000 113.49 5394118A 07-30-18 HOBBS, JEAN 07-10-18 2904 33 2 295,400 260,000 113.62 5405070A 03-25-19 VAN FRANK, LESLIE 03-04-19 3503 3 2 628,100 552,000 113.79 5406856A 05-10-19 PIETRANGELO, CARL B & SHAW 03-13-19 4511 16 2 546,900 480,000 113.94 5395985A 08-23-18 JOHNSON, MARILYN F 07-30-18 3703 10 2 691,300 605,000 114.26 5396140A 09-17-18 MONTAGUE, J DAVID 08-03-18 2507 8 2 1,498,100 1,300,000 115.24 5405273A 03-29-19 MOORE, RODDY & HEATHER 03-22-19 501 14 2 796,600 690,000 115.45 5394364A 08-06-18 MARTELLA, JOSEPH M 07-31-18 1806 19 2 1,156,800 999,000 115.80 5407577A 06-04-19 WHITE, JOHN J 05-14-19 2805 14 2 677,500 579,000 117.01 5394378A 08-08-18 CARRIER, ELIZABETH LADU 07-30-18 803 85 2 587,000 500,000 117.40 5397315A 10-09-18 OUW, WILLEM B & DE FEO, GL 10-03-18 303 5 2 843,600 710,000 118.82 5396003A 09-11-18 RUSSO, LEONARD J 08-23-18 906 14 2 573,600 482,000 119.00 5396052A 09-14-18 FITZGERALD, MADELYN 08-28-18 1708 12 2 608,800 510,000 119.37 5403081A 02-13-19 BAROL INVESTMENT GROUP, LL 02-05-19 1509 12 2 293,000 240,000 122.08 5397968T 10-25-18 MILLER, ERIC W (TRUSTEE) 10-18-18 4405 19 2 552,300 451,000 122.46 5400830F 12-24-18 WIGHT, SARAH J 12-17-18 2001 6 2 860,600 700,000 122.94 5408684A 06-07-19 BUDD, STEVEN D. 05-28-19 204 15.04 2 1,076,400 870,000 123.72 5399591A 11-26-18 SOPKIA, MARILYN J 10-29-18 1603 31 2 870,200 699,000 124.49 5394111A 07-27-18 BRUNSON, JAMES W 07-06-18 3201 22 2 452,200 362,500 124.74 5402565F 01-24-19 FRANKIEWICZ, SUSAN GARDNER 01-14-19 1711 18 C2.25 2 187,600 150,000 125.07 5401947F 01-11-19 KOEBEL, FRANK E 12-20-18 4701 23 2 691,500 540,000 128.06 5406322F 05-07-19 SCHNARR, WILLIAM & ET AL. 04-05-19 303 6 2 1,362,000 1,040,000 130.96 5401363F 01-03-19 GABLER, SIGRID C 12-07-18 1206 4 2 1,044,400 789,000 132.37 YEAR TO DATE 451 293,063,300 331,085,890 40,146.04 5394202F 08-03-18 11 MIDLAND ASSOCIATES, LLC 07-26-18 2210 8 4A 482,400 878,000 54.94 5403886F 02-06-19 NOVUS MONTCLAIR, LLC. 01-31-19 4001 5 4A 825,100 1,250,000 66.01 5393296F 07-02-18 INTRADOS 36 LLC, 06-22-18 2213 11 4A 363,200 517,000 70.25 5393351F 07-24-18 STANTON, RICHARD A 06-27-18 3201 5 4A 646,200 724,000 89.25 5394384F 08-09-18 417 BLOOMFIELD AVENUE LLC 07-09-18 3205 5 4A 968,700 980,000 98.85

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 11 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 13 MONTCLAIR TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5397833F 10-22-18 539 VALLEY ROAD CORPORATIO 09-28-18 1712 4 4A 1,176,400 1,085,000 108.42 5400572F 12-10-18 62 SOUTH FULLERTON ASSOCIA 11-28-18 2202 7 4A 2,479,900 1,800,000 137.77 YEAR TO DATE 7 6,941,900 7,234,000 625.49 5409400F 06-28-19 136 LINCOLN STREET LLC 06-14-19 3006 8 4C 501,600 800,000 62.70 5398568F 11-02-18 RADECKI, JOANNA 10-19-18 2003 7 4C 869,500 1,050,000 82.81 5401359F 12-29-18 390 ORANGE RD, LLC, 12-18-18 2904 42 4C 536,000 610,000 87.87 YEAR TO DATE 3 1,907,100 2,460,000 233.38 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 461 301,912,300 340,779,890 41,004.91

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5398458F 10-19-18 SANTOS, CARLOS & MARIA F 10-08-18 934 19.01 1 93,300 565,000 16.51 5399178F 10-30-18 VIP INVESTMENTS, LLC. 10-17-18 522 12 1 17,100 85,000 20.12 5404818F 02-27-19 MCDANIEL, MCCLAIRE 02-15-19 2680 1 1 11,300 30,000 37.67 5393506F 07-16-18 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROPERTI 04-05-18 1778 46 1 27,800 43,000 64.65 5397770F 10-15-18 848-850 SUMMER AVENUE, LLC 10-05-18 815 4 1 91,600 135,000 67.85 5396365F 09-19-18 MOLINA, SANTOS 08-24-18 244 24 X 1 157,800 230,000 68.61 5403207F 02-11-19 PALHETE, ARTUR S 01-25-19 2631 8 1 31,600 40,000 79.00 5406498F 04-29-19 GORDON, JAMES 01-23-19 3590 31 1 21,300 25,000 85.20 5405673F 04-05-19 FERREIRA, JOSE M. & MARIA 03-28-19 1813 54 1 32,800 35,000 93.71 5401137F 12-20-18 VETON TRADING CORP 11-13-18 320 56 1 29,700 29,000 102.41 5395900F 09-10-18 MCMILLAN, LIZZIE 08-22-18 3030 9 1 31,300 27,500 113.82 5395362F 08-28-18 FENA PROPERTIES, LLC. 08-03-18 321 61 1 30,200 14,000 215.71** YEAR TO DATE 12 575,800 1,258,500 965.26 5397088F 10-04-18 CARHUAVILCA, SAMUEL & GLOR 09-24-18 450 18 2 63,400 275,000 23.05 5394981A 08-16-18 EHP231N N5TH LLC, 08-10-18 1915 43 2 131,900 380,000 34.71 5397919A 10-11-18 PINTO, ANTONIO 10-04-18 2077 35 2 175,100 495,000 35.37 5393534A 07-18-18 HENRIQUES, JOAO & MARIA O 07-03-18 954 57 2 172,200 482,500 35.69 5393636A 07-25-18 A&V INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC. 07-12-18 1938 3 2 107,200 299,000 35.85 5393485A 07-13-18 128 SOUTH 13TH STREET, LLC 07-11-18 1859 48 2 130,700 355,000 36.82 5395587A 08-31-18 BURGOS, EDWIN & BURGOS, LA 08-15-18 697 54 2 120,100 325,000 36.95 5393456T 07-11-18 EMPIRE PROPERTIES GROUP LL 06-04-18 4033 64 X 2 124,300 335,000 37.10 5407652A 04-17-19 KANU, FATIMA 03-08-19 287 41 2 33,500 90,000 37.22 5398457A 10-19-18 HAYES, DOLORES A 10-05-18 2480 33 2 149,000 398,500 37.39 5408746A 06-20-19 DA COSTA, JACIR S. 06-07-19 937 61 2 218,400 580,000 37.66 5395597A 09-04-18 DASILVA, CARLOS & LEAL, CR 08-20-18 185 22 2 157,800 415,000 38.02 5409406A 06-25-19 LOPEZ, ISMAEL & SONIA 06-14-19 618 8 2 153,000 385,000 39.74 5407811F 05-17-19 TAVARES, ANTONIO H 05-10-19 2075 47 2 182,500 450,000 40.56 5395140A 08-23-18 DELLISANTI, ANTHONY 08-20-18 558 48 2 123,700 299,000 41.37 5406901F 04-09-19 SHARHABI, YONA 03-20-19 4204 17 2 152,000 360,000 42.22 5397026A 09-27-18 RODRIGUES, MARIA A. 09-17-18 926 61 2 194,600 460,000 42.30 5402464F 01-22-19 SUAREZ, ASHLEY N 01-15-19 739 40 2 210,700 495,000 42.57 5393501A 07-16-18 MONTINA HOLDINGS LLC, 06-27-18 540 68 2 57,800 135,000 42.81 5393448A 07-10-18 GUERRIER, BILLY 04-23-18 2649 39 2 165,900 385,000 43.09 5397356A 10-10-18 SAMANIEGO, FRANKLIN VINICI 09-26-18 575 92 2 77,700 180,000 43.17 5394976A 08-16-18 483 PARKER STREET, LLC. 08-09-18 671 35 2 222,800 515,000 43.26 5395366A 08-28-18 SILVATA, LLC. 08-17-18 2476 24 2 238,000 549,000 43.35 5402689F 01-24-19 MITTLEMAN, MATTY 01-17-19 262 17 2 161,400 370,000 43.62 5406386A 04-22-19 59 MAPES AVE LLC, 12-21-18 3650 31 2 161,000 369,000 43.63 5402828F 01-31-19 L & B REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS 01-25-19 2653 41 2 119,800 274,000 43.72 5395040A 08-17-18 SERAFIN, SYLWESTER 07-30-18 560 42 2 127,100 290,000 43.83 5404337A 01-04-19 ACKAH, KWANSAH 12-19-18 3723 10 2 143,300 325,000 44.09 5409410A 06-27-19 ROBINSON, GLENNARD & RIVER 06-24-19 555 10 2 119,800 270,000 44.37 5407865F 05-23-19 TEIXEIRA, ANTONIO J 04-30-19 2038 14 2 177,600 400,000 44.40

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407739F 05-09-19 JONES, JAZMINE A. 05-01-19 3665 88 2 161,400 360,000 44.83 5396629A 09-25-18 SSS INVESTMENTS LLC, 08-30-18 4079.01 82 2 149,300 330,500 45.17 5394454A 08-07-18 DAVENPORT NEWARK LLC, 06-26-18 1940 48 2 155,900 345,000 45.19 5400869F 12-11-18 ALICEA, ALEXANDER 11-30-18 1794 16 2 159,300 350,000 45.51 5395420A 08-29-18 145 RIDGE INVESTMENTS LLC 07-31-18 509 50 2 193,600 425,000 45.55 5396066A 09-13-18 EQUITY CAPITOL, LLC. & HIS 08-29-18 4040 15 2 119,300 260,000 45.88 5409357F 06-27-19 JAIVIENT INVESTMENTS, LLC. 06-19-19 491 50 2 119,300 260,000 45.88 5395033A 08-17-18 WALKER, GINA M 08-14-18 1922 25 2 149,200 325,000 45.91 5395866A 09-11-18 TUESDAY BSD LLC, 08-17-18 3733 17 2 134,400 290,000 46.34 5393965T 07-26-18 102 WEST 3RD LLC, 06-28-18 4031 13 2 156,100 335,000 46.60 5396234A 09-18-18 JJ II VENTURES LLC, 09-11-18 4095 14 2 126,700 270,000 46.93 5395160A 08-24-18 GOLDEN TOUCH REAL ESTATE I 08-10-18 4138 32 2 141,700 300,000 47.23 5394668A 08-13-18 EGOMANIAC RENOVATION,LLC 07-08-18 3677 15 2 154,000 325,000 47.38 5395053A 08-20-18 111 MAGAZINE STREET HOLDIN 08-15-18 2073 29 2 273,300 575,000 47.53 5394623A 08-13-18 PRESTIGE REALTY INVESTMENT 07-24-18 3711 39 2 142,400 299,000 47.63 5397192A 10-04-18 610 HOLDINGS, LLC. 08-09-18 3643 34 2 171,200 359,000 47.69 5393974A 07-27-18 D-SQUARED INVESTMENT,LLC 06-15-18 712 12 2 283,900 595,000 47.71 5394405A 08-02-18 50 SEYMOUR AVE ASSOCIATES, 06-13-18 2657 34 2 167,200 350,000 47.77 5395862A 09-11-18 BELTRAN, OMAR 08-10-18 937 55 2 197,100 412,000 47.84 5394394A 08-02-18 ADEFOWOKAN, ROTANNA 07-24-18 927 3 2 203,600 425,000 47.91 5409411A 06-28-19 LUONGO, JOSEPH 06-03-19 534 18 2 83,400 174,000 47.93 5395907A 09-11-18 MIAZIN, STANISLAW 08-23-18 1010 17.02 2 336,100 700,000 48.01 5394135A 07-31-18 20-22 YATES HOLDINGS, LLC. 07-24-18 3599 12 2 187,400 390,000 48.05 5394133F 07-31-18 SIMOES, LUIS & ROSA G 07-20-18 639 5 2 163,600 340,000 48.12 5404138F 03-05-19 7 PORTER PLACE, LLC. 02-13-19 3647 21 2 190,100 395,000 48.13 5396157A 09-17-18 POSSO, JORGE & ELSA 08-20-18 694 2.07 2 142,100 295,000 48.17 5395905A 09-11-18 ROSARIO, MARIO 08-22-18 2055 6 2 236,100 490,000 48.18 5393543A 07-18-18 AZEVEDO, MANUEL & MARIA 06-28-18 2477 20 2 193,200 400,000 48.30 5408842A 06-21-19 174 S 11TH LLC, 06-12-19 1813 23 2 169,500 350,000 48.43 5397035A 10-01-18 BEVINE, VICTOR 09-12-18 713 43 2 250,700 517,500 48.44 5404334A 01-02-19 LANZARA, MICHAEL 12-26-18 1005 64 2 147,900 305,000 48.49 5394518A 08-10-18 355 S 19TH LLC, 08-06-18 1792 1 2 148,300 305,000 48.62 5395794A 09-07-18 ASHANTI, ABDUL-SHABAZZ 09-04-18 4267 11 2 83,200 170,000 48.94 5409414F 06-28-19 PENA, KENNY 06-12-19 538 41 2 213,600 435,000 49.10 5404393A 03-06-19 TIRADO, MARY A 02-15-19 884 12 2 211,300 430,000 49.14 5398462F 10-19-18 OLIVER, DAVID 10-10-18 1914 18 2 173,500 352,000 49.29 5408133F 05-28-19 30 BAYVIEW HOLDINGS,LLC 05-17-19 3727 41 2 142,600 287,800 49.55 5396622A 09-25-18 424 SOUTH 17TH CAPITAL GR 09-07-18 320 50 2 188,900 380,000 49.71 5402529F 01-24-19 780 SUMMER AVE, LLC 12-06-18 777 32 2 211,400 425,000 49.74 5397085A 10-04-18 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROPERTI 07-23-18 983 19 2 234,100 469,000 49.91 5397335A 10-05-18 MEDINA, WILLIAM SR. & MARI 09-28-18 1933 37.01 2 274,800 550,000 49.96 5396384A 09-19-18 TAC CAPITAL, LLC. 09-17-18 3039 24 2 190,900 380,000 50.24 5401641A 01-03-19 IMJ1, LLC. 12-19-18 1810 59 2 159,500 317,500 50.24 5394959A 08-15-18 352 N 7TH STREET LLC, 08-10-18 1947 30 2 163,800 325,000 50.40 5395118A 08-22-18 MATOS, CHRISTOPHER 07-31-18 2802 27 2 83,700 165,000 50.73 5394489A 08-09-18 94 UNDERWOOD EQUITIES 2017 06-08-18 4099 114 2 125,600 247,500 50.75

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394801A 08-14-18 80 CLINTON AVENUE PARTNERS 08-07-18 2826 14 2 127,200 250,000 50.88 5408404A 12-18-18 GOMEZ, ANGEL 11-29-18 1796 73 2 76,400 150,000 50.93 5394048A 07-30-18 WRIGHT, KENDRA 06-19-18 4111 24 2 167,800 329,000 51.00 5407648A 04-16-19 HOWARD, JACCKIEE A & EDWAR 03-11-19 4267 8 2 81,700 160,000 51.06 5394486A 08-08-18 BOA GROUP, LLC, 07-30-18 4040 12 2 133,200 260,000 51.23 5406517A 04-30-19 DENNIS, LAVERN L 04-11-19 4266 8 2 84,800 165,000 51.39 5403976A 03-01-19 DE SOUSA, JOSE A. 02-11-19 1916 5 2 205,700 400,000 51.43 5401165A 12-26-18 RODRIGUEZ, RUBEN 12-18-18 1948 19 2 151,800 295,000 51.46 5395082A 08-22-18 JAMENT INVESTMENTS LLC 08-14-18 840 11 2 144,900 280,000 51.75 5404125F 03-04-19 NORTHSTAR EQUITIES PARTNER 02-25-19 4214 24 2 150,700 290,000 51.97 5407691F 05-06-19 SIMAO, BRIAN 04-24-19 2078 44 2 169,300 325,000 52.09 5407814A 05-20-19 RODRIGUEZ, WILSON A. & JUL 05-10-19 1912 6 2 135,700 260,000 52.19 5397053A 10-02-18 CC HOLDINGS GROUP LLC 09-18-18 324 9 2 172,700 330,000 52.33 5403213F 02-11-19 ELLERY AVENUE RENOVATIONS, 01-24-19 4136.01 10 2 141,500 269,000 52.60 5397971F 10-16-18 56-58 KEER AVE, LLC. 10-05-18 3688 5 2 154,100 292,500 52.68 5393595A 07-23-18 14-16 TREACY AVE LLC, 06-18-18 3072 12 2 124,100 235,000 52.81 5395124A 08-22-18 ALMEIDA, ANTONIO P 08-13-18 986 21 2 264,300 500,000 52.86 5396057A 09-13-18 RYE, MONIQUE 08-12-18 1873 13 2 237,000 448,000 52.90 5395718A 09-05-18 454 CLIFTON LLC, 08-27-18 608 23 2 201,700 379,900 53.09 5403163F 02-07-19 KAIYOUM, KALAMUDEEN 01-25-19 1947 26 2 116,800 220,000 53.09 5407662A 04-23-19 FERNANDEZ, RICHARD & MARIA 04-12-19 735 1.12 2 162,300 305,000 53.21 5404679A 03-12-19 POSSE, ANA M 03-05-19 685 9 2 247,500 465,000 53.23 5409405A 06-25-19 YOKONAMISH, LLC, 05-31-19 4135 46 2 114,500 215,000 53.26 5398950A 11-08-18 MMM GROUP, LLC. 10-04-18 4043.02 40 2 103,300 193,500 53.39 5396853A 09-28-18 6TH AVENUE MANAGEMENT LLC 09-21-18 1914 32 2 149,800 280,000 53.50 5394510A 08-10-18 29-31 VERNON LLC, 07-16-18 3039 26 2 187,900 350,000 53.69 5406955F 05-02-19 SORIANO, DANIELLA 04-08-19 3576 8 2 131,700 245,000 53.76 5396650A 09-26-18 87 PINE STREET, LLC. 09-12-18 2395 57 2 248,900 460,000 54.11 5395299A 08-27-18 BARNES, ADELINE M 08-17-18 4120 32 2 138,400 255,000 54.27 5406532A 04-30-19 CARVAJAL, CARLOS 04-24-19 483 36 2 152,100 280,000 54.32 5404820A 03-05-19 SEGRETO, JAY I. & MARIAM 02-21-19 938 7 2 239,900 439,900 54.54 5394798A 08-14-18 DIAZ, MARY ANN 06-21-18 958 25 2 231,900 425,000 54.56 5396370A 09-19-18 FILLIE-FABOE, CAROLYN 08-24-18 4050.01 31 2 237,700 435,000 54.64 5393536A 07-18-18 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROPERTI 05-09-18 2020 39 2 229,700 420,000 54.69 5408296F 06-06-19 170 NORWOOD, LLC. 05-28-19 4074 9 2 125,800 230,000 54.70 5404359F 03-07-19 733 S 14 LLC, 02-26-19 2634 7 2 192,300 350,000 54.94 5407816A 05-20-19 WADHWA, MUKUND ISHAN 04-01-19 764 42 2 151,300 275,000 55.02 5406511A 04-29-19 LYNCH, TESHA M 04-23-19 3726 12 2 170,800 310,000 55.10 5396657A 09-27-18 RENTAL SHOP, LLC 09-07-18 1859 52 2 149,000 270,000 55.19 5394128A 07-31-18 PUGLIESE, SABATINO 07-05-18 1128 11 2 165,700 300,000 55.23 5404338A 01-04-19 STUCKEY, LEMAN JR & THERES 12-20-18 4031 67 2 95,600 173,000 55.26 5397207A 10-05-18 RENTAL SHOP LLC, 09-07-18 282 1 2 152,100 275,000 55.31 5393967A 07-26-18 GERONIMO, LUIS B JR 06-14-18 814.01 46 2 185,400 335,000 55.34 5408754A 06-20-19 D'ALMEIDA, ANTONIO L & MAR 05-24-19 2010 30.13 2 277,100 500,000 55.42 5395065F 08-21-18 PEREZ, ANA 08-07-18 814.01 48 2 183,100 330,000 55.48 5408125A 05-23-19 ASHMAN, SIDNEY 04-24-19 1933 37.15 2 269,500 485,000 55.57

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394712A 08-14-18 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROPERTI 07-27-18 2046 37 2 278,300 500,000 55.66 5395793F 09-07-18 VELARDI, SANDRA 08-30-18 1963 44 2 167,200 300,000 55.73 5409408A 06-26-19 ERVIN, TORI R 06-18-19 4162 35 2 128,200 230,000 55.74 5394708A 08-13-18 GONZALEZ, HECTOR E 07-13-18 621 20.02 2 234,200 420,000 55.76 5403136F 02-06-19 FOREST HILLS HOLDINGS, LLC 01-24-19 485 42 2 120,000 215,000 55.81 5393608F 07-24-18 TYNES, GREGORY 07-19-18 3053.01 27 2 196,000 350,000 56.00 5403202F 02-11-19 HUNTINGTON GROUP, INC 02-05-19 3613 34 2 137,500 245,000 56.12 5394184A 08-01-18 DINDYAL, SALMA & VIJAI 07-27-18 1964 36 2 179,700 320,000 56.16 5402527A 01-24-19 ESSEX FLIPS 30 LLC, 12-27-18 2785 22 2 163,200 290,000 56.28 5396069A 09-14-18 NEWARK DEVELOPERS, LLC. 09-04-18 356 35 2 157,600 279,900 56.31 5397031A 10-01-18 RAMIREZ, LUZ A 09-19-18 2395 61 2 208,400 370,000 56.32 5395765A 09-07-18 AGUERO, JUAN J 08-07-18 818 25 2 154,900 275,000 56.33 5397922A 10-12-18 SILVA, ANTONIO P 08-30-18 1878 4.02 2 209,000 371,011 56.33 5393980A 07-27-18 MESA, YUDELKIS 07-14-18 2657 40 2 202,900 360,000 56.36 5393373T 07-03-18 VAGUEIRO, RICARDO & LUIS 06-08-18 1923 48 2 202,600 359,000 56.43 5394916A 08-15-18 PINA, RAMON 07-27-18 1850 8.02 2 273,100 484,000 56.43 5394399F 08-02-18 VALDIVIEZO, JOSE O 07-16-18 508 21 2 197,600 350,000 56.46 5407618A 04-03-19 ROBICHAUD, PAUL J & JOANIE 03-28-19 739 5 2 254,300 450,000 56.51 5404940F 03-20-19 COTTEN, JAMES R 03-05-19 2470 1.05 2 309,300 547,000 56.54 5403795F 02-26-19 MCM REAL ESTATE INVESTORS 02-08-19 677 45 2 212,200 375,000 56.59 5408477T 06-14-19 BALAZUELA, MELLBOURNE 05-28-19 335 37 2 150,100 265,000 56.64 5396059A 09-13-18 PEREZ, EDELMIRA 08-31-18 487 19 2 192,800 340,000 56.71 5406543A 05-02-19 SOLER, MILDRED 04-25-19 776.06 2.02 C2B 2 79,400 140,000 56.71 5403183F 02-08-19 EHP6ON WAKEMAN, LLC. 01-30-19 576 3 2 210,500 371,000 56.74 5394471A 08-08-18 SMITH, DOUGLAS 07-17-18 4125 93 2 136,200 240,000 56.75 5394804A 08-14-18 FERREIRA, MARIO A 07-02-18 951 14 2 142,400 250,000 56.96 5393644F 07-26-18 PROPERTY ASSET RECOVERY 07-07-18 1946.01 19.01 X 2 154,300 270,000 57.15 5395415A 08-28-18 24-26 ABBOTSFORD AVE,LLC 08-22-18 4192 44 2 195,500 340,000 57.50 5396535A 09-24-18 TONKA HOLDINGS, LLC. 09-06-18 4102 21 2 143,900 250,000 57.56 5393383A 07-05-18 SANTIAGO, IVAN/TORRES,MADE 06-29-18 1947 18 2 152,700 265,000 57.62 5397202A 10-04-18 JEAN-JACQUES, RICHARD 09-13-18 1878 36 2 210,400 365,000 57.64 5395081A 08-22-18 TONKA HOLDINGS LLC, 08-02-18 511 63 2 164,300 285,000 57.65 5393503A 07-16-18 12 WILLOUGHBY STREET NEWAR 07-02-18 3048.01 37 2 184,600 320,000 57.69 5396662A 09-27-18 215 NORTH 6TH REALTY, LLC. 09-17-18 1916 67 2 134,100 232,000 57.80 5394968A 08-16-18 GASKIN, WANDA 07-27-18 3686 13 2 153,500 264,500 58.03 5397924F 10-12-18 HOWELL, DOUGLAS 08-29-18 2656 43 2 150,900 260,000 58.04 5394131A 07-31-18 BIG KEITH, LLC. 07-24-18 1791 23 2 93,500 161,000 58.07 5402715F 01-30-19 208 MUNN CAPITAL, LLC. 01-18-19 633 34 2 209,100 360,000 58.08 5395080A 08-22-18 46 4TH STREET LLC, 08-16-18 1849 6.02 2 188,800 325,000 58.09 5395176A 08-27-18 TJDC PROPERTIES LLC, 08-16-18 443 1.38 2 102,700 175,000 58.69 5393418A 07-06-18 RODRIGUES, CESAR & MARIA Z 06-28-18 2393 16 2 161,500 275,000 58.73 5397079A 10-03-18 SIMMONS, GRAILIN 09-28-18 3735 35 2 172,300 290,000 59.41 5402008A 01-14-19 107 S MUNN AVE LLC, 01-07-19 4061 133 2 222,300 374,000 59.44 5407598A 03-26-19 SCHNEID, YAIR & ET AL. 03-13-19 3014 54 2 98,200 165,000 59.52 5398859A 10-29-18 A P BELMONT ASSOCIATES, LL 10-19-18 955 66 2 178,700 300,000 59.57 5400918A 12-13-18 188 SOUTH 9TH, LLC, 11-19-18 1812 44 2 169,800 285,000 59.58

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399812A 11-15-18 RODRIGUEZ, KATTY 10-12-18 651 19 2 214,700 360,000 59.64 5407782A 05-15-19 BRACH, SAMUEL 03-26-19 1826 25 2 154,600 259,000 59.69 5396620A 09-25-18 RENTAL SHOP, LLC, 07-06-18 339 35 2 143,700 240,000 59.88 5407751A 05-13-19 TUROK, ROI 04-30-19 147.01 2.21 C2U 2 150,000 250,000 60.00 5395361A 08-28-18 GVS REAL ESTATE CONSULTING 08-15-18 4262 14 2 151,700 252,000 60.20 5399092A 11-09-18 SCHAFER, KARINA 09-27-18 716 47 2 271,000 450,000 60.22 5401369A 12-29-18 ESTRELLA, FRANCISCO 11-27-18 1934 61 2 135,600 225,000 60.27 5404133F 03-04-19 GREEN FORMOSA PARTNERS 02-26-19 195.01 7 C7 2 271,200 450,000 60.27 5393384A 07-05-18 LAN, GUANGMING 06-26-18 4041 1 2 162,200 269,000 60.30 5407864F 05-23-19 JOHNSON, RUFUS & ANNETTE 05-01-19 4160 10 2 180,600 299,000 60.40 5401413A 01-03-19 JOHNSON, KIM D.W. & EVERET 10-28-18 755 41 2 221,100 365,000 60.58 5400867A 12-10-18 A HOLDING, LLC. 11-30-18 617.01 38 2 197,400 325,000 60.74 5408128A 05-28-19 TALBOT, ALEXIS 05-08-19 4160 21 2 182,300 300,000 60.77 5400670A 12-06-18 NEW GENERATION DEVELOPMENT 11-26-18 958 35 2 124,600 205,000 60.78 5395143F 08-23-18 FLYNN, TAMA 08-14-18 607 29 2 234,700 385,000 60.96 5397060A 10-02-18 EBB MAPES PROPERTIES,LLC 09-25-18 3069 8 2 167,800 275,000 61.02 5398926A 11-01-18 REDD, RAEEMAH & STRANGE, A 10-19-18 4042 17 2 221,200 362,500 61.02 5403113F 02-05-19 561 SUMMER AVE, LLC. 01-31-19 680 71 2 232,000 380,000 61.05 5395060A 08-21-18 EFFIONG, GODSWILL E 08-07-18 4220 21 2 155,700 255,000 61.06 5398159A 10-18-18 216 SOUTH 10TH, LLC. 09-10-18 1813 45 2 175,100 286,000 61.22 5402854A 02-01-19 SANTANA, ELIZABETH 01-29-19 850 23 2 183,200 299,000 61.27 5407700F 05-06-19 MINATEE, STEVEN & VALERIE 04-13-19 3726 6 2 150,200 245,000 61.31 5407900A 05-29-19 HALEDJIAN, MICHAEL & MARCI 05-22-19 322 1.08 2 270,100 440,000 61.39 5395429A 08-30-18 ESSEX ACQUISITIONS, LLC. 06-28-18 772 43.04 2 328,800 535,000 61.46 5395432A 08-30-18 SAURO, DAVID P & UPRIGHT, 08-10-18 785 40 2 193,600 315,000 61.46 5399057A 11-07-18 AUSTIN, FREDERICK & MONICA 10-18-18 359 31 2 166,700 271,000 61.51 5403975F 03-01-19 106-108 GOODWIN AVE ASSOCI 01-29-19 3616 21 2 215,400 350,000 61.54 5406368F 04-18-19 YOUNG, KEITH L & ELAINE V 04-10-19 4177 34 2 153,900 250,000 61.56 5402709F 01-29-19 STONE BAY, LLC. 01-14-19 1914 5 2 154,000 250,000 61.60 5409404A 06-24-19 LAGO, RAMON M 06-06-19 781 31 2 326,500 530,000 61.60 5403194F 02-08-19 SASHI HOMES, LLC. 02-01-19 3752 20 2 215,800 350,000 61.66 5400001A 11-19-18 WALLS, WILLIE D 11-05-18 258 27 2 184,500 299,000 61.71 5407899A 05-29-19 RUSH, NADIA & BENITEZ, SIL 05-17-19 361 39 2 110,200 178,000 61.91 5394449A 08-06-18 J.F.C. HOLDING CO INC 07-11-18 997 30 2 248,100 400,000 62.03 5407627A 04-08-19 JORGE, JOSE & ANA 03-26-19 575 44 2 211,000 340,000 62.06 5401689F 01-08-19 GEORGE, CHRISTINE A. 10-10-18 3640 16 2 163,300 262,900 62.11 5398488A 10-23-18 SIMMONDS, RUDOLPH L JR 10-18-18 1164 8 2 189,800 305,000 62.23 5398854A 10-29-18 SILVA, MARINO 10-09-18 806 45 2 218,600 350,000 62.46 5393633F 07-25-18 FREJUSTE, ROMAIN 06-28-18 4079 53 2 238,000 381,000 62.47 5394404A 08-02-18 LARDONE, VINCENZO 06-18-18 806 19 2 135,400 216,000 62.69 5397981A 10-17-18 TONKA HOLDINGS, LLC. 10-02-18 4064 9 2 97,200 155,000 62.71 5403100A 02-04-19 MURRAY, CHRISTOPHER 12-20-18 3693 25 2 219,600 350,000 62.74 5397729A 10-11-18 FALANA, JACQUELINE 10-03-18 3665 59 2 170,900 272,000 62.83 5400318A 11-29-18 PIROTTO, OSVALDO 11-15-18 2612 58 2 103,700 165,000 62.85 5397764A 10-15-18 22 SEYMOUR AVENUE, LLC. 10-09-18 2657 47 2 248,400 395,000 62.89 5394709A 08-14-18 CLARKE-HALL, YVONNE 06-15-18 3720.01 47 2 179,300 285,000 62.91

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407706A 05-07-19 APONTE, ROSA I. 03-20-19 600 18 2 163,600 260,000 62.92 5400344A 12-03-18 YANG, ZHIWAN 11-14-18 3091 11 2 101,000 160,000 63.13 5402825F 01-31-19 COSTA, LIZETTE R 01-04-19 1998 60.01 2 293,700 465,000 63.16 5400295A 11-28-18 YOUNG, ANGELA 11-16-18 2566 25 2 144,800 229,000 63.23 5403182A 02-08-19 RAMIREZ, MARGIANA 02-04-19 1930 18 2 139,200 220,000 63.27 5407659A 04-22-19 REONEY, LLC, 03-27-19 698 35 2 272,200 430,000 63.30 5400323A 11-29-18 MORAIS, MANUEL 11-09-18 2753 23 2 153,200 242,000 63.31 5403895F 02-28-19 162 SOUTH 7TH LLC, 02-25-19 1800 59.01 2 294,500 465,000 63.33 5407665F 04-24-19 SF HOLDING, LLC, 04-05-19 4067 33 2 228,000 360,000 63.33 5408308F 06-07-19 RAMOS, LUIS & MORRISSEY, K 06-03-19 114.01 39.06 2 307,400 485,000 63.38 5401644A 01-04-19 CHOW, ANNIE KOU & WU, LORA 12-28-18 195.01 16 C16 2 280,200 442,000 63.39 5407605A 03-28-19 LISA/SCHLEY LIMITED LIABIL 03-22-19 3088.01 1.06 2 282,100 445,000 63.39 5400972F 12-18-18 MAJEED, ZAKIR HUSSAIN 12-12-18 1915 63 2 190,000 299,000 63.55 5404132F 03-04-19 920 HUNTERDON LLC, 02-25-19 3583 11 2 143,000 225,000 63.56 5394491A 08-09-18 BOULDIN, CHERYL 07-20-18 3734 34 2 147,500 232,000 63.58 5407672A 05-01-19 DRAKE, ANTOINE WAYNE 04-25-19 560 76 2 104,900 165,000 63.58 5399816A 11-16-18 MORALES-COLON, WIRMARIE 11-05-18 759 33 2 267,400 420,000 63.67 5397765A 10-15-18 HARPER, LATEEF M 10-10-18 3702 3 2 200,600 315,000 63.68 5400102A 11-20-18 FERNANDES, JOSE A 10-01-18 511 13 2 181,600 285,000 63.72 5396012A 09-11-18 VELOSO, DANIEL 08-27-18 996 51 2 219,900 345,000 63.74 5395864A 09-11-18 MANGO MANAGEMENT LLC, 08-03-18 3035 11 2 140,300 220,000 63.77 5402844F 02-01-19 EVOLUTIONARY MARKETING, LL 12-18-18 329 48 2 150,100 235,000 63.87 5406349F 04-12-19 JAIVIENT INVESTMENTS, LLC 04-08-19 848.01 7 2 157,200 246,000 63.90 5405658F 04-04-19 BRAVO, DOMINGO & SOTO, ANA 03-29-19 4065 54 2 269,200 420,000 64.10 5394476A 08-08-18 RIVER STREET PATERSON 07-30-18 4138 33 2 134,000 209,000 64.11 5400330A 11-29-18 CARO, ANGEL L 11-19-18 557 18 2 152,800 238,000 64.20 5399093A 11-09-18 DA SILVA, STENIO 10-23-18 2013.03 2 2 209,000 325,000 64.31 5400909A 12-13-18 A HOLDING LLC, 12-05-18 2673 7.09 2 223,600 347,500 64.35 5393961A 07-26-18 RENTAL SHOP LLC, 06-15-18 531 42 2 177,200 275,000 64.44 5398884A 10-31-18 TORRES, CARMEN G 10-17-18 756 51 2 193,400 300,000 64.47 5394713A 08-14-18 SANTOS, MARIA L 08-01-18 2012 8 2 322,400 500,000 64.48 5398835A 10-26-18 KIRAGU MAINA, LLC. 10-04-18 1810 4 2 100,000 155,000 64.52 5401698A 01-08-19 RODRIGUES, ARMINDO 12-20-18 2074 51 2 168,000 260,000 64.62 5400289A 11-27-18 FONSECA, JOSE 11-13-18 1183.01 11.44 2 323,100 499,000 64.75 5395795A 09-07-18 HILL, JESSICA 08-17-18 3731.01 17 2 187,900 290,000 64.79 5393462A 07-11-18 POE PROERTIES LLC, 06-26-18 507 17 2 142,700 220,000 64.86 5404458A 03-08-19 RICHEMOND, MAJEUR 02-19-19 4127.01 54 2 249,100 384,000 64.87 5393502A 07-16-18 JOHNSON, DELORES 07-10-18 4109 48 2 139,500 215,000 64.88 5403137A 02-06-19 76-78 PACIFIC STREET, LLC. 01-16-19 946 13 2 175,200 270,000 64.89 5395073A 08-21-18 LEWIS, KWAME 08-12-18 3735 24 2 162,300 250,000 64.92 5408332A 06-12-19 ALAO, OLADIPO 05-31-19 3624 10 2 289,100 445,000 64.97 5404607F 03-12-19 VILACHA, CONCEPCION 02-19-19 2036 31 2 195,400 300,000 65.13 5403165F 02-07-19 144 DEWEY LLC, 01-29-19 3053.02 18 2 176,100 270,000 65.22 5403141A 02-06-19 GREEN STONE INVESTMENTS, L 01-18-19 325 10 2 231,600 355,000 65.24 5395797A 09-07-18 RUFFIN, ROBERT 08-02-18 4142 45 2 150,400 230,000 65.39 5396019A 09-12-18 SOARES, ERLY A 08-28-18 2055 19 2 153,700 235,000 65.40

