t he i nvestment a dvisor’s e thos … defining the decision-making and leadership dimensions for...
TRANSCRIPT
THE INVESTMENT ADVISOR’S ETHOS
… defining the decision-making and leadership dimensions for prudent investment management
Donald B Trone
President, Foundation for Fiduciary Studies
Director, U.S. Coast Guard Academy Institute for Leadership
THE INVESTMENT ADVISOR’S ETHOS
Through the eyes of your clients, you
have to be viewed as both an effective
manager and leader in order to gain
their trust and confidence.
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Ethos (ē-thäs) the distinguishing character, sentiment, moral nature, or guiding beliefs of a person, group, or institution
Merriam-Webster Dictionary
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
INVESTMENT ADVISORY ROLES
Note: Often, it is difficult to identify a bright line that marks the demarcation between one role and another.
Ultimately, status is determined in the courts by facts and circumstances.
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
INVESTMENT ADVISORY ROLES
The imperative is to define the dimensions of a decision-making process that is applicable to any advisory role –
- and also to define the leadership dimensions of the investment advisor’s unique role.
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Analyze
Strategize
Formalize
Implement
Monitor
(Acrostic) All Sinners Fall Into Madness
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Judgment
Innovation
DecisivenessCourage
Integrity
ETHOS LEADERSHIP THEORY
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Judgment
Innovation
Decisiveness
Courage
Integrity
(Acrostic) Judges In Detroit Can’t Indict
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
ETHOS LEADERSHIP THEORY
Client focus:
ServantLeadership
TransactionalLeadership
TransformationalLeadership
Needs of the client
Capacity and willingness of the
client
Legislation/Regulations
IndustryBest Practices
SituationalLeadership
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Greenleaf, CoveyBlanchard (1970)
Hersey, Blanchard (late 1960s )
Weber (1947) Burns (1978)
“The public position of the Indian has always been
entirely dependent upon our private virtue. We are
never permitted to forget that we do not live for
ourselves alone, but also for our tribe and clan. Every
child, from the first days of learning, is a public
servant in training.” Ohiyesa (Charles Eastman) Santee
INDIGENOUS WISDOM
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Fiduciary Affirmations
With “Stuart Smalley"
I'm Good Enough,
I'm Smart Enough,
and Doggone It, People Like Fiduciaries! Original Source: Al Franken, Saturday Night Live
18
1. Prepare written investment policies in accordance with standards, laws, and trust provisions
2. Diversify assets to specific risk/return profile
3. Use “prudent experts” and document due diligence
4. Control and account for investment expenses
5. Monitor the activities of “prudent experts”
6. Avoid conflicts of interest and prohibited transactions
GLOBAL FIDUCIARY PRACTICES
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
There is a complete set of
legal memoranda which
provide the fiduciary
substantiation for all 18
decision-making dimensions:
info.fiduciaryethos.com
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
GLOBAL FIDUCIARY PRACTICES
Step 1: Analyze 1.1: State covenants, goals, and objectives (“objectives”) 1.2: Define roles and responsibilities of decision-makers 1.3: Brief decision makers of applicable laws, regulations, and policy statements
Judgment
OpportunityCommitmentManagement
Capacity to CareVision and Goals
Inspiration/Persuasion
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
“People eyeing you as a potential leader tend to ask
three questions:
1. Are you committed?
2. Do you care about me?
3. Can I trust you?”
Coach Lou Holtz
Step 2: Strategize (“RATE”) 2.1: Identify sources and levels of Risk 2.2: Identify Assets 2.3: Identify Time Horizons 2.4: Identify Expected Outcomes (“performance”)
Innovation
Creativity
Risk-takingAbility to Embrace Change
Curiosity and Continual Learning
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
25
People want to be on a team. They want to
be part of something bigger than
themselves. They want to be in a situation
where they feel that they are doing
something for the greater good.
“Coach K”
Step 3: Formalize
3.1: Define the strategy that is consistent with RATE 3.2: Ensure the strategy is consistent with implementation and monitoring constraints 3.3: Formalize the strategy in a detailed written policy statement
Judgment
Relationships/Alliances
Empowerment/DelegationGood Communication Skills
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
“As a leader, you have to not only do the right
thing, but be perceived to be doing the right thing.