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396385A 09-20-18 EBA PROPERTIES LLC, 08-25-18 3613 37 2 166,800 255,000 65.41 5397329A 10-05-18 TIRADO, EDITH & VALERA, RU 09-28-18 1962 29 2 236,800 361,000 65.60 5402428A 01-18-19 VELAZQUEZ, JOHNLY 12-20-18 4261 8 2 144,600 220,000 65.73 5406445A 04-24-19 DAVENPORT NEWARK LLC, 04-01-19 1826 44 2 212,100 322,000 65.87 5393541A 07-18-18 MODARELLI, DYLAN 06-29-18 3713 6 2 131,900 200,000 65.95 5406903A 04-09-19 CHRISTIE RIVERFRONT LLC 04-05-19 2024.03 1.02 C1B 2 184,700 280,000 65.96 5396481A 09-26-18 HERNANDEZ, DWIGHT & NORMA 08-26-18 686 45 2 340,000 515,000 66.02 5396619A 09-21-18 NCCB INVESTMENTS, INC. 08-29-18 489 28 2 106,400 161,000 66.09 5408316F 06-10-19 285 WEEQUAHIC AVE LLC 11-01-18 3724 36 2 126,000 190,500 66.14 5400002A 11-19-18 STEINBERG, RIVKA 10-16-18 2694 48 2 231,800 350,000 66.23 5406355F 04-15-19 429 S 18 VENTURES, LLC 04-09-19 322 19 2 155,700 235,000 66.26 5397032A 10-01-18 FREEMAN, GWENDOLYN 09-17-18 3039 29 2 172,400 260,000 66.31 5406491A 04-29-19 COCHRAN, DIONA & DAN 04-17-19 2626 29 2 166,000 250,000 66.40 5396018A 09-12-18 BENNETT, STEPHEN M 08-28-18 1167 6.01 2 199,400 300,000 66.47 5407808A 05-17-19 SAGEWOOD SFF III, LLC 05-08-19 996 8 2 149,700 225,000 66.53 5409284A 06-26-19 PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT C 06-18-19 2073 28 2 193,000 290,000 66.55 5397489A 10-10-18 WILLIAMS, WARREN & DORA P 10-01-18 4102 5 2 163,400 245,000 66.69 5398889A 10-31-18 MELENDEZ, MILDRED 10-19-18 756 49 2 237,500 355,000 66.90 5403617A 02-14-19 AKALONU, CAROLINE 01-16-19 3041 117 2 133,800 200,000 66.90 5397365A 10-11-18 RAVELO, DANIEL 07-15-18 608 20 2 234,300 350,000 66.94 5403870A 02-28-19 SANCHEZ, MANUEL D & ROSA 02-21-19 588 11 2 251,200 375,000 66.99 5406453F 04-25-19 JOHNSTONE, DION & MALCOLM, 04-05-19 3040 7 2 247,200 369,000 66.99 5395733A 09-06-18 SILPAS ENTERPRISES LLC 08-14-18 328 42 2 164,500 245,000 67.14 5397752A 10-12-18 ROBINSON, SYLVIA & WHETSEL 09-25-18 4127 52 2 143,000 213,000 67.14 5404392A 03-04-19 HOWARD, ALEX & TINA 02-11-19 2613 17 2 151,100 225,000 67.16 5400297A 11-28-18 155 BERKELEY L.L.C., 11-05-18 638 1.26 2 332,500 495,000 67.17 5393596A 07-23-18 VARELA, CHRISTOPHER F 07-12-18 848.01 16 2 119,600 178,000 67.19 5401401A 01-02-19 MANZUETA, GELACIA ANTONIA 10-21-18 3700 48 2 181,500 270,000 67.22 5395423A 08-29-18 DOUGLAS, KENNETH M 07-31-18 4184 17 2 215,200 320,000 67.25 5408725A 06-18-19 PAULA, RUI 06-14-19 949 2 2 208,700 310,229 67.27 5407674A 05-02-19 ARRIAZA, HECTOR & PAULA 04-16-19 487 24 2 126,000 187,200 67.31 5400672A 12-06-18 155 BERKELEY, LLC, 11-27-18 638 1.15 2 336,800 499,999 67.36 5407779A 05-15-19 NICHOLAS, GEORGELINE 04-26-19 4074 36 2 116,200 172,500 67.36 5396854A 09-28-18 ONYEMEKEIHIA, PIUS 09-14-18 3088.01 1.03 2 299,800 445,000 67.37 5407692A 05-06-19 NIANG, IBRAHIMA & NDOOR, S 04-09-19 2606 1.18 2 121,300 180,000 67.39 5408848F 06-21-19 MT PROSPECT INVESTMENTS, L 03-22-19 626.01 35 2 111,200 165,000 67.39 5400881A 12-11-18 RICORD HOME RENOVATION LLC 11-20-18 4038 15 2 118,200 175,000 67.54 5405670A 04-05-19 LM 192, LLC. 01-31-19 4061 140 2 79,900 118,000 67.71 5395030A 08-17-18 MANCINI, GIOVANA 07-31-18 649 7 2 193,100 285,000 67.75 5393389F 07-05-18 CLARO, PEDRO 06-27-18 2055 44 2 545,900 805,507 67.77 5400944A 12-14-18 DASILVA, ROSANGELA N 12-07-18 2697 54 2 135,600 200,000 67.80 5407910A 05-31-19 B&J PROPERTY MGMT LLC 05-23-19 1914 4 2 163,000 240,000 67.92 5396482A 09-26-18 MINTZ, JEVON & DOROTHY E 09-11-18 3580 17 2 146,100 215,000 67.95 5403698F 02-25-19 LIRANZO, ENRIQUE 11-16-18 3733 14 2 190,400 280,000 68.00 5397048A 10-02-18 MT PROSPECT INVESTMENTS, L 09-07-18 507 21 2 126,000 185,000 68.11 5407654A 04-18-19 NJ NORTH 7TH STREET,LLC 01-16-19 1929 4 2 109,000 160,000 68.13

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 8 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407719A 05-08-19 MARINO, JOSPEHINE M 04-29-19 191 10 2 187,500 275,000 68.18 5405473A 03-29-19 WHITE, SARAH 03-18-19 3663 23 2 187,800 275,000 68.29 5393380A 07-03-18 TUESDAY BSD, LLC. 06-28-18 324 47 2 215,700 315,000 68.48 5407810A 05-17-19 2017-1 REO LLC, 04-22-19 1939 8 2 111,700 163,000 68.53 5398851A 10-29-18 EBA PROPERTIES, LLC. 10-22-18 3663 20 2 185,100 270,000 68.56 5395038A 08-17-18 RIBEIRO, MARIA N & ANTONIO 07-31-18 1937 48 2 154,500 225,000 68.67 5406489A 04-29-19 LISA/SCHLEY LIMITED LIABIL 04-22-19 3088.01 1.05 2 303,500 442,000 68.67 5404999A 03-19-19 N.E. REGISTRY, INC. 03-04-19 3571 56 2 164,900 240,100 68.68 5402457A 01-22-19 MYKE, NARELLE 01-09-19 2708 42 2 226,800 330,000 68.73 5394415A 08-03-18 402 SANFORD LLC, 07-17-18 4059 47 2 110,000 160,000 68.75 5406531F 04-30-19 423 N 6TH ASSOCIATES LLC 04-10-19 1949 64 2 137,600 200,000 68.80 5405449A 03-28-19 DASILVA, JODIMIR & LOUREIR 03-21-19 3625 26 2 254,700 370,000 68.84 5394136A 07-31-18 JALAGAM, VENKATA & MADANAG 07-27-18 2659 12 2 158,400 230,000 68.87 5408451A 06-11-19 FAULKNER, DORIS & CHERYL 05-22-19 1922 27 2 141,900 206,000 68.88 5402467A 01-23-19 BRYANT, DUNCAN ERIC 01-04-19 244 15 2 241,200 350,000 68.91 5394188A 08-01-18 DICKERSON, ARMASIAN 06-19-18 613 47 2 114,400 166,000 68.92 5404468A 03-11-19 PHILIUS, GERALD 01-31-19 4070 17 2 118,700 172,000 69.01 5395369A 08-29-18 ANDERSON, SILAS A 08-09-18 538 18 2 100,400 145,000 69.24 5396017A 09-12-18 CLERVOYANT, MADSEN 08-28-18 4096 23 2 91,800 132,500 69.28 5403619F 02-14-19 AMIN, KAMAL 02-08-19 3040 25 2 242,700 350,000 69.34 5402712F 01-30-19 LUDUENA, MARIANO & ESTEBAN 01-14-19 1810 51 2 163,300 235,000 69.49 5395077A 08-21-18 BRYANT, RAYMOND 08-07-18 3601 42 2 197,200 283,000 69.68 5396475A 09-21-18 GLUCK, SENDER 08-28-18 510 26 2 87,100 125,000 69.68 5400133A 11-26-18 BANKS, FRANCIS JR 08-30-18 4098 17 2 132,400 190,000 69.68 5407708A 05-07-19 LANGHORNE, GEORGE & WILLIA 04-29-19 3601 34 2 219,500 315,000 69.68 5401687A 01-07-19 WADE, ANTOINETTE 12-21-18 4180 12 2 160,300 230,000 69.70 5406389A 04-22-19 SANTANA, PATRICK 03-21-19 3001 7 2 218,400 313,111 69.75 5399079A 11-09-18 LAKAY NEW VENTURE LLC 11-02-18 3614 33 2 178,000 255,000 69.80 5400298A 11-28-18 VILLALBA, BERNICE R 11-16-18 1792 43.02 2 255,500 365,000 70.00 5397354A 10-10-18 RODRIGUES, NUNO & DORA 09-11-18 2689 23 2 231,100 330,000 70.03 5401663A 01-07-19 SUNSHINE GARDENS, LLC 12-07-18 750.02 3.01 C3A 2 149,000 212,500 70.12 5402604F 01-28-19 ESSEX, ANGELA 12-08-18 147.01 4.04 C4D 2 136,800 195,000 70.15 5397051A 10-02-18 SANOE, KALIFALA 09-14-18 1812 1 2 179,100 255,000 70.24 5393457A 07-11-18 NWARIHI, STANLEY 06-29-18 339 32.02 2 295,200 420,000 70.29 5394141A 08-01-18 EATA INVESTMENT LLC, 04-17-18 4063.01 74 2 196,100 279,000 70.29 5403628A 02-15-19 MACIEL, ALEXANDRE & FATIMA 02-04-19 1010 1.18 2 379,700 540,000 70.31 5405076A 03-21-19 20 SEYMOUR AVENUE LLC 02-18-19 2657 48 2 175,800 250,000 70.32 5397842F 10-16-18 GROSSKLAUS, RICHARD (TRUST 10-05-18 121 19 2 151,200 215,000 70.33 5400943A 12-14-18 PACT 275 LLC, 11-30-18 1817 28 2 211,100 300,000 70.37 5403646A 02-19-19 MENDOZA, LUMEN 02-08-19 2838 41 2 123,200 175,000 70.40 5405107A 03-22-19 GLOBAL 371, LLC, 03-18-19 612 27 2 162,100 230,000 70.48 5404153F 03-05-19 ELITE ASSET MANAGEMENT, LL 03-01-19 2768 9.15 2 299,700 425,000 70.52 5401125A 12-19-18 SAJOUS, PIERRE V 12-11-18 4275 75 2 223,600 317,000 70.54 5405493A 04-02-19 NJ WHOLESALE PROPERTIES, L 05-24-18 4173 17 2 196,800 279,000 70.54 5400345A 12-03-18 CAPITAL INVESTMENT GROUP I 11-20-18 4036 4 2 142,700 202,000 70.64 5400325A 11-29-18 SILVA, ROBERTO 11-16-18 147.01 6.04 C6D 2 130,000 184,000 70.65

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 9 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396015A 09-12-18 421 S 16TH STREET LLC 08-16-18 320 16 2 150,800 213,000 70.80 5396071A 09-14-18 LEADBETTER, CAROL J & LEWI 09-10-18 2606 1.16 2 122,200 172,500 70.84 5396366A 09-19-18 TONKA HOLDINGS, LLC. 09-06-18 3666 10 2 230,300 325,000 70.86 5406363A 04-15-19 MEJIA, EDISON R 04-09-19 2791 30 2 239,400 337,500 70.93 5408314A 06-07-19 HOUSING AND NEIGHBOROOD DE 05-08-19 1923 19 2 160,000 225,000 71.11 5409359A 06-28-19 LOGAN, JERRELL 03-22-19 3616 8 2 170,700 240,000 71.13 5395062A 08-21-18 PIMENTEL, ARTHUR 08-10-18 3744 35 2 67,600 95,000 71.16 5402031A 01-15-19 BROWN, LATONIA 12-14-18 3705 15 2 188,900 265,000 71.28 5396070A 09-14-18 SINGH, KUMARIE & CHANDRABH 08-31-18 4215 6 2 103,400 145,000 71.31 5401392F 12-31-18 BORGES, CARMINE & ELIZABET 11-18-18 1128.03 2.04 C2D 2 160,400 224,900 71.32 5404561A 03-12-19 LISA/SCHLEY LLC 03-05-19 3088.01 1.09 2 303,500 425,000 71.41 5404841A 03-20-19 LISA/SCHLEY LLC 03-05-19 3088.01 1.07 2 303,500 425,000 71.41 5396476A 09-21-18 270-272 SEYMOUR AVE, LLC. 09-14-18 3597 17 2 210,700 295,000 71.42 5405504A 04-03-19 DAVIDSON, KEITH 03-15-19 4214 62 2 246,700 345,000 71.51 5406410A 04-23-19 NCCB INVESTMENTS, INC 04-05-18 1935 13 2 134,600 188,000 71.60 5407789A 05-16-19 NCCB INVESTMENTS, INC. 04-05-19 1935 13 2 134,600 188,000 71.60 5405438A 03-27-19 160 S REALTY LLC, 03-22-19 3070 6 2 89,600 125,000 71.68 5396852A 09-28-18 KIMANI, JAMES 09-24-18 3065 12 2 236,800 330,250 71.70 5394487A 08-08-18 BORGES, NICEIA 07-31-18 2699 62 2 265,400 370,000 71.73 5409273A 06-25-19 DUARTE, MONIQUE 04-22-19 147.01 3.20 C3T 2 140,100 195,000 71.85 5394521A 08-13-18 BLAISE, WILSON 07-03-18 3092 6.04 2 295,000 410,000 71.95 5395673A 09-04-18 ROBERTS, NICOLE G 08-28-18 3601 8 2 187,100 260,000 71.96 5408259F 06-04-19 CROSS, RICHARD 04-22-19 4202 29 2 131,000 182,000 71.98 5396073A 09-14-18 HOME INVESTORS NETWORK, LL 08-30-18 315 4 2 118,300 164,000 72.13 5401703F 01-08-19 QUAD T HOLDINGS LLC, 12-21-18 1814 59 2 101,000 140,000 72.14 5393500A 07-16-18 EBB MAPES PROPERTIES, LLC. 06-29-18 3076 4 2 194,900 270,000 72.19 5398838A 10-29-18 J. RAMOS & RIBEIRO, LLC. 08-02-18 3664 57 2 303,200 420,000 72.19 5401659A 01-04-19 KATRYAN, ARTHUR EDMUND & D 11-20-18 640 17 2 263,500 365,000 72.19 5396539A 09-24-18 NICHOLAS, GEORGELINE 09-12-18 4033.01 53 2 125,100 173,000 72.31 5399995A 11-19-18 MARRONE, ROSALIE 11-05-18 1181 19 2 112,100 155,000 72.32 5398482A 10-22-18 CLEARVIEW EQUITIES, LLC. 10-16-18 3718 23 2 198,900 275,000 72.33 5400871A 12-11-18 KNOTT, DOLORES R 10-30-18 2011 45 2 170,000 235,000 72.34 5407815A 05-20-19 MOORE, AJANI 04-08-19 329 51 2 166,700 230,000 72.48 5400928A 12-14-18 COUZ RESTORATION LLC, 10-31-18 4033 71 2 217,500 300,000 72.50 5398572F 10-24-18 51 TILLINGHAST, LLC. 08-03-18 3030 49 2 237,500 327,500 72.52 5394516A 08-10-18 GUZMAN, BARBARA 07-27-18 300 20 2 229,400 316,000 72.59 5398455F 10-18-18 ROTZ, MARILYN T 08-22-18 2058 1 2 108,200 149,000 72.62 5408461A 06-12-19 SANTAVICCA, ANTHONY 05-30-19 325 51 2 216,600 298,000 72.68 5406946A 05-02-19 889 HUNTERDON STREET, LLC. 03-29-19 3586 33 2 224,200 308,000 72.79 5402585A 01-25-19 BISHOP, DANIEL G 12-11-18 1128.03 2.02 C2B 2 193,600 265,000 73.06 5402597F 01-28-19 KEIN-N2 LLC, 01-15-19 2688 16 2 222,900 305,000 73.08 5393565A 07-19-18 FORCELLO, STEVEN D & NINA 07-06-18 357 9 2 252,500 345,000 73.19 5399616A 11-14-18 MMM 72 SEY LLC, 10-30-18 3000 40 2 183,100 250,000 73.24 5405496A 04-02-19 SKYLINE CONSTRUCTION 03-25-19 2636 9 2 144,400 197,000 73.30 5396643A 09-25-18 BAIRD, LLOYD 09-04-18 4046 33 2 119,500 163,000 73.31 5394053A 07-30-18 ORTIZ-GREER, CARMENSITA 07-27-18 3644 13 2 132,000 180,000 73.33

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 10 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394401A 08-02-18 WILLIAMS, ALBERTA 07-17-18 4102 37 2 128,700 175,000 73.54 5402530A 01-24-19 JAVIER, JUAN 01-18-19 662 35 2 161,800 220,000 73.55 5393549A 07-18-18 KINA DEVELOPMENT LLC, 05-15-18 4176 29 2 138,300 188,000 73.56 5400118A 11-21-18 ALVAREZ, RAIMUNDO 11-13-18 4089 4 2 125,000 169,900 73.57 5395709A 09-04-18 SYLVESTER, NAIM 08-24-18 4138 23 2 175,500 238,500 73.58 5401671T 01-07-19 ALICHE, UZOMA 12-20-18 3029 38.01 2 294,600 400,000 73.65 5400872F 12-11-18 ALVAREZ, OSIRIS 11-29-18 669 35 2 413,200 560,000 73.79 5398828A 10-26-18 DELEON, MIGUEL & LADY 10-16-18 815 78 2 170,400 230,000 74.09 5395127A 08-22-18 STOCKTON, WILLIAM D 07-12-18 4189 19 2 163,000 219,900 74.12 5400346A 12-03-18 MATTISON, JACKIE R 11-07-18 3704 9 2 213,500 288,000 74.13 5401149A 12-21-18 NUTAKOR, ANTOINETTE & ARDE 12-18-18 1887 25.01 2 297,100 400,000 74.28 5404930A 03-19-19 ORTIZ, DANIEL 02-19-19 332 47 2 231,000 311,000 74.28 5401178A 12-27-18 BLAKE, PAUL 12-05-18 1912.01 34 2 156,100 210,000 74.33 5399243A 11-09-18 JOHNSON, GARFIELD 08-29-18 1792 4 2 185,900 250,000 74.36 5394452A 08-07-18 RENTAL SHOP, LLC, 07-17-18 3571 55 2 178,500 240,000 74.38 5396631F 09-25-18 KISSOON, REYNOLD 09-19-18 310.01 43 2 260,500 350,000 74.43 5399084A 11-09-18 CONTRERAS, LUIS 10-30-18 2481 20 2 137,700 185,000 74.43 5393404A 07-06-18 KMJ HOLDINGS LLC, 07-02-18 641 5.02 2 124,400 167,000 74.49 5393610A 07-24-18 SCOLAMIERO, BERNADETTE 07-06-18 610.01 4.03 C4B 2 130,400 175,000 74.51 5400092A 11-20-18 ATW LLC, 11-07-18 750.02 2.07 C2G 2 149,000 199,900 74.54 5395165A 08-24-18 AMADOR, NICOLE 08-17-18 1128.03 4.04 C4D 2 160,400 215,000 74.60 5409356A 06-27-19 GONCALVES, CLEMENTINA 06-05-19 1953 63 2 153,200 205,000 74.73 5395044A 08-20-18 NIKOE, JOHN L 07-30-18 322 16 2 239,300 320,000 74.78 5408309F 06-07-19 JOHNSON, JOSEPH 05-21-19 4122 29 2 207,900 278,000 74.78 5398909A 11-01-18 METROHOMES, LLC. 10-17-18 1945.01 39 2 113,700 152,000 74.80 5407913A 05-31-19 117-119 SHEPHARD AVE LLC 05-10-19 3665 94 2 177,400 237,000 74.85 5409261A 06-25-19 GORDON ACQUISITION HOLDING 06-12-19 3733 74 2 149,700 200,000 74.85 5403103F 02-04-19 BM NORTH LLC, 01-22-19 3044.02 19.01 2 250,100 334,000 74.88 5406497A 04-29-19 WOODBRIDGE RENOVATION FULT 04-18-19 4031 82 2 104,900 140,000 74.93 5398840A 10-29-18 MARTIN, JAIME SAN & MORA, 09-26-18 516 37 2 150,200 200,000 75.10 5403175A 02-08-19 GROSS, YEHUDA NESANEL 02-06-19 2693 48 2 161,500 215,000 75.12 5401164A 12-26-18 CLARKE-HALL, YVONNE 11-29-18 4061.01 86 2 225,600 300,000 75.20 5398574F 10-24-18 BATIM 18, INC. 08-09-18 2618 35 2 240,800 320,000 75.25 5393611A 07-24-18 CONFETTURA, ROBERTO 07-13-18 2024.04 1.02 C1B 2 184,700 245,000 75.39 5400348A 12-03-18 CIG RIVER RD, LLC, 11-19-18 1795 17 2 226,800 300,000 75.60 5406938A 05-01-19 BARBOSA, MARIA R & ANTONIO 04-16-19 487 10 2 151,700 200,000 75.85 5398592A 10-25-18 KAIYOUM, SHAIK M 10-23-18 1929 72 2 113,900 150,000 75.93 5404845A 03-20-19 ATW LLC, 03-12-19 750.02 2.02 C2B 2 159,500 210,000 75.95 5394504A 08-09-18 MBITHI, PETER 07-30-18 3044.02 19.03 2 250,700 330,000 75.97 5395416A 08-28-18 BELL, DONALD 08-10-18 263 47 2 125,900 165,500 76.07 5405099A 03-21-19 NAVARRO, GLOWIGR 02-15-19 2609 1.08 2 139,200 183,000 76.07 5406914A 04-16-19 HAYES, DAROLD & DIANNE 03-29-19 3721 78 2 205,400 270,000 76.07 5403890A 02-28-19 LOPEZ, LEONARDO 01-29-19 2545 20.08 2 159,800 210,000 76.10 5409353F 06-27-19 ALULEMA, PATRICIA & TERESA 02-08-19 948 1 2 190,300 250,000 76.12 5405435A 03-27-19 MEJIA, KAREN 03-20-19 2843 9 2 95,400 125,000 76.32 5403700A 02-25-19 BROWN, WILLIAM 01-10-19 350 29 2 252,200 330,000 76.42

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 11 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393559A 07-19-18 AKINYEMI, KAYODE & ABIOLA 07-13-18 1799 58 2 218,000 285,000 76.49 5403866A 02-28-19 2017-1 REO LLC, 02-12-19 4162 13 2 193,500 252,000 76.79 5394710A 08-14-18 GILKES, MARLENE 07-25-18 3061 24 2 167,500 218,000 76.83 5400877F 12-11-18 29 BURNET STREET, LLC 11-30-18 43 24 2 151,000 195,000 77.44 5394979A 08-16-18 KLIMUSHKIN, INNA 07-03-18 3063 1 2 150,400 194,000 77.53 5407793A 05-16-19 BRIDGE HOLDINGS 32, LLC. 05-07-19 932 30 2 260,000 335,000 77.61 5395412A 08-22-18 LEMON, DAVID P 05-31-18 2058.01 19 C3E 2 232,900 300,000 77.63 5396382A 09-19-18 EDMONDSON, O'RYAN FRANZ 09-13-18 4104 29 2 186,900 240,500 77.71 5404680A 03-14-19 TAUB, REIZEL 03-07-19 3048 30 2 128,700 165,000 78.00 5400897A 12-12-18 GADSDEN, SHARON 11-14-18 4202 74 2 105,500 135,000 78.15 5398855A 10-29-18 CEDARWOOD HOLDINGS, LLC. 09-17-18 4063 45 2 148,700 190,000 78.26 5407857A 05-23-19 LONEY, JOHN BOWEN JR & FRE 05-02-19 3663 80 2 183,900 235,000 78.26 5403655A 02-20-19 GOODALL, RASHAN M. 02-01-19 3633 24 2 156,600 200,000 78.30 5400668A 12-06-18 DASENT, MARY E 11-30-18 1856 18 2 133,200 170,000 78.35 5407710A 05-07-19 F.N.P., LLC. 05-02-19 750.02 2.12 C2L 2 153,000 195,000 78.46 5404567F 03-13-19 GORDON MANAGEMENT GROUP, L 02-28-19 816 28 2 212,000 270,000 78.52 5406508A 04-29-19 BESU, JAVIER 04-15-19 1780 64 2 200,400 255,000 78.59 5399073A 11-08-18 55 MONTGOMERY NEWARK, LLC. 10-26-18 2641 9 2 216,400 275,000 78.69 5399083A 11-09-18 ZOR, ARTHUR 11-01-18 1829 14 2 185,200 235,000 78.81 5393470T 07-12-18 VALENTE, CASSIANO & ET AL. 06-14-18 2012 12 2 252,300 320,000 78.84 5403970A 02-28-19 71 SUNSET AVE LLC, 02-21-19 4061 110.01 2 235,800 299,000 78.86 5408295F 06-06-19 NE INVESTMENT 852, LLC. 05-24-19 3014 62 2 228,800 290,000 78.90 5395034A 08-17-18 SANTOS, YESENIA 07-27-18 2659 10 2 207,600 263,000 78.94 5397062A 10-02-18 NEW AGE INVESTMENT PROPERT 08-23-18 2711 2 2 225,000 285,000 78.95 5406943A 05-01-19 LANKFORD, JERRY J 04-23-19 902.01 4.01 C4A 2 118,500 150,000 79.00 5402685A 01-09-19 247-249 S 11, LLC. 12-06-18 1815 20 2 159,800 202,000 79.11 5395592A 08-31-18 HARRISON, LURAL N SR & DIA 08-18-18 3739 56 2 134,600 170,000 79.18 5401166A 12-26-18 OLANIYAN, OLAKUNLE 11-08-18 147.01 2.10 C2J 2 142,700 180,000 79.28 5408448A 06-11-19 VISIONARY ASSOCIATES LLC 06-03-19 1858 43 2 176,400 222,500 79.28 5401863A 01-09-19 202 PARKER REALTY, LLC. 12-21-18 538 25 2 70,600 89,000 79.33 5407787A 05-15-19 TILLIS, ARTHUR 05-02-19 4051.01 1 2 99,200 125,000 79.36 5400004A 11-19-18 YANQUI, VICTOR E 10-26-18 1964 32 2 168,600 212,000 79.53 5396544A 09-24-18 LATACZ, ANTHONY J 09-20-18 195 2.06 C15A 2 182,300 229,000 79.61 5401412A 01-03-19 KOHAV HASHAHAR REAL ESTATE 11-30-18 3640 30 2 348,900 438,000 79.66 5405001A 03-19-19 MEDINA, EDGAR & REYNA Y. 03-11-19 612 12 2 155,400 195,000 79.69 5394711A 08-14-18 REGINA, MARINO & LUZ 08-03-18 3054 18 2 319,000 400,000 79.75 5407823A 05-20-19 AGUILERA, ESTHER 04-29-19 1181 62 2 136,200 170,000 80.12 5395863A 09-11-18 BENJAMIN, SKEETA 08-31-18 321 24 2 123,400 154,000 80.13 5399604F 11-13-18 LOPEZ, ANA & MARTE, FREDDY 10-29-18 289 27.03 2 192,600 240,000 80.25 5407802A 05-17-19 BISHOP, DARIUS & CHERYL 04-27-19 2650 45 2 156,700 195,000 80.36 5407771F 05-14-19 MILESTONE REDEVELOPMENT LL 09-21-18 3732 42 2 164,300 204,250 80.44 5405507A 04-03-19 LUCCO, FELICIA 03-12-19 2024.02 2.01 C2A 2 193,200 240,000 80.50 5399052F 11-07-18 BOOM, MICHAEL G 10-26-18 919 43.22 2 321,900 399,000 80.68 5395674A 09-04-18 BETANCOURT-DIAZ, MARIA O 08-16-18 334 22 2 220,400 273,000 80.73 5405295A 03-26-19 MALCOLM SHABBAZ URBAN RENE 03-13-19 2648 9 2 177,200 219,450 80.75 5406380F 04-22-19 BLS INVESTORS LLC, 04-12-19 3034 26 2 157,500 195,000 80.77

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 12 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5402587F 01-25-19 ELSHOWKI, ASHRAF M. 01-11-19 722 40 2 187,400 232,000 80.78 5405294A 03-26-19 CIG RIVER RD LLC, 03-13-19 3063 41 2 161,200 199,450 80.82 5408327F 06-11-19 STAFFORD, BRANDON R & DAVI 06-04-19 1168 27 2 323,400 400,000 80.85 5395719A 09-05-18 ENWERE, INNOCENT 07-27-18 320 33 2 113,200 140,000 80.86 5396393F 09-20-18 ALL STATE CAPITAL LLC 08-29-18 1827 51 2 137,700 170,000 81.00 5402821F 01-31-19 ANYANSI, GODFREY & EDITH N 12-31-18 279 42 2 158,200 195,000 81.13 5407859A 05-23-19 ROYER, NERISSA C 05-16-19 3665 53 2 181,000 223,000 81.17 5394947A 08-14-18 POE PROPERTIES LLC, 05-30-18 339 10 2 150,300 185,000 81.24 5402718F 01-30-19 BOYER, TOMORY 01-24-19 2793 11 2 245,600 302,000 81.32 5403649F 02-19-19 PIERCY, JAMAR 02-01-19 3678 1 2 183,200 225,000 81.42 5397205A 10-05-18 TRITOP REALTY, LLC. 09-26-18 3739 53 2 211,800 260,000 81.46 5399999F 11-19-18 ULLOA, FRANKLIN TEOD 11-06-18 3707 26 2 183,700 225,000 81.64 5393426A 07-09-18 WILLIAMS BARRETO, KISHA 06-14-18 209 3.19 C3J1 2 179,700 220,000 81.68 5393989A 07-30-18 69 KENT JERSEY LLC, 07-19-18 2616 17 2 121,900 149,000 81.81 5408147A 05-30-19 NEWARK NJ PROPERTIES, LLC. 05-09-19 4214 58 2 135,200 165,000 81.94 5401390A 12-31-18 CAMPETELLA, PAUL V 12-13-18 3666 26 2 217,500 265,000 82.08 5402603A 01-28-19 RODRIGUEZ, HERNAN & WAMECC 01-10-19 3068 3.04 2 292,100 355,000 82.28 5397854F 10-23-18 THE MINORITIES OF NEWARK T 10-09-18 532 46 2 115,300 140,000 82.36 5393582A 07-20-18 JOHNSON, DOROTHY 05-31-18 4100 28 2 168,900 205,000 82.39 5404344A 02-06-19 HOLMES, GARY 01-30-19 4269 41 2 272,000 330,000 82.42 5406534A 05-01-19 210 HILLSIDE A LLC, 01-08-19 2700 36 2 218,400 265,000 82.42 5403648F 02-19-19 DA SILVA, PALMIRA CRAVO 01-25-19 985 54 2 164,900 200,000 82.45 5405659A 04-04-19 CHOY, CARLOS 03-25-19 355 3 2 220,800 267,000 82.70 5409255A 06-25-19 MOINHOS, CARLOS 06-18-19 482 45 2 197,000 238,000 82.77 5401177F 12-27-18 234 N 7TH LLC, 12-20-18 1929 25 2 153,400 185,000 82.92 5405289A 03-26-19 CIG RIVER RD LLC, 03-13-19 1793 57 2 186,300 224,450 83.00 5407804A 05-17-19 HINES, LOUIS CURTIS 05-08-19 4042 10 2 133,000 160,000 83.13 5407878A 05-24-19 CAMACHO, IRENE 04-26-19 2000 80.04 2 291,100 350,000 83.17 5393479A 07-12-18 TOUSSAINT, STANLEY 06-28-18 3661 10 2 274,700 330,000 83.24 5394490F 08-09-18 362-364 N 11TH ASSOCIATES 06-13-18 1963 23 2 208,400 250,000 83.36 5406357A 04-15-19 SUMMER AVENUE NEWARK, LLC 03-29-19 577 10 2 183,400 219,900 83.40 5405276F 03-25-19 371-373 NORTH 13TH ASSOCIA 02-25-19 1962 39 2 216,900 260,000 83.42 5401172F 12-27-18 PAULA, JUAN F 12-05-18 1939 51 2 162,700 195,000 83.44 5400301F 11-28-18 FELICIANO, JOSE 11-14-18 531 70 2 259,400 310,000 83.68 5406948A 05-02-19 EVARISTO, HENRIQUE & MARIA 04-29-19 657 6 2 154,900 185,000 83.73 5404560F 03-12-19 CORR, AIDEN 02-25-19 286 9 2 150,800 180,000 83.78 5399005F 11-05-18 BOBYN, ANDREW 10-29-18 3685 29 2 230,500 275,000 83.82 5406391A 04-22-19 URBAN PROPERTIES SOLUTIONS 03-29-19 3621 20 2 268,500 320,000 83.91 5406963A 05-03-19 147-149 WEEQUAHIC NEWARK H 04-29-19 3697 64 2 155,600 185,000 84.11 5400292F 11-28-18 HASTINGS, ANGELINA JOYCE 11-21-18 554 30 2 109,400 130,000 84.15 5407733A 05-09-19 MORRIS, SHARONDA 04-02-19 3660 49 2 198,200 235,000 84.34 5402042F 01-16-19 WILSON, EARL B. 11-28-18 3090 2.02 2 282,900 335,000 84.45 5404842A 03-20-19 MOTURI, BILLIAH 03-07-19 4115 44 2 226,500 268,000 84.51 5406918A 04-16-19 RODRIGUES, JOSE 04-11-19 301 38 2 237,100 280,000 84.68 5401022F 12-26-18 375-377 SEYMOUR AVE LLC 11-15-18 3603 3 2 190,800 225,000 84.80 5408318F 06-10-19 LYONS WOODS LLC, 05-29-19 1780 14 2 195,600 230,000 85.04

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 13 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400676F 12-07-18 MONTINA HOLDINGS, LLC 11-30-18 278 3 2 140,000 164,000 85.37 5406490A 04-29-19 181 FAIRMOUNT LLC, 04-16-19 263 38 2 162,800 190,000 85.68 5406894A 04-08-19 HORTON, DAN J JR & MARY 03-28-19 2629 61 2 176,000 205,000 85.85 5400946F 12-14-18 REGILUS, NIRVA 12-04-18 3012 30 2 139,100 162,000 85.86 5393486A 07-13-18 NICHOLSON, WALTER 07-11-18 279 9 2 228,200 265,000 86.11 5393544A 07-18-18 HERNANDEZ, ROLANDO & ZULMA 06-27-18 791 20 2 118,000 136,700 86.32 5396641A 09-25-18 DIOP, NDEYE A 08-30-18 351 1.02 2 120,900 140,000 86.36 5402702F 01-29-19 MOISE, MICHELLE 12-21-18 3015.01 12 2 138,400 160,000 86.50 5408411A 03-22-19 MARTIN, SAMUEL L 03-11-19 619 48 2 129,900 150,000 86.60 5406485A 04-29-19 KRAMER, FLAVIA 03-27-19 2484 19 2 360,200 415,000 86.80 5394451A 08-07-18 LANDAVERDE-CARTAGENA, WILB 06-29-18 1183.01 11.16 2 317,100 365,000 86.88 5394714F 08-14-18 HALL, ERIC P & CASE, LIONE 07-11-18 4075 26 2 130,400 150,000 86.93 5396642A 09-25-18 TONKA HOLDINGS LLC, 06-26-18 3041 111 2 174,000 200,000 87.00 5408748A 06-20-19 STEPHENS, P & I & HENDRICK 05-13-19 3724.02 81 2 261,000 300,000 87.00 5405445A 03-28-19 TORRES, KELVIN & JOHAIVA R 03-14-19 2799.01 15 2 292,100 335,000 87.19 5407647A 04-16-19 PACHOVSKI, SLAVI & NENO 04-04-19 817 39 2 90,500 103,683 87.29 5405285A 03-25-19 OKEREKE, GEORGE & PAULA 03-06-19 3062 4 2 39,300 45,000 87.33 5393496A 07-13-18 RANKIN, LIONEL 06-18-18 4044.01 13 2 187,700 214,900 87.34 5405443A 03-28-19 ZHANG, LILLIAN 03-21-19 1860 17 2 131,200 150,000 87.47 5405463A 03-29-19 MCFARLAND, BARBARA 03-06-19 3040 34 2 227,500 260,000 87.50 5408739A 06-20-19 YERKES, FRANCESCA 05-13-19 485 70 2 154,000 176,000 87.50 5400980F 12-18-18 AUFFANT, ANTHONY J 11-14-18 1859 61 2 127,000 145,000 87.59 5403445F 02-13-19 REONEY, LLC. 01-31-19 3067 10.02 2 274,500 313,333 87.61 5396656A 09-27-18 PIERCE ARROW HOLDING,LLC 09-18-18 4077 43 2 223,600 255,000 87.69 5405466A 03-29-19 FEIJOO, FREDDY 03-13-19 777 49 2 197,400 225,000 87.73 5401183F 12-28-18 CUCO, DANIEL C 12-13-18 1179 1.05 2 346,800 395,000 87.80 5404557A 03-12-19 BRAXTON, CLARESTINE 01-30-19 2653 11 2 184,500 210,000 87.86 5394129A 07-31-18 B&B VENTURE CAPITAL II, LL 07-12-18 2691 39.06 2 299,000 340,000 87.94 5403181F 02-08-19 HOLNESS, EILEEN 02-04-19 3737 5 2 274,500 312,000 87.98 5395435A 08-30-18 ABRAHAM & RIVKA LLC, 08-15-18 4207 20 2 77,100 87,500 88.11 5397349A 10-10-18 COROZAL, LLC. 10-02-18 515 17 2 149,800 170,000 88.12 5395735A 09-06-18 GROUNDFLOOR PROPERTIES GA, 08-24-18 4108 18 2 133,700 151,000 88.54 5401009F 12-21-18 CAPITAL INVESTMENT GROUP 2 12-14-18 1929 6 2 46,500 52,500 88.57 5393499A 07-16-18 SANTANA, BALTAZAR & ROSA 05-21-18 304 6.15 2 121,400 137,000 88.61 5404288F 01-07-19 POTENTIAL INVESTMENT LLC 12-21-18 2811 17 2 137,600 155,000 88.77 5395173A 08-27-18 DOMINICI, ERIC ALEXANDER 08-01-18 1930 30 2 191,000 215,000 88.84 5396640A 09-25-18 BLOOMFIELD AUTO REPAIR, LL 09-20-18 527 12 X 2 355,700 400,000 88.93 5406341A 04-12-19 BEST, ELSIE M. 04-04-19 3624 19 2 182,300 205,000 88.93 5393412T 07-06-18 CASILLA, LAURA & ET AL. 06-27-18 284 9 2 235,900 265,000 89.02 5393461F 07-11-18 651 S 19 LLC, 06-05-18 352 23 2 145,100 163,000 89.02 5396154A 09-17-18 DAVIS, ERNEST L 08-28-18 324 14 2 147,900 165,000 89.64 5406899A 04-09-19 T & Z HOLDING1 03-25-19 278 43 2 237,600 264,999 89.66 5393424A 07-09-18 WEST BROADWAY HOLDINGS, LL 06-29-18 3593 11 2 269,100 300,000 89.70 5393430A 07-09-18 A&J ELITE PROPERTIES, LLC. 02-12-18 2646 5 2 118,500 132,000 89.77 5400866A 12-10-18 BERTOLI, GIULIO & FABIOLA 11-13-18 4119 9 2 31,500 35,000 90.00 5400308F 11-28-18 EZ CAPITAL LLC, 10-31-18 2801 47 2 257,400 285,000 90.32

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 14 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393367A 07-03-18 BARBOSA, MANUEL & ANA 06-21-18 896 29 2 135,700 150,000 90.47 5398882A 10-31-18 WHITE, HORACE L & MARY 10-08-18 3724.02 67 2 208,400 230,000 90.61 5398836T 10-26-18 SWAMI NARAVAN GROUP, LLC. 10-24-18 677 12 2 100,000 110,000 90.91 5397921A 10-12-18 WATT, PAUL A 08-31-18 3044.02 52.01 2 220,900 242,500 91.09 5406896A 04-09-19 SANTILLAN, PETER 04-03-19 359 21 2 169,000 185,000 91.35 5408600A 06-14-19 98100 SUMMIT LLC, 06-07-19 3728.01 7 2 178,200 195,000 91.38 5397058A 10-02-18 TONKA HOLDINGS, LLC 09-10-18 2626 44 2 255,000 279,000 91.40 5400879F 12-11-18 85 WILLOUGHBY LLC, 12-05-18 3054 23 2 114,500 125,000 91.60 5396540A 09-24-18 MOH MILLINGTON CAPITAL LLC 08-03-18 3035 43 2 163,100 178,000 91.63 5403973A 03-01-19 BAEZ, ELENA A. 01-03-19 2848 15.02 2 230,200 251,000 91.71 5403684F 02-22-19 82 GARFIELD AVE, LLC. 01-17-19 1874 20 2 151,600 165,000 91.88 5404163F 03-06-19 PARISH, MICHAEL (TRUSTEE) 01-30-19 3665 71 2 229,800 250,000 91.92 5397357A 10-10-18 MARTINEZ, HITALO MARVIN & 09-25-18 680 5.29 2 125,400 136,000 92.21 5403971A 03-01-19 SUTTON, STEPHANIE 01-28-19 1877 14 2 161,800 175,000 92.46 5408447A 06-11-19 BELCHER, WILLIE 05-30-19 1858 43 2 176,400 190,000 92.84 5399894A 11-07-18 HILL, CONSTANCE H 10-31-18 3566 35 2 167,200 180,000 92.89 5401685A 01-07-19 SANDERS, ZENOBIA 12-28-18 3605 24 2 167,200 180,000 92.89 5398142A 10-17-18 CESPEDES, CRISTHIAN 09-13-18 3724.02 55 2 283,400 305,000 92.92 5393578A 07-20-18 188 ASTOR LLC, 07-06-18 1181 11 2 130,200 140,000 93.00 5402845F 02-01-19 ALPHA NJ I, LLC. 01-16-19 2803 68 2 148,900 160,000 93.06 5400838F 11-15-18 COEYMAN TRUST II, 09-20-18 818 24 2 107,200 115,000 93.22 5407847A 05-22-19 GONZALEZ, GILBERTO 05-07-19 783 19 2 159,000 170,000 93.53 5408329F 06-12-19 LARKINS COMMUNITY RESTORAT 06-05-19 3665 28 2 182,700 195,000 93.69 5398390A 10-16-18 AGUIRRE, KATHERINE E SERPA 08-13-18 3034 72 2 112,700 120,000 93.92 5406544A 05-02-19 PRYOR, HAROLD 03-04-19 3720.01 57 2 183,600 195,000 94.15 5401021F 12-26-18 MURIGU, ERIC 12-18-18 3078 68 2 165,400 175,000 94.51 5395367A 08-29-18 SHAPIRO, DANIEL B 08-24-18 4034 71 2 174,900 185,000 94.54 5407701A 05-06-19 BLACKSTONE, GLENN 04-29-19 1799 19 X 2 156,100 165,000 94.61 5398897A 10-31-18 VALENTIN, MARTIN 08-03-18 817 49 2 136,100 143,806 94.64 5408261F 06-04-19 ZAGELBAUM, SHALOM 05-15-19 3042 57 2 318,000 335,000 94.93 5393492F 07-13-18 SOUTH 15 CAPITAL LLC, 05-31-18 4031 46 2 166,500 175,000 95.14 5402862F 02-04-19 BALAJI INVESTMENT GROUP LL 01-25-19 741 11 2 247,600 260,000 95.23 5395163A 08-24-18 GREENROCK PROPERTIES, LLC. 08-08-18 3569 38 2 85,800 90,000 95.33 5402716F 01-30-19 HUTSON, WILLIE M & CYNTHIA 12-05-18 2655 35 2 157,500 165,000 95.45 5407683F 05-03-19 LEE, CHRISTOPHER C 04-29-19 683 44 2 286,900 300,000 95.63 5404330A 12-28-18 FLETCHER, GERALD K & ET AL 12-14-18 329 19 2 236,400 247,000 95.71 5397322A 10-05-18 48 WAINWRIGHT STREET TRUST 10-01-18 3068 11 2 138,900 145,000 95.79 5398479A 10-22-18 SKF MANAGEMENT, LLC. 10-11-18 4176 21 2 95,800 100,000 95.80 5404355A 03-01-19 COBB, PATRICIA R. & RICHAR 02-28-19 4132 40 2 213,100 222,000 95.99 5393639A 07-25-18 GLOVER, LEE V 07-06-18 3666 29 2 163,500 170,000 96.18 5407746A 05-10-19 M2J2 PROPERTIES, LLC, 04-24-19 1818 13 2 93,900 97,500 96.31 5398160A 10-18-18 MORAES, ARMOR 09-19-18 2034.01 2.02 C2B 2 86,700 90,000 96.33 5398143A 10-17-18 T & T PROPERTY HOLDING, LL 07-31-18 3014 43 2 169,400 175,000 96.80 5408401F 12-04-18 78 BEVERLY LLC, 11-27-18 3080 22 2 254,600 263,000 96.81 5395357A 08-28-18 TAYLOR HOLDINGS, LLC. 08-21-18 1937 61 2 135,900 140,000 97.07 5407374A 05-24-19 339-341 WOODSIDE ASSOCIATE 05-08-19 777 14 2 145,700 150,000 97.13

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 15 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5400010A 11-20-18 41-43 MONTROSE ST LLC 10-12-18 4179 12 2 155,600 160,000 97.25 5397973A 10-16-18 GOMEZ, MARIA AURORA & ANN 10-05-18 560 23 2 184,800 190,000 97.26 5399006F 11-05-18 ROJAS, EMILY & BYRON S 10-26-18 681 29 2 155,900 160,000 97.44 5398816F 10-25-18 ESPINOZA, FREDDY R 09-07-18 3598 36 2 326,500 335,000 97.46 5408130F 05-28-19 BRISCO NJ, LLC, 03-22-19 740 26 2 366,200 375,000 97.65 5396016A 09-12-18 JANKLOWICZ, ALEX 06-29-18 676 5.01 2 293,900 300,000 97.97 5393560F 07-19-18 PENNYMAC CORP, LLC. 05-17-18 4127 38 2 172,200 175,000 98.40 5400916F 12-13-18 REI FAMILY,LLC, 12-07-18 926.01 2.02 C2B 2 187,000 190,000 98.42 5397046A 10-02-18 QUINN, GEOFFREY 09-20-18 229 7.13 C7M 2 108,400 110,000 98.55 5394278A 08-02-18 KMJ HOLDINGS LLC, 07-17-18 4176 43 2 159,400 160,000 99.63 5396847A 09-28-18 812 S 15TH ASSOCIATES LLC 08-28-18 2647 39 2 130,200 130,000 100.15 5394039A 07-30-18 RANKIN, LIONEL & BEVERLY 07-24-18 3603 38 2 225,500 225,000 100.22 5400952F 12-17-18 RIBEIRO, DIEGO 12-10-18 3051 43 2 235,800 235,000 100.34 5393416A 07-06-18 INACIO, MARINA 06-22-18 2071 22 2 160,800 160,057 100.46 5399056F 11-07-18 322-324 PARKER ASSOCIATES, 10-22-18 582 19 2 231,800 230,000 100.78 5406504A 04-29-19 FERNANDES, LUIS 04-12-19 2034.01 4.01 C1D 2 146,300 145,000 100.90 5395726A 09-05-18 ZAKHARIEVA, SVETLANA 08-20-18 3661 38 2 136,300 135,000 100.96 5403443F 02-13-19 DWORKIN, NEIL J. & LONNIE 01-28-19 3018 33 2 172,000 170,000 101.18 5399175A 10-29-18 MERRITT, LARRY 10-12-18 599 42 2 204,000 200,000 102.00 5408410A 03-22-19 166 S 11TH STREET LLC 02-16-19 1826 56 2 224,400 220,000 102.00 5408478F 06-14-19 WILLOW TREE GROUP LLC 05-28-19 3606 19 2 235,100 230,000 102.22 5402432F 01-22-19 MCGILL, PAMELA 01-10-19 680 5.04 2 133,000 130,000 102.31 5400278F 11-27-18 HOXHA, MEDI 11-13-18 4042 52 2 138,300 135,000 102.44 5407617A 04-03-19 CARTER, NEILON 03-27-19 3035 36 2 256,200 250,000 102.48 5403143F 02-06-19 FIELD, CRAIG 12-10-18 288 42 2 226,500 220,000 102.95 5408317A 06-10-19 MIDFIRST BANK, 05-24-19 1780 14 2 195,600 190,000 102.95 5400966F 12-17-18 RAIMO, CARMINE D III 12-06-18 487 1 2 123,600 120,000 103.00 5400115F 11-21-18 STELLAR NEWARK PROP MANAGE 10-24-18 3660 22 2 165,700 160,000 103.56 5403456F 02-14-19 TAPIA, JORGE A 02-07-19 1938 62 2 155,500 150,000 103.67 5401158F 12-24-18 ZAHNER, JOHN 12-13-18 518 37 2 137,000 132,000 103.79 5404615F 03-13-19 ESD REAL ESTATE LLC, 03-01-19 3051 6 2 192,400 184,900 104.06 5397718F 08-13-18 L&B REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS L 02-06-18 2656 1 2 193,000 185,000 104.32 5394464F 08-07-18 GG-148 CHADWICK AVE LLC 07-25-18 2687 48 2 196,200 188,000 104.36 5405683F 04-10-19 COLON HUGHES PROPERTIES, L 04-03-19 1944.01 54 2 156,800 150,000 104.53 5393617F 07-24-18 THOMAS, LAWANDA 06-28-18 4052 132 2 129,300 122,960 105.16 5394957F 08-15-18 EBURY RE LLC, 07-19-18 4138 24 2 136,800 130,000 105.23 5397076F 10-03-18 TORRES, EDWIN 08-21-18 1861 60 2 68,600 65,000 105.54 5401840F 01-08-19 NCCB INVESTMENTS INC, 12-07-18 3011 76 2 161,500 153,000 105.56 5404115F 12-07-18 OREGON STREET LLC, 11-16-18 3689 5 2 163,900 155,000 105.74 5402494F 01-24-19 106 BROOKDALE NUT NJ, LLC 12-21-18 3607 29 2 223,700 210,000 106.52 5407636F 04-11-19 60 41 STREET LLC, 04-02-19 4095 1 2 171,700 160,000 107.31 5398162F 10-18-18 CARACCIO, STEVEN 09-06-18 366 22 2 206,200 192,000 107.40 5406945F 05-02-19 662 MT PROSPECT, LLC. 04-18-19 737 12 2 188,800 175,000 107.89 5394275F 08-02-18 DEMOIR EQUITIES LLC, 07-09-18 3695 22 2 183,600 170,000 108.00 5402848F 02-01-19 RODRIGUEZ, F & RAMOS, C 12-12-18 489 74 2 86,500 80,000 108.13 5394183F 08-01-18 GEANACOPOULOS, PETER & DEB 07-19-18 1815 30 2 135,600 125,000 108.48

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 16 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401126F 12-19-18 FRAZIER, VIRGINIA 12-04-18 617.01 11 2 119,500 110,000 108.64 5397191F 10-04-18 MALASZUK, MARIA 08-23-18 537 20 2 114,200 105,000 108.76 5403686F 02-22-19 KINA DEVELOPMENT, LLC. 01-29-19 1783 60 2 152,800 140,000 109.14 5393507F 07-16-18 A&J ELITE PROPERTIES, LLC. 06-04-18 3737 10 2 245,700 225,000 109.20 5393550F 07-18-18 HUALPA, GUILLERMO 03-30-18 718 38 2 162,800 148,000 110.00 5400860F 12-10-18 REI FAMILY, LLC. 11-21-18 926.01 3.02 C3B 2 187,000 170,000 110.00 5393973F 07-27-18 SHIVERS, BERNARD 07-19-18 3067 23 2 132,500 120,000 110.42 5404147F 03-05-19 PIROTTO, OSVALDO F. 02-22-19 4051 33 2 132,500 120,000 110.42 5407642F 04-12-19 DEBROSSE, WOODLEY 04-04-19 279 31 2 131,400 119,000 110.42 5402425F 01-18-19 LEGUISAMON, ALFREDO A 12-22-18 742 17 2 238,200 215,000 110.79 5407880F 05-24-19 ISLAND SOURCE III LLC 05-08-19 3663 75 2 155,100 140,000 110.79 5403089F 11-29-18 RODAS, MARELYN N 11-07-18 680 5.22 2 133,000 120,000 110.83 5399248F 11-14-18 394 IRVINE TURNER BLVD HOL 10-16-18 2678 63 2 145,300 130,000 111.77 5408462F 06-12-19 TRITOP REALTY, LLC, 06-04-19 3057 9 2 139,700 124,000 112.66 5400992F 12-19-18 SERRANO, CARMEN L 08-14-18 811 71 2 78,900 70,000 112.71 5397918F 10-11-18 MITCHELL, LINDA R 09-12-18 3053 24 2 142,900 125,000 114.32 5404150F 03-05-19 COOPER, LAVINA 02-28-19 3065 37 2 143,300 125,000 114.64 5403861F 02-27-19 MARTINEZ, RICHARD 02-21-19 1919 72 2 138,300 120,000 115.25 5393556F 07-19-18 PERKINS, ANDREW & ET AL. 07-06-18 3052 12 2 175,500 150,000 117.00 5404474F 03-12-19 POWELL, LILLIAN 01-26-19 4003 30.02 C2A 2 126,600 108,000 117.22 5400096F 11-20-18 TOLBERT, DENISE 10-24-18 3704 5 2 105,800 90,000 117.56 5400509F 12-05-18 RENOVATION PROS, LLC. 11-20-18 3044 14 2 182,900 155,000 118.00 5393467F 07-12-18 FOREST HILL MANAGEMENT, LL 06-15-18 811 54 2 200,800 170,000 118.12 5393445F 07-10-18 ENDEAVOR INVESTMENT, 06-20-18 2804 33 2 138,800 117,000 118.63 5398483F 10-22-18 NEWARK 1836, LLC. 10-17-18 4109 14 2 107,000 89,900 119.02 5394912F 08-14-18 78 WEBSTER LLC, 08-01-18 481 22 2 185,700 155,000 119.81 5400109F 11-20-18 DINER, STEVEN J 11-01-18 147.01 7.01 C7A 2 138,100 115,000 120.09 5394182F 08-01-18 ADA NJ-PROPERTIES, LLC. 06-04-18 3035 43 2 163,100 135,000 120.81 5396020F 09-12-18 659 S 14TH NJ LLC, 08-24-18 360 12 2 169,400 140,000 121.00 5400950F 12-17-18 HAMLET, WILLIAM 11-21-18 1868 63 2 115,300 95,000 121.37 5407613F 04-01-19 MANASSE, JOY 03-19-19 3665 28 2 182,700 150,000 121.80 5397029F 10-01-18 20 MARION HOLDINGS LLC 09-21-18 4180 37 2 202,300 165,000 122.61 5399177F 10-30-18 ORADELL PROPERTY MANAGEMEN 10-01-18 4174 25 2 147,500 120,000 122.92 5402461F 01-22-19 SWEET, ALVIN 12-10-18 3756 5 2 120,500 98,000 122.96 5402705F 01-29-19 POMERANTSEV, MOSHE 01-21-19 3011 34 2 198,300 160,000 123.94 5404817F 12-19-18 SY GROUPS LLC, 11-30-18 2803 68 2 148,900 120,000 124.08 5398169F 10-18-18 HECTOR, CYNTHIA 09-20-18 1877 18 2 155,400 125,000 124.32 5393377F 07-03-18 102 COLUMBIA AVENUE 06-13-18 4032 68 2 201,900 160,000 126.19 5399859F 11-16-18 BROWN, ALONZO R 11-01-18 4066 53 2 85,300 67,170 126.99 5404349F 02-20-19 MOORE, MARY & MCMICKLE, B 01-18-19 3047 39 2 285,800 225,000 127.02 5396379F 09-19-18 10 FORTUNA ASSOCIATES, LLC 08-22-18 4120 38 2 108,600 85,000 127.76 5407716F 05-08-19 MOODY, JAMES D & MARY C 04-30-19 3007 93 2 153,500 120,000 127.92 5398156F 10-18-18 LUIS, LUIS A 10-01-18 3566 9 2 115,200 90,000 128.00 5393371F 07-03-18 EBB LITTLETON PROPERTIES, 06-04-18 1778 16 2 192,300 150,000 128.20 5395426F 08-29-18 LEGRAND, CLARISE 08-21-18 4038 14 2 115,400 90,000 128.22 5400108F 11-20-18 SULEMAN, JOHNSON 04-04-18 4064 60 2 174,100 135,000 128.96

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 17 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401147F 12-20-18 CLIMER, ANNA BELLE 07-15-18 147.01 5.13 C5M 2 130,100 100,000 130.10 5408844F 06-21-19 PAWLAK, ROBERT 05-31-19 2611 21 2 122,200 92,500 132.11 5398803F 10-22-18 SILVA, MARISTANE 10-10-18 1992 15 2 165,300 125,000 132.24 5397742F 10-12-18 SMALL, MONEEK 07-31-18 2646 25 2 111,500 84,000 132.74 5408721F 06-18-19 EZEDIEGWU, DANIEL & ADIBE, 06-06-19 351 64 2 106,500 80,000 133.13 5398392F 10-16-18 MOORE, DOUGLAS 08-09-18 4115 23 2 113,400 85,000 133.41 5400903F 12-13-18 FLEMING, MICHAEL D & YOLAN 12-07-18 3680 22 2 153,600 115,000 133.57 5408277F 06-05-19 FUNCHES, KEVIN 05-24-19 3608 7 2 152,900 113,000 135.31 5402847F 02-01-19 JOHNSON, ETHEL MARY 08-09-18 263 24 2 150,100 110,000 136.45 5399623F 11-15-18 D & D EQUITIES LLC, 11-08-18 3009 40 2 151,800 110,000 138.00 5407717F 05-08-19 JOHNSON, DERRICK L 04-26-19 4199 117 2 92,500 67,000 138.06 5402609F 01-28-19 CAJANO, CELESTE (ATTORNEY) 01-18-19 2392 26 2 126,200 90,000 140.22 5399896F 11-08-18 FLORENCE, RODNEY 10-30-18 367 60 2 246,700 175,000 140.97 5406330F 04-05-19 JONES, EVAN & LAIDFORD, MA 04-01-19 278 41 2 142,200 100,000 142.20 5393512F 07-16-18 EBA PROPERTIES, LLC. 05-20-18 3005 1 2 173,000 120,000 144.17 5400008F 11-19-18 HOTTOMES INCORPORATED 10-05-18 3604 10 2 187,900 130,000 144.54 5395154F 08-23-18 GLENN, CARL E 08-14-18 2636 14 2 145,000 100,000 145.00 5396663F 09-27-18 SABA PROPERTIES, LLC. 08-31-18 1778 56 2 139,200 95,000 146.53 5401169F 12-27-18 NWK RE, LLC. 12-14-18 1914 4 2 163,000 110,000 148.18 5403622F 02-15-19 QRJ INVESTMENTS, LLC. 02-13-19 3712 19 2 262,600 175,000 150.06 5402469F 01-23-19 PRIME RE, LLC. 01-03-19 2656 45 2 248,200 165,000 150.42 5402678F 11-27-18 DC ENTERPRISE GROUP LLC 10-23-18 4033 66 2 150,500 100,000 150.50 5396486F 09-26-18 155 PAINE AVENUE CAPITAL, 09-12-18 4053 38 2 102,400 68,000 150.59 5399996F 11-19-18 117 ASSOCIATES LLC, 11-04-18 3660 51 2 204,000 135,000 151.11 5397975F 10-16-18 NEWARK DEVELOPERS, LLC. 09-26-18 3011 70 2 169,700 110,000 154.27 5395035F 08-17-18 PALMER, WILLIAM JR 07-19-18 4033 69 2 154,700 100,000 154.70 5400940F 12-14-18 CFRE INVESTMENT FLIP, 10-05-18 4138 42 2 139,300 89,000 156.52 5407658F 04-22-19 D GLOBAL PROPERTY LLC 03-06-19 961 27 2 166,300 100,000 166.30 5393488F 07-13-18 EDGAR PROPERTY LLC 07-06-18 4172 52 2 160,300 95,000 168.74 5404676F 12-11-18 800 S 10TH ST LLC, 11-21-18 3005 45 2 211,300 125,000 169.04 5397970F 10-16-18 AMADU-SUKA, ABDAL & MUSTAP 09-06-18 3042 57 2 318,000 188,000 169.15 5393471F 07-12-18 MEDINA, GREGORIO & LAZALA, 06-19-18 3732 42 2 164,300 94,000 174.79 5398486F 10-23-18 WHITE, CATHERINE 10-12-18 4108 6 2 103,000 57,500 179.13 5395427F 08-29-18 VAYECHAL MOSHE, LLC. 08-20-18 3035 12.01 2 290,600 160,000 181.63 5399818F 11-19-18 LADO, JOHN 11-01-18 527 4 X 2 199,700 108,000 184.91 5407767F 05-14-19 HHDD, LLC, 04-08-19 561 10 2 103,200 55,000 187.64 5393629F 07-25-18 COMMUNITY ASSET PRESERVATI 05-22-18 3048.01 6 2 282,700 150,000 188.47 5396237F 09-18-18 13-15 VASSAR AVENUE ASSOC 08-30-18 3680 14 2 171,100 90,000 190.11 5394621F 08-13-18 MCMILLAN, LIZZIE 06-15-18 3030 10 2 81,800 42,500 192.47 5393992F 07-30-18 MCCOY, JAMES R 05-14-18 3729 33 2 244,800 125,000 195.84 5404331F 12-28-18 STRATEGIC INVESTMENTS & MA 11-21-18 4060 69 2 132,400 64,000 206.88** 5394475F 08-08-18 AMOS, RONNIE JR 07-31-18 4046 16 2 164,800 75,000 219.73** 5398468F 10-19-18 HOLSEY, WALTER SR 10-12-18 1891 67 2 116,800 50,000 233.60** 5402434F 01-22-19 COMPTON, TAMIKO 01-02-19 282 33 2 93,800 37,000 253.51** SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 18 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND

ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE YEAR TO DATE 764 136,692,100 191,481,815 60,358.46 5393454F 07-11-18 SIN, HYO CHU 06-14-18 64 22 4A 348,600 1,200,000 29.05 5406500F 04-29-19 487-489 BLOOMFIELD AVE 04-12-19 645 1 4A 265,400 625,000 42.46 5393482F 07-13-18 FIELDSPRING PROPERTIES LLC 06-29-18 3631 4 4A 724,900 1,675,000 43.28 5397056T 10-02-18 10TH STREET CORPORATION 09-12-18 288 22 X 4A 153,200 300,000 51.07 5397206F 10-05-18 SINENSKY, GARY B 09-28-18 1994 36 4A 625,000 1,100,000 56.82 5396164F 09-18-18 CROSS REALTY CORPORATION 09-12-18 1163 23 4A 346,900 575,000 60.33 5396466F 09-21-18 AMERICAN TOP FRIENDS, LLC. 09-11-18 368 8 4A 32,000 53,000 60.38 5398878F 10-30-18 JAMES E CHURMAN, JR. FUNER 10-16-18 1799 29 4A 49,600 75,000 66.13 5397067F 10-03-18 TORRES, DULCE 09-14-18 762 1 4A 331,500 500,000 66.30 5404166F 03-06-19 ALPINE APARTMENTS LLC 02-19-19 2697 4 4A 1,288,600 1,890,000 68.18 5407784F 05-15-19 NEVES, JOAO 05-07-19 936 4 4A 346,500 500,000 69.30 5398815F 10-25-18 IDN GROUP LLC, 09-27-18 3590 30 4A 320,500 460,000 69.67 5398163F 10-18-18 454 SPRINGFIELD AVENUE, LL 09-26-18 301.01 55 4A 291,500 415,000 70.24 5397200F 10-04-18 SOUSA, MARIA 10-03-18 955 63 4A 350,900 470,000 74.66 5404698F 03-15-19 NORTH 13TH STREET ACQUISIT 03-07-19 653 13 4A 210,900 280,000 75.32 5405078F 03-21-19 CROSS ISLAND LLC, 03-06-19 3078 17 4A 141,300 187,500 75.36 5400865F 12-10-18 RODRIGUES, MANUEL & ROSALI 10-03-18 2013 5 4A 325,000 430,000 75.58 5405674F 04-05-19 DIWAN SPIRITS, INC. 03-29-19 4207 17 4A 673,400 850,000 79.22 5403193F 02-08-19 NORTH 13TH STREET ACQUISIT 01-24-19 653 24 4A 206,300 260,000 79.35 5408138F 05-29-19 51 PACIFIC STREET LLC 05-23-19 938 29 4A 638,400 800,000 79.80 5400353F 12-06-18 ABEIGON, JOHN 10-29-18 118 9 4A 1,141,700 1,400,000 81.55 5408840F 06-21-19 FAST FLIPS LLC, 06-13-19 885 19 4A 250,000 300,000 83.33 5405499F 04-02-19 69 SHERWOOD ROAD, LLC. 01-08-19 314 14 4A 220,100 260,000 84.65 5395857F 09-10-18 219-221 FERRY STREET, LLC. 07-13-18 2030 4 X 4A 1,008,900 1,100,000 91.72 5408402F 12-04-18 116 ELM ST LLC, 11-14-18 940 15 4A 519,000 560,000 92.68 5401417F 01-03-19 ADELINE SANTA MARIA FAMILY 12-26-18 173 19 X 4A 1,448,400 1,550,000 93.45 5398603F 11-02-18 LEE, SEUNG HO & MI AE 09-11-18 60 19 4A 344,100 360,000 95.58 5395724F 09-05-18 LAFAYETTE MEDICAL ASSOC, I 08-21-18 188 33 4A 402,600 415,000 97.01 5393374T 07-03-18 SORIANO, VICTOR & MARIA 05-07-18 449 8 4A 176,600 175,000 100.91 5393518F 07-17-18 MCGREGOR, JAMES 06-28-18 874 16 4A 335,600 330,000 101.70 5400957F 12-17-18 ANSTATT, DAVID & SCALERA, 12-02-18 116 28 4A 343,900 335,000 102.66 5394421F 08-03-18 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROP XII 07-31-18 2804 2 4A 175,300 170,000 103.12 5393363F 07-02-18 TORRES, ARCADIO 06-13-18 625 17 4A 271,800 261,000 104.14 5405486F 04-01-19 MARCHITELLO, CARMEN & JOYC 03-06-19 835 15 4A 620,900 590,000 105.24 5407337F 04-08-19 SARAIVA, ANTONIO & MARIA 03-22-19 2400 40 4A 571,900 540,000 105.91 5394478F 08-08-18 WCNJ PROPERTIES LLC, 07-31-18 2826 1 4A 1,051,400 990,000 106.20 5403671F 02-21-19 TRADE WINDS REAL ESTATE, L 02-14-19 60 3 4A 335,400 315,000 106.48 5408273F 06-05-19 550 BROAD INVESTORS LLC 05-23-19 14 9 4A 20,427,600 19,000,000 107.51 5407736F 05-09-19 SHELTON, GODFREY 04-30-19 2507 17 4A 431,700 400,000 107.93 5406525F 04-30-19 WASHINGTON, ANGELO 04-12-19 1846 19 4A 250,000 230,000 108.70 5395677F 09-04-18 MAYLOCK REALTY CORP. 07-09-18 3720 1 4A 316,800 285,000 111.16 5402675F 11-20-18 W2005 WYN HOTELS, L.P. 10-31-18 150.02 162 C1A 4A 17,000,000 15,135,000 112.32