A consequence of seeking a leadership position is
being put under intense public scrutiny, being held
to high standards, and enhancing a reputation that
is constantly under threat.“
Jeffrey Sonnenfeld and Andrew Ward, Firing Back
Step 4: Implement 4.1: Define the process for selecting experts to implement the strategy 4.2: Define the process for selecting tools, techniques, and Vehicles to implement the strategy 4.3: Ensure that service agreements and contracts do not contain provisions that conflict with objectives 4.4: Define the process to compare, control, and account for fees and expenses (“costs”)
Courage
Diversity Expertise
Hard WorkHigh Energy
Self-ConfidenceDrive to Achieve Being in the Field
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
“We shall have to create leaders who embody
virtues we can respect, who have moral and ethical
principles we can applaud with an enthusiasm that
enables us to rally support for them based on
confidence and trust. We will have to demand high
standards and give consistent, loyal support to
those who merit it.”
Martin Luther King, Jr.
Step 5: Monitor 5.1: Prepare periodic reports which compare performance with objectives 5.2: Prepare periodic reports which analyze costs with performance and objectives 5.3: Conduct periodic examinations for conflicts-of-interests and self-dealing 5.4: Prepare periodic qualitative reviews of decision-makers
Integrity
TrustEthics
RespectHonesty
Team WorkPerseverance
Coaching/MentoringUnderstanding Human Nature
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
“In looking for people to hire, you look for
three qualities: integrity, intelligence, and
energy. And if they don't have the first, the
other two will kill you.”
Warren Buffet
ANSI, ISO, SAS 70, and Six Sigma share certain attributes:
1. Determining whether there is conformance to a defined standard (to the dimensions);
2. Evaluating the capability of management to ensure compliance with statutory, regulatory and contractual requirements;
3. Evaluating the effectiveness of management in meeting its objectives; and
4. Identifying areas for potential improvement.
ASSESSMENT OF DIMENSIONS
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
Source: ISO 19011
“Every night I try myself by court martial to see if I
have done anything effective during the day. I
don’t mean just pawing the ground, anyone can go
through the motions, but something really
effective.”
Winston Churchill
1. Provides a checklist of roles and responsibilities
2. Serves as a practicum to frame a long-term investment strategy, and to assess current status
3. Helps to uncover procedural shortfalls and omissions
4. Promotes investment excellence and improves the quality of services provided by investment advisors
BENEFITS OF DEFINED DIMENSIONS
Copyright © 2008. Fiduciary Ethos
“Standardization is one of the reasons why we were so successful during Katrina. We had crews come in from all of the country, but it didn’t matter; we had all been trained the same way.” (minute 51:14)
When you were born,
you cried and the world rejoiced.
Live your life so that when you die,
the world cries and you rejoice.
White Elk
Donald B. Trone, AIFA®
Don Trone is the Director of the U.S. Coast Guard Academy Institute for Leadership. He also serves concurrently as the President of the Foundation for Fiduciary Studies, and as the CEO of Fiduciary Ethos, which provides training and publications on the leadership and fiduciary dimensions of investment decision makers.
In 2008 and again in 2007 Don was named as one of the fifty most influential people in the retirement industry, and in a separate survey was named one of the eight most influential people in the financial planning profession. In 2006 and 2005, Don was selected for the prestigious IA25, the listing of the twenty-five most influential people in the investment advisory industry. In 2003, Don was appointed by the U.S. Secretary of Labor to represent the investment counseling industry on the ERISA Advisory Council.
Don is the author of The Management of American Indian Investment Decisions; co-author of two industry bestsellers, Procedural Prudence and The Management of Investment Decisions (McGraw-Hill Publishing); and, lead the development of the industry’s fiduciary handbook series, Prudent Investment Practices.
Don graduated as president of his class from the United States Coast Guard Academy, and with honors from the US Naval Flight Training Program in Pensacola, Fl. He served on active duty for ten years , including six years as a long-range search and rescue helicopter pilot. He is the 1997 recipient of the U.S. Coast Guard Academy Alumni Medal of Achievement for his distinguished military and business career. Don received his Master’s degree in Financial Services from the American College, and has completed post-graduate studies at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary and Trinity Episcopal Seminary.
43 Mohegan AveNew London, CT 06320-8111(412) [email protected]
169 Long Wharf Rd.Mystic, CT 06355(412) [email protected]
CONTACT INFORMATION
Donald B Trone
President Foundation for Fiduciary Studies
Director U.S. Coast Guard Academy Institute for Leadership