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 19 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5403640F 02-19-19 CHOE, KUM CHA 02-02-19 1905 34 4A 146,500 130,000 112.69 5408163F 06-03-19 JOMO REALTY CORP, 05-15-19 2824 16 4A 563,700 500,000 112.74 5407687F 05-06-19 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROPERTI 04-15-19 962 33 4A 252,400 220,000 114.73 5393641F 07-25-18 FIORENZA, JOHN C 07-20-18 4065 4 X 4A 441,300 375,000 117.68 5393458F 07-11-18 ALONDRA R CORP., 06-26-18 195 31.01 4A 515,900 430,000 119.98 5398394F 10-18-18 CHUNG, YANG NIM 10-01-18 4047 54 4A 332,000 275,000 120.73 5399183F 11-01-18 MORGAN, JEROME SR 10-10-18 3036 1 4A 333,000 275,000 121.09 5396645F 09-26-18 SAMUEL, STEVE 09-14-18 1186 8 4A 486,000 400,000 121.50 5407911F 05-31-19 LANTIGUA, BLADDIMIR 05-10-19 1889.01 4 4A 714,400 570,000 125.33 5407609F 03-29-19 411-419 CHESTNUT ST,UNIT 1 03-21-19 1128.03 1.01 C1A 4A 217,200 170,000 127.76 5402683F 01-09-19 ZRANCHEV FAMILY REALTY, LL 12-28-18 4140.01 34 4A 1,038,500 750,000 138.47 5405515F 04-03-19 MANGUM, LOUIS & SHIRLEY 03-22-19 2667 25 X 4A 1,299,000 785,000 165.48 5393446F 07-10-18 J.A.C. REALTY ASSOCI, 06-28-18 995 23 4A 925,000 500,000 185.00 5393601F 07-24-18 LIVINGSTON, JAMES 07-12-18 2633 9 4A 175,600 65,000 270.15** YEAR TO DATE 56 62,754,600 62,791,500 5,449.78 5395131F 08-22-18 GONZALEZ, EDWIN 07-31-18 1161 1 4B 277,500 600,000 46.25 5406524F 04-30-19 CASTRORAO, ERNEST 04-24-19 447 51 4B 531,300 1,100,000 48.30 5402489T 01-24-19 CASTRO, ROLANDO & AMANDA 01-17-19 3762 1 X 4B 495,000 750,000 66.00 5393478F 07-12-18 ZYGAL LTD, 06-28-18 3520 18 X 4B 2,678,400 3,100,000 86.40 5399186F 11-05-18 45-57 EDISON PLACE, LLC. 10-31-18 164 78 4B 5,408,300 6,150,000 87.94 5394395F 08-02-18 CRESPO REALTY LLC, 05-15-18 1158 1.04 4B 479,900 500,000 95.98 5407600F 03-26-19 PATSY RAGONESE AND SONS, I 03-19-19 971 1 4B 682,200 650,000 104.95 5403126F 02-05-19 200 BADGER AVE. CORP. 01-28-19 2692 50 X 4B 919,000 860,000 106.86 YEAR TO DATE 8 11,471,600 13,710,000 642.68 5395433F 08-30-18 18TH AVE HOLDING, LLC. 08-21-18 314 16 4C 313,600 886,000 35.40 5404346F 02-07-19 HONEY REAL ESTATE PROPERTI 02-01-19 2484 31 4C 432,400 820,000 52.73 5404342F 02-01-19 CARVALHO, MARIA 01-04-19 761 62 4C 380,200 670,000 56.75 5394450F 08-06-18 405 CHESTNUT LLC, 07-25-18 1128 12 4C 411,500 690,000 59.64 5402437F 01-22-19 MENA, MARCOS A 12-28-18 488 15 4C 186,400 312,000 59.74 5397937F 10-18-18 292 WAINWRIGHT NWK, LLC. 10-04-18 3734 59 4C 1,207,000 2,000,000 60.35 5399810F 11-15-18 AVON 368, LLC, 11-08-18 2483 34 4C 415,500 675,000 61.56 5393475F 07-12-18 257-259 SHERMAN AVENUE, LL 06-08-18 2761 28 4C 405,500 650,000 62.38 5408123F 05-21-19 NEWARK ACQUISITIONS,LLC 05-14-19 3703 1 4C 2,032,000 3,150,000 64.51 5393422T 07-09-18 COELHO, MARIA C (TRSUTEE) 06-08-18 1006 33 4C 411,500 600,000 68.58 5405514F 04-03-19 CUNHA, ROSA 03-28-19 1949 37 X 4C 446,600 647,000 69.03 5399795F 11-15-18 FERNANDES, MARIA VIEIRA 10-29-18 2012 20 4C 426,000 600,000 71.00 5402007F 01-14-19 52 NORWOOD HOLDINGS,LLC 12-27-18 4065 29 4C 346,600 465,000 74.54 5405465F 03-29-19 GARSIDE EQUITY LLC, 01-22-19 490 34 4C 1,095,100 1,450,000 75.52 5402815F 01-31-19 GUERRERO, WARNER 01-09-19 4060 76 4C 322,400 425,000 75.86 5397360T 10-10-18 PERSAUD, PONNEMA 10-04-18 779 57 4C 426,400 560,000 76.14

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 20 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 14 NEWARK CITY SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406417F 04-24-19 DA CRUZ, JOSE 04-17-19 1948 32 4C 436,100 565,000 77.19 5407740F 05-09-19 BROLLESY INVESTMENTS, INC. 04-30-19 2649 47 4C 348,000 450,000 77.33 5400116F 11-21-18 PLAZA, LUIS R 10-31-18 2796 15 4C 330,000 410,000 80.49 5395042F 08-20-18 1-7 TILLINGHAST ST LLC 08-03-18 3030 28 X 4C 979,100 1,137,500 86.07 5407912F 05-31-19 DARBRY INVESTORS CORPORATI 05-01-19 4114 53 4C 346,600 350,000 99.03 5403689F 02-22-19 YOTANGO, LLC. 01-29-19 522 48 4C 387,600 389,000 99.64 5394474F 08-08-18 CORTICADA ENTERPRISE,LLC 07-30-18 4061 40 4C 275,100 275,000 100.04 5408437F 06-10-19 297 SOUTH SEVENTH ST REALT 05-30-19 269 17 4C 286,100 274,000 104.42 YEAR TO DATE 24 12,647,300 18,450,500 1,747.94 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 864 224,141,400 287,692,315 69,164.12

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 15 NORTH CALDWELL TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396286F 09-21-18 QUINN, DIANE 07-13-18 2002 27 1 472,800 638,500 74.05 YEAR TO DATE 1 472,800 638,500 74.05 5398178A 10-29-18 PEARSON, GLENN B 10-22-18 902 10 2 274,300 380,000 72.18 5407920F 05-29-19 GERSON, GERALD 05-15-19 906 7 2 447,500 595,000 75.21 5399624A 11-19-18 CIRELLO, RICHARD 10-08-18 101 2 C0065 2 530,600 700,000 75.80 5397367A 10-09-18 ROMANO, DOMINIC & KELLI 09-27-18 1401 9 2 561,800 740,990 75.82 5409021A 06-24-19 FEULNER, DONNA 06-12-19 902 5 2 722,700 945,000 76.48 5404942A 03-20-19 GRACEN, SHANNON U 02-20-19 1103 1 2 521,900 675,000 77.32 5409303A 06-27-19 MONGIOVI, B. JAMES JR. 06-03-19 405 3 2 454,200 582,000 78.04 5397095A 10-04-18 BRIAN T BURKE LIVING TRUST 09-06-18 1404 9 2 452,100 575,000 78.63 5399900A 11-30-18 HODOR, PETER 11-19-18 505 5 2 597,000 755,000 79.07 5405888A 04-17-19 CHAKRAVARTULA, SRIHARSHA & 04-06-19 200 13 2 401,200 505,000 79.45 5400360A 12-10-18 CAGAS, CHRISTOPHER S & MIC 11-30-18 500 53 2 548,300 690,000 79.46 5407927F 06-06-19 CLARKEN-GLEASON, CATHY & J 04-03-19 301 13 2 434,800 545,000 79.78 5394529A 08-14-18 FAHMY, MONIR M & SUSAN A 07-31-18 707 23 2 614,700 767,500 80.09 5393881A 07-20-18 NESS, JAMES CORY & ET AL. 07-13-18 603 19 2 549,600 685,000 80.23 5404709A 03-14-19 O'NEILL, MARION 03-08-19 2102 6 C1042 2 326,800 405,000 80.69 5402532A 01-25-19 LEICHT, ANDREW & RAMON 01-14-19 903 15 2 690,800 855,215 80.78 5406556A 05-02-19 DEVLIN, JEFFREY & KELLY 04-29-19 906 3 2 611,600 750,000 81.55 5393647A 07-05-18 CESPEDES, STEVE & LULZIME 06-29-18 502 5 2 650,000 790,000 82.28 5395598A 08-21-18 SMITH, SHIRLEY-MAE 08-08-18 101 2 C0030 2 652,700 790,000 82.62 5393880A 07-20-18 PUREWAL, JASVINDER K 07-13-18 101 2 C0011 2 486,300 588,000 82.70 5398030A 10-25-18 MEAD, DAVID E 10-22-18 700 10 2 625,200 753,000 83.03 5399902A 12-05-18 HYLAND, TIMOTHY S & MELISS 11-16-18 700 3.02 2 549,700 655,000 83.92 5407923A 05-31-19 MAZEPA, NATALYA 05-17-19 2200 2 C0301 2 417,700 495,000 84.38 5399898A 11-29-18 IRACI, NICHOLAS S 11-08-18 706 18 2 456,200 540,000 84.48 5404478A 03-11-19 DICKSON, KIM EVA 02-11-19 2100 7 C0077 2 634,100 750,000 84.55 5394807A 08-15-18 BAIME, BARRY L 07-30-18 604 10 2 567,000 670,000 84.63 5393883A 07-23-18 CARROLL, DAVID P 07-11-18 1302 14 2 666,100 785,000 84.85 5406988A 05-09-19 YURAN, HOWARD & DANA A. 04-09-19 1902 10 2 1,083,000 1,273,000 85.07 5399250A 11-16-18 MARTIN, TRACY H 10-02-18 1406 17 2 523,600 615,000 85.14 5406990A 05-17-19 CHANG, JEFFREY 04-30-19 2102 6 C1252 2 345,700 404,000 85.57 5399631A 11-26-18 APISA, JOAN 11-20-18 1407 7 2 712,400 830,000 85.83 5409019A 06-21-19 DRATCH, EDWARD S 06-10-19 1307 1 2 788,900 917,500 85.98 5399632A 12-03-18 MALONEY-MATICH, JANE 11-15-18 904 8 2 808,800 935,000 86.50 5409020A 06-24-19 HIDDEN RIDGE @ NORTH CALDW 06-12-19 2100 7 C0010 2 606,200 699,900 86.61 5407925A 06-05-19 WORMSER, SCOTT & DANIELLE 05-03-19 300 20 2 767,500 885,000 86.72 5396487A 09-24-18 WASSERMAN, LAWRENCE J 09-07-18 906 1 2 654,500 750,000 87.27 5403714A 02-22-19 PORTANOVA, EUGENIE 02-13-19 2102 6 C1148 2 320,300 366,000 87.51 5393650A 07-06-18 RHIM, IN TAEK 06-18-18 2200 2 C1409 2 382,600 435,000 87.95 5396032A 09-12-18 ROSEN, BRETT & JULIE 08-24-18 2102 6 C0209 2 329,700 370,000 89.11 5395601A 08-28-18 OROPOLLO, TONI V. 08-03-18 1003 21 2 676,800 755,000 89.64 5393652A 07-10-18 SHEFT, ALFREDA 06-27-18 1505 3 2 688,900 760,000 90.64

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 15 NORTH CALDWELL TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406989A 05-16-19 MELAMED, EVELYN B. 05-01-19 2200 2 C0723 2 445,700 490,000 90.96 5408487A 06-11-19 CONWAY, RICHARD J JR & VEL 05-22-19 1904 2 2 728,600 800,000 91.08 5407922A 05-30-19 GALLO, VICTOR A. & LINDA V 05-10-19 1803 4 2 638,600 692,000 92.28 5407924A 06-05-19 MARCANTUONO, GLORIA ANNE 05-21-19 1406 18 2 438,700 475,000 92.36 5394527A 08-09-18 FERRARA, MATTHEW R 07-06-18 1905 2 2 778,700 840,000 92.70 5393886A 07-27-18 SILVERBLATT, HOWARD J & RE 07-11-18 301 4 2 780,300 840,000 92.89 5400511A 12-18-18 PANETTA, DAVID A 12-10-18 700 12 2 946,000 995,000 95.08 5399627A 11-20-18 PANZITTA, JOSEPH 11-07-18 300 32 2 1,234,700 1,287,000 95.94 5402533A 01-28-19 SILVER, LAWRENCE & ET AL. 12-20-18 2200 2 C1411 2 432,300 450,000 96.07 5395908A 09-07-18 RAINONE, JOSEPH JR 08-30-18 1800 13 2 659,900 680,000 97.04 5408486A 06-11-19 HAAR, JANE S & GEOFFREY M 05-24-19 2003 11 2 961,800 990,000 97.15 5406557A 05-06-19 CHATTMAN, SANDERS M. & REN 04-30-19 1200 12 2 870,200 887,500 98.05 5405115A 03-21-19 ROSENGART, HARRY Z. 02-26-19 405 25 2 790,300 799,000 98.91 5393884A 07-24-18 KUSHMA, MICHAEL B JR 07-11-18 1301 5 2 619,500 625,000 99.12 5402198A 01-16-19 ARKOFF, STEVEN I 01-04-19 1102 7 2 674,100 665,000 101.37 5401028A 12-24-18 ROSEN, KENNETH A & KAREN P 12-07-18 1300 3 2 759,300 749,000 101.38 5399629A 11-21-18 SPIELMANN, CRAIG R 10-01-18 1003 56 2 888,000 875,000 101.49 5407206A 05-22-19 MAFFEI, JAMES 05-09-19 2102 6 C1041 2 353,500 340,888 103.70 5407930A 06-10-19 BERSE, RICHARD 05-02-19 2004 4 2 1,092,600 1,040,000 105.06 5402059A 01-15-19 TARTAGLIA, MARCO 01-02-18 1003 14 2 1,055,900 999,999 105.59 5401420A 12-31-18 MCKILLON-SALAMONE, MARY EL 12-17-18 1402 16 2 926,000 870,000 106.44 5399901A 11-30-18 THIES, PETER 11-15-18 504 29 2 1,474,700 1,350,000 109.24 YEAR TO DATE 63 40,683,200 45,702,492 5,551.46 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 64 41,156,000 46,340,992 5,625.51

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401045F 12-17-18 83 MONITOR STREET JC, LLC. 12-07-18 7401 23 1 88,900 120,000 74.08 5397940F 10-12-18 TURANO, MAURIZIO & DANIELL 09-24-18 5701 24 1 208,300 280,000 74.39 YEAR TO DATE 2 297,200 400,000 148.47 5401746A 01-04-19 CRUZ, ADRIAN J & LIU, CECI 11-12-18 7800 18 2 172,000 334,000 51.50 5406993A 05-02-19 BARRERA, CONCETTA MARIE 04-12-19 7805 5 2 198,400 380,000 52.21 5403719A 02-11-19 51 PROSPECT STREET LLC 01-10-19 8801 8 2 289,200 539,000 53.65 5396171A 09-11-18 MCCUE, SALVATORE M. 08-15-18 8801 5 2 279,900 517,500 54.09 5401043A 12-17-18 CAPORALE, FRANK A 11-21-18 8102 11 2 195,400 345,000 56.64 5401432A 12-31-18 PURWIN, RONALD & FELICIA 12-10-18 5503 32 2 315,000 540,000 58.33 5396682A 09-18-18 HERBST, JOHN A & DI GENOVA 08-27-18 6402 15 2 298,500 499,000 59.82 5393662A 07-03-18 SCEPPAGUERCIO, DANA & CIFE 06-27-18 2402 28 2 263,300 430,000 61.23 5396085A 09-06-18 WENCZEL, MARK A 07-23-18 5102 3 2 256,300 415,000 61.76 5401034A 12-10-18 DE PIRO, RALPH 11-16-18 4700 33 2 452,600 730,000 62.00 5402723A 01-28-19 VERDI, ROBERT C & DEBORAH 01-10-19 2000 22 2 242,000 390,000 62.05 5405308A 03-26-19 ZAMORA, CLAUDIA 03-13-19 8303 19 2 242,800 390,000 62.26 5393690A 07-19-18 VARGAS, ALEKSANDER 07-07-18 3404 5 2 279,000 445,000 62.70 5395807A 08-27-18 VIGNALE, MICHELANGELO & CA 08-20-18 7601 9 2 287,100 450,000 63.80 5396167A 09-10-18 HADDOCK, WILLIAM A & ANN V 07-30-18 3502 21 2 332,700 520,000 63.98 5394224A 07-31-18 ROMAS, MARYANN & ROBERT G 07-16-18 200 20 2 252,900 395,000 64.03 5394217A 07-27-18 MEGLIO, RANDAL S & MERCEDE 07-19-18 5204 7 2 301,600 469,000 64.31 5393658A 07-02-18 RODRIGUEZ, BRAULIO 06-28-18 2501 7 2 277,300 430,000 64.49 5407219A 05-20-19 RIZOS, DIMITRIOS 05-08-19 7806 3 2 318,800 489,000 65.19 5396683A 09-18-18 CALUCCI, STEVEN & LOUISE P 08-29-18 8606 1 2 279,900 429,000 65.24 5393889A 07-23-18 MAIRELLA, STEVEN 07-16-18 3401 1 2 461,200 705,000 65.42 5394993A 08-15-18 DIAZ, WILLIAM 07-30-18 8902 22 2 344,000 525,000 65.52 5394716A 08-01-18 BORUCH, CHRISTINE 07-25-18 501 28 2 209,700 320,000 65.53 5400142A 11-29-18 SCHLESINGER, RICHARD 11-16-18 300 21 2 227,800 345,000 66.03 5399653A 11-26-18 MASINO, ANGELO 11-02-18 1200 2 C4202 2 129,000 195,000 66.15 5396762A 09-25-18 MILLERCHIP, JEAN M 09-09-18 8304 11 2 284,600 430,000 66.19 5402541A 01-24-19 GRAMUGLIA, JOHN 12-19-18 1200 2 C5404 2 160,100 240,000 66.71 5399650A 11-26-18 ROZANSKY, KAREN A 11-15-18 4700 21 2 371,800 557,000 66.75 5408619A 06-11-19 LEMUS, PABLO 05-30-19 2000 24 2 253,200 378,000 66.98 5393685F 07-18-18 ZUNIGA, MELISSA & CARLOS 07-09-18 7002 2 2 250,500 372,500 67.25 5408348A 05-30-19 BUTKOWSKI, GERALDINE 04-18-19 501 17 2 208,500 310,000 67.26 5401040A 12-13-18 SOKOLOWSKI, STEVEN & GIULI 11-29-18 8900 7 2 259,100 385,000 67.30 5394741F 08-14-18 JELLEY, DAVID JONATHAN & K 06-04-18 1801 4 2 340,700 505,000 67.47 5399298A 11-09-18 TOM, WING YU 10-19-18 1200 2 C5006 2 160,100 237,000 67.55 5408363A 06-12-19 OWENS, DIANE M 05-24-19 3700 1 C6509 2 196,000 290,000 67.59 5401429A 12-28-18 SANSONE, MICHAEL & COURTNE 12-07-18 300 14 2 285,000 421,500 67.62 5393897A 07-24-18 GUPTA, SANDEEP KUMAR 07-06-18 8401 29 2 341,600 505,000 67.64 5394719A 08-02-18 BIANCHI, ANTHONY R & KIMBE 07-13-18 2603 23 2 507,300 750,000 67.64 5397501A 10-04-18 PORCELLA, ROBERT A 09-28-18 7900 11 2 244,400 361,000 67.70 5404182A 02-27-19 VALBUENA, BLANCA 02-19-19 4602 1 C0208 2 80,700 119,000 67.82

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393907A 07-26-18 HANG, HUE DINH 07-11-18 7000 17 2 237,500 350,000 67.86 5393657A 07-02-18 DELORENZO, R MICHAEL 06-28-18 5300 19 2 257,400 377,500 68.19 5395804A 08-23-18 GALLAGHER, JOHN & COPPOLA, 07-26-18 3900 19 2 242,300 355,000 68.25 5409507A 06-28-19 RICCI, JOSEPH A.M. 06-19-19 3700 1 C3603 2 195,900 286,000 68.50 5396087A 09-07-18 DIPASQUALE, DOMINIK J 08-30-18 2700 1 2 287,800 420,000 68.52 5405698A 04-01-19 KIRK, JASON & SARAH 03-28-19 8200 13 2 288,000 420,000 68.57 5398958A 11-05-18 MISKOVICH, PAUL & MICHELE 10-23-18 6503 23 2 362,100 527,500 68.64 5394227A 07-31-18 LAMBROSCHINO, RICHARD A & 07-24-18 7602 12 2 242,500 353,000 68.70 5405519A 03-28-19 KLINE, RYAN & RESTAINO, JE 03-25-19 4801 2 2 292,200 425,000 68.75 5400151A 12-06-18 BAUSA, BRIAN 11-27-18 5500 6 2 346,500 500,000 69.30 5407003A 05-10-19 FERNANDEZ, KATHLEEN 04-29-19 5205 2 2 268,700 387,000 69.43 5407229A 05-24-19 SCHREIBER, MARK C & PATRIC 05-21-19 1700 10 2 334,200 480,000 69.63 5399306A 11-15-18 REID, MICHELLE R 10-28-18 2304 6 2 243,900 350,000 69.69 5409308A 06-25-19 PETINATI, ROSANGELA 06-03-19 3700 1 C6504 2 178,200 255,000 69.88 5401032A 12-07-18 WATTS, EDWARD JR & TRICIA 11-26-18 6504 16 2 287,600 409,000 70.32 5397499A 10-04-18 PICINICH, FERRUCCI 08-20-18 5902 1 2 373,100 530,000 70.40 5398189A 10-23-18 RUSSO, PAUL M & CYNTHIA 09-16-18 7603 17 2 401,600 570,000 70.46 5408353A 06-04-19 PULIATTE, JAMES 05-21-19 3301 5 2 257,500 365,000 70.55 5398204A 10-30-18 MARIN, MICHAELA & VARGA, L 10-12-18 4602 1 C0110 2 127,100 180,000 70.61 5404481A 03-07-19 HAINES, JOSEPH L 02-14-19 7302 10 C0097 2 258,200 365,000 70.74 5394992A 08-15-18 VARGA, LOUIS J 07-30-18 3400 18 2 438,000 615,000 71.22 5393892A 07-23-18 ZAIDENBERG, HALINA 07-17-18 1900 24 C0072 2 113,400 158,500 71.55 5409305A 06-24-19 BURKHARDT, BRIAN 06-17-19 1601 12 2 278,600 389,000 71.62 5403723A 02-13-19 DEVINGO, GREGORY M. & CITR 01-05-19 3901 12 2 348,900 485,000 71.94 5402542A 01-24-19 BENENATI, VINCENT A 12-26-18 8203 11 2 238,200 330,000 72.18 5393675A 07-12-18 WLADYKA, JAMES & JULIA 06-27-18 5201 22 2 362,300 500,000 72.46 5406561A 04-08-19 VIZZONE, GARY 03-25-19 8400 20 2 398,600 550,000 72.47 5407218A 05-17-19 WILLIAMS, JOSEPH 03-08-19 5800 4 2 330,500 455,000 72.64 5399303A 11-13-18 DEMATTIA, THOMAS N & JOANN 10-31-18 9700 10 C0305 2 116,300 160,000 72.69 5402721A 01-25-19 CONFORTI, JACQUELYN 01-17-19 9700 10 C0214 2 123,600 170,000 72.71 5393899A 07-24-18 TATUSKO, TERRI JO 06-19-18 1400 1 C1076 2 295,800 405,000 73.04 5402538A 01-22-19 GUTIERREZ, ANA 10-04-18 7002 1 2 216,500 295,500 73.27 5406581A 04-24-19 MATTINGLY, GEORGE C 04-12-19 1601 11 2 268,200 365,000 73.48 5407007A 05-13-19 C & F DEVELOPMENT LLC 05-02-19 9106 15 2 345,500 470,000 73.51 5405305A 03-21-19 LOOK, JEROME 02-08-19 5404 7 2 263,500 357,900 73.62 5398181A 10-18-18 CHAUHAN, RAHUL & SINGH, PA 10-15-18 1400 1 C1106 2 295,800 400,000 73.95 5393682A 07-16-18 UCCI, THOMAS 07-09-18 2701 2 2 274,000 370,000 74.05 5405522A 03-29-19 LIKA, KOZETA 03-26-19 9701 5 C1307 2 193,000 260,000 74.23 5399300A 11-09-18 SABOURIN, KATSUMI Y & BRIA 10-31-18 600 25 2 284,100 382,500 74.27 5397504A 10-05-18 GHOTRA, NAVDEEP & RAVINA 09-21-18 8300 14 2 421,600 566,000 74.49 5400143F 11-29-18 SALERNO PALOMONTE, LLC 11-19-18 2401 18 2 361,700 485,000 74.58 5408350A 05-30-19 MAMASH 18, LLC. 05-20-19 3802 19 2 421,700 565,000 74.64 5394725A 08-07-18 REPOLLET, JORGE & CARLA 07-25-18 5400 1 2 341,900 457,500 74.73 5407228A 05-24-19 HERZLICH, SANDON M JR & DA 05-16-19 5503 39 2 692,000 925,000 74.81 5409311A 06-27-19 CRISCOLA, VINCENT & TARA & 05-14-19 1200 2 C5007 2 87,600 117,000 74.87 5406589A 04-29-19 FERLUGE, CRAIG C & DINA 04-24-19 3300 4 2 507,300 677,500 74.88

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5408621A 06-13-19 BARCOS, MIGUEL & RODRIUEZ, 05-16-19 1400 1 C1087 2 273,300 365,000 74.88 5393683A 07-17-18 NEGRA, JOHN 06-19-18 4001 7 2 349,100 465,000 75.08 5393684A 07-17-18 DELIA, LEE W 06-22-18 9405 6 2 247,800 330,000 75.09 5398192A 10-24-18 REDDY, M & VENKATARAMANAPP 10-04-18 8005 12 2 402,000 535,000 75.14 5405707A 04-05-19 BELLO, FRANK & KRISTIE J 03-28-19 9600 1 C0004 2 301,300 400,000 75.33 5394999A 08-22-18 PARK, SANGHYUN 08-16-18 1000 1 C5046 2 352,100 467,000 75.40 5402201A 01-11-19 ROGHANIAN, ALAN 12-14-18 1900 7 2 373,600 495,000 75.47 5395802A 08-23-18 SEMPER, DORIS C 08-08-18 2304 2 2 258,500 342,000 75.58 5401049A 12-20-18 ERACLEOUS, KOSTADINOS 12-14-18 9701 5 C1107 2 193,000 255,000 75.69 5393887A 07-19-18 CHATLOS, COREY J. 06-27-18 1400 1 C1105 2 299,500 395,000 75.82 5405311A 03-27-19 RONAYNE, MICHAEL E & MARY 03-20-19 3600 18 2 337,500 445,000 75.84 5394220A 07-30-18 MUMCUOGLU, TASKIN & RAHSAN 07-20-18 800 1 C3043 2 353,100 465,500 75.85 5394724A 08-06-18 DILOCKER, STEPHEN M &MILLE 07-27-18 800 1 C3034 2 352,700 465,000 75.85 5393906A 07-25-18 MANDADI, GOUTHAM & SWETHA 06-29-18 800 1 C3107 2 369,900 487,500 75.88 5396175A 09-17-18 GATTUSO, JAMES J & ELAINE 08-22-18 5202 4 2 258,200 340,000 75.94 5393888A 07-20-18 BATTAGLIA, SABINO S 06-13-18 4301 34 2 527,900 695,000 75.96 5402199A 01-08-19 FUERHERM, ARTHUR E 12-28-18 3501 6 2 406,800 535,000 76.04 5393902A 07-25-18 RADICSH, MARTIN S & SARAH 03-25-18 2503 12 2 315,000 414,000 76.09 5406583A 04-25-19 ALTUNA, ARNOLD III & OFELI 04-11-19 1400 1 C1104 2 309,600 405,000 76.44 5393687A 07-19-18 GRANDONE, JOSEPH & LAUREL 06-29-18 7303 16 2 455,900 595,000 76.62 5397510A 10-11-18 SUSAR, DENIZ & PAWLOWICZ, 10-03-18 900 1 C4062 2 352,000 459,000 76.69 5401053A 12-24-18 MARSI, CARMEN 12-07-18 6505 22 2 299,600 389,999 76.82 5396168A 09-10-18 ELIZONDO, ALLAN & MARISA 08-30-18 5207 14 2 326,600 425,000 76.85 5393900A 07-24-18 BARONE, JOHN G & MARIA A 07-16-18 2800 9 2 369,600 480,000 77.00 5393896A 07-24-18 QUERIDO, GEORGE S. 06-28-18 800 1 C3085 2 366,000 475,000 77.05 5399304A 11-14-18 SIT, KA HO 10-31-18 900 1 C4068 2 350,600 455,000 77.05 5398964A 11-08-18 CICCARELLI, MARK & UHDEN, 08-31-18 4700 18 2 415,700 539,000 77.12 5399644A 11-20-18 LUGOWE, BEVERLY T 11-07-18 3602 24 2 301,600 391,000 77.14 5397942A 10-12-18 SONG, CHANHO & KIM, JAE WO 09-21-18 1000 1 C5056 2 348,100 450,000 77.36 5405704A 04-04-19 OKAMOTO, YUMIKO 04-01-19 1300 1 C2085 2 328,800 425,000 77.36 5406563A 04-09-19 HERNANDEZ, EMILY 04-03-19 9701 5 C0908 2 166,600 215,000 77.49 5393668A 07-09-18 SHAH, ASHISH & PRAJAKTA 06-29-18 900 1 C4081 2 352,700 455,000 77.52 5405706A 04-05-19 VISAKAY, AIDA 03-22-19 800 1 C3077 2 367,400 473,000 77.67 5408361A 06-12-19 MOLONEY, PATRICK & GENEVIE 05-20-19 1400 1 C1082 2 319,200 410,000 77.85 5398180A 10-18-18 CRITELLI, ROBERT J & MARIS 09-25-18 7602 21 2 155,800 200,000 77.90 5408362A 06-12-19 CULLARI, JOANNA 06-05-19 9200 2 2 249,300 320,000 77.91 5408915A 06-21-19 VARANO, JOSEPH A. 06-07-19 9701 5 C1310 2 193,000 247,500 77.98 5398960A 11-07-18 KHODAK, DENIS & YULIYA 10-29-18 1300 1 C2095 2 327,800 420,000 78.05 5394722A 08-03-18 PETERS, EDGAR 07-18-18 1600 4 2 269,300 345,000 78.06 5407000A 05-07-19 CIFUNE, JOSEPH J. 05-03-19 900 1 C4080 2 367,100 470,000 78.11 5393660A 07-03-18 BHAT, SHREEDHARA & SHUBHA 06-15-18 1300 1 C2015 2 328,800 420,000 78.29 5393688A 07-19-18 GUARIGLIA, DEBRA A 07-13-18 5404 5 2 255,200 325,000 78.52 5401753A 01-07-19 WALSH, ANNE 12-12-18 6401 14 2 264,800 337,000 78.58 5402205A 01-15-19 SANTINI, RAYMOND A 12-28-18 900 1 C4001 2 358,700 455,000 78.84 5407226A 05-24-19 BRAUN, KENNETH C & BOSONDO 04-29-19 2100 22 2 262,900 333,000 78.95 5396173A 09-14-18 DEL MAURO, NICOLA DEL & KA 08-31-18 8400 18 2 366,600 463,000 79.18

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5408351A 05-30-19 FEENEY, PEGGY ANNE 05-09-19 9701 5 C0504 2 167,900 212,000 79.20 5393691A 07-19-18 COCCO, MICHAEL S 06-25-18 4901 10 2 530,700 670,000 79.21 5401752A 01-07-19 CARTAGENA, RUBEN 01-02-19 9701 5 C0106 2 166,600 210,000 79.33 5402206A 01-16-19 BOOTWALA, ABBAS 01-09-19 800 1 C3086 2 349,100 440,000 79.34 5408914A 06-20-19 BOGZA, ILINCA R. 05-25-19 3800 18 2 313,400 395,000 79.34 5400144A 11-30-18 CURTIS, JAMES JOHN 11-24-18 600 35 2 301,600 380,000 79.37 5397101A 09-28-18 DOMINGUEZ, MARISA 09-24-18 9701 5 C0707 2 166,700 210,000 79.38 5398961A 11-07-18 WHANG, LINDA L 10-31-18 9701 5 C0309 2 190,700 239,999 79.46 5394718A 08-01-18 LA VECCHIA, DANIEL P 07-18-18 1300 1 C2025 2 330,800 415,000 79.71 5402204A 01-15-19 ADAMS, MATTHEW PETER 01-09-19 5701 5 2 543,500 681,600 79.74 5405703A 04-03-19 WALSH, DAVID M & CANDACE 03-19-19 7100 35 2 237,100 297,000 79.83 5401031A 12-07-18 D'ACHILLE, DOLORES A 11-30-18 5302 12 2 299,500 375,000 79.87 5406997A 05-06-19 PARR, JOHN J & LORI A 05-02-19 1703 30 2 391,600 489,900 79.93 5403805A 02-26-19 CARO, VANESSA 02-14-19 1400 1 C1123 2 369,900 462,500 79.98 5393910A 07-26-18 HASSAN, ISZAT S 07-12-18 1000 1 C5001 2 336,900 421,000 80.02 5396757A 09-21-18 AUGENSTEIN, GEORGE & CAROL 08-22-18 1300 1 C2069 2 328,800 410,000 80.20 5403230A 01-31-19 FERRAGAMO, JOHN 01-22-19 1300 1 C2014 2 328,800 410,000 80.20 5405701A 04-03-19 CARIO, DANIELE & ELIZABETH 03-17-19 5100 28 2 308,900 385,000 80.23 5408345A 05-28-19 BELASTOCK,DAVID M.+THORPE, 05-20-19 3502 14 2 533,800 665,000 80.27 5401428A 12-28-18 HURLEY, ROBERT A JR & JILL 12-18-18 1300 1 C2035 2 321,400 399,999 80.35 5409504A 06-28-19 AURIEMMA, NICHOLAS L 05-29-19 8400 24 2 305,400 380,000 80.37 5408364A 06-12-19 BECKER, MARK & ADRIANA 05-24-19 4000 10 2 293,700 365,000 80.47 5393666A 07-06-18 STOVBUN, ALEXEI 06-20-18 4001 23 2 555,400 690,000 80.49 5399299A 11-09-18 RIVERA, VICTOR A 10-05-18 5104 8 2 370,700 460,000 80.59 5399634A 11-16-18 FRASER, GREGORY & JANICE 11-09-18 900 1 C4008 2 354,600 440,000 80.59 5396758A 09-24-18 ABRAHAM, AJISH & SONIA 09-07-18 9201 14 2 369,200 458,000 80.61 5403725A 02-13-19 NYC REO, LLC. 01-08-19 2300 28 2 290,400 360,000 80.67 5394737A 08-14-18 BENDER, RYAN & ELIZABETH 06-25-18 1802 8 2 290,500 360,000 80.69 5406564A 04-12-19 RUDIS, KENNETH G 03-17-19 3800 14 2 237,700 294,500 80.71 5406586A 04-26-19 WEBER, MAX JAY & GRIFFIN, 04-12-19 4200 21 2 363,200 450,000 80.71 5402209A 01-17-19 WEIR, THOMAS III & WICHERT 01-11-19 1300 1 C2079 2 327,800 405,000 80.94 5394728A 08-08-18 MAAS, MARC 07-27-18 5901 2 2 297,300 367,000 81.01 5406584A 04-26-19 PALAZZOTO, MICHAEL J & CYN 04-15-19 5002 6 2 437,600 540,000 81.04 5399636A 11-19-18 CHOUKEIR, ABDOU-ALLAH 11-02-18 500 11 2 227,000 280,000 81.07 5407210A 05-15-19 ERKAVUN, GOKHAN & APIRADEE 04-29-19 800 1 C3094 2 377,200 465,000 81.12 5407223A 05-21-19 SYMCZAK, SUSAN MOORE 05-16-19 3203 12 2 332,800 410,000 81.17 5395810A 08-29-18 KOEHLER, SEAN & ELLEN 08-26-18 6600 28 2 341,000 420,000 81.19 5405312F 03-27-19 MONTCLAIR REALTY PARTNERS, 03-11-19 1000 1 C5038 2 337,800 415,000 81.40 5398182A 10-19-18 CICENIA, MARIA & ET AL. 08-24-18 7303 21 2 342,200 420,000 81.48 5396685A 09-19-18 SELARKA, URMIL & HETAL 08-27-18 2400 12.02 2 731,100 895,000 81.69 5393904A 07-25-18 GAUGHAN, THOMAS & CONSTANC 07-12-18 5601 43 2 347,500 425,000 81.76 5396754A 09-21-18 VENTURA, FRANCIS J & LORRA 09-18-18 700 26 2 368,900 450,000 81.98 5394996A 08-21-18 SCHNAPP, JEROME 07-20-18 7103 5 C0001 2 283,400 345,000 82.14 5407002A 05-09-19 VAUGHN, JAMES CRAIG & ALLA 04-26-19 5701 31 2 329,800 399,900 82.47 5396687A 09-20-18 CZERNIEWSKI, PATRICIA 08-10-18 1704 5 2 297,300 360,000 82.58 5397947A 10-17-18 SCERBO, PETER & SUSAN 10-11-18 4000 14 2 430,300 520,000 82.75

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406570A 04-18-19 VAN LEUVAN, LISA A & JAMES 04-12-19 8801 6 2 389,300 470,000 82.83 5407221A 05-21-19 MCINTOSH, MARIE A 05-07-19 9002 15 C0201 2 199,200 240,000 83.00 5405121A 03-15-19 GARG, VISHAL & KUMAR, SURE 02-20-19 800 1 C3067 2 382,800 460,000 83.22 5408341A 05-22-19 JMK DEVELOPMENT LLC, 05-16-19 5801 16 2 396,000 475,000 83.37 5401743A 01-03-19 QUIGLEY, JOSEPH & ARNETTA 12-19-18 4301 11 2 434,000 520,000 83.46 5394735A 08-13-18 BORUCH, GERARD 08-02-18 5900 11 2 371,000 444,000 83.56 5394723A 08-06-18 BAKER, JOHN & MARY ELLEN 07-17-18 5206 1 2 397,300 475,000 83.64 5397108A 10-02-18 THOMPSON, MICHAEL A. 09-11-18 2202 1 2 286,100 342,000 83.65 5393905A 07-25-18 SPIEVACK, MELISSA & ANDREW 06-12-18 2201 23 2 355,600 425,000 83.67 5403229A 01-29-19 WU, YUEDONG & LUO, MIN 01-15-19 800 1 C3036 2 354,000 422,500 83.79 5393674A 07-12-18 AVALON, JOSE DAVID & JANIE 06-28-18 400 2 2 485,200 579,000 83.80 5404266A 03-06-19 EANDOLA, MARY J 02-27-19 800 1 C3114 2 377,200 450,000 83.82 5397098A 09-28-18 VARGO, GAIL 08-27-18 1902 18 2 407,400 485,000 84.00 5401051A 12-24-18 LACY, TODD W & JENNIFER L 11-21-18 2804 7 2 563,900 670,000 84.16 5405708A 04-05-19 MILLER, JOSEPH & CHRISTIE 03-25-19 3002 15 2 454,500 540,000 84.17 5400150A 12-06-18 MATTIA, NANCY 11-28-18 4300 2 2 551,500 655,000 84.20 5393903A 07-25-18 JOSHI, AMEE 07-03-18 1300 1 C2040 2 327,800 387,500 84.59 5408343A 05-28-19 KARNIK, MILIND S.& SONAL 05-09-19 900 1 C4090 2 362,100 428,000 84.60 5403232A 02-01-19 SINGH, SULPHA BRAR 01-18-19 7801 25 2 457,400 540,000 84.70 5397941A 10-12-18 FIALLOS, JULIO C & NORMA R 10-05-18 7700 21 C0206 2 242,600 285,000 85.12 5405520A 03-28-19 BLOOMFIELD AVE 476 LLC 02-27-19 4700 1 2 364,300 428,000 85.12 5401747A 01-04-19 HARTMAN, GEORGE T 12-21-18 6502 8 2 307,800 361,000 85.26 5403718A 02-07-19 REISCH, SCOTT A 12-28-18 4900 14 2 542,700 636,000 85.33 5396759A 09-24-18 LUDWIG, CHARLENE 08-29-18 8601 2 2 294,700 345,000 85.42 5408359A 06-10-19 PUCCI, THOMAS JR & JOLIZA 05-23-19 5801 25 2 329,800 385,000 85.66 5398199A 10-29-18 CLARK, MARY CATHERINE 09-20-18 7905 14 2 231,300 270,000 85.67 5409307A 06-25-19 ESTEVES, JOHN A 06-07-19 9101 10 2 338,900 395,000 85.80 5397509A 10-09-18 FRIEDMAN, SOLOMON 09-20-18 8601 10 2 374,500 435,000 86.09 5406582A 04-24-19 DEPASCALE, PETER M 04-16-19 1400 1 C1119 2 383,700 442,000 86.81 5409506A 06-28-19 MARZO, RICHARD M 06-20-19 2300 6 2 276,200 318,000 86.86 5408618A 06-11-19 TOLENTINO, JASON & ANNETTE 05-24-19 9600 1 C0002 2 301,300 345,000 87.33 5406998A 05-06-19 SIMONE, BARRY & NATALIE 03-22-19 5701 19 2 401,800 460,000 87.35 5394994A 08-16-18 RITACCO, ANTHONY J & KIMBE 08-07-18 1902 37 2 323,400 370,000 87.41 5401422A 12-27-18 GOLD, ERIC H 12-18-18 5500 16 2 398,000 455,000 87.47 5398201A 10-30-18 GRADY, DEBORAH A 09-18-18 8304 31 2 236,600 270,000 87.63 5408360A 06-12-19 TOM, CYNTHIA R 05-31-19 3801 27 2 285,100 325,000 87.72 5397498A 10-04-18 SPOSATO, ANGELO M 09-28-18 3203 7 2 500,500 570,000 87.81 5398195A 10-25-18 BROWN, JAMES G 10-12-18 7700 21 C0208 2 246,300 280,000 87.96 5408919A 06-21-19 TOMASZEWSKI, JOHN A. 06-07-19 102 16 2 274,100 310,000 88.42 5403801A 02-21-19 DELIA, LEE W. & NANCY L. 01-25-19 9405 1 2 474,900 535,000 88.77 5396752A 09-20-18 CIRCELLI, BIAGGINO & LOUIS 09-05-18 9406 10 2 371,200 417,000 89.02 5397945A 10-17-18 DAIRE, KEVIN M 09-28-18 8600 8 2 299,400 335,000 89.37 5397939A 10-12-18 MEC INVESTMENTS, LLC. 09-23-18 700 12 2 403,600 450,000 89.69 5393661A 07-03-18 GARERI, DANNY & PAULETTE 05-30-18 1902 16 2 378,600 419,000 90.36 5399648A 11-21-18 MCCORMACK, TARA 10-26-18 5702 3 2 390,000 430,000 90.70 5397110A 10-02-18 DONOHUE, ANN M & ET AL. 08-30-18 2901 13 2 386,500 425,000 90.94

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5394739A 08-14-18 POLITO, SUSAN M. 08-06-18 7000 12 C0006 2 254,600 277,500 91.75 5403231A 01-31-19 DVDEALS LLC, 01-28-19 5900 39 2 272,600 297,000 91.78 5401433A 12-31-18 TESTA, SILVERE L & ROXANNE 12-14-18 3900 18 2 257,000 280,000 91.79 5402207A 01-16-19 FLIPING NUTLY 1 LLC, 12-27-18 300 56 2 312,800 340,000 92.00 5396686A 09-19-18 MCGRAIN, ELIZABETH 09-14-18 2903 2 2 363,200 394,500 92.07 5403236A 02-05-19 SHEPARD, RICHARD & TAGGART 01-20-19 7000 15 2 330,700 355,000 93.15 5400149A 12-05-18 MANCINO, LIVIO M & CHRISTI 11-20-18 5403 13 2 363,600 390,000 93.23 5398186A 10-22-18 DARDEN, GLENN L 10-17-18 9700 10 C0323 2 122,500 130,000 94.23 5406579A 04-24-19 DRAGOS, KATHLEEN ANN 04-11-19 3800 44 2 260,000 275,000 94.55 5406574A 04-22-19 T&A INVESTMENTS PROPERTIES 04-04-19 4301 45 2 513,800 540,000 95.15 5406995A 05-02-19 MALCZEWSKI, DAVID & ANDREA 04-25-19 5702 12 2 390,900 410,000 95.34 5399643A 11-20-18 MACDONALD, STEVEN A (TRUST 10-26-18 9302 10 2 430,300 450,000 95.62 5395806A 08-27-18 PARMAR, DUSHYANT & MASSEY, 07-28-18 5301 12 2 455,500 475,500 95.79 5396760A 09-25-18 DAVIS, ROBERT & MARTHA A 09-10-18 3002 6 2 322,300 335,000 96.21 5402722A 01-25-19 BERGER, BARBARA J & RAFFAE 01-17-19 7000 5 2 280,000 290,000 96.55 5393672A 07-12-18 STALLONE, RICKY J & ET AL. 07-03-18 8102 15 2 434,900 450,000 96.64 5401745A 01-03-19 NELSON, THERESE 12-24-18 3600 23 2 299,700 307,500 97.46 5401430A 12-29-18 FERINDE, PHILIP J 12-11-18 1800 14 2 782,600 802,500 97.52 5393908A 07-26-18 COLE, MAUREEN 07-20-18 3800 13 2 259,700 265,000 98.00 5395811A 08-31-18 PDO ASSOCIATES, LLC. 08-23-18 2903 4 2 354,600 360,000 98.50 5408342A 05-28-19 LOPEZ, ANTONIO & MONICA 04-22-19 9105 7 2 239,800 243,000 98.68 5394729A 08-10-18 SIGUENCIA, JOSE 08-03-18 8601 14 2 344,800 341,500 100.97 5398190A 10-23-18 MITCHELL, JARED & ORTIZ, J 10-10-18 9301 1 2 288,500 285,000 101.23 5406571A 04-18-19 PRESIDENT & FELLOW OF HARV 03-21-19 5601 40 2 264,800 260,000 101.85 5399308A 11-15-18 HARKINS, MARY-JO CHAGNON 11-02-18 4901 7 2 408,800 395,000 103.49 5401751A 01-04-19 OAK TREE EQUITIES, LLC. 12-18-18 601 19 2 251,800 239,000 105.36 5399640A 11-20-18 PANDYA, DILIP A 10-29-18 600 29 2 378,800 357,000 106.11 5408349A 05-30-19 FRANK, STEVEN & LINDA P. 05-18-19 1901 9 2 277,400 260,000 106.69 5403715A 02-07-19 BORBON, HELEN 01-07-19 9200 1 2 228,700 210,000 108.90 5401052A 12-24-18 SANTIAGO, SHERI & MIGUEL 12-05-18 4701 36 2 249,700 225,000 110.98 5399638A 11-19-18 SORCE, JOSEPH 10-25-18 6703 19 2 317,300 279,000 113.73 5403717F 02-07-19 CURRIER, PATRICIA ANN 10-09-18 7603 28 2 256,900 221,000 116.24 5406996F 05-06-19 VALENTINO, JAMES J & JOYCE 04-26-19 5701 34 2 303,100 250,000 121.24 5394221F 07-30-18 KOLPAK, EVE 06-13-18 501 21 2 310,300 243,000 127.70 5408622F 06-17-19 STOECKEL, ROY H JR 06-06-19 4200 18 2 744,400 503,000 147.99 YEAR TO DATE 259 83,745,500 106,160,797 20,606.08 5399633F 11-16-18 LORKIM INC, 11-06-18 7501 9 4A 1,000,000 1,885,000 53.05 5405307F 03-25-19 TOALDO, PHILIP E. 03-06-19 4401 4 4A 422,800 511,500 82.66 5400146F 12-03-18 378 FRANKLIN AVENUE ASSOC 11-14-18 4400 3 4A 425,000 505,000 84.16 5405710F 04-10-19 IMG REALTY L.L.C., 03-08-19 7604 16 X C0305 4A 446,900 530,000 84.32 5395808F 08-28-18 FRYE, GALE MADDALON 08-10-18 9104 2 4A 427,700 460,000 92.98 5406588F 04-29-19 127 E. CENTRE STREET LLC 04-22-19 9604 1 4A 429,600 460,000 93.39 5400137F 11-28-18 181 FRANKLIN AVENUE,LLC 10-09-18 7604 16 C0302 4A 201,000 195,000 103.08

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 16 NUTLEY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405306F 03-25-19 LAMAGNA, NICHOLAS J. J 02-27-19 3100 43 4A 410,100 392,500 104.48 YEAR TO DATE 8 3,763,100 4,939,000 698.12 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 269 87,805,800 111,499,797 21,452.67

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 17 ORANGE CITY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399096F 11-08-18 HARSH & NALINI, LLC. 10-18-18 4201 7 1 160,000 165,000 96.97 5393704F 07-12-18 MORADI, ISAAC 06-01-18 6401 50 1 38,300 20,500 186.83 YEAR TO DATE 2 198,300 185,500 283.80 5401071F 12-26-18 COLON, EVELYN 12-18-18 7005 6 C0102 2 65,600 170,000 38.59 5402876F 02-05-19 CASPII, LLC. 01-30-19 6003 17 2 105,300 215,000 48.98 5403843F 02-25-19 EMPIRE PROPERTIES GROUP, L 02-06-19 3304 30 2 138,700 265,000 52.34 5409594F 04-22-19 519 CHESTNUT LLC, 04-01-19 6204 11 2 160,800 285,000 56.42 5408850A 05-21-19 GILMAN, TINA 04-30-19 4803 5 2 189,800 324,000 58.58 5403734F 02-20-19 GS VALLEY, LLC. 12-10-18 6202 22 2 206,600 347,500 59.45 5401760A 01-07-19 ROCKAWAY HOLDINGS I,LLC 01-02-19 4802 3 2 219,000 360,000 60.83 5401073F 12-26-18 MOC PARROW LLC, 11-14-18 3404 9 X 2 155,100 245,000 63.31 5409569A 04-24-19 WILLIAMS, NOVELL 04-03-19 6701 13 2 239,700 364,000 65.85 5396688F 09-24-18 MEHTA, DHARAM & AURELIA 08-27-18 1702 15 C0004 2 158,200 240,000 65.92 5403731A 02-14-19 NJ LEAGUE ESSEX LLC, 02-12-19 4702 6 2 168,600 251,000 67.17 5408366A 04-10-19 GARCIA, PABLO 04-03-19 2503 9 2 173,000 255,000 67.84 5408760A 05-03-19 SHIRLEY, BARRINGTON 04-19-19 3301 46 2 118,800 171,500 69.27 5409574A 06-26-19 HARDAMON, RODERICK & KAILI 06-03-19 6602 17 2 243,700 349,500 69.73 5402062A 01-15-19 SYKES, JOHN 12-04-18 1201 1 2 222,000 315,000 70.48 5408804A 05-08-19 CENATUS, PAUL 03-11-19 1206 5 2 168,500 235,000 71.70 5409597A 05-02-19 282 PARK AVENUE, LLC. 04-26-19 1601 2 2 133,000 185,000 71.89 5408920A 05-22-19 HARRIS, BRENDA 04-06-19 6302 16 2 148,000 203,940 72.57 5409562A 06-27-19 FULLER, CORSEL & KEISHA-TA 05-30-19 4201 20 C0010 2 114,000 154,000 74.03 5404573A 03-07-19 E & J REALTY LLC, 02-25-19 1002 1 2 211,400 285,000 74.18 5400023A 11-13-18 TAVAREZ, JOSE V 09-14-18 2701 26 2 125,200 168,000 74.52 5394536F 08-01-18 AFC 384 BRADFORD ST, 07-10-18 703 37 2 263,100 350,000 75.17 5403842A 02-13-19 GOURDET, JUSNER & ANGELA 01-16-19 2401 16 2 194,200 258,000 75.27 5401069A 12-24-18 INVESTGRO PROPERTIES, LLC. 11-13-18 4701 9 2 163,800 216,000 75.83 5403242A 02-07-19 510 MONROE, LLC, 01-25-19 2702 1 2 106,100 139,000 76.33 5401770A 01-11-19 44 BELL STREET, LLC, 12-20-18 2602 7 2 199,400 260,000 76.69 5399100T 11-13-18 RUSSO, PASQUALE 10-30-18 3704 18 X 2 565,700 733,000 77.18 5409317A 06-07-19 510 MONROE LLC, 06-03-19 2504 10 2 196,000 250,000 78.40 5399098A 11-09-18 SHORT, JERELINE FARRELL 10-30-18 4802 29 2 258,300 325,000 79.48 5401068A 12-24-18 326 WA ORANGE, LLC. 12-04-18 1203 8 2 151,400 190,000 79.68 5401440A 01-03-19 DAY, ANSELEAU & CHERY, MAR 12-17-18 7004 3 2 173,100 215,000 80.51 5404572A 03-06-19 KP HOMES AND INVEST LLC 02-25-19 4703 5 2 116,900 145,000 80.62 5398608A 11-02-18 MOULTON, KEVIN 09-06-18 5801 24 2 211,800 261,500 80.99 5408624A 03-28-19 BOODO, NAZIRA 02-28-19 4401 2 C1001 2 65,000 80,000 81.25 5409119A 05-03-19 BROWN, DENNIS R. 04-24-19 5901 33 2 216,200 265,999 81.28 5408630A 04-05-19 EDWARDS, JEAN 03-29-19 1102 27 2 231,800 283,000 81.91 5403739A 02-22-19 O'KEEFE, PATRICK J. 02-14-19 3301 22 2 185,300 225,000 82.36 5396249F 09-18-18 SILVA, WALTER S & EVELYN R 08-10-18 6201 5 2 120,400 145,000 83.03 5409563A 06-27-19 CLINTON PROPERTIES UNLIMIT 05-31-19 5902 17 2 198,100 238,000 83.24 5401054A 12-13-18 GM INVESTORS CORPORATION 11-30-18 6007 24 2 176,100 210,000 83.86

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 17 ORANGE CITY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5407939A 03-19-19 LEFEBRE, BEATRIZ 03-13-19 4201 30 C0101 2 143,100 170,000 84.18 5409318A 06-26-19 NJ LEAGUE ESSEX, LLC, 06-18-19 4103 26 2 236,800 270,000 87.70 5396690A 09-26-18 657 SCOTLAND ASSOCIATES, L 09-14-18 6205 5 2 260,700 290,000 89.90 5404571A 03-06-19 RAMAGLIETTO, SILVANA 02-28-19 1201 16 2 202,500 225,000 90.00 5396113A 09-11-18 NATE REALTY LLC, 09-05-18 2002 5 2 210,100 230,000 91.35 5403741A 02-25-19 HARRIOTT, VIOLA E. 02-14-19 901 22 2 183,100 200,000 91.55 5398966A 11-05-18 MUTAH, PERPETUA & GWYNETH 10-05-18 2201 19.02 C0014 2 219,300 239,000 91.76 5400367A 12-04-18 715 BERKELEY AVENUE LLC 09-25-18 6901 17 2 417,100 450,000 92.69 5399829A 11-15-18 TOWNS, DEBORAH G 11-09-18 1206 15 2 163,000 175,000 93.14 5395438A 08-21-18 185 OAKWOOD PLACE LLC 08-09-18 3304 34 2 167,700 180,000 93.17 5401065F 12-21-18 O'BRIEN, ANN 10-10-18 6103 6 2 114,300 122,000 93.69 5409522A 04-12-19 PROPERTIES SOLUTIONS GROUP 03-22-19 301 29 2 113,100 120,000 94.25 5396088A 09-04-18 FLIPPEN, CAROL N 06-19-18 4201 20 C0008 2 114,000 119,900 95.08 5394533A 07-31-18 GARIB, ANTHONY 07-17-18 5902 11 2 204,600 215,000 95.16 5398206A 10-18-18 LYSSA, LLC. 09-27-18 6003 40 2 129,000 135,000 95.56 5409579A 06-27-19 DIXON, MARY JANE & ETHERID 03-15-19 1006 27 2 222,900 225,000 99.07 5408629A 04-05-19 MLK BLVD NWK LLC, 03-27-19 6802 1 2 233,100 235,000 99.19 5405192A 03-19-19 A&J ELITE PROPERTIES, LLC. 01-10-19 3301 55 2 110,300 110,000 100.27 5408807F 05-15-19 BLOSCHOCK, GEORGE A 01-26-19 6202 9 2 111,000 110,000 100.91 5409121A 05-15-19 ASMEROM, HENOCK & MELAKU, 04-25-19 2101 26 2 305,900 300,000 101.97 5399095A 11-08-18 MARTINEZ, DORIS 08-20-18 703 39 2 195,200 189,000 103.28 5398212T 10-26-18 DENTE, GINA 10-15-18 3801 17 X 2 270,000 260,000 103.85 5407938A 03-19-19 JONES, EILEEN P. 03-01-19 1004 2 2 117,300 110,000 106.64 5401755A 01-03-19 ADVANTAGE HOLDINGS, LLC. 08-08-18 1003 25 2 208,100 190,000 109.53 5408625A 04-01-19 NYC REO LLC, 02-27-19 703 18 2 135,400 123,000 110.08 5408803A 05-07-19 264 ODGEN ASSOCIATES, LLC. 04-15-19 4302 34 2 93,700 85,000 110.24 5409511A 04-18-19 CAMPBELL, TESSA 03-19-19 6006 8 2 110,400 99,999 110.40 5400366A 11-27-18 VITA, NELSON 11-16-18 4101 12 2 293,200 249,900 117.33 5402872A 01-25-19 FERRARA, FELIX 01-18-19 2201 3 2 198,800 165,000 120.48 5399830A 11-15-18 FULINELLO, SUZANNE 10-16-18 5802 42 2 223,800 185,000 120.97 5402730F 01-29-19 DEVINE, THOMAS 01-14-19 3403 16 2 138,800 110,000 126.18 5400022A 11-13-18 312 HAWTHORNE ST LLC, 10-31-18 1001 15 2 101,900 80,000 127.38 5408177A 03-19-19 MERWIN, RICHARD 03-08-19 2301 4 2 191,800 150,000 127.87 5403248F 02-11-19 GO AMERICA LLC, 11-06-18 4302 25 C2008 2 66,300 42,000 157.86 5397111F 10-02-18 PIERSON STREET RENOVATION, 08-15-18 3403 14 2 141,700 89,000 159.21 5404574F 03-08-19 MARSHALL, BESTLEY 01-29-19 3301 42 2 160,000 100,000 160.00 5409566F 04-23-19 VARGAS, KRISTEN 03-20-19 2701 2 2 146,200 80,000 182.75 YEAR TO DATE 77 13,911,900 16,606,738 6,901.37 5409428F 05-16-19 MDNA PROPERTY HOLDINGS, LL 05-10-19 2902 9 4A 858,000 1,450,000 59.17 5408488F 03-27-19 DORRITY, GINA F. 03-14-19 1902 17 4A 658,800 800,000 82.35 5409572F 04-25-19 BIO BROTHERS HOLDING COMPA 03-05-19 1904 2.01 X 4A 156,400 140,000 111.71 5394628F 08-01-18 GUARANTEED INVESTMENTS, LL 07-17-18 1902 18 4A 503,500 425,000 118.47 SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND

ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 17 ORANGE CITY TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE YEAR TO DATE 4 2,176,700 2,815,000 371.70 5393724F 07-25-18 471 REALTY MANAGEMENT, LLC 06-12-18 5901 29 4C 2,100,000 5,750,000 36.52 5408692F 04-11-19 OA UNO LLC, 03-21-19 1701 17 4C 1,809,700 4,700,000 38.50 5407944F 04-29-19 300 WATCHUNG REALTY, 04-12-19 1203 1 4C 581,000 1,320,000 44.02 5403897F 02-21-19 VALLEY STREET ASSOCIATES, 02-14-19 6001 4 4C 1,586,000 3,525,000 44.99 5403238F 01-31-19 DONADIO, ALEX 01-29-19 6008 23 4C 339,300 500,000 67.86 YEAR TO DATE 5 6,416,000 15,795,000 231.89 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 88 22,702,900 35,402,238 7,788.76

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 18 ROSELAND BORO SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405532A 02-22-19 MENDES, DOLLY 02-06-19 12 20 C0160 2 389,600 480,000 81.17 5397878A 09-21-18 SCARAGGI, MICHAEL & ALLISO 09-10-18 30 18 C0089 2 435,700 535,000 81.44 5397531A 07-30-18 FRIDMAN, ANGELINA 04-21-18 12 24 C1105 2 488,200 595,000 82.05 5407016A 04-05-19 PRYOR, JESSEMAN ROBE 03-23-19 12 20 C0153 2 485,700 585,000 83.03 5403250A 02-15-19 DE OLIVEIRA, MARY 01-07-19 21 88 2 484,000 565,000 85.66 5401852A 01-08-19 MUNOZ, WILLIAM 12-20-18 30 18 C0087 2 455,400 520,000 87.58 5407983A 06-10-19 CORLETT, PATRICIA 05-13-19 12 20 C0051 2 421,100 475,000 88.65 5405536A 03-15-19 RECIULSCHI, PATRICIA L. 02-25-19 12 24 C2603 2 530,400 594,000 89.29 5407018A 04-09-19 BRESLIN, MARIE A 04-04-19 12 19.81 2 304,300 340,000 89.50 5402211A 01-16-19 JEDWABNIK, LORI 01-11-19 12 24 C3620 2 516,800 575,000 89.88 5407971A 05-06-19 FARRINGTON, RAY A & CHRIST 03-28-19 39 33 2 292,200 325,000 89.91 5407021A 04-22-19 PENG, TAO & WANG, NUO 03-30-19 12 24 C3013 2 536,000 595,000 90.08 5397871A 09-04-18 COSTABILE, JAMES 08-23-18 49 93 2 428,100 473,000 90.51 5407974A 05-13-19 SCHWARTZ, BRITTANY 04-25-19 30 18 C0094 2 463,800 510,000 90.94 5397873A 09-05-18 JEGLIKOWSKI, KATHY A 08-07-18 4 1 2 396,200 430,000 92.14 5407967A 04-29-19 COLLINS, JOHN J & AMANDA 04-23-19 12 24 C5049 2 544,100 590,000 92.22 5399659A 11-20-18 CORBO, MICHAEL JR 10-26-18 12 24 C2514 2 692,000 750,000 92.27 5407023A 04-23-19 LAROSA, ROBERT & KATHRYN 03-26-19 27 1.2 2 508,400 550,000 92.44 5407966A 04-29-19 ACOCELLA, LOUIS C & SALVAT 04-10-19 12 24 C2607 2 465,200 500,000 93.04 5398620A 10-19-18 KLAWINOWSKI, ARTUR 10-02-18 23 27 2 262,600 280,000 93.79 5405534A 02-28-19 BUCHSBAUM, DANIEL L 02-06-19 12 24 C1576 2 518,900 550,000 94.35 5397874A 09-06-18 SMITH, LILLIAN 08-22-18 11 20 2 421,700 440,000 95.84 5397866A 08-20-18 SAMSON, CARL R 07-09-18 12 24 C3710 2 507,300 527,500 96.17 5399360A 11-13-18 JANN, ERIC 10-18-18 21 35 C0006 2 306,200 318,000 96.29 5400688A 12-20-18 VAN DERHOEF, ROBERT A & SH 12-06-18 14 2 2 602,700 625,000 96.43 5398610A 09-26-18 MIOLA, ANNA M 09-17-18 37 30 2 500,700 516,000 97.03 5399361A 11-15-18 ZITO, JOSEPH 10-26-18 12 24 C2712 2 696,300 710,000 98.07 5398619A 10-18-18 FESTA, SAMUEL R 10-15-18 19 7 2 481,700 490,000 98.31 5407980A 06-03-19 CIRICILLO, RICHARD A & MAR 05-15-19 13 70 C0001 2 382,300 382,000 100.08 5397523A 07-23-18 BURGDORF, JUDITH C 07-10-18 12 20 C0041 2 421,100 420,000 100.26 5399661A 11-21-18 JORDAN, ROBERT R 11-19-18 58 14 2 722,300 720,000 100.32 5397529A 07-27-18 D'ANDREA, LOUIS A & KATHLE 07-02-18 12 24 C3438 2 686,200 680,000 100.91 5407977A 05-23-19 KOTEEN, STEPHAN 05-10-19 13 6 2 656,500 649,000 101.16 5409555A 06-28-19 STEFANELLI, BARBARA M 06-14-19 34 34 2 750,000 740,000 101.35 5400685A 12-07-18 ROSELAND GREEN, LLC. 11-27-18 12 24 C8002 2 629,000 620,000 101.45 5399362A 11-15-18 MARUCCI, PATRICK+CONSTANCE 11-05-18 12 20 C0036 2 482,100 440,000 109.57 5401075A 12-26-18 HELMSTETTER,DOUGLAS J & CH 12-19-18 26 16 2 350,900 300,000 116.97 5407970A 04-29-19 HATFIELD, KATHRYN & DELEON 04-15-19 52 9 2 607,400 510,000 119.10 YEAR TO DATE 38 18,823,100 19,904,500 3,599.25 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 38 18,823,100 19,904,500 3,599.25

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 19 SOUTH ORANGE VILLAGE TW SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5396263A 09-14-18 OHLSON, JOHN & DI MARCO, N 08-31-18 1503 32 2 415,200 625,000 66.43 5406638A 05-03-19 PEDIGO, STEVEN & PITNER,BR 04-22-19 604 20 2 906,000 1,350,000 67.11 5395461A 08-22-18 HOFFS, GLEN A 08-15-18 2406 22 2 587,200 855,000 68.68 5394651A 08-16-18 HALE, DAVE C & AMY R 07-10-18 2402 49 2 552,300 804,000 68.69 5409133A 06-12-19 CUSHING, JANE E 05-29-19 2103 13 2 515,600 750,400 68.71 5399317A 11-16-18 WEISS, STEPHEN 11-02-18 802 19 2 414,500 600,000 69.08 5407998A 06-10-19 YOUNG, JOSHUA PAUL 05-28-19 2022 37 2 366,500 525,000 69.81 5409323A 06-27-19 LITWIN, MARK A. & MELISSA 06-21-19 2215 19 2 410,800 580,000 70.83 5403255A 02-11-19 BIYONG, ANDRE 02-07-19 2103 9 2 529,800 745,000 71.11 5406640A 05-06-19 CASSELLS-GRAY, JULIAN & CH 04-24-19 2002 6 2 415,000 580,000 71.55 5394144A 08-01-18 PAPPAS, HOLLY S & JAMES T 07-19-18 2207 4 2 510,000 710,000 71.83 5409138A 06-17-19 CAMPBELL, MACAULAY & LEON, 06-07-19 2204 41 2 461,200 630,000 73.21 5402216A 01-16-19 BROOKLYN HOLDINGS, LLC 01-02-19 2107 27 2 484,900 660,000 73.47 5399137A 11-08-18 LONG, BRIAN MICHAEL & RUTH 10-30-18 2211 8 2 573,000 775,000 73.94 5407230A 05-21-19 GOLDFEIN, JOHN & LORI 05-15-19 1003 5 2 706,700 955,000 74.00 5393736A 07-10-18 HASSLER, JOHN 06-29-18 505 3 2 677,200 915,000 74.01 5393820A 07-26-18 MAYNARD-PARISI, MARK J 07-17-18 1301 36 2 655,000 880,000 74.43 5406639A 05-06-19 CROSSIN, RICHARD P 03-20-19 305 5 2 455,600 610,000 74.69 5394650A 08-15-18 61 FIFTH STREET DEVELOPMEN 08-07-18 2001 19 2 491,600 656,000 74.94 5406643F 05-07-19 ADAMS, NANCY A. 04-25-19 2015 19 2 527,300 701,500 75.17 5403252A 02-06-19 BABUSHKIN, HOWARD 12-12-18 1102 8 2 771,400 1,025,000 75.26 5393732A 07-09-18 MCDERMOTT, PATRICK B & ELI 05-01-18 2022 29 2 342,600 455,000 75.30 5409129A 06-11-19 RHEE, JOO 06-05-19 1204 19 2 504,800 670,000 75.34 5409432A 06-28-19 O'DEA, ROBERT B. & DIANE 06-11-19 2017 39 2 499,700 660,000 75.71 5409320A 06-27-19 PAUL, GEOFFREY A & SILVA, 06-14-19 2204 25 2 541,900 711,000 76.22 5397785A 10-18-18 SMALLS, MATTHEW R & SAMANT 10-09-18 2209 1 2 355,000 465,000 76.34 5401853A 01-11-19 WEIR, CHARLES 01-03-19 2204 5 2 752,300 980,000 76.77 5402215A 01-15-19 COGNETTI, PAUL J 01-08-19 2109 37 2 382,000 496,400 76.95 5401774A 01-03-19 TORSSELL-BUNDZIK, D & EGNE 12-20-18 302 22 2 693,700 899,000 77.16 5409140A 06-18-19 SHORE, BERRY A & SANDRA S 06-13-19 2404 24 2 594,300 770,000 77.18 5396261A 09-13-18 SPREEMAN, GREGORY & KATHLE 08-24-18 1303 17 2 665,900 860,000 77.43 5395683A 09-04-18 GOLDNER, JUSTIN C & SHANA 08-22-18 2511 2 2 498,000 638,000 78.06 5400390A 12-17-18 SATZ, LESLIE JOEL & JOAN R 11-15-18 2604 6 2 826,100 1,057,000 78.16 5406627A 04-24-19 BAER, CHRISTOPHER & FEDDER 04-07-19 2502 11 2 637,400 815,000 78.21 5406615A 04-08-19 ZICHELLI, FRANK & MARY BET 03-19-19 2508 25 2 594,600 760,000 78.24 5399132A 11-07-18 SILVER, BRIAN M & JAMIE D 10-26-18 1206 3 2 442,400 565,000 78.30 5407996A 06-07-19 GALLAGHER, ERIN B 05-18-19 1203 4 2 414,500 526,333 78.75 5406631A 04-29-19 PREOTEASA, ANDREI G &EUGEN 04-10-19 1101 2 2 500,300 635,000 78.79 5397537A 10-12-18 LEVINE, JONATHAN W & JACQU 09-18-18 106 16 2 748,800 949,000 78.90 5399737A 11-27-18 WELCH, CRAIG E & XIOMARA C 11-19-18 1304 27 2 782,500 987,500 79.24 5405539A 04-02-19 ASNJ3, LLC. 03-21-18 2114 8 2 346,500 435,000 79.66 5407999A 06-10-19 KLAR, MICHAEL & ANNE 05-29-19 2608 4 2 502,600 630,000 79.78 5395611A 08-29-18 APPIAH-PIPIM, SHAHRI G & G 08-20-18 1503 3 2 766,100 955,000 80.22 5409150A 06-24-19 UNSWORTH, MICHAEL 05-21-19 2213 13 2 661,800 825,000 80.22 5397118A 10-05-18 TITELBAUM, JULES A & SUSAN 08-13-18 201 64 2 698,200 870,000 80.25 5402218A 01-17-19 COOMBE, SIMON & AILEEN 01-12-19 410 8 2 589,900 735,000 80.26

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 19 SOUTH ORANGE VILLAGE TW SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393751A 07-25-18 SHIPPY, GARY M 07-20-18 2112 21 2 411,000 512,000 80.27 5394649A 08-13-18 LARSON, KEVIN M 07-26-18 1103 4 2 971,000 1,209,325 80.29 5406616A 04-09-19 SINGER, GREGG R & DEBORAH 04-03-19 2407 15 2 611,800 759,000 80.61 5394646A 08-09-18 METZ, NORMAN J 07-13-18 1803 9 2 567,300 702,000 80.81 5394556A 08-07-18 DAMOR, FRITZNER & MARGARET 08-02-18 2108 9 2 503,000 621,000 81.00 5400387A 12-10-18 DEROCHE, LAURA & JUSTIN 11-29-18 804 14 2 421,200 520,000 81.00 5398509A 11-01-18 FRANKLIN, DONALD & PAULA 10-26-18 2208 12 2 495,800 610,000 81.28 5407234A 05-24-19 ASHFIELD, BENJAMIN L 05-17-19 1202 2 2 549,900 675,000 81.47 5406644A 05-07-19 SPENCER, JEFFERY & MARREN, 05-02-19 2406 8 2 469,100 575,000 81.58 5395688A 09-05-18 ROTH, GARY L & LOPES, ANNE 08-30-18 2101 20 2 567,300 695,000 81.63 5406650A 05-14-19 TAPPER, DAVID & GREGOIRE, 04-24-19 2015 16 2 518,300 632,500 81.94 5409321A 06-27-19 FREEDSON, MARGARET & BEAL, 06-20-19 1805 13 2 590,400 720,000 82.00 5393743A 07-17-18 NEL, LEE 07-03-18 2215 9 2 402,200 490,000 82.08 5402882A 02-04-19 SPECTOR, JESSE 01-24-19 413 11 2 534,000 650,000 82.15 5393741A 07-17-18 BEYTH, DAVID 07-08-18 1302 13 2 613,100 745,000 82.30 5393739A 07-16-18 MARGENT, GABRIEL & ROBIN 06-11-18 2501 46 2 668,900 810,000 82.58 5402572A 01-22-19 GALLUCCI, GLEN (TRUSTEE) 01-16-19 2209 13 2 537,400 650,000 82.68 5396806A 09-28-18 ROSS, KEVIN 09-18-18 2303 9 2 331,000 400,000 82.75 5393733A 07-09-18 SILVA, JOANICE 07-03-18 2112 20 2 372,700 450,000 82.82 5396288A 09-21-18 KERNAN, JAMES S & KERRY H 09-04-18 1302 9 2 745,900 899,000 82.97 5399878A 12-05-18 DENEEN, BRENDAN & FIELD, K 11-21-18 2210 6 2 308,700 372,000 82.98 5396266A 09-17-18 HIRSCH, ADAM A & FEDER, SH 09-11-18 105 15 2 680,200 817,500 83.20 5406630A 04-26-19 RUBENSTEIN, PHILIP A & DIA 03-19-19 2017 48 2 541,300 650,000 83.28 5395684A 09-04-18 SUN, SHIWEN & ZHANG, HE 07-26-18 2107 28 2 262,400 315,000 83.30 5406649A 05-13-19 PENA-BELLARD, YOCASTA & JA 04-30-19 1901 10 2 351,300 421,000 83.44 5401191A 12-28-18 CHARLEX II LLC, 12-17-18 2112 28 2 375,100 445,000 84.29 5399874A 12-05-18 EPSTEIN, MATTHEW T & ERICA 11-13-18 2508 5 2 650,100 770,000 84.43 5406624A 04-24-19 QINGQIN SELF-DIRECTED LLC 12-05-18 408 8 2 347,200 410,000 84.68 5409430A 06-28-19 STONE REALTY 100 CORP 06-18-19 706 17 2 335,000 395,000 84.81 5395610A 08-28-18 SCHATTEN, DAVID J 08-20-18 2608 8 2 552,600 649,000 85.15 5403257A 02-14-19 DAVIS, SCOTT B 01-17-18 2017 1 2 762,100 895,000 85.15 5396403A 09-24-18 SCHWARTZ, JAMIE P 09-14-18 1903 54 C0054 2 393,300 461,500 85.22 5402570A 01-22-19 CURZON, ANDREW & LANA L 01-09-19 1105 16 2 842,300 987,500 85.30 5407378A 05-22-19 SENIOR, CRAIG K 04-30-19 1102 7 2 900,900 1,055,000 85.39 5401079A 12-20-18 RAICHURA, ROCHAN & MANISHA 12-14-18 2209 11 2 522,200 611,500 85.40 5406610A 04-05-19 BRESSLER, WILLIAM & LISA 03-26-19 1204 18 2 534,800 626,000 85.43 5406623A 04-23-19 BROUS, DAVID BARON & MIRIA 04-11-19 205 14 2 729,400 853,350 85.47 5397218A 10-09-18 O'CONNOR, MAUREEN A 09-30-18 104 1 2 838,100 980,000 85.52 5405213A 03-25-19 ANGLADE, MICHELLE 03-08-19 2203 1 C0030 2 89,900 105,000 85.62 5393748A 07-24-18 BEAUCHAMP, DAVID 07-09-18 1010 9 2 532,400 620,000 85.87 5398227A 10-30-18 ARONSON, LAURENCE S 10-17-18 206 9 C0009 2 514,100 597,250 86.08 5409141A 06-18-19 PICANO, STEPHEN & KEEN, LI 06-14-19 902 8 2 493,300 570,000 86.54 5402214A 01-15-19 331 VOSE LLC, 01-04-19 2110 9 2 573,800 663,000 86.55 5407992A 06-03-19 CLARK, JASON & LYONS, SCOT 05-17-19 1606 7 2 753,600 870,000 86.62 5402883A 02-04-19 ROHRS, JEFFREY K 01-29-19 302 73 2 839,400 969,000 86.63 5394745A 08-17-18 ROSENBERG, MARC & PRIES, L 08-08-18 412 8 2 578,900 665,000 87.05

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 19 SOUTH ORANGE VILLAGE TW SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399675A 11-26-18 PANTONI, MARC & JENNIFER S 11-07-18 2407 12 2 779,100 893,000 87.25 5398224A 10-30-18 KIMBERLAND, MARGARET HOSFO 10-23-18 1903 6 C0006 2 363,300 416,000 87.33 5402217A 01-17-19 NYE, JOHN B.A. & KATHLEEN 01-11-19 1201 13 2 712,300 815,000 87.40 5398625A 11-05-18 HUQ, MUZAMIL & SAEED, NURE 10-09-18 106 24 2 831,600 950,000 87.54 5400388A 12-10-18 NEWCOMBE, JONATHAN & ARIEL 11-30-18 701 9 2 636,900 725,000 87.85 5393747A 07-19-18 MURRAY, KEVIN 06-11-18 1903 1 C0001 2 373,500 425,000 87.88 5397534A 10-12-18 TRIEBWASSER, M & JACOBSEN, 09-27-18 2102 12 2 426,900 485,000 88.02 5401444A 12-29-18 DEONARINE, MAHENDRA & SMIT 11-16-18 1903 71 C0071 2 383,400 435,000 88.14 5394652A 08-16-18 BEATTIE, NICHOLAS F & MARG 08-03-18 2003 14 2 388,700 440,000 88.34 5405211A 03-19-19 PRYBYS, ANTHONY 03-07-19 1103 7 2 670,100 757,000 88.52 5407232A 05-24-19 LPVI6-340 TILLOU, LLC 05-11-19 2604 4 2 1,287,300 1,450,000 88.78 5404717A 03-15-19 PRIDE DEVELOPMENT, LLC. 03-04-19 2215 22 2 449,200 505,000 88.95 5399665A 11-20-18 CONWAY, RYAN P & KATIE K 11-07-18 1103 2 2 605,000 680,000 88.97 5397117A 10-05-18 ALLEN, KEVIN & LABITA, CHR 09-21-18 1405 20 2 755,500 849,000 88.99 5395607A 08-23-18 SHARVIT, DANIEL & SARA 08-16-18 602 4 2 476,300 535,000 89.03 5407233A 05-24-19 ZIEMKE, KAREN SUE 05-21-19 2008 14 2 685,600 770,000 89.04 5406635A 05-01-19 SPENCER, JACK 04-26-19 1105 5 2 1,037,400 1,165,000 89.05 5409134A 06-12-19 COURTNEY, SCOTT & PONTIUS, 06-10-19 2507 22 2 538,000 604,000 89.07 5404399A 03-08-19 IBRAHIM, MOHAMED 01-22-19 2201 22 2 454,500 510,000 89.12 5393744A 07-18-18 LABAT, MICHAEL L & CHRISTI 07-11-18 1206 6 2 469,300 525,000 89.39 5401775A 01-04-19 377 WILDEN REALTY, LLC. 12-27-18 901 41 2 402,500 449,999 89.44 5397542A 10-16-18 LOREE, MELISSA J 09-24-18 2110 19 2 358,500 400,000 89.63 5393738A 07-13-18 DALCE, WILSON 06-21-18 702 50 2 694,900 775,000 89.66 5398225A 10-30-18 SIMARI, JAMES & JOAN 10-25-18 1404 7 2 789,500 880,000 89.72 5406613A 04-08-19 HIGH JUMP REALTY LLC, 03-26-19 2106 21 2 448,600 500,000 89.72 5393821A 07-26-18 SARNEY, DORI 07-19-18 2508 19 2 571,600 635,000 90.02 5403851A 02-28-19 CONKLIN, ANDREW P & MELANI 02-22-19 901 31 2 371,100 412,000 90.07 5406621A 04-17-19 SADASY, LENOX & MIMA 04-10-19 2209 6 2 540,500 600,000 90.08 5402886A 02-05-19 RUNCIE, DINA L 01-29-19 2406 15 2 649,300 720,000 90.18 5401077A 12-20-18 WELLEN, DAVID G & CARRIE G 11-29-18 2009.01 1 C0001 2 257,100 285,000 90.21 5409324A 06-27-19 SUKHIJA, AKANSHA & SANDHU, 06-21-19 2019 1 C0002 2 212,300 235,000 90.34 5407028A 05-17-19 MEIER, RONALD 05-10-19 1804 1 C0001 2 482,500 531,000 90.87 5396268A 09-19-18 BRICE, ROSA & FLANA, JACQU 09-04-18 805 7 2 642,800 707,000 90.92 5404714A 03-14-19 KUMAR, NEHA 03-11-19 105 22 2 707,200 775,000 91.25 5402743A 01-31-19 SUMNER, WILLIAM T & MIRIAM 12-17-18 411 8 2 776,700 850,000 91.38 5403748A 02-25-19 KASSOFF, GWENDOLYN J. & MI 02-15-19 2602 11 2 687,400 748,000 91.90 5399312A 11-14-18 FETNER, WILLIAM T JR 09-14-18 2510 34 2 543,800 589,900 92.19 5407030A 05-20-19 BURN, ELLIOT 05-15-19 2205 16 2 578,400 627,000 92.25 5403256A 02-11-19 KEYSTONE PROPERTIES,LLC 01-22-19 1201 7 2 822,300 888,750 92.52 5395460A 08-22-18 LISHCHYNSKY, LADA 07-27-18 1007 40 2 514,500 555,000 92.70 5400392A 12-17-18 SOUTHERS, DAVID & LAZALA, 11-29-18 1603 7 2 830,500 895,000 92.79 5407997A 06-07-19 GRAHAM, MARK A & MCELROY, 05-29-19 811 7 2 494,600 532,500 92.88 5403807A 02-15-19 COTLER, LINDSEY & VERNITA 01-20-19 1901 18 C0003 2 296,200 318,500 93.00 5393998A 07-30-18 HUNTER, WILLIAM & LORRIE 07-13-18 2219 7 2 457,100 491,000 93.10 5405127A 03-22-19 LEVROC REALTY LLC, 03-12-19 2021 12 2 456,100 489,500 93.18 5394810A 08-21-18 ARANEO, ANTONIO 08-14-18 2017 24 2 350,400 375,000 93.44

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 19 SOUTH ORANGE VILLAGE TW SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5393729A 07-05-18 LAFONTANT, ALAIN A & STACY 06-29-18 505 1 2 626,300 670,000 93.48 5394230A 08-02-18 POWER, BERNADATTE F & JANE 07-23-18 904 4 2 430,400 460,000 93.57 5394648A 08-13-18 BOOKER, TONI L 07-20-18 1903 55 C0055 2 388,800 415,000 93.69 5401192A 12-28-18 SEVERIN, WILLIAM BRUSK & S 12-11-18 1402 14 2 759,700 810,000 93.79 5409148A 06-24-19 BANKS, JAY L 05-31-19 2208 9 2 489,900 522,000 93.85 5405540A 04-02-19 GIBBONS, L & LONGSTREET, D 02-25-19 2215 16 2 583,300 620,000 94.08 5404713A 03-14-19 YOOSUF, HUSSAIN SEYED 03-07-19 607 1 2 800,200 850,000 94.14 5396259A 09-10-18 BRUNO, MICHAEL & ZACK, ELI 08-31-18 1602 7 2 607,000 640,000 94.84 5398219A 10-23-18 KING, MALIK & MICHELLE 10-17-18 2115 1 2 374,700 395,000 94.86 5402575A 01-25-19 MARTIN, ANDREW & KERRY 01-10-19 2205 24 2 645,500 680,000 94.93 5395682A 09-04-18 TWYMAN, MATTHEW & CARMEN 08-22-18 2607 1 2 669,700 705,000 94.99 5406612A 04-05-19 WORCESTER, RICHARD C 03-29-19 1302 10 2 734,100 770,000 95.34 5396267A 09-18-18 TRAINOR, IAN XAVIER & ROSE 08-29-18 201 29 2 629,800 657,500 95.79 5399904A 11-30-18 VOISIN, DEBORAH 11-08-18 2112 6 2 374,100 390,000 95.92 5399663A 11-19-18 SUAREZ, VICTOR 11-09-18 1703 3 2 793,300 825,000 96.16 5407991A 06-03-19 MORIN, NATHAN B & SAMANTHA 04-16-19 808 18 2 540,700 560,000 96.55 5409149A 06-24-19 NOLL, RICHARD 05-20-19 807 16 2 415,700 430,000 96.67 5393740A 07-16-18 GLINE, GERALD H & ROBIN E 06-09-18 2501 3 2 747,800 772,500 96.80 5396265A 09-17-18 CROSS, JULIEN & JENNIFER 08-29-18 903 22 2 605,500 625,000 96.88 5393749A 07-25-18 79 SUNSET AVENUE LLC, 07-18-18 810 10 2 543,000 560,000 96.96 5397115A 10-04-18 LAZARUS, ARTHUR & DORFMAN, 09-26-18 1503 33.31 2 841,100 867,500 96.96 5407988A 05-30-19 ALGHANDOOR, AMR 05-20-19 1805 6 2 778,000 799,000 97.37 5399667A 11-20-18 CAPRI, STEPHEN F & DUNN, P 11-07-18 507 30 2 1,039,200 1,065,000 97.58 5403461A 02-20-19 TOMMASO, ANNE K & HINSKE, 02-08-19 702 19 2 620,600 635,000 97.73 5393819A 07-25-18 SANDS, GLADYS 07-09-18 2507 21 2 501,600 512,500 97.87 5409144A 06-19-19 PEDDLE, DOUGLAS & RACHEL 06-17-19 2407 5 2 607,100 620,000 97.92 5393752A 07-25-18 DENIZARD, ERNSLEY & BETTY 07-18-18 2101 27 2 559,100 570,000 98.09 5405541A 04-02-19 ESSEX URF, LLC. 03-15-19 2109 4 2 379,600 387,000 98.09 5409147A 06-20-19 GRANT, JUSTIN P. & ANIKA D 06-14-19 2115 23 2 441,800 450,000 98.18 5406620A 04-16-19 ZIEFERT, JON S & JAMES M 04-05-19 307 29.01 2 1,031,300 1,050,000 98.22 5399316A 11-16-18 ABRUZZO, PAUL 10-25-18 2022 10 2 428,400 436,000 98.26 5406625A 04-24-19 57 NORTH WYOMING ASSOCIATE 04-16-19 1801 6 2 750,200 760,000 98.71 5398221A 10-29-18 CUCCINIELLO, CAROL 10-19-18 2114 12 2 365,400 370,000 98.76 5399315A 11-15-18 O B SMART REAL ESTATE, LLC 11-08-18 705 58 2 445,900 449,700 99.15 5394746A 08-20-18 MANDELBAUM, SUSAN 07-31-18 101 29 2 971,500 979,000 99.23 5395608A 08-23-18 MERTON, TODD & KATHERINE 08-16-18 2604 30 2 806,800 810,000 99.60 5407994A 06-04-19 KAY-KNOWLING, DEBORAH G 05-15-19 1003 3 2 622,600 625,000 99.62 5399135A 11-08-18 MYSORE, V & VENKATESAN, A 10-31-18 1403 7 2 647,600 650,000 99.63 5399136A 11-08-18 BANKS, MICHAEL C & CAROLYN 10-29-18 904 20 2 549,000 550,000 99.82 5397787A 10-19-18 GARDNER, JAMES L & MARCIA 10-12-18 2502 7 2 775,400 775,000 100.05 5393728A 07-02-18 SALIKHOVA, AZIZA 06-27-18 2003 19 2 331,500 328,500 100.91 5397539A 10-15-18 KAEFER, JOHN 09-20-18 2115 12 2 405,700 401,000 101.17 5407027A 05-15-19 MENARD, WILLIAM & HARUKA 05-04-19 2110 3 2 406,500 400,000 101.63 5399134A 11-08-18 POTTERS, GARY & CYNTHIA J 10-25-18 2601 53 C0053 2 214,300 210,000 102.05 5403744A 02-22-19 WALKER, RUSSELL C. & ANDRE 01-11-19 1104 1 2 647,400 631,500 102.52 5403745A 02-22-19 GOLDFARB, IRVIN D. & ANGEL 02-11-19 1602 10 2 820,500 800,000 102.56

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 19 SOUTH ORANGE VILLAGE TW SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405314A 03-27-19 WALTERS, JAMES 03-15-19 408 14 2 571,800 556,000 102.84 5406645A 05-13-19 KRUPSKI, JESSE M & LOND L 05-07-19 1503 33.56 2 789,000 765,000 103.14 5395612A 08-30-18 COTE, MONIQUE A 08-20-18 2111 15.01 2 538,700 520,000 103.60 5406633A 05-01-19 TROTTER, TARIK & MICHELLE 04-23-19 1503 33.32 2 932,600 900,000 103.62 5397535A 10-12-18 TAMBOR, RONALD & NATALIE 09-20-18 2601 5 C0005 2 366,000 350,000 104.57 5406636A 05-02-19 RYAN, RONALD & JOLENE 04-20-19 605 9 2 915,900 870,000 105.28 5396269A 09-19-18 COHEN, JONATHAN J & MARTHA 09-13-18 2501 12 2 686,100 650,000 105.55 5401855A 01-14-19 LOCKETT, MAUREEN 01-04-19 804 5 2 491,200 465,200 105.59 5396809A 09-28-18 VYAKARNAM, ANANDITA 09-24-18 201 34 2 794,800 752,500 105.62 5405543A 04-03-19 D'AMICO, WAYNE A (CO-T 03-27-19 2103 5 2 371,200 350,000 106.06 5394228A 08-02-18 ELMOUJI, ERIN & ADIL 07-26-18 807 8 2 466,800 440,000 106.09 5395685A 09-04-18 MAJMUDAR, KAUSHAL & AHALYA 08-28-18 1503 33.26 2 941,200 885,000 106.35 5402741A 01-31-19 DAVIS, JAMES G 01-10-19 2010 7 2 414,500 389,000 106.56 5394553A 08-06-18 MEYERSON, LEONARD & CLAIRE 08-01-18 2405 6 2 649,800 609,000 106.70 5396401F 09-24-18 WILEY PROPERTIES, LLC. 08-24-18 807 12 2 404,100 375,000 107.76 5402742A 01-31-19 MURY, JEANINE 01-28-19 2301 26 2 259,000 240,000 107.92 5404199A 03-04-19 TUCKER, JOHN 01-14-19 2209 2 2 498,800 460,000 108.43 5409431A 06-28-19 WEINTRAUB, STEPHEN G & SHE 05-20-19 1503 33.39 2 939,200 862,000 108.96 5405545A 04-04-19 BODNER, ROSEMARY & ARNOLD 03-29-19 2601 1 C0071 2 303,500 278,000 109.17 5407995A 06-06-19 SMITH, MARK S & ELIZABETH 05-31-19 1503 33.67 2 893,100 815,500 109.52 5402739A 01-29-19 FITZPATRICK, KEVIN & AMY 01-15-19 2102 26 2 439,500 400,000 109.88 5399139A 11-09-18 LESLIE, GREGORY W & DONNA 10-11-18 802 7 2 521,700 474,000 110.06 5396805A 09-27-18 WILLIAMS, HUMPHREY O & BAR 09-17-18 705 21 2 564,900 510,000 110.76 5403811A 02-27-19 CAMPBELL, PAUL A 02-18-19 1404 1 2 928,200 835,000 111.16 5402576A 01-25-19 FAIRBROTHER, N & BADRE, M 01-12-19 806 10 2 459,400 410,000 112.05 5409130A 06-11-19 RUSH, ALVIN & JACQUELYN E 05-15-19 605 21 2 626,700 555,000 112.92 5395606A 08-22-18 112 CONNETT PLACE LLC 07-19-18 1007 29 2 832,800 735,000 113.31 5395814A 09-11-18 AMENT, ADRIENNE WASS 08-06-18 2601 10 C0010 2 257,200 225,000 114.31 5408002A 06-10-19 MOORE, JOYCE P. 05-24-19 808 2 2 626,300 530,000 118.17 5396272A 09-21-18 ANBAR, DAN & SYBILLE 08-16-18 1303 24 2 899,900 760,000 118.41 5397543A 10-16-18 BARRETT, TIMOTHY & TERESA 10-05-18 1202 14 2 610,300 515,000 118.50 5401193A 12-28-18 OGUNDIPE, AKINWALE O & AKI 11-29-18 2405 17 2 480,300 405,000 118.59 5394674A 08-16-18 MKANDAWIRE, JIMMY B 08-07-18 702 34 2 392,000 330,000 118.79 5401080A 12-20-18 LEGG, BRIAN & DEGAGNE, REN 12-17-18 106 9 2 1,053,100 880,000 119.67 5393737A 07-12-18 BEN-ALI, RUSSELL & RICARDO 06-28-18 403 4 2 577,700 479,000 120.61 5403747A 02-25-19 KARASIG, MYRNA S. 01-23-19 2401 4 2 441,500 365,000 120.96 5394552A 08-06-18 JEFFERSON, ROSLYN J 07-19-18 706 2 2 366,800 303,000 121.06 5395687A 09-05-18 SALAZAR, MARY A & KORENSTE 08-18-18 2106 15 2 316,400 260,000 121.69 5409146A 06-20-19 LIPKIN, EUGENE 05-31-19 105 18 2 855,100 680,000 125.75 5406611A 04-05-19 GRIFFIN, GAYLE W 04-01-19 1703 15 2 693,800 550,000 126.15 5402577A 01-25-19 SELLARS, KEVIN & JEFFERSON 01-03-19 2403 20 2 721,100 570,000 126.51 5397536F 10-12-18 BROWN, RAYMOND M & WANDA 09-13-18 1103 5 2 620,100 485,000 127.86 5407026F 04-29-19 SPINDELL, MARILYN 04-11-19 2601 1 C0008 2 374,800 280,000 133.86 5393750F 07-25-18 LA CONTI, MERYL 07-17-18 2506 12 2 972,700 720,000 135.10 5407987F 05-28-19 CHESTNUT, CRANDAL A 05-10-19 2106 9 2 425,000 305,000 139.34 5408000F 06-10-19 BONILLA, WILLIAM N 06-03-19 603 17 2 534,000 383,000 139.43

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 19 SOUTH ORANGE VILLAGE TW SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5395609F 08-27-18 OUDINE, GLORIA A & JOHN M 08-10-18 201 69 2 1,119,600 765,000 146.35 5399879F 12-06-18 ZWIEBEL, NOREEN M 11-28-18 2017 12 2 573,700 370,000 155.05 5401082F 12-21-18 HUGHES, HARRIET 12-13-18 705 54 2 358,100 230,500 155.36 YEAR TO DATE 233 134,830,300 147,909,107 21,658.06 5408001F 06-10-19 CALIVER INC, 05-30-19 1006 4 4A 1,705,800 2,615,000 65.23 5398222F 10-30-18 BAAR, LLC. 10-15-18 2107 31 4A 524,600 625,000 83.94 YEAR TO DATE 2 2,230,400 3,240,000 149.17 5403254F 02-08-19 PICKWICK ASSOCIATES, LLC. 01-31-19 2017 21 4C 1,641,700 2,700,000 60.80 YEAR TO DATE 1 1,641,700 2,700,000 60.80 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 236 138,702,400 153,849,107 21,868.03

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 20 VERONA TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406656A 04-24-19 HAMILTON, MICHAEL 04-05-19 101 1 C0502 2 182,500 260,000 70.19 5402750A 01-30-19 RAYFIELD, RHODA 01-17-19 101 1 C0726 2 176,100 250,000 70.44 5403262A 02-14-19 ZIMMERMAN, FATIMA I 01-15-19 101 1 C1016 2 176,100 250,000 70.44 5406672A 05-13-19 2 CLARIDGE UNIT 12GE LLC 05-03-19 102 1 C1213 2 275,200 389,000 70.75 5408697A 06-18-19 CHASE, GARY 05-24-19 102 1 C0813 2 226,800 300,000 75.60 5409155A 06-24-19 HOLZ, RANDEE 05-27-19 712 1 C0140 2 175,000 230,000 76.09 5405719A 04-05-19 SINDHWANI, SAAHIL KUMAR 03-29-19 1712 1 C0046 2 178,100 234,000 76.11 5408013A 06-12-19 CALLE, GIOVANNY & MORALES, 05-31-19 101 1 C0317 2 318,200 415,000 76.67 5403815A 02-25-19 DEROSA, ROBERT & SUSAN 02-12-19 1003 25 2 362,400 466,000 77.77 5405546A 03-28-19 GASTON, ELIZABETH 03-07-19 101 1 C0316 2 176,100 225,000 78.27 5403819A 02-26-19 TAMMI, NANCY 02-08-19 2104 6 2 426,100 541,000 78.76 5406667A 05-06-19 BURKAT, DONNA 04-18-19 101 1 C0902 2 186,100 235,000 79.19 5406670A 05-08-19 ROCHE, KATHLEEN F 04-30-19 2103 11 2 396,600 500,000 79.32 5403814A 02-25-19 NICHOLSON, MICHAEL E. & LE 01-02-19 1006 15 2 374,300 461,000 81.19 5407381A 05-29-19 KIEVIT, MARA 05-23-19 1710 1 C0109 2 166,900 205,000 81.41 5405128A 03-22-19 PEREZ, KARRIN 03-08-19 712 1 C0114 2 175,000 212,600 82.31 5408007A 06-03-19 DIMAIOLO, MICHAEL & ANGELA 05-15-19 803 7 2 453,900 550,000 82.53 5406659A 04-24-19 CAPPELLO, LOUIS JR 04-11-19 1711 1 C0107 2 151,000 182,000 82.97 5405894A 04-22-19 WILLIAMS, BRYAN S 03-25-19 614 1 C0109 2 195,200 234,900 83.10 5406661A 05-01-19 ROSA, FABIO MENESES & FLAV 04-18-19 1805 13 2 442,600 527,000 83.98 5405898A 04-22-19 POLL, SARA & BRIAN 04-05-19 616 1 C0020 2 145,100 172,500 84.12 5403816A 02-25-19 LIFE-LONG INVESTMENTS, LLC 02-14-19 101 1 C0207 2 330,800 385,000 85.92 5404858A 03-20-19 HARDENBERG, BRIAN 03-08-19 712 1 C0122 2 172,800 201,000 85.97 5405723A 04-17-19 BEACON HILL ASSOCIATES 04-12-19 207 1 C0002 2 318,700 370,000 86.14 5408005A 05-28-19 SALTALAMACCHIA, ANTHONY J 05-21-19 804 11 2 600,300 695,000 86.37 5409326A 06-26-19 KIRBY, JAMES T 06-17-19 901 6 2 454,600 525,000 86.59 5405900A 04-23-19 CARRIONE, DANIELLE 04-04-19 1712 1 C0081 2 168,100 193,000 87.10 5406671A 05-09-19 GEANGU, CONSTANTIN & DOINA 04-18-19 105 4 2 440,800 505,000 87.29 5408369A 06-11-19 MATE, LASZLO & KEREKES, JU 05-16-19 101 1 C0221 2 186,900 214,000 87.34 5404201A 03-06-19 LUSKIN, CLARK & NINA 02-25-19 1201 20 2 363,200 414,000 87.73 5402887A 02-01-19 MOATES, KIMBERLY & WILLIAM 01-22-19 1711 1 C0002 2 172,000 195,000 88.21 5402746A 01-23-19 PINNIX, RYAN M & RENATE 01-04-19 2101 12 2 498,200 563,000 88.49 5407380A 05-29-19 SAYEGH, DOREEN 04-30-19 207 1 C0003 2 318,700 360,000 88.53 5402891A 02-06-19 NORTH NJ HOUSE BUYERS 2, L 02-04-19 302 26 2 784,400 885,000 88.63 5409157A 06-25-19 VENCALKOVA, ROMANA 06-17-19 1003 2 2 426,700 477,500 89.36 5405549A 04-02-19 LOMBARDI, PETER 03-26-19 2104 17 2 447,300 499,000 89.64 5409366A 06-28-19 MCCARTHY, JUSTIN L 06-14-19 712 1 C0029 2 181,900 202,000 90.05 5408009A 06-06-19 46 FAIRVIEW ASSOCIATES, LL 05-30-19 1604 24.01 2 707,200 785,000 90.09 5402745A 01-18-19 NEVINS, AUDREY & MCNAMARA, 01-14-19 712 1 C0149 2 196,600 217,500 90.39 5406655A 04-24-19 GREENBERG, ELIZABETH R. 04-16-19 1901 33 2 443,300 490,000 90.47 5405008F 03-21-19 BLEIBERG, FRANCES (TRUST) 03-12-19 101 1 C0300 2 122,300 135,000 90.59 5407236A 05-22-19 DITRANI, ROSEMARY 05-06-19 616 1 C0009 2 145,100 160,000 90.69 5408010A 06-10-19 ITSKOVICH, MILANA 05-30-19 2210 9 2 540,400 594,500 90.90 5403820A 02-26-19 CLANCY, THEODORE F 02-05-19 1605 21 2 376,800 413,500 91.12 5409362A 06-28-19 GACCIONE, COURTNEY 06-24-19 602 10 2 583,200 640,000 91.13 5409153A 06-24-19 MORIYAMA, TAIKI 06-10-19 2105 3 2 479,000 525,000 91.24

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 20 VERONA TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5409325A 06-26-19 PANDA GROUP LLC, 06-14-19 102 1 C1220 2 219,600 240,000 91.50 5405899A 04-23-19 VERONANJ LLC, 04-01-19 1110 100.04 2 709,600 775,000 91.56 5408006A 05-30-19 DICKISON, ROBERT A. 05-20-19 1702 29 2 440,700 475,000 92.78 5407032A 05-20-19 HEASLIP, RICHARD JR (TRUST 05-14-19 1106 9 2 436,000 469,000 92.96 5404859A 03-20-19 LANZILLI, JOSEPH & JOAN 03-15-19 712 1 C0054 2 181,900 195,500 93.04 5406668A 05-07-19 NATHAN, WILLIAM & THOMAS H 05-03-19 102 1 C0804 2 357,400 384,000 93.07 5407238A 05-24-19 CANAVAN, NANCY E & MCDONOU 05-14-19 2006 21 2 439,500 468,000 93.91 5406653A 04-16-19 KELLENBERGER, ROBERT 04-03-19 1401 2 2 459,300 485,000 94.70 5404720A 03-14-19 NORTON, WILLIAM 02-25-19 1107 9 2 475,000 501,000 94.81 5404576A 03-12-19 MAGNESIA CONSTRUCTION LLC 02-28-19 908 16 2 342,800 360,000 95.22 5405893A 04-22-19 MCKEE, DAVID & LEVKOFF, MA 04-10-19 102 1 C0902 2 242,800 255,000 95.22 5408014A 06-12-19 GROSS, PAGET 04-26-19 102 1 C0521 2 353,100 370,000 95.43 5409156A 06-24-19 RINI, CHRISTINE M 05-28-19 605 4 2 525,200 550,000 95.49 5406660A 04-30-19 SIERCHIO, DANIEL A 03-29-19 1607 32 2 470,400 490,000 96.00 5406652A 04-09-19 CHANLEY, PAUL & ROSEANN 01-31-19 1101 6.02 2 677,000 700,000 96.71 5409365A 06-28-19 MARSDEN, ELIZABETH RUS 04-11-19 1704 1 2 397,000 410,000 96.83 5403818A 02-26-19 DELL'AQUILA, CYNTHIA 02-12-19 1007 8 2 567,000 582,500 97.34 5402751A 01-31-19 WILKINS, GORDON & THUY-AN 01-09-19 1802 15 2 548,300 555,000 98.79 5408004A 05-28-19 MASSEY, JUDITH 04-02-19 1501 32 2 411,900 415,000 99.25 5405547A 03-28-19 CLAREMONT VENTURE, INC 03-08-19 807 20 2 423,300 425,000 99.60 5403261A 02-11-19 RICHMOND, WINSLOW JR 01-14-19 203 45 2 427,300 427,500 99.95 5402890A 02-06-19 GMS PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, 01-24-19 902 20 2 545,900 545,000 100.17 5406666A 05-06-19 SPADAFINO, VIRIGINIA 04-29-19 1712 1 C0092 2 168,100 165,000 101.88 5408011A 06-10-19 ERIKSSON, HANS G & THERESA 05-30-19 2209 18 2 866,100 850,000 101.89 5406673A 05-14-19 ARACIL, MARIA 05-02-19 908 22 2 549,000 536,000 102.43 5404647A 03-13-19 GAINES, BRETT ALLEN 03-06-19 303 3 2 724,600 705,000 102.78 5408012A 06-12-19 POWERS, JAMES J & PATRICIA 06-03-19 1304 10 2 533,100 515,000 103.51 5403750A 02-22-19 MARTINO, JOSEPH D 01-04-19 1304 8 2 622,900 585,000 106.48 5405720A 04-05-19 TESTA, ANGELA J 03-27-19 101 1 C0203 2 176,100 165,000 106.73 5409154A 06-24-19 DENTON, JOHN H & HOLLY W 06-10-19 501 41 2 858,800 785,000 109.40 5405215F 03-25-19 GILANI, SHAMSHAD H 02-28-19 2005 27 2 681,400 600,000 113.57 5405901F 04-23-19 BURGOS, WILFREDO & FELICIT 04-18-19 705 2 2 394,500 345,000 114.35 5405317F 03-26-19 BEACON HILL ASSOCIATES 03-21-19 207 1 C0051 2 340,900 284,000 120.04 YEAR TO DATE 79 30,385,100 33,096,500 7,148.58 5402744F 01-18-19 TTY CITY PROPERTIES, LLC. 01-14-19 1709 2 4A 528,000 560,000 94.29 5408370F 06-14-19 J.M.D. ENTERPRISES LLC 04-22-19 1603 10 4A 382,100 375,000 101.89 YEAR TO DATE 2 910,100 935,000 196.18 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 81 31,295,200 34,031,500 7,344.76

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 21 WEST CALDWELL TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5399374A 10-01-18 CORRY, AMANDA L 09-21-18 2201 67 2 276,800 440,000 62.91 5398983A 08-31-18 DUPLICA, JOHN & CERI L 06-05-18 803 32 2 405,200 569,900 71.10 5397548A 07-05-18 SHORT, DENNIS J & NANCY E 06-06-18 309 4 2 413,400 570,000 72.53 5398637A 08-17-18 ICHKHANIAN, CLAUDE & JUDY 08-10-18 311 5 2 414,500 550,000 75.36 5407244A 05-13-19 ISAACSON, BRADLEY D & JULI 04-24-19 2804 6 2 456,000 597,500 76.32 5398235A 08-06-18 SANTAGATO, SEAN & KAITLIN 07-24-18 801 5 2 333,700 436,000 76.54 5398231A 07-26-18 ADAMO, MICHAEL A & MELISSA 07-03-18 507 15 2 359,500 467,500 76.90 5402220A 01-08-19 MERRELL, RAYMOND C 01-02-19 100 34 2 385,100 499,900 77.04 5403752A 02-06-19 VALVANO, LOIS A 01-14-19 1602 17 2 386,100 500,000 77.22 5408771A 06-06-19 EARLE, RAYMOND D. & JILL E 05-30-19 903 21 2 434,300 550,000 78.96 5398399A 07-27-18 MANSHADI, ARASTOO D & BANA 06-26-18 2205 2 C0700 2 257,500 325,000 79.23 5397884A 07-13-18 DAMER, GORDON & MAUREEN 07-05-18 408 12 2 548,100 690,000 79.43 5399365A 09-13-18 CAPPUCCIO, MARK & ANASTASI 08-31-18 2605 19 2 299,600 375,500 79.79 5397387A 07-10-18 D'ONOFRIO, PALMA 06-18-18 2603 14 2 421,200 527,000 79.92 5408924A 06-12-19 BERTRAND, KELLY ANN 05-24-19 2401 21 2 298,700 373,000 80.08 5399690A 10-09-18 AVIADO, DOMINGO G & BAHIA, 09-28-18 2802 12 2 411,200 510,000 80.63 5399689A 10-09-18 GARNER, JOHN D & MAUREEN 09-27-18 2205 3 C001H 2 165,600 205,000 80.78 5397890A 07-20-18 PALLANTE, PATRICIA 07-09-18 604 1 2 520,500 640,000 81.33 5408768A 06-04-19 GRASSO, ITALO & CHRISSY 05-22-19 2606 12 2 372,500 458,000 81.33 5402221A 01-09-19 RIZZOLO, ROBERT J & CAROL 01-04-19 306 34 2 495,300 607,000 81.60 5398517A 08-21-18 SCHOONOVER, MARVIN D 08-15-18 208 68 2 661,300 810,000 81.64 5400039A 10-31-18 CHMIELOWIEC, STANLEY F 10-23-18 2204 6 2 369,000 450,000 82.00 5399688A 10-04-18 CHRISTOPHER, VINCENT E & A 10-01-18 3305 19 2 413,500 502,500 82.29 5399907A 10-29-18 MCALISTER, EDWARD J & ELAI 10-23-18 308 4 2 445,400 539,500 82.56 5405902A 04-03-19 MONDELLO, DIANE V 03-29-19 208 30 2 441,900 532,500 82.99 5408926A 06-14-19 JOANNIDIS, CHRIS & ROSEMAR 05-23-19 2901 26 2 532,200 640,000 83.16 5397885A 07-13-18 KEHAYES, STEVEN & NANCY 06-26-18 302 49 2 520,600 625,000 83.30 5399687A 10-04-18 MUZLET, LAUREN & ADAMCSIK, 09-25-18 706 21 2 339,100 405,000 83.73 5408770A 06-06-19 DORIA, JOSEPH A. & ANDREA 05-31-19 201 41 2 511,600 610,000 83.87 5398987A 09-07-18 CONFORTI, DAMIAN P & NICOL 09-04-18 2205 18 2 422,700 503,000 84.04 5397891A 07-23-18 DIMONTE, BERNARD P 07-17-18 804 15 2 449,700 535,000 84.06 5401784A 12-26-18 BRAEN, RYAN JOSEPH 10-15-18 803 7 2 342,000 405,000 84.44 5398398A 07-25-18 VERTES, PETER & JILL 06-18-18 2703 15 2 464,100 549,000 84.54 5399369A 09-20-18 METZ, PATRICK & LISA 08-09-18 1805 14 2 404,700 475,000 85.20 5409517A 06-24-19 CARRINGTON, DANIELLE 06-10-19 706 27 2 332,700 389,000 85.53 5398979A 08-21-18 BOCCHINI, VINCENT JAMES 08-10-18 101 12 2 440,900 515,000 85.61 5398980A 08-21-18 ALONZO, JOSEPH 07-20-18 2304 27 2 450,000 525,000 85.71 5406675A 04-08-19 CUTALO, JOSEPH & MARIANNAE 04-05-19 2607 36.01 2 736,500 855,000 86.14 5408017A 05-17-19 LEVY, WILLIAM A 05-04-19 407 6 2 492,200 570,000 86.35 5399693A 10-12-18 ZARKOWSKI, CAROL A 09-20-18 508 26 2 361,200 417,500 86.51 5405321A 03-25-19 TRIGAZIS, HELEN 03-05-19 310 11 2 459,800 531,000 86.59 5397888A 07-19-18 FEENEY, RITA 07-10-18 705 4 2 514,000 592,500 86.75 5407240A 05-02-19 BUSTARD, MICHAEL & CAITLIN 04-25-19 1101 33 2 337,500 389,000 86.76 5400406A 12-06-18 SANDLER, JEANNE P 11-26-18 508 13 2 327,400 376,000 87.07 5405550A 03-29-19 BUONO, CARMINE G 03-26-19 202 18 2 362,800 416,000 87.21 5397550A 07-10-18 LEVITT, KENNETH 05-31-18 3307 9 2 469,700 536,000 87.63

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 21 WEST CALDWELL TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5398234A 07-27-18 FIORE, JOSEPH R & SUSAN J 07-12-18 304 14 2 447,800 510,000 87.80 5399685A 10-03-18 KONG, NORMAN & LI, JINGYI 09-11-18 2201 25 2 500,000 569,500 87.80 5399366A 09-14-18 CAPADONA, BRADLEY & CARA 08-08-18 101 4.02 2 714,300 812,500 87.91 5398397A 07-25-18 KANG, DAE HAP & HEE SON 05-17-18 3001 5 2 456,200 518,000 88.07 5399909A 11-08-18 GEORGE, TITO A & THOMAS, A 10-18-18 900 33 2 531,100 600,000 88.52 5402073A 01-10-19 MATESIC, IVICA JOHN 01-04-19 3301 18 2 460,500 520,000 88.56 5399910A 11-13-18 PACIOREK, PETER MICHAEL 10-26-18 701 25 2 514,400 580,000 88.69 5409519A 06-27-19 IZRAELI, THERESE & DANIEL 06-09-19 1800 6 2 355,500 400,000 88.88 5399367A 09-17-18 CHEN, WEN PU & LIU, MEI CH 08-24-18 3301 7 2 507,500 570,000 89.04 5408922A 06-11-19 HUEGEL, CHRISTOPHER & MERE 03-11-19 303 13 2 477,000 535,500 89.08 5399373A 09-27-18 BLANK, LEROY & ELAINE R 08-02-18 1808 25 2 377,900 421,000 89.76 5400693A 12-07-18 GERA, SUNIL & DIMPLE 11-30-18 1101 45 2 328,100 365,000 89.89 5397889A 07-20-18 DYDO, JOHN 07-16-18 502 30 2 374,800 416,000 90.10 5403754A 02-11-19 SCOTT, GREGORY & DONNA 01-04-19 200 17 2 563,500 625,000 90.16 5402072A 01-10-19 DE FILIPPO, GERARD 01-04-19 404 16 2 415,300 459,900 90.30 5399908A 11-07-18 ANGERER, RICHARD W & BARBA 10-29-18 705 11 2 478,900 530,000 90.36 5409518A 06-24-19 TORLUCCIO, OTTAVIO 06-13-19 508 53 2 454,200 500,000 90.84 5408773A 06-07-19 CARAVELA, THOMAS R & KRIST 05-30-19 701 26 2 871,900 954,000 91.39 5400402A 11-20-18 PLATH, CHRISTOPHER & NICOL 11-09-18 902 18 2 594,300 650,000 91.43 5398981A 08-23-18 LIANG, I-HSUN & LIN, JU-SH 08-02-18 2701 12 2 540,800 590,000 91.66 5399368A 09-20-18 POMERANCE, DONALD H & HARR 09-04-18 2704 20 2 449,400 490,000 91.71 5398988A 09-10-18 WARD, STAN 09-03-18 601 39 2 356,500 388,000 91.88 5398515A 08-15-18 ZAK, PABLO & VIVIAN 08-02-18 2201 2 2 275,200 297,500 92.50 5397547A 07-02-18 VENEZIA, LOUIS 06-21-18 2700 18 2 616,100 660,000 93.35 5409516A 06-24-19 GROSSMAN, JED & PATRICIA 06-07-19 708 6 2 803,100 860,000 93.38 5402070A 01-07-19 DA SILVA, NAIR 12-06-18 2902 11 2 651,300 690,000 94.39 5398985A 09-06-18 HAHN, CHARLES R. 08-31-18 310 5 2 506,900 524,500 96.64 5399692A 10-10-18 RAMOS, RIGOBERTO & ZASKIA 10-05-18 2402 2 2 280,500 290,000 96.72 5399372A 09-25-18 WANG, ZHEN & LU, WENYUN 09-11-18 2000 1.16 2 720,200 740,000 97.32 5398400A 08-06-18 CAMPANELLA, ANNE 07-25-18 2901 8 2 457,500 460,000 99.46 5404491A 02-26-19 VAJRAMANI, JAYATHIRTHA 01-27-19 3000 24.04 2 779,900 775,000 100.63 5400403A 11-26-18 COMPAGNONE, FRANCO & ANITA 11-14-18 2205 3 C001Q 2 188,800 187,000 100.96 5408925A 06-13-19 HOLAK, IRENE S 05-24-19 1809 5 2 359,800 355,000 101.35 5400401A 11-15-18 PITTA, BERNICE 10-29-18 2600 1 2 474,400 468,000 101.37 5404490A 02-08-19 STEFANELLI, RALPH & LISA 01-16-19 2000 1.13 2 715,600 705,000 101.50 5398986A 09-07-18 O'CONNOR, JEANNE N 08-24-18 308 12 2 499,700 490,000 101.98 5405129A 03-20-19 BOPPERT, VICTORIA A 02-13-19 302 59 2 549,200 535,000 102.65 5401445A 12-19-18 BISCHOFF, MARGUERITE V 12-04-18 306 36 2 490,700 475,000 103.31 5408928A 06-18-19 CREO, JOHN & RITA 06-13-19 2203 27 2 492,800 475,000 103.75 5404492A 03-05-19 PALERMO, BARBARA ANN & JOS 02-06-19 2604 8 2 312,300 300,000 104.10 5408923A 06-11-19 DEL PRETE, FRANK G III 05-30-19 2500 46.05 2 657,700 615,000 106.94 5407243A 05-08-19 CLEMENTS, NORMA A 04-26-19 2401 30 2 355,600 332,500 106.95 5397549A 07-05-18 BINETTI, RICHARD G 06-28-18 3001 21 2 482,200 450,000 107.16 5400405A 11-28-18 VAZQUEZ, PETER J. 11-13-18 2000 1.09 2 841,700 775,000 108.61 5400037A 10-18-18 MCMAHON, THOMAS 10-16-18 1808 9 2 247,900 223,985 110.68 5408769A 06-06-19 LEPELSTAT, MARTIN L. (TRUS 05-23-19 208 38 2 561,800 505,000 111.25

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 21 WEST CALDWELL TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5404489A 01-16-19 LOUGHNEY, VIRGINIA M 01-14-19 502 25 2 558,100 495,000 112.75 YEAR TO DATE 93 42,906,200 48,272,685 8,278.21 5399370F 09-21-18 TEAM G, LLC. 08-21-18 1602 2 C112A 4A 141,100 157,500 89.59 5400594F 12-11-18 KDA ENTERPRISES, LLC. 11-28-18 2100 2 4A 5,161,500 5,225,000 98.78 5399906F 10-19-18 175 FAIRFIELD INVESTMENTS, 10-15-18 1200 3 C751D 4A 182,600 153,000 119.35 YEAR TO DATE 3 5,485,200 5,535,500 307.72 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 96 48,391,400 53,808,185 8,585.93

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5395225A 07-20-18 LEBAN-GOODBAR, AMY 07-17-18 41 157 2 219,400 365,000 60.11 5408667A 06-14-19 BERLET, ANTHONY C & KERRY 06-05-19 103 4 2 1,134,500 1,850,000 61.32 5405753A 03-29-19 CRESPO, SABRINA M 03-20-19 179.07 1 2 212,500 335,700 63.30 5395189A 07-10-18 GORDON, PAUL H. 07-03-18 139 23 2 175,900 277,000 63.50 5398521A 09-21-18 BARDOUILLE, YOLANDA A & TA 09-16-18 114.01 41 2 247,600 387,500 63.90 5401798A 11-02-18 ORBAN, ZOLTAN & REVESZ, SZ 10-30-18 75 49 2 222,300 345,000 64.43 5403900A 08-15-18 FELLNER, GARY & ADA 08-08-18 110 2 C0720 2 160,000 245,000 65.31 5402278A 11-30-18 BROWN, DEWITE 11-20-18 3.01 61 2 236,800 360,000 65.78 5398248A 08-17-18 MARSHALL, EDWARD TERRY & D 07-18-18 122 54 2 145,200 220,000 66.00 5408673A 06-14-19 DETORE, JOSEPH A 05-23-19 161.02 53 2 214,800 325,000 66.09 5402236F 11-16-18 NOVRIT, BEVERLY A.& ROGER 09-21-18 172.13 4 2 195,300 295,000 66.20 5401486A 10-26-18 MAYO, JERMAL & MICHELLE 10-24-18 23 44 2 258,700 390,000 66.33 5402274A 11-30-18 SCIOSCIA, ANDREW J 11-15-18 59.04 1.15 2 229,200 345,000 66.43 5402082A 11-26-18 OTOVIC, RIFAT & HAMIDIJA 11-19-18 36 9 2 250,000 375,000 66.67 5409339A 06-25-19 WU, CHUN-TE 06-10-19 140.02 61.01 C0036 2 140,000 210,000 66.67 5395242A 07-26-18 TIMMONS, DANIEL & SANDRA 03-10-18 153.11 64 2 242,800 363,600 66.78 5399385A 10-12-18 FITZPATRICK, COLLEEN 09-17-18 140.03 6 2 204,400 306,000 66.80 5402083A 11-26-18 MARTINELLI, DONALD K & ELA 11-08-18 175 305 2 251,100 375,000 66.96 5395196T 07-16-18 RAPOSA, GARY & ET AL. 07-02-18 179.07 51 2 204,500 305,000 67.05 5401810A 11-08-18 CHARLES, REGINALD & APRIL 09-28-18 125.02 148 2 184,400 275,000 67.05 5399377A 10-09-18 BLAKE, ROBERT J & ELLEN LA 09-27-18 159.03 90 2 286,900 425,000 67.51 5406691A 04-16-19 ESTEPAN, DOMARYS 04-10-19 172.07 47 2 257,300 380,000 67.71 5403307A 12-19-18 NADOLSKI, WILLIAM C 12-03-18 179.08 2 2 219,000 323,000 67.80 5395234A 07-24-18 AGUDELO, MAGNOLIA 06-25-18 25 6 2 237,800 350,000 67.94 5404771A 01-30-19 SANGWAN, PRADEEP & MEHTA, 01-17-19 105 1 C0041 2 208,000 306,000 67.97 5395262A 08-03-18 BAVA, BRAD 07-20-18 172.02 12 2 251,600 370,000 68.00 5404755A 01-23-19 ROTHMAN, ALAN 01-14-19 176.02 48.10 C0147 2 343,500 500,000 68.70 5398304A 09-06-18 ARONSON, JOHN R 07-18-18 55.06 13 2 362,200 525,000 68.99 5403907A 08-16-18 PELLAND, EVA 08-02-18 164.07 16 2 275,300 399,000 69.00 5403901A 08-15-18 MALDONADO, OSCAR A JR & AL 08-09-18 176.06 17 2 307,100 445,000 69.01 5408048A 06-03-19 FRASIER, PATRICK 05-06-19 24 44 2 200,100 289,900 69.02 5404737A 01-11-19 ORTIZ, RAFAEL 12-17-18 155.05 12 2 321,200 465,000 69.08 5404781A 02-04-19 GRAMCKO, HELEN 01-30-19 153.11 70 2 252,400 365,000 69.15 5404952A 02-15-19 DOBRIAN, ALEXANDER & ELZA 01-31-19 151.03 28 2 253,000 365,000 69.32 5397558A 08-14-18 TAGUE, HUGH JR & KATHRYN M 07-26-18 173.07 7 2 349,200 500,000 69.84 5398536A 09-27-18 KAHN, ARLENE 08-31-18 179.07 49 2 223,700 320,000 69.91 5403288A 12-07-18 DE MARTINIS, CAMILLO & MAR 11-20-18 153.11 49 2 245,000 350,000 70.00 5405743A 03-27-19 MITCHEL, CHARLES 03-12-19 110 2 C0116 2 211,000 300,000 70.33 5395248A 07-27-18 LESSER, RUSSELL & JAMIE 07-16-18 43.07 22 2 435,500 617,243 70.56 5404880A 02-07-19 ROSSINOW, SUSAN 01-30-19 107 1.04 C0011 2 459,900 651,500 70.59 5405731A 03-19-19 CURRAN, DENNIS 03-15-19 94 12.03 2 777,600 1,100,000 70.69 5398260A 08-22-18 BRUNO, MATTHEW R 08-15-18 26 29 2 222,700 315,000 70.70 5398534A 09-27-18 SIDIROPOULOS, Z & AMOURGIO 09-17-18 155.14 9 2 286,900 405,000 70.84 5398295A 09-05-18 DIBBLE, JOHN & COLLEEN 08-28-18 161.02 40 2 223,500 315,000 70.95 5403956A 01-07-19 ROZANSKY, HERBERT 12-29-18 175.01 186.01 2 228,000 320,000 71.25 5403318A 12-21-18 MANESIS, ANDREAS T & ET AL 09-18-18 176.06 16 2 270,900 380,000 71.29

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 2 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5405729A 03-19-19 MERZIUS, SIMONE 02-27-19 125.02 354 2 235,800 330,000 71.45 5404877A 02-06-19 MCGUIRE, ANDREW P & PATRIC 01-18-19 179.02 34 2 279,500 389,900 71.69 5404739A 01-14-19 SHULMAN, BRADLEY & SHOSHAN 12-31-18 175.17 6 2 315,500 440,000 71.70 5401815A 11-08-18 EBNER, BONNIE & IAN 10-09-18 152.13 12 2 304,700 424,500 71.78 5402089F 11-27-18 PANAX PROPERTIES, LLC. 11-06-18 45.06 11 2 383,500 530,000 72.36 5395251A 07-27-18 ZARRO, MICHAEL & DEBORAH 07-13-18 54.02 47.07 2 275,000 380,000 72.37 5404731A 01-09-19 DE VARELA, GLADYS PAZMINO 12-31-18 113.02 82 2 210,000 290,000 72.41 5395632A 08-09-18 ALONSO, DOMINGO 07-26-18 129 68 2 180,000 248,000 72.58 5408792A 06-19-19 CRESTMONT GARDENS DEVELOPE 06-07-19 154 11.01 C0084 2 120,000 165,000 72.73 5395258A 08-02-18 ARTEAGA, JOSEPH J 07-03-18 168.05 6 2 323,700 445,000 72.74 5395272A 08-07-18 CROWLEY, ANDREW & ASHLEY 07-16-18 175.10 8 2 290,600 399,000 72.83 5403306A 12-19-18 RAFF, LEONARD J & RHODA M 10-18-18 168.03 17 2 288,500 395,000 73.04 5402893A 12-03-18 BARIAGABER, ASSEFAW 11-14-18 58 76 2 328,100 449,000 73.07 5405774A 04-05-19 LEWIS, WILLIE & ET AL. 03-29-19 114 62 2 237,500 325,000 73.08 5404757A 01-24-19 RUSSO, MARK & ET AL. 01-14-19 73.01 59 2 294,000 400,000 73.50 5406746A 05-10-19 PINTO, NICOLA 04-25-19 122 62 2 199,200 270,000 73.78 5398535A 09-27-18 FISCHGRUND, SHEILA A & MIL 08-30-18 152.16 12 2 324,700 440,000 73.80 5408064A 06-07-19 MARINO, LORRAINE & GRIPPAL 05-08-19 176.19 4 2 258,800 350,000 73.94 5402257A 11-29-18 LE, JONATHAN D & MARIJA 11-15-18 173.05 17 2 225,600 305,000 73.97 5398346A 09-17-18 RUEBENS, MANFREDO D & CLAU 09-10-18 94 12.02 2 1,102,800 1,490,000 74.01 5404758A 01-24-19 CRESTMONT GARDENS DEVELOPE 01-04-19 154 11.01 C0036 2 120,000 162,000 74.07 5405903A 04-17-19 CRESTMONT GARDEN DEVELOPER 04-12-19 154 11.01 C0003 2 120,000 162,000 74.07 5406743A 05-09-19 CRESTMONT GARDENS DEVELOPE 05-03-19 154 11.01 C0037 2 120,000 162,000 74.07 5406747A 05-13-19 CRESTMONT GARDENS DEVELOPE 05-01-19 154 11.01 C0032 2 120,000 161,710 74.21 5402232A 11-15-18 ZEWOLDI, YACOB 10-18-18 166 48 2 326,600 440,000 74.23 5398280A 08-29-18 DAMMACCO, JOHN C 08-14-18 53 16 2 370,000 497,500 74.37 5402753A 12-11-18 MACDONALD, PHILIP E 11-26-18 105 1 C0042 2 237,300 319,000 74.39 5401788A 10-30-18 BURGOYNE, STEVEN & AUBLE, 10-18-18 154.17 128 2 298,400 401,000 74.41 5398312T 09-10-18 HOLLAND, MARY ROSE (TRUSTE 08-16-18 86.07 26 2 335,000 450,000 74.44 5398284A 08-30-18 SUSS, RONALD S & LISA R 08-14-18 52.07 11 2 362,200 486,000 74.53 5403269A 07-06-18 MOTA, PEDRO RAFAEL & CARLA 06-27-18 155.22 42.01 C0267 2 425,000 570,000 74.56 5407047A 05-16-19 LAHENS, DOMINIQUE 05-03-19 141 5 2 213,500 286,000 74.65 5404736A 01-10-19 LEE, ROGER F 12-14-18 172.17 9 2 333,700 446,750 74.70 5395237A 07-25-18 LATORE, JAMES & CHRISTINE 07-18-18 173.01 14.01 2 284,100 380,000 74.76 5398523A 09-24-18 CASTILLO, DOUGLAS & REBECC 08-29-18 85.04 20 2 314,200 419,650 74.87 5398264A 08-23-18 BROWNING, SARAH & LELUGA, 07-21-18 113 286 2 209,700 280,000 74.89 5408791A 06-19-19 MALHOTRA, PAWAN & PINKY 05-24-19 166.13 1 C0844 2 340,000 454,000 74.89 5402276A 11-30-18 ANDERSON, PHILIP I 11-21-18 146 72 2 258,500 345,000 74.93 5399382F 10-12-18 MASTER FORM ENGINEERING, L 09-26-18 44.02 53 2 487,400 650,000 74.98 5405748A 03-29-19 FUERTE, VANESSA 03-22-19 71.01 56 C0049 2 156,000 208,000 75.00 5403919A 10-31-18 SOMERS, MICHAEL & NICOLE 10-14-18 59.01 16 2 360,600 480,000 75.13 5402260A 11-29-18 CIFELLI, GINO & MARIA 10-24-18 155.01 20 2 330,600 440,000 75.14 5398330A 09-12-18 SMITH, DR FRANZ 08-30-18 72 59 2 218,000 290,000 75.17 5402248A 11-20-18 HASMI, KAMAL & AFTAB, SANI 10-19-18 175.19 17 2 281,200 374,000 75.19 5409347A 06-27-19 GILBREATH, T & WALPOLE, K 06-17-19 159.03 87 2 330,900 439,000 75.38 5409342A 06-26-19 MITTLEMAN, STANLEY & SHEBA 06-06-19 175.23 36 2 287,900 381,560 75.45

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 3 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401469A 10-23-18 LANFRANK, ANITA M 10-09-18 65 39 2 242,000 320,000 75.63 5395270A 08-07-18 JOSEPH, ANDRE & THOMAS, ME 07-23-18 25 24 2 255,800 338,000 75.68 5408662A 06-12-19 HANCHETT, GREGG D & DONNA 06-03-19 140.04 24 2 250,000 330,000 75.76 5399701A 10-11-18 ANDERSON, STEPHEN & SHANIS 10-02-18 151.06 10 2 299,800 395,500 75.80 5409346A 06-27-19 LOPEZ, DAVID D & FERRER, I 03-29-19 158.14 279 2 404,200 532,300 75.93 5395254A 07-31-18 KASCH, KATHERINE D M & PAT 07-16-18 161.01 3 2 421,900 555,000 76.02 5395627A 08-09-18 JULIEN, BRANDON 07-17-18 116 30.01 2 251,500 330,000 76.21 5405131A 01-08-19 WALKER, KIMBERLY A 11-07-18 172.16 24 2 278,500 365,000 76.30 5398519A 09-20-18 CARO, VICTORIA 09-14-18 72 7 2 229,000 300,000 76.33 5397559A 08-14-18 ROBINSON, BRIAN E & PERRY, 07-17-18 105 4 C0088 2 228,700 299,000 76.49 5405173A 03-20-19 FRIAS, JUAN PABLO 03-14-19 40 6.02 2 272,100 355,500 76.54 5395261A 08-03-18 FERGUSON, KEITH 07-25-18 140.03 21 2 229,000 299,000 76.59 5409336F 06-24-19 LEINWAND, JASON (CO-TRUSTE 06-06-19 176.02 48.10 C0141 2 382,400 499,000 76.63 5395012A 07-30-18 BUERROSSE, JOHN P & MARY L 07-20-18 153.02 15 2 303,000 395,000 76.71 5402272A 11-29-18 JANIN, BERTANDO & RHILEY 11-10-18 155.22 42.01 C0263 2 318,700 415,000 76.80 5399387A 10-12-18 HENDEE, VIRGINIA & HUETZ, 09-21-18 45.11 42 2 457,100 595,000 76.82 5395633A 08-09-18 DAVIDSON, KEITH 07-25-18 50.01 44 2 351,300 457,000 76.87 5405906A 04-17-19 LAUREANO, MELINDA A. 04-03-19 71.01 56 C0076 2 173,100 225,000 76.93 5401813A 11-08-18 AYAD, MAGED & FUENTES, GLO 10-12-18 161.06 38 2 466,100 605,500 76.98 5398297A 09-05-18 POSEY, JAMES MICHAEL & DEB 08-22-18 58.01 13 2 340,700 441,000 77.26 5402906A 12-05-18 LITTLE, LUCI JANE & PETER 11-16-18 179.16 11 2 406,500 525,000 77.43 5395188A 07-10-18 WALTER, CHARLES F 06-25-18 41.01 150 2 321,400 415,000 77.45 5403911A 09-20-18 GOLDBERG, HOWARD & PHYLLIS 09-06-18 176.15 26 2 325,700 420,000 77.55 5401804A 11-07-18 SCHUB, STUART L & RUSSELL 10-10-18 154.10 7 2 249,000 321,000 77.57 5404992A 03-06-19 ZERAI, GHEBREMEDHIN 02-04-19 137 16 2 256,500 330,000 77.73 5395230A 07-23-18 CANNICI, MATTHEW 06-06-18 176.07 4 2 272,500 350,000 77.86 5399111A 10-03-18 CIBOUX PROPERTIES, LLC. 09-20-18 154 11.01 C0012 2 120,000 154,000 77.92 5395200A 07-16-18 BERMAN, SIDNEY 06-18-18 105 8 C0295 2 297,600 380,000 78.32 5402268A 11-29-18 BELLINO, MICHAEL J 11-13-18 175.02 4 2 282,200 360,000 78.39 5403934A 12-28-18 REIMMER, ROSEMOND 12-05-18 147 26.08 2 231,600 295,000 78.51 5408071A 06-07-19 MIAN, FARHAD & AMMARA 05-10-19 155.22 42.01 C0266 2 423,600 539,000 78.59 5403902A 08-15-18 CLARKE, KECIA M 08-07-18 179.18 7 2 580,000 737,500 78.64 5406720A 04-29-19 DECAPUA, JOSEPH M & SARA J 03-23-19 55.06 14 2 310,100 394,000 78.71 5408023A 05-20-19 GARB, SANDRA & ET AL. 05-15-19 166.15 5 C0039 2 260,000 330,000 78.79 5394586A 07-06-18 KHARONOV, ARTHUR & MARETA 06-25-18 32 21 2 296,700 375,000 79.12 5398291A 09-04-18 EL ATAT, FADI 08-28-18 176.02 48.10 C0044 2 290,000 365,000 79.45 5394579A 07-05-18 GOLDSTEIN, JONATHAN & LILI 06-28-18 152.22 1413 C0021 2 377,500 475,000 79.47 5401812A 11-08-18 MARINO, ERNEST & PATRICIA 11-02-18 165.02 14 2 337,800 425,000 79.48 5401806A 11-07-18 ROSENTHAL, JAMES & VICKI 10-12-18 166.15 11.04 C0216 2 875,000 1,100,000 79.55 5394578T 07-05-18 RINGEL, GAIL S & ET AL. 05-25-18 86.01 14 2 354,100 445,000 79.57 5398261A 08-22-18 MONTANANO, MATTHEW V. 07-19-18 55.07 1 2 378,000 475,000 79.58 5404753A 01-22-19 VARUGHESE, ANISHA & ET AL. 12-19-18 71.01 56 C0029 2 195,000 245,000 79.59 5402254A 11-21-18 BAT SHEVA MITZVAH CAMPAIGN 11-13-18 110 2 C0223 2 206,200 259,000 79.61 5403943A 01-03-19 MIHUTOIU, CEZAR A & DANIEL 12-24-18 172.16 8 2 330,500 415,000 79.64 5405130A 01-03-19 WOLFF, ADAM & ANGELA 12-27-18 43.03 12 2 322,700 405,000 79.68 5408798A 06-20-19 SCRIVENER, NORMAN 06-14-19 160 1 C0401 2 307,100 385,000 79.77

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 4 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5408676A 06-17-19 SCARBROUGH, PATRICIA A & J 06-11-19 155.12 18 2 301,300 377,500 79.81 5398525A 09-24-18 CARSON, DAVID & JANIE 09-10-18 153.18 16 2 327,600 410,000 79.90 5406708A 04-24-19 FEREBEE, LEONETTE M 04-11-19 46.05 1 2 318,800 399,000 79.90 5404727A 01-08-19 HILLMAN, BRIAN L 12-04-18 141 41 2 299,800 375,000 79.95 5406723A 05-01-19 CRESTMONT GARDENS DEVELOPE 04-24-19 154 11.01 C0060 2 120,000 150,000 80.00 5397135A 08-13-18 BECKER, KENNETH P 07-27-18 154.03 11 2 334,500 418,000 80.02 5403286A 12-06-18 SHOEMAKER, BRIAN 11-26-18 54 84.01 2 289,200 361,000 80.11 5398287A 08-30-18 MCCORMACK, TIMOTHY N & BET 08-01-18 58.04 11 2 412,900 515,000 80.17 5405145A 03-08-19 LEKOETJE, ADE MAMONYANE 02-27-19 166.14 8 2 325,100 405,000 80.27 5394567A 07-03-18 WATSON, RICHARD P 06-13-18 155.22 42.01 C0008 2 320,300 399,000 80.28 5408058A 06-05-19 BOSSMAN, DAVID M 05-13-19 46.05 12 2 341,300 425,000 80.31 5406744A 05-10-19 122 MAIN STREET REALTY GRO 05-01-19 89 36 2 333,900 415,000 80.46 5398348A 09-18-18 HINTON, LONNIE 08-14-18 168.03 13 2 293,700 365,000 80.47 5403945A 01-03-19 JOSEPH, MARIO & ROLAINE 12-14-18 161.02 41 2 269,700 335,000 80.51 5400045A 09-19-18 JACOBS, HARRIET 09-05-18 153.11 63 2 233,500 290,000 80.52 5408055A 06-04-19 DANIELS, COLIN & JULIANNE 05-17-19 58.02 5 2 467,400 580,000 80.59 5403955A 01-07-19 MAMO, TEBEYENE 12-18-18 166.14 12 2 379,400 470,000 80.72 5403936A 12-29-18 FELDMAN, ELIHU J 12-14-18 151 47 2 242,200 300,000 80.73 5398251A 08-20-18 DAVIS, PATRICIA 07-20-18 105 1 C0051 2 210,200 260,000 80.85 5402901A 12-05-18 SCHMITT, MICHAEL & SHANNON 11-29-18 37 58 2 287,100 355,000 80.87 5398337A 09-14-18 FRIEDMAN, WILLIAM H & KARE 08-17-18 154.03 13 2 384,300 475,000 80.91 5406696F 04-16-19 BATTERMAN, FREDRIC L 03-21-19 168.16 3 2 412,700 510,000 80.92 5397136A 08-13-18 PRAKASH, RAJEEV 07-22-18 155.22 42.01 C0073 2 379,600 469,000 80.94 5408074A 06-10-19 HARDAWAY, VIETTA 05-17-19 155.20 69 2 278,600 343,700 81.06 5406736A 05-08-19 GAWENUS, DAVID & MARYBETH 03-29-19 153.03 27 2 255,400 315,000 81.08 5402266A 11-29-18 TALESNICK, MELANIE 11-19-18 164 15 C0052 2 245,000 302,000 81.13 5398272A 08-27-18 GIBBS, DARRYL W & ANTOINET 08-08-18 158 51 2 547,700 675,000 81.14 5402255A 11-28-18 BYRUM, WARREN H III & KEIK 11-12-18 40 44 2 316,600 390,000 81.18 5398529A 09-25-18 STONE, JAY & JACQUELINE 09-10-18 57 7 2 442,800 545,000 81.25 5403310A 12-20-18 SIEGRIST, ELIZABETH 12-13-18 105 4 C0081 2 321,500 395,000 81.39 5408035A 05-28-19 WINTERS, TYREE 05-21-19 176.02 48.10 C0003 2 297,400 365,000 81.48 5395017A 08-02-18 DAVIS, TERESA ANN 07-05-18 125.02 149 2 203,100 249,000 81.57 5405744A 03-27-19 WILLIGES, GEORGE R 03-19-19 158.01 53.09 2 420,200 515,000 81.59 5398319A 09-10-18 SHRESTHA, NIVA 09-04-18 105 7 C0404 2 342,700 420,000 81.60 5405785A 04-10-19 STEIN, SHIRLEY 03-26-19 173.20 42 2 343,400 420,000 81.76 5397131A 08-08-18 ABORISADE, OLUWAKEMI 07-26-18 164.03 11 2 306,800 375,000 81.81 5406695A 04-16-19 CIG MEADE LLC, 03-21-19 120.01 10 2 221,200 270,000 81.93 5398289A 09-04-18 SLUCKER, RUDY & LINDA 08-16-18 107 1.04 C0076 2 455,000 555,000 81.98 5406742A 05-09-19 COCUZZA, ANGELO & FRANCA 04-22-19 175.30 352 2 410,000 500,000 82.00 5404879A 02-06-19 TRENOSKY, GONZALO & THOMAS 01-31-19 168.05 7 2 313,300 382,000 82.02 5405764A 04-01-19 CICIOLA, GERALD & CATHERIN 03-16-19 166.12 37 2 500,300 610,000 82.02 5409348A 06-27-19 GAST, BARBEL DOROTHEA 06-07-19 169.01 6.01 C0124 2 658,700 803,000 82.03 5409335A 06-24-19 MEZRIN, VADIM 05-29-19 171 29 2 557,400 679,000 82.09 5395630A 08-09-18 EISENSTEIN, EVELYN P 08-02-18 168.11 4 2 440,000 535,000 82.24 5398301A 09-06-18 SELTZER, THOMAS 08-24-18 168 1.19 2 499,300 607,000 82.26 5401811A 11-08-18 LEVEE, IRA & BARBARA 10-18-18 105 4 C0118 2 312,000 378,000 82.54

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 5 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406716A 04-29-19 JORGENSON, KEITH G & LUCIL 04-12-19 155.07 22 2 293,000 355,000 82.54 5399378A 10-09-18 LABAT, YANCEY C & ANDREA L 09-19-18 165.02 9 2 353,400 428,000 82.57 5398316A 09-10-18 PRICE, JOEL R & SUSAN S 08-30-18 158.21 12 2 429,500 520,000 82.60 5397129A 08-08-18 HABERMAN, JESS L 07-30-18 168.09 3 2 488,400 589,000 82.92 5395195A 07-13-18 MEHTA, MAHESH 07-03-18 105 5 C0252 2 311,200 375,000 82.99 5398247A 08-17-18 BHAGAT, YAMAL & SCHECTAL Y 07-09-18 173.02 20 2 341,600 410,000 83.32 5404728A 01-09-19 39 ASPEN RD ASSOCIATES, LL 12-19-18 164.07 22 2 321,700 386,000 83.34 5402277A 11-30-18 D'AMICO, CHRISTINE 11-21-18 62 20 2 221,000 265,000 83.40 5403909A 08-29-18 LEFEVRE, JEAN & JI, LIANYI 08-17-18 175.11 6 2 305,800 365,000 83.78 5404946A 02-13-19 WHITE, DONALD KEVIN & KIM 01-18-19 116.01 81.01 2 201,100 240,000 83.79 5405735A 03-25-19 D'ASARO, VALERIE 03-04-19 109 1.01 C0097 2 423,400 505,000 83.84 5403933A 12-28-18 BARNETT, SHARON & LEICHTER 12-18-18 153.08 36 2 241,500 288,000 83.85 5403323A 12-24-18 EWING, TINA R 10-31-18 155.22 42.01 C0259 2 385,500 459,500 83.90 5395274A 08-07-18 TRIPP, SHIRLEY A 07-16-18 2.01 63 2 226,600 270,000 83.93 5394580A 07-05-18 VARUGHESE, SAJI & ANISHA 06-19-18 71.01 56 C0020 2 195,000 232,000 84.05 5405158A 03-13-19 OZER, ROBERT & LISA 03-07-19 178.27 37 C0210 2 345,000 410,000 84.15 5403949A 01-04-19 CALLE, FRANKLIN P & MASACH 12-18-18 172.01 6 2 168,400 200,000 84.20 5406745A 05-10-19 DAVIS, HOWARD & EILEEN 04-26-19 45.07 11 2 510,000 605,000 84.30 5405134A 01-08-19 ABRAHAM, VINOD 12-12-18 152.22 1413 C0010 2 371,100 440,000 84.34 5406709A 04-25-19 DALESSIO, PENNY & MICHAEL 03-28-19 107 1.04 C0008 2 472,300 560,000 84.34 5403910A 09-05-18 DASILVA, JOSE JORGE & ELEV 08-24-18 18 38 2 308,300 365,000 84.47 5404987A 03-05-19 KAIMEH, ELI 02-14-19 155.22 42.01 C0190 2 300,000 355,000 84.51 5401452A 10-18-18 FRIEDMAN, MATTHEW & FRANCE 10-10-18 52.06 13 2 486,200 575,000 84.56 5406732A 05-07-19 LANE, DONALD R. & PANSY M. 04-11-19 158.23 57 2 422,100 499,000 84.59 5403950A 01-04-19 33 OAK BEND ROAD, LLC. 08-29-18 97 24.02 2 1,100,000 1,300,000 84.62 5398285A 08-30-18 ADAMS, ROBERT M & ASHLEY 08-05-18 41.01 123 2 398,300 470,000 84.74 5403319A 12-21-18 WOODARD, BRENDAN 12-12-18 105 8 C0316 2 371,300 438,000 84.77 5404891A 02-11-19 KLEIVEN, ROY 01-31-19 148.04 5 2 285,100 336,000 84.85 5402273A 11-30-18 CASTRO, ALEXANDER J 11-13-18 158.16 1 2 501,900 590,000 85.07 5398257A 08-21-18 STERN, STANLEY 07-11-18 107 1.04 C0081 2 425,600 500,000 85.12 5408056A 06-05-19 CARUSO, MICHAEL R & BARRET 05-22-19 167.01 31 2 577,200 678,000 85.13 5401816A 11-08-18 PRESSMAN, HILDA 10-01-18 152.22 1413 C0028 2 391,800 460,000 85.17 5408059A 06-05-19 EVERGREEN CAPITAL, LLC 05-15-19 166 51 2 417,700 490,000 85.24 5400065A 10-17-18 PURPURA, RICHARD A & JANIC 09-28-18 32 7 2 290,000 340,000 85.29 5398341A 09-14-18 SARTI, EVAN E 09-04-18 164 16 C0028 2 255,900 299,900 85.33 5408664A 06-13-19 PROPERTIES SOLUTIONS GROUP 06-05-19 74 27 2 362,900 425,000 85.39 5399114A 10-15-18 GOLDMAN, ROBERT & NANCY 10-05-18 168.09 9 2 451,800 529,000 85.41 5406738A 05-08-19 KAPLAN, RAY JASON & ALISSA 05-01-19 155.22 42.01 C0046 2 316,000 370,000 85.41 5398540A 09-28-18 HASSAN, SABINA 09-12-18 176.15 17 2 316,900 371,000 85.42 5399381A 10-12-18 TESTA, RAYMOND & PATRICIA 10-01-18 158 28.02 2 546,900 640,000 85.45 5395271A 08-07-18 TRANQUADA,WARREN SCOTT & A 07-24-18 176.01 9 2 280,400 328,000 85.49 5405154A 03-12-19 CONFESSORE, LOUIS J JR 02-28-19 107 1.04 C0101 2 430,000 503,000 85.49 5405132A 01-08-19 MARSH, LEVERNE RENAY 12-14-18 107 1.04 C0108 2 444,900 520,000 85.56 5405907A 04-22-19 KLAUSNER, TONIA & JEREMY M 04-11-19 40 18 2 359,600 420,000 85.62 5395244A 07-26-18 GRIMSHAW, GLENN 06-18-18 155.22 42.01 C0041 2 319,200 372,000 85.81 5398315A 09-10-18 KUSHNER, HAROLD K 08-28-18 175.11 3 2 326,300 380,000 85.87

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 6 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5398345A 09-17-18 BUONO, CAROL 08-21-18 105 4 C0128 2 287,700 335,000 85.88 5398269A 08-27-18 SINGH, ANNETTE & GEORGE 07-09-18 178.14 25 C0077 2 326,500 380,000 85.92 5404764A 01-25-19 FLIPPING WEST ORANGE, LLC. 12-27-18 154.01 4 2 255,200 297,000 85.93 5402093A 11-28-18 SANTOMO, ANTONIETTA 10-16-18 158.05 23 2 412,500 480,000 85.94 5405146A 03-11-19 SPENCE, DAMIAN 02-27-19 130 50 2 225,700 262,500 85.98 5408854A 06-19-19 JACKOWITZ, SUSAN 05-28-19 164 27 C0039 2 245,000 284,500 86.12 5408661A 06-12-19 SULLIVAN, BRIAN & ERIN 05-04-19 55.06 8 2 513,000 595,000 86.22 5408787A 06-18-19 MOHAMMED, AMINAH 06-06-19 35 17 2 327,800 380,000 86.26 5407054A 05-17-19 POND, CHARLES G & VERONICA 05-10-19 176.02 48.10 C0123 2 327,900 380,000 86.29 5395245A 07-27-18 FOTUNOFF, MIRIAM 07-10-18 105 4 C0097 2 250,300 290,000 86.31 5400050A 10-03-18 MARTINEZ, THELMA 09-27-18 105 5 C0283 2 317,300 367,500 86.34 5408931A 06-21-19 WASKO, ALYSON & JAMES 06-12-19 140.02 61.01 C0002 2 168,500 195,000 86.41 5404980A 02-28-19 CARR, LEONARD JOSEPH 01-31-19 89 41.02 2 475,400 550,000 86.44 5404749A 01-18-19 DEFINIS, PATRICIA 01-10-19 179.06 5 2 276,000 319,000 86.52 5402911A 12-31-18 LI, DIYA 12-17-18 155.22 42.01 C0104 2 328,900 380,000 86.55 5405148A 03-11-19 FMO, LLC, 02-21-19 166.15 11.04 C0405 2 1,430,700 1,650,000 86.71 5406722A 04-30-19 OLIVEIRA, CARLA 04-19-19 140.02 61.01 C0034 2 130,000 149,900 86.72 5408051A 06-03-19 FLIP THE DREAM 23 LLC 05-09-19 176.13 8 2 386,700 445,000 86.90 5408040A 05-30-19 61 FOREST HILL WEST ORANGE 04-23-19 37 23 2 440,900 507,000 86.96 5404765A 01-28-19 GISE, JEANINE 12-21-18 155 27 C0127 2 235,000 270,000 87.04 5403327A 12-26-18 WEIR, MATTHEW C & MARGARET 12-17-18 86.04 9 2 370,100 424,900 87.10 5405760A 04-01-19 BERG, ANALESA B 02-27-19 105 6 C0178 2 270,300 310,000 87.19 5394582A 07-05-18 GAVARNY, SEAN & MELISSA NE 06-07-18 71.01 56 C0015 2 122,300 140,000 87.36 5395256A 08-02-18 GOMEZ, FRANCISCO E 07-11-18 71.01 56 C0048 2 163,800 187,500 87.36 5404959A 02-21-19 MALPELLI, ELAYNE 01-16-19 175.23 46 2 310,200 355,000 87.38 5403289A 12-07-18 MB REAL ESTATE, LLC. 11-07-18 11 5 2 181,800 208,000 87.40 5403324A 12-24-18 ELC RESIDENCES, LLC. 12-11-18 176.02 48.10 C0111 2 336,500 385,000 87.40 5408066A 06-07-19 UNION HOLDING GROUP LLC 05-16-19 82.01 17 2 456,300 522,000 87.41 5395243A 07-26-18 TIBOUTI, ABDEL MAJID 07-11-18 80.01 1.01 2 496,500 567,500 87.49 5405157A 03-13-19 ZINS, BARRY & BARBARA 02-27-19 178.40 84 C0107 2 350,000 400,000 87.50 5400053A 10-05-18 NEITZEL, KARL 09-21-18 85.06 2 2 216,200 246,470 87.72 5405771A 04-03-19 EL-ATAT, FADI 02-28-19 105 9 C0357 2 289,700 330,000 87.79 5405769A 04-03-19 GARDNER, ADRIENNE JEAN 03-28-19 154 11.01 C0004 2 125,000 142,000 88.03 5408075A 06-10-19 ANDERSON, ARGENETT 05-30-19 33 30 2 251,100 285,000 88.11 5409333A 06-24-19 MINTON, DOUGLAS J 06-06-19 58.03 9 2 410,000 465,000 88.17 5395246A 07-27-18 JENKINS, JERRAUNE & TERESS 06-27-18 161.06 39 2 472,500 535,000 88.32 5399001A 10-02-18 KENNEDY, RODERICK & GRACE 08-10-18 113.01 8 2 1,175,000 1,330,000 88.35 5404964A 02-25-19 BUONO, THOMAS A. & AMY C. 02-12-19 105 9 C0368 2 291,600 330,000 88.36 5395190A 07-11-18 KAY, ANDREW & HOLLY 06-20-18 167.01 15 2 689,200 779,900 88.37 5402253A 11-21-18 CLARK, NEDRA 11-12-18 105 5 C0275 2 291,600 329,900 88.39 5405171A 03-20-19 MCFARLANE, DANA 03-13-19 40 6 2 265,400 300,000 88.47 5409435A 06-27-19 NOEL, JENNIFER 06-12-19 113 307.01 C0002 2 203,500 230,000 88.48 5401474A 10-24-18 ARBELO, CHRISTEN & PABLO 10-12-18 167.03 45 2 593,000 670,000 88.51 5404945A 02-13-19 BRANCH, GABRIELLE 03-29-18 176.02 48.10 C0093 2 398,700 450,000 88.60 5403939A 12-29-18 CARUNCHO, JACOB G & EVELYN 12-19-18 172.14 21 2 230,400 260,000 88.62 5404961A 02-22-19 CLAUDE, WILDER & CHERY, NI 02-05-19 122 63 2 212,900 240,000 88.71

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 7 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401468A 10-23-18 MADUS, AMY JUNE & STOLTZ, 10-16-18 155.22 42.01 C0222 2 337,200 380,000 88.74 5403908A 08-20-18 RABA, CHRISTOPHER & THERES 08-09-18 168 1.01 2 536,200 603,000 88.92 5405734A 03-25-19 ENCH, JENNIFER 02-28-19 155.22 42.01 C0145 2 371,700 418,000 88.92 5403922A 10-31-18 BLUE, JESSE E & DANA M 10-24-18 151.02 4 2 342,600 385,000 88.99 5406683A 04-08-19 60 MELLON AVE LLC, 03-26-19 175.08 8 2 267,200 300,000 89.07 5406688A 04-12-19 GATTENS, JEFFREY T & SHANN 03-20-19 45.07 23 2 530,000 595,000 89.08 5401458A 10-18-18 NATHAN, MARK D & DINA 09-27-18 139 2 2 236,200 265,000 89.13 5405775A 04-05-19 FUTORNICK, MARJORIE 02-28-19 179.02 23 2 267,400 300,000 89.13 5404991A 03-06-19 GRAUB, MATTHEW F & JENNA 02-03-19 178.19 17 C0187 2 321,100 360,000 89.19 5404751A 01-18-19 SHIELDS, JEFF & LOPEZ, ANA 01-10-19 54.02 47 2 364,200 408,000 89.26 5395217A 07-19-18 FENG, QIYU 06-29-18 155.22 42.01 C0192 2 326,300 365,000 89.40 5397553A 08-10-18 RAINS, JOEL E 08-06-18 105 1 C0003 2 252,600 282,500 89.42 5400049A 10-03-18 CHUNG, GOOK PYO & YOUNG SO 09-27-18 155.01 16 2 319,400 357,000 89.47 5404887A 02-08-19 FLIPPING NEWARK 002, LLC. 01-23-19 154 11.01 C0095 2 179,000 199,995 89.50 5407050A 05-16-19 TOLKOWSKY, PHYLLIS 05-10-19 176.19 9 2 300,000 335,000 89.55 5402090A 11-27-18 WEST ORANGE CONDOS, LLC. 11-19-18 38 73 C0011 2 107,500 120,000 89.58 5401491A 10-29-18 TIERNEY, KEVIN J & KAUFER, 10-17-18 155.22 42.01 C0060 2 342,700 382,000 89.71 5409344A 06-27-19 TCHAIKOWITZ, NESS & JEANNA 06-14-19 155.22 42.01 C0112 2 332,000 370,000 89.73 5404746A 01-18-19 JACOBSON, MARION 01-18-18 176.02 48.10 C0120 2 366,700 407,500 89.99 5407049A 05-16-19 BROWN, SHAWN & RAZWEL L. 05-08-19 164 30 C0071 2 255,800 284,000 90.07 5401479A 10-25-18 PAULOSE, SAJU K. 10-22-18 173.14 4 2 338,500 375,000 90.27 5395210A 07-18-18 SOMERS, ANDREW 06-29-18 155.22 42.01 C0143 2 323,300 358,000 90.31 5398244A 08-17-18 DAVIS, EUGENE I & STACEY R 07-20-18 166.04 29 C0077 2 275,000 304,400 90.34 5398336A 09-13-18 LOCKE, RONALD & ET AL. 08-13-18 29 16.01 2 246,100 272,000 90.48 5404984A 03-04-19 LIPSIC, DAVID A & DANA 02-11-19 178.18 33 C0179 2 377,800 417,500 90.49 5402252A 11-21-18 DESIKAN, RAJESH & ANUPMA 11-12-18 152.22 1413 C0040 2 398,200 440,000 90.50 5403944A 01-03-19 LI, ZHUOYU & WU, JIAXIN 12-27-18 166.13 1 C0423 2 335,000 370,000 90.54 5405909A 04-22-19 1001 SMITH MANOR INC, 03-29-19 109 1.01 C0100 2 385,000 425,000 90.59 5406753A 05-15-19 GARRETT, LUGENE & BROWER, 04-22-19 159.10 2 2 394,400 435,000 90.67 5395205A 07-17-18 GERIN, ROBERT A 06-27-18 172.05 26 2 335,800 370,000 90.76 5398530A 09-25-18 ALBANO, MICHELLE & RADFORD 09-11-18 155 27 C0135 2 270,000 297,500 90.76 5401473A 10-24-18 FABIYI, MELANIE N & OLUSEG 09-22-18 175.01 180 2 343,000 377,000 90.98 5404878A 02-06-19 73 MAPLE AVE ASSOCIATES, L 01-07-19 161.01 24 2 475,300 522,000 91.05 5408033A 05-28-19 ALMEIDA, MELISSA 05-13-19 155 27 C0180 2 260,000 285,000 91.23 5401476A 10-25-18 MOSKOWITZ, ESTHER 10-12-18 154.17 137 2 310,400 340,000 91.29 5398283A 08-30-18 BULTHAUPT, CYNTHIANNE 08-21-18 178.44 1 C0286 2 336,900 369,000 91.30 5403925A 11-01-18 FISHKIN, MARK & ADRIA 10-25-18 80.02 27 2 543,600 595,000 91.36 5407052A 05-17-19 KUWADEKAR, ADITYA SANJEE 04-25-19 105 5 C0257 2 315,200 345,000 91.36 5405759A 03-29-19 SHAH, SUSHANT & VORA, PRAC 02-21-19 105 7 C0387 2 329,200 360,000 91.44 5395013A 07-30-18 BANNETT, SYBIL 06-08-18 105 5 C0274 2 274,400 300,000 91.47 5399698A 10-11-18 SKOKANDICH, PATRICIA B & R 10-04-18 154.17 138 2 356,800 390,000 91.49 5402269A 11-29-18 JJC REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS C 10-26-18 77 27 2 377,100 412,000 91.53 5403941A 01-03-19 WANG, MICHAEL C 12-11-18 105 4 C0127 2 270,300 295,000 91.63 5405913A 04-22-19 RIOPEL, JOSEPH A & ELIZABE 04-15-19 112 1 2 605,000 660,000 91.67 5405739A 03-26-19 LEWIS, DEBRA 03-13-19 178.40 82 C0106 2 349,200 380,000 91.89 5408660A 06-12-19 PACKER, MARK E & LAURA 05-24-19 42.05 17 2 491,700 535,000 91.91

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 8 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5406726A 05-01-19 CAP, JOHN JR & HELEN G 12-20-18 47 27 2 328,100 356,000 92.16 5395181A 07-06-18 GIBBS, ROSALIND & ROCKFORD 06-12-18 155.22 42.01 C0138 2 300,000 325,000 92.31 5405730A 03-19-19 MORRIS, ARLENE 03-02-19 155 27 C0167 2 278,800 302,000 92.32 5402228A 11-14-18 MADERAZO, RONALDO P & ROSE 10-08-18 164 37 C0032 2 258,700 280,000 92.39 5395199A 07-16-18 KIM, PAUL T & CHRISTINA 06-30-18 155 27 C0119 2 266,600 288,000 92.57 5402899A 12-04-18 DAVIS, ELAINE P 11-26-18 155 27 C0162 2 288,500 311,000 92.77 5401801A 11-05-18 AGYEI, JULIETTE & HENRY 10-12-18 175.23 5.20 2 249,800 269,000 92.86 5408032A 05-28-19 FRIEDMAN, DONALD 05-01-19 179.20 12 2 645,600 695,000 92.89 5404874A 02-06-19 GRIOLA, RICHARD R & JENNIF 01-24-19 46.04 27 2 348,400 375,000 92.91 5398262A 08-23-18 SANDEEP, MALLIPATNA & MINI 08-20-18 168.09 12 2 441,500 475,000 92.95 5402091A 11-27-18 VENEZIA, KRISTOPHER R 10-29-18 149 26 2 660,000 710,000 92.96 5405784A 04-10-19 DITTO, GUIDO & HO, RAY 04-05-19 164 35 C0066 2 242,000 260,000 93.08 5408029A 05-24-19 CURATOLO, BIAGIO & NICOLE 04-22-19 146 12.01 2 214,100 230,000 93.09 5403335A 12-31-18 PATTON, PAM 12-13-18 109 1.01 C0042 2 424,300 455,000 93.25 5398524A 09-24-18 HUCKVALE, MANINA URGOLO & 09-15-18 172.15 13 2 253,900 272,000 93.35 5403296A 12-13-18 SANDMAN, ADAM & MELISSA 11-30-18 178.32 16 C0137 2 371,500 397,500 93.46 5406689A 04-16-19 SCHIANO, NANCY M 04-05-19 155.22 42.01 C0054 2 345,000 368,400 93.65 5398282A 08-30-18 CAVANAUGH, DENNIS M & LIND 08-01-18 178.45 9 C0282 2 351,300 375,000 93.68 5405791A 04-15-19 KISSEL, ANDREA & AVRAN SCH 03-21-19 110 2 C0502 2 206,200 220,000 93.73 5404986A 03-05-19 KRONMAN, BARRY 02-11-19 84.01 6 C0002 2 469,000 500,000 93.80 5394583A 07-05-18 ADAMS, KEVIN L 06-25-18 169.01 6.01 C0146 2 657,300 700,000 93.90 5401464A 10-19-18 CUNNINGHAM, DANIEL J & MIC 09-28-18 116.01 73 2 353,700 376,500 93.94 5395266A 08-06-18 DORWART, JASON & FINNERTY, 07-26-18 167.03 18 2 640,000 680,000 94.12 5397132A 08-10-18 NORDEN, SAMPHEL & CHOI, SU 07-28-18 164 25.01 C0075 2 258,900 275,000 94.15 5398249A 08-20-18 RYAN, TIMOTHY P & RYAN, KE 08-13-18 58.03 7 2 503,800 535,000 94.17 5395247A 07-27-18 ZEEVALK, GEORGE R 07-03-18 125.02 353 2 193,100 205,000 94.20 5406712A 04-25-19 Z PERKINS DRIVE, LLC, 03-29-19 164 32 C0013 2 255,000 270,000 94.44 5402755A 12-11-18 BERKOWITZ, DAVID 11-19-18 176.20 6 2 339,400 359,000 94.54 5399105A 09-25-18 SCHWARTZ, BENNETT & DEBRA 09-20-18 101.01 2 2 925,000 977,500 94.63 5395249A 07-27-18 PORTNOY, MANNY S.K. 07-18-18 107 1.04 C0110 2 542,500 572,500 94.76 5398327A 09-12-18 URMAN, DMITRY & TATYANA 08-17-18 164 17 C0024 2 255,900 270,000 94.78 5402264A 11-29-18 SADEGHI, LEILA 11-26-18 105 1 C0015 2 256,700 270,000 95.07 5398325A 09-12-18 PETERSON, FRANCIA 08-15-18 38 73 C0008 2 95,200 100,000 95.20 5395619A 07-10-18 GOTTLIEB, HENRY 06-26-18 178.27 39 C0209 2 364,400 382,500 95.27 5398994A 09-28-18 MONTAGANO, ANTONIO 09-12-18 71.01 56 C0068 2 178,800 187,500 95.36 5406721A 04-29-19 BARON, DAVID J & PAMELA E 04-09-19 169.02 2 C0006 2 715,100 749,900 95.36 5401492A 10-29-18 YAOUANE, JEAN PIERRE & MAR 06-21-18 102 7.02 2 1,050,000 1,100,000 95.45 5404873A 02-06-19 ALI, ZALINA 01-29-19 49 5.01 2 375,000 392,000 95.66 5398267A 08-24-18 ARMSTEAD, MARCUS E & KAREN 08-16-18 80.02 26 2 585,000 610,000 95.90 5398265A 08-24-18 KATSEV, I ELLIOT 07-16-18 175.02 170 2 235,000 245,000 95.92 5398522A 09-21-18 LYNETTE, ELLEN H & ANDREW 09-17-18 166.15 11.04 C0214 2 913,300 950,000 96.14 5404896A 02-13-19 EJH&C INVESTMENTS, LLC. 01-15-19 118 14 2 197,500 205,000 96.34 5405149A 03-11-19 ROBINSON, BRIAN E 03-02-19 166.15 62 2 665,200 690,000 96.41 5404784A 02-05-19 FAUST, FRANCES 01-25-19 41 163 2 279,800 290,000 96.48 5398298A 09-05-18 COSSETTI, JOSEPH A & KELLY 08-29-18 169.01 6.01 C0045 2 695,300 720,000 96.57 5404886A 02-08-19 MUSSO, SALVATORE J 02-01-19 141 50.02 2 267,800 277,000 96.68

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 9 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5397137A 08-13-18 LOKOS, RONALD 07-31-18 169.01 6.01 C0052 2 715,100 738,300 96.86 5395206A 07-17-18 PATEL, MAYOOR M 07-05-18 109 1.01 C0009 2 413,500 425,000 97.29 5403960A 01-07-19 STULBERGER, AUDREY 12-20-18 178.26 33 C0212 2 360,700 370,000 97.49 5404744A 01-17-19 ESSEX URF LLC, 12-19-18 103 11 2 810,000 830,000 97.59 5403334A 12-28-18 PANA REALTY, LLC, 12-19-18 52.08 10 2 473,400 485,000 97.61 5405788A 04-15-19 SETH, AMIT& AARTI ETALS 04-01-19 166.15 65 2 693,700 710,000 97.70 5404966A 02-25-19 KROMAS, BORIS & MARINA 02-08-19 169.02 2 C0010 2 671,800 685,000 98.07 5403954A 01-04-19 NORDAN REALTY CORPORATION 12-17-18 167.03 1 2 705,600 719,000 98.14 5405779A 04-05-19 OKAFOR, SEBASTIAN & ET AL. 04-01-19 124 16 2 181,600 185,000 98.16 5405778A 04-05-19 POLGAR, SARA 03-30-19 155 27 C0141 2 273,900 279,000 98.17 5398343A 09-14-18 INOCENCIO, MARK 09-04-18 105 7 C0402 2 319,200 325,000 98.22 5395211A 07-19-18 SPENCE, GAIL 06-18-18 154 11.01 C0046 2 143,200 145,000 98.76 5395197A 07-16-18 NORDAN REALTY CORP, 06-29-18 167.01 1 2 730,100 739,000 98.80 5404948A 02-14-19 MISTRY, KANUBHAI 02-07-19 114.01 10 2 247,100 250,000 98.84 5407042A 05-03-19 SARRAM LLC, 04-30-19 177.11 10 2 525,000 530,000 99.06 5403297A 12-13-18 CHRISTIANA, CHARLES 12-05-18 178.12 48 C0067 2 323,400 324,900 99.54 5402229A 11-14-18 BARTOSIK, WARREN T & DANIE 10-29-18 169.01 6.01 C0134 2 712,200 715,000 99.61 5398320A 09-10-18 MAYER, PHYLLIS H 08-31-18 154 20 2 301,200 302,000 99.74 5406728A 05-02-19 GOMEZ, JUAN C. & MARIA P. 04-05-19 173.20 35 2 355,000 355,000 100.00 5407045A 05-03-19 MARAZERE, FESTUS & FLORENC 04-30-19 120.01 38 2 199,900 199,900 100.00 5405912A 04-22-19 CLEARY, THERESA B 04-08-19 148.05 11 2 390,600 390,000 100.15 5400043A 09-18-18 LEE, GWANG NAM & CHRISTINA 08-12-18 166.13 1 C0529 2 377,600 375,000 100.69 5395191A 07-11-18 FIGUEIREDO, FRANCISCO & TA 06-22-18 12 12 2 176,700 175,000 100.97 5406739A 05-08-19 PRUSIN, WENDY & STEIN, GRE 04-10-19 169.02 2 C0053 2 658,400 650,000 101.29 5394573A 07-03-18 DIMURO, GIOVANNINA 06-26-18 86.03 17 2 344,700 340,000 101.38 5405168A 03-20-19 SHERRY, FRANCIS E JR 03-14-19 82.02 13.01 2 643,800 635,000 101.39 5405747A 03-29-19 CIANCIA, JAMES 03-25-19 172.26 15 2 569,300 560,000 101.66 5398241A 08-16-18 SSC II REAL ESTATE LLC 07-27-18 178.54 2 2 629,600 617,500 101.96 5395255A 08-01-18 MCGAFFEY, KYLE & MICHELLE 07-25-18 114 26.01 2 693,900 680,000 102.04 5403921A 10-31-18 AMERICAN REAL ESTATE, LLC. 09-06-18 46.02 4 2 357,300 350,000 102.09 5408067A 06-07-19 NADLER, LISA & THOMAS I 05-21-19 169.01 6.01 C0092 2 685,000 670,000 102.24 5405736A 03-25-19 LIEBERMAN, SIMONA 03-13-19 154.17 135 2 364,100 355,671 102.37 5398288A 08-30-18 WEILL, MARGO 08-21-18 166.15 11.04 C0014 2 800,000 780,000 102.56 5408046A 05-31-19 SALERNO, ALEXANDER & ELIAS 05-20-19 79 33 2 600,000 585,000 102.56 5409437A 06-28-19 HOLCOMB, DARRELL 05-15-19 173.20 16 2 280,200 273,000 102.64 5402081A 11-26-18 SAMPATH, VIJAY & AMEESHA M 11-08-18 167.01 12 2 750,000 730,000 102.74 5409349A 06-27-19 TOBY, MELODIE M. 05-31-19 48 3 2 485,000 472,000 102.75 5407253A 05-23-19 PALEFSKY, IRWIN 05-15-19 169.02 2 C0039 2 687,800 667,500 103.04 5398998A 10-01-18 PRINZ, BARBARA & ARBEIT, H 09-06-18 178.29 15 C0153 2 351,300 340,800 103.08 5395273A 08-07-18 FIELDMAN, ROBERT J & CHERI 07-20-18 169.02 2 C0084 2 673,500 653,000 103.14 5401463A 10-19-18 MARGOLIS, DAVID & MICHELLE 08-28-18 169.01 6.01 C0154 2 671,800 650,000 103.35 5408933A 06-21-19 FLOWERS, ANDRE 05-22-19 45.02 28 2 381,600 369,000 103.41 5404881A 02-07-19 STEIDLEY, KENNETH DAVID 12-18-18 178.08 11 C0042 2 402,300 389,000 103.42 5406730A 05-06-19 FERRARINI, S DANTE 04-24-19 169.02 2 C0007 2 698,900 675,000 103.54 5408651A 05-22-19 GORDON, ALICE 05-06-19 105 5 C0261 2 269,300 260,000 103.58 5406701A 04-22-19 PRUPIS, SHERI & NAJER, ALB 03-21-19 176.18 10 2 245,400 236,000 103.98

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 10 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401800A 11-05-18 DEOTERIS, PETER & MARCIA 10-10-18 107 1.04 C0139 2 540,900 520,000 104.02 5398322A 09-11-18 DELLA ROCCA, RALPH J 08-30-18 107 1.04 C0098 2 541,700 520,000 104.17 5399703A 10-15-18 KULLMAN, BETTY 10-08-18 76 1.03 2 604,300 580,000 104.19 5408041A 05-30-19 DUGAL, GURJIT & HANEERA 05-13-19 169.01 6.01 C0003 2 673,500 645,000 104.42 5398329A 09-12-18 MOLLARD, WILLIAM B JR & RH 08-09-18 94 12.05 2 789,800 754,000 104.75 5398350A 09-18-18 JOYCE, CHARLES V 08-26-18 153.17 5 2 397,100 378,000 105.05 5404954A 02-19-19 HALPERT, ALAN & LINDA 01-03-19 107 1.04 C0035 2 542,500 515,000 105.34 5395201A 07-16-18 FITCHET, MARTIN Q 07-02-18 101.02 1.05 2 1,583,100 1,500,000 105.54 5407248A 05-21-19 FUNG, BRUCE 05-08-19 169.01 6.01 C0056 2 699,400 660,000 105.97 5406681A 04-08-19 PHILBURN, LILLIAN M 03-28-19 164.05 12 2 303,700 285,000 106.56 5398537A 09-28-18 GELLER, MICHAEL 08-20-18 169.01 6.01 C0132 2 698,900 655,000 106.70 5408785A 06-18-19 BYER, PETER 05-23-19 112.02 12 2 539,000 502,000 107.37 5402909A 12-13-18 ALEXANDRE, SURUMEGA 12-03-18 114.01 9 2 220,200 205,000 107.41 5405142A 03-07-19 MALOOF, MARILYN 02-28-19 169.01 6.01 C0128 2 700,200 650,000 107.72 5403291A 12-10-18 PARKER, VALARIE & REID, AN 11-28-18 86.01 11 2 458,900 423,000 108.49 5403914A 09-24-18 ALEXANDER, JONATHAN & VIVI 09-04-18 169.01 6.01 C0130 2 709,300 650,000 109.12 5409439A 06-28-19 PIETROBON, MARIA & ALBERTO 04-24-19 81.01 9 2 257,100 235,000 109.40 5408073A 06-07-19 PASCERI, GIANNA 05-28-19 140.02 61.01 C014A 2 170,000 155,000 109.68 5403270A 07-09-18 RAKLYAR, EDUARD & IRINA 07-02-18 178.54 22 2 756,300 688,000 109.93 5397128F 08-08-18 SARNER, BRYN (TRUSTEE) 07-26-18 176.04 5 2 276,100 250,000 110.44 5405135A 02-05-19 BACCOLI, LYNDA M 01-29-19 169.02 2 C0016 2 726,200 655,000 110.87 5395011A 07-30-18 MIKHELIS, FELIX & MARGARIT 07-19-18 164 19 C0046 2 243,000 219,000 110.96 5405139A 03-06-19 KOSCIELNY, WALDEMAR 02-28-19 46.02 16 2 418,600 370,000 113.14 5403276A 08-09-18 COHEN, MELVIN 06-21-18 166.15 11.04 C0210 2 913,900 800,000 114.24 5405904A 04-17-19 LANNON, CAROLYN 04-08-19 72 46 2 234,400 205,000 114.34 5401809A 11-08-18 PLANES, FRANK A & JEANETTE 10-26-18 179.17 22 2 630,000 549,000 114.75 5408072F 06-07-19 MELLER, JUNE 05-30-19 169.01 6.01 C0057 2 695,300 600,000 115.88 5395212A 07-19-18 ANTILES, HANNAH J & LEONAR 06-26-18 103 20.01 2 1,175,000 999,000 117.62 5403915A 10-02-18 NITTI, RONALD L & KATHLEEN 09-20-18 178.37 69 C0176 2 397,600 337,500 117.81 5395193A 07-11-18 208 MUNN CAPITAL, LLC. 06-12-18 113.01 246 2 194,600 165,000 117.94 5402894A 12-03-18 TORREFRANCA, MELBA 11-26-18 168.05 1 2 280,300 237,000 118.27 5400051A 10-04-18 ORR, JAMES C & SHARON 09-06-18 94.01 2.08 2 950,000 800,000 118.75 5401484A 10-26-18 OAK KNOLL ASSOCIATES 10-18-18 164 11 C0003 2 255,800 212,000 120.66 5402270F 11-29-18 RUSSO, PASQUALE & SALESE, 11-23-18 44.02 26 2 270,000 220,000 122.73 5403274F 08-08-18 KATZ, HEIDI J 07-24-18 166.15 11.04 C0016 2 751,500 605,000 124.21 5402075F 11-19-18 PANNUCCI, ROSEMARY 10-31-18 175.23 5.22 2 250,700 200,000 125.35 5403277F 08-10-18 ALZADON, RICARDO P & FE V 07-27-18 158.18 6 2 477,800 381,000 125.41 5402078F 11-26-18 GELTMAN, ZELLA 11-12-18 164 39 C0032 2 255,800 195,000 131.18 5400059T 10-16-18 LANCASTER, JEAN L 09-24-18 59.02 4 2 290,600 219,000 132.69 YEAR TO DATE 453 168,450,300 193,366,249 39,241.83 5408777F 02-05-19 DKM REALTY, LLC. 01-25-19 19 6 4A 500,500 1,045,000 47.89 5395224F 07-20-18 39 SHIVA, LLC, 06-28-18 141 1.01 4A 534,500 850,000 62.88 5408779F 04-04-19 ORTHUS REALTY LLC, 03-28-19 152.02 132 4A 3,900,000 5,750,000 67.83

SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 042 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 11 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 07 - 22 WEST ORANGE TWP SERIAL RECORDING GRANTOR NAME DEED LOCATION OF PROPERTY QUAL CL NUM ASSESSED SALES RATIO # DATE DATE BLOCK LOT ETC CODE SALES VALUE PRICE 5401805F 11-07-18 443 MAIN STREET, LLC. 11-02-18 125.03 45 4A 535,000 685,000 78.10 5405166F 03-20-19 REUVEN AND ADI LLC 02-11-19 114 110 4A 400,000 465,000 86.02 5398347F 09-17-18 NORTIC REALTY CORPORATION 08-22-18 18 52 4A 1,254,500 1,325,000 94.68 5404892F 02-13-19 C AND N PROPERTIES, INC. 01-30-19 158.02 99 4A 441,000 450,000 98.00 5395253F 07-31-18 FREESE, ROBERT SR 07-20-18 119 32 4A 344,500 325,000 106.00 YEAR TO DATE 8 7,910,000 10,895,000 641.40 5395226F 07-20-18 VERNIERO, MARTIN J 06-14-18 125 5 4B 243,500 359,000 67.83 YEAR TO DATE 1 243,500 359,000 67.83 5408028F 05-24-19 RODRIGUEZ, ENRIQUE 05-09-19 7 25 4C 310,400 340,000 91.29 YEAR TO DATE 1 310,400 340,000 91.29 DISTRICT TOTALS YEAR TO DATE 463 176,914,200 204,960,249 40,042.35 SYSTEM NO : 151 STATE OF NEW JERSEY RUN DATE: 190916 SYSTEM : SALES RATIO DIVISION OF TAXATION RUN TIME: 200014 PROGRAM NO: JOB4288A- 043 LOCAL PROPERTY TAX PAGE NO : 1 FREQUENCY : ON DEMAND ACCUMULATIVE USABLE SALES ESSEX COUNTY CURRENT SAMPLING PERIOD: 7-1-18 TO 6-30-19 PROP CLASS NUM OF TRANS ASSESSED VALUE SALES PRICE RATIO CLASS 1 33 4,639,100 5,877,060 3,055.66 CLASS 2 4,584 2,004,689,300 2,277,159,807 396,959.60 CLASS 3A CLASS 3B CLASS 4A 163 139,642,200 151,183,800 15,280.66 CLASS 4B 17 18,767,400 23,838,500 1,296.21 CLASS 4C 49 34,886,600 58,474,165 3,487.20 CLASS 5A CLASS 5B COUNTY TOTALS 4,846 2,202,624,600 2,516,533,332 420,079.33

system no : 151 state of new jersey run date: 190916 ... · 5404000a 03-06-19 soto, gertrudis...

Documents